Rubric for Response Paper to Transformative Curriculum Leadership & Articles CRITERIA LENGTH
Length is minimal – 6 or less paragraphs
Length is less than satisfactory – 8 - 9 paragraphs 4 Ideas are fairly developed and related to the course idea
LIKES
2 Not related to the course idea at all
DISLIKES
4 Not related to the course idea at all
6 Ideas are fairly developed and related to the course idea
4 PERSONAL Poorly developed RESPONSE and does not catch the central idea
6 Is on the target, but it is not developed enough
4 TOTAL
6
Length is adequate – 10 – 11 paragraphs 5 Ideas are adequately developed and related to the course idea 7 Ideas are adequately developed and related to the course idea 7 Is sufficiently explained and developed 7
Length is excellent in terms of criteria: 12 or more paragraphs 6 Ideas are fully developed and related to the course idea. 8 Ideas are fully developed and related to the course idea. 8 Is excellent and goes beyond the idea to pose new ideas and questions 8