Your Christ Is Too Small 2.0

Your YOUR

CHRIST christ Is Too Small IS TOO SMALL

JURGEN SCHULZ

!"#$%&'()'*+,"-. -1-

''' '''4(51' '''/012*3 '''2*'3(( '''*6788 !!!!! !!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()!*+

!!!!!!!,-./01!23!4"5-67

-2-

!519:;'()'*/058< 89:$;<#=>#?@$;&'3A#$B CDDE F(=9&#G!C3D

-3-

! Dedicated to my wife !"#$%&'()$%"&$"(*$+&,,&%#-$'#$.#/&)-$ %"(0$1*$2#(*&)(.,#3()-$#4#)$+520"#26 7"#$"(*$,&4#-$'#$'&2#$0"()$8$#4#2$ -#*#24#-3()-$0"#)$*&'#6 7"#$,#0*$9&-$*"&%$5:$1)$"#2$,1+#;$ ()-$10$1*$%&)-#2+5,$0&$.#"&,-6 7"#$"(*$%(,<#-$./$'/$*1-#$1)$0"#$=&52)#/$ &+$-1*>&4#21)?$0"(0$@#*5*$ 1*$?2#(0#2$()-$+(2$'&2#$%&)-#2+5, 0"()$%#$#4#2$1'(?1)#-6 A#,&4#-$B#)-/;$0"1*$1*$+&2$/&56

-4-

"

Foreword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

-5-

U;==&;@(9! (G)! :%! #G! KL(! =#A>9_! AL:=AL(9! @#! K#! %&(A(9_!'&Q(!A#$(9!;%;=K3!OL(!:G&W(=9(!)#(9!G#K!Q:GAV K&#G! P(''! ;%;=K! Q=#$! 5&$3! IK! &9! #G'+! N&G! 5&$N! KL;K! KL&G@9!L#')!K#@(KL(=3 I! *('&(W(! KL;K!/#)! &9!A;''&G@! 5&9! %(#%'(! *;A>! K#!KL(! "(GK=;'&K+! #Q! "L=&9K3! ](! L;W(! *((G! )(G#$&G;K&#G! A(GK(=()R! )#AK=&G(! A(GK(=()R! (`%(=&(GA(! A(GK(=()3! /#)a9!)(A';=()!%:=%#9(!&9!NK#!@;KL(=!K#@(KL(=!&G!#G(! ;''! KL&G@9! &G! "L=&9KN! Y0%L3! ZMZD\3! 5(! P#:')! L;W(! :9! "L=&9K!A(GK(=()3! OL(! %=(9(GK! *##>! &9! A#$%&';K&#G! #Q! J:#K(9! )=;PG! Q=#$! ;! P&)(! W;=&(K+! #Q! 9#:=A(9R! ;:KL#=9! ;G)! KL(#V '#@&A;'!%(=9%(AK&W(93!5#P(W(=!)&W(=9(R!;'$#9K!;''!KL(! P=&K(=9!A&K()!9L;=(!;!A#$$#G!Q#A:9!;G)!;!$:K:;'!;KV K=;AK&#G!K#!KL(!A#=(!&99:(M!OL(!6#=)!,(9:9!"L=&9K3!OL(+! =($&G)!:9!KL;K!&Ka9!;''!;*#:K!5&$3 29P;')!"L;$*(=9!9;&)R!NI!KL&G>!&Q!I!L;W(!;G!;$*&K&#G! &K!&9!KL;K!I!$&@LK!L;W(!L#G#=;*'(!$(GK&#G!&G!;G+#G(b9! %(=9#G;'! =(';K&#G9L&%! P&KL! #:=! 6#=)! ,(9:9! "L=&9K3N! 4&$&';='+R!&Q! KL(!Q#''#P&G@!$;K(=&;'!(GA#:=;@(9!9#$(! K#! K:=G! KL(&=! (+(9! K#! ,(9:9R! I! P&''! Q(('! P(''! =(A#$V %(G9()3! 4#!=(;)!#G3!.(Q'(AK3!0G<#+3!SG)R!;9!+#:!)#R!$;+!+#:! Q&G)!KL;K!(W(=+KL&G@!('9(!@=#P9!N9K=;G@('+!)&$!&G!KL(! '&@LK!#Q!5&9!@'#=+!;G)!@=;A(3N

-6-

# Content ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

Z3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!%(=&%L(=;'!V!c C3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!)#AK=&G;'!V!dZ d3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!&G9K&K:K&#G;'!V!ef f3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!=('&@&#:9!V![[ e3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!9(AK;=&;G!V!ZDD g3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!K=&W&;'!V!ZCf [3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!hG&K(!V!Zf[ E3!H#:=!"L=&9K!&9!K##!A':KK(=()!V!Z[Z

-7-

The Lord Jesus Christ +=&&>?'@%'#%A"+%A'?>')')')

' $

B'C(1D*' $ C!"#$D5)*:#(<(.,#$?1+0E$1*$.#/&)-$-#*>21:01&)

! $

B'D(/312;:! $ CF1*$D5)*#(2>"(.,#$21>"#*E$-#+/$-#+1)101&)

' $

B'31530 $ CF#$1*$($,141)?$G#2*&);$)&0$($:2&:&*101&)

' $

B'E12;/2E8:*' $ CF#$1*$0"#$:#2*&)1+1>(01&)$&+$(,,$41205#

' $

B'6(178234' $ CH52$*0()-(2-$1*$)&0$($>&-#$.50$($I"(2(>0#2

' $

B'1:8292(; $ CF#$-1-$)&0$>&'#$0&$.21)?$2#,1?1&)$.50$J1+#

' $

B'30:(8(94 $ CF#$1*$0"#$41*1.,#$-1*:,(/$&+$9&-K*$:#2*&)(,10/

' $

B'*4*3:6* $ CL,,$(00#':0*$0&$>&)0(1)$F1'$+(1,$'1*#2(.,/

' $

B'30:'F2F8: $ C!"#$%2100#)$B&2-$*"#-*$,1?"0M$F#$87$0"#$,1?"0

-8-

G

Your Christ is too peripheral

$

N4#2/0"1)?$>&'#*$+2&'$F8OM N4#2/0"1)?$"(::#)*$0"2&5?"$F8O$ N4#2/0"1)?$#)-*$5:$1)$F8O6 L,%(/*$?,&2/P L,%(/*$:2(1*#P .2US14!ZZMdg!!YOL(!U(99;@(\

-9-

$

!I!KL&G>!KL(!! $&G:K(!P(!!!! *(@&G!K#!@(K ;P;+!Q=#$

,(9:9! 5&$9('QR!

P(!*(@&G! K#!A'#:)!#:=!!!!!! KL(#'#@+3 $CL)&)/'&5*

- 10 -

$ !"L=&9K&;G&K+!

&9!"L=&9K_!!!!!!!

;G)!P(!=:&G!#:=!!! =('&@&#G!&Q!P(! A(GK=(!&K!!!!!!! ;G+PL(=(!('9(3 !!

$C@('#*$76$70#%(20

- 11 -

$

IG!KL(!1(P!O(9K;$(GK

,(9:9!:%9K;@(9

!(W(=+#G(!('9(3!5(!&9!G#K!#G'+

KL(!A(GK(=

#Q!KL(!/#9%('_!5(!&9!KL( PL#'(!/#9%('3! 5(!&9!KL(!

/##)!1(P93 $CA2#))()$O())1)?$

- 12 -

$

X(P;=(!#Q!

;!=('&@&#G!&G!PL&AL!

"L=&9K!&9!G#K

KL(!Q&=9K!Q#=($#9KR!

AL&(QR!%=&GA&%;'!!!!! #*<(AKR^KL(

W(=+!S'%L;

&G!KL(!;'%L;*(K!#Q!

+#:=!Q;&KL3 C@6$I6$Q/,#$$

- 13 -

$ OL(!$(99;@(

!!!!

#Q!"L=&9K!&9!G#K!!!!!!!

"L=&9K&;G&K+3 OL(!$(99;@( !#Q!"L=&9K!&9! "L=&9K3!! C9(2/$L'12(5,0

- 14 -

$ OL(!@##)!G(P9! #Q!KL(!@#9%('!

&9!G#K!;G!;GG#:GA($(GK #=!;!%=#A';$;K&#GR !&Ka9!;!i(=9#GM !,(9:9!KL(!"L=&9K3 !,(9:9!&9

!KL(!@#9%('3 CJ#&)(2-$7%##0$$

- 15 -

$

04-4! "L=&9K!3!3!3!P;'>()!&GK#! K&$(! ;G)! J:&(K'+! )&W&)()! &K! &GK#! *(Q#=(! ;G)! ;QK(=^X3"3! ;G)! S3j3!5(!P;'>()!&GK#!KL(!=(;'$!#Q! KL#:@LK! ;G)! ;'K(=()! ;''! #:=! A#GV A(%K&#G9! ;*#:K!/#)!;G)!'&Q(! ;G)! )(9K&G+3! 5(! P;'>()! &GK#! #:=! $#=;'! A#GA(%K&#G9! ;G)! A#)(9R! ;G)!G#P!P(!;=(!@##)!#=!*;)!;AV A#=)&G@! K#! PL(KL(=! P(! ($*#)+! 5&9! 9%&=&K! #=! G#K3! 5(! P;'>()! &GK#! KL(!AL;#9!#Q!L:$;G!=(';K&#G9L&%9! ;G)! %=#<(AK()! ;! k&G@)#$! PL&AL! &9!)(9K&G()!K#!@;KL(=!;''!#:=!AL;#9! &GK#! A#9$#9R!K#! *(! KL(! @#;'! ;G)! (G)!#Q!;''!L:$;G!L&9K#=+3!

J

$CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 16 -

$ OL(!A(GK=;'!Q;AK! #Q!KL(!:G&W(=9(!;G)!

KL(!%(=Q(AK!

(GA+A'#%()&;!#Q!!!!!!!!!! ;''!$#=;'!;G)!!!!!! 9%&=&K:;'!K=:KL!!!!!!!!!!!!

&9!&G!"L=&9KR!!!!!!!!!

KL(!IGA;=G;K(!]#=)R!! KL(!6;$*!9';&GR!KL(!!!!!!! ;9A(G)()!k&G@3! CL,#R()-#2$O(>J(2#)

- 17 -

$

"L=&9K&;G&K+!!

P&KL#:K!"L=&9K!&9! ;!AL(9K!P&KL#:K!

;!K=(;9:=(R!!!!!

;!Q=;$(!P&KL#:K!

;!%#=K=;&KR!!!!!!

;!A#=%9(!P&KL#:K!

*=(;KL3

C@&")$Q6$B6$70&00$

- 18 -

$ OL&9!&9!;!=(;9#G!

Q#=!$:AL!#Q!KL( !%#P(='(99G(99!#Q!#:=! AL:=AL(9!K#);+_

!P(!L;W(!A#GW(=K() %(#%'(!K#!KL(!AL:=ALR !K#!#:=!)#AK=&G(9R!K#! #:=!%=#<(AK9!;G)! #=@;G&l;K&#G9^!!

K#!;'$#9K !;G+KL&G@!*:K! "L=&9K!5&$9('Q3 $$CQ1><$@&/)#2

- 19 -



%$/#)!L;9!G#KL&G@!! Q#=!5&9!"L:=AL!*(+#G)!

PL#!"L=&9K!&9! &G!5&$9('Q3! 5(!&9!9:QQ&A&(GKR!

5(!&9!9:%(=&#=R! 5(!&9!9#W(=(&@GR!

5(!&9!9:%=($(R! ;G)!5(!&9!KL(!

9:$$;K&#G!

#Q!;''!/#)!L;9!Q#=!:93! CS(41-$A2/()0

- 20 -

$

!IO!I4!O50! 1SO-.0!2T! "5.I4O! O2!X0!O50!

"01O0.3

$CS1#021>"$A&)"&#++#2$

- 21 -

$ "L=&9K&;G&K+

!

)#(9!G#K!(`&9K!

Q#=!;!$#$(GK! !

#=!&G!;G+!=(9%(AK! ;%;=K!Q=#$! "L=&9K3! $$CT(2,$A(20"$

- 22 -

$

50! 9K#=+! &9! K#')! KL;K! PL(G! /L;K;$;!X:))L;!P;9!)+&G@!3!3!3! 9#$(!#Q!L&9!)&9A&%'(9!;9>()!L#P!KL(+! A#:')! *(9K! =($($*(=! L&$3! 5(! K#')! KL($! G#K! K#! *#KL(=_! KL;K! &K! P;9! L&9! K(;AL&G@R! G#K! L&9! %(=9#GR! KL;K! $;KV K(=()3!4:AL!&9!KL(!*;9&9!#Q!=('&@&#G!^! &)(#'#@&A;'R! %L&'#9#%L&A;'R! ():A;K&W(! *('&(QV9+9K($93! 4:AL! &9! G#K! KL(! A;9(! P&KL! ,(9:9! "L=&9K! ;G)! "L=&9K&;G&K+3! 0W(=+KL&G@!A(GK(=9!&G!5&$3!0W(=+KL&G@! &9! &GL(=(GK! &G! ,(9:9R! 5&9! i(=9#G! ;G)! 5&9! A#GK&G:&G@! ;AK&W&K+3! 0W(=+KL&G@! Q:GAK&#G9!#G'+!*+!KL(!)+G;$&A!#Q!KL(! =&9(G!;G)!'&W&G@!6#=)!,(9:9!"L=&9K3

T

$C@('#*$L6$U&%,#2

- 23 -

$

-1jSU01OS66HR!#:=!6#=)a9! $(99;@(!P;9!5&$9('Q3!5(!)&)! G#K! A#$(! $(=('+! K#! %=(;AL! ;! /#9%('_!5(!L&$9('Q!&9!KL;K!/#9%('3! 5(! )&)!G#K!A#$(!$(=('+! K#!@&W(! *=(;)_!5(!9;&)R!NI!;$!KL(!*=(;)3N! 5(!)&)!G#K!A#$(!$(=('+!K#!9L()! '&@LK_!5(!9;&)R!NI!;$!KL(!'&@LK3N!5(! )&)!G#K!A#$(!$(=('+!K#!9L#P!KL(! )##=_!5(!9;&)R!NI!;$!KL(!)##=3N!5(! )&)! G#K! A#$(! $(=('+! K#! G;$(! ;! 9L(%L(=)_!5(!9;&)RNI!;$!KL(!9L(%V L(=)3N!5(!)&)!G#K!A#$(!$(=('+!K#! %#&GK!KL(!P;+_!5(!9;&)R!NI!;$!KL(! P;+R!KL(!K=:KLR!;G)!KL(!'&Q(3m

F

$C@6$71-,&%$A(R0#2

- 24 -

$ "L=&9K&;G&K+

! &9!G#K!;!)()&A;K&#G! K#!;!9+9K($! #Q!=:'(9!#=!#Q!KL#:@LKR! *:K!;!)()&A;K&#G!

K#!;!i(=9#G3!

OL&9!&9!:G&J:(!;$#G@!KL( !!=('&@&#G9!#Q!KL(!P#=')3! $CB1,,1('$!#':,#

- 25 -

$

0! P;9! ;9>()! #GA(! *+! ;! 5&G):! %=#Q(99#=! PL;K! &K! P;9!KL;K!L(!L;)!Q#:G)!&G!"L=&9K&V ;G&K+!3!3!3!KL;K!L(!L;)!G#K!Q#:G)!&G! L&9! #')! =('&@&#G3! nI! L;W(! Q#:G)! "L=&9KRm! 9;&)! 4;)L:! 4:G);=! 4&G@L3!n2L!+(9R!I!>G#PRm!9;&)!KL(! %=#Q(99#=! =;KL(=! &$%;K&(GK'+3! nX:K! PL;K! %;=K&A:';=! )#AK=&G(! L;W(!+#:!Q#:G)!#=!%=&GA&%'(!KL;K! +#:!)&)!G#K!L;W(!*(Q#=(om ! nOL(! %;=K&A:';=! KL&G@! I! L;W(! Q#:G)Rm! =(%'&()! 4;)L:! 4:G);=! 4&G@LR!n&9!"L=&9K3m

H

$C@&")$Q6$B6$70&00

- 26 -

$

0W(=+KL&G@! N"L=&9K&;GN!

&9!)(=&W()!Q=#$!KL(! X(&G@!;G)!;AK&W&K+!#Q!,(9:93 !S''!#Q!"L=&9K&;G&K+!&9! A#GK&G@(GK!;G)!)(%(G)(GK #G!5&$R ! !;G) (`%=(99&W(!#Q!5&$3!

"L=&9K&;G&K+!&9! "L=&9Kp! C@('#*$L6$U&%,#2

- 27 -

$ ](!L;W(!&G9K=:AK()!

KL(!AL:=AL!&G!G(;='+ (W(=+KL&G@!*:K!*(A#$&G@!!!!!!!!!

)&9A&%'(9!#Q! ,(9:9!"L=&9K3!

](!L;W(!Q&''()!%(#%'(!

P&KL!)#AK=&G(9 &G9K(;)!#Q!j(&K+_ P(!L;W(!@&W(G!KL($! $;G:;'9!&G9K(;)!#Q!

0$$;G:('3

$$CU2()>1*$U2()?1:(?)#$$$

- 28 -

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

$

IQ!I!;$!K#!>G#P!/#)R!I!P&''!! ! ! >G#P!5&$!KL=#:@L!,(9:93 IQ!I!;$!K#!@;&G!>G#P'()@(R!! ! &K!&9!)(%#9&K()!&G!,(9:93 IQ!I!;$!K#!L;W(!P&9)#$R! ! I!P&''!Q&G)!&K!&G!,(9:93 IQ!/#)!)P(''9!&G!$(R!&K!&9! ! *(A;:9(!,(9:9!)P(''9!&G!$(3 IQ!I!P&9L!K#!9K:)+!/#)R! ! I!$:9K!9K:)+!,(9:93 IQ!KL(!5#'+!4%&=&K!&9!;AK&W(!!! ! &G!$+!'&Q(R!I!P&''!L(;=!5&$!! ! ! 9%(;>!#Q!,(9:93 $C9(/,#$S6$N2%1)

- 29 -

$ O#!*(

"L=&9K&;G9

&9!K#!'&W(!#:=!'&W(9 !KL=#:@LR!#GR!&GR :G)(=R!:GK#R!Q#=!;G) !'&>(!,(9:9!"L=&9KR !;G)!"L=&9K!KL(G !!*(A#$(9!KL(!!! A(GK(=!#Q !#:=!'&W(93 $$C@&")$Q6$B6$70&00

- 30 -

!

H

Your Christ is too doctrinal V&5$*#(2>"$0"#$7>21:052#*;$ +&2$1)$0"#'$/&5$0"1)<$/&5$"(4#$ #0#2)(,$,1+#M$()-$0"#*#$(2#$0"#/$$$$ %"1>"$0#*01+/$&+$ON6 !,251!eMdc!!

- 31 -

&

IK!&9!"L=&9K!5&$9('QR

!G#K!KL(!X&*'(R!PL#!&9!KL( !K=:(!P#=)!#Q!/#)3!OL( X&*'(R!=(;)!&G!KL( !=&@LK!9%&=&K!;G) P&KL!KL(!@:&);GA(!#Q!@##) !K(;AL(=9R!P&''!*=&G@!:9 !K#!5&$3!](!$:9K!G#K! :9(!KL(!X&*'(!;9!;!9#=K!#Q! (GA+A'#%()&;!#:K!#Q!PL&AL! K(`K9!A;G!*(!K;>(G!Q#=!!!!! :9(!;9!P(;%#G93 $$$CI6$76$J#%1*

- 32 -

&

OL(!4A=&%K:=(9! 9L#:')!*(!=(;)! P&KL!KL(!;&$!#Q!

Q&G)&G@!"L=&9K!

&G!KL($3!]L#(W(=!K:=G9! ;9&)(!Q=#$!KL&9!#*<(AKR! (W(G!KL#:@L!L(!P(;=9!L&$V 9('Q!#:K!;''!L&9!'&Q(!&G!'(;=G&G@R !L(!P&''!G(W(=!=(;AL! KL(!>G#P'()@(!

#Q!KL(!K=:KL3 $C@&")$I(,41)

- 33 -

&

5:G)=()9!#Q!%(#%'(!! K#);+!;=(!)(W#K&G@!KL($V! 9('W(9!K#!%L;9(9!#Q! K=:KLR!K#!A;:9(93!!

,(9:9!"L=&9K!G(W(=!

;9>9!:9!K#!)(W#K(!#:=9('W(9! K#!;!A;:9(!#=!;!A=(()_!!!!!!!!!!!

5(!;9>9!:9

K#!)(W#K(!#:=9('W(9

K#!5&$!;*9#':K('+R! ;G)!K;>(!:%!KL;K!

A=#99!);&'+3

CH*%(,-$I"('.#2*

- 34 -

&

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`%(=&(GA()3! OL(&=! Q;&KL! P;9!G#K!Q#:G)()!#G! ;! *##>_! KL(&=! Q;&KL!P;9!Q#:G)()!#G!;!%(=9#G3V

T

CB1,,1('$A(2>,(/$$$$

- 35 -

&

/#)!)&)!G#K!<:9K!!!!

<:9K!=(W(;'!Q;AK:;'!);K;R! &GQ#=$;K&#G;'!%=#%#9&K&#G9!

#Q!;!*('&(QV9+9K($!

#Q!)#AK=&G(!#=!KL(#'#@+R!!! *:K!5(!N=(W(;'()!

5&9!4#G333m! Y/;'3!ZMZC\3

$C@('#*$L6$U&%,#2

- 36 -

&

2G(!#Q!KL(!%=&$;=+

9AL($(9!#Q!KL(!)(W&'! &9!K#!K:=G!KL(!X&*'(!&GK#!KL(! O=((!#Q!kG#P'()@(! Q#=!:9R!&G9K(;)!#Q!KL(!

O=((!#Q!6&Q(3!!!!!!!!!!!!

5(!&9!9((>&G@!K#!$;>(!&K! ';P!K#!:9!=;KL(=!KL;G!;!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=(W(';K&#G!#Q!"L=&9KR!!!!!!!!! &G!PL#$!;'#G(!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

'&Q(!&9!Q#:G)3 CQ1><$@&/)#2

- 37 -

&

5I4! K(G)(GA+! K#! K=;G9V Q#=$! KL(! P#=>! #Q! KL(! 6&W&G@!/#)!&GK#!;!%L&'#9#%L&V A;'! )#AK=&G(! &9! KL(! A#G9K;GK! K($%K;K&#G!#Q!KL(#'#@+R!;G)! KL(&=! @=(;K(9K! )&9'#+;'K+! PL(G!KL(+!K=;G9Q#=$!KL(!;AV K&#G! #Q! KL(! 4%&=&K! PL&AL! *=&G@9! Q#=KL! Q=:&K! &G! KL($V 9('W(9! &GK#! ;G! (KL&AR! ;! G(P! ';PR! &GK#! %=&GA&%'(9! PL&AL! #G'+!L;W(!K#!*(!q;%%'&()3b

T

C@(>W5#*$N,,5,

- 38 -

&

OL(!L&9K#=&A;'! ,04-4! &9!L&$9('Q!KL(!!!!!!!!!!! ($*#)&$(GK! #Q!K=:KL333 C@&")$Q6$B6$70&00

- 39 -

&

OL(+!YKL(!(;='+!"L=&9V K&;G9\!)&)!G#K!9;+R! NOL&9!&9!KL(!K=:KLM! P(!P&''!'(;=G!&KR!

;G)!&K!P&''!&G9K=:AK!:93N! OL(+!9;&)R!NOL&9!&9!KL(!

6#=)M!P(!L;W( P;&K()!Q#=!5&$R! ;G)!5(!P&''!9;W(!:93N CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 40 -

&

OL(!]#=)!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *(A;$(!Q'(9L^ ;G)!KL(G!KL=#:@L! KL(#'#@&;G9!&K! *(A;$(!P#=)9! ;@;&G3! CT(2,$A(20"

- 41 -

&

50!9#VA;''()!NAL:=AL!Q;V KL(=9N! #Q! KL(! Q&=9K! Q(P! A(GK:=&(9! #Q! "L=&9K&;G&K+! 3! 3! 3! =():A()! "L=&9K&;G&K+! &GK#! $#=;'&9K&A! ;G)! (KL&A;'! =('&@V &#:9!=:'(9!;G)!&GK#!A=(();'&9V K&A! A#GA(%K9! #Q! A#==(AK! A#GV K(GK! #Q! KL#:@LK3! OL(+! 9#! J:&A>'+!'(K!@#!#Q!KL(!)+G;$&A! '&Q(!#Q!,(9:9!"L=&9K!;9!KL(!(9V 9(GA(!#Q!"L=&9K&;G&K+R!;G)!;'V '#P()!&K!K#!*(A#$(!$(=('+!;! *('&(Q!9+9K($3

T

C@('#*$L6$U&%,#2

- 42 -

&

OL(!2G(!PL#!

&9!KL(!P;+R!KL(!K=:KL ;G)!KL(!'&Q(!3!3!3

!P&''!G#K!*(!=():A()! K#!#:=!'#@&A;'! A;K(@#=&(9! ;G)!&GK(''(AK:;'!

Q#=$:';93 C!&)/$I(':&,&

- 43 -

&

50! *=(;>! #Q! "L=&9K&;G&K+! P&KL!"L=&9KR! K:=G&G@! 5&$!! &GK#!KL(!]#=)!*(A#$(!P#=)R! P;9! KL(! $#9K! )&9;9K=#:9! *=(;>!%#99&*'(3!T#=!&K!@;W(!:%! KL(! #G(! KL&G@! &G! "L=&9K&;G&K+! KL;K! $;>(9! &K! :G&J:(^KL(! ]#=)! *(A#$(! Q'(9L3! S''! KL(! #KL(=! Q;&KL9! L;W(! KL(! ]#=)! *(A#$(! P#=)R! *:K! #G'+! KL(! "L=&9K&;G! Q;&KL! L;9! KL(! ]#=)! *(A#$(!Q'(9L3

T

CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 44 -

&

OL(!(99(GA(!#Q!!!!!!!!!!!! "L=&9K&;G&K+! &9!G#K!;!9K;G);=)&l() *('&(QV9+9K($3

OL(!(99(GA( !#Q!"L=&9K&;G&K+!

&9!G#K!;!A#G9(G9:9! #Q!)#AK=&G(333! ,(9:9!"L=&9K! &9!KL(!(99(GA(! #Q!"L=&9K&;G&K+3 C@('#*$L6$U&%,#2

- 45 -

&

T(P!P(=(!

;9!A;=('(99!#Q !#=KL#)#`! Q#=$:';9! ;9!,(9:93 CI6$T6$A(22#00

- 46 -

&

SU!G#K!9:AL!;!Q##'!;9! K#!=:G!;$:A>!;@;&G9K! KL(#'#@+R!;9!9#$(!%(#%'(! &G!KL&9!);+!)#3!X:K!PL;K!I! P&9L!K#!&G9&9K!:%#G!&9!KL;K! KL(!Q&=9K!Q#=$!#Q!"L=&9K&;GV &K+! &9! G#K! ;! KL(#=+R! *:K! ;! L&9K#=+R!;G)!KL;K!KL(!=(W(V ';K&#G! #Q! /#)! &9! KL(! *&#@V =;%L+!#Q!;!$;G3!

I

CL,#R()-#2$O(>J(2#)

- 47 -

&

OL(!)#AK=&G;' !9K;K($(GK

#Q!"L=&9K&;G&K+R PL&AL!&9!KL(!W(=*;'! (`%=(99&#G!#Q! KL(!6&W&G@!O=:KLR!

$;+!L;W(!*((G! $&9K;>(G!Q#= KL(!O=:KL!&K9('Q3 CB#*,#/$B6$X#,*&)

- 48 -

&

OL#9(!PL#!

L;W(!9:AA(()()!&G!

)(Q&G&G@!)#AK=&G(! $#9K!A'#9('+!

L;W(!'#9K!"L=&9K!

!$#9K!A#$%'(K('+3 C@('#*$L6$70#%(20

- 49 -

&

O50!2X,0"O! 2T!TSIO5! I4!12O! O50!O0S"5I1/! X-O!O50!

O0S"50.3

$C7&2#)$T1#2<#?((2-

- 50 -

&

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i;:'!A;''9! ,(9:9!KL(! N:G9%(;>;*'(!@&QKN^+#:!A;GaK!9%(;>! 5&$!A#$%'(K('+3!IG!KL(!(G)!+#:!L;W(! K#!>G(('!&G!;)#=;K&#G!;K!KL(!]#G)(=! #Q!KL(!]#=)3!

T

$CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*$$

- 51 -

&

IK!&9!%#99&*'(!K#!*(!

(`;AK!;G)!A#==(AK!

&G!+#:=!)#AK=&G(!;G)! K#!*(!%(=Q(AK'+!)(;)3! ]L;K(W(=!$;+!*(!KL(! G(()!#Q!KL(!=(A#W(=+! #Q!'#9K!K=:KLR! KL(!G(()!#W(=!;''333! &9!KL(!=(A#W(=+!#Q!9%&=&K:;'! =(W(';K&#G!;9!K#!

KL(!6#=)!,(9:9R! K#!9((!5&$!;G(P3 $$$C!6$L5*01)C7:(2<*$

- 52 -

&

A#/&)-$0"#$*(>2#-$:(?#$$ 8$*##<$0"##;$J&2-M$ O/$*:1210$:()0*$+&2$0"##;$ H$J141)?$B&2-P CO(2/$J(0".52/

- 53 -

I

Your Christ is too institutional $!"#$I"52>"$1*$I"21*0Y*$.&-/;$ $1)$%"1>"$"#$*:#(<*$()-$(>0*;$ $./$%"1>"$"#$+1,,*$#4#2/0"1)?$ %10"$"1*$:2#*#)>#6 0i504IS14!ZMCd!!YOL(!U(99;@(\

- 54 -

' IG!A#GW(=9&#G!

+#:!;=(!G#K!;KK;AL() %=&$;=&'+!K#!;G!#=)(=R !G#=!K#!;G!&G9K&K:K&#GR!!

G#=!;!$#W($(GKR!

G#=!;!9(K!#Q!*('&(Q9R!G#=!;!

A#)(!#Q!;AK&#G!^!

+#:!;=(!;KK;AL()!%=&$;=&'+

K#!;!i(=9#GR!

;G)!9(A#G);=&'+!K#!KL(9(!!!! #KL(=!KL&G@93 !! $CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*$

- 55 -

'

"526S.4! #Q! "L:=AL! 5&9K#=+! L;W(! &G)&A;K()! KL;K! KL(! A#GA(%K! #Q! #=KL#V )#`+! P;9! &GK=#):A()! &GK#! "L=&9K(G)#$R! G#K!&G! KL(! Z9K! "(GK:=+R!*:K!(;='+!&G!KL(!fKL! "(GK:=+R! :G)(=! KL(! '(;)(=V 9L&%!#Q!KL(!.#$;G!($%(=#=! "#G9K;GK&G(3! 5(! )(9&=()! ;! :G&Q&()! "L=&9K&;G&K+! ;9! ;! 9K;K(! =('&@&#GR! &G! #=)(=! K#! A#G9#'&);K(!L&9!#PG!%#P(=3 !!

S

CS()1#,$L)-#2*#)

- 56 -

' S''!KL(!P=(KAL()! $(99!KL;K!(`&9K9!

&G!KL(!#=@;G&l;K&#G!#Q! "L=&9K&;G&K+!K#);+!3!3!3! &9!*(A;:9(!9#$(KL&G@!

9%(A&Q&A!&G!&K9('QR!

(&KL(=!;!$#W($(GKR! ;!$&99&#GR!;!K(;AL&G@R! ;!K(9K&$#G+R!;!Q(''#P9L&%R!

L;9!K;>(G!KL(!%';A(! #Q!"L=&9K3 !! $C!6$L5*01)$7:(2<*

- 57 -

' "L=&9K&;G&K+! ;%%(;'9!

K#!;''!G;K&#G9R! =;A(9!;G) !A=(()9R!*:K!+#: !L;W(!$;)(!&K!9#

(AA'(9&;9K&A;'!

KL;K!&K!;%%(;'9!K#!

G#*#)+3! !!

$CQ(.1)-2()(0"$!(?&2#

- 58 -

' IK!&9!;!K=;@&A!

$&9=(%=(9(GK;K&#G! #Q!KL(!"L:=AL!PL(G! KL(!*;9&9!#Q!#:=! A#$$#G;'&K+! &9!A;'A:';K()!*+! )#AK=&G;'!;@=(($(GKR! =;KL(=!KL;G! KL(!&G)P(''&G@!

6#=)!,(9:93! !!

$C@('#*$L6$U&%,#2

- 59 -

'%

!

2-! A;G! 9>(KAL! ;! Q;&='+! ;AA:=;K(! %&AK:=(! #Q! KL(! L&9K#=+! #Q! KL(! "L:=AL! '&>(!KL&9M!/#)! @;W(!;! P#G)(=V Q:'!Q=(9L!*=(;KL!#Q!5#'+!4%&=&K!'&Q(!Y#G! KL(!);+!#Q!i(GK(A#9KR!;G)!=(%(;K()'+R! ):=&G@! =(G(P;'! )#PG! KL(! A(GK:=&(9\! ;G)! $;G! A#$(9! ;'#G@! ;G)! 9;+9R! n]#G)(=Q:'p! 1#PR! '(Kb9! 9(K! :%! ;! "L:=AL! %=(9(=W;K&#G! 4#A&(K+! K#! >((%! KL&G@9! @#&G@3m! SG)! L(! *(@&G9! K#! #=V @;G&l(! ;! G(P! )(G#$&G;K&#GR! ;! G(P! Q(''#P9L&%R!;!)&QQ(=(GK!9K=:AK:=(R!Q=(9L! =:'(9! ;G)! =(@:';K&#G9! ;G)! ;AK&W&K&(9R! ):=&G@! PL&AL! KL(! 5#'+! 4%&=&K! J:&(K'+! Y;G)! #QK(G! :GG#K&A()\! $;>(9! L&9! )(V %;=K:=(3!j#(9!KL&9!G(P!Q#=P;=)! '##>V &G@! Q=;$(P#=>! A#'';%9(! #W(=G&@LKo! 1#K!;! *&K! #Q! &Kp! IK!@#(9! #GR!+(;=! ;QK(=! +(;=R!(W(G!A(GK:=+!;QK(=!A(GK:=+^KL(! P#=')b9!A#:GK(=Q(&K!#Q!KL(!=(;'!KL&G@3

Y

$CS(41-$B(0*&)

- 60 -

'

/=(;K!K=:KL9!P(=(!

=(9K#=()!K#!KL(!AL:=AL! KL=#:@L!(W(=+!%=(W&#:9 =(W&W;'3!U;G+!#Q!KL(9( K=:KL9!P(=(!A;==&()!K#! (`K=($(9!;G)!(==#=! *(A;:9(!KL(!AL:=AL ;''#P()!KL($!K#!*(A#$(! KL(!Q#A;'!%#&GK! &G!%';A(!#Q!KL(!#G'+! 2G(!:%#G!]L#$! P(!$:9K!>((%!#:=! ;KK(GK&#G3! !! CQ1><$@&/)#2

- 61 -

'

U;G+!PL#!9L#:')!*(

)&9A&%'(9!#Q!,(9:9

K#);+!;=(!9K&''!#G'+ !)&9A&%'(9!#Q333!;!=(Q#=$(=R! ;!=('&@&#:9!@=#:%!#=!!!!!! (W(G!;G!&)(;!rKL;Ks!

L;9!)&9%';A() KL(&=!'#+;'K+!K#

!,(9:9!"L=&9K3 !!

C9#&Z2#/$!6$A5,,

- 62 -

' 1(;='+!(W(=+

)(G#$&G;K&#G

!#=!$#W($(GK!9(($9!K#!! !)(W('#%!;!%;=K&A:';= !9';GK!#=!9+9K($!#Q K=;)&K&#G9R!9#$(!#Q!PL&AL !:'K&$;K('+!#*9A:=(!KL(! 9&$%'&A&K+!;G)!%:=&K+ !#Q!)(W#K&#G!K#!

"L=&9K3 !!

CU2()>1*$U2()?1:(?)#

- 63 -

'

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

M

!!

CQ1><$@&/)#2

- 64 -

'

1! KL(! *(@&GG&G@! KL(! "L:=AL! P;9!;!J%-->KL,MN!#Q! $(G!;G)! P#$(G!PL#!A(GK(=()!KL(&=!'&W(9!#G! KL(! '&W&G@! "L=&9K3! OL(+! L;)! ;! %(=V 9#G;'! ;G)! W&K;'! #%-=?M>&L,MN! K#! KL(! 6#=)3!IK!K=;G9Q#=$()!KL($!;G)!KL(! P#=')! ;=#:G)! KL($3! OL(G! KL(! "L:=AL!$#W()!K#!/=((A(R!;G)!&K!*(V A;$(!;!N,M->L>N,O3!6;K(=!&K!$#W()! K#!.#$(R!;G)!&K!*(A;$(!;G!M&L?M?"P ?M>&3!1(`K!&K!$#W()!K#!0:=#%(!;G)! &K!*(A;$(!;!+"-?"#%3!T&G;''+!&K!$#W()! K#! S$(=&A;R! ;G)! &K! *(A;$(! ;G!%&P ?%#N#ML%3! ](aW(! @#K! Q;=! K##! $;G+! AL:=AL(9!;G)!9#!Q(P!J%-->KL,MNL3

I

!!

$CQ1>"(2-$F(,4#2*&)

- 65 -

'

H52$,100,#$*/*0#'*$ $ "(4#$0"#12$-(/;$ !"#/$"(4#$0"#12$-(/$ $ ()-$>#(*#$0&$.#$M$ !"#/$(2#$.50$.2&<#)$$ $ ,1?"0*$&+$!"##;$ L)-$!"&5;$H$J&2-;$ $ (20$'&2#$0"()$0"#/6 !!! VS:KL#=!-G>G#PG

- 66 -

'

5SO! ;$! I! @#&G@! K#! P#=>! Q#=o! S$! I! @#&G@! K#! P#=>! K#! K=+! K#! (9K;*'&9L! 9#$(! 9#A&V (K+R! 9#$(! )(G#$&G;K&#GR! #=! 9#$(!a:G)(G#$&G;K&#GRa!K#!P&G! ;!%';A(!Q#=!;!K(;AL&G@R!#=!;G!&GV K(=%=(K;K&#GR! #=! ;! 9+9K($! #Q! K=:KLo!I9!&K!K#!9#$(!O5I1/!KL;K!I! ;$!)(W#K()R! #=!&9! &K! K#! 9(A:=(! Q#=!KL(!6#=)!,(9:9!5&9!;*9#':K(! A(GK=;'&K+!;G)!9:%=($;A+o !! C!6$L5*01)C7:(2<*

W

- 67 -

'

X(P;=(!#Q

;G+KL&G@!KL;K A#$%(K(9! P&KL!'#+;'K+! K#!,(9:9! "L=&9K3!! CH*%(,-$I"('.#2*

- 68 -

'%

4!'#G@!;9!=('&@&#G!P;9! )(G#$&G;K&#G;'V A(GK=&A!/#)!A#:')!G#K!K=:9K! :9! P&KL! %#P(=3! 5;)! L(! )#G(!9#R!&K!P#:')!L;W(!=:G! &GK#! ;! )(G#$&G;K&#G;'! $(@;'#V$;G&;!3!3!3!X:K!&Q!=(V '&@&#G!&9!"L=&9KVA(GK=&AR!&Q!K#! *(! ;! "L=&9K&;G! &9! K#! *(! "L=&9K'&>(R!K#!A;KAL!L&9!$&G)! ;G)!4%&=&KR!KL(G!I!KL&G>!/#)! A;G! *;A>!KL;K! P&KL! %#P(=! K#!KL(!:K$#9K!3!3!3!/#)!A;G! K=:9K!:9!P&KL!%#P(=!L(=(3

A

CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 69 -

' ]L;K!&9!K=:(

!#Q!;'' !#=@;G&l;K&#G9R!*:&')&G@9R &G)&W&):;'!%(#%'(R ;G)!KL(!PL#'(!#Q A=(;K&#G!&9!K=:(!#Q AL:=AL(9M!OL(+ !(`L&*&K!'&Q(!PL(G KL(+!;=(!)(Q&G()!*+!;G) !'&W(!#:K!#Q!;!A(GK(=! =;KL(=!KL;G!PL(G!KL(+ !;=(!)(Q&G()!*+!;G)!'&W(!#G !KL(!%(=&$(K(=3 C92#?&2/$L6$A&/-

- 70 -

'

,:);&9$!P;9!;!Q#')R

!;!A&=A:$Q(=(GA(

!P&KL#:K!;!A(GK(=R !*:K!"L=&9K&;G&K+!&9!;!Q'#A>R !PL(=(!P(!L;W(!;

!A(GK(=!P&KL#:K!; !A&=A:$Q(=(GA(3!](

!L;W(!G#!P;''!;*#:K!:9R!*:K !P(!;=(!@;KL(=() !;=#:G)!5&$R!#:= !!/##)!4L(%L(=)3!'' CF6$L6$82&)*1-#

- 71 -

'%

50! AL:=AL! &9! KL(! AL:=AL! PL(G! &Kb9! ;''! ;*#:K! KL(! IG&K&;K#=R! KL(! 2=&@&G;K#=R! KL(! IG9K&@;K#=R! KL(!4;A=&Q&A&;'!6;$*!#Q!KL(! "L:=AL3! OL(=(! &9! G#! #KL(=! Q#A;'! %#&GKR! G#! #KL(=! =(;V 9#GR! G#! #KL(=! %#&GKR! G#! #KL(=!$#K&W;K&#GR!G#!#KL(=! 9K=:AK:=(333!<:9K!KL(!i(=9#G! #Q! ,(9:9! '&W&G@! 5&9! '&Q(! KL=#:@L!5&9!%(#%'(333!

T

C7&=&52)#2$'(?([1)#

- 72 -

'

OL(!AL:=AL!L;9 #G'+!KL&9!K;9>M!K#

!($*#)+!"L=&9KR !$;G&Q(9K!5&9!G;K:=(R

)($#G9K=;K( /#)a9!'#W(!K#!KL( P#=')!;G)!%=#A';&$ 5&9!6#=)9L&%!#W(=

!;''!KL&G@93 CO()+2#-$F(,,#2

- 73 -

'

8+$%#$(2#$0"#$A&-/$ B"/$(2#)Y0$F1*$(2'*$2#(>"1)?$ B"/$(2#)Y0$F1*$"()-*$"#(,1)?$ B"/$(2#)Y0$F1*$%&2-*$0#(>"1)?$

!

L)-$1+$%#$(2#$0"#$A&-/$ B"/$(2#)Y0$F1*$+##0$?&1)?$ B"/$1*$F1*$,&4#$)&0$*"&%1)?$ $$0"#2#$1*$($%(/6 V";9K&G@!"=#PG9

- 74 -

' OL(!"L:=AL

! !=(%=(9(GK;K&#G &9!KL(!

;G)!A#GK&G:;K&#G!

#Q!"L=&9K3

$CL-&,:"$7(:"12

- 75 -

' 1#!;99($*'+R

G#!AL:=ALR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

G#!$#W($(GKR!!!!!!!!!!!!! G#!K(9K&$#G+R!!!!!!!!!!!!!! G#!Q(''#P9L&%! !&9!<:9K&Q&()!&G &K9!(`&9K(GA(! Q=#$!/#)a9!9K;G)%#&GK (`A(%K!&G9#Q;=!;9

"L=&9K!&9

(`%=(99()!*+!&K3!! $C!6$L5*01)C7:(2<*

- 76 -

Q

Your Christ is too religious U&2$1)$I"21*0;$)#10"#2$&52$'&*0$$$$$$$$$$$$ >&)*>1#)01&5*$2#,1?1&)$)&2$-1*2#?(2-$&+$ 2#,1?1&)$('&5)0*$0&$()/0"1)?6$B"(0$ '(00#2*$1*$*&'#0"1)?$+(2$'&2#$1)0#21&2\$ +(10"$#R:2#**#-$1)$,&4#6 /S6SOIS14!eMg!!YOL(!U(99;@(\

- 77 -

(

H#:!)&)!G#K!

=(A(&W(!;!=('&@&#G! ;*#:K!,(9:9R!!!! *:K!KL(!;AK:;'!!!!!!

i(=9#G! #Q!,(9:93!

$CU2()>1*$U2()?1:(?)#

- 78 -

(

5&9!;&$!P;9

G(W(=!K#!@&W(!:9!; !!G(P!=('&@&#G!&G!#=)(= KL;K!P(!$&@LK!'&W(!;!*&K

$#=(!)(A(GK'+t

&G!KL;K!A;9(!U#9(9!;G) L&9!';P!P#:')!L;W(!!!!!!

9:QQ&A()3!'

$CI"21*0&:"#2$A,5'"(2-0

- 79 -

( /#)!

&9!G#K!! &GK(=(9K()!&G!! =('&@&#G3 $

CB1,,1('$!#':,#

- 80 -

(

O;>(!#G(!'##>!

;K!AL:=AL!L&9K#=+!;G)! +#:!P&''!9((!KL;K "L=&9K&;G&K+!G(()9 !K#!L(;=!KL(!$(99;@(!#Q

,(9:9!;9!$:AL! ;9!#=!$#=(!KL;G $#9K!=('&@&#G93 CA25R/$I(4#/

- 81 -

( ,(9:9!

A;''9!$(GR! G#K!K#!;!!!!!!!!!!!!! G(P!=('&@&#GR!!!!!!!!!! *:K!K#!'&Q(3 CS1#021>"$A&)"&#++#2

- 82 -

(

.('&@&#G!!

&9!;!9;K;G&A!

A#:GK(=Q(&K! #Q!;!=(';K&#GV 9L&%!P&KL!/#)3 CQ&.#20$F#1-,#2

- 83 -

(

.('&@&#:9!9&G!! &9!KL(!#G'+!9&G!!!! ,(9:9!%:*'&A'+! A#GQ=#GK()3 C92#?&2/$L6$A&/-

- 84 -

(

4;K;G!&9!G#KR!!!

;9!$(G!9:%%#9(R! KL(!&G9K&@;K#= !!!!#Q!KL(&=!A=&$(93! .('&@&#G!&9!KL(!

9%(A&;'!9%L(=(! #Q!L&9!&GQ':(GA(3

C712$Q&.#20$L)-#2*&)

- 85 -

(

U(G!G(W(= )#!(W&'

9#!A#$%'(K('+ !;G)!AL((=Q:''+!;9 PL(G!KL(!)#!&K!Q=#$!

=('&@&#:9 A#GW&AK&#G3 CA,(1*#$G(*>(,

- 86 -

(

OL(!(99(GA(!#Q!KL( !=('&@&#:9!9%&=&K!! &9!@(KK&G@!'&Q(!Q=#$! *(&G@!K=:(=!;G)!$#=( =&@LK(#:9!KL;G!#KL(=9R =;KL(=!KL;G!

@(KK&G@!'&Q(! Q=#$!/#)!;'#G(3 IK!&9!'&W&G@!Q=#$!KL( %(=&$(K(=!=;KL(= !KL;G!KL( !A(GK(=3 C92#?&2/$L6$A&/-

- 87 -

(

IK!&9!;!%=#Q#:G) &=#G+!KL;K!KL( 4#G!#Q!/#)! W&9&K()!KL&9!%';G(K ;G)!#G(!#Q!KL(!AL&(Q A#$%';&GK9!;@;&G9K! L&$!P;9!KL;K!L(!P;9!!!

G#K!=('&@&#:9! (G#:@L3

CQ#.#>>($O6$G1::#20

- 88 -

(

2:=!'&Q(!&9!G#K!K#

*(!Q#:G)!&G!#:= A#==(AK!)#AK=&G( #=!&G!#:=!%&(K+R!;9 &$%#=K;GK!;9!KL(9(!;=(3!!!!!! O#!@(K!'&Q(!Q=#$ KL(9(!&9!=('&@&#G3 !2:=!'&Q(!&9!=;KL(=!K#! *(!Q#:G)!&G!,(9:9! "L=&9KR!;G)!&G!,(9:9! "L=&9K!;'#G(3 C92#?&2/$L6$A&/-

- 89 -

( !!!

.('&@&#G!3!3!3

!&9!KL(!;KK($%K()!!!!

=(%';A($(GK #Q!KL(!)&W&G(

P#=>!*+!;!!!!!!!!!!!

L:$;G! $;G:Q;AK:=(3 CT(2,$A(20"

- 90 -

(

2!9:$$;=&l(!AL:=AL!L&9V K#=+! &G! ;! A=;99R! *:K! G#K! ;'K#@(KL(=! &G;AA:=;K(R! P;+333! ,(9:9! A;$(! P&KL! KL(! $(9V 9;@(! N.('&@&#G! &9! =():G);GK3! /#)!L;9!@#G(!#:K!#Q!KL(! =(V '&@&#G!*:9&G(99!;G)!L(!P;GK9! +#:!K#!(`%(=&(GA(!(W(=+KL&G@! +#:! K:=G()! K#! =('&@&#G! Q#=^ Q#=@&W(G(99R! 9;'W;K&#GR! &GV 9K=:AK&#G^KL=#:@L! $(3N! SG)! L&9! Q#''#P(=9! 9;&)R! N]#P3!]L;K!;!A##'!&)(;3!](! 9L#:')!*:&')!;!=('&@&#G!#:K!#Q! KL;KpN!SG)!KL(+!)&)3!

T

CA25R/$I(4#/

- 91 -

(

.('&@&#G!9L&QK9! #:=!Q#A:9!#QQ ,(9:9!"L=&9K !;G)!%';A(9!&K!#G!!!!! #:=9('W(9!;G)!L#P P(''!P(!;=(!#=!;=(GaK! %(=Q#=$&G@3 C70#4#$O>]#/

- 92 -

(

2j!&9!G#K!&GK(=(9K()!&G!=('&@&#GR! *:K! 5(! &9!K=($(G)#:9'+!&GK(=V (9K()! &G! '&Q(3! H#:! A;GG#K! =(;)! KL(! 1(P! O(9K;$(GK! P&KL#:K! =(;'&l&G@! KL;K!KL(!6#=)!,(9:9!)&)!G#K!A;=(!;! PL&K!Q#=!KL(!4;**;KL!=(@:';K&#G9!#Q! L&9!);+!PL(G!KL(+!P(=(!9(K!;@;&G9K! KL(!G(()!#Q!;!*=#>(G!$;G!Q#=!L(;'V &G@3!/#)!&9!G#K!&GK(=(9K()!&G!9K;&G()! @';99! P&G)#P9R! #=@;G! 9#'#9R! A#GV @=(@;K&#G! L+$G9! #=! (W(G! %;9K#=;'! %=;+(=9! L;'Q! 9#! $:AL! ;9! L(! &9! &G! %=#):A&G@! '#W(! Q&''()! L#$(9R! @(GV (=#:9! L(;=K9! ;G)! *=;W(! $(G! ;G)! P#$(G!PL#!A;G!'&W(!=&@LK!&G!$&)9K! #Q!KL(!P#=')!;G)!>((%!KL(&=!L(;)9! ;G)!L(;=K9!:G)(Q&'()3

G

CQ(/$70#-'() - 93 -

(

](!G(()!K#!;9>! Q#=@&W(G(99!Q=#$ /#)R!Q=#$!KL(!P#=')R! Q#=!*(&G@!=('&@&#:93 !](!L;W(!9K=&W(G!K#!*( !=('&@&#:9!PL(G!P(! P(=(!A;''()!K#!!!!!!

*(!'#W&G@3

C92#?&2/$L6$A&/-

- 94 -

(

X06I0F0! &G! ;! 9(A:';=! "L=&9K3! I!)#! G#K!*('&(W(! &G!;!=('&@&#:9!"L=&9K3!I!*('&(W(! #G(!#Q!KL(!PL#'(!)&QQ&A:'K&(9! #Q! "L=&9K&;G&K+! &9! P(aW(! %:K! "L=&9K!&G!;!9%(A&;'!*:&')&G@!Q#=! ;!9%(A&;'!#AA;9&#GR!P&KL!9%(V A&;'!Q#=$9!#Q!P#=9L&%R!9%(A&;'! $:9&AR! 9%(A&;'! (W(=+KL&G@3! ":K!KL(!9%(A&;'!#:K_!%:K!+#:=! L;G)9!&G!+#:=!%#A>(K!;G)!@#! &G!+#:=!#')!*':(!<(;G93!"L=&9K! &9!;!9(A:';=!%(=9#G3

I

CX&2'()$925..$

- 95 -

(

!U;G+!;!9#:'!*(@&G9!

K#!A#$(!K#!/#) !PL(G!L(!Q'&G@9!#QQ

!*(&G@!=('&@&#:9R

!*(A;:9(!KL(=(!&9!#G'+ !#G(!U;9K(=! #Q!KL(!L:$;G!L(;=KR!;G)! ;G)!KL;K!&9!G#K!=('&@&#G

!',(9:9!"L=&9K3 CH*%(,-$I"('.#2*

- 96 -

(

06I/I21!3!3!3!&9!;!'#9(=R! ;! 9K=&AK'+! Q;''(G!;AK&WV &K+3!IK!L;9!;!Q;&'()!%;9K!;G)! ;! *;G>=:%K! Q:K:=(3! OL(=(! P;9! G#! =('&@&#G! &G! 0)(G! ;G)!KL(=(!P#GaK!*(!;G+!&G! L(;W(G_!;G)! &G!KL(!$(;GV K&$(! ,(9:9! L;9! )&()! ;G)! =&9(G! K#! %(=9:;)(! :9! K#! >G#A>!&K!;''!#QQ!=&@LK!G#P3

R

CQ&.#20$I(:&)

- 97 -

(

06I/I21! &9! $;G;@()! 9%&=&K:;'&K+^;G! ;KV K($%K!K#!$;>(!%(#%'(!Q(('! *(KK(=! ;*#:K! KL($9('W(9! P&KL#:K! L('%&G@! KL($! )&9V A#W(=! KL(! =(;'&K+! #Q! KL(&=! #PG!Q=&(G)9L&%!P&KL!KL(!6&WV &G@!/#)3!IK!&9!$;Ga9!;KK($%K! K#!)#!/#)a9!P#=>3

R

CB(/)#$@(>&.*#)

- 98 -

(

.0! +#:! K&=()o! ]#=G! #:Ko! X:=G()! #:K! #G! =('&@&#Go! "#$(!K#!$(3!/(K!;P;+!P&KL!$(! ;G)! +#:b''! =(A#W(=! +#:=! '&Q(3! Ib''! 9L#P! +#:! L#P! K#! K;>(! ;! =(;'! =(9K3! ];'>! P&KL! $(! ;G)! P#=>! P&KL! $(! ^! P;KAL! L#P! I! )#! &K3! '(;=G! KL(! :GQ#=A()! =L+KL$9! #Q! @=;A(3! I! P#GbK! ';+! ;G+KL&G@! L(;W+!#=!&''VQ&KK&G@!#G!+#:3!k((%! A#$%;G+! P&KL! $(! ;G)! +#:b''! '(;=G!K#!'&W(!Q=(('+!;G)!'&@LK'+3m

A

C@#*5*$I"21*0$C$O(00"#%$^^\_`Cab$ c!"#$O#**(?#d

- 99 -

R

Your Christ is too sectarian 8*$I"21*0$ -141-#-e Z!"2.I1O5IS14!ZMZd

- 100 -

) j&9:G&K+!&G

!KL(!X#)+!#Q!"L=&9K !&9!KL(!9A;G);' !#Q!KL(!;@(93 'OL(!@=(;K(9K!9&G !#Q!KL(!"L:=AL!&9!G#K!!!!!!!!!!

'+&G@R!9K(;'&G@R!)=:G>(GV G(99R!;):'K(=+^G#K

(W(G!$:=)(=^ *:K!KL(!9&G!#Q! )&9:G&K+3! CG(5,$N6$A1,,"#1'#2

- 101 -

) OL(!*;9&9!

#Q

!#:=!Q(''#P9L&%

&9!G#K!;=#:G)!KL&9!!! )#AK=&G(R!KL;K )#AK=&G(R!KL(!#KL(= )#AK=&G(_!#=!;=#:G)!KL&9! @=#:%R!KL;K!@=#:%R #=!KL(!#KL(=!@=#:%3!IK!&9 ;=#:G)!"L=&9K!;G) #G'+!;=#:G)!

"L=&9K3

CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 102 -

) "L=&9K!&9!#:= :G&K+R

! G#K!)#@$;9R!G#K!%#'&K&(9R !G#K!=&K:;'9M!#:=!#G(G(99

!&9!;!#G(G(99!#Q!'&Q(3! ](!G(()!Q#=!#:=!A(GK=(!G# !K#P(=!P&KL!;!K#%!=(;AL&G@ !K#!L(;W(GR!P(!L;W(!;

!'&W&G@!6#=)!PL# &9!P&KL!:9R!;G)!&G!5&$R P(!*(&G@!$;G+R!

!;=(!#G(3

CL,#R()-#2$O(>J(2#)

- 103 -

)!

](!)#!G#K $;>(!;!A=(()R! *:K!"L=&9K! KL(!@=#:G)! ;G)!K(=$!#Q! :G&#G3 C@&")$X#,*&)$S(2./

- 104 -

) % U+!Q(''#P9L&%!

&9!G#K!A#GA(=G()!9#!$:AL! P&KL!PL;K!I!L#')!*:K!P&KL! ]L#!L#')9!$(3! 1#K!9#!$:AL!P&KL!;!A=(()!

*:K!P&KL!KL(!"L=&9K3! IK!=(9K9!G#K!9#!$:AL! &G!;G!;@=(($(GK! #G!KL(!)#AK=&G( #Q!=()($%K&#G!*:K!

&G!;!A#$$#G! &GK(='#A>!P&KL!

KL(!.()(($(=3 C9#&++2#/$!6$A5,,

- 105 -

) -G&K+

!)#(9!G#K! A#$(!Q=#$ *('&(W&G@!KL(! KL(!9;$(!KL&G@! *:K!Q=#$! K=:9K&G@!KL(! 9;$(!%(=9#G3 CO1<#$B#,,*

- 106 -

)

10! $&@LK! KL&G>! KL;KR! P&KL! KL(! X&*'(! ;9! KL(! A(GK(=! #Q! "L=&9K&;G&K+R! KL(! :G&K+! #Q! "L=&9K&;G9! A#:')! *(! (;9&'+! =(;'&l()3! X:K! :GQ#=K:V G;K('+! KL&9! L;9! G#K! %=#W()! K=:(R!KL#:@L!P(!A;G!A#G9&)(=! &K! Q#=K:G;K(! &G)(()! KL;KR! ;9! KL&9!&G;*&'&K+! K#!:G&Q+!%=#W(9R! KL(!'(KK(=!#Q!KL(!X&*'(!A;GG#K! =(;''+!=(%';A(!KL(!'&W&G@!"L=&9K! ;9!KL(!A(GK(=!#Q!#:=!Q;&KL3

O

CT&<1>"1$T52&*(<1

- 107 -

) OL(!%#9&K&#G %

I!L;W(!(W(=!$;&GK;&G()R #Q!:G&#G!P&KL!KL(

PL#'(!A&=A'(

!#Q!/#)a9!=()(($()R!

P&KL#:K!(`A':9&W(!!!!!! ;KK;AL$(GK!K#! ;G+!9(AK&#G! #Q!&K!&9!);&'+!$#=(! %=(A&#:9!!!!!!!! &G!$+!(+(93!

CL)0"&)/$X&221*$92&4#*

- 108 -

)

10! #*9K;A'(! P(! $:9K! #W(=A#$(! &9! KL(! &'':9&#G! KL;K! P(R!*(A;:9(!#Q! #:=! ;*&'&K+! K#!N=&@LK'+!)&W&)(!KL(!P#=)RN!;=(! $#=(! 9%&=&K:;'! KL;G! KL#9(! &G! #KL(=! AL:=AL(93!OL&9! )(A(%K&#G! &GQ(AK9! AL:=AL(9! ;A=#99! KL(! *#;=)3! "#G9(J:(GK'+R! P(! =(V $;&G! )&W&)()R! >(%K! &G! &9#';K&#G! *+! #:=! #PG! 9%&=&K:;'! %=&)(R! G(W(=! )&9A(=G&G@! KL;K! KL(! (GV ($+! L;9! KL(! AL:=AL! )#PG! KL(! 9K=((K!9&$&';='+!KL&G>&G@!KL(+!;=(! $#=(!9%&=&K:;'!KL;G!:93

O

CU2()>1*$U2()?1:(?)#

- 109 -

) 4#!'#G@!

;9!

P(!<:)@(!"L=&9K! K#!*(!)P(''&G@! P&KL!;!%(=9#GR!

KL;K!&9!#:=! P;==;GK!Q#=! =(A(&W&G@! L&$3

CL)0"&)/$X&221*$92&4#*

- 110 -

)

OL(!%';@:(9!#Q!!!!!!!! A#GK=#W(=9+!!!!!!! ;G)!)&W&9&#G!;G)! P(;>G(99!P&''!*(! ';=@('+!'&QK()!PL(G ;G)!@(K!*;A>!K# KL(!A(GK(=^ "L=&9K3! CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 111 -

) OL;K!&9!KL(!

*#G)!#Q!:G&#G

^KL;K!P( !!*('#G@!K#!"L=&9K3! !!2G(!P&KL !"L=&9K^KL;K!&9!!!!!!!!!!! KL(!@=(;K!*#G) !!K#!>((% !!*(Q#=(!:93 C9#&2?#$O5#,,#2

- 112 -

) ]L(G!#KL(=!&99:(9 !;=(!;''#P()!K#!%#';=&l( KL#9(!Q#=!PL#$!

"L=&9K!&9!6#=)R!!

KL;K!&99:(R!PL;K(W(=!&K!&9R!!!!! &9!('(W;K()!K#! ;!%#9&K&#G!#Q!@=(;K(=! &$%#=K;GA(!KL;G!

"L=&9K!5&$9('Q3 !

CQ1>"(2-$F(,4#2*&)

- 113 -

)

!!! !]L(G(W(=!KL(!! !!%(=&%L(=+ !&9!&G!);G@(=!#Q!

)&9%';A&G@! KL(!A(GK(=R!

P(!;=(!G#K!Q;=!!!!!!! =($#W()!Q=#$!!!! &)#';K=+3 CS6$L6$I(2*&)

- 114 -

) OL(!%=#*'($

!#Q!:G&K+!

P&''!*(!P(''!#G!KL(!

P;+!K#!9#':K&#G!

&Q!KL(!3!3!3!AL:=AL!$;>(9

"L=&9K!A(GK=;' ;G)!;''!('9(

!$;=@&G;'3! CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 115 -

) ]L;K(W(=! +#:!$;>(!

KL(!&99:(R! +#:!$;>(!

KL(!&)#'3 CL50"&2$f)<)&%)

- 116 -

) O#!9%(;>!%';&G'+!3!3!3!

&K!&9!G#K!)&QQ(=(GK!#%&G&#G9R !G#=!;!)&QQ(=(GA(!&G!<:)@$(GK!

;*#:K!=(W(;'()!K=:KL9R! G#=!;!)&QQ(=(GK!%=;AK&A(!&G! 9;A=()!;)$&G&9K=;K&#G9R!*:K!

%=&)(R!9('QV&GK(=(9KR

'#W(!#Q!L#G#:=R!=(%:K;K&#GR ;G)!)#$&G&#G!3!3!3!KL;K!;=( !KL(!K=:(!A;:9(! #Q!KL;K!)(Q(AK!#Q! (W;G@('&A;'!:G&K+3 C@&")$H%#)

- 117 -

) I!;$!%(=9:;)()

KL(!$#=(!KL(!'#W( #Q!/#)!&9!9L()!;*=#;) &G!#:=!L(;=K9R!KL(!$#=( ;''!G;==#PG(99!#Q 9%&=&K!P&''!9:*9&)(!!!!! ;G)!@&W(!P;+3 C9#&2?#$B"10#+1#,-

- 118 -

)

1OI6!I!A;G!'(;=G!K#!9((! $+!*=#KL(=b9!Q;:'K9!;9!;! $(=(! $#K(! A#$%;=()! P&KL! KL(!=(;'&K+!#Q!KL(!6#=)!'&W&G@! &G! 5&$! ;G)! #G! KL(! #KL(=! L;G)! 9((! $+! #PG! A=&K&A;'! ;G)!G(@;K&W(!=(;AK&#G!K#!L&$! ;9!;!@=(;K!P##)(G!*(;$!#Q! 9&G! &G! $+9('QR! I! 9L;''! G(W(=! Q&G)!KL(!>(+!K#!:G&K+!3!3!3!

U

CX&2'()$925..

- 119 -

) 4(AK;=&;G&9$

&9!(99(GK&;''+!; !!Q;&':=(333!K#! ($*=;A(!&G!#:=!!!! ;QQ(AK&#G9!;''!PL#!

*('#G@!K#!! "L=&9K3

CL50"&2$5)<)&%)

- 120 -

) H)# H)#

!AL:=AL3! !Q;&KL3!H)#!6#=)3!1#K! X;%K&9KR!G#K!U(KL#)&9KR!!! G#K!S)W(GK&9K3!!!!!!!!!!!! ,:9K!"L=&9K&;G93!!!! 1#!)(G#$&G;K&#G93!!!!! 1#!L&(=;=AL&(93!!!!!!!!!!! 1#!K=;)&K&#G93!!!!!!!!!!!!!

,:9K!"L=&9K3 CO(R$J5>(-&

- 121 -

) %

X.IOI45! G#*'($;G!! %=(;AL&G@! KL(! @#9%('! &G!4P()(G!9#$(!+(;=9!;@#! P;9!;9>()!*+!;!';)+!PL;K! AL:=AL! L(! *('#G@()! K#3! NO#! KL(! "L:=AL! #Q! "L=&9KN! P;9!L&9!=(%'+3!NH(9R!*:K!K#! PL;K! *=;GALoN! 9L(! &GV 9&9K()3! NU;);$R! I! )#! G#K! *('#G@!K#!;G+!*=;GAL3!I!*(V '#G@!K#!KL(!O=:G>3N!

A

- 122 -

) OL(!T;KL(=!

L;9!)(A=(()!KL;K!

"L=&9Ka9!"L:=AL!

9L;''!*(!:G&K()3! 5&9!4#G!L;9!%:=AL;9()!&KR! ;G)!KL(!5#'+!4%&=&K !&9!L(=(!K#!(9K;*'&9L!&K3 OL(!!*;KK'(!+#:!;=(!Q;A&G@!

&9!;!)&9K=;AK&#G_!

KL(!=(;'!&99:(!&9!K#! $;&GK;&G!KL(!#G(G(99!

#Q!"L=&9K3

CU2()>1*$U2()?1:(?)#

- 123 -

S

Your Christ is too trivial U&2$*&'#$'#);$*02(/1)?$+2&'$0"#*#$ 0"1)?*;$"(4#$052)#-$(*1-#$0&$ +2510,#**$-1*>5**1&)666 Z!OIU2O5H!ZMg!1S4X

- 124 -

*

5#P!$;G+ '(;)(=9!L;W(!!!!!!!!

9;))'()!KL(&=!%(K %((W(9R!)=;PG!KL(&= 9P#=)9!#Q!*&KK(=G(99 ;G)!';:GAL()!&GK# *;KK'(!;@;&G9K!*=(KLV =(G!#W(=!&99:(9!KL;K

;=(!G#K!P#=KL )&9A:99&G@o CO(R$J5>(-&

- 125 -

*!

S''!KL(9(!%(KK+!!!!!!!!!!! ! !!!! '&KK'(!KL&G@9!KL;K )&W&)(!KL(!L(;=K!#Q!KL( 9;&GK9!&9!$(=('+!@&W&G@ !;$$:G&K&#G!K# KL(!L#9K9!#Q!(W&'!;G)

P(;>(G&G@!KL(! 9%&=&K:;'!%#P(=!! #Q!KL(!9;&GK93'

CF(2&,-$706$@&")

- 126 -

*

IQ!P(!)#!G#K!>((%

!#:=!;KK(GK&#G :%#G!KL(!:'K&$;K( %:=%#9(!#Q!/#)R P(!P&''!A#GK&G:;''+ *(!)&9K=;AK()

*+!KL(!'(99(=!!!!!!!! %:=%#9(9!#Q!/#)3 CO1<#$A1><,#

- 127 -

*

](!;=(!#QK(G!

)&9K=;AK()

Q=#$!KL(!.&W(=!#Q!6&Q(! *+!KL(!'&KK'(!

K=&*:K;=&(9! KL;K!Q(()!&K3! CQ1><$@&/)#2

- 128 -

*

50!,(=:9;'($!'(;)(=9!A;$(!G(;=! K#!9$#KL(=&G@!KL(!@#9%('!&G!KL(! *(@&GG&G@3!IK! P;9! i;:'! PL#! '##9()!&K! Q=#$! &K9!,(P&9L!Q(KK(=93! 5(!);=()!Q#'V '#P!KL(!'&W&G@!"L=&9K!&GK#!KL(!L(;=K!#Q! %;@;G&9$3! 5(! A;$(! *;A>! ;G)! K#')! PL;K! /#)! L;)! P=#:@LK3! OL(! ,(=:9;V '($! '(;)(=9333! )=(P! :%! 9#$(! #Q! KL(! KL&G@9! A#G9&)(=()! (99(GK&;'! Q#=! KL(! "L=&9K&;G9! ;$#G@! /(GK&'(9333! NK#! ;*V 9K;&G!Q=#$! KL&G@9!9K=;G@'()!;G)! Q=#$! *'##)3N! X&G)&G@! :%! KL(! @#9%('! #Q! "L=&9K!P&KL!KL;Kp!2Q!A#:=9(!&K!)=#%%()! ;P;+R!Q#=!KL(!@#9%('!P;9!;K!@=&%9!P&KL! *&@@(=!&99:(93!IK!$;+!*(!KL;K!K#!Q:K:=(! "L=&9K&;G9!9#$(!#Q!KL(!KL&G@9!KL;K!P(! A#G9&)(=!(99(GK&;'!&G!#:=!9+9K($9! P&''! 9(($!<:9K!;9!;*9:=)!;9!KL&9!)#(9!K#!:93

T

-N6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 129 -

*

OL(!%=#*'($!P&KL !KL(!AL:=AL!K#);+!&9! G#K!A#==:%K&#G3!IK!&9!G#K!!! !!&G9K&K:K&#G;'&9$3!1#R!KL( !%=#*'($!&9!Q;=!$#=( !!9(=&#:9!KL;G!9#$( KL&G@!'&>(!KL(!$&G&9K(=! =:GG&G@!;P;+!P&KL!KL(! #=@;G&9K3!OL(!%=#*'($!&9! %(KK&G(993!X';K;GK! %(KK&G(993! -O1<#$V(>&)#,,1

- 130 -

*!

!!!! OL(!9(G9&K&W&K+ ! #Q!$(G!K#!

9$;''!$;KK(=9

;G)!KL(&=!&G)&QQ(=(GA(!

K#!@=(;K!#G(9R &G)&A;K(9!;!

9K=;G@(

!&GW(=9&#G3!

-A,(1*#$G(*>(,

- 131 -

*

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i(K(=R! #=! i;:'R!#=!S%#''#9_!K#!9%(;>!&G!K#G@:(9R!#=!G#K! K#! 9%(;>!&G!K#G@:(9_!L#P!$(G! 9L#:')!*(V L;W(R!;G)!L#P!P#$(G!9L#:')!*(L;W(333!2G! ;G)!#G!&K!P(GKR!;G)!#G!;G)!#G!&K! 9K&''!@#(9! K#);+333!](!)#!G#K!G(()!$#=(!#Q!KL(!6#=)R! 9&GA(!P(!;=(!;'=(;)+!A#$%'(K(!&G!"L=&9K!^! P(!<:9K!G(()!'(99!#Q!(W(=+KL&G@!('9(3

T

-I"1:$A2&?-#)

- 132 -

*

OL(!$;&G!KL&G@!!!!!!!

&9!K#!>((%!!!!!!!

KL(!$;&G!KL&G@!!!!

KL(!$;&G! KL&G@3!

-70#:"#)$Q6$I&4#/

- 133 -

*

6(K!$(!@&W(!+#:!9#$( =(;'!$&9AL&(Q9M !'&W&G@!Q#=!9L#PR! '#9&G@!KL(!PL#'(! &G!KL(!%;=K&A:';=9R! &G):'@(GA(!#Q W&K;'!%#P(=9!&G!

K=&W&;'&K&(93

-Q(,:"$B(,-&$N'#2*&)

- 134 -

*

% O!&9!K&$(!KL(!AL:=AL! J:&K!%=(K(G)&G@!KL;K! %(KK&G(99!)#(9GaK!$;KK(=3! i(KK&G(99! L;9! *(A#$(! ;! 9(=&#:9! )&9(;9(! &G! KL(! "L:=AL!#Q!,(9:9! "L=&9KR!;! )&9(;9(! PL&AL! A#GK&G:(9! K#!=(9:'K!&G!K(=$&G;'!A;9(9! #Q! )&9A#=)R! )&9=:%K&#GR! ;G)!)(9K=:AK&#G3

I

-O1<#$V(>&)#,,1

- 135 -

*

% 0.5Si4! +#:aW(! L(;=)! ;*#:K! KL(! Q;=$(=! PL#! P;9!#:K!P#=>&G@!&G!L&9!Q&(')3!5(! 9;P!;!$#:9(!;G)!KL;K!;G@(=()! L&$3! 4#! L(! K##>! L&9! L#(! ;G)! *(@;G!K#!@#!;QK(=!KL;K!$#:9(3! 5(! 9%(GK! KL(! G(`K! KL&=K+! $&GV :K(9! AL;9&G@! ;G)! *(;K&G@! ;K! KL;K!$#:9(!;G)!Q&G;''+!L(!>&''()! &K3! OL(G! L(! '##>()! *;A>! ;G)!! =(;'&l()! L(! L;)! P=(A>()! ;G! ;A=(!#Q!L&9!A=#%93

P

-B(22#)$B1#2*.#

- 136 -

*

1#KL&G@!&9! $#=(!:GP#=KL+! #Q!;!P&9(!$;G !#=!#:@LK!K#!K=#:*'( !L&$!$#=(!KL;G!K# !L;W(!;''#P() !$#=(!K&$(!Q#= !K=&Q'&G@!:9('(99 KL&G@9!KL;G!KL(+

)(9(=W(3 -G,(0&

- 137 -

*

T=#$!;!%=#:)! )#AK#=!#Q!KL(#'#@+R !Q=#$!;!A#GK(GV K&#:9!%;9K#=R!;G) !Q=#$!:9('(99 !J:(9K&#G9R!$;+! /#)!)('&W(=! L&9!"L:=AL3 CO(201)$J50"#2$

- 138 -

*

5#P!$;G+

%:'%&K!L#:=9!! L;W(!*((G !P;9K()!#G !%=(;AL&G@!KL(!

K=&W&;'o

-O(R$J5>(-&

- 139 -

*

0! %;KK(=!#Q!&GK#! ;=@:$(GK9!;*#:K! %=()(9K&G;K&#G_!P(!P##'V@;KL(=!&G! KL(!KL&=)! L(;W(G_!P(!)&@=(99! &GK#!A#GV <(AK:=(9! ;*#:K! KL(! ;K#G($(GK_! P(! )&V W(=K! #:=9('W(9! *+! A#:GK&G@!$&=;A'(9!#=! A#''(AK&G@! @=;$$;K&A;'! #))&K&(93! SG)! KL(G!4K3!,#LGa9!W&9&#G!&GK(==:%K9!:93!](! ;=(! 9K;=K'()! #:K! #Q! #:=! P##'@;KL(=&G@! )&@=(99&#G9R! #:=! K;G@(GK&;'! ;=@:$(GK9R! #:=!&G;KK(GK&W(!)&W(=9&#G93!2:=!&$;@&G;V K&#G9! ;=(! >&G)'()! P&KL! ;! W&9&#G^#Q! "L=&9K3! ](! ;=(! =#:9()R! ;KK(GK&W(R! ;'(=K3! 0W(=+KL&G@! 9:))(G'+! &9! &G! %=#%#=K&#G3! "L=&9K!&9!KL(!';9K!P#=)333!OL&9!&9!KL(!@#;'! K#P;=)9! PL&AL! (W(=+KL&G@! &9! ;&$()333! OL(! .(W(';K&#G! @&W(9! :9! KL(! ';9K! P#=)! #G!"L=&9KR!;G)!KL(!P#=)!&9!KL;K!"L=&9K!&9! KL(!A(GK(=!;G)!;K!KL(!A(GK(=3!''

W

-N5?#)#$G#0#2*&)$$$ - 140 -

*

OL&G@9!PL&AL $;KK(=!$#9K!

$:9K!G(W(= !!*(!;K!KL(!$(=A+ #Q!KL&G@9!PL&AL!!! $;KK(=!'(;9K3

C@&"())$B6$9�"#

- 141 -

*

501! P(! ;=(! A#GA(GK=;K()! :%#G!KL(!%=&$;=+!%:=%#9(9! #Q! /#)! KL(!9(A#G);=+!%:=%#9(9! P&''! KL(G! 9(=W(! KL(! #G(3! IQ! #:=! (+(! &9! 9&G@'(R! #G! 5&$R! KL(G! KL(! PL#'(!*#)+!P&''!*(!Q:''!#Q!'&@LK3!IQ! #:=!(+(!&9!G#K!9&G@'(!*:K!)&W&)()! &GK#! KL(! $;G+! 9(A#G);=+! %:=V %#9(9R! &K! P&''! *(A#$(! );=>G(99! &G9K(;)! #Q! '&@LK3! 0W(G! KL#:@L! KL(+!$;+!*(!K=:KL9!KL(+!P&''!9K&''! )(A(&W(!:9_!KL(+!P&''!*(A#$(!)&9V K#=K()!;G)!(`K=($(!&Q!#:=!Q#A:9! &9!G#K!#G!KL(!6#=)!5&$9('Q3!!

W

CQ1><$@&/)#2

- 142 -

*

OL(=(!;=(!;G!

&GQ&G&K+!#Q! ;G@'(9!;K!PL&AL! #G(!Q;''9R!#G'+! #G(!;K!PL&AL!!!!!!!!!!!!!! #G(!9K;G)93 C96$T6$I"#*0#20&)

- 143 -

*

50.0!&9!#G'+!#G(!9;Q(! ;G)! 9:=(! A(GK(=! #Q! "L=&9K&;G!(`%(=&(GA(R!)#AV K=&G(! ;G)! K(9K&$#G+! ;G)! KL;K!&9! ,(9:9!"L=&9K3!4K;G)! ;K! ;G+! #KL(=! %#&GKR! G#! $;KK(=! L#P! @##)R! ;G)! +#:!P&''!*(A#$(!'#%9&)()3! 4K;G)! P&KL! 5&$! ;G)! +#:! >((%!+#:=!*;';GA(R! Q#=!*+! 5&$!;''!KL&G@9!A#G9&9K3

T

C]()>#$F(4)#2

- 144 -

*

6##>!;K!KL&G@9! ';=@('+!;G)! )#GaK!9%(G)! +#:=!'&Q(!%';+&G@! P&KL!%&(A(9!#Q! 9A;QQ#')&G@3' -F(2&,-$706$@&")

- 145 -

*

/(GK'($(GR!

Q#=!KL(!'#W(!#Q !/#)R!'(K!:9!*:+!!!!!

*&@!$;%93 CJ&2-$7(,1*.52/

- 146 -

T

Your Christ is too finite I"21*0$6$6$6$?14#*$5*$ 0"#$.#*0$:1>052#$&+$9&-$ %#Y,,$#4#2$?#06 C!"2.I1O5IS14!ZMg!YOL(!U(99;@(\

- 147 -

+

,(9:9!"L=&9K

5&$9('Q!&9!KL( Q&G;'!(`(@(9&9 #Q!;''!K=:KL3!5(!&9 ;''!KL;K!P(!G(()!K# >G#P!;*#:K!

/#)3

CO(=&2$B6$8()$!"&'(*

- 148 -

+

OL(!.(W(';K&#G! #Q!/#)!&9!G#K!!!!!!!!! ;!*##>!#=!;!!!!!!!! )#AK=&G(R!*:K!;!!!! '&W&G@!i(=9#G) CN'1,$A25))#2

- 149 -

+

]&9)#$R!!!!!!! /#)a9!*':(%=&GK

!Q#=!L:$;G9R!;K!';9K! L(=9('Q!*(A#$(9!!!!! L:$;G3 OL(!4L(>&G;L!!!! K:=G9!#:K!K#!L;W(!;!

L:$;G!Q;A(3 CX6$!6$B21?"0

- 150 -

+

H#:=!&$;@( !#Q!/#)

!&9!KL(!9&G@'(!$#9K &$%#=K;GK !('($(GK!#Q!+#:= 9%&=&K:;'! <#:=G(+3

C92("('$I&&<#

- 151 -

+

,04-4!!!!!!!!!

I4!/2j!!!!!!!!! 6IF0j!XH! US13 CU2#-#21><$9&-#0

- 152 -

+

5(!r,(9:9s!&9! KL(!'&W&G@R! A#GA=(K(R!

($*#)&()! %&AK:=(!#Q!

/#)3

C92#?&2/$L6$A&/-

- 153 -

+

]L(G!P(!Q;&'!

K#!9((!,(9:9

;9!5(!&9R!P(!P(!K(G)! K#!A=(;K(!/#)!&G!#:=! #PG!&$;@(3! OL&9!L;9!*((G!KL(!

KL(!@=(;K!Q;&'&G@ !#Q!KL(!AL:=AL! KL=#:@L!KL(!;@(93 C!#22/$7&'#241,,#

- 154 -

+

,(9:9 P;9!/#)b9! (`;AK =(%'&A;3

CG"1,1:$V()>#/

- 155 -

+

I!*('&(W(!

&G!KL(!/#)!PL#9(!

(`;AK!&$%=&GK

&9!#G!)&9%';+!

@:=@'&G@!&G!KL(!$;G@(=R ;=@:&G@!&G!KL(!K($%'(R! !*'(()&G@!#G!KL(!A=#993 I!*('&(W(!&G!KL(!/#) $;)(!>G#PG!&G!!!!!!!

,(9:9333

CX6$!6$B21?"0

- 156 -

+

,(9:9!&9! /#)!9&$%'&Q&()R !/#)!;%%=#;AL;*'(R!

!/#)!:G)(=9K;G);*'(R!

!/#)!'#W;*'(3!

]L(G!I!9;+!n/#)m! I!KL&G>!,(9:93! SG)!G#KL&G@!L&@L(=!A;G! *(!KL#:@LK!#=!9;&)p!

,(9:9!&9!KL(!';9K!

P#=)!KL;K!A;G!*(!9;&)! ;*#:K!/#)3 $CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 157 -

+

IG!,(9:9R!

/#)!';+!)#PG!#G!KL(!

)&99(AK&#G!K;*'(R! ;9!&K!P(=(R

!9K=(KAL()!#:K

!&G!A=:A&Q#=$!%#9K:=(!Q#=! KL(!9A=:K&G+!!!!!!!!!!! #Q!;''!9>(%K&A9!PL#!!!!!!!!!! L;W(!(W(=!'&W()3!' CG"1,1:$V()>#/

- 158 -

+

,(9:9!&9! KL(!]#=)!#Q!/#)3!! 5(!&9!G#K KL(!*(9K!]#=)3!! 5(!&9!G#K! KL(!:'K&$;K(!]#=)3 !5(!&9!G#K

KL(!9(;'!#Q!9(=&(9!#Q !&$%=#W&G@!P#=)93!!!!

5(!&9!KL(! ]#=)3!

CL50"&2$5)<)&%)

- 159 -

+

SG!#')!"L&G(9(!9AL#';=R! ;QK(=!'&9K(G&G@ !Q#=!KL(!Q&=9K!K&$(!K#!KL(

9K#=+!#Q!KL(!'#W&G@R !9;A=&Q&A&G@!/#)R

(`A';&$()!K#!L&9!G(&@L*#=R!

DS1-)K0$8$0#,,$/&5 $0"#2#$&5?"0$0&$.#$($$$$$$ 9&-$,1<#$0"(0eE' CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 160 -

+

OL(=(!;=(!$;G+!KL&G@9!

P(!A;GaK!(`%';&G3

!5#P(W(=!G#P!P(!L;W(

;G!(`%';G;K&#G !#Q!/#)a9!!G;K:=(^

!,(9:9!"L=&9K3!

OL(=(!G(()!G(W(=!

*(!A#GQ:9&#G!

;*#:K!5&$!;@;&G3! CN5?#)1($G21>#

- 161 -

+

!,(9:9! A;$(!K#

=(W(;'

KL(!K=:(!Q;A( !#Q!/#)3! Cg(41#2$L6$7()0('(21(

- 162 -

+

I!>G#P!#Q! G#!/#)!#KL(=!

KL;G!KL(!#G(! A;''()!,(9:9!

"L=&9K3

CO(201)$J50"#2

- 163 -

+

/#)a9!K#K;'!!!!!!!!! (`%';G;K&#G!!!!!!! #Q!5&$9('Q!K#! $;G!&9!,(9:9! "L=&9K3 CN5?#)1($G21>#

- 164 -

+

SG+KL&G@!KL;K!! #G(!&$;@&G(9!#Q! /#)!;%;=K!Q=#$! "L=&9K!&9!#G'+!:9(V '(99!KL&G>&G@!;G)! W;&G!&)#';K=+3 CO(201)$J50"#2

- 165 -

+

IQ!I!P(=(!K#!9&K!)#PG! K#!K=+!K#!KL&G>!#:K!

KL(!>&G)!#Q!/#)!!!!!!!!!! I!P#:')!'&>(!K#!9((! &G!KL(!:G&W(=9(R! Q#=!KL(!'&Q(!#Q!$(R!

I!A#:')GbK!KL&G>!

#Q!;G+KL&G@!L&@L(=! KL;G!KL;K!5(!9L#:')!*(!!!!!!!!!!

'&>(!"L=&9K3

CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 166 -

+

!]L;K!$;>(9! "L=&9K&;G&K+!

"L=&9K&;G

&9!A(GK(=&G@!

&G!/#)!

;9!>G#PG!

&G!,(9:93

CO(2>5*$@6$A&2?

- 167 -

+

OL(!@=(;K(9K! G(P9!KL;K!L;9!

(W(=!*((G!*=#>(G! K#!KL(!L:$;G!=;A(! &9!KL(!G(P9!KL;K!

/#)!&9!'&>(! "L=&9K3 CN6$70(),#/$@&)#*

- 168 -

+

16H! K#! KL(! (`K(GK! KL;K!P(!=(9#'W(!&G!#:=! $&G)9!;G)!L(;=K9!KL;K!/#)! '##>9! '&>(! ,(9:9^)+&G@! ;! /#)VQ#=9;>(G!)(;KL!#G!KL(! A=#99! &G!#=)(=!K#! #%(G! :%! KL(! Q(''#P9L&%! #Q! KL(! %(=V Q(AKR! '#W&G@R! K=&:G(! A#$V $:G&K+^A;G!P(!$;>(!;G+! %=#@=(99! &G! (`%=(99&G@! /#)a9!'#W(!&G!#:=!'&W(93

O

C92#?&2/$L6$A&/-

- 169 -

+

02./0! X:KK=&A>R! Q#=$(=! AL;%';&G!;K!5;=W;=)R!=(A;''9! KL;K!9K:)(GK9!P#:')!A#$(!&GK#! L&9!#QQ&A(R!%'#%!)#PG!#G!;!AL;&=! ;G)!)(A';=(M!nI!)#GbK!*('&(W(!&G! /#)3m!!!!!!!!! ! X:KK=&A>!P#:')!@&W(!KL&9!)&9V ;=$&G@! =(%'+M! n4&K! )#PG! ;G)! K(''! $(! PL;K! >&G)! #Q! /#)! +#:! )#GbK! *('&(W(! &G3! I! %=#*;*'+! )#GbK! *('&(W(! &G! KL;K! /#)! (&V KL(=3m!SG)!KL(G! L(!P#:')! K;'>! ;*#:K! ,(9:9R! KL(! A#==(AK&W(! K#! ;''!#:=!;99:$%K&#G9!;*#:K!/#)3

G

CG"1,1:$V()>#/

- 170 -

U

Your Christ is too cluttered !"#2#$1*$&),/$I"21*0$6$6$6$ F#$1*$#4#2/0"1)?6 "26244IS14!dMZZ!!Y,(=:9;'($!X&*'(\

- 171 -

,

!2:=!@=(;K(9K

!G(()!;G)!/#)a9! @=(;K(9K!@&QK!K#!:9R!

&9!K#!;P;>(G!:9!!!! K#!KL(!9:QQ&A&(GA+R

9:%=($;A+R! !;G)!)(9K&G+R! #Q!KL(!6#=)!

,(9:9!"L=&9K3 CU(%)$G(21*"

- 172 -

,

OL(!#G(!PL#! L;9!"L=&9K!L;9!

(W(=+KL&G@3!!!

OL(!#G(!PL#!L;9! (W(=+KL&G@!(`A(%K !Q#=!"L=&9K!=(;''+!!!!!! L;9!G#KL&G@3 CL5?5*01)#$&+$F1::&

- 173 -

,

.(V9K;K(!K#!+#:=9('Q!

!PL;K!+#:!*('&(W(R!! KL(G!)#!;P;+!P&KL!

;9!$:AL!#Q!&K! ;9!%#99&*'(R!;G)!@(K! *;A>!K#!KL(!*()=#A>!! #Q!KL(!"=#99! #Q!"L=&9K3 CH*%(,-$I"('.#2*

- 174 -

,

OL(!=&9(G!W&AK#=&#:9!

,(9:9!3!3!3!P;9!;''

!KL(!(;='+!"L=&9K&;G! A#$$:G&K+!L;)!3!3!3! OL;Ka9!G#K!=L(K#=&A_ KL;Ka9!L&9K#=+3!OL(+ L;)!#G'+!,(9:9!;G)!P(! >((%!KL&G>&G@!!KL;K! P(!G(()!9#$(V

KL&G@!('9(3

CA2#))()$O())1)?

- 175 -

,

50.0!&9!#G'+!#G(!=(V ';K&#G9L&%!KL;K!$;KV K(=9R! ;G)! KL;K! &9! +#:=! %(=9#G;'! =(';K&#G9L&%! K#! ;!%(=9#G;'!=()(($(=!;G)! 6#=)3!6(K!(W(=+KL&G@!('9(! @#R! *:K! $;&GK;&G! KL;K!;K! ;''!A#9K9R!;G)!/#)!P&''!Q:'V Q&''! 5&9! %:=%#9(! KL=#:@L! +#:=!'&Q(3

T

CH*%(,-$I"('.#2*

- 176 -

,

/#)!&9!

A;''&G@!:9!K#!;G! :G)&9K=;AK()! %;99&#G!Q#=! 5&9!4#G3! CU(%)$G(21*"

- 177 -

,

!I!Q(;=R!'(9K!9#$(V

L#P!;9!KL(!9(=%(GK

)(A(&W()

0W(!*+!L&9!A=;QK&G(99R! 9#!+#:=!$&G)9!$;+ *(!A#==:%K()!Q=#$ KL(!9&$%'&A&K+!KL;K! &9!&G!"L=&9K3!' CG(5,$0"#$L:&*0,#

- 178 -

,

](!$:9K!9K=&W(!!!!!!!!

K#!%=#A';&$!;!$(99;@(!KL;K! N=(VA#GW(=K9N!"L=&9K&;G9!

*;A>!K#!"L=&9K!

Q#=!S66!KL;K!5( !&9^K=;G9Q#=$&G@! $;G+R!#GA(!;@;&GR!&GK#

i(=9#GV)=&W(G

!)&9A&%'(93

CS(41-$A2/()0

- 179 -

,

A#$!"&5$'/$41*1&);$ H$J&2-$&+$'/$"#(20$$ X(5?"0$.#$(,,$#,*#$0&$'#;$ 7(4#$0"(0$!"&5$(20M$ !"&5$'/$.#*0$0"&5?"0$$$ A/$-(/$&2$./$)1?"0$ B(<1)?$&2$*,##:1)?;$ !"/$:2#*#)>#$'/$,1?"06 VEKL!"(GK:=+!I=&9L!L+$G

- 180 -

,

5(!&9!;!%;KLR!&Q!;G+!*(!$&9'()R 5(!&9!;!=#*(R!&Q!;G+!G;>()!*(R IQ!;G+!AL;GA(!K#!L:G@(=R! 5(!&9!*=(;)R IQ!;G+!*(!;!*#G)$;GR! 5(!&9!Q=((R IQ!;G+!*(!*:K!P(;>R! 5#P!9K=#G@!&9!5(R O#!)(;)!$(G!'&Q(!5(!&9R! O#!9&A>!$(G!L(;'KLR O#!*'&G)!$(G!9&@LKR! SG)!K#!KL(!G(()+!P(;'KLR S!%'(;9:=(!P&KL#:K!'#99R! S!K=(;9:=(!P&KL#:K!9K(;'KL3 $C91,#*$U,#0>"#2

- 181 -

,

.(W&W;'!

&G!&K9!(99(GA(!&9

G#KL&G@!$#=( KL;G!#:=!Q&G)&G@

,(9:9

;QK(=!L;W&G@! '#G@!9K=:@@'()!&G #KL(=!)&=(AK&#G9 ;G)!;K!';9K!

Q&G)&G@!5&$3 CQ&/$F#**1&)

- 182 -

,

F7/V'3('!:*5*'78(;: ]L(G!+#:!A;GaK!Q&@:=(!#:K! PL(KL(=!K#!9&K!;K!5&9!Q((KR!P;'>!&G! ;!$;GG(=!P#=KL+!#Q!5&9!A;''R! 9K;G)!&G!*;KK'(R!#=!=:G!KL(!=;A(! P&KL!)&'&@(GA(R!"#!$%!#$&'!#(!)'#! *+,-!#(!.'%/%!+0(1'!2!2!2 ]L(G!+#:!A;GaK!(W(G!=($($*(=M! OL(!KP(GK+VKP#!AL;=;AK(=&9K&A9!#Q! ;!@##)!P&Q(!#=!L:9*;G)R!KL(! 9(W(G!9K(%9!#Q!;%%(;'!K#!;:KL#=V &K+R!KL(!(&@LK!KL&G@9!K#!)#!PL(G! +#:!;=(!P#==&()R!#=!KL(!G&G(!P;+9! #Q!'#W(R'"#!$%!#$&'!#(!)'#!*+,-!#(!! .'%/%!+0(1'!2!2!2

- 183 -

,

]L(G!+#:!L(;=M!&K!&9!%=(R!$&)R! %#9KR!;R!#=!%;GR!)#GaK!K;>(!KL(! N$;=>RN!&K!&9!NK&$(R!K&$(!;G)!L;'Q! ;!K&$(RN!;G)!+#:!A;GaK!@(K! KL=#:@L!KL(!G(`K!L#:=R'"#!$%!#$&'! #(!)'#!*+,-!#(!.'%/%!+0(1'!2!2!2 ]L(G!+#:!L(;=!K(9K&$#G&(9!#Q! #KL(=9M!=;&9&G@!KL(!)(;)R!%=;+&G@! ;''!G&@LKR!Q;9K&G@!Q#=K+!);+9R!'(;)V &G@!KL#:9;G)9!K#!KL(!6#=)R!;G)! $($#=&l&G@!KL(!(GK&=(!X&*'(R!;G)! +#:!L(;=!&K!KL=#:@L!9#$(#G(! PL#!L;9GaK!)#G(!;G+!#Q!&KR'"#!$%! #$&'!#(!)'#!*+,-!#(!.'%/%!+0(1'!2!2!2

- 184 -

,

]L(G!+#:!L(;=M!L;W(!Q;&KLR!P#=>! L;=)R!=(%(GKR!A#GJ:(=R!@&W(R!9:QV Q(=R!9;A=&Q&A(R!(W;G@('&l(R!$;>(! )&9A&%'(9R!P;&K!#G!5&$R!P;'>!&G! 5&$R!%&A>!:%!+#:=!A=#99R!A';&$! +#:=!%#99(99&#G9R!;G)!%=;+R!;G)! +#:!Q(('!%:''()!KL(G!)&QQ(=(GK!)&V =(AK&#G9!#G!;!=;A>R!"#!$%!#$&'!#(! )'#!*+,-!#(!.'%/%!+0(1'!2!2!2 $

C@1'$O(/

- 185 -

,

5SF0! ;! )=(;$! KL;K! KL(! A(GK=;'&K+!;G)!9:%=($;A+! #Q! ,(9:9!"L=&9K! P&''! *(!KL(!Q#V A:9R! KL(! $;&G9K;+R! ;G)! KL(! %:=9:&K! #Q!(W(=+!"L=&9K&;G! ;G)! (W(=+! AL:=AL3! SG)! KL;K! /#)b9! )(;=!%(#%'(!P&''! G#!'#G@(=!*(! #*9(99()!P&KL!9%&=&K:;'!;G)!=(V '&@&#:9! KL&G@9! K#! KL(! %#&GK! #Q! )&W&9&#G3! X:K! KL;K! KL(&=! #*9(9V 9&#G! ;G)! %:=9:&K! P#:')! *(! ;! %(=9#G^KL(!6#=)!,(9:9!"L=&9K3

I

CU2()<$]1&,(

- 186 -

,

66!KL(! KL&G@9! I!#GA(! KL#:@LK!P(=(!9#!&$V %#=K;GK! L;W(! K:=G()! K#! ):9K3! 1#KL&G@! A;G! A#$V %;=(! P&KL! KL(! :G9%(;>V ;*'(! %=&W&'(@(!#Q! >G#P&G@! "L=&9K!,(9:9!;9!$+!U;9K(=_! IaW(!KL=#PG!&K!;''!;P;+!9#! KL;K!I! A;G!($*=;A(! ,(9:9! ;G)!*(!($*=;A()!*+!5&$3!

A

CG(5,$0"#$L:&*0,#$ c:(2(:"2(*#d

- 187 -

,

OL(=(!&9!G#KL&G@ P#=KL!'&W&G@!Q#=!! *:K!5&$R !;G)!5&9!'#W&G@>&G)G(99! &9!*(KK(=! KL;G!'&Q(3 CI"(2,#*$F6$7:52?#&)

- 188 -

,

S''!P(!G(() ;=(!L(;=K9!KL;K! P&''!G#K!*( 9;K&9Q&() !P&KL!9#$(KL&G@! #=!9#$(#G(!'(99! KL;G!5&$3 CU2()>1*$U2()?1:(?)#

- 189 -

,

!](!$:9K!G(W(=

!;@;&G!;''#P

!!#:=9('W(9!K#! *(!)&9K=;AK()!!!! Q=#$!KL(!

9&$%'&A&K+

!#Q!)(W#K&#G!K#!

"L=&9K!5&$9('Q3! CQ1><$@&/)#2

- 190 -

-

The End cL,0"&5?"$%#$%1,,$$$$$$$$ )#4#2$?#0$0&$0"#$#)-$&+$$$$$ #R(,01)?$F1*$?2#(0)#**6d

- 191 -

! The Author @52?#)$7>"5,[$1*$($I()(-1() $'1**1&)(2/$%"&$"(*$%&2<#1)$A&,141($+&2$&4#2$a&$/#(2*6$ F#$1*$0"#$"5*.()-$&+$($ 2#'(2<(.,#$%1+#;$0"#$+(0"#2$ &+$+14#$.1>5,052(,$>"1,-2#);$$$ ()-$0"#$&.=#>0$&+$$$$$ 5)#R:,(1)(.,#$?2(>#6 h*5'(=&2<&i?'(1,6>&'j

- 192 -