Feasibility Study for Closure of State Institutional Facilities Christopher Murray & Associates July 17, 2009
Project Team • • • •
Christopher Murray & Associates Davis Deshaies Berk & Associates Ambia /A&E Team
Project Approach
Making Sense out of Complexity
Create a Shortlist of Options Identify stakeholders
Confer with stakeholders
Assess impact on community SUBMIT FINAL REPORT
Assess impact on, and alternatives for , employees
Assess impact on residents and families
IDENTIFY POTENTIAL SITES FOR CLOSURE OR DOWNSIZING
Assess capacity of potential consolidation facilities / programs
Analyze population projections and needs
Identify consolidation / relocation options
Identify capital & operating costs & savings of closures
Identify alternative uses and costs to convert / reopen
Identify secondary impacts of closures
Identify stakeholders
OFM review & comments
Summarize other considerations Identify staffing needs and other operating costs
Identify capital needs & costs
Develop implementation plans
Identify preferred alternatives
Prepare draft report Confer with stakeholders
Revisions
Assess impact on receiving communities
Calculate life cycle costs & savings
OFM review & comments
Analyze Capital & Operating Costs
Evaluate Secondary Impacts/Alternative Uses
Identify & Confer with Stakeholders
Assess Impact on Employees
Assess Impact on the Community
Analyze Population Projections / Needs
Identify Consolidation/Relocation Options
Assess Capacity of Facilities/Programs
Assess Capital & Operating Costs
Assess Impact on Communities
Calculate Life Cycle Costs and Savings
Assess Impact on Residents & Families
Summarize Non-Financial Considerations
Identify Preferred Alternatives
Development Implementation Plans
Prepare Draft Report
OFM /Agency Review & Comment
Prepare Second Draft
OFM /Agency Final Review & Comments
Submit Final Report
Presentations as Necessary
Project Schedule Jul 2009
ID
Description of Activity
Start
7/5
1 2
Identify potential sites for closure or downsizing Identify stakeholders related to potential closures /downsizing
7/ 9/2009
7/17/ 2009
7/20/ 2009
7/22/ 2009
3
Confer with stakeholders
7/27/ 2009
8/24/ 2009
4
Identify characteristics dislocated populations
7/20/ 2009
7/28/ 2009
5
Assess impact on residents
8/13/ 2009
8/28/ 2009
8/ 4/2009
8/18/ 2009
7/20/ 2009
8/27/ 2009
7/27/ 2009
8/ 4/2009
8/ 4/2009
8/ 6/2009
8/10/ 2009
8/24/ 2009
7/30/ 2009
8/28/ 2009
8/ 4/2009
8/21/ 2009
8/24/ 2009
9/14/ 2009
8/24/ 2009
9/14/ 2009
7/20/ 2009
8/ 6/2009
8/ 4/2009
8/21/ 2009
6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
& needs of & families
Assess impact on , and alternatives for , employees Assess impact on communities with potential closure or downsizing Identify sites /options for relocating dislocated populations Identify stakeholders for receiving communities /sites Confer with stakeholders Assess impact on potential receiving communities Assess capacity of potential receiving facilities /programs Identify capital needs & costs at potential receiving facilities / programs Identify staffing needs & costs at potential receiving facilities / programs Identify capital & operating costs & savings from facility closures Identify secondary financial impacts of closures Identify possible alternative uses & cost to convert / reopen Calculate life cycle costs and savings of alternatives
Aug 2009
Sep 2009
Oct 2009
Finish
8/20/ 2009
9/ 1/2009
9/14/ 2009
9/16/ 2009
19
Summarize other considerations
8/31/ 2009
9/16/ 2009
20
Identify preferred alternatives
9/17/ 2009
9/21/ 2009
21
Develop implementation plans
9/21/ 2009
9/29/ 2009
22
Prepare draft report
9/21/ 2009
10/1/ 2009
23
OFM review & comment
10/1/ 2009
10/7/ 2009
24
Prepare penultimate draft
10/8/ 2009
10/ 14/2009
25
OFM review & comment
10/ 15/2009
10/ 19/2009
26
Prepare & submit final report
10/ 20/2009
10/ 22/2009
7/12
7/19
7/26
8 /2
8/9
8/16
8/23
8/30
9/ 6
9 /13
9 /20
9/27
Presentations will take place between Nov
10/4
10/11
10 /18
10 /25
1, 2009 and Feb 1, 2010
Discussion