[ !,
v .!.v vv
E e./
cr]t6f
&L
Let's
_-
i
c-
'.,,t
L.l
Ln,y red u,er rre di\.!sung among itrer selks b!l a vcr! rmlortanl lirty to ihc conlers tjoi ts nisiurg," he says. lle n.les a !cr..,dion em.nLt}!!]ublic th3t t . ir '" . n | 't.r L r.n.!.ior .r-!_
't!rtr!l]*1tu!- -- -' !-b-.t.'-Ll" :i :r.r ",cl r" l,L" ,.ne roiio l rneor . h" ''i Ajms lDs sL,ggesied
thli
ho{ bcst to engage onlnie s.
o
-!_i-T-u-
1
ihe C.lernDreDt stn
as to avoid the pitfa cncomtererl elsewh.re Officials lron counhies such as Britai]t, Autr. ia and the Uniied Staies that Aims .o)rsulted al siressed that e engaEement should complemer not replace, traditjonal mems ol gove.nnent-cll
Po,
On how
\rarnly Singafore's politicians
'hptn."rn,LV , .orP,.r\
€mbra
.
tlri chanuc r lecesarv. B.ltJ" odt,t o" h 'l - n"s r ' C . $ '\ " ,
\iLlsrlblF .rution . He cjtes as an exanFle th€ covelimcnt's not to reply to lelters to The Straiis TiD€s
ilrdi !ir Fllrli5licd onlirc. jn thc newsp.rtcr itrelf.
fo.r d''-,1 o: Iorh.l otfln) i nersDJDcr Ie.ir.d mldr ,her I h ^nF !l \€5fretasr)ex nnr.r "d ln rh€ onliire world r "Dcn' His €r?€lience as chqlrman of the , councild ihe Inpaci of Ne; Media in socialv, or Arms. bar lert ure for m"r pd-ror-in', hi"f ot Sinsa' Dore PIe6s Hoid]nes'tn8li h snd Malay NewsPJ * Division (onvrft ed thaL I nr saw ol new m'
1'I
' ,];.,boJ
' ,
ln
-we L-v b,
ortuorrabl,
s'n '' \-oL"-or"' F,6daP. brdr o'!
rh." o" nu;ttrHj-n lou
rnr,oi.vojfut.' hr te l.lnsrEbt ll is a licF slaped by e year of visitilg seYe!
.ro'l)tri:s. conductinE focus group djscls3iors cross-scclior wiih the !)osr for a rsDort on hne IeErnrtion a
sii]l
thinl thri js \rroii: " dc.hres ihr !cie(
But, he adds, "t Nppose ii nlDlies somc discotr can uderstand b€cause there's a lot of dl slructive cynicjsm in cyberspace. !eople use an(
n).n iy and easy access io post comentsi som( limes they shoot from the hip. I "so it's like the wild wnd west rNofar as publ lLu rail:,'
didloguc js coDcerned."
But
th€re.re lso
"habitable places"
n to rrf lr .nF4Ti "n*'j'rou -":r l,i- :-- ?j. }da;i.s";i;Tl-. idq+.tr, 94\ in fact, irm irr. e pl4t&rm }her€-yorlsq dra. ^r. irrr !"-.rjl -rn . l 'l a. rrJnn.n -n lr rr r ;J;ir-$r-D..Id
.
and enBagcment
media on iraditional ncdia.
lx ll
mernb r parel
sJ
"p
l; ih r€Dort r€lcased lasi wee!' Ainis recomn,""aea u'ai rt e cou"'nmer' adopt e-en8asemenl ., DoL v, whi.h would be a l.di.al deparlur€ from th;.!ftnt consultatior taking place olrline d€. idec whrl i wdt. dj No*. rhc Covpnu
cyb€r
,zJ dd roioflo$.\r. -tr T" p "ri::-tJ. ,\d i ove m
ir)
M, r.hconl dnd
D
spac€, he observes, such as ile spaccs crealed t mainstream riedia players Singapore Press llol( ings aDd Mediacory SingaDore. He also notes thc serious and thought provokir viows expressed onwebsites such ar The Onljne Cil
of th€ publi. md holdjng dialogdcs adire bloggers here' in lrepsrati''n whele SingilFore should head h on-
noi'Led br th-c Covp:iraenr jn Mdrcr l.'l ved lo wth cruz"n( r-o" s5" ru;.." ^. ioo1 "ngag.ment " ia cvof developments the lighi in ought to ch?nge,
b,
fori I
'(\\!.r,f,1 i'lr'", ' pJ\11'r.\ i \i,
ing to b€ a major chsnnel of com'nunication gojrg
tirl)n, rrrintl
nevspapernur, quite appa.cntly se:zed by ihe li€f that new media ca no longer be ignor.d.
'.
He s3ys tbe sterd
|,,i .!1..'to
loli Io,!
:ind relircrs," h. sal's Hnn€ver, what is terliatrs rnost strikng
V'.heonp
rrew or
ll. r'npd.I,I
Th4 biggc.t chlllenge fac rg traditional medja to find ways io continlle proliding value to the
Despitc decad€s of flippx)g through newspaper
for his daily dose of nerrs. he now confessesr
do|'t rely on n€wspapers to tell
n1e
onrqaijons to ove.throif ihe goverDment in
"i
I
there are deD Bang
n€cd the nelrspa!.n to telt me lchai is yo!
lic nohL\
I hatp.,nErhprp.$tut it"l 'o iriJn 1L, lobl[-\,T 'n. f r! .| . ^hytr.!! t. rr,d rf" '1, . olr'(. tdp"r. n.l qrcarer rrcmim on inrl\sls thrn most "\ '". . :T,6-0 p , ifi ,n;"," \. u .d.tdedr_lno !-rd r',' \ .. /.1 iL. o,^... ll .cr
DrdN ofthelonvelsations wiil b€ initiaied bv
[email protected]
"rr
,L.ed byN'ring".o1
ulJrjonprPcr onbe
ror
eramDle and invites citirens to respond q,,i
ri-.
en;sdec
arornol\L lriF'd inte'" -
tionbetqeen the G;vernncnt and citizens on pnh-
j wilo " nro ' -oo arr up p ce\ in whrll inte!.,"dc i? r."nctn ol\p"ldg"numberorpdn;iM, ( rLone
In iehl rha- eoLtg b) lo u ,omnrr'. oned b' AIm publ'
teLL.
oi rsion "'. " tor 'u h e-FlaasPmen i "ovcrwhe nut. -Linor .; ,. reet rhev ar€ d,. u-rra dmong lh"n-
selves,6dt a v€ry irportant paru to the conlersari.r i! mic.ifd'r hF srvs
i,
*: +.t
-sL
e, ,.
.F
'i
"^+t
+..
l:i .' + ;6E -
E-3:16.,'
5
:+oqi
+
-E .6P i.
IlgE'-'d {r"F=-*E F '-;=r-!:;i qiFD_;R'::
de
:'":
'.
5
- a.ziL e 9!Bg
= 3
4e:f *-= " 7i 7,-q' "i :6iFf Es'EF ",r&F s
e;.P;r?ag :*:#3i4=Hb -&lFi €e4=TE s i: f: 'i:FU, :-* q €-E -E F
.T
, .& 9E? irSLlo' S r'. = *e-e ; U
0
t
L
&
LJ re*;b Ne
q) F) Fr \r
g) o
()
a)
o.
0.)
t OJ
F,
€
c)
-T
o) 0)
a
o c_)
F
o)
5
bD O 0.)
.13
g
-E -d O
0) (E
E
o
(\)
.lJ
o\)fL--
bD <1.)
o)
o o. *lE
ii-:
i€.;: ;;; ,f;jti
ij iiiir$$gEi q':{
;ii,iuiiii;qii! iii:iiil
El? € 1iLg d
gggaE i-3ii
{ 6-"i "at€ r 5E
€isEir€tE E-."r iE e i
9 E€ 7.
i; E;fHl.i*EijE^ E-^3Ei F:E=
5:H € il*EE;:it g ArBl
r,
ir
a ii=2e e zE -*Ei 3.8 3€-:5 ts 5
-9
,'
l!'i t ,rj *"tt
T{BET RIO'Ts
China ac:ffitlses Western media t:f distqlrtimg ffacts ik jiriq t;ke', I i : lr:ttqri j*ul r;:;l il:tl i': 1;be{: in sl*tr'r its;!cie 0f cli:nit Bv SlNl
(l
A5 CHINA chaferones
a
iourn.li\t< ! oup of ioreiSn , T bFt l1 .ry toL rhe tLi\t
tine since thc \torst an ri Chincsc nots in tNo dec
ldes broke oul r.rcently, Bei
jr.8 r' lr,,rd,t s ,rl \JSrn! llr uun I op. ! 'i dr $i 1. .c{ tr,!.i rn iddih' n , tre D,LicLr'[re t,'r
L.lF f.rltri,'uL
d5
r.ircLl reDorl! on LlLc dn r.n, s.li{:'l a(o nig to B.i tnrs lras krllcd al
l.isr
n e Nn nedia Lrcre lrrve r!. iLlegin-e
.u;le lse ol images
Ln.':
or loot-
b \ cstern me |i , !t lrt! rn uJrIe LNN rrL'i ,rc
EI]C
''Sr)mc Wesledr Iicdia
.eglecied ihe facls and lr. 5ented Jrnor rrJ ePor t ng toL nl rc than !0 dJ\ 5, thF olticial Xinhua !.qG a gency
said
in a conncntary
Ti.se
on
stori.s. conntete
s'ilh scrcer shols ol the ol ien{lnle Dredia, a!!ear to
ha!e ireen based o. a Yo lbo anritei rfteo ac eusing the Wenern tredD
.t
Flr
f.\elJ
. ,nrlP Ch .r
natemerl for Inis,traichinB a Mdr.h ll7 thoto ol clashes h.tr,.-rf tLn fibcl 1 olts c,, rD,i I I tre rn llrpil ail
rot.e I'rt rLllri'8,n lr mrs.i. Clr,. r r:,, I
l,I rnE ro uliLb hd,
beer .irc!htj.g
on
tensive 1.!s rnto a dc.Ll wcll oI rrotul.r Ch,nese nr tionalisn s'tnch has scen CNN geLl,ng lDle Lrlls .nd threats rn rcc$!l da,vs
'Ihc rercri!ed
sniear
canpaigr bv lht Westcrn medk has sr! id Cbinese n.riz.ns Lo D.st onlinc n'cs lri c ,r. br '""c' '.r"rn .LLll l\l rr rrstc:dr ''Whxl vo! c.r fLrd in \1esL_ err nr-eJr!? Nl.griJi.enL lrish aDd rnrlrag'rolLs liesl" 1,i rnr!e rri .rse. Xin hua ;n'Nldr(ht3N!1 tb.1 PIi
lV
RTL
had a?ologised n, x
car)tion sdvins Clntese Po lice were cracklrs dolvn on a
N utu tL.d .ll Ll.rLN ol.lrs lrrred L.verJ!r, the ( NN s hrh r. . a.cu5cd .l del,t, eraLelv croliPiDg srone LL, !$ lxr rroler\ uIi.f J Irr r,.. rti,t shoued :rflr iN{:ks runblins nlo Li].s.i,
ir a stalemenl iL had nred the lDage Puely
said
tD
for icchDical re!soos .Dd had capLtoued
r1
acctrmlelY
Anilvsts said ihe e.ros
lvesieni nedii olliits ;feDrcbablv dte Lo sloplL ne$s. and bi talkine thenr rp, Berjins aould be lrylns
lv
2?
ln receni d,rYS
le athv sloics
sra;ni. Ioolagc oI Til,.taDs
dren.c, tlcijinE s medix ot
YlN
lN Brl)rNti
rN,,
vate (;rrman bro,rd.!srer
tilh !ic l n., ,r JS i .lJi en rh, r\ ., rd L).:ir:s -L ,l
Pla\'i,rs to a doDestic ar
Chhd CattcsPonLle l
,
Live lnter !r. ws
llnc
5ettin13
r{:.orts
or lh.
reccnL
Chinese medix has cited
exanrlles
Lo
I lron tll ,, ABC:.Jphun lu, r pelt
L tlee,r
Some ol lhe mcdi! .tr|!rrts nghlghtld Lrt'
i
ilarb; ccTV req\pi '.r Clrin, Dril\
wourded terso! jnro an
NeDel q'as sxid Lo bc ol
hr\r' ihit ,l sh!wed IhLnrse pohce hehins !n+
n'1. I \ldII carr!
!
r
German newspaper BerlineY MorsenPost: LdPt o. t.i r !rebstte DrLtuIe in rns Lie ti^nr\t 'nd ra! h.rne ralcn aNa) b! DUh,e wlci tlrr rhot., r,!ur!h +ro n eJ 'oolicc in Lhasa rescuine : Han Chinese assatrLted
[Ihile {]hini, lcteli lhese ,lir.rsnrs aL tlr rveJ!t)!. n.di.r. oueiilotrr Ic benrr m,$i oier n!,ninil req'; l,h.kour aDd !vhil [)1
television RTL: N? r.lcs. s.crnir lor.es 'Iibelrr frirLsleN wu.
lowcd:
;
r{LL}i.PuLt,' Id !ltr.tr' , cre,l ae|'LnH i^m' ,, r .i ,i . ii,, ., \ uhnle
Ch0csc !eL'1d$ nr Ir! websil,r thrL .lrorve.i
Lr form.J pdun[ 'vetr IidiaD !olice oflicers
rhe,.tcltlidlaitng .l . rnrc sid.(l accoinl .r stil. tele!rsur. .ccLlsirrg the Dllai Ln.,. s diqre' ol pLd lg the {nren
'llr..liI
lcitdres.do
iJ.nlrli(al ..i allinese
cNN, 1r. r, ... ricl!rc r!lo1(l.d br
to craSgerite such errcrs F.i.. !r"raed ni his iai(e.
roL n.LIsn D,o{e5!., v, t;,r,,n,nLp ol' Rermr UnL g srL.ll.,s. '.:srr, .lii ,P.1r .,l,rn, L t,i\ \ould !nt be kncLated ervwher.. buL
tlc
Chrtcse lhornd aho "lis
te. natienllv to tbe crilicil vie;s pat ;ul bv th. wcst Desnitc
iis
Pledses to
oncr jp to loreign nedia ah rd,l l,L L,\nri,iL' Be trng I'1,.1 nurr Jr,l llu\hrf ioLrre, ou,, al cr\ ou1 of Iibet, nhe1. \'io
test5 btokc ont lasl D'eeh
huck. wilb otre shownt
clposc srch
television N-TV:
.drrt.1 froic-.sor at ti.l!c1e1! ol Calilo,nra ar Llerk.l.). said "lbc eL ,os car Ilrdlv be lnte'T)r.l_ . c.. , Ll .l, ^nspirJ'! \ i,,, .l1u,r ThL 'il.R, tions are an ove.reactnnii rh,:
.nd elhnic Tibet.n !r.as iI Sr.br.n, G!!su and Qurs h.i where a ltavc o! Pro
'delileml. ttistakcs" r.revision
]vledrr fxfcrr \iao
Oiane,
lenG .iuDt.d on M.1ch l'1.
ihe rtttird straight
lN AN atlemlrl lo show the $rcsien iredn ,s
lo.lell.]c irLemalion.l crill cisn oi its d..Ldown ir'li-
, Fox Tv:
C.rPrr
,. iu
ar,n,ese miliL.Lr\
\, Lr r un,L nrolr P e ,n,., \ Lli lLrhrn ,nr e l,sL weoli, Beiling rodNl' tooli I .reiqr loi rnrl -t | .r thrL! L .r\ cpo tirH li rP I ' Lhxsa. F t ili€ mov. hds s.arked oles .1 rlnfauness oironE to"mahsts rot s.icct
At; rculi,,e press conlel rr! resr"'dJ]. u,eLUn Minblr \ \pDl_esmJl] Qr ot Li rA ii'cd.l.LrrgL .Lrc.n!ns !rt that rnd .b\lr .ies Lr in {oreisr lounal' isd;av in relorting llcTi L
A rotrch crasDer?ted, hc .lei.nded rhe 1o;k.joa'n b1 savinp trial repoli.rs lvelc leare lroluL spols
';dcio ft', r,.uit-v
reannrs
r
d lor
l\il .ne .rror1$ r.b!L r.!l: llo,id thos. areis hrve 'Lrecrr n!)L dangciqls thr. LFq r)f,\lSharrsl.r'l 5EE TDIT'4RIA!,
f€;H :+{r ::+
if!: is *:l=e:j ! sifiiF:jii€;:i:
E:t€:q.+r E:si
;sis;;i:;i;ixi
;i+5 g:!€ i:ii" g!E!,;FiP;-d,:€
l:iffEq;i,EiiE
t:? EE Et :; id,;zlFl ;E:t ::: s€i: [!iIf s;:ii,*E ;:jiEfi
;s;ffir#€i
a)
o
a !) tr
F
5
a l-{
{,
p
9r : E
i s
r! tu
bO a.) b) t-i
o
c.)
U1
()
z
.;t;;q:oE; E16i! : PEE B;q E EBB J
d q) a.) l-.{ o a
v
6
;fii;i:fflf;i$iii iiii#ie*fifiu,fi *t;;;**u+;
z :
ri
:-.E
ii*xii,j:'*;
giEg'
e:
''E :;fi :EE-3!F -E
G)
5
"", ! l;:i:! :i. *:i"!- . ! ir;l "";'"" ri'.r:r,F:Ii.'-i+r_, ,. i :E.;i;!:;+;-" :t' :!+ :! ;, ;,: ;:,i" " .'ir.;F:Erlri;: ;i:' i: --'i: jt i; ,:;l ;:,;ii,j,,;;;;i,.ili,;,, i1 ;;"li ., i- :;u r!1eJl ;i;P-i.l , :,:,'i: l;;''i:'i ;;:;i;; *9 . " !-.t ;:i:; :;l!Et^f*!i 1.0
,,: I
; . \ it-= !-Jl
1""qajtE. 5: j.T F
".i': i'l;i,;.,:";",; i"ii+ ;;;iirii LiiE :';,
ii
3 o
i
=
r
*it:;Eirt:: Eg'.:s--ti-::
q
€".f i :E; d! F! Ef:
- " i;;."" ,,ii , H a l:r:,tirli; -:tsi':ra **:i*r*'l: ,,=; i=;ui,*,i, !i r.,": l: i :tps;;:ai r= "l ;;- ':i :5:.;iii!:
!i :,E:
' ii:
.-E=.i: ; ;: !IsE
:;i;i;*i:i':="P1-/
titi>
: i:
::Esi
,.
i$ rU;-'
";"n Elqr[f; ;i f5!tz' .-;j.!3 r E-!=::'€ i&li :
:"it';.iFi; i,E,:*",1P"!9;t' i;!i;! c:i;: "'; ' :; i 1:;5 ,::=! ! !i
-:"
d
l
e
(n
U
H
F J
o A
c)
r pn{
p
O
z t-l
H
a
rl]
z
c)
-1 H
ti
fi
d rl
o :ll
riui ,;iltll :;:: I*:ht;i; a;*;j,fi;'*;
!tiiii:iigii::'i ;il: *;i!' 91+
-c
:;; ii F
tt?i!:;'!I't
-
i !s €; E -E=€s *4p.sB €g .E'=E-! k g $;< il ^.! rE 5 i.=.s i:6=e ;E -. o 6'g d z .= i *r i F:" i_ ; € E j : : ;
Eiss*ts€s !s!EI:
i :,TF
*,* irui*ffi*il'
t,Eo.
;
t'ki:a!cY
;:
,, atP - -6 : !6 t,, u!
4
is;isrs :t a-2?za@ i:
!ElFiEH:eli .E3*:ti 5€ Er ii1". i(: iri zi: :: ':a=-
245
-i y?tP !gr,,i:r-
lz r; >6 Zt 4F 9. Yt
E!;;.:;: qYoegSEd-:
la .t: - :i !g=:;"::!:
.
--EiE!lhdE; 3
*11t i bz6
r.a
i;i)!:r: t ju a. Zit=,o,
'i
Ear't:"
a
:! =; . -- -:'.a.,-= \:=, .'-
i: =iii'-jr i:-r .: -.;;, ;=
:s co
l: t:..::r. rt'l-=. ij 11.: a -:l=.
:z::4-
c.!
3i23r:8:1F;;i;:FE E' t iSIEE;EpEr
.t11=t iz.i : : ':1. ._Lt = :1.::, . ;
|
s 3
t4i
i;i:
z E k
!'
€;:e i: 93:.5!&
t
I
1\;-;Eita:!.?' =
:i 1r)
1a2:\
:! ?:;
!:
e6ag SilF -
.:.: :-- a
.: f :: :,., s
-"
i:i;; :ii .=F::!: i:b, , P T1,=;
!?!
ta !ii ;.E :iin :;
-,:: -
;s;tui;
: ;r
!!+ e;issgi 3;;r i:5€d€
3i:suEg;:i ];i;i
!-;3;g
I,\y:i?r,ft,j,:f€i5gii$#;,Slt*;*1{i5it*,t*
\r
INSiGI{-f
\tP r04J,
aar,i
i: t:r'f
0nline debate is easy - the real challenge is in taking advocacy to the people
BY
L-rk{ .na
c1gss^ Oo\
r\'!iDore
s
-.!,o D,,1,
ir*r rlD" .Fv ofiidivid,
slLh-|n3, Plofe5!o' wsliei rression giv.s drem the rishi
u!< humm rr2rrc to iurrb
rh.L po,n-d ;sendr\
cates
wiih ihe sam; r,.\n ot
lcan tuo .6Dce'!ed bloEpds ro.hiriense hi (rdru{r. no
'CYBER
MA-T.TFRS
Flurnan rights: **i:[1i:*i;:*:. Going beyond ffi:r*.:i:t* Internet Chatter Mr Ne E J:v wore on dre Ilos sre The oltrne citizcn
'rl!. righrs Lo lreedom or
sid nean rjgha commissi6, nRn tu!r,i!- --.h bo s doqr 1! the kind ofPoweFAs*n n
On l,u,n;n rahr. ese.t !leni\ !J i knee rerk" !c!ist Dd b.,""-- s. s"id selnnar He is .\si, .eaional direcior lor the Genewa bascd ce.lle i" aene,.r. ri., .r, ^,e.n riF r"r", o. h"; oFerabsas thtoj i D r e , .. , c . c ^i! reglo|whelenationalsow€r. , ,
Lr.or {,""i. nho
; ,
,
.
,
Trre
M;laysian comnnssion
Prrh"nci ; 19ee rnd nis r,enddi.c r "".-". FonE in their linse.s !,r,r d n{.rdIom;n!
rat!
tude tow*ds nlhE Eiues
whtlE tr 6 ieaireD,,,. ,. ."e the b.A,"i,"e, n;;b
n:rro!
"t re]afeddebatehere'atsonrc
humao rrehis
{ho]]IrvaureenMaroney'{L
said Nr5 rl,e Asia Fii, ni F.i,niafnn raseo lrs sub,id was.re Je.l sbiritv or a lt;naD{iPhrs conr
clanLir Gnbriel.
the
nsha pr;ccss is . g.od Fl..e Truc, there ale brsic h! n,an nshts standards
rrnqt, ad-
bur rhc,r !oi r ,;hi-,
6; <en:
rnti.r !on Dor, ri, , HL"i,,, nrh6 ..r\o.i.r JmourG io kind of Lalf skn!,Gh. halt ' wnile ft_is crsv t" """"gh LlrrouPh rhe rnr.rn.r ti!r; r
clElse, fs ]o!E rid; dul soo. rorndnia,-a charler sigred nr November Las ver! has firil rv rcsor,ld to ;.eatc n r.nw iar Lr,s
o!.,o.lon ","i",.,,.
offrt,.. ,"1" pr. :-".r
,Dd
tfr
,\'N(;CP('RL'S
I LLL( OMMUNICA'I'ION\
MARr{',7
0",.
Seisrnic cl range in tkre air
Th< co, J!])se!r
10,red
o
drar EcuDrbe.rs
d !r!1ir,
ca! !Dr!r
.r!!
rh
Si.!rer
onrr.'
D'c,,,!
d,roi
hi
irn
r- !,-!-
ri, H!b
h
rnioor Lcnj-!:
lmagine if you had only one fibre-optic cable in your home and you could select the b.oadband service you heede.t or the TV programmes vou wantedTh's rs not a fantasyun,n-,rErerr! r'rnJ'II.e\-ilLl!('J
,.,,
o rr ,!,otn-
r,,\ines
!. ..r5"n ",, .";.
],
I mp p"L . Dro,," ,rra dr!JLl.jiood(]
rtrir-er i,,,.,i-rr. , - , o c- ,,f. ure ,.,.i,n; ,
tj
J
s
t
; *
M
;*:i.Hi
l,{) ;;'; r'3
;:iirb; ::!:::5 3iie:a.r Ei,!eC3;
i::E; iI
3
E
ot;-.:-t
v i
B
i
;5E - df
i
EO
:q" ; :5
5F ! **
seq;*
: ;9i5;
!3El;;,I33 i =:Ii5
E;EgE:
ru;;;;j:
:i !;i: ::;: #g a- e: +1i
:9:e; :iP s; - i:;*! ; E:!:: !3 9;=q.;; ei
E
L a€3-""* O;s;Ei9
.:
;E;= s gEl
f :'E
3
3't
di i;'at e:-€ig;
E
F:i!T!'i
5
;:i$4r: --! !si -i !:
E!2P
,
i;.E
"Br " E. ! iEs
:!
lg ;ii"j . *U
;: i:;9
;-;:=
:ii
lr::;j t;::;r ri: =t;t;;:; ;:, :l:. jl;!ii11ii:' !d ii:,i; ;i: I xq
).2=i5:.
) li;*:?
a
il l,i: !: " iz;j:1 )
i:i;!
;r r; ;;;:r. 3 6
ltlitri';'tti'iiil;ii"iiiTiilifu
iiiliiiiiliil;lli,ililiii!;i*g ii
::;:i ;';i ;:: := -: =,
3a
E!
d
*5
;9, :e &.,
!'r
t:1
::.::
1;jr;,;,';;;, ;: a0 ,ii:r;i=:i':; ;; +d @ -l FI .F<
\J
-U
dJ (fr @ Jd Frd
=l
!g
JJ
(-.
d F{ -3 ()
oFq
U
m
qJ Fr prl
65
.tii ifi; ;;a FA : t C ,i\r1r.2)i a = tt .ait,:":iri ho E ;Eii;-.,iri.r ol4 € li :r":'::q-=::: - >!
q:-;:-r:-!
d.,.1
AN
wr H
p,6,;;iir*_;.,: tr 5: ! ?rEZ \.-,
bi' ! js iliy 4 I i; Jfra; i?;;i ;:: B: tri i i ':. l iii;lii: fi;ii ;:i ri l. s, s !gr:; l5iin ?;;;€il\ir1i aI ;i ;!;;"!il H, ! h4 ur9 : Erti tl: ir f,rr;" ;61 ' i 8ll !fti;lii;g;ii;i ;ii l; {: ; !!-,1!:i3iI c; ; :Et;{l;*fiii{!i ;t! s;i t" rPritrltrrlgiifr; .; q.i 8Yi E
!l
b
\.
rtfiiifliii
3e
3
ts14
o
i!ffiq$$iitrFifixil[if!iii;ii
qtr
\)
P
E
!3 E1
i! :l I :
Elii qg
.i
5
'5
;l E! I
iiiiiEiffiiiiiiiii,i l
oi!
-- 5>:
t;;; i!iiiir$rii!13i$
b
i; i;riE:ir;cig,;r *: B! fi fiffg!;{iic?fiig l.niz
i?iii
F
"4J:
s} l;inggifili?iia
FJ \
a) N h
tA1J
,
a.AE
g;{i{iiiiitlE*iiti iJ
ri0r ;Alo.o
oo:4n.6
i#lsill
>
\
t \ \
bl
e
gil*silfil
u): il \) \) \
9i!
:
v
L,J
*,!!e oq'6X J
v --: -ouO
-9 \, \).
ill llilill
li
tJ..
U
0,,
x!
HT
O
CA 3 d) p-E FE
A', \J, E:fl;g J'r -\
(^.d;C
lifiiiiiili rlir illlillrl i*lii il liii
,ra
€ E3€€f.
t )-{ ur+t-{
E-E;--FF= ? . 6 34
I-{
!.8
-)
-O \*r rG) (-1 p t-{ -{
i-{.-1
io r
)-{
(D
oo 6 oo l-1 t-{
c) r-
l(J J \./
f-q l&{
"= s€€: i?+ :;? E Ef r , "d.=z E,- E *
:FF;
FI
sgg=
Ee€e
E€
E; iE
5l
Eli Ee
F": F S-i' = .5_qE3.Eg
,€ilgc€3a$38
:;Eaaag5Efgg€-
EE
Esle*a 7-p+alz
E"FE=
=€:-9 E.!lE E fe€ ae!{39s} :1 o E 4 x: ! *-
E;};E: ii*r€E€r€ ;fi s*:5 5 r3
=?
-i
E!€
!:EE siSi E A.E EAEa.23 =
'F q ! U E
E"';
F
EE.1 oE :€5i 3E E.E! -+Bs c g€5€ €iEE €Ed?Q;.---o-
;€ FEEE€;"F -*c;3=*tsFEe *9E+*-5:cr+ H
EE*9€.8'gEE :S. *EEE a= e d E- d
1;i E-€+E -e?E -5 3 ;EiE tsrl U=EF 4
tE
--*-
I
^.6 -i"a€
Eg;E ff;-d;f>E"*91 E
! HE :3€
SiEEi
+
E
5
"E
(t) 0.)
co
.9 5
O
a >>
.E
&€=i19+E€E-e re .5lE EE i.,la€l €3i€i€€* e3 43EC <
E;s E.* +! !Pc€EEs-l EE ? +g!-;e
$
E E! H:;*5E € i; F"uE;!E*+ s.g
q) Lr
a
!l *l Erg
EfFaE€e:] ;€ E E Eg-s.El :lEEI e -=l E EE;;E€€€I 3 E:E 3l :l I €l il*l g et";ii:: E :.-rj€ Se* :l :l 5 :i!334E';ts :1 EE5Ee-lEE!tu -E :i:l g*l *E s* E;l ;lPI ii flE;:cElEil€€ g EE 9 :3 d 9 5: iEE *l 6 isl-;l{[E'E . * il=l e-e*iElHEFIgE'
€l;l€
E €giE€€e€ > :. - s.ji !.P 6:
iser *Et.ei*:et .9;;E5
-si:]
3;:;agEE
EEis
€
E
6l R
?l.t ,;E El
iElp.lE E]
i . 3t,lul9
an
;r fl BF 3*I;l 5l€EI E'l# El; llEl€i
El*
1?t
cl-l
slF al €
s E;i. :ElE I:11;l3l ts13
d
E E€i€€-:€3E
E:*;,a",??E
E_4
E E
H€
$?fi?
E13€ E E El? $€
-P' 3=CeiE?13 *?€i
F i
Rt
9i Er
Jd!ffi.c Etl.;iEEtf,2 a ,F.6
Cg
q.)
,za
g€r
E
:
B
E
P S
t:E-+: : Be E --E.tPp
5=;
€ €€E* s; ! EIEiElA .ggc R'EE !4 Ai!-i Y ;kldi €€ 3 837,- guug €g? qH .e2 aB.sd :E6l€de g?E EE; * 56 O €€€lgflg',€t 'IsEh>€ €E= $E €ig ssE g:e E€ 1 ; h+ (-) !;6 -tE fe€e Ea;iiffi€r; i B5 e;'Z"daeP-= (l) 3
OD
(-)
.E p
€d.e
Hi
A-A:d .9 5
a
S
a€e E.z
!-7-4 cA+ ia: EleesEga:* i.Ff E3= &c i E F?+3Ei !;e.er
:iEE;gEEE f 3* F eEE 5pa
+J !./
Eeaga€
5-
, ct)
rkO
j€ :HE=E *EE ?EEF" -a: t-c
:
Ei
;l e;l=aEEI4 E:E9liil Ell 315 Hts s': 3l: jl €13 €l :15 rl€
EEE1;,€FEl€i
;1
t1€ €l€l €l €i
"81
Etd
J
!
-o t! ,j;.;;* ; :;jei!;i E:; pii:st ,r E i [; -P -:i - 9;E gi: -9: E - i jl;itie:lerr., d N i;+ C) 3 r;!;i;E*gqibl;Bit b0
ili,i;i*l*t i; Fr I
3
F
i
;iitfli:i
? !J
iiriii=
o a.2tPd2 t ]-l.i
i.
.o
a I.r o
) 1)
00
,{
n 1)
I-{
tJ
Ei;!
g*E
t
C)
z1 ;lg
1tr;13
6
g
;E
ilE*;;iti;if;;,;;:i efflEtji3i!iei$jifti ;ci*€E3€: g';;';i-A;r
Ar
;*iii: i;iiii'iiH;ffi a
;;i;: :iri,iei i{Elfifudf f,gj ilrE
Q
r
$[d;|nf
rl:
;iliiiiff
ii fi ;i!sif,tiislSi:
a
iiiiiiiiiiiiiliiiiii
k
:6 i
;l{ ql: +t;'i
Bi.ail
: S
a! :lt oo ,d a c6 aEi jl$ E1:tffi:
'f!
(.) I-(
o i{sffi ltrl n rliiiiiiiiigilgsil; iiBffiiiffii g
3E
Eli;
"lE -
s3 rH
a
O
Ell;ffif;iiill€
(g
eA-r ;l{ flf,sil?: E.9E? E]H T{ r $:: !r F; ! i?!te;
O
)
(,)
t;i:
Eili t3tsgs5;
""1
-€E€ q$
ii;iiitii?iiii:ii;ii
+;l€ illlitg ig o
ii:
a
! E!,* ? ",En fl€iry ,r!:E
a rit iE;l*i;X ;l it; a
iffiiri P 9"..;;
iiEi;iiilili5EFi i:iii;€"Eliliiq:;
L
:-iE;
i;i s: :: ll; li :r;
E
?:it ;ltr -t 3l.lffE;
)
J
d,.r
ELI
I
)
ilEl J
;iEiil;li ii:; ii;-
dR FP H!F::IFi; ri: C.l:5:rE€
€
1:H:i ;!a;: 13
i{ ;::iiiilu i;ru
frfr 14
E
€E=.=E.E E E e= i=
!?
--=
=
>
E s€aa€ y. H E+) 9. gEE =8. -^E
TEzEEa *-= d;i9=
L
9< 6 E(J
= i=-6--EZ1
o
dEE=
S:2
-
= -E -
-
@
=E E-=EEE.=
i:* a aaEE=, - A td=
_d -d ?', -2 az
ts E9 -" 6 t E €€.S =g=:-= 9 -a.: @ = -< 1{: !! F
<-r -ci,
R
E H -+-
i =
* E
5 E€. QP E -a.E-,+ a a ?* E =E
S c-)
q>
H
cl L>
a
=E=EZ=i.€e AA ==€E
5
5=JEg=E ==E EE EE€EEi= tsc E=EE= BH E# E-F€=Etl 3*
v€ >F€ ='= =a
.e)
E
ga
:!t
a:t
-9
Gts
+
-?
o
E <
€ qE a= EE € F_9 ZE=A -=3 = >e;.9-=iE
-9
a)' I-
=?=:5fr; o= A€€E€€3 3e z+ 3= € hr 9 .E
=H-ioF-.9.e
c;^ "d;
.aJ
xl'e
.E
E jj
.3
4
€E 5
-s -e
e
9
a
F,
.!-
F R
a.
a e= 'A *E 3 E €E .it o :oa E 6. =
Ez E'i, aq -i1 ?
€gq €F E aa E z q E -i ::* '=t
b :e .E;
a;
gE
€-6 Y-E d-=
e'
5EE€€AFE H ff g I €-3 3 r
r g .* zlE H -e g-a-E 2 B -: u= e
rt5
p.E Eb .?,e-= E E€-= E E<
EEc E{-Ee
= H
EEEZ7,2
eEe s€EH *E.sa?? +cE :.q +F-E3E i S
=E E,ntr EeEkEeEA;EF E3i C,
3eE g =€:e sF=
€€ 9=E -- E =-
+E= E:3 a?= + 'iia= _.. r.a:-
EEE€€F€€
-:31 ==€ C€"E E :E b A .=)
€+€g---5.H3,:€E = g
=8E:E
=,=-
g
H=
a a:d F egqEEV4€= E;-*EZaEe g
-5E
€-; .2=
E.a i-"i-.^.d a fr
=e
3:4. :z-e-iz s€ g'-?e i=
EE€"E€ EE-gEEE€€E 'e, = .lE€ E eE z9, SeEE*E -E==..";=,q
.e{
:;€
4
ae
= = 3.E
E
re
=-E=-*.Ats.=eeA-E=AZ E A- g+5 E 9"=- I E-=p -.3 o E _=.!i E qr: -A E *{;-= ea
t_ d€'i 9"o J.J(-F
E EE+= E€EE 3 ; E iE€: EEZ' E EE€= E;=3 E I-?ad::-q",>.=9l
EACE6gs+E+e = € €eVEZEEE$fi?=: =€ 6S sE€;? g=€;=f i=
* ;,;
iii;':il
1;j:
mlfi
ffi'
ir'ri.
'
lii;;*
*=
;#TTtii
i?#i,;liii;i
;s i iia;i;;;t i#i;iHtl::;i
',;l; ;.1'1 ii; ':i 'i,:',';;i , i-.i,'; :_,;,:,,; r'i,;
;
",;'; i,=,;:;,:.i,i;.:, ;;ii 'ie
EF
;E
3€ }E
.€
::,.;ll,i,J;;;;'rir
;;iri:tu I
il;:md;;Hdt;
l, ;l ;iiiir;*
i;ii#:; :ij#;i:
ii*liig;igff1;'{il,
tia -g: 7t; 4
bfi
si il-
2E
'!!
l&
?9 e
HA
?"n
q.E
5
.E
E
\;u'fi*ilii,i##;ffiiii;
.rr rtr. A,..,-r:
More help with up baby ..bripging
4 announces measures .v encourage peopJe
"
have more children l
jy Lt Xurnwc fl ]IruCAI, CORTISPOADINT I
iM[ Mi]lSl[R Lee H$en ""hBed
f
Loona
r'Bhi in to the cootrowBrat issue
en.-ragDg -5ingaloreans..to-iave
?
I
ona a8ain
wh{
he sDoke at _
N:rDndl Day Rally ihtr yed. Ihis i5 the scond tine in iour vea hat he hA hckled the hsue. tbe fini be.a,his inaugural r&lly in zOot. le mounced a ralt of neasues rh.t
lcost the covdi$ent $7oo milion a
q,
bugiag
jr.o_hitffil
to
hp!!!!&!tls}_e]!$i!q_slp!!4!t: D,&usLDfu&enihood. fhe mersues mclMe. bo,e $ar€Iaity rwlol-trrlrlhers, noF ld i!@nrNX f or aving child&n, Dore subsidis for chitd, ,,iore leave toJ parenh to care for a hc chld, rd ryeniubsAe
M*"r-
4plodlltion iechriquer while DeDUt! Prhe lvli ter wnn,,
,
Seng
- who
{iI
r\sus -
s in rhuse of popul,: piovidenoF derais on
. bulk ofthsemssu$ at a bres c.ir4e loday, pM ke in h\ tuiv nn sni- dght Fovided a few of lis ;wn. 'he lwo Covsnhenr mrtctrnatu!
its e so nged
.
. So.ral DeveloDneni Un,r rhtr' beyelolment aenjce, w l be
!o.s
to bcreqe synsRLer. ouhit wiJlalso do;ond,r: of private seclor datftig agencies to
lhis new su@
Uut thev ee reDuiabh
At ure famili tewt; larenh (wheihd )rornolh ) ca! no{ izltraid leave up
fioDi{o -
to coe
'19j!!4rs ' cldrJu tud!! sver yeaN old Tlrey c{ als ia}e sDaid have of uo wel
to
i oid
.le
.:reErrrF-nis urdi!-t$!
Eabv Bonlt
re!!s.!!l !e his Rrlly
ash irreniivs for
er!9,tdqd !9y9qqq.9
sp*.h,
Iir Le
!I!
skeiched
Jl.ilusoph) behrnd the (hsee\ He : ired il br .otuld$ons afGr n aus discursion wiihfocus groups dd
I
tr
tr
systenratic approach focued
or
es: geitLlg peopk mffned, helothose m red to have ald brihE ;F
reni belping parehis najiiain
life bau.!
dnd
tnjtly,
ricd Loulks to coh.etrc. 4 fiequeit thene
\
puioh
sn
u
hetDup
ner]'
knde
to bP moE r,tuJsed aoup[\ for
,nfl
shnuid \h&e
rc\poh!b riies ror
rhus-
The Pline Mnstq Droudtv rec:lted hnw h. hid.hdnged dEpe\ h; hl5 cht_ dren afterhe Aot mdried, and ihar hd h:d doft so wiihout pickbg ov babies.
(!o do it, tbrl mpM5 !nrbodr rD do he srd, be:flrr
Anoihr ro\t of
freqtreni thehe: th!
h nt
{fl r,
jinh.i,rl
babrc Thtr, hrnot!Lt. saj lirradornlly rclt mor rah J b, hrsh.
tr
Dronr. snmen, rs rhet hivsto loreln moE $ n.omP in lrder io hr\r hn p ro cde for a baby -),r\|]"rr, t,..,.
eaLe,
g"
I:1::1"1":1! :". :,,." copdSn "l ro eer p&enrs l'!_,lt!!jl
Ilaj 6
Mr
..11"' wd- i-a.hulorJy )]jll]a$nn
Le
nored u
rytv.
clrld({e \eriq h-deAseq rfdd-hf
rfies,
oay
,IE !!\snh€nt !,
1 budd uD
th!
rnra rhmgs rcB\ba rh. subridis ntr cbld; rqe5inB rhe qL;rhry oi.,,! arihe and
ilumshs
the n@ber oi
sinilely, ih. Covdnneri vrl]
be en-
hdring the kindequten scto alre.rlv a vdy "lively' one he noted. singaloEt beby voA go blck Ddry
.
pd 4d ro,pr wb. \
_
t
ar o
low nres.
i on.o,t"d
h"vedf sero...
L,o ,
hr I hak F(utr"d D or\ m.mrlsJh.
Tha,o.lrp,L rv,are, rh.r i. lp Mr Lrepo,."doJ r mb-ol b"be pq m',Fd wona ]rEle o. Lrlrlbd, ".;;;;i,:ir;, r,%.!o.r, li !t:!lpq Lerq- tt.r ap Jv nelr ,,-. , rlh , olomrc ol U.r or -i. l9e"red re 0 r. r. o)(. " .i.r t1p o - ,r.i.r,.. rr. 1rr-,rL..L".t.o.prbB(D ,. l00t .ori.m t../. " ".,"..i"^,t, 8"DorF'r omp..roLobrri-t tne.o,.rp,r..,,r"... "I.,l,r\drop.,. rjgrpoe! d,.,rud.n.r,;,,." i .
=gEF t -: , Insm.e
places
erEnding
the nFd Ior
a
talq's. caE or chidr_el Lrcludirg
{'..vd ..-.Lte. T" ur^
oh
I "d ,h"
d"oJ
od'. re\ari\. h.
tndpd M
fol, /e! . rn., ,.e "r.ndpd nEh.iehiiy b;ve to tb!@ sobtlN, and eighl prer.or. p u.! hdh +r, rMORI NATTONAL !,ar- .I er Dp.lons
RALl.y
RIPoRTS,
PRI
ru t
Mr I oh
E
l2-At0 rEDrTonAL pacEA2S plcts
.hot
I
rod
Bonus scheDe. Mr t.ee,s plearo sirsaporedns on d"' n
gn' P:"
-:se.orrrnrr \dler!" r es nive
r rrdlrrd happr
[email protected]
su
\ou, D..o
liJL
,
f
iur
q
9;
)-{
h e. q I
G i i /&{ t-l -
Fffi,
gr* - l!
3
." 1E
..t:
rlrl
E
a tt.{
oo d a ir{ t-l .F{ -r{ G oo F4 C) o) G L{ t-{d c.) O
,iii$ifl;i
u i:riEtiH:l::; ::ri-liilq';:$c '
EF
a lc
-1
;
E
h 6
C)
i^,ipN
;(r
'd'
lu
*9.:g
.EL
(,
j;:a e;rix;ill i?r*tEli$tE;;
.! .ii!
E
-t-t E;+E
E
3e > d)
'a
'
!l
El
A) I-r
0)
L. () I-r OJ
hD -l
bo
;l
;ei;:rEi
r"
Il
fE fi;:=r.i9P:l
E{€:l .9 9l E: yIE?;EEE
!rl *i
5;iFH{HE{;f ;{$il nEt
E;Elr
r; FFr
rI El
Li l-r
!ot i;c;?ftiiE* cf, Eiiiff;lii=iig$ .1;:,: ij lE 299 rd4ij! E.! 9ib i_ glEl siH ii*a i EsE fri; t€43t 3l: 5: ioXH E3f E:ea ! 43f ;E!85 $;{ i ElEl :lt *si er ti ! ;l A;€eft;#H;;AH 4!--7t "u * ir ! ei l*;f i!i -3 g; iltlli Eii ;nFE ; >i!!!Ei,-e tEzE ;l in 9r-a>Zz..,a.. 4r9-i t 4iiet iI ir:! ?q," ii"ljr ii:ki I= u:E€{!!r-3
P.,
E
x d
Q
6
lri
I-r €.)
lP
+J U)
ho O O bo I-{
e
€+ ,p€;E :E
3
Esl
LU
C)
L
9
fir"q r.-: s€ :l f€ sE!:i f,le*fl d;l *-!tib=E; d
ii;{gE;rn+i bD
9t-
:i;;;;"9i{;tJl ,tc tF
I-.r
tr
"3
!€ ;3
: F P{ El ' fl d -Er
fr5 :E * a& €EiEE oo;E; rE . 38i .E sl
0)
!lE lr
il C# fr 5.Sl dq rl e g:t * g
,E
.E
p
i,a, 2z
-l:l olAl
6b
r:
o
+J
boi
d2 ji!i
ao!
e
E
E
e
ouaqa
;
-Lo
^a^t:
E]
gEHflfi::F;,r+Ei !l il 8.9:tsi :. Ji-+a f;*e" *: frEi2':{4, a(A!: C. n ;a! 4-1'\ '-:. =4t
_a___
BY SLD-A^N CrrL{
BETITR II{CAGEMTNT
riFAl vel.ones the libcrdierion
irDwAy throuEh his N.lio!.t Day Raxy ldress the
rrine Mi'inbr
rished
ori ,
onounded by the Pri,Te Minisrer. 1.lis
rd pni.eed.d to l,lm tlr audiercebaf.re hih in the auditoriuh. Behnd hin, on a gisr screen, rhe audirce saw themselles featur.d on the wrh ige olthe Frine Mnistefs offlc€ live. ''There you ar., sihple as that I ve irst made our fi6i non lolitical yideo,, he said td hrghter from the audience. I Mr Lees candid cahera home.r hetd rerions point. Anyone cxn now be m hateui tiln naker, captuinE polihcs .n film, and leopk will do so. 'so, qe !esot to,llowpohncal sdeor lobjre
;hone
Ii.,rhtb*';;l;;*-"hh
m;;l;-i-h-eAiI
ed
Feoplc can dasily mske ejdeos
vnl Dcrease the opporrunfties for S,nEalor*nrlo give then views and allow
por jtj cai
padies to
iett{
engaEe
.yber'cilizenr. PAP wilt opelate responsibly Fithin tbe new and
e4randed boundaies to ilforn. educ,re xnd rea.n ou to yomger voters r[ough !:i,.D\F itrom\ OlcdI, odr soat,, to
.rerte arDndu've en! ,.nh.hr
vheiner onlhe or *ithin rle re;.rar lublic, for politjcal issues to be dis.us,ed senddy rnd produ!rrvelv. to help find 5oluron5 rof.haDenses ti.i
roii",,
Mkdbn rfidlG
lv! for H.,, P f o$djb{ !..Etiry llprdrr duiia.nd ns h.di')
uDload
the. .the lntehet.r k how peopl€ comuicate or ll0 flvouR GRAItr$. JUST A nto{r ' . \!eb in daily life. 1ltoy nake videos, ,The prhd M'n'\tPr E hopinathar tt liss clips aroDnd," Mr rf,e srtd in srneapoens *iilso on thetri€nded his Nstioml D3y R,lly speddh on wbat
Sud.y. no* hake tbe cut with rhe
Jactual tnsoB: 'ill d
thart him for these ..n!essioE. He scetu ro foreet thar rhe nsht to h:lepoLtici fiths or the riRht 10 bold demondr.trons are !:rr aid knees to
footase dodDentaties
reroldirrs ot live evenk.
Brt sone dnD8s still von,t pass 'tf /ou hale a lolitical connElcial so ttrat
Itt
not r qdestiof of fi\uuc bens aLed from the C.vernncnt ll\ a_
tk
pnrely made-up haterirli p&risan trr, fooE&p dirtoned to cleatr r sl:ntinDre$ion. l think thole 3ho,r.r nrl betxcen vhat is ok .nd whar is not
j.yillfuh, Kd6.dnl
rl{Ir.8
ofrlE R.Iam
i"It
ys stmilar lo non Foliticd mms.
vith
?;so6hin and filnr c'iasification si,nd rds, be sajd, with a Fanel to d.cide \ether or nor a political tiln *ould 'rl'i'e ovenid4 .oN'deElon tr to ore eive the ht€sfltv, qualtv, ad hoh;jtv f ou lolitical dkcouse," he said.
ht
doesn't
bGt
people
srurt
hale
sense ta
soon
jur
€irpl,ed ror
SecuJr 13 of rhe Fit Acr disstows ' . baking, reprod!.rior, djsrribution i scledning oi ,,p.rty lolitlcst filns".
fh filns,rederined
as those
ravoum!
polrtjot pa y or DUshinr u Dolitr.al
- Mr rze s.id loliticll filhs were '1P!11lrI: q: Fnn6!!drJ{e rlst o'p( to i nind.r is<sraloha]ly, coo].ardlhlnt thioucn de!1ffi xth di ]ortutrre rnd Dake : conedergd ",4nd olr *ory n th,t filhs are an nolive hedjun the jbF.t of seNing )mcthinE oh a lilD js qdre ditterenr
rh
to telt the Aood fiom thc bad, hurh from rrlseh;od, he sad. sl!'ndfrlm m*er T:n pin p'n s haDrt' enou,{h
L
"A ge$tre
ilt:
beennadp, lndrAess r the srarr ofa towjrd\ [ss i.enet]c sov-
has
losirlve rhnA Thtr
iorc jo,rho,
P.litk:l frlm: lere boned to yes6
lrrr hi.l ch4
3sme
de nost of rhe rine nor
fll ra fhht th. &dhft! ti tho.udhodm ll$ r m.dt. ptw. ft. dndtd do.E noMl M i sdr6 polnt fltm qn m* !. het nh.n.kr. \'0. Or0 D vor,D utt
o utdoor protests okay, brut
only at peakers'
orner' ', , ,., I
Li PMLeer?hinedtotherrTooirrongau- causr rher€ r .tEady a ptaF $t fors dicnce at rhe Natiordl Day raul why burve.hoo5. rod" iiet;L-" wh"*_I]S6!t49tc?!!!9!914!!ld@r dchon- hry rpnri tions on outdom denronsrra any soestoHons t_i,b parkr be sdd. .Eiio"s sll lom be rlowidTo-aa; tons hrve beonnahtainsd. H. n onc ot rs peolle {ho vero r
BYJnnxMy Au YoNc
u4!Il!'.t!Feqf?l5 csn4
odrcon rmi5law.ndordcr,sndse- chargedre.ennyloriakinsFa inrnile, or:/ l o," r!,"p,nd' Th rotJb"nor.rhpror,n.h,d iFo1. sJ" "nll.o b..' " o!,qd"r o reJ ro ", rvisr and -!:! ltj !. L, , Lld -d"n " \4.' 1.. 1" h"vp - d.""r ; opro! :or no.irl Ll\ bu on Sundrv ..?J- !--ll l" I r L d o F -I L'Letrrdlrliradn?t. choo rlre.g {i,2: Piih. M,;ter Le. lG,en Lourr -ii r&glc,- r'. "id .t.ei lJrv r aherh -,a-"r i.'",,i. b " . H"Jr.iho" r n re.ding sonDtlin( in coldDrint. It nfs ron visceiallr. t{ engaees }olr orrd \oonoe,r. r.1 I I' i'" I Fsoud tr'tbethrsttr or .tio,s befors your thinkiis lrocesses r.,"*-t.tt.-*"+,*i,trs 's.r.l H.;;';;.i;;;; t" h.r,r,,,. kick m, and if rou are walrhing it itr a ,F. q 'D" ".'1 0" h", , ". "d;'";;";:.:;; . ,;;,;;,;;;;;,1:, ' tr _.or 'n (it 'owd, n)even more powerful r .'gndad r' a fotuc DcoDl "1heh, p€\.ror6 L.n gd 5rtrred up:nd rl . ,ph.:n gcr curi.d :rry , s,p'k., 'oaer in Ponc L,D pr! -):'1.'i:..:' '" "9 ,'''c p .":"i.".rli'". ,-,' " o Ineprohiseof soneloUtic.l fil,ns b..r,i ,on.,.uo, -ar"- il--l*, !Y:!l- iordn earroLL,,"'i. -" ,hoa b"u""r",.,;e ts alloyetl *as chee.ad by film-m.ker ".-,,1 or re. h. cd lrtyn See, vho had two of lis 6lns roriun- e.-br' ro p.,.h"MR, i'""i]-'X.l , .,1' ,4o . ."r " ,, o" .,_dLr ''" .. ,..*..r. .,,i1 ,:":,1* ,'*" U:_!!:drj!i:1 'This is by I* the most obvious retrxa Ichi , ' t -": n h.o oruowlo i of poutisl space in sinA,Dole jb rhe .iuehc'.ognr< """ ihd" ' ' -'".;, " ln z0 yers. rr vil le$en t$ climare of rr:,o r" @.d.r rno,c ,,-, '_o",. -_'_n*.-.-_._.r.._ ";; r*" in { nomci'l8 th. ho!. he rorod I zr ror ooe { qrt scnior Resea.ctr Fellos Tar Tarn ' "'"'" 'n.,r *"r',,r."r'r'r"Jrd. Lo.,c. :i,,. :.";:....: :. i".,:";,;'" :" r frcn the Institnte of Poljcy Studjes \un"cdro,Jt rr Dpror.'.,or\,,, ,N, ",...t1i*' j..o reri,.,d.. "\,".-.-,.. lered thcre r. bc no condtiobs in, ,o."*r-" "i,. r., ,i,ii ,,.. ,t,',,,ii.t i,i,"i ,i'jir ii,. ;,;i;";,;;;, ,r ,h", o"."n,.,.
'j'.
u """.h,
...;
:r,r.. ,.
,;..
";
UI
\).*
NI \lr
h)" Cr)
h. \
t\) \
c l\)
>
! P; T b! d Ar:U P
/o i
i2 6 t siigr6-"j 53F! 5
k
,
24 ii :!:il+F , Q:
i*
4,lBl
hsF
liii[!;;]i,iiii
.E
1 -? ; !' o ! X;6 5 E.t;
iiEi t;9"
n.r"i
;i;fii;,;lffFn:E;
a oao'E;!
t; b
-q"6o
.!;6?
!.,i
4,,"
iB ''€
; lx l!! ft! a
E; yqE
E
r
ir
;ii:ii
E
i! ;
.9 TO q;
;.7 3)ii
E
;i
J::IHiI o-" y g.i 1J HQ b !l.!l .l
iriiiiiiini*iril i PZ'
3
3l 5 h e
Eq 6
E
;L
ii Ezi -H9f;FE i J q Tq .il €1 { '.a :.5 $ i
f,i;li
g
Do
!iii{iffiiti i ;.!E.f -;c:h6tE9
:HE{ 3J9SEJdi;TJT
!-9J;,
iIEEii
..4
;?4 .E bo I ii> k i>- i.5 ; 'e 39 $r]i
i;
It
ell; i j is:g €l o ;..F r *!; {lFqE ::Pi:E:d ;SEo? riE i E al{ .1r i ; ? 3:l€eg o?P:F }ENVi
;F} ig,::E g i $ii *
!f; 9l : l9
!!
:-i9e:6-Eoojl 5i ' iH-i i.3Ji1; ; ;:q oud ;r:311 e;l! {r
2
v
.E
.t
fl
c!io
o ! d!
' ;il3 i Srit ? tl3 € B :t i,; llT q !;38 E
ifi,,Eii:isiit:'a
1 E
i
\
u l\) \
i\)
B-
c:9€
E
:Eril 6ll ,09
i;ii!iliiiiiiitiiiii
ii: :;i ;1i?j;*il:i: Fii;;i :i:i i; i Iirul'irt$,iilt'i
\ \)
tN \J
:l;]$i ; i ;1iH,
u tl *
z
j
{
z
l: ;: ;i;9:
i:f;i!li!;ij q;i";:5?';!
::
i';
ii;;
t
'I5!"'il
a
o-F
r)aq)
t\) (\ \
3
z
'liii;; r;;; :;;ff iiiiii i:;
U0 !iiil+:;ri;ri;ir f\J
*+
I
;iin;
lF-'ib; lEtAe
!'l;
iI t4l.32
Y..,t >_>
in
;'iui'
;F!'A
Iii; ;iiisi iii iiiiii "ii*:t*': j
iii;
ii;li; iiiriiiiiiliiliiiii'i;ifiii
THE S']'R{iTS'I'I\'IES SATLITIDAY.
ruNIi
28 20ou
,,"4r!ri ,'a 11r_.tr.!i
waste exp0rfs Delegates at UN taiks urge nations to manage their own electronics trash
BAt DELEGATES at a United Na,
tions (UN) conference decided a8alnst bauing loxic wasre cxtorts, instead encouasirw co!, ldes to lake tliei. omi aalion to addre$ the steady stream of dan
{erous chemic.ls and ol.l PlP. ironic itcms that litter ihe latrd fills ol po.r nations. Supl,orL for r hJn durtnE thl week lo, r meet,nc on iliu i:asel conventioD was driven bv Ai,.i
$1,.h rLArc.trhaL waJ ro pr,'te.r rheir LitizPrs. Jnd b\ rhe frrron-
rt
rJ.
rhe
lc\r
an Unr {1, s 1,,!h ati."dv Droli,b jls toxic exporls. But lhe proposal ran iDro stiff
opposilion from
ihe
Uniled
Shtes, Japan, Canada and lDdia over concerns th.]lit would stifle recvcliDg irdustries in the devel
.ped w.rllj thdr are Luorunp "
amid !he nqnx pnces of nchls
The deleSatcs
insread
enielged lron lalks vcsterdav wilh a rumber of otliet
".",i ures, inLludnA rndusrrv+!DDorted Errdclrne5 for dr\posl,,a ;lrcl|hones dnd Jn aenemeri to stdr r similar discu$ioDs 0n old.om.,,, ter equipment.
"It \ v.r! sad, rer\ sad. \rrd I1, lrtr lucketi. .ooi,_t,n.r", "r {he S.rttle Lrased Blset Acrion Nerwo,l, Jid, g rl JL is gro!pt rrdlr PoPl it thr convErfj.n wr( to ecl nriior6 to mrna.e rt,ci own \vrstc Jr homc n;tcrd or Conpanies, mostlv in ,i.h na
tions, pav 1o sliD
th;ir .teclrotr ics plste to othir courhnrs fo, dEpn\al but r, unLtFir tu.r how rnrnl t,'ture| i$Lhwd(rrrr. / But jusl aLolt cveNone at
ur. CJl, !,,n\rnr!.n as.iO rt,.L tt,. rrJilL ,r rirLL !Ianr.its ,s hra. thal c!cnlual disDosrl .f rhp rd\tr ,. , ftcn In.lLlraudru. rnd
CO[,lPUlER VYASiF: [leasures comine our of rhe tdlh! io.tude dn agreement io start worl on BUidetines tor dicposine of ord computers.
boundary Movements of Hazardous Wasles aDd their DisDosal The 1989 Dact allows iti 170 meLnbc^ tihin lnpol1s and requues c\t'.rters to arin con(ert
beforc sendins toxic natcrials
Critics argre tirat i$ltlicieDr
l!nds, srdesprcrd ro(uDtro! th. (Jr' is 3
and rhe ibsence of
paficipart havc undemrined thc
conveDtion, lcaviDg rillions ot poor !eople cxposcd ro hcavv
meials and olher toxir6. Mani, s rn .ut rtt'I hrn ,,n exp.rirni 'y wrsLu i, the onl\ sol;'h.n roxiL Hoy evc.. rdusLtv reue\cnt: i \ F\ sird ltrat tlr. n;\ rolLDrar! Drdasures adopted at thc co e; cnce could lead to the c.€atnnr
.f
cerlified .ecycl'ne Iacilities_ $hi.lr would be e,recirll\ \rRnrti Lrnt rn develoFrnE ,1,!.arie5 v hrri old cl.!truntr rrems ,,ot. Itrlr ludlill\ ,,' a'c t,,"..,t ," The hopc, 1oo. is
rhar
aDv oI
the countrics would use the ;.w guid.lines to..eate rhcir orD rc cycln,g hws th,t {oukl a.ldress lhe estiDatcd 20 lrilli.\r 10 50
tl:rtdLbun,.$.u.;\,u
millioD tolnes ol trscd eiectroli.
slronqlhen the tlascl Conwtsn iron .n thc Cortrol ol Trons
Mr tuck Go$ olhe lnfo'dalion TechnoloAv lndusrry Cou! {:i1 s'hich nr.hdes nrosr najor
Tl,u r rn' ' sed tlrn rr,, "."^ holdcsl attcnlpl ar rhe.onl!rencc Lo
Lohputer ind prTtermJnulalrur ers. e,d rhe Lamputer Axrdelues Nould offer a uDivers:tl l.ame ivork thal would sive the 1ndus, trV confiJcn.e th.n rts produLrs wcre beins, r.y.led re\ponsrblv
The rssuc uf toxiL cxn,,fs took (entre strre D 200! ivhcn
hundr-ds of ti,nnes ot {a\re dxmfed.r^xrd ihe lron Cuist s n, rin uty ot Ah,drin. kiti s ere
ingatleast 10 people anll leavlng
lcni oI tl,ou5Jrdr utD6Dl!: $.k Fur nritrl, ,,t rl,c we.i i'i ra!. tLie .!cLr.te r.voh ed around the
export ban. But as a deadlo.k nf lersificd- Ildonls'. Dnt nrrh . compro;ise, which i!'said !ould
allow !a,1ies to rcvisil lhe issue
AnionS othe.lh'!Es, the strteDrenl encouraees naLjons to Dxss ],ws, as lhe EU did. that ir;uld
i,rr Il,
tnYr! r\t.rts nr \h,rjt ui rI boon.!io,L.,f.,rr r,r,',tr .
sr(t. n'1h, ,l ,,. O'. ' dL J fI1,P( Lr\e:A elLl Lu look $,r\ ot rcsol\ rfe tL ' rmfrsse 'Mr q.hrn 5terncr r.r.r ri\e .l rec to. Jnd deteLL,ll€ral
'ln th. Liplrr .i Jrrlt.rfg rh1 L,a
rhP
1., ior t|.1rN tsnvnonment ProSrimmc, said ol tlre stal.rneDt "Tha1 is ! vcry positive sis ASS0CiTTEIT FirFgS
,
\,l!ul\Eru11r, ]v1,.!i(Ln
19 Zou
gt"vqlr\*r,i
hio time-out for By NayeN Cqerrn,r
,
on. and
But perception is reali
ty, gnd the i1l-pervasiv
For 1:fte St/aits Timei
!nl,n+de.! The imDort of better aDd cbeapei goods has alwavs affected ineffi_
cient producers and brought'pain. Coni"m"i"
Eqn, *gqq!&;dq: our rtremctent
jobp it is
industries lost.Is this what is haooening in the US now? ' ' Economist Robert Las,rence's new sfudv. BIl1eCollar Blues. shoii tiat a
significant amouDt oj slgtrrrcant of
what \YIar the me Usj-loForts uJrloFotts $ is no
medta steteoscoDicrll.
magnifies the dark oerceri
tions about trade'. EIei tron-tlme r,rletolic coul(
do F,,orse thaD iust deeDer ttus. perception; coulc lo
it ci< politicia0s jnr.
self-firJfillbg protectionisi
'
The period between tlre two world wars. when a, anti-globa sation back-
rasn produced a tariff war, holds serious w.rn-
lg?gelprolqqqdjlga€SF callv As D .F( .l +hoca
rt o{ the chtu adges taking place ir the ecoiemv. DeY alirling inveshtent fti manuJachiring, atrd DfoductiviDUt
Iesslv cli-Dloitins the fear-
ful irood of ate.
th"e
ele.tor-
While their Democtat-
ic colleasues in the US Congress refuse to approve free trade
agre'e-
ments Degotiated bv the administration w;tli Colotrbia, South Korea and Panama, Senator Barack Obama calls Ior a reneeotiation of thc r4-via.-6ta North Americair Free Trade Agreement 0.{afta) and )eflatol l1lllarv (]linton wants a "tim"e-out" oD free trade pacts.
ls trade th_e main reason for growjig ioblessness in the US - or for that matter. anvwhere' else? The qiestidn ls as old as trade itself. Everyone agrees that \fitlout trade. we would
bc€-.r_qE!go_rt-Lo{r-lo-6a and $,c:rvrne $ htt l^Ie we_ar. -Tia d-srew to al:1ow for s&ills siecialisa-
ty _growih wrought .by tecbological and rianasdllent ian-"ovation ment imovation olaved D]avea a Euch biPser much bieser rold. ikr ' 2091-2003 peridr rigdr,((Ay 12'ang. !9rye9* cetrt. of Eanufecturine. estimatad, iobs lost were estimatld.
+'Fi
to have been due ia trade I
The data also lavs to rest a lnl'th about Ainerican jobi outsourced iI1 droves to lndia - or in popular parJance,'-'BangaLoleo vIIlCla1 data shows.that out of almost
one mi11io[ iobs lost in 2004. less tlan 10 oer cent - oDlv 73.217 - wire due to outsdurcias. Of these- three in 10 we"re senl ibroad and the rest
went to other Darts of the US. Professoi Lawrence concludes that thele is overrl'hekning eviderce that the US has benefited from gJobal engagements, which has helo-edraise its gross domeslia product bv I0 Der .enr
'p-*E$biD
,Sormer Dre(idcn' I.or]Iler iresidential economic adviser Alan Blnder, who raised the alarm in 2006 about a new industrial revolution embodied-in outsourcins challengjng America. ii now wo ied about ihe
growing aDti:globalisation sentiment. He now
for {indins "',r'avs to make Americ-ans irore corDfortable wjth siobalisation". The nevi oresic?Ds
dent, he savs, wouldhave to use tha Dresidential brl-
ly pulpit: oot to bullv.
but to ex'Dlai! whv slobalisation is bolh iiie"vitable aod more ao ooDorfunitv ' thall a threat- ' Presidential hoDe{uis nlay find it poljtjc fo call tor a time-out on trad-. agreements, but tbe proc, ess of slobaLisatjon diiven by billions o{ people's desire to live b4ttei brooks
no time-out.
If
irade
is
forced to shut down. as ih the 1930s. the r6srlts could b e dis astrous for all. Tho writer is director of Dublications at the Yale bentre lor the sl dv nt
Globalisation and ;diior al
Yaleclobal 0nline.
EEEFEE;€g
E3:E;iEe€ ?:e:c;;:=:€=:€E alA ==EE'E€EE11 EEg^EE;EEEE E€€g€
ziEFE,E?E
lg;ti =:c;;;;?:i€ =:;; r: . IEE=EEEE g.;* g;'eE:; :;; lE -; u"VEry"E:E==
A::.i= Ee.:==iAii.=r i
€7
c3 -tEr e3 F-"
Q q.)
a4 q> \.1-)
a ct c3 s) c->
-
a
i r€;: E;E E; fl€€E;= g + r€ eF-:c:.!tE F€Ei =; i=F;i;iE-:i:Ei€€€:E sC€
.++ +
Eiz: ? t; e€t;FE 1j e EEE;:-;7EsEE!eEE44F; : E€ ?iE EE;Zc eEE E= Fi A:EI i; -EEEE ;g;q;€ :€
:Ec:€=;;r;aeE:;c€€ ;IE != ?;E i3;;;€Eg;E: tEEE::EZE sE * i€; 'EE;i AAFE -EE
S€
F3-^Fq €=56E-
F =
>= E.:= F 9: :r=sEEc.g = 4==.::
=
EEg€gggg€g
+
H.EVIEW THE S']'RAITS
TIM!S TUESDAY, MAY 13
2OO3
'MOVING BEYOND THE GLOBALISATION PARADIGM
Enter the Cognitive, 5, ge Droo(s
8Y DA!,rD
The cognitive age
IF YOU so inro a qood ti
paradigm emphasises
or book\ un stobrtrJrron son,. qill hud I Some *rtJ
psychology, culture and pedagogy - the specific procrsses
brary, you
ljll
lind th.u$nds
wd'n dbout 5 drnseE Bui rhey will asrce !hor itobilLsJlion k Lhc chief o'o.es dnv. ins our ase. Our'L're\
:re
that foster learning.
t,e
ldA rEndo cd br rhe in dc?sirs dovencni oi loods. tcoP
e
\'
rn,1.:prb d.tu; bor.
rieglubrlinhonrEmdm
rrrl rld
{r
a
tr
fo
rirJLarenr,
'n hnlorical .ara crtain
.v.: Ttiere s,eie on.e .a, ron stares l*c ihe us and rhe European po(en, wtose
,{
t
cognitive age, you're focusinq on the real sourct of prosperity and understand that your anxiety is not being caused by a foreigner.
6
econonries could be securcd
wilhirborde's Alt no{ GDi-
rr nv$\ rr.e\
h,\ hle)lcd rF
Te.hnoro'Pr D
lfyou understand that you are living at the beginning of a
i$np neij.
compeiirior i5 rtobrt and
)
s:h.i prFd am naiio. .an now ria!et 24.000km in aD ln anr B,n mo(t mpod,iLprn ol rn 'h€ romrllln! rourne\ b the hn Ieq .enhhetre\ ihe .'n a bel**.,re^o"''.'.'.e:r,,od rh;,aflor5 ;p,on\ 'rheelubal
Noq e\c6, n:de rbroJd Amc;
ed cutrendes rhids
' !,n m:n!h.turiis
rs Ln
f
de_
Mn Hirrary Clhron smn,arke_d th. .rnativ. rc!,
orLhe hrar Does rfic,nd,\,d. ual havelhe capacitY to under
,
weeks .Ao: "Thc! cahe for lLhc ilerl .onoJiies rnd no 6odi sJ d r;yrh,ns rhEv
nand the nfomation? Iroei he or she h3ve the
'r:.ulti 'na erTl!,t ,f Are rhEre asunptions rhar disro.t *ay il is pe.ceiwed?
' ru noboLl' _:rd r.lihinq L$ -n. i,, ,he ofi,:..-;. prn,er, people u ho ,tid !turr !.t. r rn1!e r!b, 3nd proI.(
onst 'h.y.Jnre ob\ $rrlodtdbe ouBolred ind oobod,, qrd Jn!1hrna 1 Lhe
ilisations Tlese
call.d
!iEi,;i,, len ent flr pol h! Jr LL al ov rh!ntobl rqluLdh,{s rur ercnoor! rr dit,,q. them o prerend 'oe_rhrr bl 'e. u r I nr ,Ddc deal, thlv can r$urse econonrtr rn( irl ft iim.d odIu br 1ryc;n
r Luwilhem
ro
sloba \!oremi$ !nd por'n.: s nsrnns d\ ihecom "rth Bur iheret a DrobrenL rhe way ihe
dic( las evoh,ed ll doisi't
eeh ron o1 uhr s h:fodriurlFq r.r Clob.liMtionis rc.l and nn, rc rn Irt iust noi thc ccn. irrl Io(e dii\rnR !cononrr re3rr/
1,,!c scen rhen iobs shiDDcd
o!rr ! . hon hn share oi
:
d,llerco, lofle';.
(..-.d,n
LUL eloU
t.omncrc
lounted Io,
rob.Earion
dccades. Capilal does ndecd flow aroundthe world Bnr a\
Prore$or Pankaj chena*ar
qiih
glob:tMionpam
: {ni
aDd de
I
n,L!ion ov.r rhe t,fl te*
..
Brt rhe eo;n'1'!€ rai p,fr . dism 3r plFsi\", p5\.t.toPr. cuxure and redasoF rhc \prrif. prore$e\ rh Ioner lerrn nq ri emlll,trtrr\ lhir
aerteconim,
and so.ial d{rse as a trrea1 rieranrilist conFetiti.n, with !dr DU{ leims .omneti.c tor
ab*n.ti. r
rhe Chinese" or ,,rbe
Ind,a.5 . arc do,ns LhL\
t h! aro5Jlshor
lrr\
\
TlLeElobnis:' oi L iLdrm lPadj oeoole tu rec a.onortr de\eloprDeni :i: ro'nr of for eixn pnli(\ a\ a eEnd !odor lilion betueen nationsrod aiv
no oDe said anvihinP And for
ro
imprnies open plan(s over
sers, but thai ji mxinly so ther p,.du.Lion l?.iliilea.an bc .ldse {o local n$kaLs
N!f i,th, arobd[5rL!nD]r
,dfi..13(fne"h.n'-' ph.d l! maftLl,.i!m! l; {
5eir.h n,n. hr5 Daded od the
U5 iIJre oJilob]rn-ntr
facturine odpur h:- sduallv incrused stiFhdY sin.e 1930. 1he chiel j.re resharnra
mdi!hriunns r ielhrolopr !:LrhanL" th:netred b\ .on
w'l oihef!onjpr'!er crkdJ, !rLlom prht ou
'iemran\
Tlanks ioiturdv'iion din uf^crurinU p'oduch,nr hJ5
doublcd ovcr lwo dc.rdc! EdelavcF low reoutrc lcs.r
buinrdrt h,RHj \r.i l.d *orr
T..rnolosicai chrnse at chitu ust :s I dois r\e Anen.a r!1r Wilrm over tec6
holt of Ue !.AND cor.oDron has noren that b€r;eei 1994 and 2004 rhe Cninese shed 25 niuion ma.utactur.
iq
robs, 10 tiDes mdre rhaD
srccss dnv'n! t lIlei; cental nbr slolalkruon rri -rcftndri.n
Lhe J
,nr!rm:non flrn n hlpn.n tr in ro!:r..d J LLr .P[ o^, rnd r'ou {lobiltrld d L,e l3p p€n ns.,c L'tI rou rok uo
.,er, ro
d", " ". '.,!;
."
h"
trca5ed
b";", 'm,r", ".,' denan.l5 od Lud,D
U rou 3re I vnra
unde6lrnd $at vor atihc b!Prnntr;13
cognili!e a3e, you on the realsource
L.usi.a
'e olprcspei:
Ia and Luder$and drr v.ui ,irxiery is nor t.'ne.auseit lv and rhe skith re;olL ion a). ehich paadia; you.mbmtu derernines wbi.h l3.h 3nd 'one-dies)ou
rtop[isFe
ocr;llc o.e* hlv. r"lr"" i" loi6 with tfie !lobalisaLron parodiaiir
lrt
tinie ro nov!
iasL
}THE WORLD \qE LIVE IN
More global more troubl
yca h
1997 alhina
the global econony.
there has b€en no lerce divi dend. lven though'tlere were
omino$ sisns - the 1993 bonb lhat ;xDloded uoder the World Tnde Gnkr. the 1998 bombinrs ol US embassies in Alrira ind tle 2000 at' tack or $e USS Cole tu fie
port o[
Ade[,
-
Yemen
lew
iaid
rh; A(ir; firaDrial
orce the Soviets had vitl_
beed to the Slowing ihent ol l\lam$t extrenism.
crisis.
r4ionk ba*eb were afterl
emcrshs
oI ltrc
dmwn &oo Ahhaflslan, tle world Iorgot aboul $c jrtrad
aitliueh the deve)oPed
ed.
o/orld\
n ikeb
agaimt the inradem.
remained re_
TIIE RIGITT DCT
no out ol loreiRr exchanae and rould nol wilhland ttre sriseored nm o[ ils cnrrmcv. lt'ar bark ad r omPaoes
Americans are in
thi
US. $hi1e instituliotral
Iudn
decisions being
Soulh-east Aiian eaonomies
0mens lIlE {ltimate theat
to
hfinan
survival is slobal warnins dinale chnse. lte hab ol nl[ons. nuvbe bi honr, of people iray be da,t
and
tats
fte oolar ice cnD ii nelt' ftis lirs higsereil Rursi'
,qed ide.
Qnada, Denmarl., Nonrat lic LIS and oticrnrlions abuttins $e Archc to lay drlr ln xeriions ol lhe Arcti(. Ilre scranble ior the richt ulder lhe ice is on. lbe Krcm.
the sabed al the Nort Pole. Canada has dained omenhro ol lhe Nodh.ver' Pasare. bul ilsca levck n, rn inrindate nanv aillions r peoplc, and rf gl;cie$ i, tie
tied
Global player
to election
Wien lhe cnmch croe, shed for the
exit, sellinn local stock and ruriencies, disregarding tbe roudriei' fundaf, eDlals The suddm wibdn{d ol liquidi-
Esioo\ slock nar_
wi
Tm
tle cenual balk lbjlard, hdorcsia, lilalay'
US
-
enbloiled in llar inien nable prol
datelins.
snasred bv
lihad io Alshadstao sas buta plelude6 global jfiad
Ao\,,,n Lhrt elusive t$o-sla1
kmiovei lran's nuchci pro_ (rannle and unable lo pi
SeDl 11, 2001 was
ft'ets bmke
ol
\\Lr
lcoro(tuIorPeruLl trme ffr c.*efuldrlil,eto-
without their
ol dollaru
tv l,.on lie
loStrc
risor
as Trbel and dre Ar dcs melt away, leavirrB mor millons w$oui enotrgh w. be no "[le al ler, there
way out of haq
lad hvesled bil'
tloseifleston
urlh ro n url rt
Himil
now find the dght
ir tle stock narlel6 ol lhe booniog li'ons
0
sril,P, hr urrnt\
;n
mu(
kaq. They
aeex hom lhe devel-
nned vrorld
populn
Dlanl a titaniun Russian lla
Right or wrong,
iere heavily indebted io loreiBn
lxllr. 'rla
lin has sent $borariDes t"
udo&!ed. n; mitir m5 ercciPilrled when ihe Banl 6f 1liailard lalivelv
jn bank, espedally tlose
l
hon. qllhoLrt the ures5ure\ 0l cL'tironeennB, tti deLrde o hi, or h.i .orre o{a,tLon
sbck narleb 10 Yeirs ago, in Julv 1997, wili li€ omel ol davs all
s
rnd, |e
1}1! Cold WaI is over, bul
cl.0lAUSATl0N'S power sa frflt demonsh?te/ in $e
Willin
rc
lo ger " i'residel)l Bus ltor \ llDlo r!' \''rll roL b-
un
Security threats
KU,N YEW
BY LXE
l0
Indii ,,1'ere ninorplayen. Nnv' lhP growlL rnlo t|e 11'od{l s l\!olargtn r'onorures is.realing n(r dJrro r\ rn
and
te
hmrng
Doint. The Uniled Siates and world were shocked bY
iie
lvi!
solution lor lssei/Palesline DMv aDDeaI werkc[ed 3od ue,iw llut whether vou a
for oi asaiNL US Doliries
r
hao ,nd'elsewberc: fte lact tJraimanv of the world\ prol,'
sh and Soub Korea. DBwing o! il5 exPerience
L\e desl$ctiotr ol lle
tle bternitional Morctarv Fuld inr_ oosed mredies tiat maaY crit' i.! helieve made lbe situatiod worse. Miny Asian ba*s
?enlason. US loftes let?lial
hmr rainot be el{eLrlvel
hv"iamfue AJshanistrn in Ocdber. fte-do"ire fol lic world vas clear: Yor are ei
mrnared \vilhout the arti\ n: rtLci"nation ol the US.
weDtbellrup, and D,rnY com
asainsl ur. In
Towers
in IrtinAnedca.
'
DaDies werc
vean later thev had substao 6rl nrrrort accirLrnt surpluscs, ar wellas af,ple
Iilen
loreip
cul
mrrket{,as sold do'm in JulY ,rnd Ausu5l rhis yPJ,.
ilr
Lnn'
uuon $'rsd rornredr,rkll lo Frirone and
mLcrr ng
]!trn
and
tim
to
Alrr Thesrh Pnrne
noridage lorns at thc mo{ ot
Marh 2001 lhe invaded lraq and over'
threw Saddam
HLissein
Rjght or wong, Arneic?ns ttris vere a US pmbhm, but lhey bad becn passed oo lhrough CD0s (m lilemh\ed debt obligalio$) to lulop e n ba s and irxunnce conPa nies and lo llru najor bankr h Clina a
New York's stock
"
'
ther Yrith rs (the US) oI u U"S
ir
attacl( on the
ed
binlftPled
WtrJe many Asian cour_ ift{red larye c1lfieDt a(' .ornl deli{it5 Ic9b. 10 lnes
ald itre
Although
lL.
eritr,,-u'e to
Asian banks and lnsuranrr comDanies $as no1 hI(lr, rhei;dock m? etslell Asra J
econonies
sill
depeld otr
Ameimr consume$. Henc€,
rf tle lub pnrc
mortgJge
nrobhn sDIl[ over ioio lhe
iS
real e,on, ny, reduclng
ronsumer
de,n
d,
Asia\ er
noits r.,nll declnre and econom lslow. i, gLo{ah
x
TheNr d'ssiuiegicnaltcA rnd
tnttrlron
,hrrgd
rd,rlr
1rcrd\ dLrr
hr\c
ng
tlc
are
h lmo. Tlev nusi
ll"i
now oulot lraq
Snd tle riRlt rnthoLrt tlLeu dccrsions be
ins tied lo cle!tion daleln$ P;e$dent GeorRe W Bush ha\ mrdr clcar [i! Dllcv to
ilober{ DraDeI. dLrthoi of Dc.d ( rrLarri a buok nn lhe
Itcndin! 'To tron where
rididtrl*
aetu\ n tre,rdenLrrl 3 Po5i
tl;
w
ll
he
tor orti
ble aboul su$eioing ir Pres
woiddbadeisbowAneti' wJi bolltrce bacl asah..F{
ir$dhffifttwfi1dkinostd nenic sociehi il has lhe Do5' hnovative {iconollY wiib itl leadinPadse lecbnolog both ci"viljai and nilih,'l Bu{ Riven Russia! anti
Irr
rgiur vur.u Ndriom lrf UftlPd no$llon. rlio;. lhc trnrvCourri Counri l'ldlnot be t \ectntv 'n]lnot ' rivein50lfinq tl./o imn et lront rL.qln r{e ptoblefl tr".ts le,
t*llit,
it'It
" 'ii nudear progmmrne ano ros' ovot rht
filil
r
llrrlskr Me!!Lo!
"aie{ Ihrirdir t s ruaooft '?Plerrs I re-{-l[r€nl !sue olforbP5 magail[e.
rr