STUDY OF DRUG LICENSING AND FINANCIAL STATUS OF THE DRUG SHOPS IN RURAL AND URBAN AREAS
A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF PHARMACY, STAMFORD UNIVERSITY BANGLADESH IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE DEGREE OF BACHELOR OF PHARMACY (HONS.)
SUBMITTED BY MD. XXXX ID NO: BPH -XXXXXXXX BATCH NO: xx
th
MARCH 200X
THE DEPARTMENT OF PHARMACY STAMFORD UNIVERSITY BANGLADESH
DECLARATION
I do hereby declare that the project report, entitled ―Study of drug licensing and financial status of the drug shops in rural and urban areas‖ presented to the Department of Pharmacy, Stamford University Bangladesh, is the outcome of the investigation performed by me under the supervision of Md. Xxxx, Associate Professor, the Department of Pharmacy, Stamford University Bangladesh. I also declare that no part of this Project Report has been or is being submitted elsewhere for the award of any Degree or Diploma.
Md. Xxxx ID NO: BPH -xxxxxxxxxx (Examinee)
Md. Xxxxxxxxxx Associate professor, Department of Pharmacy Stamford University Bangladesh (Supervisor)
APPROVAL This is to certify that project report on Drug shop titled “Study of drug licensing and financial status of the drug shops in rural and urban areas.” submitted by Md. Xxxx, Enrollment no: BPH: xxxxxxx during the last semester of the B Pharm. program embodies original work done by him and this report submission is a partial fulfillment of the requirements of the Bachelor of Pharmacy in Stamford University Bangladesh.
Signature of the supervisor Name
: Md. Xxxxxxxx
Designation : Associate Professor, Department of Pharmacy University
: STAMFORD UNIVERSITY BANGLADESH
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
We cannot achieve anything worthwhile in the field of technical education unless or until the theoretical education acquired in the classroom is effectively wedded to its practical approach that is taking place in the modern industries and research institutes or in the area of product selling of those industries. It gives me a great pleasure to have an opportunity to acknowledge and to express gratitude to those who were associated with my Project. Constraints are the best source of inspiration and opportunity to explore us. Communication is the key towards all the responsibilities and demands of time, travel, work in competitive work. It is plus to have effective, secures communication. I am grateful to all personalities for stimulating and thought provoking during the entire project. For the successful completion of this project, I feel deep senses of gratitude to Md. Xxxxxxxxx, Associate Professor, my project supervisor, for motivating and inspiring to achieve the best and providing opportunity to explore for gathering knowledge and information. At last I would again like to express my sincere thanks to those proprietors of those drug shops, drug sellers and other medical representative for their friendly guidance during the entire stretch of this report. Every new step I took was due to their persistent enthusiastic backing and I acknowledge that with a deep sense of gratitude.
TABLE OF CONTENTS MAIN HEADINGS
PAGENO.
Chapter 1 1.1) Introduction and Background…………………………………………………... 1.2) Purpose and importance of this survey…………………………………………. 1.3) Drugs act, Criteria and importance of having Drug Selling License…………... 1.4) Importance and Role of registered Pharmacist in community pharmacy……….
1 2 2 5
1.5) Bad effect of unavailability of having Drug Selling License and Role of registered Pharmacist in drug shops……………………………………………..
6
2.1) Questionnaire and Limitations………………………………………………….
7
Chapter 2 2.2) Picture of surveyed rural area………………………………………………….. 2.3) Data of rural areas………………………………………………………………
8 11
2.4) List of the name of the companies according to their selling products in those surveyed rural area….........…………………………………………………….. 2.5) Picture of surveyed urban area………………………………………………….
21
2.6) Data of Urban areas…………………………………………………………….
22 24
3.1) Table, graph and findings on the Drug selling license in drug shops ………….
34
Chapter 3 3.2) Table, graph and findings on available registered Pharmacist in drug shops….. 3.3) Table, graph and findings on the selling per month in drug shops………..…... 3.4) Table, graph and findings on the present investment in drug shops………..…. 3.5) Table, graph and findings on MPO visits the drug shops……………………… 3.6) Table, graph and findings on most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer……….....
36 41 43 45
3.7) Table, graph and findings on most dispensed drug as Pain Killer……...………
47 48
4.1) Results..................................................................................................................
49
Chapter 4 4.2) Conclusion…………………………………………………............................... 4.3) Reference.............................................................................................................
50 50
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this survey was to provide information about the status of the drug shops according to their having the drug selling license, financial status, most dispensed drugs and the number of MPOs that visits to the drug shops in rural and urban area. Here I tried to fetch out the data and information about the availability of Pharmacist, having drug selling license, the present investment, sales per month, most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer and as Pain Killer and the number of MPOs that come to visit from various drug company in to the drug shops in the both rural and urban areas. In Bangladesh, the government healthcare system remains a very minor source of health care for rural households. The availability of registered physicians and pharmacists is scarce in our country, and the people, the majority of whom are underweight as indicated by body mass index measurement; have to depend on pharmacy salespersons, quacks and herbal or spiritual healers. Unlike most develop countries, almost every pharmacy salesperson illegally recommends and sells prescription medicines. In addition, there are also unqualified village 'doctors' who do not own a pharmacy shop but provide written prescriptions. However, the treatments provided by these village 'doctors' remain open to question, with instances of maltreatment or inadequate treatment. The treatments are mostly symptomatic and polypharmacy is common, with antibiotics and vitamins prescribed widely. In this project I, especially, tried to highlight that there are very insufficient pharmacist are involved in our community pharmacy and due to that reason of maltreatment or irrational drug use is going on and there is a great prospect for the pharmacist in community pharmacy to serve the people and for their job.
Chapter 1
1.1) Introduction and Background: Doing research is an opportunity to the students to express their ideas, concepts and opinions after research. In a developing country like Bangladesh with 120 million people and limited financial resources in the health sector, the rational treatment of most common diseases is essential. 85% of the population lives in rural communities; poor social economic conditions, demographic structure, system of sanitation, water supply and food are the reasons for the common prevailing diseases. The concept of essential drugs in Bangladesh was introduced in 1982 after the implementation of the national drug policy and drug ordinance (Drug Control Ordinance, 1982). The impact of the national drug policy on actual drug use with regard to disease patterns and drug utilization patterns, compounding, dispensing and consumption, etc. have not been properly assessed either at macro or micro levels. Similarly, no comprehensive study has been conducted to assess the extent of rational prescribing and dispensing, except a few works which were carried out on these aspects at micro level. Inappropriate drug use has been identified as an important health and economic problems in primary health care and such prescribers should explore practical ways to promote rational drug use. According to the Drugs (Control) Ordinance 1982 which controls the manufacture, import, distribution, and sale of drugs in Bangladesh it is said in section (viii) that no person, being a retailer, is allowed to sell any drug without the personal supervision of a pharmacist registered in any Register of the Pharmacy Council of Bangladesh. But irrational and inappropriate prescribing is observed in both graduate and non-graduate medical prescribers in both rural and urban areas in Bangladesh and most of the time the drugs are dispensing to the patients without the direct supervision of any registered pharmacist. On the other hand the many people have their own drug shops which are not licensed for selling drugs and from those drug shops the less quality and irrational drug dispensing is going on everyday in absence of a proper guidance of a qualified registered pharmacist. So it is required to have a registered pharmacist in every licensed drug shop but unfortunately the ratio of qualified registered pharmacist in even licensed shop is very poor. It is happening all most every day in many drug shops that wrong and irrational drug dispensing in going on, especially, in rural areas where a lot of MPOs visit to the licensed and non licensed drug shops and try to promote their low quality of drug products and increasing the selling of those low quality products of different little companies around the whole country. Considering those common problem I have done a survey and project report on drug shops in both rural and urban areas under a constant supervision of my honorable project supervisor to fetch out the actual data and picture of those drug shops. I had to explore in the fields and drug shops and I had to collect the data on some specific questions. Those questions was asked by myself to the drug sellers or to the proprietor of the drug shops in both rural and urban area to get the actual picture of the percent of licensed drug shops, community pharmacist, approximate sales per month and present investment in their drug shops, number of MPOs visits to their drug
shops and the most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer and as Pain Killer and the age of their drug shops. 1.2) Purpose and importance of this survey: This Survey has been done to get know the actual current conditions of the drug shops in both rural and urban areas where irrational drug dispensing is going on every day in absence of qualified registered pharmacist which causing many bad and sometimes adverse effect to the patient by the community pharmacy. 1.3) Drugs act, Criteria and Importance of having Drug Selling License: Grant of drugs selling licenses: Food and Drug Administration, Grants Selling Licenses for Drugs according to the provisions of Drugs and Cosmetics Act-1940. For the sale of Allopathic, Homeopathic drugs in form 20, 21, 20B, 21B, 20A, 21A, 20C, 20D, 20F, 20G, 20BB, 21BB. For the sale of Ayurvedic Drugs and Cosmetics no sale license is required.
The Requirements of Sales premises are as follows: Minimum carpet area:• For Retail sale - 10 square meter • For Wholesale - 10 square meter • For Retail - Wholesale - 15 square meter
Storage facilities: Adequate storage facilities including cupboards with glass doors, racks refrigerator and UPS are required. Procedure to obtain Drug Selling license (Fresh): Stage 1: Application for grant of Selling License The applicant has to make application in the requisite form viz 19, 19A, 19B, 19AA details of.
Forms and pay: Necessary fees as given in fee chart
Documents to be attached along with the application form: • Requisite Application Form. • Receipt for the fees paid or challan, as the case may be or their attested copies. • Layout plan of selling premises in 3 copies. • Documents viz. rent receipt, purchase documents or its attested copies showing lawful possession of the premises. • Documents relating to the constitution of the firm viz. Partnership-deed, memorandum and article of association etc. • Full particulars of the competent technical staff /registered persons along with copies of their educational qualification, experience and registration certificates. • Full name of the proprietor or the partners, as the case may be shall be provided in the application. In Case of private or public limited concerns, full name of the Directors who sign the application and the authorized signatory, if any, shall be provided in the application. • Documents for the purchase of Refrigerator/Deep freezer (For Vaccines / Sera).
Stage 2: Inspection The application is scrutinized and premises inspected.
Stage 3: Grant of License If all conditions as prescribed by the act are complied license is granted.
Procedure to Renew Drug selling license Licenses in Forms 20, 21, 20B, 21B, 20A, 21A, 20C, 20D, 20F, 20G, 20BB, 21BB be renewed.
Stage 1: Application for renewal of Drug Selling License The applicant has to make application in the requisite form19, 19A, 19B, 19AA and pay necessary fees as given in fee chart The mode of payment of fees is same as fresh license.
Documents to be enclosed along with application of renewal of license:• Copy of cash receipt or challan for payment of fees. • Xerox copy of License /Previous renewal certificate. • Documents viz. rent receipt, purchase documents or its attested copies showing lawful possession of the premises. • Full particulars of the competent technical staff /registered persons along with copies of their educational qualification, experience and registration certificates. Stage 2: Inspection The application is scrutinized and premises inspected . Stage 3: Grant of License If all conditions as prescribed by the act are complied license is granted. So drug shops have to be licensed according to the drugs act to maintain rational use of drugs.
1.4) Importance and Role of registered Pharmacist in community pharmacy: Pharmacist: Pharmacists are health professionals who practice the art and science of pharmacy. Qualifications and registration for the Pharmacists: The requirements of pharmacy education, pharmacist licenser and post-graduate continuing education vary from country to country and between regions/localities within countries. In most countries, prospective pharmacists study pharmacy at a pharmacy school or related institution. Upon graduation, they are licensed either nationally or by region to dispense medication of various types in the settings for which they have been trained. Role of the Pharmacists in Community pharmacy: A pharmacy is the place where most pharmacists practice the profession of pharmacy. It is the community pharmacy where the dichotomy of the profession exists—health professionals who are also retailers.
Picture 1: The pharmacist’s role is to dispense drug according to the Doctor’s prescription. Community pharmacies usually consist of a retail storefront with a dispensary where medications are stored and dispensed. The dispensary is subject to pharmacy legislation; with requirements for storage conditions, compulsory texts, equipment, etc., specified in legislation. Where it was once the case that pharmacists stayed within the dispensary compounding/dispensing medications; there has been an increasing trend towards the use of trained pharmacy technicians while the pharmacist spends more time communicating with patients. All pharmacies are required to have a pharmacist on-duty at all times when open. They also play roles as a community pharmacist are those:
Nutrition Counseling
Decreased medication errors
Women Welfare-Pregnancy and Infant Care
Rational Use of Drugs
Increased patient compliance in medication regime
Better chronic disease state management
Lessening the cost of prescription drug insurance
Sexually Transmitted Diseases-AIDS
Alcohols, Drug Abuse and Smoking Cessation
Family Planning
Individualization of Drug Therapy
Fostering strong pharmacist-patient relationships
1.5) Bad effect of unavailability of having Drug Selling License and Role of registered Pharmacist in drug shops: Poor and irrational prescribing are frequently done and wrong treatment happen mostly in absence of a qualified registered pharmacist from the both licensed and non licensed drug shops. The non graduate drug seller can prescribe wrong drug, which is illegal, from the non licensed drug shops and can be responsible for the bad or adverse happen frequently to the patient. Those are like:
Over use of antibiotics, metronidazoles and anti diarrhoeals; Indiscriminate use of injections; Prescribing of tab iron and vitamin B complexes randomly; and Inappropriate dosages and duration of antibiotics. Inappropriate dispensing of drug
Key reasons for this include:
Inadequate education and training of prescribers; Misleading promotional activities by pharmaceutical companies; Uncertain diagnosis; Patients desire; Prescribers relying on their clinical experiences; Irrational prescribing by peers; Lack of monitoring system.
Chapter 2 2.1) Questionnaire: Several questions had been asked to them and those are: Q1. What are the most dispensed drugs as general Pain Killer in your shop? Say two or three brand or group name. Q2. What are the most dispensed drugs for Gastric Ulcer in your shop? Say two or three brand or group name. Q3. How many MPO or Medical Representative visit to your shop? From how many companies? Q4. What is the age of your drug shop? Q5. What is the present or current investment in your shop? Q6. What is the amount of average sale per month in your shop? Q7. Do you have Drug selling License for this drug shop? Q8. Is there any registered pharmacist in your drug shop? Q9. What is the educational qualification of the drug dispenser or seller in your drug shop? Object of those above question:
To find out the most dispensed drug as pain killer and for Gastric ulcer. To find out the number of MPOs come from different companies. To find out the financial status of the drug shop i.e. the investment and sales. And the most important things are to find out the percent of licensed and non licensed drug shop and also the percent of registered pharmacist in drug shops in both rural and urban surveyed areas.
Limitation:
Few persons did not answer of some questions. Few persons did not give accurate answer or information. The data obtained from some specific areas does not represent the exact or the total accurate picture of the whole country.
2.2) Picture of surveyed rural area:
Picture 2: Map of Ghatail Upazila.
Picture 3: One of surveyed drug shop.
Picture of surveyed rural area:
Picture 4: Aerial View of the survey area – GHATAIL. Page | 9
Picture 5: Aerial View of the survey area – SONARGAON. Page | 10
2.3) Data of rural areas: Area Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
1. Ghatail
Morshed Drug House
Flexi (Acelofenac)
Seclo (Omeprazol)
25 MPO
24y
8 lakh.
3 lakh.
YES
LMAF
2. Ghatail
Arup Drug House
Acelofenac
Ranitidine
25 MPO
8y
10 lakh.
3 lakh.
YES
No
3. Ghatail
Reba Medical Hall
Clofenac
Cosec (Omeprazol)
25 MPO
10y
8 lakh.
3 lakh.
YES
LMAF
4. Ghatail
Maya Medical Hall
Mervan (Acelofenac)
Neotack (Ranitidine)
25 MPO
30y
12 lakh
6.6 lakh.
YES
Yes
5. Ghatail
Kazi Pharmacy
Indoxyl (Indomethacin)
Normacid (Ranitidine)
50 MPO
6m
2 lakh.
0.8 lakh.
YES
No
6. Ghatail
Shorna Medical
Isocloamax, Move.
Neotack (Ranitidine)
25 MPO
6y
Not known
2.1 lakh.
YES
No
Page | 11
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
7. Ghatail
Shefa Pharmacy
Clofenac
Losectil (Omeprazol)
10 MPO
7y
3 lakh.
0.6 lakh
YES
No
8. Ghatail
Takwa Medical Hall
Clofenac
Seclo (Omeprazol)
25 MPO
4y
2 lakh.
1.2 lakh.
YES
No
9. Ghatail
Selim Pharmacy
Clofenac, Ciprocin (Ciprofloxacin)
Losectil (Omeprazol)
20 MPO
37y
0.5 lakh.
0.45 lakh.
YES
Yes
10. Ghatail
Mattri Medical Hall
Acelofenac, Etorix (Etoricoxib).
Omeprazol
16 MPO
26y
2 lakh.
1 lakh.
YES
Yes
11. Ghatail
Rahaman A Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
25 MPO
20y
3 lakh.
1.5 lakh.
YES
Yes
12. Ghatail
M/S Arif Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine, Omeprazol.
16 MPO
30y
0.5 lakh.
0.3 lakh.
YES
Yes
Page | 12
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
13. Ghatail
Siddiq Pharmacy
Paracetamol, Ace Plus.
Neotack (Ranitidine)
25 MPO
21y
Not known
0.36 lakh.
YES
Yes
14. Ghatail
Rahaman Pharmacy
Acelofenac
Ranitidine, Omeprazol.
10 MPO
22y
3 lakh.
0.6 lakh.
YES
Yes
15. Ghatail
Amena Pharmacy
Flexi (Acelofenac)
Neotack (Ranitidine)
25 MPO
7y
Not known
0.6 lakh.
YES
No
16. Ghatail
M/S Masud Medical Hall
Napa (Paracetamol).
Antacid, Ranitidine.
20 MPO
12y
0.5 lakh.
0.3 lakh.
YES
Yes
17. Ghatail
Sujit Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium, Acelofenac.
Antacid Plus, Ranitidine.
25 MPO
8y
0.6 lakh.
0.3 lakh.
YES
No
18. Ghatail
Dipta Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium, Acelofenac.
Ranitidine
20 MPO
11y
0.2 lakh.
0.18 lakh.
YES
Yes
Page | 13
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
19. Ghatail
Khandaker Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
25 MPO
17y
0.5 lakh.
0.45 lakh.
YES
Yes
20. Ghatail
Shobuj Medical Hall
Clofenac
Ranitidine
25 MPO
4y
0.5 lakh.
0.15 lakh.
YES
No
21. Ghatail
Jewel Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Neotack (Ranitidine), Neoceptin (Ranitidine).
20 MPO
12y
0.65 lakh.
0.6 lakh.
YES
No
22. Ghatail
Tanmoy Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
80 MPO
3y
1 lakh.
0.75 lakh
YES
Yes
23. Ghatail
Panna Medical Hall
Corax
Seclo (Omeprazol), Neotack (Ranitidine).
25 MPO
2y
15 lakh.
2.4 lakh.
YES
Yes
24. Ghatail
Faisal Medical Hall
Etorix (Etoricoxib)
Losectil (Omeprazol)
50 MPO
10y
1 lakh.
0.6 lakh.
YES
No
Page | 14
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
25. Ghatail
Kausiq Pharmacy
Clofenac
Antacid Plus, Seclo (Omeprazol).
25 MPO
2y
1.5 lakh.
0.6 lakh.
YES
Yes
26. Ghatail
Maa Medical Hall
Acelofenac. Paracetamol, Ace Plus.
Antacid, Ranitidine.
25 MPO
4y
1 lakh,
0.45 lakh.
YES
Yes
27. Ghatail
Hamdard Labratories.*
__
__
No Other MPOs
11m
15 lakh.
6 lakh.
YES
Yes
28. Ghatail
Payel Medical Hall
Flexi (Acelofenac)
Neotack (Ranitidine)
30 MPO
__
4 lakh.
2.4 lakh.
YES
Yes
29. Ghatail
Khan Popular Pharmacy
Acelofenac, DiclofenacSodium.
Ranitidine
20 MPO
3 lakh.
0.36 lakh.
YES
Yes
30. Ghatail
Unique Pharmacy
Acelofenac
Ranitidine
2 lakh.
0.45 lakh.
YES
No
__
20 MPO
__
Page | 15
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
31. Porabari
Doctor’s Medical Hall
Flexi (Acelofenac)
Apex (Ranitidine)
12 MPO
__
1 lakh.
0.25 lakh.
YES
Yes
32. Porabari
G K Pharmacy
Acelofenac
Ranitidine
12 MPO
__
2 lakh.
0.6 lakh.
YES
No
33. Chandpur Sadar.
Milon Pharmacy
Paracetamol
Antacid Plus
20 MPO
8y
7lakh
3 lakh
Yes
No
34. Chandpur Sadar
Gazi Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
40 MPO
30y
16 lakh.
6 lakh.
Yes
C grade Registered Pharmacist
35. Chandpur Sadar
Metro Pharmacy
Paracetamol
Antacid Plus
25 MPO
3y
Yes ___
___
C grade Registered Pharmacist
36. Panam City, Sonargoan
Addarsha Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
1.2 lakh
0.9 lakh
Yes
No
Ranitidine
15 MPO
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
20y
Page | 16
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
37. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Seba Medical Hall
Paracetamol Acelofenac
Antacid Plus Ranitidine
20 MPO
11y
0.5 lakh
1.2 lakh
Yes
C grade Pharmacist
38. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Mousumi Drug House
Paracetamol + Neotack Wrong!
Omeprazol
30 MPO
1y6m
2.5 lakh
0.75 lakh
No
No
39. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Khandoker Medical centre
Acelofenac
Ranitidine
20 MPO
3y
2.5 lakh
0.9 lakh
Yes
C grade Pharmacist
40. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Islamia Pharmacy
Etoricoxib DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Omeprazol
25 MPO
20y
0.5 lakh
0.45 lakh
Yes
C grade Pharmacist
41. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Janata Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Omeprazol Antacid plus (Pantoprazol –for female)
25 MPO
3y6m
1 lakh
0.45 lakh
Yes
No
42. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Sirin Pharmacy
Paracetamol
Ranitidine Omeprazol Pantoprazol
30 MPO
12y
4 lakh.
3.6 lakh
Yes
LMAF
Page | 17
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
43. Progoti Medical Mogra Hall Para, Sonargoan
No drug without prescription
Ranitidine
15 MPO
20y
44. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Ma Pharmacy
Paracetamol Acelofenac
Antacid Plus Omeprazol
45 MPO
45. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Bhuyan Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
46. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Mamun Pharmacy
No drug without prescription
47. Sawkat Medical Mogra Centre Para, Sonargoan 48. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Nupur Drug House
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
8 lakh
9 lakh
Yes
DMF
16y
6 lakh
4.5 lakh
Yes
C grade Pharmacist
30 MPO
5y
6 lakh
3 lakh
Yes
C grade Pharmacist
Ranitidine
25 MPO
3y
4 lakh
3 lakh
Yes
No
Paracetamol + Caffeine
Pantoprazol
14 MPO
2y6m
3 lakh
No
No
No drug without prescription
No drug without prescription
Yes
LMAF
-----
35 MPO
2y6m -------
Page | 18
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
49. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Sonargoan Pharmacy
Bad Practice
Ranitidine
60 MPO
50y
18 lakh
7.5 lakh
Yes
DMF
50. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Habib Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium Acelofenac
Ranitidine Omeprazol
70 MPO
10y
1.5 lakh
1.2 lakh
Yes
LMAF
51. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Modern Medicine Hall
Paracetamol
Antacid Plus
50 MPO
3y6m
1.5 lakh
1.5 lakh
Yes
LMAF
52. Sufia Pharmacy Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Paracetamol
Antacid Plus
20 MPO
4y
Yes
No
-----
------
53. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Japani Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Antacid Plus Ranitidine
30 MPO
8m
6 lakh
1.2 lakh
Yes
LMAF
54. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Eva Drug House
Paracetamol
Ranitidine
20 MPO
18y
3 lakh
0.9 lakh
Yes
B grade Pharmacist
Page | 19
Area
Name of the Most Drug Dispensary dispensed drug as Pain Killer
55. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Ali Drug House
56. Mogra Para, Sonargoan
Limon Pharmacy
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Paracetamol DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
25 MPO
Paracetamol
Ranitidine
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
10y
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
0.9 lakh
Yes
Yes
0.75 lakh
Yes
Yes
-----
25 MPO
8y ----
Page | 20
2.4) List of the name of the companies according to their products in those surveyed rural area: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
Square Pharmaceuticals Ltd. ACI Limited Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd. The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Industry Lt Novartis (Bangladesh) Ltd. Novo Healthcare and Pharma Ltd. Nuvista Pharma Ltd. Opsonin Pharma Ltd. Orion Infusion Ltd. Pacific Pharmaceuticals Peoples Pharma Ltd. Incepta Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Jayson Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Navana Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Glaxosmithkline Bangladesh Ltd. The Acme Laboratories Ltd. Globe Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Somatec Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Desh Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Apollo Pharmaceuticals Drug International Ltd. Eskayef Bangladesh Ltd. Gaco Pharmaceuticals Apex Pharma Ltd. Aristopharma Ltd. Asiatic Laboratories Ltd. Beacon Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Nipa Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Hudson Pharmaceuticals Ltd.
31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60.
Jalalabad Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Janata Health care Kapricorn Enterprise Ltd. Kumudini Pharma Ltd. Libra Infusions Ltd. Popular Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Proteety Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Rangs Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Rasa Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Chemist Laboratories Ltd. City Overseas Ltd. Doctor’s Chemical Works Ltd. General Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Gonoshasthaya Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Hamdard Laboratories Bangladesh Ultra Pharma Ltd. Unimed & Unihealth Manufacturers Ltd. Zenith Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Ziska Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Biopharma Laboratories Ltd. Medicon Laboratories Ltd. Medimet Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Ambee Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Amico Laboratories Ltd. A.H Janakalyan Pharmaceuticals Alco Pharma Ltd. Belsen Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Skylab Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Pharmaco International Ltd.
61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74.
Pharmadesh Laboratories Ltd. Chemico Laboratories Ltd. Reckitt Benckiser Ltd. Shamsulalamin Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Shuvro Ltd. Silva Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Healthcare Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Modern Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Supreme Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Bristol Pharma Ltd. Central Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Renata Ltd. Rephco Laboratories Ltd. Sanofi Aventis
Page | 21
2.5) Picture of surveyed urban area:
Picture 6: Aerial View of the survey area – Merul and South Badda. Page | 22
Picture 7: Aerial View of the survey area – East and Middle Badda. Page | 23
2.6) Data of urban areas: Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
1. South Badda
Talukder Medical Hall
----
Ranitidine
20 MPO
2. South Badda
Jibon Drug House
Ace Plus Etoricoxib
Neotack (Ranitidine) Seclo (Omeprazol)
5 MPO
3. South Badda
Ali Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Neotack (Ranitidine)
4. South Badda
Badda Medical Hal
Napa Acelofenac
5. South Badda
Dwan Medical Hall
6. South Badda
Sima Medical Hall
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
14y
License
Degree of the seller
Yes
No
----
----
29y
3 lakh
1.8 lakh
Yes
Yes
40 MPO
20y
1.5 lakh
1.5 lakh
Yes
Registered Pharmacist (C)
Ranitidine Seclo (Omeprazol)
3 MPO
20y
3 lakh
1.5 lakh
No
No
Napa Paracetamol DiclofenacSodium
Neotack (Ranitidine) Antacid Plus
8 MPO
1y
4 lakh
1.6 lakh
No
No
Napa Extra DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Antacid Plus
Yes
-----
0.75 lakh
Registered Pharmacist (C)
30y ___
Page | 24
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
7. South Badda
Islam Drug House
Depend Upon Condition
Depend Upon Condition
12 MPO
8. South Badda
Krisna Nursing Hall
No drug without prescription
3MPO
9. South Badda
Bismillah Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
10. South Badda
Nir Dental and Medical Care
Acelofenac
Depend Upon Condition
11. South Badda
Lutfun Medical Hall
Paracetamol
Ranitidine
12. Middle Badda
Nahar Drug House
DiclofenacSodium
No drug without prescription
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
10y
2 lakh
License
Degree of the seller
Yes
Registered Pharmacist (B)
Yes
Yes
___
____
____
___
2 MPO
4y
Secret
0.6 lakh
Yes
No
5 MPO
5y
3 lakh
1.8 lakh
Yes
LMAF
Yes
LMAF
Yes
LMAF
8y ___
Ranitidine
Sales per month
5 MPO
7y
___
___
7 lakh
2.1 lakh
Page | 25
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
13. Middle Badda
Cosmic Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
10 MPO
15y
3 lakh
14. Middle Badda
Al-Amin Pharmacy
Paracetamol
Ranitidine
4 MPO
16y
1.5 lakh
15. Middle Badda
Monowara Drugs
DiclofenacSodium
Omeprazol
16. Middle Badda
Apan Medical Hall
Paracetamol + Antacid Wrong!
Antacid Plus Neotack (Ranitidine)
17. Middle Badda
Ma Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Omeprazol
18. DIT, Middle Badda
Medicine Plus
DiclofenacSodium
Omeprazol
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
1.8 lakh
Yes
LMAF
Yes
Registered Pharmacist (B)
Yea
BRMA
-----
4 MPO
15 MPO
1y6m ___
___
12y
2 lakh
1.2 lakh
Yes
LMAF
6y
2 lakh
0.6 lakh
Yes
No
6m
3 lakh
1.5 lakh No
No
------
4 MPO
Page | 26
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
19. DIT, Middle Badda
Neha Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Depend on condition
10 MPO
Paracetamol DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Omeprazol
Ranitidine
20. DIT, Middle Badda
Golden Pharmacy
21. DIT, Middle Badda
S.S Mediacal Hall
Paracetamol + caffeine
22. Middle Badda
Gourinodi Medical Hall
Paracetamol
23. Middle Badda
M.S Medical
DiclofenacSodium Acelofenac
24. Middle Badda
Asim Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium Paracetamol
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
4y
Sales per month
3 lakh
License
Degree of the seller
Yes
LMAF
Yes
LMAF
___
3y ___
___
____ 2 MPO
7y
3 lakh
1.8 lakh
Yes
Yes
No Answer
7y
3 lakh
0.9 lakh
Yes
LMAF
Ranitidine Antacid
10 MPO
5y
No
LMAF
___
0.12 lakh
Antacid Plus
10 MPO
2.5lakh
0.6 lakh
Yes
LMAF
No Answer
1y
Page | 27
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
25. East Badda
Tareq Medical Corner
DiclofenacSodium
Antacid Plus Ranitidine Omeprazol
7 MPO
5y
3 lakh
1.3 lakh
Yes
Yes
26. East Badda
Joy Dev Medical Hall
Acelofenac Paracetamol
Seclo (Omeprazol)
15 MPO
12y
1.5 lakh
Yes
Yes
27. East Badda
Mahabub Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
6 MPO
8m
4 lakh
1.6 lakh
Yes
No
28. East Badda
Hamim Clinic
Acelofenac DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Omeprazol
8 MPO
8m
15 lakh
6 lakh
No
No
29. East Badda
Siam Pharmacy
Paracetamol
Ranitidine Antacid Plus
10 MPO
5y
2 lakh
0.6 lakh
Yes
Yes
30. East Badda
ICL Health Care
Paracetamol Aceclofenac Ibuprofen
Ranitidine
10 MPO
1y
3 lakh
1.8 lakh
Yes
No
----
Page | 28
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
31. East Badda
Amena Pharmacy
Acelofenac
Losectil (Omeprazol)
3 MPO
2y
4 lakh
1.5 lakh
Yes
No
32. East Badda
Jahanara Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
8 MPO
7y
15 lakh
6 lakh
Yes
Yes
33. East Badda
Sonar Bangla Medical Corner
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
4 MPO
3y
4 lakh
1.5 lakh
No
No
34. East Badda
Barisal Pharmacy
Paracetamol Cefenal DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Omeprazol
15 MPO
7y
10 lakh
Yes
Yes
35. East Badda
Annanda Mediacal Certre
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
15 MPO
10y
15 lakh
7 lakh
Yes
36. East Badda
Ma Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium Paracetamol + Caffeine
Ranitidine Omeprazol Esomeprazole
25 MPO
1y
4 lakh
1.6 lakh
Yes
____
LMAF
LMAF
Page | 29
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
37. East Badda
Rahaman Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium Mephenamic Acid
Ranitidine Omeprazol
30 MPO
39y
1.5 lakh
0.75 lakh
Yes
C grade Registered Pharmacist
38. East Badda
Ashik Pharmacy
Clofenac DiclofenacSodium Ketefen
Neotack (Ranitidine)
6 MPO
3y
3 lakh
1.4 lakh
Yes
LMAF
39. East Badda
Doctor’s Pharmacy
Paracetamol DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Omeprazol
5 MPO
4y
6 lakh
3.5 lakh
No
No
40. East Badda
Mollah Pharmacy
No drug without prescription
No drug without prescription
2 MPO
1.5y
0.2 lakh
Yes
LMAF
41. East Badda
Kazi Pharmacy
DiclofenacSodium Paracetamol Acelofenac
Ranitidine Omeprazol
20 MPO
7y
4 lakh
1.2 lakh
Yes
LMAF
42. East Badda
Desh Medical Centre
Ibuprofen DiclofenacSodium
Neotack (Ranitidine)
10 MPO
5y
4 lakh
1.6 lakh
Yes
Yes
___
Page | 30
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer Neotack (Ranitidine)
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
43. East Badda
Mukta Medicine Corner
DiclofenacSodium Paracetamol
44. East Badda
Vhuiyan Pharmacy
45. East Badda
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Paracetamol Acelofenac
Ranitidine Omeprazol
30 MPO
20y
Mokta Pharmacy
Clofenac DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
12 MPO
20y
46. East Badda
Tanvir Drug House
Paracetamol
Ranitidine
16 MPO
47. East Badda
Biplab Health Care
Acelofenac DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Omeprazol Esoprajol
48. East Badda
Taslima Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium with Amoxicillin
Ranitidine
13m
Sales per month
1.5 lakh
___
License
Degree of the seller
Yes
LMAF
Yes
C grade Registered Pharmacist
___
4 lakh
1.5 lakh
Permission of Permission of Drug Drug Administration Administration
___
___
1y
1.5 lakh
0.6 lakh
No
LMAF
20 MPO
6y
2.5 lakh
1.2 lakh
No
LMAF
12 MPO
1y
4 lakh
1.6 lakh
No
LMAF
Page | 31
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
49. East Badda
Bismillah Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine
15 MPO
3y
3 lakh
0.45 lakh
Yes
LMAF
50. East Badda
Shakil Pharmacy
Napa Paracetamol DiclofenacSodium
Ranitidine Omeprazol Pantoprazol
14 MPO
10y
6 lakh
3 lakh
No
LMAF
51. Merul Badda
Matri Sheba Medical Hall
DiclofenacSodium
Antacid Plus Ranitidine
10 MPO
7
4 lakh
1.5 lakh
Yes
LMAF
52. Merul Badda
Manikgoan Medical Hall
Napa Extra
Ranitidine
7 MPO
6
4 lakh
1.8 lakh
Yes
No
53. Merul Badda
Vojon Mediacal Hall
Ace Napa Extra Ibuprofen Etoricoxib
Ranitidine
15 MPO
1y6m
3 lakh
1.8 lakh
Yes
LMAF
54. Merul Badda
Rajit Medical Hall
Ranitidine
12 MPO
2y6m
3 lakh
1.5 lakh
No
Yes
___
Page | 32
Area
Name of the Drug Dispensary
Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer
Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer
Number of MPOs that came to the Dispensary
Age of the Present Dispensary Investment
55. Merul Badda
Sheba Pharmacy
Paracetamol Diclofenac
Antacid Plus Ranitidine
15 MPO
7y
56. Merul Badda
Noyon Pharmacy
Diclofenac
Ranitidine
8 MPO
5y
Sales per month
License
Degree of the seller
6 lakh
2 lakh
Yes
Yes
2.5 lakh
1.5 lakh
Yes
No
Page | 33
Chapter 3 3.1) Table, graph and findings on the Drug selling license in drug shops: Table 1: Rural Areas
Number of drug shops
Number of Licensed drug shops
Number of Non-Licensed drug shops
Ghatail, Tangail.
32
32
0
Sonargaon, Narayangang. Chandpur sadar
21
19
2
3
2
1
Total
56
53
3
Table 1: Those estimated data in this table has been derived after surveying 56 drug shops in the rural areas (Ghatail, Sonargaon and Chandpur sadar). Here the table is representing the comparative values of the number of licensed and non licensed drug shops. Here we got 53 drug shops have drug selling license and 3 are non-licensed among 56 the of surveyed drug shops.
5%
Licensed Non-Licensed
95%
Figure 1 Figure 1: This pie-chart is representing the ratio of licensed and non-Licensed drug shops in those rural areas (Ghatail, Sonargaon and Chandpur sadar). Here we found that 95% and 5% drug shops are licensed and non-licensed respectively. Findings 1: There are 5% drug-shops are non-licensed but there should not have any drug shop
without drug selling license according to the drugs acts. Page | 34
Table 2: Urban Areas
Badda, Dhaka.
Number of drug shops
Number of Licensed drug shops
Number of Non-Licensed drug shops
56
43
13
Table 2: Those estimated data in this table has been derived after surveying 56 drug shops in the urban areas (Badda). Here the table is representing the comparative values of the number of licensed and non licensed drug shops. Here we got 43 drug shops have drug selling license and13 are non-licensed among the 56 of surveyed drug shops.
23% Licensed Non-Licensed 77%
Figure 2 Figure 2: This pie-chart is representing the ratio of licensed and non-Licensed drug shops in the urban area (Badda). Here we found that 77% and 23% drug shops are licensed and non-licensed respectively. Findings 2: There are 23% drug-shops are non licensed but there should not have any drug shop without drug selling license according to the drugs acts and the percent of licensed drug shop is less in urban area than rural area.
Page | 35
Ratio of licensed drug shop in rural and urban area: Rural
53
Urban
43
Total
56
Figure 3
Figure 3: This Bar-Chart is representing the total comparative ratio of licensed drug shop in urban and rural areas. Total 120 shops were surveyed, 56 shops in rural and another 56 shops in urban areas. The above Bar-Chart is showing the ratio of Total shop : Shops in urban areas: Shops in rural area is equal to 56 : 43 : 53 i.e. 77% and 95% (see figure 2 and 1) shops are licensed in urban and rural area respectively in those surveyed areas.
3.2) Table, graph and findings on available registered Pharmacist in drug shops: Table 3: Rural Areas
Number of drug shops
Number of Pharmacist
Number of LMAF diploma holder
Do not have required Degree
Ghatail, Tangail.
32
5
5
11
Sonargaon, Narayangang. Chandpur sadar
21
0
5
1
3
2
0
27
Total
56
7
10
39
Table 3: Those estimated data in this table has been derived after surveying 56 drug shops in the
rural areas (Ghatail, Sonargaon and Chandpur sadar). Here the table is representing the comparative values of the number of pharmacist, the number of LMAF diploma holder and do not have required degree in those drug shops. Here we got only 7 pharmacists. Also 10 LMAF diploma holders and 39 persons have no required degree for drug selling. Page | 36
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Series 1
Total Shop
Pharmacist
LMAF
Do not have required degree
56
7
10
39
Figure 4 Figure 4: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the data of registered pharmacist, LMAF diploma holder and do not have required degree in rural areas according to the table-3 explained in above.
11%
Pharmacist Total shop
89%
Figure 5 Figure 5: This pie chart is representing the ratio of the registered pharmacists and total shops in those rural areas. Here the ratio has found as the Total shop : Pharmacist is equal to 89 : 11. Findings 3: Very poor number of pharmacists is available in those rural areas which is a serious ignoring of the drug acts. Page | 37
Table 4: Urban Areas
Badda
Number of drug shops Number of Pharmacist
Number of LMAF diploma holder
Do not have required Degree
56
23
25
8
Table 4: Those estimated data in this table has been derived after surveying 56 drug shops in the urban area (Badda). Here the table is representing the comparative values of the number of pharmacist, the number of LMAF diploma holder and do not have required degree in those drug shops. Here we got only 8 pharmacists. Also 23 LMAF diploma holders and 25 persons have no required degree for drug selling.
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Series 1
Total Shop
Pharmacist
LMAF
Do not have required degree
56
8
23
25
Figure 6 Figure 6: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the data of registered pharmacist, LMAF diploma holder and do not have required degree in urban areas according to the table-4 explained in above.
Page | 38
12%
Pharmacist Total shop
88%
Figure 7 Figure 7: This pie chart is representing the ratio of the registered pharmacists in those urban areas and total shops. Here the ratio has found as the Total shop : Pharmacist is equal to 88 : 12. Findings 4: Very poor number of pharmacists is also available in those urban areas which are a serious ignoring of the drug acts. Table 5: Area
Licensed shops
Pharmacist
LMAF
Rural
Number of shops 56
54
7
10
Urban
56
43
8
23
Total
112
97
15
33
Table 5: Those estimated data in this table has been derived after surveying 112 drug shops in the
both rural (56) areas and urban (56) areas. Here the table is representing the comparative values of the number of licensed drug shops, the number of pharmacists and the number of LMAF diploma holder in those drug shops. Here we got 97 licensed shops and total only 15 pharmacists in 112 drug shops. Also 33 LMAF diploma holders in out of 112 surveyed shops.
Page | 39
120 100 80 60 40 20 0
Rural
Urban
Total
Number of shops
56
56
112
Licensed shops
54
43
97
Pharmacist
7
8
15
LMAF
10
23
33
Figure 8 Figure 8: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the total data summary of licensed shops, registered pharmacist and LMAF diploma holder in both rural and urban areas according to the table-5 explained in above. Total Shops
Number of Pharmacist
12%
88%
Figure 9 Figure 9: This pie chart is representing the total ratio of the registered pharmacists in both rural and urban areas and total shops. Here the ratio has found as the Total shop : Pharmacist is equal to 88 : 12. Findings 5: Very poor number of pharmacist is available in both rural and urban areas which is a serious ignoring of the drug acts. Page | 40
3.3) Table, graph and findings on the selling per month in drug shops: Table 6: Amount of average Sales/Month
Rural
Urban
Less than 50 thou
14
3
50 thou
14
8
1 lakh
5
5
1.5 lakh
2
21
2 lakh
4
2
3 lakh
7
1
3.5 lakh
1
1
4.5 lakh
1
6 lakh
2
2
7 lakh
1
1
9 lakh
1
12 lakh
1
No Answer
3
12
Total
56
56
Table 6: The estimated data found in here after surveyed 112 little drug shops in both rural (56) and urban (56) areas. Here 3 and 12 person did not answer in rural and urban area about their sales per month respectively. There I have got 14 (rural) and 3 (urban) little shops where the average sale per month is less than 50 thousand. Here also 14 (rural) and 8 (urban) little shops where sale per month is 50 thousand to less than one lakh, and 2 (rural) and 21 (urban) little shops where a sale per month is around 1.5 lakh. Findings 6: We can see that in the little or medium drug shops in urban areas has more sales per month compare to the rural areas if we compare those 1, 2, 3 and 4 no rows in above table-6.
Page | 41
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Less 1.5 3.5 than 50 1 lakh 2 lakh 3 lakh lakh lakh 50 thou thou
Rural
14
14
5
2
4
7
1
Urban
3
8
5
21
2
1
1
No 4.5 12 6 lakh 7 lakh 9 lakh Answe Total lakh lakh r 1
2
1
2
1
1
1
3
56
12
56
Figure 10
Figure 10: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the total data summary of sales per month, mostly, into the little drug shops in both rural and urban areas according to the table-6 explained in above.
Page | 42
3.4) Table, graph and findings on the present investment in drug shops: Table 7: Amount of Present Investment Less than 50 thou
Rural
Urban
1
0
50 thou
9
0
1 lakh
6
0
1.5 lakh
1
6
2 lakh
5
4
2.5 lakh
2
3
3 lakh
5
14
4 lakh
3
11
6 lakh
3
3
7 lakh
1
1
8 lakh
3
10 lakh
1
12 lakh
1
15 lakh
4
20 lakh
2
No Answer
9
10
Total
56
56
1
3
Table 7: The estimated data found in here after surveyed 112 little drug shops in both rural (56) and urban (56) areas. Here 9 and 10 person did not answer in rural and urban area about their present investment in their shops respectively. There I have got 1 (rural) and 0 (urban) little shops where the approximate present investments are less than 50 thousand. Here also 9 (rural) and 0 (urban) little shops where the approximate present investment is 50 thousand to less than one lakh, and 6 (rural) and 0 (urban) little drug shops where the approximate present investment is 1 lakh to less than 1.5 lakh. Findings 7: We can see that in the little or medium drug shops in urban areas have more investment compare to the rural areas if we compare those 1, 2, and 3 no rows in above table-7.
Page | 43
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Less No 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 4 6 7 8 10 12 15 20 than 50 Answ Total 50 thou lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh lakh er thou
Rural
1
9
6
1
5
2
5
3
3
1
Urban
0
0
0
6
4
3
14
11
3
1
3
1 1
1
4 3
2
9
56
10
56
Figure 11
Figure 11: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the total data summary on current or present investment into the little drug shops in both rural and urban areas according to the table-7 explained in above.
Page | 44
3.5) Table, graph and findings on MPO visits the drug shops: Table 8: Number of MPO goes to the drug shop
Rural Area
Urban Area
Less than 5 MPO 5 MPO 10 MPO
5
11 10 14
15 MPO 20 MPO
4 11
8 3
25 MPO
21
1
30 MPO 35 MPO
5 1
2 1
40 MPO
1
45 MPO 50 MPO
1 3
60 MPO
1
70 MPO
1
80 MPO
1
NO Answer
1
6
Total
56
56
Table 8: The estimated data found in here after surveyed 112 little drug shops in both rural (56) and urban (56) areas. Here I got 11 and 10 shops (row 1 and 2) in those surveyed urban area where less than 5 and more than 5 to 9 MPO visits respectively but there is no little or medium drug shop in rural area where less than 5 or 5 to 9 MPO visit from different companies. In the lower part table also showing that there are 3 drug shops in rural areas in where about 60, 70 and 80 MPO visit respectively from different companies but there is no drug shop in those surveyed urban areas where 60 or 70 or 80 MPO visit from different companies. Findings 8: More MPOs from more companies are more available in rural area compare to the urban area. May be due to this reason less quality or substandard product is more available in rural areas than urban area.
Page | 45
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Less NO 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 60 70 80 than 5 Answ Total 5 MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO MPO er MPO
Rural Area Urban Area
11
10
5
4
11
21
5
1
14
8
3
1
2
1
1
1
3
1
1
1
1
56
6
56
Figure 12
Figure 12: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the total data summary of the number of MPO visits to the drug shops in both rural and urban areas from different companies according to the table-8 explained in above.
Page | 46
3.6) Table, graph and findings on most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer: Table 9: Most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer Ranitidine Omeprazol Antacid Plus Pantoprazol Others Total
Rural
Urban
33 10 10 1 2 56
41 5 4 0 6 56
Table 9: This table representing the comparative sales amount of Antacid Plus, Ranitidine, omeprazol and other groups of drugs as the most dispensed drug for Gastric ulcer. Here Ranitidine is the most dispensed drug Gastric Ulcer. On the other hand the Omeprazol, Antacid plus and other drugs are in 2nd, 3rd and 4th position used for Gastric ulcer treatment. Findings 9: Ranitidine is the most dispensed drug for Gastric Ulcer treatment which is a H2 receptor antagonist. But omeprazol should be the most used drug for Gastric Ulcer treatment as it is a proton pump inhibitor which works at the last stage of acid secretion and more appropriate to use than Ranitidine. 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
Ranitidine
Omeprazol
Antacid Plus
Pantoprazol
Others
Total
Rural
33
10
10
1
2
56
Urban
41
5
4
0
6
56
Figure 13 Figure 13: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the total data for the most dispensed drugs for Gastric Ulcer treatment according to Table-9 explained in above. Page | 47
3.7) Table, graph and findings on most dispensed drug as Pain Killer: Table 10: Most dispensed drug as Pain Killer Diclofenac Sodium Paracetamol Acelofenac Others Total
Rural
Urban
18 6 13 19 56
21 22 5 8 56
Table 10: This table representing the comparative sales amount of Paracetamol, Diclofenac, Acelofenac and other groups of drugs as pain killer. Here Diclofenac Sodium is the most dispensed drug as general pain killer. The Paracetamol is in 2nd position, used as general pain killer in both rural and urban area. Findings 10: Diclofenac Sodium is the most dispensed drug as general pain killer in both rural and urban area. But other groups (19) are also use mostly in rural areas where sometimes antibiotics are used as wrong treatment as painkiller as I have observed twice during this survey. 60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Diclofenac
Paracetamol
Acelofenac
Others
Total
Rural
18
6
13
19
56
Urban
21
22
5
8
56
Figure 14 Figure 14: This Bar-Chart is illustrating the total data for the most dispensed drugs as pain killer according to Table-10 explained in above. Page | 48
Chapter 4 4.1) Results: 1. Among the 112 surveyed drug shops I have found about 5% and 23% (see figure-1 & 2) drug shops are non-licensed in rural and urban area respectively. So those non-licensed drug shops are ignoring the Drug acts and the percentage of licensed drug shops is more in rural areas than urban areas that I have found from this survey. 2. There are only 11% and 12% (see figure-5 & 7) qualified registered pharmacist in rural and urban areas respectively and I found only 15 pharmacists (see table-5) in 112 surveyed Drug shops. The total percent of community pharmacist is 12% (see figure-9) which is the main cause of mal-treatment or irrational drug use in our country. 3. Here (see table-6) I have got 14 (rural) and 3 (urban) little shops where the average sale per month is less than 50 thousand. Also 14 (rural) and 8 (urban) little shops where sale per month is 50 thousand to less than one lakh, and 2 (rural) and 21 (urban) little shops where a sale per month is around 1.5 lakh which indicates that the amount of drug selling is more in urban area in spite of less licensed drug shops than rural areas. 4. There I have got 1 (rural) and 0 (urban) little shops (see table-7) where the approximate present investments are less than 50 thousand. Also 9 (rural) and 0 (urban) little shops where the approximate present investments are 50 thousand to less than one lakh, and 6 (rural) and 0 (urban) little drug shops where the approximate present investments are 1 lakh to less than 1.5 lakh which also indicates that the investment is more in urban area in spite of less licensed drug shops than rural areas. 5. This project report has revealed that there are 11 and 10 shops (see table-8) in those surveyed urban area where less than 5 and more than 5 to 9 MPO visits respectively but there is no little or medium drug shop in rural area where less than 5 or 5 to 9 MPO visit from different companies. The lower part of the table-8 also showing that there are 3 drug shops in rural areas where about 60, 70 and 80 MPO visit respectively from different companies but there is no drug shop in those surveyed urban areas where 60 or 70 or 80 MPO visit from different companies. So the table-8 indicating that more MPOs from more companies are more available in rural areas compare to the urban areas. Due to this reason less quality or substandard products are more available in rural areas than urban areas. 6. This project report has revealed that Ranitidine is the most dispensed drug (see figure-13) for Gastric Ulcer treatment.
Page | 49
7. This project report has also revealed that Diclofenac Sodium is the most dispensed drug (see figure-14) as general Pain Killer.
4.2) Conclusion: Considering the results and findings that I have already mentioned after every table or chart or graph I have found that the drug shops in both rural and urban areas are not running according to the Drug Acts. I have surveyed 112 drug shops where most drug shops are running on little or medium investment and where the non-licensed drug shop is more in urban area than rural areas but the present investment into the drug shops are more in urban areas than the rural areas. Also the drug selling is more in urban areas than rural areas as like the more present investment in urban areas. From the above results, it is clearly manifested that the number of qualified Pharmacists are very inadequate who have definite beneficial roles regarding health matters in community pharmacy. But a pharmacist is the legally qualified and professionally competent person to handle drugs and allied supplies required for the patients within and outside the hospital. Most of the maltreatment and irrational use of drugs is happening or responsible due to do not having adequate number of qualified registered pharmacist in drug shops. I have found only 15 pharmacists in 112 surveyed drug shops and it is a matter of regret that the government of our country is taking very little effort to employ highly skilled pharmacy personnel in community pharmacy. But in the developed countries, pharmacists are in unique position in this regard and there have a lot of job scopes for them, especially, in community pharmacy. So the governmental health policy should be modify by incorporating pharmacist and increase their job scopes in community pharmacy and there should not have any non-licensed drug shop to improve and ensure the better health service for the safety, rational use of drugs and wellbeing of the patients of our country. 4.3) Reference: 1) banglapedia.search.com.bd/ 2) pubmedcentral.nih.gov/ 3) pdfcoke.com/doc/4951691/Role-of-Pharmacists 4) The Drug Control Ordinance 1982
Page | 50