)$5(&2126&(1=$ C
3HUPHWWH"&DUOD3RQWL
$QWRQLR6LOYHUVWULQL
3LDFHUHVLJQRU6LOYHVWULQL
D
3HUPHWWH")UDQFR&RUWL
0DUJKHULWD5LFFL
3LDFHUHVLJQRUD5LFFL
3HUPHWWH"/DVLJQRUD'XFFLLOVLJQRU&URFH
3LDFHUHVLJQRUD'XFFL3LDFHUHVLJQRU&URFH
%XRQDVHUDVRQR$QWRQLR0DUFKHVLH/HL"
0ROWRSLDFHUHVLJQRU0DUFKHVL
7XVHL/XFLRYHUR"
6LVRQR/XFLR%DFFLDQL
6HLGL0LODQRQR"
1RVRQRGLTXL
DIL
HVVHUHGL
DILGLQGHOD
LR
VRQR
HXVXQW
WX
VHL
WXHúWL
HO
HD
HVVHUH
OXL OHL
q
HVWH
8QLWj
,RVRQRGL)LUHQ]HH/HLVLJQRULQD"
6RQRGL)LUHQ]HDQFK¶LR
$KVu"(DQFKHL%LDQFKL"
/XLVuPDOHLqGL/HFFH
LOVLJQRU%LDQFKL ODVLJQRUD%LDQFKL
L%LDQFKL
/HLqLOVLJQRU%DFFL"
6uVRQR3LHUR%DFFL
ÊGLTXL"
1RVRQRGL%DUL
&2081,&$5( 7XVHL
&DOXGLR
YHUR
6u
VRQR«
)UDQFD « /HLq
QR
1R
LOVLJQRU&URFH ODVLJQRUD)UDQN ODVLJQRULQD6WHLQ «
6HL
GL
Ê
5RPD
VRQRGL«
0LODQR $PEXUJR 6WRFFDUGD 0RQDFR «
(ORURFKLVRQR"
6RQR5RFFR%DUELH/XFLDQD&DWUDUR/XLqGL3DOHUPRHOHLGL/XFFD
LR VRQR±ORUR VRQR HXVXQW±HLHOHVXQW
4XDOqLO6XRQRPHVLJQRUH"
,RVRQR&DUOR0DFFKLH/HL"
,OPLRQRPHq0DVVLPR%DUDJOL
0ROWRSLDFHUHVLJQRU%DUDJOL
VLJQRUH
GRWWRUH
SURIHVVRUH
VLJQRU%DUDJOL
GRWWRU&DUOL
SURIHVVRU%RVVL
&RPHVLFKLDPDVLJQRULQD"
6FXVLQRQFDSLVFR«
&RPHVLFKLDPDLO6XRQRPHSHUIDYRUH
$KLOPLRQRPH"$QWRQHOOD(OLD
0ROWRSLDFHUHVLJQRULQDÊLWDOLDQDRVYL]]HUD"
6RQRLWDOLDQD
6FXVL/HLqLOVLJQRU'RPLQLFL"
1RQRQVRQRLOVLJQRU'RPLQLFLLOPLRQRPHq%DFK
%DFK"$OORUD/HLQRQqLWDOLDQR%DFKqXQQRPHWHGHVFRYHUR"
6uVRQRWHGHVFR
(GLGRY¶q"
'L+HLGHOEHUJ
&2081,&$5( 6FXVL
VLJQRUH
/HLq
LWDOLDQRD
VLJQRUD
WHGHVFRD
VLJQRULQD
VYL]]HURD
YHUR
1R
QRQVRQR VRQR
DXVWULDFRD DPHULFDQRD MXJRVODYRD IUDQFHVH LQJOHVH RODQGHVH (GLGRY¶q"
6RQRGL«
LWDOLDQRD «
35(6(17$56,
8QLWj
4XDOqLO6XRQRPH"
*LQR*HPLQLDQL
4XDOqOD6XDSURIHVVLRQH"
6RQRPHFFDQLFR
'DTXDQGRqLQ5RPDQLD"
'DXQDDQQR
ÊTXLFRQODIDPLJOLD"
1R0LDPRJOLHqDQFRUDLQ,WDOLD
*UD]LHVLJQRU*HPLDQLQL
/HLGLGRY¶HVLJQRUD"
6RQRGL5HJJLR&DODEULD
&RPHVLFKLDPD"
*LDQQD%RUJKHVLFDVDOLQJD
ÊTXLD5RPDGDPROWRWHPSR"
1R6RQRTXLFRQLEDPELQLVRORGDXQPHVH
(VXRPDULWR"
/XLqLQ*HUPDQLDGDGXHDQQL
0LOOHJUD]LHVLJQRUD LQ
vQLQ5RPDQLD LQ,WDOLD ODD5RPD
*LQR*HPLDQLQLPHFFDQLFR *LDQQD%RUJKHVLFDVDOLQJD *LXOLD6DQWDQJHORVWXGHQWHVVD 6HUJLR*DJOLDUGLJHODWDLR
(/HLVLJQRULQDGDTXDQWRWHPSRqLQ,WDOLD"
'DVHPSUH6RQRQDWDLQ,WDOLDPDPLRSDGUHHPLDPDGUHVRQRGL*LDUUHSURYLQFLDGL&DWDQLD
ÊQDWDD5RPD"
1RD0LODQR0DGDXQDVHWWLPDQDVRQRTXLSHUVWXGLDUHOLQJXH
0ROWHJUD]LHVLJQRULQD
$QFKH/HLqLQ5RPDQLDFRQODIDPLJOLD"
1RODPLDIDPLJOLDqLQ,WDOLDD/RQJDURQH
ÊTXLSHUODYRUR"
6uPDVRORSHUDOFXQLPHVL
(FRPHPDL"
6RQRJHODWDLRVRQRVHLPHVLTXLHVHLPHVLLQ,WDOLD
3DUODURPHQR"
6RORXQSRFR
XQDQQR
GXHDQQL
RL
XQPHVH
GXHPHVL
HL
XQDVHWWLPDQD
GXHVHWWLPDQH
DH
LOPLRQRPH
QXPHOHPHX
LOWXRQRPH
QXPHOHW X
LOVXRQRPH
QXPHOHV X
LO6XRQRPH
QXPHOHGXPQHDYRDVWU
LOVLJQRU=DFFKLqLWDOLDQR
$GMHFWLYXOVHDFRUG vQJHQúLQXP UFX
ODVLJQRUD=DFFKLqLWDOLDQD
VXEVWDQWLYXOvQVR LW$GMHFWLYXOvQHHVWH
LOVLJQRU'XSRQWqIUDQFHVH
LQYDULDELOvQJHQODVLQJXODU
ODVLJQRUD'XSRQWqIUDQFHVH
SHUz
ODPLDSURIHVVLRQH±LOPLRQRPH
PLDPRJOLH±PLRPDULWR
ODPLDIDPLJOLD
PLDPDGUH±PLRSDGUH
ODWXDSURIHVVLRQH±LOWXRQRPH
WXDPRJOLH±WXRPDULWR
ODWXDIDPLJOLD ODVXDSURIHVVLRQH±LOVXRQRPH
VXDPRJOLH±VXRPDULWR
ODVXDIDPLJOLD OD6XDSURIHVVLRQH±LO6XRQRPH
6XDPRJOLH±6XRPDULWR
OD6XDIDPLJOLD 0LFKLDPR*LXVHSSH%HQLJQLVRQRGL&DWDQLDHGDDOFXQLDQQLLQVHJQRTXLD%XFDUHVWLQXQD VFXROD SHU UDJD]]L LWDOLDQL 6RQR TXL FRQ PLD PRJOLH &DWDULQD PLR ILJOLR 0LFKHOH H PLD ILJOLD 0DUJKHULWD 0LFKHOH H 0DUJKHULWD VRQR QDWL TXL &RVu PLD PRJOLH FKH q DQFKH OHL LQVHJQDQWH DGHVVRqDFDVDSHUFKpLEDPELQLVRQRDQFRUDSLFFROL
&2081,&$5( 4XDOq
ODWXD
SURIHVVLRQH"
6RQR
OD6XD
PHFFDQLFR PHGLFR
ODVXD
Ê
FDVDOLQJD LQVHJQDQWH PDHVWURD LPSLHJDWRD VHJUHWDULRD RSHUDLRD SHQVLRQDWRD VWXGHQWHHVVD GRWWRUHHVVD SURIHVVRUHHVVD «
'DTXDQWRWHPSR
VHL
TXL
'DTXDQGR
q
LQ« D«
6RQR Ê
TXL
GD
PROWR
LQ«
SRFR
D«
XQ
WHPSR PHVH DQQR
XQD
VHWWLPDQD
PROWL
DQQL
SRFKL
PHVL
DOFXQL
JLRUQL
GXH PROWH SRFKH DOFXQH VHL
VHWWLPDQH
%XRQJLRUQRVLJQRUH/HLqTXLLQYDFDQ]DFRQODIDPLJOLDYHUR"
6uVLDPRWXWWLTXLD1HWWXQRDOODSHQVLRQH'RULD
'DTXDQWRWHPSR"
'DTXDWWURJLRUQL"
1RQVLHWHLWDOLDQLYHUR"
6uVuVLDPRLWDOLDQL
4XDOqLO6XRQRPH"
6DOYDWRUH0DUFROLQL
'LGRY¶q"
6RQRQDWRHDELWRD3DGRYDPDODYRURD*RUJRQ]ROD
7DQWHJUD]LHVLJQRU0DUFROLQLHEXRQHYDFDQ]H
3UHJRHDUULYHGHUFL SDUODUH
ODYRUDUH
VWXGLDUH
DELWDUH
LR
SDUOR
ODYRUR
VWXGLR
DELWR
WX
SDUOL
ODYRUL
VWXGL
DELWL
SDUOD
ODYRUD
VWXGLD
DELWD
SDUOD
ODYRUD
VWXGLD
DELWD
OXL OHL /HL
HVVHUH QRL
VLDPR
YRL
VLHWH
ORUR
VRQR
&2081,&$5( (WX /HL
GRYH
DELWL
$ELWR
D
DELWD ODYRUL
5RPD« /DYRUR
DOOD
ODYRUD VWXGL
0LODQR
9RONVZDJHQ%$6)),$7 SHQVLRQH«VFXRODLWDOLDQD
6WXGLR
VWXGLD
LQ
,WDOLD*HUPDQLD
D
)LUHQ]H%RQQ
&2*120,,7$/,$1, , FRJQRPL SL IUHTXHQWL LQ *HUPDQLD VRQR 0OOHU R 6FKPLGW LQ )UDQFLD 'XSRQW LQ ,QJKLOWHUUD6PLWK«HLQ,WDOLD" ,QXQDVWDWLVWLFDPROWRLQWHUHVVDQWHLO3URIHVRU ('H)HOLFH8QLYHUVLWjGLQ*HQRYD RVVHUYD FKHLOFRJQRPHSLIUHTXHQWHLQWXWWD,WDOLDq5RVVLFRQYDULDQWLUHJLRQDOL5XVVR/RUXVVR5XVVLDQ 5RVVLHOOR5RVVLQL5XJJLXHPROWLDOWUL ,O3URIHVRU'H)HOLFHSUHVHQWDDQFKHOHOLVWHGLIUHTXHQ]DUHJLRQHSHUUHJLRQHHFLWWjSHUFLWWj (FFRSHUHVHPSLRDOFXQLGDWLSHUDOFXQHFLWWj
1RUG D7RULQR)HUUHUR5RVVL*DOOR%LDQFR D0LODQR5RVVL&RORPER)HUUDUL%LDQFKL%UDPELOOD D%ROQD]R)HUUDUL0DLU5RVVL3LFKOHU
D9HQH]LD9LDQHOOR6FDUSD5RVVL D7ULHVWH)XUOjQ)RQGD'HJUDVVL)HUOXJD D*HQRYD3DURGL5RVVL7UDYHUVR
&HQWUR D%RORJQD5RVVL9HQWXUL0RQWDQDUL D)LUHQ]H5RVVL,QQRFHQWL%LDQFKL&RQWL D5RPD5RVVL0DQFLQL5LFFL'H$QJHOLV
6XG D1DSROL(VSRVLWR5XVVR5RPDQR'H/XFD D%DUL/RUXVVR&DVVDQR5DQLHUL0LOHOOD D3DOHUPR0HVVLQD5XVVR5RPDQR*DPELQR D&DJOLDUL6DQQD0HOLV6HUUD/RL ('H)HOLFH,FRJQRPLLWDOLDQL,O0XOLQR%RORJQD /¶LWDOLDQRVLSDUOD 1DWXUODPHQWH LQ ,WDOLD PD DQFKH LQ 7LFLQR LQ 6YL]]HUD LQ ,VWULD LQ -XJRVODYLD H D 0DOWD GRYHHVLVWRQRFRPXQLWjLWDOLDQH ( SRL LQ WXWWL L SDHVL GL HPLJUD]LRQH LQ $PHULFD LQ $UJHQWLQD LQ %UDVLOH LQ 6YL]]HUD LQ )UDQFLDLQ%HOJLRLQ2ODQGDHLQ*HUPDQLD
8QLWj
$/7(/()212
%XRQJLRUQRGRFWRU3HUVHOOL
$KVLJQRUD)UDQFDFKHVRUSUHVD&RPHVWD
%HQHH/HLGRWWRUH"
$EEDVWDQ]DEHQHJUD]LH
%XRQDVHUDVLJQRU7XFFL
&KHSLDFHUHFRPHVWDVLJQRUD%LDJL"
0ROWREHQHH/HL"
&RVuFRVuJUD]LH
&LDR3DROR
&KHSLDFHUHFRPHVWDL/DXUD"
%HQLVVLPRHWX"
1RQF¶qPDOHJUD]LH
C
2JJLVWDPHJOLRVLJQRUD7UX]]L"
1RSXUWURSSRQRQVWRDQFRUDEHQH
VWDUH
DVWD
DYHUH
DDYHD
VDSHUH
DúWL
VWR
VWDX
KR
DP
VR
úWLX
VWDL
VWDL
KDL
DL
VDL
úWLL
VWD
VW
KD
DUH
VD
úWLH
]HUR
XQR
GXH
WUH
TXDWWUR
FLQTXH
VHL
VHWWH
RWWR
QRYH
GLHFL
XQGLFL
D
&RPHVWDODVLJQRUD7UX]]L"
6WDDQFRUDPDOH%LVRJQDFKLDPDUHXQPHGLFR
,OGRWWRU&RPLVVRqPROWREUDYRHQRQDELWDORQWDQR
&KHQXPHURKD"
$OORUD
1RqVEDJOLDWR
&LDR6HUJLRFKHVRUSUHVD&RPHVWDL"
6WREHQHJUD]LH
1RQDELWLSLLQYLD'DQWHYHUR"
1R DGHVVR DELWR LQ YLD (UFROH q SURSULR TXL YLFLQR OD WHU]D YLD D VLQLVWUD LO QXPHUR q D GHVWUDVXELWRGRSRODFKLHVD
+DLDQFKHLOWHOHIRQR"
6uFHO¶KRKRLO
&LDR$QWRQLR
&LDR*LDQQDFKHSLDFHUH6WDLEHQH"
6uPROWR(WX"
$QFK¶LR VWR EHQH 6DL FKH GD GXH PHVL VWXGLR PHGLFLQD TXL D 0LODQR" ( WX QRQ VWXGL SL TXL YHUR"
1RDGHVVRVWXGLRD5RPD
$5RPD(FKHLQGLUL]]RKDL"
$ELWRLQSLD]]D&DYRXUSUHVVR*LRUJLLOQXPHURGLWHOHIRQRq
%HQH6HFDSLWRD5RPDWHOHIRQR
EXRQR$GMHFWLY
EHQH$GYHUE
EXRQDVHUD
VWDUHEHQH
EXRQHYDFDQ]H
SDUODUHEHQH
EXRQJLRUQR
ODYRUDUHEHQH
EXRQLVWXGL
VWXGLDUHEHQH
&KH
/HR /HD 6DL
QXPHUR« FKHq«
FKH«
&HQXP U /HRFDUHHVWH /HDFDUHHVWH ùWLLF
C
*LJLKDLLOQXPHURGL3LD"
1RQRQKRLOVXRQXPHUR
D
*LQDVDLWXFKHQXPHURKD3LD"
1RQQRQORVR0DODVLJQRUD0DFFKLKDLOVXRLQGLUL]]R
E
6FXVLVLJQRUD0DFFKLVDGRYHDELWD3LDDGHVVR"
0DVu$ELWDD)URVLQRQHLQYLD7RUULFFHOOL
+DDQFKHLOQXPHURGLWHOHIRQR"
6uq
0ROWHJUD]LHVLJQRUD
3UHJRHVHWHOHIRQLD3LDFDULVDOXWL
«HFKHQXPHURDYHWHYRL"
,OWHOHIRQRQRQFHO¶DEELDPR0DPLR]LRFKHDELWDDOVHFRQGRSLDQRVu+DLO
/HRVDLWXFKHQXPHURKD3LHWUR"
&KH3LHWUR""
3LHWUR6DYL«ORVWXGHQWHLWDOLDQR«O¶DPLFRGL7HUHVD)HUUL«
$KVu«0DSHUFKqQRQWHOHIRQLDL)HUUL")RUVHORURKDQQRLOVXRQXPHUR
&HUWRPDVRQRDQFRUDLQYDFDQ]D
$OORUDELVRJQDGRPDQGDUHD5LWDRD/HQDOHDPLFKHGL7HUHVD
DYHUH3OXUDO
VDSHUH
DEELDPRDYHP
VDSSLDPR úWLP
DYHWH
DYH L
KDQQR
DX
VDQQR
KDL
$QJHOD0DULR
KD
VLJQRUD«VLJQRU«
KD
úWL L úWLX
&2081,&$5( &KHQXPHUR
VDSHWH
LO
OD
SURIHVVRU0DUFKL
+R
+D
O¶
GRWWRU'HO%XRQR
IDUPDFLD
SROL]LD OR
LO
VWXGLR%UDXOLQ
]LR&DUOR
DHURSRUWR
DXWRIILFLQD
$&,$'$&
LQVHJQDQWHGL/HR DPLFDGL*LXOLR
1RQKD
L
VLJQRUL %LDQFKL
DEELDPR
OH
WXHDPLFKH/HDH3LD
KDQQR
DYHWH KDQQR
WHOHIRQR
C
0DPPDLOWHOHIRQR
$UULYRVXELWR
D
«3URQWR"
SURQWRVLJQRUD&DJOLHUL"
6uVRQRLRFKLSDUOD"
6RQR*LXVHSSH)UDQFHVFKLF¶q$QWRQLRSHUIDYRUH"
0D$QWRQLRQRQDELWDSLTXLVWXGLDD)LUHQ]H2UDSHUzqDOFXQLJLRUQDDOO¶HVWHURD9LHQQD
2K0D/HLKDLOVXRQXRYRLQGLUL]]RGL)LUHQ]HVLJQRUD"
6uXQPRPHQWR«YLD*LRWWRRLOVXRQXPHURq
6DDQFKHLOSUHILVVRGL)LUHQ]HSHUSLDFHUH"
6uq
7DQWHJUD]LHVLJQRUD
3UHJRQRQF¶qGLFKH
3URQWRFKLSDUOD"
3URQWR0DULD"6HLWX"
1RTXLIDPLJOLD*LJOLDQR
0DTXDOqLO6XRQXPHUR"
$KVFXVLKRVEDJOLDWRQXPHUR
3URQWRVLJQRULQD"4XLSDUOD%HUJHU
%XRQJLRUQRVLJQRU%HUJHU
,OVLJQRU)DJJLqLQXIILFLRRJJL"
1RSXUWRSSRRJJLQRQF¶qSHUFKqQRQVWDEHQH
2K $UULYR DGHVVR GD 6WRFFDUGD H VRQR TXL D %RORJQD VROR RJJL +D LO VXR QXPHUR SULYDWR SHU IDYRUH"
&HUWRXQPRPHQWRSHUSLDFHUH(FFR
*UD]LHVLJQRULQD/HLqPROWRJHQWLOH
«H/HLVDSDUODUHPROWREHQHO¶LWDOLDQR&RPSOLPHQWL
SHUIDYRUH SHUSLDFHUH SUHJR
7HOHIRQDUHLQ,WDOLD 'RYH" $OOD SRVWD FRPH LQ 5RPDQLD" 5DUDPHQWH0HJOLR DOOD6,3RDOFHQWUDOLQRWHOHIRQLFR LQXQDFDELQDWHOHIRQLFDSXEEOLFD DO EDU FRQ XQ WHOHIRQR D VFDWWL H VHPSUHOjF¶qTXHVWRVLPEROR
QRQF¶H QRQFLVRQR
&RPH" FRQJHWWRQL DGHVVRDQFKHPRQHWH FRQODVFKHGDPDJQHWLFDSHUWHOHIRQDWHXUEDQHLQWHUXUEDQHHLQWHUQD]LRQDOL (SHUWHOHIRQDUHLQWHOHVHOH]LRQHLQ5RPDQLDELVRJQDIDUHLOSUHILVVRLQWHUQD]LRQDOH
'29(6,9$67$6(5$"
8QLWj
%XRQDSSHWLWR
*UD]LHDOWUHWWDQWR
ÊYHURFKHYDLDVWXGLDUHLQ,WDOLD$OHVVDQGUD"
6uYDGRD9HQH]LDSHUXQDQQR
&KHEHOOR(FRPHPDL"
&RQXQDERUVDGLVWXGLR
0DJQLILFR$OORUDWDQWLDXJXULHEXRQRVWXGLR
*UD]LH*LRYDQQL
ÊYHURFKHYDYLDGDTXLVLJQRU6FLJOLDQR"
6uODSURVVLPDVHWWLPDQDYDGRD7RULQRSHUODYRUR
(OD6XDIDPLJOLD"
6WDDQFRUDTXLD%UHVFLD
$OORUDEXRQDIRUWXQD
*LQRVDLSHUFKp%HSSHYDIXRUL"
6uYDDOFRUVRGLWHGHVFR
(KL%HSSH%XRQODYRUR
'RYHYDLQYDFDQ]DTXHVW¶DQQRVLJQRUD6FLDFRYHOOL"
$OPDUH$QGLDPRDWURYDUHDPLFLDOO¶LVRODG¶(OED
&KHEHOOR(TXDQGRYDYLD"
'RPHQLFD
*LjGRPHQLFD"$OORUDEXRQYLDJJLRHEXRQHYDFDQ]H
6LHWHDFDVDTXHVWRZHHNHQG7RP"
1RQRQFLVLDPR
(GRYHDQGDWH"
$QGLDPRWXWWLLQVLHPHDOODJRGL*DUGD
(SRLDQGDWHLQEDUFDDYHOD"
6u
%HDWLYRL$OORUDEXRQILQHVHWWLPDQD
*UD]LH(WXGRYHYDL/HR"
6WR LQ FLWWj SHUFKp KR PROWR ODYRUR 0D IRUVH GRPHQLFD VHUD KR XQ SR¶ GL WHPSR H YDGR IXRUL FRQ&ODXGLD
$OORUDEXRQDGRPHQLFD(QRQODYRUDUHWURSSRHK DQGDUH YDGR
DQGLDPR
DQGDUHDWURYDUH
YDL
DQGDWH
DQGDUHDSUHQGHU
YD
YDQRR DQGDUHIXRUL DQGDUHYLD DQGDUFL
XQDVHUD±EXRQDVHUD
XQYLDJJLR±EXRQYLDJJLR
XQRVWXGLR±EXRQRVWXGLR
9DLJLjDFDVD*LDFRPR" 6uVRQRPROWRVWDQFR9DGRVXELWRDOHWWR $OORUDEXRQDQRWWHDEXRQULSRVR
$K&DUOR9RLFLVLHWHDOILQHVHWWLPDQD"
1RQRQWXWWL0LRSDGUHHPLDVRUHOODYDQQRDSUHQGHUHPLRIUDWHOOR*LXVHSSHLQ)UDQFLD
(WXQRQFLYDL"
1R,RYDGRLQPRQWDJQDDVFLDUHFRQXQDPLFR
&KHEHOOR$OORUDEXRQGLYHUWLPHQWR
&LDR'RYHYDL*LDQQL"
$OOXQLYHUVLWjSHUFKpKRXQHVDPHGLIUDQFHVH
$OORUDLQERFFDDOOXSR
*UD]LH(GRYHDQGDWHYRLGXH"
$QGLDPRGD$QJHODSHUFKpRJJLqLOVXRFRPSOHDQQR
$K$XJXULDQFKHGDSDUWHPLDHWDQWHEHOOHFRVH 9DGR
,WDOLD
9DGR
LQ 6RQR
D FLWWj
&2081,&$5( 'RYH
YDL
9DGR
1DSROL
6RQR
$QJHOD GD
FDVD
6RQR
DPLFL
DGHVVR
9DGR
D
7RULQR VFXROD
YD
TXHVWDVHUD
FDVD OHWWR
DQGDWH
GRPDQL
$QGLDPR
GRPHQLFD DO
ODJR
TXHVWRZHHNHQG
PDUH
DOILQHVHWWLPDQD
FRUVRG¶LWDOLDQR ODYRUR
ODSURVVLPDVHWWLPDQD
FRPSOHDQQRGL*LQR
LOPHVHSURVVLPR
EDU ULVWRUDQWH
LQYDFDQ]D TXHVW¶DQQR
DOOD
IHVWDGL$QJHOD VFXRODLWDOLDQD
O¶DQQRSURVVLPR DOO¶
LVRODG¶(OED XQLYHUVLWj HVWHUR
LQ
$PHULFD YDFDQ]D EDUFDDYHOD
XIILFLR PRQWDJQD 5LYLHUD FLWWj GD
$OORUD
EXRQDQRWWH
EXRQULSRVR
*UD]LHDOWUHWWDQWR
GRPHQLFD
ODYRUR
0ROWHJUD]LH
IRUWXQD
YLDJJLR
7DQWHJUD]LH
EXRQRVWXGLR
ZHHNHQG ILQHVHWWLPDQD GLYHUWLPHQWR
*LQR$QJHOD«
'RYHYDL*LJL"
$OO¶XQLYHUVLWjF¶qXQDIHVWDHFLYDGRFRQJOLVWXGHQWLGHOPLRFRUVR
$OORUDEXRQGLYHUWLPHQWR*UD]LH
0DPPDYDGRDOODIHVWDGHOO¶8QLWjFRQJOLDPLFL
9DEHQHPDQRQULWRUQDUHWDUGL
%XRQGLYHUWLPHQWR
OR JOL
ORVWXGHQWH±JOLVWXGHQWL
VWXGLRVYL]]HUR]LRVFL
O¶DPLFRJOLDPLFL
LWDOLDQRLQVHJQDQWHDQQRDXJXULR
O¶
7DQWLDXJXUL $FKL±&XL" 3HQWUXFLQH"
DO
SLFFROR0DWWHR
DL
5RVVL
D/HL
DOOR
]LR
DJOL
VSRVL
DYRL
DOO¶
LQVHJQDQWH
DOOD
6XDIDPLJOLD
DPLFL DOOH
WXHDPLFKH
9DLIXRUL1LFROD"
6uYDGRDSUHQGHUHL5RVVLHGDQGLDPRLQVLHPHDOODVDJUDGHOODVDUGHOOD
&KHEHOOR%XRQGLYHUWLPHQWRHVDOXWLDL5RVVL
&2081,&$5( 'RYHDQGDWH
2JJLF¶q
ODVDJUD
GHO
YLQR
ODIHVWD
GHOO¶
PDU]R
ODIHVWD
GHOOR
VSRUW
ODIHVWD
GHOOD
0DGRQQDGHOOH*UD]LH
ODIHVWD
GHOO¶
8QLWj
ODVDJUD
GHL
IXQJKL
ODVDJUD
GHJOL
VSDJKHWWL
ODVDJUD
GHOOH
FDVWDJQH
HFLDQGLDPRFRQDPLFL %HDWLYRL %XRQGLYHUWLPHQWR
*UD]LH
'RYHYDL%UXQR"
9DGRDWHOHIRQDUHD*HPPDqPDODWD
&KHFRV¶KD"
1RVLVDDQFRUD+DODIHEEUHHPDOGLWHVWD
2KPLGLVSLDFHPROWR7DQWLVDOXWLHDXJXULGDSDUWHPLD
3URQWR"6RQR5HQDWD3HUFKqQRQVLHWHVWDWLDOFRUVRLHULVHUD"1RQVWDWHEHQH"
1RQRQPROWRSXUWRSSR
&KHFRVDDYHWH"
6LDPRWXWWLDOHWWRFRQO¶LQIOXHQ]D
$KPLGLVSLDFH$OORUDFLYHGLDPRVRORODSURVVLPDVHWWLPDQD"
6uVHVWLDPRPHJOLR
%HQH$OORUDFLDRHDXJXULGLRJQLEHQH
&LDRHJUD]LH
9DLIXRUL5HQDWD"
6uYDGRDSUHQGHUHOHPHGLFLQHSHUJOL6SLQHOOL
$KVWDQQRPDOH"
6uKDQQRO¶LQIOXHQ]D
2KPLGLVSLDFH6HYDLGDJOL6SLQHOOLWDQWHEHOOHFRVHGDSDUWHPLD
VWDUH
DVWD
VWDWRDLH
VWLDPR
VW P
VRQR
VLDPR
VWDWH
VWD L
VHLVWDWRVWDWD
VLHWHVWDWLVWDWH
VWDQQR
VWDX
q
VRQR
&2081,&$5( 9DL
DQFKH
WX
9D
/HL
$QGDWH
YRL
DOOD
IHVWD
GL
*LQR
VDJUD
GHO
VLJQRU«
1R
KR DEELDPR
VWRPDFR
GHOOR
VSRUW
GHOOD
VLJQRUD
ODIHEEUH
0DGRQQD
O¶LQIOXHQ]D
VDUGHOOD
PROWRODYRUR
GHOO¶
8QLWj
GHL
5RVVL
GHJOL
JROD
VRQR
FRQO¶LQIOXHQ]D VLDPR
6SLQHOOL GHOOH
PDODWRD VWDQFRD
VWXGHQWL VSDJKHWWL
PDODWLH VWDQFKLH
FDVWDJQH
JLjLQYDFDQ]D
VWR 1RQRQ
$OORUDFLDRHWDQWHEXRQHFRVH
GHQWL
YLQR
IXQJKL
&KHSHFFDWR0LGLVSLDFHPROWR
PDOGLWHVWD
PDOH
VWLDPR WDQWREHQH
*UD]LH(EXRQGLYHUWLPHQWR
&2081,&$5( 3HUFKp
YDL
YLD
9DGR
DWURYDUH
YD
IXRUL
$QGLDPR
DSUHQGHUH
LO
VLJQRU&RVFLDQL
DFKLDPDUH
OD
VLJQRUD%XVFHQL
L
)DVFH
JOL
6FLOOD
OH
PLHDPLFKH
D
0DULR
DO
PHGLFR
DOOR
]LR
DOO¶
LQVHJQDQWH
DOOD
VLJQRUD&UHVFL
DL
5RVVL
DJOL
6FKPLGW
DQGDWH
0DULR
DWHOHIRQDUH
JLjDFDVD
DODYRUDUH DVWXGLDUH
&2081,&$5( 3HUFKp
QRQ
VHL
6RQR
VWDQFRD
6LDPR
VWDQFKLH
VWDWRD
D
q VLHWH
VWDWLH
DO
0LODQR
6RQRVWDWRD
PDODWRD
VFXROD
6LDPRVWDWLH
PDODWLH
WHDWUR
PDOH
ODJR
LQYDFDQ]D
FRUVR
DVFLDUH
ODYRUR
DSUHQGDUH«
FRQFHUWR
DWURYDUH«
FRPSOHDQQRGL« IHVWDGL« VDJUDGL« XQLYHUVLWj XIILFLR FLWWj GLVFRWHFD 0DXUL]LR 6HUHQD PLDVRUHOOD PLRIUDWHOOR
'RYHYDVWDVHUDVLJQRU5RVVL"
*OL LWDOLDQL YDQQR YROHQWLHUL DOOH IHVWH LQ SLD]]D 6H DQGDWH LQ ,WDOLD SHU HVHPSLR LQ DJRVWR DYHWHFHUWDPHQWH OD SRVVLELOLWj GL YHGHUH XQD GL TXHVWH IHVWH WDQWR LQ SLFFROL SDHVL TXDQWR LQ JUDQGL FLWWjFRPH3DOHUPR6LHQDHFF
6RQR IHVWH GL FDUDWWHUH SROLWLFR FRPH OD IHVWD GHOO¶8QLWj OD IHVWD GHOOH GRQQH FLRq OD IHVWD GHOO¶ PDU]R JDVWURQRPLFR OH VDJUH FRQ OH GLYHUVH VSHFLDOLWj UHJLRQDOL H UHOLJLRVR VSHFLDOPHQWH LQDJRVWROHGLYHUVHIHVWHGHOOD0DGRQQD PDVRSUDWWXWWRSRSRODUH ODVHUDFLVRQRFRQFHUWLGLFDQWDQWLSLRPHQRIDPRVLVSHWWDFROLWHDWUDOLEDOOLHGHOODEXRQDPXVLFD $QFKHLQIHEEUDLRHPDU]RFLVRQRGHOOHPDQLIHVWD]LRQLSRSRODULPROWRLQWHUHVVDQWLQRQVROR SHU JOL LWDOLDQL SHU HVVHPSLR LO FDUQHYDOH 'D DOFXQL DQQL LO &DUQHYDOH GL 9HQH]LD q GL QXRYR IDPRVRPDFLVRQRGHOOHIDPRVHIHVWHLQSLD]]DSHULOFDUQHYDOHDQFKHLQFLWWjSLSLFFROHHLQSDHVL GHO6XGHGHO1RUGD,YUHDLQ3LHPRQWHD%DULLQ3XJOLDLQ6DUGHJQDHFF
8QLWj
&+(25(6212" C
&KHRUDq3DROR"
ÊO¶XQD
0DPPDPLDFKHWDUGL
D
&KHRUHVRQR"
6RQROHGLHFLHPH]]RPH]]D
$FFLGHQWLVRQRLQULWDUGR
XQGLFL
GRGLFL
WUHGLFL
TXDWWRUGLFL
TXLQGLFL
VHGLFL
GLFLDVVHWWH
GLFLRWWR
GLFLDQQRYH
YHQWL
YHQWXQR
YHQWLGXH
YHQWRWWR
YHQWLQRYH
WUHQWD
WUHQWXQR
WUHQWDGXH
WUHQWRWWR
WUHQWDQRYH
TXDUDQWD
TXDUDQWXQR
TXDUDQWDGXH
TXDUDQWRWWR
TXDUDQWDQRYH
FLQTXDQWD
FLQTXDQWXQR
FLQTXDQWDGXH
FLQTXDQWRWWR
FLQTXDQWDQRYH
C
D
6DLFKHRUDq/RUHQ]D"
+DLO¶RUD*LDFRPR"
6uVRQROHWUHPHQRXQ TXDUWR
6u«OHVHLLQSXQWR
&KH EHOOR Ê DQFRUD SUHVWR $OORUD UHVWR DQFRUDXQSR¶TXL
0HQRPDOH1RQqWDUGL$OORUDDUULYRDQFRUDLQ WHPSR
C
6RQRJLjOHXQGLFL3LHUR"
1RQVRQRQKRO¶RURORJLR
D
$OORUD3LHURFKHRUHVRQR"
0H]]DQRWWHPHQRYHQWL
&2081,&$5( 6DL
FKHRUDq"
6D
FKHRUHVRQR"
1R
QRQORVR
QRQKRO¶RURORJLR
6DSHWH +DL
3HFFDWR*UD]LHORVWHVVR
VDSSLDPR
PLGLVSLDFH
O¶RUD
SXUWURSSR
+D $YHWH
6u
q
PH]]RJLRUQR
&KHEHOOR
qDQFRUDSUHVWR
PH]]DQRWWH
0HQRPDOH
QRQqWDUGL
ODPH]]D
KRDQFRUDWHPSR
O¶XQDH«
QRQVRQRLQULWDUGR
OH
DUULYRDQFRUD
LQWHPSR
0DPPDPLD
qWDUGL
$FFLGHQWL
qJLjWDUGL
qPROWRWDULG FKHWDUGL VRQRLQULWDUGR QRQKRSLWHPSR
$FKHRUDDQGDWHGD)UDQFDVWDVHUD"
$OOHRWWRHPH]]R
4XDQGRYDLGDOPHGLFR*LXOHWWD"
6WDPDWWLQD+RXQDSSXQWDPHQWRDOOH
1LQDDFKHRUDYDLDOH]LRQHTXHVWRSRPHULJJLR"
9DGRYLDYHUVROHWUHHPH]]D+ROH]LRQHGDOOHTXDWWURDOOHVHL
)LQRDOOHVHL"$OORUDQRQYDLDSUHQGHUH*LDQFDUORDOODVWD]LRQH"
0DVu6HFLYDGRVXELWRGRSRODOH]LRQHFRQODPDFFKLQDGL)UDQFRDUULYRDQFRUDLQWHPSR
%HQH$OORUDVLHWHWXWWLDFDVDGRSROHVHWWHYHUR"
6uFHUWR/RVSHWWDFRORFRPLQFLDVRORDOOHQRYHQR"
6uVu QRYHPEUH OXQHGu
OH]LRQHOHJJHUHLOWHVWRSDJ VWD]LRQH 1%WHOHIRQDUH D)UDQFRSHU
ODPDFFKLQD VSHWWDFROR
&2081,&$5( $FKHRUD
YDL YD DQGDWH
&LYDGR
FDVD
D
OH]LRQH ODYRUR
DO
DQGLDPR
FRUVRGLIUDQFHVH
YHUVROH
GRSROH
IHVWDGL*LQD
VDJUDGHOYLQR GD
6HUJLR
GDO
PHGLFR
GHQWLVWD
GDOOR
]LR&DUOR
GDOO¶
LQVHJQDQWHGL«
GDOOD
VLJQRUD«
WXDDPLFD &UHVFL
GDJOL
6FHQD
GDOOH
WXHDPLFKH
VWDPDWWLQD
TXHVWDPDWWLQD
VWDVHUD
TXHVWDVHUD
VWDQRWWH
TXHVWDQRWWH
TXHVWRSRPHULJJLR RJJLSRPHULJJLR
&KHJLRUQRqRJJL"
0DUWHGuSHUFKp"
+RXQDSSXQWDPHQWRGDOGHQWLVWD
(DFKHRUD"
$OOHTXDWWURPHQRXQ TXDWUR
$OORUDDUULYLDQFRUDLQWHPSR
«
GDL
RJJL
«HTXDQGRFLYHGLDPR"
/DSURVVLPDVHWWLPDQDYDEHQH"
6uPDFKHJLRUQR"
0DUWHGu/XQHGuVRQRDQFRUDLQ6LFLOLD
$KVu$OORUDPDUWHGu(FKHRUD"
&HUFRGLHVVHUHDFDVDWXDIUDOHVHWWHHOHVHWWH HPH]]RG¶DFFRUGR"
FRPSOHDQQRGL« DOOD
DOOH
%HQLVVLPR DFDVDPLD
ODPLQHDFDV
DFDVDWXD
ODWLQHDFDV
DFDVDVXD
ODHOHDDFDV
DFDVD6XD
OD'XPQHDYRDVWU
LOODGHQWLVWD
FRPXQLVWD
WXULVWD
VRFLDOLVWD
JLRUQDOLVWD
IDVFLVWD
DFDV
&2081,&$5(
(TXDQGRFLYHGLDPR
/XQHGu 0DUWHGu 0HUFROHGu *LRYHGu 9HQHUGu 6DEDWR 'RPHQLFD
%HQHDOORUDDUULYHUGHUFLDOXQHGu PDUWHGu «
2JJLqLOYHUR"
6uSHUFKp"
%LVRJQDWHOHIRQDUHD0DULDqLOVXRFRPSOHDQQR
$KVuPDIRUVHqPHJOLRSDVVDUHDFDVDVXD
6uqYHUR$OORUDFLDQGLDPRLQSRPHULJJLR
4XDQWLQHDEELDPRRJJL"
2JJLqO¶XQGLFL
$KPHQRPDOH+RDQFRUDXQDVHWWLPDQDGLWHPSRSHUSDJDUHO¶DVVLFXUD]LRQHGHOODPDFFKLQD
4XDQGRYDLDWURYDUHWXDPDGUHLQ,WDOLD,YRQD"
,OSULPR
(TXDQGRVHLGLQXRYRD%XFDUHVW"
,OYHQWL
ÊYHQHUGuQR"$OORUDFLYHGLDPRYHQHUGuVHUDDFDVDPLDG¶DFFRUGR"
&2081,&$5( &KH
JLRUQR
RJJL"
q
/XQHGu
$OORUD
RJJL
q
0DUWHGu
ODIHVWDGL)UDQFR LOFRPSOHDQQRGL1LQD
«
ELVRJQD
WHOHIRQDUHDOO¶DVVLFXUD]LRQH DOO¶LQVHJQDQWHGL« DO¶XIILFLRYLDJJL
4XDQWLQH
,OSULPR
DEELDPRRJJL"
GXH
DOPHGLFR DOSURIHVVRUH
WUH
SDVDUHGD/XLJL
«
DQGDUHGDL&DVLUDJKL
/¶RWWREUH «
SDJDUHO¶DVVLFXUD]LRQH VWDPDWWLQD
KR
XQDSSXQWDPHQWRGDOO¶DYYRFDWR
/¶XQGLFL
GDOPHGLFR
«
GDOGHQWLVWD GDOGRWWRUH FRQ6WHIDQR F¶q
XQPDWLQHq
TXHVWR SR
XQFRQFHUWRDOO¶XQLYHUVLWj
PHULJJLR
ODEDQGDLQSLD]]D ODOH]LRQHG¶LWDOLDQR LOFRUVRGLJLQQDVWLFD
VWDVHUD
LOWHDWURLQSLD]]D O¶©$LGDª O¶©2WHOORª LO©5LJROHWWRª DUULYD
LOPLRFRQRVFHQWHGL7RULQR
ULWRUQD
PLRIUDWHOORGDOOHYDFDQ]H PLDILJOLDGD3HUXJLD
/(25(
,/*,2512
qO¶XQD
qLOSULPR
VRQROHGXH
qLOGXH
DOOH
LO
ILQRDOOH
ILQRDO
GDOOHDOOH
GDODO
YHUVROH
YHUVRLO
GRSROH
GRSRLO
IUDOHHOH
IUDLOLO
SULPDGHOOH
SULPDGHO
&LDR7LQD$FKHRUDYLHQLJLRYHGu"
$OOHRWWRG¶DFFRUGR"
6uYDEHQH$QFK¶LRDUULYRGDOO¶XIILFLRYHUVROHRWWR
6HDUULYLSLWDUGLDVSHWWRDOEDU
%HQH$OORUDDJLRYHGu
3URQWR3DROD"$OORUDTXDQGRYLHQLDWURYDUFL"
6HVLHWHG¶DFFRUGRYHQJRLOFRQ1LFROHWWD
,OqVDEDWRYHUR"
6u
%HQLVVLPR$OORUDYHQLDPRDOODVWD]LRQH$FKHRUDDUULYL"
$OOH
%HQH(5HQ]RILQRDTXDQGRqDOFRQJUHVVRLQ)UDQFLD"
)LQRDO9LHQHDSUHQGHUFLFRQODPDFFKLQDLO
0DQRQUHVWDTXLDOPHQRXQRRGXHJLRUQL"
8QJLRUQRIRUVH«
&RVuSRFR&KHSHFFDWR
(KVu0DLOKDXUJHQWLLPSHJQLGLODYRUR&RPXQTXHFLYHGLDPRWXWWLD3DVTXD
+DLUDJLRQH$OORUDLQWDQWRDVDEDWR
6u&LDRPDPPDHWDQWLVDOXWLDSDSj
4XDQGRYHQJRQRLWXRLJHQLWRUL/DXUD"
'RPHQLFDPDWWLQD
9DLDOODVWD]LRQH"
6uDOOHGLHFLPDVRQRVHQ]DPDFFKLQD
$OORUDFLYHQJRDQFK¶LR&LDQGLDPRFRQODPLDYDEHQH"
2KJUD]LH$QWRQLRVHLXQYHURWHVRUR
3URQWR5RVDOED"$FKHRUDYHQLWHGRSRGRPDQL"
,R YHQJR IUD OH H OH H PH]]D 3ULPD KR XQ DSSXQWDPHQWR GDO GHQWLVWD $UULYR FRQ OD PHWURSROLWDQD9DEHQHFRVu&KLDUD"
%HQLVVLPR+ROH]LRQHVRORGDOOHDOOHHDOOHVRQRFHUWDPHQWHDFDVD()UDQFRQRQYLHQH"
0D Vu FKH YLHQH 3HUz DUULYD GRSR OH SHUFKp GRSRGRPDQL LQ XIILFLR FL VRQR L VXRL FROOHJKL LQJOHVLHOXLFLVWDILQRDOOH
9HQJROXQHGuRPHUFROHGuVLJQRUD*XJJL"
4XDQGRYDPHJOLRSHU/HL"
ÊOHVWHVVR
%HQHDOORUDIRUVHqPHJOLRPHUFROHGuSHUFKpILQRDOXQHGuKRTXLLPLHLDPLFLWHGHVFKLHQRQVR DQFRUDDFKHRUDYDQQRYLD
PLRSDGUH PLDPDGUH WXRSDGUH WXDPDGUH VXRSDGUH VXDPDGUH
LPLHLJHQLWRUL
LWXRLJHQLWRUL
LVXRLJHQLWRUL
PLDVRUHOOD±OHPLHVRUHOOH WXDVRUHOOD±OHWXHVRUHOOH 1%$UWLFROXOKRW UkWvQVR HúWHQXPDLIRUPHOHGHSOXUDO
9HQJR"
YHQLUH YHQJR YLHQL
YHQLDPR
DQGDUHDWURYDUH
YHQLWH
YHQLUHDWURYDUH
YHQJRQR
DQGDUHDSUHQGHUH YHQLUHDSUHQGHUH
YLHQH
C
4XDQGRYLHQH3DROR"
,QJHQQDLR
D
4XDQGRDQGDWHLQIHULH"
$OO¶LQL]LRGLDJRVWR
C
4XDQGRYLHQHWXDPDGUH"
$PHWj/XJOLR
D
4XDQGRYDLLQ,WDOLD"
$OODILQHGLJLXJQR
&2081,&$5( 4XDQGR
YLHQL
TXL
YLHQH
LQ*HUPDQLD
YHQLWH
D*HQRYD
9HQJR
9HQLDPR
DWURYDUFL
LQ
JHQQDLR
LOSULPR
IHEEUDLR
GXH
PDU]R
«
DSULOH
O¶RWWREUH
PDJJLR
O¶XQGLFL
JLXJQR
«
OXJOLR
YHUVRLO
DJRVWR
«
VHWWHPEUH
DOO¶LQL]LRGL
RWWREUH
DOODILQHGL
QRYHPEUH
DPHWj
GLFHPEUH
%XRQDVHUDVLJQRUD6FLSSLÊYHURFKHTXHVW¶DQQRYDLQYDFDQ]DLQ6DUGHJQD"
6uDQGLDPRD3DODXDWURYDUHDPLFL
(TXDQGRFLDQGDWH"
'DOSULPRDOOXJOLR
&KHEHOOR,RVRQRD9LJQRODGDO,XJOLRDODJRVWR)RUVHFLYHGLDPR"
0DFHUWR&ODXGLD9DLVRODD9LJQROD"
1RFRQXQDFROOHJD$EELDPRXQDFDPHUDDOO¶+RWHO©6SLDJJLDG¶2URª
$OORUDFLWHOHIRQLDPRLOYHUVROHGLVHUDSHUGDUFLXQDSSXQWDPHQWR9DEHQH"
%HQLVVLPR
+DLLOQXPHURGHOO¶DOEHUJR"
6uXQPRPHQWRq0DLOSUHILVVRGL9LJQRODQRQORVR
9DEHQHFRVu1RQFLYDLFRQODPDFFKLQDYHUR"
1R,RHODPLDFROOHJDQRQDEELDPRODPDFFKLQD
$OORUDqPHJOLRFKHYHQLDPRQRLD9LJQROD«qDQFKHXQOXRJRFRVuEHOOR
%HQLVVLPR$OORUDDUULYHUGHUFLLQ6DUGHJQDVLJQRUD
6uHLOWHOHIRQRLR&LDR&ODXGLD
&2081,&$5( (TXDQGR
YLHQL
3UHVWRGRPDQLGRSRGRPDQL
YLHQH
$OOHYHUVROHGRSROH
YHQLWH
)UDOHHOH /XQHGuPDUWHGu« /DVHWWLPDQDSURVVLPDODSURVVLPDVHWWLPDQD ,ODSULOH YHUVRLOPDJJLRGRSRLO« )UDLOHLO ,OPHVHSURVVLPR ,QJHQQDLRIHEEUDLR« $1DWDOHD3DTXD ,OSURVVLPRDQQRO¶DQQRSURVVLPR
%HQHDOORUDDUULYHGHUFL
DSLWDUGL
$UULYHGHUFL
DSUHVWR
(LQWDQWRWDQWHEHOOHFRVH
DOOH« DO« DOO¶« DOODSURVVLPD VHWWLPDQD«
8QLWj
,//$9252
6RQR /XLJL%DUGLKRRWWRDQQLHDELWRD&RVHQ]D/DPDWWLQDYDGRD VFXROD D SLHGL R FRQ OD ELFLFOHWWDSHUFKpODVFXRODqYLFLQD&RPLQFLDPRDOOHRWWRHPH]]RHLRYDGRYLDGDFDVDDOOHRWWRH GLHFL 'RSR OD VFXROD D PH]]RJLRUQR H PH]]R YDGR D FDVD D PDQJLDUH ,O SRPHULJJLR IDFFLR L FRPSLWLHVWRFRQLPLHLDPLFL*XDUGROD79RYDGRGDLQRQQL 0LFKLDPR$QWRQLD&DVWHOOLVRQRVSRVDWDPDQRQKRDQFRUDILJOL ,RVRQRLQIHUPLHUD HPLR PDULWRODYRUDLQXQ¶DJHQ]LDWXULVWLFD 2JQLJLRUQRPLDO]RDOOHVHWWHPHQRXQ TXDUWR3ULPDSUHSDURLOFDIIqHIDFFLDPRFROD]LRQH LQVLHPH 3RL YHUVR OH VHWWH H PH]]D SRUWR PLR PDULWR DOO¶DJHQ]LD LQ PDFFKLQD H GRSR YDGR DOO¶RVSHGDOH'LVROLWRODYRURGDOOHRWWRDOOHTXDWWURFRQXQDEUHYHSDXVDSHULOSUDQ]R0DQJLRDOOD PHQVD0LRPDULWRLQYHFHSUDQ]DTXDVLVHPSUHGDVXDPDGUHFKHDELWDYLFLQRDOVXRXIILFLR 'RSRLOODYRURIDFFLRODVSHVD HYDGR DSUHQGHUHPLRPDULWR$UULYDWD ILQDOPHQWH D FDVD PL ULSRVRXQSR¶HSRLSUHSDURODFHQD 7DOYROWDIDFFLRDQFKHLOWXUQRGLQRWWH 0LR PDULWR ODYRUD VSHVVR DQFKH GL VHUD ID WUDGX]LRQL H VFULYH OHWWHUH LQ LQJOHVH H WHGHVFR D FOLHQWLVWUDQLHULGHOVXRXIILFLR $QFK¶LRQHOWHPSROLEHURPLRFFXSRGLOLQJXHRJQLJLRYHGuIUHTXHQWRXQFRUVRGLVSDJQROR 9(5%(/(5()/(;,9( ULSRVDUVL±DVHRGLKQL
PLULSRVR
DO]DUVL
DVHWUH]L
WLULSRVL
RFFXSDUVLGL«
DVHRFXSDGH
LQWHUHVVDUVLGL«
DVHLQWHUHVDGH
LQIRUPDUVLGL«
DVHLQIRUPDGHVSUH
LQFRQWUDUVL
DVHvQWkOQL
FLULSRVLDPR
WURYDUVL
DVHDIOD
YLULSRVDWH
VHQWLUVL
DVHVLP L
VLULSRVD
VLULSRVDQR 9HUEHOHUHIOH[LYHLWDOLHQHVHOHFWHD] ODWLPSXULOHFRPSXVHDX[LOLDUXO(66(5( PLVRQRRFFXSDWRDPDPRFXSDW
&2081,&$5( $FKHRUD
WLDO]L
ODPDWWLQD
'LVROLWR
PLDO]R
VLDO]D
YHUVROH«
YLDO]DWH
FLDO]LDPR
GRSROH«
VLDO]DQRL«
VLDO]DQR
IUDOH«HOH«
IDFFLR
ODGRFFLD
&2081,&$5( &KHFRVD
DOOH«
IDL
ODPDWWLQD
3ULPD
ID
GLPDWWLQD
SRL HGRSR
IDWH IDQQR
LEDPELQL
LO
UDJD]]L
GL QHO
SRPHULJJLR
FROD]LRQH IDFFLDPR
JLQQDVWLFD
IDQQR
ODVSHVD LOSUDQ]R LODYRULGLFDVD LFRPSLWL
ODVHUD
XQSR¶GLVSRUW
GLVHUD
XQDWUDGX]LRQH ODFHQD XQFRUVRGL«
,OPLRQRPHq/RUHQ]D5HJDKRYHQW¶DQQLHVRQRVWXGHQWHVVDGLDUFKLWHWWXUD $ELWR DG $VWL H VWXGLR DOO¶XQLYHUVLWj GL 7RULQR 2JQL PDUWHGu JLRYHGu H YHQHUGu YDGR D 7RULQR FRQ LO WUHQR SHUFKp QRQ KR OD PDFFKLQD 3DUWR YHUVR OH RWWR H D 7RULQR SUHQGR LO WUDP R O¶DXWREXV $PH]]RJLRUQRPDQJLRTXDOFRVDLQFLWWjHULWRUQRDFDVDGRSROHOH]LRQL 4XDOFKHYROWDPLLQFRQWURD7RULQRFRQDOWULVWXGHQWLHGRUPRGDXQ¶DPLFD 0LLQWHUHVVRDQFKHGLDUUHQGDPHQWRHLOPHUFROHGuPDWWLQDODYRURTXDOFKHRUDQHOORVWXGLRGL XQ DUFKLWHWWR TXL DG $VWL &RVu KR OD SRVVLELOLWj GL LPSDUDUH TXDOFRVD H GL JXDGDJQDUH XQ SR¶ q SURSULRXQDEXRQDVROX]LRQH 6RQR &DUOR &DUXVR KR DQQL H YLYR FRQ PLD PRJOLH D %RORJQD GRYH VRQR DQFKH QDWR 6LFFRPH L QRVWUL GXH ILJOL VRQR JLj JUDQGL H QRQ DELWDQR SL D FDVD QRVWUD DQFKH PLD PRJOLH KD ULFRPLQFLDWRDODYRUDUHIDO¶LQVHJQDQWHDOOLFHRHGqPROWRFRQWHQWD /DPDWWLQDSRUWRPLDPRJOLHDVFXRODLQPDFFKLQDHSRLYDGRLQXIILFLR6RQRLQJHJQHUHHPL RFFXSRGLHOHWWURQLFD ,OSUDQ]R"+RXQDSDXVDGLODYRURPROWREUHYHGDOO¶XQD DOOHGXHHQRQYDGRD FDVDSHUFKp PLDPRJOLHKDVFXRODILQRDOO¶XQDHPH]]D 0ROWLYDQQRDPDQJLDUHTXDOFRVDTXLLQFHQWUR,OPLRFROOHJDSHUHVHPSLRYDTXDVLVHPSUH DOOD WUDWWRULD TXL YLFLQR GRYH VL LQFRQWUD FRQ DOWUL FROOHJKL PDQJLD EHQH H VSHQGH SRFR 0D LR GL VROLWRSUHQGRVRORTXDOFRVDDOEDU 3UHIHULVFRPDQJLDUHODVHUDDQFKHSHUFKpPLDPRJOLHFXFLQDPROWREHQH
4XDOqODWXDSURIHVVLRQH"&RVDIDLQHOODYLWD "
6RQRLQVHJQDQWH)DFFLRO¶LQVHJQDQWH
LOPLRFROOHJD LPLHLFROOHJKL
TXDOFRVD
ODPLDFROOHJD OHPLHFROOHJKH
&2081,&$5( &RPH
YDL
D
YD DQGDWH
TXDOFKHFRVD
DOFXQHFRVH
TXDOFKHYROWD
DOFXQHYROWH
TXDOFKHJLRUQR
DOFXQLJLRUQL
VFXROD
&L
YDGR
7RULQR DO
ODYRUR
DOO¶
XQLYHUVLWj
D
SLHGL
FRQODLQ
ELFLFOHWWD
DQGLDPR
PRWRFLFOHWWD PDFFKLQD
DJHQ]LD
PHWURSROLWDQD
RVSHGDOH DOOR
VWXGLR
LQ
XIILFLR
WUHQR
FRQLOLQ
WUDP DXWREXV
FRQOLQ
EDQFD
DHUHR
IDEEULFD YDFDQ]D
&2081,&$5( 'RYH
WLLQFRQWUL
FRQL
WXRL
FROOHJKL
VLLQFRQWUD
6XRL
DPLFL
YLLQFRQWUDWH
YRVWUL
FRQRVFHQWL SDUHQWL
&LLQFRQWULDPR
D
FDVDQRVWUD
DO
EDU ULVWRUDQWH
DOOD
PHQVD WUDWWRULD
LQ
FLWWj FHQWUR
0L FKLDPR *LDFRPR &DQGROLQL H VRQR RSHUDLR /DYRUR LQ IDEEULFD TXL D 8GLQH PD YLYR LQ SURYLQFLDHRJQL JLRUQRYDGRVX H JLLQWUHQR+RTXDVLXQ¶RUDH PH]]R GL YLDJJLR /D PDFFKLQD q SL FRPRGD FHUWR 0D FRQ LO SUH]]R GHOOD EHQ]LQD FRVWD WURSSR )LQLVFR GL ODYRUDUH DOOH VHWWH H DUULYR D FDVD YHUVR OH QRYH SHUFKp GD TXL D FDVD PLD QRQ F¶q XQD OLQHD GLUHWWD PD D 3DOPDQRYD ELVRJQD FDPELDUH WUHQR 6H SHUGR OD FRLQFLGHQ]D ULWRUQR DQFRUD SL WDUGL H TXDQGR DUULYR PLD PRJOLH GRUPH JLj OHL OD PDWWLQD VL DO]D PROWR SUHVWR SHUFKp FRPLQFLD D ODYRUDUH DO SDQLILFLR JLj DOOHVHL0DDOO¶XQDILQLVFHHGqVXELWRDFDVDFRQLEDPELQL
/DYRUR DO &RPXQH GL )LUHQ]H GDOOH RWWR DOOH GXH VHQ]D SDXVD &RQ TXHVW¶RUDULR GL ODYRUR FRQWLQXDWR PL WURYR PROWR EHQH SHUFKp DOOH GXH H PH]]R VRQR JLj D FDVD &RQ LO WUDIILFR FKH F¶q PLRPDULWRHGLRSUHIHULDPRODVFLDUHODPDFFKLQDDFDVDGXUDQWHLOJLRUQRDQFKHSHUFKpDELWLDPRLQ XQ TXDUWLHUH QRQ ORQWDQR GDO FHQWUR H FL VRQR EXRQL PH]]L SXEEOLFL ( LQROWUH QRQ VL WURYD PDL XQ SDUFKHJJLR $UULYDWD D FDVD PDQJLR TXDOFRVD LQVLHPH D PLR PDULWR 0LFKHOH $EELDPR XQ SLFFROR QHJR]LRGLYHVWLWLSHUEDPELQLQHOFHQWURVWRULFR0LRPDULWRFLODYRUDWXWWRLOJLRUQR FRQXQDSDXVD GLGXHRUHSHULOSUDQ]R,RFLYDGRSHUTXDOFKHRUD±GLVROLWRGDOOHFLQTXHLQSRL±TXDQGRPLVRQR ULSRVDWDXQSR¶/DVHUDQRQVLDPRPDLDFDVDSULPDGHOOHQRYH4XDQGRDUULYRSUHSDURODFHQDPD TXDOFKH YROWD DQGLDPR D PDQJLDUH IXRUL FL LQFRQWULDPR FRQ DOFXQL DPLFL H FL GLYHUWLDPR XQ SR¶ 9LYHUHFRVuPLSLDFH
YLFLQRDOFHQWUR ORQWDQRGDOFHQWUR
QRQVRQRPDL
VH VHKRWHPSR TXDQGRDUULYR
'DGRPDQLEHQ]LQDSLFDUD PDODPDJJLRUSDUWHGHJOLLWDOLDQLSUHIHULVFHDQFRUDODPDFFKLQD
LRSUHIHULVFR
QRLSUHIHULDPR
ILQLUH
WXSUHIHULVFL
YRLSUHIHULWH
FDSLUH
ORURSUHIHULVFRQR
SXOLUH
OXL OHL
SUHIHULVFH
LQFHQWUR
QHOFHQWURVWRULFR
QHLJLRUQLIHVWLYL
LQFLWWj
QHOODJUDQGHFLWWj
QHJOLDQQLSDVVDWL
LQ,WDOLD
QHOO¶,WDOLDFHQWUDOH
QHOOHSURVVLPHVHWWLPDQH
&2081,&$5(
&DSLVFL &DSLVFH
EHQH
LOWHGHVFR
6u
ORFDSLVFR
IUDQFHVH
&DSLWH
O¶LQJOHVH
FDSLVFRPR
ORVSDJQROR
PROWREHQH 1RQRQ
FDSLDPR
LWDOLDQR ,WXRL
EDPELQL
6XRL
ILJOL
YRVWUL
DPLFL
VYHGHVH
EHQH
FDSLVFRPR
DEEDVWDQ]DEHQH
&2081,&$5( 4XDQGR
GLODYRUDUH
ILQLVFL
)LQLVFR
DOOH«
ILQLVFH
VWXGLDUH
YHUVROH«
ILQLWH
IDUHLOPLOLWDUH
)LQLDPR
LO«
ILQLVFRQR
IDUHJOLHVDPL
)LQLVFRQR
LQ«
0LFKLDPR3LHUR)RUQDFLDULKRDQQLGDXQDQQRKRODPDWXULWjHFHUFRODYRUR6RQRXQR GHL WDQWL JLRYDQL LWDOLDQL GLVRFFXSDWL 1RQ q IDFLOH PD LR PL VRQR XQ SR¶ RUJDQL]]DWR 'XUDQWH OD JLRUQDWDVRQRVHPSUHLQJLUR 0L DO]R DOOH VHWWH IDFFLR OD GRFFLD SUHQGR XQ FDIIq H YDGR D FRPSUDUH LO JLRUQDOH SHU JXDUGDUH JOL DQQXQFL 3DVVR DQFKH DOO¶XIILFLR FROORFDPHQWR H PL LQIRUPR VH F¶q TXDOFKH SRVVLELOLWj 6H WURYR TXDOFRVD WHOHIRQR R FL YDGR 0D VRQR VHPSUH ODYRUL SHU SRFKL JLRUQL $ PH]]RJLRUQR H PH]]RWRUQRDFDVD±DELWRDQFRUDFRQLPLHLJHQLWRUL±HSUDQ]LDPRWXWWLLQVLHPH ,OSRPHULJJLRGzOH]LRQLGLPDWHPDWLFDRIDFFLRTXDOFKHVHPSOLFHODYRUHWWR )UDTXDWWURPHVLYDGRPLOLWDUHHSRLYHGLDPR
2FFDVLRQLSHUJLRYDQL &(5&+,$02JLRYDQLDPERVHVVLDQFKHVHQ]DHVSHULHQ]D LQWHUHVVDWLVHWWRUHLQIRUPDWLFD0LODQR 7,32*5$),$FHUFDUDJD]]RWXWWRIDUH 7HOHIRQDUHRUHSDVWL &(5&+,$02VWXGHQWHSHUOH]LRQLG¶LQJOHVHWHU]DPHGLD 7HOHIRQDUH
5LFHUFDGLSHUVRQDOH &203$*1,$WHDWUDOHFHUFDWHFQLFROXFLSHU SURJUDPPD]LRQHWRXUQpHHVWLYD7HOHIRQDUHRUDULRXIILFLRGD OXQHGLGDOOHRUHDO &21,8*,DQ]LDQLFHUFDQRGRQQDWXWWRIDUHILVVDUHIHUHQ]LDWD 7HOHIRQDUH &$6$GLFXUDSULYDWDYLFLQDQ]H0LODQRULFHUFDSHU DVVXQ]LRQHLPPHGLDWDLQIHUPLHULHSURIHVVLRQDOLRJHQHULFL 6FULYHUHD&RUULHUH±+0LODQRRWHOHIRQDUHDOOR RUHXIILFLR
6RQRYHQXWDTXLD5DYHQQDQHOO¶RWWDQWDWUH GRSRODPRUWHGLPLRPDULWR'D DOORUDYLYR FRQLPLHLILJOL0DWWHR5DIIDHOODH*LXOLDGLHDQQLHKRULFRPLQFLDWRDODYRUDUH3ULPDGHO PDWULPRQLRSHUDOFXQLDQQLPLVRQRRFFXSDWDGLSXEEOLFLWjPDRUDODYRURLQEDQFD /DPDWWLQDSRUWR*LXOLDDOO¶DVLORHJOLDOWULYDQQRLQELFLFOHWWDDVFXROD 3RLYDGRLQEDQFDHODYRURILQRDOOH3HUIRUWXQDKRWURYDWRXQDVLJQRUDFKHVLRFFXSDGHOOD FDVDHGHLEDPELQLPHQWUHLRVRQRLQEDQFDSXOLVFHHPHWWHDSRVWRODFDVDIDODVSHVDFXFLQDHYDD SUHQGHUH*LXOLDDOO¶DVLOR'RSRO¶XQDHPH]]DTXDQGRLEDPELQLVRQRULWRUQDWLGDVFXRODPDQJLDQR WXWWLLQVLHPH 1HO SRPHULJJLR L UDJD]]L IDQQR L FRPSLWL YDQQR D IDUH XQ SR¶ GL VSRUW D FDVD GL DPLFL R JXDUGDQROD79 ,RODVHUDGRSRLOODYRURSUHIHULVFRVWDUHFRQLEDPELQLHSRLTXDQGRGRUPRQRVRQRWURSSR VWDQFD SHU DQGDUH GD TXDOFKH SDUWH 6ROR RJQL WDQWR YDGR IXRUL FRQ TXDOFKH FROOHJD PD DOWULPHQWL FRQ WUH EDPELQL XQD FDVD H LO ODYRUR SHU XQD GRQQD GHOOD PLD HWj q GLIILFLOH DYHUH DOWUL FRQWDWWL 3HUFLzQRQFRQRVFRDQFRUDPROWDJHQWHTXLD5DYHQQD
PHQWUHYHUE
GXUDQWHDUWLFROVXEVWDQWLY
PHQWUHVRQRLQEDQFD« GXUDQWHLOJLRUQR«
+R VHVVDQWRWWR DQQL H GDO VHWWDQWD DELWR VROD TXL QHOOD FLWWj YHFFKLD 0LR ILJOLR &DUOR DELWDD0LODQRFRQODVXDIDPLJOLD+DSRFRWHPSRPDWHOHIRQDVSHVVR /DPLDJLRUQDWD"ÊPROWRPRQRWRQD 2JQLPDWWLQDSUHVWRIDFFLRODVSHVDQHLQHJR]LTXLDOO¶DQJRORPHWWRDSRVWRODFDVDSUHSDUR LOSUDQ]R«SRLQRQKRSLPROWRGDIDUHHDVFROWRYROHQWLHULODUDGLR ,O SRPHULJJLR RJQL WDQWR YDGR D WURYDUH OD PLD DPLFD 0DULD FKH DELWD GDOO¶DOWUD SDUWH GHOOD FLWWjHSUHQGLDPRLOFDIIqLQVLHPHRDQGLDPRDLJLDUGLQLSXEEOLFL0DGLVROLWRVWRDFDVDOHJJRXQD ULYLVWDRXQEXRQOLEURRJXDUGROD79LOWHOHJLRUQDOHSHUVHQWLUHOHQRWL]LHLILOPG¶DPRUHTXDOFKH EXRQILOPJLDOORRXQ¶RSHUDVXOWHU]RSURJUDPPD 0DSHUORSLYDGRDOHWWRSUHVWR , PLHL YLFLQL GL FDVD LQYHFH VRQR WXWWL PROWR RFFXSDWL YDQQR YLD OD PDWWLQD H ULWRUQDQR OD VHUD(KVRQRJLRYDQLORUR0DVRQRDQFKHPROWRJHQWLOLVD"$LXWDQRVHKRELVRJQRGLTXDOFRVDVH QRQ PL VHQWR EHQH FKLDPDQR LO PHGLFR YDQQR D SUHQGHUH OH PHGLFLQH H IDQQR OD VSHVD 6SHVVR VXRQDQRRWHOHIRQDQRSHUVDSHUHFRPHVWR 4XDQGRSDUWRQRSHUOHYDFDQ]HODVFLDQRTXLOHORURFKLDYL
QRVWURYRVWURILJOLR
LOORURILJOLR
3RVHVLYXO
QRVWUDYRVWUDILJOLD
ODORURILJOLD
vQWRWGHDXQD
³ORUR´
LQRVWULYRVWULILJOL
LORURILJOL
DUWLFRO
OHQRVWUHYRVWUHILJOLH
OHORURILJOLH
HVWH
vQVR LW
DYHUHWHPSRGLIDUH
DQGDUHDSUHQGHUH
DYHUHGDIDUH
FHUFDUHGLIDUH
YHQLUHDWURYDUH
F¶qGDIDUH
ODSRVVLELOLWjGL«
FRPLQFLDUHDORYRUDUH
ILQLUHGL«
FRQWLQXDUHDVWXGLDUH
GH
+RELVRJQRGLXQPHGLFR %LVRJQDFKLDPDUHLOPHGLFR
&2081,&$5( 'LFKHFRVD
WLRFFXSL
QHO
WXR
WHPSROLEHUR"
0LRFFXSR
GL
PXVLFD
VLRFFXSD
6XR
YLRFFXSDWH
YRVWUR
&LRFFXSLDPR
VSRUW OLQJXH
VLRFFXSDQR
ORUR
6LRFFXSDQR
SROLWLFD VWRULD DUFKLWHWWXUD ILORVRILD DUUHGDPHQWR DUWHPRGHUQD DUWHDQWLFD GDQ]D IRONORUH SLWWXUD MD]] DUFKHRORJLD PRELOLDQWLFKL
1829,25$5,',/$92523(59,9(5(0(*/,2 /HWWHUHDOO¶(XURSHR 6LVDFKHLQPROWHJUDQGLFLWWjLWDOLDQHLQDOFXQHRUHGHOJLRUQRLOWUDIILFRqYHUDPHQWHFDRWLFR HVLUHVWDEORFFDWLSHUVWUDGDSHUPROWLVVLPRWHPSR(TXHVWRSHUFKpODJHQWHDOPDWWLQRYDDOODYRUR LQ PDFFKLQD LQ DXWREXV LQ WUDP GRSR PH]]RJLRUQR YD D FDVD D SUDQ]R QHOOH SULPH RUH GHO SRPHULJJLRULWRUQDLQXIILFLRRLQIDEEULFDHODVHUDULWRUQDDFDVD Ê YHUDPHQWH DVVXUGR IDUH VX H JL TXDWWUR YROWH DO JLRUQR OD VWHVVD VWUDGD 3HQVLDPR DOO¶HQHUJLDEXWWDWDYLDDOO¶LQTXLQDPHQWRDOQHUYRVLVPRFKHWXWWRTXHVWRSRUWD 0DSHUFKpQRQODVFLDPRGDSDUWHOHQRVWUHWUDGL]LRQLHQRQDGRWWLDPRDQFKHLQ,WDOLDSHUWXWWL O¶RUDULR XQLFR FRQWLQXDWR ODYRUR GDOOH H PH]]R DOOH H PH]]R FRQ XQD EUHYH SDXVD H SRL WXWWL D FDVD" &RVu JLj IDQQR LQ ,WDOLD JOL LPSLHJDWL GHL 0LQLVWHUL GL PROWL &RPXQL H XIILFL SXEEOLFL H FRVu ODYRUDQRWXWWLJOLHXURSHLFRQPROWHFRQVHJXHQ]HSRVLWLYHSHULQHUYLO¶DPELHQWHHO¶HFRQRPLD 5LQR9HJOLD Ê YHUR JOL DOWUL HXURSHL KDQQR O¶RUDULR XQLFR FRQWLQXDWR PD SHUFKp DGRWWDUH DQFKH QRL TXHVWD ©EDUEDULHª" /R VWUHVV GHO WUDIILFR WHUULELOH" 3UHQGLDPR O¶DXWREXV &HUWR 0ROWLVVLPL HXURSHL VRQR D FDVD JLj DOOH FLQTXH PD D PH]]RJLRUQR PDQJLDQR LQ IUHWWD H PDOH QHL SXE EDU H QHOOH PHQVHHDOOHVHLGLVHUD JXDUGDQR JLjOD79$QFKHTXHVWRqVWUHVV(LOWUDIILFRFDRWLFRVXOOHVWUDGH HXURSHH GDO FHQWUR DOOD SHULIHULD QRQ F¶q GDOOH VHWWH LQ SRL PD GDOOH TXDWWUR H PH]]R DOOH FLQTXH $QFKHTXHVWRqVWUHVV,RSUHIHULVFRIDUHXQDOXQJDSDXVDSHULOSUDQ]RHODYRUDUHODVHUD *LDQQL)DUVLD
/269$*2
8QLWj
'EJGEQUCHCEEKCOQ!#XGVGWPCRTQRQUVC!
&DUORWWD KDL WHPSR VWDVHUD" $QGLDPR LQVLHPH DO FRQFHUWR" $O 3DOD]]HWWR F¶q 5RFN-D]] &DQWD DQFKH*LDQQD1DQQLQL
3XUWURSSR SHU PH QRQ q SRVLELOH )XOYLR +R JLj XQ LPSHJQR VRQR DUULYDWL L QRVWUL FRQRVFHQWL WHGHVFKLHXVFLDPRWXWWLLQVLHPH
&KHSHFFDWR+RJLjLELJOLHWWL
6uqXQYHURSHFFDWR8Q¶DOWUDYROWDFLYHQJRPROWRYROHQWLHUL
³)UDWUHRUHJUDQGHFRQFHUWR5RFN-D]]DO3DOD]]HWWR´
&LDR5REHUWDGRYHYDLFRVuLQIUHWWD"
+RDOFXQHFRVHGDVEULJDUHDOFHQWUR
0DDQFKH)DELRYDLQFLWWjHKDODPDFFKLQD3HUFKpQRQFLYDLFRQOXL"
ÊXQDEXRQDLGHDVRSUDWWXWWRFRQTXHVWDSLRJJLD
C
&LDR*LDQQL&RPHYD"
%HQHJUD]LH
&KHIDLGRPHQLFD"
1RQORVRDQFRUD
9RJOLDPRDQGDUHLQVLHPHDOODSDUWLWD"
6HQRQSLRYHPROWRYROHQWLHUL
6HQWL &HVDUH YLHQL FRQ QRL GD 6HUHQD VWDVHUD GRSR LO WHDWUR" 9RJOLDPR SDVVDUH WXWWL GD OHL SHUFKpFRPSLHJOLDQQL
6uYROHQWLHULÊXQDEHOO¶LGHD
6LJQRULQD 6LOYLD KD YRJOLD GL YHQLUH FRQ PH DO FLQHPD GRPDQL VHUD" +R VHQWLWR FKH DO ³0HWURSRO´GDQQRXQILOPPROWREXRQR
0LGLVSLDFHPROWLVVLPRVLJQRU%XUJHUPDGRPDQLQRQqSURSULRSRVVLELOHDEELDPRRVSLWLDFHQD
3HFFDWR(GRSRGRPDQL"
'RSRGRPDQLVRQROLEHUD
$OORUDWHOHIRQRGDYRLYHUVROHVHLHSRLYHGLDPRG¶DFFRUGR"
6uYDEHQHGDOOHLQSRLVRQRDFDVD
C
2KVLJQRUD&DUOHWWL
%XRQJLRUQRVLJQRULQD+HOJDVFXVLVHGLVWXUERPDVD« /HLqTXLGDSRFRQRQFRQRVFHDQFRUD EHQH OD FLWWj LO QRVWUR TXDUWLHUH LO PHUFDWR H L QHJR]L H FRVu KR SHQVDWR FKH IRUVH KD YRJOLD GL YHQLUHDIDUHODVSHVDFRQPH
*UD]LHVLJQRUD&DUOHWWL/HLqYHUDPHQWHPROWRJHQWLOH9HQJRYROHQWLHUL&LDQGLDPRVXELWR"
1RIUDXQ¶RUDSHU/HLYDEHQH"
%HQLVVLPR$QGLDPRDSLHGL"
6uVuIDFRVuEHOWHPSRHQRQqORQWDQR
$OORUDDSLWDUGLHJUD]LHVLJQRUD
LOWHPSRqEHOOR
IDEHOWHPSR
LOWHPSR
EHOWHPSR
ORVSHWWDFROR
EHOORVSHWWDFROR
LQHJR]L
EHLQHJR]L
FRQGDSHUPH WH OXL OHL /HL QRL YRL ORUR
*UDQIROODSHULOFDOGRDOODSLVFLQDGL/HJQDQR D
&LDR+HOJD&RPHYDFRQTXHVWRFDOGR"9LHQLFRQQRLLQSLVFLQD"
1RQSRVVRKRXQDSSXQWDPHQWRFRQODPLDYLFLQD9DGRFRQOHLDOPHUFDWR
3HFFDWR$OORUDXQ¶DOWUDYROWD
E
&LDR$QJHOD+DLYRJOLDGLYHQLUHFRQPHDJLRFDUHDWHQQLV"
3XUWURSSR QRQ SRVVR +DQQR FKLDPDWR &KLDUD H LO VXR UDJD]]R H YDGR FRQ ORUR LQ SLVFLQD 0D SHUFKpQRQFLYLHQLDQFKHWX"
&RQTXHVWRWHPSRqFHUWDPHQWRPHJOLR
9DEHQHYHQJRYROHQWLHULFRQYRL
$UULYDXQDVHWWLPDQDFDOGLVVLPD
'DOJLXJQRGHOPDLUHJLVWUDWHWHPSHUDWXUHFRVuDOWHVRSUDWWXWWRQHO6XG
&2081,&$5( +DL +D
YRJOLDGL
DQGDUH
YHQLUH
FRQPH
FRQWH
FRQOXL
FRQ/HL
FRQOHL
FRQQRL
FRQORUR
FRQYRL
YHQLUHFRQPH
D
QRL
SUDQ]R
GD
0DULR
FHQD
$YHWH
VWDVHUD
WHDWUR DQGDUHFRQOXL
DO
FRQFHUWR
OHL
FLQHPD
ORUR
PHUFDWR
RJJLSRPHULJJLR GRPDQL
GDO
VLJQRU6FLSLRQH
GRPDQLVHUD
GRWWRU)UDQFLVFL
VDEDWR GRPHQLFD
DOO¶
RSHUD
GDOO¶
DPLFRGL&HQFLR
DOZHHNHQG
DOOR
VWDGLR
GDOOR
]LR
YHQHUGu
DOOD
IHVWD«
GDOOD
VLJQRUD1DUGL
«
JLDUGLQL
GDL
%LDQFKL
SXEEOLFL
GDJOL
DPLFLIUDQFHVL
GDOOH
DPLFKHGL*LQD
VDJUD« SDUWLWD VSLDJJLD DL
6u
YROHQWLHUL
SXUWURSSR
RJJL
SHUPH
qXQDEXRQD¶LGHD
PL
TXHVWR SRPH
QRL
EHOO¶LGHD
FL
ULJJLR
QRQSRVVR
1R
XQ¶RWWLPDLGHD YHQJR YHQLDPR SRVVR SRVVLDPR
SRVVR SRVVLDPR
GLVSLDFHPD
VWDVHUD
FRQWH
YROHQWLHUL
GRPDQL
FRQYRL
GRPDQLVHUD VDEDWR
YHQLUFL
DQGDUFL
GRPHQLFD DOZHHNHQG
FRQOXL
YHQHUGu
FRQOHL
«
FRQORUR
QRQqSRVVLELOH
SRVVLDPR WHPSR
QRQKR DEELDPR KR DEELDPR
SUHIHULVFR SUHIHULDPR
YRJOLD
RVSLWL GDIDUH XQLPSHJQR
DQGDUH«
6H GRPHQLFD F¶q LO VROH H DEEDVWDQ]D QHYH SRVVLDPR DQGDUH WXWWL LQ PRQWDJQD D VFLDUH 3RWHWH SRUWDUH DQFKHODVOLWWDSHULEDPELQL
,RFLYHQJRPROWRYROHQWLHULFRQLEDPELQLPD3DROR QRQ SXz YD SHU XQD VHWWLPDQD LQ ,QJKLOWHUUD H SDUWH JLjVDEDWR
(VHLQPRQWDJQDIDEUXWWR"
5HVWLDPRLQFLWWjHIDFFLDPRTXDOFRVDLQVLHPH
%HQHDOORUDFLVHQWLDPRVDEDWR
3URQWR&DWHULQD"6RQRLR6LOYLD
2KFLDR6LOYLDFRPHVWDL"
%HQHEHQH«VHQWL,HULKDLGRPDQGDWRFRPHVLSXzSDVVDUHLOZHHNHQG+RXQDSURSRVWDGDWR FKHLQ5LYLHUDIDFDOGRHF¶qYHQWRSRVVLDPRDQGDUHDIDUHLOZLQGVXUI6HKDLYRJOLDSXRLYHQLUFL DQFKHWXSRVVLDPRGRUPLUHLQFDPSHJJLR
ÊXQ¶RWWLPDLGHD9HQJRQRDQFKHLYRVWULUDJD]]L"
1RSHUORURO¶DFTXDqDQFRUDWURSSRIUHGGDSHUSRWHUIDUHLOEDJQR6RQRGDLQRQQL
%HQH(TXDQGRSDUWLWH"
9HQHUGuQHOWDUGRSRPHULJJLR1HOODQRVWUDPDFFKLQDF¶qSRVWRDQFKHSHUWH
%HQLVVLPR$OORUDDYHQHUGu
'RPDQL DUULYDQR L PLHL DPLFL IUDQFHVL QRQ FRQRVFRQR OD FLWWj QRQ SDUODQR LWDOLDQR HG LR KR WHPSRSHUORURVRORQHOSRPHULJJLRSHUFKpKRDQFRUDGDIDUHLQXIILFLR
%H¶GLPDWWLQDSRVVRQRIDUHXQDJLWDD0XUDQRDOOHGXHYDLDSUHQGHUHLWXRLDPLFLDOYDSRUHWWR DQGDWHDSUDQ]RGDTXDOFKHSDUWHHSRLSRWHWHIDUHXQJLURSHU9HQH]LDQR"
ÊXQDEXRQDLGHD
SRWHUH
VDSHUH
SRVVR SRVVLDPR
VRVDSSLDPR
SXRL
SRWHWH
SXz
SRVVRQR
SDUODUHLWDOLDQR
&2081,&$5( $QGLDPR
LQVLHPH
LQ6SDJQD
9RJOLDPRDQGDUH
6u
5LYLHUD
9LHQL
FRQPH
9LHQH
QRL
PROWRYROHQWLHUL qXQDEHOO¶LGHD
FHQWUR
qXQDEXRQ¶LGHD
SLVFLQD
VH
EDUFD VOLWWD
9HQLWH
QRQIDIUHGGR EUXWWRWHPSR SLRYH
GLVFRWHFD
F¶qLOVROH YHQWR
DJLRFDUH
DEEDVWDQ]DQHYH
VFLDUH
IDEHOOR
EDOODUH
EHOWHPSR
PDQJLDUH
FDOGR
SUDQ]DUH FHQDUH IDUHLOEDJQR
KR
XQDSSXQWDPHQWR
DEELDPR
XQLPSHJQR RVSLWL
LOZLQGVXUI
GDIDUH
ORVFLG¶DFTXD
GDODYRUDUH
MRJJLQJ
QRQSRVVRSHUFKp« QRQSRVVLDPRSHUFKp«
$OORUDPDPPDFKHFRVDIDFFLRRJJL"
3XRLDQGDUHLQSLVFLQDIDFDOGR
&LVRQRVWDWRLHUL
$OORUDSHUFKpQRQFKLDPL7RPPDVR"3RWHWHDQGDUHDJLRFDUHDERFFHDOSDUFR
7RPPDVRqSDUWLWRLHULHQRQF¶qQHVVXQRGHLPLHLDPLFL
(QRQKDLYRJOLDGLDQGDUHDJLRFDUHJLFRQJOLDOWULEDPELQLGHOODFDVD"
ÊXQDEXRQDLGHD«SRVVLDPRDQGDUHDJLRFDUHQHOJLDUGLQRTXLYLFLQR
&2081,&$5( *LRFKLDPR
LQVLHPH
9RJOLDPRJLRFDUH
DFDUWH
ÊXQDEHOO¶LGHD
ERFFH
EXRQ¶LGHD
WHQQLV FDOFLR
3XUWURSSRDGHVVRQRQKRWHPSR
SDOOD
1RQRKRYRJOLD3UHIHULVFR«
SDOODPDQR SDOODYDOR
0DQRQYHGLFKH
SDOODFDQHVWUR
qYLHWDWRTXL" QRQVLSXz"
0DLRQRQVRJLRFDUHEHQHD«
&2081,&$5(
(GLR
FKHFRVD
SRVVR
(/HD
FKH
SXz
GRPHQLFD
IDEUXWWR
SXz
(QRL
FRVD
SRVVLDPR
GRPDQL
SLRYH
SRVVLDPR
JLRFDUHD«
SRWHWH
IDUHLOEDJQR
(GL«
IDUH
DOZHHNHQG
6H
QRQIDIUHGGR
F¶qVROH SRVVRQR
YHQWR QHYH IDEHOOR EHOWHPSR FDOGR
SXRL
SRVVRQR
DQGDUHD« LQ«
XQJLUR XQDJLWD XVFLUHFRQ«
&LDR&DUOD+DLYRJOLDGLYHQLUHFRQQRLDIDUHORVFLQDXWLFRGRPDQLSRPHULJJLR"
6uYROHQWLHUL'RPDQLSRVVRYHQLUHQRQKRQLHQWHGDIDUH
%HQLVVLPR(IRUVHDQFKHL1DUGLKDQQRWHPSRHYRJOLDGLYHQLUH
, 1DUGL QRQ FL VRQR H QRQ SRVVRQR YHQLUH QHDQFKH DOOD IHVWD GL *LQR OXQHGu VHUD +DQQR WHOHIRQDWR O¶DOWUR LHUL QRQ ULWRUQDQR GDOOH YDFDQ]H SULPD GL PHUFROHGu SHUFKp OD ORUR ILJOLD VL q DPPDODWDDOO¶LPSURYYLVR
QRQ±PDL
QRQ
QLHQWH QXOOD
0DLFLVRQRVWDWR
1LHQWHqLPSRVVLELOH
QRQQHVVXQR
1HVVXQRKDWHOHIRQDWR
QRQQHDQFKH
1HDQFKHOXLqYHQXWR
&LDR/DOOD*UD]LHSHULOELJOLHWWLQR
$KILQDOPHQWH'RYHVHLVWDWD"
,QFLWWjFRQXQQRVWURDPLFR3HUVWDVHUDVLDPRG¶DFFRUGR3RVVLDPRYHQLUH
%HQHDOORUDFLYHGLDPRDOOHRWWRHXQ TXDUWRGDYDQWLDOWHDWUR
%HQLVVLPR&LDRHDVWDVHUD
SULPDGL GDYDQWLD
XQDPLDDPLFD
SULPDGLGRPHQLFDSULPDGHOO¶XQD
XQDWXDULVSRVWD
GDYDQWLDFDVDPLDGDYDQWLDOEDU
XQQRVWURDPLFR
'RYHVLYDWXWWLLQVLHPHVWDVHUD"
,R KR XQD SURSRVWD 6L SXz DQGDUH DOOR VSHWWDFROR LQ SLD]]D +R VDSXWR GD &DUOD FKH F¶q XQ JUXSSRWHDWUDOHGL3DUPD
(FKHF¶qGLEHOORGDYHGHUH"
1RQORVRPDSRVVLDPRJXDUGDUHVXOJLRUQDOHRLQIRUPDUFL
6WDVHUDDOOD79QRQF¶qSURSULRQLHQWHGLGLYHUWHQWHGDYHGHUH&KHVLIDGLEHOOR$QQD"
6HQWL0DUFRqWDQWRFKHQRQDQGLDPRDEDOODUH6WDVHUDVLYDLQGLVFRWHFD
%XRQDLGHD(WXFKHIDL'DULD"
6HFLDQGDWHYHQJRDQFK¶LRFRQYRL
%HQHYHQLDPRDFDVDWXDDOOHRDOOH"
ÊORVWHVVR
3$57,&,3,8/75(&87 DUHDWRDQGDUH±VRQRDQGDWRD LUHLWRFDSLUH±KRFDSLWR
HUHXWRVDSHUH±KRVDSXWR YHQLUH±VRQRYHQXWRD
4XL LQ SDHVH QRQ F¶q SURSULR QLHQWH GL LQWHUHVVDQWH GD IDUH 9RJOLDPR DQGDUH LQ FLWWj D IDUH XQ JLUR"
%HQHVLYDDSLHGL"
0DqORQWDQR3HUFKpQRQSUHQGLDPRSLXWWRVWRO¶DXWREXV"ÊSLFRPRGR
+DLUDJLRQH*LDQIUDQFR
&KHVLIDGRPHQLFD)UDQFR"
6HQRQIDEUXWWRWHPSRSRVVLDPRDQGDUHDOPDUHYDEHQH"
0D FDUR ID DQFRUD WURSSR IUHGGR QRQ VL SXz QHDQFKH IDUH LO EDQJR 3HUFKp QRQ IDFFLDPR LQYHFHXQDJLWDD9HQH]LD"/uF¶qVHPSUHTXDOFRVDGLEXRQRGDYHGHUH+ROHWWRVXOJLRUQDOHFKH FLVRQRGHOOHPDQLIHVWD]LRQLFXOWXUDOLPROWREHOOH
+DLUDJLRQHqPHJOLR$OORUDDQGLDPRD9HQH]LD(ORSRVVLDPRGLUHDQFKHDG$JQHVHIRUVHFL YLHQHDQFKHOHL
'RYHVLYDWXWWLLQVLHPH
GRYHDQGLDPR"
&KHF¶q
GLEHOOR
GDYHGHUH"
&KHVLSXz«
FKHSRVVLDPR«
&¶qTXDOFRVD
GLEXRQR
GDOHJJHUH"
&KHVLID
FKHIDFFLDPR"
1RQF¶qQLHQWH
GLGLYHUWLPHQWH
GDIDUH
&2081,&$5(
&KHFRVD &KH
VLIDWXWWLLQVLHPH
&RVD
VWDVHUD
+DLWX
XQDSURSRVWD
GRPDQL
+D/HL
XQ¶LGHD
VDEDWRSRPHULJJLR
$YHWHYRL
GRPHQLFD 'RYH
VLYDWXWWLLQVLHPH
TXHVWRZHHNHQG
)RUVHF¶qTXDOFRVDGLEHOOR
GDYHGHUH
EXRQR
DWHDWURDOWHDWURLQSLD]]D
VHQWLUH
DOFLQHPDFDEDUHW-D]]&OXE
LQWHUHVVDQWH
DOO¶RSHUDXQLYHUVLWj
GLYHUWHQWH
DOOD79GLVFRWHFD³%LEHURQ´ QHOODJDOOHULDG¶DUWH
0DIDFRVuEHOOR3HUFKpQRQ
DQGLDPR
LQYHFH
DEDOODUH
SLXWWRVWR
DOODVDJUDDOO¶DSHUWR
PDQJLDUH
LOEDJQRORVFL
IDUH
QDXWLFR
JLRFDUH
DWHQQLVDERFFH
XQDJLWDD« XQJLURSHU««LQEDUFD FRQODEDUFDFRQLOZLQGVXUI LQEDUFDLQZLQGVXUI
+DL+D$YHWHUDJLRQHÊPROWRPHJOLR 1
1LQR(
(OVD8
8JRLOPDULWRGL(OVD
1
±&LDR(OVDFLDR8JR&RVDVLIDTXHVWRZHHNHQG"
(
±9HQHUGuSRVVLDPRDQGDUHWXWWLLQVLHPHD5RPD$YHWHYLVWRTXHOORFKHF¶qVFULWWRTXL" &LVRQREXRQHFRPELQD]LRQLSHUFHQWRPLOD OLUHSHUHVHPSLR
(VLDELWDDOO¶+RWHO$WODQWHRDOO¶8QLYHUVR 1
±ÊXQDEXRQDLGHD(OVD
8
±$OORUDSRVVLDPRWHOHIRQDUHQRLDOO¶+RWHO$WODQWH
(
±6uHIDFFLDPRODSUHQRWD]LRQHSHUQRLTXDWWUR«
1
±0DIRUVHKDQQRYRJOLDGLYHQLUHDQFKHL%HUWL
(
±1RQRORURVRQRD1DSROLFRQLORURRVSLWLGL6DOLVEXUJR«
8
±ÊVHQWL1LQRDQGLDPRFRQODQRVWUDPDFFKLQD"
1
±6uqPHJOLR9HQLDPRDFDVDYRVWUDYHQHUGuPDWWLQDSUHVWRODVFLDPRTXLODQRVWUDPDFFKLQDH SDUWLDPR
(
±%HQHPDSULPDFLVHQWLDPRDQFRUD
1
±'¶DFFRUGR$OORUDFLDRHDSUHVWR
3URQWR%UXQD"
2KFLDR9DOHQWLQDFRPHVWDL"
%HQLVVLPR$OORUDFKHIDLVDEDWRVHUD"(VFLFRQQRL"
0DKQRQORVR«FKHFRVDDYHWHYRJOLDGLIDUH"
,OWHPSRQRQqEHOORHDOFLQHPDQRQF¶qQLHQWHGLLQWHUHVVDQWH«
(DWHDWUR"
$O©3ROLWHDPDªF¶qTXDOFRVDPDqWURSSRWDUGLSHUWURYDUHSRVWRSHUWXWWL
$OORUDSRVVLDPRDQGDUHDPDQJLDUHGD©*LQRªHSRLGHFLGHUHFKHFRVDIDUH
0D VDL *LDQQD KD GHWWR FKH OHL H 3DROR DGHVVR QRQ KDQQR PROWL VROGL OXL KD IDWWR JOL HVDPL DOFXQLPHVLIDPDqDQFRUDVHQ]DODYRUR6HVDEDWRDQGLDPRGD©*LQRªORURQRQYHQJRQR«
$OORUD YHQLWH WXWWL GD QRL GRPDQL 6H ID EHOOR VWLDPR LQ JLDUGLQR VH QR UHVWLDPR LQ FDVD 3LQR ULWRUQDVWDVHUDGDOOD&DODEULDHSRUWDPROWHEXRQHFRVH3RVVLDPRLPSURYYLVDUHXQDFHQDIUHGGD HVWLDPRXQSR¶LQVLHPH«
'¶DFFRUGRPDVRORVHSRUWLDPRWXWWLTXDOFRVD«%LVRJQDDYYLVDUHDQFKHJOLDOWUL«
,RWHOHIRQRD'LQDDL0DUDVVLHD*LDQIUDQFR«
(LRLQWDQWRFKLDPR/XLVDHL%X]]L
0DQRQKDQQRVFULWWRFKHUHVWDQRD*UDGRILQRDGRPHQLFD"
1RVRQRGLULWRUQRJLjGDLHUL
$OORUDFLVHQWLDPRYHUVROHTXDWWURYDEHQH"
'¶DFFRUGRDSLWDUGL GLUH
KRGHWWR
OHJJHUH
KROHWWR
VFULYHUH
KRVFULWWR
IDUH
KRIDWWR
3RVVLDPRGHFLGHUH
FKHFRVDIDUH
1RQVRDQFRUD
FRPHIDUH GRYHDQGDUH
&DURKDLOHWWRFKHVXOVHFRQGRFDQDOHGHOODWLYVWDVHUDF¶qXQDWUDQVPLVVLRQH«
79 79 VHPSUH 79 0D DO ZHHNHQG VL SRVVRQR IDUH WDQWH DOWUH FRVH Ê XQD VHUDWD FRVu EHOOD 3HUFKp QRQ HVFL FRQ PH" 3RVVLDPR IDUH XQD SDVVHJJLDWD QHL GLQWRUQL FHUFDUH XQD WUDWWRULD DOO¶DSHUWRHPDQJLDUHTXDOFRVD &KHFRVDVLSXzIDUH" 6LSXzIDUHXQDSDVVHJJLDWD JLWDD« XQJLURSHU« 6LSRVVRQRIDUHPROWHFRVH
&2081,&$5(
9RJOLDPRXVFLUH
LQVLHPH
6uSHUFKpQR
(VFL
FRQPH
1RSXUWURSSRRJJLQRQSRVVR
YDGR
D«
(VFH
QRL
QRQSRVVLDPR
DQGLDPR
LQ« GD«
8VFLUH HVFR
FRQ«
XVFLDPR
LQ«
/H79SULYDWHLQ,WDOLD q O¶DQQR GL QDVFLWD GHOOH SULPH WHOHYLVLRQL SULYDWH LQ ,WDOLD )LQLVFH FRVu LO PRQRSROLR GHOOD5$,ODWHOHYLVLRQHGL6WDWR$OO¶LQL]LROH79SULYDWHVRQRSLGLD5RPDD0LODQR PD PROWH DQFKH QHOOH SLFFROH FLWWj GL SURYLQFLD 6RQR ILQDQ]LDWH GD LQGXVWULDOL HGLWRUL SDUWLWL H JUXSSL SROLWLFL RUH VX FL VRQR PROWLVVLPL ILOP WHOHILOP FDUWRQL DQLPDWL H PROWD SXEEOLFLWj 'RSROHGLVHUDSRLFLVRQRILOPHURWLFLFKHPDPPD5$,QRQSUHVHQWD OH 79 SULYDWH QHJOL XOWLPL DQQL KDQQR DYXWR XQ¶LPSRUWDQWH HYROX]LRQH PROWH QRQ HVLVWRQRSLPHQWUHWUHGLTXHVWH±&DQDOH,WDOLDH5HWH±QRQKDQQRSLFDUDFWWHUHORFDOHPD HQWUDQRQHOOH FDVHGLTXDVLWXWWLJOLLWDOLDQLHVRQRLQJUDQGHFRQFRUUHQ]DFRQOD 5$, &L VRQR PHQR ILOPHURWLFLDQFRUDSLSXEEOLFLWjSURJUDPPLGLYDULHWjHWHOHILOPDPHULFDQL
6LSXzYLYHUHVHQ]D79 VRQR OH IDPLJOLH LWDOLDQH FKH SUHQGRQR SDUWH DG XQ VLQJRODUH HVSHULPHQWR GHOOD ULYLVWD WHOHYLVLYD©6RUULVLHFDQ]RQL79ªSHUTXDWWURVHWWLPDQHVLLPSHJQDQRDQRQDFFHQGHUHOHORUR79H QHOOR VWHVVR WHPSR D UHJLVWUDUH SHU LVFULWWR WXWWH OH UHD]LRQL GHOOD IDPLJOLD LQ TXHVWD QXRYD VWUDQD VLWXD]LRQH *OL RUJDQL]]DWRUL GHOO¶HVSHULPHQWR FL GLFRQR ©/D JHQWH RJJL YHGH QHOOD 79 XQ PH]]R SHU QRQHVVHUHSLVROLPDDQFKHXQ PH]]R SHU GLPHQWLFDUH L SURSUL SUREOHPL SHU LVRODUVL LQ IDPLJOLD H QHOODVRFLHWjGRSRWDQWHRUHGLODYRUR 8RPLQLHGRQQH YHFFKL H EDPELQL SDVVDQR RUH H RUH GDYDQWL DOO¶DSSDUHFFKLR WHOHYLVLYR VHQ]D SDUODUH FRQ QHVVXQR /D 79 RJJL q SHU PROWH SHUVRQH XQD YHUD H SURSULDGURJD0DTXHVWRqVEDJOLDWROD79QRQqQpSLQpPHQRFKHXQPH]]RGLFRPXQLFD]LRQH 2JQXQR KD OD SRVVLELOLWj GL GLUH ©4XHVWR SURJUDPPD PL SLDFH H OR JXDUGR TXHVWR QR H SHUFLz QRQ OR JXDUGRª H IDUH FRVu XQD VHOH]LRQH $EELDPR IDWWR TXHVWR HVSHULPHQWR SURSULR SHU GLPRQVWUDUH FKH GD XQD SDUWH RJJL q LPSRVVLELOH YLYHUH VHQ]D WHOHYLVLRQH PD GDOO¶DOWUD q SRVVLELOH QRQ HVVHUH VFKLDYLGHOODWHOHYLVLRQHHJXDUGDUHLSURJUDPPLDSLFFROHGRVLª ©,Q TXHVWD SULPD VHWWLPDQD WXWWR q DQGDWR YHUDPHQWH EHQH VLDPR UHVWDWL D FDVD H DEELDPR SDVVDWROHVHUDWHLQVLHPHDSDUODUHD JLRFDUH DFDUWHH DOHJJHUHª FL KD GHWWR LO VLJQRU /L]]L FKH FRQ OD VXD IDPLJOLD SUHQGH SDUWH DOO¶HVSHULPHQWR ©0D OD SURVVLPD VHWWLPDQD«PLR ILJOLR GL DQQL YRUUHEEH YHGHUH DOPHQR TXDOFKH YROWD L FDUWRQL DQLPDWL H D PH PDQFD LO WHOHJLRUQDOH 0LD PRJOLH LQYHFH q FRQWHQWD SHUFKp VWLDPR SL WHPSR LQVLHPHª (G XQ¶DOWUD PDGUH GL IDPLJOLD ©6HQ]D 79 OD VHUDDQGLDPRVSHVVRIXRULDOFLQHPDDWHDWURRDFDVDGLDPLFL1DWXUDOPHQWHTXHVWHVHUDWHVRQRSL FDUH 0D SRVVR GLUH FKH VRQR IHOLFH GL TXHVWR HVSHULPHQWR /D SURVVLPD VHWWLPDQD SHUz F¶q XQD SDUWLWD PROWR LPSRUWDQWH LQ 79 H DQGLDPR WXWWL D FDVD GL PLR IUDWHOOR +R GRPDQGDWR DJOL RUJDQL]]DWRULGHOO¶HVSHULPHQWRVHVLSXzHKDQQRGHWWRGLVuª
/()(67( WLLQYLWR
DOOHRUH
GD
&DUOR
LOJLRUQR LQYLD
8QLWj
GLFHPEUH 5RVVLQL
)HGHULFD
&HQLFRQQRL*LDFRPR"+RSUHSDUDWRLWRUWHOORQLDOODSDQQD
7RUWHOORQL" (G LR QRQ SRVVR UHVWDUH FKH VIRUWXQD Ê JLj WDUGL H DOOH QRYH GHYR UHJLVWUDUH XQD WUDQVPLVVLRQHGDOODUDGLR
2JJLSUDQ]LGDPH&DUODYDEHQH"5RVDKDIDWWRLOSDVWLFFLRGLEURFFROL
*UD]LHVLJQRUDDFFHWWRPROWRYROHQWLHUL$FKHRUDPDQJLDWH"
)LQRDTXDQGRGHYLVWDUHDOO¶HVSRVL]LRQH"
3RVVRHVVHUHTXLDOO¶XQDHPH]]D
9DEHQHFRVuDOORUDPDQJLDPRYHUVROHGXH
«DOORUDDUULYHUGHUFLVLJQRU/XJDULQLHJUD]LHGLWXWWR
0D FRPH GHYH SURSULR DQGDUH GRWWRUH" 3HUFKp QRQ SUHQGH LO SURVVLPR WUHQR H UHVWD D FHQD GD QRL"0LDPRJOLHKDSUHSDUDWRLOSROORDUURVWR«HORVDIDUHPROWREHQH
*UD]LHGHOO¶LQYLWRPDSXUWURSSRGHYRULILXWDUH6WDVHUDLPLHLPLDVSHWWDQR±VRQRLQJLURJLjGD XQD VHWWLPDQD ± H GRPDQL PDWWLQD SUHVWR LQ XIILFLR GREELDPR DQFRUD SUHSDUDUH PROWH FRVH SHU ODILHUDGL)UDQFRIRUWH
3HFFDWR0DFDSLVFR«$OORUDWDQWLVDOXWLDL6XRL
*UD]LH8Q¶DOWUDYROWDUHVWRYROHQWLHUL
6HQWL*LQRWXH /LVDPDQJLDWHTXDOFRVD TXL FRQ QRL QR" +R SUHSDUDWR L FDQQHOORQL H XQD EHOOD LQVDODWD«2GRYHWHDQGDUHYLDDQFKHYRL"
0DQR$FFHWWLDPRPROWRYROHQWLHULVHQRQGLVWXUELDPR
0DVFKHU]DWH6LDPRFRQWHQWLGLDYHUYLDQFRUDXQSR¶TXLGDQRL
2KJUD]LH(L'H/XFDQRQUHVWDQR"
1R'HYRQRDQGDUHDSUHQGHUHLOORURILJOLRDOO¶DHURSRUWRHSRL«ODVLJQRUDVWDDGLHWD
&2081,&$5(
0DQJL
FRQPH
0DQJLD
FRQQRL
6u
YROHQWLHUL
0DQJLDWH 3UDQ]L
GDPH
3UDQ]D
GDQRL
VHQRQGLVWXUQR
DFFHWWR
1R
DFFHWWLDPR
FRQSLDFHUH
VHQRQGLVWXUELDPR
PLGLVSLDFHPD
QRQSRVVR
SHUFKp«
FLGLVSLDFHPD
QRQSRVVLDPR
3UDQ]DWH
DVSHWWR
RVSLWL
DVSHWWLDPR
XQDWHOHIRQDWD
&HQL
GHYR
DQGDUH«
&HQD
GREELDPR
DQFRUDIDUH« ULILXWDUHSHUFKp«
&HQDWH 5HVWL
DFROD]LRQH
5HVWD
DSUDQ]R
5HVWDWH
DFHQD
&2081,&$5( 'HYL
JLjDQGDUH
1RQUHVWL
'HYH
UHVWD
'RYHWH
UHVWDWH
D«
1R
GD«
SXUWURSSR
GHYR
DQFRUD
WHOHIRQDUHD« SRUWDUH«D«
GREELDPR
DQGDUHDSUHQGHUH« SUHSDUDUHPROWRSHU« VWXGLDUHSHU« IDUHLFRPSLWL IDUHDOFXQLODYRUL VFULYHUHXQDOHWWHUD UDJJLXQJHUHL« ILQLUHXQDWUDGX]LRQH SXOLUHODFDVD
5LPDQHWH GD QRL SHU LO ILQHVHWWLPDQD &ODXGLD" )D EHO WHPSR H FRVu SRVVLDPR IDUH LO EDJQR SUHQGHUH LO VROH DQGDUH LQ EDUFD IDUH XQD EHOOD SDVVHJJLDWD DO IDUR SURYDUH LO QXRYR ULVWRUDQWH H«
6uVDUHEEHPROWREHOORHWLULQJUD]LRPDSXUWURSSRGREELDPRSDUWLUH(QULFDLRGHYRILQLUHXQD WUDGX]LRQHHQWUROXQHGuH&DUORYRUHEEHDQGDUHDO)HVWLYDOGHOOD&DQ]RQHSRSRODUH
3HFFDWR 0D SULPD GL SDUWLUH GRYHWH PDQJLDUH DQFRUD TXDOFRVD GL EXRQR 8QD IULWWXUD GL SHVFH YDEHQH"
2KVuJUD]LH
3URQWR&DUPHOD"6RQRLR/LD
$KFLDR/LD
6HQWL KR VDSXWR GDL WXRL JHQLWRUL FKH LO ILQHVHWWLPDQD WX H 6DQGUR VLHWH TXL D 3DUPD SHU XQ FRQYHJQR6DUHLWDQWRFRQWHQWDGLULYHGHUYLGRSRWDQWRWHPSR6LHWHOLEHULVDEDWRVHUD"
6uPDQRQVDSSLDPRDQFRUDILQRDTXDQGRGXUDQROHGLVFXVVLRQL
1RQ ID QLHQWH 3UHSDUR TXDOFRVD GL IUHGGR H SRWHWH GRUPLUH TXL GD QRL &RVu SRVVLDPR DOPHQR FKLDFFKLHUDUHXQSR¶
%HQLVVLPR/LDHJUD]LHGHOO¶LQYLWR
$OORUDYLDVSHWWRVDEDWRLQVHUDWD
&21',
,21$/35(=(17
YRUUHL
VDUHL
YRUUHEEH
VDUHEEH
&2081,&$5( +R
/HRKD
SUHSDUDWR
LOSDVWLFFLR
PDQJLDWH
GDPH
IDWWR
SROORDUURVWR
SHUFKp QRQ
SUDQ]DWH
QRL
ODIULWWXUDGLSHVFH
FHQDWH
LWRUWHOOLQLDOODSDQQD
UHVWDWH
FDQQHOORQL
ULPDQHWH
GHWWRFKH
DYHWHWHPSRVWDVHUD
SDVVDWH
VFULWWRFKH
VLHWHTXLGRPDQL
YHQLWH GRUPLWH
6DUHEEHPROWREHOOR
*UD]LHGHOO¶LQYLWR
PDSXUWURSSR
QRQSRVVLDPRDFFHWWDUHGREELDPR« GREELDPRULILXWDUHSHUFKp
6HQWLWH2JJLYLLQYLWRWXWWLTXDQWLDFDVDPLDHFLIDFFLDPRXQDEHOODPDQJLDWD+R FRPSUDWRDO PHUFDWR WDQWH EHOOH FRVH PR]]DUHOOD H DOWUL IRUPDJJL PHODQ]DQH SRPRGRUL LQVDODWD H XQ EHO FRFRPHUR)DFFLDPRXQDEXRQDSDUPLJLDQD
%HQLVVLPR*UD]LHGHOO¶LQYLWR6WHOOD
0D0DULRH5LWDQRQORVDQQRDQFRUD&KLOLSXzLQIRUPDUH"
,RSDUORFRQ5LWDODLQFRQWURTXHVWRSRPHULJJLRDOH]LRQH
(GLRSRVVRGLUORD0DULRORYHGRDOODSURYD
%HQH$OORUDDVWDVHUD
&2081,&$5( 3RVVLDPRLQYLWDUHDQFKH
0DULR
OR
YHGL
0DULD
OD
YHGH
OD
L/XFD
OL
YHGHWH
OL
/HDH5LD
OH
GRPDQL
6u
OR
LQFRQWUR
D«
LQFRQWULDPR
OH
PLFRQRVFH WLLQYLWR ORYHGR
352180(3(5621$/(Ì1$&8=$7,9
ODLQFRQWUR FLFKLDPD
$FHVWHIRUPHQHDFFHQWXDWHSUHFHGvQWRWGHDXQDYHUEXOSHUVRQDO
ÌQSUH]HQ DJHUXQ]LXOXLúLDLQILQLWLYXOXLVHXQHVFGXS DFHVWHD
YLLQYLWR
6DUHLFRQWHQWRGLYHGHUOD
OLLQIRUPR OHUDJJLXQJR
DLXWDUH ULQJUD]LDUH
ÌQVWUXFWXULOHYHUEDOHIRUPDWHGLQ DQGDUH YHQLUH SRWHUH GRYHUH VDSHUH YROHUH LQILQLWLY
SURQXPHOHQHDFFHQWXDWSUHFHG VDXXUPHD] YHUEXO
SULPDGL
OLSRVVRLQIRUPDUH
SRVVRLQIRUPDUOL
SULPDGLSDUWLUHGRYHWH« SULPDGLSDUWLUHWLWHOHIRQR
3URQWR/XFD"6RQRLR6LPRQHWWWD6RQRHQWUDWDSURSULRDGHVVRQHOORPLDVWDQ]DHKRYLVWRLGXH ELJOLHWWL«PDFRPHKDLIDWWRDWURYDUOLSURSULRDOO¶XOWLPRPRPHQWR"""
6DLSHUPHQLHQWHqLPSRVVLELOH«
/RVRORVR«TXDVLQLHQWH « 0D VFKHU]L D SDUWH q VWDWD XQD EHOOD VRUSUHVD 1DWXUDOPHQWH FL YHQJRPROWRYROHQWLHUL+ROHWWRODFULWLFDqPROWREXRQD&LLQFRQWULDPRGDYDQWLDOWHDWUR"
1RQVDUHEEHPHJOLRDQGDUFLLQVLHPH"9HQJRDSUHQGHUWL«GLFLDPRDOOHPHQRXQ TXDUWR"
%HQLVVLPR*UD]LHGHOO¶LQYLWRHXQEDFLRQH
&2081,&$5( (
OR
LQYLWL
0DULD
OD
LQYLWD
VD
L%RUJKL
OL
LQYLWLDPR
VDSHWH
OHDPLFKHGL«
OH
LQYLWDWH
0DULR
3HUFKpQRQ
&2081,&$5( +R
XQELJOLHWWR
0DQRQ
VDL
FKHQRQ
F¶q" FLVRQR"
DQFKHSHU
$EELDPR GXHELJOLHWWL
OR
YHGR
/RUHQ]D
OD
YHGLDPR
L)XQDUL
OL
OHDPLFKHGL«
OH
/RUHQ]R
PDQRQ
SLRJJL
/R
SRVVR
LQIRUPDUHLR
OR
LQFRQWUR
DPH]]RJLRUQR
/D
SRVVLDPR
QRL
OD
LQFRQWULDPR
QHOSRPHULJJLR
SURYD OH]LRQHGL
/L
OL
DOOH
/H
OH
YHUVRVHUD
DOOD
PHQVD
WUDWWRULD DO
EDU
GD
DPLFL
C &DUD8WH KR VDSXWR GD 3LHUR FKH KDL DYXWR PROWR GD IDUH QHOO·XOWLPR SHULRGR FKH KDL IDWWR JOL HVDPL H FKHVRQRDQGDWLEHQH&RQJUDWXOD]LRQL+RWDQWDYRJOLDGLULYHGHUWLHSHUFLzYRUUHLLQYLWDUWLDYHQLUHTXL GD QRL DO PDUH 'RPHQLFD L PLHL JHQLWRUL YDQQR LQ $PHULFD GD SDUHQWL HG LR UHVWR VROD FRQ OH PLH VRUHOOH1RQOHFRQRVFLDQFRUDYHUR"6RQRPROWRDOOHJUHHVLPSDWLFKH 6H SXRL YHQLUH VLDPR LQ TXDWWUR ² VDUHEEH WDQWR EHOOR 4XL ID DQFRUD FDOGR PHQWUH GD YRL ID IUHVFR FRPH KR OHWWR VXO JLRUQDOH 8QD UDJLRQH GL SL SHU YHQLUH TXL $VSHWWR XQD WXD WHOHIRQDWD SHU JLRYHGuRYHQHUGuVHUD
&RQXQDIIHWWXRVRDEEUDFFLR D
&LDR)UDQFD
$KVHLWX8WH6WDLEHQH"3XRLYHQLUH"
6uVu6RQRPROWRFRQWHQWDGHOWXRLQYLWR+RSURSULRELVRJQRGLXQSR¶GLYDFDQ]DHPLUDOOHJUR DQFKHGLFRQRVFHUHOHWXHVRUHOOH3HUPHVDUHEEHLGHDOHDUULYDUHGRPHQLFDYHUVRODFLQTXH
%HQLVVLPR L PLHL JHQLWRUL GHYRQR SDUWLUH DOOH TXDWWUR H PH]]D LR OL SRUWR DOO¶DHURSRUWR H SRL YHQJRDSUHQGHUWLDOODVWD]LRQH
&KHEHOOR1RQYHGRO¶RUDGLVWDUHXQSR¶FRQWH
$QFK¶LR&LDRHDGRPHQLFD
$1&25$&$/'21(/&(175268' $5,$)5(6&$(1892/($/125'
&2081,&$5( 9RUUHLLQYLWDUHDQFKH
&DUOR
OR
FRQRVFL
&DUOD
OD
FRQRVFH
OD
JOL6FLSLL
OL
FRQRVFHWH
OL
OHVRUHOOHGL«
OH
0DVuFKH
OR
FRQRVFR FRQRVFLDPR
OH
0LODQR,XJOLR &DUD*LRYDQQD GXHULJKHSHUFRPXQLFDUYLXQDEHOODQRWL]LDLHULKRVXSHUDWRFRQVXFFHVVRDQFKHO·XOWLPRGHJOL HVDPLILQDOLGLGLSORPDHVRQRFRVuGLYHQWDWDWUDGXWWULFHHLQWUHSUHWHDSLHQRWLWROR 9RUUHLIHVWHJJLDUHO·DYYHQLPHQWRVHQ]DIRUPDOLWjPDFRQPROWDDOOHJULDLQIDPLJOLDHLQVLHPH FRQJOLDPLFLSLFDUL7XVHLQDWXUDOPHQWHWUDTXHVWLSHUFLzVDUHLPROWROLHWDGLYHGHUWLTXLVDEDWR OXJOLRYHUVROHFLQTXHËFKLDURFKHO·LQYLWRYDOHDQFKHSHUWXRPDULWR 0LSXRLFKLDPDUHSHUXQDFRQIHUPDHQWURYHQHUGu"2." &RUGLDOPHQWH
,YRQD
C &HUYLJQDQRDJRVWR &DULVVLPD*LXOLD LO VHWWHPEUH DOOH 3LHUR HG LR FL VSRVLDPR QHO PXQLFLSLR GL &HUYLJQDQR 7X 0DULR HG L UDJD]]L VLHWH LQYLWDWL QDWXUDOPHQWH 6H QRQ SRWHWH YHQLUH DOOD FHULPRQLD YHQLWH GLUHWWDPHQWH DO ULVWRUDQWH ©$OOD 3RVWDª )HVWHJJLDPROuFRQDOFXQLDPLFLHWXWWDODIDPLJOLD
&RQWDQWLVDOXWLDIIHWWXRVL %LDQFD
D 0LODQR %LDQFDFDULVVLPD WL ULQJUD]LR WDQWR SHU LO WXR LQYLWR 9HQLDPR FHUWDPHQWH FRQ L UDJD]]L H FL UDOOHJULDPR PROWR GL SRWHU HVVHUH SUHVHQWLDOOHYRVWUHQR]]H
7LVDOXWRDIIHWWXRVDPHQWH
E 0LODQR &DULVVLPL FL GLVSLDFH PROWLVVLPR GL GRYHU ULQXQFLDUH DOO¶XOWLPR PRPHQWR DO YRVWUR LQYLWR , UDJD]]L KDQQR OD YDULFHOOD H QRQ SRVVLDPR ODVFLDUOL VROL &KH VIRUWXQD 6DUHEEH VWDWR WDQWR EHOOR WUDQVFRUUHUH FRQ YRL TXHVWD JLRUQDWD GL IHVWD,QRJQLFDVR0DULRLUDJD]]LHGLRIDFFLDPRLQRVWULPLJOLRULDXJXULDWHHD3LHUR &DULVDOXWLHEDFL *LXOLDH0DULR
LOWUHQRGLUHWWR
YHQLUHGLUHWWDPHQWH
XQVDOXWRDIIHWWXRVR
VDOXWDUHDIIHWWXRVDPHQWH
XQDFRPXQLFD]LRQHEUHYH
FRPXQLFDUHEUHYHPHQWH
XQVDOXWRFRUGLDOH
VDOXWDUHFRUGLDOPHQWH
EXRQRD±EHQHEUXWWRD±PDOH EXRQRDPLJOLRUHEHQHPHJOLR
0$75,021,25(/,*,26220$75,021,2&,9,/(" ,Q FKLHVD R DO PXQLFLSLR TXHVWR q LO SUREOHPD 8IILFLDOPHQWH JOL LWDOLDQL VRQR TXDVL WXWWL FDWWROLFL ± LO PD GL HVVL VROR LO YD D PHVVD OD GRPHQLFD 4XDQGR DUULYD LO PRPHQWR GL VSRVDUVLSHUzSRFKLULQXQFLDQRDOODFHULPRQLDLQFKLHVDSHUVSRVDUVLVRORFLYLOPHQWH %LVRJQD SRL VDSHUH FKH LQ ,WDOLD LO PDWULPRQLR UHOLJLRVR YDOH DQFKH DJOL HIIHWWL FLYLOL FKL VL VSRVDLQFKLHVDGRSRODFHULPRQLDGHYHILUPDUHLQVDFUHVWLDDQFKHLOFRQWUDUURGLPDWULPRQLRFLYLOH HFRVuqVSRVDWRDQFKHSHUOR6WDWR0DOHFRVHFDPELDQRHGRJJLVLUHJLVWUDXQDQXRYDWHQGHQ]D&L VRQR]RQHLQ ,WDOLDGRYHLPDWULPRQLFLYLOLVRQRLOHSLD7ULHVWHLOD0LODQRLO HD 1DSROLLO 6H ODVFLDPR OH JUDQGL FLWWj GHO QRUG H GHO VXG H JXDUGLDPR OD VLWXD]LRQH QHOOH ]RQH GL FDPSDJQDYHGLDPRFKHLPDWULPRQLFLYLOLVRQRLQYHFHPROWRUDULHTXHVWRDOVXGFRPHDOQRUGQHO 9HQHWRLQSURYLQFLDGL9HURQD HLQ&DODEULDLQSURYLQFLDGLQ5HJJLR OHSHUFHQWXDOLVRQRFLUFDGHO
3URQWR 9LQFHQ]R" 6RQR LR *LXVHSSH 6WR ILQHQGR GL PRQWDUH LO ILOP GHOOH YDFDQ]H $YHWH YRJOLDGLJXDUGDUOR"3RWHWHYHQLUHGRSRFHQD"
6u YHQLDPR YROHQWLHUL 7DQWR SL FKH VWLDPR SHQVDQGR GL DQGDUH DQFKH QRL LQ 6LFLOLD O¶DQQR SURVVLPR
&LDR7LQD3DRORHGLRVWLDPRRUJDQL]]DQGRXQDIHVWLFFLRODSHUVWDVHUDHYRJOLDPRLQYLWDUHDOFXQLDPLFL 3RVVLDPRJLRFDUHDFDUWH«LRKRJLjSUHSDUDWROHODVDJQH9LHQLVXDQFKHWX"
3XUWURSSRQRQSRVVRVWDVHUDGHYRSURSULRODYRUDUH6WRVFULYHQGRXQDUHOD]LRQH6RQRDQFRUDDOO¶LQL]LRH ODGHYRILQLUHHQWURJLRYHGu)LQFKpQRQKRULVROWRTXHVWRSUREOHPDQRQSRVVRSHQVDUHDGDOWUR
3RYHUHWWD$OORUDEXRQODYRUR0LIDFFLRVHQWLUHJLRYHGu
*(581=,8 VWXGLDUH
VWXGLDQGR
VFULYHUH
VFULYHQGR
GRUPLUH
GRUPHQGR
IDUH
IDFHQGR
GLUH
GLFHQGR
67$5(*(581=,8 VWRWHOHIRQDQGR
WHOHIRQH]DFXPvQDFHVWPRPHQW
VWROHJJHQGR
FLWHVFDFXPvQDFHVWPRPHQW
VWRXVFHQGR
LHVDFXPvQDFHVWPRPHQW
3URQWR1LQD"&KHFRVDVWDLIDFHQGRGLEHOOR"
2K QLHQWH GL VSHFLDOH VRQR LQ FXFLQD H VWR SUHSDUDQGR LO SUDQ]R $ SURSRVLWR VH KDL YRJOLD SXRL PDQJLDUHFRQQRL
0DYHUDPHQWHVWRIDFHQGRXQDGLHWD
1HDQFKHQRLPDQJLDPRPROWRFRQTXHVWRFDOGR
(FKHFRVDSUHSDULGLEXRQR"
)DFFLRXQPLQHVWURQHHSRLVDOWLDPRLOVHFRQGRPDSHUWHSRVVRIDUHXQ¶LQVDODWDHXQSR¶GLIRUPDJJLR
'¶DFFRUGRYLIDFFLRYROHQWLHULFRPSDJQLD(YRLPLSRWHWHUDFFRQWDUHTXDOFRVDGHOOHYRVWUHYDFDQ]H
&2081,&$5( &¶q
&DUOR
&LVRQR
9RUUHL
LQYLWDUOR
D«
3XUWURSSRRUD
&DUOD
LQYLWDUOD
QRQSXz
/HRH'LQD
LQYLWDUOL
QRQSRVVRQR
/HDH'LQD
LQYLWDUOH
VWD
ODYRUDQGR DVSHWWDQGRXQD«
VWDQQR
ULSDUDQGRODPDFFKLQD VWXGLDQGRFRQ« SUHSDUDQGR« JLRFDQGRD« SRUWDQGRJOLDPLFLD« IDFHQGRLOEDJQR XQDWUDGX]LRQH SUHQGHQGRLOVROH VFULYHQGRXQD« XVFHQGRFRQ« GRUPHQGR
C
0LODQR
(JUHJLRGRWWRU)UDFFL VRQRYHQXWRDVDSHUHGDOGRWWRU*UDVVLFRQFXLKRSDUODWRLHULDOWHOHIRQRFKHTXHVWDYROWDKDLQWHQ]LRQH GLYHQLUHLQ,WDOLDSHUXQSHULRGRSLOXQJR4XHVWDVDUHEEHXQDEXRQDRFFDVLRQHSHUYHGHUFLFRQSLFDOPDHQRQ VRORGXUDQWHLQRVWULFROORTXLG¶DIIDULLQGLWWDRWUDXQDHUHRHO¶DOWUR 6DUHLSHUFLzPROWROLHWRGLDYHUODRVSLWHQHOODQRVWUDFDVDLQFDPSDJQDYLFLQRD0LODQRSHUWXWWDODGXUDWD GHO6XRVRJJLRUQR 1HOODVSHUDQ]DGLYHGHU/DSUHVWRGDQRLHLQDWWHVDGLXQD6XDFRQIHUPD
/D6DOXWRFRUGLDOPHQWH
*LRYDQQL1DUGL
352180(/(5(/$7,9 $YHQGRLOGHVLGHULRGL«
)UDQFR
KDWHOHIRQDWR
6LFFRPHDEELDPRLOGHVLGHULRGL«
FKH )UDQFD
KRYLVWRLHUL
6SHUDQGRGL«/DVDOXWLDPR«
FRQFXLKRSDUODWR GDFXLVRQRVWDWRLHUL
,%LDJL
DFXLKRVFULWWR GLFXLDYHWHSDUODWR
TXHVWDRFFDVLRQHqEXRQD
TXHVWDqXQDEXRQDRFFDVLRQH
TXHVWHODVDJQHVRQREXRQH
TXHVWHVRQRGHOOHEXRQHODVDJQH
&2081,&$5( 3HUFKpQRQLQYLWLDQFKH
FKH
LOUDJD]]R
DELWDTXLYLFLQR
JOLDPLFL ODUDJD]]D
KDLFRQRVFLXWRD« FRQ
FXL
VHLVWDWRDD«LQ«
OHDPLFKH
/R
YRUUHLLQYLWDUH
PD
VWXGL GD
KDLSDVVDWRLOZHHNHQG
GL
PLKDLWDQWRSDUODWR
QRQF¶qqSDUWLWRSHU«
/L
QRQFLVRQRVRQRDQGDWLLQYDFDQ]D
/D
qDQGDWDYLDqDOO¶RVSHGDOH
OH
KDQQRO¶LQIOXHQ]DVRQRPDODWH
&2081,&$5( 3URQWR
VLJQRUD« VLJQRU«
/D
GLVWXUER
LQYLWDU/D
DSUDQ]R
GRPDQL
FKLDPR
SHUFKpYRUUHL
SRUWDU/D
DFHQD
VWDVHUD
FHUFR
YHGHU/D
DWHDWUR
YHQHUGu
LQFRQWUDU/D
LQFLWWj
VDEDWR
VDOXWDU/D
DFDVDPLD
GRPHQLFD
DYHU/D
TXLGDQRL
«
YHQLUHD WURYDU/D
DFDVD6XD
SDVDUHD SUHQGHU/D
LQXIILFLR HSRL«
'¶DFFRUGR
/D
VLJQRUD« VLJQRU«
ULQJUD]LR
PROWR
YHQJRDWURYDUH
PROWRYROHQWLHUL
YHGR
FRQSLDFHUH
DVSHWWR 6FXVL
SRVVRULFKLDPDUH UDJJLXQJHUH
SLWDUGLSHUFKpDGHVVR« VWR«
WURYDUH PDLR
QRQ/D
VHQWRPROWRPDOH
/DOLQHDqGLVWXUEDWD
VHQWREHQH FRQRVFR
+DVEDJOLDWRQXPHUR
$7$92/$
8QLWj
7LSRVVRRIIULUHTXDOFRVDGDEHUH/XFLD"8QDSHULWLYR"
*UD]LHVu&DUOR«PDQLHQWHGLIRUWHSHUIDYRUH«FRQTXHVWRFDOGR+DLXQDQDOFROLFR"
6uXQELWWHUWLYD"
*UD]LHOREHYRYROHQWLHUL
&KH FRVD EHYHWH" 9L SRVVR GDUH TXDOFRDVD GL IUHVFR" 8QD VSUHPXWD G¶DUDQFLD" 8Q VXFFR GL DOELFRFFD"
8QDVSUHPXWDG¶DUDQFLD*LDQQL/DSUHQGRYROHQWLHULSHUFKpKRPROWDVHWH
(WX0DULVDFKHFRVDEHYL"
3HUPHSLXWWRVWRLOVXFFRGLDOELFRFFD
&2081,&$5( 7L
SRVVRRIIULUH
9L
TXDOFRVDGL
IUHVFR
GDEHUH
8Q
DSHULWLYR&LQ]DQR
GDUH
EXRQR
&DPSDUL&\QDU0DUWLQL
IDUH
DOFROLFR
ELWWHU&URGLQR
SUHSDUDUH
DQDOFROLFR
DPDUHWWRDPDUR
FDOGR
FDIIqFDSSXFFLQRHVSUHVVRWq
IRUWH
VXFFRGLIUXWWDGLSHVFD
RIIUR
GLDOELFRFFD
Gz
VSUHPXWDG¶DUDQFLDGLOLPRQH
IDFFLR 8QD
SUHSDUR
GLSRPSHOPR OLPRQDWDFDPRPLOOD
3UHQGL
JUDSSDELUUD
3UHQGH
DUDQFLDWD
3UHQGHUH
8Q¶
DFTXDPLQHUDOH DFTXDWRQLFD
%HYL
VSXPDQWH
%HYH
8QR
%HYHWH
1RJUD]LH
6uJUD]LH
0DKQRQORVR
DGHVVRQRQEHYRQLHQWH
«OR
EHYR
SUHQGR
«OD
SUHQGR
SUHIHULVFR«
KRVHWH
«O¶
DFFHWWR
SUHQGRSLXWWRVWR«
KRJLjEHYXWRXQ«XQD« DGHVVRQRIRUVHSLWDUGL
YROHQWLHUL
IRUVHqPHJOLR«
PL FL
SXRL
GDUH IDUH
LQYHFH
XQ« XQD«
«PDKDFHUWDPHQWHPROWDIDPHGRSRLOYLDJJLRVLJQRUD&DVLUDJKL&KHFRVD/HSRVVRRIIULUH"
6H QRQ /H GLVSLDFH VLJQRUD 0DVL VROR TXDOFRVD GL OHJJHUR VD KR XQ SR¶ GL SUREOHPL GL GLJHVWLRQH
&DSLVFR&RPHSULPRSUHIHULVFHXQDPLQHVWUDR/HIDFFLRXQSR¶GLSDVWDDOEXUUR"
/DPLQHVWUDPLYDEHQHJUD]LH
(SRLSHUVHFRQGR"8QDIHWWLQDGLYLWHOORFRQXQSR¶GLQYHUGXUDFRWWD"
6u/HLqPROWRJHQWLOHJUD]LH
5,6725$17(
4XDQGRKDLWURSSRODYRUR
4XDQGRQRQKDLSLYRJOLD
©$/35,02
GLVWDUHDFDVD
3,$772ª
4XDQGRWLVHQWLVRORRVROD
4XDQGRLOWUDIILFRWLURYLQDLQHUYL
1RQSUHUGHUHODFDOPD 9LHQLDOSULPR3LDWWR± GDQRLWXWWRqSLURVD
6LDPRVRORDOO¶LQL]LR
,&DPSLRQLLWDOLDQLGLEDVNHWGHO
HJLjWDQWL
%LOO\KDQQRIHVWHJJLDWR
SDUODQRGLQRL
³$O3ULPR3LDWWRODORURYLWWRULD´
&2081,&$5( &KHFRVD
/H
SRVVR
GD
RIIULUH GDUH
4XDOFRVDGL
IRUWH
EHUH
VLJQRUD
PDQJLDUH
VLJQRUH
IUHVFR
«
DQDOFROLFR
SUHSDUDUH
VHQRQ/H GLVSLDFH
IUHGGR FDOGR OHJJHUR
&2081,&$5( &KHFRVD
WL /H YL
RIIUR
D
IDFFLR
SHU
FROD]LRQH XQWqFDIIq« SDQLQR
SUHSDUR
*UD]LH
OR
SUHQGR
OD
SUHQGLDPR
OL XQDEULRFKH FLRFFRODWD SUDQ]R
XQPLQHVWURQH ULVRWWR DUURVWR SDVWLFFLR
FHQD
XQDSDUPLJLDQD IULWWXUDGL« SDVWDDVFLXWWD VSDJKHWWL WRUWHOOLQL FDQQHOORQL ODVDJQH
OH
YROHQWLHUL
(FKHFRVD/HIDFFLRGLEXRQRVWDVHUD"©.DVVOHUªFRQFUDXWLHSDWDWH"/HSLDFH"
,FUDXWLPLSLDFFLRQRPD©.DVVOHUªQRQORVR&KHFRV¶q"
ÊFDUQHGLPDLDOHSUHSDUDWDLQPRGRSDUWLFRODUHÊXQDQRVWUDVSHFLDOLWj%LVRJQDDVVDJJLDUOD
%HQHODSURYRPROWRYROHQWLHUL
«DOORUDGRPDQLVLHWHJLjTXLDOO¶RUDGLSUDQ]RFKHEHOOR(FKHFRVDSRVVRRIIULYL"+RSHQVDWR GLIDUYLLUDYLROLLQEURGRHSRLXQEHOSLDWWRGLIHJDWRDOODYHQH]LDQDFRQSROHQWD9LYD"
%XRQDLGHD,WXRLUDYLROLFLSLDFFLRQRPROWRHSRLLOIHJDWR«
(SHULEDPELQL"$QFKHSHUORURXQSR¶GLEURGR"
0DVDLPDPPDLOEURGRQRQJOLSLDFH«PDSHUORURQRQF¶qSUREOHPDSHU$QJHOLQDSUHQGLXQ SR¶GLVDOVDHOHIDFFLDPRGXHVSDJKHWWLH)UDQFHVFRKDODVXDSDSSDJOLEDVWD«
%HQH$OORUDDGRPDQL%XRQYLDJJLR
&2081,&$5( SLDFH
7L
LOQRVWUR
FDIIq
2KVu
OR
EHYR
OD
EHYLDPR
IRUPDJJLR
OL
PDQJLR
SDQH
OH
PDQJLDPR
YLQR /H ODQRVWUD
9L
PROWRYROHQWLHUL
SDVWD ULFRWWD SLDWWLWLSLFL
LQRVWUL
SURVFLXWWL
SLDFFLRQR
VSHFLDOLWj
OHQRVWUH
ROLYH
&2081,&$5( $
0DUFR
SLDFH
LO
6XRPDULWR
6XRFROOHJD L
OR
PDQJLD
OD
WXDDPLFD
SLDFFLRQR
VSLQDFL DVSDUDJL
7XRLILJOL
]XFFKLQL OH
6XRL
PDQJLDPR
JOL
ODVDJQH
OH
SDWDWH FDURWH
352180(/(3(5621$/(Ì1'$7,9 PL
/H
WL
FL
JOL
YL
OH
JOL
1%
4XDQGRYHGLL&URWWL"
'RPDQL*OLGzOH]LRQHGLWHGHVFR'zORUROH]LRQHGL«
&RVDSRUWR/RUR"RILFLDO
OL
SHSHURQL JOL
6XDFROOHJD WXRLDPLFL
OH
FDODPDUL FUDXWL
WXDPDGUH
$L
PROWR
FDUQH YHUGXUD
SLDFFLDPR
WXDVRUHOOD $OOD
SLDFH
SDVWD
7LQD 6XDPRJOLH
JOL
SROOR OD
WXRDPLFR
$
6u
IHJDWR
WXRSDGUH $O
EURGR
YROHQWLHUL
6HYROHWHSRVVRSUHSDUDUYLTXDOFRVDGLEXRQR
0D%UXQDQRQYRJOLDPRGLVWXUEDUH
6FKHU]DWH"9LSLDFFLRQRLVDOWLPERFFDRSUHIHULWHOHVFDORSSLQHDOPDUVDOD"
&RPHYXRLWX%UXQDSHUPHqORVWHVVR
$OORUDGHFLGLWX%LDQFD
9DEHQH)DLLVDOWLPERFFDSHUzQRLWLDLXWLDPRLRIDFFLRO¶LQVDODWDH3LHURSUHSDUDODWDYROD
'¶DFFRUGR(SRLYLRIIURXQEXRQ JHODWR(VHORGHVLGHUDWH SRL DQGLDPR IXRUL H FRVu YL IDFFLR DQFKHYHGHUHLOQRVWURQXRYRDSSDUWDPHQWR
9XROHDQFRUDGHOOHVDUGLQHGRWWRUH"
6uPROWRYROHQWLHUL6RQREXRQLVVLPH9RJOLRSURSULRVDSHUHFRPHOHID
&HUWR /H SRVVR GDUH OD ULFHWWD 1RQ VRQR GLIILFLOL GD SUHSDUDUH H VRQR SURQWH LQ XQD TXDUDQWLQD GLPLQXWL
6DUGLQHLQIRUQRDOSRPRGRUR ,QJUHGLHQWLSHUSHUVRQH .J GL VDUGLQH FXFFKLDLDWH GL SDQJUDWWDWR XQD VFDWROD GL SRPRGRUL SHODWL GD JU XQ EHO PD]]HWWRGLSUH]]HPRORWULWDWRGXHVSLFFKLG¶DJOLRWULWDWLIDFROWDWLYL ROLRGLROLYDVDOHHSHSH (VHFX]LRQH 3XOLUHLOSHVFHHODVFLDUVFRODUHO¶DFTXD0HWWHUHGHOO¶ROLRLQXQWHJDPHHDJJLXQJHUHVXOIRQGRGHL SRPRGRUL D SH]]HWWL SRL IDUH XQR VWUDWR GL VDUGLQH 0HWWHUFL VRSUD GHO SDQJUDWWDWR SH]]HWWL GLQ SRPRGRUR SUH]]HPROR DJOLR XQ ILOR G¶ROLR XQ SR¶GL SHSH H SRL IDUH XQ VHFRQGR VWUDWR FRPH LO SULPR &RSULUH LO WXWWR FRQ SDQJUDWWDWR ROLR H SHSH H FXRFHUR SHU PLQXWL QHO IRUQR VFDOGDWR D 6HUYLUHVXELWREHQFDOGR
6HYXRL,VDVWDVHUDSRVVRSUHSDUDUWLGHJOLVSDJKHWWLDOO¶DJOLRHROLR7LSLDFFLRQR"
(FRPH
(D*LDFRPR"
3HQVRGLVuPDORSXRLFKLHGHUHDOXLGLUHWWDPHQWH JUDPPL
GLEXUUR
9XRL
XQELFFKLHUH
GLYLQR
9XROH
XQFXFFKLDLR
GLDFHWR
3UHQGL
GHOOHVDUGLQH
XQDIHWWLQD
GLYLWHOOR
3UHQGH
GHLUDYLROL
XQSR¶
GLVDOVDSDVWD
DQFRUD
GHOODYHUGXUD GHOIHJDWR
GHJOLVSDJKHWWL
&2081,&$5( 9XRL
DQFRUD
SROOR
GHO
*UD]LH
FRQWRUQR
QR
SHVFH
9XROH GHOO´
DUURVWR
PDQRQ
YRJOLR
VRQREXRQLVVLPLH PLSLDFH
PDQJLDUH WURSSR
PROWR
FLSLDFFLRQR
DQWLSDVWR
9ROHWH
qEXRQLVVLPRD
YRJOLDPR
LQVDODWD GHOOR
VSH]]DWLQR ]DEDJOLRQH
GDOOD
FDUQH IUXWWD YHUGXUD SROHQWD SLVHOOL
GHL
IDJLROL VDOWLPERFFD GHJOL
VSLQDFL ]XFFKLQL
GHOOH
SDWDWH PHODQ]DQH
'RWWRUHYXROHDQFRUDGHOOHIUDJROHDOODSDQQD"
/H IUDJROH OH PDQJLR PROWR YROHQWLHUL PD QRQ QH SUHQGR WURSSH « EDVWD FRVu ( VHQ]D SDQQD SHUIDYRUH
&RQXQSR¶GLPDUDVFKLQR"
6uYROHQWLHULJUD]LH
,QIULJRULIHURKRDQFRUDGHOODSHSHURQDWD1HYXRLXQSR¶*LXOLDQD"
9ROHQWLHULPDVRQRDGLHWD«
0DQHSXRLSUHQGHUHDOPHQRTXDOFKHFXFFKLDLRWDQWRSHUDVVDJJLDUOD
7XVHLSURSULRODPLDURYLQD«
/HIUDJROHOHPDQJLRYROHQWLHUL,OYLQRORFRPSURLR
GHOOD 9XRL3UHQGL 9XROH3UHQGH 9ROHWH3UHQGHWH
GHO GHOO¶ GHOOR GHOOH GHL GHJOL
«" «" «" «"
YXRLSUHQGL" QH
«"
YXROHSUHQGH" YROHWHSUHQGHWH"
«" «"
/#0)+#4(4'5%1010(4'&&1 70)+1401&+&+'6##06+%#.&1
0DWWLQR VXFFRGLSRPSHOPR IHWWDGLSDQHWRVWDWRFRQGXHFXFFKLDLQLGLPLHOHHJUGLEXUURIUHVFR JUGLIUXWWDIUHVFD 2UH XQDEDQDQD
0H]]RJLRUQR JUGLSURVFLXWWRFUXGRFRQGXHIHWWHGLPHORQH JUGLPR]]DUHOODHXQSRPRGRURFRQROLRRULJDQRVDOHHSHSH ELFFKLHUHGLYLQRELDQFRIUHVFRVRUVHJJLDWRGXHSLFFROHIHWWHGLPHORQH 2UH XQDJURVVDIHWWDGLDQJXULDIUHVFD
6HUD LQVDODWDPLVWDGLVWDJLRQHSRU]LRQHPHGLDJU JUGLSHVFHJULJOLDWRDEROOLWR LQVDODWDGLFHWULOLFRQGLWDFRQROLR ELFFKLHUHGLYLQRELDQFRIUHVFRVRUVHJJLDWR PDFHGRQLDGLPHORQHDQJXULDHIUXWWDGLVWDJLRQH 3ULPDGLFRULFDUVL XQLQIXVLRWLHSLGRGLFDPRPLOODHPHQWDFRQDJJLXQWDGLIRJOLHGLPHQWDIUHVFD
&2081,&$5( 6LJQRUH
SUHQGH
GHO
YLQR
*UD]LH
QH
SUHQGRYROHQWLHUL
XQSRFR
6LJQRUD
GROFH
TXDUWR
6LJQRULQD
EURGR
SLDWWR
DUURVWR
SH]]R
GHOO¶
DPDUHWWR LQVDODWD GHOOR
VWUXGHO VSH]]DWLQR
GHOOD
PLQHVWUD YHUGXUD
ELFFKLHULQR XQDSRU]LRQH IHWWD WD]]D GXHFXFFKLDL GLWD
IUXWWD GHL
SHSHURQL ULSLHQL UDYLROL
GHOOH
FR]]H PHODQ]DQH
GHJOL
DVSDUDJL
$OORUDFKHFRVDWLSUHSDURSHUFHQD"
0DKQRQORVR6WDVHUDQRQKRPROWDIDPH $OOH&DUXJDWWLHGLRDEELDPREHYXWRXQDSHULWLYR DOEDUHGLRKRPDQJLDWRDQFKHXQWUDPH]]LQR
6HYXRLFLVRQRDQFRUDGHLSHSHURQLULSLHQLGLLHULHGHOORVSH]]DWLQR
0DQRQKDLTXDOFRVDGLSLOHJJHUR"
$OORUD WL IDFFLR SLXWWRVWR XQD ELVWHFFD FRQ XQ SR¶ G¶LQVDODWD R YHUGXUD R XQ EURGR ( F¶q DQFKH GHOIRUPDJJLR«
)DFFLDPRFRVuPDQJLRXQ¶LQVDODWDHGHOIRUPDJJLRHSRLXQSR¶GLIUXWWD
/D]LDKDSRUWDWRGHOOHEXRQHFLOLHJHQHYXRL"
6uQHKRSURSULRYRJOLD
&KHFRVDEHYL"8QELFFKLHUHGLQYLQRURVVR"
6uVuYROHQWLHUL
(GRSR"8QFDIIq"
1RJUD]LH6HORSUHQGRSRLQRQGRUPR
&2081,&$5( +R
GHO
GHOOD
EXRQ
EXRQD
YLQR
EXRQL
EXRQH
SLDFFLRQR
OR
EHYR
OD
OD
PDQJLR
OL
OL
SURYR
OH
OH
DVVDJJLR
QH
KR
PR]]DUHOOD
YROHWH
SRPRGRUL GHOOH
FL
YXROH
ILFKL
IUDJROH FLOLHJH
2KVu
SLDFH
SURVFLXWWR
XYD GHL
YXRL
PL
QH
OR
SURYDUH
PROWR
SURSULRYROHQWLHUL
SURSULRYRJOLD
5LWRUQDODWDYRODUDIILQDWD ,OFDPHULHUH
«HRJJLVHYRJOLRQRSRVVLDPRRIIULUH/RURGHJOLDQWLSDVWLVSHFLDOL«
,OVLJQRUH
(FKHFRVDF¶qGLEXRQR"
,OFDPHULHUH
$EELDPRPHODQ]DQHDOODVLFLOLDQDYLWHOORWRQQDWRHSLQ]LPRQLR
,OVLJQRUD
(FKHFRV¶qLOSLQ]LPRQLR"
LOFDPHULHUH
ÊYHUGXUDIUHVFDFUXGDLQXQDVDOVLQDGLROLRSHSHHVDOH6HYXROH/HPRVWURLR FRPHVLPDQJLD
/DVLJQRUD
%HQHDOORUDLRORSURYR«
&2081,&$5( 2JJL
GHO
EXRQ
UDGLFFKLR
1H
YXRL
6u
QH
SUHQGR
XQELFFKLHUH
SUHQGLDPR
ELFFKLHULQR
KR
DUURVWRGL«
YXROH
DEELDPR
IULWWRPLVWR
YROHWH
TXDUWR
EURGR
YRJOLRQR
OLWUR
SRVVR
SHVFH
JRFFLR
RIIULUH
JRUJRQ]ROD
SH]]R
SRVVLDPR
YLQRORFDOH
SH]]HWWLQR
RIIULUH
)UDVFDWL
SR¶
JHODWR
SLDWWR
PLQHVWURQH
XQDIHWWD
ULVRWWR
SRU]LRQH
IRUPDJJLR
ERWWLJOLD
VSXPDQWH
XQRXQD
VSH]]DWLQR
GXHWUH«
]DEDJOLRQH
PH]]DSRU]LRQH
JUDSSD
PH]]DERWWLJOLD
EXRQR
GHOOD
EXRQD
ELUUD LQVDODWDPLVWD PDFHGRQLD PR]]DUHOOD FDFLRWWD PLQHVWUD SDUPLJLDQD ]XSSDYHUGH GHL
EXRQL
ERFFRQFLQL FDODPDUL SHSHURQL ]XFFKLQL VDOWLPERFFD
GHOOH
EXRQH
WDJOLDWHOOH SHQQH ODVDJQH IHWWXFFLQH PHODQ]DQH VRJOLROH FR]]H IUDJROH SHVFKH VFDORSSLQHDO YLQRELDQFR
OR
PDQJLR
OD
PDQJLDPR
OL
EHYR
OH
EHYLDPR
YROHQWLHUL
/¶LWDOLDQRDWDYROD ,Q ,WDOLD HVLVWH DQFRUD OD GLYLVLRQH WUDGL]LRQDOH LQ WUH SDVWL SULQFLSDOL GXUDQWH OD JLRUQDWD OD PDWWLQD F¶q OD FROD]LRQH GHWWD DQFKH ©SULPD FROD]LRQHª H OD VHUD GRSR OH RWWR H PH]]R OD FHQD FKH DOFXQL LWDOLDQL FKLDPDQR ©LO SUDQ]Rª ( SRL SHU FKL YXROH FL VRQR ©VSXQWLQLª ©PHUHQGHª H ©PHUHQGLQHªWUDXQSDVWRDO¶DOWUR 0D LO PRGR GL YLYHUH LQ ,WDOLD q LQ FRQWLQXD HYROX]LRQH H DQFKH D WDYROD O¶LWDOLDQR VWD FDPELDQGR &HUWDPHQWH UHVWD O¶DELWXGLQH GL PDQJLDUH D SUDQ]R H D FHQD XQ SDVWR FDOGR H SL VRVWDQ]LRVR H GL QRQ IDUH TXDVL FROD]LRQH ± VL SUHQGRQR VROR XQD WD]]D GL FDIIq GXH ELVFRWWL H GHOOD PDUPHOODWDDFDVDRLOIDPRVRFDSSXFFLQRFRQODEULRFKHRFRQXQDSDVWDDOEDUSULPDGLDQGDUHD ODYRUDUH,OEUHDNIDVWEULWDQQLFRQRQKDDYXWRVXFFHVVR 3HU PRWLYL SUDWLFL SHUz RJJL LO SUDQ]R q SL OLPLWDWR DQFKH VH UHVWD OD GLYLVLRQH LQ SULPR VHFRQGR FRQWRUQR IUXWWD H FDIIq ,O SULPR SLDWWR RJJL QRQ F¶q TXDVL SL VXOOD WDYROD GL TXHOOL FKH VRQR D GLHWD PD UHVWD SHU JOL DOWUL DQFKH VH VRQR VROWDQWR ©GXH VSDJKHWWLª ,O VHFRQGR q TXDVL VHPSUHXQDELVWHFFDRXQDIHWWLQDFRQO¶LQVDODWD &¶qQDWXUDOPHQWHJHQWHFKHDSUDQ]RPDQJLDDOODPHQVDRYDDOEDUHVLSUHQGHXQSDQLQRXQ WUDPH]]LQR XQ WRDVW LQ SLHGL PD FL VRQR DQFRUD PROWL LWDOLDQL FKH SUHIHULVFRQR IDUH FKLORPHWUL H FKLORPHWULGLDQGDWDHULWRUQRSHUDQGDUHDSUDQ]RDFDVD &LELGLHWHWLFLSURQWLGDFRQVXPDUH &RPH LQ $PHULFD *HUPDQLD H )UDQFLD DQFKH D 0LODQR GD TXDOFKH WHPSR q SRVVLELOH SRUWDUVL D FDVD XQ SUDQ]R JLj FXFLQDWR D EDVVR FRVWR H ©WXWWD VDOXWHª EDVDWR VX RWWLPDOL SULQFLSL GLHWHWLFL©/¶DQJRORGHOODQDWXUDªFRVuVLFKLDPD±YXROHHVVHUHXQDWDYRODFDOGDVSHFLDOHFKHRIIUH FDUQL ELDQFKH SULPL SLDWWL WUDGL]LRQDOL SUHSDUDWL VHQ]D JUDVVL FRQ FDORULH H SURWHLQH LQ JLXVWD TXDQWLWjFKHQXWURQRODVFLDQGRXQVHQVRGLOHJJHUH]]DHGLJHULELOLWj ©1RL VHJXLDPR WXWWR LO FLFOR GDOOD SURGX]LRQH DOOD FRQVXPD]LRQHª FL GLFH OD GLUHWWULFH ©, SURGRWWL IUHVFKL YHQJRQR GDOOD QRVWUD IDWWRULD GL FDPSDJQD OD *LQD! YLFLQR D 3DYLD GRYH ODYRULDPR VHFRQGR SULQFLSL GL DJULFROWXUD SXOLWD! VHQ]D WURSSH VRVWDQ]H FKLPLFKH 4XHVWR FL SHUPHWWH GL IDUH XQD SROLWLFD GHL SUH]]L EDVVL GD QRL XQ SULPR FRVWD OLUH XQ VHFRQGR GL FDUQH XQVHFRQGRGLYHUGXUHLOGROFHGDOOHDOOHOLUH ,QRVWULSULPLSLDWWLWLSLFLWRUWHOOLQLGLPDJURFUrSHVFRQIXQJKLH]XFFKLQLODVDJQHYHUGLFRQ YHUGXUH LQVDODWD GL ULVR 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD L VHFRQGL DEELDPR OR VSH]]DWLQR GL FDUQH ELDQFD WDFFKLQR R SROOR LO SROOR LQ XPLGR LO FRQLJOLR DO PDLV 7UD OH YHUGXUH F¶q XQ SLDWWR VSHFLDOH O¶LQVDODWD GL JHUPRJOL GL VRLD ULFFD GL SURWHLQH YHJHWDOL 7UD OH ELELWH F¶q LO Wq DOOH PRUH H DO JHOVRPLQRHSHUTXHOOLFKHSURSULRYRJOLRQRLOYLQRXQURVDWRDEDVVDJUDGD]LRQHDOFROLFDª %XRQL FLEL GD SRUWDUVL D FDVD R LQ XIILFLR QHOOD SDXVD GL PHQVD /¶RUDULR GH ©/¶DQJROR GHOOD QDWXUDªqGDOOHDOOHHGDOOHDOOH
IRUPDJJLR FKHEXRQRORVSXQWLQR FKHEXRQDODFHQD &LVRQRPROWHSHUJXVWDUHLOIRUPDJJLRWXWWHXJXDOPHQWHDSSHWLWRVHHQXWULHQWL(VLSXzVFHJOLHUHIUD WDQWLJXVWLGLYHUVL4XHOORFKHQRQFDPELDPDLq LO SLDFHUH GL XQ FLER VDQR H JHQXLQR ,O IRUPDJJLR q FRVu ULFFR GL SURWHLQH YLWDPLQH H VDOL PLQHUDOL GD FRQVWLWXLUH XQ DOLPHQWH FRPSOHWR 8QD YHUD H SURSULD ULVRUVD GL HQHUJLD SHU WXWWL H LQ SDUWLFRODUH SHU L SL JLRYDQL 2JJL LO IRUPDJJLR q XQD VFHOWD SUDWLFDHGLQWHOOLJHQWH3HUYLYHUHPHJOLR
IRUPDJJLRXQDEXRQDVFHOWD
&KHFRVDVWDLIDFHQGRLQFXFLQD"+DLELVRJQRGHOPLRDLXWR&DPLOOD"
1RQRKRTXDVLILQLWRJUD]LH5RVD
0DWLGzYROHQWLHULXQDPDQRVHYXRL
6HQHKDLSURSULRYRJOLDSXRLPHWWHUHYLDTXHOODUREDFKHVWDVXOWDYROR
(GRYHODPHWWR"
,SLDWWLHLELFFKLHULYDQQROuLQDOWRDGHVWUDHOHDOWUHFRVHOuDVLQLVWUDLQEDVVR
&DSLWR«(SRL"
*LjFKHFLVHLSXRLDFFHQGHUHLOIXRFRVRWWRODSHQWRODHPHWWHUHVDOHQHOO¶DFTXDSHUIDYRUH"
&HUWR(SUHSDURODWDYRODYDEHQH"
6uPDSRVVLDPRIDUORLQVLHPH
,QTXDQWLVLDPR"
,QVHWWH«+DQQRVXRQDWR«
9DGRDGDSULUHLRODSRUWD
3URQWRVLJQRUD%RULRVL"+RVHQWLWRGDPLRILJOLRFKH/HLQRQVWDEHQHHGqDOHWWRFRQODIHEEUH /DSRVVRDLXWDUH"/HRFFRUUHTXDOFRVDLQIDUPDFLD"
2KVuVLJQRUD&DUOLGHOO¶DVSLULQDHXQRVFLURSSRSHUOHWRVVH+RTXLODULFHWWDGHOPHGLFR
%HQH$OORUDYHQJRJL«/HVHUYHDQFKHTXDOFRVDDOPHUFDWR",RFLYDGRLQRJQLFDVR
1RQKRSLIUXWWDLQFDVDPLVHUYRQRGHOOHEDQDQHHTXDOFKHPHODSHULOEDPELQR
$SURSURVLWR/HSRVVRWHQHUHLR6WHIDQRRJJLSRPHULJJLR"
/HLqPROWRJHQWLOHJUD]LHPDQRQqQHFHVVDULRDOOHWUHYLHQHPLDPDGUH
0DIRUVHSRVVRDQGDUHDOPHQRDSUHQGHUORDOO¶DVLORDOO¶XQD
2KJUD]LHVDUHEEHPROWRJHQWLOH
&¶qELVRJQRGLDLXWR"3RVVRHVVHU/HXWLOHLQTXDOFKHPRGRVLJQRUD"
6uJUD]LHKRXQJXDVWRLOPRWRUHQRQSDUWHHIDVWUDQLUXQRUL6DUHEEHFRVuJHQWLOHGDFKLDPDUH O¶$&,"
&HUWRORIDFFLRVHQ]¶DOWUR
*UD]LH/HLqPROWRJHQWLOH
KRELVRJQRGHOJLRUQDOHGHLJLRUQDOL
DYHUHELVRJQRGL
FLRFFRUUHODPDFFKLQD PLWLJOLOH/HRFFRUUH±RFFRUURQR
PLRFFRUURQRLOLEUL
FLYLJOLVHUYHVHUYRQR
/HVHUYHTXDOFRVD« JOLVHUYRQR«
+RVHQWLWRFKHVHLVHQ]DPDFFKLQD3DWUL]LDFKHFRVDqVXFFHVVR"3RVVRIDUHTXDOFRVDSHUWH"
6DL OD VHWWLPDQD VFRUVD 'LQR KD SUHVR OD PLD H KD DYXWR XQ SLFFROR LQFLGHQWH 1LHQWH GL JUDYH PD GD DOORUD KR OD PDFFKLQD LQ RIILFLQD H QHDQFKH RJJL q SURQWD ( SHQVDUH FKH SURSULR RJJLSRPHULJJLRPLVHUYHSHUSRUWDUHODQRQQDGDOPHGLFR&KHUDEELD
6HQWL«6HYXRLWLSUHVWRYROHQWLHULODPLDILQRDGRPDQLQRQQHKRELVRJQR&KHQHGLFL"
0D*LRYDQQLWXVHLYHUDPHQWHXQDPLFR
KRELVRJQRGHOOLEUR
QHKRELVRJQR
KRYRJOLDGL«
QHKRYRJOLD
qFRQWHQWRGHJOLVFL
QHqFRQWHQWR
FRVDSHQVLGHOILOP
FRVDQHSHQVL
&2081,&$5( +DL
ELVRJQRGLDLXWR"
6u
+D
JUD]LH
$YHWH
JLjFKH
&¶q 7L
SRVVRDLXWDUH"
WL
/D 7L
KDL VHQHYRJOLD KD
/H SRVVR
/H
HVVHUHXWLOH"
RFFRUUH
DLXWR"
VHUYH
TXDOFRVD"
SXz PL
1R
QRQ
DLXWDUPLLQFXFLQD
SXz
LQFDVD DQGDUHDSUHQGHUH«
FLVHL F¶q
DFRPSUDUH« DIDUH«
VHUDEEHSRVVLELOH
SXRL
GDUHXQDPDQR"
SXRL
SUHVWDUPL«GDUPL« PHWWHUHYLD«
HVVHUHFRVuJHQWLOHGD
SRUWDUHLEDPELQLD« FKLDPDUH«
VHUYH
GHOYLQRGHOODWWHXQRVFLURSSR«
RFFRUUH
GHOODIXWWDGHOO¶DVSLULQD
VHUYRQR
GHLSRPRGRULGHJOLVSDJKHWWL
RFFRUURQR
GHOOHEDQDQHGHOOHSHVFKH«
RFFRUUH qQHFHVVDULR
JUD]LH
QHKRELVRJQR KRTXDVLILQLWR
(KL3LQXFFLDFKHFLIDLTXL"SRVVRGDUWLXQDPDQR"
2K$QGUHD,OPRWRULQRQRQPLIXQ]LRQDSLHGLRIUDPH]]¶RUDKRXQDOH]LRQH«
9LHQLWLGzLRXQSDVVDJJLR'RYHGHYLDQGDUH"
,QSLD]]D*ROGRQL
9DGR DQFK¶LR GD TXHOOH SDUWL 3RVVR ODVFLDUWL LQ YLD &DUGXFFL 2K JUD]LH $QGUHD VHL SURSULR XQ WHVRUR0DFKHIDFFLRGHOPRWRULQR"
3RVVLDPRPHWWHUORLQPDFFKLQDHSRUWDUORQHOO¶RIILFLQDTXLLQYLD'DQWH
2KJUD]LH«
/DVFLDIDFFLRLR
0DQRqOHJJHUR7XLQWDQWRDSULGLHWUR«HFFRIDWWR
+DLFKLXVREHQH"$OORUDDQGLDPR
&2081,&$5(
&¶qELVRJQRGHDLXWR"
2KJUD]LHQRQqQHFHVVDULRPD
7L
YHQLUHDSUHQGHUH
VHYXRLSXRL
DQGDUHDSUHQGHUH«
SRUWDUHGDOPHGLFR
VHYXROHSXz
SRUWDUHLEDPELQLD«
/D
SRVVR
DOO¶RVSHGDOH
WHOHIRQDUHDOGRWWRU«
DOFHQWUR
WHQHUHODEDPELQD
7L
GDUHXQSDVVDJJLR
/H
DQGDUHDIDUHODVSHVD
FKLPDUHO¶$&,LOPHGLFR
DSUHQGHUHLEDPELQL
SUHVWDUPLXQSR¶G¶ROLR«
DSUHQGHUHOHPHGLFLQH
DLXWDUPLD«
SUHVWDUHODPDFFKLQD
SUHSDUDUPLTXDOFRVDGD«
WHQHUHLEDPELQL
GDUPLXQSDVVDJJLRILQR« IDUHLFRPSLWLFRQ«
*UD]LD H *LDQSLHUR VRQR XQD JLRYDQH FRSSLD /HL q LQVHJQDQWH H RJJL GHYH DQGDUH D VFXROD DQFKH QHO SRPHULJJLR SHU XQD ULXQLRQH *LDQSLHUR LQYHFH q OLEHUR H UHVWD D FDVD FRQ L EDPELQL $OO¶RUDGLSUDQ]RSDUODFRQVXDPRJOLH
«0HQWUHQRQFLVHLSRVVRIDUHTXDOFRVDLQFDVD"
2KJUD]LH«SHUIDYRUHPHWWLXQSR¶LQRUGLQHODFDPHUDGHLEDPELQLH«SXRLDQGDUPLDIDUHOD VSHVD"
6uWLKRGHWWRFKHRJJLKRWHPSR
%HQH DOORUD JXDUGD XQ SR¶ WX FKH FRVD FL RFFRUUH H YD¶ DO VXSHUPHUFDWR TXL DOO¶DQJROR ,Q RJQL FDVRQRQGLPHQWLFDUHSHUIDYRUHODWWHXRYDVDOHH]XFFKHURSHUFKpQRQQHDEELDPRSL
(DEELDPRYHUGXUD"
$KQR&RPSUDXQFKLORGLSRPRGRULXQSR¶GLFDURWHGHOVHGDQRHTXDOFKHFLSROOD
%HQH(DGHVVRFKHYDLYLDODYRLSLDWWL
$KJUD]LH(VHYXRLSXOLVFLDQFKHXQSR¶ODFXFLQDSHUIDYRUHPDVHQRQQHKDLYRJOLDFLSHQVR LRTXDQGRWRUQR
$FKHRUDULWRUQL"
9HUVROHRWWR«$KVu DQFRUD XQD FRVD ID¶ L FRPSLWL FRQ *LXOLD H DOOH VHWWH GD¶ OD SDSSD D /HR /DFHQDODSUHSDURLRFHUFRGLHVVHUHDFDVDLOSLSUHVWRSRVVLELOH
9DEHQH&LDRWHVRUR6WD¶WUDQTXLOOD3HQVRLRDWXWWR
,03(5$7,9SHUVRDQDD,,DVLQJXODU DUHD HUH LUH
L
QRQDVSHWWDUH
VFULYL
QRQSUHQGHUH
DSUL
QRQSDUWLUH
SXOLVFL
YLHQLWLHQLHVFL
FL
DVSHWWD
YDLIDLGDL
D
3HQVLWXDFRPSUDUH«6uFLSHQVRLR
YD¶ID¶GD¶
&2081,&$5( 6HQWLSRVVR
GDUWLXQDPDQR
2KVu
DVSHWWD
TXLILQRDOO¶DUULYRGL«
HVVHUWLXWLOH
JUD]LH
FDPELD
LSLDWWLLELFFKLHUL
HVVHUWLG¶DLXWR
FHUFD
LOQXPHURGL«GLDSULUH«
IDUHTXDOFRVDSHUWH
FRPLQFLD
DSUHSDUDUH«
IDUHTXDOFRVDLQFDVD
FRPSUD
SDQHROLR«
FKLDPD
LOPHGLFRPLRPDULWRO¶$&,
GRPDQGD
D«O¶LQGLUL]]RGL«
JXDUGD
VHF¶q«GRY¶q«
JLRFD
FRQLEDPELQL
SDVVD
DOSDQLILFLRLQIDUPDFLD
SRUWD
*LQDDVFXRODDOO¶DVLOR
SURYD
DGDSULUHODERWWLJOLD
UHVWD
TXLXQPRPHQWRH«
WHOHIRQD
DOO¶DHURSRUWR
DFFHQGL
LOJDVLOIXRFR
PHWWL
LSLDWWLVXOWDYRORYLDOD«
ULPDQL
TXLFRQLEDPELQL
VFULYL
DOO¶DVVLFXUD]RQHD«
DSUL
OHERWWLJOLHODVFDWROD
ILQLVFL
GLODYDUHLSLDWWL
SXOLVFL
ODFXFLQD
YLHQL
DSUHQGHUPLDOOH«
WLHQL
ODEDPELQDXQPRPHQWR
YD¶
DSUHQGHUH«DOPHUFDWR
ID¶
ODVSHVDLFRPSLWLFRQ«
GD¶
ODSDSSDD«TXDOFRVD«
LQFXFLQD
,)$5((121)$5( &RQWLQXDUHVXOPRGHOOR 3HUFKpQRQODDEEDVVLXQSR¶"±$EEDVVDODXQSR¶SHUSLDFHUH 3HUFKpQRQODVFULYLVXELWR" 1RQO¶KDLDQFRUDFKLXVR" 7LSUHJKLDPRGLSUHQGHUORSHUQRL 'HYLILQLUODSUHVWR 3HUFKpQRQJOLWHOHIRQLHQWURTXHVWDVHUD" 3XRLDVSHUWWDUPLGDYDQWLDOO¶XIILFLR 'HYLGLUPLWXWWR 3HUFKpQRQOLDYYHUWL" 1RQO¶KDLDQFRUDPHVVRQHOIULJRULIHUR" 'HYLSXOLUODDWWHQWDPHQWH 3HUFKpQRQO¶KDLDQFRUDIDWWR"
)RUPXODWHSHULYRVWULDPLFLLWDOLDQLODULFHWWDGLXQDVSHFLDOLWDURPHQD
)DFFLDPRORDOORUD $YHWHLQYLWDWRDQFKH$OEHUWRHODVXDUDJD]]D" 1RFLVLDPRGLPHQWLFDWLLQYLWDUOL ,QYLWLDPROLVXELWR *LDQQDSRWUHEEHYHQLUHFRQQRLRQR" 7HOHIRQDUOH BBBBBBBBBBBBVRFKHqDFDVD ,OGLUHWWRUHYXROGDUYLXQDQRWL]LDLPSRUWDQWH $VFROWDUOR BBBBBBBBBBBBB ¨
&LVHUYLUHEEHODPDFFKLQDHQWURRJJL 5LSDUDUOD BBBBBBBBBBBBQHOSRPHULJJLR
7XVDLGRYHVLSRVVRQRSUHQRWDUHLELJOLHWWLSHULOFRQFHUWR" 1RLQIRUPDUVL BBBBBBBBBBBBBSUHVVRLOWHDWUR &RPHVLIDSHUDUULYDUHD3LD]]D'XRPR" &KLHGHUOR BBBBBBBBBBBBDXQSDVVDQWH ¨
,QFRPLQFLDDIDUIUHVFR 0HWWHUVL BBBBBBBBBBBBBTXDOFRVDDGGRVVR 6HQWLUHRJJLGDQQRLOILOPGL)HOOLQLSHUO¶XOWLPDYROWD $OORUDDQGDUFL BBBBBBBBBBBBBTXHVWDVHUD
0HWWHWHODIRUPDDGDWWDGHOYHUERFRPHQHOVHJXHQWHHVHPSLR
6HYHQLUHD5RPDVLJQRUDSDVVDUHGDQRL 6HYLHQHD5RPDVLJQRUDSDVVLGDQRL 6HSDVVDUHGDOODIDUPDFLDVLJQRUD%LDJLFRPSUDUHXQSR¶GLQDVSULQDSHUPH 6HDYHUHWHPSRVLJQRU%ULJQRQHYHQLUHGDPH 6HSUHIHULUHVLJQRULQD&DUGHOODILQLUHSULPDTXHVWDOHWWHUD 6HLQFRQWUDUHLOVLJQRU0DUFHOOLQLVLJQRUDVWDUHDWWHQWDDQRQGLUJOLWURSSR 6HQRQWURYDUORGDYDQWLDFDVDVXDVLJQRUHDYHUHSD]LHQ]DHVDOLUHGDOXL 6HYROHUHYHQLUHVLJQRUDVFULYHUPLGXHULJKH 6HWHOHIRQDUHDL6LPRQHOOLVLJQRULQD7XFFLVDOXWDUOLGDSDUWHQRVWUD 6HDUULYDUHD0LODQRVLJQRUHDYYHUWLUFLVXELWR 6HDQGDUHLQ)UDQFLDVLJQRULQDIHUPDUVLD3DULJLSHUDOFXQLJLRUQL 6HYHGHUH6DQGURVLJQRUDGLUJOLGLYHQLUHGDPH
,OFDSRGjGHJOLRUGLQLDOODVXDVHJUHWDULD
WHOHIRQDUHVXELWRDOODEDQFD
SRUWDUPLODFRUULVSRQGHQ]DFRQODGLWWD 9DU]L
IDUHXQFDIIqSHUQRL
DFFRPSDJQDUHODVLJQRUDLQSRUWLQHULD
YHGHUHVHqDUULYDWRLOQXRYRFOLHQWH
SUHQRWDUHXQSRVWRVXOO¶DHUHRSHU0LODQR
QRQSHUGHUHWHPSR
XVFLUHVXELWR
LQIRUPDUVLSUHVVRO¶XIILFLRSDVVDSRUWL
QRQGLPHQWLFDUHGLFKLDPDUHO¶DYYRFDWR
JXDUGDUHVHODIDWWXUDqJLjSDJDWD
VSHGLUHTXHVWDOHWWHUDHQWURRJJL
'DWHGHOOHLSHUHVHPSLR &DUODFRPSUDXQSR¶GLQIUXWWDSHUPH±6LJQRUDFRPSULXQSR¶GLQIUXWWDSHUPH )UDQFRYDLDGDSULUHODSRUWD *LDQQDVFHJOLWXSHUQRL 1RQSDUWLUHFRVuSUHVWR 3UHQRWDGXHSRVWLSHUTXHVWDVHUDSHUIDYRUH 9LHQLGDQRLGRPDQLPDWWLQD 1RQSHUGHUHO¶LQGLUL]]R0DUFR &HUFDGLDUULYDUHLQWHPSR 1RQGLUHQLHQWHD*LXOLDSHUIDYRUH 1RQDFFHWWDUHTXHVWHFRQGL]LRQL 6FLRJOLSULPDXQSR¶GLEXUUR7HUHVD 1RQGLPHQWLFDUORSHUIDYRUH $OHVVDQGURSRQLORVXOWDYROR
5LVFULYHWHLGLDORJKLVHQ]DXVDUHO¶LPSHUDWLYR *LDFRPRYLHQLTXL 3HUIDUHFKHFRVD" $LXWDPLXQSR¶FRQTXHVWDWUDGX]LRQH ,QFKHPRGR" %DWWLTXHVWDSDJLQDDPDFFKLQD 9DEHQH )DLSULPDLFRPSLWL$QJHOD 3HUFKpQRQOLSRVVRIDUHSLWDUGL" 1RQFRQWUDGGLUPLVHPSUH $QFKHJOLDOWULYDQQRRUDLQSLVFLQD &LzFKHIDQQRJOLDOWULPLLQWHUHVVD3ULPDVWXGLDGRSRHVFL ¨
6LJQRULQDEDWWDTXHOODUHOD]LRQH0LVHUYHVXELWR 0DQRQGHYRILQLUHODOHWWHUDDOOD%XO]RQL"
¨
1RQqXUJHQWH6LSUHRFFXSLSULPDGHOODUHOD]LRQH 1RQHVFDDTXHVW¶RUDVLJQRUDÊPROWRSHULFRORVR 'HYRDQGDUFLDGRJQLFRVWR $OORUDYDGDLQWDVVu 3DVVDWHGDQRLHSUHQGHWHXQFDIIq *UD]LHGHOO¶LQYLWRGREELDPRDQGDUHDOODVWD]LRQHDSUHQGHUHLQRVWULDPLFLWHGHVFKL 3RWHWHSRUWDUHDQFKHLYRVWULDPLFL 0LGLVSLDFHDEELDPRJLjSUHVRXQLPSHJQRFRQL7RPDVHOOLFHQLDPRGDORUR $OORUDYHQLWHXQDOWURJLRUQR3HUzDYYHUWLWHFLSULPD '¶DFFRUGR
5HIRUPXODUHLQ,,DSHUVRQDVLQJRODUH 0LGLFDQRVXELWRFLzFKHYRJOLRQRVLJQRUL'LWHPLVXELWRFLzFKHYROHWH %XRQJLRUQRHQWULQRSXUHVLDFFRPRGLQR 0ROWRJHQWLOH 6LVLHGDQRXQPRPHQWR,OGRWWRUHqOLEHURIUDSRFR *UD]LH
¨
3UHQGDQRSXUHXQDOWURSR¶GLYLQR 9ROHQWLHULJUD]LH 0LDVFROWLQRSHUIDYRUH &LGLFD 3RVVLDPRSUHQGHUHXQDOWURSR¶GLFDIIq" 6LVHUYDQRSXUH
¨
1RQYHQJDQRDGLVWXUEDUPLSURSULRDGHVVR 1RQVLDPRYHQXWLSHUTXHVWR
&RPELQDUH D
1RQKRYRJOLDRJJLGLPHWWHUHRUGLQHVXOODPLDVFULYDQLD
o
$OORUDIDOORQHOSRPHULJJLR
o
3HUFKpQRQORIDLGRPDQL"
o
3HUFKpQRQORIDGRPDQLPDWWLQD"
o
1RQqPROWRXUJHQWHORSRWUHVWLIDUHGRSRSUDQ]R
E $FFLGHQWLFLPDQFDODSDVWD o
+DLFRPSUDWROHWDJOLDWHOOH"
o
3UHJKLDPRODVLJQRUD6DQWLQLGLSUHVWDUFLXQSR¶GLQVSDJKHWWL
o
/DPHWWRLRQHOO¶DUPDGLR
o
9DLDFXFLQDUODVXELWR
F
'RYHFLYHGLDPRTXHVWDVHUD"
o
'HFLGLORWX
o
3HUFKpQRQPLDVSHWWDDOOHWUHGDYDQWLDFDVDVXD"
o
,QFRQWULDPRFLDOEDULQYLD3HWUDUFD
o
1RQSRWUHVWLYHQLUPLDSUHQGHUHLQXIILFLR"
G ,QGRYLQDFKLYLHQHDFHQDTXHVWDVHUD" o
2JJLPLKDWHOHIRQDWR$GULDQRGDOO¶$PHULFD
o
$EELDPRLQYLWDWRTXDOFXQR"
o
9DLDGDSULUHODSRUWD
o
1RQQHKDLGHD
&RPELQDUHGRPDQGDHULSRVWD &RPHIDFFLRDVPRQWDUOR"
D
4XDQGRGRYUzHVVHUHDOODVWD]LRQHTXHO
E 1HSDUOHUzFRQLOGLUHWWRUH
JLRUQR"
F
$SSHQDDYUzXQSRGLWHPSR )UDQFHVFDSDUWLUjVHQ]DGLPH
1RQSRWUHVWLDFFRPSDJQDUPLWX"
G 1RQWLSUHRFFXSDUHWLDLXWHUzLR
&KHIDUDLGRPHQLFD"
H
6WDLFHUWDJOLULIHULUzWXWWR
3HUFKpVHLFRVuDUUDEELDWR(Q]R"
I
&HUWRWHOHIRQHUzDOPHGLFRHQWURRJJL
&KHJOLOHJJHUDL"
J 1RQVRDQFRUDO¶RUDHVDWWD7LDYYHUWLUz
4XDQGROROHJJHUDL" 1RQGHYLFKLDPDUHORVWXGLRPHGLFRSHU VDSHUHLOULVXOWDWRGHOO¶DQDOLVL" &RPHIDUzDWURYDUHXQDOEHUJRQHOSHULRGR GHOODILHUD" 1RQKDLXQDSURSRVWD"
TXDOFKHJLRUQRSULPD K 7LSXRLULYROJHUHDOO¶XIILFLRLQIRUPD]LRQL L
6LYHGUj
M
)RUVHDQGUzDWURYDUHLPLHLJHQLWRUL
&RPHILQLUjTXHVWDVWRULD" )DEUL]LRWHOHIRQDD9DOHULDFKHKDFRQRVFLXWRDOFXQLJLRUQLIDLQXQDGLVFRWHFD9RUUHEEHLQYLWDUOD D FHQD LQ XQ ULVWRUDQWH LO SURVVLPR ILQH VHWWLPDQD &KLHGH D 9DOHULD FKH IDUj VDEDWR H GRPHQLFD SHU SURSRUOHGLXVFLUH9DOHULDQRQKDPROWRLQWHUHVVHGLULYHGHUOR3HUQRQ HVVHUHVFRUWHVHODVFLD DSHUWD ODSRVVLELOLWjGLUHYHGHUVLLQXQ¶DOWUDRFFDVLRQH 5LFRQVWUXLWHLQGXHIUDYRLDWHOHIRQDWDGL)DEUL]LRD9DOHULD
D )DEUL]LR QRQ ULQXQFLD 4XDQGR GXH VHWWLPDQH GRSR KD VXSHUDWR FRQ VXFFHVVR O¶HVDPH ILQDOH DOO¶XQLYHUVLWj YXROH IHVWHJJLDUH O¶DYYHQLPHQWR LQYLWDGR DOFXQL DPLFL 0DQGD XQ LQYLWR DQFKH D 9DOHULD 0HWWHWHORQHOODVHTXHQ]DJLXVWD &DUD9DOHULD LQVLHPHDJOLDPLFL FRQVXFFHVVR
LQTXHVWRSHULRGR
GDOOHRUHLQSRL
SHUFKp KR GRYXWR SUHSDUDUH WHPSR
VDEDWRLOVHWWHPEUH
FKHQRQFLVLDPRULYLVWL
GLIDUPLVHQWLUH
VH YHUUDL DQFKH WX
JOLHVDPLILQDOL
O¶DOWUR LHUL
FKH KR VXSHUDWR
PLqGLVSLDFLXWRPROWR &RUGLDOPHQWH
)DEUL]LR E(9DOHULDFKHULVSRQGHUj"6LIDUjLQIOXHQ]DUHGDOO¶RURVFRSR"
)DWHGHOOHIUDVLFRPHQHOVHJXHQWHHVHPSLR SDUODUH±SULPD±WXSRL±SDUODUH±QRL 3DUODSULPDWXSRLSDUODUHPRQRL VFULYHUH±ODOHWWHUD±WXQRL±LPEXFDUOD DQGDUH±SULPD±OHLVLJQRUD3DULVL%UXQR±DUULYDUH±GXHRUHGRSR DYYHUWLUH±YRL±O¶DPLFDDQGDUHDSUHQGHUOD±LR±DFDVDVXD IDUH±QRL±SHUSULPLWX±IDUH±GRSRGLQRL EHUH±SULPD±WXSRL±EHUH±LR WHOHIRQDUH±WX±DL6DEDWLQLQHOIUDWWHPSR±LR±VIRJOLDUH±LOJLRUQDOH ILQLUH±SULPD±YRLORUR±SRWHUHDVSHWWDUYL VFHJOLHUH±SULPD±OHLVLJQRULQD3URLHWWLGRSR±VFHJOLHUH±LR LQFRPLQFLDUH±WXQRL±VHJXLUWL YHGHUH±SULPD±OHLQRL±YHGHUH±GRSR
VDUzIHOLFH
YRUUHLIHVWHJJLDUHO¶DYYHQLPHQWR QRQ KR DYXWR
ODYDUVL±RUD±WXLR±ODYDUVL±SLWDUGL YHQLUH±SULPD±OHLJOLDOWUL±YHQLUH±GRSR
7URYDUHVLQRQLPLSHUJOLDYYHUELGLPRGR (QULFRQRQDPDODIUHWWDSUHIHULVFHIDUHOHFRVHFRPRGDPHQWH 0LKDULVSRVWRVLQFHUDPHQWH )RUWXQDWDPHQWHLOWUHQRQRQqDQFRUDSDUWLWR /DVLJQRUD'HOOD9DOOHYHVWHVHPSUHHOHJDQWHPHQWH 'LPPLEUHYHPHQWHFKHWLKDGHWWR 9LVDOXWLDPRDIIHWWXRVDPHQWH $QWRQHOODVLqFRPSRUWDWDRJJLPROWRVWUDQDPHQWH ,OVLJQRU&RQWLqQXRYDPHQWHTXLLQSRUWLQHULD 0DWWKLDV q DQGDWR DOO¶XIILFLR PRWRUL]]D]LRQH SHU LQIRUPDUVL VXOOD SDWHQWH LWDOLDQD ,O SROL]LRWWR JOL KD FRQVLJOLDWR GL UHFDUVL DOO¶XIILFLR VWUDQLHUL 0DWWKLDV VL q UHFDWR D TXHVWR XIILFLR PD KD GRYXWR IDUH OD FRGD SULPD GL HQWUDUH /¶LPSLHJDWR O¶KD PDQGDWR DG XQD VFXROD JXLGD 4XL JOL KDQQR GDWR XQ PRGXOR GD ULHPSLUH 0DWWKLDV QRQ FDSLVFH WXWWH OH GRPDQGH 9D GDOO¶DPLFR $GULDQRSHUIDUVLDLXWDUHHJOLSDUODPDOHGHJOLXIILFLLWDOLDQL 5LFRQVWUXLWHLOGLDORJRIUD0DWWKLDVH$GULDQR
5RPDJLXJQR
&DULVVLPLVLJQRUL*LOEHUWL
YL ULQJUD]LR PROWR SHU OH IRWR FKH PL DYHWH PDQGDWR 6RQR YHUDPHQWH EHOOH H PL KDQQR IDWWR ULFRUGDUHLPRPHQWLIHOLFLFKHDEELDPRWUDVFRUVRLQVLHPH
6SHUR VHPSUH FKH PDQWHUUHWH OD SURPHVVD GLQ YHQLUPL D WURYDUH UHVWR FRVu SRWUHPR SDVVDUH DQFRUDTXDOFKHJLRUQRLQFRPSDJQLD5LQJUD]LDQGRYLDQFRUDYLVDOXWRDIIHWWXRVDPHQWH
0LOHQD
/D VLJQRUD *LOEHUWL UDFFRQWD D VXD ILJOLD LO FRQWHQXWR GL TXHVWD OHWWHUD &KH FRVD GLFH OD VLJQRUD *LOEHUWL"
,,6&216,*/,$5((9,(7$5( &RPSOHWDUHLVHJXHQWLGLDORJKLSHULVFULWWR
&KLWLKDGHWWRGLDVSHWWDUPL" 0DULRBBBBBBBBBKDGHWWR &KLOHKDGDWRTXHVWRFRQVLJOLR" ,OVLJQRU%LDQFKLBBBBBBBKDGDWR &RVDIDUDL"5LIHULUDLFLzFKHKDLVHQWLWRDOWXRFDSR" &HUWRBBBBBBBBBBBULIHULUz ¨
6FXVLVDGRYHVLYHQGRQRLELJOLHWWLSHULOFRQFHUWR" 1RQRQORVR%LVRJQDLQIRUPDUHBBBBBBBBBBSUHVVRLOWHDWUR 3RWUHLFKLHGHUORDOODVLJQRUD*LRUJL" 6HFRQGRPHIDUHEEHPHJOLRDQRQFKLHGHUHBBBBBBBBBB 6DSHWHULHPSLUHTXHVWRPRGXOR" /¶LPSLHJDWRBBBBBBBBBBBKDVSLHJDWR
¨
2JJLGHYRSDVVDUHGD(OHQDSHULQYLWDUODDOODQRVWUDIHVWD 6uqYHURULFRUGDBBBBBBBBBB $YHWHJLjDYYHUWLWRL3LDFHQWLQLGHOODYRVWUDSDUWHQ]D" 1RDSSHQDDYUHPRGHFLVRODGDWDSUHFLVDBBBBBBBBIDUHPRVDSHUH &KLSUHSDUDRJJLLOSUDQ]RDLWXRLILJOL" 1RQWLSUHRFFXSDUHBBBBBBBBBBBSUHSDUDQRGDVROL
¨
0LSRWUHEEHPRVWUDUHFRPHVLID" 9ROHQWLHULBBBBBBBBBPRVWURVXELWR &KHQHGLFL"/RFRPSURTXHVWRYHVWLWR" BBBBBBBBBBBVFRQVLJOLRSHUFKpFRVWDWURSSR
3HUFKpVHPSUHDOPDUH" )DWHSURSRVWHSHUIHULHXQSR¶GLYHUVH'RYHYLSLDFHUHEEHWUDVFRUUHUOH"0RWLYDWHODVFHOWD
/DVLJQRUD$JX]]LWURYDVHPSUHXQPRWLYR SHU DYYHUWLUH JOL DOWUL GL TXDOFKH SHULFROR &KH GLFHQHOOHVHJXHQWLVLWXD]LRQL"
7877,6(1(9$112
&RPSOHWDWHFRQXQDIRUPDYHUERDQGDUVHQH
'HYLJLjBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB/XLVD" 6uGHYRHVVHUHDOO¶XQLYHUVLWjDOOHQRYH(WXTXDQGRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB" ,RRJJLQRQKROH]LRQH5HVWRTXLSHUVWXGLDUH)RUVHSDVVRGD*LDQQLQHOSRPHULJJLRSHUIDUPL DLXWDUHQHLFRPSLWLGLPDWHPDWLFD 3HUFKpQRQBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVLJQRUD0DULDQL"/HLVWDDVSHWWDQGRLQXWLOPHQWH 1RQVRQRQYRUUHLRIIHQGHUOR0DIRUVHKDUDJLRQHDOORUDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ¨
&DUORBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBJLj" 6uXQTXDUWRG¶RUDID1RQqSRWXWRUHVWDUHSHUFKpGRPDQLGHYHSDUWLUHSHU$QFRQD 3HUFKpBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB"/DIHVWDQRQqDQFRUDLQFRPLQFLDWD &LGLVSLDFHQRQSRVVLDPRUHVWDUH'REELDPRWRUQDUHDFDVDFROO¶DXWREXVSHUFKpLQTXHVWLJLRUQL VLDPRVHQ]DPDFFKLQD 6HqSHUTXHVWRQRQGRYHWHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB9HORGDUHPRQRLXQSDVVDJJLR &RPHqDQGDWDODULXQLRQH" 0ROWREHQHqJLjILQLWDWXWWLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (WXSHUFKpVHLULPDVWRLQXIILFLR" 9RUUHLDQFRUDSDUODUHXQPRPHQWRFRQLOFDSRSULPDGLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
¨
$VSHWWLDPRJLjGDXQ¶RUD)RUVHDEELDPRVEDJOLDWRJLRUQR
¨
2KqYHURFRPHVLDPRVWXSLGLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBDOORUD
6uRUDPLULFRUGRDEELDPRGHWWRPDUWHGuGHOODVHWWLPDQDSURVVLPDHQRQTXHVWRPDUWHGu
3URYDWHDGLUORLQPRGRSLFRUWHVH
$YHWHTXDOFKHOLEURGDUHJDODUPL" 9LHQLDFHQDGDPHTXHVWDVHUD" &¶qTXDOFXQRFKHPLGjXQDPDQR" 9HQJRYROHQWLHUL 'LFRFKHWXWWRYDEHQH 0LSDVVLLOSDQHSHUIDYRUH" 3RWHWHLQGLFDUPLODVWUDGD" 9RJOLRGLUYLGXHSDUROH 0LIDTXHVWDFRUWHVLD" 6DLGLUPLFKHGHYRIDUHLQTXHVWRFDVR" 1RLVLDPRGLSDUHUHGLYHUVRGDOYRVWUR 3HQVRGLVu 3XzGLUPLSHUIDYRUHFKHRUHVRQR" 1RQVRQRGLTXHVWRSDUHUH
8QVRJQRDGRFFKLDSHUWL6HIRVVLULFFR
&KHSHQVDWHGHOVRJQRGLTXHVWRVLJQRUH"
/HJJHWHTXDQWRVHJXH4XDOLSRVWLGLIHULHFRQVLJOLHUHVWHDOOHVHJXHQWLSHUVRQHRIDPLJOLH" 'DFLDH*LDQFDUOR'L/RUHQ]RKREE\OHLVWRULDIROFORUHOXLPDQJLDUHEHQHIRWRJUDIDUH *LRYDQQD '¶$PHOLD LPSLHJDWD D 0LODQR q LQWHUHVVDWD D FRQRVFHUH GXUDQWH OH IHULH OH UHJLRQL LWDOLDQH TXHOOH FKH VRQR PROWR GLYHUVH GDOOD /RPEDUGLD GRYH YLYH 1HO WHPSR OLEHUR VL GHGLFD DOOD SLWWXUD , 5LFFL GXH IOLJOL H DQQL LQWHUHVVL OXL ELRORJLD OHL ULSRVDUVL SDVVHJJLDUH L JHQLWRUL GL OHL DELWDQRYLFLQRD0LODQR 0DVVLPR %DOGLQHOOL VWXGHQWH GL DUFKHRORJLD VSLULWR GL DYYHQWXUD JOL SLDFFLRQR L SRVWL VHPSOLFL GRYHODQDWXUDqDQFRUDLQWDWWD
&RQWLQXDUHVXOPRGHOOR 6HFRQGRODUDGLRLQRVWULDYHUH BBBBBBDYUHEEHURBBBSHUVR 6HFRQGRODVLJQRUDL9DOPDUHQJRHVVHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBJLjSDUWLWL $VHQWLUHOXLQRQDYHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSDUODWRFRQQHVVXQR 6HFRQGROHXOWLPHLQIRUPD]LRQLLOSUHVLGHQWHDUULYDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBRJJLD5RPD $ VHQWLUH OD ORUR YHUVLRQH GHL IDWWL L QRVWUL OL DYHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB SURYRFDWL GXUDQWH OD SDUWLWD
(OHLFKHFRVDIDUHEEH" 6HXQ¶DPLFDODLQYLWDVVHDSUDQ]RSHUGRPDQLFRVDULVSRQGHUHEEH" &KHFRVDIDUHEEHVHDYHVVHSLWHPSROLEHUR" 6HXQFRQRVFHQWHOHFKLHGHVVHLQSUHVWLWRLOVXRQXRYRJLUDGLVFKLFKHFRVDJOLGLUHEEH" 'RYHDQGUHEEHVHSRWHVVHIDUHXQYLDJJLRPROWROXQJR" 6HLOVXRSDUWQHUODVXDSDUWQHUQRQWRUQDVVHXQDQRWWHDFDVDVHQ]DDYYHUWLUODFRVDSHQVHUHEEH" 6HGRYHVVHYLYHUHGDVRORGDVRODSHUVHLPHVLLQXQDLVRODFKHFRVDVLSRUWHUHEEH"
&RPSOHWDWHVHJXHQGRO¶HVVHPSLR 6HVEULJDUVL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBDUULYHUHPPRLQWHPSRDOO¶XOWLPRVSHWWDFROR 6H 5REHUWR FRPSRUWDUVL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB GD YHUR DPLFR WL VFRQVLJOLHUHEEH GL HVVHUH FRVuLPSUXGHQWH &LFDSLUHPPRPHJOLRVHGLVFXWHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWUDQTXLOODPHQWH 6H VDSHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB FRQ SUHFL]LRQH O¶RUDULR GHO WUHQR YHUUHL D SUHQGHUWL DOOD VWD]LRQH 6HFLGDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBXQDPDQRVDUHPPRPROWRFRQWHQWL )RUVHORDVFROWHUHVWLVHWHORVFRQVLJOLDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFRQGHFLVLRQH 6HLQWHUHVVDUVHQH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWXVDUHPPRFHUWLGLULVROYHUHLQEUHYHWHPSRL QRVWULSUREOHPL 6HVWDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFRQYRLD0LODQRYLDLXWHUHLVHQ]¶DOWUR 6HWHORFRQVLJOLDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBJOLDOWULJOLGDUHVWLDVFROWR /HVSLHJKHUHEEHURSLFKLDUDPHQWHGRY¶qODGLIILFROWjVHSRWHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSDUODUOHGLQ SHUVRQD 9HORGLUHPPRFKLDUDPHQWHVHQRQHVVHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBG¶DFFRUGR 6HJOLHORGLUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWHORGDUHEEH 6HIDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSLFDOGRSRWUHPPRDQGDUHDOPDUH
/HL VL WURYD LQ XQR VFRPSDUWLPHQWR SHU QRQ IXPDWRUL QHO WUHQR 5RPD ± 1DSROL 8Q VLJQRUH GL PHGLDHWjHQWUDQHOORVFRPSDUWLPHQWRFRQXQDVLJDUHWWDDFFHVD$OO¶LQL]LROHLQRQJOLGLFHQLHQWH PDTXDQGROXLVWDSHUDFFHQGHUVLXQ¶DOWUDVLJDUHWWDDOORUDOHL OR DYYHUWH FKH TXL QRQ q SHUPHVVR IXPDUH 'D SULPD OXL ID ILQWD GL QRQ DYHU FDSLWR GRSR XQ VHFRQGR DYYHUWLPHQWR VSHJQH OD VLJDUHWWD1DVFHFRVuXQGLDORJRVXOYL]LRGLIXPDUH&RPSOHWDWHTXHVWRGLDORJR
'(/,772 ',)802 GL*LRYDQQL0DULD3DFH ÊJLXVWRYLHWDUHODVLJDUHWWDLQWXWWLLORFDOLSXEEOLFLHQHJOLXIILFL" 8QVRQGDJJLR7HOHPDUNSHU³/¶(VSUHVVR´ULYHODFKHLWDOLDQL VXFHQWRVRQRIDYRUHYROLDXQDOHJJHLQTXHVWRVFHQDULR
6FXVLVLJQRUHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB $KFRPHVRQRVHPSUHSLHQLTXHVWLWUHQLSHU1DSROL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB /DVSHJQRVXELUR'HYHVFXVDUHVLJQRUD1RQSRVVLDPRVHPSUHDWWHQHUFLDWXWWHOHUHJROH )RUVHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBLQXQRVFRPSDUWLPHQWRSHUIXPDWRUL 6uPDQRQKRWURYDWRSRVWR&HUWRQRQIXPDUHPLIDEHQHqGDWHPSRFKHLOPHGLFRPHOR YLHWD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ÊYHURPDQRQFLULHVFR4XDQGRLOODYRURqWDQWRHVRQRQHUYRVRXDQVLJDUHWWDPLIDEHQHPL FDOPD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB $QFKHVHQRQIXPDVVLQRQVHUYLUHEEHPROWR4XDVLWXWWLLFROOHJKLLQXIILFLRIXPDQR 'DQRLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBLQPROWLXIILFL 6HIRVVHFRVuDQFKHQHOODPLDGLWWDDYUHLSLPRWLYLSHUQRQIXPDUHSL
4XDOLUHD]LRQLVRQRJLXVWH" ±6LDPRXQTXDUWRG¶RUDLQULWDUGR D
±7HPRGLQRQIDUHLQWHPSRSHUO¶XOWLPRVSHWWDFROR
E ±7HPRFKHLOWUHQRVLDJLjSDUWLWR F
±7HPRFKHQRQDUULYLDWHLQWHPSRSHUO¶XOWLPRVSHWWDFROR
G ±$OORUDVEULJDWLDQFKHWX ±+RVHQWLWRFKHLOQXRYRILOPGL)HOOLQLqXVFLWRTXHVWLJLRUQL$QGLDPRDYHGHUOR" D
±&UHGRFKHQRQYDOJDODSHQD,ILOPGLQ)HOOLQLVRQRVHPSUHODVWHVVDFRVD
E ±&UHGRGLDYHUORJLjYLVWRD5RPD F
±&UHGRFKHVLDEXRQR
G ±1RQSRVVRSHUGHUHGXHRUHDOFLQHPDKRWDQWRGDIDUH ±)RUVHVDUHEEHPHJOLRSDVVDUHSULPDSHULOFHQWURDYUHLGDIDUHGHJOLDFTXLVWL&KHQHGLFH" D
±1RQPLVHPEUDFKHVLDXQDEXRQDSURSRVWDSHUFKpPROWLQHJR]LVRQRDQFRUDFKLXVL
E ±0LVHPEUDGLDYHUORJLjYLVWR F
±1RQPLVHPEUDLOFDVRFKH/HLIDFFLDXQJLURFRVuOXQJRSHUPH
±1RQULHVFRDWURYDUHLSDQWDORQLGL/HD D
±6EULJDWHYL1RQYRJOLRHVVHUHVHPSUHLQULWDUGRSHUFROSDYRVWUD
E ±/DVFLDSHUGHUH1RQYRJOLRFKH/HDYDGDLQSDQWDORQLDOWHDWUR F
±1RQYRJOLRFKHIDFFLDWHXQWDOHGLVRUGLQH
9DRFDEROLXWLOL LOJUHPELXOHúRU XO ORVSHFFKLRRJOLQGD ODVFRSDP WXUD
,,,&2081,&$5((&$3,56, 6SHULDPREHQH
&RPSOHWDUHLVHJXHQWLGLDORJKL +DLLGHDVH&DUORYHUUjTXHVWDVHUDDSRUWDUFLLOLEUL" 1RQORVR6SHURBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSHUFKpPLVHUYRQRGRPDQL )RUVHqPHJOLRGDUJOLXQFROSRGLQWHOHIRQR 'RPDQLODJLXULDDVVHJQHUjLSUHPLQHOODJDUDGLSLWWXUD %XRQDIRUWXQD*LDQQL6SHURBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ¨
,OVLJQRU3LDQWRQLPLKDSUHJDWRGLDYYLVDUODFKHRJJLQRQSXzPHWWHUVLLQFRQWDWWRFRQOHL 6SHUDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGRPDQL *UD]LHGLDYHUPLDYYHUWLWR $QGUDLLQIHULHODVHWWLPDQDSURVVLPD/XFLD" 6HORVDSHVVL8QFROOHJDVLqDPPDODWRGXHJLRUQLIDHQRQVLVDTXDQGRWRUQHUjLQXIILFLR $OORUDVSHULDPRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 1RQqJLjWDUGLVLJQRUD" 6uVSHURSHUzBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
D&RPHVLVFULYH"&RQXQDP!RFRQGXH"
E&RPHVLVFULYHLOSOXUDOHGL
FRPLQFLDUH
DUDQFLD
FRPRGR
ODJR
LPDJLQH
PRJOLH
GLPL
PHGLFR
FRPXQLFD]LRQH
IDUPDFLD
DPDODUVL
JLRFR
GDPL
SURYLQFLD
LPHGLDWR
VSLDJJLD
SRPRGRUR
ILJOLR
$PDUHWWR
DOEHUJR
6X XQ JLRUQDOH LWDOLDQR DYHWH OHWWR LQ XQ¶LQVHU]LRQH FKH XQD VFXROD GL OLQJXH FHUFD XQXQD GRFHQWH6LWUDWWDGLLQVHJQDUHLOWHGHVFR HO¶LQJOHVHDG DGXOWL9LVWRFKHYROHWHSUHVHQWDUYLSHULO SRVWR WHOHIRQDWH DOOD VFXROD GL OLQJXH SHU FKLHGHUH LQIRUPD]LRQL TXDQWH OH]LRQL OD VHWWLPDQD LQ FKH RUD TXDOH SDJD FKH WLSR GL FRQWUDWWR HFF /D VHJUHWDULD YL PHWWH LQ FRPXQLFD]LRQH FRQ LO GLUHWWRUH FKH YL LQIRUPD VXL GHWWDJOL &RQFRUGDWH XQ DSSXQWDPHQWR 5LFRQVWUXLWH TXHVWD WHOHIRQDWD ODYRUDQGR LQ XQ JUXSSR GL WUH SHUVRQH OD SHUVRQD FKH VL SUHVHQWD SHU LO SRVWR OD VHJUHWDULDLOGLUHWWRUH
6LHWHG¶DFFRUGR³/¶LPSRUWDQWHqIDUHTXHOORFKHFLSLDFH´"
7UDVIRUPDWHOHVHJXHQWLJUDVLXVDQGRVL 5DFFRQWDQRWDQWHVWRULHVXGLOXL &KHFRVDGDQQRTXHVWDVHUDDOFLQHPD" 'LFRQRFKHIDEHQHULSRVDUVLGRSRSUDQ]R 'RYHDQGLDPRWXWWLLQVLHPH"
3RVVLDPRIDUHXQDEHOODJLWD &KHIDFFLDPRGRPDQLSRPHULJJLR" 3DUODQRVSHVVRGLTXHVWDSURSRVWD &RQTXHVWREXVDUULYLDPRVHPSUHGLHFLPLQXWLLQULWDUGR
&RPSOHWDWH 6HEEHQH IDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB XQ WHPSR VSOHQGLGR 1LQR QRQ KD YRJOLD VL XVFLUH FRQ JOL DPLFL 3UHIHULVFH VWDUH D FDVD VHQ]DVHQ]D FKH YHGHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB QHVVXQR &KHJOLVDUjVXFFHVVR" /D SDVWD OD SRVVLDPR IDUH SL WDUGL 0D SULPD GLSULPD FKH DUULYDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB JOL DPLFLELVRJQDDQGDUHDFRPSUDUHXQSR¶GLYLQR 6HEEHQH QRQ HVVHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB FRPSLWR VXR OR IDUj VHQ]D VHQ]D FKH JOL DOWUL OR VDSHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3ULPD GLSULPD FKH SDUODUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB FRQ LO WXR FDSR FHUFD GL LQIRUPDUWL VXL WXRL GLULWWL$OWULPHQWLSRWUHVWLDYHUHXQDEUXWWDVRUSUHVD
&HUWRRLQFHUWR" &UHGLFKH0DULRYHQLUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBDOODFRQIHUHQ]D" 0LGLFHFKH0DULRYHQLUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBDOOHRWWR 6RFKHJOL$JRVWLQLHVVHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWRUQDWLLHUL 3HQVLFKH&DUORDYHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBJLjWHOHIRQDWR" ,FROOHJKLQRQVDQQRFRPHHVVHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVXFFHVVR 1RQF¶qQHVVXQRTXLFKHFLSRWHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBDLXWDUH" ,QTXHVWDDJHQ]LDQHVVXQRSDUODUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBLOWHGHVFR 3XzGDUVLFKH*LDQQLUHVWDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGDQRLLOILQHVHWWLPDQD 6RQR FRYLQWD FKH OHL GRYHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB VFULYHUH XQD OHWWHUD DOO¶DJHQ]LD GL WXULVPR 0LVHPEUDFKHWXDPDGUHVWDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSRFREHQH +RFDSLWRGDWHPSRFLzFKHYROHUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGLUHVLJQRUD'H/XFD ÊLPSRUWDQWHFKHWXWWLVLSUHSDUDUH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBEHQH
'LWHFRQDOWUHSDUROHOHH[SUHVVLRQLLQFRUVLYR %XRQJLRUQR/HLqLOFROOHJDWUDQVIHULWRGD1DSROL" 6u'DWRFKHODYRUHUHPRLQVLHPHSRVVLDPRGDUFLGHOWXVHYXROH 9ROHQWLHULFRVuVDUjSLIDFLOHLQWHUGHUVL9HGLWHORGLFRVXELWRLRVRQREXRQRHFDURSHUzQRQ KR SHOL VXOOD OLQJXD 6H WLGHYR GLUH TXDOFRVD WH OD GLFR VXELWR H LQ IDFFLD 1RQ VRSSRUWR TXHOOL FKHWLIDQQRLFDULQLGDYDQWLHSRLDSSHQDYROWLOHVSDOOHSDUODQRPDOHGLWH$SURSRVLWRKDLJLj FRQRVFLXWRLOFDSR" 6u PL KD FRQFHVVR XQ¶XGLHQ]D QRQ q GXUDWD FKH PH]]R PLQXWR $YUHL YROXWR GLUJOL SHU TXDOH WLSR GL ODYRUR PL VHQWR SL SUHSDUDWR PD PL KD WROWR VXELWR OD SDUROD GL ERFFD H PL KD VSHGLWR LQ TXHVWRXIILFLR6SHULDPREHQH 1RQ IDUWL LOOXVLRQL 6H YXRL VRSUDYYLYHUH TXD GHQWUR GHYL PRVWUDUH L GHQWL Ê O¶XQLFR PRGR SHU IDUWLULVSHWWDUH
)DWHGHLGLDORJKLLQVHUHQGRLVHJXHQWLPRGLGLGLUH FLVRQRTXDWWURJDWWLFLVRQRSRFKHSHUVRQH YLYHUHDOODJLRUQDWDYLYHUHVHQ]DSHQVDUHDOIXWXUR SDUODUHGHOSLHGHOPHQRSDUODUHGLFRVHEDQDOL PHWWHUVLQHLSDQQLGLTXDOFXQRLPPDJLQDUHGLHVVHUHDOSRVWRGLTXDOFXQRQHOOHVXHFRQGL]LRQL FDSLUHDOYRORVXELWRVHQ]DVSLHJD]LRQL
0HWWHWHDOSDVVDWR
6LSDUODGLOHL±6LqSDUODWRGLOHL 6LFUHGHDOOHVXHSDUROH 6LYDDPDQJLDUHIXRULTXHVWDVHUD 6LJLRFDGRPHQLFD" 2JJLVLSDUWHDOOHQRYH 3HUFKpQRQVLIDQLHQWH" &LVLYHGHGXHYROWHDOPHVH 1HOOHIHULHVLVFULYHDWXWWLJOLDPLFL (FLVLULSRVD 1RQVLGLFHQLHQWHDSURSRVLWR" 'RYHFLVLLQFRQWUD"
$OWULHTXLYRFL ,QXQDFRPXQLFD]LRQHWHOHIRQLFDDGHVHPSLR LOPLWWHQWHqFKLWHOHIRQD LOULFHYHQWHqFKLULVSRQGH LOFDQDOHqLOWHOHIRQR LOPHVVDJJLRqFLzFKHVLGLFH LOFRGLFHqODOLQJXDFKHVLSDUODLWDOLDQRGLDOHWWRIUDQFHVHHFF /DXUD QRQ VHQWH EHQH FLz FKH $QWRQLR GLFH SHUFKp OD OLQHD q GLVWXUEDWD ,QYHQWDWH XQD WHOHIRQWDWD LPPDJLQDQGRFKHRJQLWDQWRQRQVLVHQWDEHQHSHUHVHPSLR ,OFDQHqVFDSSDWR &KLqVFDSSDWR"
,QRJQLJUXSSRF¶qXQDSDURODIXRULSRVWR&DQFHOODWHOD LPEXFDUH±VFULYHUH±PDQJLDUH±PDQGDUH VRJJLRUQR±FKLDVVR±ODYRULLQFRUVR±GLVWXUER VDSHUH±FRQRVFHUH±SDUODUH±UDFFRPDQGDUH SHUIHWWDPHQWH±SXQWXDOPHQWH±PROWREHQH±FRUUHWHPHQWH SDUODUH±GLVWUXJJHUH±OHJJHUH±SURQXQFLDUH
)DWHGHOOHIUDVL IHUPDUVLVXELWR±VH±VDSHUHFKH GLUHODYHULWj±VH±WX FKLHGHUH QRQSHUGHUHLOWUHQR±VH±QRL VEULJDUVL SDUODUQH±VHORUR YHGHUVL FRPSUDUHXQUHJDORSHUWH±VHLR DYHUHVROGL YHQLUHDOODYRVWUDIHVWD±VH±YRL DYYHUWLUFL LQYLWDUPL±VH±OXL DQGDUHDFLQHPD IDUHGLYHUVDPHQWH±VH±LR HVVHUHDOWXRSRVWR FDSLUYL±VHYRL VSLHJDUHLGHWWDJOL LQFRQWUDUHGHOOHGLIILFROWj±VH±OHL DVFROWDUHLQRVWULFRQVLJOL ULXVFLUH±VHWX DLXWDUOD
&RPSOHWDWHOHVHJXHQWLIUDVL 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWHOLULGDUHLVXELWR 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBO¶DYYHUWLUHEEH 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBQRQORIDUHEEHLQTXHVWDPDQLHUD 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFDPELHUHPPRFDVD 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSDUOHUHLFRQLOWXRFDSR 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSRWUHVWHIDUHDQFRUDLQWHPSR 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWLDLXWHUHEEHUR 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBYHUUHLDSUHQGHUWL 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBQRQVDUHVWLQHPPHQRFRQWHQWD 6HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBJOLHORGLUHPPR
&RQWLQXDUHVXOPRGHOOR BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
5RVDOEDO¶KDWURYDWRLQXQJUDQGHPDJD]]LRQR
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
6RQRDUULYDWLLHUL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 1RQKRFDSLWRSHUFKpQRQVHLYHQXWR
9RJOLRGLUHFKHQRQVRQRG¶DFFRUGR BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 1RQqFKHQRQYRJOLDPRYHQLUH ÊFKHQRQDEELDPRWHPSR
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB /¶KRLPSDUDWRLQXQDVFXRODGLOLQJXH VLJQRUD
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB *LXVHSSHPHO¶KDGHWWR
,95$&&217$5()$77,3$66$7, 0HWWHWHDOSDVVDWR
'LFHFKHYLHQH±+DGHWWRFKHYHQLYD 6FULYRQRFKHDUULYDDOOHXQGLFLLQSXQWR 5LVSRQGRQRFKHLOIUDWHOORVWDOHJJHQGR 6SLHJDFKHQRQqFRVu 'LFRQRFKHLOVHUYL]LRSRVWDOHQRQIXQ]LRQDEHQH 5LVSRQGHFKHD*HQRYDIDEHOWHPSR 6FULYHFKHO¶DOEHUJRQRQKDSLFDPHUHGLVSRQLELOL 'LFKLDUDQRFKHLOWHVWLPRQHQRQGLFHODYHULWj 'LFHFKHLJHQLWRULVRQRPROWRFRQWHQWLGHOVXRDUULYR
0HWWHWHDOSDVVDWR
'HVFULYHWHLQIRUPDGLGLDULRXQIRUWHWHPSRUDOHHOHLPSUHVVLRQLFKHYLKDIDWWR
&RQIURQWLWUDSDUROHVLPLOL
D6DSHWHGLUHFKHGLIIHUHQ]DF¶qWUD EDPELQR±UDJD]]R
TXDOFKHYROWD±VHPSUH
VWXGLDUH±OHJJHUH
VHGXWR±LQSLHGL
DUUDEELDWR±WULVWH
E&RQHVHPSLVSLHJDWHTXHOORFKHKDQQRLQFRPXQHTXHVWHFRSSLHGLYRFDEROLSRLTXHOORFKHKDQQR GLGLYHUVR RSHUDLR±LPSLHJDWR
FRPSOHDQR±RQRPDVWLFR
GHVLGHUDWH±YROHUH
WUHQR±PHWURSROLWDQD
FRUUHUH±FDPPLQDUH
VRUSUHVD±UHJDOR
SHQGRODUH±YLDJJLDWRUH
FRVWDUH±SDJDUH
3HUFKpQRQKDLIDWWRODVSHVD0DUJKHULWD" 1RQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB SRWXWR IDUOR SHUFKp BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB GRYXWD DQGDUH D VFXROD SHUSDUODUHFRQO¶LQVHJQDQWH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBYROXWRSDUWHFLSDUHDQFKHL9HGRYHOOL/HLVDSHUFKpQRQBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB YHQXWL" 6uBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGRYXWLSDUWLUHSHU0LODQR D
4XDQWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFRVWDWHOHQXRYHVFDUSH" /HBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSDJDWHOLUH 3HUFKpQRQBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBYROXWRDQGDUHDOFLQHPDTXHVWDVHUD/XFD" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB GRYXWR ULPDQGDUH SHUFKp L PLHL DPLFL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB DUULYDWL GD 3DOHUPR BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVWDWRDOODPRVWUDGLFXLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSDUODWR" 1RBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBULQXQFLDWR5HQDWRFLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBDQGDWRPLBBBBBBBBBBBB UDFFRQWDWRFKHLTXDGULQRQJOLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSLDFLXWLSHUQLHQWH
D
&RQTXHVWRWHPSRPHUDYLJOLRVRULPDQHWHDFDVD" 3XUWURSSRODEDPELQDVLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBDPPDODWDHQRQSRVVLDPRODVFLDUODVROD 'RYHYDLQIHULHTXHVW¶DQQR" 6WRDFDVDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBYLDJJLDWRWDQWRLQYLWDPLDRUDSUHIHULVFRULSRVDUPL &LGLVSLDFHFKHQRQBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSRWXWLYHQLUH $OORUDYHQLWHGRPDQLVHUDHIDFFLDPRXQDEHOODVSHFKHWWDWD 9DEHQH
D
,QWXWWLTXHVWLJLRUQL/RUHQ]RBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVSHVRVROWDQWROLUH *OLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBEDVWDWRFRVuSRFR" $FFLGHQWLFRPHPLIDQQRPDOHLSLHGL &KHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBIDWWR" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFDPPLQDWRSHUSLGLWUHRUHLQFLWWj
0HWWHWHDOSDVVDWRSURVVLPR
&KHWHPSR" 1HYLFDSDUHFFKLJLRUQLGLVHJXLWR )DPROWRIUHGGRLQPRQWDJQD 1HOOHFDOGHVHUHG¶HVWDWHVSHVVRODPSHJJLD 3ULPDWXRQDHSRLSLRYH /DPDWWLQDIDDQFRUDPROWRIUHVFR $5RPDIDSLGLJUDGL
6SLHJDWHOHGXHVWRULHOOH
©&¶qXQVRORSRVWRDOPRQGRªGLFHYDLOIDPRVROLQJXLVWDIUDQFHVH3LHUUH/DUURXVVH©GRYHVLSXz HVVHUHDVVROXWDPHQWHFHUWLGLWURYDUHDPRUHIHGHOWjULFFKH]]DHVDOXWHQHOGL]LRQDULRª $ %DGJDVWHLQ $XVWULD +DQV %DFK KD ULVFKLDWR GL QRQ SRWHU HQWUDUH QHOOD VDOD GHOOH IHVWH GHO PXQLFLSLR GRYH VWD SHU HVVHUH IHVWHJJLDWR LO VXR FHQWHVLPR FRPSOHDQQR 1HVVXQR OR DYHYD ULFRQRVFLXWRSHUFKpLOJLRUQRSULPDHJOLVLHUDWDJOLDWRODEDUEDFKHDYHYDVHPSUHSRUWDWRPROWR OXQJD 4XDQGR LO VLQGDFR JOL KD FKLHVWR SHUFKp OR DYHYD IDWWR KD ULVSRWR WLPLGDPHQWH ©0L LQYHFFKLDYDª
&RPSOHWDWHOHVHJXHQWLIUDVLSHUHVHPSLR 0LDYHYDQRRIIHVRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 0LDYHYDQRRIIHVRHSHUFLzQRQKRYROXWRSLYHGHUOLR 0LDYHYDQRRIIHVRHLRQRQFLVRQRDQGDWR 1RQDYHYRVWXGLDWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 6LHUDVHQWLWDSRFREHQHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB $YHYDQRVSHUDWRILQRDOO¶XOWLPRBBBBBBBBBBB *OLHORDYHYDSURLELWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB $YHYRFRQILGDWRDOXLLOPLRVHJUHWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 1RQWLDYHYRULFRQRVFLXWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &LDYHYDWHSURPHVVRWDQWHFRVHBBBBBBBBBB $YHYDPRIDWWRPDOHLFRQWLBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3ULPDPLHUDSLDFLXWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
&RPHDQGUjDILQLUHTXHVWDVWRULD",QYHQWDWHXQDILQH
)DUHRODVFLDUH"
3HUFKpDUULYDWHFRVuWDUGL" 6LDPR SDVVDWL GDOOD VLJQRUD *LVPRQGL &L KD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB HQWUDUH SHU SDUODUH XQ PRPHQWRGHOQXRYRFRQWUDWWRGLDIILWWR %LVRJQDDQFKHIDUHOHYDOLJLH 1RQWLSUHRFFXSDUHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBIDUHDPH
D
9XROHFKHOHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBYHGHUHTXDOFKHGHSOLDQW" 1RJUD]LHQRQPLLQWHUHVVD &RPHDYHWHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSHUWURYDUHLELJOLHWWL" 1RQDEELDPRDYXWRELJOLHWWLODPDVFKHUDFLKDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBHQWUDUHJUDWLV &KHEHOYHVWLWR$QLWD'RYHO¶KDLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBIDUH" 1RQO¶KRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBIDUHO¶KRFRPSUDWRQHOODERXWLTXHGLIURQWHDO'XRPR
D
&RPHHQWULDPRQHOO¶DSSDUWDPHQWR"1RQDEELDPROHFKLDYL $QGLDPRGDOOD]LDHFHOHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGDUH &DSLVFRFKHWXHULPROWRGLVSLDFLXWDSHUTXHVWDIDFFHQGD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSHUGHUHQRQQHSDUOLDPRSL
&RQWLQXDUHVXOPRGHOOR
'RSRFKHDYHYDOHWWRLOJLRUQDOH
KDFRPLQFLDWRDODYRUDUH
'RSRDYHUOHWWRLOJLRUQDOH
KDFRPLQFLDWRDODYRUDUH
6XELWRGRSRFKHHUDYDPRDUULYDWLFLqFDSLWDWDTXHVWDGLVJUD]LD (UDPROWRFRQWHQWDGRSRFKHDYHYDGHWWRTXHVWR 3DUWLUDQQRGRSRFKHDYUDQQRFDULFDWRLEDJDJOL 'RSRFKHKRILQLWRTXHVWDGLIILFLOHWUDGX]LRQHYRJOLRULVSRVDUPLXQSR¶ &KHIDUDLGRSRFKHDYUDLILQLWRODVFXROD" 'RSRFKHHUDVWDWDGDQRLqDQGDWDDSUHQGHUHXQWqGDXQPLFR 1RQVLHWHVWDQFKLGRSRFKHDYHWHFDPPLQDWRWDQWR" 'RSRFKHVLqPDQJLDWRPROWRELVRJQDIDUHXQSLVROLQR
'HVFULYHUHOHLPPDJLQLVHJXHQWL
5DFFRQWDWHFLzFKHVWDVXFFHGHQGR 9RFDEXOLXWLOL LOULWUDWWRSRUWUHWXO
LOFLOLQGURFLOLQGUXO
LOFDSSHOORGLSDJOLDS O ULDGHSDL
EDVVRVFXQGPLF
3HUFKp XQ URPDQ]R R XQ ILOP SROL]LHVFR VL FKLDPD ©XQ JLDOORª" 0HWWHWH XQD FURFHWWD VXOOD ULVSRVWDFKHYLVHPEUDSLJLXVWD
o
&KLYHGHROHJJHXQJLDOORGLYHQWDWXWWRJLDOORSHUODSDXUDFKHSURYD
o
,SULPLURPDQ]LSROL]LHVFKLDYHYDQRODFRSHUWLQDJLDOOD
o
3HUFKpD6KHUORFN+ROPHVSLDFHYDPROWRLOJLDOOR
o
,QPROWLILOPSROL]LHVFKLLSHUVRQDJJLLPSRUWDQWLVRQRFLQHVL
6RVWLWXWHO¶DJJHWWLYREXRQRFRQXQRGHLYRFDEROLTXLHOHQFDWL
WUDQTXLOOREUDYRYDQWDJJLRVRDYDQWDMRV YDOLGRYDODELO JHQWLOHPDQJLDELOHFRPHVWLELO IUHVFR 6LDWDQWREXRQDGDDVFROWDUPLVLJQRUD 1DGLDKDGHOOHEXRQHUDJLRQL /DFDUQHQRQqSLEXRQD ,OSLFFRORFDQHVHQHVWDYDEXRQRLQXQDQJROR 4XHVWLIXQJKLQRQVRQREXRQL 0LKDIDWWRXQEXRQSUH]]R )DELRqXQEXRQUDJD]]R
&RPELQDWHFRQXQDIUHFFLD LQRPLHJOLDJJHWWLYLVRWWRHOHQFDWL
VRSUDELWR
SROL]LHVFR
JLRUQDWD
YHORFH
SDQWDORQL
ELRQGL
WUHQR
ELDQFD
IURQWLHUD
VSLULWRVD
LPSHUPHDELOH
IUDQFHVH
FDSHOOL
ODUJD
EDPELQD
JULJLD
LQFRQWUR
VWDQFR
FDQH
EHLJH
URPDQ]R
ELDQFKH
FDUWD
WHGHVFRVYL]]HUD
UDJD]]D
LQWHUQD]LRQDOH
IRUPDJJLR
YLYDFH
JRQQD
VWUHWWL
FDO]H
HOHJDQWH
'LFKLVRQRWXWWHTXHVWHFRVH"
D 3RVVRSUHQGHUHXQDWWLPRTXHVWRJLRUQDOH"ÊVXRVLJQRUD" 6uBBBBBBBBBBB/RSXzWHQHUHO¶KRJLjOHWWR *UD]LHWDQWH
+RGLPHQWLFDWRLPLHLRFFKLDOLGDVROH'LFKLVRQRTXHVWLELDQFKL" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBOLSXRLPHWWHUHLRDGHVVRSUHQGRLOVROH
D
'LFKLqTXHVWDVHGLDDVGUDLR" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBPDVLHGLWLSXUHQRLDQGLDPRLQEDUFDRUD *XDUGDVXOODVHGLDDVGUDLRF¶qODFUHPDVRODUHWLSRWUjVHUYLUHGXUDQWHODJLWDLQEDUFD 1RBBBBBBBBBBBBBGHYHDYHUODGLPHQWLFDWD$QWRQHOOD+RODPLDTXLQHOODERUVD 'LFKLVRQRTXHVWHVFDUSH"6RQRWXH" 1RBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 'LFKLVRQRDOORUD" BBBBBBBBBBBIRUVHBBBBBBBBBBBBBDPLFDGL/XLVD
E7UDQVIRUPDWHLOVHJXHQWHGLDORJRFDPELDQGRRJJHWWRRRJJHWWL HSURSULHWDULR &KHGLVRUGLQHLQFDVDLOJLRUQRGRSRODIHVWD$LXWDPLDPHWWHUHXQSR¶GLRUGLQH*XDUGDFKH EHOO¶DFFHQGLQR'LFKLVDUj" ÊGL&DUOR$PLGHLO¶KDSRVDWRVXOSLDQRIRUWHSULPDGLVXRQDUH
$JJLXQJHWHJOLDJJHWWLYLQXRYRYHFFKLRSRYHURDOOHSDUROHLQFRUVLYR
4XHVWDYROWD*LDQFDUORKDFRPSUDWRXQDPDFFKLQD1RQJOLSLDFFLRQROHPDFFKLQHXVDWH ,YRVWULFRQRVFHQWLOLDYHWHULYLVWL" ,QTXHVWRORFDOHVLSXzJLjGHJXVWDUHLOYLQR 0LD]LDGHYHVHPSUHPHWWHUHWXWWRLQRUGLQHSHUJOLDOWUL ,HULKRLQFRQWUDWRXQDPLFR +DLWXO¶LQGLUL]]RGHL'H*UHJRULR" 'D$QQD0DULDKRFRQRVFLXWRXQDVLJQRUDGLRWWDQW¶DQQL ÊXQDIDPLJOLDOXLqGLVRFFXSDWRGDWHPSR
)DWHLOSOXUDOHGHLVHJXHQWLQRPLHDJJHWWLYL
XQDJLDFFDODUJD±GHOOHJLDFFKHODUJKH XQDJRQQDYHUGHVFXUR XQFDO]LQRELDQFR XQDJRQQDJULJLD XQDIDPLJOLDULFFD XQDFDPLFHWWDURVD XQDUDJD]]DVHULD XQVLJQRUHSHUEHQH XQDVFDUSDEOX XQPDJOLRQHEHLJH XQDULXQLRQHLWDORWHGHVFD XQYLDJJLROXQJR XQYHVWLWRODUJR
,/RPEDUGLKDQQRPHVVRDSRVWRLOORURDSSDUWDPHQWR
&KHFRVDqFDPELDWR" 3HUHVHPSLR$GHVWUDSULPDF¶HUD
0HWWHWHOHVHJXHQWLIUDVLDOSDVVDWRSURVVLPR
/DSRUWDYLHQHFKLXVD±/DSRUWDqVWDWDFKLXVD ,ELJOLHWWLYHQJRQRYHQGXWLSUHVVRO¶DJHQ]LDGLWXULVPR /DFROOHJDqWUDVIHULWDGDOODFHQWUDOH 9HQLDPRGLPHQWLFDWLGDWXWWLLQRVWULDPLFL 6LHWHYLVWLVSHVVRLQTXHVWDWUDWWRULD 6RQRJLjDYYLVDWD ,OFDSRUHSDUWRqDVFROWDWRGDWXWWLJOLLPSLHJDWL /DFDVDYLHQHULFRVWUXLWD 6HLLQIRUPDWR"
0HWWHWHOHVHJXHQWLIUDVLDOODIRUPDSDVVLYD
8QVDUWRGL0LODQRKDFXFLWRTXHVWDEHOODJLDFFD 8QJUXSSRGLQHVWUHPLVWLDYHYDVHTXHVWUDWRLILJOLGLTXHVWDIDPLJOLD 4XDOHFRPSDJQLDUDSSUHVHQWDTXHVWRVSHWWDFROR" 8QHVSHUWRVSLHJKHUjODWHFQLFKHGHOODYHQGLWD /LKRSUHVLLRTXHVWLELJOLHWWL ,OJLRUQDOLVWDFULWLFDLOQXRYRILOPGL)HOOLQL &KLOHVDOYHUj" ,JDQJVWHUKDQQRXFFLVRLOEDPELQR 6HPLLQYLWDVVHURFLDQGUHLYROHQWLHUL
7UDQIRUPDWHOHVHJXHQWLIUDVLLQPRGRGDHVSULPHUHXUJHQ]D
/DWUDGX]LRQHYLHQHIDWWDVXELWR±/DWUDGX]LRQHYDIDWWDVXELWR 4XHVWHOHWWHUHVDUDQQRVSHGLWHHQWUROHVHL /DWHOHIRQDWDDOGRWWRUHYLHQHIDWWDVXELWR 4XHVWRGHSOLDQWVDUjLQYLDWRGRPDQL ,'HO7XUFRVDUDQQRLQIRUPDWLVHQ]¶DOWUR 4XHVWDPDFFKLQDqULSDUDWDSULPDGLSDUWLUH
6DSHWHLQGLFDUHLOFRQWUDULR"
QHUR
QXRYR
EHOOR
SRYHUR
IDFLOH
DFFHVLELOH
JLRYDQH
ODUJR
XOWLPR
VLPSDWLFR
QD]LRQDOH
ELRQGR
FRUWR
YLYDFH
DQWLFR
SDUL
SLFFROR
URVVRFKLDUR
JXDVWR
LPSRVVLELOH
9)$5(3$5$*21, ,WDOLDQLHURPHQL D
/HJJHWHJOLHVHPSLHSRLFRQWLQXDWHYRL
/¶,WDOLDSLYLWD
OD5RPDQLDSLRVSLWDOLWj
SLVROH
SLJHQHURVLWj
E 'LVFXWHWHWUDYRLVXTXHVWHFDUDWWHULVWLFKH3HUHVHPSLR 6uqYHURSHUFKpKRYLVWR 1RQVLSXzGLUHLQDVVROXWRSHUFKpKRFRQRVFLXWR
3LRPHQR 8QDOWURLQWHUURJDWLYRSRVWRGD5REHUWR*HUYDVR&KLPLGLFHFKHQHOUHVWRGHOFRVPRGXH SLGXHIDFFLDVHPSUHTXDWWUR"YIO1U /HJJHWH
±
±
GL SLRGL PHQR"SLRPHQRGL"SLRPHQRFKH" 8IID)LQDOPHQWHDEELDPRILQLWR$QGLDPRFHQHVXELWR (FKLPHWWHRUGLQHTXL" )DWHORYRLSHUFKpLRKRODYRUDWRBBBBBBBBBBBYRL &RPHVRQRVWDWHOHYRVWUHIHULHLQ'DQLPDUFD" $EEDVWDQ]DEHOOH4XVW¶DQQRDEELDPRDYXWRPROWDBBBBBBBBBBBSLRJJLDBBBBBBBBBBGXHDQQL ID
D
&RPHPDLTXHVWREUXWWRYRWRLQPDWHPDWLFD" $KTXHVWDPDWHPDWLFDLRQRQODFDSLVFR
D
)RUVHVDUjSHUFKpWLDSSOLFKLSRFR 1RQRPLDSSOLFRBBBBBBBBBBBBBGHJOLDOWULFRPSDJQL 1RQDEELDPRBBBBBBBBBBBBBROLR*LDQQD" 1RELVRJQDFRPSUDUOR +DLJLjSURYDWRODQXRYDPDFFKLQDGDVFULYHUHQHOO¶XIILFLRGL/RUHQ]R"ÊPROWRSHUIH]LRQDWDÊ O¶XOWLPRPRGHOOR /¶KRSURYDWDÊRWWLPD9RUUHLFRPSUDUQHXQDFRVu6DLTXDQWRFRVWD" 1RQHVDWWDPHQWHPDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBPLOLRQL
$KPROWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGLTXDQWRSHQVDVVLLR 6uTXHVWLPRGHOOLWDQWRSHUIH]LRQDWLFRVWDQRVHPSUHBBBBBBBBBBBBB
D
&RPHVWDLOQRVWURSLFFRORSD]LHQWH" %HQHGRWWRUHPDQRQKDDSSHWLWR
D
0DLRPDQJLRFRPHVHPSUHPDPPD 1RQRLQTXHVWRJLRUQLKDLPDQJLDWRPROWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBGHOVROLWR
5REHUWR*HUYDVRVRVWLHQH
,OSURJUHVVRUHQGHODYLWDSLFRPRGDQRQSLEHOOD 6LHWHG¶DFFRUGR"$SSRUWDWHHVHPSLSURRFRQWURTXHVWDRSLQLRQH
4XHVWRRTXHOOR" 3RQHWHGHOOHGRPDQGHDGDWWHSHUOHVHJXHQWLULVSRVWH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB" 0LSLDFHGLSLTXHOORYHUGH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB" &RQVWDQRPHQRGLTXHOOLSHULOWHDWURFUHGR
D
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB" 4XHOORSLLPSRUWDQWHqO¶XOWLPR BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB" ,OFDUQHYDOHD9LDUHJJLRPLqSLDFLXWRPROWRPHQRGLTXHOORD9HQH]LD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB" ,OWXRDSSDUWDPHQWRPLVHPEUDPROWRSLJUDQGHGLTXHOORGHJOL$JRVWLQL
&RPSOHWDWH $YHWHYLVWRODPRVWUDGL*XWWXVR" 6uFLqSLDFLXWDPROWRGLSLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFKHKDRUJDQL]]DWRLOFRPXQHGXHDQQL ID +DLULWURYDWRODFKLDYH" 1RKRJLjJXDUGDWRQHOODERUVDHQHOOHWDVFKHGHOVRSUDELWR *XDUGDDQFKHLQBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGHOO¶LPSHUPHDELOH
D
4XDOHWLVHPEUDPLJOLRUH" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBJLDOORPLSLDFHGLSL &KHFRVDPLFRQVLJOL" 3UHQGLTXHVWLFDO]LQLTXLBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFRVWDQRPHQRPDQRQVRQRGLEXRQDTXDOLWj 6LHWHSLFRQWHQWLGLTXHVWDPDFFKLQD" 1RqPHQRVSD]LRVDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFKHDYHYDPRSULPD
6HPSUHTXHVWLVXSHUODWLYL )DWHGHLSLFFROLGLDORJKLVHJXHQGRO¶HVHPSLR &HUFDWHGLYDULDUHOHSDUROHLQ QHUHWWR LOQXRYRFROOHJD TXHVWRSDOD]]R O¶XOWLPDWUDQVPLVVLRQHFRQ TXHVWHSHUH O¶DPLFDGL*LRYDQQL TXHVWDSRHVLD LQXRYLYLFLQLGLFDVD LOWHPSRUDOHGLLHUL TXHVWHFRQVLGHUD]LRQL LFLRFFRODWLQLGLTXHVWDSDVWLFFHULD
2UJDQL]]DWHXQDWDYRODURWRQGDVXOO¶DUJRPHQWRGHOFDORGHOOHQDVFLWH2JQXQR FHUFKL SULPD SHU FRQWR VXR GL HOHQFDUH OH FRQVHJXHQ]H FKH LO FDOR GHOOD QDWDOLWj SXz DYHUH 3RL QHOOD GLVFXVVLRQHRJQXQRGRYUHEEHGLIHQGHUHODSURSULDSRVL]LRQHSHUHVHPSLR 1RQqJUDYHSHUFKpLOPRQGRqJLjWURSSRDIIROODWRR ,OFDORSUHRFFXSDLSROLWLFLSHUFKpQRQVLVDFRPHILQDQ]LDUHOHSHQVLRQL 'LVFXWHWHDQFKHLQFKHPDQLHUDOR6WDWRSRWUHEEHLQGXUUHODJHQWHDIDUHSLILJOL
7UDVIRUPDWH EXRQR"QR EXRQLVVLPR VWDQFR"QR VWDQFRPRUWR 9LVLHWHGLYHUWLWLLHULVHUD" 'LYHUWLWLSURSULRQRPDODULXQLRQHqVWDWDLQWHUHVVDQWH &KHQHGLFLGHOODUHD]LRQHGL&DWHULQD" $KqXQDGRQQDVHQVLELOH
D
/HLYDDQFRUDVSHVVRGDJOL$FFDUGR" 6uFLYDGRVSHVVR 4XDOHROLRSUHQGH" 4XHOORYHUJLQH &RPHqVWDWRLOWHPSRGXUDQWHOHYRVWUHIHULH" 3XUWURSSRKDIDWWREUXWWRWHPSRQHOODSULPDVHWWLPDQD3HULOUHVWRVROHJJLDWR
D
+DLFRQRVFLXWRODPRJOLHGL5REHUWR" 6uqVLPSDWLFDPDqWURSSRJLRYDQHSHUOXL /HVHPEUDSRVVLELOHWXWWRTXHVWR" &HUWRFKHqSRVVLELOH
1RQYLVLHWHDQFRUDVHFFDWLGLWXWWRTXHVWRODYRUR" 6uQHVLDPRVWXIL
D
/HILJOLHGHOODVLJQRUD9HQWXULKDQQRFRQVHJXLWRODODXUHDWXWW¶HGXH /RVRVRQRVHPSUHVWDWHGLOLJHQWL 7LSLDFHODPLDQXRYDSROWURQD" %HOODVuPDQRQqFRPRGD
0HJOLRXQWHOHJUDPPDRXQDWHOHIRQDWD" D
/HJJHWHODOHWWHUDGL7HUHVDHGLWHOHFRVHSLLPSRUWDQWLSHUFRPSRUUHXQWHOHJUDPPD
GLFKHRFRPH" *LRYDQQDqODSLJLRYDQHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBWXWWL 1RQqFDPELDWRDIIDWWRÊWRUQDWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBHUDSDUWLWR 3UHIHULVFRDVFROWDUHTXHVWRGLVFRFRQWHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBJXDUGDUHODWUDVPLVVLRQH 6LDSSOLFDPROWRSLBBBBBBBBBBBDOWULFRPSDJQL ,OORURJLDUGLQRqJUDQGHBBBBBBBBBBBLOSDUFRSXEEOLFRDOFHQWUR 7URYRTXHVWRGLYDQRSLFRPRGRBBBBBBBBBBBBBSROWURQH $EELDPRODYRUDWRPHJOLRRJJLBBBBBBBBBBBBBLQWXWWDODVHWWLPDQDVFRUVD 6RQRSLFRQWHQWDGHOVXRODYRURBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGHOPLR 4XHVWDWUDGX]LRQHqGLIILFLOHBBBBBBBBBBBBBTXHOODIDWWDSHUO¶,VWLWXWRGHOOD(QFLFORSHGLD +DLPDQJLDWRPHQRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBPH3HUFKpQRQQHSUHQGLXQDOWURSR¶"
/HJJHWH OD VHJXHQWH OHWWHUD &KH QH SHQVDWH GHOOD ULVSRVWD GL 6XVDQQD $JQHOL" Ê YHUR FKH PROWD JHQWH QRQ YXROH SL IDUH ODYRUL XPLOL" 6SLHJDWH DL YRVWUL FRQRVFHQWL LWDOLDQL TXDOFKH OD VLWXD]LRQHRFFXSD]LRQDOHGHJOLLQVHJQDQWLURPHQL
D
3DUDJRQDWHIUDORUROHWHPSHUDWXUHD5RPDQHLWUHLJLRUQLGLVHJXLWR
E 3DUDJRQDWHOD WHPSHUDWXUD D 7RULQR FRQ TXHOOD D 5HJJLR &DODEULD TXHOOD D )LUHQ]H FRQ TXHOOD D 3HVFDUDHTXHOODD%DULFRQTXHOODD9HQH]LD
&RPSOHWDWHTXHVWLGXHEUDQLXVDQGROHVHJXHQWLSDUROHQHOODIRUPDJLXVWD D
LQIHULRUHLQSHJJLRLOSLDQWLFRPDVVLPRVXSHULRUH
/DGRQQDLQ3HUVLD 1HL WHPSL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB OD GRQQD JRGHYD LQ 3HUVLD GL XQD HOHYDWD FRQGL]LRQH H GHOOD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB OLEHUWj VL PXRYHYD LQ SXEEOLFR OLEHUDPHQWH SRVVHGHYD H DPPLQLVWUDYD SURSULHWjSRWHYDGLULJHUHDIIDUL'RSR'DULRODFRQGL]LRQHGHOODGRQQDFDPELzBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB VRSUDWWXWWR WUD L ULFFKL $OOH GRQQH GL FODVVH BBBBBBBBBBBBB IX SURLELWR GLQ IUHTXHQWDUH XRPLQL LQ SXEEOLFR /H GRQQH GHL FHWL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB PDQWHQQHUR LQYHFH OD ORUR OLEHUWj SHUFKp GRYHYDQRODYRUDUH E SHJJLRUHPHQRLQPHJOLRPHJOLRPDJJLRUHSHVVLPRPLJOLRUH
,WHPSLSDVVDWL 6SHVVRVLGLFHFKHGXUDQWHJOLXOWLPLGXHVHFROLOHFRVHQRQVRQRFDPELDWHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB SHUFKp QHL YHFFKL WHPSL OD YLWD HUD BBBBBBBBBBBBBB GL TXHOOD FKH q RJJL 6L ULPSLDQJH LO SDVVDWR GLFHQGR FKH OD WUDQTXLOOLWj HUD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB FKH OD JHQWH DYHYD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB SUHRFFXSD]LRQLFKH VL YLYHYD LQVRPPD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 7XWWR TXHVWR QRQ q HVDWWR 8Q VHFROR ID OD FRQGL]LRQH XPDQD H VRFLDOH HUD DQFRUD BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB GLQ TXDQWR JLj VDSSLDPR 3HU HVHPSLRLOWUDWWDPHQWRGHJOLRSHUDLDOO¶LQL]LRGHOO¶LQGXVWULDOL]]D]LRQHHUDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
9,&+,('(5(('(6,'(5$5( 'REELDPRIDUHWDQWLIDYRUL &RPSOHWDWHLVHJXHQWLGLDORJKL D
E BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
3RWUHVWLIDUPLXQDFRUWHVLD"
&HUWDPHQWH'LPPL
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
3DVVDGDOODSRVWDHIDLTXHVWRYDJOLDSHUPH
)LQRDFKHRUDqDSHUWR"
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
1RQLPSRUWD/RSXRLDQFKHIDUHGRPDQL
0L GLVSLDFH G2PDQL LR VRQR LPSHJQDWD
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
ILQR DOOH RWWR GL VHUD 3HUFKp QRQ FKLHGL D 3DVTXDOHFKHFLYDGDOXL"
(FFRFHQWRPLODOLUH
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
7UDVIRUPDWHOHIUDVLXVDQGRLOJHUXQGLR3HUHVHPSLR 0HQWUHSDVVHJJLDYRQHOSDUFRKRLQFRQWUDWRPLDFRJQDWD 3DVVHJJLDQGRQHOSDUFRKRLQFRQWUDWRPLDFRJQDWD 0HQWUHIULJJHYRODFDUQHPLVRQREUXFLDWD 4XDQGRODYHGUzJOLHORULIHULUz /¶KDQQRYLVWRTXDQGRWRUQDYDQRDFDVD 7LKDWHOHIRQDWRSHUFKpVLqULFRUGDWRGHOODWXDSDUWHQ]D 4XDQGRVLIDQQRGHJOLHUURULVSHVVRVLLPSDUD 9LVWRFKHJOLHORFKLHGLWXIRUVHORIDUj
6RVWLWXLWHLOJHUXQGLRQHOOHVHJXHQWLIUDVLFRQXQ¶DOWUDHVSUHVVLRQH 3DVVHJJLDQGR DWWUDYHUVR OH VWUDGH GHOOD FLWWj )UDQFHVFD KD YLVWR PROWH QHOOH FRVH QHOOH YHWULQH GHLQHJR]L 9LDJJLDQGRV¶LPSDUD /DYDQGRVLKDVHQWLWRVTXLOODUHLOWHOHIRQRPDQRQKDULVSRVWR &RQVHJQDQGRJOLHOLJOLKDGHWWRGLFRQVHUYDUOLEHQH $EELDPRWUDVFRUVRODGRPHQLFDGRUPHQGR &RQVLGHUDQGRODVLWXD]LRQHFLGHFLGHUHPR 6HQHDQGzEURQWRODQGR ,QFRQWUDGROLJOLHORGLUz $QGDQGRLQFHQWURSRWUHVWLULWLUDUHOHVFDUSHGDOFDO]RODLR 6SROYHUDQGRKRURYHVFLDWRLOYDVR
&RPSOHWDWHLVHJXHQWLGLDORJKLFRQLOYHUERVWDUH $WWHQ]LRQH0DUFRVWDOHJJHQGR±*LRYDQQDVWDSHUXVFLUH 'REELDPRDQFRUDDVSHWWDUHPROWR" 1RO¶LPSLHJDWRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBGDXQPRPHQWRDOO¶DOWUR &KHID&DUODDGHVVR" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBLOVROH
¨
&KHVWDYDWHIDFHQGRTXDQGRVRQRDUULYDWLLSRPSLHUL" ,RBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBLQFHQWUR5HQ]RBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBODELFLFOHWWDURWWD &KHYROHYLGLUH" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBFKHQRQqJLXVWRIDUHLQTXHVWRPRGR 4XDQWRWHPSRKDLDQFRUD" /¶DHUHRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBIDYHQWLPLQXWL
¨
6FXVLFKHKDGHWWR" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFKHODVLJQRUDVHQHULFRUGHUj
6HPSOLILFDWHOHVHJXHQWLIUDVLVRVWLWXHQGRLOJHUXQGLRFRQDOWUHHVSUHVVLRQL (VVHQGRDUULYDWLLQDQWLFLSRKDQQRDWWHVRGDYDQWLDOODSRUWD $YHQGRORDFTXLVWDWRLQFRQWDQWLKDLULVSDUPLDWRTXDVLODPHWj (VVHQGRPHQHDQGDWDSULPDQRQKRYLVWRLOILQDOHGHOORVSHWWDFROR $YHQGRODYRUDWRILQRDPH]]DQRWWHLOJLRUQRGRSRHUDPROWRVWDQFD (VVHQGRVWDWLFKLDPDWLLQFDXVDQRQDYHYDQRSRWXWRSLWDFHUH
6DSUHVWHHVSULPHUHLVHJXHQWLGHVLGHULLQPDQLHUDSLFRUWHVH"
9RJOLRFKHDUULYLDWHHQWUROHVHL 9RUUHLFKHDUULYDVWHHQWUROHVHL 'HVLGHUDFKHVXRPDULWRODSRUWLIXRULDFHQDRJQLVHUD 'HVLGHURFKHWXSUHQGDXQELJOLHWWLDQFKHSHUPH 9RJOLRFKHOHLVFULYDVXELWRTXHVWDOHWWHUD 1RQYRJOLDPRFKHVLDWHLQULWDUGR 'HVLGHURFKHLFROOHJKLULQXQFLQRDOORURSURJHWWR 9RJOLRFKHWXPLGLDULVSRVWDHQWURPDUWHGu
6H SRWHVWH IDUH XQ OXQJR YLDJJLR LQ ,WDOLD GRYH GHVLGHUHUHVWH DQGDUH" 0RWLYDWH OD YRVWUD VFHOWD &KH FRVD FULWLFD LO JLRUQDOLVWD QHO EUDQR ULSRUWDWR" &RVD FKLHGH DL SROLWLFL H DJOL DPPLQLVWUDWRULORFDOL"
E , YRVWUL DPLFL GL 0LODQR YRJOLRQR VDSHUH TXDOL VHUYL]L WHOHIRQLFL FL VRQR LQ 5RPDQLD (OHQFDWHJOLHOLVSLHJDQGRTXDOLLQIRUPD]LRQLSRVVRQRULFHYHUH
&HUFDWHGHJOLDJJHWWLYLGHULYDWLGDLYHUELHOHFDQWLSHULVHJXHQWLVRVWDQWLYL
XQDPDQLIHVWD]LRQH±LQWHUHVVDUHXQDPDQLIHVWD]LRQHLQWHUHVVDQWH GHLULVXOWDWL±VRGGLVIDUH ODFDUWD±YLQFHUH GHOOHSURSRVWH±FRQYLQFHUH XQDVSLDJJLD±LQYLWDUH GHJOLRFFKL±EULOODUH XQDVHUDWD±GLYHUWLUH XQURPDQ]R±FRPPXRYHUH GHOOHEHYDQGH±GLVVHWDUH
(VSULPHWHLYRVWULGLHFLSLJUDQGLGHVLGHUL&HUFDWHGLIRUPXODUOLRJQXQRLQPRGRGLYHUVR 3DUODWHFRQJOLDOWULGHLYRVWULHGHLORURGHVLGHUL 6HFRQGR YRL q JLXVWR FKH VL IDFFLD SXEOLFLWj DL SURGRWWL FKH SRVVRQR QXRFHUH DOOD VDOXWH FRPH SHU HVHPSLR EHYDQGH DOFROLFKH H VLJDUHWWH" 'LVFXWHWHQH LQVLHPH SUHQGHQGR OR VSXQWR GDO DQQXQFLRSXEEOLFLWDULRQHOODSDJLQDDFFDQWR
9,,$0$5((2',$5( 8QDPRUHIROOH
6FULYHWHXQDOHWWHUDG¶DPRUHVHUYHQGRYLGHOOHVHJXHQWLIUDVL 0LDDGRUDWD )RUVHQRQPLKDLDPDWRDEEDVWDQ]D &KHIDUzRUDVHQ]DGLWH" 'DTXDQGRLHULVHUDFLVLDPRGHWWLDGGLRQRQULHVFRDWURYDUHSDFH $FKLGHGLFKHUzLPLHLSHQVLHULLPLHLVRJQL" 7X QRQ YXRL YHUDPHQWH XQD FDVD XQD IDPLJOLD OD WXD DVSLUD]LRQH q UHDOL]]DUWL QHO FDPSR SURIHVVLRQDOH 6HQWRFKHLQVLHPHDOQRVWURDPRUHqILQLWDSHUPHODJLRYLQH]]DHODVSHUDQ]DGLIHOLFLWj &ROSDVVDUHGHOOHRUHVLYDFKLDUHQGRSHUzLQPHODUDJLRQHSHUFXLFLVHSDULDPR /¶XQLFD LPPDJLQH RVVHVVLYD FKH KR LQ PHQWH q OD WXD ILJXUD HVLOH FKH VL DOORQWDQD OHQWDPHQWH LQHVRUDELOLPHQWHGDPHGDOODPLDYLWD $GGLR WXRSHUVHPSUH
)DEUL]LR
0HWWHWHOHVHJXHQWLIUDVLDOSDVVDWR
6RFKHVHLSDUWLWDDOFXQLJLRUQLSULPD
'LFHFKHODOHWWHUDQRQqDQFRUDDUULYDWD
6LDPRFRQYLQWLFKHORIDUDLEHQH
&KLWLGLFHFKHQRQYLHQH"
6DLFKH&DUORODYRUDDOOD0RWWD"
&LVFULYRQRFKHYHUUDQQRLOPHVHSURVVLPR
3ULPDGLVSRVDUVL&DUORKDSURPHVVRWDQWHFRVHDOODVXD&ULVWLQD
7LSRUWHUzLOFDIIqDOHWWR
$ELWHUHPRLQXQDJUDQGHEHOODFDVDYLFLQDDOPDUH
)DUHPRPROWLYLDJJL
7LDLXWHUzQHOOHIDFFHQGHGLFDVD
0LLQWHUHVVHUzVRORGLWH
1RQGLPHQWLFKHUzPDLLOWXRFRPSOHDQQR
'RSRFLQTXHDQQLGLPDWULPRQLR&ULVWLQDULFRUGDD&DUORWXWWHTXHVWHSURPHVVH
0LKDLSURPHVVRFKH
&RQWLQXDWHRUDYRL
&RPSOHWDWHFRQDOFXQRRFLDVFXQR
1RQYHGRBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBPRWLYRSHUDUUDEELDUVL
$BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBLQYLWDWRqVWDWRFRQVHJQDWRLOSURJUDPPDGHOODVHUDWD
6XBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBSDJLQDDYHYDVFULWWROHVXHRVVHYD]LRQL
4XHOVLJQRUHQRQSRVVLHGHBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBVHQVRGHOO¶XPRULVPR
1RQKDBBBBBBBBBBBBBBFRPSUHQVLRQHSHUOHLGHHGHJOLDOWUL
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBFDSRUHSDUWRGHYHDYYHUWLUHLVXRLGLSHQGHQWL
/HJJHWH LO VHJXHQWH EUDQR H WURYDWH XQ VRWWRWLWROR SHU RJQL SDUDJUDWR R SDUWLUH GD ©,O FHQWUR3DQQXQ]LRª
$FRQWDWWRFRQOHIRU]HGHOO¶RUGLQH ,PPDJLQDWHOHVHJXHQWLVLWXD]LRQL ,QXQDVWUDGDVHFRQGDULDIXRULGLXQSDHVHVLHWHVWDWLFRLQYROWLLQXQLQFLGHQWHFKH KD FDXVDWR XQ GDQQRDOODYRVWUDPDFFKLQD&KHELVRJQDIDUH"$FKLSRWUHVWHULYROJHUYL" 'XUDQWHXQDJLWDFROOHWWLYDFKHqVWDWDRUJDQL]]DWDGDXQ¶DJHQ]LDGLWXULVPRDYHWHSHUVRODYRVWUD FDUWDG¶LGHQWLWj&KHIDUH"'RYHDQGDUH" 3DUWHFLSDQGRDXQDPDQLIHVWD]LRQHQHOFHQWURGLXQDFLWWjLWDOLDQDYLqVWDWRUXEDWRLQPH]]RDOOD IROOD LO SRUWDIRJOLR FRQ OD FKLDYH GHOOD PDFFKLQD FRVu FKH QRQ SRWHWH SL SDUWLUH FRQ OD YRVWUD DXWR$FKLULYROJHUVL" /D SROL]LD YL IHUD VX XQD VWUDGD VHFRQGDULD SHUFKp VLHWH DQGDWL ROWUH L FHQWRYHQWL 5LFRVWUXLWH LO GLDORJRIUDYRLHLOSROL]LRWWRWHQHQGRSUHVHQWHFKHQRQDYHWHFRQYRLODVRPPDVXIILFLHQWHSHUOD PXOWD
'LVFXWHWHVXLYRVWULFRQFHWWLGLXJXDJOLDQ]D 3HUFKpWXWWLKDQQRJOLVWHVVLGLULWWLPDQRQOHVWHVVHSRVVLELOLWj" &KH QH SHQVDWH GHOOD GHILQL]LRQH GL XQ SROLWLFR LWDOLDQR FKH KD GHWWR FKH O¶XJXDJOLDQ]D q OD WROOHUDQ]DGHOOHGLYHUVLWj"
(OHFDQWH WXWWR FLz FKH SXz QXRFHUH DOOD VDOXWH GHL FLWWDGLQL QHL SDHVL LQGXVWULDOL]]DWL H DOWDPHQWH SRSRODWL FRPH O¶,WDOLD 3DUODWH GHOOH PLVXUH FKH RJQXQR SXz SUHQGHUH D GLIHVD GHOOD SURSULD VDOXWH