Trace3dplus _standard_140_results.pdf
This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it. If you are author or own the copyright of this book, please report to us by using this DMCA report form. Report DMCA
Overview
Download & View Trace3dplus _standard_140_results.pdf as PDF for free.
More details
- Words: 11,701
- Pages: 146
Trane C.D.S. 3600 Pammel Creek Rd La Crosse, WI 54601 USA Tel (608) 787-3926 Fax (608) 787-3005 http://www.tranecds.com
October 5, 2018
Subject: TRACETM 3D Plus v1.25.286 Compliance with ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 140-2014
Dear TRACETM 3D Plus User: We are pleased to inform you that TRACE 3D Plus v1.25.286 was tested in compliance with ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Standard Method of Test for the Evaluation of Building Energy Analysis Computer Programs. Test results, supplemented by graphs and explanatory notes, accompany this letter. As you may know, ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1, Energy Standard for Buildings, Except LowRise Residential Buildings, stipulates that any computer program that is used to demonstrate code compliance via the performance path’s Energy Cost Budget Method must be tested in accordance with Standard 140. TRACE 3D Plus v1.25.286 has completed the BESTEST validation for calculation and comparison with similar analysis programs as required by ASHRAE Standard 140. Standard 90.1 defines minimum requirements for the design of energy-efficient buildings and is used by many state and local code-writing bodies as the “standard of care” in their jurisdictions. Building-energy simulation programs such as TRACE 3D Plus, are used to estimate the difference in energy costs between the design- and budget-building models specified in Section 11 of Standards 90.1. If you have any questions about the testing documentation that accompanies this letter, or about any of Trane’s design and analysis tools, please contact our C.D.S. Support Center by phoning (608)787-3926 or emailing [email protected] .
Best regards,
Delia Estrada Product Development Manager Trane C.D.S. Attachments: Results and modeling notes from Standard 140 testing of TRACETM 3D Plus
STANDARD 140 – EXTENDED COMMENTS Action taken to update TRACE 3D Plus simulation engine as a result of Standard 140 testing: 1) When analyzing the Bestest CE100 results, it was discovered that the Coil:Cooling:DX:VariableSpeed object, when used as a child of the UnitarySystem object, was using 7.7% more fan energy when compared against the Coil:Cooling:DX:SingleSpeed as child object. In the UnitarySystem code, the SetOnOffMassFlowRate function missed the switch for fan operating mode (and missed the fact that this code is in IN the cycling fan part of the code) and sets the compressor off mass flow rate equal to the idle flow rate. Once this was corrected, the fan energy associated with the VS and Single Speed models matched. 2) When analyzing the Bestest CE545 results, the VS coil compressor energy was higher by 17.8% while the attached fan was lower by 16.5% compared to the single speed DX model. While the air flow through the fan is the same for each coil model, the fan RTF was different. The reason for this was that VS DX cooling coil did not set the global variable OnOffFanPartLoadFraction so the fan did not know its RTF had increased slightly due to cycling losses. This was corrected and now the data matches between VS and Single Speed DX models.
2
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-1. BESTEST BASIC Annual Incident Solar Radiation
Diffuse + Direct (kWh/m2)
2000
1500
1000
500
0 600 NORTH
600 EAST
600 WEST
600 SOUTH
600 HORZ.
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-2. BESTEST BASIC Annual Transmitted Solar Radiation - Unshaded 1200
Diffuse + Direct (kWh/m2)
1000
800
600
400
200
0 620 WEST
600 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-3. BESTEST BASIC Annual Transmitted Solar Radiation - Shaded 1000
Diffuse + Direct (kWh/m2)
800
600
400
200
0
630 WEST
610 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-4. BESTEST BASIC Annual Transmissivity Coefficient of Windows (Unshaded Transmitted)/(Incident Solar Radiation) 0.800
Transmissivity Coefficient
0.700
0.600
0.500
0.400
0.300
0.200
0.100
0.000
620 WEST
600 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-5. BESTEST BASIC Annual Overhang and Fin Shading Coefficients (1-(Shaded)/(Unshaded)) Transmitted Solar Radiation 0.400
Shading Coefficient
0.300
0.200
0.100
0.000
630/620 WEST
610/600 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-6. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Annual Heating
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
10
8
6 For Case 650, heating always off
4
2
0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-7. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Annual Sensible Cooling
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
10
8
6
4
2
0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-8. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Peak Heating 8
Peak Heating Load (kW)
7 6 5 4 For Case 650, heating always off
3 2 1 0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
ESP/DMU S3PAS/SPAIN
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
BLAST/US-IT TSYS/BEL-BRE
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
DOE21D/NREL TASE/FINLAND
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
SRES-SUN/NREL TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-9. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Peak Sensible Cooling 8
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-10. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Annual Heating
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
8
6
4
For Case 950, heating always off
2
0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
960 Sunspace
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-11. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Annual Sensible Cooling
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
960 Sunspace
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-12. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Peak Heating 7
Peak Heating Load (kW)
6 5 4 For Case 950, heating always off
3 2 1 0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-13. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Peak Sensible Cooling
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
5
4
3
2
1
0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-14. BESTEST BASIC Maximum Hourly Annual Temperature Free-Float Cases 80
Maximum Temperature (°C)
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 600FF - Low Mass Building with South Windows
900FF - High Mass Building with South Windows
650FF Case 600FF with Night Ventilation
950FF Case 900FF with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-15. BESTEST BASIC Minimum Hourly Annual Temperature Free-Float Cases
Minimum Temperature (°C)
10 5 0 -5 -10 -15 -20 -25 600FF - Low Mass Building with South Windows
900FF - High Mass Building with South Windows
650FF Case 600FF with Night Ventilation
950FF Case 900FF with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-16. BESTEST BASIC Average Hourly Annual Temperature Free-Float Cases 35
Average Temperature (°C)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 600FF - Low Mass Building with South Windows
900FF - High Mass Building with South Windows
650FF Case 600FF with Night Ventilation
950FF Case 900FF with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
960 Sunspace
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-17. BESTEST BASIC South Window Shading (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.0
Load Difference (MWh)
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5 610-600 Low Mass, Heating S. Shade
610-600 Low Mass, Cooling S. Shade
910-900 High Mass, Heating S. Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
910-900 High Mass, Cooling S. Shade SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-18. BESTEST BASIC South Window Shading (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.2
Load Difference (kW)
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0
-1.2 610-600 Low Mass, Heating S. Shade
610-600 Low Mass, Cooling S. Shade
910-900 High Mass, Heating S. Shade
910-900 High Mass, Cooling S. Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-19. BESTEST BASIC East & West Window (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 3
Load Difference (MWh)
2
1
0
-1
-2
-3
-4 620-600 Low Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
620-600 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation
920-900 High Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
920-900 High Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-20. BESTEST BASIC East & West Window (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.0
Load Difference (kW)
0.5 0.0 -0.5 -1.0 -1.5 -2.0 -2.5 -3.0 620-600 Low Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
620-600 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation
920-900 High Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
920-900 High Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-21. BESTEST BASIC East & West Shaded Window (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.5
Load Difference (MWh)
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0 630-620 Low Mass, Heating E&W Shade
630-620 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Shade
930-920 High Mass, Heating E&W Shade
930-920 High Mass, Cooling E&W Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-22. BESTEST BASIC East & West Shaded Window (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.2
Load Difference (kW)
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0 630-620 Low Mass, Heating E&W Shade
630-620 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Shade
930-920 High Mass, Heating E&W Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
930-920 High Mass, Cooling E&W Shade SRES-SUN/NREL
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-23. BESTEST BASIC Thermostat Setback (Delta) Annual Heating
Load Difference (MWh)
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5 640-600 Low Mass, Heating Heating Setback
940-900 High Mass, Heating Heating Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-24. BESTEST BASIC Thermostat Setback (Delta) Peak Heating 3.0
Load Difference (kW)
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 640-600 Low Mass, Heating Heating Setback
940-900 High Mass, Heating Heating Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-25. BESTEST BASIC Vent Cooling (Delta) Annual Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (MWh)
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5
-3.0 650-600 Low Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
950-900 High Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-26. BESTEST BASIC Vent Cooling (Delta) Peak Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (kW)
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0 650-600 Low Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
950-900 High Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-27. BESTEST BASIC Sunspace (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
2
1
0
-1
-2
-3 960-900 High Mass, Heating Sunspace
960-900 High Mass, Cooling Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-28. BESTEST BASIC Sunspace (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (kW)
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5
-3.0 960-900 High Mass, Heating Sunspace
960-900 High Mass, Cooling Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-29. BESTEST BASIC AND IN-DEPTH Mass Effect (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (MWh)
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-4.0
-5.0
-6.0
-7.0 800-430 Mass, Heating w/ Op. Win.
800-430 Mass, Cooling w/ Op. Win.
900-600 Mass, Heating
900-600 Mass, Cooling
940-640 Mass, Heating w/ Heating Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
950-650 Mass, Cooling w/ Night Vent
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-30. BESTEST BASIC AND IN-DEPTH Mass Effect (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0
Load Difference (KW)
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5 800-430 Mass, Heating w/ Op. Win.
800-430 Mass, Cooling w/ Op. Win.
900-600 Mass, Heating
900-600 Mass, Cooling
940-640 Mass, Heating w/ Heating Setback
950-650 Mass, Cooling w/ Night Vent
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-31. BESTEST IN-DEPTH South Window (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 8
Load Difference (MWh)
6
4
2
0
-2
-4
-6 600-430 Low Mass, Heating S. Window
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
900-800 High Mass, Heating S. Window
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
900-800 High Mass, Cooling S. Window SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-32. BESTEST IN-DEPTH South Window (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 6
Load Difference (kW)
5
4
3
2
1
0
-1 600-430 Low Mass, Heating S. Window
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
900-800 High Mass, Heating S. Window
900-800 High Mass, Cooling S. Window
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-33. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Heating Cases 195 to 250
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
240 Internal Gains
SRES/BRE
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-34. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Sensible Cooling Cases 195 to 250
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
240 Internal Gains
SRES/BRE
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-35. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Heating Cases 195 to 250
Peak Heating Load (kW)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
240 Internal Gains
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-36. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Sensible Cooling Cases 195 to 250
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
240 Internal Gains
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-37. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Heating Cases 270 to 320
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 270 South Windows
280 Cavity Albedo
290 South Shading
300 East/West Windows
310 East/West Shading SRES/BRE
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
* SRES/BRE Cases 270, 290-320 have input error likely affecting results by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
320 Thermostat
*
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-38. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Sensible Cooling Cases 270 to 320
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 270 South Windows
280 Cavity Albedo
290 South Shading
300 East/West Windows
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
* SRES/BRE Cases 270, 290-320 have input error likely affecting results by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
310 East/West Shading SRES/BRE
320 Thermostat
*
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-39. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Heating Cases 270 to 320
Peak Heating Load (kW)
4
3
2
1
0 270 South Windows ESP/DMU
280 Cavity Albedo BLAST/US-IT
290 South Shading SRES-SUN/NREL
300 East/West Windows TSYS/BEL-BRE
310 East/West Shading TASE/FINLAND
320 Thermostat
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-40. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Sensible Cooling Cases 270 to 320
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
8
6
4
2
0 270 South Windows ESP/DMU
280 Cavity Albedo BLAST/US-IT
290 South Shading SRES-SUN/NREL
300 East/West Windows TSYS/BEL-BRE
310 East/West Shading TASE/FINLAND
320 Thermostat
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-41. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 195 to 220 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0 200-195 Heating Surface Convection
200-195 Cooling Surface Convection
ESP/DMU
210-200 Heating Ext IR (Int IR "off") BLAST/US-IT
210-200 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR "off") TSYS/BEL-BRE
220-215 Heating Ext IR (Int IR "on")
220-215 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR "on")
TASE/FINLAND
215-200 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "off")
220-210 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "on")
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-42. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 195 to 220 (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.0
Load Difference (MWh)
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 200-195 Heating Surface Convection
200-195 Cooling Surface Convection
ESP/DMU
210-200 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR "off") BLAST/US-IT
220-215 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR on) TSYS/BEL-BRE
215-200 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "off")
215-200 Cooling Int IR (Ext IR "off")
TASE/FINLAND
220-210 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "on")
220-210 Cooling Int IR (Ext IR "on")
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-43. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 220 to 270 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 12
Load Difference (MWh)
10 8 6 4 2 0 -2 -4 230-220 Heating Infiltration
230-220 Cooling Infiltration
240-220 240-220 Heating Cooling Internal Gains Internal Gains
250-220 Heating Ext Solar Absorptance
250-220 Cooling Ext Solar Abs.
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
270-220 Heating South Windows SRES/BRE
270-220 Cooling South Windows
*
* SRES/BRE Case 270 has input error likely affecting 270-220 sensitivity results for heating by <0.2 MWh/y (<6%), and for cooling by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-44. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 220 to 270 (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 7
Load Difference (kW)
6 5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 230-220 Heating Infiltration
230-220 Cooling Infiltration
240-220 Heating Internal Gains
240-220 Cooling Internal Gains
250-220 Cooling Ext Solar Absorpance
270-220 Cooling South Windows
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-45. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 270 to 320 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
1
0
-1
-2
-3
-4 280-270 Cooling Cavity Albedo
320-270 Heating Thermostat
320-270 Cooling Thermostat
290-270 Cooling South Shading
300-270 Cooling E&W Windows
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
310-300 Heating E&W Shading SRES/BRE
310-300 Cooling E&W Shading
*
* SRES-BRE Cases 270, 290-320 have input error likely affecting sensitivity results for heating by <0.2 MWh/y (<6%), and for cooling by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-46. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 270 to 320 (Delta) Peak Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (kW)
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5
-3.0
-3.5 280-270 Cavity Albedo ESP/DMU
320-270 Thermostat BLAST/US-IT
290-270 South Shading
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
300-270 E&W Windows TASE/FINLAND
310-300 E&W Shading TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-47. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Annual Heating Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
800 High Mass Opaque Windows SRES/BRE
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-48. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Annual Sensible Cooling Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
800 High Mass Opaque Windows SRES/BRE
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-49. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Peak Heating Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Peak Heating Load (kW)
5
4
3
2
1
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
800 High Mass Opaque Windows
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-50. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Peak Sensible Cooling Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
800 High Mass Opaque Windows
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-51. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 395 to 600 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
8
6
4
2
0
-2
-4 400-395 Low Mass, Heating Surf. Conv. & IR
410-400 Low Mass, Heating Infiltration
420-410 Low Mass, Heating Int. Gains
430-420 Low Mass, Heating Ext. Solar Abs.
430-420 Low Mass, Cooling Ext Solar Abs.
600-430 Low Mass, Heating S. Window
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
440-600 Low Mass, Heating Cavity Albedo SRES/BRE
440-600 Low Mass, Cooling Cavity Albedo
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-52. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 395 to 600 (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 6
Load Difference (kW)
5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 400-395 Low Mass, Heating Surf. Conv. & IR
400-395 Low Mass, Cooling Surf. Conv. & IR
410-400 Low Mass, Heating Infiltration
410-400 Low Mass, Cooling Infiltration
420-410 Low Mass, Heating Int. Gains
420-410 Low Mass, Cooling Int. Gains
430-420 Low Mass, Cooling Ext. Solar Abs.
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
440-600 Low Mass, Cooling Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-53. BESTEST Case 900FF Annual Hourly Temperature Frequency 500 Hourly Occurrences For Each 1 ºC Bin
Number of Occurrences
400
300
200
100
0 -10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Temperature Bins (°C) ESP/DMU SRES-SUN/NREL TSYS/BEL-BRE
BLAST/US-IT SRES/BRE TASE/FINLAND
DOE21D/NREL S3PAS/SPAIN TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
50
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-54. BESTEST Case 600 Cloudy & Clear Day Hourly Incident Solar South Facing Surface 600
Incident Solar Radiation (Wh/m2)
500
Clear Day (July 27) 400
300
200
Cloudy Day (March 5) 100
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-55. BESTEST Case 600 Cloudy & Clear Day Hourly Incident Solar West Facing Surface
Incident Solar Radiation (Wh/m2)
1000
800 Clear Day (July 27)
600
400
200 Cloudy Day (March 5) 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-56. BESTEST HOURLY FREE FLOAT TEMPERATURES Clear Cold Day - Cases 600FF and 900FF 40 Case 600FF 30
Temperature (°C)
20
10 Case 900FF 0
-10
-20
-30 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-57. BESTEST HOURLY FREE FLOAT TEMPERATURES Clear Hot Day - Cases 650FF and 950FF 60
Case 650FF
Temperature (°C)
50
40
30 Case 950FF 20
10
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-58. BESTEST HOURLY LOADS Clear Cold Day, Case 600 Heating (+), Sensible Cooling (-) 5
Heating or Sensible Cooling Load (kW)
4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-59. BESTEST HOURLY LOADS Clear Cold Day, Case 900 Heating (+), Sensible Cooling (-)
Heating or Sensible Cooling Load (kW)
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-1. HVAC BESTEST: Mean COP 4.5 4 3.5
COP
3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-2. HVAC BESTEST: (Maximum - Minimum)/Mean COP
Fractional Variation
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-3. HVAC BESTEST: Mean COP Sensitivities 1.5
delta COP
1
0.5
0
-0.5
-1
-1.5
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-4. HVAC BESTEST: Total Space Cooling Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-5. HVAC BESTEST: Total Space Cooling Electricity Sensitivities 1000
500
0
-500
-1000
-1500
-2000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-6. HVAC BESTEST: Compressor Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
1600 1400
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-7. HVAC BESTEST: Total Compressor Electricity Sensitivities 600 400 200
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
0 -200 -400 -600 -800 -1000 -1200 -1400
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-8. HVAC BESTEST: Total Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-9. HVAC BESTEST: Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Sensitivities 100
50
0
-50
-100
-150
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-10. HVAC BESTEST: Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
80 70
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
60 50 40 30 20 10 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-11. HVAC BESTEST: Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Sensitivities 30 20
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
10 0 -10 -20 -30 -40 -50 -60 -70
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-12. HVAC BESTEST: Total Coil Load 6000
Load (kWh thermal)
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-13. HVAC BESTEST: Total Coil Load Sensitivities delta Load (kWh thermal)
3000 2000 1000 0 -1000 -2000 -3000 -4000 -5000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-14. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Coil Load 5000
Load (kWh thermal)
4500 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-15. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Coil Load Sensitivities delta Load (kWh thermal)
1000 500 0 -500 -1000 -1500 -2000 -2500 -3000 -3500 -4000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-16. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Coil Load 3500
Load (kWh thermal)
3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-17. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Coil Load Sensitivities delta Load (kWh thermal)
3000
2000
1000
0
-1000
-2000
-3000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-18. HVAC BESTEST: Mean Indoor Drybulb Temperature 30
Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-19. HVAC BESTEST: (Maximum - Minimum)/Mean Indoor Drybulb Temperature 0.09
Fractional Variation
0.08 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-20. HVAC BESTEST: Mean Indoor Humidity Ratio 0.018
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.016 0.014 0.012 0.01 0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-21. HVAC BESTEST: (Maximum - Minimum)/Mean Indoor Humidity Ratio 0.1
Fractional Variation
0.09 0.08 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-22. HVAC BESTEST: Total Zone Load 6000
Load (Wh thermal)
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-23. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Zone Load 4500
Load (Wh thermal)
4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-24. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Zone Load 3500
Load (Wh thermal)
3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-25. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Coil Load - Zone Load (Fan Heat)
Load (kWh thermal)
250
200
150
100
50
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-26. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Coil Load - Latent Zone Load (Should = 0) 5
Load (kWh thermal)
0 -5 -10 -15 -20 -25 -30 -35
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-1. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Total Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
60000
50000
40000
30000
20000
10000
0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-2. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Total Space Cooling Electricity Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (kWh)
8000 6000 4000 2000 0 -2000 -4000 -6000 -8000 -10000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-3. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Total Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (Wh/h)
16000 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-4. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Total Space Cooling Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (Wh/h)
3000 2000 1000 0 -1000 -2000 -3000 -4000 -5000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-5. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Compressor Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
45000 40000
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-6. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Compressor Electricity Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (kWh)
6000
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
4000
2000
0
-2000
-4000
-6000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-7. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
12000
10000
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-8. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (kWh)
4000 2000 0 -2000 -4000 -6000 -8000 -10000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-9. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
5000 4500
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.2-10. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Consumption Sensitivities 600 400 200 0 -200 -400 -600
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
-800 -1000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-11. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Total Coil Load 180000
Load (kWh thermal)
160000 140000 120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-12. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Total Coil Load 70000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
60000 50000 40000 30000 20000 10000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-13. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Total Coil Load Sensitivities 40000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000 -15000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-14. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Sensible Coil Load 160000
Load (kWh thermal)
140000 120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-15. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Sensible Cooling Load Sensitivities 25000
Load (kWh thermal)
20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000 -15000 -20000 -25000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-16. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Sensible Coil Load 40000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-17. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Latent Coil Load 50000
Load (kWh thermal)
45000 40000 35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-18. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Latent Cooling Load Sensitivities 25000
Load (kWh thermal)
20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000 -15000 -20000 -25000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-19. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Latent Coil Load 45000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
40000 35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-20. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Latent Coil Load Sensitivities 35000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-21. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean COP2 3.8 3.6 3.4
COP2
3.2 3.0 2.8 2.6 2.4 2.2 2.0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-22. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean COP2 Sensitivities 0.8
0.6
COP2
0.4
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-23. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum COP2 8
7
COP2
6
5
4
3
2
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-24. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum COP2 Sensitivities 4 3 2
COP2
1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-25. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum COP2 3.5
COP2
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-26. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum COP2 Sensitivities 0.7 0.6 0.5
COP2
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 -0.1 -0.2 -0.3
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-27. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Indoor Dry-Bulb Temperature 35
Temperature (°C)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-28. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean IDB Sensitivities 20
Temperature (°C)
15
10
5
0
-5
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-29. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Indoor Dry-Bulb Temperature 40
Temperature (°C)
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-30. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum IDB Sensitivities 25
Temperature (°C)
20
15
10
5
0
-5
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-31. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum Indoor Dry-Bulb Temperature 35
Temperature (°C)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-32. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Zone Humidity Ratio 0.016
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.014 0.012 0.010 0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0.000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-33. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Humidity Ratio Sensitivities 0.01
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0 -0.002 -0.004 -0.006 -0.008
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-34. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Zone Humidity Ratio
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.025
0.020
0.015
0.010
0.005
0.000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-35. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Humidity Ratio Sensitivities
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.015
0.010
0.005
0.000
-0.005
-0.010
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-36. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum Zone Humidity Ratio 0.018
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.016 0.014 0.012 0.010 0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0.000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-37. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Relative Humidity 100
Relative Humidity (%)
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-38. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Relative Humidity Sensitivities 30
Relative Humidity (%)
20 10 0 -10 -20 -30 -40
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-39. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Zone Relative Humidity 100
Relative Humidity (%)
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-40. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Relative Humidity Sensitivities 60
Relative Humidity (%)
40 20 0 -20 -40 -60 -80
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-41. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum Zone Relative Humidity 100
Relative Humidity (%)
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-42. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day Electricity Consumptions 6000
Consumption (Wh/h)
5000
Total (compr + both fans) CE500 CE530, Dry Coil
Indoor Fan
Outdoor Fan CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
4000
3000
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
2000
1000
0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-43. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day Coil Loads 16000
Daily Load (Wh/h thermal)
Total 14000
CE500
CE530, Dry
Sensible CE500, Wet
CE530, Dry
Latent CE500, Wet
CE530, Dry
12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-44. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day COP2 4.5 4.0
CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
3.5 3.0
COP2
2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 -0.5 -1.0 -1.5
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-45. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day Humidity Ratio 0.020
CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.015
0.010
0.005
0.000
-0.005
-0.010
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-46. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly Electricity Consumption 10000
Electricity Consumption (Wh/h)
9000 8000 7000
Compressor + OD Fan
6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-47. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly Coil Loads 25000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
20000
15000
10000
Sensible 5000
Latent 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-48. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly COP2 3.8
3.6
COP2
3.4
3.2
3.0
2.8
2.6 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-49. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly Zone Humidity Ratio 0.012
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.011
0.010
0.009
0.008
0.007
0.006 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-50. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly EDB & EWB 29 27
Temperature (°C)
EDB 25 23 21 19
EWB
17 15 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-51. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly ODB 34 32
Temperature (°C)
30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-52. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly OHR 0.02
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.018
0.016
0.014
0.012
0.01
0.008
0.006 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-1. Comparison of the Energy Delivered for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 90
Analytical Verification Tests
Comparative Tests
Total Furnace Load (GJ)
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-2. Comparison of the Energy Consumed for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 120
Total Furnace Input (GJ)
Analytical Verification Tests
Comparative Tests
100
80
60
40
20
0
ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-3. Comparison of the Fuel Consumed for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 0.00035
Fuel Consumption (m3/s)
Analytical Verification Tests
Comparative Tests
0.00030 0.00025 0.00020 0.00015 0.00010 0.00005 0.00000
ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-4. Comparison of the Fan Energy for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 600
Comparative Tests
Cumulative Fan Energy (kWh)
Analytical Verification Tests
500
400
300
200
100
0 HE150 Continuous Circ. Fan ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
HE160 Cycling Circ. Fan EnergyPlus/GARD
HE170 Draft Fan
DOE-2.1E/CETC
HE210 Realistic Weather
HE220 Setback Thermostat
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
HE230 Undersized Furnace TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-5. Comparison of the Mean Zone Temperature for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Comparative Test Cases
Mean Zone Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0 HE210 Realistic Weather ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
HE220 Setback Thermostat EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
HE230 Undersized Furnace TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-6. Comparison of the Maximum Zone Temperature for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Comparative Test Cases Maximum Zone Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0 HE210 Realistic Weather
HE220 Setback Thermostat
HE230 Undersized Furnace
* ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
* ESP-r's finite-difference discretization scheme with respect to time can be fully explicit, fully implicit, or any weighting in between. The program's default 50/50 weighting was employed for the simulations reported here and was found to produce some temperature solution oscillations for particular cases. However, subsequent analysis revealed that these oscillations had no effect upon the predicted fuel and electricity consumptions, the metrics of primary interest in these test cases.
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-7. Comparison of the Minimum Zone Temperature for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Comparative Test Cases
Minimum Zone Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0 HE210 Realistic Weather ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
HE220 Setback Thermostat EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
HE230 Undersized Furnace TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
October 5, 2018
Subject: TRACETM 3D Plus v1.25.286 Compliance with ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 140-2014
Dear TRACETM 3D Plus User: We are pleased to inform you that TRACE 3D Plus v1.25.286 was tested in compliance with ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Standard Method of Test for the Evaluation of Building Energy Analysis Computer Programs. Test results, supplemented by graphs and explanatory notes, accompany this letter. As you may know, ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1, Energy Standard for Buildings, Except LowRise Residential Buildings, stipulates that any computer program that is used to demonstrate code compliance via the performance path’s Energy Cost Budget Method must be tested in accordance with Standard 140. TRACE 3D Plus v1.25.286 has completed the BESTEST validation for calculation and comparison with similar analysis programs as required by ASHRAE Standard 140. Standard 90.1 defines minimum requirements for the design of energy-efficient buildings and is used by many state and local code-writing bodies as the “standard of care” in their jurisdictions. Building-energy simulation programs such as TRACE 3D Plus, are used to estimate the difference in energy costs between the design- and budget-building models specified in Section 11 of Standards 90.1. If you have any questions about the testing documentation that accompanies this letter, or about any of Trane’s design and analysis tools, please contact our C.D.S. Support Center by phoning (608)787-3926 or emailing [email protected] .
Best regards,
Delia Estrada Product Development Manager Trane C.D.S. Attachments: Results and modeling notes from Standard 140 testing of TRACETM 3D Plus
STANDARD 140 – EXTENDED COMMENTS Action taken to update TRACE 3D Plus simulation engine as a result of Standard 140 testing: 1) When analyzing the Bestest CE100 results, it was discovered that the Coil:Cooling:DX:VariableSpeed object, when used as a child of the UnitarySystem object, was using 7.7% more fan energy when compared against the Coil:Cooling:DX:SingleSpeed as child object. In the UnitarySystem code, the SetOnOffMassFlowRate function missed the switch for fan operating mode (and missed the fact that this code is in IN the cycling fan part of the code) and sets the compressor off mass flow rate equal to the idle flow rate. Once this was corrected, the fan energy associated with the VS and Single Speed models matched. 2) When analyzing the Bestest CE545 results, the VS coil compressor energy was higher by 17.8% while the attached fan was lower by 16.5% compared to the single speed DX model. While the air flow through the fan is the same for each coil model, the fan RTF was different. The reason for this was that VS DX cooling coil did not set the global variable OnOffFanPartLoadFraction so the fan did not know its RTF had increased slightly due to cycling losses. This was corrected and now the data matches between VS and Single Speed DX models.
2
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-1. BESTEST BASIC Annual Incident Solar Radiation
Diffuse + Direct (kWh/m2)
2000
1500
1000
500
0 600 NORTH
600 EAST
600 WEST
600 SOUTH
600 HORZ.
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-2. BESTEST BASIC Annual Transmitted Solar Radiation - Unshaded 1200
Diffuse + Direct (kWh/m2)
1000
800
600
400
200
0 620 WEST
600 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-3. BESTEST BASIC Annual Transmitted Solar Radiation - Shaded 1000
Diffuse + Direct (kWh/m2)
800
600
400
200
0
630 WEST
610 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-4. BESTEST BASIC Annual Transmissivity Coefficient of Windows (Unshaded Transmitted)/(Incident Solar Radiation) 0.800
Transmissivity Coefficient
0.700
0.600
0.500
0.400
0.300
0.200
0.100
0.000
620 WEST
600 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-5. BESTEST BASIC Annual Overhang and Fin Shading Coefficients (1-(Shaded)/(Unshaded)) Transmitted Solar Radiation 0.400
Shading Coefficient
0.300
0.200
0.100
0.000
630/620 WEST
610/600 SOUTH
ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-6. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Annual Heating
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
10
8
6 For Case 650, heating always off
4
2
0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-7. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Annual Sensible Cooling
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
10
8
6
4
2
0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-8. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Peak Heating 8
Peak Heating Load (kW)
7 6 5 4 For Case 650, heating always off
3 2 1 0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
ESP/DMU S3PAS/SPAIN
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
BLAST/US-IT TSYS/BEL-BRE
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
DOE21D/NREL TASE/FINLAND
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
SRES-SUN/NREL TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-9. BESTEST BASIC Low Mass Peak Sensible Cooling 8
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 395 Solid Conduction
430 Opaque Windows
600 South Windows
610 S. Windows + Overhang
620 East & West Windows
630 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
640 Case 600 with Htg. Temp. Setback
650 Case 600 with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-10. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Annual Heating
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
8
6
4
For Case 950, heating always off
2
0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
960 Sunspace
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-11. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Annual Sensible Cooling
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
960 Sunspace
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-12. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Peak Heating 7
Peak Heating Load (kW)
6 5 4 For Case 950, heating always off
3 2 1 0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-13. BESTEST BASIC High Mass Peak Sensible Cooling
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
5
4
3
2
1
0 800 Opaque Windows
900 South Windows
910 S. Windows + Overhang
920 East & West Windows
930 E&W Windows + Overhang & Fins
940 Case 900 with Htg. Temp. Setback
950 Case 900 with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-14. BESTEST BASIC Maximum Hourly Annual Temperature Free-Float Cases 80
Maximum Temperature (°C)
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 600FF - Low Mass Building with South Windows
900FF - High Mass Building with South Windows
650FF Case 600FF with Night Ventilation
950FF Case 900FF with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-15. BESTEST BASIC Minimum Hourly Annual Temperature Free-Float Cases
Minimum Temperature (°C)
10 5 0 -5 -10 -15 -20 -25 600FF - Low Mass Building with South Windows
900FF - High Mass Building with South Windows
650FF Case 600FF with Night Ventilation
950FF Case 900FF with Night Ventilation
960 Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-16. BESTEST BASIC Average Hourly Annual Temperature Free-Float Cases 35
Average Temperature (°C)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 600FF - Low Mass Building with South Windows
900FF - High Mass Building with South Windows
650FF Case 600FF with Night Ventilation
950FF Case 900FF with Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
960 Sunspace
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-17. BESTEST BASIC South Window Shading (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.0
Load Difference (MWh)
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5 610-600 Low Mass, Heating S. Shade
610-600 Low Mass, Cooling S. Shade
910-900 High Mass, Heating S. Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
910-900 High Mass, Cooling S. Shade SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-18. BESTEST BASIC South Window Shading (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.2
Load Difference (kW)
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0
-1.2 610-600 Low Mass, Heating S. Shade
610-600 Low Mass, Cooling S. Shade
910-900 High Mass, Heating S. Shade
910-900 High Mass, Cooling S. Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-19. BESTEST BASIC East & West Window (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 3
Load Difference (MWh)
2
1
0
-1
-2
-3
-4 620-600 Low Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
620-600 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation
920-900 High Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
920-900 High Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-20. BESTEST BASIC East & West Window (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.0
Load Difference (kW)
0.5 0.0 -0.5 -1.0 -1.5 -2.0 -2.5 -3.0 620-600 Low Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
620-600 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation
920-900 High Mass, Heating E&W Orientation
920-900 High Mass, Cooling E&W Orientation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-21. BESTEST BASIC East & West Shaded Window (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.5
Load Difference (MWh)
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0 630-620 Low Mass, Heating E&W Shade
630-620 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Shade
930-920 High Mass, Heating E&W Shade
930-920 High Mass, Cooling E&W Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-22. BESTEST BASIC East & West Shaded Window (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.2
Load Difference (kW)
0.0
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0 630-620 Low Mass, Heating E&W Shade
630-620 Low Mass, Cooling E&W Shade
930-920 High Mass, Heating E&W Shade
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
930-920 High Mass, Cooling E&W Shade SRES-SUN/NREL
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-23. BESTEST BASIC Thermostat Setback (Delta) Annual Heating
Load Difference (MWh)
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5 640-600 Low Mass, Heating Heating Setback
940-900 High Mass, Heating Heating Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-24. BESTEST BASIC Thermostat Setback (Delta) Peak Heating 3.0
Load Difference (kW)
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 640-600 Low Mass, Heating Heating Setback
940-900 High Mass, Heating Heating Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-25. BESTEST BASIC Vent Cooling (Delta) Annual Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (MWh)
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5
-3.0 650-600 Low Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
950-900 High Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-26. BESTEST BASIC Vent Cooling (Delta) Peak Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (kW)
-0.2
-0.4
-0.6
-0.8
-1.0 650-600 Low Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
950-900 High Mass, Cooling Night Ventilation
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-27. BESTEST BASIC Sunspace (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
2
1
0
-1
-2
-3 960-900 High Mass, Heating Sunspace
960-900 High Mass, Cooling Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-28. BESTEST BASIC Sunspace (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (kW)
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5
-3.0 960-900 High Mass, Heating Sunspace
960-900 High Mass, Cooling Sunspace
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-29. BESTEST BASIC AND IN-DEPTH Mass Effect (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (MWh)
-1.0
-2.0
-3.0
-4.0
-5.0
-6.0
-7.0 800-430 Mass, Heating w/ Op. Win.
800-430 Mass, Cooling w/ Op. Win.
900-600 Mass, Heating
900-600 Mass, Cooling
940-640 Mass, Heating w/ Heating Setback
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
950-650 Mass, Cooling w/ Night Vent
SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-30. BESTEST BASIC AND IN-DEPTH Mass Effect (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 0
Load Difference (KW)
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5 800-430 Mass, Heating w/ Op. Win.
800-430 Mass, Cooling w/ Op. Win.
900-600 Mass, Heating
900-600 Mass, Cooling
940-640 Mass, Heating w/ Heating Setback
950-650 Mass, Cooling w/ Night Vent
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-31. BESTEST IN-DEPTH South Window (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 8
Load Difference (MWh)
6
4
2
0
-2
-4
-6 600-430 Low Mass, Heating S. Window
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
900-800 High Mass, Heating S. Window
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
900-800 High Mass, Cooling S. Window SRES/BRE
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-32. BESTEST IN-DEPTH South Window (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 6
Load Difference (kW)
5
4
3
2
1
0
-1 600-430 Low Mass, Heating S. Window
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
900-800 High Mass, Heating S. Window
900-800 High Mass, Cooling S. Window
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-33. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Heating Cases 195 to 250
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
240 Internal Gains
SRES/BRE
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-34. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Sensible Cooling Cases 195 to 250
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
240 Internal Gains
SRES/BRE
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-35. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Heating Cases 195 to 250
Peak Heating Load (kW)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
240 Internal Gains
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-36. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Sensible Cooling Cases 195 to 250
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 195 Solid Conduction
200 Surface Convection Int IR="off" Ext IR="off"
210 Infrared Radiation Int IR="off" Ext IR="on"
215 Infrared Radiation Int IR="on" Ext IR="off"
220 In-Depth Base Case
230 Infiltration
240 Internal Gains
250 Exterior Solar Absorptance
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-37. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Heating Cases 270 to 320
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 270 South Windows
280 Cavity Albedo
290 South Shading
300 East/West Windows
310 East/West Shading SRES/BRE
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
* SRES/BRE Cases 270, 290-320 have input error likely affecting results by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
320 Thermostat
*
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-38. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Annual Sensible Cooling Cases 270 to 320
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 270 South Windows
280 Cavity Albedo
290 South Shading
300 East/West Windows
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
* SRES/BRE Cases 270, 290-320 have input error likely affecting results by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
310 East/West Shading SRES/BRE
320 Thermostat
*
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-39. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Heating Cases 270 to 320
Peak Heating Load (kW)
4
3
2
1
0 270 South Windows ESP/DMU
280 Cavity Albedo BLAST/US-IT
290 South Shading SRES-SUN/NREL
300 East/West Windows TSYS/BEL-BRE
310 East/West Shading TASE/FINLAND
320 Thermostat
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-40. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Low Mass Peak Sensible Cooling Cases 270 to 320
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
8
6
4
2
0 270 South Windows ESP/DMU
280 Cavity Albedo BLAST/US-IT
290 South Shading SRES-SUN/NREL
300 East/West Windows TSYS/BEL-BRE
310 East/West Shading TASE/FINLAND
320 Thermostat
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-41. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 195 to 220 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0 200-195 Heating Surface Convection
200-195 Cooling Surface Convection
ESP/DMU
210-200 Heating Ext IR (Int IR "off") BLAST/US-IT
210-200 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR "off") TSYS/BEL-BRE
220-215 Heating Ext IR (Int IR "on")
220-215 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR "on")
TASE/FINLAND
215-200 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "off")
220-210 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "on")
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-42. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 195 to 220 (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 1.0
Load Difference (MWh)
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 -0.2 -0.4 -0.6 200-195 Heating Surface Convection
200-195 Cooling Surface Convection
ESP/DMU
210-200 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR "off") BLAST/US-IT
220-215 Cooling Ext IR (Int IR on) TSYS/BEL-BRE
215-200 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "off")
215-200 Cooling Int IR (Ext IR "off")
TASE/FINLAND
220-210 Heating Int IR (Ext IR "on")
220-210 Cooling Int IR (Ext IR "on")
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-43. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 220 to 270 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling 12
Load Difference (MWh)
10 8 6 4 2 0 -2 -4 230-220 Heating Infiltration
230-220 Cooling Infiltration
240-220 240-220 Heating Cooling Internal Gains Internal Gains
250-220 Heating Ext Solar Absorptance
250-220 Cooling Ext Solar Abs.
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
270-220 Heating South Windows SRES/BRE
270-220 Cooling South Windows
*
* SRES/BRE Case 270 has input error likely affecting 270-220 sensitivity results for heating by <0.2 MWh/y (<6%), and for cooling by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-44. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 220 to 270 (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 7
Load Difference (kW)
6 5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 230-220 Heating Infiltration
230-220 Cooling Infiltration
240-220 Heating Internal Gains
240-220 Cooling Internal Gains
250-220 Cooling Ext Solar Absorpance
270-220 Cooling South Windows
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-45. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 270 to 320 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
1
0
-1
-2
-3
-4 280-270 Cooling Cavity Albedo
320-270 Heating Thermostat
320-270 Cooling Thermostat
290-270 Cooling South Shading
300-270 Cooling E&W Windows
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
310-300 Heating E&W Shading SRES/BRE
310-300 Cooling E&W Shading
*
* SRES-BRE Cases 270, 290-320 have input error likely affecting sensitivity results for heating by <0.2 MWh/y (<6%), and for cooling by <0.2 MWh/y (<3%)
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-46. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 270 to 320 (Delta) Peak Sensible Cooling 0.0
Load Difference (kW)
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5
-2.0
-2.5
-3.0
-3.5 280-270 Cavity Albedo ESP/DMU
320-270 Thermostat BLAST/US-IT
290-270 South Shading
SRES-SUN/NREL
TSYS/BEL-BRE
300-270 E&W Windows TASE/FINLAND
310-300 E&W Shading TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-47. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Annual Heating Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Annual Heating Load (MWh)
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
800 High Mass Opaque Windows SRES/BRE
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-48. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Annual Sensible Cooling Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Annual Cooling Load (MWh)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
800 High Mass Opaque Windows SRES/BRE
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-49. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Peak Heating Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Peak Heating Load (kW)
5
4
3
2
1
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
800 High Mass Opaque Windows
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-50. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Peak Sensible Cooling Cases 395 to 440, 800, 810
Peak Cooling Load (kW)
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 395 Low Mass Solid Conduction
400 Low Mass Opaque Windows
410 Low Mass Infiltration
420 Low Mass Internal Gains
430 Low Mass Ext. Shortwave Absorptance
440 Low Mass Cavity Albedo
800 High Mass Opaque Windows
810 High Mass Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-51. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 395 to 600 (Delta) Annual Heating and Sensible Cooling
Load Difference (MWh)
8
6
4
2
0
-2
-4 400-395 Low Mass, Heating Surf. Conv. & IR
410-400 Low Mass, Heating Infiltration
420-410 Low Mass, Heating Int. Gains
430-420 Low Mass, Heating Ext. Solar Abs.
430-420 Low Mass, Cooling Ext Solar Abs.
600-430 Low Mass, Heating S. Window
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
440-600 Low Mass, Heating Cavity Albedo SRES/BRE
440-600 Low Mass, Cooling Cavity Albedo
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-52. BESTEST IN-DEPTH Cases 395 to 600 (Delta) Peak Heating and Sensible Cooling 6
Load Difference (kW)
5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 400-395 Low Mass, Heating Surf. Conv. & IR
400-395 Low Mass, Cooling Surf. Conv. & IR
410-400 Low Mass, Heating Infiltration
410-400 Low Mass, Cooling Infiltration
420-410 Low Mass, Heating Int. Gains
420-410 Low Mass, Cooling Int. Gains
430-420 Low Mass, Cooling Ext. Solar Abs.
600-430 Low Mass, Cooling S. Window
440-600 Low Mass, Cooling Cavity Albedo
ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-53. BESTEST Case 900FF Annual Hourly Temperature Frequency 500 Hourly Occurrences For Each 1 ºC Bin
Number of Occurrences
400
300
200
100
0 -10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Temperature Bins (°C) ESP/DMU SRES-SUN/NREL TSYS/BEL-BRE
BLAST/US-IT SRES/BRE TASE/FINLAND
DOE21D/NREL S3PAS/SPAIN TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
50
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-54. BESTEST Case 600 Cloudy & Clear Day Hourly Incident Solar South Facing Surface 600
Incident Solar Radiation (Wh/m2)
500
Clear Day (July 27) 400
300
200
Cloudy Day (March 5) 100
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-55. BESTEST Case 600 Cloudy & Clear Day Hourly Incident Solar West Facing Surface
Incident Solar Radiation (Wh/m2)
1000
800 Clear Day (July 27)
600
400
200 Cloudy Day (March 5) 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
SRES/BRE
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-56. BESTEST HOURLY FREE FLOAT TEMPERATURES Clear Cold Day - Cases 600FF and 900FF 40 Case 600FF 30
Temperature (°C)
20
10 Case 900FF 0
-10
-20
-30 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-57. BESTEST HOURLY FREE FLOAT TEMPERATURES Clear Hot Day - Cases 650FF and 950FF 60
Case 650FF
Temperature (°C)
50
40
30 Case 950FF 20
10
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-58. BESTEST HOURLY LOADS Clear Cold Day, Case 600 Heating (+), Sensible Cooling (-) 5
Heating or Sensible Cooling Load (kW)
4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 -5 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.2 - Building Thermal Envelope and Fabric Load Cases 195-960 & 600FF-950FF TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B8, Section B8.1 Example Results, by Trane® Commercial Systems (Tr
Figure B8-59. BESTEST HOURLY LOADS Clear Cold Day, Case 900 Heating (+), Sensible Cooling (-)
Heating or Sensible Cooling Load (kW)
4.0
3.5
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour of Day ESP/DMU
BLAST/US-IT
DOE21D/NREL
SRES-SUN/NREL
S3PAS/SPAIN
TSYS/BEL-BRE
TASE/FINLAND
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-1. HVAC BESTEST: Mean COP 4.5 4 3.5
COP
3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-2. HVAC BESTEST: (Maximum - Minimum)/Mean COP
Fractional Variation
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-3. HVAC BESTEST: Mean COP Sensitivities 1.5
delta COP
1
0.5
0
-0.5
-1
-1.5
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-4. HVAC BESTEST: Total Space Cooling Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-5. HVAC BESTEST: Total Space Cooling Electricity Sensitivities 1000
500
0
-500
-1000
-1500
-2000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-6. HVAC BESTEST: Compressor Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
1600 1400
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-7. HVAC BESTEST: Total Compressor Electricity Sensitivities 600 400 200
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
0 -200 -400 -600 -800 -1000 -1200 -1400
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-8. HVAC BESTEST: Total Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-9. HVAC BESTEST: Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Sensitivities 100
50
0
-50
-100
-150
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-10. HVAC BESTEST: Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
80 70
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
60 50 40 30 20 10 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
delta Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.1-11. HVAC BESTEST: Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Sensitivities 30 20
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
10 0 -10 -20 -30 -40 -50 -60 -70
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-12. HVAC BESTEST: Total Coil Load 6000
Load (kWh thermal)
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-13. HVAC BESTEST: Total Coil Load Sensitivities delta Load (kWh thermal)
3000 2000 1000 0 -1000 -2000 -3000 -4000 -5000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-14. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Coil Load 5000
Load (kWh thermal)
4500 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-15. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Coil Load Sensitivities delta Load (kWh thermal)
1000 500 0 -500 -1000 -1500 -2000 -2500 -3000 -3500 -4000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-16. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Coil Load 3500
Load (kWh thermal)
3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-17. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Coil Load Sensitivities delta Load (kWh thermal)
3000
2000
1000
0
-1000
-2000
-3000
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-18. HVAC BESTEST: Mean Indoor Drybulb Temperature 30
Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-19. HVAC BESTEST: (Maximum - Minimum)/Mean Indoor Drybulb Temperature 0.09
Fractional Variation
0.08 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-20. HVAC BESTEST: Mean Indoor Humidity Ratio 0.018
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.016 0.014 0.012 0.01 0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-21. HVAC BESTEST: (Maximum - Minimum)/Mean Indoor Humidity Ratio 0.1
Fractional Variation
0.09 0.08 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-22. HVAC BESTEST: Total Zone Load 6000
Load (Wh thermal)
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-23. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Zone Load 4500
Load (Wh thermal)
4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-24. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Zone Load 3500
Load (Wh thermal)
3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-25. HVAC BESTEST: Sensible Coil Load - Zone Load (Fan Heat)
Load (kWh thermal)
250
200
150
100
50
0
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE100-CE200
Figure B16.5.1-26. HVAC BESTEST: Latent Coil Load - Latent Zone Load (Should = 0) 5
Load (kWh thermal)
0 -5 -10 -15 -20 -25 -30 -35
CA-SIS/EDF
CLIM2000/EDF
DOE-2.1E/CIEMAT
DOE-2.1E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
TRNSYS-real/TUD
Analytical/TUD
Analytical/HTAL1
Analytical/HTAL2
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
TRNSYS-ideal/TUD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-1. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Total Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
60000
50000
40000
30000
20000
10000
0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-2. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Total Space Cooling Electricity Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (kWh)
8000 6000 4000 2000 0 -2000 -4000 -6000 -8000 -10000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-3. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Total Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (Wh/h)
16000 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-4. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Total Space Cooling Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (Wh/h)
3000 2000 1000 0 -1000 -2000 -3000 -4000 -5000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-5. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Compressor Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
45000 40000
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-6. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Compressor Electricity Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (kWh)
6000
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
4000
2000
0
-2000
-4000
-6000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-7. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
12000
10000
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-8. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Indoor (Supply) Fan Electricity Consumption Sensitivities Electricity Consumption (kWh)
4000 2000 0 -2000 -4000 -6000 -8000 -10000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-9. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Consumption Electricity Consumption (kWh)
5000 4500
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Electricity Consumption (kWh)
Figure B16.5.2-10. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Outdoor (Condenser) Fan Electricity Consumption Sensitivities 600 400 200 0 -200 -400 -600
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
-800 -1000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-11. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Total Coil Load 180000
Load (kWh thermal)
160000 140000 120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-12. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Total Coil Load 70000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
60000 50000 40000 30000 20000 10000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-13. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Total Coil Load Sensitivities 40000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000 -15000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-14. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Sensible Coil Load 160000
Load (kWh thermal)
140000 120000 100000 80000 60000 40000 20000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-15. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Sensible Cooling Load Sensitivities 25000
Load (kWh thermal)
20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000 -15000 -20000 -25000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-16. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Sensible Coil Load 40000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-17. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Latent Coil Load 50000
Load (kWh thermal)
45000 40000 35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-18. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Latent Cooling Load Sensitivities 25000
Load (kWh thermal)
20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000 -15000 -20000 -25000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-19. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Peak Hour Latent Coil Load 45000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
40000 35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-20. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Latent Coil Load Sensitivities 35000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 -5000 -10000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-21. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean COP2 3.8 3.6 3.4
COP2
3.2 3.0 2.8 2.6 2.4 2.2 2.0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-22. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean COP2 Sensitivities 0.8
0.6
COP2
0.4
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-23. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum COP2 8
7
COP2
6
5
4
3
2
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-24. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum COP2 Sensitivities 4 3 2
COP2
1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-25. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum COP2 3.5
COP2
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-26. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum COP2 Sensitivities 0.7 0.6 0.5
COP2
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 -0.1 -0.2 -0.3
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-27. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Indoor Dry-Bulb Temperature 35
Temperature (°C)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-28. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean IDB Sensitivities 20
Temperature (°C)
15
10
5
0
-5
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-29. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Indoor Dry-Bulb Temperature 40
Temperature (°C)
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-30. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum IDB Sensitivities 25
Temperature (°C)
20
15
10
5
0
-5
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-31. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum Indoor Dry-Bulb Temperature 35
Temperature (°C)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-32. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Zone Humidity Ratio 0.016
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.014 0.012 0.010 0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0.000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-33. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Humidity Ratio Sensitivities 0.01
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0 -0.002 -0.004 -0.006 -0.008
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-34. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Zone Humidity Ratio
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.025
0.020
0.015
0.010
0.005
0.000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-35. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Humidity Ratio Sensitivities
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.015
0.010
0.005
0.000
-0.005
-0.010
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-36. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum Zone Humidity Ratio 0.018
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.016 0.014 0.012 0.010 0.008 0.006 0.004 0.002 0.000
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-37. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Relative Humidity 100
Relative Humidity (%)
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-38. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Annual Mean Relative Humidity Sensitivities 30
Relative Humidity (%)
20 10 0 -10 -20 -30 -40
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-39. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Zone Relative Humidity 100
Relative Humidity (%)
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-40. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Maximum Relative Humidity Sensitivities 60
Relative Humidity (%)
40 20 0 -20 -40 -60 -80
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-41. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 - CE545 Hourly Minimum Zone Relative Humidity 100
Relative Humidity (%)
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-42. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day Electricity Consumptions 6000
Consumption (Wh/h)
5000
Total (compr + both fans) CE500 CE530, Dry Coil
Indoor Fan
Outdoor Fan CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
4000
3000
EnergyPlus can't disaggregate compressor and condenser fan energy
2000
1000
0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-43. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day Coil Loads 16000
Daily Load (Wh/h thermal)
Total 14000
CE500
CE530, Dry
Sensible CE500, Wet
CE530, Dry
Latent CE500, Wet
CE530, Dry
12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 0
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-44. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day COP2 4.5 4.0
CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
3.5 3.0
COP2
2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 -0.5 -1.0 -1.5
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-45. HVAC BESTEST: f(ODB) for CE500, CE530 Specific Day Humidity Ratio 0.020
CE500, Wet Coil
CE530, Dry Coil
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.015
0.010
0.005
0.000
-0.005
-0.010
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-46. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly Electricity Consumption 10000
Electricity Consumption (Wh/h)
9000 8000 7000
Compressor + OD Fan
6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-47. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly Coil Loads 25000
Load (Wh/h thermal)
20000
15000
10000
Sensible 5000
Latent 0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-48. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly COP2 3.8
3.6
COP2
3.4
3.2
3.0
2.8
2.6 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-49. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly Zone Humidity Ratio 0.012
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.011
0.010
0.009
0.008
0.007
0.006 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-50. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly EDB & EWB 29 27
Temperature (°C)
EDB 25 23 21 19
EWB
17 15 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
TRNSYS/TUD
DOE-2.2/NREL
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL
EnergyPlus/GARD
CODYRUN/UR
HOT3000/NRCan
TRACE 3D Plus
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-51. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly ODB 34 32
Temperature (°C)
30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014 Test Results Comparison for Section 5.3 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests CE300-CE545 TRACETM 3D Plus V1.25.286 (TRACE 3D Plus) vs. Annex B16, Section B16.5.2 Example Results
Figure B16.5.2-52. HVAC BESTEST: CE300 June 28 Hourly OHR 0.02
Humidity Ratio (kg/kg)
0.018
0.016
0.014
0.012
0.01
0.008
0.006 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
Hour
TRNSYS/TUD CODYRUN/UR
DOE-2.2/NREL HOT3000/NRCan
DOE-2.1E-E/NREL TRACE 3D Plus
EnergyPlus/GARD
24
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-1. Comparison of the Energy Delivered for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 90
Analytical Verification Tests
Comparative Tests
Total Furnace Load (GJ)
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-2. Comparison of the Energy Consumed for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 120
Total Furnace Input (GJ)
Analytical Verification Tests
Comparative Tests
100
80
60
40
20
0
ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-3. Comparison of the Fuel Consumed for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 0.00035
Fuel Consumption (m3/s)
Analytical Verification Tests
Comparative Tests
0.00030 0.00025 0.00020 0.00015 0.00010 0.00005 0.00000
ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-4. Comparison of the Fan Energy for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Test Cases 600
Comparative Tests
Cumulative Fan Energy (kWh)
Analytical Verification Tests
500
400
300
200
100
0 HE150 Continuous Circ. Fan ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
HE160 Cycling Circ. Fan EnergyPlus/GARD
HE170 Draft Fan
DOE-2.1E/CETC
HE210 Realistic Weather
HE220 Setback Thermostat
Analytical/Quasi-Analytical
HE230 Undersized Furnace TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-5. Comparison of the Mean Zone Temperature for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Comparative Test Cases
Mean Zone Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0 HE210 Realistic Weather ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
HE220 Setback Thermostat EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
HE230 Undersized Furnace TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-6. Comparison of the Maximum Zone Temperature for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Comparative Test Cases Maximum Zone Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0 HE210 Realistic Weather
HE220 Setback Thermostat
HE230 Undersized Furnace
* ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
* ESP-r's finite-difference discretization scheme with respect to time can be fully explicit, fully implicit, or any weighting in between. The program's default 50/50 weighting was employed for the simulations reported here and was found to produce some temperature solution oscillations for particular cases. However, subsequent analysis revealed that these oscillations had no effect upon the predicted fuel and electricity consumptions, the metrics of primary interest in these test cases.
ASHRAE Standard 140-2014, Informative Annex B16, Section B16.6 Example Results for Section 5.4 - HVAC Equipment Performance Tests HE100-HE230
Figure B16.6-7. Comparison of the Minimum Zone Temperature for the Fuel-Fired Furnace Comparative Test Cases
Minimum Zone Temperature (°C)
25
20
15
10
5
0 HE210 Realistic Weather ESP-r/HOT3000/CETC
HE220 Setback Thermostat EnergyPlus/GARD
DOE-2.1E/CETC
HE230 Undersized Furnace TRACE 3D Plus/Trane
Related Documents
Trace3dplus _standard_140_results.pdf
May 2020 1More Documents from "Melvin Sanchez"
Trace3dplus _standard_140_results.pdf
May 2020 1
Vendele-a-la-mente-no-a-la-gente.pdf
May 2020 2
Pbl 30 Last.docx
December 2019 25
Current Skripsi Revisi (1).docx
December 2019 26
