+,3Ð7(6('(60$5$1'$&+((9,'È1&,$6 ,03/,&$d¯(6($3/,&$d¯(6 /HRQDUGR)'GD0RWWD OPRWWD#DPD]RQFRPEU
&RQVHOKHLUR)XUWDGR %HOpP3$%UDVLO 6HWHPEUR
5(6802 (P 6PDUDQGDFKH SURS{V TXH QmR Ki XPD YHORFLGDGH OLPLWH QD QDWXUH]D EDVHDGR QR SDUDGR[R (35%HOO (LQVWHLQ 3RGROVN\ 5RVHQ %HOO (PERUD SDUHoD TXH HVWH SDUDGR[R IRL UHVROYLGR UHFHQWHPHQWH DLQGD Ki YiULDV RXWUDV HYLGrQFLDV TXH QRV JXLDP D DFUHGLWDU TXH D KLSyWHVH GH 6PDUDQGDFKH HVWi FRUUHWD QD PHFkQLFD TXkQWLFD H DWp QDV WHRULDV GH XQLILFDomR 6H D KLSyWHVH GH 6PDUDQGDFKH UHYHODUVH YHUGDGHLUD HP TXDOTXHU FLUFXQVWkQFLD DOJXQV DVSHFWRV GD ItVLFD PRGHUQD WHUmR TXH VH ³UHDMXVWDU´ SDUD FRQFRUGDU FRP D KLSyWHVH GH 6PDUDQGDFKH (P DGLomR TXDQGR R VLJQLILFDGR GD KLSyWHVH GH 6PDUDQGDFKH WRUQDUVH WRWDOPHQWH HQWHQGLGR XPD UHYROXomR QDWHFQRORJLDHVSHFLDOPHQWHQDVFRPXQLFDo}HVLUiVXUJLU
, (9,'È1&,$6'()(1Ñ0(126683(5/80,1$,6($+,3Ð7(6('( 60$5$1'$&+(
$SDUHQWHPHQWH IRL 6RPPHUIHOG TXHP SULPHLUR QRWRX D SRVVtYHO H[LVWrQFLD GH SDUWtFXODV PDLV UiSLGDV TXH D OX] PDLV WDUGH FKDPDGDV GH WDFK\RQV SRU )HLQEHUJ >@ 7RGDYLD WDFK\RQV SRVVXHP PDVVD LPDJLQiULD DVVLP QXQFD IRUDP GHWHFWDGRV H[SHULPHQWDOPHQWH3RUPDVVDLPDJLQiULDHQWHQGHPRVXPDPDVVDSURLELGDSHODWHRULDGD UHODWLYLGDGH (QWUHWDQWR D UHODWLYLGDGH QmR SURtEH GLUHWDPHQWH D H[LVWrQFLD GH SDUWtFXODV VXSHUOXPLQDLV VHP PDVVD FRPR R IyWRQ PDV VXJHUH TXH IHQ{PHQRV VXSHUOXPLQDLV FXOPLQDULDP HP YLDJHP QR WHPSR (QWmR PXLWRV ItVLFRV DVVXPLUDP TXH IHQ{PHQRV VXSHUOXPLQDLV QmR H[LVWHP QR XQLYHUVR RXWUD IRUPD WHUtDPRV TXH H[SOLFDU WRGRV RV SDUDGR[RVGRWLSR³PDWHRVHXDY{´>@8PIDPRVRH[HPSORGHSDUDGR[RGHVWHWLSRpR SUREOHPDGHFDXVDOLGDGH $VHUSXEOLFDGR6PDUDQGDFKH+\SRWKHVLV(YLGHQFHV,PSOLFDWLRQVDQG$SSOLFDWLRQVHP³6PDUDQGDFKH 1RWLRQV-RXUQDO´9RO8QLYHUVLW\RI&UDLRYD1HZ0H[LFRj FRQYLWH GH'U0LQK3HUH]
0HVPRDVVLPDPHFkQLFDTXkQWLFDVXJHUHTXHPRYLPHQWRVVXSHUOXPLQDLVH[LVWHP'H IDWRKiKLSyWHVHVGDH[LVWrQFLDREULJDWyULDGHPRYLPHQWRVVXSHUOXPLQDLVQDQDWXUH]D> @ 2 SDUDGR[R (35%HOO p R PDLV IDPRVR H[HPSOR 3RQGHUDQGR VREUH HVWH SDUDGR[R 6PDUDQGDFKH SURS{V HP HP XPD SDOHVWUD DR %UDVLO TXH QmR Ki WDO YHORFLGDGH OLPLWH QR XQLYHUVR FRPR SRVWXODGR SRU (LQVWHLQ >@ 3DUHFH TXH HVWH SDUDGR[R IRL UHFHQWHPHQWHUHVROYLGRSRU/(6]DEy>@0HVPRDVVLPDLQGDKiYiULDVHYLGrQFLDVGH YHORFLGDGHVLQILQLWDVFRPXQLFDomRLQVWDQWkQHD QRXQLYHUVRFRPRYHUHPRVEUHYHPHQWH
,$7HRULDGH5RGULJXHV0DLRULQR
(VWXGDQGR VROXo}HV GDV HTXDo}HV GH 0D[ZHOO H 'LUDF:H\O :DOG\U5RGULJXHV-UH -RVp 0DLRULQR IRUDP FDSD]HV GH SURSRU XPD WHRULD XQLILFDGD SDUD FRQVWUXomR GH YHORFLGDGHV DUELWUiULDV QD QDWXUH]D SRU DUELWUiULD HQWHQGHVH d Y d F HP >@ (OHVWDPEpPVXJHULUDPTXHQmRKiWDOYHORFLGDGHOLPLWHQRXQLYHUVRDVVLPDKLSyWHVHGH 6PDUDQGDFKH S{GH VHU SURPRYLGD D WHRULD FRPR WHRULD GH 6PDUDQGDFKH5RGULJXHV 0DLRULQR650
)DWR~QLFRGDWHRULDGH5RGULJXHV0DLRULQRpTXHRSULQFtSLRGDUHODWLYLGDGHHVSHFLDO VRIUH XPD TXHEUD HQWUHWDQWR PHVPR FRQVWUXo}HV UHODWLYtVWLFDV GD PHFkQLFD TXkQWLFD FRPR D HTXDomR GH 'LUDF FRQFRUGDP SOHQDPHQWH FRP IHQ{PHQRV VXSHUOXPLQDLV 'H DFRUGRFRPDWHRULDGH5RGULJXHV0DLRULQRDWpPHVPRXPFRQMXQWREHPSRVLFLRQDGRGH HVSHOKRVSRGHDFHOHUDUXPDRQGDHOHWURPDJQpWLFDDYHORFLGDGHVVXSHULRUHVDGDOX](VVD DILUPDomRIRLPDLVWDUGHFRQILUPDGDSRU6DDULH5HLYHOW >@TXHSURGX]LUDPXPD RQGD;QRPHDGDGHVWDIRUPDSRU-</XXPFRQWULEXLGRUGH5RGULJXHV XVDQGRXPD OkPSDGDGH[HQ{QLRLQWHUFHSWDGDFRPXPFRQMXQWRGHOHQWHVHRULItFLRV $ WHRULD 650 p XPD FRQVWUXomR PDWHPiWLFD SXUD H IRUWH GD HTXDomR GH RQGD UHODWLYtVWLFDTXHQRVLQGLFDTXHQmRKiQHQKXPDYHORFLGDGHOLPLWHQRXQLYHUVR
,([SHULPHQWRV6XSHUOXPLQDLV
0XLWRV H[SHULPHQWRV SULQFLSDOPHQWH PRGRV HYDQHVFHQWHV UHVXOWDP HP SURSDJDomR VXSHUOXPLQDO2SULPHLURPRGRHYDQHVFHQWHEHPVXFHGLGRIRLREWLGRHPSRU1LPW] >@1LPW]SURGX]LXXPVLQDOFHPDLVWDUGHXPVLQDO)0FFRPDD VLQIRQLDGH 0R]DUW (VVH VXFHVVR GH 1LPW] VHULD PDLV WDUGH VXSHUDGR SRU RXWURV UHVXOWDGRV DWp YH]HVPDLVUiSLGRVTXHDFRQVWDQWHF
1R FDVR GR H[SHULPHQWR GH 1LPW] QmR HVWi FODUR VH HOH YLROD R SDUDGR[R GH FDXVDOLGDGH (P FRQWUDSDUWLGD / - :DQJ $ .X]PLFK H $ 'RJDULX UHFHQWHPHQWH SXEOLFDUDPXPH[WUDRUGLQiULRUHVXOWDGRGHGLVSHUVmRDQ{PDODRTXDOXPSXOVRGHOX]IRL DFHOHUDGR r YH]HV D YHORFLGDGH GD OX] VHP YLRODU R SDUDGR[R GH FDXVDOLGDGH SRUWDQWRUHVXOWDQGRHPYLDJHPQRWHPSR1DSUiWLFDLVWRVLJQLILFDTXHXPSXOVRGHOX] SURSDJDQGRSHODFpOXODGHYDSRUDW{PLFRDSDUHFHQDVDtGDPXLWRDQWHVGHWHUSURSDJDGRD PHVPDGLVWkQFLDQRYiFXRHRSLFRGRSXOVRSDUHFHVDLUGDFpOXODDQWHVPHVPRGHHQWUDU >@
,5HYLVmRGD9HORFLGDGHGD*UDYLGDGH
$WHRULDJHUDOGDUHODWLYLGDGHSRVWXODTXHDYHORFLGDGHGDJUDYLGDGHpDPHVPDTXHD FRQVWDQWH F 3RUpP VH D YHORFLGDGH GD OX] QmR p D YHORFLGDGH OLPLWH GR XQLYHUVR QmR VHULDKRUDGHUHYLVDUHVWHSRVWXODGR"9DQ)ODQGHUQSXEOLFRXDOJXQVUHVXOWDGRVDVWURItVLFRV TXHLQGLFDPTXHDJUDYLGDGHpVXSHUOXPLQDO>@2EVHUYDo}HVGHDOJXPDVJDOi[LDVIHLWDV SHOD 1$6$ VXJHUHP TXH DOJXPDV JDOi[LDV HVWmR JLUDQGR FRP YHORFLGDGH VXSHUOXPLQDO >@ 2VGDGRVGH9DQ)ODQGHUQIRUDPPDLVWDUGHVH[SOLFDGRVSRUXPDWHRULDTXHQmRXVDYD GH PRYLPHQWRV VXSHUOXPLQDLV SRU ,ELVRQ 3XWKRII H 6 5 /LWWOH >@ $LQGD DVVLP REVHUYDo}HV GH VLQDLV VXSHUOXPLQDLV YLQGR GH JDOi[LDV SHUPDQHFH LQH[SOLFDGDV SHOR SRQWRGHYLVWDVXEOXPLQDO
,7DFK\RQV
$OJXQVPRGHORVGDWHRULDGHVXSHUFRUGDVQRVVDPDLVSURPLVVRUDFDQGLGDWDSDUDWHRULD XQLILFDGDGDItVLFDLQFOXLWDFK\RQVDVSDUWtFXODVKiEHLVGHYLDMDUPDLVUiSLGRTXHDOX] 0HVPR DVVLP ItVLFRV HQFRQWUDUDP XPD PDQHLUD GH ³FRUWDU´ D WHRULD GH PDQHLUD TXH DV VROXo}HV GH WDFK\RQV GHVDSDUHFHP DOJXQV RXWURV FRPR )UHHGPDQ GHIHQGHP TXH D WHRULDGHVXSHUFRUGDVQmRGHYHULDVHUFRUWDGDGHWDOIRUPDHPDEVROXWR>@$WHRULDGDV VXSHUFRUGDV p SURYDYHOPHQWH R PHOKRU FDPSR SDUD R HVWXGR GH WDFK\RQV SRLV QmR LUi IRUoDU R XVR GR DUWLItFLR GH PDVVD LPDJLQiULD 3URI 0LFKLR .DNX FRPSDURX D LGpLD GH PDLV GLPHQV}HV HP ItVLFDDXPHVTXHPDGHPDWUL]HVHPVHX+\SHUVSDFH,PDJLQHXPD PDWUL][DTXDOWHPRVGHQWURDWHRULDGDUHODWLYLGDGHHRXWUDPDWUL][RQGHWHPRVR 0RGHOR3DGUmR6HFRQVWUXLUPRVXPDPDWUL]PDLRUGLJDPRV[VHULDPRVFDSD]HQWmR GHLQFOXLUDPEDVDPHFkQLFDTXkQWLFDHDUHODWLYLGDGHHPXPD~QLFDPDWUL](VWDpDLGpLD SULQFLSDO GH XQLILFDomR D SDUWLU GD DGLomR GH PDLV GLPHQV}HV 'D PHVPD PDQHLUD WUDEDOKDQGR DSHQDV FRP PDWUL]HV [ QmR WHPRV HVSDoR VXILFLHQWH SDUD WUDEDOKDU FRP WDFK\RQV 7RGDYLD HP XPD PDWUL] PDLRU WHUtDPRV R HVSDoR QHFHVViULR SDUD HQFRQWUDU FRQVWUXo}HVVyOLGDVGHPRGHORVGHWDFK\RQV 7DFK\RQVMiIRUDPGHXPDPDQHLUDREVFXUDREVHUYDGRVHPFKXYHLURVGHDUGHUDLRV FyVPLFRV
,,,03/,&$d¯(6($3/,&$d¯(6 'H DFRUGR FRP D WHRULD GH 5RGULJXHV0DLRULQR D FRQVHTrQFLD GD H[LVWrQFLD GH IHQ{PHQRV VXSHUOXPLQDLV VHULD D TXHEUD GR SULQFtSLR GD UHODWLYLGDGH PDV QmR SUHFLVDUtDPRVDOWHUDUQDGDQDPHFkQLFDTXkQWLFD0DLVSUHFLVDPHQWHQRVSDUHFHTXHpD PHFkQLFDTXkQWLFDTXHPHVWiEDQLQGRDDQWLJDWHRULDUHODWLYtVWLFDVHJXQGRDWHRULD650 $SHVDU GLVVR QD UHDOLGDGH D WHRULD GD UHODWLYLGDGH DFHLWD DOJXP WLSR GH FRPXQLFDomR VXSHUOXPLQDO TXH UHVXOWD HP YLDJHP QR WHPSR FRPR :DQJ H VHXV FRQWULEXLGRUHV PRVWUDUDP
7DOYH] QyV SRGHUHPRV QXP IXWXUR GLVWDQWH HQYLDU PHQVDJHQV SDUD R IXWXUR RX SDVVDGR 'H TXDOTXHU IRUPD IHQ{PHQRV VXSHUOXPLQDLV WHULDP XPD DSOLFDomR PDLV UHDOLVWDFRPFRPXQLFDomRORFDOSRLVGHDFRUGRFRPDWHRULD5RGULJXHV0DLRULQRDRQGD ;pIHFKDGD QRVHQWLGRTXHHODQmRSHUGHHQHUJLDHQTXDQWRYLDMD(QWmRXPDPHQVDJHP GHUiGLRVXSHUOXPLQDOGHRQGD;FKHJDULDDVHXGHVWLQRFRPTXDVHDPHVPDFRQGLomRHP TXHIRLHQYLDGDHQLQJXpPH[FHWRRGHVWLQRSRGHULDHVSLDURFRQWH~GRGDPHQVDJHP$ LQYHQomR GH XP WDO WUDQVPLVVRU VXSHUOXPLQDOVHULDGHJUDQGHSRGHUDVVRFLDGRDSDVWLOKD SDUDGHVYLDUDOX]HPR GR0,7QDPDQXIDWXUDGHILEUDVySWLFDV
,,,&21&/86®2 2VYiULRVH[SHULPHQWRVHWHRULDVVyOLGDVTXHQDVFHPGDPHFkQLFDTXkQWLFDHQYROYHQGR IHQ{PHQRV VXSHUOXPLQDLV VmR DOWRQtYHLV GH LQGLFDomR GD KLSyWHVH GH 6PDUDQGDFKH TXH QmR Ki WDO YHORFLGDGH OLPLWH QD QDWXUH]D ,VWR LPSOLFD HP XPD TXHEUD GR SRVWXODGR GD UHODWLYLGDGHGH(LQVWHLQPDVQmRHPQHQKXPFDPSRGDPHFkQLFDTXkQWLFDDWpPHVPRQD IXQomR GH RQGD UHODWLYtVWLFD &RPR HP QRVVD HYROXomR FKHJRX XP WHPSR HP TXH D PHFkQLFD QHZWRQLDQD QmR HUD VXILFLHQWH SDUD FRPSUHHQGHU DOJXQV QRYRV DVSHFWRV GD QDWXUH]DWDOYH]VHDSUR[LPDXPWHPSRHPTXHDWHRULDGDUHODWLYLGDGHGH(LQVWHLQGHYH VHUGHL[DGDGHODGRSRLVHQWmRDPHFkQLFDTXkQWLFDLUiJRYHUQDU
$*5$'(&,0(1726'U0LQK3HUH]GD$PHULFDQ5HDVHDUFK3UHVVSHORFRQYLWH GLVFXVV}HVPDWHULDOHWF
5()(5È1&,$6 >@ )UHHGPDQ'DYLG%H\RQG(LQVWHLQ'LVFRYHU\ )HE
>@ +HUEHUW1LFN)DVWHUWKDQ/LJKW6XSHUOXPLQDO/RRSKROHVLQ3K\VLFV3OXPH%RRNV 1HZ@ 6KDQ*DR 4XDQWXPVXSHUOXPLQDOFRPPXQLFDWLRQPXVWH[LVW-XQ SK\VLFV,40&*6(
>@ 6KDQ*DR4XDQWXPVXSHUOXPLQDOFRPPXQLFDWLRQGRHVQRWUHVXOWLQFDVXDOORRS SDUDGR[HV -XQ TXDQWSK,40
>@ 6PDUDQGDFKH)ORUHQWLQ7KHUH,V1R6SHHG%DUULHU,Q7KH8QLYHUVH%XOOHWLQRI3XUH DQG$SSOLHG6FLHQFHV'HOKL,QGLD9RO' 3K\VLFV 1RS $OVRDW KWWSZZZJDOOXSXQPHGXaVPDUDQGDFKHSK\VLFVKWP >@ 6]DEy/(&RPSOHWH5HVROXWLRQRIWKH(35%HOO3DUDGR[(|WY|V%XGDSHVW -XQ TXDQWSK(|WY|V+36
>@ 5RGULJXHV:DOG\U$ 0DLRULQR-RVp($XQLILHGWKHRU\IRUFRQVWUXFWLRQRI DUELWUDU\VSHHGVVROXWLRQVRIWKHUHODWLYLVWLFZDYHHTXDWLRQV5DQGRP2SHUDQG 6WRFK(TX9RO1RS
>@ 6DDUL3 5HLYHOW.(YLGHQFHRI;6KDSHG3URSDJDWLRQ,QYDULDQW/RFDOL]HG/LJKW :DYHV3K\V5HY/HWW >@ 1LPW]*6XSHUOXPLQDO6LJQDO9HORFLW\$QQGHU3K\VLNS >@ :DQJ/- .X]PLFK$ 'RJDULX$*DLQDVVLVWHG6XSHUOXPLQDO 3URSDJDWLRQ1DWXUHS-XO\
>@ )ODQGHUQ79DQ7KHVSHHGRIJUDYLW\± ZKDWWKHH[SHULPHQWVVD\3K\V/HWW$
>@ +DUPRQ%$*DODWLF6XSHUOXPLQDO6RXUFH,Q UG,17(*5$/:RUNVKRSWKH ([WUHPH8QLYHUVH7DRUPLQD,WDO\ 6HS(GE\*3DOXPER$%D]]DQR DQG&:LQNOHU $VWURSK\V/HWW&RPPXQDVWURSK >@ ,ELVRQ0LFKDHO 3XWKRII+DUROG( /LWWOH6FRWW57KHVSHHGRIJUDYLW\ UHYLVLWHG3K\V/HWW$1RY SK\VLFV