Psychographics and its Limitations
By: Cheryl Kan • Dong Tianzhao • Karen Chen • Kelvin Lee • Ng ShiQi • Valerie Wong
Traditional Segmentation • GEOGRAPHIC – Variables like Continent, Country size, Climate etc
• DEMOGRAPHIC – Age, Gender, Sexual Orientation, Family Size, etc
• BEHAVIORAL – Benefit sought, product usage rates, brand loyalty, product end use, readiness-to-buy, etc
Evolution of Psychographics Segmentation • Globalization – changes in the socio economic structure – blurring of social class lines
– Market saturation • leading to fewer physical differences between brands • tapping into emotional elements of decision-making
Evolution of Psychographics Segmentation • Rise of the ‘creative class’ • Bringing about the cognitive elite (Herrnstein and Murray, 1994) • A more technologically advanced society creates new breed of consumers and its associated emerging markets -removing traditional criteria eg. race, gender or class -Making purchase or consumer decisions based primarily on evolved cognitive ability
The Limitations of Psychographics Segmentation Costly and Time Consuming • costly to launch • difficult to implement on a wide scale • requires involvement of: – Focus groups / Extensive Market Data collection – Intensive surveys – Anthropologists and psychologists needed
The Limitations of Psychographics Segmentation Difficult to define and measure • Other factors of purchasing behaviours – Age – Income – Economic situation
• No single psychographic analysis can be used universally
Two Assumptions 1. Percentage of customers conforms to a defined psychographic profile – People don’t always think the same – Individual personalities & perceptions – E.g. hybrid cars
2. Members of psychographic group behaved as predicted – Individual belongs to upper class might not go for luxurious cars or houses
Homogeneous & Heterogeneous Society • Japan case study… – Market is homogenous – Advertisers do not segment the market using psychographics – Fear of • Implosion and the disability of psychographical segmentation to stimulate consumerism • Failure of campaign will be disastrous due to the homogenous nature of target market and consumers
Conclusion • Researching into lifestyles, personalities and consumer mentality is resource-heavy and time/cost consuming. • Marketers and advertisers still exercise the implementation of psychographics with much success. This however is often to a niche market E.g. Porsche Cars • To achieve optimised results, psychographics should be used in tandem with other forms of segmentation and marketing/advertising tools