Modele Econometrice

Uploaded by: Cătălin
0
0

April 2020
PDF

This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it. If you are author or own the copyright of this book, please report to us by using this DMCA report form. Report DMCA

Overview

Download & View Modele Econometrice as PDF for free.

More details

Words: 104,317
Pages: 239

Preview
Full text

Cuprins

I. Introducere: Ce este econometria? .................................................................

3

II. Principalele tipuri de modele econometrice utilizate în economie ..........

11

III. Modelul unifactorial .........................................................................................

24

IV. Modelul multifactorial .......................................................................................

70

V. Modalităţi de includere a variabilelor calitative în modelul econometric

100

VI. Serii cronologice analizate atât prin prisma componentelor, cât şi a nestaţionarităţii şi cointegrării ....................................................................

110

VII. Modele dinamice destinate includerii efectelor decalate în timp ........

129

VIII. Modele stochastice de prognoză ................................................................

143

IX. Elemente de analiză spectrală ........................................................................

168

X. Modele econometrice cu ecuaţii multiple .......................................................

177

XI. Aplicaţii econometrice la nivel de firmă .......................................................

204

Anexe ...........................................................................................................................

233

&DSLWROXO, ,QWURGXFHUH&HHVWHHFRQRPHWULD"

6FXUWLVWRULFSULYLQGDSDUL LDúLGH]YROWDUHDHFRQRPHWULHL 8Q PRPHQW LPSRUWDQW vQ FRQVWLWXLUHD úL GH]YROWDUHD (&2120(75,(, FD GLVFLSOLQ HFRQRPLF GH IURQWLHU DS UXW vQ GRPHQLLOH GH LQWHUIHUHQ

DOH WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH VWDWLVWLFLL úL

PDWHPDWLFLL VH FRQVLGHU DQXO GHFHPEULH FkQG VD vQILLQ DW OD &OHYHODQG 6RFLHWDWHD GH (FRQRPHWULH (FRQRPHWULF 6RFLHW\ DYkQGXL FD LQL LDWRUL SH ,UYLQJ )LVFKHU ± SUHúHGLQWH / 9 %RUWNLHZLF]5)ULVFK++RWHOOLQJ/6FKXPSHWHU1:LHQHUúLDO LL 8QUROGHRVHELWvQGH]YROWDUHDúLSRSXODUL]DUHDHFRQRPHWULHLODDYXWUHYLVWDDFHVWHLVRFLHW

L

Ä(FRQRPHWULFD´FDUHDSDUHWULPHVWULDOvQFHSkQGGLQLDQXDULH (WLPRORJLF WHUPHQXO GH HFRQRPHWULH SURYLQH GLQ FXYLQWHOH JUHFHúWL HLNRQRPLD HFRQRPLH úL PHWUHQ P VXU (O D IRVW LQWURGXV GH F WUH 5DJQDU )ULVFK HFRQRPLVW úL VWDWLVWLFLDQ QRUYHJLDQ SULQ DQDORJLH FX WHUPHQXO ÄELRPHWULH´ IRORVLW GH )U *DOWRQ úL . 3HDUVRQ OD VIkUúLWXO VHFROXOXL;,;FDUHGHVHPQDFHUFHW ULOHELRORJLFHFHXWLOL]DXPHWRGHOHVWDWLVWLFLLPDWHPDWLFH 'DU QX FHL FDUH DX LQWURGXV WHUPHQXO úL DX vQILLQ DW 6RFLHWDWHD GH (FRQRPHWULH DX úL ÄLQYHQWDW´DFHDVW GLVFLSOLQ 6XE DVSHFW LVWRULF VWXGLHUHD FDQWLWDWLY D IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH HVWH PXOW PDL YHFKH 3ULQWUH SUHFXUVRULL HFRQRPHWULHL PRGHUQH SRW IL FLWD L ) 4XHVQD\ : 3HWW\ *UHJRU\ .LQJ $ &RXUQRW/HRQ:DOUDV((QJHO$0DUVKDOO5$)LVKHU.3HDUVRQúLDO LL ÌQ SHULRDGD FRQWHPSRUDQ FRQWULEX LL LPSRUWDQWH OD GH]YROWDUHD HFRQRPHWULHL DX IRVW DGXVH GH

vQ GRPHQLXO DQDOL]HL HFRQRPLFH D FHUHULL 0 )ULHGPDQ 7 +DDYHOPR 5 6WRQH + :DOGúD

vQ GRPHQLXO IXQF LLORU GH SURGXF LH & : &REE 3 + 'RXJODV . - $UURZ *

vQ GRPHQLXO PRGHOHORU PDFURHFRQRPLFH $ 6 *ROGEHUJHU 2 2QLFHVFX / 9

vQ GRPHQLXO PHWRGHORU GH DQDOL] D GDWHORU VDX DO HFRQRPHWULHL ÄI U PRGHOH´ 7 :

7LQWQHU .DQWDUHYLFL/5.OHLQ-7LQEHUJHQ +7KHLO $QGHUVRQ-3%HQ]pFUL++RWHOOLQJ5$)LVKHUúLDO LL ÌQ PRPHQWXO DFWXDO LPSXOVLRQDW SXWHUQLF GH UHYROX LD WHKQLFRúWLLQ LILF ± FX UHDOL] UL GH YkUI vQ GRPHQLXO FDOFXODWRDUHORU HOHFWURQLFH ± HFRQRPHWULD D GHYHQLW XQ LQVWUXPHQW PHWRGRORJLF GH ED] LQGLVSHQVDELO WHRULHL úL SUDFWLFLL HFRQRPLFH SHQWUX LQYHVWLJDUHD ULJXURDV D IHQRPHQHORU úL SURFHVHORUHFRQRPLFH

'HILQL LLOHHFRQRPHWULHL 'H]YROWDUHD UDSLG D HFRQRPHWULHL D JHQHUDW IRUPXODUHD PDL PXOWRU GHILQL LL FX SULYLUH OD GRPHQLXO DFHVWHL GLVFLSOLQH HFRQRPLFH 7RWXúL PDUHD PDMRULWDWH D DFHVWRUD SRDWH IL vQFDGUDW vQ XUP WRDUHOHWUHLJUXSH D ±GHILQL LDLVWRULF E ±GHILQL LDUHVWULFWLY F ±GHILQL LDH[WLQV

1XPHOHVFULVHFXLWDOLFHvLGHVHPQHD] SHODXUHD LL3UHPLXOXL1REHOvQHFRQRPLH

3

D 'HILQL LDLVWRULF

DHFRQRPHWULHLDIRVWIRUPXODW GH5)ULVFKvQSULPXOQXP UDOUHYLVWHL

Ä(FRQRPHWULFD´ vQ LDQXDULH ÄH[SHULHQ D D DU WDW F ILHFDUH GLQ XUP WRDUHOH WUHL SXQFWH GH YHGHUH DO VWDWLVWLFLL DO WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH úL DO PDWHPDWLFLL HVWH R FRQGL LH QHFHVDU VXILFLHQW SHQWUXRvQ HOHJHUHHIHFWLY DUHDOLW

GDU QX úL

LORUFDQWLWDWLYHGLQHFRQRPLDPRGHUQ XQLILFDUHDORU

HVWHDFHHDFDUHDVLJXU HILFLHQ D(FRQRPHWULDHVWHWRFPDLDFHDVW

XQLILFDUH´

&RQIRUP DFHVWHL GHILQL LL VXV LQ WRULL HL FRQVLGHU F SULQ HFRQRPHWULH VH vQ HOHJH VWXGLHUHD IHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPLFHSHED]DGDWHORUVWDWLVWLFHFXDMXWRUXOPRGHOHORUPDWHPDWLFLL E 'HILQL LD UHVWULFWLY &KLFDJR

SURSXV GH &RZOHV &RPPLVVLRQ IRU 5HVHDUFK LQ (FRQRPLFV

FRQVLGHU

F

QX

H[LVW

HFRQRPHWULH

GDF

LQYHVWLJDUHD

IHQRPHQHORU

HFRQRPLFHQXVHIDFHFXDMXWRUXOPRGHOHORUDOHDWRDUHVWRFKDVWLFH 6XV LQ WRULL DFHVWHL GHILQL LL / 5 .OHLQ ( 0DOLQYDXG * 5RWWLHU LQFOXG vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPHWULHL QXPDL FHUFHW ULOH HFRQRPLFH FDUH XWLOL]HD] PHWRGHOH LQGXF LHL VWDWLVWLFH ± WHRULD HVWLPD LHL YHULILFDUHD LSRWH]HORU VWDWLVWLFH ± OD YHULILFDUHD UHOD LLORU FDQWLWDWLYH IRUPXODWH vQ WHRULD HFRQRPLF FXSULYLUHODIHQRPHQHOHVDXSURFHVHOHHFRQRPLFHFHUFHWDWH &RQIRUPDFHVWRUGHILQL LLXQVWXGLXHFRQRPHWULFSUHVXSXQH H[LVWHQ D SUHDODELO

D XQHL WHRULL HFRQRPLFH SULYLQG IHQRPHQXO SURFHVXO VDX VLVWHPXO

HFRQRPLF FHUFHWDW SH ED]D F UHLD VH FRQVWUXLHúWH PRGHOXO HFRQRPLF FDUH UHSUH]LQW IRUPDOL]DUHD LSRWH]HORUWHRULHLHFRQRPLFHFXSULYLUHODIHQRPHQXOSURFHVXOVDXVLVWHPXOLQYHVWLJDW SRVLELOLWDWHD

DSOLF

ULL

PHWRGHORU

LQGXF LHL

VWDWLVWLFH

OD

YHULILFDUHD

LSRWH]HORU

WHRULHL

HFRQRPLFHFRQVWUXLUHDPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULFúLUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWXLD $FHDVW GHILQL LH UHVWULFWLY H[FOXGH GLQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPHWULHL FHUFHW ULOH HFRQRPLFH FDUH QXVHIXQGDPHQWHD] SH R WHRULH HFRQRPLF ± LPSOLFLW VDX H[SOLFLW SULYLQG PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF DO IHQRPHQXOXL SURFHVXOXLVDXVLVWHPXOXLVWXGLDW RLQWHUSUHWDUHDOHDWRDUHDPRGHOXOXLUHVSHFWLY $VWIHO DQDOL]D VHULLORU FURQRORJLFH PRGHOXO OXL /HRQWLHI %/5 FD úL VWDWLVWLFD HFRQRPLF FDUHVHIXQGDPHQWHD] SHPHWRGDEDODQ HORU QXLQWU vQVIHUDGHFXSULQGHUHDHFRQRPHWULHLSULPD GHRDUHFH H[LVWHQ D XQHL WHRULL HFRQRPLFH QX HVWH QHFHVDU LDU XOWLPHOH GRX ILLQGF QX SHUPLW DSOLFDUHDPHWRGHORULQGXF LHLVWDWLVWLFH F 'HILQL LDH[WLQV

DHFRQRPHWULHLSURPRYDW GHHFRQRPLúWLLGLQ

ULOHDQJORVD[RQH LQH

VHDPD GH SXWHUQLFD GH]YROWDUH DS UXW GXS D PHWRGHORU FHUFHW ULL RSHUD LRQDOH WHRULD RSWLPXOXLWHRULDVWRFXULORUWHRULDJUDIHORUWHRULDGHFL]LLORUWHRULDMRFXULORUHWF 3ULQ HFRQRPHWULH vQ VHQVXO ODUJ DO WHUPHQXOXL VH vQ HOHJH HFRQRPHWULD GHILQLW vQ PRG UHVWULFWLY DGLF LQFOXGH GRPHQLLOH PHQ LRQDWH DWXQFL FkQG HD HVWH vQ HOHDV FDUH VH DGDXJ

PHWRGHOH FHUFHW

vQ VHQV UHVWULFWLY OD

ULL RSHUD LRQDOH ÌQ SUH]HQW vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPHWULHL VH LQFOXG úL

WHKQLFLOHPRGHUQHGHDQDOL] DGDWHORUVDXDQDOL]DPDULORUWDEHOH 'HRDUHFH vQF QX VD FULVWDOL]DW R FRQFHS LH XQLWDU SULYLQG ÄIURQWLHUHOH´ HFRQRPHWULHL vQ PDQXDOHOH VDX WUDWDWHOH GH HFRQRPHWULH DXWRULL GH UHJXO vúL PHQ LRQHD] FRQFHS LD SH ED]D F UHLD úLDXVWUXFWXUDWOXFU ULOH ÌQ DUD QRDVWU DWkW vQ OLWHUDWXUD GH VSHFLDOLWDWH GHúL UDUHRUL VH IDF SUHFL] UL H[SUHVH FkW úL SULQ VWUXFWXUD SODQXULORU GH vQY DSOLFDW

FD PHWRG

JHQHUDO

PkQW GH OD IDFXOW

LOH HFRQRPLFH HFRQRPHWULD HVWH FRQFHSXW

GH LQYHVWLJDUH FDQWLWDWLY

úL

D IHQRPHQHORU úL SURFHVHORU HFRQRPLFH ±

DGLF vQDFFHS LXQHDODUJ DWHUPHQXOXL 8Q GRPHQLX PDL SX LQ DERUGDW DWkW WHRUHWLF FkW úL SUDFWLF vO FRQVWLWXLH PHWRGHOH HFRQRPHWULHLvQVHQVXOUHVWULFWLYDOWHUPHQXOXLUHVSHFWLYPRGHOHOHDOHDWRDUHVWRFKDVWLFH 0RGHOHOH GHWHUPLQLVWH XWLOL]DWH vQ PRG FXUHQW úL GH PXOW YUHPH vQ WHRULD úL SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF GLQ DUD QRDVWU VXQW GH PXOWH RUL LQDGHFYDWH SHQWUX D H[SOLFD úL PDL DOHV SHQWUX D SURJQR]D SHUWLQHQW HYROX LD IHQRPHQHORU SURFHVHORU VDX VLVWHPHORU HFRQRPLFH HOHPHQWH GLQDPLFH SULQQDWXUDORU 'H DVHPHQHD vQ VWXGLLOH PXOW PDL UHFHQWH VH LQVLVW DVXSUD IDSWXOXL F VWXGLXO VHULLORU GH WLPSSULYLQGHYROX LDIHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPLFHQXSRDWHILLQGHSHQGHQWGHWHRULDHFRQRPLF 6HDXvQ YHGHUH vQ DFHVW VHQV QX DWkW GHWHUPLQDUHD úL H[WUDJHUHD HFRQRPHWULF D WHQGLQ HL FkW úL DVSHFWHOH

4

OHJDWH GH HIHFWXO vQWkU]LDW vQ WLPS SURSDJDUHD LPSXOVXOXL XQRU YDULDELOH H[RJHQH DVXSUD YDULDELOHL SURJQR]DWHQDWXUDRVFLOD LLORUGHGLIHULWHIUHFYHQ HHWF$FHVWHDVXQWPRWLYHOHFDUHDXGHWHUPLQDWFD PRGHOHOH GLQDPLFH ± ED]DWH SH DQDOL]D HYROX LHL vQ WLPS D IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH ± V úL J VHDVF

ORFXOvQDUVHQDOXOPRGHOHORUHFRQRPHWULFHSUH]HQWDWHvQDFHVWFXUV

1R LXQLúLFRQFHSWHIXQGDPHQWDOHDOHHFRQRPHWULHL 0HWRGD PRGHOHORU VDX PHWRGD PRGHO ULL UHSUH]LQW SULQFLSDOXO LQVWUXPHQW GH LQYHVWLJDUH HFRQRPHWULF DIHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPHWULFH 'DU PRGHODUHD VDX PHWRGD PRGHOHORU QX FRQVWLWXLH R QRXWDWH vQ úWLLQ D HFRQRPLF 7DEORXO HFRQRPLF DO HFRQRPLVWXOXL IL]LRFUDW ) 4XHVQD\ OHJLOH OXL (QJHO FRHILFLHQWXO GH HODVWLFLWDWH IRUPXODW GH 0DUVKDOO UHSUH]LQW PRPHQWH LVWRULFH GH OD FDUH FHUFHWDUHD HFRQRPLF WUHFH GH OD HWDSD GHVFULSWLY OD HWDSD GH H[SOLFDUH IRUPDO D FDX]HORU úL IRUPHORU GH PDQLIHVWDUHDOHIHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPLFH XQ LQVWUXPHQW GH FHUFHWDUH úWLLQ LILF

ÌQ JHQHUDO 02'(/8/ UHSUH]LQW FRQYHQ LRQDO

KRPRPRUI

VLPSOLILFDW

DRELHFWXOXLVXSXVFHUFHW

)LLQGRFRQVWUXF LHDEVWUDFW vQFDUHVHQHJOLMHD] SURSULHW

R LPDJLQH

ULL LOHQHHVHQ LDOHPRGHOXOHVWHPDL

DFFHVLELOLQYHVWLJD LHLvQWUHSULQVHGHVXELHFWDFHDVWDILLQGXQDGLQH[SOLFD LLOHPXOWLSOHORUXWLOL] ULSH FDUHPRGHOXOOHDUHvQHSRFDFRQWHPSRUDQ 8WLOL]DW vQ HFRQRPLH PRGHOXO LPDJLQH DEVWUDFW IRUPDO D XQXL IHQRPHQ SURFHV VDX VLVWHPHFRQRPLF±VHFRQVWUXLHúWHvQFRQFRUGDQ

FXWHRULDHFRQRPLF UH]XOWkQGPRGHOXOHFRQRPLF

0RGHOXOHFRQRPLFUHSURGXFkQGvQPRGVLPEROLFWHRULDHFRQRPLF DRELHFWLYXOXLLQYHVWLJDW SULQ WUDQVIRUPDUHD VD vQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF GHYLQH XQ RELHFW VXSXV FHUFHW

ULL úL H[SHULPHQW

ULL

YHULILF ULL GHODFDUHVHRE LQLQIRUPD LLQRLSULYLQGFRPSRUWDPHQWXOIHQRPHQXOXLUHVSHFWLY ÌQ DFHVW PRG UHSUH]HQW

ULOH HFRQRPHWULFH VSUH GHRVHELUH GH PRGHOHOH HFRQRPLFH FDUH

H[SOLF VWUXFWXUD IHQRPHQXOXL VDX SURFHVXOXL HFRQRPLF GH SH SR]L LD WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH DX vQWRWGHDXQD R ILQDOLWDWH SUDFWLF

RSHUD LRQDO

HOH GHYHQLQG LQVWUXPHQWH GH FRQWURO úL GLULMDUH GH

VLPXODUHúLGHSUHYL]LXQHDIHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPLFH 9$5,$%,/(/(FDUHIRUPHD] VWUXFWXUDXQXLVLVWHPHFRQRPHWULFGXS QDWXUDORUSRWIL D YDULDELOHHFRQRPLFH E YDULDELODHURDUHDOHDWRDUH X F YDULDELODWLPSW D 9DULDELOHOH HFRQRPLFH GH UHJXO VH vPSDUW vQ YDULDELOH H[SOLFDWH UH]XOWDWLYH VDX (1'2*(1( <

L = Q úL YDULDELOH H[SOLFDWLYH IDFWRULDOH VDX (;2*(1( ;

LQGHSHQGHQWH GH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH <

Q

QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU UH]XOWDWLYH N

M = N

QXP UXO

YDULDELOHORUIDFWRULDOH ÌQFD]XOPRGHOHORUGHVLPXODUHVDXGHSURJQR] YDULDELOHOH; VHPDLvPSDUW

vQYDULDELOHH[RJHQHSUHGHWHUPLQDWHYDULDELOHGHVWDUHDVLVWHPXOXL±FDSDFLWDWHDGHSURGXF LHDXQHL

vQWUHSULQGHUL VDX FX ODJ ± [

LPSR]LWXOSHSURILWHWF

\

úL YDULDELOH LQVWUXPHQWDOH VDX GH FRPDQG HFRQRPLF GREkQGD

E 9DULDELOD$/($72$5(XVLQWHWL]HD] DQVDPEOXOYDULDELOHORUFXH[FHS LDYDULDELOHORU ; FDUH LQIOXHQ HD] YDULDELOD HQGRJHQ < GDU FDUH QX VXQW VSHFLILFDWH vQ PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF

$FHVWHYDULDELOHIDFWRUL SHED]DLSRWH]HORUWHRULHLHFRQRPLFHVXQWFRQVLGHUDWHIDFWRULvQWkPSO WRUL

QHHVHQ LDOL VSUH GHRVHELUH GH YDULDELOHOH ; FDUH UHSUH]LQW IDFWRULL GHWHUPLQDQ L HVHQ LDOL DL YDULDELOHL<

'HDVHPHQHDYDULDELODHURDUHUHSUH]LQW HYHQWXDOHOHHURULGHP VXU ±HURULvQWkPSO WRDUHúL

QXVLVWHPDWLFH±FRQ LQXWHGHGDWHOHVWDWLVWLFHSULYLQGYDULDELOHOHHFRQRPLFH 3H ED]D DFHVWRU SUHPLVH HFRQRPLFH VH DFFHSW F YDULDELOD DOHDWRDUH ÄX´ XUPHD] R OHJH GH SUREDELOLWDWH /X vQ DFHVW VFRS IRUPXOkQGXVH R VHULH GH LSRWH]H VWDWLVWLFH FX SULYLUH OD QDWXUD

5

GLVWULEX LHL DFHVWHL YDULDELOH LSRWH]H VWDWLVWLFH FDUH YRU WUHEXL WHVWDWH FX WHVWH VWDWLVWLFH DGHFYDWH ILHF UHLLSRWH]H F 9DULDELOD7,03WVHLQWURGXFHvQDQXPLWHPRGHOHHFRQRPHWULFHFDYDULDELO H[SOLFDWLY D IHQRPHQXOXL HQGRJHQ < LPSULPkQGXVH DFHVWRUD XQ DWULEXW GLQDPLF VSUH GHRVHELUH GH PRGHOHOH VWDWLFH

'HúL WLPSXO QX SRDWH IL LQWHUSUHWDW FD YDULDELO FRQFUHW HFRQRPLF VH UHFXUJH OD DFHDVW YDULDELO H[SOLFDWLY ILFWLY GLQGRX PRWLYH vQSULPXOUkQGWLPSXOFDYDULDELO HFRQRPHWULF SHUPLWHLGHQWLILFDUHDXQRUUHJXODULW

LvQWU

XQ SURFHV HYROXWLY FHHD FH FRQVWLWXLH XQ SULP SDV VSUH VSHFLILFDUHD SUHFLV D XQRU YDULDELOH FDUH DF LRQHD] vQWLPS vQ DO GRLOHD UkQG HO UHSUH]LQW P VXUD DUWLILFLDO D DFHORU YDULDELOH FDUH DF LRQHD] DVXSUD YDULDELOHL < FDUH ILLQG GH QDWXU FDOLWDWLY QX SRW IL FXDQWLILFDWH úL FD DWDUH QLFL VSHFLILFDWH vQ PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF 8Q H[HPSOX FXQRVFXW vQ DFHVW VHQV vO FRQVWLWXLH IXQF LD GH SURGXF LH &REE 'RXJODVFXSURJUHVWHKQLFDXWRQRP 4

$.

/

XQGH

H

ÂX

4

.

FDSLWDOXO

/

IRU DGHPXQF

H

QXP UXOQDWXUDO

W

YROXPXOIL]LFDOSURGXF LHL

WLPSXO YDULDELO DOHDWRDUH

X $

úL F

SDUDPHWULL IXQF LHL F UHSUH]HQWkQG P VXUD

HFRQRPHWULF DLQIOXHQ HLSURJUHVXOXLWHKQLFDVXSUDYROXPXOXLSURGXF LHL 6XUVDGHGDWH9DULDELOHOHHFRQRPLFHVHLQWURGXFvQWUXQPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFFXYDORULOHORU UHDOHVDXHPSLULFH\

\ \ «\ [

[ [ «[ Q

QXP UXOXQLW

LORUREVHUYDWH $FHVWHYDORUL

DOH YDULDELOHORU XQXL PRGHO VH SRW RE LQH SH GRX F L ILH SH ED]D VLVWHPXOXL LQIRUPD LRQDO VWDWLVWLF EDQFD GH GDWH ILH SULQ HIHFWXDUHD GH REVHUY UL VWDWLVWLFH VSHFLDO RUJDQL]DWH ± GH WLSXO DQFKHWHORU VWDWLVWLFH 2 SUREOHP IXQGDPHQWDO FDUH VH ULGLF vQ DFHDVW HWDS R UHSUH]LQW FDOLWDWHD GDWHORU

VWDWLVWLFH UHVSHFWLY DXWHQWLFLWDWHD úL YHULGLFLWDWHD DFHVWRUD 'DF XQ PRGHO HFRQRPLF VH FRQVWUXLHúWH FX GDWH IDOVH VDX DIHFWDWH GH HURUL GH P VXU HO YD F S WD DFHVWH GHILFLHQ H ILLQG FRPSURPLV VXE DVSHFWRSHUD LRQDO 'HRDUHFH SUREOHPD DXWHQWLFLW

LL GDWHORU HFRQRPLFH LQH GH GRPHQLXO VWDWLVWLFLL HFRQRPLFH

QH YRP UH]XPD QXPDL D DPLQWL F GDWHOH VWDWLVWLFHFDUHSULYHVFYDULDELOHOHHFRQRPLFHVSHFLILFDWHvQ PRGHOWUHEXLHV ILHFXOHVHI U HURULVLVWHPDWLFHGHREVHUYDUHúLGHSUHOXFUDUHvQGHSOLQLQGFRQGL LLOH GHRPRJHQLWDWH2PRJHQLWDWHDGDWHORUSUHVXSXQH FROHFWDUHDORUGHODXQLW

LVWDWLVWLFHRPRJHQH

UHSUH]HQWDUHDDFHORUDúLGHILQL LLúLPHWRGRORJLLGHFDOFXOFXSULYLUHODVIHUDGHFXSULQGHUHDOH DFHVWRUDvQWLPSVDXvQVSD LX GHVFULHUHD HYROX LHL IHQRPHQHORU vQWUXQ LQWHUYDO GH WLPS vQ FDUH QX VDX SURGXV PRGLILF UL IXQGDPHQWDOHSULYLQGFRQGL LLOHGHGHVI úXUDUHDSURFHVXOXLDQDOL]DW H[SULPDUHDYDULDELOHORUvQDFHOHDúLXQLW

LGHP VXU FRQGL LHFDUHVHUHIHU vQPRGVSHFLDO

ODHYDOXDUHDLQGLFDWRULORUHFRQRPLFLvQSUH XULFRPSDUDELOHVDXSUH XULUHDOH Ä0DWHULDSULP ´SHQWUXFDOFXOHHFRQRPLFHRFRQVWLWXLHVHULLOHFURQRORJLFHVHULLGHWLPSVDX VHULL GLQDPLFH PDL UDU VHULLOH WHULWRULDOH DOH YDULDELOHORU HFRQRPLFH UHVSHFWLYH SUHOXDWH VDX FRQVWUXLWHSHED]DE QFLLGHGDWHVWDWLVWLFHH[LVWHQWH 2 VHULH FURQRORJLF VH FRQVWUXLHúWH SULQ REVHUYDUHD YDULDELOHORU < úL ; SH SHULRDGH HJDOH GH WLPSW

7WUHSUH]HQWkQGOXQLWULPHVWUHDQL ODDFHHDúLXQLWDWHHFRQRPLF

W

7

[

[

[

[

\

\

\

\

6

ÌQ FRPSDUD LH FX DFHDVWD R VHULH GH VSD LX UH]XOW SULQ REVHUYDUHD YDULDELOHORU < úL ; vQWUR DQXPLW SHULRDG GH WLPS OXQ WULPHVWUX VHPHVWUX DQ OD XQ DQXPLW QXP U GH XQLW

HFRQRPLFH RPRJHQH L = Q Q

QXP UXO XQLW

L VRFLR

LORU GH DFHODúL SURILO FH DSDU LQ DFHOXLDúL VHFWRU

HFRQRPLFHWF2DVWIHOGHVHULHVHSUH]LQW GHUHJXO VXEXUP WRDUHDIRUP [

[

[

[

\

\

\

\

^[ ` L = Q SRDWH IL LQWURGXV FX

ÌQWUXQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF XQ IHQRPHQ HFRQRPLF ; XUP WRDUHOHYDORUL

[ [ [ YDORULH[SULPDWHvQXQLW

9DORULUHDOHVDXHPSLULFH[

LGHP VXU VSHFLILFH

QDWXULL IHQRPHQXOXL ; HOH ILLQG P ULPL FRQFUHWH úL SR]LWLYH GHFL DSDU LQ VLVWHPXOXL QXPHUHORU UD LRQDOH9HFWRUXOYDORULORUOXL;[

[ [ [ SRDWHILGHILQLWSULQGRLSDUDPHWUL

PHGLDDULWPHWLF DYDULDELOHL;

[ = 0 [ =

[ Ç

Q

DEDWHUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF DYDULDELOHL; =

s

s

"

!

s

=

!

= 0 [

0 [

=

Q

Ç [

-[

ILLQGGLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHL

'H RELFHL VH FRQVLGHU F YDULDELOD ; XUPHD] R GLVWULEX LH QRUPDO GH PHGLH [ úL GH DEDWHUHPHGLHS WUDWLF

#

/[

9DORULOHFHQWUDWH [ $

1 [

%

#

= [$ - [

$FHVWHYDORULVXQWWRWP ULPLFRQFUHWHGDUHOHDSDU LQVLVWHPXOXLQXPHUHORUUHDOHDYkQGDWkW YDORULSR]LWLYHFkWúLQHJDWLYH 6H SRDWH GHPRQVWUD XúRU F DFHVWH YDORUL FHQWUDWH DX PHGLD HJDO FX ]HUR LDU GLVSHUVLD ORU HVWHHJDO FXGLVSHUVLDYDORULORUUHDOH

0 [ =

0 > [

Q

Ç [

@=

Q

-[ =

L

Ç [

=

Q

Ç [

L

-[

= 0 [

9DORUL FHQWUDWH úL QRUPDWH VDX DEDWHUL VWDQGDUG [ '

((

=

[' - [

&

0HGLD úL GLVSHUVLD

s

DFHVWRUYDORULHVWH 0 [

) )

0 > [

ÌQ SOXV ID

=

Q

Ç

@=

Q

[

+

-[

s

*

» [ Çª ½

=

-[ ± ²

L

s

GH DFHVWH GRX SURSULHW

DEVWUDFWH DGLPHQVLRQDOH $FHVWH FDOLW

Õ

[

=

L / [

,,

s s

[

[

=

-

1 DEDWHULOH VWDQGDUG VXQW P ULPL

L FRQGXF DWkW OD GLPLQXDUHD FDOFXOHORU VWDWLVWLFH FX DFHVWH

-

5HOD LD /[

1 VH FLWHúWH YDULDELOD

[

..

=

s

0

[ / - [ XUPHD] OHJHD GH SUREDELOLWDWH QRUPDO DYkQG

PHGLDHJDO FX]HURLDUDEDWHUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF HVWHHJDO FXXQXOHJHDQRUPDO FHQWUDW úLUHGXV

7

YDORULFkWúLODHIHFWXDUHDGHFRPSDUD LLvQWUHGLVWULEX LLOHPDLPXOWRUIHQRPHQHHFRQRPLFHGHQDWXUL GLIHULWH 8Q PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF SRDWH IL IRUPDW GLQWUR VLQJXU

UHOD LH VDX GLQWUXQ VLVWHP GH UHOD LL

VWDWLVWLFH$FHVWHUHOD LLSRWILUHOD LLGHLGHQWLWDWHVDXGHWHUPLQLVWHUHOD LLGHFRPSRUWDPHQWUHOD LL WHKQRORJLFHúLUHOD LLLQVWLWX LRQDOH 5HOD LLOHGHLGHQWLWDWHVXQWGHWLSXOHFXD LLORUGHEDODQ

IRORVLWHvQÄ6LVWHPXOGHEDODQ HDOH

HFRQRPLHLQD LRQDOH´ 5HOD LLOH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW VXQW DFHOH HFXD LL VWRFKDVWLFH FDUH UHIOHFW úL PRGHOHD] XQ SURFHV GH OXDUH D GHFL]LHL FDUH vQFHDUF V GHVFULH U VSXQVXO YDULDELOHL HQGRJHQH < VXE IRUPD GHFL]LHL OD XQ VHW GH YDORUL DOH YDULDELOHORU H[RJHQH 'H H[HPSOX vQWUXQ PRGHO PDFURHFRQRPLF UHOD LLOH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW VH UHIHU OD GHSHQGHQ H SULYLQG FRQVXPXO LQYHVWL LLOH LPSRUWXO úL H[SRUWXOVLVWHPXOGHSUH XULFHUHUHDPRQHWDU HWF 5HOD LLOH WHKQRORJLFH GHVFULX DWkW LPSHUDWLYHOH GH RUGLQ WHKQRORJLF SULYLQG SURGXF LD FkW úL UHOD LLOHWHKQLFRHFRQRPLFHH[LVWHQWHvQSURGXF LHIRU DGHPXQF úLIRQGXULOHGHSURGXF LHDOHXQHL XQLW

L DOH XQHL UDPXUL VDX DOH HFRQRPLHL QD LRQDOH $FHVWH UHOD LL WHKQRORJLFH VXQW UHSUH]HQWDWH GH

FXQRVFXWHOHIXQF LLGHSURGXF LHGHGLIHULWHWLSXUL 5HOD LLOH LQVWLWX LRQDOH VXQW IRORVLWH SHQWUX D H[SOLFD vQ PRG GHWHUPLQLVW VDX VWRFKDVWLF IHQRPHQHOHFDUHVXQWGHWHUPLQDWHILHGHOHJHILHGHWUDGL LHVDXILHGHRELFHLXUL'LQUkQGXODFHVWRUD IDF SDUWH GH H[HPSOX HFXD LLOH FDUH H[SOLF VWDELOLUHD LPSR]LWHORU VDX D FRWL]D LLORU vQ IXQF LH GH YHQLW 7LSRORJLDPRGHOHORUHFRQRPHWULFHHVWHH[WUHPGHYDVW 7RWXúLXQPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFSRDWH IL FRQVWUXLW SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO XQHL VLQJXUH HFXD LL GH FRPSRUWDPHQW WHKQRORJLFH VDX LQVWLWX LRQDOH VDX FX DMXWRUXO XQXL VLVWHP GH HFXD LL GH JHQXO FHORU SDWUX UHOD LL PHQ LRQDWH PDL VXV GHQXPLWH PRGHOHFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH 1

7HVWHOH VWDWLVWLFH VXQW LQVWUXPHQWH GH OXFUX LQGLVSHQVDELOH LQYHVWLJD LHL HFRQRPHWULFH

1HFHVLWDWHD XWLOL] ULL DFHVWRUD HVWH GHWHUPLQDW GH IDSWXO F GHPHUVXO HFRQRPHWULF FRQVW vQWUR vQúLUXLUHORJLF GHLSRWH]HSULYLQGVHPQLILFD LDYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQHDFDOLW DJUDGXOXLGHSHUIRUPDQ

LLHVWLPD LLORURE LQXWH

DPRGHOHORUFRQVWUXLWH$FFHSWDUHDVDXUHVSLXQJHUHDLSRWH]HORUIRUPXODWH 2

vQ HFRQRPHWULH VH SRDWH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO PDL PXOWRU WHVWH FHOH PDL X]XDOH ILLQG WHVWXO

WHVWXO W

WHVWXO)HWF 3H OkQJ DFHVWH WHVWH VWDWLVWLFH vQ SUDFWLFD FXUHQW vQ GLYHUVH GRPHQLL VH IRORVHúWH IUHFYHQW XQ WHVW GHQXPLW ÄWHVWXO HURULL´ ÌQ JHQHUDO DSOLFDUHD DFHVWXL WHVW SUHVXSXQH FRPSDUDUHD D GRX YDORUL

YDORDUHDREVHUYDW VDXHVWLPDW

7

YDORDUHDWHRUHWLF DúWHSWDW VDXSURJQR]DW

3HED]DFHORUGRX YDORULVHGHILQHVF HURDUHDDEVROXW H

HURDUHDUHODWLY H

U

D

= -7

=

-7 7

¢

6HFRQVWUXLHVFFHOHGRX LSRWH]H +3 §7 + 4 7

7

6WDELOLQGXVH DUELWUDU R YDORDUH DEVROXW (5 VDX UHODWLY (6 GH HFKLYDODUH D FHORU GRX

YDORUL úL7 UHJXODGHDOHJHUH GHFL]LHDFHORUGRX LSRWH]HHVWHXUP WRDUHD HVWH DFFHSWDW LSRWH]D +3 GDF (

D

ÊH

D

VDX (

U

ÊH

U

Ü FHOH GRX YDORUL úL 7 VXQW

HFKLYDOHQWHDGLF GLIHUHQ HOHGLQWUHHOHVXQWvQWkPSO WRDUHúLQXVLVWHPDWLFH

8

9H]L ± LSRWH] VWDWLVWLF WHVW HURDUH GH JUDGXO úL JUDGXO SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH QLYHO GH VHPQLILFD LH ± 'LF LRQDU

VWDWLVWLFHFRQRPLF'&6%XFXUHúWL

9

8QDVWIHOGHWHVWúLFULWHULXGHGHFL]LHVHXWLOL]HD] vQFRPHU XOFXSURGXVHvPEXWHOLDWHVDXDPEDODWHSHQWUXFDUHGH

UHJXO FULWHULXOGHGHFL]LHHVWHGH

GLQYROXPXOVDXJUHXWDWHD7DDPEDODMXOXL

8

HVWH DFFHSWDW LSRWH]D + 4 GDF (

D

>H

D

VDX (

U

>H

U

Ü FHOH GRX YDORUL úL 7 GLIHU

VHPQLILFDWLY úL QX SRW IL FRQVLGHUDWH FD HFKLYDOHQWH UHVSHFWLY H[WUDVH GLQ DFHHDúL XUQ VDX GLQWUR FROHFWLYLWDWHRPRJHQ $FHVW WHVW DO HURULL HVWH XWLOL]DW vQ PRG FXUHQW vQ GRPHQLXO DQDOL]HL VWDWLVWLFRHFRQRPLFH D YDULD LHL vQ WLPS úLVDX vQ VSD LX D XQXL IHQRPHQ HFRQRPLF GDU SRDWH IL DSOLFDW úL vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPHWULHLGDUFXGLVFHUQ PkQWúLQXvQPRGH[FHVLY

/RFXOúLUROXOHFRQRPHWULHLvQVLVWHPXOúWLLQ HORUHFRQRPLFH $SDUL LD úL UDSLGD DILUPDUH D HFRQRPHWULHL WUHEXLH vQ HOHDV úL H[SOLFDW SULQ SULVPD UDSRUWXOXL GLDOHFWLF GLQWUH WHRULH úL SUDFWLF D FRQH[LXQLL LQYHUVH SR]LWLYH FH VH PDQLIHVW vQWUH HOHPHQWHOHDFHVWXLUDSRUW 'H]YROWDUHD FRQWLQX úL GLQDPLF D IRU HORU GH SURGXF LH VXE LPSDFWXO SURJUHVXOXL úWLLQ LILF úLWHKQLFPRGLILF FRQGL LLOHúLLQWHUGHSHQGHQ HOHGLQSURGXF LHUHSDUWL LHFLUFXOD LHúLFRQVXPFHHD FH SH SODQ WHRUHWLF úL SUDFWLF FUHHD] SUREOHPH GLILFLOH SULYLQG H[SOLFDUHD úL GLULMDUHD HYROX LHL IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFRVRFLDOH F WUH DQXPL L LQGLFDWRUL LQW IRUPXOD L úL XUP UL L GH R DQXPLW SROLWLF HFRQRPLF 1HFHVLWDWHD HODERU

ULL XQRU LQVWUXPHQWH GH LQYHVWLJDUH úL GH VSRULUH D HILFLHQ HL PHWRGHORU

GH RUJDQL]DUH GLULMDUH úL FRQGXFHUH D HFRQRPLHL SH GH R SDUWH úL VXFFHVHOH PHWRGHORU VWDWLVWLFR PDWHPDWLFH vQ DOWH GRPHQLL DOH úWLLQ HL ± IL]LF GHWHUPLQDWDGRSWDUHDGHF

FKLPLH DVWURQRPLH HWF ± SH GH DOW

SDUWH DX

WUHúWLLQ HOHHFRQRPLFHDDFHVWRUPHWRGH

(FRQRPHWULD VD IRUPDW úL VH GH]YROW QX vQ XUPD XQXL SURFHV GH GLYHUVLILFDUH D úWLLQ HL HFRQRPLFHFLSULQLQWHJUDUHDGLQWUHWHRULDHFRQRPLF

PDWHPDWLF

úLVWDWLVWLF

ÌQ FDGUXO DFHDVWHL WULDGH WHRULH HFRQRPLF PDWHPDWLF ± VWDWLVWLF ORFXO FHQWUDO vO RFXS WHRULD HFRQRPLF 'HúL SHQHWUDUHD úWLLQ HL HFRQRPLFH GH F WUH PHWRGHOH VWDWLVWLFRPDWHPDWLFH UHSUH]LQW XQ SURJUHV FDOLWDWLY QX WUHEXLH XLWDW IDSWXO F IHQRPHQHOH HFRQRPLFH SH OkQJ FRPSRQHQWD ORU FXDQWLILFDELO FRQ LQ DVSHFWH FDUH QX SRW IL UHSUH]HQWDWH SULQ FDQWLWDWH $FHVWH L DOH IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH FRQVWLWXLH vQ JHQHUDO OLPLWHOH HFRQRPHWULHL vQ VLVWHPXO

SDUWLFXODULW

úWLLQ HORUHFRQRPLFH 'H UHPDUFDW F UDSRUWXULOH HFRQRPHWULHL FX úWLLQ HOH HFRQRPLFH QX VXQW QXPDL GH GHSHQGHQ

ÌQWUDGHY U XQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF QX VH SRDWH HODERUD GDF QX VD FRQVWLWXLW R WHRULH HFRQRPLF D RELHFWXOXL FHUFHWDW 6LPLOLWXGLQHD VD IRUPDO FX RELHFWXO HFRQRPLF LQYHVWLJDW GHSLQGH GH QLYHOXO GH DEVWUDFWL]DUH D WHRULHL GH GHILQLUHD XQLYRF úL RSHUD LRQDO D QR LXQLORU úL FDWHJRULLORU HFRQRPLFH GH VFRSXULOH XUP ULWH GH WHRULD HFRQRPLF VFRSXUL HXULVWLFH VDX GH GLULMDUH SULYLQG RELHFWXOVWXGLDW 0RGHOXO DVWIHO FRQVWUXLW UHSUH]LQW UHSUH]LQW F

R YHULJ

LQWHUPHGLDU

vQWUH WHRULH úL UHDOLWDWH (O

R FDOH GH FRQIUXQWDUH D WHRULHL FX SUDFWLFD VLQJXUXO PRG GH H[SHULPHQWDUH SH ED]D

UXLD úWLLQ D HFRQRPLF

vúL SRDWH IXQGDPHQWD LSRWH]HOH GLQ PRPHQW FH RELHFWXO V

X GH FHUFHWDUH

SRDWHILQXPDLREVHUYDWQXúLL]RODWúLFHUFHWDWvQODERUDWRU 3ULQ

DFHDVW

YDOLGHD] UHQXQ

H[SHULPHQWDUH

PLMORFLW

GH

PRGHOXO

HFRQRPHWULF

úWLLQ HOH

HFRQRPLFH

VDX HODERUHD] PHWRGH QRL vúL FRQIUXQW SUREOHPHOH GH VHPDQWLF úL VHPLRWLF

HFRQRPLF vPERJ

LQGXúL vQ IHOXO DFHVWD VLVWHPXO GH LQIRUPD LL SULYLQG VWUXFWXUD úL HYROX LD

RELHFWXOXLHFRQRPLF ÌQ SUH]HQW WLSRORJLD PHWRGHORU HFRQRPHWULFH XWLOL]DWH GH úWLLQ HOHHFRQRPLFHHVWHH[WUHPGH YDVW )RORVLUHD GLQ FH vQ FH PDL DPSO D DFHVWRU PRGHOH OD LQYHVWLJDUHDIHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPLFHVH GDWRUHD] SURJUHVHORUvQVHPQDWHI FXWHvQGRPHQLXOPHWRGHORUGHHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOHORU úL DO WHVWHORU GH YHULILFDUH SH FDUH VH IXQGDPHQWHD] DFHVWHD úL QX vQ XOWLPXO UkQG DO XWLOL] ULL FDOFXODWRDUHORU HOHFWURQLFH FDUH SHUPLW UH]ROYDUHD RSHUDWLY D FHORU PDL FRPSOH[H PRGHOH HFRQRPHWULFH

9

3DUWLFXODUL]kQG OHJ WXULOH HFRQRPHWULHL FX XQHOH GLQWUH GLVFLSOLQHOH HFRQRPLFH HVWH QHFHVDU V VXEOLQLHP FRUHVSRQGHQ D GLQWUH PRGHODUHD HFRQRPHWULF úL SUHYL]LXQH 3UHYL]LXQHD PDFUR VDX PLFURHFRQRPLF UHSUH]LQW XQ GRPHQLX FDUH XWLOL]HD] vQ PDUH P VXU UH]XOWDWHOH VLPXO ULL úL PDL DOHV DOH SUHGLF LHL HFRQRPHWULFH $FWLYLWDWHD GH SUHYL]LXQH D HFRQRPLHL HVWH DFHHD FDUH ÄRIHU ´ R VHULH GH HOHPHQWH XWLOH HODERU ULL PRGHOXOXL SULYLQG vQGHRVHEL HWDSD GH VSHFLILFDUH D DFHVWXLD ÌQ DFHDVW HWDS SUHYL]LXQHD GHILQHúWH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH UH]XOWDWLYH úL SDFKHWXO YDULDELOHORU H[RJHQH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH RELHFWLYHORU XUP ULWH vQ IXQF LH GH LQIRUPD LLOH VWDWLVWLFH H[LVWHQWH (FRQRPHWULD OD UkQGXO HL FRQWULEXLH OD RE LQHUHD YDULDQWHORU HFRQRPLFH RIHULQG LQIRUPD LL FX SULYLUH OD FRPSRUWDPHQWXO YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH vQ GLYHUVH DOWHUQDWLYH GH DF LRQDUH D SkUJKLLORU HFRQRPLFH ÌQ DFHVW IHO SUHYL]LXQLL HFRQRPLFH L VH RIHU R SHUVSHFWLY vQ OHJ WXU FX FHHD FH VDU SXWHD vQWkPSOD vQ YLLWRU ILH úL vQ OLQLL PDUL vQ UDSRUW FX GLIHULWHOH YDULDQWH DOH SROLWLFLL HFRQRPLFH FDUHDUSXWHDILDSOLFDWH 0HQ LRQ P GH DVHPHQHD OHJ WXUD HFRQRPHWULHL FX VLVWHPXO ILQDQFLDUFRQWDELO GRPHQLX vQ FDUHPRGHODUHDS WUXQGHWRWPDLPXOW±YH]LPRGHOHOH$5&+'HDVHPHQHDWUHEXLHUHPDUFDWIDSWXO F OD HODERUDUHD PRGHOHORU HFRQRPHWULFH VH UHFRPDQG FX R WRW PDL PDUH LQVLVWHQ

LQWURGXFHUHD

UHOD LLORU ILQDQFLDUEDQFDUH FD ILLQG GHRVHELW GH VHPQLILFDWLYH SHQWUX GHVFULHUHD PHFDQLVPHORU HFRQRPLFH 'RPHQLXO FRRSHU ULL HFRQRPLFH LQWHUQD LRQDOH FDGHDOWIHOúLFHOSULYLQGFRPHU XOLQWHULRU GRPHQLX vQ FDUH SUHYL]LXQLOH VXQW JUHX GH UHDOL]DW DOWIHO GHFkW FX DMXWRUXO PHWRGHORU VWDWLVWLFH UHSUH]LQW GHDVHPHQHDVHFWRDUHDOHHFRQRPLHLFHSRWEHQHILFLDGHUH]XOWDWHOHHFRQRPHWULHLvQFHHD FH SULYHúWH SODQLILFDUHD úL HILFLHQWL]DUHD DFWLYLW

LORU GHVI úXUDWH (VWH WRWRGDW QHFHVDU V VXEOLQLHP

IUHFYHQ D WRW PDL PDUH D DSOLF ULL PHWRGHORU HFRQRPHWULFH vQ OXFU UL GLQ GRPHQLXO ELRORJLHL PHGLFLQHLGHPRJUDILHLúLvQVSHFLDOvQGRPHQLXOPDUNHWLQJXOXLPDQDJHPHQWXOXLVDXYLLWRURORJLHL ÌQ FRQFOX]LH VH SRDWH UH LQH LGHHD F PHWRGD HFRQRPHWULHL HVWH PHWRGD PRGHO ULL VDX PHWRGD PRGHOHORU 0RGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF ± H[SUHVLH IRUPDO LQGXFWLY D XQHL OHJLW

L HFRQRPLFH ±

UHSUH]LQW XQ PLMORF GH FXQRDúWHUH D XQXL RELHFW HFRQRPLF LDU PRGHODUHD HFRQRPHWULF HVWH R PHWRG FDUH FRQGXFH OD RE LQHUHD GH FXQRúWLLQ H VDX LQIRUPD LL QRL SULYLQG VWDUHD VWUXFWXUD FRQH[LXQLOHGLQWUHHOHPHQWH úLHYROX LDXQXLSURFHVVDXVLVWHPHFRQRPLF

%,%/,2*5$),( %DURQ7%LML(úLFROHFWLY6WDWLVWLF

WHRUHWLF

úLHFRQRPLF

(GLWXUD'LGDFWLF úL3HGDJRJLF

%XFXUHúWL *LUDXG5&KDL[1eFRQRPpWULH38)3DULV *XMDUDWL51%DVLF(FRQRPHWULFV

: ;

HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
/DEURXVVH&,QWURGXFWLRQDO¶pFRQRPpWULH'XQRG3DULV 3HFLFDQ(7 Q VRLX2(FRQRPHWULHOLWR$6(%XFXUHúWL 7UHELFL90LF

HQFLFORSHGLHGHVWDWLVWLF

(GLWXUDùWLLQ LILF úL(QFLFORSHGLF %XFXUHúWL

9DQJUHYHOLQJKH*eFRQRPpWULH+HUPDQQ&ROOHFWLRQ0pWKRGHV3DULV

'LF LRQDUVWDWLVWLFHFRQRPLF'&6%XFXUHúWL

10

&DSLWROXO,, 3ULQFLSDOHOHWLSXULGHPRGHOHHFRQRPHWULFHXWLOL]DWHvQ HFRQRPLH

'HVFULHUHDHFRQRPHWULF

DGHSHQGHQ HORUúLLQWHUGHSHQGHQ HORUGLQWUH

IHQRPHQHOHHFRQRPLFH 7HRULD HFRQRPLF VWXGLD] IHQRPHQHOH úL SURFHVHOH HFRQRPLFH SRUQLQG GH OD SUHPLVD F DFHVWHD QX VH GHVI úRDU OD vQWkPSODUH FL SH ED]D XQRU OHJL SURSULL UHODWLY VWDELOH úL UHODWLY UHSHWDELOHVSHFLILFHQDWXULLDFHVWRUIHQRPHQH 'HRDUHFH IHQRPHQHOH GLQ HFRQRPLH VXQW vQ JHQHUDO FXDQWLILFDELOH OHJLOH HFRQRPLFH SRW IL GHVFULVH VXE IRUPD XQRU OHJ WXUL FDQWLWDWLYH D XQRU GHWHUPLQ UL QXPHULFH vQWUH DFHVWH IHQRPHQH $FHVWIDSWIDFHSRVLELO XWLOL]DUHDVWDWLVWLFLLúLPDWHPDWLFLLGHF WUHWHRULDHFRQRPLF ÌQ SOXV VXFFHVHOH GHRVHELWH RE LQXWH GH DVWURQRPLH SULQ XWLOL]DUHD PHWRGHORU VWDWLVWLFR PDWHPDWLFH±GHVFRSHULUHDSODQHWHL1HSWXQvQFDXUPDUHDFDOFXOHORUHIHFWXDWHGHDVWURQRPXO IUDQFH] 8UEDLQ GH 9HUULHU VDX D SODQHWHL 3OXWRQ vQ vQ XUPD FDOFXOHORU HIHFWXDWH vQ GH DVWURQRPXO DPHULFDQ 3HUFLYDO /RZHOO HWF ± DX FRQYLQV HFRQRPLúWLL GH XWLOLWDWHDúLQHFHVLWDWHDDGRSW ULLDFHVWRUPHWRGHDGRSWDUHMXVWLILFDW GHFHOSX LQGRX PRWLYH $WkWIHQRPHQHOHDVWURQRPLFHFkWúLIHQRPHQHOHHFRQRPLFHQXSRWILGHFkWREVHUYDWHHOHQX SRW IL QLFL L]RODWH GLQ PHGLXO UHDO úL QLFL UHSURGXVH vQ ODERUDWRU SHQWUX D IL FHUFHWDWH vQ FXUVXO XQRU H[SHULHQ HFRQWURODWH ÌQ HFRQRPLH DF LRQHD] DQXPLWH OHJL DVHP Q WRDUH SULQ IRUPXODUHD ORU FX OHJLOH FH VH PDQLIHVW vQ DOWH GRPHQLL DOH úWLLQ HL ± IL]LF FKLPLH DVWURQRPLH HWF ,VWRULD GRFWULQHORU JkQGLULL HFRQRPLFHUHOHY XUP WRDUHOHH[HPSOHvQDFHVWVHQVFXPDUIL

OHJHDOXL0DOWKXV±vQOXPHSURGXF LDDJULFRO FUHúWHvQSURJUHVLHDULWPHWLF LDUSRSXOD LDvQ

OHJLOHOXL(QJHO ±DWXQFLFkQGYHQLWXOQD LRQDOFUHúWHvQWUR DU GH]YROWDW

SURJUHVLHJHRPHWULF D FKHOWXLHOLOHDOLPHQWDUHFUHVFvQWURSURSRU LHPDLPLF E FKHOWXLHOLOHSHQWUXvPEU F PLQWHFUHVFvQDFHHDúLSURSRU LH F FKHOWXLHOLOH SHQWUX EXQXUL GH IRORVLQ

vQGHOXQJDW FUHVF vQWUR SURSRU LH PDL

PDUH

OHJHDOXL3DUHWRGHVFULHSRODUL]DUHDYHQLWXULORUUHVSHFWLYXQQXP UWRWPDLPDUHGHORFXLWRUL DXYHQLWXULPLFLLDUXQQXP UWRWPDLPLFGHORFXLWRULDXYHQLWXULIRDUWHPDUL \ =

XQGH [

$ [

YHQLWXOIDPLOLLORU

/HJLOHOXL(QJHODXIRVWIRUPXODUL]DWHGH7|UQTXLVWSULQLQWHUPHGLXOXUP WRDUHORUPRGHOH

[

D

\ = D

E

\ = D

F

\ = D[

[ +E

[ -F [ +E

+ X

+ X

[ -F [ +E

XQGH\ X

+ X

FKHOWXLHOLOHIDPLOLLORU[

YHQLWXOIDPLOLLORUDEF

SDUDPHWULLPRGHOHORU

YDULDELODDOHDWRDUH

11

\

QXP UXO

[ $D

N

IDPLOLLORU

\ = 1

([

Ë [

DO

)

N

F URU

YHQLW

HVWH

PDL

PDUH

VDX

HJDO

FX

YHQLWXO

SDUDPHWULLIXQF LHL

)DSWXO F R VHULH GLQ DFHVWH IRUPXO UL DX IRVW FULWLFDWH UHIRUPXODWH VDX GH]YROWDWH GH WHRULD HFRQRPLF LQWHUHVHD] PDL SX LQ vQ FD]XO GH ID GHVFULHUL ULJXURDVH OLSVLWH GH DPELJXLW

7UHEXLH DSUHFLDW LQWHQ LD DXWRULORU GH D RIHUL

L FX SRVLELOLW

L RSHUD LRQDOH SULYLQG H[SOLFDUHD UHJODUHD úL

GLULMDUHDIXQF LRQ ULLPHFDQLVPHORUHFRQRPLFH ([LVWHQ D RELHFWLY D DFHVWRU OHJ WXUL OHJL HFRQRPLFH UHODWLY VWDELOH úL UHODWLY UHSHWDELOH GLQWUHIHQRPHQHOHúLSURFHVHOHFHIRUPHD] XQVLVWHPHFRQRPLFUHSUH]LQW VXSRUWXOWHRUHWLFSHFDUH HFRQRPHWULD vúL IXQGDPHQWHD] UHIOHFWDUHD IRUPDO D DFHVWRUD $FHVWH OHJ WXUL SRW IL GHVFULVH FX DMXWRUXOPHWRGHORUVWDWLVWLFRPDWHPDWLFH ÌQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPLF GHúL H[LVW R PDUH GLYHUVLWDWH GH PRGHOHOH PRGHODUHD DFHVWRUD OD RULFHQLYHO±PLFURVDXPDFURHFRQRPLF±VHSRDWHLQWHUSUHWDFXDMXWRUXOXUP WRDUHLVFKHPH

; ^

`<

6

) LJ X UD

XQGH <

\ YROXPXOLHúLULORUGLQVLVWHP L = Q

;

[ IDFWRULLFDOLWDWLYLúLFDQWLWDWLYLFDUHLQIOXHQ HD] LHúLULOH\ M = P

6

VWUXFWXUDVLVWHPXOXLSULQLQWHUPHGLXOF UHLDIDFWRULL[ GHWHUPLQ LHúLULOH\

'DF QHUHIHULPODXQSURFHVGHSURGXF LHGHH[HPSOXDQDOL]DHFRQRPLF HIHFWXDW SHED]D VFKHPHL GH PDL VXV HYLGHQ LD] IDSWXO F LQGLFDWRULL GH UH]XOWDWH \

4 ± YROXPXO SURGXF LHL

JOREDOHPDUI VDXQHWH±GHSLQGDWkWGHYROXPXOúLQDWXUDIDFWRULORUGHSURGXF LHUHVSHFWLYYROXPXO úL FDOLWDWHD RELHFWHORU PXQFLL 0 YROXPXO úL QLYHOXO WHKQLF DO PLMORDFHORU GH PXQF . QXP UXO H[SHULHQ DúLQLYHOXOGHLQVWUXLUHDOIRU HLGHPXQF / FkWúLGHPRGXOORUGHLQWHUDF LXQHvQFDGUXO VWUXFWXULLWHKQLFHRUJDQL]DWRULFHDSURFHVXOXLGHSURGXF LH &XQRDúWHUHD OHJLW

LL GH YDULD LH vQ WLPS VDX vQ VSD LX D XQXL LQGLFDWRU GH HIHFW HFRQRPLF vQ

IXQF LHGHYDULD LDIDFWRULORUFXDQWLILFDELOLVHSRDWHIDFHIRORVLQGGRX PRGHOHGHOXFUX D 3ULPXOFHOPDLIUHFYHQWXWLOL]DWúLvQSUH]HQWvOFRQVWLWXLHPRGHOXOGHWHUPLQLVWFDUHUHIOHFW OHJ WXUD IXQF LRQDO GLQWUH HOHPHQWHOH GH LQWUDUH úL GH LHúLUH DOH VLVWHPXOXL ± YDULDELOHOH H[RJHQH úL YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH 3H ED]D GHILQL LLORU IRUPXODWH GH WHRULD HFRQRPLF FX SULYLUH OD HOHPHQWHOH RELHFWXOXL UHVSHFWLY VWDWLVWLFD HFRQRPLF XWLOL]kQG PHWRGH SURSULL H[SULP SULQWUXQ VLVWHP GH LQGLFDWRUL HOHPHQWHOH FXDQWLILFDELOH DOH VLVWHPXOXL HFRQRPLF 3H ED]D SDUDPHWULORU GH SHUIRUPDQ DL VLVWHPXOXL VDX DL LQGLFDWRULORU GH HILFLHQ

D IDFWRULORU GH SURGXF LH VH FRQVWUXLHVF PRGHOH

HFRQRPHWULFH GHWHUPLQLVWH vQWUH HIHFWH úL HIRUWXUL H[SOLFkQGXVH YDULD LD YDULDELOHORU IDFWRULDOH úL D LQGLFDWRULORUGHSHUIRUPDQ

VDXGHHILFLHQ

DOHDFHVWRUD

$VWIHOvQFD]XOXQXLSURFHVGHSURGXF LHVHGHILQHVF 4

FRQVXPXOVSHFLILF F =

SURGXFWLYLWDWHDPXQFLL Z =

HILFLHQ DIRQGXULORUIL[H H =

0

Ü4 4 /

F¢0

Ü4

4 .

Ü4

Z¢/

H¢.

3H ED]D PRGHOHORU GHWHUPLQLVWH úL GH H[HPSOX SULQ RSHUD LL VLPSOH VHSRWRE LQHPRGHOHGHWHUPLQLVWHFHFRQ LQWUHLúLSDWUXIDFWRUL $VWIHOSHED]DUHOD LLORU úL VHRE LQH

12

Z ¢/ =H ¢.

Z = H¢

.

/

Z = H¢ I

=

XQGH I

. /

UHSUH]LQW vQ]HVWUDUHDWHKQLF DPXQFLL

5HOD LD GHYLQH 4 =Z ¢ / = H ¢ I 4 Ç

¢/

ÌQ FD]XO XQXL DQVDPEOX GH L XQLW

= Ç H

¢ I

¢ /

L VDX UDPXUL HFRQRPLFH UHOD LD VH vQVXPHD]

$FHDVW UHOD LHvQPXO LW FXWHUPHQXO /

4 Ç

XQGH J

=

H Ç

= /

¢ I

/ Ç

¢

/ / Ç

¢Ç /

=

/ Ç

/ VHWUDQVIRUP vQ

H ¢ I ¢J ¢Ç

UHSUH]LQW VWUXFWXUDIRU HLGHPXQF

0RGHOXO UHIOHFW GHSHQGHQ DGHWHUPLQLVW GLQWUHHIHFWXOHFRQRPLF4úLFHOHWUHLJUXSH GHIDFWRULXWLOL]DWHGHDQDOL]DHFRQRPLF IDFWRULFDOLWDWLYLVWUXFWXUDOLúLFDQWLWDWLYL ÌQJHQHUDOXQPRGHOGHWHUPLQLVWVHH[SULP SULQUHOD LD \

I[ VDX\

I[ [ «

0RGHOHOH GHWHUPLQLVWH VH XWLOL]HD] FXUHQW vQ SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF OD DQDOL]D SH IDFWRUL D YDULD LHL vQ WLPS VDX VSD LX D PXOWRU IHQRPHQH HFRQRPLFH ÌQ DFHVW VFRS PRGHOXO GHWHUPLQLVW UHSUH]LQW VXSRUWXOWHRUHWLFDODSOLF ULLPHWRGHLLQGLFLORU±WHULWRULDOLVDXGLQDPLFL±PHWRG DOHF UHL DYDQWDMHúLOLPLWHVXQWELQHFXQRVFXWHHFRQRPLúWLORU E $O GRLOHD PRGHO GH OXFUX HVWH UHSUH]HQWDW GH PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF ± vQ VHQVXO GHILQLULL UHVWULFWLYH D HFRQRPHWULHL ± FDUH IXQGDPHQWkQGXVH SH PHWRGD UHJUHVLHL PHWRG VWDWLVWLFLL GHVFULH OHJ LQIOXHQ

WXUD VWDWLVWLF

VDX VWRFKDVWLF

GLQWUH LQWU

VSHFLILF

ULOH VLVWHPXOXL ± IDFWRULL GH

;±úLLHúLULOHDFHVWXLD±YDULDELOHOHUH]XOWDWLYH
I; 8

$FHVWSURFHGHXVHED]HD] SHSULQFLSLXOFXWLHLQHJUHSULQFLSLXFLEHUQHWLFFDUHvQHFRQRPLH VH IRORVHúWH DWXQFL FkQG GHVFULHUHD IRUPDO D VWUXFWXULL VLVWHPXOXL HVWH LQDFFHVLELO GLQ FDX]D LPSRVLELOLW

LL RE LQHULL LQIRUPD LLORU QHFHVDUH VDX FkQG RE LQHUHD DFHVWRU LQIRUPD LL DU QHFHVLWD

FKHOWXLHOLH[FHVLYHFDUHQXVHMXVWLILF SULQDSRUWXOvQFXQRDúWHUHSHFDUHvOUHDOL]HD] 6SUH GHRVHELUH GH PRGHOXO GHWHUPLQLVW DFFHSWDW I U UH]HUYH GH WHRULD úL SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF LQWURGXFH vQ VFKHPD GH GHVFULHUH DOHJLW

LLGHPDQLIHVWDUH

DXQXLIHQRPHQVDXSURFHVHFRQRPLFúLRYDULDELO DOHDWRDUHVDXvQWkPSO WRDUH8 $SDUHQW DFHDVW PRGDOLWDWH GH IRUPDOL]DUH D OHJ WXULORU GLQWUH IHQRPHQHOH HFRQRPLFH DU FRQWUD]LFH WHRULD HFRQRPLF ± IHQRPHQHOH QX VH SURGXF OD vQWkPSODUH FL SH ED]D XQRU OHJL SURSULL LQHUHQWH ORU ± DúD FXP VD DILUPDW OD vQFHSXWXO DFHVWXL FDSLWRO $FHDVW LQWHUSUHWDUH HVWH LQH[DFW $FFHSWDUHDLQWURGXFHULLYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUHvQYHGHUHDH[SOLF ULLOHJLW

LLGHYDULD LHDXQXLIHQRPHQ

HFRQRPLFFRQFUHWHVWHFHUXW GHXQXOGLQPRWLYHOHGHPDLMRV DSDUL LD úL YDULD LD vQ WLPS VDX VSD LX D XQXL IHQRPHQ HFRQRPLF HVWH GHWHUPLQDW GH XQ VLVWHP QXPHURV GH IDFWRUL FDOLWDWLYL úL FDQWLWDWLYL ,PSRVLELOLWDWHD FXDQWLILF ULL DQXPLWRU IDFWRUL SUHFXP úL GLILFXOW

LOH ULGLFDWH GH UH]ROYDUHD XQRU PRGHOH FX PXOWH YDULDELOH IDFWRULDOH FRQGXF OD R

VSHFLILFDUH IRUPDO LQFRPSOHW GLQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH HFRQRPLF D RELHFWXOXL LQYHVWLJDW $FHDVW VSHFLILFDUHIRUPDO LQFRPSOHW HVWHFRUHFWDW úLYL]XDOL]DW FXDMXWRUXOYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUH8 OHJ WXUD FDX] HIHFW QX SRDWH IL FHUFHWDW vQ PRG QHPLMORFLW vQ ODERUDWRU DúD FXP SURFHGHD] úWLLQ HOH WHKQLFH GHRDUHFH RELHFWXO HFRQRPLF LQYHVWLJDW QX SRDWH IL L]RODW H[WUDV GLQ PHGLXO HFRQRPLF FL QXPDL REVHUYDW SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO GDWHORU VWDWLVWLFH 3H ED]D DFHVWRUD SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO XQXL PRGHO VWDWLVWLFRPDWHPDWLF OHJ WXUD RELHFWLY HVWH HVWLPDW DSUR[LPDW SULQ PLMORFLUHDLQIRUPD LHLVWDWLVWLFH

13

GH IRDUWH PXOWH RUL GDWHOH VWDWLVWLFH SURYLQ GLQ REVHUY UL VHOHFWLYH VHULLOH FURQRORJLFH DYkQG

GH

DVHPHQHD

DFHDVW

SDUWLFXODULWDWH

GLQ

VRQGDMH

DOHDWRDUH

FDUH

LPSULP

WXWXURU

LQGLFDWRULORUFHUFHWD LSHED]DORUDFHDVW SDUWLFXODULWDWHVWDWLVWLF 3HQWUX D MXVWLILFD FRQFUHW QHFHVLWDWHD IRORVLULL YDULDELOHL DOHDWRDUH 8 vQ FDGUXO XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF FkW úL GDWRULW XQRU LQDGYHUWHQ H FH VH vQWkOQHVF vQ SUDFWLF GDWRULW XWLOL] ULL XQRU PRGHOH GH UHJUHVLH vQ ORFXO PRGHOHORU HFRQRPLFH GHWHUPLQLVWH YD IL DERUGDW VXFFLQW DFHDVW SUREOHP 'H IRDUWH PXOWH RUL VH VWXGLD] OHJ WXUD GLQWUH XQ LQGLFDWRU DO SURGXF LHL 4 úL SURGXFWLYLWDWHD PXQFLL Z VDX GLQWUH SURGXFWLYLWDWHD úL vQ]HVWUDUHD WHKQLF D PXQFLL I FX DMXWRUXO XQHLIXQF LLGHUHJXO GHIRUPD4

DE¢ZVDXZ

DE¢I

7HRULD HFRQRPLF D IRUPXODW GHSHQGHQ D GLQWUH YDULDELOHOH GH PDL VXV SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO PRGHOHORUGHWHUPLQLVWH4 4

D E¢Z úL Z

Z¢/úLUHVSHFWLY:

H¢IÌQFRPSDUD LHFXDFHVWHDPRGHOHOH

D E¢I VXQW DIHFWDWH GH HURUL GH VSHFLILFDUH úL GH LGHQWLILFDUH (URDUHD GH

VSHFLILFDUH HVWH UHSUH]HQWDW DWkW GH QHJOLMDUHD IDFWRUXOXL / ± IRU D GH PXQF VDX D HILFLHQ HL IRQGXULORUIL[HFkWúLGHIDSWXOF SDUDPHWULLPRGHOHORUYRUILFDOFXOD LSULQHVWLPD LLVWDWLVWLFHFDV QX PDL DPLQWLP GH IDSWXO F GH FHOH PDL PXOWH RUL GDWHOH VWDWLVWLFH SURYLQ GLQWUXQ VRQGDM 9L]XDOL]DUHD úL LQWHUSUHWDUHD FRUHFW D OHJ WXULL GLQWUH YDULDELOHOH UHVSHFWLYH LPSXQH VSHFLILFDUHD YDULDELOHORUDOHDWRDUHvQFDGUXOPRGHOHORUHFRQRPHWULFH 5HIHULWRU OD HURDUHD GH LGHQWLILFDUH DFHDVWD FRQVW vQ DOHJHUHD JUHúLW D IXQF LHL PDWHPDWLFH )XQF LD 4

D E¢ZDUDW F GDF Z

DWXQFL4

DVWIHOGHVLWXD LLPRGHOXOYDWUHEXLV ILHGHIRUPD\

DFHHDFHUHSUH]LQW RDEHUD LHHFRQRPLF ÌQ E¢[X

3ULQFLSDOHOHWLSXULGHPRGHOHHFRQRPHWULFHXWLOL]DWHvQHFRQRPLH ÌQ PRPHQWXO DFWXDO WLSRORJLD PRGHOHORU HFRQRPHWULFH HVWH H[WUHP GH GLYHUVLILFDW WRWXúL vQ IXQF LHGHDQXPLWHFULWHULLGHFODVLILFDUHHOHVHSRWvQFDGUDvQFkWHYDWLSXULVDXFODVHSULQFLSDOH 0RGHOHXQLIDFWRULDOHúLPRGHOHPXOWLIDFWRULDOH ÌPS

U LUHD PRGHOHORU vQ DFHVWH GRX

IXQF LH GH QXP

FODVH HVWH I

FXW

DúD FXP LQGLF

UXO YDULDELOHORU IDFWRULDOH IRORVLWH vQ YHGHUHD H[SOLF

úL GHQXPLUHD ORU vQ

ULL VLPXO

ULL VDX SURJQR]HL

YDULDELOHORUGHSHQGHQWH 0RGHOXO XQLIDFWRULDO \ HFRQRPLFH GDWRULW

I[ X HVWH IRORVLW vQ PRG IUHFYHQW OD PRGHODUHD IHQRPHQHORU

DYDQWDMHORU SH FDUH OH SUH]LQW

VLPSOLWDWH RSHUDWLYLWDWH úL FRVW UHGXV SHQWUX

RE LQHUHD OXL 8WLOL]DUHD XQXL DVWIHO GH PRGHO VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SH LSRWH]D F vQ UkQGXO IDFWRULORU YDULDELOHL UH]XOWDWLYH \ H[LVW XQ IDFWRU GHWHUPLQDQW [ FHLODO L IDFWRUL FX H[FHS LD DFHVWXLD ILH DX R LQIOXHQ

vQWkPSO WRDUH DFHúWLD ILLQG VSHFLILFD L vQ PRGHO SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO YDULD LHL UH]LGXDOH X ILH

DXIRVWLQYDULDELOLvQSHULRDGDDQDOL]DW úLFDDWDUHQXDUHVHQVVSHFLILFDUHDORUvQPRGHO 'DF LSRWH]D GH PDL VXV QX SRDWH IL DFFHSWDW FD] IUHFYHQW vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPLF VH FRQVWUXLHúWH XQ PRGHO PXOWLIDFWRULDO GH IRUPD \

I[ [ « [ X M = Q XQGH N

QXP UXO

YDULDELOHORUIDFWRULDOH 0RGHOXO

PXOWLIDFWRULDO

HOLPLQkQG

GHILFLHQ D

PRGHOXOXL

XQLIDFWRULDO

WUDQVIRUP

vQV

DYDQWDMHOH DFHVWXLD vQ GH]DYDQWDMH 'LQ DFHVW PRWLY VH UHFRPDQG FD vQ SUDFWLF V QX VH IRORVHDVF XQPRGHOFXPDLPXOWGHWUHLVDXSDWUXYDULDELOHIDFWRULDOH 7RDWH PRGHOHOH HFRQRPHWULFH IRORVLWH SkQ vQ SUH]HQW SRW ILvQFDGUDWHvQWUXQDGLQWUHDFHVWH FODVH'LQFDWHJRULDPRGHOHORUXQLIDFWRULDOHGHPQHGHPHQ LRQDWVXQW OHJHD FHUHULL ± &

IS X XQGH &

YROXPXOFHUHULLXQXLSURGXVLDUS

SUH XOXQLWDUDO

SURGXVXOXL OHJHDRIHUWHL±2

IS XXQGH2

YROXPXORIHUWHL

14

PRGHOXO FRQVXPXOXL ± &

I9 X XQGH &

FRQVXPXO XQXL SURGXV L LDU 9

YHQLWXO

XQHLIDPLOLL PRGHOXO FKHOWXLHOLORU GH SURGXF LH &K vQ IXQF LH GH YROXPXO SURGXF LHL 4 ±&K

I4

X PRGHOXO OHJLL LPSR]LWXOXL , SH YHQLW 9 ± ,

I9 X YDULDELOD DOHDWRDUH X VHPQLILFkQG

DEDWHUHD GH OD GHSHQGHQ D IXQF LRQDO D LPSR]LWXOXL SH YHQLWXO VDODULD LORU FDXUPDUHDXQRUP VXUL GHSROLWLF VRFLDO 6WUXFWXUDO PRGHOHOH PXOWLIDFWRULDOH VXQW GH R PDUH GLYHUVLWDWH &D UHJXO JHQHUDO HOH VH FRQVWUXLHVF SULQ GH]YROWDUHD PRGHOXOXL XQLIDFWRULDO DO YDULDELOHL H[SOLFDWH \ 3H OkQJ YDULDELOD IDFWRULDO LQL LDO [ VH LQWURGXF ILH DOWH YDULDELOH H[RJHQH [ [ « [ ILH YDORUL GHFDODWH DOH DFHVWRUD[ [ «[ 0RGHOHOLQLDUHúLPRGHOHQHOLQLDUH &ODVDDFHVWRUPRGHOHHVWHGHILQLW GHIRUPDOHJ WXULLGLQWUHYDULDELODUH]XOWDWLY úLYDULDELOHOH IDFWRULDOH 6XE IRUP JHQHUDO XQ PRGHO OLQLDU PXOWLIDFWRULDO VH SUH]LQW DVWIHO\

E

E [

E [

« X 0RGHOHOH QHOLQLDUH VH LGHQWLILF FX DMXWRUXO IXQF LLORU QHOLQLDUH FXP DU IL IXQF LD H[SRQHQ LDO KLSHUERO IXQF LDORJLVWLF SDUDERO HWF 'HRDUHFHFHOHGRX JUXSHGHPRGHOHSRVHG SDUWLFXODULW

LVSHFLILFHQHYRPUHIHULODFkWHYD

GLQWUHHOHSRUQLQGGHODXQFD]FRQFUHWFDUHGHDOWIHODúLJHQHUDWUHOHYDUHDDFHVWRUD $VWIHO DQDOL]D OHJ WXULL GLQWUH FRQVXPXO XQXL DQXPLW SURGXV úL YHQLWXO XQHL IDPLOLL VH SRDWH IDFHFXDMXWRUXOXQRUPRGHOHGHIRUPD &

&

DE9X±PRGHOOLQLDU D9

X±PRGHOQHOLQLDU

$FHVW PRGHO SRDWH IL WUDQVIRUPDW SULQORJDULWPDUHvQWUXQPRGHOOLQLDUvQWUHORJDULWPLLFHORU GRX YDULDELOHH[LVWkQGUHOD LD ORJ&

ORJDEORJ9ORJX

XQGH &

FKHOWXLHOLOHPHGLLGHFRQVXPSHRIDPLOLH

9

YHQLWXOPHGLXSHRIDPLOLH

6D FRQVWDWDW vQV F PRGHOXO OLQLDU SUH]LQW FkWHYD QHDMXQVXUL 3ULPXO VH UHIHU OD IDSWXOF DQXPLWHHOHPHQWHGHFRQVXPQXVHPRGLILF vQPRGOLQLDUFXHYROX LDYHQLWXULORUIDPLOLHL± XQHOHSUH]LQW XQDQXPLWQLYHOGHVDWXUD LHSURGXVHOHDOLPHQWDUHvQVSHFLDOLDUDOWHOHDXRH[LVWHQ

SDVDJHU $O GRLOHD QHDMXQV vO FRQVWLWXLH FRHILFLHQWXO GH HODVWLFLWDWH FDUH HVWH YDULDELO úL GLIHULW GH FRHILFLHQWXOGHUHJUHVLH 6H úWLH F vQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO OLQLDU FRHILFLHQWXO GH UHJUHVLH HVWH UHSUH]HQWDW GH SDUDPHWULL YDULDELOHORUIDFWRULDOH6HPQXOFRHILFLHQWXOXLLQGLF VHQVXOOHJ WXULLE!OHJ WXU GLUHFW E OHJ WXU LQYHUV LDU P ULPHD OXL HVWH P VXUD YDULD LHL OXL \ OD R PRGLILFDUH FXRXQLWDWHDYDULDELOHL IDFWRULDOH&RHILFLHQWXOGHHODVWLFLWDWHVHGHILQHúWHDVWIHO F

=

G& &

G9 9

=-

D D + E9

$FHVWD GLIHU úL HO vQ UDSRUW FX SDUDPHWUXO E 3HQWUX XQ QLYHO DO OXL & GDW F GHSLQGH GH P ULPHDYHQLWXOXL'DF D!úLE!DWXQFLF 'HRDUHFHvQSUDFWLF HUDGHGRULWV VHGLVSXQ GHRHODVWLFLWDWHFRQVWDQW DFRQVXPXOXLVDX DFHUHULLvQUDSRUWFXYHQLWXOIDPLOLHLVDXFXSUH XOSURGXVXOXLVDUHFXUVODPRGHOXO ÌQDFHVWFD]FHLGRLFRHILFLHQ LVXQWHJDOLE

FHúLFRQVWDQ LSHQWUXXQDQXPLWHOHPHQWGH

FRQVXP VHPQXO úL P ULPHD ORU RIHULQG LQIRUPD LL QHFHVDUH DQDOL]HL HFRQRPLFH D UDSRUWXOXL FHUHUH RIHUW vQVHQVXOXUP WRU GDF E ± FHUHUHD VDX FRQVXPXO SURGXVXOXL UHVSHFWLY WLQGH V GLVSDU GH SH SLD

VDX GLQ

FRQVXPXOSRSXOD LHL GDF E±FHUHUHDVDXFRQVXPXOSURGXVXOXLWLQGHVSUHXQDQXPLWSUDJGHVDWXUD LH GDF E! ± FHUHUHD VDX FRQVXPXO SURGXVXOXL QX VXQW VDWLVI FXWH VDX QX DGPLW XQ QLYHO GH VDWXUD LH

15

0RGHOHSDU LDOHúLPRGHOHJOREDOHDJUHJDWH $FHVWH PRGHOH UH]XOW vQ XUPD FODVLILF ULL PRGHOHORU HFRQRPHWULFH vQ UDSRUW GH VIHUD ORU GH FXSULQGHUH ,QFOXGHUHD XQXL DQXPLW PRGHO vQ FODVD PRGHOHORU SDU LDOH VDX JOREDOH HVWH UHODWLY 5HIHULQGXQH FRQFUHW OD PRGHODUHD FRQVXPXOXL SRSXOD LHL PRGHOXO FRQVXPXOXL DOLPHQWDU DO SRSXOD LHL HVWH XQ PRGHO SDU LDO vQ UDSRUW FX PRGHOXO JOREDO DO FRQVXPXOXL WRWDO DO SRSXOD LHL ± DFHVWDUH]XOWkQGGLQDJUHJDUHDFRQVXPXULORUDOLPHQWDUQHDOLPHQWDUúLGHVHUYLFLLÌQDFHODúLWLPS FRQVXPXO DOLPHQWDU DO SRSXOD LHL DSDUH FD XQ PRGHO JOREDO DJUHJDW vQ UDSRUW FX PRGHOHOH SDU LDOH

DOHFRQVXPXOXLSHJUXSHRPRJHQHGHFRQVXPDWRULHWF

([SOLFD LLOH GH PDL VXV DX XUP ULW V MXVWLILFH LGHHD F RULFH GHVFULHUH HFRQRPHWULF WUHEXLH V VH IXQGDPHQWH]H SH R FRQFHS LH HFRQRPLF H[SOLFLW VDX LPSOLFLW D IHQRPHQXOXL VWXGLDW 8Q PRGHOHFRQRPHWULFFDUHQXUHVSHFW DFHDVW FRQGL LHUHSUH]LQW RVLPSO VSHFXOD LHPDWHPDWLF I U YDORDUHWHRUHWLF VDXSUDFWLF SHQWUXúWLLQ DHFRQRPLF &ODVLILFDUHD PRGHOHORU HFRQRPHWULFH vQ FHOH GRX WLSXUL SHUPLWH vQV GLVFX LD SUREOHPHL SULYLQG DJUHJDUHD PRGHOHORU SDU LDOH VDX LQYHUV GHVSUH VHPQLILFD LD PRGHOXOXL JOREDO vQ UDSRUW FX PRGHOHOHSDU LDOH $FHDVW SUREOHPD YD IL DERUGDW vQ PRG FRQFUHW vQ FD]XO PRGHO ULL FRQVXPXOXL SRSXOD LHL GHRDUHFHVHYRUSXWHDIRUPXODREVHUYD LLSHUWLQHQWHFDUHU PkQYDODELOHSHQWUXRULFHDOW VLWXD LH )LHPRGHOXO D E [ X L = P

\

W = Q

XQGH

\

FRQVXPXO

[

YHQLWXOJUXSHLLvQDQXOW

$FHVWPRGHOUHSUH]LQW PRGHOXOSDU LDODOJUXSHLRPRJHQHLGHFRQVXPDWRULvQSHULRDGDGHQ DQLÌQVXPkQGFHOHLPRGHOHSDU LDOH VHRE LQHPRGHOXODJUHJDWDODFHVWRUD

Ç\ L

LW

= ÇD L L

+ ÇE [ L L

+ ÇX LW

LW

L

'DF VHLQWURGXFQRWD LLOH

Ç\

LW

Ç[

LW

L

L

Ç DL L

=< = ;

FRQVXPXOWRWDODOSRSXOD LHLvQPRPHQWXOW

W

W

YHQLWXULOHSRSXOD LHLvQPRPHQWXOW

= D úL Ç X = X LW W L

0RGHOXODJUHJDWGHYLQH <

= D + Ç E [ + X

0RGHOXO JOREDO DO FRQVXPXOXL SRSXOD LHL FRQVWUXLW vQ DFHHDúL SHULRDG GH WLPS W vQ IXQF LH GHYHQLWXULOHSRSXOD LHLHVWHGHIRUPD <

= D + E;

'DF WHUPHQXO Ç E [ L L

<

LW

+ X

GLQUHOD LD VHvQPXO HúWHFX

= D +

Ç E [

Ç [

¢ Ç [

+ X

= D +

Ç E [

Ç [

Ç[ Ç[

¢ ; + X

PRGHOXODJUHJDWGHYLQH

&RPSDUkQG PRGHOXO DJUHJDW UH]XOWDW SULQ vQVXPDUHD PRGHOHORU SDU LDOH FX PRGHOXO JOREDO VHGHGXFHF

1H UHIHULP OD JUXSH RPRJHQH GH FRQVXPDWRUL GXS P ULPHD YHQLWXULORU SH FDWHJRULL VRFLRSURIHVLRQDOH SH PHGLL GH SURYHQLHQ

HWF

16

E =

ÇE !

! [ ! "

! " Ç[ !

DGLF SDUDPHWUXO E GLQ PRGHOXO JOREDO ± FRHILFLHQWXO GH UHJUHVLH DO FRQVXPXOXL WRWDO vQ UDSRUW FX YHQLWXULOHSRSXOD LHL±UH]XOW FDRPHGLHDULWPHWLF DFRHILFLHQ LORUSDU LDOLGHUHJUHVLHSRQGHUD LFX YHQLWXULOHFRQVXPDWRULORUGLQJUXSDL[ # $

2 DOW UHOD LH FH VHSRDWHGHGXFHvQWUHFRHILFLHQWXOJOREDODOUHJUHVLHLEúLFHLSDU LDOLE VH

Ö UHIHU ODHVWLPDWRUXODFHVWXLD E

'LQPRGHOXO SULQDSOLFDUHD0&003HVWLPDWRUXOOXLEHVWHHJDOFX

Ö E =

(

)(;

-<

% Ç < %

(

- ; %

)

) &

- ;

% Ç ; %

XQGH

< =

Q

;

' ' < QLYHOXOPHGLXDQXDODOFRQVXPXOXLSRSXOD LHLvQSHULRDGD W = Q ¢Ç

=

¢ Ç;

Q

W

QLYHOXOPHGLXDQXDODOYHQLWXOXLSRSXOD LHL

W

6HFDOFXOHD] PHGLDOXL

XQGH [ 1

=

Q 0

/ . 2 [ 1 0 Ç

UHSUH]LQW PHGLDYHQLWXULORUJUXSHLLGHFRQVXPDWRULvQSHULRDGDW

6F ]kQGGLQPRGHOXO PRGHOXO VHRE LQHUHOD LD 3 <4 - < = Ç E3 [3 4 - Ç E3 [ 3 3

= Ç E3 3

([3 4

- [ 3

)

FDUH VH LQWURGXFH vQ UHOD LD RE LQkQGXVH XUP WRDUHD UHOD LH D FRHILFLHQWXOXL JOREDO GH UHJUHVLH

Ö E =

ÇE 6

(

«

- [

65 Ç [ Ã 5 ¬ 6

7HUPHQXO

9

(

(

- [

8

)(;

)

- ;

9 :

(

- ;

9 Ç ; 9

5

- ;

7

5 Ç ; 5 89 Ç [

)(; 6

)

- ;

)

)³ á ã

Ö 8 QXUHSUH]LQW DOWFHYDGHFkWHVWLPDWRUXOFRHILFLHQWXOXLGH =T

UHJUHVLH D YHQLWXULORU FRQVXPDWRULORU GLQ JUXSD L vQ IXQF LH GH YHQLWXULOH SRSXOD LHL HVWLPDW SH ED]D IXQF LHLGHUHJUHVLH [ ùWLLQGF Ç [ L

LW

LW

Ö = S

= ;

W

L

Ö ; +T L

W

Ö UH]XOW F Ç S L L

Ö = úL Ç T L

=

L

5HYHQLQGODUHOD LD VHGHGXFHF Ö E = ÇE; ;

Ö; ¢T

DGLF FRHILFLHQWXO JOREDO GH UHJUHVLH HVWH HJDO FX VXPD SURGXVHORU GLQWUH FRHILFLHQ LL SDU LDOL GH UHJUHVLH DL FRQVXPXOXL vQ IXQF LH GH YHQLW SH JUXSH RPRJHQH GH FRQVXPDWRUL úL FRHILFLHQ LL GH UHJUHVLHDLDFHVWRUYHQLWXULvQIXQF LHGHYHQLWXULOHSRSXOD LHL

17

5H]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHPDLVXVVHSRWJHQHUDOL]DXúRUHOHU PkQkQGYDODELOHvQRULFHVLWXD LHvQ FDUH VH GLVFXW UDSRUWXO GLQWUH XQ PRGHO SDU LDO úL PRGHOXO JOREDO DO XQHL YDULDELOH UH]XOWDWLYH \ vQ IXQF LH GH XQD VDX PDL PXOWH YDULDELOH IDFWRULDOH [ vQWUH FDUH H[LVW R UHOD LH GH GHSHQGHQ

OLQLDU

ÌQ FD]XO GHSHQGHQ HORU QHOLQLDUH GXS OLQLDUL]DUHD DFHVWRUD IRUPXOHOH GH PDL VXV YRU F S WD SDUWLFXODULW

LVSHFLILFH

ÌQILQDOGLVFX LDUDSRUWXOXLPRGHOHSDU LDOHPRGHOHJOREDOHSHUPLWHIRUPXODUHDXUP WRDUHORU FRQFOX]LL DJUHJDUHD PRGHOHORU SDU LDOH QX FRQGXFH OD RE LQHUHD PRGHOXOXL JOREDO DO YDULDELOHL UHVSHFWLYH PRGHOXOJOREDOUH]XOW FDRPHGLHDPRGHOHORUSDU LDOH vQ SODQ WUDQVYHUVDO UHVSHFWLY vQ SURILO WHULWRULDO GH H[HPSOX VDX FD H[SOLFD LH LVWRULF D GHSHQGHQ HL GLQWUH GRX VDX PDL PXOWH IHQRPHQH HFRQRPLFH PRGHOXO JOREDO VH SRDWH HVWLPD SH ED]DPRGHOHORUSDU < LDOHGDF VHDFFHSW FDVHPQLILFDWLY YDORDUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLJOREDOGHUHJUHVLH

YH]LUHOD LD

vQ VFRSXUL GH SURJQR] PRGHOXO JOREDO QX FRQGXFH OD UH]XOWDWH VHPQLILFDWLYH GHFkW GDF FRHILFLHQWXOJOREDOGHUHJUHVLHU PkQHVWDELO 'LQUHOD LD VHGHGXFHF DFHDVW FRQGL LHVHUHDOL]HD] vQXUP WRDUHOHVLWXD LL

E=

E

(" )L

= P FRHILFLHQ LL SDU LDOL GH UHJUHVLH VXQW FRQVWDQ L úL HJDOL FX FRHILFLHQWXO JOREDO

GHUHJHUHVLH

Ö T

L

= FRQVWDQWvQRUL]RQWXOGHSURJQR] FHHDFHSUHVXSXQHRFUHúWHUHSURSRU LRQDO vQWUHQLYHOXO

YDULDELOHL IDFWRULDOH SH DQVDPEOXO XQLW JUXSHOHFROHFWLYLW

LORU VWDWLVWLFH úL QLYHOXO DFHVWHL YDULDELOH FHQWUDOL]DWH SH

LL

0RGHOHVWDWLFHúLPRGHOHGLQDPLFH 8QPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFVWDWLFHVWHDFHODvQFDUHGHSHQGHQ DYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHÄ\´ID

GH

YDORULOHYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQHÄ[> ´VHUHDOL]HD] vQDFHHDúLSHULRDG GHWLPS \

I[ ?A@ «[>A@ «[BC@ X @ W = Q M = N

6SUH GHRVHELUH GH DFHVWHD PRGHOHOH HFRQRPHWULFH GLQDPLFH VH GHILQHVF SULQ XUP WRDUHOH WLSXUL D ,QWURGXFHUHDvQSDFKHWXOGHYDULDELOHH[SOLFDWLYHÄ[> ´vQPRGH[SOLFLWDYDULDELOHLWLPS \@

I[ ?A@ [D-@ W X @

8QDVWIHOGHPRGHOVHMXVWLILF DWXQFLFkQG SULQWUH IDFWRULL LPSRUWDQ L GH LQIOXHQ F URU LQIOXHQ

DL YDULDELOHL \ VH DIO úL IDFWRUL GH QDWXU FDOLWDWLY D

QX SRDWH IL UHIOHFWDW GH PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF GDWRULW OLSVHL XQHL P VXUL VWDWLFH

DGHFYDWH GH H[HPSOX LQIOXHQ D SUHIHULQ HORU VDX JXVWXULORU SRSXOD LHL DVXSUD FRQVXPXOXL VDX LQIOXHQ DSURJUHVXOXLWHKQLFvQIXQF LLOHGHSURGXF LH SRDWH IL DFFHSWDW LSRWH]D XQXL HIHFW LQHU LDO vQ HYROX LD IHQRPHQXOXL \ LSRWH] FDUH vQ GRPHQLXO IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH SRDWH IL DFFHSWDW GDWRULW PDVHL VRFLDOH FDUH OH JHQHUHD] úL GH FDUHEHQHILFLD] E PRGHOH DXWRUHJUHVLYH ± FkQG vQ SDFKHWXO GH YDULDELOH H[SOLFDWLYH Ä[> ´ VH LQWURGXFH úL YDULDELODH[SOLFDW Ä\´GDUFXYDORULGHFDODWH\ @ E? \ @ E D «\ @ E B UHSUH]HQWkQGXQPRGHODXWRUHJUHVLYGH RUGLQXOÄN´ \@

I[ @ \ @ E B X @

F PRGHO FX GHFDODM vQ FDUH YDULDELOD IDFWRULDO Ä[´ vúL H[HUFLW LQIOXHQ D DVXSUD YDULD LHL YDULDELOHLÄ\´SHPDLPXOWHSHULRDGHGHWLPS \

XQGHN

I[ @ «[ @ E? «[ @ E F X @

W = Q M = N N < W

OXQJLPHDSHULRDGHLGHGHFDODMODJ

([HPSOH G

&RHILFLHQWXO JOREDO GH UHJUHVLH ILLQG PHGLD DULWPHWLF SRQGHUDW D FRHILFLHQ LORU SDU LDOL E H UHOD LD ±VHSXQH

SUREOHPDUHSUH]HQWDWLYLW

LLDFHVWXLD

18

.@

I, @ «, @ E? «, @ E B X @

XQGH .@ ,@

IRQGXULOHIL[HSXVHvQIXQF LXQHvQSHULRDGDW LQYHVWL LLOHHIHFWXDWHvQSHULRDGDWN«W 4I

I, @ «, @ E? «, @ E B X @

XQGH 4@ ,@

SURGXF LDPHGLHODKD FDQWLWDWHDGHvQJU ú PLQWHODKD

$FHVWH WLSXUL GH PRGHOH D E F VH XWLOL]HD] vQ VSHFLDO OD SURJQR]D IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH'DF SULPHOHPRGHOH±WLSXODE QXULGLF GLILFXOW

LSULYLQGLGHQWLILFDUHDHVWLPDUHD

úL YHULILFDUHD DFHVWRUD HOH ILLQG GH JHQXO PRGHOHORU HFRQRPHWULFH PXOWLIDFWRULDOH PRGHOHOH GLQDPLFHFXGHFDODMSUH]LQW FkWHYDGLILFXOW

L

3ULPDVHUHIHU ODP ULPHDGHFDODMXOXLÄN´±FXFkWDFHVWDHVWHPDLPDUHFXDWkWVHSLHUGPDL PXOWH YDORUL DOH YDULDELOHORU QHDMXQV FH LPSXQH FRQVWUXLUHD XQHL VHULL OXQJL GH GDWH D IHQRPHQHORU DQDOL]DWHSHFkQGvQHFRQRPLHVHOXFUHD] GHRELFHLFXHúDQWLRDQHGHYROXPPLF $ GRXD GLILFXOWDWH R UHSUH]LQW H[LVWHQ D IHQRPHQXOXL GH PXOWLFROLQHDULWDWH vQWUH YDORULOH GHFDODWH DOH YDULDELOHL H[RJHQH ±

FRY ([

W

[

W -N

FRQGXFHODRE LQHUHDGHHVWLPDWRULQHVHPQLILFDWLYL

)¹

" W = Q N < W ± PXOWLFROLQHDULWDWH FDUH

EL

<

K V J

0RGHOHFXRVLQJXU

HFXD LHúLPRGHOHFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH

$O WXUL GH DFHVWH WLSXUL GH PRGHOH HFRQRPHWULFH VH PDL SRW FRQVWUXL úL PRGHOH FX R VLQJXU

HFXD LHúLPRGHOHFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH 'LQFDWHJRULDPRGHOHORUFXVLQJXU

HFXD LHIDFSDUWHWRDWHPRGHOHOHSUH]HQWDWHPDLVXV

0RGHOHOH HFRQRPHWULFH FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH VXQW IRUPDWH GLQWUXQ VLVWHP GH HFXD LL $FHVWHD VHSRWSUH]HQWDVXEGRX IRUPHVXEIRUP 8Q PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VXE IRUP

VWUXFWXUDO VWUXFWXUDO

úLVXEIRUP

UHGXV

VDXFDQRQLF

UHSUH]LQW WUDQVSXQHUHD IRUPDO ± SULQWUXQ

VLVWHPGHHFXD LL±DSURFHVXOXLHFRQRPLF)RUPDJHQHUDO DDFHVWXLPRGHOHVWHXUP WRDUHD < ? E ?MD
E ?MN
F ?? ; ? F ?MD ;D FDP? ; ? FDD ;D

F ?MO ;O FDO ;O

8 ? 8D

ENP? < ? END

FNP? ; ? FND ;D FNO ;O

8N

< = L

Q ±YDULDELOHH[SOLFDWHVDXHQGRJHQH

;> M

P ±YDULDELOHH[SOLFDWLYHVDXH[RJHQH

5H]ROYDUHD XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF SUHVXSXQH HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU E = > úL F = > FX DMXWRUXO XQHLDQXPLWHPHWRGHVWRFKDVWLFHGHHVWLPDUHDDFHVWRUD 'LQWUHPHWRGHOHIRORVLWHODHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFPHQ LRQ P PHWRGDFHORUPDLPLFLS WUDWH0&003 vQWURVLQJXU WUHDSW 0:DOG 0&003vQGRX WUHSWH+7KHLO 0&003vQWUHLWUHSWH$=HOOQHU PHWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

LLPD[LPHFXLQIRUPD LHOLPLWDW $QGHUVRQ5XELQ

'HRDUHFHDSOLFDUHDXQHLPHWRGHGHHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOVXEIRUP VWUXFWXUDO FRQGXFH OD RE LQHUHD GH HVWLPD LL GHSODVDWH DOH SDUDPHWULORU E = > úL F = > PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF VXE DFHDVW IRUP WUHEXLHWUDQVIRUPDWVXEIRUP UHGXV VDXFDQRQLF 8Q PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF HVWH VXE IRUP UHGXV VDX FDQRQLF GDF ILHFDUH YDULDELO HQGRJHQ HVWHH[SULPDW QXPDLvQIXQF LHGHYDULDELOHOHH[RJHQH

19

0RGHOHHXULVWLFHVDXUD LRQDOHúLPRGHOHGHFL]LRQDOHVDXRSHUD LRQDOH 7LSRORJLD PRGHOHORU HFRQRPHWULFH HVWH IRDUWH YDVW WRWXúL DFHVWHD SRW IL vPS U LWH vQ GRX PDULJUXSHPRGHOHHXULVWLFHVDXUD LRQDOHúLPRGHOHGHFL]LRQDOHVDXRSHUD LRQDOH 0RGHOHOHHXULVWLFHVDXUD LRQDOHVXQWIRORVLWHvQVSHFLDOGHWHRULDHFRQRPLF SHQWUXDH[SOLFD SH R FDOH PDL VLPSO XQ VLVWHP FRPSOH[ GH GHSHQGHQ H úL LQWHUGHSHQGHQ H FH VH PDQLIHVW vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPLF 0RGHOXO WHRUHWLF UHSUH]LQW GH IDSW R IRUP VLPSOLILFDW D PRGHOXOXL UHDO GHRDUHFHvQFDGUXODFHVWXLDQXSRWILLQFOXúLWR LIDFWRULL 0RGHOHOH GHFL]LRQDOH VDX RSHUD LRQDOH VH XWLOL]HD] vQ VSHFLDO vQ SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF HOH ILLQG IRORVLWH OD IXQGDPHQWDUHD XQRU GHFL]LL GH SROLWLF HFRQRPLF VLPXODUH úL OD SURJQR]D IHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPLFH (YLGHQWF GLIHUHQ DGLQWUHDFHVWHGRX PRGHOHQXHVWHDEVROXW DGLF XQPRGHOUD LRQDOVDX WHRUHWLFSRDWHILXWLOL]DWFDXQPRGHORSHUD LRQDOGDF SRWILDFFHSWDWHDQXPLWHLSRWH]H 8Q H[HPSOX GH PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF FH SRDWH IL IRORVLW DWkW vQ VFRSXUL HXULVWLFH FkW úL vQ VFRSXULRSHUD LRQDOHvOUHSUH]LQW PRGHOXOHFRQRPHWULFXWLOL]DWODGHVFULHUHDSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUX 3HED]DWHRULHLHFRQRPLFHDGHILQLULLXQHLSLH HOLEHUHúLDFRQFHSWXOXLGHKRPRHFRQRPLFXV ILLQ

UD LRQDO FRPSRUWDPHQWH ORJLFH PRGHOXO XWLOL]DW OD GHVFULHUHD IRUP ULL SUH XOXL GH HFKLOLEUX

HVWH 3

I& X

3

I2 ]

2

ÌQVLWXD LDSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUX&

3HFDOHORJLF VHGHGXFHF UHOD LDGLQWUHSUH úLFHUHUHHVWHGHIRUP LQYHUV úLF RDVWIHOGH UHOD LHSRDWHILGHVFULV FXDMXWRUXOXQHLIXQF LLPRQRWRQGHVFUHVF WRDUHOLQLDU VDXSXWHUH )XQF LHOLQLDU 3 )XQF LHSXWHUH3

DE&E Q

D&

OQDEOQ&

ÜOQ3

ÌQPRGDQDORJVHSRDWHGHGXFHF OHJHDRIHUWHLSRDWHILGHVFULV FXDMXWRUXODFHORUDúLIXQF LL )XQF LHOLQLDU 3 )XQF LHSXWHUH3

ab2 R

a2

!OQ2

OQabOQ2

$FHDVWDvQVHDPQ F OHJHDRIHUWHLúLDFHUHULLSRDWHILGHVFULV ILHFXDMXWRUXOXQHLGUHSWHILH SHED]DXQHLVF ULORJDULWPLFH

3

OQ3

&2

OQ&OQ2

)LJXUD'UHDSW )LJXUD6FDU ORJDULWPLF (VWH FXQRVFXW IDSWXO F H[SOLFDUHD IRUP ULL SUH XOXL GH HFKLOLEUX VH IDFH SH ED]D XQXL JUDILF GHIRUPD

&U

3

2S

&S

(U

3U

T

2U

(S T

3S T

3V

2S

T

&S

T

2U

)LJXUD

T

&U

T

2V

T

&V

T &2

20

,QWHUSUHWkQG PRGLILFDUHD SUH XOXL GH HFKLOLEUX GHVFULV FX DMXWRUXO XQHL IXQF LL OLQLDUH SXWHP FRQVWDWD F vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH FHUHUHD VH PRGLILF FUHúWH LDU RIHUWD U PkQH FRQVWDQW DFHDVW PRGLILFDUH SUHVXSXQH ILH R GHSODVDUH SDUDOHO FX SULPD GUHDSW ILH GUHDSWD SLYRWHD] GLQ SXQFWXO GHLQWHUVHF LHFXD[D2\ ÌQSULPXOFD]3 GUHSWHLGLVWDQ DID

DE&Ü3¶

D ?

E& LDUvQDOGRLOHDFD]VHPRGLILF SDQWD

GHRULJLQHU PkQkQGFRQVWDQW 3´

DE ? &

ÌQ SUDFWLF FHOH GRX VLWXD LL DSDU FkQG DX ORF FRPSHQV UL ± SULPXO FD] UHVSHFWLY FkQG DX ORFLQGH[ UL±DOGRLOHDFD] ÌQ PRG DQDORJ VH SURFHGHD] úL vQ FD]XO PRGLILF ULL RIHUWHL VDX D PRGLILF ULL VLPXOWDQH D FHUHULLúLRIHUWHL ÌQ SOXV GHVFULHUHD OHJLL FHUHULL FX DMXWRUXO XQHL IXQF LL PDWHPDWLFH SHUPLWH GHILQLUHD ULJXURDV DXQRUFRQFHSWHHFRQRPLFHFXPDUILFRHILFLHQWXOPDUJLQDOúLFRHILFLHQWXOGHHODVWLFLWDWH $VWIHOvQFD]XOXQHLGUHSWHFRHILFLHQWXOPDUJLQDOHVWHGHIRUPD

FP =

3

&

= E Ü FP = F W

LDUFRHILFLHQWXOGHHODVWLFLWDWHHVWHGHIRUPD FH =

3

3

¢

&

&

=

E& D +E &

3 - D

=

= -

D+E&

D D+E&

Ü FH

[ ]

vQDFHVWFD]H[LVWkQGRHODVWLFLWDWHULJLG ÌQ JHQHUDO WHRULD HFRQRPLF XWLOL]HD] FX SUHGLOHF LH IXQF LD SXWHUH SHQWUX D H[SOLFD IRUPDUHDSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUXUHIHULWRUODOHJHDFHUHULL Q 3

D&

ÜOQ3

OQDEOQ&

$FHDVW IXQF LH SUH]LQW SURSULHWDWHD F SDQWD GUHSWHL UHVSHFWLY FRHILFLHQWXO PDUJLQDO HVWH HJDO FX FRHILFLHQWXO GH HODVWLFLWDWH F P = F H =

OQ

OQ

3 &

= E UH]XOWkQG FRHILFLHQWXO GH

HODVWLFLWDWH D SUH XOXL vQ IXQF LH GH FHUHUH DWXQFL FkQG OHJHD FHUHULL SRDWH IL GHVFULV FX DMXWRUXO X QZY N\[ HW

IXQF LHLSXWHUHVDXDFHOHLH[SRQHQ LDOH3

$FHVW PRGHO UD LRQDO VDX HXULVWLF SRDWH IL XWLOL]DW FD PRGHO RSHUD LRQDO UHVSHFWLY vQ YHGHUHD FDOFXO ULLSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUXGDF SRWILDFFHSWDWHFkWHYDLSRWH]HFXPDUIL VHFXQRDúWHQXP UXOFXPS U WRULORUúLFHODOYkQ] WRULORU VH FXQRVF RS LXQLOH IHUPH DOH DFHVWRUD SULYLQG FDQWLWDWHD FHUXW VDX RIHULW VSUH YkQ]DUH SUHFXPúLSUH XOGHFXPS UDUHúLGHYkQ]DUHUHVSHFWLYSUHIHULQ HOHFXPS U WRULORUúLYkQ] WRULORUDX XQFDUDFWHUFHUWúLQXDOHDWRU $FHVWH LSRWH]H VH YHULILF vQ JHQHUDO SH SLD D EXUVLHU XQGH GH UHJXO SUH XO GH HFKLOLEUX DO XQHLDF LXQLVDXSURGXVPDUI VHFDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXOPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULFXUP WRU V DGPLWHPF SHQWUX]LXD+VHFXQRVFXUP WRDUHOHGDWHUHIHULWRDUHODSUH XOGHFXPS UDUHúL YROXPXOFHUHULLGHDF LXQLSUHFXPúLSUH XOGHYkQ]DUHúLYROXPXORIHUWHLDFHVWRUD

7DEHO 2IHUWD

EXF 3UH

OHLEXF 7DEHO &HUHUH

EXF 3UH OHLEXF

21

'HVFULHUHDHFRQRPHWULF DIRUP ULLSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUXVHUHDOL]HD] FXDMXWRUXOPRGHOXOXL 3

I& X

3

I2 ]

&

2

3HQWUX LGHQWLILFDUHD OHJLL FHUHULL úL D RIHUWHL YRU WUHEXL FRQVWUXLWH VHULLOH VWDWLVWLFH úL VH YD HIHFWXDUHSUH]HQWDUHDJUDILF DDFHVWRUD &RQVWUXLUHDVHULLORUVWDWLVWLFHVHIDFHSHED]DXUP WRUXOXLUD LRQDPHQW GDF XQFXPS U WRUDFKL]L LRQHD] RFDQWLWDWHGHDF LXQLODXQDQXPLWSUH HOYDFXPS UDFX DWkWPDLPXOWFXFkWSUH XOYDILPDLPLF GDF XQ RIHUWDQW vúL YLQGH DF LXQLOH OD XQ DQXPLW SUH HO OH YD YLQGH FX DWkW PDL PXOW FX FkW SUH XOYDILPDLPDUH 5H]XOW DVWIHO XUP WRDUHOH VHULL VWDWLVWLFH FRQVWUXLWH vQ XUPD RUGRQ ULL SUH XULORU DQXQ DWH GH FXPS U WRULúLRIHUWDQ L 7DEHO

&

2IHUWD

3UH XO

&HUHUHD

EXF

OHLEXF

EXF

2

]_^Z` a bdc

]_^Z` a efc

gAh iCjkPl-a ]m^ ` a efc c

gAh iCjkPl-a ]m^ ` a bnc c

3

)LJXUD)RUPDUHDSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUX ÌQ XUPD UHSUH]HQW ULL JUDILFH VH REVHUY F OHJLOH FHUHULL úL DOH RIHUWHL SRW IL DSUR[LPDWH FX GRX IXQF LLOLQLDUHGHIRUPD /HJHDFHUHULL3

DE&]

/HJHDRIHUWHL3

ab2X

ÌQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU D E a b VHDSOLF PHWRGDFHORUPDLPLFLS WUDWHILHF UXL Ö

Ö

Ö b Ö E a PRGHOvQSDUWHUH]XOWkQGDVWIHOHVWLPDWRULLSDUDPHWULORU D

9ROXPXOGHHFKLOLEUXVHFDOFXOHD] DVWIHO

2 = & Ü D + E & = a + b 2 Ü 2 = & =

a-D

E -b

22

LDUSUH XOGHHFKLOLEUXYDIL

3 =

D + E ¢

a -D

E -b

=

a E - D b

E -b

8Q DVWIHO GHPRGHORSHUD LRQDOVHIRORVHúWHODHVWLPDUHDFXUVXOXLYDOXWDUIL[LQJXOEDQFDU úL

ODHVWLPDUHDSUH XULORUDF LXQLORUSHSLH HOHGHFDSLWDO

'H DVHPHQHD DFHVWD SRDWH IL DGDSWDW úL OD DQDOL]D FHUHULL úL RIHUWHL RULF UXL EXQ VDX VHUYLFLX

GHFRQVXPGDF LSRWH]HOHPHQ LRQDWHPDLVXVSRWILDFFHSWDWH

%,%/,2*5$),( WHRUHWLF

%DURQ7%LML(úLFROHFWLY6WDWLVWLF

úLHFRQRPLF

(GLWXUD'LGDFWLF úL3HGDJRJLF

%XFXUHúWL %DOWDJL%(FRQRPHWULFV6SULQJHU%HUOLQ *LUDXG5&KDL[1eFRQRPpWULH38)3DULV *UHHQH+:(FRQRPHWULF$QDO\VLV0DFPLOODQ3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\1HZ
HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
/DEURXVVH&,QWURGXFWLRQDO¶pFRQRPpWULH'XQRG3DULV p 0DGGDOD*6,QWURGXFWLRQWR(FRQRPHWULFVo

HG0F0LOODQ&R1HZ
3HFLFDQ(7 Q VRLX2(FRQRPHWULHOLWR$6(%XFXUHúWL 3LQG\FN 5 6 5XELQIHOG ' 6 (FRQRPHWULF 0RGHOV DQG (FRQRPLF )RUHFDVWV q

p

HG 0F

*UDZ+LOO1HZ
D IRUP

ULL SUH XOXL GH HFKLOLEUX vQ HFRQRPLD GH SLD

5HYLVWD5RPkQ GH6WDWLVWLF QUSDJ

23

&DSLWROXO,,, 0RGHOXOXQLIDFWRULDO

6SHFLILFDUHDúLGHILQLUHDPRGHOXOXLXQLIDFWRULDO

6SHFLILFDUHD XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VH IDFH SH ED]D WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH D IHQRPHQXOXL REVHUYDWúLFRQVW vQSUHFL]DUHDYDULDELOHLHQGRJHQHúLDYDULDELOHLH[RJHQH 8QPRGHOXQLIDFWRULDOVHSUH]LQW DVWIHO \

= I [ + X

XQGH \ [ X

(\

K \ ) YDULDELODHQGRJHQ VDXUH]XOWDWLY ( [ [ K [ ) YDULDELODH[RJHQ VDXIDFWRULDO VDXFDX]DO (X X K X ) YDULDELODUH]LGXDO DOHDWRDUHVDXHURDUH

\

5HOD LD UHSUH]LQW R LSRWH] FRQVWUXLW SH ED]D WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH úL SUHVXSXQH F IHQRPHQXO HFRQRPLF \ HVWH UH]XOWDWXO DF LXQLL XQXL FRPSOH[ GH IDFWRUL IHQRPHQXO HFRQRPLF [ HVWH IDFWRUXO SULQFLSDO HVHQ LDO FH GHWHUPLQ IHQRPHQXO \ UHVWXO IDFWRULORU ILLQG FRQVLGHUD L QHHVHQ LDOL FXDF LXQHvQWkPSO WRDUHHLILLQGVSHFLILFD LvQPRGHOXOHFRQRPHWULFFXDMXWRUXOYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUH X&DRULFHLSRWH] WHRUHWLF HDSRDWHILDGHY UDW VDXIDOV ±[HVWHVDXQXHVWHIDFWRUXOKRW UkWRUDO IHQRPHQXOXL \ ± LDU YDOLGDUHD VDX LQYDOLGDUHD XQHL DVWIHO GH LSRWH]H VH IDFH vQ XUPD XQXL ÄH[SHULPHQW´VWDWLVWLF 7HRULD HFRQRPLF D IRORVLW úL IRORVHúWH vQ QXPHURDVH FD]XUL PRGHOXO XQLIDFWRULDO SHQWUX D IXQGDPHQWD úL GHVFULH PHFDQLVPXO GH IRUPDUH úL GH PDQLIHVWDUH D OHJLORU HFRQRPLFH ÌQ DFHVW VHQV SRWILPHQ LRQDWH

OHJHD FHUHULL &

I3 X I¶3 Ó FHUHUHD & XQXL DQXPLW SURGXV FUHúWH VDX VH

UHGXFHGDF SUH XO3 DFHVWXLDVHPLFúRUHD] VDXVHP UHúWH

OHJHDRIHUWHL2

J3 XJ¶3 !ÓRIHUWD2 XQXLSURGXVFUHúWHVDXVHGLPLQXHD]

GDF SUH XO3 DFHVWXLDVHP UHúWHVDXVFDGH

IXQF LDGHSURGXF LHDFKHOWXLHOLORUWRWDOHDOHXQHLILUPH&K

I4 X

I¶4 !

Ó FKHOWXLHOLOH GH SURGXF LH FUHVF VDX VFDG GDF YROXPXOSURGXF LHLFUHúWHVDXVFDGHvQ VLWXD LDvQFDUHSURGXFWLYLWDWHDU PkQHFRQVWDQW

OHJLOHFRQVXPXOXL±IRUPXODWHGH(QJHOúLGHVFULVHGHIXQF LLOHOXL7RUQTYLVW±FRQVLGHU YHQLWXO 9 FRQVXPDWRUXOXL FD SULQFLSDO IDFWRU DO FRQVXPXOXL & XQXL SURGXV VDX JUXSH GHSURGXVH&

I9 XI¶9 !

'H DVHPHQHD IRDUWH PXOWH DQDOL]H HFRQRPLFH XWLOL]HD] PRGHOXO XQLIDFWRULDO SHQWUX D H[SOLFDúLSURVSHFWDGHSHQGHQ DGLQWUHGRX IHQRPHQHFXPDUIL

FRUHOD LDGLQWUHFUHúWHUHDSUH XULORUúLFUHúWHUHDVDODULLORU

FRUHOD LDGLQWUHFUHúWHUHDSUH XULORUúLUDWDúRPDMXOXL±FXUEDOXL3KLOLSV

FRUHOD LDGLQWUHFUHúWHUHDVDODULLORUúLSURGXFWLYLWDWHDPXQFLLHWF

,GHQWLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLXQLIDFWRULDO ,GHQWLILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL FRQVW vQ DOHJHUHD XQHL IXQF LL VDX D XQXL JUXS GH IXQF LL PDWHPDWLFH FX DMXWRUXO F UHLD VH XUP UHúWH V VH GHVFULH V VH DSUR[LPH]H YDORULOH YDULDELOHL HQGRJHQH \ QXPDL vQ IXQF LH GH YDULD LD YDULDELOHL H[RJHQH [ )XQF LLOH PDWHPDWLFH FDUH VH SRW XWLOL]D vQ DFHVW VHQV ± IXQF LL OLQLDUH VDX QHOLQLDUH ± VXQW QXPHURDVH úL GH IRUPH GLYHUVH SULQWUH DFHVWHDILJXUkQGúLFHOHSUH]HQWDWHvQFRQWLQXDUH

24

\

\

D

DE!

E!

DE!

E

D!E

D

[

)XQF LDOLQLDU D

\

DE[X

)XQF LDVHPLORJDULWPLF

[

DEORJ[X

\

\

\

E!

E

E

QLYHOGHVDWXUD LH

D

E!

E E

[

)XQF LDSXWHUHúLIXQF LDORJDULWPLF \

D[ X

ORJ\

ORJDEORJ[XVDXORJ\

[

)XQF LDLQYHUV KLSHUEROD

\ =D +

E [

+X

DEORJ[X

\

\

\

E! H[SD

QLYHOGHVDWXUD LH EF!

E

)XQF LDORJLQYHUV ORJ \ = D +

[

E [

+X

EF!

E F -

E

[

F

)XQF LDORJORJLQYHUV

ORJ \ = D +

E [

+ F ORJ [ + X

25

\

DF!

\

D

E

F!

\

\

E! DF!

E

DF \

E!

\

-

DF

F

H

3DUDERODGHJUDGXO,, \ = D + E[ + F[

+ X

[

E

E!

[

3DUDERODORJDULWPLF

\ = D + E ORJ [ + F (ORJ [

)

+X

\

D

\

1LYHOGHVDWXUD LH

,,

D

\

D!E!

D!E

1LYHOGH

,

VDWXUD LH

&

[

+ '

#

" $&%('*) !

[

H

)XQF LLOHOXL7RUQTXLVW

\ =D

,

,,

[ [ +E

\ =D

[ -F [ +E

\ = [ (D + E ORJ [

)+X

+ X DE >

+X

[ -F

\ = D[

,,,

)XQF LDOXL.RQLXV

[ +E

D F > E > -F

[ ËF

+ X D F > E > -F

[ ËF

\

F

1LYHOGHVDWXUD LH

E!

E

\

\ =

E

[

F

=

F

5 6 4 1 2&3 0

+H

\ =

+X

. / - ,

+H

F + H

9

: 8 7

+X

+X

)XQF LDORJLVWLF

$OHJHUHDXQHLDQXPLWHIXQF LLPDWHPDWLFHFDIXQF LHGHUHJUHVLHDXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULF± <

I[ ± VH IDFH SH ED]D YDORULORU UHDOH VDX HPSLULFH DOH FHORU GRX IHQRPHQH HFRQRPLFH

26

VLVWHPDWL]DWH ILHvQVHULLVSD LDOH\ ; [ ; L = Q Q

QXP UXOXQLW

LORUVWDWLVWLFHRPRJHQHODFDUH

VDX vQUHJLVWUDWvQWURDQXPLW SHULRDG GHWLPSYDORULOHFHORUGRX IHQRPHQH\úL[ILHvQVHULLGH WLPS \ < [ < W = Q Q

QXP UXO SHULRDGHORU GH WLPS vQ FDUH VDX vQUHJLVWUDW YDORULOH FHORU GRX

IHQRPHQH\úL[ODDFHHDúLXQLWDWHVWDWLVWLF 'LVSXQkQG GH R VHULH VWDWLVWLF SULYLQG YDULD LD vQ WLPS VDX vQ VSD LX D FHORU GRX YDULDELOH HFRQRPLFH YH]L WDEHOXO SUREOHPD LGHQWLILF ULL FRQVW vQ D DOHJH R IXQF LH PDWHPDWLF < < I[ <

FX DMXWRUXO F UHLD FXQRVFkQG YDORULOH IHQRPHQXOXL HFRQRPLF

V VH DSUR[LPH]H V VH

[ <

HVWLPH]H FkW PDL ELQH FX HURUL FkW PDL PLFL YDORULOH HPSLULFH DOH IHQRPHQXOXL \ <

\ = \> B B B

\? SULQYDORULOHWHRUHWLFH

7DEHO [<

\<

[=

\=

[>

\>

FPC

\ [

M

M

[?

\?

\

=

[

B

- \

B

- [

B

B

A @

A @

=

FH G

F D E F D \ E

[

H H

- \I

= FP

- [I

H

FH K

=

[

¢

\ [

L

- \

- [

L

L

¢

J

\

M N

-

\K

- \

[K

- [

J

J

M

M N

F

[

F D E F D [ E

- \

J

M L

F

\

L

= FP

FH P

=

[P \P

O Q

¢

O

Q

\P

- \P

[P

- [P

O Q O Q

$FHDVW RSHUD LHVHSRDWHIDFHvQJHQHUDOXWLOL]kQGXUP WRDUHOHSURFHGHHGHOXFUX D SURFHGHXOJUDILF E SURFHGHXOFRQVHUY ULLDULLORU F SURFHGHXOFDOFXOHORUDOJHEULFH D 3URFHGHXOJUDILFFRQVW vQFRQVWUXLUHDFRUHORJUDPHLGLQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOH

\ \

Y[Z]\

/

\

6 X

/

[

)LJXUD /D FRQVWUXLUHD FRUHORJUDPHL VFDOD SH FHOH GRX D[H 2\ úL 2[ WUHEXLH V VH FDOFXOH]H SH ED]DXUP WRDUHLUHJXOL 2[ FP

$

U

/

=

[

RTSVU

- [ /

W

27

2\ FP

$b /

=

\

^T_a`

- \

c

/

DGLF YDULD LD ILHF UHL YDULDELOH H[SULPDW SULQ DPSOLWXGLQHD DFHVWHLD $d úL $e HVWH UHSUH]HQWDW SULQWUXQ XQ VHJPHQW GH GUHDSW DYkQG DFHHDúL OXQJLPH / SH FHOH GRX D[H ÌQ DFHVW PRG LQWHQVLWDWHDOHJ WXULLGLQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOHH[SULPDW SULQDPSOLWXGLQHDDFHVWRUDQXHVWHYLFLDW GHJUDILF±SULQDSODWL]DUHDVDXDOXQJLUHDDFHVWXLD 3ULQXQLUHDFXVHJPHQWHGHGUHDSW DSXQFWHORU1[ < \ < VHRE LQHJUDILFXOSXQFWHORUHPSLULFH ±YH]L)LJXUDÌQIXQF LHGHIRUPDJUDILFXOXLSXQFWHORUHPSLULFHVHDOHJHRIXQF LHPDWHPDWLF DOF UHLJUDILFDSUR[LPHD] FHOPDLELQHJUDILFXOSXQFWHORUHPSLULFH ÌQXUPDDFHVWHLRSHUD LLVHYDDOHJH

IXQF LDOLQLDU < <

DE[ < ±GDF FXUEDHPSLULF SRDWHILDSUR[LPDW FXRGUHDSW

IXQF LDSXWHUH< <

D[ <

f

±GDF FXUEDHPSLULF SRDWHILDSUR[LPDW FXFXUEDDFHVWHLIXQF LL

VDX OQDEOQ[ < ±GDF FXUEDHPSLULF SRDWHILDSUR[LPDW FXRGUHDSW SH

OQ< <

XQJUDILFGXEOXORJDULWPLF

h iml

g

h ikj

IXQF LD H[SRQHQ LDO < <

Hn

o

d f < GDF

FXUED HPSLULF SRDWH IL DSUR[LPDW FX JUDILFXO DFHVWHL

IXQF LL VDX OQ< <

DE[ < ±GDF FXUEDHPSLULF SRDWHILDSUR[LPDW FXRGUHDSW

SHXQJUDILFVHPLORJDULWPLF

h iml

g H

p <

j

DE[ < Ó< <

OQDEOQ[ <

l

g

h ikj

E 3URFHGHXO FRQVHUY

ULL DULLORU FRQWLQX SURFHGHXO JUDILF úL FRQVW vQ D FRPSDUD VXSUDID D

FXUEHL HPSLULFH Ä6´ ± YH]L ILJXUD ± FX VXSUDIH HOH WHRUHWLFH 6q DOH FHORU K M = K IXQF LL PDWHPDWLFHM

ÓIXQF LDOLQLDU M

ÓIXQF LDSXWHUHHWF

28

6XSUDID D DIHUHQW FXUEHL HPSLULFH Ä6´ VH YD FDOFXOD SULQ vQVXPDUHD VXSUDIH HORU WUDSH]HORU DO F URU QXP U Q GHSLQGH GH QXP UXO SXQFWHORU HPSLULFH 1[ < \ < W = Q LDU VXSUDIH HOH WHRUHWLFHDOHIXQF LLORUPDWHPDWLFHDFFHSWDWHvQXUPDYL]XDOL] ULLFXUEHLHPSLULFHVHYRUFDOFXODFX DMXWRUXOIRUPXOHL 6

M

=

[

rts]u Ï I [

v

([ )G[

M

ÌQ ILQDO DOHJHUHD FHOHL PDL DGHFYDWH IXQF LL GH UHJUHVLH VH SRDWH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO XUP WRDUHL UHJXOL PLQ

6 -6

w

6

w

w

F 3URFHGHXO FDOFXOHORU DOJHEULFH VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SH SURSULHW IXQF LLOHPDWHPDWLFH\

&P =

\

=

\

[ \ \

I[ SULYLQGXUP WRULLLQGLFDWRUL

±YLWH]DGHYDULD LHDEVROXW DIXQF LHLVDXFRHILFLHQWXOPDUJLQDO

[

I [

&H =

LOH SH FDUH OH SRVHG

±YLWH]DPHGLHGHYDULD LHDIXQF LHLYDORDUHDPHGLH [ [

=

OQ \ OQ [

± YLWH]D GH YDULD LH UHODWLY D IXQF LHL VDX FRHILFLHQWXO GH HODVWLFLWDWH

ÌQ DFHVW VHQV YRP H[HPSOLILFD SURSULHW

LOH DFHVWRU LQGLFDWRUL SHQWUX FkWHYD FDWHJRULL GH

IXQF LLGHUHJUHVLH 'HRDUHFH [ úL \ GHVFULX IHQRPHQH HFRQRPLFH YDORULOH ORU WUHEXLH V ILH SR]LWLYH 'HFL IXQF LLOH GH UHJUHVLH VXQW GHILQLWH SH LQWHUYDOXO >¸@ >¸@ 9DULDELOD \ UHSUH]LQW YDULDELOD HIHFWLDUYDULDELOD[YDULDELODFDX] \

DE[

ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHSDUDPHWUXOEHVWHSR]LWLYVHVSXQHF H[LVW RGHSHQGHQ úL HIHFW LDU FkQG SDUDPHWUXO E HVWH QHJDWLY VH VSXQH F H[LVW R GHSHQGHQ

GLUHFW vQWUHFDX]

LQYHUV vQWUH FDX] úL

HIHFW 3DUDPHWUXODUHSUH]LQW YDORDUHDHIHFWXOXLDWXQFLFkQGFDX]DHVWHHJDO FX]HUR 3DUDPHWULL D úL E QX SRW IL vQ DFHODúL WLPS QHJDWLYL GHRDUHFH VDU RE LQH SHQWUX \ GRDU YDORUL QHJDWLYH ÌQIXQF LHGHYDORULOHSDUDPHWULORUDúLEH[LVW WUHLFD]XUL

\

\

DEË

\

D

D!

E!

E

D D

[

[

-

D &P

= \ xë

=E

[

D

D

-

E

&P

E

&P E!

E

[

[

E

E

29

ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHE!ODRFUHúWHUHFXRXQLWDWHDOXL[vLYDFRUHVSXQGHRFUHúWHUHFXEXQLW DOXL\ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHE!ODRFUHúWHUHFXRXQLWDWHDOXL[vLYDFRUHVSXQGHRVF GHUHFXEXQLW

L LD

OXL\ \

E \

=

\ [

=E +

D [

\

E

E

[

D!E!

[

DE!

\

OLP OLP OLP

= E

\

\

\

= ¸ SHQWUXD!

\

= -¸ SHQWUXD

[

[ E

E D!E DE

ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH FDX]DHVWHPD[LP DFHDVWDWLQGHVSUHLQILQLWHIHFWXOPHGLXILLQGHJDOFX E $WXQFL FkQG FDX]D WLQGH F WUH ]HUR LDU SDUDPHWUXO D HVWH SR]LWLY HIHFWXO PHGLX HIHFWXO SH ILHFDUH XQLWDWH GH FDX] YD WLQGH V ILH PD[LP VSUH LQILQLW LDU GDF SDUDPHWUXO D HVWH QHJDWLY HIHFWXO PHGLXWLQGHV ILHPLQLPVSUHPLQXVLQILQLW

F

&H = \ y ë ¢

[ \

=

OLPz &H =

{ |

E[ D + E[

&H

OLP &H =

} ~

[

&RHILFLHQWXO GH HODVWLFLWDWH H[SULP FX FkWH SURFHQWH VH PRGLILF HIHFWXO DWXQFL FkQG FDX]D VHPRGLILF FXXQSURFHQW6HREVHUY F ODRPRGLILFDUHFXXQSURFHQWDFDX]HLSHQWUXYDORULPLFL DOHDFHVWHLDWLQ]kQGF WUH]HURHIHFWXOQXVHPRGLILF FXQLFLXQSURFHQWÌQFD]XOYDORULORUPDULDOH FDX]HL PRGLILFDUHD FX XQ SURFHQW D DFHVWHLD LPSOLF R PRGLILFDUH FX XQ SURFHQW D HIHFWXOXL ,QGLIHUHQW GH YDORULOH FDX]HL XQHL PRGLILF UL GH XQ SURFHQW D DFHVWHLD vL YRU FRUHVSXQGH PRGLILF UL DOHHIHFWXOXLFXSULQVHvQWUH]HURúLXQX

\

= D +

E [

DE!

OLP \

\

= +¸

OLP

D

\

= D

[

\ ë = -

E [

< Ü \HVWHGHVFUHVF WRU

30

D &P = -

E [

&P

OLP &P = -¸ OLP &P =

[

ë (&P )

=

(- E ) ¢

( )

¢ [ =

([ )

E [

Ü

&PHFUHVF WRUSH

'HFLODFUHúWHULDOHFDX]HLHIHFWXOVFDGH3HQWUXYDORULPLFLDOHFDX]HLPRGLILF ULOHHIHFWXOXL VXQWIRDUWHPDULWLQ]kQGVSUHLQILQLWLDUSHQWUXYDORULIRDUWHPDULDOHFDX]HLPRGLILF ULOHHIHFWXOXL FD XUPDUH D PRGLILF ULL FDX]HL WLQG VSUH ]HUR &X FkW YDORULOH FDX]HL VXQW PDL PDUL FX DWkW HIHFWXO YDULD] PDLSX LQODYDULD LLOHFDX]HL

E \

=

D [

+

E [

OLP

\

\

\ £ ë

= +¸

= -

'HRDUHFH

D [

¢

¡ OLP

-

[

[!

¢

E

D

\

=

¢ [ = -

¢

[

¢

» D[ + E ± ª ² [ ½ Õ

E! Ü \ ¤ ë <

Ü \

GHVFUHVF WRU

[

ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH FDX]D WLQGH VSUH LQILQLW HIHFWXO PHGLX DGLF HIHFWXO SH XQLWDWHD GH FDX] HVWH ]HUR $WXQFL FkQG FDX]D WLQGH F WUH ]HUR HIHFWXO SH ILHFDUH XQLWDWH GH FDX] WLQGH VSUH LQILQLW (IHFWXO PHGLX HVWH GHVFUHVF WRU GHFL FX FkW FDX]D HVWH PDL PDUH HIHFWXO SHXQLWDWHDGHFDX] HVWH PDLPLF

F &H = \ ¥ ë ¢

[ \

= -

E D[ + E

&H

OLP &H = -

[

OLP ¦ ¨ §

&H =

&H ª ë = -E ¢

- D[ + E

©

¢D =

DE D[ + E

©

> Ü

&HHVWHFUHVF WRU 6H REVHUY F OD R PRGLILFDUH FX XQ SURFHQW D FDX]HL SHQWUX YDORUL PLFL DOH DFHVWHLD WLQ]kQG F WUH ]HUR HIHFWXO VH PRGLILF VFDGH FX XQ SURFHQW ÌQ FD]XO YDORULORU PDUL DOH FDX]HL PRGLILFDUHDFXXQSURFHQWDDFHVWHLDQXLPSOLF QLFLRPRGLILFDUHDHIHFWXOXL,QGLIHUHQWGHYDORULOH FDX]HL OD PRGLILF UL FUHúWHUL FX XQ SURFHQW DOH DFHVWHLD OH FRUHVSXQG PRGLILF UL VF GHUL DOH HIHFWXOXL FXSULQVH vQWUH ]HUR úL XQX &X FkW YDORULOH FDX]HL VXQW PDL PDUL FX DWkW PRGLILF ULOH UHODWLYHDOHHIHFWXOXLVXQWPDLPLFL

31

\

DE[F[

«

DEúLFQXVXQWWR LHJDOLFX]HUR

*UDILFXODFHVWHLIXQF LLGHSLQGHGHSDUDPHWULLDEúLF'HH[HPSOXSHQWUXD!EF!VH RE LQHXUP WRUXOJUDILF

\

\ ¬ë

[

D

[

Á Â ¿ À Ã

= F[ + E = Ü [ = -

E F

\ ëë = F > Ü [FRUHVSXQGHOXL\PLQLP

Ä

Å» ´ E ± PLQ \ ª ² µ F Õ F ®½ Ý

[

Ç

ÅÆ

D &P = \ ® ë

= F[ + E

'DF F HVWH QHJDWLY DWXQFL &P HVWH GHVFUHVF WRU GHFL YDULD LLOH HIHFWXOXL FD U VSXQV OD YDULD LDFDX]HLVXQWGLQFHvQFHPDLPLFL'DF EHVWHSR]LWLYvQVHDPQ F SHQWUXRFDX] PDLPLF GHFkW±EFHIHFWXOFUHúWHFDXUPDUHDFUHúWHULLFDX]HL3HQWUXRFDX] PDLPDUHGHFkW±EFHIHFWXO VFDGH FD XUPDUH D FUHúWHULL FDX]HL 'DF E HVWH QHJDWLY HIHFWXO YD VF GHD FD XUPDUH D FUHúWHULL FDX]HL ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH F HVWH SR]LWLY &P HVWH FUHVF WRU GHFL YDULD LLOH HIHFWXOXL FD XUPDUH D YDULD LLORU FDX]HL VXQW GLQ FH vQ FH PDL PDUL 'DF E HVWH QHJDWLY vQVHDPQ F SHQWUX R FDX] PDL PLF GHFkW ±EF HIHFWXO VFDGH FD XUPDUH D FUHúWHULL FDX]HL 3HQWUX R FDX] PDL PDUH GHFkW ±EF HIHFWXOFUHúWHFDXUPDUHDFUHúWHULLFDX]HL'DF EHVWHSR]LWLYHIHFWXOYDFUHúWHFDXUPDUHDFUHúWHULL FDX]HL

&P

E!

F!

E

E

[

Ê

Ë ÈÉ

E \ =

D + E[ + F[ [

¯

SHQWUXDF! \

± ° ² OLP

\

\ ½ ë

E +

DF [

D

Ì

» \ ª ª ½

= +¸ OLP¶ \

· µ

· ´ ¶

=

F[

» [

»

-D

D ± ² = F ² Õ

=

D

³

½ ¾ ¼ Ü [

¸º¹ »

=

= +¸

D F

DF + E

32

+

[

\ ëÍ

D F

_Ô E +

\

DF £ F &H = \ ë ¢

&H

OLP Ï Ñ Ð

&H =

OLPÒ &H =

Ó Ô

\

[ \

=

E[ + F[

Î

D + E[ + F[

Î

[

Õ

D[ D! GHRDUHFH \ WUHEXLH V ILH SR]LWLY LDU IXF LD SXWHUH HVWH R IXQF LH SR]LWLY úL

E¹GHRDUHFHDOWIHOVDURE LQHRIXQF LHOLQLDU \

\

E!

E

E! D &P E \

[

=

DE[ \ [

Õ(Ö]×

[ \

E

Ü JUDILFVLPLODUFXFHODOIXQF LHLLQL LDOH

= D¢[

F &H = \ ¢

[

Ú Ø

Ù

Ü JUDILFVLPLODUFXFHODOIXQF LHLLQL LDOH

= D ¢E ¢ [

Ü Û Ý

[ D¢[

Û

=E

&H

E

E!

[ E

E

'DF E HVWH FXSULQV vQWUH ]HUR úL XQX DWXQFL FDX]D YDULD] vQ DFHODúL VHQV FX HIHFWXO GDU FRHILFLHQWXOPDUJLQDOILLQGGHVFUHVF WRUvQVHDPQ F YDULD LLOHHIHFWXOXLVXQWGLQFHvQFHPDLPLFL 'H DVHPHQHD úL HIHFWXO SH XQLWDWHD GH FDX] HVWH FX DWkW PDL PLF FX FkW FDX]D HVWH PDL PDUH 7RWXúL GDF H[LVW R YDULD LH GH XQ SURFHQW D FDX]HL HIHFWXO YD YDULD FX E SURFHQWH LQGLIHUHQW GH P ULPHDFDX]HL 'DF E HVWH PDL PLF GHFkW XQX DWXQFL FDX]D YDULD] vQ VHQV LQYHUV HIHFWXOXL &RHILFLHQWXO PDUJLQDO ILLQG GHVFUHVF WRU vQVHDPQ F YDULD LLOH HIHFWXOXL VXQW GLQ FH vQ FH PDL PLFL 'H DVHPHQHD úL HIHFWXO SH XQLWDWHD GH FDX] HVWH FX DWkW PDL PLF FX FkW FDX]D HVWH PDL PDUH 'DF H[LVW R YDULD LH GH XQ SURFHQW D FDX]HL HIHFWXO YD YDULD FX E SURFHQWH LQGLIHUHQW GH P ULPHD FDX]HL 'DF EHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWXQXDWXQFLFDX]DYDULD] vQDFHODúLVHQVFXHIHFWXO&RHILFLHQWXO PDUJLQDOILLQGFUHVF WRUvQVHDPQ F YDULD LLOHHIHFWXOXLVXQWGLQFHvQFHPDLPDUL'HDVHPHQHDúL

33

HIHFWXOSHXQLWDWHDGHFDX] HVWHFXDWkWPDLPDUHFXFkWFDX]DHVWHPDLPDUH'DF H[LVW RYDULD LH GHXQSURFHQWDFDX]HLHIHFWXOYDYDULDFXESURFHQWHLQGLIHUHQWGHP ULPHDFDX]HL 3ULQ FRPSDUDUHD SURSULHW

LORU LQGLFDWRULORU WHRUHWLFL DL IXQF LLORU GH UHJUHVLH ± YDULD LH

FRQWLQX ± FX LQGLFDWRULL HPSLULFL ± YDULD LH GLVFUHW ± DL FHORU GRX YDULDELOH FDOFXOD L SH ED]D VHULHL VWDWLVWLFH ± FP

á

=

à

\

- \

à

[

- [

à ß Þ

=

á

FH

à ß Þ

\

GHUHJUHVLHDLF UXLLQGLFDWRULDXSURSULHW

à

à ß Þ

- \

à ß Þ

\

[

à

- [

[

à ß Þ

± VH YD SXWHD DOHJH DFHD IXQF LH

à ß Þ

LDSURSLDWHFXLQGLFDWRULLHPSLULFL

'H H[HPSOX GDF FRHILFLHQ LL PDUJLQDOL DL YDULDELOHL \ vQ UDSRUW GH YDULDELOD [ FDOFXOD L SH ED]DVHULHLVWDWLVWLFHVXQWDSUR[LPDWLYLHJDOL \

ã

- \

[

ã

- [

VHYDDOHJHIXQF LDOLQLDU < ç

â

â

\

ä

- \

[

ä

- [

ã

ã

K

\

å

- \

å æ â

[

å

- [

å æ â

DE[ ç VDXIXQF LDSXWHUH< ç

FW "W = Q

D[ ç

Õ

vQFD]XOvQFDUHFRHILFLHQ LL

HPSLULFLGHHODVWLFLWDWHYRUILDSUR[LPDWLYLHJDOL [ \

â â

¢

\

ã

- \

[

ã

-[

â

â

[ \

ã ã

¢

\

ä

- \

[

ä

-[

ã ã

K

[

å æ â

\

å æ â

¢

\

å

- \

å æ â

[

å

-[

å æ â

'H UH LQXW F vQ HFRQRPLD UHDO GDWHOH VWDWLVWLFH UHOHY FRUHOD LL GLYHUVH úL FRQWUDGLFWRULL FDUH QX SRW IL GHVFULVH FX R VLQJXU IXQF LH PDWHPDWLF ÌQ DVWIHO GH FD]XUL VH UHFRPDQG FD LGHQWLILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL HFRQRPHWULF V VH IDF FX DMXWRUXO PDL PXOWRU IXQF LL GH UHJUHVLH XUPkQG FD vQ ILQDO ± vQ HWDSD GH YHULILFDUH D PRGHOXOXL ± V VH GHFLG DVXSUD XQHL VLQJXUH IRUPH D PRGHOXOXL

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFXQLIDFWRULDO

3DUDPHWULL XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VXQW UHSUH]HQWD L GH FRHILFLHQ LL IXQF LHL GH UHJUHVLH DFFHSWDW vQ HWDSD GH LGHQWLILFDUH D DFHVWXLD $FHúWL SDUDPHWULL ILLQG QHFXQRVFX L HL YRU WUHEXL HVWLPD L DSUR[LPD L SH ED]D GDWHORU H[SHULPHQWDOH VLVWHPDWL]DWH vQ VHULLOH VWDWLVWLFH DOH FHORU GRX YDULDELOH\úL[SULQYDORULOH\ ç [ ç W = Q )XQF LLOHGHUHJUHVLHDOHXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFXQLIDFWRULDOSRWILIXQF LLOLQDUH< VDXIXQF LLQHOLQLDUHFDGHH[HPSOX Õ

IXQF LDSXWHUH±< ç

IXQF LDH[SRQHQ LDO ±< ç

IXQF LDGHJUDGXOGRL±< ç

IXQF LDORJLVWLF ± <ð

D[ ç

=

é ÕVê

Hè

ç

DE[ ç F[ ç F

+ H

ï ñ í]î ì

ë

DE[

'HRDUHFH vQ QXPHURDVH FD]XUL IXQF LLOH QHOLQLDUH FXUELOLQLL SRW IL OLQLDUL]DWH HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFVHYDD[DQXPDLSHFD]XOPRGHOHORUOLQLDUH/LQLDUL]DUHDXQXL PRGHO QHOLQLDU VH SRDWH IDFH SULQ PDL PXOWH SURFHGHH FXP DU IL ORJDULWPDUHD PRGHOXOXL HFRQRPHWULFVFKLPE ULGHYDULDELO VWDELOLUHDDUELWUDU DYDORULLXQRUSDUDPHWULHWF 'HH[HPSOX

/LQLDUL]DUHDSULQORJDULWPDUH )LH PRGHOXO QHOLQLDU H[SULPDW SULQ IXQF LD SXWHUH ± \ ç

Õ D [ ç

X ç 3ULQ WUDQVIRUPDUH

ORJDULWPLF DFHVWDGHYLQH OQ\ ç

ò

\ç

OQDEOQ[ ç OQX ç VDX

ò

$E[ ç XQGH \ç

ò

ò

X ç

OQ\ ç

34

$

OQD

ò

[ç

OQ[ ç ó

ò

OQX ç ô

Xç

&D]XOPRGHOXOXLQHOLQLDUH[SRQHQ LDO±\ ç 3ULQORJDULWPDUHDFHVWDGHYLQH OQ\ ç

/LQLDUL]DUHDSULQVFKLPEDUHGHYDULDELOH

1RWkQGFX[ ×

ç

[ ç [ë

ç

E õ E × [Eë [ ç

ë

[ ç

ò DE[ ç X ç

ë

ö

ö

BBBEö [ ç X ç

[ ç VHRE LQHPRGHOXOOLQLDUPXOWLIDFWRULDO

«[ö ç

\ç

ç X ç

ò

DE[ ç OQX ç Ó\ ç

)LHPRGHOXOQHOLQLDU±\ ç

é ÕVê

Hè

E õ E × [ ×

ç Eë

[ë

«Eö [ö ç X ç

ç

DYDORULLXQRUSDUDPHWUL

/LQLDUL]DUHDSULQIL[DUHDDUELWUDU

$FHVW PRGHO SRDWH IL DSOLFDW DWXQFL FkQG SH ED]D XQHL DQDOL]H HFRQRPLFH D IHQRPHQHORU VWXGLDWH VH SRDWH HYDOXD YDORDUHD XQXL SDUDPHWUX 'H H[HPSOX IXQF LD ORJLVWLF VH SUHWHD] IRDUWH ELQHODGHVFULHUHDHYROX LHLFRQVXPXOXL\ XQXLDQXPLWSURGXVvQIXQF LHGHYHQLWXOFRQVXPDWRUXOXL [ 'DU FRQVXPXOXQXLDQXPLWSURGXVDUHDQXPLWHOLPLWHUD LRQDOHUHVSHFWLYXQQLYHOGHVDWXUD LH QLYHOHVWLPDWSULQSDUDPHWUXOÄH´DOIXQF LHLORJLVWLFH6WDELOLQGYDORDUHDSDUDPHWUXOXLSULQFRQVWDQWD ÄF´ ± DFHVW OXFUX VH SRDWH IDFH ILH SULQ FDOFXOH VWDWLVWLFH GH VSHFLDOLWDWH ILH SULQ SUHOXDUHD YDORULL DFHVWXLD GH OD R DU GH]YROWDW XQGH FRQVXPXO DFHOXL SURGXV VD VWDELOL]DW ± IXQF LD ORJLVWLF VH SRDWHWUDQVIRUPDvQWURIXQF LHOLQLDU \

=

ø

F +H

ü ÷ ùûú ý

» F Ü ª \ ø ½

± - ² = H Õ

ò \ç

DE[ ç XQGH \

ü ÷ ùûú

þ ø

» F = OQ ª \ ø ½

ý

» F Ü OQ ª \ ø ½

± - ² = D + E[ Õ

Ü

ø

± - ² Õ

5HYHQLQGODSUREOHPDHVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFDFHúWLDSRWILFDOFXOD L FXDMXWRUXOPDLPXOWRUPHWRGHFXPDUIL D PHWRGDSXQFWHORUHPSLULFH03( E PHWRGDSXQFWHORUPHGLL030 F PHWRGDFHORUPDLPLFLS WUDWH0&003 G PHWRGDFHORUPDLPLFLS WUDWHJHQHUDOL]DW H PHWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

LLPD[LPH090 FXLQIRUPD LHOLPLWDW VDXFRPSOHW

0HWRGHOH D úL E VH IRORVHVF DWXQFL FkQG QX VH XUP UHúWH R ULJRDUH VWDWLVWLF D FDOFXOHORU GDWRULW VLPSOLW

LL úL UDSLGLW

LL FDOFXOHORU VDX FkQG DSOLFDUHD 0&003 HVWH DQHYRLRDV

QHFHVLWkQGFDOFXOHFRPSOLFDWH 0HWRGHOH G úL H DX PDL PXOW YDORDUH WHRUHWLF GHRDUHFH vQ HFRQRPLH LSRWH]HOH SH FDUH VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SRW IL DFFHSWDWH FX PXOW UH LQHUH vQ SOXV FDOFXOHOH FRPSOLFDWH SH FDUH OH VROLFLW P UHVFPXOWFRVWXOHVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORUI U DJHQHUDRFUHúWHUHSHP VXU DSUHFL]LHLHVWLPD LLORU (VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOOLQLDUXQLIDFWRULDOSUHVXSXQH

H[LVWHQ DVHULHLVWDWLVWLFHDFHORUGRX YDULDELOHHFRQRPLFH

7DEHOXO

[ç

\ç

[ç

[×

\×

[×

ë ë

[ ç \ ç

[ × \ ×

[ [ ç

\ \ ç

[

ë

[ ç

ë

ÿ

Ö \

Ö X

= \

Ö - \

Ö Ö +E =D [

Ö X

= \

Ö - \

Ö Ö +E =D [

ÿ

Ö X

XÖ

[ \

Ö \

[ ç \ ç

Ö \

Ö Ö +E =D [

Ö

Ç\

Ö X

= \ Ç XÖW

Ö - \ =

Ö X

Q

Ö Ç X W

35

PRGHOXOHFRQRPHWULFOLQLDU \

Ö \ Ö

X

DE[ X

Ö Ö + E[ = D = \

Ö - \

XQGH \ [ DE Ö Ö E D

YDORULOHHPSLULFHDOHYDULDELOHORUGLQVHULDVWDWLVWLF DDFHVWRUD SDUDPHWULLPRGHOXOXL HVWLPD LLOHDFHVWRUD

X

YDULDELODHURDUH

XÖ

HVWLPD LDOXLX

W

XWLOL]DUHDXQHLPHWRGHGHHVWLPDUHSHQWUXDFDOFXODHVWLPDWRULLSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXL

ÌQDFHVWVHQVQHUHIHULPOD D 0HWRGD SXQFWHORU HPSLULFH 03( FRQVW vQDOHJHUHDXQXLQXP UGHSXQFWHHPSLULFH 0[ \ HJDO FX QXP UXO SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL &RRUGRQDWHOH DFHVWRU SXQFWH VH LQWURGXF vQ IXQF LD GH UHJUHVLH D PRGHOXOXL úL YD UH]XOWD XQ VLVWHP GH HFXD LL HJDO FX QXP UXO DFHVWRUD 'H H[HPSOX vQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL OLQLDU YH]L UHOD LD YRU WUHEXL DOHVH GRX SXQFWH )LH DFHVWHD 0 [ \ úL0 [ \ \ \ \

Ö + EÖ[ = D Ö + EÖ[ = D

´ ¿

\

Ö = µ Ü D

¿ Ý

[

[

[

[

Ö E =

\

\

[

[

'HUHJXO DOHJHUHDSXQFWHORUHPSLULFHVHIDFHILHSHED]DUHSUH]HQW ULLJUDILFHDFHORUGRX VHULLVWDWLVWLFHvQVHQVXOF DFHVWHDDUWUHEXLV ILHIRDUWHDSURDSHGHGUHDSWDYLUWXDOWUDVDW VDXV ILH LQWHUVHFWDWHGHDFHDVWDILHSULQDSUHFLHUHDF DFHVWHSXQFWHVXQWUHSUH]HQWDWLYHSHQWUXFDUDFWHUL]DUHD YDULD LLORUFHORUGRX IHQRPHQHúLQXVXQWUH]XOWDWXOXQRUFRQGL LLVSHFLDOH E 0HWRGDSXQFWHORUPHGLL030 ±SUHVXSXQHFDFHOHGRX VHULLVWDWLVWLFHV ILHvPS U LWH vQWUXQ QXP U GH VXEVHULL HJDO FX QXP UXO HVWLPDWRULORU 3HQWUX ILHFDUH VXEVHULH VH YRU FDOFXOD PHGLLOH DULWPHWLFH DOH FHORU GRX YDULDELOH $FHVWH YDORUL PHGLL VH YRU LQWURGXFH vQ IXQF LD GH UHJUHVLH úL VH YD FRQWLQXD SURFHGXUD FD vQ FD]XO 03( 'DF QXP UXO WHUPHQLORU VHULLORU VWDWLVWLFH QXHVWHGLYL]LELOFXQXP UXOSDUDPHWULORUVHYDUHQXQ DODXQQXP UGHWHUPHQL±FHLPDLvQGHS UWD L vQ WLPS VDX GH PHGLD FHORU GRX YDULDELOH 'H H[HPSOX vQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL OLQLDU QXP UXO SDUDPHWULORU HVWH HJDO FX GRL 'DF VHULLOH GH WLPS DOH FHORU GRX YDULDELOH VH UHIHU OD QRX SHULRDGH W = VH YD UHQXQ D OD YDORULOH SULPHL SHULRDGH UHVSHFWLY OD [ úL \ ÌQ DFHVW FD] FHOH GRX VHULLYRUIL »[ ª ª \ ½

[

»[ ª ª \ ½

[

[

\

\

\

[ \

[ ± ² Ü ² \ Õ \

[

[ \

[ ± ² Ü ² Õ \

=

=

= =

([

+ [

(\

+ \

+ [

+ [

+ \ )

+ \

([

+ [

(\

+ \

+ [

)

+ \

+ [

)

+ \ )

36

3ULQLQWURGXFHUHDDFHVWRUYDORULvQUHOD LD UH]XOW \ Ö + EÖ[ D

= \

Ö + EÖ[ D

\

Ö = µ Ü D

¿ Ý

= \

´ ¿

[

[

[

[

Ö E =

\

\

[

[

F 0HWRGD FHORU PDL PLFL S

WUDWH 0&003 ±HVWHWHKQLFDGHOXFUXFHDPDLGHVIRORVLW

OD HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF 8WLOL]DUHD DFHVWHL PHWRGH SRUQHúWH GH OD XUP WRDUHOHUHOD LL DE[ X

\

Ö Ö + E[ = D

Ö \

= \

Ö X

Ö - \

Ö Ö -E -D [

= \

XQGH \ [

YDORULOHUHDOHDOHFHORUGRX IHQRPHQHHFRQRPLFHH[LVWHQWHvQ

VHULLOHVWDWLVWLFHDOHDFHVWRUD Ö \

YDORULOH WHRUHWLFH DOH YDULDELOHL \ RE LQXWH QXPDL vQ IXQF LH GH

ÖúL EÖ YDORULOHIDFWRUXOXLHVHQ LDO[ úLGHYDORULOHHVWLPDWRULORUSDUDPHWULORUDúLEUHVSHFWLY D

XÖ

W

HVWLPD LLOHYDORULORUYDULDELOHUH]LGXDOHX

3UDFWLF0&003FRQVW vQDPLQLPL]DIXQF LD

(

Ö Ö E ) D

) = PLQ Ç " (\ ! !

Ö ! - \

)

" (\ ! = PLQ Ç !

#

DGLF D PLQLPL]D VXPD S WUDWHORU GLVWDQ HORU ID

#

)

Ö ! Ö -E -D [

GH D[D R< GLQWUH YDORULOH UHDOH \ úL YDORULOH

Ö WHRUHWLFH \ &RQGL LDGHPLQLPDIXQF LHL UH]XOW GLQ

Ö Ö E ) D

Ö D

'

,

Ö Ö E ) D

VLVWHPGHHFXD LLFHGHYLQHvQILQDO

¿ ¿

&

%

(

= Ü Ç \

Ö E

Å

(

= Ü Ç$ \

* )

+

.

Ö Ö +E ¢ Ç[/ QD

/ - 0

¿D Ö ¢Ç[/ ¿ ®

+

Ö Ö -E -D [

&

Ö Ö -E -D [

+

)(- ) = Ü Ç (\ &

)(- [ +

) = Ü Ç(\ +

&

Ö Ö -E -D [

Ö Ö [ -E [ -D [

+

+

) = &

+

(

) =

. = Ç\ /

/ - 0

Ö +E ¢Ç[/

. 1

= Ç\ / [/ / - 0

GLQFDUHVHYRUFDOFXODYDORULOHHVWLPDWRULORU HVWLPD LDSDUDPHWUXOXL D

Ö Ö + E QD Ç [

2

= Ç \

2

Q

â

Ö Ö + E D

Ç [ Q

=

2

Ç \ Q

2

â

Ö = D

\

Ö - E[

HVWLPD LDSDUDPHWUXOXL E

Q Ö E =

Ç[4 Q Ç[4

Ç\ 4 Ç\ 4 [4 Ç[4 Ç[4

3

=

Q Ç\ 4 [4 Q Ç[4

3

- Ç\ 4 Ç[4 -

(Ç [ 4 ) 3

Ç\ 4 [4 =

Q Ç[4 Q

- [ \

3 - [

3

37

GLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHL[ s7

5

([ 6

Ç

=

Ç[9

=

- [

5

8

8

- [

Ç\ < [<

Ç

=

Q

Q

+ [

([ 6

8

5

- [

Ç[9

=

) 5

6 [ + [

=

Q

8

8

- [

Q

5

Ç [

6

- [

Q

Ç [

6

+ [

Q

5

=

- [ \

Q

Ö ÜE =

)

s;

:

FRYDULDQ DGLQWUHYDULDELOHOH\úL[

FRY

(\

)=

[

Ç ([ =

- [

)(\ =

)

- \

Q

=

- \

Ç[ >

-[

Q

Ç\ >

(\ sB

[

@

)

=

- [ = \ - [\ =

+ [ ¢ \

)

Q

Ç[ > \ >

+[ ¢\ =

Q

FRY

Ö Ü E =

Ç ([ = \ =

Q

Ç ([ A

- [

Ç ([ A

- \ ¢[ -[ ¢ \ +[ ¢ \ =

)(\ A - [

)

@

)

- \

=

Ç[= \ =

-

Q

Ç[ ? \ > Q

-[ ¢ \

FRHILFLHQWXOGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU DFHORUGRX YDULDELOH

U \ [ = U [ \ = XQGH C D

FRY\ [ s

[

s

Ö Ü U \ [ = E ¢

\

s s

[

Ö Ü E = U \ [ ¢

\

s

s

\

[

DEDWHULOHPHGLLS WUDWLFHDOHYDULDELOHORU\úL[

6LVWHPXO GH HFXD LL IRUPDW GLQ UHOD LLOH úL UH]XOWDW vQ XUPD DSOLF ULL 0&003 SRDUW QXPHOH úL GH VLVWHP GH HFXD LL QRUPDOH $FHVW VLVWHPGHHFXD LLSRVHG FkWHYD LFXPDUIL

SURSULHW

'LQHFXD LD VHGHGXFHF

(

Ö - EÖ[ E -D

Ç \ E

E

) = Ç XÖE

ÖE = ± YDULDELOD DOHDWRDUH X F HVWH GH VXP QXO úL = Ü 0 X

E

HYLGHQWGHPHGLH]HUR

(

G

G \ Ç

Ö Ö -E -D [

)= Ç G (\

G

G

Ö - \

G

)=

G \ Ü Ç

G

Ö G \ = Ç

Ö HVWHHJDO FXVXPDLQIRUPD LLORUWHRUHWLFH Ç I \

I

G

± VXPD YDORULORU HPSLULFH Ç H \

H

±SULQFLSLXOFRQVHUY ULLLQIRUPD LLORU

'LQUH]ROYDUHDVLVWHPXOXLGHHFXD LLUH]XOW F

Ö = \ - EÖ[ ± GUHDSWD GH UHJUHVLH Ö D \J

Ö Ö + E[ J WUDVDW SH ED]D 0&003 WUHFH SULQ = D

SXQFWXO 0 [ \ ±YH]LILJXUD

Ö E =

Ç (\ W

Ö \K

- \

Ç ([ W Ç

=

W

W

«\

W

Ã [ W ¬

)([ W - [

- \ - [

Ç ([ W

¢

)

- [

W

- \

=

([ W

- [

Ç [( \

)

- [

)

)

á ³ ã

[

Ç EW =

W

)([ W

Ç ([ W

([ W

Ç ([ W

- [

)] ¢

- [

)

)

- [ - [

)

([ W

([ W

- [

- [

)

)

=

] Ü

SDQWD

GUHSWHL

GH

UHJUHVLH

W

Ö Ö + E[ K HVWH R PHGLH DULWPHWLF D SDQWHORU GUHSWHORU FH SRW IL WUDVDWH SULQ SXQFWHOH = D

38

0 [ \

úL

DEDWHULORU [

0

- [

W

W

[

\

W

W

UHVSHFWLY

EE

=

\ E

- \

[E

-[

SRQGHUDWH

FX

S WUDWXO

YDULDELOHLIDFWRULDOH[±YH]LILJXUD

E

\

V

=

\ [

V V

- \ - [

Ö = D + E[ \

\R

U

E

=

\ [

U U

- \ - [

0 \

0T

\Q \P

0

S

[P

[Q

[

[R

[

)LJXUD

E =

EM

( [M

L

- [)

( [M

L

- [)

+ EL +

( [L

( [L

L

- [)

L

- [)

+

K + EN + K + ( [N

( [N

L

- [)

L

- [)

ÖúL EÖ VHYRUSXWHDFDOFXODYDORULOHWHRUHWLFH 'XS HVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUDúLESULQYDORULOH D

DOHIHQRPHQXOXLH[SOLFDW\ Ö \K

Ö Ö + E[ K úLDSRLHVWLPD LLOHYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUHXSULQ X ÖO = D

= \ O

Ö O - \

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOHúL 9HULILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULF

ÌQWUXFkW PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF vQ HWDSHOH GH VSHFLILFDUH LGHQWLILFDUH úL HVWLPDUH VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SH DFFHSWDUHD XQRU LSRWH]H GH OXFUX FkW úL SH GDWH H[SHULPHQWDOH GH VRQGDM HVWH QHFHVDU FD vQDLQWH GH XWLOL]DUHD VD FD LQVWUXPHQW SHUWLQHQW VFRSXOXL XUP ULW DFHVWD V ILH YHULILFDW WHVWDWILOWUDW ÌQDFHDVW HWDS VHSXQHSUREOHPDVLPLOLWXGLQLLGLQWUHPRGHOXOHFRQRPLFUHDOGHVFULV GHVHULLOHVWDWLVWLFHDOHIHQRPHQHORUDQDOL]DWHúLPRGHOXOWHRUHWLFGHQDWXU HFRQRPHWULF FRQVWUXLW úLUH]ROYDW ÌQ HFRQRPLH VSUH GHRVHELUH GH GRPHQLXO WHKQLF GH H[HPSOX QX SXWHP YRUEL GH R VLPLOLWXGLQH DEVROXW vQWUH PRGHOXO WHRUHWLF úLPRGHOXOUHDOFXPSRDWHV H[LVWHvQWUHPDFKHWDXQHL FO GLUL úL FO GLUHD FRQVWUXLW FL GH R VLPLOLWXGLQH VWDWLVWLF vQWUH FHOH GRX PRGHOH vQ VHQVXO F PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF SRVHG úL GHVFULH vQ PDUH vQ PHGLH SULQFLSDOHOH FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH PRGHOXOXL HFRQRPLFUHDO 3UDFWLF DFFHSWDUHD HFRQRPHWULF D PRGHOXOXL WHRUHWLF FD PRGHO VLPLODU FD DSUR[LPD LH VWDWLVWLF HFKLYDOHQW FXPRGHOXOUHDOSUHVXSXQH 9HULILFDUHD LSRWH]HORU SH FDUH VH IXQGDPHQWHD] HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF

9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLHVWLPDWRULORUSDUDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULF

9HULILFDUHDVLPLOLWXGLQLLPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULF

39

9HULILFDUHDLSRWH]HORUSHFDUHVHIXQGDPHQWHD] HVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHO HFRQRPHWULF

ÌQJHQHUDOHVWLPDWRUXOVDXHVWLPD LDHVWHRDSUR[LPD LHDXQHLGLPHQVLXQLSULYLQGXQDQXPLW IHQRPHQ $FHDVW GLPHQVLXQH YROXP VXSUDID

YDORDUH HWF H[DFW VWDELO úL UHSHWDELO DGLF

FRQVWDQW UHSUH]LQW SDUDPHWUXOP VXUD XQHLFDUDFWHULVWLFLDOXQHLvQVXúLULDXQLW 6WDWLVWLFDFDOFXOHD] SDUDPHWULLFDUDFWHULVWLFLORUXQLW XQHL REVHUY UL WRWDOH DVXSUD FROHFWLYLW

LORUVWDWLVWLFH

LORUVWDWLVWLFHDOHXQHLSRSXOD LLvQXUPD

LL VWDWLVWLFH 'DF GDWHOH SULYLQG YDORULOH FDUDFWHULVWLFLORU

SURYLQGLQWURREVHUYDUHVHOHFWLY VRQGDM LQGLFDWRULLFDOFXOD LGLQDFHVWHGDWHUHSUH]LQW HVWLPD LLOH VWDWLVWLFH DOH SDUDPHWULORU DGLF DOH LQGLFDWRULORU FDUH VDU IL RE LQXW GLQ SUHOXFUDUHD GDWHORU SURYHQLWH GLQWUR REVHUYDUH WRWDO 'DU VWDWLVWLFD QX IRORVHúWH W RULFH IHO GH DSUR[LPD LL GH HVWLPD LL

DOHSDUDPHWULORUFLQXPDLHVWLPD LLGHPD[LP YHURVLPLOLWDWH

'LQ DFHVW PRWLY HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SH FkWHYDLSRWH]HSHFDUHWUHEXLHV OHSRVHGHPRGHOXOHFRQRPHWULF±\ X

DE[ X X X

$FHVWHLSRWH]HVHUHIHU OD &HOH GRX YDULDELOH \ X úL [ X VXQW REVHUYDWH I U HURUL GH P VXU X X HVWHRYDULDELO DOHDWRDUH

, Y

LDU YDULDELOD [ X HVWH XQ IHQRPHQ FX YDORUL SUHGHWHUPLQDWH

! YDULDELOD H[SOLFDW \ X HVWH OD

UkQGXOHLRYDULDELO DOHDWRDUH 9DULDELOD DOHDWRDUH

,Z

]

'

X^ = '

]

X]

X X HVWH GH PHGLH QXO 0X X

=

K= '

]

X\

= s[

]

úL GH GLVSHUVLH FRQVWDQW

"W = Q ,SRWH]D,Z SUHVXSXQHF HURULOHX X VXQW

_

_

KRPRVFHGDVWLFHúLQXKHWHURVFHGDVWLFH ' X ` ¹ ' X _ ¹

K¹ '

_

Xb

¹ sa

_

9DORULOHYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHVXQWLQGHSHQGHQWHQXVXQWFRUHODWH DGLF QXH[LVW IHQRPHQXO

,c

GHDXWRFRUHODUHDHURULORU FRY X e X d

ÅL ¹ M ÜHURULOHVXQW LQGHSHQGHQ WH = ® ¹ L ¹ M ÜHURULOHVXQW DXWRFRUHODWH

9DULDELOD DOHDWRDUH X X XUPHD] GLVWULEX LD QRUPDO GH PHGLH ]HUR úL GH DEDWHUH PHGLH

, f

h

=

S WUDWLF FRQVWDQW úLHJDO FX s g

= FW UHVSHFWLY/X X

sg

1

i

'DF DFHVWH LSRWH]H SRW IL DFFHSWDWH LDU HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXLOLQLDUXQLIDFWRULDO ±\ X

DE[ X X X ±DWXQFLVHSRWGHPRQVWUDXUP WRDUHOH 6H HIHFWXHD] R VHOHF LH GH YROXP Q DGLF VH REVHUY YDORULOH FDUDFWHULVWLFLL [ úL SHQWUX

ILHFDUHYDORDUHREVHUYDW YDORULOHFDUDFWHULVWLFLL \

[=[

j

= \ 6HRE LQHDVWIHOVHOHF LD[ X \ X X k W

3HED]DDFHVWHLVHOHF LLVHHVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULLDúLEGLQPRGHOXOGHUHJUHVLHOLQLDU \ X

Wml npo l qsr

DE[ X

X X 3DUDPHWULLDúLESRWILHVWLPD LSULQ

PHWRGD FHORU PDL PLFL S WUDWH SULQ FDUH VH PLQLPL]HD] VXPD S WUDWHORU HURULORU DGLF IXQF LD

(

Ö Ö E ) D

PHWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

/ (\

W

D E ) = I

) = PLQ v

u Öv t wX Ç

x

u

(

t w \ v = PLQ Ç v

Ö v Ö -E -D [

x

)

LLPD[LPHSULQFDUHVHPD[LPL]HD] IXQF LDGHYHURVLPLOLWDWHDGLF

(\ ) ¢ I (\

) ¢ ¢ I ( \

Q

)

W = Q XQGHIHVWHUHSDUWL LDFDUDFWHULVWLFLL\

7HRUHPD 'DF YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO X X HVWH UHSDUWL]DW QRUPDO DYkQG PHGLD HJDO FX ]HUR úL DEDWHUHD PHGLHS WUDWLF

i DWXQFLPHWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

LLPD[LPHHVWHHFKLYDOHQW FXPHWRGDFHORUPDLPLFL

S WUDWH

y

9H]LWHRUHPDúL

40

'HPRQVWUD LH ÌQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL OLQLDU \ = D + E[ + X XHVWHUHSDUWL]DW 1 FX\UHSDUWL]DW 1D+E[

i FHHDFHHVWH HFKLYDOHQW

)XQF LDGHYHURVLPLOLWDWHDFDUDFWHULVWLFLL\HVWH

(

Ö Ö E / \ z D

(

Ö Ö E / \ D

(

Ö Ö E / \ D

)= I

(\ ` ) ¢ I (\ _ ) ¢ ¢ I (\ b )

)=

p s

) = ªª »

{ ~

H

± ² ² p s Õ

½

} | ( } { { ) |

¢H

» Ö Ö Ö E Ö E ÃOQ ª PD[ / \ D â PD[ OQ / \ D = PD[ ª Ã ½ ¬

» 'HRDUHFH HVWHFRQVWDQW OQª ª ½

» = N + ª½

± ² ² p s Õ

s

¥ -

s

¨

¥

¥

¨

¢ ¢

) (

«

» ÃOQ ª PD[ ¢ ¤ £ ª Ã ½ ¬

H

p s

~

|

(

{ {

)|

Ü

LLPD[LPHSUHVXSXQHPD[LPL]DUHDIXQF LHLGHYHURVLPLOLWDWH

0HWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

«

{

Ç (\ ¦ ©

¦ §

(

± « \ ¦ ² PLQ ¤ £ ¢ Ã¦ Ç § © ¬ Õ

± ² ² p s Õ

Ö ¦ Ö -E -D [

Ö ¦ Ö -E -D [

¨

)

á ³ ã

± ² ² p s Õ

-

s

¡

(\ Ç

Ö Ö -E [ -D

¡ á

)

³ ³ ã

Q

= N=FRQVWDQW

¨ á

)

³ = N + PD[ ¢

¤ £

³ ã

» = N + ª½

s

¨

« Ã ¬

-

s

¥

¨

(

Ç (\ ¦ ©

¦ §

± Ö Ö E ) D ² PLQ ¢ Õ

¤ £

Ö ¦ Ö -E -D [

¨

)

á ³ ã

=

)

ÌQ FRQFOX]LH D GHWHUPLQD PD[LPXO IXQF LHL GH YHURVLPLOLWDWH HVWH HFKLYDOHQW FX D GHWHUPLQD PLQLPXOVXPHLS WUDWHORUHURULORU 2EVHUYD LH 6H úWLH F HVWLPDWRULL GH YHURVLPLOLWDWH PD[LP VXQW HVWLPDWRUL QHGHSODVD L FRQVLVWHQ L úL HILFLHQ LDGLF Ö Ö = D 0 E 0 D = E HVWLPDWRULLVXQWQHGHSODVD L

Ö D

Ö Ö úL E RULFH DOW HVWLPDWRU SHQWUX D úL E DUH GLVSHUVLD PDL PDUH GHFkW GLVSHUVLD OXL D

Ö ª D E ª E HVWLPDWRULLVXQWFRQVLVWHQ L É É É É

HVWLPDWRULLVXQWHILFLHQ L

ÌQFD]XOUHSDUWL LHLQRUPDOHDYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHHVWLPDWRULLRE LQX LSULQPHWRGDFHORUPDL

PLFL S WUDWH VXQW QHGHSODVD L FRQVLVWHQ L úL HILFLHQ L ÌQ FRQVHFLQ

DFHúWL HVWLPDWRUL SRW IL

FRQVLGHUD LGUHSWFHLPDLEXQLvQSURFHVXOGHGHFL]LHVDXGHPRGHODUHHFRQRPHWULF 7HRUHPD 'DF YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO HVWH UHSDUWL]DW QRUPDO DYkQG PHGLD HJDO FX ]HUR úL GLVSHUVLD

¬ s«

» ª

Ö = FW DWXQFL E HVWHUHSDUWL]DW 1 ª E ª ª ½

± ²

² s°

®

(

Ç [¯

¯ ±

²

- [

)

² ² ² Õ

41

'HPRQVWUD LH

´

³ (\ µ - \ Ç ¶

µ

Ö E =

´

·

³ ([ µ Ç

-[ )

¶

µ

)([ µ - [ )

´

´

¶

³ \µ Ç µ

=

´

¶ ¶ ([ µ - [ ) - \ Ç ³ ([ µ - [ ) ³ \µ Ç µ µ = ´ ´ · ³ ([ µ Ç

-[ )

¶

µ

([ µ

³ ([ µ Ç ¶

µ

-[

)

·

-[ )

´ ¶ ³ aµ \ µ = Ç µ

XQGH - [

[º

=

aº

Ç ([ º »

a 1

)

- [

º ¸ X¾

¼

¹

( s ½ ) Ü

\ ¾

(D

a 1

) W=«Q

+ E[ ¾ s ½

Ö ÌQ FRQFOX]LH E ILLQG FRPELQD LH OLQLDU GH YDULDELOH DOHDWRDUH UHSDUWL]DWH QRUPDO HVWH úL HO UHSDUWL]DWQRUPDO

À

À

Ö ¿ Â aÁ 0 \ Á 0 E = Ç

Á

È '

Ä

È

Ö Ã Ç aÅ E = Ç

Å

Ä È

=sÆ

\ Å

Å

Ã Ç aÅ Ç

À

¿ Â aÁ D + Ç ¿ Â Ea Á [ Á = Ç

Á

È '

À

¿ Â a Á D + E[ Á = Ç

Á

Á

È

6HFDOFXOHD] Q

Ça W =

W

=

[

Q

Ç

W =

- [

W

Q

Ç [W

=

- [

W =

Ì

Ça Í [ Í

Í Ë É

Ì

= Ç

Í Ë É

([ Í

Ça Ð

Ð Î Ñ

Ò

([ Ð

Ï

= Ç

Ð Î Ñ

« Ï

(

- [

=

Ê

)

=

Ò

Ì

)

á

([ Ð

(

- [

Ç[Í

)

Í Ë É

Ê

Ê Ì

- [ Ç [ Í

+ Q[

Í Ë É

Ì

(

Ç [Í

Í Ë É

Ê

- [

)

=

Ò

- [

Ì

=

Ê

Ç [Í

Í Ë É

Ç Ð Î Ñ

³ ã

Í Ë É

Ï

Ì

- [ Ç[Í

Í Ë É

Ò

) Ò

Ç [Ð ÃÐ Î Ñ ¬

- [

Ç [Í

- [

Ç[Í

- [ [Í

(

Ì

Í Ë É Ï

)

Ê

Ì

)

'HFL Ö 0 E =E

Ø '

Ö E =

Ø sÖ

Ç ([ Õ Õ Ó ×

Ø

Ô

- [

)

7HRUHPD 'DF YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO HVWH UHSDUWL]DW QRUPDO DYkQG PHGLD HJDO FX ]HUR úL GLVSHUVLD

Ú sÙ

» ª Ö HVWHUHSDUWL]DW 1 = FW DWXQFL D

ª ª ª ½

à D

sÞ

» ª

¢ª

ª Q ª ½

à +

[

à

Ü

Ç ([ Ý Ý Û ß

- [

)

± ± ² ² ² ² ² ² ²² Õ Õ

42

'HPRQVWUD LH

â ã

Ö Ö = \ -E D [ =

á ä \ ã Ç â

â

á ä aã \ ã - [ Ç ã

Q

»

â

±

á ä ª = Ç - [a ã ² \ ã ã ½ Q Õ

á ä bã \ ã = Ç ã

XQGH

=

bå Xç

Q

a 1

- [ a å W=«Q

( s æ ) Ü

\ ç

(D

a 1

) W=«Q

+ E[ ç s æ

Ö ILLQG FRPELQD LH OLQLDU GH YDULDELOH DOHDWRDUH UHSDUWL]DWH QRUPDO HVWH úL HO ÌQ FRQFOX]LH D

UHSDUWL]DWQRUPDO

é

é

Ö = Ç è ë bê 0 \ ê 0 D

ê

í ñ

ñ

Ö = Ç ì ð bî D

'

ñ

í ñ

\ î =sï

'

î

é

é

è ë b ê D + E[ ê = Ç è ë bê D + Ç è ë Eb ê [ ê = Ç ê ê ê ñ

ì ð bî Ç î

6HFDOFXOHD]

ô

ô ò

õ

«

= Ç ó

ó bõ Ç

ò Ã

õ

¬Q

ø ù

ø ö

û

Ç ü ú ý

bü

þ

«

= Ç ÷

÷ bù [ ù Ç

û

= Ç

ü ú ý

« Ã ¬Q

¬Q

- [a

³ ã

ô =- [ Ç ó aõ

ü

á

þ =

³ ã

ø

á

-

Q

= [ - [ Ç ÷ aù [ ù

[ ù

³ ã

=

ò

õ

- [ aù

ö Ã

ù

á

- [ aõ

[

û

Ç ü ú ý

Q

a

þ

+ [

ü

=

ö

ù

û

Ç ü ú ý

ü

a

þ

=

Q

+

[

([ ü

û

Ç ü ú ý

þ þ

- [

)

'HFL Ö =D 0 D

'

Ö =s D

» ª

ª

ª Q ª ½

+

Ç ÿ

± ²

[

([

- [

)

²

² ² Õ

7HRUHPD 'DF [ HVWHIL[DWLDUYDULDELODUH]LGXDO HVWHUHSDUWL]DW QRUPDODYkQGPHGLDHJDO FX]HUR

úLGLVSHUVLD s

Ö Ö +E Ö =D = FW DWXQFL \ [

» ª

HVWHUHSDUWL]DW 1 ª D + E[ ª

s

» ª

ª

ª Q ª ½

ª ½ 'HPRQVWUD LH

+

([

Ç

([

- [

)

- [

±± ²²

)

² ² ²² ²² ÕÕ

Ö Ö +E Ö =D \ [

= Ç

«

+

Ã ¬Q

Ö = \ + E ([

([

- [ )a

á ³ ã

- [

)=

Ç

\

Q

+

([

- [

)Ça

\

\

= Çg

\

=

XQGH g

X

=

Q

a 1

+

([

- [ )a W=«Q

( s ) Ü

\

a 1

(D

+ E[

s

) W=«Q

43

'HFL

Ö ILLQG FRPELQD LH OLQLDU GH YDULDELOH DOHDWRDUH UHSDUWL]DWH QRUPDO HVWH úL HO \

UHSDUWL]DWQRUPDO

b 0 \ 0 \ = Ç ' 6HFDOFXOHD]

$

#g \ = Ç !

(

(

= Ç '

)

' g Ç

) %

) %

,

«

- + 0

g1

1Ç / 2

= Ç .

[-

3

- +

'

« Ã ¬Q

$

=s"

!

á

- [ )a )

+ ([

3

« á = Ç + ([ 4 - [ )a1 2 Ã ³ 1/ Q ¬ ã

0

=

Q

$ !

á ³ ã

+

$ !

#g Ç

g = Ç

([ 4 - [ ) Q

- [

= [ + ([

[-

Eg D + Ç

[

([ &

=+

³ ã

- [ )a -

*

D + E[

\

([ &

+

Ã ¬Q

,

-

. g Ç

$ !

g = Ç

(

)Ç ' a)

,

)Ç . a-

-[

*

=

) %

- +

[-

3 0 3 4 Ça1 + ([ - [ ) Ça1 1/ 2 1/ 2 0

= [ +

([ *

-[

([ 4

-[ )

=

Q

+

)= [*

3

([1 1Ç / 2 0

-[

3

)

'HFL

;

Ö = D + E[ 0 \

'

:

Ö =s8 \

» ª

:

ª

+

ª Q ª ½

6

([ ;

7Ç 5 9

)

- [

([ 7

± ²

:

²

:

)

- [

² ² Õ

7HRUHPD

s<

'DF YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO HVWH UHSDUWL]DW QRUPDO DYkQG PHGLD HJDO FX ]HUR úL GLVSHUVLD

=

= FW » ª

1 ª s B

» ª

D

DWXQFL

ª -

ª

ª ª ½

ª ½

Q

-

@

HURDUHD

([ A

AÇ ? C

)

([ A

= \

Ö> X

Ö - \

>

>

W

HVWH

Q

UHSDUWL]DW

±± ²²

D

-[

SUHYL]LXQLL

D

² ²

-[

)

ÖE X

= \

²² ²² ÕÕ

'HPRQVWUD LH

Ö - \

E

= \

E

E

Ö Ö -E -D [

E

XQGH

&&

Ö E VXQWUHSDUWL]D LQRUPDO D

XG

( s F ) Ü

a 1

\

G

a 1

(D

+ E[

G

s

F ) W=«Q

Ö H ILLQG FRPELQD LH OLQLDU GH YDULDELOH DOHDWRDUH UHSDUWL]DWH QRUPDO HVWH úL HD ÌQ FRQFOX]LH X UHSDUWL]DW QRUPDO

ÖI = 0 \ 0 X '

J

Ö K ) = 0 (X ÖK (X

0 \

Ö 0 \

QO

M

L

= '

= '

Ö - \

I

) - 0 (XÖK

J

O

L

\

Ö \

Q

J

M

)

I

= 0 \ Ö = 0X

K

J

Ö +0 \

Ö Ö +E - 0 D [

O

=sS

O

((\ K

I

= D + E[ I

- D - E[ I

K ) ) = 0 (\ K ) - 0 (\ K L L L M = s N + D + E[ M

=0

+ 0 \

Q

I

» ª ª

ªQ ª ½

Ö -\

J

+

R

[

Q Ç T P

Q [

J

Q

-[

± ²

O

-[

O

Ö \

J K ) + 0 (\Ö K )

² + (D + E[ ² ² Õ

=

Q O )

44

U

0 \

U

Ö \

V

= D + E[ U

Ö Ö +E 0 XZ D [

X

Ö E = Ça Y

\

Y W [

Ö U Ö +E [ + 0 XU D

Ö Ö = 0 X Z \ - E [ + E[

Z

µ Ü

= 0

^

^

\

^

e

0

Q

f

\

f

g \ Ç b

0 [ Ç k l

i

m p qa Ç

0 [

o n

i \ n

X

X = [0 Ç k l

i a

i

m n

o

o

Q

Ç a N 0 \N XW =

N =

n

n

0 Xd

Q

a

X = [ Ç k la

i

N =

W

s

n

j

n

0 \ X

o

N =

N =

[ - [

Q

Q

Q

^

i

p qa o nÇ

Ç a N 0 D + E[N XW + Ç a N 0 XN XW =

=

X

±á ²³ = Õã

0 \ X

\ X = [

o

ca

]

]

\

Ç a N 0 D + E[N + XN XW =

Q

=

Q

i

\

s

m n

]

a ^ ]Ç _ `

]

a ^ ]Ç _ `

\

=

j

\

+ [

h

i \

\ X = [ 0 Ç p qa

]

\

+ 0 [

^

=

Xd

h

j

]

\

] _ `

GHRDUHFHHURULOHVXQWQHFRUHODWHvQWUHHOH

i a

¿ Ý

« » X \ - [ Ça ] ] _ ` Ã ^ ª ½ ¬

\ - 0 [ Ça ]

0 Xd \ =

h

´ ¿

Z

Y

Ö Ö +E 0 X D [

= 0 X

Ö U Ö U Ö U Ö +E Ö +E Ö +E [ + X U D [ = 0 D + E[ U D [ + 0 X U D

= 0 D + E[ U

Q

Ç a N D + E[N 0 XW + a W 0 XW XW

N =

Ç [W - [

W =

'HFL

Ö Ö +E 0 Xt D [

t

=

Q

su

w

+

s

[

tÇ r v

- [

t [t

w

- [

w

'LQUHOD LLOHDQWHULRDUHUH]XOW F

'

}

=s{

Öz X

- s {

}

}

» ª ª

ª Q ª ½

+

y

+ D + E[

[

zÇ x |

- [

z

[

z

z

+s{

}

» ª

¢ª

ª Q ª ½

+

}

² - D + E[ ² ² Õ

y

[

zÇ x |

± ²

}

- [

}

z

}

- [

z

- [

[z

=s

{

± ²

}

}

» ª

ª ª ª ½

}

Q

² + D + E[ ² ² Õ

-

y

[

zÇ x |

- [

z

[

z

z

}

-

± ²

}

- [

}

² ² ² Õ

7HRUHPD 'DF YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO HVWH UHSDUWL]DW QRUPDO DYkQG PHGLD HJDO FX ]HUR úL GLVSHUVLD

s~

= FW DWXQFL

Q à

Ç XW

Q - W =

HVWHXQHVWLPDWRUQHGHSODVDWSHQWUXGLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH s

45

'HPRQVWUD LH 7UHEXLHGHPRQVWUDWF

» 0 ª

½ Q -

Ö ÇX

± ² =s

Õ

)RORVLQGWHRUHPDDQWHULRDU UH]XOW F

» 0ª

½ Q -

=

Ö ÇX

» ª

ª ª ½

Q -

Õ

Q

-

± ²=

Ç ª

Q -

Ç

=

± ²

-[

[

-[

[

Ö Ç0 X

² ¢s

Q -

=

² ² Õ

Ç'

Ö = X

» ª

Ç [

ª Q -

Q - ª

Ç

ª ½

[

± ²

-[

-[

² ¢s ² ² Õ

=s

7HRUHPD

s

'DF YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO HVWH UHSDUWL]DW QRUPDO DYkQG PHGLD HJDO FX ]HUR úL GLVSHUVLD

= FW » ª

1 ª s

DWXQFL

» ª

ª

ª +

ª ½

ª ª ½

Q

HURDUHD

([

+

Ç

)

([

= \

Ö - \

HVWH

UHSDUWL]DW

² ² SHQWUXRULFHt

)

- [

Ö X

±± ²²

- [

SUHYL]LXQLL

²² ²² ÕÕ

'HPRQVWUD LH 6HUHLDGHPRQVWUD LDWHRUHPHLXQGHWVHvQORFXLHúWHFXtQúLGHRDUHFHtQHVWHPDLPDUH FDQSHQWUXRULFHN

a Ç

0 \ X

Q 0 X X N

Q+ t

= UH]XOW F

= úL 0 XQ+ t \ = 'HFL 0 X

¡

Ö Ö +E D [

¡

=

ÌQILQDOUH]XOW F

'

¤

Ö § ¢ ¦ )=s© (X

- (D + E[

¤

¬ « ± )

+ (D + E[

°

=s

®

°

» ª

§ ¢ ¦ )

ª + ª ª ½

Q

¤

+s

+

©

¤

([ ¬ « ± ¬

([ Ç ª ¯

» ª

ª + ª ª ½

- [ - [

Q

§

([ ¨ ¨Ç £ ¥

- [ - [

± ²

¤

)

¤

)

² + ² ² Õ

(D

+ E[

§ ¢ ¦ )

¤

-

± ²

°

)

+

([ § ¢ ¦

²

°

)

² ² Õ

'HPRQVWUD LDSHQWUXQRUPDOLWDWHúLYDORDUHDPHGLHHVWHLGHQWLF FXFHDGHODWHRUHPD 'HRDUHFH FHOH SDWUX LSRWH]H , ² ,³ ,´ úL ,µ DX IRVW DFFHSWDWH D SULRUL vQ HWDSD GH HVWLPDUH D SDUDPHWULORUvQDFHDVW HWDS XUPHD] FDHOHV ILHWHVWDWHLDUHYHQWXDOHOHDEDWHULGHODFHULQ HOHORU V ILHFRUHFWDWHSULQXWLOL]DUHDXQRUSURFHGXULHFRQRPHWULFHDGHFYDWHILHF UHLDEDWHUL 'H UHJXO vQ FD]XO XQXL QXP U PDUH DO REVHUYD LLORU HIHFWXDWH W = Q Q a LSRWH]D GH QRUPDOLWDWHDYDULDELOHLHURDUHX¶ VHDFFHSW I U UH]HUYH 9HULILFDUHDLSRWH]HORUGHIXQGDPHQWDUHD0&003

, ² 9DULDELOHOH[úL\QXVXQWDIHFWDWHGHHURULGHP

VXU

$FHDVW LSRWH] VHSRDWHYHULILFDFXUHJXODFHORUWUHLVLJPDUHJXO FDUHFRQVW vQYHULILFDUHD XUP WRDUHORUUHOD LL [

W

([ s

[

)â

[ - s

[

< [

W

< [ + s

[

46

¸

\

(

\ s

)â ·

\ - s

< \

·

¸

< \ + s

·

XQGH

s

s

[

\

Ç ([ W

=

- [

)

Q Ç (\

=

- \

W

)

Q

'DF YDORULOH DFHVWRU YDULDELOH DSDU LQ LQWHUYDOHORU

[

W

([ s

[

)

úL

\

º

(

)

\ s ¹

LSRWH]DGHPDLVXVSRDWHILDFFHSWDW I U UH]HUYH $FHDVW LSRWH] UHIHULWRDUH OD FDOLWDWHD GDWHORU vQUHJLVWUDWH VH FRQVLGHU UH]ROYDW vQ HWDSD GHSUHOXFUDUHDGDWHORUREVHUYDWHVWDWLVWLFVDXFHOPDLWkU]LXvQHWDSDGHLGHQWLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXL ,³ ,SRWH]DGHKRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWHDYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH±9DULDELODDOHDWRDUHUH]LGXDO XHVWHGHPHGLHQXO

0

Ö )= (X

LDUGLVSHUVLDHL V ¼ ½

»

HVWHFRQVWDQW

úLLQGHSHQGHQW

GH;

3H ED]D DFHVWHL LSRWH]H VH SRDWH DGPLWH F OHJ WXUD GLQWUH < úL ; HVWH UHODWLY VWDELO &RQWUDULXODFHVWHLLSRWH]HHVWHKHWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWHD ÌQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL OLQLDU

= D + E[ ¾

\¾

Ö¿ + X ¾ UH]LGXXULOH X

= \

¿

Ö - \

¿

= \

¿

Ö Ö -E -D [

¿

VXQW

KRPRVFHGDVWLFH GDF GLVSHUVLLOH ORU VXQW FRQVWDQWH úL HJDOH FX GLVSHUVLLOH WHRUHWLFH SHQWUX RULFH W úL VXQWLQGHSHQGHQWHGHYDULDELODH[RJHQ [ VÀ

ÂÃ

ÖÁ = 0 X

Â

=s

&RQWUDULXO KRPRVFHGDVWLFLW GLVSHUVLLOHHJDOHFLGLIHULWH 0

XÅ

Ä

À

Â

" W = Q

LL HVWH KHWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWHD FDUH vQVHDPQ F HURULOH QX DX

¹ 0 XÄ

Ä

¹ ¹ 0 X Ç

Ä

¹sÆ

Ä

'DF GLVSHUVLLOH QX PDL VXQW HJDOH HVWLPDWRULL U PkQ QHGHSODVD L GDU QX PDL VXQW HILFDFH 0&003 FRQGXFkQG OD R VXEHVWLPDUH D SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL LQIOXHQ kQG VHQVLELO úL FDOLWDWHD GLIHULWHORUWHVWHVWDWLVWLFHDSOLFDWHDFHVWXLD 'HSLVWDUHDKHWHURVFHGDVWLFLW

LLVHSRDWHUHDOL]DSULQPDLPXOWHSURFHGHH

,ÈÊÉ Ë 3URFHGHXO JUDILF FDUH FRQVW vQ FRQVWUXLUHD FRUHORJUDPHL SULYLQG YDORULOH YDULDELOHL

IDFWRULDOH [ úL DOH YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH X 'DF SH P VXUD FUHúWHULL VF GHULL YDORULORU YDULDELOHL IDFWRULDOH[VHREVHUY RFUHúWHUHVF GHUH DYDORULORUYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHXvQVHDPQ F FHOHGRX YDULDELOHVXQWFRUHODWHúLQXLQGHSHQGHQWH

Ö X

Ö X

[

[

)LJXUD&RUHODUHSR]LWLY

)LJXUD&RUHODUHQHJDWLY

,ÈÊÉ È 3URFHGHXOGLVSHUVLLORUYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH

$FHVW SURFHGHX VH SRDWH DSOLFD DWXQFL FkQG VH GLVSXQH GH VHULL OXQJL GH GDWH ÌQ DFHVW FD] VHULD YDORULORU YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH VH vPSDUWH vQ GRX VDX PDL PXOWH JUXSH SHQWUX ILHFDUH JUXS FDOFXOkQGXVH GLVSHUVLLLOH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH V Ì Í

Î

Ð

VÌ Í

Î

Ï

'DF VH DFFHSW LSRWH]D F GLVSHUVLLOH

DFHVWRU JUXSH QX GLIHU VHPQLILFDWLY VHDFFHSW LSRWH]DGHKRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWHúLVHXWLOL]HD] WHVWXO )LVKHU6QHGHFRU

GDF V Ô

GDF V Ô

Ñ

Ñ

Ó

Ó

VÔ ¹ VÔ

Ñ

Ñ

DWXQFLVHDFFHSW LSRWH]D,È

Ò Ò

DWXQFLVHUHVSLQJHLSRWH]D,È

47

7HVWXO )LVKHU6QHGHFRU FRQVW vQ FDOFXODUHD UDSRUWXOXL GLQWUH FHOH GRX GLVSHUVLL GLVSHUVLD DYkQG YDORDUHD FHD PDL PDUH ILLQG SODVDW OD QXP U WRU LDU GDF QXP UXO GH WHUPHQL DL VHULHL HVWH LPSDU VH UHFRPDQG HOLPLQDUHD WHUPHQXOXL GLQ PLMORFXO VHULHL DVWIHO vQFkW V VH DMXQJ OD VXEHúDQWLRDQHHJDOH

VÛ

=

)Ü

× ß Ù Ù Þ

Ù

VÛ

> )

GDF )

Ú Ö Ø ×

=

Ý

Ç

Ø

Ù

Q - N -

X

× Ú Ö Õ Ø Ù

Ù

Ù

Q - N -

DWXQFL LSRWH]D GH KRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWH HVWH LQILUPDW GHFL HURULOH VXQW

» Q ± » Q ± a ª - ² ª - ² ½ Õ ½ Õ

F

Ç X

KHWHURVFHGDVWLFHHOLPLQDUHDDFHVWXLIHQRPHQI FkQGXVHFXDMXWRUXOPHWRGHLUHJUHVLHLSRQGHUDWH

Ê )

GDF )

» Q ± » Q ± a ª - ² ª - ² ½ Õ ½ Õ

F

DWXQFLVHDFFHSW LSRWH]DGHKRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWH

,ÈÊÉ à &DOFXOXOFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU VLPSO

äá

Uâ

FRY (X [

=

sâ

s

)

Ç (X

=

á

)([ ã

-X

ã

Q s

â

s

- [

)

á

=

ÇX

ã ([ ã

- [

Q sâ s

)

á

GDF YDORDUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU HVWHDSUR[LPDWLYHJDO FX]HUR±Uåçæ

VHDFFHSW LSRWH]DGHKRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWHYDULDELOHOHXúL[ILLQGLQGHSHQGHQWH

GDF YDORDUHD FRHILFLHQWXOXL GH FRUHOD LH OLQLDU HVWH GLIHULW GH ]HUR ± Uåçæ

DUHVSLQJHLSRWH]DGHKRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWH

è

è

@DWXQFL

¹ DWXQFL VH

,ÈÊÉ é $FFHSWDUHD VDX UHVSLQJHUHD LSRWH]HL GH KRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWH VH PDL SRDWH UHDOL]D úL FX

DMXWRUXOPHWRGHLDQDOL]HLYDULD LHL

&HOH GRX UHVWULF LL HQXQ DWH PDL VXV VH UHDOL]HD] GDF YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO X úL YDULDELOD H[SOLFDWLY [ VXQW LQGHSHQGHQWH 3H DFHDVW SUHPLV VH IXQGDPHQWHD] XWLOL]DUHD PHWRGHL DQDOL]HL YDULD LHLODDFFHSWDUHDVDXUHVSLQJHUHDLSRWH]HLGHKRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWH 0HWRGDDQDOL]HLYDULD LHLSRUQHúWHGHODUHOD LD - \ = \

ê

\

(\ ì

î

ó

ò õ (\ ôÇ ô

- \

ö

)

=

ï ó

ò õ [( \Ö ôÇ ô

'DU \ ÷

= D + E[ ÷

Ö \

Ö Ö +E =D [

û

Ö ù X

ý <Öú Ü Ç ú ü

ø

= \

- \ \

ú

í ð

ô

=

-\

ï

Ö - \

ô

Ö - \

ê

ö

) ]

(\ ì

ñ

Ö + \

ê

Ö - \

î

Ö = Ç [ \

=

ó

ï

í ð

ô Çò õ (\Ö ô

ì ï

- \

- \

ê

Ö + \

ì

- \ + \

ó ô ô ò õ (\

ö

)

)

- \

+ Ç

ï

ë

Ö -\

Ö - \

ô

ö

)

ï

]

ñ

ó ô ô ò õ (\Ö

+ Ç

- \

)( \

ô

Ö - \

ô

)

+ X ÷

Ö Ö +E Ü \ =D [

ø

Ö - \

ù

Ç \

) + (\

- \

)

- \

ë

ù

Ö Ö + EÖ[ - < ú = Ç D

vPS U LPUHOD LD ODQ Ü s

=s

Ö - EÖ[ X Öú -D

ú [

+s

Ö X

Ö = E Ç [

ú

- [ Xú

Q Q

Ö = Q E FRYX ú [

ú

'DF

Ö + E FRYX [

3HQWUX FD HJDOLWDWHD V VH YHULILFH HVWHQHFHVDUFD FRYX [ = E ¹ $FFHSWDUHDLSRWH]HL ,þ SHED]DDQDOL]HLYDULD LHLFRQVW vQ

6H FDOFXOHD]

Ö - \ Ç <

Ç\

- \

Ç\

Ö -<

= $ ´

¿ ¿ = % µ ¿ =& ¿ Ý

GDF $

%& DWXQFL YDULDELOHOH X ÿ úL [ ÿ VXQW LQGHSHQGHQWH úL VH

DFFHSW ,þ

GDF $¹%&DWXQFLX ÿ úL[ ÿ VXQWFRUHODWHúLVHUHVSLQJH,þ

48

'DF VH FRQVWDW H[LVWHQ D IHQRPHQXOXL GH KHWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWH DFHVWD WUHEXLH HOLPLQDW GHRDUHFH SUH]HQ D OXL GHWHUPLQ VXEHVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL úL RE LQHUHD GH YDORUL YLFLDWH ILLQGDIHFWDW FDOLWDWHDHVWLPDWRULORUDFHúWLDQHPDLILLQGHILFLHQ LGLVSHUVLHPLQLP (OLPLQDUHDIHQRPHQXOXLGHKHWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWHVHSRDWHUHDOL]DSULQXUP WRDUHOHSURFHGHH D &RQVWUXLUHDPRGHOXOXLSHED]DDEDWHULORUFHQWUDWHDOHYDULDELOHORU = D + E[ ÷

)LH \ ÷

Ö \

Ö Ö +E =D [

+ X÷

\ = D + E[ + X

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ± Ü \

1RWkQGFX

\ [

W

W

= \ = [

- \ = E [

W

- \ ´ ¿

W

¿<Ö ®

¿ Ý

=E [

W

µ Ü

- [

W

Å\ ¿

- [ +X

W

Ö =E [

W

W

+X

W

W

W

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWUXOXLESUHVXSXQHPLQLPL]DUHDIXQF LHL

( )

(

Ö ) E = PLQ Ç \

)

-<

= PLQ Ç (\

Ö -E [

)

úLFDOFXOXOGHULYDWHLSDU LDOHDIXQF LHL

(

Ö ) E = Ü Ç \

W

Ö -E [

W

) ¢ (- [ W ) =

â ÇX W

([ W

- [

)=

Ü FRY (X

¹ s

FHHDFHvQVHDPQ

[

W

W

)=

E 0HWRGDUHJUHVLHLSRQGHUDWH )LHPRGHOXOLQL LDO \ ÷

= D + E[ ÷

+ X ÷

+HWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWHDSUHVXSXQH 0 X

= l s s = l s

s

«««««

s

= l s

XQGHl HVWHXQFRHILFLHQWGHSRQGHUDUH (VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXLSUHVXSXQHPLQLPL]DUHDIXQF LHL

Ö Ö E = PLQ PLQ ) D

Ç

Ö Ö E = PLQ &RQIRUPUHOD LHL PLQ ) D ÌQ UHOD LD FDQWLW SUDFWLF DEDWHULOH VWDQGDUG s

LOH s

s

Ç

\ l

Ö Ö - E[ - D

Ö Ö - E[ - D

\

!

" # úL l $ VXQW vQ JHQHUDOQHFXQRVFXWH6DFRQVWDWDWvQV F vQ

& % VXQW DSUR[LPDWLY SURSRU LRQDOH FX YDORULOH YDULDELOHL H[RJHQH [

DGLF

s) s

( = s ) [' , +

=s

, [*

«««««

s

, .

=s

, [-

&RUHOkQGUHOD LLOH úL UH]XOW F UHOD LD GHYLQH Ö Ö E = PLQ ) D

s2

4

0

PLQ Ç

1

[1

4

Ö Ö - E[1 \1 - D

4

=

s2

4

0

Ö 1 » \1 - D Ö -E [ ª PLQ Ç / 3 ª 1 [1 ½

± ² ² Õ

4

=

s2

4

0

» \1 PLQ Ç / 3 ª 1 ª [1 ½

Ö -D

[1

± Ö - E² ² Õ

4

49

'DU UHOD LD HVWH HFKLYDOHQW FX DSOLFDUHD 0&003 PRGHOXOXL LQL LDO GXS FH vQ SUHDODELODIRVWvPS U LWOD[ 5

\6

= D + E[ 6

+ X6

Ü

_ [ 6

8

\6

= D

[6

;

9 »X

Ö Ö E 7 : ª PLQ ) D = PLQ Ç

9

½

[6

+E +

8

± ²

[9

X6 [6

;

9 » \

7 : ª = PLQ Ç 9

Õ

½

[9

Ö -D

[9

± Ö -E ² Õ

Ö Ö úL E DOH IXQF LLORU úL úL &DOFXOkQG GHULYDWHOH SDU LDOH vQ UDSRUW FX D DQXOkQGXOHVHDMXQJHODDFHODúLVLVWHPGHHFXD LLSHED]DF UXLDVHGHWHUPLQ FHLGRLHVWLPDWRUL Å

Ö = Ü ¿ ) D ¿

Ö ) E = Ü

¿

¿ ®

Å ¿

¿Ö E = ¿

Ç

¿

Ü ¿

¿D Ö = ¿ ¿ ®

[?

>

Ö D Ç

Ç Ç

\? [?

[?

>

>

>

[<

Ö -E

Ö + EÇ

=

Ö + QE =

[<

[?

[?

\?

Ç

QÇ

¿

¿

Ö D Ç

-

Ç

[?

[<

Ç

Ç

» ± ² - Çª ² ª [? ½ Õ

Ç Ç

=

>

Ç

\< [<

=

\< [<

\? [?

>

[? [?

>

8Q FD] FRQFUHW GH XWLOL]DUH D DFHVWHL PHWRGH R FRQVWLWXLH VLWXD LD vQ FDUH VH XUP UHúWH PRGHODUHDLQYHVWL LLORUXQRULQWUHSULQGHULGHGLPHQVLXQLGLIHULWHvQIXQF LHGHFDSLWDOFLIUDGHDIDFHUL úLYHQLW,

I.&$9 X

2 DOW PHWRG FRQVW vQ VHJPHQWDUHD HúDQWLRQXOXL vQ VXEFROHFWLYLW

L RPRJHQH GLQ SXQFW GH

YHGHUHDOQLYHOHORUIDFWRULORUXUPDW GHRUHVSHFLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLSHQWUXILHFDUHVHJPHQWvQSDUWH ÌQ PRG FXUHQW DFHVW SURFHGHX VH XWLOL]HD] OD HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF SULYLQG FHUHUHD VDX FRQVXPXO SRSXOD LHL ID

GH XQ SURGXV GH IRORVLQ

FXUHQW

GHRDUHFH VD FRQVWDWDW F GLVSHUVLD FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH FRQVXPXOXL FUHúWH SH P VXUD FUHúWHULL QLYHOXOXL YHQLWXOXL ,@ 9DORULOH YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH X VXQW QHFRUHODWH UHVSHFWLY QX H[LVW

IHQRPHQXO GH

DXWRFRUHODUHDHURULORU FRYX B X A = 0 X B X A = " W N = Q W < N 'HRDUHFHDSOLFD LLOHSUDFWLFHDXDU WDWF DFHVWIHQRPHQHIUHFYHQWvQVSHFLDOvQFD]XOVHULLORU FURQRORJLFH LQWHUGHSHQGHQWH YHULILFDUHD DFHVWXLD HVWH QHFHVDU PDL DOHV vQ FD]XO FDOFXOHORU GH SURJQR] 0&003 vQ FD]XO H[LVWHQ HL IHQRPHQXOXL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH

0 X D X C ¹ QX PDL

SHUPLWH RE LQHUHD GH HVWLPDWRUL HILFLHQ L SUH]HQWkQG WRWRGDW GLVWRUVLXQL GH OD YDORULOH UHDOH 6H S VWUHD] vQV FDOLWDWHDDFHVWRUDGHDILFRQVLVWHQ LIDSWFHLPSXQHLQWURGXFHUHDvQFDOFXODXQRUVHULL GHGDWHVXILFLHQWGHOXQJLHúDQWLRQGHYDORULFkWPDLPDUH $XWRFRUHODUHD HURULORU VH GDWRUHD] DQDOL]HL vQ WLPS D OHJ WXULL GLQWUH YDULDELOH UHVSHFWLY D XQXL HIHFW LQHU LDO vQ HYROX LD YDULDELOHORU VDX DOW FDX] DU FRQVWLWXL R HURDUH GH VSHFLILFDUH D PRGHOXOXL UHVSHFWLY RPLWHUHD XQHL YDULDELOH H[SOLFDWLYH [ 5 FX LQIOXHQ

SXWHUQLF DVXSUD YDULDELOHL

HQGRJHQH\ 'HSLVWDUHDDXWRFRUHO ULLHURULORUVHSRDWHIDFHXWLOL]kQGXUP WRDUHOHSURFHGHH

50

Ö 3URFHGHXOJUDILF±VHUHDOL]HD] FRUHORJUDPDvQWUHYDORULOHHVWLPDWHDOHYDULDELOHLHQGRJHQH <E úL Ö YDORULOHYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH X

ÖF X

Ö \

G

)LJXUD

*UDILF DXWRFRUHOD LD HURULORU VH PDQLIHVW ILH SULQWUXQ QXP U IRDUWH PLF VDX IRDUWH PDUH GH VFKLPE UL DOH VHPQXOXL YDULDELOHL DOHDWRDUH ILH FD XUPDUH D XQRU VFKLPE UL VLPHWULFH R RVFLOD LH UHJXODW DYDORULORUYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHID

Ö GHYDORULOHOXL \

&DOFXOXOFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHGHRUGLQXO Q

Ö X Ö ÇX W W

U

=

W =

Q

Ö X Ö ÇX W W

-

=

Q -

W =

Q

Ö Ç X W

Ö ÇX

W =

W =

-

W -

$FHVWDHVWHGHILQLWvQLQWHUYDOXO [- ] DYkQGXUP WRDUHDVHPQLILFD LH

Å - DXWRFRUHOD LH VWULFW QHJDWL Y

U

¿ =

LQGHSHQGHQ

¿ + DXWRFRUHOD LH VWULFW SR]LWL Y ®

7HVWXO'XUELQ:DWVRQFRQVW vQFDOFXODUHDYDORULL

J

ÖK Ç (X

G =

K H M

ÖK -X

J Ç K H L

M

I

L )

M

ÖK X

$FHDVW YDORDUH HPSLULF ÄG´ VH FRPSDU FX GRX YDORUL WHRUHWLFH G N úL GO SUHOXDWH GLQ WDEHOXO GLVWULEX LHL 'XUELQ:DWVRQ YH]L $QH[D QU vQ IXQF LH GH XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a DUELWUDU DOHV a

( Q Q

Ë )

VDX a

GH QXP UXO GH YDULDELOH H[RJHQH N úL GH YDORULOH REVHUYDWH

5HJXODGHGHFL]LHDDSOLF ULLWHVWXOXLVHSUH]LQW vQWDEHOXOXUP WRU
G N ÊGÊGO

$XWRFRUHODUH

,QGHFL]LH

SR]LWLY

GO

(URULOHVXQW LQGHSHQGHQWH

GO

ÊGÊG N

,QGHFL]LH

G N
&HL GRL DXWRUL DFFHSWkQG LSRWH]D GH QRUPDOLWDWH D YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH DX GHPRQVWUDW F GLVWULEX LD YDULDELOHL DOHDWRDUH G HVWH FXSULQV vQWUH GRX GLVWULEX LL OLPLW G N úL GO DOH F URU P ULPL GHSLQG GH SUDJXO GH VHPQLILFD LH a GH QXP UXO GH YDULDELOH H[RJHQH N úL GH QXP UXO GH YDORUL REVHUYDWHQQË 'H]YROWkQGUHOD LDOXLGDFHDVWDGHYLQH

51

R

G =

R

U

ÖS X Ç U

+

SP

ÖS Q X Ç U

SP

R

U T

ÖS X ÖS - Ç X

SP U

R

Q T

U

ÇT XÖ S SP

W

ÖX 3HQWUXXQQVXILFLHQWGHPDUHFHOHWUHLVXPH Ç V X

Y

X Y

UHOD LDOXLGYDILHJDO FX

Ö] Ç Z X

] ^

^

\

_ Ö] [ Ç Z X ] _

^

ILLQGDSUR[LPDWLYHJDOH

d

Öe X Ç c

ea

G = -

=

` b

c

Ç XÖ e ea b

Ök X Ç i

kg

Öe X

d ` b

j

6HQRWHD] FX Uh

\

Ök X

j f h

Ç kg h

Ök X

f h FRHILFLHQWXOGHDXWRFRUHOD LHGHRUGLQXODUH]LGXXULORUX l

i

(

ÜG = - U

( )

m

)Ü U

( )

m

G

=-

Ü G >@

FXVHPQLILFD LD Å - Ü DXWRFRUHOD UH VWULFW QHJDWL Y ¿ U

¿ ¿

Ü

= ¿ ¿

¿ ®

¿

LQGHFL]LH

¿ ¿

Ü G =

Ü LQGHSHQGHQ

æ Ü

Å

¿

LQGHFL]LH

Ü DXWRFRUHOD UH VWULFW

¿

æ

¿ ®

SR]LWL Y

ÌQJHQHUDODXWRFRUHOD LDHURULORUHVWHSURYRFDW GHGRX FDX]H ILH F YDULDELOD HQGRJHQ \ VH DXWRFRUHOHD] vQ HYROX LD VD FD XUPDUH D XQXL HIHFW LQHU LDO JHQHUkQGRDXWRFRUHODUHvQWLPSDHURULORU ILH GDWRULW RPLWHULL XQHL YDULDELOH H[RJHQH [ FX LQIOXHQ

VHPQLILFDWLY DVXSUD OXL \ DGLF D

XQHLHURULGHVSHFLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULF (OLPLQDUHD IHQRPHQXOXL GH DXWRFRUHODUH D YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH X l ± vQ FD]XO GHSLVW ULL VDOH ± VHIXQGDPHQWHD] SHHYLWDUHDFDX]HORUFDUHvOJHQHUHD] 2 PRGDOLWDWH GLUHFW GH D HYLWD FRQVHFLQ HOH VWDWLVWLFH SH FDUH OH JHQHUHD] DFHVW IHQRPHQ R FRQVWLWXLHXWLOL]DUHDXUP WRDUHORUSURFHGHH

D $SOLFDUHD 0&003 JHQHUDOL]DWH vQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL FDUH vQ FD]XO DXWRFRUHO ULL UH]LGXXULORU SHUPLWH RE LQHUHD GH HVWLPDWRUL QHGHSODVD L FRQVLVWHQ L úL HILFLHQ L $FHDVW PHWRG HVWH UHFRPDQGDW vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU FDX]DOH HVWH VXSHULRU OXL

Ö XQXPRGHOHPXOWLIDFWRULDOH (VWLPDWRULLPRGHOXOXLVHRE LQDVWIHO % = ; 9 XQGH9

-

;

-

; 9

-

<

PDWULFHDYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORUUH]LGXXULORU

E 8QDOWSURFHGHXHVWHXUP WRUXO )LH PRGHOXO OLQLDU XQLIDFWRULDO \

W

= D + E[

W

+X

W

6H HVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULL DFHVWXLD D úL E FX

DMXWRUXO 0&003 6H FDOFXOHD] YDORULOH DMXVWDWH DOH YDULDELOHL HQGRJHQH

Öo UH]LGXXULOH X

= \

o

Ö - \

o

= \

o

Ö Ö -E -D [

Ö \n

Ö Ö + E[ n úL = D

o úL VH DSOLF WHVWXO ³G´ 'DF LSRWH]D GH

52

LQGHSHQGHQ

¹

D YDULDELOHORU UH]LGXDOH ,p QX SRDWH IL DFFHSWDW Uq

Ur

= -

G

DFHDVWD

SUHVXSXQHRDXWRFRUHODUHGHRUGLQXOvQWkLDHURULORUUHVSHFWLY Ö s - = Ux X

Ö s tvu + ] s uwX

XQGH]y HVWHYDULDELODDOHDWRDUHFHYHULILF LSRWH]HOH,z ,p úL,{ ùWLLQGF

Ö } | = \~ } | - \ Ö -E Ö ~ } | = \ ~ } | -D [ ~ } |

Ö~ X

ÌQORFXLQGUHOD LLOH úL vQUHOD LD VHRE LQH \

Ö Ö - E[ - D

\

- U

Ö \ - D Ö - E[ + ]

= U

Ö \ = D Ö - U + E [ - U [ + ]

ÌQ HFXD LD YDULDELOHOH \ úL [ VXQW FXQRVFXWH LDU YDORDUHD FRHILFLHQWXOXL GH DXWRFRUHOD LHVHYDFDOFXODFXUHOD LD

U

=

X Ç

X

Ç X

6H LQWURGXF YDORULOH DFHVWXLD vQ UHOD LD úL VH YRU HVWLPD SDUDPHWULL D úL E SULQ Ö DSOLFDUHD GLQ QRX D 0&003 )LH Ö a úL b HVWLPD LLOH SDUDPHWULORU D úL E FDOFXODWH SH ED]D

GLIHUHQ HORUGHRUGLQXOvQWkLDOHYDULDELOHORU\úL[ 6HDMXQJHDVWIHOODPRGHOXO \

XQGH

\

- U

- U

\ = a - U + b [ - U [

\ UHSUH]LQW GLIHUHQ HOH WHRUHWLFH DMXVWDWH GH RUGLQXO vQWkL DOH YDULDELOHL

HQGRJHQH\FDOFXODWHSHED]DIXQF LHLGHUHJUHVLH F 3URFHGHXOSULQEDOHLDM+LOGUHWK/X 'DF H[LVW FRUHOD LHVHDMXQJHODUHOD LD \

- U

Ö \ = D Ö ¡ - U + E¡ [ - U [ + ] Ü \ ¢

£

= D¤

+ E¤ [ ¢

£

+ ]¢

3URFHGHXOSULQEDOHLDMFRQVW vQDWULEXLUHDGHYDORULOXLU ¥§¦§¨ vQLQWHUYDOXO>@ÜDXWRFRUHODUH SR]LWLY VDXvQWUH>@ÜDXWRFRUHODUHQHJDWLY 'HH[HPSOXvQFD]XOXQHLDXWRFRUHO ULSRLWLYHLVHDWULEXLHOXLU ¥§¦§¨ XUP WRDUHOHYDORUL

ª

U ¥§¦§¨ >ÜÇ]© U ¥§¦§¨ >ÜÇ]© U ¥§¦§¨ >ÜÇ]©

ª

ª

'HFLPLQLPXOVHVLWXHD] vQLQWHUYDOXO>@ 6H GDX DSRL YDORUL OXL U Ç]

«

«µ RSULQGXQH OD YDORDUHD SHQWUX FDUH VH RE LQH PLQ

Ö Ö úL E 3HQWUXDFHDVW YDORDUHVHS VWUHD] HVWLPDWRULL D RE LQX LvQDFHVWFD]

G 3URFHGHXOLWHUDWLYDOOXL'&RFKUDQúL&2UFXWW 6HFRQVLGHU PRGHOXO \

W

= D + E[

W

+X

W

6HHVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULLPRGHOXOXLVHDSOLF WHVWXO

': VH FDOFXOHD] FRHILFLHQWXO GH DXWRFRUHOD LH GH RUGLQXO vQWkL úL VH vQORFXLHúWH YDORDUHD VD vQ HFXD LDLQL LDO RE LQkQGXVHPRGHOXO \

¬

=D

+E [

W

+ ]

W

ÌQFD]XODFHVWXLPRGHOVHYHULILF GDF

VD HOLPLQDW VDX QX DXWRFRUHOD LD HURULORU ÌQ FD] FRQWUDU VH FRQWLQX SURFHGHXO SkQ FkQG VH DWLQJH DFHVWGH]LGHUDW H 3URFHGHXO'XUELQ \

Ö Ö - E[ - D

- U±

Ö ¯ ° \ ® ¯ - D Ö - E[ ® ¯ + ]

53

Ö Ö ² E² 6H FDOFXOHD] U ¥§¦§¨ VH LQWURGXFH vQ UHOD LD úL UH]XOW HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU D

$FHDVW PHWRG G UH]XOWDWHEXQHQXPDLvQFD]XOH[LVWHQ HLXQHLDXWRFRUHOD LLGHRUGLQXOvQWkLúLHVWH DSOLFDELO vQFD]XOvQVHOXFUHD] FXXQQXP UPDUHGHGDWH I 8QHRUL HOLPLQDUHD DXWRFRUHOD LHL VH SRDWH UHDOL]D úL SULQ FRQVWUXLUHD PRGHOXOXL SH ED]D GLIHUHQ HORUGHRUGLQXOvQWkLDOHYDULDELOHORU \

W

- \

W -

= D + E [

-[

W

W -

+]

W

Ü \

W

= D + E[

W

+]

W

J 3HQWUX HOLPLQDUHD DXWRFRUHOD LHL VH SRDWH FRQVWUXL XQ PRGHO QRX vQ FDUH VH LQWURGXFH R YDULDELO ILFWLY VXSOLPHQWDU $FHDVW PHWRG SRUQHúWH GH OD LGHHD F YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO X QX HVWH LQIOXHQ DW QXPDL GH IDFWRUL DOHDWRUL FL H[LVW FHO SX LQ XQ IDFWRU VLVWHPDWLF FDUH SURYRDF DXWRFRUHOD LD ,³ /HJHD GH SUREDELOLWDWH D YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH X HVWH OHJHD QRUPDO DEDWHUHPHGLHS

WUDWLF

GH PHGLH QXO

úL

s´ X N(0,s´ )

6H úWLH F GDF HURULOH XUPHD] OHJHD QRUPDO GH PHGLH ]HUR úL GH DEDWHUH PHGLH S WUDWLF V µ ¶ FRQVHFLQ DLSRWH]HORU, · ,¸ ,¹ DWXQFLDUHORFUHOD LD

Ö 3 (X

W

ÊW

a

V

Ö X

)=-a

3HED]DDFHVWHLUHOD LLvQIXQF LHGHGLIHULWHSUDJXULGHVHPQLILFD LH a GLQWDEHODGLVWULEX LHL QRUPDOHVDXDGLVWULEX LHL6WXGHQWVHYRUSUHOXDYDORULOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHOXL W º

9HULILFDUHD LSRWH]HL GH QRUPDOLWDWH VH SRDWH IDFH SH ED]D XQXL JUDILF vQ FDGUXO F UXLD SH D[D Ö 2[ VH YRU UHSUH]HQWD YDORULOH DMXVWDWH DOH YDULDELOHL \ \ YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH X W

a

¢V

Ö X

W

» LDU SH D[D 2\ VH YRU WUHFH YDORULOH

'DF YDORULOH HPSLULFH DOH YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH VH vQVFULX vQ EDQGD

FX XQ DQXPLW SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a LSRWH]D GH QRUPDOLWDWH D YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH SRDWH

ILDFFHSWDW FXDFHVWSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH±YH]LILJXUD

X

+ WÂ

¢ VÀÁ

Ö \

- WÂ

¢ VÀÁ

)LJXUD

9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLHVWLPDWRULORUSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULF

'DF FHOH SDWUX LSRWH]H SRW IL DFFHSWDWH VH SRDWH GHPRQVWUD YH]L 7HRUHPD F 0&003 HVWH HFKLYDOHQW FX 090 PHWRGD YHURVLPLOLW

LL PD[LPH úL GHFL HVWLPDWRULL

RE LQX LvQDFHVWFD]VXQWQHGHSODVD LFRQYHUJHQ LúLHILFLHQ L Ö Ö úLE 'H DVHPHQHD YH]L 7HRUHPD úL FHL GRL HVWLPDWRUL D VXQW YDULDELOH DOHDWRDUH

UHSDUWL]DWHQRUPDO Ö Ö = 1 D V ¼ ½ / E = 1 E V¾¿ / D

XQGH

54

»

=

V ÅÆ

V

Ö E

Ç ª ª

VÄ

V

=

+

Q

ª ½

Ç ([ W

[ Ç ([

Ã

± ²

Ç - [

Ã

X

)

- [

Ö DEDWHUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF DHVWLPDWRUXOXL D

²

Ç

² Õ

Ö DEDWHUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF DHVWLPDWRUXOXL E

)

W

Ê VÉ

=

Q -

Ö È X Ç

È

Ê

È \ Ç =

È

Ö - \

È

Ê

Q -

GLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHYH]LWHRUHPD

9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLHVWLPDWRULORUFRQVW vQDDFFHSWDVDXDUHVSLQJHXQDGLQFHOHGRX LSRWH]H +

+

ÅD = ®E = ÅD ¹ ®E ¹

Ö Ö úL E 7HVWXO DGHFYDW DFHVWXL VFRS D ILLQG YDULDELOH QRUPDOH HVWH WHVWXO ³W´ 3ULQ FHQWUDUHD úL Ö Ö úL E Ö QRUPDUHD HVWLPD LLORU D vQ FD]XO LSRWH]HL + Ë / D

YDORULOH FDOFXODWH W Ò

Õ ÐÔÓ

=

Ö - D

ÐÑ

V

Ü

úL W ØÚÙÔÛ

=

Ö E -

V

Ö×

Ö 1 V Ì Í úL / E

1 V Î Ï VH RE LQ

$FHVWH YDORUL FDOFXODWH VDX HPSLULFH VH FRPSDU FX

YDORDUHDWHRUHWLF W

YDULDELO QRUPDO GDF W = Q Q! SUHOXDW GLQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL QRUPDOH vQ

IXQF LHGHRYDORDUHDUELWUDUDOHDV DSUREDELOLW DFHVWHYDORULGHUHJXO ILLQGS W

!

LL³S´VDXDSUDJXOXLGHVHPQLILFD LHÄ

S

!

S

!

´S

YDULDELO 6WXGHQW GDF W = Q QÊ SUHOXDW GLQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL 6WXGHQW vQ

Ý ÞÔß à ávâäã§å

IXQF LH GH YDORDUHD VWDELOLW SHQWUX

úL GH QXP UXO JUDGHORU GH OLEHUWDWH QN Q

QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU H[RJHQH [æ M = N N

REVHUYD LLORU N

QXP UXO

QXP UXO SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL

HFRQRPHWULF 3HED]DFHORUGRX YDORULWçÚèÔé úLW

õ W ðÚñÔò GDF

]HURVHUHQXQ

=

ô W ðÚñÔò =

V ñï Ö E Vîï

ÊW

ó íì

´ ¿ ¿

µ ÊW

ó íì

ô W ðÚñÔò =

Ö D V ñï Ö E Vîï

>W

ó íì

!VHUHYLQHODSULPDHWDS FXRQRX VSHFLILFDUH

´ ¿ ¿

ó íì

! HVWLPDWRULL QX VXQW VHPQLILFDWLY GLIHUL L GH

¿ Ý

µ >W

! VH DFFHSW + Ë

¿

ODHLúLODPRGHO

õ W ðÚñÔò = GDF

Ö D

ê ë UHJXODGHGHFL]LHDWHVWXOXLHVWH

! VH DFFHSW + ã

! PRGHOXO D IRVW FRUHFW VSHFLILFDW LGHQWLILFDW úL

¿

¿ Ý

HVWLPDWúLVHFRQWLQX GLVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF

55

õ

GDF

Ö D

=

W ðÚñÔò

ÊW

V ñï

¿ ¿

!VHUH LQHPRGHOXO\

µ

Ö E

ô W ðÚñÔò =

´

ó íì

>W

Vîï

I[ X

E[XúLVHFRQWLQX GLVFX LD

¿

ó íì

¿ Ý

HFRQRPHWULF ÌQSUDFWLF GHRDUHFHW Ëvö

Ëø÷ HFRQRPLúWLLDFFHSW LSRWH]D+ ã HVWLPDWRULLVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYL

GDF

ú

=

W ýÚþÔÿ

ù W ýÚþÔÿ =

Ö D

Ë

V þü

Ö E

Ë

Vûü

Ö Ö úLE ÌQ DFHODúL WLPS úWLLQG F D VXQW UHSDUWL]D L QRUPDO VH SRDWH HVWLPD LQWHUYDOXO GH

vQFUHGHUHDOSDUDPHWULORUDFHVWRUD Ö -W 3 (D

(

Ö 3 E -W

¢V

Ö ÊE ÊE +W

¢ Vîï

ó íì

Ö +W ÊD ÊD

ó íì

)=

¢V

S =-a

)=

¢Vîï

S =-a

3DUDPHWULLDúLEYRUILFRQVLGHUD LVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHUL LGH]HURGDF

(

Ö W 3 D = D

(

Ö 3 E = E W

¢V

¢V

)

> = S =-a

)

> = S =-a

9HULILFDUHDVLPLOLWXGLQLLPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULF

Ö 0RGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF \

Ö Ö +E =D [

HVWH H[SUHVLD IRUPDO D PRGHOXOXL HFRQRPLF UHDO \

D E[ X FRQFHSXW SH ED]D WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH úL UH]XOWDW SH ED]D XQXL VLQJXU

I[ X

H[SHULPHQWXQXLVLQJXUVRQGDMVWDWLVWLF &DDWDUHvQDFHDVW HWDS VHXUP UHúWHV VHYHULILFH

GDF LSRWH]D GH SRUQLUH ± [

SULQFLSDOXO IDFWRU GH LQIOXHQ

D IHQRPHQXOXL \ ± HVWH

FRUHFW VDXQX

GDF OHJLWDWHDHFRQRPLF GLQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOHHVWHGHIRUPD\

GDF UH]XOWDWHOH RE LQXWH SRW IL FRQVLGHUDWH VLVWHPDWLFH ± vQ VHQVXO F VH YRU RE LQH

DE[

DSURDSH DFHOHDúL UH]XOWDWH GDF VH YD UHSHWD H[SHULHQ D FX DOWH VRQGDMH GH YROXP úL VWUXFWXU DOWH XQLW

L VWDWLVWLFH GLIHULWH ± VDX vQWkPSO WRDUH DGLF UH]XOWDWH GLIHULWH

SHQWUXVRQGDMHGLIHULWH ÌQ JHQHUDO VFRSXULOH XUP ULWH vQ DFHDVW HWDS VH UH]ROY FX DMXWRUXO PHWRGHL DQDOL]HL YDULD LHLFXQRVFXW úLVXEQXPHOHGHPHWRGD$129$ 0HWRGDDQDOL]HLYDULD LHLSRUQHúWHGHODLGHQWLWDWHD \

- \ = \

Ç \

XQGH \

-\

Ö - \

Ö + \

[

Ö = Ç <

- \

- \ + \

(\

)

- \

Ö -<

]

=

(\

Ö - \

Ö + \

- \

)

YDORULOHUHDOHDOHIHQRPHQXOXL\

5HOD LD U PkQH YDODELO vQ WRDWH FD]XULOH GH PRGHOH OLQLDUH VDX OLQLDUL]DELOH ÌQ FD]XO DFHVWRUD GLQ XUP VH YD

LQHFRQWGHVHPQLILFD LDVLPEROXULORU'HH[HPSOX

PRGHOXO SXWHUH \ UHOD LD YRUIL\

D [

OQ\

Ö \

X

! OQ \

OQ

Ö \

\

OQ D E OQ [ OQ X

=

Q

Ç OQ \

!

=

Q

'HFL vQ DFHVW FD] VHPQLILFD LLOH VLPEROXULORU GLQ

Ö Ç OQ \

!

X

OQ\ OQ

Ö \

56

YDORULOHWHRUHWLFHDOHIHQRPHQXOXL\

Ö \

Ö \

Ö Ö +E =D [

\ =

"

Ç\

Q

=

Q

"

Ö Ç\

(

=

Ö Ö +E [ Ç D

Q

"

Ö Ö +E )= D [

3ULQULGLFDUHDODS WUDWDELQRPXOXLGLQSDUWHDGUHDSW DUHOD LHL UH]XOW

$

%# & % (

Ç \

- \

$

'

%# & %

Ö == Ç< - \

'

$

%# & %

%

Ö + Ç \ - <

'

$

%# & %

%

%

Ö Ö + Ç< - \ \ - <

7HUPHQLLUHOD LHL VHGHILQHVFSULQ

,

*(

3

1

9

-+ ) / Ç 0. 2( 0

= Ç(\ - \)

9

=

YDULD LDWRWDO DYDULDELOHL\SURYRFDW GHWR LIDFWRULLV LGHLQIOXHQ

3

Ö \ - \)

YDULD LD IHQRPHQXOXL \ SURYRFDW QXPDL GH YDULD LD IDFWRUXOXL [

FRQVLGHUDWIDFWRUXOSULQFLSDODOYDULDELOHL\DGLF YDULD LDOXL\H[SOLFDW GHPRGHOXOHFRQRPHWULF

4

9

/

3

0. 2 0

= Ç(\ - Ö \

3

0)

YDULD LD UH]LGXDO VDX YDULD LD IHQRPHQXOXL \ JHQHUDW GH F WUH IDFWRULL

QHVSHFLILFD L vQ PRGHO DFHúWL IDFWRUL ILLQG FRQVLGHUD L ± vQ HWDSD GH VSHFLILFDUH ± GUHSW IDFWRUL FX LQIOXHQ

8

76 5

Ö Ç \

vQWkPSO WRDUHQHHVHQ LDOLSHQWUXDH[SOLFDYDULD LDIHQRPHQXOXL\

7

- \ \

7

Ö - \

9 9

7

Ö Ö +E = Ç D [

9

FRY[ X

7

Ö Ö -E Ö -D [ X

9

7

7

Ö = E Ç [

- [ X

7

Q

Ö = Q E FRY X

Q

7 7

=

[

DGLF [ úLX VXQWYDULDELOHLQGHSHQGHQWH$FHDVW FRQGL LHVHUHDOL]HD] GDF

:

HURULOHVXQWKRPRVFHGDVWLFHYH]LLSRWH]D, 'HUHJXO UH]XOWDWHOHDSOLF ULLPHWRGHL$129$VHSUH]LQW vQWUXQWDEHOGHIRUPD 7DEHOXO 6XUVDGH

0 VXUD

1XP UXO

'LVSHUVLL

9DORDUHDWHVWXOXL

YDULD LH

YDULD LHL

JUDGHORU

FRUHFWDWH

Ä)´

;

GH

9DULDQ D

1

9

H[SOLFDW GHPRGHO 9DULDQ D

4

9

UH]LGXDO 9DULDQ D

9

WRWDO

/

3 3

OLEHUWDWH

3

0. 2 0

= Ç (Ö \ - \)

/

0. 2 0 3 / Ç 0. 2( 0

= Ç(\ - Ö \

=

)

N =

3

0) 3

V

\ - \)

Q - N -

V

Q

OP

G FED =

=

D

9

9

Q

O

N

G

N

Q - N -

=

)

V

H

M LH K IJ V

>@?=<=AC? < B

)

Q -

3HED]DGDWHORUGLQWDEHOVHSRWWHVWDXUP WRDUHOHLSRWH]H +

S

R W VU X ] \[

V

= V

TR

! FHOH GRX GLVSHUVLL VXQW DSUR[LPDWLY HJDOH DGLF LQIOXHQ D IDFWRUXOXL [

QXGLIHU GHLQIOXHQ DIDFWRULORUvQWkPSO WRUL +

Y

V

¹ V

ZX

! LQIOXHQ D IDFWRUXOXL [ úL D IDFWRULORU vQWkPSO WRUL ± P VXUDW SULQ FHOH

GRX GLVSHUVLL ± GLIHU VHPQLILFDWLY úL GHFL VH SRDWH WUHFH OD GLVFX LD VLPLOLWXGLQLL D YHURVLPLOLW

LL

PRGHOXOXLWHRUHWLFvQUDSRUWFXPRGHOXOUHDO 'XS FXP VH úWLH WHVWDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL GLQWUH GRX GLVSHUVLL VH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO GLVWULEX LHL WHRUHWLFH)LVKHU6QHGHFRUUHVSHFWLYFXWHVWXOÄ)´&XQRVFkQGFHOHGRX YDORUL

f

^

PRGHOXO H[SRQHQ LDO \ WHUPHQLORU

H

_a`cb d ^

^

X

^

!OQ\

^

DE[ OQX

^

! \

^

e

^

OQ\

Ö \

g

OQ

Ö \

h

\

PHGLDJHRPHWULF D

57

)

FDO

V

=

\ [

V

=

9

[

N

X

9

X

Q - N -

YDORDUHD FDOFXODW D YDULDELOHL Ä)´ SH ED]D UH]XOWDWHORU

PRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULF )

i jckai jml

YDORDUHDWHRUHWLF DYDULDELOHLÄ)´SUHOXDW GLQWDEHODUHSDUWL LHL)LVKHU±6QHGHFRU

vQIXQF LHGHXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH

k

l

OLEHUWDWHY

NY

VDX

VDX

úLGHQXP UXOJUDGHORUGH

QN

5HJXODGHGHFL]LHHVWHXUP WRDUHD

n rp qts o prqts

o

VHDFFHSW + úLVHUHVSLQJH+ GDF )

i jckai jml

Ê )

n

VHDFFHSW + úLVHUHVSLQJH+ GDF

)

i jckai jml

> )

o

'DF VHDFFHSW + úLGDF YDULDELODXHVWHLQGHSHQGHQW GHIHQRPHQXO[FRY[X

u

u

HFXD LDDQDOL]HLYDULD LHLHVWH

9

v

=9

x

+9

zy

HFXD LHFDUHSULQvPS U LUHDOD 9

=

7HUPHQXO

5

9 9

~

{

|{

=

+

9 9

9 9

w

u

VHWUDQVIRUP vQ

{

}{ |

DWXQFL

Ü =

9

VH

9

~

{

|{

QXPHúWH

¢ +

9 9

¢

{

}{ |

FRHILFLHQW

GH

GHWHUPLQDUH

úL

DUH

XUP WRDUHOH

VHPQLILFD LL

Å Ü \ ¹ I [ + X Ü [ QX HVWH IDFWRU FDX]D DO IHQRPHQXOX L \

5

¿

}Ü \ = I [ + X Ü[ HVWH IDFWRU DO YDULDELOHL \GDU QX HVWH IDFWRU HVHQWLDO ¿ ¿ = ¿ ¿

}Ü

\ = I [ + X Ü[ HVWH XQ IDFWRU HVHQWLDO DO IHQRPHQXOX L \

¿ Ü \ = I [ Ü[ HVWH VLQJXUXO IDFWRU GH LQIOXHQWD DIHQRPHQXOX L \ ® 3H ED]D DILUPD LLORU GH PDL VXV VH GHGXFH XúRU F XQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF HVWH FX DWkW PDL SHUIRUPDQW FX FkW YDORDUHD OXL 5

VH DSURSLH PDL PXOW GH XQX UHVSHFWLY FX FkW VH DSURSLH PDL

PXOWGH

5

6WDWLVWLFLQWHQVLWDWHDOHJ WXULLGLQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOHVHP VRDU FXDMXWRUXOLQGLFDWRUXOXL GHQXPLWUDSRUWGHFRUHOD LH

5

=

5

=

9 9

=

-

9 9

Å Ü [ úL \ VXQW LQGHSHQGHQ WH ¿

5

}ÜFRUHODWLHVODE ¿ ¿ = ¿ ¿

}ÜFRUHODWLH SXWHUQLF

¿ ÜFRUHODWLHGHWHUPLQLVW ®

\ HVWH FRUHODW VWULFW FX [

ÌQFD]XOXQHLOHJ WXULOLQLDUHvQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOH±\ OQ X OQ \

GHPRQVWUDF UDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LH 5

DE[XOQ\

OQDEOQ[

D E[ OQ X HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU ILLQG RE LQX L FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 VH SRDWH

HVWHHJDOFXFRHILFLHQWXOGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU U

58

5

= U

U

FRY \ [

=

s

Ç \

=

s

- \ [ Qs

s

- [

Ö = E

s s

'H DVHPHQHD WHVWDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VH SRDWH IDFH WRW FX WHVWXO Ä)´ GDU SRUQLQG GH OD YDORDUHD UDSRUWXOXL GH FRUHOD LH 5 5

rt

V

=

)

=

V

9

$VWIHO

ªr«t¬

Q - N -

=

GDF )

N

¢

HFRQRPHWULFRE LQXW GDF

)

»r¼t½

=

Q - N - N

5

N

- 5

¢

±

5

- 5

9

Q - N -

Ê )

±

5

¾ ¹º ³ ¯ · À¿

=9

- 5

¨© ¢ ¦ ¨© ¡ § ¦

> )

HFRQRPHWULF DHFXD LHLDQDOL]HLYDULD LHL±9

=

¹º ² ¯ ¸ ® · ® ° ¿ Á¿ Â +9

VDX D FRHILFLHQWXOXL GH GHWHUPLQDUH

¢

Q - N -

Ü 5

N

¥ ¤£

Ü 5

¶ µ´

= Ü VH UHQXQ

OD PRGHOXO

¹ Ü VH WUHFH OD GLVFX LD

±YH]LUHOD LD

8WLOL]DUHDPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULFXQLIDFWRULDO ÌQ SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF XQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VH XWLOL]HD] SHQWUX H[SOLFDUHD YDULD LHL IHQRPHQXOXL UH]XOWDWLY \ vQ UDSRUW GH YDULD LD IDFWRUXOXL V X [ SHQWUX HVWLPDUHD YDORULORU SUREDELOH DOH IHQRPHQXOXL \ VLPXODUHD DFHVWXLD vQ IXQF LH GH SRVLELOHOH YDORUL SH FDUH HFRQRPLF OH SRDWH vQUHJLVWUD IDFWRUXO [ úL vQ ILQDO SURJQR]D IHQRPHQXOXL \ vQ IXQF LH GH YDORULOH IHQRPHQXOXL [ SH LQWHUYDOXOGHSURJQR] YY

K

3HQWUX D SHUPLWH FD XWLOL]DWRULL V YHULILFH SURSULHW

LOH SHUIRUPDQ HOH XQXL PRGHO

HFRQRPHWULFRE LQXWDFHVWDWUHEXLHSUH]HQWDWFXXUP WRDUHOHLQIRUPD LL

Ö \

Ã

Ö Ö +E =D [

V

ÄÅ

V

Ã

ÆÇ

5

G

V

ÈÉ

'LVSXQkQGGHDFHVWHLQIRUPD LLVHSRDWHWHVWD

LQGHSHQGHQ DHURULORUÓWHVWXOÄG´±'XUELQ±:DWVRQ

VHPQLILFD LDHVWLPDWRULORUÓWHVWXOÄW´

VLPLOLWXGLQHDPRGHOXOXLÓWHVWXOÄ)´

ÌQ DQXPLWH FD]XUL FkQG VDX HVWLPDW GRX PRGHOH SHQWUX VSD LL GLIHULWH GRX MXGH H VDX GRX SLH H GLIHULWH VDX SHQWUX SHULRDGH GH WLPS GLIHULWH DOH DFHORUDúL GRX IHQRPHQH \ úL [ GH H[HPSOX VWDELOLW

0

Ê

\ = D

Ê

+ E [ úL

LLUHODWLYHDOHJLW +

+

Î

Ð

E

Í

E

Ð

=E

¹E

$VWIHO

Ê

GDF W

Ì

Ï

ÓrÔtÕ

Ë

0

\

= D

Ë

+E

Ë

[ VH SRDWH WHVWD LSRWH]D RPRJHQLW

LL VDX

LLGLQWUHFHOHGRX IHQRPHQH

Ü FHOH GRX PRGHOH VXQW UHODWLY RPRJHQH VDX OHJ WXUD HVWH UHODWLY VWDELO vQ WLPS

Ü FHOHGRX PRGHOHQXVXQWRPRJHQHOHJ WXUDQXHVWHUHODWLYVWDELO

=

E V

×

Ö

ÒÙ

-E

Ö

+ V

Ö ÒØ

ÊW

Ñ

Ú

Ü VHDFFHSW +

59

GDF W

ÓrÔtÕ

×

Ö ÒÙ

E

=

V

-E

Ö

Ö ÒØ

+ V

Ú

>W

Û

Ñ

Ü VHDFFHSW +

'H UH LQXW F LSRWH]D + HVWH IRORVLW vQ VSHFLDO vQ GRPHQLXO SURJQR]HL GHRDUHFH DFFHSWDUHD HL SUHVXSXQH H[LVWHQ D XQHL OHJ WXUL UHODWLY VWDELOH vQ WLPS SUHPLV FH MXVWLILF SUHYL]LXQHD IHQRPHQXOXL\SHED]DYDORULORUYLLWRDUHDOHIHQRPHQXOXL[ÌQDFHODúLWLPSvQWRDWHFHOHWUHLGLUHF LL vQ FDUH SRDWH IL IRORVLW XQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF YDORULOH IHQRPHQXOXL SRW IL HVWLPDWH ILH SH ED]D

Ö HVWLPD LHLSXQFWXDOH \

Ã

Ã

Ö Ö +E =D [

(

Ö 3 \

à

Ü

-W

ILHSHED]DXQXLLQWHUYDOGHvQFUHGHUH

¢V

Þß Ý

Ê \

à

à

Ö Ê \

+W

Ü

¢V

Þß Ý

)=

S =-a

'H UHJXO SURJQR]D IHQRPHQXOXL \ GDF VH FXQRVF YDORULOH YDULDELOHL IDFWRULDOH [ SHQWUX PRPHQWXO QY VH UHDOL]HD] SH ED]D XQXL LQWHUYDO GH vQFUHGHUH GHRDUHFH \ HVWH R YDULDELO Ö DOHDWRDUH QRUPDO GH PHGLH \ 0&003

(

Ö 3 \

óíò

âãá

-W

ë

¢V

XQGH \

ôöõø÷ ü ùûú

Ö - \

Ê \

óíò

Ö Ê \

ó íò

+W

ë

¢V

)=

ðñ ï ìî

é

ê

úL , DOH

S =-a

= HVWLPD LDSXQFWXDO DYDORULLGHSURJQR] SHQWUXYDULDELOD\FDUHVHFDOFXOHD] FX

Ö \

ðñ ï ìî

YH]L LSRWH]HOH ,

YDORDUHDUHDO DYDULDELOHL\vQPRPHQWXOGHSURJQR] Q + Y

DMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

V

æç å è ä

úL GH DEDWHUH PHGLH S WUDWLF V

þ ÿý

Ö Ö +E =D [

þÿý

DEDWHUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF DHURULLGHSUHYL]LXQHFDOFXODW FXUHOD LD

V

=

V

=

» ª

¢ª +

V

ª ª ½

Q

+

([

Ç

([

- [

)

- [

)

± ²

² ² ² Õ

'LQ UHOD LD GH PDL VXV UH]XOW F HURDUHD GH SUHYL]LXQH V

HVWH FX DWkW PDL PLF FX FkW

QXP UXO GH REVHUYD LL YD IL PDL PDUH FX FkW YDORULOH YDULDELOHORU vQ PRPHQWXO GH SURJQR] QY YRU IL PDL DSURSLDWH GH PHGLD ORU FX FkW GLVSHUVLD YDULDELOHL H[RJHQH [ YD IL PDL PDUH úL FX FkW GLVSHUVLD YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH V

HVWH PDL PLF LDU DFHDVWD YD IL FX DWkW PDL PLF FX FkW PRGHOXO

Ö VDX FX FkW HFRQRPHWULF YD H[SOLFD R SDUWH WRW PDL PDUH GLQ YDULD LD YDULDELOHL SURJQR]DWH \

UDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LH 5

\

[

YDDYHDRYDORDUHPDLDSURSLDW GHXQX

Ö $SUHFLHUHD SURJQR]HL XQXL IHQRPHQ \ SH ED]D XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF \

Ö Ö +E =D [ VH

SRDWHIDFHFXDMXWRUXODGRX QR LXQLVLJXUDQ DSURJQR]HLúLSUHFL]LDSURJQR]HLQR LXQLFDUHVHDIO vQUHOD LHLQYHUVSURSRU LRQDO 6LJXUDQ D SURJQR]HL HVWH GDW GH SUREDELOLWDWHD S FX FDUH HVWH HVWLPDW LQWHUYDOXO GH vQFUHGHUHLDUSUHFL]LDSURJQR]HLGHUHOD LD = \

HURDUHDDEVROXW H

HURDUHDUHODWLY H ( =

Ö - \ H'

Ö $ ! # \

= W

¢ =

W+

¢ V ¢ V% & * " ) Ö $ ! # \

¢

'DUGDF SÓUH]XOW F VLJXUDQ DSURJQR]HLFUHúWHLDUGDF WÓ

UH]XOW F HURDUHDFUHúWH

LDUSUHFL]LDVHGLPLQXHD] 'LQDFHVWPRWLYHVWLPDUHDYDORULORUSUREDELOHDOHIHQRPHQXOXL\VHIDFH SH ED]D XQRU YDORUL SUHVWDELOLWH SULYLQG VLJXUDQ D úL SUHFL]LD SURJQR]HL 'H H[HPSOX VH SRDWH SUHFL]D F SURJQR]HOHYRUWUHEXLDFFHSWDWHFXRSUREDELOLWDWHGDW S

!

LDUHURDUHD

GHSURJQR] ±SHXQDQXPLWRUL]RQWDOSURJQR]HL±WUHEXLHV ILH

60

H 0 =

W5

¢ V. / 2 4 Ö - 3 , \

1

¢ Ê ( (

([HPSOXGHDSOLFDUHDPRGHOXOXLXQLIDFWRULDO 6H FXQRVF XUP WRDUHOH GDWH SULYLQG 3,%XO UHDOORFXLWRU úL VDODULXO PHGLX UHDO vQ SHULRDGD vQUHJLVWUDWH vQ FD]XO 5RPkQLHL FHL GRL LQGLFDWRUL VXQW H[SULPD L vQ SUH XULOH DQXOXL 7DEHOXO $QXO

3,%UHDOORFXLWRU

6DODULXOUHDOORFXLWRU

PLLOHL

OHL

6XUVDGHGDWH$QXDUXO6WDWLVWLFDO%15

6HFHUH D 6SHFLILFDUHD LGHQWLILFDUHD úL HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL HFRQRPHWULF FH GHVFULH

OHJ WXUDGLQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOH

E 9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLSDUDPHWULORUúLDYHURVLPLOLW

F ÌQ FD]XO XQXL QLYHO DO 3,%XOXL UHDOORFXLWRU GH PLL OHLSHUVRDQ V VH HVWLPH]H

LLPRGHOXOXL

VDODULXOPHGLXUHDOORFXLWRU

5H]ROYDUH

D 3HED]DGDWHORUSUREOHPHLVHSRDWHFRQVWUXLXQPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFXQLIDFWRULDOGHIRUPD

XQGH

\YDORULOHUHDOHDOHYDULDELOHORUGHSHQGHQWH

[YDORULOHUHDOHDOHYDULDELOHORULQGHSHQGHQWH

X YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO UHSUH]HQWkQG LQIOXHQ HOH FHORUODO L IDFWRUL DL YDULDELOHL \

\

= I [ + X

QHVSHFLILFD L vQ PRGHO FRQVLGHUD L IDFWRUL vQWkPSO WRUL FX LQIOXHQ H QHVHPQLILFDWLYH DVXSUD YDULDELOHL\

$QDOL]D GDWHORU GLQ WDEHO vQ UDSRUW FX SURFHVXO HFRQRPLF GHVFULV FRQGXFH OD XUP WRDUHD

VSHFLILFDUHDYDULDELOHORU

\VDODULXOUHDOORFXLWRUUHSUH]HQWkQGYDULDELODUH]XOWDWLY

[ 3,%XO UHDOORFXLWRU IDFWRUXO FRQVLGHUDW SULQ LSRWH]D GH OXFUX FX LQIOXHQ D FHD PDL

SXWHUQLF DVXSUDYDULDELOHL\

61

6SHFLILFDUHD XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF SUHVXSXQH GH DVHPHQHD DOHJHUHD XQHL IXQF LL

PDWHPDWLFH

(

( [ ))

I

FX DMXWRUXO F UHLD SRDWH IL GHVFULV OHJ WXUD GLQWUH FHOH GRX YDULDELOH ÌQ FD]XO

XQXLPRGHOXQLIDFWRULDOSURFHGHXOFHOPDLGHVIRORVLWvOFRQVWLWXLHUHSUH]HQWDUHDJUDILF DFHORUGRX úLUXULGHYDORULFXDMXWRUXOFRUHORJUDPHL

6DODULXOPHGLXUHDOORF

3,%ORFXLWRU

)LJXUD'LQDPLFDVDODULXOXLPHGLXUHDOORFvQIXQF LHGH3,%XOUHDOORFXLWRU

'LQ JUDILF VH SRDWH REVHUYD F GLVWULEX LD SXQFWHORU HPSLULFH SRDWH IL DSUR[LPDW FX R GUHDSW &D DWDUH PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF FDUH GHVFULH OHJ WXUD GLQWUH FHOH GRX YDULDELOH VH WUDQVIRUP vQWUXQ PRGHO OLQLDU XQLIDFWRULDO

\ 6

= D + E[ 6

+ X W = D úL E UHSUH]HQWkQG

SDUDPHWULLPRGHOXOXL E Ë SDQWDGUHSWHLILLQGSR]LWLY GHRDUHFHOHJ WXUDGLQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOH HVWHOLQLDU úLGLUHFW

8UP WRDUHD RSHUD LH FRQVW vQ HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL D úL E FX DMXWRUXO

$

HVWLPDWRULORU D úL E ÌQDFHVWVFRSVHYDXWLOL]DPHWRGDFHORUPDLPLFLS WUDWH0&003

$

(

Ö Ö E ) D

)

8:9

= PLQ Ç (\ < < 7 8

)

Ö < - \

8:9

;

(

= PLQ Ç \ < < 7 8

Ö < Ö -E -D [

) ;

&RQGL LDGHPLQLPDDFHVWHLIXQF LLUH]XOW GLQ Ö Ö ) = Ü QD Ö +E ) ë(D Ç [=

Ö Ç [= ( )= Ü D

Ö )ëE

= Ç \=

Ö +EÇ [=

>

= Ç \ = [=

Ö Å Ö + E D = ¿ Ü Ö ¿ D Ö + E = ® YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOH

62

7DEHOXO

@

$QXO

1U

[?

\?

[? \?

Ö A \

[?

FUW

ÖD X

C

([ F

-[

E

)

B

7RWDO

Ö X

7DEHOXOFRQWLQXDUH

(\ H

- \

)

G

ÖK J X I

ÖO (X

ÖO N M -X

)

L

ÖO X ÖO Q X P

U \T

= \T

-

- \ T S R

Y

[X

= [X

-

- [ X W

V

([ Z )

[]\

`a`

[ ^_ \^

63

7DEHOXOFRQWLQXDUH

b Ö c \

= \ D

Ö D ]

d

Ö D - \

d

(

[e

f

- [

f

)

g

(

\e

f

- \

f

)

g

Ö j i ]

h

Ö (]

n

Ö n m l - ]

)

k

Ö p ]

o

ÌQXUPDUH]ROY ULLVLVWHPXOXLGHHFXD LLVHRE LQFHLGRLHVWLPDWRUL Ö = - D Ö E =

3HED]DHVWLPDWRULORUVHYRUFDOFXODYDORULOHHVWLPDWHDOHYDULDELOHL\

= - + [ q

Ö q \

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

E ÌQYHGHUHDYHULILF ULLVHPQLILFD LHLSDUDPHWULORUúLDPRGHOXOXLVHYRUFDOFXOD

YDORULOHYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH

DEDWHUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF DYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH V s t

= \ r

Ör X

Ö r YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD - \

Ç (\ v

)

Ö v - \

u

Vwx

=

Vyz

=

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

DEDWHULOHPHGLLS WUDWLFHDOHFHORUGRLHVWLPDWRUL

V ~

=

V}~

Ã ¬

+

Q

V

=

V

Ç ( [ - [ )

-

á

[ Ç ([ |

=

XQGHNQXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

{

{ « Ã

Q - N -

- [

)

{

³ = ³ ã

=

=

á « + = Ã ³ ã ¬

=

=

=

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOH

64

UDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LH

5 =

9 9

Ç (\

=

-

9

=

9

-

Ç (\

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOH

YDULDELOD'XUELQ:DWVRQG

Ö Ç (X

G =

Ö -X

Ö ÇX

)

)

- \

)

Ö - \

=

-

=

=

=

=

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOH

$VWIHOPRGHOXOHVWLPDWGHYLQH

Ö \

= - + [

5 =

G =

V

=

9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLPRGHOXOXLQHFHVLW

YHULILFDUHDLSRWH]HLGHLQGHSHQGHQ

DHURULORU

YHULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLHVWLPDWRULORU

YHULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLUDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LH

9HULILFDUHD LSRWH]HL GH LQGHSHQGHQ

D HURULORU FDUH SUHVXSXQH

FRY( X X

)

= VH

UHDOL]HD] FX DMXWRUXO WHVWXOXL'XUELQ:DWVRQFRQVWkQGvQFDOFXODUHDYDULDELOHL G úLFRPSDUDUHDVD FX GRX YDORUL WHRUHWLFH G úL G

(G

= ) SUHOXDWH GLQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL 'XUELQ

= G

:DWVRQ vQ IXQF LH GH XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a (a = ) GH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU H[SOLFDWLYH N

(N

= ) úLGHQXP UXOREVHUYD LLORU Q ( Q Ë )

'HRDUHFH YDORDUHD FDOFXODW HVWH FXSULQV vQ LQWHUYDOXO G

G

UHJXOD GH

GHFL]LHLQGLF DXWRFRUHOD LHSR]LWLY FDUHWUHEXLHHOLPLQDW

'LQ DFHVW PRWLY QX PDL DUH VHQV WHVWDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL HVWLPDWRULORU úL D UDSRUWXOXL GH

FRUHOD LH HVWLPDWRULL QHPDLILLQG HILFLHQ L GHFL VH LPSXQH PDL vQWkL HOLPLQDUHD IHQRPHQXOXL GH DXWRFRUHOD LHDHURULORU

(OLPLQDUHD IHQRPHQXOXL GH DXWRFRUHODUH D HURULORU SUHVXSXQH HIHFWXDUHD XUP WRDUHORU

RSHUD LL

HURULOHILLQGFRUHODWHDGLF X

= U

( )

()

+ ]

X

VHYDHVWLPDYDORDUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHGHRUGLQXO

£

£

Ö¤ X Ö¤ ÇX

¤ ¥ ¢ £ U( ) =

Ö¤ ÇX

úWLLQGF

=

¤ ¥ ¢

¡ Ö¤ ÇX

¦

¢

=

=

¤ ¥

¦

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOH

\§

¦

¢

¤ ¥ ¢

Ö¤ X Ö¤ ÇX

= D + E[ §

\¨ © ª

+ X§

= D + E[ ¨ © ª

Ü X§

+ X¨ © ª

= \§

- D - E[ §

Ü X¨ © ª

= \¨ © ª

- D - E[ ¨ © ª

H[SUHVLLOHRE LQXWHSHQWUX X « úL X ¬ ¯® YRUILvQORFXLWHvQUHOD LD úLVHRE LQH

\°

- D - E[ °

\³

- U µ

( )

\³ ´ µ

= U ²

( )

(

(\°

± ²

= D - U µ

( )

- D - E[ ° ± ²

) + E( [ ³

)

- U µ

+ ]°

( )

[³ ´ µ

) + ]³

65

·

= \¶

- U ¹

\¶ ¸ ¹

= [º

- U ½

[º ¼ ½

1RWkQGFX

\¶

[º

D½

= D - U ½

E¾

= E

VHRE LQH

»

( )

(

¿

( )

( )

= DÁ

\ À

)

+ EÁ [ À

¿

+ ] À

Ö À Ü \

¿

Ö + EÁ [ À

Ö Á =D

¿

$

ÌQYHGHUHDHVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORU D Â úL E Ã VHDSOLF 0&003

(

ÖÅ Ö Å E ) D

Ö Ì ) ë(D

)

(

É

Ä = PLQ Ç \ È È Ç

) = Ü (Q

Ö Ð ( )= Ü D

Ö ) ë EÐ

$

Å:Æ

ÅD Ö Ò ¿

Ö Ì - )D

Ç[Î

Í

Ö - EÅ [ È

Ö Å -D

Ö + EÌ Ç [ Ë

(

Ö + EÐ Ç [ Î

Ö + E Ñ

Ê Ï

)

Í

É

) Ç

= Ç\ Ë

Ê

= Ç\ Î

Í

Í [Î

=

Ü

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOH

Ö + E Ñ

Ö Ò ¿ D ®

=

Ó LQXW YDILGHIRUPD Ó )XQF LDGHUHJUHVLHRE = - + [ Ô

Ö Ô \

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

&DúLvQFD]XOPRGHOXOXLLQL LDOVHYRUFDOFXOD

YDORULOHYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH

Ö Ö ]

Õ

Ö Ö - \

Õ

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

DEDWHUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF DYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH

Ú

=

VØÙ

= \ Ö

=

sØ

(Q

Ç] ×

Ú

=

- ) -

=

=

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

DEDWHULOHPHGLLS WUDWLFHDOHFHORUGRLHVWLPDWRUL « V Þß ä

=

á VÝ

Ã Ã Ã

(Q

- )

+

=

Û à á V

Ç

([ å

- [

UDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LH

)

=

Ü

- [

Ü

á

)

³ = ³

«

Ã ¬

³ ã

+

á

á

³ = ã

=

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

5ë=

(

]

W =

âã

³

[

Ç [Û

Ã ¬

V Öæ E

á

Ü á

-

=

=

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

66

YDULDELOD'XUELQ:DWVRQ

çè

G ë =

Ö (]

Ç

ë ì ê

Ö ë - ]

ë çè

Ö ë Ç]

) ç

í

é =

é

=

ë ì é

3HED]DFDOFXOHORUGHPDLVXVUH]XOW PRGHOXO

Ö Ö \

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQDúL

Õ

= - + [ Ö

Õ

5 ë =

G ë =

Vî ï

8WLOL]kQG WHVWXO 'XUELQ:DWVRQ SHQWUX D YHULILFD GDF IHQRPHQXO GH DXWRFRUHOD LH D IRVW

=

HOLPLQDWSHQWUXXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH a = C N = Q = @ YDORULOHWHRUHWLFHDOHYDULDELOHL

VLWXHD]

DVWIHO

Gò

= ÌQ FRPSDUD LH FX DFHVWHD YDORDUHD HPSLULF G ë = VH

= G ð

'XUELQ:DWVRQ VXQW G ñ

= < G ë = < - G ò

=

FHHD

FH

LQGLF

LQGHSHQGHQ D

HURULORU

DXWRFRUHOD LDILLQGDVWIHOHOLPLQDW

(VWLPDWRULLPRGHOXOXLVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHUL LGH]HURGDF

W ó ÷ø û

=

W

=

W

=

W

=

Ë W

Vô ù û

ú(

ü ýÿ õ ýþ ö ý ü )

- Ö E V

ËW

=

( )

=

/XFUkQG FX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a (a = ) GLQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL 6WXGHQW VH SUHLD

YDORDUHD W

$

Dü

= &RPSDUkQG DFHDVW YDORDUHFXYDORULOHFDOFXODWHSHQWUXFHLGRLHVWLPDWRUL

VHFRQVWDW F

W "$# % W -/. 0

*

= < W

!

= Ü SDUDPHWUXO D & QXHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULWGH]HUR

= > W

( ( ) , + ''

= Ü SDUDPHWUXO E 1 HVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULWGH]HUR

$

$

9HULILFDUHD YHURVLPLOLW

LL PRGHOXOXL VH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO DQDOL]HL GLVSHUVLRQDOH DQDOL]D

YDULD LHL ±YH]L7DEHOXO 'LQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL )LVKHU6QHGHFNRU FX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH GH úL vQ IXQF LH GH = N = úL Y

QXP UXO JUDGHORU GH OLEHUWDWH Y 2 )

5 5 6 4 44 8 7 7

= 'HRDUHFH )>

= > )

3

= (Q - ) - N - = VH SUHLD YDORDUHD WHRUHWLF

: : ; = < 9 < 99

= UH]XOW IDSWXO F PRGHOXO OLQLDU HVWH

HVWLPDWFRUHVSXQ] WRU )?

5DSRUWXO GH FRUHOD LH HVWH VHPQLILFDWLY GLIHULW GH ]HUR GDF VH YHULILF LQHJDOLWDWHD

@A C @ F XQGHYDORDUHDHPSLULF DYDULDELOHL)LVKHU6QHGHFRUHVWH Ë )BDCA EG

)I

H

=

5

J

- 5

J

¢

(Q

- ) - N - N

=

-

6H FRQVWDW F )>

= > )

: : ; = < 9 < 99

¢ =

= GHFL SHQWUX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH GH

YDORDUHDUDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LHHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULW GH]HUR

67

7DEHOXO 6XUVDGH

0 VXUDYDULD LHL

YDULD LH 9DULDQ D H[SOLFDW GHPRGHO

'LVSHUVLLFRUHFWDWH

OLEHUWDWH

QSR

KL

K P T (

T 9 MON

1UJUDGHORUGH

Ö = Ç \

T

L

- \

)

=

N

Y

=

VX U W

=

9DULDQ D

9

UH]LGXDO

aSb

c f h

( g c e

i \ = dÇ

9DULDQ D

9

WRWDO

p

lnm

e

Ö - \

( s r

t \ =qÇ o

V

=

9

WHVWXOXL)

Y U

V N

=

^

)

=

c

g )

=

(Q

-) - N - =

=

=

o

U

9DORDUHD

o

) r

-\

=

j

=

9k

- ) - =

` ] _ \ [ _ ` VZ

=

=

j

(Q -) - N

-

=

(Q

Vk

=

V

=

Ö ÌQ FRQFOX]LH PRGHOXO \

v

u

= - + [

v

u

SRDWH IL DSUHFLDW FD UHSUH]HQWDWLY

SHQWUX GHVFULHUHD GHSHQGHQ HL GLQWUH VDODULXO PHGLX UHDOORFXLWRU úL 3,%XO UHDOORFXLWRU DFHVWD H[SOLFkQGGLQYDULD LDWRWDO DYDULDELOHLGHSHQGHQWHDGLF YDULD LDVDODULXOXLPHGLXUHDOORF VHGDWRUHD] vQSURSRU LHGH3,%XOUHDOORFXLWRU 9y

z

= 9w

z

+ 9x

z

Ü =

9w 9y

z z

+

9x 9y

z

z

úLFDDWDUHSRDWHILXWLOL]DWvQYHGHUHDGHWHUPLQ ULLSURJQR]HL

F ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH VDODULXOXL PHGLX UHDOORFXLWRU L VH DWULEXLH YDORDUHD [ {

PLL

OHLORFXLWRU3,%XOUHDOORFXLWRUYDILHJDOFX

Ö \

~$ /} ~

Ö Ö +E =D [

= - + ¢ = OHL

|

3H ED]D LSRWH]HL IRUPXODWH OD SXQFWHOH SUHFHGHQWH 3,%XO UHDOORFXLWRU \ XUPHD] R

Ö úLGHDEDWHUHPHGLHS WUDWLF GLVWULEX LHQRUPDO VDXGLVWULEX LD6WXGHQWGDF Q Ê GHPHGLH \

V

/ ( \

)=

1

Ö (\

V

)

V

=

¡

V

» ª ª

Ö \

PLLOHL

3HQWUX[ {

+

½

Q

+

([

(

Ç [

- [

- [

)

)

$ / ± ² ² Õ

=

= OHL

» ¢ ª + + ª ½

( - )

± ² = ² Õ

(VWLPDUHD 3,%XOXL UHDOORFXLWRU FDUH VH SRDWH RE LQH GDF VDODULXOXL PHGLX UHDOORFXLWRU LD

YDORDUHD[ {

PLLOHLORFXLWRUSHED]DXQXLLQWHUYDOGHvQFUHGHUHVHFDOFXOHD] FXUHOD LD

(

Ö 3 \

3HQWUX a

³ ¶ µ ¤ ª$« ´ ©/ª

-W

¢

V±

² ° ¬® ¯ £ §¨ ¥ ¦

Ê \

³ ¶ µ ¤ ª$« ´ ©/ª

Ö Ê \

³ ¶ µ ¤ ª$« ´ ©/ª

+W

¢

V±

¬ ¯ £ §¨ ¥ ¦ ² °®

= GLQWDEHODGLVWULEX LHL6WXGHQWVHSUHLDYDORDUHD W

)=

S =-a

¸ ¸ ¹ ·· » º

=

'HFL FX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH GH VDX FX RSUREDELOLWDWHHJDO FXYDORDUHD3,%

XOXLUHDOORFXLWRUYDILFXSULQV vQLQWHUYDOXO

(

3 \

3 \

(

¿ Â Á Ã $½ ¾ /¼ ½ À Ç Ê É Ë Å$Æ /Ä Å È

)

[ ¢ ] = - =

)

[ ] =

68

%,%/,2*5$),(

%DOWDJL%(FRQRPHWULFV6SULQJHU%HUOLQ *LUDXG5&KDL[1eFRQRPpWULH38)3DULV *UHHQH+:(FRQRPHWULF$QDO\VLV0DFPLOODQ3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\1HZ
ÌSÍ

HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
*XMDUDWL51(VVHQWLDOVRI(FRQRPHWULFV0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
ÌSÍ

HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
/DEURXVVH&,QWURGXFWLRQDO¶pFRQRPpWULH'XQRG3DULV 0DGGDOD*6,QWURGXFWLRQWR(FRQRPHWULFV

ÌSÍ

HG0F0LOODQ&R1HZ
3LQG\FN 5 6 5XELQIHOG ' 6 (FRQRPHWULF 0RGHOV DQG (FRQRPLF )RUHFDVWV

ÎÍ

HG 0F

*UDZ+LOO1HZ

69

&DSLWROXO,9 0RGHOXOPXOWLIDFWRULDO

6SHFLILFDUHDúLGHILQLUHDPRGHOXOXLPXOWLIDFWRULDO

6XEIRUP JHQHUDO XQPRGHOH[SOLFDWLYPXOWLIDFWRULDOVHGHILQHúWHSULQXUP WRDUHDUHOD LH \

I[ X

XQGH \ [

YDULDELODHQGRJHQ GHSHQGHQW VDXH[SOLFDW YDULDELOHOHH[RJHQHLQGHSHQGHQWHVDXH[SOLFDWLYH

M = N N

X

QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

YDULDELODUH]LGXDO VDXDOHDWRDUHVDXHURDUH

I [

IXQF LD GH UHJUHVLH FX DMXWRUXO F UHLD YRU IL HVWLPDWH DSUR[LPDWH YDORULOH

YDULDELOHL\GHWHUPLQDWHQXPDLGHLQIOXHQ DIDFWRULORU[ FRQVLGHUD LHVHQ LDOLSULQFLSDOLKRW UkWRUL H[FHSWkQG LQIOXHQ D FHORUODO L IDFWRUL DL IHQRPHQXOXL \ FDUH VXQW FRQVLGHUD L IDFWRUL QHHVHQ LDOL QHVHPQLILFDWLYL GH H[SOLFDUH D DSDUL LHL úL D HYROX LHL vQ WLPS úL vQ VSD LX D IHQRPHQXOXL \ DFHúWLD ILLQGWUDWD LVHSDUDWFXDMXWRUXOYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHX 0RGHOXO

HFRQRPHWULF

WUHEXLH

LQWHUSUHWDW

FD

R

H[SUHVLH

IRUPDO

D

PHWRGHL

HFRQRPHWULFHGHLQYHVWLJDUHDXQXLRELHFWHFRQRPLF 5HDOLWDWHD\

7HRULD>I[ @ÌQWkPSODUHDX

&D UHJXO JHQHUDO úL IXQGDPHQWDO VSHFLILFDUHD XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VH IDFH SH ED]D WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH )HQRPHQXO HFRQRPLF \ VH SUHFL]HD] SH ED]D FRQFHSWHORU GHILQL LLORU úL D UHOD LLORU FDX] HIHFW HODERUDWH GH F WUH DFHDVWD úL VH DFFHSW IHQRPHQXO [ FD IDFWRU HVHQ LDO VDX VH UHVSLQJHúLVHWUHFHvQFDWHJRULDIDFWRULORUvQWkPSO WRULSULQLQWHUPHGLXOYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUHX 'LPHQVLXQHDSDFKHWXOXLGHYDULDELOHH[SOLFDWLYH[ GHSLQGHvQV úLGHEDQFDGHGDWHVWDWLVWLFH DYDULDELOHORUUHVSHFWLYHGHFDQWLWDWHDúLGHFDOLWDWHDDFHVWRUD ÌQ HFRQRPLH PRGHOHOH PXOWLIDFWRULDOH DX R DULH YDVW GH DSOLFDUHDFHVWHDSXWkQGILXWLOL]DWH vQPDLPXOWHVLWXD LLúLVXEGLYHUVHIRUPHFDGHH[HPSOX D PRGHODUHDFRQVXPXOXL &

I931 X

XQGH &

FRQVXPXOXQXLSURGXVVDXJUXSHGHSURGXVH

9

YHQLWXOSHIDPLOLH

3

SUH XOSURGXVXOXLVDXLQGLFHOHSUH XULORUJUXSHLGHSURGXVH

1

QXP UXOPHPEULORUXQHLIDPLOLL

E IXQF LDGHSURGXF LH&REE'RXJODV 4

I./ X

XQGH 4

YROXPXOYDORDUHDSURGXF LHL

.

FDSLWDOXO

/

IRU DGHPXQF

F PRGHODUHDHYROX LHLSUH XULORU

,

I, ,

XQGH

, X

LQGLFHOHYHQLWXULORUVDODULLORU FRQVXPDWRULORU

,

LQGLFHOHFXUVXOXLYDOXWDU

,

LQGLFHOHPDVHLPRQHWDUH

,

LQGLFHOHSUH XULORU

,

70

,GHQWLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLPXOWLIDFWRULDO

&D úL vQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL XQLIDFWRULDO LGHQWLILFDUHD HFRQRPHWULF FRQVW vQ DOHJHUHD XQHL IXQF LLPDWHPDWLFHvQYHGHUHDGHVFULHULLOHJ WXULLDUHOD LHLGLQWUHYDULDELODHQGRJHQ \úLIDFWRULLV L GHLQIOXHQ

[ [ «[ «[ $FHDVW DOHJHUHVHIDFHvQFRQFRUGDQ

FXVHULLOHVWDWLVWLFHVHULLGH

VSD LXVDXGHWLPSDOHYDULDELOHL\úLDOHYDULDELOHORU[ DOHDFHVWRUYDULDELOHSUHOXDWHGLQWURED] GH GDWHVDXFRQVWUXLWHvQXUPDXQRUREVHUY ULVWDWLVWLFHVSHFLDORUJDQL]DWH $VWIHOGDF VHGLVSXQHGHXUP WRDUHOHLQIRUPD LL [

[

«

[

\

[

[

«

[

\

[

[

«

[

\

M

M

«

M

M

[

[

«

[

\

XQGH

W = Q Q

M = N N

QXP UXOWHUPHQLORUVHULLORUVWDWLVWLFH QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

,GHQWLILFDUHD SUHVXSXQH FD SH ED]D GDWHORU H[SHULPHQWDOH \ úL [ V VH J VHDVF R IXQF LH PDWHPDWLF <

I[ FXDMXWRUXOF UHLDV VHHVWLPH]HYDORULOHYDULDELOHL\QXPDLSHED]DYDORULORU

YDULDELOHORU[

6SUH GHRVHELUH GH FD]XO XQLIDFWRULDO XQGH SURFHGHXO JUDILF VDX FDOFXOHOH DOJHEULFH RIHUHDX

LQIRUPD LLUHODWLYFRUHFWHSHQWUXLGHQWLILFDUHDIXQF LHLGHUHJUHVLHvQFD]XOPRGHOHORUPXOWLIDFWRULDOH DFHVWOXFUXU PkQHYDODELOGRDUvQFD]XOvQFDUHVHYDOXFUDFXVHULLELGLPHQVLRQDOH\ [ \ [ \ [ «\ [ 8Q DOW PRG GH DOHJHUH D IXQF LHL GH UHJUHVLH PXOWLIDFWRULDOH FRQVW XWLOL]DUHD HVWLPDUHD YHULILFDUHD úL FRPSDUDUHD PDL PXOWRU WLSXUL GH IXQF LL GH UHJUHVLH úL GH D GHFLGH vQ ILQDO ± YH]L FRHILFLHQ LLGHSHUIRUPDQ

DLXQXLPRGHOPXOWLIDFWRULDOOLQLDU±FDUHHVWHFHOPDLSHUIRUPDQWPRGHO

vQUDSRUWFXGDWHOHH[SHULPHQWDOH 'HUHJXO vQHFRQRPLHSULQFLSDOHOHIXQF LLGHUHJUHVLHPXOWLIDFWRULDOHVXQWGHIRUPD IXQF LDOLQLDU E E [ E [ «E [

<

IXQF LDOLQLDU GXEOXORJDULWPLF

= E

<

Ü OQ <

¢ [

¢

= OQ E

+E

OQ [

!

K ¢ [

IXQF LDOLQLDU VHPLORJDULWPLF = H

<&

Ü OQ<

W

% + ' % *$ *# ' % ) $ ) # '

=E

VDX = E5

<0

Ü OQ< Ü OQ< XQGH b

= OQ E

= b

W

¢ E4

= OQ E

W

¢ [

+E [

. 2-

¢E

(

3. 1 -

¢

+ OQ E

+ b [

W

+ b

W

[

+

OQ [

K + E

[

K ¢ E/ ¢[

+ E

' % " $ "# +E

W

+

W

. ,-

K+E

+

N

[

+ OQ E W

¢[

NW

W

K+ b

N

+ [

OQ [

K + OQ E

NW

N

¢[

NW

M b

M

= OQ E

M

M = N

71

'HUH LQXWF DWkWvQHWDSDGHVSHFLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLFkWúLvQHWDSDGHLGHQWLILFDUHVROX LLOH DFFHSWDWH

[6 ±SULQFLSDOLLIDFWRULGHLQIOXHQ

<8

= I

([ 78 ) = E ;

+ E: [ : 8

+ E9 [ 9 8

+

DLIHQRPHQXOXL\

K + E7

M = N W = Q UHOD LDGHGHSHQGHQ

[ 78

QXVXQWDOWFHYDGHFkWVLPSOHLSRWH]HGHOXFUX 9DOLGDUHD VDX LQILUPDUHD DFHVWRUD YD FRQVWLWXL GH DOWIHO SULQFLSDOXO RELHFWLY DO HWDSHL GH YHULILFDUHHFRQRPHWULF DPRGHOXOXL

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXLPXOWLIDFWRULDO

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXLVHIDFHvQXUPDHWDSHLGHLGHQWLILFDUHDDFHVWXLD'HRDUHFH PDUHD PDMRULWDWH D PRGHOHORU HFRQRPHWULFH SRW IL OLQLDUL]DWH XQ PRGHO PXOWLIDFWRULDO vQ IRUP JHQHUDO VHSUH]LQW DVWIHO E = [ = < E > [ > < E ? [ ?< «E 6 [6 < «E @ [@ < XA

\ < XQGH W = Q Q

QXP UXOWHUPHQLORUVHULLORUVWDWLVWLFH

M = N N

QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

FHHDFHDQDOLWLFGHYLQH = E

Å \ F

G

+ EF

+ E D

[ FHF

[ F D

+È+ E C

[ FIC

+ XF

¿ D = E G + E F [ DF + E D [ DHD + È + E C [ DEC + X D ¿ \ ¿

XQGH[ =

¿ \ B ®

= E

G + E B

+ E D

[ BF

[ BED

+ È+ E C

[ BC

+ XB

« UHSUH]LQW YDULDELODFHVHDWDúHD] WHUPHQXOXLOLEHUDOHF UHLYDORUL[ <

= VXQWHJDOHFXXQLWDWHD "

= Q

W

'HILQLQGFX

< =

» \ L ª

± ²

ª

²

K ª \ ²

M

ª ª \ J ½

YHFWRUXO

FRORDQ

DO

YDULDELOHL

HQGRJHQH

\

<

W = Q

GH

² ² Õ

GLPHQVLXQHQ » ª

;

=

O M

[ O O

KKK [

ª

[ Q O

KKK[

Q M

[ P O

KKK [

P M

ª ª ª ª

KKKKKKKK

ª ½

[ N

O

KKK [

N M

± ² ² ² ² ²

PDWULFHD YDULDELOHORU H[RJHQH [6 M = N GH

² ² Õ

GLPHQVLXQHQN »E ª

U ± ²

ªE % =

ª ª ª

E

M

ª ªE ½

T ² ²

S

² YHFWRUXO FRORDQ DO SDUDPHWULORU E 6 ²

Y[Z

WX V

GH GLPHQVLXQH N

²

R ² Õ

72

»X ª

^

ªX 8 =

ª ª

M

½

X

ª

² ²

]

X

ª

± ²

_

²

YHFWRUXO FRORDQ DO YDULDELOHL DOHDWRDUH X <

W = Q

GH GLPHQVLXQH

² ²

\

Õ

Q 5HOD LD VXEIRUP PDWULFHDO GHYLQH ;Â%8

<

5HOD LD VHPDLSRDWHVFULHDVWIHO »\ ª

a

ª\

`

ª

² ²

M

ª ª \ ½

» ª

± ²

ª

= ª

a a KK [ a d

[

` a KK [ ` d

± ²

»E ª

²

¢

²

KKKKKKK² ª ² [ c a KK [ c d ½ Õ ª

² ² Õ

c

[

Q

Q N +

ªE ª

b a

² ²

M

ª ª E ½

d

»X ª

± ² +

² ² Õ

ªX ª ª

`

M

ªX ½

N +

a

± ² ² ² ²

c

² Õ

Q

)XQF LD GH UHJUHVLH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH PRGHOXOXL VFULV VXE IRUPD XQHL HFXD LL PDWULFHDOH HVWH

Ö Ö < = ; ¢ %

5H]LGXXULOH e HVWLPD LLOHYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUHX VHGHILQHVFDVWIHO Ö =< 8

-<Ö = <

Ö

XQGH <

Ö ¢%

- ;

YDORULOHHVWLPDWHDMXVWDWH DOHYDULDELOHL<

ÌQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO PXOWLIDFWRULDO SDUDPHWULL SRW IL HVWLPD L SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO PDL PXOWRU PHWRGH FXP DU IL PHWRGD SXQFWHORU HPSLULFH PHWRGD SXQFWHORU PHGLL PHWRGD FHORU PDL PLFL S WUDWH0&003 PHWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

LLPD[LPHHWF

0HWRGD SXQFWHORU HPSLULFH úL PHWRGD SXQFWHORU PHGLL VXQW IRORVLWH vQ FD]XO PRGHOHORU vQ FDUH DSOLFDUHD PHWRGHL FHORU PDL PLFL S WUDWH HVWH DQHYRLRDV QHFHVLWkQG FDOFXOH FRPSOLFDWH GH UHJXO SHQWUXIXQF LLOHQHOLQLDUHIXQF LDORJLVWLF 0HWRGD FHORU PDL PLFL S WUDWH HVWH PHWRGD FHO PDL GHV XWLOL]DW ÌQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO PXOWLIDFWRULDODSOLFDUHDDFHVWHLDSUHVXSXQHPLQLPL]DUHDIXQF LHL

g

$ ) (% ) =

P LQ

Çj fh

(

X

f

i

= P LQ 8 ë8

= P LQ

(<

$)

- <

= P LQ < ë< - % ë( ; ë< ) + % ë ( ; ë;

$

$

)% )

$

i

(

= P LQ < -

$)

i

;%

Ö FDUHLPSOLF FDOFXOXOGHULYDWHLIXQF LHLvQUDSRUWFXHVWLPDWRUXO %

$ ) ( % ) $

%

= Ü - ( ; ë< ) + ( ; ë;

)%

$

=

Ü ( ; ë; ) % = ; ë<

$

= P LQ

(<

-

$ ) ë (<

;%

-

$) =

;%

úLDQXODUHDDFHVWHLD

ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHPDWULFHD;¶; DGPLWHLQYHUV SULQvQPXO LUHDODVWkQJDDHFXD LHLPDWULFHDOH l FX;¶; k

UH]XOW F

(;

ë; )

m n

(;

ë; ) % =

$

(;

ë; )

m n

(;

ë< )

(VWLPDWRULLSDUDPHWULORUVHFDOFXOHD] DVWIHOFXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

Ö % =

(;

ë ;

r

)o (;

ë <

)=

Ör ± »E ª ² Öq ªE ² ª ª

M

ªÖp E ½

² ²

² Õ

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFPXOWLIDFWRULDOOLQLDUVHSRDWHIDFHúLSHED]D PDWULFHLYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORUúLDPDWULFHLFRHILFLHQ LORUGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU VLPSOL

73

)LHPRGHOXO = Ev

\s

+ Eu [ u s

+ Et [ t s

+ Xs

6HvQVXPHD] úLVHvPSDUWHODQRE LQkQGXVHHFXD LD

\ = Ew

[x + E xy

[z + Ez{

6HVFDGHHFXD LD GLQ úLUH]XOW

- \ = E }~ ([ } |

\|

- [}

)

+ E ([ |

)

- [

+ X|

6HQRWHD] FX

\

[

[

= \

W

= [

= [

W

- \

W

- [

- [

W

0RGHOXO FRQVWUXLWSHED]DDEDWHULORUFHQWUDWHVWDQGDUG DOHYDULDELOHORUGHYLQH

\

=E [

W

+E

W

[

+X

W

W

9DORULOHDMXVWDWHDOHYDULDELOHLHQGRJHQHVHFDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

Ö = E [

Ö <

Ö +E [

E

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUDFHVWXLPRGHOVHUHDOL]HD] FXDMXWRUXO0&003

(

(

) = PLQ

Ö Ö ) E E

\ Ç

Ö -<

) = PLQ

(

\ Ç

Ö - E [

Ö -E [

)

0LQLPXO DFHVWHL IXQF LL HVWH GDW GH FDOFXOXO GHULYDWHORU SDU LDOH vQ UDSRUW FX SDUDPHWULL PRGHOXOXL

(

)

Ö Ö Å ) E E ¿ ¿

( )

Ö E

¿

(

)

Ö Ö ) E E

(

¿ ®

)

Ö E

(

Ö = ÜE Ç [

Ö = ÜE Ç[

)

[

Ö +E

Ç[

(

Ö +E

Ç [

[

= Ç \

)

= Ç \

[

[

)LHFDUHGLQHFXD LLOHVLVWHPXOXLGHHFXD LL VHvPSDUWHODQ Ö ¿ E ¿

¿ Ö E ¿ ®

Ç ([ - [

Å

Ç ([

)

Q

Ö + E

)([

- [

Ç ([

)

- [

Q

- [

)([

Q

Ç ([

Ö + E

)

- [

- [ Q

=

)

=

Ç (\ Ç (\

- \

)([

- [

Q - \

)([

- [

)

)

Q

ÌQILQDOVLVWHPXOGHHFXD LLVHSUH]LQW DVWIHO

Ö ÅE ¿ s

Ö + E FRY( [ [

Ö ¿E FRY( [ [ ®

) + EÖ

s

)=

FRY( \ [

)

= FRY( \ [

)

(VWLPDWRULLSDUDPHWULORUVHYRUFDOFXODDVWIHO FRY( \ [

Ö E

=

FRY( \ [

)

FRY( [ [

)

s

FRY( [ [

)

s

Ö E

=

FRY( [ [

s

FRY( [ [

) )

FRY( [ [

)

s

)

s FRY( \ [

FRY( \ [

FRY( [ [

)

) )

s

74

7HUPHQXO OLEHU E SRDWH IL HVWLPDW GLQ UHOD LD GXS FDOFXOXO HVWLPDWRULORU SDUDPHWULORU E ¡ úL E ¢ DVWIHO

$

$

$

= \ - E ¤y [¤

E£

- E ¥{ [¥

¦ 0DWULFHDYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORUVHGHILQHúWHDVWIHO » ª

¦ [§ FRY( \

s«

9 = ª FRY( [ § \ ) ª ½

FRY( [

¦

)

sª ©

¦

\)

FRY( [ [ §

FRY( \ [

¦

FRY( [¦ § [

)

¦

)± ²

)² ²

sª ¨

Õ

VDXvQFD]XOJHQHUDO » ª

s³

¬

FRY( \ [

ª FRY( [ \ ) 9 =

ª

FRY( [ ¬ \ )

ª

ª

s± ¯

FRY( [ ¬ [

(

Q

s

s

(

=

[´

FRY

(\

MW

W =

)=

M

FRY( [ ¬ [ ²

)

FRY( [ [ ²

s± ®

s± °

FRY( [ ² [ ¬

)

²

)²

¬

² ²

² ² ² Õ

)

Q

[

)

)

Ç [

FRY( [ ² [

)±

HVWHGLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHL\

Q

Q

¬

)

FRY( \ [ ²

W

W =

=

\

FRY( [ [ ¬

)

)

Ç \

FRY( \ [ ¬

ª ª FRY( [ ² \ ) ½

XQGH

)

¬

HVWHGLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHL [ µ·¶ M = Q Ç (\

)([

- \

W

Q

Ö 'LVSXQkQGGHPDWULFHD9HVWLPDWRULL E

Ö = E

\ [

M

)

- [

MW

¸

=

Ç \

W

[

MW

Q

VHFDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

¹º

XQGH

¹

Ö E ¾

º ¼

Ö = E»

=

» ¿

(- )

9

½

¼

M = N

¹H¹

9

= GHWHUPLQDQWXOPDWULFHLYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORUGLQFDUHVHHOLPLQ

9ÀEÁÂ

OLQLD\úLFRORDQD [ Ã

= GHWHUPLQDQWXO PDWULFHL YDULDQ HORU úL FRYDULDQ HORU GLQ FDUH VH HOLPLQ

9ÄHÄ

OLQLD\úLFRORDQD\ 5DSRUWXO GH FRUHOD LH PXOWLSO SRDWH IL H[SULPDW FX DMXWRUXO PDWULFHL YDULDQ HORU úL FRYDULDQ HORUDVWIHO

5

\ [

=

Å

-

9 9

¢

s

\\

\

(VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL FX DMXWRUXO PDWULFHL FRHILFLHQ LORU GH FRUHOD LH OLQLDU SUHVXSXQHHIHFWXDUHDXUP WRDUHORURSHUD LL VHvQPXO HúWHUHOD LD FX

sË

\

É

- \

sË

= EÏ s Ê Í

Æ

s

s

([Ï É

Æ

úL

- [Ï

sÊ Í

sÈ Ç

sÈ Ç

)

+ EÎ s Ê Ì

([ Î É

- [Î

sÊ Ì

)

É

+X

75

DEDWHULOHVWDQGDUGQRUPDWHVHQRWHD] FX

\Ñ

Ò Ò

\Ñ - \

=

× ×

[ ÕÖ - [ Õ

=

[ ÕÖ

sÐ

sÔ Ó

UHOD LD GHYLQH

\Ø

sÚ

Û Û

Û Û

Û Û

= EÝ s Ù ß [ Ý Ø

+ EÜ s Ù Þ [ Ü Ø

+ XØ

IXQF LDGHUHJUHVLHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHHVWHXUP WRDUHD

áà à

à áà

Ö = Eä s â æ [ ä

Ö <

Öã ã + E sâ å [

àEáà

VH HVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULL PRGHOXOXL Eç M = FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 FDUH SUHVXSXQH PLQLPL]DUHDIXQF LHL

(

) = PLQ

Ö ) Eò

( )

Ö ) Eó

( )

Ö Eó

6HúWLHF U

í

(

ì sñ Ç é

Ö -< î

\ î

(

= Ü ®

=

Q s

W

ü

)

WM

ü

Ç \

(

õ õ ø ú Ç [ ô ô

W

)

WM

(

) = sö ø

)

= sö

(

ô Ç \ ô

ô Ç (\ ô

ï ï Öè è - E sð ê [ î õ õ

õ õ

ù [ ô

õ õ [

õ õ ø ô

è

)

)

)

[

W

\ î

(

Öø + E s÷

ï ï Öé é - E sð ë [ î

õ õ õ õ ù ø ú Ç [ ô [ ô ô

Öø + E s÷

(

ó [

é

î

Ç \

=

(

ï ï

ì = PLQ Ç sñ

ø

õ õ

[ s

\

)

í

õ õ õ õ ù ø û Ç[ ô [ ô ô

Öù ¿ E s÷

Ç \

è

ï ï

ÅÖ ù ù E s÷ û Ç [ ô ¿ ô

[ ýó

\

î

ï ï

Ç [ WM

)

ÿ

úL U ÿ þ

=

ÌQDFHVWFD]VLVWHPXOGHHFXD LLQRUPDOH GHYLQH Ö ÅE ¿ Ö E ¿ ®

Ö +E

s

s

U

s

= s

U

Ö +E

s

= s

U

U

0DWULFHDFRHILFLHQ LORUGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU VLPSO DYDULDELOHORUVHGHILQHúWH » ª

5 = ªU ª ½U

5 =

ª

±

U

²

²

² Õ

U

U

U

U

U

U

U

U

$

U

'LVSXQkQGGHDFHDVW PDWULFHHVWLPDWRULL E

$

Ö E

Ö = E

=

U

ªU ½

ªU ª

U

U

VDXvQFD]XOJHQHUDO » ª

U

(- )

!#"

5

5

¢

s s

$

± ² ² ²

² ² Õ

= E VHFDOFXOHD] SHED]DUHOD LHLXUP WRDUH

XQGH

5

5

&' % ))

(

= GHWHUPLQDQWXOPDWULFHL5GLQFDUHVDHOLPLQDWOLQLD\úLFRORDQD [ = GHWHUPLQDQWXOPDWULFHL5GLQFDUHVDHOLPLQDWOLQLD\úLFRORDQD\

&XDMXWRUXODFHVWHLPDWULFLVHSRWFDOFXOD

76

FRHILFLHQ LLGHFRUHOD LHSDU LDOL

. 2 - +2 - *

=

. 2-*2-+

=

U

1 3,

5

(- )

5

U

1 3,

./.

5

5

(- )

5

.0- + - +- *

.0- *

./.

5

- +- *

UDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LHPXOWLSO

5

\ [

(

5

=

5

\\

,SRWH]HSHQWUXHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORU

$SOLFDUHD 0&003 vQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO PXOWLIDFWRULDO VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SH FkWHYD LSRWH]HúLDQXPH

4

5

6

, 9DULDELOHOH\[ «[ QXVXQWDIHFWDWHGHHURULGHP VXU

7

5

, 9DULDELOD DOHDWRDUH UH]LGXDO 8 HVWH GH PHGLH QXO 0X GLVSHUVLD

HL

s

8#:

HVWH

FRQVWDQW

úL

LQGHSHQGHQW

GH

YDULDELOHOH

8

0X

«

H[RJHQH

;

;

KRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWH

<

9

0X

LDU

LSRWH]D

GH

, 9DORULOH YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH 8 VXQW LQGHSHQGHQWH UHVSHFWLY QX H[LVW IHQRPHQXO GH DXWRFRUHODUHDHURULORUFRYX

?

=

X

>

"W W = Q

, /HJHD GH SUREDELOLWDWH D YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH HVWH OHJHD QRUPDO GH PHGLH ]HUR úL GH

:

DEDWHUHPHGLHS WUDWLF s ÌQ DIDUD DFHVWRU LSRWH]H FDUH VXQW DFHOHDúL úL vQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO XQLIDFWRULDO H[LVW R

@

;

LSRWH] VSHFLILF PRGHOXOXL PXOWLIDFWRULDO úL DQXPH , 9DULDELOHOH H[RJHQH ; VXQW LQGHSHQGHQWH vQWUH HOH IRUPkQG XQ VLVWHP GH YHFWRUL OLQLDUL LQGHSHQGHQ L ÌQ FD] FRQWUDU DSDUH IHQRPHQXO GH

A5

PXOWLFROLQLDULWDWH FDUH LPSOLF LPSRVLELOLWDWHD FDOFXO ULL PDWULFLL LQYHUVH;¶; HVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORU

4

'DF LSRWH]HOH, «,

B

Ö X

= \

B

B

C

YDORULOHHPSLULFHDOHYDULDELOHLHQGRJHQH<

B

Ö <

YDORULOH WHRUHWLFH DOH YDULDELOHL HQGRJHQH FDOFXODW SH ED]D IXQF LHL GH

B

Ö Ö Ö UHJUHVLH < = ;% VDX <

I

G

=

ÇX

OP Q

V

H

G

Q - N -

REVHUYD LLLDUN

R

H[LVW DWXQFLVHSRWGHPRQVWUDXUP WRDUHOH

Ö - < HVWLPD LLOHYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH8

XQGH \

s

@

SUHFXP úL D

= V

N

R

F

Ö = E

E EB

Ö +E [

D DB

Ö + + E [

HVWLPD LD GLVSHUVLHL s

K

J

D YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH X Q ILLQG QXP UXO GH

QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[SOLFDWLYH ¢F

LM W;

XQGH F

( ( V U TS

HVWLPD LLOHGLVSHUVLLORUSDUDPHWULORU E

HOHPHQWXO M VLWXDW SH GLDJRQDOD SULQFLSDO D PDWULFHL LQYHUVH ;¶;

M = N

X=

;

PHGLD FRQGL LRQDW D YDULDELOHL < vQ IXQF LH GH YDORULOH IDFWRULORU ; OD PRPHQWXO W HVWH

B

Ö HJDO FX < 0 <

W ;

Y

Ö =<

W

Ö =E

Ö +E [

Ö + + E

N

[

N

77

GLVSHUVLD FRQGL LRQDW D YDULDELOHL < HURDUHD GH HVWLPDUH D DFHVWHLD VH FDOFXOHD] FX DMXWRUXOUHOD LHL V

c ] a` _^

» ª XQGH ;

W

=

ª

[

ª

M

½

[

ª

Z

Ö -<

Z

c

=V

\

c

[ + ; Z

[

(;

;

)

b d

;

Z

]

± ²

ª [ W ª

= 0 \

² ²

W

²

e

HVWHYHFWRUXOFRORDQ DOYDORULORUYDULDELOHORUIDFWRULDOH; vQPRPHQWXOW

² ² Õ

NW

f

GHGLPHQVLXQHN LDU ; ë = WUDQVSXVDPDWULFHL; W

9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLPRGHOXOXL

9HULILFDUHD

VHPQLILFD LHL

PRGHOXOXL

SUHVXSXQH

YHULILFDUHD

0&003 YHULILFDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL HVWLPDWRULORU D YHURVLPLOLW

LSRWH]HORU

GH

DSOLFDUH

D

LL PRGHOXOXL úL D VHPQLILFD LHL

UDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LH ÌQ DFHDVW HWDS HVWH QHFHVDU YHULILFDUHD D SRVWHULRUL ! D LSRWH]HORU GH DSOLFDUH D 0&003GHRDUHFHvQJHQHUDOHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUVHHIHFWXHD] vQXUPDDFFHSW ULLDSULRULFH DYDODELOLW

LLLSRWH]HORUHQXQ DWH

g

h

i

j

k

Ö 9HULILFDUHD LSRWH]HORU , , , úL , FD úL WHVWDUHD HVWLPDWRULORU E D PRGHOXOXL úL D

UDSRUWXOXL GH FRUHOD LH

5

XQLIDFWRULDOH

n oml

VH IDFH GXS DFHOHDúL SULQFLSLL SUH]HQWDWH vQ FD]XO UHJUHVLHL

p

9HULILFDUHD LSRWH]HL , SUHVXSXQH FD YDULDELOHOH H[RJHQH V IRUPH]H XQ VLVWHP GH YHFWRUL OLQLDULLQGHSHQGHQ LUHVSHFWLYYDULDELOHOHH[RJHQHV QXILHFRUHODWH 2SXVXO DFHVWXL IHQRPHQ vO UHSUH]LQW PXOWLFROLQLDULWDWHD YDULDELOHORU H[RJHQH FDUH HVWH XQ IHQRPHQ IRDUWH IUHFYHQW vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPLF GDWRULW PXOWLSOHORU UHOD LL GH GHSHQGHQ LQWHUGHSHQGHQ

úL

GLQWUH IHQRPHQHOH HFRQRPLFH ÌQ DFHVW VFRSVHLPSXQHRDERUGDUHHFRQRPHWULF vQ

VFRSXOGHSLVW ULLúLHOLPLQ ULLDFHVWXLD 'HSLVWDUHD IHQRPHQXOXL GH PXOWLFROLQHDULWDWH VH SRDWH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO PDL PXOWRU SURFHGHH FXPDUIL UHSUH]HQWDUHD JUDILF D VHULLORU GH YDORUL FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH YDULDELOHORU H[SOLFDWLYH YH]L )LJXUD QU ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH VH FRQVWDW DQDORJLL vQ HYROX LH DFHVWHD LQGLF H[LVWHQ D XQHL FRUHOD LLVXILFLHQWGHLQWHQVHvQWUHYDULDELOHOHUHVSHFWLYH

q

[

r

[

[

s

W )LJXUDQU

78

FDOFXOXO GHWHUPLQDQWXOXL PDWULFHL ;C; ';C; vQ VHQVXO F SH P VXU FH VH DSURSLH GH ]HUR DFHVWD LQGLF R LQWHUFRUHODUH GLQ FH vQ FH PDL VWUkQV 'DF ';C; VH FRQVLGHU F

t

IHQRPHQXOGHPXOWLFROLQLDULWDWHHVWHSUH]HQW

FDOFXOXO P ULPLL FRHILFLHQWXOXL GH GHWHUPLQDUH 5 $FHDVW YDORDUH HVWH FRPSDUDW FX P ULPHD DFHOXLDúL FRHILFLHQW RE LQXW vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH XQD GLQWUH YDULDELOHOH IDFWRULDOH D IRVW RPLV GLQPRGHOÌQFD]XOvQFDUHYDORULOHFRHILFLHQ LORUVXQWDSURSLDWHFDP ULPHVHSRDWHFRQVLGHUD F YDULDELODRPLV HVWHFROLQLDU FXFHOHODOWHYDULDELOHIDFWRULDOH$EVHQ DDFHVWHLYDULDELOHGLQPRGHO DU IL GH GRULW vQWUXFkW DU FRQGXFH OD GLPLQXDUHD PXOWLFROLQLDULW

LL I U D DIHFWD VHPQLILFDWLY JUDGXO

GHGHWHUPLQDUHDIDFWRULORUDVXSUDYDULDELOHLHIHFW WHVWHOH VWDWLVWLFH 6WXGHQW W XWLOL]DW vQ YHGHUHD YHULILF ULL VHPQLILFD LHL SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL úL )LVKHU6QHGHFRU ) XWLOL]DW vQ YHGHUHD YHULILF ULL VHPQLILFD LHL PRGHOXOXL ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH WHVWXO ) VHPQDOHD] VHPQLILFD LH LDU WHVWXO W DSOLFDW DFHOXLDúL PRGHO VHPQDOHD] QHVHPQLILFD LL vQ UkQGXO SDUDPHWULORU DFHVW OXFUX UHSUH]LQW XQ LQGLFLX F PXOWLFROLQLDULWDWHD HVWH SUH]HQW (IHFWHOH PXOWLFROLQLDULW

LL VXQW SURSRU LRQDOH FX LQWHQVLWDWHD SUH]HQ HL DFHVWHLD vQ UkQGXO

YDULDELOHORU H[SOLFDWLYH 9DORULOH HVWLPDWRULORU SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL VXQW DIHFWDWH DYkQG GUHSW FRQVHFLQ

GHIRUPDUHD DFHVWRU YDORUL vQWUR DVHPHQHD P VXU vQFkW GHYLQH QHLQWHOLJLELO LQIOXHQ D

VHSDUDW D YDULDELOHORU H[SOLFDWLYH DVXSUD YDULDELOHL HIHFW 0XOWLFROLQLDULWDWHD DIHFWHD] GH DVHPHQHDúLJUDGXOGHGHWHUPLQDUHDIDFWRULORUDVXSUDYDULDELOHLHIHFWvQVHQVXOGLPLQX ULLVDOH $WHQXDUHDPXOWLFROLQLDULW

LLSRDWHILUHDOL]DW DVWIHO

GDWRULW IDSWXOXL F VHULLOH GH GDWH SULYLQG YDULDELOD HIHFW úL IDFWRULL V L GHWHUPLQDQ L VXQW DOF WXLWHGHFHOHPDLPXOWHRULGLQWUXQQXP UUHGXVGHWHUPHQLQ VHUHFRPDQG LQFOXGHUHD GHWHUPHQLVXSOLPHQWDULQ! DVWIHOvQFkWHYHQWXDOHOHDQDORJLLGDWRUDWHKD]DUGXOXLV ILHSHFkW SRVLELOHOLPLQDWH vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH GRX YDULDELOH FDX]DOH VXQW LQWHQV FRUHODWH XQD GLQWUH HOH HVWH FROLQLDU FXFHDODOW VHSRDWHUHQXQ DODXQDGLQWUHHOHFRQVLGHUkQGXVHF YDULDELODRPLV HVWHH[SULPDW GH FHDUH LQXW vQPRGHO

u v w

GDF GDWHOH VXQW SUH]HQWDWH VXE IRUP GH VHULL FURQRORJLFH VH SRW FDOFXOD GLIHUHQ HOH GH RUGLQXO D

f

\ ± \

fx v

f e

± VDXSRWILORJDULWPDWHYDORULOHOXL < ;

FDX]DWHGHSUH]HQ DWUHQGXOXLvQFDGUXOVHULLORUGHGDWH

vQVFRSXODWHQX ULLFROLQLDULW

LL

XWLOL]DUHD GH VHULL GH GDWH IRUPDWH vQ RSWLF WUDQVYHUVDO VHULL VLQFURQH SRDWH FRQVWLWXL R PRGDOLWDWH GH GLPLQXDUH VDX FKLDU GH HOLPLQDUH D LQWHUGHSHQGHQ HL IDFWRULORU $FHDVW VLWXD LH HVWH YDODELO vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH REVHUYDUHD VH UHIHU OD XQHúDQWLRQVWDWLVWLFGHvQWUHSULQGHULMXGH HIDPLOLL HWF &D XUPDUH D IDSWXOXL F GDWHOH VXQW FXOHVH SHQWUX DFHHDúL SHULRDG GH WLPS SH ED]D DFHOHDúL PHWRGRORJLL GDU vQ FRQGL LL GLIHULWH GH PDQLIHVWDUH D IDFWRULORU H[LVW úDQVH PDL PDUL FD LSRWH]D SULYLQGLQGHSHQGHQ DIDFWRULORUV ILHUHJ VLW vQVHWXOGHGDWH (OLPLQDUHD IHQRPHQXOXL GH PXOWLFROLQLDULWDWH SRDWH IL UHDOL]DW FX DMXWRUXO XUP WRDUHORU SURFHGHH 0HWRGH DSULRULFH VXQW XWLOL]DWH vQ YHGHUHD VHOHFW ULL úL RUGRQ ULLLQWURGXFHULLvQPRGHOD YDULDELOHORUH[SOLFDWLYH8QDGLQWUHDFHVWHPHWRGHHVWHPHWRGDUHJUHVLHLLWHUDWLYHFDUHFRQVW vQ FDOFXOXO PDWULFHL FRHILFLHQ LORU GH FRUHOD LH OLQLDU FRUHVSXQ] WRUL YDULDELOHORU H[RJHQH $FHDVW PDWULFH UH]XOW vQ XUPD HOLPLQ ULL OLQLHL \ úL FRORDQHL \ GLQ PDWULFHD FRHILFLHQ LORU GH FRUHOD LHOLQLDU FRUHVSXQ] WRDUHPRGHOXOXLUHVSHFWLY

» ª

5

} {|

| z} U| y }

}~| z

U

ª U =

ª ª ª ª ½

|y|z

|}

||z

}~| U| z | U| y | U

||y

U

U

U

}~| y U| z | y U

U

± ² ² ²

² ²

² Õ

79

3HED]DDFHVWHLPDWULFHVHIXQGDPHQWHD] PHWRGDUHJUHVLHLSDVFXSDV3ULPDRSHUD LHFRQVW vQGHSLVWDUHDIHQRPHQXOXLGHFROLQLDULWDWHGLQWUHYDULDELOHOHH[RJHQH'DF vQPDWULFHDFRHILFLHQ LORU GHFRUHOD LHH[LVW GRX YDULDELOHH[SOLFDWLYHDOF URUFRHILFLHQWGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU LQGLF RFRUHOD LH SXWHUQLF SR]LWLY VDX QHJDWLY VH UHFRPDQG GH OD vQFHSXW UHQXQ DUHD OD XQD GLQWUH DFHVWH YDULDELOH 6H YD UH LQH DFHD YDULDELO SHQWUX FDUH H[LVW SUH]XP LD F QX HVWH DIHFWDW GH HURUL UHQXQ DUHDI FkQGXVHGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHVWDWLVWLFúLHFRQRPLF $GRXDRSHUD LHFRQVW vQDSOLFDUHDPHWRGHLUHJUHVLHLSDVFXSDV$FHDVWDSRDWHILIRORVLW vQ GRX PDQLHUHDVFHQGHQWúLGHVFHQGHQW SRUQHúWH GH OD DQDOL]D FRHILFLHQ LORU GH FRUHOD LH

0HWRGD UHJUHVLHL SDV FX SDV DVFHQGHQW

nm l

&RQGL LDFDSULPDYDULDELO V ILHLQWURGXV vQPRGHOHVWHGDW GHUHOD LD

U

PD[ U M

)LH U

\[

= PD[ U M

\[

\[

Ü \

Ü 0

=D

Ö \

Ö = D

+ D [

Ö [ +D

+X

6HFDOFXOHD] FRHILFLHQ LLGHFRUHOD LHSDU LDO U

XQGH M = N

/DSDVXOVHLQWURGXFHYDULDELOD[FDUHSUH]LQW FHDPDLSXWHUQLF FRUHOD LHFX X UHVSHFWLY

PD[ U M

X

[

)LH [

YDULDELODQRX FHYDILLQWURGXV vQPRGHO \

= D

+ D [

+ D [

+X

M = N úLVHLQWURGXFHvQPRGHOYDULDELODFHDPDLSXWHUQLFFRUHODW FX

6HFDOFXOHD] U

X

úLVHFRQWLQX SURFHGHXO 7RDWHDFHVWHPRGHOHRE LQXWHSHSDUFXUVVHWHVWHD] FXDMXWRUXOWHVWHORUFXQRVFXWHÄW´úLÄ)

´ XUP ULQGXVH úL YHULILFDUHD FRQGL LHL 5

\ [

< 5

t

\ [

[

< < 5

\ [

[

[

DGLF DUH ORF R

FUHúWHUHSURJUHVLY DFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHGHWHUPLQDUH5 0HWRGDUHJUHVLHLSDVFXSDVGHVFHQGHQW

\ =D

(V

D

+D [

) (V

D

+D

) (V

[

D

)

+ + D

N

(V

[

D

N

)

+X

SUHVXSXQHFRQVWUXLUHDPRGHOXOXL

5

\ [ [

SHQWUX FDUH VH FDOFXOHD] DEDWHULOH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH SDUDPHWULORU 9RU IL HOLPLQDWH GLQ PRGHO DFHOH YDULDELOHSHQWUXFDUHVHUHDOL]HD] FRQGL LD

Ö _ D V

¡ ¢

_

Ê W

£

Ö Ü D

@

'XS FH VH HOLPLQ YDULDELOHOH SHQWUX FDUH VH YHULILF FRQGL LD UHVSHFWLY VH FRQVWUXLHúWH PRGHOXO QXPDL vQ IXQF LH GH YDULDELOHOH U PDVH FRQVLGHUDWH FD DYkQG R LQIOXHQ FRQIRUPSDVXOXL )LH D

¤

VHPQLILFDWLY

¥

@ Ü VHHOLPLQ YDULDELOD[ 6HFRQVWUXLHúWHPRGHOXO \ =D

+ D [

+ D [

+ + D

N

[

N

+X

5

\ [

§ ¦ [

[

¨

6H FRPSDU FHL GRL FRHILFLHQ L GH GHWHUPLQDUH úL WUHEXLH V UH]XOWH F HL VXQW DSUR[LPDWLY

¥

HJDOL(OLPLQDUHDYDULDELOHL[ QXGLPLQXHD] FXQLPLFJUDGXOGHSHUIRUPDQ

DOPRGHOXOXL

2 DOW FDWHJRULH GH PHWRGH FDUH SRDWH IL IRORVLWH OD VHOHF LD YDULDELOHORU IDFWRULDOH VXQW PHWRGHOH DSRVWHULRULFH FDUH FRQVWDX vQ FRQVWUXLUHD GH PRGHOH HFRQRPHWULFH FX WRDWH YDULDELOHOH H[SOLFDWLYHúLDFFHSWDUHDDFHVWRUDFDYDULDELOHH[RJHQHVHPQLILFDWLYHQXPDLGXS YHULILFDUHDWHVWHORU VWDWLVWLFH FDUH YDOLGHD] DFHDVW LSRWH] $FHVWH PHWRGH VH ED]HD] SH GHILQLUHD úL LQWHUSUHWDUHD JUDGXOXL GH SHUIRUPDQ

DO PRGHOXOXL $VWIHO FRHILFLHQ LL GH SHUIRUPDQ

JOREDO VH FDOFXOHD] FX

80

DMXWRUXO UHOD LHL 5

5

¯±° µ ¸ ¶ µ

9

=-

¯ ´³·² ¯ ´³

©

® ª

=-

9 9

© ¬« © ª

LDU FRHILFLHQ LL GH SHUIRUPDQ

SDU LDO FX UHOD LD

9

ÌQDFHVWVHQVVHFRQVWUXLHúWHPRGHOXO 0

\

= \ +X

W

YDULDELODUH]LGXDO 9

0

\

W

¹

º

=E

=9

ÜX

¹

½»

+E [

(\

= Ç

W

= \

+X

¼

W

º

- \ SHQWUX FDUH VH FDOFXOHD] YDULD LD H[SOLFDW GH

)

- \

¹

Ü<

W

W

Ö =E

Ö +E [

M 0

T

\

\

T W

=E

+ + E

[

T

+X

TW

TW

Ü

9

Ü

9

Ã

X

N

N W

=E

+ + E

XQGHM

W = Q Q

[

N

+X

NW

NW

Ä

X

(

W

(

W

= Ç \

M 0

W

Ü 9

= Ç \

T

N

¾ ÂÀ

Ö -<

= Ç

)

T W

Ö -<

)

N W

(\ Á

¿

Ö -<

Á

¿ ¾

)

QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

«T«NN

QXP UXOREVHUYD LLORU

3HED]DDFHVWXLPRGHOVHSRWGHILQLXUP WRDUHOHQR LXQL D FRHILFLHQ LL GH SHUIRUPDQ

JOREDO DLXQXLPRGHOIRUPDWGLQ«T«NYDULDELOH

Å

H[SOLFDWLYHvQUDSRUWFXPRGHOXOLQL LDO0

5

Ç ÊÉÈ

5

=-

= -

Ì

9

È

9

Æ

X

9

M 5

9

Ç

ÇË

Í Ò Ñ Î

=-

=

9

Ð

ÍÏ Î

9

Í

M 5

=-

N

9

X

Ó

9

E FRHILFLHQ LLGHSHUIRUPDQ

5

ØÚÙ ßáÛ ß

= -

9

Ø

ÞÝ

SDU LDO DLXQXLPRGHO0

Þ Ø ÝàÜ ÞÝ

-9 9

Ø

= -

9

Ø

ÞÝ Øà Ü ÞÝ

9

ÔÖÕ×

ID

Ô

GH0

$FHDVW UHOD LH SRDWH IL IRORVLW vQ FD]XO UHJXOHL GH DFFHSWDUH D LQWURGXFHULL VDX H[FOXGHULL YDULDELOHL[

âäãæå

0

T

5

T

= -

9 9

X

ç

81

0

9DULDELOD[

âäãæå

T +

5

T +

=-

X

9

é

êè

HVWHVHPQLILFDWLY GDF 5

$FHDVW UHJXO DUH R GHILFLHQ

Ç

÷ öõ

W =

=

Q

Ç

W =

(<Ö W

Q

5

ëíì îï

> 5

î

ë

â 5

T +

> 5

â 9

T

ð óòôñ

<9

ð óò

GHRDUHFH D IRVW FRQVWUXLW SH ED]D UDSRUWXOXL GH FRUHOD LH 5

FDUHDIRVWFDOFXODWFXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

$FHVWD QX

9

(\

)

- \

W

Q

- \

)

Ç

=

(

W =

-

Q

Ç

W =

\

(\

W

)

- \

)

Ö -<

W

W

LQH VHDPD GH GRX QHDMXQVXUL FDUH DSDU vQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL PXOWLIDFWRULDO

UHVSHFWLY GH QXP UXO GH REVHUYD LL SH ED]D F URUD DX IRVW HVWLPD L SDUDPHWULL PRGHOXOXL úL GH QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUIDFWRULDOHDOHPRGHOXOXL 3HQWUX HOLPLQDUHD DFHVWRU YLFLL DOH UDSRUWXOXL GH FRUHOD LH FODVLF DFHVWD VH vQORFXLHúWH FX UDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LHDMXVWDWFRUHFWDW DF UXLUHOD LHGHFDOFXOHVWHXUP WRDUHD 5

ù

=

-

(

Q -

¢ - 5

Q - N

ø

)

2%6 1XP UXO REVHUYD LLORU WUHEXLH V ILH PDL PDUH GHFkW QXP UXO SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL Q Ë N +

'HDVHPHQHDVHREVHUY F vQFD]XOXQXLPRGHOXQLIDFWRULDON FRUHOD LHVXQWHJDOHÌQFD]XOvQFDUHN!Ü 5

D

>5

\

[

ú

FHOHGRX UDSRUWXULGH

2DOW SUREOHP FDUHVHULGLF HVWHDFHHDSULYLQGDOHJHUHDFHOXLPDLEXQPRGHOPXOWLIDFWRULDO GLQJUXSXOPRGHOHORUSRVLELOHFRQVWUXLWHvQIXQF LHGHIDFWRULLH[SOLFDWLYL 5H]ROYDUHD DFHVWHL SUREOHPH SHUPLWH DWkW DOHJHUHD FHOXL PDL EXQ PRGHO FkW úL HOLPLQDUHD LL

PXOWLFROLQLDULW

8QPRGHOPXOWLIDFWRULDOHVWHGHIRUPD

å

û

ü

I[ «[ «[ X

\

ü

3H ED]D FHORU [ YDULDELOH IDFWRULDOH VH SRW FRQVWUXL XUP WRDUHOH PRGHOH FDUDFWHUL]DWH SULQ

ÇX

VXPDS WUDWHORUDEDWHULORU 0 \

ýþ

(

VDXSULQUDSRUWXULOHGHFRUHOD LH 5

I[ X SX

0 \

5

I[ [ X SX

M

I[ «[ X SX

M

0 \

I[ «[ X SX

5

5

\

[

)

[

5

0 \

\

ÿ

ÌQ PRG ORJLF LQWURGXFHUHD XQHL YDULDELOH IDFWRULDOH vQWUXQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF HVWH MXVWLILFDW GDF

SX

-5

!SX

< 5

!

K!SX < K< 5

!

K!SX < K< 5

3H ED]D FHORU GRX UHOD LL DOHJHUHD FHOXL PDL EXQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF VH SRDWH IDFH SH ED]D XUP WRDUHORUUHVWULF LL ILH ILH

PLQ

Ç

PD[ 5

XQGHN

X

(

M

= N

)

QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[SOLFDWLYHH[RJHQH

82

$FHVWHGRX UHVWULF LLWUHEXLHFRPSOHWDWHGHXUP WRDUHOHFDOFXOH ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH GLIHUHQ HOH GLQWUH VXPHOH S WUDWHORU HURULORU VDX GLQWUH UDSRUWXULOH GH FRUHOD LH DMXVWDWH FRUHFWDWH D GRX PRGHOH FX XQ QXP U GLIHULW GH YDULDELOH H[RJHQH UHVSHFWLY 0

úL 0 T ¹ N N ! T QX VXQW HYLGHQWH DFFHSWDUHD XQXLD GLQWUH PRGHOH VH SRDWH UHDOL]D FX DMXWRUXO

WHVWXOXL)LVKHU±6QHGHFRUFDUHFRQVW vQYHULILFDUHDLQHJDOLW GDF )

9

=

$

-9

# &

# %

9

Q - N -

¢

N -T

" %

=

9

-9

" &

" %

9

LL Q - N -

¢

N -T

" %

Ë )

' !

!

UH]XOW F vQWUHFHOHGRX PRGHOHH[LVW GLIHUHQ HVHPQLILFDWLYHLDUFHOPDLEXQPRGHOYDILDOHVvQ FRQIRUPLWDWHFXUHVWULF LLOHPHQ LRQDWHDQWHULRU GDF )

< )

F

)

a Y

Y

DWXQFL GLIHUHQ HOH GLQWUH FHOH GRX PRGHOH QX VXQW VHPQLILFDWLYH

(

UH]XOW F VHDOHJHPRGHOXOFXQXP UXOGHYDULDELOHH[SOLFDWLYHFHOPDLPLF ÌQYHGHUHDDSOLF ULLDFHVWXLWHVWVHGHILQHVFXUP WRDUHOHP ULPL

+

0

9-

95

= Ç * / X

.

= Ç 2 7 X8

6

4

UHSUH]LQW VXPDS WUDWHORUHURULORUFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHPRGHOXOXL0

,

,

3

8

/0 8

UHSUH]LQW VXPDS WUDWHORUHURULORUFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHPRGHOXOXL0

4

W = Q Q M

9

QXP UXOREVHUYD LLORU QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

ÈTÈNN

Y :

1

N±TY;

QXP UXOJUDGHORUGHOLEHUWDWH

Q±N±Y : úLY;

ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF VH XWLOL]HD] vQ VSHFLDO OD SURJQR]D IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFHHVWHQHFHVDU YHULILFDUHDVWDELOLW

LLvQWLPSDOHJLW

LLGHHYROX LHDIHQRPHQXOXLDQDOL]DW

vQ IXQF LH GH HYROX LD IDFWRULORU V L $FHVW OXFUX VH SRDWH UHDOL]D FX DMXWRUXO WHVWXOXL &KRZ FDUH VH DSOLF DVWIHO ILHPRGHOXOXQLIDFWRULDOLQL LDO

DE[ <>= X <>= W = Q 9

\ <>=

?

X

Q

Ç

=

X

W

W =

SHFDUHvOvPS U LPvQGRX PRGHOH D : E : [ = X :>= W = Q

\ :>=

D; E; [ = X;B= W = Q

\;B=

Q

ÇX

W =

Q

Q

:

Q

;

Q

W

Q

F

Ç

=

X

W =

Q

ÇX

+

W

F

W = Q

9

+ Q 9

W

+

@

â9

X

X

X

Q

A

A

Ç

=

=9

W

W =

Q

D

X

=

W = Q

X

ÇX

F

C

W

+

+9

X

E

QXP UXOGHREVHUYD LL

7HVWDUHDLSRWH]HLGHVWDELOLWDWHFRQVW vQDOHJHUHDXQHLDGLQXUP WRDUHOHLSRWH]H

H

+G 'DF 9

J I

H

@9

UH]XOW F OHJLWDWHD GH HYROX LH D IHQRPHQXOXL HVWH VWDELO vQ WLPS

J

LDUPRGHOXOSRDWHILXWLOL]DWvQYHGHUHDHIHFWX ULLSURJQR]HL + K 'DF 9

H

J I

¹9

H

UH]XOW F OHJLWDWHDGHHYROX LHDIHQRPHQXOXLQXHVWHVWDELO vQWLPS

J

LDUPRGHOXOQXYDSXWHDILXWLOL]DWvQYHGHUHDHIHFWX ULLSURJQR]HL $SOLFDUHDWHVWXOXL)LVKHU6QHGHFRUFRQVW vQ

O

GDF )

S

=

9

R N 9

-9

O R

O

R

¢

Q - (N + ) N +

Ê )

T Q P

M QP L

83

VH DOHJH LSRWH]D +G vQ FD] FRQWUDU VH DOHJH LSRWH]D + K Y;

QXP UXO JUDGHORUGHOLEHUWDWHHVWHY :

N

QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

Q±N N

6LPXODUHúLSURJQR]

'DF vQ XUPD HWDSHL GH YHULILFDUH D VHPQLILFD LHL PRGHOXOXL DX IRVW VDWLVI FXWH FRQGL LLOH FHUXWHGHWHVWHOHúLLSRWH]HOHSUH]HQWDWHPDLVXVDWXQFLVHSRDWHDILUPDIDSWXOF PRGHOXOHVWHFRUHFW VSHFLILFDW LGHQWLILFDW úL HVWLPDW úL FD DWDUH SRDWH IL XWLOL]DW OD SURJQR]D úL VLPXODUHD IHQRPHQXOXL DQDOL]DW ÌQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO PXOWLIDFWRULDO GDF VH FXQRVF YDORULOH YDULDELOHORU IDFWRULDOH ;U SHQWUX PRPHQWXO QY SURJQR]D YDULDELOHL HQGRJHQH VH UHDOL]HD] SH ED]D XQXL LQWHUYDO GH vQFUHGHUH Ö GHRDUHFH < HVWH R YDULDELO DOHDWRDUH QRUPDO GH PHGLH <

V

Y\ Z

Ö <

[

W

X V

úL GH DEDWHUH PHGLH S WUDWLF

¢V

b a_ g f e

YH]LLSRWH]HOH+ K úL+] DOH0&003

[

Ö 3< i

d

-W

` h

¢V

^ ch

Ê \

b a_ g f e

Ö Ê< i

i ` h

d

+W

` h

^ ch

] = - a

XQGH \jlknm Ö -<

YDORDUHDUHDO DYDULDELOHL\vQPRPHQWXOGHSURJQR] Q + Y

o

= HVWLPD LDSXQFWXDO DYDORULLGHSURJQR] SHQWUXYDULDELOD\FDUHVHFDOFXOHD] FX

s prq

DMXWRUXOUHOD LHL Ö <w

y

x v

Ö = E

Ö + E

|

¢ [w

{

x v { u

Ö + E

z

¢ [w

x v z u

+

K + EÖ t

¢ [w

x v t u

6XEIRUP PDWULFHDO UHOD LDGHPDLVXVGHYLQH

XQGH » ª

Y

=

ª ª

[

ª

ª ª[ ½

~

}

} Ö } = ; ë % = ; ë ( ; ë;

)

(;

ë<

)

± ²

ª[ ;

Ö <

Q +Y

²

Q +Y

²

M Q +Y N

²

YHFWRUXO FRORDQ D YDORULORU GH SURJQR] DOH YDULDELOHORU

[ SHQWUX

² ² ² Õ

PRPHQWXO Q + Y W

m

YDULDELOD DOHDWRDUH 6WXGHQW VDX YDULDELOD QRUPDO ] GDF Q! SUHOXDW GLQ WDEHOXO

GLVWULEX LHLUHVSHFWLYHvQIXQF LHGHSUDJXOGHVHPQLILFD LHaúLGHQXP UXOJUDGHORUGHOLEHUWDWHY Q±N V

=

V

=

V

[

¢ + ;

(

¢ ;

;

)

¢;

] UHSUH]LQW

DEDWHUHD GH SURJQR]

DYDULDELOHLHQGRJHQH<FDUHH[SULP HURDUHDGHSUHYL]LXQH (URDUHD GH SUHYL]LXQH V

HVWH FX DWkW PDL PLF FX FkW QXP UXO GH REVHUYD LL YD IL PDL

PDUHFXFkWYDORULOHYDULDELOHORUvQPRPHQWXOGHSURJQR] QY YRUILPDLDSURSLDWHGHPHGLDORU FXFkWGLVSHUVLLOHYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH; YRUILPDLPDULúLFXFkWGLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHV

HVWHPDLPLF 'LVSHUVLD YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH V

YD IL FX DWkW PDL PLF FX FkW PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF YD

H[SOLFD R SDUWH WRW PDL PDUH GLQ YDULD LD YDULDELOHL SURJQR]DWH < VDX FX FkW UDSRUWXO GH FRUHOD LH 5

YDDYHDRYDORDUHPDLDSURSLDW GH

([HPSOXGHUH]ROYDUHDXQXLPRGHOOLQLDUPXOWLIDFWRULDO 8Q vQWUHSULQ] WRU FXPS U XQ PDJD]LQ DYkQG R VXSUDID

¡

GH P vQWUXQ FDUWLHU vQ FDUH

ORFXLHVF vQ MXU GH GH IDPLOLL 2 VRFLHWDWH GH FRQVXOWDQ

GH PDQDJHPHQW FRPHUFLDO vO

84

LQIRUPHD] F FLIUD GH DIDFHUL D PDJD]LQHORU FX SURILOXO UHVSHFWLY GHSLQGH OLQLDU GH VXSUDID D FRPHUFLDO D PDJD]LQXOXL úL GH QXP UXO IDPLOLLORU GLQ FDUWLHUXO UHVSHFWLY FDUH GH UHJXO FXPS U GHODPDJD]LQXOFHOPDLDSURSLDWÌQDFHVWVHQVvLSXQHODGLVSR]L LHLQIRUPD LLOHUHIHULWRDUHODDFHúWL LQGLFDWRULvQUHJLVWUDWHODPDJD]LQHDYkQGDFHODúLSURILO

7DEHOXO 1XP UGHIDPLOLLVXWH

¡

6XSUDID DFRPHUFLDO ]HFLP &LIUDGHDIDFHULPLOOHL

6HFHUH

D 3H ED]D GDWHORU SUREOHPHL

LQkQG FRQW GH VHPQLILFD LD HFRQRPLF D IHQRPHQHORU

REVHUYDWH V VH FRQVWUXLDVF PRGHOHOH HFRQRPHWULFHFXDMXWRUXOF URUDSRDWHILVWXGLDW GHSHQGHQ D GLQWUHIHQRPHQHOHUHVSHFWLYH

E 6 VHHVWLPH]HSDUDPHWULLPRGHOHORUFRQVWUXLWHODSXQFWXOD

F 'LQ FHOH WUHL PRGHOH XWLOL]DWH SHQWUX GHVFULHUHD GHSHQGHQ HL FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL GH FHL GRL

IDFWRULV VHDOHDJ FHOPDLEXQPRGHO

G 6 VH HVWLPH]H FLIUD GH DIDFHUL SH FDUH R SRDWH RE LQH vQWUHSULQ] WRUXO GDF YD FXPS UD

PDJD]LQXOUHVSHFWLY

H ùWLLQG F SHQWUX IXQF LRQDUHD PDJD]LQXOXL FKHOWXLHOLOH OXQDUH VXQW vQ MXU GH PLOOHL

HVWLPD LFDUHHVWHULVFXOFDvQWUHSULQ] WRUXOV RE LQ XQSURILWPDLPLFVDXHJDOFX

I 6 VH DUDWH úL DOWH PRGDOLW

L GH UH]ROYDUH D PRGHOXOXL PXOWLIDFWRULDO SH ED]D PDWULFHL

FRHILFLHQ LORUGHFRUHOD LHúLDPDWULFHLYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORU

5H]ROYDUH

D 'HVFULHUHD HFRQRPHWULF D OHJ WXULL GLQWUH FHOH WUHL YDULDELOH \ FLIUD GH DIDFHUL [ ¢

QXP UXOGHIDPLOLLúL [ £ VXSUDID DFRPHUFLDO VHSRDWHIDFHFXDMXWRUXODWUHLPRGHOH

\¤

= I

([¥ ¤ )

+ X¥

\¦

= I

([§ ¦ )

+ X§

0RGHOXO PXOWLIDFWRULDO \ ¨

= I

¨ [ª ¨ ) ( [ ©«

0RGHOXO XQLIDFWRULDO

QXP UXOXLGHIDPLOLL

0RGHOXO XQLIDFWRULDO

VXSUDIH HLFRPHUFLDOH

H[SOLF YDULD LD FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL SH VHDPD

¤

¦

H[SOLF YDULD LD FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL SH VHDPD

+ X¬

¨

H[SOLF YDULD LD FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL SH VHDPD

DPELORUIDFWRUL

,GHQWLILFDUHD IXQF LLORU GH UHJUHVLH D SULPHORU GRX PRGHOH VH UHDOL]HD] FX DMXWRUXO

UHSUH]HQW ULLJUDILFHDYDULDELOHL\vQIXQF LHGHFHOHODOWHGRX YDULDELOHIDFWRULDOH [ © UHVSHFWLY [ ª

½ ³´n ± ® ±²n ¯ ® ¯°n ®

¯B

±´

³n

µ²

®

¶´

·n

¸nº¹¼»

)LJXUD

85

È ÃÁ¾Á¾ Â ¿ ¾ Ân¾Á¾ À ¿ ¾ ÀB¾Á¾ ¿ ¾ ¾ ¾

ÀB¾ ¿

À ¿

Ân¾

Â ¿

ÃÁ¾

Ã ¿

Ä ¾ÆÅ´Ç

)LJXUD

'HRDUHFH JUDILFHOH GH PDL VXV DUDW F OHJ WXUD GLQWUH \ úL [ © UHVSHFWLY \ úL [ ª SRDWH IL DSUR[LPDW FXRGUHDSW PRGHOHOHGHPDLVXVGHYLQ

\ É

= DÊ

[Ê + E ÊË

\ Ì

=

+

\ Ï

= DÐ

0RGHOXO HVWH XQ PRGHO PXOWLIDFWRULDO OLQLDU GHRDUHFH \ ILLQG FRUHODW OLQLDU FX [ Ê

DÍ

+ XÊ

É

EÍÎ [Í Ì

+ EÐ [ Ò

Ï

+

É

XÍ Ì

+ FÐ [ Ñ

Ï

+ XÐ

Ï

UHVSHFWLYFX [ Í VHGHGXFHXúRUF YDILFRUHODWOLQLDUúLvQUDSRUWFXDPELLIDFWRUL

E (VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUFHORUWUHLPRGHOH

0RGHOHFRQRPHWULFSULYLQGGHSHQGHQ DGLQWUHFLIUDGHDIDFHULúLQXP UXOGHIDPLOLL

(VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL \ Ì

= DÊ

[Ê + E ÊË

Ì

+ XÊ

Ì

VH YD IDFH SH FX DMXWRUXO SDFKHWXOXL

GHSURJUDPH(;&(/ED]DXUP WRDUHORUVHULLVWDWLVWLFHSUH]HQWDWHvQ7DEHOXO 7DEHOXO 1U

[Ê

Ì

\Ó

FUW

<

Ô

=

+ [

ÕÔ

X×

Ö

= \Ö

- <Ö

ØÛ Ù X ÙÚ

(XÒ Ï

ÏÜ Ò - X ÒÚ

)

Ñ

XÞß

Ý

7RWDO

86

6800$5<287387 6HPQLILQG

5HJUHVVLRQ6WDWLVWLFV 0XOWLSOH5

56TXDUH

= 5

= 5á

= Vãä

$GMXVWHG

5

= 5

6TXDUH 6WDQGDUG(UURU 2EVHUYDWLRQV

à

à

âå

= Q

$129$ 5HJUHVVLRQ

GI

66

= N

=Q-N -

=Q-

5HVLGXDO

7RWDO

=

Ç ( <æ

=

Ç (\î

= Ç

- \)

(\ ö

- <î

)

- \

)

06

ç

õ

ï

=

= Vòó

ì Vèêë é ðñ ô

)

)í

9DULDEOH

&RHIILFLHQWV

WHUPHQOLEHU

Ö ÷ D

Ö E

[ÿ

6WDQGDUG(UURU

Vùú V

W6WDW

ø

W þ üý û

W

(VWLPDWRULLPRGHOXOXLVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHUL LGH]HURGDF

W

=

$

D V

Ë W

(

)

úL W

$

=

E V

'HRDUHFH

,

W

=

Ö D V

GH]HUR

W

]HUR

6

=

*+ '

Ö E V

"

=

.

45 1

=

= < W

= > W

Ë W

$ ) $&% ( "#"

/ 3 /&0 2 .#.

! (

)

=

=

-

SDUDPHWUXO D QXHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULW

$

7

Ö SDUDPHWUXO E HVWH VHPQLILFDWLY GLIHULW GH

7HVWXO)LVKHU6QHGHFRULQGLF IDSWXOF UH]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYHFXXQSUDJGH

=

VHPQLILFD LHGH )

= > )

9 < 9&: ; 8 ; 8#8 B B E @ C ?A@ C >

=

5DSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LHHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULWGH]HURGDF VHYHULILF UHOD LD

)

)

ÌQ IXQF LH GH XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a = úL GH QXP UXO JUDGHORU GH OLEHUWDWH

Y

G

= N = úL Y

H

D

F

=

(Q

- )

=

5

> )

- 5

-

=

= Q - N - = - = VHSUHLDYDORDUHDWHRUHWLF )

6H FRQVWDW F )

= > )

J M J&K L I L I#I

J M J&K L I L I#I

=

= GHFL SHQWUX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH GH

YDORDUHDUDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LHHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULW GH]HUR

ÌQ YHGHUHD YHULILF ULL LSRWH]HL GH LQGHSHQGHQ

D HURULORU VH FDOFXOHD] YDORDUHD YDULDELOHL

'XUELQ:DWVRQ

87

G =

=

3HQWUX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a = GLQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL 'XUELQ:DWVRQ VH SUHLDX

YDORULOHSHQWUXFD]XO Q = N = QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[SOLFDWLYH G

&XP - G

Q

= Ê G = Ê - G

QHJDWLY

P

3HED]DGDWHORUGHPDLVXVPRGHOXOGHYLQH

<

= + [

SR

5 =

G =

V

= úL G

O

=

= UH]XOW LQGHFL]LH WLQ]kQG VSUH DXWRFRUHODUH

SR

N

VU T

=

0RGHOHFRQRPHWULFSULYLQGGHSHQGHQ DGLQWUHFLIUDGHDIDFHULúLVXSUDID DFRPHUFLDO

(VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL \

VWDWLVWLFHSUH]HQWDWHvQ7DEHOXO

W

X

= D

XYX W

+ E [

+ X

XW

VH YD IDFH SH ED]D XUP WRDUHL VHULL

7DEHOXO

1U FUW

[

[Z

\

\

<

]

=

+ [

^]

X

_R

R R

= \ -<

X

[a\ b `

(X

cf

-X

c fe d c

)

X

hh g

Y

7RWDO

ÌQXUPDIRORVLULLSURJUDPXOXL(;&(/VDXRE LQXWXUP WRDUHOHUH]XOWDWH

6800$5<287387

6HPQLILQG

5HJUHVVLRQ6WDWLVWLFV 0XOWLSOH5

56TXDUH

= 5

= 5

$GMXVWHG

5

6TXDUH 6WDQGDUG(UURU 2EVHUYDWLRQV

i

= 5

=V

j

k

m n lo

= Q

88

$129$

GI

66

= N

=Q-N -

=Q-

5HJUHVVLRQ

5HVLGXDO

7RWDO

q

p

=

Ç (<

=

Ç (\

= Ç

(\

x

- \) - <

x

)

- \

)

v rtu s z | } {~

06

y

= V

=V

)

)

w

9DULDEOH

&RHIILFLHQWV

WHUPHQOLEHU

Ö D

Ö E

[

6WDQGDUG(UURU

V

V

W6WDW

W

W

'HRDUHFH W

W

Ö D

=

ª¬« ¥

V

=

Ö E

=

¤

¨© ¥ $®

=

V

= > W

= > W

=

¢ § ¢&£ ¦ ¡#¡

=

¯

$

UH]XOW F DPELL HVWLPDWRUL D a =

úL E VXQW VHPQLILFDWLY GLIHUL L GH ]HUR FX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH

7HVWXO)LVKHU6QHGHFRULQGLF IDSWXOF UH]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYHFXXQSUDJGH

µ

= > )

VHPQLILFD LHGH )

± ´ ±&² ³ ° ³ °#° ¶ ¶ ¹ ¼ ¹&º » ¸ » ¸#¸

=

6HYHULILF GHDVHPHQHDVHPQLILFD LDUDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LH

·

=

)

½

6H FRQVWDW F )

(Q

- )

5

=

- 5

= > )

-

=

= GHFL SHQWUX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH GH

YDORDUHDUDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LHHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULW GH]HUR

ÌQ YHGHUHD YHULILF ULL LSRWH]HL GH LQGHSHQGHQ

D HURULORU VH FDOFXOHD] YDORDUHD YDULDELOHL

'XUELQ:DWVRQ G =

=

3HQWUX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a = GLQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL 'XUELQ:DWVRQ VH SUHLDX

YDORULOHSHQWUXFD]XO Q = N = QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[SOLFDWLYH G

Á

= > G

À

=

ÅG &XP G ®

3HED]DGDWHORUGHPDLVXVPRGHOXOGHYLQH

<

ÃÂ

Á

= < - G

= + [

À

ÃÂ

=

¾

= úL G

¿

=

UH]XOW F HURULOHVXQWLQGHSHQGHQWH

5 =

G =

V

0RGHO HFRQRPHWULF PXOWLIDFWRULDO SULYLQG GHSHQGHQ D FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL GH VXSUDID D

ÆÅ Ä

=

FRPHUFLDO úLGHQXP UXOGHIDPLOLL

(VWLPDUHD

SDUDPHWULORU

HIHFWXDUHDXUP WRDUHORUFDOFXOH

XQXL

PRGHO

PXOWLIDFWRULDO

\

Ç

= D

È

È ÊÇ

+E [

È ÉÇ

+ F [

+X

ÈÇ

QHFHVLW

89

( Í Í Í )

Ö EÖ FÖ ) D

Ì Í Ï ÏË Ì(

Î Í ÎÏ )

RE LQHUHDVLVWHPXOXLGHHFXD LLQRUPDOHSULQDSOLFDUHD0&003FDUHFRQVW vQ Ö -D

= PLQ Ç \

Í ÌÏ

Í

Ö -E [

- FÖ [

0LQLPXO DFHVWHL IXQF LL HVWH GDW GH FDOFXOXO GHULYDWHORU SDU LDOH vQ UDSRUW FX SDUDPHWULL

PRGHOXOXL

Ð

ÓÐ ( Ó ×(× Û(Û

Ð ÒÓ Ö Ô× Ù ÚÛ

Ð ÑÓ ) Ö Õ × ) Ô× Ù ØÛ ) ØÛ

Ö ) ë(D

Ö ) ëE

) ë(FÖ

'XS HIHFWXDUHDFDOFXOHORUUH]XOW XUP WRUXOVLVWHPGHHFXD LL

Ö) Ù

(

Å QD Ö

)=

Ð

Ü Ç \

Ö -D

= Ü Ç \

Ö -D

)=

Þ

Þ

Þ

¿ Ö ¿D Ç [ ®

ßÜ

Ö -D

Ü Ç \

Þ

Ö +E Ç[

¿ ¿ Ö Ç[ D

Þ

ßÜ

- FÖ [

(- ) =

Ö -E [

- FÖ [

(-

[

Ö -E [

- FÖ [

(-

[

Ù

Þ ÝÜ Ü Ýß Ü Þ ß Ü Ý Ü ß Ü Ý Ü Þ ÝÝ Ü

+ FÖ

Ö +E Ç[

ÝÜ

Ö

Ö -E [

+ FÖ

Þ

Ö +E Ç[

= Ç\

Ç[

Ç[

+ FÖ

[

= Ç[

[

= Ç[

Ç[

ßÜ Ü ÝÜ Ü \

)=

)=

\

9DORULOH HVWLPDWRULORU UH]XOW vQ XUPD UH]ROY ULL VLVWHPXOXL GH HFXD LL DOH F UXL QHFXQRVFXWH

àáàáà

VXQW FHL WUHL SDUDPHWULL D E F LDU YDORULOH WHUPHQLORU VLVWHPXOXL GH HFXD LL VH RE LQ SH ED]D WDEHOXOXLFRORDQHOH

7DEHOXO 1U FUW

[

ãâ

æ

\

[

\

[

ê çèç

\

[

íïëìî ë [

ñò

[

ð

ôô

[

ó

<

õ

=

+ [

÷õ öõ

X

ùø

= \

ø

-<

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWUXOXL D

$

ú

Ö D

ý

=

Ç[

Ö D

ÿ

þ

\

\

Q

Ç[

üþ þ ûþ þ

Ç[

Ç\

é çèç

+ [

7RWDO

[

åä

Ç[

üþ

ûþ

ûþ ü Ç üþû û þ Ç þ ü û Ç ûþ Ç þ þ üû Ç û þ Ç þ ü Ç üþ û û þ Ç þ ü û Ç ûþ Ç þ þ Ç[ [

[

üû þ

Ç[ [

[

[

[

[

[

[

[

[

[

[

[

=

ø

=

90

Ö ÌQPRGDQDORJVHRE LQYDORULOHFHORUODO LGRLSDUDPHWULL E

2 FDOH PDL UDSLG GH HVWLPDUH D SDUDPHWULORU VH UHDOL]HD] XWLOL]kQG FDOFXOXO PDWULFHDO

Ö = úL F

=

VLVWHPXOGHHFXD LLGHPDLVXVGHYHQLQG

(;

ë; ) % =

$

(;

ë< )

ÌQPXO LQGODVWkQJDH[SUHVLDFX ( ; ë; )

( ; ë; )

Ö ( ; ë; )%

=

( ; ë; )

RE LQHP

( ; ë< )

5H]XOW F » D ±

$

% =

ª

$ $ E

²

=

ª ² ª ² ½ F Õ

(;

ë; )

(;

ë< )

$

XQGHPDWULFLOHVXQWGHIRUPD »

ª ª

ª

ª

ª

ª

ª ª ª

; =

ª ª ª ª

ª ª

ª

½

ª

ª ² ª

²

ª

² ²

ª ª

²

< =

ª

ª

²

ª

²

ª

ª

ª

² ²

8 =

²

ª

²

ª

²

²

ª

² ²

ª ª ª

²

ª ² ª

²

ª ª

²

ª ² ª ² ½ Õ

² Õ

ª ª

ª ²

²

ª ª

ª ²

²

ª

²

ª ²

²

ª

²

ª ²

² ² ²

Ö » X ª Ö ªX

» ± ª ²

² ²

ª

±

Ö

X

M M M M M M M M M

± ² ² ² ² ² ² ² ² ² ²

² ² ² ² ² ² ²

ª ² ª ² Ö X ½ Õ

6HFDOFXOHD] PDWULFLOH

( ; ë; ) =

» ª

ª ª ½

± ²

²

² Õ

( ; ë< ) =

; ë;

» ± ª ²

ª ² ª ² ½ Õ

=

(;

ë; )

=

»

-

- ª ª ½ -

ª

-

-± -

²

² ² Õ

91

( ; ë; )

(;

)

ª -

² Õ

- ± ²

- ²

ª - ½

- ²

-

-

= ª -

- ± ²

ª - ½

» ª

ë ;

=

-

» ª

-

² Õ

&DOFXOkQGSURGXVXO

( ; ë; ) ( ; ë< )

Ö % =

Ö ± »D » ± ª ² ª ² Ö = ª E ² = ª ²

9DORULOHWHRUHWLFHDOHFLIUHLGHDIDFHULUH]XOW GHFLGLQUHOD LD

&DOFXOXO FHORUODO L LQGLFDWRUL DL PRGHOXOXL PXOWLIDFWRULDO VH YD IDFH XWLOL]kQG XUP WRDUHOH

ª ² Ö F ½ Õ

ª ² ½ Õ

< = + [ + [

UHOD LL

V

UH]LGXDOHX$

F12

=

, -

(

V * +

Q - N -

(\ Ç

,) + ( + = V' + F . . %& )

=

!

Q - N -

HVWLPD LD GLVSHUVLHL s # " D YDULDELOHL

= HOHPHQWXOVLWXDWSHGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDO DPDWULFHLLQYHUVH ( ; ë; )

6

5 6

6

V ; 8 : 8 9 8 ( 7 7

)

= V< 8

Ç (<>

5 =

» ª

5

Ç ( \>

¢ª

=

- \)

=

=

G =

ÖE B Ç (X B ? D

- XÖ E B

A

@

C

)

Ç ( \>

- <>

)

- \)

=

»V; 8 ª 56

ª : ² = V 8 ª 56 ² ªV 9 8 Õ ½

3 4

± ²

² ² ² Õ

= UDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LH

D YDORDUHD YDULDELOHL 'XUELQ:DWVRQ FDOFXODW vQ YHGHUHD

D

WHVW ULLLSRWH]HLGHLQGHSHQGHQ

-

Ç ( \>

56

± ²

ª ½

- \)

E Ç XÖ B B ? C

)

Ö ÇX

HVWLPD LLOHGLVSHUVLLORUSDUDPHWULORU D /0 E /0 F / XQGH

A

-<

DHURULORU

9HULILFDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL DFHVWHLD VH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO WDEHOHL 'XUELQ:DWVRQ GLQ FDUH VH

H[WUDJ YDORULOH G F

= úL G G

= vQ IXQF LH GH XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a = GH QXP UXO

YDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH N = úLGHQXP UXOREVHUYD LLORU Q = (Q = )

5H]ROYDUHD PRGHOXOXL VD UHDOL]DW FX DMXWRUXO SURJUDPXOXL (;&(/ FRQGXFkQG OD DILúDUHD

XUP WRDUHORUUH]XOWDWH 6800$5<287387 6HPQLILQG

5HJUHVVLRQ6WDWLVWLFV 0XOWLSOH5

56TXDUH $GMXVWHG

5

= 5

= 5I

6TXDUH 6WDQGDUG(UURU 2EVHUYDWLRQV

= 5 H

H

= VJ K

= Q

92

$129$

66

5HJUHVVLRQ

GI

= N

Ö M -\ ) = Ç(\

5HVLGXDO

=Q-N -

7RWDO

=Q-

ÖU = Ç(\ U - \

= Ç(\ [

06

L

)S

VW = VX Y

T

)

Z

)

= VNPQ O

)

-\

R

9DULDEOH

&RHIILFLHQWV

6WDQGDUG(UURU

W6WDW

WHUPHQOLEHU

Ö \ D

V^_ ]

W c ab `

[ dfe

Ög E

Vij h

Wn lm k

[ope

Ö \ F

V rs q

W v tu h

9DULDEOH

0HDQYDOXH

6WDQGDUGGHYLDWLRQ

IDPLOLL

[w

s xfy

VXSUFRP

[

s {}|

&$

z

\

s ~

ÌQXUPDWHVW ULLVHPQLILFD LHLSDUDPHWULORUVDFRQVWDWDWF W

= < W = > W

= UH]XOW F SDUDPHWUXO D QXHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULWGH]HUR

$

$

= UH]XOW F SDUDPHWUXO E HVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULWGH]HUR

W

W

&RPSDUkQG YDORDUHD FDOFXODW D YDULDELOHL 'XUELQ:DWVRQ G ¡

= > W

WDEHODWH VH REVHUY F

G£

= UH]XOW F SDUDPHWUXO F HVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULWGH]HUR

$

= > G ¢

= úL

G¥

= < - G ¤

= FX FHOH GRX YDORUL = GHFL HURULOH VXQW

LQGHSHQGHQWH

'HRDUHFH

)¬

= > )§ « §ª ¨ © ¨ ¦§

= UH]XOW F YDORDUHD UDSRUWXOXL GH FRUHOD LH HVWH

VHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULW GH]HURFXXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LHGH

8WLOL]kQGHFXD LDDQDOL]HLYDULD LHL ®

Ç (\

- \)

=

Ç (\

- <

)

®

+

»

UH]XOW F PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF H[SOLF ª ª ½

Ç ( <

Ç (<°

Ç ( \°

- \)

¯

- \)

®

±

¯

- \)

² GLQ YDULD LD WRWDO D FLIUHL GH ² Õ

DIDFHUL

ÌQFRQFOX]LHSXWHPDILUPDF PRGHOXOHVWHFRUHFWVSHFLILFDWDGLF YDULDELOHOH [ ¦ ± úL [ ³ ² VXQW

IDFWRULVHPQLILFDWLYLDLFLIUHLGHDIDFHULGHRDUHFHHVWLPDWRULLORUVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHUL LGH]HURúL FRUHFWLGHQWLILFD LGHRDUHFHPRGHOXOH[SOLF FHDPDLPDUHSDUWHGLQYDULD LDFLIUHLGHDIDFHUL

$

'H DVHPHQHD UHOD LLOH

E¼

V· ´ ¾

> WÁ

µ

¸º ¹ ¿ ½ ¿À

$

F¼ V» ´ ¾

> WÁ

¶

¸º ¹ ¿ ½ LQGLF úL IDSWXO F FHOH GRX YDULDELOH [ ² ¿À

úL [ ³ ² QX VXQW FRUHODWH OLQLDU 'DF DFHVWHD DU IL IRVW FRUHODWH OLQLDU SXWHUQLF DWXQFL XQXO GLQWUH HVWLPDWRUL DU IL IRVW QHVHPQLILFDWLY FHHD FH vQVHDPQ F XQD GLQWUH FHOH GRX YDULDELOH WUHEXLH HOLPLQDW GLQPRGHO

93

$

3ULQ XWLOL]DUHD XQXL PRGHO OLQLDU PXOWLIDFWRULDO FHL GRL HVWLPDWRUL E Â úL F Ã UHSUH]LQW

FRHILFLHQ LL GH UHJUHVLH FRHILFLHQ LL PDUJLQDOL VDX

\

[ Ä

\

$

FHHD FH vQVHDPQ F OD R PRGLILFDUH

[ Å

GH D QXP UXOXL GH IDPLOLL FLIUD GH DIDFHUL D PDJD]LQXOXL YD VXIHUL R PRGLILFDUH GH Æ PLO OHL LDU GDF VXSUDID D FRPHUFLDO VH YD PRGLILFD FX P FLIUD GH DIDFHUL YD VXSRUWD R

PRGLILFDUHGHPLOOHL

&DDWDUHPRGHOXOFDUHGHVFULHOHJ WXUDGLQWUHIHQRPHQHOHDQDOL]DWHHVWH

<Ê Ç

G =

VÍ Ì Ë

= + [É Ç + [È Ç

5 =

=

F $OHJHUHD FHOXL PDL EXQ PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF GLQ FHOH WUHL PRGHOH DQDOL]DWH VH YD IDFH SH

ED]DWDEHOXOXLGHPDLMRVvQUDSRUWFXPRGHOXOLQL LDO 0 Î

7DEHOXO 6LPEROXO

9DULD LD

PRGHOXOXL

6WUXFWXUDPRGHOXOXL

QHH[SOLFDW GH

0Ï

(O

)

(O

= )

0ì

(O

= )

â

\à

\

í

= Dî

9æ ä

= \ + Xá

+ Eî [î

í

+ Xî

=

ï

9ó ñ

í

í

< ë = + [î

(O

= )

= Dÿ

\þ

<þ

ÿ

+ Eÿ [ÿ þ

0

(O

= )

\

<

= D

+ Xÿ þ

= + [ÿ þ

+ E [

+ F [

+ X

= + [

5Ô Ò Ñ

ç

â

Ç ( \å

=

9

+ [

=

- \)

Ç (\ ò

- <ò

(\

Ç

5è é è

)

)

=

Ç (\

- <

=

Õ×Ö 5Û Þ Ü Û

ç çê

Õ

9Ú Ù

= -

Ø

ÕÝ

9Ú Ù

)

ù×ú

5û ü

ù

=

= -

=

5ù ü û

=

9

= ô õ

5 ø

=

= ô õ 5ô ø = = -

9è

SDU LDO

Ó Ð

9Ñ

9ë

GHSHUIRUPDQ

=

5÷ ø

= -

-<

9

&RHILFLHQ LL

=

9

=-

ôöõ

ï

ð

=

= -

â

=

= 9ã

Ð

=

í

0ý

SHUIRUPDQ Ð

PRGHO

=

0ß

&RHILFLHQ LLGH

5

= -

=

5

= -

=

9

9 9

=

=

1RW

M = T N N = QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

W = Q Q = QXP UXOREVHUYD LLORU

O = P P = QXP UXOPRGHOHORUFRQVWUXLWH P =

ÌQFD]XOPRGHOHORUFXDFHODúLQXP UGHYDULDELOHH[RJHQHFHOPDLEXQHVWHGDWGHUHVWULF LD

PD[ 5

3H ED]D DFHVWXL FULWHULX VH REVHUY F 5

= > 5

= UHVSHFWLY PRGHOXO

94

0

!

H[SOLF PDL ELQH YDULD LD FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL \ vQ IXQF LH GH VXSUDID D FRPHUFLDO [

FRPSDUD LHFXPRGHOXO 0

#

$

"

vQ

FDUHXWLOL]HD] FDYDULDELO H[RJHQ QXP UXOGHIDPLOLL [

ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHVHFRPSDU GRX PRGHOHDOF URUQXP UGHYDULDELOHH[RJHQHHVWHGLIHULWGH

H[HPSOX PRGHOXO 0

%

FX 0

6QHGHFRU

DOHJHUHD FHOXL PDL EXQ PRGHO VH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO WHVWXOXL )LVKHU

8WLOL]DUHDDFHVWXLWHVWvQDFHVWFD]FRQVW vQ

FDOFXODUHDYDORULLHPSLULFHDYDULDELOHL )

'

.

9

3

(+

2 /0

-9

N - T

9

=

,

-9

N - T

=

)

(*

9

=

)

,

7 45

-9

2 /1 7 46

9

)*

Q - N - 9

2 /1

Q - N -

9

7 46

=

9

-,

-9

&,

)*

-9

-,

+9

, )+

N - T

9

, )*

Q - N -

)

)

SUHOXDUHD GLQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL )LVKHU6QHGHFRUDYDORULLWHRUHWLFHDYDULDELOHL)vQIXQF LH

8

-

,

- -

-

=

-

=

GHXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH a úLGHQXP UXOJUDGHORUGHOLEHUWDWH Y SHQWUX a = )

'HRDUHFH

< A @ ; @ ;=< I )

9

= N - T Y

:

= Q - N - UHVSHFWLY

=

C H CGF EBE BDC

= > )

FUHúWH JUDGXO GH SHUIRUPDQ

= SULQ LQWURGXFHUHD YDULDELOHL

DO DFHVWXL PRGHO vQ UDSRUW FX PRGHOXO 0

B

[ vQ PRGHOXO

0

vQ DFHODúL WLPS LQIOXHQ D

DFHVWHLYDULDELOHDVXSUDYDULDELOHL\HVWHVHPQLILFDWLY

&DDWDUHPRGHOXOFDUHH[SOLF FHOPDLELQHYDULD LDFLIUHLGHDIDFHULHVWHPRGHOXO 0

< = + [

G =

V

LJ

J

+ [

KJ

5 =

ON M

=

G 'HRDUHFH VD FRQVWDWDW F PRGHOXO 0

H[SOLF FHO PDL ELQH YDULD LD FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL

DFHVWD YD IL XWLOL]DW vQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL YDORULORU SUREDELOH DOH FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL SHQWUX vQWUHSULQ] WRUXO UHVSHFWLY ÌQ DFHVW FD] GDF [ HJDO FX

V QSU R

<

$X

= D [

QTU R W Y

$X

+ E [

QTU R W Z

= [

$X

+ F [

B

= [

QTU R W [

P

= vQ PHGLH FLIUD GH DIDFHUL HVWH

XQGH

<

= HVWLPD LDSXQFWXDO DYDORULLGHSURJQR] SHQWUXYDULDELOD\

\

= YDORDUHDUHDO DYDULDELOHL\vQPRPHQWXOGHSURJQR] Q + Y

6XEIRUP PDWULFHDO UHOD LDDQWHULRDU GHYLQH

XQGH

C

_ \T^ ] `Tb a

f cTe d

;

m

<

» ª

n i m kl n i m kj

=ª [ ª ½

o

[

d

d

= ; ë % = ; ë ( ; ë; )

$

gh

; ë<

± ²

² UHSUH]LQW PDWULFHD FRORDQ D YDORULORU GH SURJQR] DOH YDULDELOHORU ² Õ

[ M = SHQWUXPRPHQWXO Q + Y

p t qsr

<

= + + = PLOOHL

95

ÌQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL LQWHUYDOXOXL GH vQFUHGHUH SHQWUX DFHDVW YDORDUH SUREDELO HVWH QHFHVDU

FDOFXODUHDGLVSHUVLHLDFHVWHLYDORULFXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

V

V

V

~ u xz| { y

= V

v

~

[ +

w

; ë ( ; ë; )

«

Ã = + ( Ã

=

}

;

w]

)ª -

ª - ½

Ã ¬

- ±» ± á ²ª ²³ - ²ª ² = ³

-

» ª

-

²ª ² ³ Õ½ Õã

,QWHUYDOXO GH vQFUHGHUH D SURJQR]HL FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL HVWLPDW FX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH

a = SHQWUXFDUHYDORDUHDOXL W

YDFDOFXODFXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

[

? =

SUHOXDW GLQWDEHODGLVWULEX LHL6WXGHQWHVWH W

-W V

Ê \

]

Ê<

+W V

= VH

=-a

ÌQFRQFOX]LHFXXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LHGHFLIUDGHDIDFHULDvQWUHSULQ] WRUXOXLUHVSHFWLY

3<

3 [ - Ê \ 3[ Ê \

Ê + ] = - =

Ê ] =

YDILFXSULQV vQWUHúLPLOLRDQHOHL

( U ) HVWHHJDO

H ùWLLQGF UDWDSURILWXOXL

XQGH

&$ = FLIUDGHDIDFHUL\

&7 = FKHOWXLHOLWRWDOH

3H ED]D GDWHORU SUREOHPHL UH]XOW F DQWUHSUHQRUXO SHQWUX D RE LQH XQ SURILW PDL PLF VDX

HJDO

FX

U

(

)

WUHEXLH

&$ = ( + ) =

=

&$ - &7 &7

V

FX

(

UHDOL]H]H

8WLOL]kQGPRGHOXOHFRQRPHWULF 0

R

FLIU

GH

DIDFHUL

GH

FHO

PXOW

)

PLO

OHL

UH]XOW F FLIUDGHDIDFHULDDFHVWRUPDJD]LQHXUPHD] R

GLVWULEX LHQRUPDO GHPHGLH < = PLOOHLúLGHDEDWHUHPHGLHS WUDWLF V DWDUH

Ü &$ = U &7 + &7 Ü &$ = &7 + U

¡

= PLOOHLúLFD

- < () ± » 3 (< Ê ) = 3ª W Ê ² = 3 (W Ê -) = 3 (W Ë ) = ½ Õ ÌQ FRQFOX]LH DQWUHSUHQRUXO DUH úDQVH GH D QX UHDOL]D XQ SURILW GH DFHDVWD

UHSUH]HQWkQG ULVFXO V X GH D QXúL UHDOL]D GH]LGHUDWXO SURSXV vQ XUPD FXPS U ULL PDJD]LQXOXL UHVSHFWLY

I (VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF PXOWLIDFWRULDO OLQLDU SH ED]D PDWULFHL

YDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORUúLDPDWULFHLFRHILFLHQ LORUGHFRUHOD LHOLQLDU VLPSOL

)LHPRGHOXO

6HvQVXPHD] úLVHvPSDUWHODQRE LQkQGXVHHFXD LD

6HVFDGHHFXD LD GLQ úLUH]XOW

1RW PFX

¢

\

= E

\ = E

\

\

[

[

«

°± ³´ ² ¶· µ

¥

¤ ¤¢

¦

§¨§

= [

°

³² ¶µ

= [

+E [

©ª©

+ E [

- \ = E

= \

£ £¢

+E [

+ E [

¬ ( ¬« [

- [

¬)

¢

+X

+ E

®¯ ( ® « [

- [

®

)

«

+ X

- \

³

- [ - [

¶

96

0RGHOXO FRQVWUXLWSHED]DDEDWHULORUFHQWUDWHDOHYDULDELOHORUGHYLQH \

¹

¹ » »¸

¹ º º¸

= E [

¸

+E [

+X

ÌQDFHVWFD]PDWULFHDYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORUPRGHOXOXLVHGHILQHúWHDVWIHO

» ª

s

¼

ª

XQGH

¼ ÁÂÁ

½)

¼

FRY( \[

½

¼

FRY( \[

À ¿À ¿ ( ¼ ½ )

9 = ª FRY( [ \ )

s

FRY ( [ \ )

½

¸

½ ¼ ¼ À ¾À ¾

FRY( [ [

FRY [ [

s

)± ²

)² ² Õ

ÆÂÇ

s

Ã

È Å Ä ÇÆ ( ) ÄÉ ÐDÑ Ï Ò ÊË Ç ÊÎ Ð ( ) \

Å

=

HVWHGLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHL\

Q

[

Ò GÌ Í

=

s

FRY \ [

Q

(

Õ

Ç(\

)=

Ú

(

Ö

- \) [

ÖÕ

- [

)

Q

[

=

[

=

\

=

Ù

ÓÔ Ø×ÖÕØ Ö×

HVWHGLVSHUVLDYDULDELOHL [

=

Ç

\

Q

[

M =

7DEHOXO 1U

[

FUW

Ý ÜÛ

= [

ÜÛ

à ßÞ

Ü

- [ [

= [

ßÞ

- [

ß

\

á

â

= \

á

- \

[

æçæ å ãäã \

[

ëéë êé èéê è \

[

ñòñ îð ìíï ì [

7RWDO

s

s

s

ï óÂó õ

÷ ö÷ ö ú ü ûü û

= (s

ó

ï

)

ï

=

(

õ ÷ö)

(

üû

= s

= s

=

ú

=

)

=

ú

õ

=

=

ô

FRY( \[

FRY( [ [

FRY( \[

)=

ù ø ý)

)= =

=

=

=

97

» ª

9 = ª

± ²

ª ½

²

² Õ

Ö 'LVSXQkQGGHPDWULFHD9HVWLPDWRULL E

XQGH

Ö E

9

Ö = E

=

9

(- )

Ö = E

ÿþ

VHFDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

M = N

9

= GHWHUPLQDQWXOPDWULFHLYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULDQ HORUGLQFDUHVHHOLPLQ OLQLD\

úLFRORDQD [

9

= GHWHUPLQDQWXO PDWULFHL YDULDQ HORU úL FRYDULDQ HORU GLQ FDUH VH HOLPLQ OLQLD \

úLFRORDQD\

(- )

Ö E =

Ö E

(- )

=

=

= -

=

-

=

(VWLPDWRUXO E VHFDOFXOHD] GLQUHOD LD

Ö E

Ö Ö = \ - E [ - E [

Ö E

=

0DWULFHD FRHILFLHQ LORU GH FRUHOD LH OLQLDU VLPSO D YDULDELOHORU SH ED]D UHOD LHL VH

$

Ö Ü E

= - -

GHILQHúWH »

U !

5 = ª U!

ª

ª ½ U "

XQGH

U+ & * & -,

=

» ª

Ç

%

\ ( [()

Ç

Ç

(\ (

5 = ª ª ½

² Õ

! U "$

=

²

" ² U!#

%

Qs + & s * & ,

±

U "

%

%

\ ( [ ()

'

%

) Ç

([ ( ) %

)

² FDOFXODW FXDMXWRUXOSURJUDPXOXL(;&(/

² Õ

$

&XDMXWRUXODFHVWHLPDWULFLHVWLPDWRULL E/1. 0 3

$

E574 6 9

XQGH

5 => <

5 @@

$

= E8

=

± ²

'

( -)

8 : ;

556 9

s 5

555

s 6 9

$

= E2 VHSRWFDOFXODDVWIHO

= GHWHUPLQDQWXOPDWULFHL5GLQFDUHVDHOLPLQDWOLQLD\úLFRORDQD [ ? = GHWHUPLQDQWXOPDWULFHL5GLQFDUHVDHOLPLQDWOLQLD\úLFRORDQD\

98

Ö EB =

(- )A

=

Ö ED

=

C

(- )

=

ÌQPRGDQDORJHVWLPDWRUXO E E VHFDOFXOHD] GLQUHOD LD

1RW &D XUPDUH D QXPHURDVHORU vQPXO LUL úL URWXQMLUL DX DS UXW PLFL DEDWHUL vQWUH YDORULOH

$

ÖF E

=

HVWLPDWRULORURE LQX LODSXQFWXOE vQFRPSDUD LHFXFHOHRE LQXWHODSXQFWXOI

%,%/,2*5$),(

%DOWDJL%(FRQRPHWULFV6SULQJHU%HUOLQ *LUDXG5&KDL[1eFRQRPpWULH38)3DULV *UHHQH+:(FRQRPHWULF$QDO\VLV0DFPLOODQ3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\1HZ
GIH

HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
*XMDUDWL51(VVHQWLDOVRI(FRQRPHWULFV0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
GIH

HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
/DEURXVVH&,QWURGXFWLRQDO¶pFRQRPpWULH'XQRG3DULV 0DGGDOD*6,QWURGXFWLRQWR(FRQRPHWULFV

GIH

HG0F0LOODQ&R1HZ
3LQG\FN 5 6 5XELQIHOG ' 6 (FRQRPHWULF 0RGHOV DQG (FRQRPLF )RUHFDVWV

JKH

HG 0F

*UDZ+LOO1HZ
99

&DSLWROXO9 0RGDOLW

LGHLQFOXGHUHDYDULDELOHORUFDOLWDWLYHvQPRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF

([LVW vQ HFRQRPLH R FODV GH YDULDELOH GH LPSRUWDQ vQVXúLULFDOLW

GHORF QHJOLMDELO FDUH VH UHIHU OD

LúLFDWHJRULLHWFDF URUGLPHQVLXQHVHH[SULP SULQDWULEXWHVDXGHQXPLULFHSULYHVF

FDWHJRULLOH FODVHOH VLWXD LLOH (OH VXQW GHQXPLWH YDULDELOH &$/,7$7,9( VDX YDULDELOH DWULEXWLYH ,QWHUHVHD] FXGHRVHELUHYDULDELOHOHFDX]DOHGHQDWXU FDOLWDWLY 'DF GHH[HPSOXQHUHIHULPILHúLQXPDLODFHLGRLSROLDLHFRQRPLHLúLDQXPHODFHUHUHúL RIHUW vQWkOQLP GHVWXOH YDULDELOH FDOLWDWLYH FX LQIOXHQ H VHPQLILFDWLYH $VWIHO FHUHUHD HVWH FRQGL LRQDW QX QXPDL GH P ULPHD YHQLWXOXL SUH XOXL HWF FL úL GH JUDGXO vQ FDUHSURGXVXOVDWLVIDFH FXPS U WRUXO GRULQ D GH RULJLQDOLWDWH VDX GH D IL OD PRG D DFHVWXLD JUDGXO GH FRQúWLLQ

LQWHQVLWDWHDVHQWLPHQWXOXLUHOLJLRVHWF ÌQFHSULYHúWHRIHUWDúLSURGXF LDFDUHVWDXODED]DDFHVWHLDHDGHSLQGHGHYDULDELOHQXPHULFH FDSLWDO QXP U GH VDODULD L HWF GDU úL GH JUDGXO GH RUJDQL]DUH D SURGXF LHL SROLWLFD GH VWLPXODUH JUDGXOGHSUHJ WLUHDOVDODULD LORUFDOLILFDUHD FDSDFLWDWHDORUFUHDWLY FOLPDWXOVRFLDOHWF 3UREOHPD FDUH VH SXQH FHO SX LQ SHQWUX HFRQRPHWULFLDQ HVWH GH D H[SULPD QXPHULF QLYHOXO XQRU DVWIHO GH YDULDELOH PDL DOHV GDF UROXO ORU HVWH LPSRUWDQW VDX GDF HIHFWHOH GH QDWXU FDOLWDWLY SUH]LQW LQWHUHV 'H vQGDW FH SUREOHPD P VXU ULL HVWH VROX LRQDW VH GHVFKLGH SRVLELOLWDWHD LQWURGXFHULL YDULDELOHORU FDOLWDWLYH vQ PRGHOH GH QDWXU FDQWLWDWLY FHHD FH DU FRQWULEXL VXEVWDQ LDO OD UHGXFHUHD JUDGXOXL GH QHGHWHUPLQDUH úL GHFL OD R PDL FRPSOHW H[SOLFD LH D HYROX LHL IHQRPHQHORU GLQ HFRQRPLH ÌQ FHOH FH XUPHD] QH YRP UHIHUL OD SRVLELOLW

LOH GH P VXUDUH D YDULDELOHORU FDOLWDWLYH vQ

YDULDQWHOHvQWkOQLWHSkQ vQSUH]HQWvQOLWHUDWXUDGHVSHFLDOLWDWH $ ([SULPDUHDYDULDELOHLFDOLWDWLYHvQPRGLQGLUHFWSULQLQWHUPHGLXOXQHLYDULDELOHQXPHULFH UHSUH]HQWDWLYHVDXFXFDUHHVWHLQWHQVFRUHODW 3UH]HQW P R VXLW GH VLWXD LL GHVSULQVH GLQ DQDOL]D XQRU PRGHOH FRQFUHWH vQ FDUH VD DSHODW ODDFHDVW PRGDOLWDWHGHH[SULPDUHDFDOLW

LL

7DEHOXO 9DULDELODFDOLWDWLY

9DULDELODQXPHULF XWLOL]DW

6WLPXODUHDVDODULD LORU

FXDQWXPXOVSRUXULORUGHVDODULL

3ROXDUHDDWPRVIHUHL

FDQWLWDWHDGHVXOID LvQDHU

2UJDQL]DUHDSURGXF LHL

UDWDXWLOL] ULLWLPSXOXLGHPXQF

3UHJ WLUHDSURIHVLRQDO

QXP UGHDQLGHúFRDO DEVROYL L

(GXFD LDIHPHLLvQVRFLHWDWH

SRQGHUHDSRSXOD LHLIHPLQLQHDQDOIDEHWH

3URJUHVXOWHKQLF

WLPSXO P VXUDW SULQ QXP UXO GH DQL FDUH QH GHVSDUWGHXQÄDQGHED] ´

$FHDVW PHWRG GH HYDOXDUH IUHFYHQW XWLOL]DW SUHVXSXQH vQORFXLUHD YDULDELOHL FDOLWDWLYH SULQWUR YDULDELO UHSUH]HQWDQW 'H H[HPSOX GDF DGPLWHP F SURGXFWLYLWDWHD PXQFLL vQ LQGXVWULD PRELOHL HVWH GHSHQGHQW GH FDOLILFDUHD VDODULD LORU úL GH YROXPXO IRQGXULORU IL[H PRGHUQH DWXQFL SHQWUX D LQWURGXFH vQ PRGHO SULPD YDULDELO FDX]DO FDUH HVWH GH QDWXU FDOLWDWLY DSHO P OD R YDULDELO QXPHULF ÄGHUHSUH]HQWDUH´úLDQXPHODÄYHFKLPHDvQPHVHULH´'HVLJXUF vQWUHP LHVWULD SULFHSHUHD PXQFLWRULORU úL QXP UXO GH DQL GH YHFKLPH SRW H[LVWD GLVFRUGDQ H úL FD XUPDUH R YDULDELO UH]LGXDO WUHEXLH DYXW vQ YHGHUH 'DU vQWUH YDULDQWD FDUH DU SUHVXSXQH H[FOXGHUHD YDULDELOHL FDOLWDWLYH úL PHQ LQHUHD XQXL VLQJXU IDFWRU YROXPXO IRQGXULORU IL[H úL YDULDQWD FDUH LQFOXGH YDULDELOD ÄFDOLILFDUH´ SULQ LQWURGXFHUHD YDULDELOHLUHSUH]HQWDQW YHFKLPHD vQ PHVHULH HVWH

100

GH SUHIHUDW FHD GHD GRXD YDULDQW $FHDVWD SHQWUX F vQ SULPD YDULDQW XQLIDFWRULDO HVWLPDWRUXO SDUDPHWUXOXL Äk ´ GLQ PRGHOXO 3URGXFWLYLWDWH

k k )RQGXUL )L[H HVWH LQFRQVLVWHQW úL SDU LDO

GLVWRUVLRQDW LDU vQ FHD GH D GRXD YDULDQW vQ FDUH 3URGXFWLYLWDWH

k k 9HFKLPHk )RQGXUL

)L[H HVWLPD LLOH SDUDPHWULORU VXQW FRQVLVWHQWH PRGHOXO QHLQFOX]kQG R HURDUH LPSRUWDQW GH VSHFLILFDUHDEVHQ DXQXLIDFWRUVHPQLILFDWLY ÌQWUXFkWDFHDVW FDOLWDWHDHVWLPDWRULORUQHLQWHUHVHD] FX GHRVHELUH UH]XOW F GHFkW V RPLWHP R YDULDELO FDX]DO LPSRUWDQW SH PRWLY F HVWH QHFXDQWLILFDELO PDL LQGLFDW HVWH V R OX P vQ FDOFXO ILH úL SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO XQHL YDULDELOH UHSUH]HQWDQWFKLDUGDF DOHJHUHDDFHVWHLDGLQXUP YDULDELOHHVWHGLVFXWDELO % ([SULPDUHDQXPHULF DYDULDELOHORUGLFKRWRPLFH ([LVWHQ DXQHLYDULDELOHFDUHVHSRDWHSUH]HQWDGRDUVXEGRX DVSHFWHFDUHVHH[FOXGUHFLSURF SULYLQGH[LVWHQ DQRQH[LVWHQ DDFFHSWDUHDUHIX]XOXUEDQUXUDOPDVFXOLQIHPLQLQHWFIDFHSRVLELO WUDQVIHUDUHD vQ VSD LXO QXPHULF SULQ DWULEXLUHD P ULPLL SHQWUX XQD GLQWUH DOWHUQDWLYH úL SHQWUX FHDODOW DOWHUQDWLY 'HRVHELPXUP WRDUHOHVLWXD LL % &D]XOXQLIDFWRULDOvQFDUHIDFWRUXO[HVWHGHQDWXU ELQDU 'HH[HPSOXvQPRGHOXOOLQLDU \Ö

XQGH

k k [

\

LQYHVWL LL

[

IRUPDGHSURSULHWDWHFXDOWHUQDWLYHOHSURSULHWDWHGHVWDW SURSULHWDWHSULYDW

(VWLPDWRULLSDUDPHWULORUVHRE LQXWLOL]kQGIRUPXOHOHRELúQXLWH úL Ö D

Ö [ = \ -D

Ç [ Ö D

L

=

- [ \

L

Ç [ L

Å - GDF FXPHQ LXQHDF - GDF ®

- \

L

- [

L

Ö [ = ÜD

= \

Ö [ =Ü D

Ö +D

[ =

= \

[ =

'HFL Ö D

= \

-D Ö = \ - \

ÌQWUDGHY UGDF VLPEROL] PFX 0\ [

0\ [

\

D D

\

LDUSHQWUXYDULDELODELQDU [

Ç[ = Ç[

Ç \ = Q \ Ç [\

= Q

\

= Q + Q

\

$WXQFL

Ö D

RSHUDWRUXO

Ç

=

Ç \ - \ [ - [ Ç [ - [

=

Ç [

- [ [ + [

vQ FDUH LQWURGXFkQG vQ SDUDQWH]H

úLvPS U LQGWRWXOODQúL LQkQGVHDPDGHHJDOLW

GLFKRWRPLFHGDUúLGHIDSWXOF \ = Ö D

- [ \ - [ \ + [\

Ç [\

= \

Ç \ Q

[ =

Ç [ Q

LOHDQWHULRDUHVSHFLILFHYDULDELOHL

DMXQJHPODUHOD LLOH

- \

101

Ö D

Ö 'DF D

= \

Ö = \ -D

- \

Ç\

¢[ =

Q

- \

- \ ¢

Q Q

= \

Ö GHFXUJH OD IHO FD vQ FD]XO DWXQFL WHVWDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL HVWLPDWRUXOXL D

YHULILF ULLVHPQLILFD LHLGLIHUHQ HLGLQWUHGRX PHGLLDGLF W

\

=

FDOF

- \

s

Q

+

s

Q

% &D]XOPXOWLIDFWRULDOvQFDUHYDULDELOHOHH[SOLFDWLYHVXQWELQDUH 'HH[HPSOXvQFD]XOPRGHOXOXLOLQLDU Ö \ = D

Ö [ + D Ö ] +D

XQGH \

YHQLWXOQD LRQDO

[

WLSXOGHHFRQRPLHFHQWUDOL]DWSODQLILFDW

]

VWDUHDGHSDFH

GHSLD

GHU ]ERL 3URFHGkQG VLPLODU FD]XOXL DQWHULRU % DMXQJHP OD XUP WRDUHOH UHOD LL SHQWUX HVWLPDWRUL vQ UDSRUWFXPHGLLOHYDULDELOHLHIHFWRE LQXWHSHQWUXGLYHUVHFRPELQD LLGHVLWXD LL Ö =D

\

\

= D Ö

Ö + D

\

Ö =D

Ö + D

'DF QRW PFX \

\ \ FHOHWUHLVLWXD LLGHPDLVXVvQRUGLQHDSUH]HQW ULLUH]XOW F Ö D

Ö D

D

= \

= \ = \

- \ - \

%! &D]XOvQFDUHPRGHOXOLQFOXGHXQIDFWRUFDOLWDWLYúLXQIDFWRUQXPHULF 'HH[HPSOXvQFDGUXOPRGHOXOXL Ö \ =D

Ö [ +D Ö ] + D

XQGH \

FHUHUHDGHVHUYLFLL

[

YHQLW

]

PHGLXOXUEDQ UXUDO

ÌQDFHVWFD] SHQWUX ] = Ü \ = D

+ D [ + X

SHQWUX ] = Ü \ = D $

+ D# [ + D "

+ X"

= D$

+ D " + D# [ + X "

FHHDFHSUHVXSXQHFDvQWUHFHOHGRX VLWXD LLV DSDU GHRVHELULGRDUvQFHSULYHúWHSUDJXOGHSRUQLUH Ö % LDU FHO GHDO GRLOHD HVWH D Ö vQ VHQVXO F vQ SULPXO FD] DFHVWD HVWH D

Ö + D

SDQWD P VXUDW GH

Ö ILLQGDFHHDúL*UDILFVLWXD LDHVWHLOXVWUDW GHGRX GUHSWHSDUDOHOH SDUDPHWUX D 'DF VH FRQVLGHU F YDULDELOD FDOLWDWLY PHGLXO ] LQIOXHQ HD] SDQWD OLQLHL GH UHJUHVLH SRDWHILDFFHSWDW YDULDQWD \

D & D ' [D( ]E[]X

&D]vQFDUH SHQWUX]

Í\

D & D ' [X

102

SHQWUX]

D & D( D ' E [X

Í\

&RPSDUD LD GLQWUH VLWXD LD vQ FDUH ] SRUQLUHGLIHULWD & GDF ]

ab[X

úL VLWXD LD vQ FDUH ]

D & D( GDF ]

HYLGHQ LD] DWkW QLYHOXO GH

FkWúLIDSWXOF GUHSWHOHDXSDQWHGLIHULWHD ' ¹b

QHUHSHWkQGXVHVLWXD LDGHSDUDOHOLVPDQWHULRU 2 PRGDOLWDWH GH YHULILFDUH JOREDO D PRGHOXOXL vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH DO WXUL GH R YDULDELO H[SOLFDWLY QXPHULF UHJ VLPXQDVDXPDLPXOWHYDULDELOHELQDUHSRDWHXUPDHWDSHOHWHVWXOXL)FD] vQFDUH) )+*-,

)/. UH]XOW DVWIHO

ÇX [

V

=

)

FDOF

- ÇX [

ÇX [

V

Ë )

a V Q - N

V

Q - N

XQGH

ÇX [

0

ÇX 3

VXPDS WUDWHORUHURULORUvQYDULDQWD\

12

I[

VXPD S WUDWHORU vQ YDULDQWD vQ FDUH LQFOXGHP DO WXUL GH [ úL R

YDULDELO YDULDELOHELQDUH QXP UXOGHYDULDELOHELQDUHLQWURGXVH

V

QXP UXOGHFD]XULPLQXVQXP UXOGHSDUDPHWUL

Q±N

%4 &D]XOvQFDUHYDULDELODHIHFWHVWHGHQDWXU ELQDU 'HH[HPSOXvQPRGHOXO Ö \Ö = D

Ö [ + D

XQGH \ [

vQ]HVWUDUHDIDPLOLHLFXXQDXWRWXULVP YHQLWXO

ÌQDFHVWFD]GHRVHELPVLWXD LLOH SHQWUX\ SHQWUX \

IDPLOLDQXSRVHG DXWRWXULVPUH]XOW F D & D ' [ IDPLOLD SRVHG DXWRWXULVP UH]XOW F O D &

D ' [

X XFHHDFHLPSOLF

KHWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWHD SHUWXUED LHL OD FDUH VH DGDXJ IDSWXO F UHSDUWL LD DFHVWHLD QX HVWH QRUPDO &D XUPDUH HVWLPD LLOH SHQWUX SDUDPHWULL FX GHRVHELUH SHQWUX HúDQWLRDQH PLFL VH VLWXHD] vQ DIDUD SRVLELOLW

LORUGHWHVWDUHRELúQXLW

0RGHOXO H[SULP YDULDELOD GLFKRWRPLF \ FD R IXQF LH OLQLDU GH [ DúD vQFkW 0\ 5 [ 5 UHSUH]LQW PHGLD YDULDELOHL DOHDWRDUH \ 5 FRQGL LRQDW GH [ 5 $úDGDU 3\

[ 5 UHSUH]LQW

SUREDELOLWDWHD SHQWUX H[HPSOXO FRQVLGHUDW FD IDPLOLD ÄL´ V SRVHGH DXWRWXULVP vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH GLVSXQH 0

(\

L

[

GH L

)

Ö =D

YHQLWXO

Ö [ +D

SUREDELOLWDWHD FD \

L

[ 5

$FFHSWkQG

LSRWH]D

vQ FDUH GDF QRW P FX 3 5

IUHFYHQW

LQYRFDW

SUREDELOLWDWHD FD \

0X 5

RE LQHP

úL FX 3 5

SXWHP FRQVHPQD SHQWUX YDULDELOD GLFKRWRPLF \ XUP WRDUHD GLVWULEX LH úL

QLYHOHX 5 FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH \ 5

vQ±3 5 FD]XULFXX 5

\ 5

vQ3 5 FD]XULFXX 5

D & ±D ' [

±D & ±D ' [

'HUH LQXWIDSWXOF X 5 SUH]LQW GRDUGRX YDORULXUPkQGRGLVWULEX LHELQRPLDO

6

$FHVWIDSW

QXDUHHIHFWDVXSUDHVWLPD LLORUSDUDPHWULORUDFHVWHDU PkQQHGHSODVDWH 0DLFRQVHPQ PF SHQWUX Q¸ HVWLPD LLOH VXQW vQ JHQHUDO QRUPDO GLVWULEXLWH $FHDVWD DUH LPSOLFD LL DVXSUD WHVW ULL vQ VHQVXO F SHQWUXHúDQWLRDQHPDULYHULILFDUHDVHUHDOL]HD] vQFRQGL LLRELúQXLWH

7

'LVWULEX LD ELQRPLDO VH UHIHU OD SURFHVH vQ FDUH VH UHDOL]HD] ÄQ´ H[SHULHQ H LQGHSHQGHQWH FRUHVSXQ] WRU VFKHPHL

XUQHL OXL %HUQRXOOL XUQ FDUH FRQ LQH 1 ELOH GH PDL PXOWH FXORUL LDU ELOD H[WUDV HVWH UHSXVD vQ XUQ 'DF DYHP vQ YHGHUH GRX DOWHUQDWLYH GH U VSXQV GDVDXQXELODDOE VDXELODQHDJU DWXQFLSUREDELOLWDWHDGHDSDUL LHDXQHLDGLQWUH DOWHUQDWLYHV RQXPLQ$HVWHFRQVWDQW úLHJDO FXÄS´LDUGHQHDSDUL LHDUHVSHFWLYHLDOWHUQDWLYHHVWH±S 'DF ; 8

9:

UHSUH]LQW YDULDELOD DOHDWRDUH SULYLQG QXP UXO GH DSDUL LL D DOWHUQDWLYHL $ vQ FHOH ÄQ´ H[SHULHQ H LQWHUHVHD] SUREDELOLWDWHD DSDUL LHL HYHQLPHQWXOXL $ GH N RUL vQ Q H[SHULHQ H LQGHSHQGHQWH ± SUREDELOLWDWH FDUH UH]XOW GLQ WHUPHQXO JHQHUDODOGH]YROW ULLELQRPXOXLOXL1HZWRQGHXQGHúLGHQXPLUHDUHSDUWL LHL

103

3H

GH

DOW

SDUWH

PRGXO

vQ

FDUH

HYROXHD]

X5

QX

HVWH

FDUDFWHULVWLF

LSRWH]HL

GH

KRPRVFHGDVWLFLWDWHvQWUXFkWGHSLQGHGHDOWHUQDWLYHOHYDULDELOHL\FDUHODUkQGXOHLGHSLQGHGH[ 5 &D XUPDUHX 5 GHSLQGHGH[ 5 FHHDFHHVWHFDUDFWHULVWLFKHWHURVFHGDVWLFLW

LLFXLPSOLFD LLQHGRULWHDVXSUD

HILFLHQ HLHVWLPDWRULORU2VROX LHvQDVWIHOGHVLWXD LLDUFRQVWDDúDFXPYRPDU WDvQ&DSLWROXO9,,, vQ GLYL]DUHD WHUPHQLORU UHJUHVLHL OD HOHPHQWXO GH SRQGHUDUH UHSUH]HQWDW GH DEDWHUHD PHGLH S WUDWLF s ÌQFD]XOQRVWUXDPY ]XWF YDORULOHOXL\DSDUFXSUREDELOLWDWHD3 5 UHVSHFWLY±3 5 DVWIHOvQFkW s<

;

= 3< - 3< FHHDFHUHSUH]LQW GLVSHUVLDSHQWUXFD]XOYDULDELOHLELQDUH

3HQWUXDRE LQHHVWLPD LDDEDWHULLPHGLLS WUDWLFHsILLQGQHFXQRVFXW vQWUXFkWúL0\ 5 [ 5 D & D ' [ HVWH QHFXQRVFXW VH SURFHGHD] OD HVWLPDUHD HFXD LHL GH UHJUHVLH \ Ö> D Ö= \ Ö LDUDSRL Z Ö RE LQI U D LQHVHDPDGHKHWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWH HVWLPD LLOH D R

\

XUP WRDUH L

Z

L

=D

HWDS

Z

+ D [

L

VH L

SURFHGHD]

Z

L

+X

L

Z

L

OD

RE LQHUHD

vQFDUH Y? = X ?

Z?

L

D & D ' [ X 6H

= \Ö

L

YDULDQWHL

- \Ö

L

ÌQWU

WUDQVIRUPDWH

HVWHKRPRVFHGDVWLF

([HPSOHGHXWLOL]DUHDYDULDELOHLGLFKRWRPLFHGXPP\ vQPRGHOH $QDOL] PSHQWUXvQFHSXWFD]XOFHOPDLIUHFYHQWvQFDUHSULQWUHUHJUHVRULDSDUúLYDULDELOH FDOLWDWLYHGHWLSGLFKRWRPLF \ 5

D & D ' [ 5 D( G 5 X 5

XQGH \

FRQVXPXOGHFDIHD

[

YkUVWD

G

YDULDELODGLFKRWRPLF FXYDORULOHSHQWUXIHPLQLQ SHQWUXPDVFXOLQ

6 FRQVLGHU PGDWHOH 7DEHOXO \

[

G

ÌQXUPDHVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORUSHED]DUHOD LLORU úL RE LQHP Ö@ D

ÖA D

ÖB D

$úDGDU OD R FUHúWHUH D YkUVWHL FX XQ DQ FRQVXPXO GH FDIHD D FUHVFXW vQ PHGLH FX F QL vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH YDULDELOD ' HVWH FRQVWDQW vQ VHQVXO F VXQW OXDWH vQ FRQVLGHUDUH QXPDL GDWHOH SHQWUX FDUH'

VDXQXPDLGDWHOHSHQWUXFDUH'

Ä&UHúWHUHD´YDULDELOHLGLFKRWRPLFH

' GH OD OD DUH GUHSW HIHFW R VF GHUH D FRQVXPXOXL vQ PHGLH FX F QL vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH YDULDELOD;±YkUVWDHVWHPHQ LQXW FRQVWDQW &D]XO PDL UDU vQWkOQLW vQ FDUH YDULDELOD HIHFW HVWH GH WLS GLFKRWRPLF VH UHIHU OD UHSUH]HQWDUHD \

D & D ' [X

XQGH \

[

vQ]HVWUDUHDSRVHVLD FXXQWHOHIRQPRELO

SHUVRDQDSRVHG XQDVWIHOGHWHOHIRQ

SHUVRDQDQXSRVHG XQDVWIHOGHWHOHIRQ

YHQLWXOPHGLXOXQDU

'DWHOHRE LQXWHvQXUPDXQXLVRQGDMVXQWXUP WRDUHOH

104

7DEHOXO \

[

PLOOHL 5H]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHvQXUPDHVWLP ULLVXQW Ö@ D

Ö D

,QWHUSUHWDUHDSDUDPHWULORUHVWLPD LHVWHXUP WRDUHD Ö@ D

H[SULP ÄSUREDELOLWDWHD´FDRSHUVRDQ I U XQYHQLWFkWGHFkWVHPQLILFDWLY[

V SRVHGHXQWHOHIRQ

Ö D

UHVSHFWLY OD R FUHúWHUH FX PLO D YHQLWXOXL PHGLX OXQDU úDQVD

SUREDELOLWDWHD FDRSHUVRDQ V SRVHGHWHOHIRQFUHúWHvQPHGLHFX & ([SULPDUHDQXPHULF DYDULDELOHORUSROLFKRWRPLFH ÌQ VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH YDULDELOD FDOLWDWLY SUH]LQW PDL PXOW GHFkW GRX DOWHUQDWLYH DFHVWRUD OL VHDWULEXLHQRWHVDXGXS FD]QXPHUHGHRUGLQHvQUDSRUWFXDSDUWHQHQ DODRVWDUHVDXDOWD 'HRVHELPXUP WRDUHOHVLWXD LL & 9DULDELODFDOLWDWLY SUH]LQW RGLYHUVLWDWHGHVW ULI U DLPSOLFDRRUGRQDUHDDFHVWRUDvQ UDSRUWFXLQWHQVLWDWHD $VWIHO GH YDULDELOH VXQW QD LRQDOLWDWHD UHOLJLD DSDUWHQHQ D OD R VRFLHWDWH QHOXFUDWLY UDVD HWF ÌQ DVWIHO GH FD]XUL SXWHP SURFHGD OD IHO FD úL vQ FD]XO YDULDELOHL ELQDUH OD DWULEXLUHD GH YDORUL HFKLGLVWDQWH«GLYHUVHORUDOWHUQDWLYH ([HPSOHGHDSOLFDUHDYDULDELOHORUSROLFKRWRPLFHvQPRGHOH 3URGXF LDvQVHFWRUXO]RRWHKQLFRE LQXW GHILUPD0HVWHvQIXQF LHGHDQRWLPS$úDGDU 4C

D & D ' $ C X C

XQGH DQRWLPSXO SUH]LQW DOWHUQDWLYHOH FXQRVFXWH F URUD OL VH DWULEXLH YDORUL

$

DVWIHOSULP YDUD± YDUD± WRDPQD± LDUQD± 5DWD SURILWXOXL vQ vQWUHSULQGHULOH FRPHUFLDOH HVWH FRQVLGHUDW GHSHQGHQW GH IRUPD GH SURSULHWDWHFHHDFHDFRQGXVODHFXD LD 3) 5

D & D ' 3URSULHWDWH 5 X 5

XQGH 3URSULHWDWHDSRDWHILGHVWDW± SDUWLFXODU ± PL[W ± 5HIHULQGXQHODDFHVWXOWLPH[HPSOXV REVHUY PF ÖH SHQWUXÄ3URSULHWDWHDPL[W ´RE LQHP D

ÖG + D

= \ E/F

J KML N OQP R+P O I D

'H DVHPHQHD VH SRDWH SURFHGD OD WUDQVIRUPDUHD PRGHOXOXL DVWIHO vQFkW vQ GUHDSWD VHPQXOXL GHHJDOLWDWHV DSDU GRX YDULDELOHELQDUH \ ÌQFDUH[(

D & D ' [ ' D( [( X

GDF SURSULHWDWHDHVWHPL[W [(

GHVWDWILHSDUWLFXODU UHVSHFWLY[ '

GDF SURSULHWDWHDQXHVWHPL[W HVWHILH

GDF SURSULHWDWHDHVWHSDUWLFXODU [ '

QX HVWH SULYDW HVWH ILH GH VWDW ILH PL[W 5H]XOW F DWXQFL FkQG [ ' FkQG [(

[ '

[(

GDF SURSULHWDWHD UHVSHFWLY DWXQFL

ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH SRDWH IL XUPDW VFKHPD GH RE LQHUH D HVWLPDWRULORU SUH]HQWDW vQ

FD]XOYDULDELOHORUH[SOLFDWLYHELQDUH%

105

3HQWUX YHULILFDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL GHSHQGHQ HL YDULDELOHORU SROLFKRWRPLFH GH WLSXO FHORU S

SUH]HQWDWHVHXWLOL]HD] WHVWXO

6 H[HPSOLILF P R DVWIHO GH WHVWDUH SHQWUX FD]XO vQ FDUH YDULDELOHOH FDOLWDWLYH VXQW IRUPD GH SURSULHWDWH [ DWLWXGLQHD LQYHVWLWRULORU VWU LQL \ ÌQ XUPD FKHVWLRQ ULL XQXL QXP U GH GH LQYHVWLWRULVWU LQLVDDMXQVODGLVWULEX LD7DEHOXO 7DEHOXO ,QWHQ LDLQYHVWLWRUXOXLVWU LQ

7RWDO

3URSULHWDWHDVHFWRUXO SDUWLFXODU

PL[W

GHVWDW

,QYHVWHVF

1XLQYHVWHVF

7RWDO

+T QXH[LVW OHJ WXU vQWUHIRUPDGHSURSULHWDWHúLDWLWXGLQHDLQYHVWLWRULORUVWU LQL /HJHD GH UHSDUWL LH FDUH QH VW vQ DWHQ LH vQ DVWIHO GH SUREOHPH vQ FDUH LQWHUYLQ VXPH GH S

S WUDWHGHYDULDELOHDOHDWRDUHLQGHSHQGHQWHQRUPDOHHVWHOHJHD

YDORDUHDFDOFXODW

c

+

+

FDOF

[

= ÇÇ L

Q

LM

M

- Q Q

M

- ¢ ]

L

=

L

+

- ¢ ]

3

3

¢

[

M

[

[

- ¢ ]

¢

- ¢ ]

+

¢

[

+

[

- ¢ ]

+

¢

- ¢ ]

¢

+

¢

=

YDORDUHDWDEHODW SHQWUX3

úLY

JUDGHGHOLEHUWDWHHVWH c

U W Y W X VU Z

=

ÌQWUXFkWYDORDUHDFDOFXODW HVWHVXSHULRDU FHOHLWDEHODWHSXWHPDILUPDFXRSUREDELOLWDWHGH D QX JUHúL GH 3

F H[LVW OHJ WXU vQWUH IRUPD GH SURSULHWDWH úL DWLWXGLQHD LQYHVWLWRULORU

VWU LQL &[ 9DULDELOD FDOLWDWLY SUH]LQW LQWHQVLW

L GLIHULWH PRWLY SHQWUX FDUH DFHVWRUD OL VH DWULEXLH

QXPHUHGHRUGLQHVDXVHSURFHGHD] ODFDOFXOXOQRWHORUSURSRU LRQDOHFXLQWHQVLWDWHD $VWIHO GH VLWXD LL VXQW SUH]HQWH vQGHRVHEL vQ VWXGLLOH GH PDUNHWLQJ VRFLRORJLH SROLWRORJLH vQ FDUHRSLQLDVDWLVIDF LDvQFUHGHUHDLQVWUXLUHDHWFSRWV GLIHUHFDLQWHQVLWDWH $WULEXLUHD GH YDORUL SHQWUX XQHOH GLQWUH YDULDELOH HVWH IDFLOLWDW GH IDSWXO F XQLWDWHD GH REVHUYDUH HVWH vQFDGUDW vQWUR FDWHJRULH vQ UDSRUW FX QLYHOXO GH LQVWUXLUH YDORDUHD UH]XOWDWHORU GRWDUHD JHQHUD LD HWF $VWIHO vQWkOQLP SHUVRDQH DEVROYHQWH DOH XQHL WUHSWH GH vQY

PkQW

FDOFXODWRDUHGHRDQXPLW JHQHUD LHKRWHOXULGHDQXPLWHFDWHJRULLHWFÌQDVWIHOGHVLWXD LLDWULEXLUHD GH QXPHUH GH RUGLQH FDUH V XUPH]H VXFFHVLXQHD FDWHJRULLORU vQ FDUH HVWH vQFDGUDW XQLWDWHD GH REVHUYDUH DU UHSUH]HQWD R UH]ROYDUH D SUREOHPHL FXDQWLILF ULL 1HDMXQVXO FRQVW vQ IDSWXO F YDORULOH DVWIHODWULEXLWHVXQWHFKLGLVWDQWHFHHDFHQXFRUHVSXQGHvQWRWGHDXQDGLVWDQ HORUGLQWUHFDWHJRULLOHGH FDOLWDWH ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH LQWHQVLWDWHD GHSHQGHQ HL vQ FD]XO XQRU DVWIHO GH YDULDELOH VH UHFRPDQG XWLOL]DUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHFRUHOD LHDUDQJXULORUQXPHUHORUGHRUGLQH ÌQYDULDQWD6SHDUPDQDFHVW FRHILFLHQW UH]XOW SURFHGkQG LQL LDO OD VWDELOLUHD UDQJXULORU SHQWUX ILHFDUH YDULDELO vQ UDSRUW FX LQWHQVLWDWHD SUH]HQ HL IHQRPHQXOXL RE LQHUHD GLIHUHQ HORU vQWUH UDQJXULOH GH SH DFHODúL UkQG G 5 5\^]

5 _ ±5`a] 5 _ DSOLFDUHDIRUPXOHLFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHFRUHOD LH6SHDUPDQ ([HPSOXOSUH]HQWDWvQ7DEHOXOUHG FRQFUHWWRDWHDFHVWHHWDSH

106

7DEHOXO &DOLWDWHDVHUYLFLXOXL

9kUVWDPHGLH

\

DVDODULD LORU

L

5DQJXOQRWD SULYLQG

[

5\

5`

)RDUWHELQH

'LIHUHQ HvQWUHUDQJXUL

G5

5\ 5`

GL

(

%LQH

6DWLVI F WRU

1HVDWLVI F WRUL

6XERULFHFULWLF

&RHILFLHQWXOGHFRUHOD LHDUDQJXOXLHVWHRE LQXWFRQIRUPUHOD LHL

¢ ÇG U

6

=-

L

Q ¢ Q

L

=-

-

¢

¢

+

-

=

&RUHOD LD GLQWUH FHOH GRX YDULDELOH GLQWUH FDUH XQD HVWH GH QDWXU FDOLWDWLY HVWH IRDUWH LQWHQV LDUHYROX LLOHVXQWGHDFHODúLVHQV ' 0 VXUDUHDSULQLQWHUPHGLXOHYROX LHLIUHFYHQ HL 2 SRVLELOLWDWH GH D DMXQJH OD FXDQWLILFDUHD UROXOXL SH FDUH vO DX YDULDELOHOH FDOLWDWLYH vQ HFRQRPLH HVWH RIHULW GH YDULDELOLWDWHD IUHFYHQ HL )DSWXO F SXWHP GHWHUPLQD QXP UXO GH FD]XUL H[LVWHQW SH GLYHUVH WUHSWH FDOLWDWLYH IDFH FD YDULDELOD V ILH FDUDFWHUL]DW FD QXP UDELO VSUH GHRVHELUH GH IHQRPHQHOH P VXUDELOH FDUDFWHUL]DWH FD ILLQG QXPHULFH &D XUPDUH HYROX LD IUHFYHQ HL SH GLYHUVH FDWHJRULL GH FDOLWDWH RIHU SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D LQWURGXFH YDULDELOD FDOLWDWLY vQ GLYHUVHFDOFXOHGHQDWXU HFRQRPLF ([HPSOX 'HSHQGHQ D GLQWUH GRX YDULDELOH FDOLWDWLYH VDWLVIDFHUHD FHUHULL úL WLSXO GH VRFLHWDWH HVWH P VXUDW SRUQLQGXVH GH OD HYROX LD SDUDOHO D QXP UXOXL GH FD]XUL vQUHJLVWUDWH vQ DQXPLWH VW UL FDOLWDWLYH VHPQLILFDWLYH GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD WHRULHL HFRQRPLFH $VWIHO GH FHUHUL DU SXWHD IL FHUHUHD QHVDWLVI FXW \ úL SURSULHWDWHD SDUWLFXODU [ 'DWHOH FX DMXWRUXO F URUD H[HPSOLILF P SURFHGHXO VXQWXUP WRDUHOH 7DEHOXO $QXO

7ULPHVWUXO

,,

,,,

,9

,

,,

,,,

1XP UXOFHUHULORUQHVDWLVI FXWHODPDWHULDOH

GHFRQVWUXF LL\ 3RQGHUHDVHFWRUXOXLSDUWLFXODUvQFRPHU XO FXPDWHULDOHGHFRQVWUXF LL[ Ö (VWLPDWRULL PRGHOXOXL OLQLDU \Ö = D

Ö [ VXQW D Ö + D

Ö = D

= - FHHD FH LQGLF R

VF GHUH vQ PHGLH FX FD]XUL D FHUHULORU QHVDWLVI FXWH OD R FUHúWHUH FX D SRQGHULL VHFWRUXOXL SDUWLFXODUvQFRPHU XOFXPDWHULDOHGHFRQVWUXF LL 02'(/8/ /2*,7 ± VH UHIHU OD VLWXD LL vQ FDUH YDULDELOD HIHFW \ HVWH ELQDU GHSHQGHQW GH YDULDELOD QXPHULF FDX]DO [ 6H FRQVLGHU F SH P VXU FH IDFWRUXO [ VH PRGLILF vQ VHQV FUHVF WRU VDX vQ VHQV GHVFUHVF WRU VH FXPXOHD] HOHPHQWH FDUH IDF FD HIHFWXO V WUHDF GH OD R DOWHUQDWLY \

OD FHDODOW \

'H H[HPSOX GHFL]LD XQXL FKLULDú GH D FXPS UD DSDUWDPHQWXO

RIHULW GH SURSULHWDU VSUH YkQ]DUH GHSLQGH GH YHQLW RS LXQHD SHQWUX U VSXQVXO GD VDX QX OD R SURSXQHUHGHSLQGHGHP ULPHDDYDQWDMHORUHWF([LVW DúDGDUVLWXD LLvQGHRVHELvQQHJRFLHULvQFDUH

107

SH P VXU FH IDFWRUXO [ VH PRGLILF vQ DFHHDúL P VXU DSDU PRGLILF UL úL vQ FH SULYHúWH úDQVD GH D RSWDSHQWUXRDOWHUQDWLY VDXDOWDDGHFL]LHLILQDOH ([LVWHQ DDQXPDLGRX DOWHUQDWLYHSHQWUX\IDFHFDSHP VXU FHvQDLQW PSHVFDUDYDORULORU [ b V QHDSURSLHPGHXQÄSXQFWGHFRWLWXU ´GHODFDUHRS LXQHDLQL LDO \

VHPRGLILF UDGLFDO\

8QPRGHOGHGHVFULHUHDXQXLDVWIHOGHSURFHVVHED]HD] SHIXQF LDORJLVWLF vQVHQVXOF = 0 \ = [

3

L

'DF QRW PFX] b

L

=

+H

- D +E[

c

DE[ b UHOD LD GHYLQH

3f =

+ H

g e d

úL UHSUH]LQW R IXQF LH FXPXODW GH UHSDUWL LH GH WLS ORJLVWLF >@ 3XWHP DILUPD F SH P VXU FH ] b FUHúWH GH OD ¸ OD ¸ 3 b VH PRGLILF GH OD OD H[SULPkQG FRUHVSXQ] WRU UHOD LHL GHSHQGHQ D QHOLQLDU vQ UDSRUW FX ] b SUHFXP úL vQ UDSRUW FX SDUDPHWULL 'H H[HPSOX GHFL]LD GH SDUWLFLSDUH VDX QHSDUWLFLSDUH OD R DIDFHUH \ GHSLQGH GH SRQGHUHD SURILWXOXL FHGDW [ 1RW PFX3 b SUREDELOLWDWHD GH SDUWLFLSDUH úL FX ±3 b

SUREDELOLWDWHD GH QHSDUWLFLSDUH &RUHVSXQ] WRU

PRGHOXOXL/RJLW 3f =

+ H

g e d

UHVSHFWLY - 3 = L

+H

-]

+H

=

h

3HQWUXDVWDELOLSURSRU LDDFFHSW ULLID

-]

+H

h

-

-]

h

=

H

-]

+H

h

-]

h

GHSURSRU LDQHDFFHSW ULLDYHPvQYHGHUHUDSRUWXO

3

L

=

- 3

+H H

L

-]

+H

i

-]

=

i

H

-]

-]

=H

i

]

i

i

ÌQYHGHUHDOLQLDUL] ULLDSHO PODORJDULWPLLQDWXUDOLúLRE LQHP » OQ ª ½

j

5DSRUWXO OQ

3

3

L

- 3

L

± ² = ] Õ

L

¢ OQ H = ]

L

= D + E[

L

HVWH GHQXPLW Ä/RJLW´ úL HVWH UHGDW SULQ VLPEROXO /$úDGDU/

j

- 3

DE[ b

3DUDPHWUXO E H[SULP vQ FD]XO H[HPSOXOXL FRQVLGHUDW FX FkW VH PRGLILF ORJDULWPXO UDWHL GH DFFHSWDUH/ ODRPRGLILFDUHFXFXDSRQGHULLSURILWXOXLFHGDW DIDFWRUXOXL ÌQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU VH UHFRPDQG XWLOL]DUHD PHWRGHL YHURVLPLOLW

LL PD[LPH

>@ÌQVLWXD LDvQFDUHGLVSXQHPGHGDWHVWUXFWXUDWHSHJUXSHGHFD]XULFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHQLYHOHORU[ b SXWHPXWLOL]DXUP WRUXODOJRULWP SHQWUX ILHFDUH QLYHO [ b VH FDOFXOHD] SH ED]D GDWHORU RE LQXWH SHQWUX XQ QXP U GH Q FD]XUL SURSRU LD Q 1

L

= 3 L

L

XQGH Q b

QXP UXOGHFD]XULGHDFFHSWDUH\ b GLQJUXSDL

1b

QXP UXOWRWDOGHFD]XULGLQJUXSDL

SHQWUXILHFDUHQLYHO[ b VHGHWHUPLQ QLYHOXOORJLWXOXL/ b /k

= OQ

3k - 3k

108

VH SURFHGHD] OD DSOLFDUHD 0&003 SHQWUX HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU D úL E GLQ Ö + EÖ[ =D

Öl PRGHOXO /

l vQWUXFkW YDULDELOD / b HVWH OLQLDU GHSHQGHQW GH [ b 'HRDUHFH SHUWXUED LD HVWH

KHWHURVFHGDVWLF VHUHFRPDQG YDULDQWDSRQGHUDW D0&003vQFDUHSRQGHUHDHVWH 1 b 3 b ±3 b

Z b

5H]XOW DVWIHOHJDOLWDWHD

Z

L

/

=D

L

Z

L

+ E[

L

Z

+X

L

Z

L

L

VDX P

L

Ö =D

Ö Q + D

L

+Y

L

([HPSOXGHDSOLFDUHDPRGHOXL/RJLW 6H FRQVLGHU XQ DQVDPEOX LSRWHWLF GH FD]XUL GH QHJRFLHUH vQ FDUH vQ UDSRUW FX SURFHQWXO GH SURILW FHGDW SDUWHQHUXOXL DX IRVW vQUHJLVWUDWH VFKLPE UL DOH GHFL]LHL LQL LDOH GH QHSDUWLFLSDUH OD DFFHSWDUHD QHJRFLHULL 'DWHOH SUHFXPúLUH]XOWDWHOHFRUHVSXQ] WRUPHWRGHLSUH]HQWDWHVXQWvQVFULVH vQ7DEHOXO 7DEHOXO 3URILW

&HQWUXGH

[

LQWHUYDO[

m

1U

1UWRWDO

FHORUFH

GH

DFFHSW

FD]XUL

Q n

1 n

3o =

Qo 1o

- 3p

3q - 3q

/r

= OQ

3r - 3r

Z = L

=1 3 (-3 ) L

L

L

P = Z / Q = Z ; L

L

L

L

L

L

5H]XOW F Ö D Ö D

= - =

$VWIHO vQFkW GDF QH UHIHULP GH H[HPSOX OD FD]XO L FRQWUDFWXOHVWHGH3s

úDQVD GH D DFFHSWD

02'(/8/ 352%,7 QRUPLW HVWH UHFRPDQGDW vQ DFHODúL JHQ GH VLWXD LL GHVFULVH GH PRGHOXO /RJLW FX FDUH GH DOWIHO VH DVHDP Q IRDUWH PXOW 'HRVHELUHD FRQVW vQ IDSWXO F IXQF LD GH UHSDUWL LHFXPXODW QXPDLHVWHGHWLSORJLVWLFFLHVWHRUHSDUWL LHQRUPDO VWDQGDUG PRWLYSHQWUX FDUH PRGHOXO HVWH GHQXPLW úL ÄQRUPLW´ 6 FRQVLGHU P UHOD LD GH GHSHQGHQ

\

D t D u [ X vQ

FDUH\HVWHRYDULDELO ELQDU 'DF \SRDWHvQUHJLVWUDRJDP LQILQLW GHQXDQ HÄSHFDOHDFDUHGXFH´ GH OD R GHFL]LH \

OD RSXVD HL \

VH DSHOHD] OD IXQF LD FXPXODWLY GH UHSDUWL LH SHQWUX D

UHDOL]D WUDQVIRUPDUHD WUHSWHORU FDOLWDWLYH DOH YDULDELOHL LQL LDOH \ vQ WHUPHQL SUREDELOLVWLFL 3 v FX DVLJXUDUHDXQHLUHOD LLPRQRWRQHvQWUH\ v úL3 v ÌQSULQFLSLXVHSRDWHSURFHGDODvQORFXLUHDIXQF LHLGH WLSORJLVWLF FXH[SUHVLDFXUEHLIXQF LHLGHUHSDUWL LHQRUPDO UHGXV SURFHGkQGXVHVLPLODUFD úL vQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL /RJLW ÌQ SUDFWLF HVWH SUHIHUDW PRGHOXO /RJLW PRWLY SHQWUX FDUH D IRVW SUH]HQWDWPDLSHODUJ

%,%/,2*5$),(

*ULIILWKV : -XGJH * &DUWHU + ± /HDUQLQJ DQG 3UDFWLFLQJ (FRQRPHWULFV :LOH\ 1 <

-RKQVWRQ-±(FRQRPHWULF0HWKRGV0F*UDZ+LOO1<

.PHQWD-±(OHPHQWVRI(FRQRPHWULFV0F0LOODQ&R1<

3HFLFDQ(±(FRQRPHWULH(GLWXUD$OO%XFXUHúWL

109

&DSLWROXO9, 6HULLFURQRORJLFHDQDOL]DWHDWkWSULQSULVPDFRPSRQHQWHORU FkWúLDQHVWD LRQDULW

LLúLFRLQWHJU

ULL

'DWHOH VWDWLVWLFH FDUH UHIOHFW UH]XOWDWHOH DQXDOH WULPHVWULDOH OXQDUH HWF SULYLQG DFWLYLW

LOH

HFRQRPLFHVHFDUDFWHUL]HD] QXDWkWSULQVWDELOLWDWHFkWPDLFXUkQGSULQIOXFWXD LLGHODRSHULRDG OD DOWD &URQRJUDPHOH YH]L )LJXUD úL )LJXUD vQI

LúkQG HYROX LD XQRU YDULDELOH HFRQRPLFH

VXQWHORFYHQWHvQDFHVWVHQV

'LQ SHUVSHFWLYD HFRQRPHWULHL SUREOHPD HYROX LHL SURFHVHORU HFRQRPLFH vQ WLPS LQWHUHVHD]

GDWRULW XUP WRDUHORUPRWLYH

P VXUDUHD UROXOXL XQRU IDFWRUL FDOLWDWLYL QHQXPHULFL FDUH vúL GHVI úRDU DF LXQHD vQ GHFXUVXO WLPSXOXL SURJUHVXO WHKQLF DFXPXO ULOH GH EXQXUL SURFHVHOH GH vQY

DUH HWF SRDWH IL DERUGDW

OXkQGvQFDOFXOYDULDELODWLPSSULYLW FDXQúLUGHQXPHUHvQSURJUHVLHDULWPHWLF

DF LXQHD XQRU FDX]H QX DIHFWHD] LQVWDQWDQHX YDULDELOD HIHFW FL GXS XQ LQWHUYDO GH WLPS ODJ PDLPXOWVDXPDLSX LQvQGHOXQJDW'HDLFLLQWHUHVXOSHQWUXFXQRDúWHUHDGLVWDQ HLvQWLPSODFDUH VH PDQLIHVW LQIOXHQ D IDFWRULORU LQWHUYDOXOXL GLQWUH HYROX LD XQRU YDULDELOHVHPQDO YDULDELOH SUHFXUVRDUH úL PRGLILFDUHD YDULDELOHL HIHFW vQWkU]LHUHD OD FDUH DSDU LPSOLFD LLOH HFRQRPLFH JHQHUDWHGHP VXULOHJXYHUQDPHQWDOH

HYLGHQ LHUHD LQYDULDQ LORU WHQGLQ D HYROXWLY RVFLOD LLOH VLVWHPDWLFH vQ VHQVXO P VXU ULL LQWHQVLW

LLDFHVWRUDúLPRGHO ULLUROXOXLORUvQHYROX LDYLLWRDUHDSURFHVXOXLHFRQRPLF

7HQGLQ DJHQHUDO

5HSUH]HQW ULOH JUDILFH YH]L )LJXUD úL )LJXUD HYLGHQ LD] SH OkQJ LQVWDELOLWDWHD

LQGLFDWRULORU úL IDSWXO F vQ JHQHUDO HYROX LD FXUVXOXL GH VFKLPE )LJXUD HVWH vQ FUHúWHUH LDU FHDDGDWRULHLH[WHUQH)LJXUD LQGLF VHPQHGHvQFHWLQLUHDFUHúWHULLDSURSLLQGXVHGHXQQLYHO VWDELO 7DEHO (YROX LD FXUVXOXL GH VFKLPE PHGLX OXQDU OHLGRODU 68$ vQ LQWHUYDOXO 9,,, ;,,

,

,,

,,,

,9

9

9,

9,,

9,,,

,;

;

;,

;,,

)LJXUD 7DEHO (YROX LD GDWRULHL H[WHUQH SH WHUPHQ PHGLX úL OXQJ D 5RPkQLHL GDWH DQXDOH SULYLQGVLWXD LDOD;,,DILHF UXLDQGLQLQWHUYDOXO

110

$QXO

\PLOOHL

)LJXUD 7DEHO1XP UXOPLLORFXLWRUL GHORFXLWRULGLQ%XFXUHúWLvQLQWHUYDOXO

)LJXUD 7(1',1

$ *(1(5$/

GHQXPLW úL WUHQG VH PDQLIHVW FD R PRGLILFDUH XQLIRUP

FRQVHFYHQW FX HD vQV úL I U DVSHULW

L H[SULPkQG vQWUR IRUP VWLOL]DW HYROX LD XQXL IHQRPHQ vQ

GHFXUVXOXQHLSHULRDGHvQGHOXQJDWH 2 OHJH FYDVLJHQHUDO GH HYROX LH D IHQRPHQHORU GLQ QDWXU úL VRFLHWDWH SRDWH IL SXV vQ HYLGHQ

GH FXUED ORJLVWLF

$VWIHO GH HYROX LL vQWkOQLP DWXQFL FkQG XUP ULP vQ WLPS QLYHOXO

YkQ] ULORU XQXL SURGXV SH SLD D LQWHUQ QXP UXO SRSXOD LHL XQHL WHKQRORJLLvQSURGXF LHFRQVXPXOvQFD]XOXQXLQRXSURGXVSHSLD

UL JHQHUDOL]DUHD XQHL QRL

111

)XQF LDORJLVWLF UHSUH]LQW XQPRGHODOFUHúWHULLFDUHGHIDSWLQFOXGHPDLPXOWHWHQGLQ HvQ VXFFHVLXQH$VWIHOvQSULPDID] HYROX LDSRDWHILVFKL DW SULQWURGUHDSW SHQWUXFDDSRLFUHúWHUHD V GHYLQ H[SRQHQ LDO SkQ vQSUHDMPDSXQFWXOXLGHLQIOH[LXQH ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH HYROX LD DPLQWHúWH GH R IXQF LH VHPLORJDULWPLF LDU vQ SDUWHD ILQDO SXWHP DSHOD OD XQ SROLQRP GH JUDGXO GRL ÌQ UDSRUW FX HYROX LD IHQRPHQXOXL vQ WLPS SXWHP DYHD vQ YHGHUH úL DOWH PRGHOH HYROXWLYH UHGDWH SULQ IXQF LL QHOLQLDUH vQ YHGHUHD H[SULP ULL ÄVWLOL]DWH´ D WUDLHFWRULHL HYROXWLYH ÌQ YHGHUHD IDFLOLW ULL FDOFXOHORU VH UHFRPDQG SHQWUX PDMRULWDWHD IXQF LLORU QHOLQLDUH WUDQVIRUPDUHDvQYDULDQWDOLQLDUL]DW $VWIHOGDF HYROX LDXQXLSURFHVHVWHFRUHFWGHVFULV GHUHOD LD

ÌQORFXLQG

W

= D + E

\

W

+ X

= ] VHDMXQJHODIRUPDOLQLDU \ = D + E] + X

ÌQ FD]XO HYROX LHL GHVFULVH GH XQ SROLQRP GH JUDG PDL PDUH GHFkW XQX GH H[HPSOX

\ = D + EW + FW

+ X VHvQORFXLHúWHW

]FHHDFHFRQGXFHOD

\ = D + EW + F] + X

ÌQFD]XOIXQF LHLORJDULWPLFHDYkQGXUP WRDUHDIRUP ORJ

ÌQORFXLQGSH ORJ

= D + E ORJ

\ \

=

ORJ

Z

W

=

W

+ X

] VHDMXQJHODIRUPDOLQLDU

Z = D + E] + X

)RUPXOHOH

XWLOL]DWH

SUHVXSXQ

H[LVWHQ D

XQHL

'HSHQGHQ D YDULDELOHL Ä\´ GH HYROX LD WLPSXOXL W

UHOD LL

IXQF LRQDOH

GH

WLSXO

\ = I W

« WUHEXLH vQ HOHDV vQ VHQVXO F Ä\´

GHSLQGH GH XQ DQVDPEOX GH IDFWRUL D F URU HYROX LH vQ GHFXUVXO WLPSXOXL SRDWH IL VLQWHWL]DW GH FUHúWHUHDvQSURJUHVLHDULWPHWLF DYDULDELOHLÄW´

7HQGLQ D RE LQXW vQ FD]XO XQHL FRUHFWH VSHFLILF UL D PRGHOXOXL UHSUH]LQW R HYROX LH ÄvQ

PHGLH´ R PHGLH vQ PLúFDUH 9DORULOH HPSLULFH \ VH VLWXHD] vQ MXUXO WHQGLQ HL GHVFULLQG IOXFWXD LL VLVWHPDWLFH DIHFWDWH HYHQWXDO GH SHUWXUED LH vQ FD]XO HYROX LLORU FX VH]RQDOLWDWHVDXFLFOLFLWDWH VDX VLPSOHDEDWHULGHWLSDOHDWRUFDXUPDUHDDF LXQLLIDFWRULORUDFFLGHQWDOL

([WUDSRODUHD WHQGLQ HL SHQWUX SHULRDGH YLLWRDUH FD GH DOWIHO úL LQWHUSRODUHD YDORULORU DEVHQWH

GLQ FDGUXO VHULHL FURQRORJLFH LPSOLF DFFHSWDUHD LSRWH]HL FRQVHUY ULL GLQDPLFLL DQVDPEOXOXL GH IDFWRULFDUHLQIOXHQ HD] YDULDELODHIHFW

ÌQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU SRDWH IL XWLOL]DW 0&003 'DWRULW HYROX LHL FX R UD LH

FRQVWDQW D YDULDELOHL ÄWLPS´ VH UHFRPDQG vQGHRVHEL GDF IXQF LD HVWH SROLQRPLDO QXPHURWDUHD FHORU Q SHULRDGH DVWIHO vQFkW Ç W ë = $VWIHO SHQWUX Q LPSDU W¶ = « « UHVSHFWLY SHQWUX Q SDU W¶ = « ; ; ; ; ; ; « $FHDVW QRWD LH FRQGXFH OD VLPSOLILFDUHD IRUPXOHORU GH HVWLPDUH D SDUDPHWULORU ÌQ FD]XO IXQF LHL OLQLDUH \ = D D W X UHOD LLOH úL GHYLQ Ç \ Ö D

=

W

=

Q

Ç\ Ö! D

W

W

W

¢W ë

Ç (W ë)

W

ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD] QHSURSXQHPV H[HPSOLILF PPRGDOLWDWHDGHGHWHUPLQDUHDWHQGLQ HLDWkW

SHQWUX FD]XO vQ FDUH VH DFFHSW YDULDQWD OLQLDU SULYLQG HYROX LD FXUVXOXL GH VFKLPE )LJXUD FkW úL SHQWUX FD]XO QHOLQLDU SULYLQG HYROX LD GDWRULHL H[WHUQH FD] vQ FDUH DGRSW P IXQF LD VHPLORJDULWPLF \ = D + E ORJ W + X 5H]XOWDWHOHSUHOLPLQDUHVXQWUHGDWHvQWDEHOXOGHPDLMRV

112

7DEHOXO Ö Ö +E 7HQGLQ DOLQLDU \Ö = D ¢W ë

W¶

\Ö

W¶

\

\ÂW¶

7RWDO

Ö = D Ö E =

=

=

7DEHOXO Ö Ö = D Ö + E ¢ ORJ W 7HQGLQ DQHOLQLDU \

W

ORJW

\

Ö = - D Ö E =

ÌQ FD]XO SROLQRPXOXL GH JUDGXO GRL \ "

= D%

+ D$ W + D# W

#

GHULYDWHORU SDU LDOH vQ UDSRUW FX SDUDPHWULL SHQWUX H[SUHVLD

+ X"

VH DMXQJH vQ XUPD DQXO ULL

PLQ Ç \ W

XUP WRUXOVLVWHPGHHFXD LLvQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUH Ç W ë = Ç W ë

W

-D

-D W -D W

OD

=

113

Å ¿

Ö QD

Ö + D

ÇW ë

¿

W

W

W

¿ ¿ Ö ÇW ë = Ç\ D ¿

= Ç\

W

W

Ç\ Ö W ëD

=

¿

W

W ë

ÇW ë

W

¿Ö Ö ÇW ë D ÇW ë +D = ÇW ë \ ¿ ® W W W

W

6LVWHPXOSHUPLWHRE LQHUHDHVWLPD LLORUFXXQQXP UUHGXVGHFDOFXOH ÌQ FD]XO IXQF LLORU QHOLQLDUHFDUHDXGHYHQLWOLQLDUHvQXUPDXQRUWUDQVIRUP ULVH LQHVHDPD HYLGHQWGHQDWXUDWUDQVIRUP ULORUHIHFWXDWHSURFHGkQGXVHvQFRQVHFLQ

ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHIXQF LDORJLVWLF PHQ LRQ PF HDGHVFULHVFKHPDWLFHYROX LDXQXLQXP U

PDUHGHIHQRPHQHúLSURFHVHvQGHRVHELvQVLWXD LLOHvQFDUHLSRWH]DDGPLWHULLXQXLÄPHGLXvQFKLV´GH GHVI úXUDUH D FUHúWHULL HVWH SODX]LELO 0RGHOXO ORJLVWLF SRDWH IL H[SULPDW vQ PDL PXOWH YDULDQWH GLQWUHFDUHPHQ LRQ P Ö \

&

Ö Ö + E¢F Ö = D

XQGH DEF W Ö = \

Ö D + H

) * + (* '

SDUDPHWULL «

XQGH

W

«Q

D

GHFUHúWHUH SDUDPHWUXUHSUH]HQWkQGOLPLWDVXSHULRDU ,

E

SDUDPHWUXH

F

SDUDPHWUXFDUHH[SULP SDQWDFXUEHLDEF!

LQGLF SR]L LDFXUEHLvQUDSRUWFXD[DWLPSXOXL

9DULDQWD HVWH XWLOL]DW FX SUHF GHUH vQ VWXGLLOH HFRQRPLFH úL GHPRJUDILFH 9LWH]D GH

FUHúWHUH H[SULPDW GH SULPD GHULYDW D IXQF LHL GHVFULV GH UHOD LD HVWH SURSRU LRQDO FX UDSRUWXO FD 3XQFWXO GH LQIOH[LXQH D FXUEHL HVWH GH FRRUGRQDWH EFD ÌQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU D E úL F HVWH XWLOL]DW ILH 0&003 ILH PHWRGD SXQFWHORU HFKLGLVWDQWH $FHDVW GLQ XUP PHWRG SUHVXSXQH VHJPHQWDUHD VHULHL FURQRORJLFH vQ WUHL S U L HJDOH GHILQLQG GLQ ILHFDUH R YDORDUH FDUDFWHULVWLF YDORDUHD GH PLMORF \ \ \ 'DF DYHP vQ YHGHUH F UHOD LD IDFHSRVLELO HJDOLWDWHD

H

/ 0 -.

=

D - \ \

Ü E - FW = OQ

D - \ \

DWXQFLvQORFXLQGYDULDELOD\FXYDORULOHFHORUWUHLYDULDQWHRE LQHP

Ü E = OQ

SHQWUXPRPHQWXOW

NÜ E - FN = OQ

SHQWUXPRPHQWXOW

NÜ E - FN = OQ

XQGH N

D - \

SHQWUXPRPHQWXOW

(JDOLW

\

D - \ \

D - \ \

1

GLVWDQ DvQWUHYDORULOHFDUDFWHULVWLFH

2

LOHIRUPHD] XQVLVWHPGHWUHLHFXD LLFXWUHLQHFXQRVFXWH

3

Ö Ö ÌQWUDGHY U FHD GHD GRXD GHULYDW D IXQF LHL VH DQXOHD] SHQWUX W = E Ö LDU H[SUHVLD SHQWUX W = E F Ö HVWH F

Ö HJDO FX D

114

(YROX LD XQXL SURFHV HFRQRPLF SH R WUDLHFWRULH GH WLS 6 SRDWH HYLWD ID]D ILQDO GH VWDJQDUH

XUPDW GH VF GHUHD GH QLYHO SULQ DWUDJHUHD XQRU QRL IDFWRUL LQRYD LL vQ WHKQRORJLH IDFLOLW

L OD

FXPS UDUH LQWUDUHD SH QRL SLH H HWF FDUH V UHODQVH]H SURFHVXO SH R WUDLHFWRULH FDUH UHLD OD R DOW VFDU HYROX LD DQWHULRDU 6XFFHVLXQHD GH DVWIHO GH IXQF LL ORJLVWLFH GHVI úXUDWH OD QLYHOH WRW PDL vQDOWHHVWHGHVFULV GHDúDQXPLW &85%

Ì1)

ù85

72$5(2DVWIHOGHUHSUH]HQWDUHGHVFULHúL

SHUPLWH H[WUDSRODUHD XQHL HYROX LL GHVI úXUDWH SH FRDPD XQHL FXUEH GH WLS 6 ÌQI úXU WRDUHD HVWH DVWIHO R WDQJHQW FRPXQ WXWXURU FXUEHORU GHVI úXUDWH vQ VXFFHVLXQHD vQWUXQ LQWHUYDO GH WLPS GH UHJXO vQGHOXQJDW2SUH]HQWDUHIRUPDO DXQHLDVWIHOGHHYROX LLDUHvQYHGHUHH[LVWHQ DXQHLIDPLOLL GHFXUEHIW\a

a$)LHFDUHFXUE HVWHGHILQLW SH, 4

'HILQLP vQI úXU WRDUHD DFHVWRU FXUEH IXQF LD

C5

>D 4

E 4 @QXQHDS UDWGLVMXQFWLYH

,5

5 DVWIHO FD

Å I W \ a = ®

PD[ \

3UREOHPD SRDWH IL SXV vQ FRQWH[WXO GHWHUPLQ ULL XQXL H[WUHP FX OHJ WXUL SHQWUX FDUH FRQVWUXLP ODJUDQJLDQXO

/W\al

\lW\a

(JDODUHD FX ]HUR D GHULYDWHORU vQ UDSRUW FX \ a úL l UHSUH]LQW FRQGL LD QHFHVDU SHQWUX

DWLQJHUHD XQXL H[WUHP 8OWLPHOH GRX HFXD LL OD FDUH VH DMXQJH UHSUH]LQW XQ VLVWHP FDUH LQFOXGH SULQWUHVROX LLúLSHFHOHGHVWLQDWHUH]ROY ULLSUREOHPHLGHPD[LPFDUHQHVW vQDWHQ LH

([WUDSRODUHD SH FXUED vQI úXU WRDUH D IRVW DSOLFDW vQGHRVHEL vQ WHKQRORJLH GHúL HFRQRPLD

SULQSURFHVHOHGHWUDQ]L LHHYROX LDFHUHULLLQRYD LDvQODQVDUHDúLUHODQVDUHDSURGXVHORUHWFRIHU XQ GRPHQLXGHVFKLVFHUFHW ULLúLVWXGLLORUDSOLFDWLYHSULQDFHDVW PHWRG

7HQGLQ D LQGLIHUHQW GH IXQF LD XWLOL]DW VH RE LQH vQORFXLQG SDUDPHWULL FX HVWLPDWRULL

RE LQX LSULQ0&003VDXDOWHPHWRGHúLDWULEXLQGYDORULvQVXFFHVLXQHYDULDELOHLW 3UHYL]LXQHD UH]XOWDW FD R H[WUDSRODUH D WHQGLQ HL VH RE LQH VLPLODU GDU YDORULOH YDULDELOHL W VXQWSURLHFWDWHvQYLLWRU$VWIHOSHQWUXPRGHOXOOLQLDURE LQHPXUP WRDUHOHYDORULSURJQR]DWHSULYLQG FXUVXO GH VFKLPE PHGLX OXQDU vQ OXQLOH LDQXDULH IHEUXDULH PDUWLH úL DSULOLH OHL OHLOHLOHL ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH PRGHOXO QHOLQLDU SUHGLF LLOH SULYLQG GDWRULD H[WHUQ SHQWUX DQLL úL VXQWGHPLOOHLúLUHVSHFWLYPLOOHL

3UHGLF LLOH RE LQXWH SULQ H[WUDSRODUH vQ UDSRUW FX VXFFHVLXQHD YDORULORU ÄW´ VXQW WULEXWDUH

HYROX LHL DQWHULRDUH ILLQG OHJDWH RUJDQLF GH DFHDVWD SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO SDUDPHWULORU $FHVWD HVWH SULQFLSDOXO PRWLY SHQWUX FDUH SURJQR]HOH GH DFHVW JHQ VXQW XQHRUL HWLFKHWDWH GUHSW ÄSUHYL]LXQL QDLYH´ VDX JHQHUHD] DSUHFLHUL VFHSWLFH FRUHVSXQ] WRU F URUD ÄHFRQRPLúWLL UHXúHVF V HODERUH]H SUHYL]LXQL SULYLQG «WUHFXWXO´ 'DU GDF DYHP vQ YHGHUH VSHFLILFXO HYROX LHL XQXL QXP U PDUH GH YDULDELOH HFRQRPLFH QX VH SRDWH QHJD IDSWXO F vQ FRQGL LL QRUPDOH GH GHVI úXUDUH SUHGRPLQDQ D IDFWRULORU FDUH DF LRQHD] vQ VHQVXO FRQVHUY ULL WHQGLQ HL IDFH FD H[WUDSRO ULOH SULYLQG vQGHRVHEL YLLWRUXODSURSLDWV ILHvQJHQHUDOFRQILUPDWHGHUHDOLWDWHÌQVLWXD LLOHvQFDUHVHSUHFRQL]HD] VDXVH SUHY G VFKLPE UL LPSRUWDQWH vQ UkQGXO IDFWRULORU FH GHWHUPLQ IHQRPHQXO \ SURJQR]HOH ED]DWH SH H[WUDSRO UL QX VXQW LQGLFDWH vQWUXFkW FRQGL LLOH GLQ WUHFXW QX VH UHJ VHVF ILH úL OD PRGXO JHQHUDO vQ YLLWRU

6

ÌQ XUPD XQRU DUWLILFLL DOJHEULFH FDUH VH UHIHU OD HOLPLQDUHD QHFXQRVFXWHL ÄF´ vQ XUPD VF GHULL SURGXVXOXL FHOHL GHD

GRXD HFXD LL PXOWLSOLFDWH FX GLQ FHD GHD WUHLD HFXD LH HOLPLQDUHD QHFXQRVFXWHL E GLQ VLVWHPXO IRUPDW GH UH]XOWDWXO DQWHULRUúLHFXD LD úLL]RODUHDQHFXQRVFXWHLÄD´FDUHvQXUPDDQWLORJDULWP ULLHYLGHQ LD] RHFXD LHGHJUDGXOGRL 5 G FLQDSR]LWLY DHFXD LHLGLQXUP HVWH Ö = D

\ \ \ -

\

\ \ -

7

> \ +

\

7

\ @

VROX LH FDUH SULQ vQORFXLUHD SDUDPHWUXOXL ÄD´ GLQ HFXD LD IDFH

Ö 0LK LO 1 ± SRVLELO RE LQHUHD HVWLPD LHL SHQWUX E UHVSHFWLY vQORFXLQG vQ HFXD LD RE LQHP HVWLPDWRUXO F 0DWHPDWLFLVSHFLDOHDSOLFDWHvQHFRQRPLHYROOLWR$6(%XFXUHúWL

115

6H]RQDOLWDWHD 6H]RQDOLWDWHD UHSUH]LQW DFHD FRPSRQHQW VLVWHPDWLF FH VH PDQLIHVW SULQ RVFLOD LL GH SHULRDG PDL PLF VDX HJDO FX XQ DQ UHSHWDELOH vQ WLPS 'HQXPLUHD GH VH]RQDOLWDWH VHPQDOHD] FDX]D SULQFLSDO D DFHVWRUIOXFWXD LLFDUHFRQVW vQVFKLPEDUHDDQRWLPSXOXL3ULQH[WHQVLHDFHVWJHQ GH IOXFWXD LL VH UHIHU úL OD LQWHUYDOH PDL PLFL GHFkW XQ VH]RQ WULPHVWUX FXP DU IL OXQD VDX V SW PkQD ÌQ DFHVW FD] HOH VDU SXWHD GDWRUD úL DOWRUIDFWRULGHFkWFHLFOLPDWHULFLúLDVWIHOGHIDFWRUL SRW IL WUDGL LD YDFDQ HOH úFRODUH SODWD VDODULLORU UHSDXVXO GXPLQLFDO DOWHUQDQ D ]LQRDSWH FLFOXULOH ELRORJLFHHWF

'LQSXQFWGHYHGHUHDOSRVLELOLW

LORUGHP VXUDUHVH]RQDOLWDWHDVHPDQLIHVW VXEIRUPDXQRU

DEDWHUL GH OD PHGLH FDUH UHYLQ VLVWHPDWLF $FHVW DVSHFW GH RVFLOD LH vQ MXUXO XQXL QLYHO GH UHIHULQ

PHGLD VHREVHUY PDLFODUODVHULLOHVWD LRQDUH

$VWIHOvQYDULDQWDDGLWLY PRGHOXOSRDWHILIRUPXODWFDRVXP GHPHGLL = \ + V9

\ 89

XQGH L

«PDQL

M

«KVH]RDQH

Ç\ \

:

V:

+ X 8 9

;

=

;:

K

= \

:

- \

([HPSOXSULYLQGPRGXOGHHYDOXDUHDVH]RQDOLW

LL

6HFXQRVFXUP WRDUHOHGDWHSULYLQGHYROX LDSURGXF LHLGHFLPHQWvQ5RPkQLDvQDQLLúL FLIUHURWXQMLWHUHSUH]HQWkQGVXWHGHPLLWRQH VHULDILLQGVWD LRQDU vQFHLGRLDQL 7DEHOXO

7ULP

,

,,

,,,

,9

,

,,

,,,

,9

3URGXF LD

0HGLDWULPHVWULDO HVWH \ V<

V

=

DEDWHULGHODPHGLHDOHPHGLLORUWULPHVWULDOH

= \

- \

2VFLOD LD

\Ö

=

+

VH]RQLHU

= - = \Ö

- = - V ÄSXULILFDW ´

GH

= V

DEDWHULOH

= + = \Ö

=

V

vQWkPSO WRDUH

= \Ö

= - X = >

UH]XOW

DVWIHO

= YDORUL FDUH VH UHSHW DQ GH

DQ

0DL IUHFYHQWH VXQW VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH VHULD HVWH QHVWD LRQDU LQFOXGH úL WHQGLQ D JHQHUDO ÌQ

DVWIHO GH VLWXD LL GDWHOH HPSLULFH VH UDSRUWHD] OD WHQGLQ

PHGLD vQ PLúFDUH &DOFXOHOH GHFXUJ

FRQIRUPXQXLDOJRULWPGHVFULVvQWDEHOXO

([HPSOX 6H FXQRVF XUP WRDUHOH GDWH SULYLQG SURGXF LD GH EHUH RE LQXW vQ GRL DQL VXFFHVLYL vQ

5RPkQLDYDORULURWXQMLWHUHSUH]HQWkQGVXWHGHPLLGHKHFWROLWUL

7HQGLQ D FD úL YDORULOH H[WUDSRODWH DOH WHQGLQ HL YH]L 7DEHOXO FRORDQD DX UH]XOWDW

vQXUPDDSOLF ULLPRGHOXOXLOLQLDU = - W

\Ö

W = - - - -

?

116

SHQWUXFDUH

Ö D

=

Ö D

-

=

=

= -

ÌQFHSULYHúWHVH]RQDOLWDWHDDXIRVW GLQ DQXO L úL DQXO L $VWIHO V

FDOFXODWH V < UHSUH]HQWkQGPHGLDYDORULORUWULPHVWUXOXLM

= + = 0HQ LRQ P F YDORULOH WULPHVWUXOXL M

SHQWUX FDUH VH FDOFXOHD] DVIHO GH PHGLL UHSUH]LQW UH]XOWDWH DOH UDSRUWXOXL FDOFXOXO YDORULORU V < VD DMXQV OD HYDOXDUHD LQWHQVLW 5DSRUWkQG

DFHVWH

HYDOX UL

SULPH

OD

PHGLD

ORU

LL VH]RQDOLW

\ Ö \

@A @A

FRORDQD 3ULQ

LL vQ XUPD XQXL SULP ILOWUX

V =

DX

UH]XOWDW

,1',&,,

'(

6(=21$/,7$7( GXS XQ DO GRLOHD ILOWUX FRORDQD ÌQ XOWLPD FRORDQ D WDEHOXOXL VDX RE LQXW YDORUL FDUH LQFOXG DPEHOH FRPSRQHQWH VLVWHPDWLFH WUHQGVH]RQDOLWDWH FD XUPDUH D XWLOL] ULL PRGHOXOXLGHWLSPXOWLSOLFDWLY 7DEHOXO 7ULP

$QXO

L = P M = K

3URGXF LD

'HWHUPLQDUHD

VXWHPLLKO

WHQGLQ HL

\

W¶

W¶

B

'HWHUPLQDUHDVH]RQDOLW

\Ö

V

=

LM

\ \Ö

LM LM

V

M

=

L

L

,

6HULD DMXVWDW

\W¶

LL

Ç V LM L

LC

=

VC V

P

\

LM

Ö =\

LM

¢L M

,,

,,,

,9

,

,,

,,,

,9

7RWDO

V =

D VG

GÇ F E

=

=

8QLQWHUHVDSDUWHvOSUH]LQW VH]RQDOLWDWHDvQYDULDQWDvQFDUHHDHVWHLQWURGXV vQPRGHOSULQ LQWHUPHGLXOYDULDELOHLYDULDELOHORUELQDUH 0RGHOXO

\H

= DJ

GHVFULH

UROXO

+ D I ; H XQGH;

VH]RQDOLW

\ =D

XQGH 6K

+ D ;

+E

6

ILH

SULQ

SUH]HQWDUHD

D

SDWUX

HFXD LL

GLIHULWH

YDULDELODQXPHULF ILHFDUHILLQGVSHFLILF VH]RQXOXLÄV´FD]vQFDUH

SDUDPHWUXODÄSUHLD´úLHIHFWXOVH]RQDOLW

LL

+E 6

+E

LLILHSULQWURHFXD LHGHIRUPD

6

+ X

VH]RQXO M YDU WRDPQ LDUQ FX YDORULOH XQX FD] vQ FDUH FHOHODOWH GRX VH]RDQH GHYLQ

]HUR VDX]HUR 6HPQLILFD LD VH]RQDOLW LSRWH]HLQXOHE

B

EL

EM

LL SHQWUX HYROX LD YDULDELOHL \ SRDWH IL YHULILFDW SULQ WHVWDUHD

0HQ LRQ P F vQ YHGHUHD HYLW ULL QHGHWHUPLQ ULL vQ FD]XOXWLOL] ULL0&003VHUHQXQ ODXQXOGLQWUHFHOHSDWUXVH]RDQH

117

0RGHOXO&DORWGHDERUGDUHVLPXOWDQ

DWUHQGXOXLúLVH]RQDOLW

LL

ÌQWUXFkWSURFHVHOHHFRQRPLFHQHVWD LRQDUHúLFXVH]RQDOLWDWHSUH]LQW RVFLOD LLVLVWHPDWLFHSH IRQGXO XQHL WHQGLQ H HYROXWLYH úL vQ LQWHUDF LXQH FX HD VD F XWDW FD úL UHSUH]HQW ULOH SULQ PRGHOH HFRQRPHWULFH SULYLQG DVWIHO GH HYROX LL V ILH FRQIRUPH DFHVWHL UHDOLW

L 2 DVWIHO GH UHSUH]HQWDUH R

FRQVWLWXLH PRGHOXO HODERUDW GH SURIHVRUXO IUDQFH] *HUDUG &DORW ,SRWH]HOH DYXWH vQ YHGHUH OD GHILQLUHDPRGHOXOXLVXQW

WHQGLQ DJHQHUDO HVWHOLQLDU

VH]RQDOLWDWHD HVWH VWD LRQDU RVFLOD LLOH S VWUHD] SHULRDGHOH vQ FDUH DSDU YkUIXUL úL

SHUWXUED LDXUPHD] RGLVWULEX LHQRUPDO

F GHUL

N

&RQVWUXLUHD PRGHOXOXL DUH GUHSW SXQFW GH SOHFDUH IRUPD OLQLDU \ O

= DQ

+ D P W + X O

6H]RQDOLWDWHD HVWH LQWURGXV vQ PRGHO SULQ GLYL]DUHD SDUDPHWUXOXL D R vQ HOHPHQWH FDUH VH UHIHU OD

RUGRQDWDODRULJLQHSULYLQGWUHQGXO$ úLFRQVWDQWHOHVK FkWHXQDSHQWUXILHFDUHVXESHULRDG DQXDO

ÌQ FH SULYHúWH YDULDELOD ÄW´ DFHDVWD GHYLQH XQ DJUHJDW FDUH SHUPLWH GHUXODUHD WLPSXOXL SH

WULPHVWUHOXQLúLDQL$FHDVWDHVWHVLPEROL]DW FXMLKXQGHM

«KSHULRDGHVXEDQXDOHL

«P DQL 0RGHOXOVHSUH]LQW DVWIHO \U

= $ + D W M + LK + V U

V ST

+ XU

V ST

(VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU SRDWH IL I FXW XWLOL]kQG 0&003 (YLGHQW vQ XUPD DQXO ULL

GHULYDWHORU SDU LDOH SUHVXSXV GH DFHDVW PHWRG VH DMXQJH OD XQ QXP U GH K HFXD LL 3HQWUX

Y Ö ÖZ IDFLOLWDUHD RE LQHULL UDSLGH D HVWLPDWRULORU $ D VÖ Z VÖ VÖ X

UHFRPDQG P XWLOL]DUHD UHOD LLORU GH

[

FDOFXOODFDUHVDDMXQVvQXUPDXQRUDUWLILFLLDOJHEULFHHIHFWXDWHDVXSUDVLVWHPXOXLGHKHFXD LL

\

&DORW*±&RXUVGHVWDWLVWLTXHGHVFULSWLYH'XQRG3DULV

]

&RUHVSXQ] WRU 0&003 PLQLPL]DUHD H[SUHVLHL

* = Ç >\ LM

SUHVXSXQH

DQXODUHD

GHULYDWHORU

SDU LDOH

vQ

UDSRUW

FX

- D M + LK - w @

LM

SDUDPHWULL

b ` M + LK + Pv w _ M = K + FRQGXFH OD HJDOLWDWHD D c Ç

`

a

UH]XOW

F

$ = \ - Df

Vi

= \

= \

PK +

'DF

PLQ Ç X

wk

M

-D

M

XQGH

P

\

Ç M + LK

ÌQWUXFkW

d

a

úL

d

$V

w

a

`

= $ + V^

w^

GHULYDWHORU

vQ

UDSRUW

FX

GH XQGH vQ XUPD vPS U LULL OD P

FRQVLGHUkQG

L

PHGLD JHQHUDO

XQGH

$=

K

LQkQG VHDPD GH H[SUHVLLOH DQWHULRDUH SULYLQG

e w Ç wg

e

RE LQHP

úL $ UH]XOW F

K + ± » h - \ - ª M ²D ½ Õ

i

w

$QXODUHD

b` \ = Ç

M + LK

PLQ Ç X

- Dl

nr

vQ

P - K

= \k

DYHP

m op

= PLQ Ç

Ç

L = M =

P

j (M Ç

[\

YHGHUH

M + LK

-

($

F

+ D

(M

0&003

+ LK ) + V

)]

M

SUHVXSXQH

úL

GDF

PLQLPL]DUHD

LQHP

VHDPD

GH

H[SUHVLHL HJDOLWDWHD

+ LK ) DMXQJHPODH[SUHVLD

n = PLQ Ç o

q

« Ã ¬

\

n

m op

» - ª \ ½

n

- D

s

GHXQGHUH]XOW IRUPXODXWLO HVWLP ULLSDUDPHWUXOXL

P

Ç

o

(M

+ LK

)+

D

s (M

+ LK

±á

)²

³ Õã

r

D t YH]LUHOD LD

118

Öw D

=

z u w

P P

y

-

L \ { Ç {v x

- \

XQGH

\

L

\

PHGLDXQHLVXESHULRDGH

Ö $= \ -

VÖi

= \

PHGLDVXESHULRDGHLvQDQXOL

PK +

i

Ö| D

K + ± » Ö h - \ - ª M ²D ½ Õ

XQGH

\

PHGLDVXESHULRDGHLMLQGLIHUHQWGHDQ

M

([HPSOX 8WLOL]kQG GDWHOH SULYLQG SURGXF LD GH EHUH ± YH]L WDEHOXO FRORDQD SHQWUX DFHDVW VHULH K

WULPHVWUH L

DQL GDWHOH VXQW SUH]HQWDWH vQWUXQ WDEHO FX GXEO LQWUDUH %X\V%DORW

DVWIHOvQFkWV SXWHPRE LQHUDSLGPHGLLOHWULPHVWULDOH Ö D

=

¢

[

+ - ] = - ¢ +

Ö $ = Ö V Ö V

(-

) =

= - - ( - )(- ) = - = Ö V

~

= Ö V}

= -

7DEHOXO 7ULP

,

,,

,,,

,9

7RWDO

\

7RWDO

\ =

$QL

\ M

L

$JUHJDWXOFRPSRQHQWHORUVLVWHPDWLFHWUHQGVH]RQDOLWDWH UH]XOW DVWIHO

119

\Ö \Ö \Ö \Ö \Ö \Ö \Ö \Ö

Ö Ö M + LK + VÖ = $ +D

= =

= + - ¢ + ¢ + - = =

=

= + - ¢ + ¢ + - =

= + - ¢ + =

=

&LFOLFLWDWHD ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH RVFLOD LLOH LQWHUDQXDOH FLFOLFH FDUDFWHUXO ORU VLVWHPDWLF HVWH PDL SX LQ HYLGHQWvQVHQVXOF DWkWLQWHUYDOHOHODFDUHRVFLOD LLOHVHPDQLIHVW FkWúLLQWHQVLWDWHDORUSUH]LQW R UHODWLY LQFRQVWDQ

vQ GHFXUVXO WLPSXOXL 'HVLJXU DFHVW VSHFLILF DO HYROX LHL FDUH LQFOXGH R

VXILFLHQW GR] GH DOHDWRULX vQFkW IDFH GLILFLO vQFRUVHWDUHD vQ PRGHOH SUHGLFWLYH VDU GDWRUD IDFWRULORU JHQHUDWRUL GH DVWIHO GH RVFLOD LL )DFWRULL FHL PDL LPSRUWDQ L FDUH LQIOXHQ HD] FLFOXO DIDFHULORU VXQW OHJD L GH UHvQQRLUHD PLMORDFHORU GH SURGXF LH IOXFWXD LL vQ GRPHQLXO LQYHQ LLORU FRQIOLFWHOHVRFLDOHSVLKRORJLDSRSXOD LHLHWF 2 HYDOXDUH QXPHULF D LQWHQVLW

LL YDOXOXL GH UHFHVLXQH VDX D FHOXL GH UHYLJRUDUH úL

H[SDQVLXQHHFRQRPLF SRDWHILRE LQXW DVWIHO

L

F W

=

YDORUL QLYHODWH úL GHVH]RQDOL ]DWH QLYHOH DOH WHQG LQW HL

6HPQDO PGHDVHPHQHDYDULDQWD L

=

XQGH \Ö

\

- \Ö \Ö

¢

WUHQG

1XP U WRUXO UHOD LHL SUHVXSXQH HOLPLQDUHD SHUWXUED LHL XWLOL]kQG PHGLL PRELOH IXQF LL SROLQRPLDOH HWF SUHFXP úL HOLPLQDUHD VH]RQDOLW

LL vQ LSRWH]D vQ FDUH DFHDVWD H[LVW

RSHUD LXQH FDUH SUHVXSXQH GLYL]DUHD YDORULORU FDUDFWHULVWLFH OD LQGLFLLGHVH]RQDOLWDWHÌQDFHVWIHOOD FLFOLF QXP U WRUXO UDSRUWXOXL DSDU YDORUL FDUH LQFOXG GRDU WHQGLQ D JHQHUDO úL FRPSRQHQWD

5DSRUWkQG DFHVW ÄDJUHJDW´ WUHQGFLFOLFLWDWH OD WUHQG UH]XOW LQGLFLL GH FLFOLFLWDWH L

(L SRW IL

VXSUDXQLWDUL PDUFkQG H[SDQVLXQHD HFRQRPLF VDX VXEXQLWDUL VHPQDOkQG LQWHQVLWDWHD UHFHVLXQLL HFRQRPLFH

7HQGLQ DVHULDLQWHJUDW

VHULLOHFRLQWHJUDWHúLLPSOLFD LLOHDFHVWRUD

DVXSUDDQDOL]HLUHJUHVLHL

3UREOHPD H[LVWHQ HL WHQGLQ HL JHQHUDOH vQ VHULD GH GDWH LQWHUHVHD] QX QXPDL VXE DVSHFWXO

SURJQR]HL H[WUDSRO ULL HYROX LHL vQ WLPS FL úL GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD DFXUDWH HL SDUDPHWULORU GH UHJUHVLH HVWLPD LFDúLGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHDODQDOL]HLHFKLOLEUXOXLHFRQRPLFSHWHUPHQOXQJ

ÌQ HFRQRPLH PDMRULWDWHD VHULLORU HFRQRPLFH SULYLQG LQGLFDWRULL LPSRUWDQ L SUH XULOH FXUVXO

GH VFKLPE PDVD PRQHWDU FRQVXPXO H[SRUWXO HWF SUH]LQW WHQGLQ FRQVLGHUDWH 1(67$

$VWIHO GH VHULL VXQW

,21$5( )DSWXO F WHUPHQLL VHULHL FURQRORJLFH DX vQ JHQHUDO WHQGLQ H GH

FUHúWHUHVDXGHVF GHUHvQGHFXUVXOWLPSXOXLIDFHFDPHGLDúLUXOXLYDORULORUOXL\ V GLIHUHvQIXQF LH

120

GH PRPHQWXO W GHODFDUHFRQVLGHU PF vQFHSHVHULD0DLPXOWFKLDUúLGLVSHUVLDúLFRYDULDQ DVXQW GHSHQGHQWHGHYDULDELODWLPSW

6(5,$ 67$

HVWH DFHD VHULH DOH F UHL YDORUL RVFLOHD] PDL PXOW VDX PDL SX LQ

,21$5

DOHDWRUvQMXUXOXQXLQLYHOGHUHIHULQ

±PHGLDILLQGGHFLvQWURVWDUHGHHFKLOLEUX0DLSUHFLVVHULD

VWD LRQDU HVWH UH]XOWDWXO XQXL 352&(6 672&+$67,& 67$

,21$5 SHQWUX FDUH PHGLD úL

GLVSHUVLD VXQW FRQVWDQWH LQGLIHUHQW GH PRPHQWXO GH OD FDUH FRQVLGHU P F vQFHSH VHULD LDU

FRYDULDQ D GHSLQGH QXPDL GH GLVWDQ D ODJXO GLQWUH XQLW

LOH GH WLPS SHQWUXFDUHHVWHFDOFXODW

>@

$úDGDU 0 \ s

\

= \

W

= 0 >\

FRY \

\

W

W

W +N

- 0 \

= 0 >\

W

W

@

=s

- 0 \

W

@> \

@

W +N

- 0 \

W

5HYHQLQG OD VHULLOH QHVWD LRQDUH PHQ LRQ P F R WLSRORJLH D PDQLIHVW ULL WUHQGXOXL vQ GDWH HYLGHQ LD] GLVWLQFW

7HQGLQ D GH WLS GHWHUPLQLVW FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ IDSWXO F HVWH LQYDULDELO XúRU GH SUHY ]XW PHQ LQkQGXVH vQ WLPS DWkW FD GLUHF LH FkW úL FD SDQW (D SRDWH IL LQFOXV vQ IXQF LD GH UHJUHVLH FDXQIDFWRUGLVWLQFWVLPEROL]DWFXOLWHUDWDVWIHO \ = D

+ D [ + D W + X

7HQGLQ DGHWLSVWRFKDVWLFvQVHQVXOF VHPRGLILF SHGLYHUVHOHVHFYHQ HGHWLPS ÌQ UDSRUW FX PRGDOLWDWHD vQ FDUH HVWH UHFRPDQGDW HOLPLQDUHD WHQGLQ HL GLQ VHULD GH GDWH

GHRVHELP

6HULL QHVWD LRQDUH GHQXPLWH úL VHULL 763 ÄWUHQG VWDWLRQDU\ SURFHVVHV´ vQ FDUH WUHQGXO VH

UHFRPDQG V ILHHOLPLQDWSULQVF GHUHDDFHVWXLDGLQúLUXOGHGDWHHPSLULFHWHUPHQFXWHUPHQ \

W

= \

XQGH \Ö

W W

- \Ö

W

= WHQGLQ D

6HULL QHVWD LRQDUH GHQXPLWH VHULL '63 ÄGLIIHUHQFH VWDWLRQDU\ SURFHVVHV´ vQFDUHWUHQGXOVH

UHFRPDQG V ILH HOLPLQDW SULQ FDOFXOXO GLIHUHQ HORU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL \ HYHQWXDOGHRUGLQXOGRL \

= D\

W

W

= D\

W

- D\

W -

W

= D\

W

= \

- \

W

W -

VDXPDLPDUH

ÌQ OLWHUDWXUD HFRQRPHWULF GH GDW PDL UHFHQW vQWkOQLP VHULL FURQRORJLFH FDUDFWHUL]DWH SULQ

WHUPHQLFD

6(5,( ,17(*5$7

± DFHD VHULH QHVWD LRQDU FDUH SRDWH IL WUDQVIRUPDW vQWUR VHULH

VWD LRQDU SULQFDOFXOXOGLIHUHQ HORUGHRUGLQXOvQWkLVHULHLQWHJUDW GHRUGLQXOvQWkL±, \

W

= D\

W

FDOFXOXO \

W

= D\

= \

W

- \

W -

GLIHUHQ HORU W

= D\

W

W -

RUGLQXO

GRL

VHULH

LQWHJUDW

GH

RUGLQXO

GRL

±

,

DVWIHO

HWF

6HULD OD FDUH VH DMXQJH vQ ILQDO vQWUXFkW QX PDL LQFOXGH WHQGLQ FRQVLGHUDW VHULHLQWHJUDW

DGLF

LDU GDF WHQGLQ D QX D IRVW HOLPLQDW vQ WRWDOLWDWH VH SURFHGHD] OD

GH

- D\

GHRUGLQXO]HUR±,

ILLQG GHFL VWD LRQDU HVWH

6(5,, &2,17(*5$7( ± VXQW FRQVLGHUDWH DFHOH VHULL FURQRORJLFH FDUH LQWHJUDWH ILLQG GH DFHODúL RUGLQ DGPLW R FRPELQD LH OLQLDU FDUH HVWH LQWHJUDW GH RUGLQ ]HUR VDX vQ RULFH FD] HVWH LQWHJUDW GH RUGLQ PDL PLF GHFkW RUGLQXO GH LQWHJUDUH D VHULLORU LQL LDOH $VWIHO vQ FD]XO D GRX VHULL [ \ ILHFDUH ILLQG LQWHJUDW GH RUGLQXO vQWkL GDF H[LVW R FRPELQD LH OLQLDU Ä]´ FDUH SRDWH UH]XOWD DVWIHO ]

\

[ VDX ]

\ [

VDX PDL IUHFYHQW ]

\

D D [ FDUH HVWH

LQWHJUDW GH RUGLQXO ]HUR DILUP P F FHOH GRX VHULL VXQW FRLQWHJUDWH GH RUGLQXO vQWkL $úDGDU

$YHPvQYHGHUHVHULLOHVODEVWD LRQDUH

7HUPHQXOHQJOH]HVFÄLQWHJUDWH´DUHúLVHPQLILFD

LDGHDFRPSOHWDSULQvQVXPDUHDS U LORUFHHDFHvQDQDOL]DVHULLORUGH

GDWH DU UHSUH]HQWD R PRGDOLWDWH GH D UHFRPSXQH VHULD SULQ vQVXPDUHD SULPXOXL WHUPHQ FX GLIHUHQ HOH GH RUGLQXO , UHVSHFWLYDGLIHUHQ HORUGHRUGLQXO,SULQvQVXPDUHDFHORUGHRUGLQXO,,HWF

121

GDF \ ,

[ ,

úL ] ,

DILUP P F [ \ &,

$VWIHO GH VHULL VXQW FDUDFWHUL]DWH FD

ILLQGvQWURUHOD LHGHHFKLOLEUXSHWHUPHQOXQJ ]

8QLQWHUHVDSDUWHSUH]LQW FRPELQD LDOLQLDU FDUHFRQGXFHODRE LQHUHDYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOHX D

\

X FDUDFWHUL]DW FD ILLQG LQWHJUDW GH RUGLQ ]HUR ÌQWUR DVWIHO GH VLWXD LH

D [

ÄWHUHQXO HVWH SUHJ WLW´ SHQWUX R DQDOL] GH UHJUHVLH GH FDOLWDWH vQ FDUH HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU VXQW

FRQVLVWHQ L WHVWXO W úL ) RIHULQG UH]XOWDWH LPSRUWDQWH SHQWUX R DVWIHO GH DQDOL] 2 GHILQL LH D FRLQWHJU ULL DYkQG XQ JUDG PDL PDUH GH JHQHUDOL]DUH HVWH XUP WRDUHD FRPSRQHQWHOH YHFWRUXOXL ; VXQW GH RUGLQ E G GDF WRDWH FRPSRQHQWHOH YHFWRUXOXL ; VXQW LQWHJUDWH GH DFHODúL RUGLQ G úL GDF = a ë; UHSUH]LQW R VHULH LQWHJUDW

H[LVW XQ YHFWRU aa DVWIHO vQFkW YHFWRUXO = RE LQXW DVWIHO =

GHRUGLQGEE! >@9HFWRUXOÄ=´HVWHGHQXPLWYHFWRUGHFRLQWHJUDUHUHVSHFWLYGDF FRPELQD LD

OLQLDU HVWH UHSUH]HQWDW GH GLIHUHQ D \D D [ SDUDPHWUXO D SRDWH IL GHQXPLW SDUDPHWUX GH LQWHJUDUH5HJUHVLDvQV úLSHQWUXDVWIHOGHVHULLSRDWHILÄHWLFKHWDW ´GUHSWUHJUHVLHGHFRLQWHJUDUHLDU vQWUHJGHPHUVXOHVWHQXPLW$1$/,=

'(&2,17(*5$5(

3HQWUX PRGHODUHD HFRQRPHWULF SUH]LQW LQWHUHV DúD FXP DP DU WDW vQGHRVHEL VLWXD LD vQ

FDUHSHQWUXGRX VHULLFRLQWHJUDWHFRPELQD LDOLQLDU \D D [

XHVWHLQWHJUDW GHRUGLQ]HUR

$FHDVWD D FRQGXVODUHPDUFD³WKHYDOXDEOHFRQWULEXWLRQRIWKHFRQFHSWVRILQWHJUDWLRQXQLWURRWHWF LVWRIRUFHXVWRILQGRXWLIWKHUHJUHVVLRQUHVLGXDOVDUHVWDWLRQDU\´>@ 3HQWUX D vQFDGUD R VHULH FURQRORJLF vQWUXQD GLQWUH FDWHJRULLOH PHQ LRQDWH VH DSHOHD] OD UHSUH]HQW UL SULQ WDEHOH JUDILFH FURQRJUDPH FRUHORJUDPH GDU PDL DOHV OD WHVWHOH VWDWLVWLFH 'LQWUH PRGDOLW

LOH GH YHULILFDUH UHODWLY QXPHURDVH GHVFULVH vQ DUWLFROHOH úL F U LOH GH HFRQRPHWULH PDL

UHFHQWHQHUHIHULPvQGHRVHELODDFHOHDFDUHVXQWOHJDWHGLUHFWGHFDOLWDWHDSDUDPHWULORUGHUHJUHVLHGH DILFRQVLVWHQ L

$VWIHOvQYHGHUHDFDUDFWHUL] ULLVHULHLSULQFDOLILFDWLYXOVWD LRQDU VDXQHVWD LRQDU QHSXWHP

ED]D SH FURQRJUDP úL SH )81&

,$ '( $872&25(/$5( r FDUH H[SULP LQWHQVLWDWHD

GHSHQGHQ HLGLQWUHYDORULDOHVHULHLDIODWHODRGLVWDQ r

=

N

0

(\ W

- 0 \ )( \

- 0 \ )

ÌQFD]XOSURFHVHORUVWD LRQDUH s

r

[( \ W

0

=

FRYN FRY

\

=s

¤

W +N

(\ W

¢0

\

GHNXQLW

- 0 \ )]

+N

LGHWLPS

- 0 \ )

DVWIHOvQFkW r

¤¥ £

=

=

FRY \ s

W

¢s

¡

\

\

FRY \ ¡ \ ¡ s¨

§

¦

©

\

W +N

¡¢

VDXPDLVLPSOX

ÌQSUDFWLF SURFHG PODHVWLPDUHDIXQF LHLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHXWLOL]kQGXQHúDQWLRQGHQYDORUL

&D XUPDUH VH RE LQ FRHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U SHQWUX Q YDORUL LDU UHOD LD JHQHUDO GH FDOFXO

GHYLQH

« ¯

U¯

3HQWUXN

=

Ç° \ ® ®ª

- \ \ ®

Ç° \® ®ª

Ç \

U

=

W =

W

- \

- \ \

±

Ç \

W +

- \

Q

W =

3HQWUXN

- \

¯

RE LQHP Q -

¬

W

- \

RE LQHP

²

8QXOGLQWUHPRWLYHOHSHQWUXFDUHQXQHOLPLW PODXQVLQJXUWHVWSHQWUXRSUREOHP VROX LH GDW vOUHSUH]LQW úLIDSWXO

F SDFKHWHOH GH SURJUDPH UHFHQWH LQFOXG R JDP YDULDW GH WHVWH vQGHRVHEL SHQWUX DFHODúL RELHFWLY ÄDILúDWH´ SULQ VLPEROXULVDXHWLFKHWHODFRQLFHFDUHPHULW V ILHFXQRVFXWH

122

Q -

Ç \

U

=

- \ \

W

W =

W +

- \

Q

Ç \

- \

W

W =

³

9HULILFDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH vQ VHQVXOWHVWXOXLW SRDWHUHSUH]HQWD

XQ FULWHULX GH DSUHFLHUH $VWIHO 7(678/ %$57/(77 VH ED]HD] SH LGHHD F vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH

VHULD FURQRORJLF HVWH SXU DOHDWRDUH FRHILFLHQ LL HVWLPD L GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U U « U VXQW

´

DSUR[LPDWLY QRUPDO GLVWULEXL L GH PHGLH ]HUR úL GH GLVSHUVLH s

=

Q

&D XUPDUH GDF DYHP vQ

YHGHUH UHSDUWL LD QRUPDO UHGXV VWDQGDUG SXWHP VWDELOL LQWHUYDOXO GH vQFUHGHUH vQ FDUH VH vQFDGUHD] U .

N FX3

DVWIHO±sÊU ÊsXQGH s =

Q

ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH HVWLPD LLOH U VH vQFDGUHD] vQ LQWHUYDOXO PHQ LRQDW DILUP P F LSRWH]D

QXO r

HVWH FRQILUPDW ÌQ FD] FRQWUDU U VH VLWXHD] vQ DIDUD LQWHUYDOXOXL LSRWH]D QXO HVWH

LQILUPDW FHHDFHvQVHDPQ F YDORDUHDOXLr GLIHU VHPQLILFDWLYGH]HUR

* 3 %R[ úL ' $ 3LHUFH DX SURSXV 7(678/ 4 SULYLQG LSRWH]D VLPXOWDQHLW

LL

QHVHPQLILFD LHLWXWXURUFRHILFLHQ LORUGHDXWRFRUHOD LH+ µ GHILQLQGDVWIHOYDULDELOD

·

º

¶ ¹ U¸ 4 = Q Ç

¸

FDUH XUPHD] DVLPSWRWLF GLVWULEX LD

FX ÄP´ JUDGH GH OLEHUWDWH 'DF 4 !

»

¼

LSRWH]D QXO HVWH

LQILUPDW vQVHQVXOF FHOSX LQXQXOGLQWUHFRHILFLHQ LLr GLIHU VHPQLILFDWLYGH]HURLDUGDF 4

»

¼

VHULDHVWHFRQVLGHUDW VWD LRQDU

½

2 YDULDQW R UHSUH]LQW úL 7(678/ /-81*%2; /% SHQWUX FDUH D IRVW GHILQLW

YDULDELOD

P » ± UÖ N ² § /% = Q Q + Ç ª ª Q - N ² N = ½ Õ

»

¼

7HVWXO /% HVWH UHFRPDQGDW VSUH GHRVHELUH GH WHVWXO 4 ± UHOD LD vQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH

HúDQWLRQXO GH GDWH HVWH UHGXV Q 6LPLODU FD]XOXL DQWHULRU SHQWUX /% ! LQILUPDW QX WR L FRHILFLHQ LL r¾

»

VSUH GHRVHELUH GH /%

¼

¼

LSRWH]D QXO HVWH

FD] vQ FDUH + µ HVWH FRQILUPDW

FRHILFLHQ LLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHILLQGQHVHPQLILFDWLYL

»

2 PRGDOLWDWH GH YHULILFDUH FX XQ VSHFWUX PDL ODUJ vQ VHQVXO F SRDWH IL DSOLFDW úL SHQWUX D

DUJXPHQWD RS LXQHD vQWUH VHULD 736 úL VHULD '36 VDX VHULD &, À

µ

LL

XQLW

¿

úL VHULD &,

HVWH WHVWXO U

G

FLQLL

81,75227±7(67 $YkQGGUHSWSXQFWGHSOHFDUHPRGHOXO \

U\

Á

X

9DULDELOD ÄX ´ ILLQG QHDXWRFRUHODW GH PHGLH ]HUR úL GLVSHUVLH FRQVWDQW VH FRQVLGHU F

SHQWUXU

FD]vQFDUH\

ILLQGGHFLQHVWD LRQDU

\

Á

X YDULDELOD\ HVWHUH]XOWDWXOXQXLSURFHVGHPHUVODvQWkPSODUH

'DF DYHPvQYHGHUHYDULDQWDvQFDUHDSDUHúLSDUDPHWUXOOLEHU

Â

3HQWUXYHULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHFRUHOD LHVLPSO VHXWLOL]HD] WHVWXO

Ê

W ÄÆÅÇ

Ä¿ÈÇ ÅÉ

U

=

- U

Ã

Q -

Ë *0/MXQJ*3(%R[±2QD0HVXUHRI/DFNRI)LWLQ7LPH6HULHV0RGHOV%LRPHWULFDQR Ì

7HUPHQXOGH³XQLWURRW´VHUHIHU ODU G FLQLOHXQXLSROLQRPvQFDUHDSDUHXQRSHUDWRU%ODSXWHUHD«vQIXQF LH

GH P ULPHD vQWkU]LHULL $VWIHO SHQWUX \ \

Í

Ï ÍÎ Ï

E \

Ð ÍÎ Ð

Í

E \

X W

%\ SHQWUX \

ÍÎ Ï

Í

Ð

% \ SHQWUX \

ÍÎ Ð

Í

Ñ

ÍÎ Ñ Ð

Í

% \ «'HH[HPSOXPRGHOXODXWRUHJUHVLY

«Q SRDWHILUHGDWDVWIHO\ l %l %l l %

Í

Ï

Ð

Ð

Ï

X GDF U G FLQLOHl l

Í

Ï

Ð

Ë

Ï

Ð

ILH PDL PLFL GHFkW GDU GDF l $úDGDU HFXD LD \

Ï

E E

Ð

vQVLWXD

Í

Ï ÍÎ Ï

Ë

E \

Ð

úL Ãl Ã DILUP P F H[LVW R U G FLQ XQLWDU SHQWUX FDUH E

Ð Í Î Ð X Í LDvQFDUHÃE Ð Ã E \

Ï

Ò

SRDWHILXWLOL]DW SHQWUXDYHULILFDLSRWH]DQXO l

Ë

Ï

E

Ð

Ï Ð

E úLl l

E LDU % HVWH XWLOL]DW vQ VHQVXO DU WDW &RQGL LD GH VWD LRQDULWDWH SUHVXSXQH FD ÃE Ã ÃE ÃDGLF DWkWl FkWúLl úL E

Ð

Ò

V

l

Ò

GDF Ãl ÃVWDELOLQGGDF

Ò

123

\Ó

D Ô \ Ó

XQGHY Ó

ÕÔ

Y Ó

HURDUHVWD LRQDU GHPHGLH]HURúLs

Ö SULQvQORFXLULVXFFHVLYHDOHYDULDELOHL\ Ó ÕÔ \ Ó Õ Ö \ Ó ÕÔ D Ô \ Ó Õ Y Ó ÕÔ \Ó

ÕÖ

D Ô \ Ó

ÕØ

ÕÖ

Y Ó

Ö×

«FXH[SUHVLLOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUH

VHDMXQJHvQILQDOGXS GHFDODUHDvQWLPSSkQ ODXOWLPXOWHUPHQúLvQVXPDUHODH[SUHVLD \

= W ¢ DÛ

Ù

+ \

+ ÇY

Ú

Ù

VDXPDLVLPSOX \Ó

D Ü

XQGH

D Ô WX Ó

DÜ

\ Ü

= ÇY

XÝ

Ý

1HOVRQ úL 3ORVVHU GHQXPHVF SURFHVXO GHVFULV GH UHOD LD FD ILLQG XQ SURFHV 763 LDU HOHPHQWXO±FKHLHHVWHWUHQGXOUHSUH]HQWDWvQPRGHOGHYDULDELODÄW´

&RQVHPQ P GH DVHPHQHD F YDULDQWD LQL LDO \ Ó

VWkQJDHJDOLW

LLGLIHUHQ D\ Ó \ Ó \ Ó \ Ó

ÕÔ

DÔ

ÕÔ

D Ô Y Ó

\ Ó

ÕÔ

Y Ó SRDWH IL UHGDW DYkQG vQ

UHSUH]HQWkQGXQSURFHV'63vQFDUHHOHPHQWXO±FKHLHHVWHGLIHUHQ DGHRUGLQXOvQWkL

\ Ó \ Ó

ÕÔ

\Ó

Ô

$PEHOHYDULDQWHGHÄSUHOXFUDUH´DPRGHOXOXLLQL LDOGHÄPHUVODvQWkPSODUH´\ Ó

D Ô

\ Ó

ÕÔ

X Ó DXFDHOHPHQWFRPXQIDSWXOF XUP UHVFHOLPLQDUHDWHQGLQ HLOLQLDUHH[LVWHQWHvQGDWHDVWIHOvQFkW

V VHDMXQJ ODXQÄUHVWFXUDW´SXUDOHDWRU 'DF RELHFWLYXOHVWHUHDOL]DWSULQFDOFXOXOGLIHUHQ HORUGH

RUGLQXO vQWkL DILUP P F SURFHVXO HVWH GH WLS '63 LDU GDF GLIHUHQ HOH GH RUGLQXO vQWkL QX UH]ROY SUREOHPD VH UHFRPDQG OXDUHD vQ FDOFXO D WHQGLQ HL úL L]RODUHD DFHVWHLD GH GDWHOH LQL LDOH ILH SULQ LQFOXGHUHD H[SOLFLW vQ PRGHO D YDULDELOHL WUHQG ILH SULQ FDOFXOXO SUHDODELO DO WHQGLQ HL úL HOLPLQDUHD DFHVWHLDGLQGDWH± \

W

- \Ö

=X

W

W

3HQWUX D VWDELOL ÀÀ GDF VHULD HVWH GH WLS 763 VDX '63 DYHP vQ YHGHUH 7(678/ ',&.(<

)8//(5 ')WHVW

ÌQ DFHVW VFRS VH FRQVLGHU GUHSW SXQFW GH SRUQLUH R IRUP PDL JHQHUDO D

PRGHOXOXLFDUHLQFOXGH³HQFRPSDVV´ FHOHGRX IRUPHGHPDQLIHVWDUHDOHWUHQGXOXLvQGDWH \Ó

D Ü U\ Ó

XQGH

YÓ D Ü UD Ô W

ÕÞÔ

D Ô WY Ó

×Ö

¹

SDUDPHWULL «Q

ÌQVLWXD LDvQFDUH

D Ô

ÃUÃSURFHVXOHVWHGHWLS763

ÌQWUDGHY USHQWUXD Ô

YDULDELO VWD LRQDU GHPHGLH]HURúLs

úLU

SURFHVXOHVWHGHWLS'63

U

H[SUHVLDGHYLQH\ Ó

D Ü \ Ó

ÕÔ

Y Ó DGLF \ Ó \ Ó

ÕÔ

D Ü Y Ó ILLQG

FDUDFWHUL]DW FD '63 vQWUXFkW D Ü Y Ó UHSUH]LQW XQ SURFHV VWD LRQDU RVFLOkQG DOHDWRU vQ MXUXO

SDUDPHWUXOXL D Ü 3HQWUX U GH P ULPH QHW LQIHULRDU FHOHL FDUH LQGLF DXWRFRUHOD LH U SUDFWLF QHVHPQLILFDWLY H[SUHVLD GHYLQH \ Ó

DÜ

DúWHSW PFDY Ó V vQWUXQHDVF FRQGL LLOHVWD LRQDULW

D Ô W Y Ó DGLF SURFHV 763 SHQWUX FDUH QH

LL'HPHQ LRQDWF GHSDUWDMDUHDHVWHVXILFLHQWV

VHED]H]HSHYHULILFDUHDSDUDPHWUXOXLÄU´

6LPLODU VLWXD LHL vQWkOQLWH vQ FD]XO YHULILF ULL VHPQLILFD LHL SDUDPHWUXOXL GH UHJUHVLH YH]L

Ö ´ SUHFXP úL Ä s &DSLWROHOH ,,, úL ,9 VH HVWLPHD] Ä U

FRPSDU FXW Ó

ìîí ï ð ìîÓ vQWUXFkWGLIHU

á¿â à ß

´ VH GHWHUPLQ QLYHOXO W çÆèé

ç¿êé èë

Ö s = U

å æä ã

úL VH

GHYDORULOHUHSDUWL LHL6WXGHQWGXS FXPXUPHD] V DU W P

ññ

' $ 'LFNH\ : $ )XOOHU ± 'LVWULEXWLRQ RI WKH (VWLPDWRUV IRU $XWRUHJUHVVLYH 7LPH 6HULHV ZLWK D 8QLW 5RRW

-RXUQDORI$PHULFDQ6WDWLVWLTXH$VVRFLDWLRQQR

124

GDF Wòìîð

òóð ìîÓ W Ó ìîí ï ð ìîÓ +µ

SURFHV763

GDF Wòìîð

U

HVWHLQILUPDW DFHDVWDvQVHDPQ F VXQWHPvQSUH]HQ DXQXL

òóð ìîÓ !W Ó ìîí ï ð ìîÓ LSRWH]D QXO

HVWH DFFHSWDW U

SURFHVXO HVWH GH WLS '63 2

H[HPSOLILFDUHDFDOFXOHORUHVWHUHGDW vQDSOLFD LDFDUHXUPHD] PHQ LXQLORUUHGDWHvQFRQWLQXDUH

0HQ LXQL D ÌQWUXFkW SDUDPHWUXO ÄU´ VH UHIHU OD FRHILFLHQWXO GH DXWRFRUHOD LH D F UXL YDORDUH HVWH FHO PXOW HJDO FX XQX DXWRFRUHOD LH SHUIHFW UH]XOW F vQ FD]XO XQXL SURFHV '63 HVWLPDWRULL U ô XUPHD] RGLVWULEX LHFkWGHFkWVLPHWULF vQMXUXODGHY UDWHLYDORULU

QX

SHQWUXVLPSOXOPRWLYF U ô

QX SRDWH GHS úL QLYHOXO XQX 5HSDUWL LD QRUPDO VDX UHSDUWL LD 6WXGHQW QX SRDWH IL GHFL LQYRFDW 6ROX LDDIRVWGDW GH)XOOHUúL'LFNH\FDUHDXRE LQXWYDORULFULWLFHSULQVLPXO ULGHWLS0RQWH&DUOR SHQWUXGLYHUVHYDULDQWHGHH[SULPDUHDSURFHVXOXLQHVWD LRQDUYDORULSHFDUHOHVLPEROL] PILHWõ ILHtWDX

ûü

öø÷ùú öøõ

E 0&003 SRDWH IL OD IHO GH ELQH DSOLFDW úL SHQWUX WUDQVIRUPDUHD OLQLDU D H[SUHVLHL OD FDUH DMXQJHP GDF VF GHP GLQ DPEHOH S U L SH \ Ó D\ ý

= D

+ U

- \ ý þ ÿ

+ Dÿ W

+ Xý

'DF VLPEROL] P FX U

Ö SDUDPHWUXOXL E vQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUH+ E

FHHD FH FRQGXFH OD H[SUHVLD

ÕÔ

E XUPHD] V YHULILF P VHPQLILFD LD

Ö 9HULILFDUHDGHFXUJHVLPLODUvQWUXFkWDWHVWDGDF E

Ö = HVWHDFHODúLOXFUXFXDYHULILFDGDF U

Ö 9DULDQWD WHVW ULL VHPQLILFD LHL HVWLPDWRUXOXL E HVWH SUHIHUDW GDWRULW IDSWXOXL F PDMRULWDWHD SDFKHWHORU GH SURJUDPH RIHU YDORUL SHQWUX ÄW´ vQ FD]XO LSRWH]HL QXOH IRUPXODWH vQ UDSRUW FX ]HUR + E

3H GHDOW SDUWHXWLOL]DUHDSDUDPHWUXOXLERIHU DYDQWDMXODERUG ULLSUREOHPHLvQWURYDULDQW

JHQHUDO DPRGHOXOXLDXWRUHJUHVLYvQVHQVXOLQWURGXFHULLWXWXURULQIOXHQ HORUvQWkU]LDWH

D\ = E\

Ç E

+

D\

XQGH

+ H

= -

E

Ç

U

M = S -

E =

Ç

U

-

$FHDVW YDULDQW ÄH[WLQV ´ D WHVWXOXL HVWH vQWkOQLW VXE GHQXPLUHD GH 7(678/ $')

$XJPHQWHG'LFNH\±)XOOHUWHVW ([HPSOX

)LH GRX YDULDELOH HFRQRPLFH FDUH DX vQUHJLVWUDW vQWUXQ LQWHUYDO GH OXQL XUP WRDUHOH

YDORUL

ñ

9DORULFULWLFHW VWDELOLWHGH'LFNH\úL)XOOHU 7DEHOXO 7LSXOGHPRGHO

3REDELOLWDWHDGHDRE LQHRYDORDUHLQIHULRDU QLYHOXOXL

GDF Q

\ \ \

U\ D

D

Y

U\

U\ Y

Y

D W

GDF Q

6XUVD76WHZDUG±(FRQRPHWULFV7K$OODQ1<

125

9 Ó

= Ó

1H SURSXQHP V FDUDFWHUL] P ILHFDUH VHULH SULQ SULVPD WHVWXOXL %DUWOHWW D WHVWXOXL 4 D

WHVWXOXL/%SUHFXPúLDWHVWXOXL'LFNH\)XOOHU

&D]XOVHULHL9 Ó

&RHILFLHQ LLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHYH]LUHOD LD RE LQX LSHQWUXN

-

U

Ö

Ê U

Ê

UØ

â - Ê U

ÌQWUXFkW

FRHILFLHQ LL

VH

VXQWXUP WRULLU Ô

vQFDGUHD]

vQ

Ê DILUP PF VHULDHVWHDOHDWRDUHS

N

LQWHUYDOXO

ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHWHVWXO4RE LQHPFRUHVSXQ] WRUUHOD LHL 4

ü

ü

ü

¢

$FHDVW YDORDUHHVWHLQIHULRDU QLYHOXOXLWDEHODWc

ü

$SOLFkQGWHVWXO/MXQJ%R[±YH]LUHOD LD UH]XOW F » /% = ¢ ( + ) ¢ ª ª - ½

+

(-

)

± ² = - ² Õ

+

-

1LYHOXO DFHVWHL YDORUL VH DIO PXOW VXE FHO DO YDORULL WDEHODWH c

ü

FHHD FH LQGLF

IDSWXOF vQFD]XODPEHORUYHULILF UL4/% VWD LRQDULWDWHDVHULHL9

&D]XOVHULHL= &RHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH RE LQX L U

DIDUD LQWHUYDOXOXL -

Ê U

Ê

U

â - Ê U

U

VH VLWXHD] vQ

Ê GLPLQXkQGXVH OHQW FHHD FH

N

LQGLF QHVWD LRQDULWDWHD$FHHDúLFRQFOX]LHUH]XOW úLvQXUPDDSOLF ULLWHVWHORU4úL/% 4

¢

ü

ü

ü

» /% = ¢ ( + ) ¢ ª ª - ½

+

+

-

-

vQWUXFkWDPEHOHYDORULOHRE LQXWHGHS úHVFQLYHOXOYDORULLWDEHODWHc

"!$# !&%'

± ² = ² Õ

ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH WHVWXO 'LFNH\ )XOOHU DSOLFDW VHULHL =õ vQWUXFkW DFHVWD LQFOXGH FRPSRQHQWD

WUHQGDFRQGXVFRUHVSXQ] WRUUHOD LHL ODHFXD LD \

D

(;

ë ;

),

()

D W

*

] û

-

-

()

úLW

vQ FDUH ; LQFOXGH HOHPHQWHOH YHFWRUXOXL DUWLILFLDO GH

-

= ª -

-

ª ½

W

«VHSUH]LQW vQXUPDFDOFXOHORUDVWIHO

» ª

()

- ± ²

- ²

² Õ

HVWH LQIHULRU OXL ÃU Ã VHULD HVWH QHVWD LRQDU GH WLS 763 6H SRDWH

ÌQWUXFkW U

DILUPD F PRGHOXO ]Ö

W =

U\

0HQ LRQ P F PDWULFHD LQYHUV ; ; +

HOHPHQWDOHYHFWRUXOXL]

!

¢

W

= + W GHVFULH FRUHFW HYROX LD DVSHFW FRQILUPDW úL GH IDSWXO F

- = HVWHLQIHULRUYDORULLWDEHODWHW

YH]LWDEHOXO

$QDOL]D HIHFWHORU SH FDUH OH JHQHUHD] SUH]HQ D VDX DEVHQ D WUHQGXOXL vQ GDWH úL vQ JHQHUDO

vQWUHJ GHPHUVXO GH YHULILFDUH úL FDWHJRULVLUH D VHULLORU GH GDWH WHVWH DQDOL]D GH FRLQWHJUDUH SUREOHPDU G FLQLORUXQLW

LL SUH]LQW LQWHUHVGLQXUP WRDUHOHSXQFWHGHYHGHUH

126

FDOLWDWHD UH]XOWDWHORU PRGHOXOXL HFRQRPHWULF GHSLQGH úL GH P VXUD vQ FDUH WHQGLQ D

HYROXWLY VHÄLQWHUSXQH´vQDQDOL]DUHOD LHLGHGHSHQGHQ

GLQWUHGRX VDXPDLPXOWHSURFHVH3XWHP

DILUPD F vQ VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH VHULLOH GH GDWH PDL DOHV VHULLOH FURQRORJLFH FRQVWLWXLH ED]D GH GDWH LQIHUHQ D VWDWLVWLF VH ED]HD] vQGHRVHEL SH SURSULHW

LOH VHULHL JHQHUDWH GH SURFHVHOH VWRFKDVWLFH

VWD LRQDUH DúD FXP vQ FD]XO XWLOL] ULL GDWHORU SHQWUX XQ HúDQWLRQ LQIHUHQ D VWDWLVWLF GHSLQGH GH SURSULHW

LOHHúDQWLRQXOXLGHDILUHSUH]HQWDWLYúLGHYROXPVXILFLHQWGHPDUH>@

3HQWUX DQDOL]D GH UHJUHVLH HVWH LPSRUWDQW FD YDULDELOHOH \ úL [ [ V ILH FRLQWHJUDWH FHHD FH

Ö . DFHDVWD RIHULQG R ED] VROLG VROX LLORU HVWLPD LLORU LPSOLF VWD LRQDULWDWHD VHULHL UH]LGXXULORU X SUHFXPúLWHVWHORUWúL)

0DLPXOWVHSRDWHDUJXPHQWDF SHQWUXGRX VHULL\ [ FRLQWHJUDWH&, /

!

FRQYHUJ PDL UDSLG VSUH DGHY UDWHOH YDORUL D úL D ILLQG VXSUDFRQVLVWHQ L

û

# 0

Ö2 D Ö1 HVWLPDWRULL D

vQGHRVHEL SHQWUX ÄQ´

VXILFLHQWGHPDUH>@ ,QFOXGHUHD vQ DQDOL]D GH UHJUHVLH D GRX VDX PDL PXOWH VHULL FDUHQXVXQWFRLQWHJUDWHDYkQG

GH UHJXO JUDGH GH LQWHJUDUH GLIHULWH DUH FD UH]XOWDW RE LQHUHD XQXL FRHILFLHQW GH GHWHUPLQDUH 5 DSURSLDW GH XQX SUHFXP úL YDORUL SHQWUX ÄW´ FDOFXODW VXSHULRDUH FHORU WDEHODWH vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH ÄG´ FDOFXODW WHVWXO 'XUELQ:DWVRQ HVWH DSURSLDW GH ]HUR VHPQDOkQG DXWRFRUHOD LD YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH ÌQ DVWIHO GH VLWXD LL VH FRQVLGHU F UHJUHVLD UHOHY R GHSHQGHQ

ÄFHO SX LQ H[DJHUDW ´

VDXDOWIHOVSXVVXQWHPvQSUH]HQ DXQHLUHJUHVLLvQGRLHOQLFHSDUHDILFRUHFW YHULILFDUHSUH]LQW

VXVSLFLXQL*UDQJHUúL1HZEROGDXHWLFKHWDWRDVWIHOGHUHJUHVLHFXGHQXPLUHDGH û43

³6SXULRXVUHJUHVVLRQ´

GDUODRPDLDWHQW

&HL GRL DXWRUL DX SURSXV úL R PRGDOLWDWH SUDFWLF GH D GHSLVWD IDOVHOH UHJUHVLL DILUPkQG F vQ

VLWXD LOH vQ FDUHû 5

HVWHvQGRLHOQLF

! G /

57698 5;:8 69 0

DFHDVWDUHSUH]LQW XQVHPQDOF HVWLPDWRULLVXQWVXVSHF LLDUUHJUHVLD

³VSXULRXV´

GHSDUWDMDUHD vQ VHULL GH WLS 763 úL '63 SUH]LQW LQWHUHV DWkW SHQWUX SURJQR] vQ VHQVXO F VHULLOH 763 IDF SRVLELO RE LQHUHD GH SURJQR]H SHUIRUPDQWH FKLDU úL SH WHUPHQ OXQJ FkW úL SHQWUX DQDOL] vQWUXFkW DFHOHDúL VHULL 763 WUHEXLH IHULWH GH WUDQVIRUP UL SUHFXP FHOH H[SULPDWH GH GLIHUHQ HOH GH RUGLQXO vQWkL D\ D[ vQWUXFkW DVWIHO GH SUHOXFU UL DU GXFH OD SLHUGHUHD XQRU LQIRUPD LLXWLOHOHJDWHvQGHRVHELGHOHJ WXUDSHWHUPHQOXQJGLQWUHFHOHGRX YDULDELOH VHULLOH FRLQWHJUDWH HYLGHQ LD] R UHOD LH GH HFKLOLEUX SH WHUPHQ OXQJ vQ HFRQRPLH (URDUHD Ö < vQWUXFkW IRUPHD] R VHULH VWD LRQDU FDUH RVFLOHD] vQ MXUXO OXL ]HUR VHPQDOHD] VWDELOLWDWHD X

HYROX LHL vPSUHXQ D FHORU GRX YDULDELOH $VWIHO GH UHOD LL GH HFKLOLEUX SH WHUPHQ OXQJ SRW IL ÄGHFRQVSLUDWH´ SULQ DQDOL]D GH FRLQWHJUDUH HIHFWXDW SHQWUX YDULDELOHOH HFRQRPLFH LPSRUWDQWH SUHFXP SUH XUL úL VDODULL LPSRUW úL H[SRUW SUH XUL úL FRVWXUL SUH XULOH GLQ MXGH XO L úL SUH XULOH GLQ

MXGH XOMHWF

=>

ÌQPRGHOXO\

FDUH XÖ

E

=

D[ XFRQVLGHU PVHULLOH\ [ &,

?

?

?

?

@A BAC

FHHDFHLPSOLF X

?

\D[ vQFDUHVHULDX ,

?

?

@DC

ÌQP VXUDvQ

Ö VH DEDWH GH OD DGHY UDWD YDORDUH D SDUDPHWUXOXL D vQUHJLVWU P FRUHVSXQ] WRU DEDWHUL DOH VHULHL D \

E

Ö[ - D

E

GHODFHHDFHvQ HOHJHPSULQHYROX LHVWD LRQDU 7RWRGDW úLvPSU úWLHUHDYDULDELOHL X Ö

F

YDILvQFUHúWHUH

ÌQWUXFkW 0&003 SUHVXSXQH RE LQHUHD GH HVWLPDWRUL FDUH V PLQLPL]H]H vPSU úWLHUHD YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH DFHVW RELHFWLYVHUHDOL]HD] vQP VXUDvQFDUH

Ö VHDSURSLHGHÄD´DSURSLHUHFDUHHVWHFXDWkWPDLUDSLG FXFkWVHULD XÖG HVWH D

PDLDSURSLDW GHVHULDVWD LRQDU

=H

=I

&:-*UDQJHU31HZEROG6SXULRXV5HJUHVVLRQLQ(FRQRPHWULFV-RXUQDORI(FRQRPHWULFVYRO 'DF vQ PRGHOXO \

D

D [ X YDULDELOD [ QX UHSUH]LQW XQ UHJUHVRU VWRFKDVWLF FL GLPSRWULY SUH]LQW R WHQGLQ

D

A

HYLGHQW FD]vQFDUH;¶;QQXFRQYHUJHVSUHXQÄQLYHO´OLPLW RPDWULFHILQLW QHVLQJXODU DIHFWkQGGHFLFRQVLVWHQ D HVWLPDWRULORUÌQJHQHUDOvQHFRQRPLHVHULLOHGHGDWHVXQWQHVWD LRQDUHUHSUH]HQWkQGUH]XOWDWHVLPLODUHFHORUJHQHUDWHGH SURFHVH

GH

PHUV

OD

vQWkPSODUH

LQGHSHQGHQWH

VXSUDGLPHQVLRQHD] HYHQWXDOD GHSHQGHQ

GDU

vQWkPSO WRU

DVHP Q WRDUH

7HQGLQ D

H[LVWHQW

vQ

GDWH

[ \ DVSHFW VHPQDODW GH YDORULOH FDOFXODWH SHQWUX ÄW´ WHVWXO W FDUH VXQW

VXSHULRDUH FHORU WDEHODWH FKLDU úL vQ VLWXD LL vQ FDUH GHSHQGHQ D OD FDUH VH UHIHU HVWH VODE LQH[LVWHQW FKLDU $FHDVWD úL GDWRULW IDSWXOXL F SHQWUX VHULLOH LQWHJUDWH YDORULOH OXL W úL ) UH]XOWDWH GLQ FDOFXOH QX XUPHD] UHSDUWL LD 6WXGHQW UHVSHFWLY )LVKHU DúD FXP QH DúWHSWDP vQ FD]XO DFFHSW ULL LSRWH]HL QXOH 7HVWXO ÄG´ vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH VHPQDOHD] DXWRFRUHOD LD YDULDELOHL XÖ

J

HVWH VLQJXUXOFDUHÄGHFRQVSLU ´IDOVDGHSHQGHQ

&DXUPDUHDWXQFLFkQGGLVSXQHPGHVHULL

FURQRORJLFH GH GDWH HVWH UHFRPDQGDELO FD DQDOL]D GH FRLQWHJUDUH V SUHFHDG DQDOL]D GH UHJUHVLH ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH H[LVW VHPQDOHFXSULYLUHODRIDOV UHJUHVLHHVWHSUHIHUDELOV vQORFXLPYDORULOHOXL\ úL[ FXGLIHUHQ HOHGHRUGLQXOvQWkL

?

?

D\D[

127

0HWRGHOH GH HYDOXDUH D FRPSRQHQWHORU VLVWHPDWLFH RVFLODWRULL VH]RQDOLWDWH FLFOLFLWDWH

SUH]HQWDWH vQ DFHVW FDSLWRO VH ED]HD] vQ VSHFLDO SH HYDOX UL GH QDWXU VWDWLVWLF LQGLFL PHGLL ÌQ FDSLWROHOH XUP WRDUH YRP SUH]HQWD PHWRGH PDL UDILQDWH FDUH GHúL PDL ELQH IXQGDPHQWDWH QX FRQGXFvQPRGDXWRPDWODUH]XOWDWHPXOWPDLSUHFLVH $P SXWHD GH DVHPHQHD DG XJD F WRDWH DFHVWH PHWRGH UH LQ FHHD FH HVWH HVHQ LDO UHSHWDELO

GLQPDQLIHVW ULOHFRQVWDWDWHvQWUHFXW

%,%/,2*5$),(

%R[ * ( 3 -HQNLQV * 0 ± 7LPH 6HULHV $QDO\VLV )RUHFDVWLQJ DQG &RQWURO +ROGHQ'D\ 6DQ)UDQFLVFR

&XWKEHUWVRQ.+DOO6±$SSOLHG(FRQRPHWULFV7HFKQLTXHV:KUHDWRQV/WG

)RPE\7%5KRGHV*±$GYDQFHVLQ(FRQRPHWULFV-$,*UHVV/RQGRQ

*UDQJHU&:-±6SHFWUDO$QDO\VLVRI(FRQRPLF7LPH6HULHV3ULQFHWRQ8QLY3UHVV1<

*ULIILWKV : -XGJH * &DUWHU +LOO 5 ± /HDUQLQJ DQG 3UDFWLFLQJ (FRQRPHWULFV -RKQ :LOH\ DQG6RQV

*XMDUDWL'±%DVLF(FRQRPHWULFV0F*UDZ+LOO,QF1<

+DUYH\$&±7LPH6HULHV0RGHOV+RZHVWHU1<

-RKQVWRQ-±(FRQRPHWULF0HWKRGV0F*UDZ+LOO1<

0DGGDOD*6±,QWURGXFWLRQWR(FRQRPHWULFV0F0LOODQ3XEO

3HFLFDQ(6±(FRQRPHWULH(GLWXUD$OO%XFXUHúWL 7HUWLúFR 0 6WRLFD 3 3RSHVFX 7K ± 0RGHODUHD úL SUHGLF LD VHULLORU GH WLPS (GLWXUD $FDGHPLHL%XFXUHúWL

128

&DSLWROXO9,, 0RGHOHGLQDPLFHGHVWLQDWHLQFOXGHULLHIHFWHORUGHFDODWHvQ WLPS

0RGHOXO/DJ (IHFWXO FHORU PDL PXOWH GLQWUH LPSXOVXULOH GDWH HFRQRPLHL SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO IDFWRULORU H[RJHQL PRGLILFDUHD SUH XOXL XQXL SURGXV GH ED] LQYHVWLUHD GH IRQGXUL SHQWUX GH]YROWDUHD XQXL VHFWRU HFRQRPLF GHFODQúDUHD GH JUHYH vQ LQGXVWULD H[WUDFWLY FDODPLW

LOH QDWXUDOH HWF VH UHVLPWH

GXS WUHFHUHDXQXLLQWHUYDOPDLPLFVDXPDLPDUHGHWLPS

ÌQWUHPRWLYHOHFDUHSURYRDF vQWkU]LHULvQPDQLIHVWDUHDDF LXQLLXQXLIDFWRUGHRVHELP

PRWLYH GH QDWXU SVLKRORJLF GLQWUH FDUH PHQ LRQ P RELFHLXULOH LQHU LD WHDPD 'H

H[HPSOX R FUHúWHUH EUXVF D YHQLWXOXL QX GHWHUPLQ R PRGLILFDUH WRWDO D FRQVXPXOXL GDWRULW SH GH R SDUWH D RELúQXLQ HORU úL JXVWXULORU vQFHW

HQLWH LDU SH GH DOW SDUWH D WHPHULORU F ÄDFHDVWD QX

YD GXUD´ FD XUPDUH D QHFXQRDúWHULL SDU LDOH D FDUDFWHUXOXL SHUPDQHQW VDX WUDQ]LWRULX DO PRGLILF ULL FDX]HL PRWLYHGHQDWXU WHKQRORJLF GLQWUHFDUHFHOHSULYLQGDGDSWDUHDOLQLLORUGHIDEULFD LHVDXD UHFRQYHUVLHLIRU HLGHPXQF IDFFDXQLPSXOVSULYLQGFDSLWDOXOGHH[HPSOXLHIWLQLUHDXWLODMHORU VDX PkQDGHOXFUXGHH[HPSOXFUHúWHUHDVDODULLORUvQWUXQQRXVHFWRUGHDFWLYLWDWH V SURGXF XQHIHFW FDUHGRDUGXS XQWLPSVHYDPDQLIHVWDSUHJQDQW PRWLYH GH RUGLQ LQVWLWX LRQDO OHJDWH vQGHRVHEL GH REOLJD LLOH FRQWUDFWXDOH FDUH FRQGL LRQHD] DSURYL]LRQDUHD OLYUDUHD vQFDVDUHD GUHSWXULORU vQFDVDUHD GREkQ]LL SHQWUX GHSR]LWH OD WHUPHQ FDUH GH UHJXO DXGDUXOGHDvQWkU]LDVFKLPEDUHDvQUDSRUWFXPRGLILFDUHDÄSHVWHQRDSWH´D XQRUFRQGL LL ([LVWHQ DvQHFRQRPLHDXQRUDVWIHOGHPRWLYHIDFHFDvQWkU]LHUHDU VSXQVXOXLODXQHOHP VXUL LPSXOVXUL PRGLILF UL GH SROLWLF HFRQRPLF V VH PDQLIHVWH GH R DVHPHQHD PDQLHU vQFkW HODVWLFLWDWHDSHWHUPHQVFXUWGHYLQHLUHOHYDQW

'RDU WUHFHUHD WLPSXOXL úL ÄGH]OHJDUHD´ GH REOLJD LLOH RELFHLXULOH úL WHPHULOH FDUH OHDJ

FRPSRUWDPHQWXODJHQ LORUHFRQRPLFLGHWUHFXWIDFFDUROXOIDFWRUXOXLV DSDU WRWPDLUHOHYDQW

ÌQUDSRUWFXGXUDWDGHDúWHSWDUHDHIHFWXOXLvQWkU]LHULOHSRWIL GH GXUDW IRDUWH VFXUW PRGLILFDUHD WHPSHUDWXULL FRQVXPXO GH E XWXUL FUHúWHUHD RIHUWHL GH

SURGXVHGHILFLWDUHYkQ] ULOHVFKLPEDUHDSUH XOXLQLYHOXOYkQ] ULORUHWF

GH GXUDW VFXUW GH UHJXO PDL PLF GH XQ DQ LQWHQVLILFDUHD UHFODPHL YkQ] ULOH

VWLPXOHQWHOHPDWHULDOHSURGXF LDFUHúWHUHDGREkQ]LORUFUHúWHUHDGHSXQHULORUFUHúWHUHDLQIOD LHL DFFHOHUDUHDFLUFXLWXOXLEDQLORU

GH GXUDW PHGLH vQWUH DQL PRGHUQL]DUHDWHKQRORJLHLSURGXF LDPRGLILF ULGHOHJLVOD LH FRPSRUWDPHQWXO

HFRQRPLF

vPEXQ W

LUHD

FDOLW

LL

SURGXVXOXL

FUHúWHUHD

YkQ] ULORU

LQGXVWULDOL]DUHDFDOLWDWHDPHGLXOXLHWF

GH OXQJ GXUDW LQYHVWL LL vQ WUDQVSRUWXUL UHQWDELOL]DUHD WUDQVSRUWXULORU SUHFXP úL D DOWRU

DFWLYLW vQY

L LQYHVWL LL vQ FRQVWUXF LL GH]YROWDUHD SURGXF LHL úL D VWDQGDUGXOXL GH YLD

PkQWXOXLFUHúWHUHDSURGXFWLYLW

LLúLDFDOLW

LLDFWLYLW

GH]YROWDUHD

LORUHWF

2 PHQ LXQH DSDUWH PHULW D IL I FXW FX SULYLUH OD FRQH[LXQLOH GH WLS IHHGEDFN úL IHHG

IRUHZDUG FDUH SUHVXSXQ úL HOH R GLVWDQ

vQ WLPS GH OD GHFODQúDUHD XQHL DF LXQL UHVSHFWLY DWLQJHUHD

XQXLRELHFWLYSkQ ODFRQVWDWDUHDHIHFWXOXL

3UREOHPHOH GH P VXUDUH FDUH DSDU vQ VSHFLILFDUHD úL XWLOL]DUHD PRGHOXOXL ODJ vQ DQDOL]D úL

SURJQR]DHFRQRPLF VXQW D VWDELOLUHDXQLW

LLGHWLPSODFDUHVHUHIHU ILHFDUHQLYHODOYDULDELOHORUPRGHOXOXL

129

E GHOLPLWDUHDvQWkU]LHULLDSDUL LHLHIHFWXOXL F HVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORU

LL GH WLPS F UHLD vL FRUHVSXQGH XQ QLYHO \ SUHVXSXQH DOHJHUHD vQWUH

D 6WDELOLUHD XQLW

SRVLELOLW

LOH GH D RE LQH GDWH DQXDOH WULPHVWULDOH OXQDUH V SW PkQDOH HYHQWXDO FLQFLQDOH VDX

GHFHQDOH 8Q LQWHUYDO XQLWDWH GH WLPS SUHD PDUH IDFH LQDFFHVLELO GHSLVWDUHD GH LQIOXHQ H FX vQWkU]LHUL GH GXUDWH VFXUWHLDUDOHJHUHDXQHLXQLW

LGHWLPSSUHDPLFLSRDWHSURYRFDGLILFXOW

LvQFH

SULYHúWH RE LQHUHD GDWHORU VDX HOLPLQDUHD vQWkU]LHULORU GH GXUDW OXQJ &D XUPDUH QH ED] P vQ RS LXQLOH QRDVWUH SH SDUWLFXODULW XOWLPXO UkQG SH SRVLELOLW

LOH IHQRPHQXOXL RELHFWLYHOH GHPHUVXOXL HFRQRPHWULF úL QX vQ

LOH H[LVWHQWH GH D RE LQH GDWH SULYLQG XQLWDWHD GH WLPS FRQVLGHUDW

UHYHODWRDUH5HIHULWRUODDFHVWGLQXUP DVSHFWPHQ LRQ PF GHVHRULGDWHOHVXQWDQXDOHFD]vQFDUH SRVLELOLW

LOHGHDOHJHUHVXQWDSURDSHQXOH

E 'HOLPLWDUHD vQWkU]LHULORU OD FDUH HIHFWXO U VSXQGH DWXQFL FkQG YDULDELOD H[RJHQ VH PRGLILF SRDWH EHQHILFLD GH DYDQWDMHOH XQHL UHSUH]HQW UL JUDILFH DGHFYDWH DFHVWXL VFRS $VWIHO FURQRJUDPDSULYLQGHYROX LDYDULDELOHLFDX]DOHH[SXV SHRKkUWLHGHFDOFúLVXSUDSXV FURQRJUDPHL YDULDELOHL HIHFW SRDWH SXQH vQ HYLGHQ

SULQWUR VLPSO GHSODVDUHDXQHLDGLQWUHFURQRJUDPHSHD[D

WLPSXOXL RDQDORJLHFDUHDSDUHGXS XQDVDXPDLPXOWHXQLW

LGHWLPS

F ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHSDUDPHWULLPRGHOHORUFXHIHFWvQWkU]LDWPRGHOHODJPRGHOHGLQDPLFH

DFHúWLD VXQW YDULDELOL FD QXP U vQ UDSRUW FX WLSXO GH PRGHO UH]XOWDW vQ XUPD VSHFLILF ULL ÌQ PRG IUHFYHQWGHRVHELP

PRGHOHXQLIDFWRULDOHvQFDUHHIHFWXOVHUHVLPWHGXS RvQWkU]LHUHGHRXQLWDWHGHWLPS \

D D [

X

XQGH \ [

SURGXFWLYLWDWHDVDXRIHUWDVDXUHFROWD XWLODMHVDXFHUHUHDVDXXPLGLWDWHDVROXOXL

PRGHOH DXWRUHJUHVLYHvQFDUHvQWkU]LHUHDHVWHGLVWULEXLW HúDORQDW SHPDLPXOWHXQLW

LGH

WLPS \

D D \ XQGH\

D

\

X

FRQVXPXOVDXDFXPXO ULOHVDXSURILWXO

PRGHOH PL[WH vQ FDUH YDULDELOHOH FDX]DOH FX VDX I U HIHFW vQWkU]LDW SRW IL GH QDWXU H[RJHQ [ VDXDXWRFRUHODWH\ \

D D [ D [

D \

X

XQGH \ [

FHUHUHDFDOLWDWHD YHQLWXOXWLODUHD

G 0RGHOHvQFDUHYDULDELODIDFWRULDO [ vúLWUDQVPLWHHIHFWXOvQPRGWUHSWDWDWkWvQSHULRDGD WFkWúLSHSDUFXUVXOXQXLQXP UILQLWGHSHULRDGHGHvQWkU]LHUH $úDGDUHVWHSUHVXSXV RGLVWULEX LHDLQIOXHQ HLSHPDLPXOWHSHULRDGHGHWLPSODJGLVWULEXLW VDXvQWkU]LHULHúDORQDWH \

D D [ D

[

D

[

D

[

X

XQGH

\

SURGXF LD \

[

LQYHVWL LLOH

LQIOD LD [

\

FUHúWHUHDRIHUWHLGHEDQL [

P ULPHDGHSR]LWXOXL GREkQGDFXFDSLWDOL]DUH

ÌQWUXQ DVWIHO GH PRGHO SDUDPHWUXOXL D vL SXWHP DWULEXL VHPQLILFD LD HFRQRPLF GH

PXOWLSOLFDWRU GH LPSDFW H[SULP PRGLILFDUHD vQ PHGLH D YDULDELOHL \ OD R PRGLILFDUH XQLWDU D YDULDELOHL [ vQ DFHHDúL SHULRDG ÄW´ 'DF PRGLILFDUHD YDULDELOHL [ VH PHQ LQH úL vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH DWXQFL D D H[SULP PRGLILFDUHD YDULDELOHL \ vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH UHVSHFWLY D D D vQ SHULRDGD YLLWRDUH HWF $VWIHO GH VXPH SDU LDOH UHSUH]LQW PXOWLSOLFDWRUL LQWHULPDUL vQ WLPS FH VXPD E

D D

D D UHSUH]LQW vQ UHOD LD PXOWLSOLFDWRUXO WRWDO SH WHUPHQ OXQJ

>@

130

ÌQWUH YDULDQWHOH PRGHOXOXL FX ODJ GLVWULEXLW VH GHWDúHD] SULQ IUHFYHQ D DSDUL LHL ORU vQ

VWXGLLOHDSOLFDWLYH

D YDULDQWDGHVFUHúWHULLvQWLPSDHIHFWXOXLJHQHUDWGHPRGLILFDUHDIDFWRUXOXL \

D D [ N[

N

[

X N

E YDULDQWDFUHúWHULLWUHSWDWHDHIHFWXOXLXUPDW GHRGHVFUHúWHUHWUHSWDW SkQ ODDQXODUH \

D E [

E

[

E [

E E E !E !!E

X

ÌQDLQWH GH D DERUGD PDL vQ GHWDOLX PRGHOHOH VSHFLILFH ILHF UHL YDULDQWH PHQ LRQ P F vQ

SULQFLSLXPHWRGDFHORUPDLPLFLS WUDWHSRDWHILXWLOL]DW vQYHGHUHDHVWLP ULLvQGLYHUVHYDULDQWH2 SULP YDULDQW VDUGDWRUDOXL$OWúL7LQEHUJHQFDUHDXSURSXVFDvQFD]XOPRGHOXOXLFXODJGLVWULEXLW V VHSURFHGH]HVHFYHQ LDODVWIHO vQWURSULP HWDS V VHHVWLPH]HSDUDPHWULLPRGHOXOXL

\

D D [ X

FHDGHDGRXDHVWLPDUHV VHUHIHUHOD \

D D [ D

[

X

[

D

XUPkQGDSRLPRGHOXO \

D D [ D

[

X

úL DúD PDL GHSDUWH SkQ FkQG P ULPHD QHVHPQLILFDWLY D XOWLPXOXL SDUDPHWUX VDX VFKLPEDUHD VHPQXOXLDFHVWXLDvQUDSRUWFXHVWLPD LLOHDQWHULRDUH V RSUHDVF vQGHS UWDUHDvQWUHFXWÌQDFHVWIHO SH OkQJ HVWLPDWRUL VDU UH]ROYD úL SUREOHPD VWDELOLULL RELHFWLYH D RUGLQXOXL P ULPLL ODJXOXL PRGHOXOXL FX HIHFWH vQWkU]LDWH 0RWLYH SUHFXP PXOWLFROLQLDULWDWHD GLQWUH [ \

úL HIHFWXO HL

ÄGLVWUXFWLY´DVXSUDHVWLPD LLORUFDúLGLPHQVLXQHDUHODWLYUHGXV DVHULLORUGHWLPSGHFDUHGHUHJXO GLVSXQHPDXI FXWFDSURFHGHXOV ILHFDOLILFDWGUHSWQHSHUIRUPDQWúLV FDG vQXLWDUH ÌQ PRG IUHFYHQW SHQWUX PRGHOHOH SUH]HQWDWH vQ UHOD LLOH VH SURFHGHD] OD HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU IRORVLQG 0&003 GHúL XQHOH YLRO UL DOH LSRWH]HORU PHWRGHL VXQW UHFXQRVFXWH $VWIHO H[LVWHQ D vQWkU]LHULL vQ GHFODQúDUHD HIHFWXOXL IDFH FD HVWLPDWRULL V QX ILH HILFLHQ L úL QLFL VXILFLHQW GH VWDELOL GDWRULW GHSHQGHQ HL YDULDELOHL FDX]DOH GH SHUWXUED LH FD úL GDWRULW FROLQHDULW

LL $VWIHO GH YLRO UL DOH LSRWH]HORU 0&003 DSDU FX R GHRVHELW FODULWDWH vQGHRVHEL

vQWUXQ PRGHO DXWRUHJUHVLY FX ODJ GLVWULEXLW ÌQ )LJXUD VXQW VFRDVH vQ HYLGHQ

SULQ V JH L

GHSHQGHQ HOHQHGRULWHGLQWUHXQHOHYDULDELOH \

= I \

\

\

= I \ \

\

= I \

X

X

\ X

)LJXUD

ÌQVFRSXOHYLW ULLDFHVWRUVXUVHGHGHIRUPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUHVWLPD LVHUHFRPDQG

PHWRGD YDULDELOHORU LQVWUXPHQWDOH vQ YHGHUHD vQORFXLULL YDULDELOHL \

FX R DOWD LQWHQV

FRUHODW FXDFHDVWDGDULQGHSHQGHQW vQUDSRUWFXSHUWXUED LD

UHDOL]DUHDXQRUWUDQVIRUP ULGHYDULDELOHvQYHGHUHDUHGXFHULLQXP UXOXLDFHVWRUDvQGHRVHEL

vQ PRGHOHOH FX ODJ GLVWULEXLW 7UDQVIRUPDUHD .R\FN OD FDUHQHUHIHULPSUHVXSXQHFDvQFD]XO PRGHOXOXL V UHDOL] P R GHFDODUH FX R XQLWDWH GH WLPS GHFL \ GHYLQH \

[ GHYLQH [

V

([SULPDUHDÄPRGHOFXODJGLVWULEXLW´HVWHLQVSLUDW GHGHQXPLUHDGLQOLPEDHQJOH] ÄGLVWULEXWHGODJPRGHO´7RWDúDGHELQHDU

SXWHDILIRORVLW H[SULPDUHDGHDVW GDW SUHOXDW GLQOLPEDIUDQFH] ÄPRGHOFXvQWkU]LHULHúDORQDWH´

131

vQPXO LP DFHDVW QRX HFXD LH FX R FRQVWDQW ÄN´ úL FHHD FH UH]XOW V VF GHP GLQ HFXD LD LQL LDO 2E LQHP

\ N\

D ±D ND [ D N[

±D N[

D N [

±D N [

X ±NX

ÌQXUPDVLPSOLILF ULORUvQODQ DMXQJHPODRUHOD LHPDLVLPSO \

D N N\

D [ X ±NX

ÌQ HFXD LD OD FDUH VD DMXQV IHQRPHQXO PXOWLFROLQLDULW

LL SUH]HQW vQ HFXD LD

HVWHGLPLQXDWvQPDUHP VXU FHHDFHQXVHSRDWHDILUPDúLFXSULYLUHODLQGHSHQGHQ DIDFWRUXOXLGH SHUWXUED LH ([HPSOX 6H FXQRVF XUP WRDUHOH GDWH VWDWLVWLFH OXQDUH SULYLQG HYROX LD WD[HL VFRQWXOXL [ úL D UDWHL PHGLLDGREkQ]LORUEDQFDUHDFWLYH\ vQLQWHUYDOXOLXQLH±PDUWLH 7D[D

VFRQWXOXL 5DWD GREkQ]LL

$FFHSWkQGXVH LSRWH]D SURSXV GH WHRULD HFRQRPLF FRQIRUP F UHLD PRGLILFDUHD WD[HL VFRQWXOXLLQIOXHQ HD] UDWDGREkQ]LLvQSHULRDGDUHVSHFWLY GDUúLvQSHULRDGHOHLPHGLDWXUP WRDUHD IRVWDGRSWDWXUP WRUXOPRGHOFXODJGLVWULEXLW \

D D [ N[

N

[

X

ÌQ XUPD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU FX DMXWRUXO SDFKHWXOXL GH SURJUDPH (;&(/ VDX RE LQXW

XUP WRDUHOHUH]XOWDWH 6800$5<287387

5HJUHVVLRQ6WDWLVWLFV

0XOWLSOH5

56TXDUH

$GMXVWHG56TXDUH

6WDQGDUG(UURU

2EVHUYDWLRQV

$129$

GI

66

06

)

5HJUHVVLRQ

5HVLGXDO

7RWDO

&RHIILFLHQWV

6WDQGDUG(UURU

W6WDW

,QWHUFHSW

;9DULDEOH

;9DULDEOH

132

ÌQILQDODUH]XOWDWXUP WRUXOPRGHO \Ö

W

= + \

W -

+ [

W

0RGHOXO FX ODJ GLVWULEXLW FDUH SUHVXSXQH WUDQVIRUPDUHD .R\FN HVWH FRQVLGHUDW UHVWULFWLY FKLDUULJLGvQFHSULYHúWHPRGXOGHDERUGDUHDLQIOXHQ HLvQWkU]LDWH>@

0RGHOXO $/021 SDUH SULQ FRPSDUD LH PDL IOH[LELO FRQVLGHUkQG LQIOXHQ D UHSDUWL]DW vQ

WLPSFDILLQGELQHGHVFULV GHXQSROLQRPGHJUDGXOGRL

$FHDVWD DU vQVHPQD F HIHFWHOH PRGLILF ULL IDFWRUXOXL GHYLQ WRW PDL SURQXQ DWHSHP VXU FH

vQDLQW P vQ WLPS VH DWLQJH XQ PD[LP GXS FDUH LQWHQVLWDWHD HIHFWHORU VFDGH 1X HVWH H[FOXV QLFL SRVLELOLWDWHD FD EROWLUHD FXUEHL V ILH LQYHUV úL QLFL VLWXD LD vQ FDUH XQ SROLQRP GH JUDGXO WUHL VDX PDL PDUH GHVFULH PDL ELQH HYROX LD LQWHQVLW

LL LQIOXHQ HL vQWkU]LDWH 6KLUOH\ $OPRQ FRQVLGHU

ED]kQGXVH SH WHRUHPD OXL :HLHUVWUDVV F SDUDPHWULL PRGHOXOXL FX ODJ GLVWULEXLW \

E [

E [

D

E

[

X SRW IL DSUR[LPD L SULQWUXQ SROLQRP GH JUDGXO L FRUHVSXQ] WRU OXQJLPLL

vQWkU]LHULLODJXOXL $VWIHOSHQWUXFD]XOvQFDUHLQWHQVLWDWHDLQIOXHQ HLXUPHD] vQWLPSRIXQF LHUHSUH]HQWDW GH

XQSROLQRPGHJUDGXOGRLDYHPvQYHGHUHH[SUHVLD E

D D LD L

UHVSHFWLYvQFD]XOJHQHUDODFHVWDDUHH[SUHVLD E

D D LD

L

L

D

P

OXQJLPHDPD[LP DODJXOXL

(WDSHOHSUHPHUJ WRDUHDSOLF ULLSURSULX]LVHDSURFHGHXOXLSURSXVGH$OPRQVHUHIHU OD D VWDELOLUHD QXP UXOXL PD[LP GH SHULRDGH vQ FDUH LQIOXHQ D vQWkU]LDW HVWH VHPQLILFDWLY

DYkQGXVHvQYHGHUHIDSWXOF XQQXP USUHDPDUHP! SRDWHP ULFRQVLGHUDELOULVFXOGHDLQFOXGH LQIOXHQ H LUHOHYDQWH FX HIHFWH QHGRULWH DVXSUD SUHFL]LHL HVWLPDWRULORU vQ WLPS FH XQ QXP U SUHDPLF ULVF V ÄVFRDW GLQ MRF´ HIHFWH vQWkU]LDWH VHPQLILFDWLYH GHWHUPLQDQWH DVXSUD YDULDELOHL \ $QDOL]D VHPQLILFD LHLSDUDPHWULORUvQVHQVXOWHVWXOXLÄW´DUSXWHDILXWLO vQVWDELOLUHDP ULPLLODJXOXL E VWDELOLUHD JUDGXOXL SROLQRPXOXL P XWLOL]DW SHQWUX D GHVFULH HYROX LD SDUDPHWULORU vQ UDSRUW FX vQWkU]LHUHD ÌQ IXQF LH GH QXP UXO SXQFWHORU GH WXUQXU HVWH VWDELOLW úL JUDGXO SROLQRPXOXL 'H H[HPSOX GDF SH P VXU FH LQWHUYDOXO GLQWUH GHFODQúDUHD FDX]HL úL SURGXFHUHD HIHFWXOXL FUHúWH LQIOXHQ D vQFHSH SULQ D FUHúWH DWLQJH XQ PD[LP GXS FDUH GHVFUHúWH ± VH DSUHFLD] H[LVWHQ D XQXL VLQJXU SXQFW GH WXUQXU VFKLPEDUH GH VHQV DVWIHO vQFkW XQ SROLQRP GH JUDGXO GRL HVWH FRQVLGHUDW DGHFYDW ÌQWUXFkW úL vQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL $OPRQ H[LVW SHULFROXO FD PXOWLFROLQLDULWDWHD V DIHFWH]H UH]XOWDWHOHVHUHFRPDQG FDQXP UXOUHJUHVRULORU[

[

[

V ILHFkWPDLPLF

$FHVWHDVSHFWHRGDW UH]ROYDWHVHSRDWHWUHFHODHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUÌQDFHVWVFRSDYHP

vQ YHGHUH R HYROX LH D LQWHQVLW

LL LQIOXHQ HL vQWkU]LDWH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH SROLQRPXOXL GH JUDGXO GRL

IUHFYHQW XWLOL]DW vQ DSOLFD LL FRQFUHWH E

D

D L D L vQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO FX ODUJ GLVWULEXLW

SHQWUXWUHLSHULRDGHGHvQWkU]LHUH \

D E [ E [

E

[

E

[

X

'DF DYHPvQYHGHUHUHOD LD úLRLQWURGXFHPvQ RE LQHP

2 IXQF LH FRQWLQX vQWUXQ LQWHUYDO vQFKLV SRDWH IL DSUR[LPDW SH vQWUHJ LQWHUYDOXO GH F WUH XQ SROLQRP GH JUDG

FRUHVSXQ] WRU FDUH GLIHU ID

GH IXQF LH FX R YDORDUH PDL PLF GHFkW RULFH FDQWLWDWH SR]LWLY GDW vQ ILHFDUH SXQFW GLQ

LQWHUYDO>@

133

\

= D +

Ç D

= D + D

+ D L + D L

[

[ Ç

L[ Ç

+ D

+X

=

L Ç

+ D

[

ÌQFRQWLQXDUHGHILQLPYDULDELOHOH] ] ] DVWIHO

=

=

=

= Ç[ W

= Ç L[ W

-L

L =

= ÇL

-L

L =

[

X

W -L

L =

0RGHOXO SRDWHILUHIRUPXODWDVWIHO

# %

#

\

'

DD = !

D =

D =

(VWLPDWRULL D " D $ D & D VXQWRE LQX LFXDMXWRUXO0&003

3DUDPHWULLPRGHOXOXLLQL LDO VXQWHVWLPD LXUPkQGSURFHGHXOUH]XOWDWGLQWHRUHPDOXL

:HLHUVWUDVVDVWIHO

,

*

ODJ = E

,

ODJ

) = E

=

,

( E

ODJ =

,

ODJ = E

,

=

+

*

= D

,

* D

+

,

= D

,

) D

+ D

,

* D ,

,

) + D *

,

)

+

(

,

( D ,

+ D + D

(

ÌQFD]XOJHQHUDOvQFDUHODJXOHVWHGHP ULPHN

0

E1

=

0

/ D

+

0

. N D

+ N

- 0

D

-

ÌQ FH SULYHúWH DFXUDWH HD HVWLPD LORU DVWIHO RE LQXWH PHQ LRQ P F PXOWLFROLQLDULWDWHD FRQWLQX V UHSUH]LQWH R ÄSUREOHP ´ DFHDVWD úL SHQWUXIDSWXOF YDULDELOD=UHSUH]LQW RFRPELQD LH OLQLDU DYDULDELOHORU;FDUHVXQWIUHFYHQWFROLQLDUH /DDFHVWHDVHPDLDGDXJ XQHOHOLPLWHGDWRUDWH VXELHFWLYLVPXOXLWRWDOVDXSDU LDO FDUHLQWHUYLQHvQRS LXQHDSULYLQGJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXLúLP ULPHD ODJXOXL 7RWXúL PRGHOXO $OPRQ SUH]LQW úL R VHULH GH DYDQWDMH ILLQG PDL IOH[LELO vQ VHQVXO F IDFH SRVLELO DOHJHUHD vQWUH GLYHUVH WLSXUL GH LQIOXHQ H vQWkU]LDWH GHVFULVH SULQWUXQ JUDG DGHFYDW DO SROLQRPXOXL ODFDUHVHDGDXJ IDSWXOF YDULDELOD< DVWIHO úL ULVFXO FRUHO ULL XQXL IDFWRU

\

QXDSDUHvQSRVWXUDGHUHJUHVRUHOLPLQkQGXVH

FX SHUWXUED LD ULVF H[LVWHQW vQ FD]XO RS LXQLL SHQWUX

YDULDQWDFDUHLPSOLF WUDQVIRUPDWD.R\FN

0RGHOHOHODJSHUPLWDQDOL]DVHPQDOHORU9$5,$%,/(/2535(&8562$5(úLRE LQHUHDGH

SUHYL]LXQL ED]DWH SH HYROX LD DFHVWRUD 6WXGLXO HYROX LHL YDULDELOHORU SUHFXUVRDUH OLGHUL D F URU FDOLWDWH GH D VHPQDOD DSDUL LD XQRU HIHFWH HFRQRPLFH QHGRULWH HSXL]DUHD UHVXUVHORU LQIOD LD VDWXUDUHD SLH HL HWF OH IDFH GHRVHELW GH XWLOH DQDOL]HL úL SURJQR]HL &XQRDúWHUHD XQRU DVWIHO GH YDULDELOH P VXUDUHD vQWkU]LHULL úL LQWHQVLW

LL HIHFWXOXL ORU DWXQFL FkQG HOH SRW GHWHUPLQD YDULDELOD ±

HIHFWSRDWHILDERUGDW SULQPRGHOHGHWLSXOFHORUSUH]HQWDWH±

5HG PPDLMRVH[HPSOHGHYDULDELOHOLGHULSUH]HQWDWHvQSDUDOHOFXYDULDELOHDF URUHYROX LH

VXFFHGHOLGHULORUvQWUXQPRGDVHP Q WRUGXS WUHFHUHDXQXLLQWHUYDOPDLPLFVDXPDLPDUHGHWLPS

134

9DULDELOD³OLGHU´VHPQDO

6XFFHVLXQHDSUREDELO GHHYHQLPHQWHúL HYROX LL

/DSURGXVXO$

&UHVFVWRFXULOHODSURGXF WRUL

3UH XO VFDGH

SURGXF LD VWDJQHD] VDX VH

GLPLQXHD] /DSURGXVXO%FRQVLGHUDWQHFHVDU

6FDGHRIHUWD

&HUHUHD QHVDWLVI FXW FUHúWH FUHúWH

SUH XO

SURGXF LD SULYLQG SURGXVXO %

VDXvQORFXLWRULLDFHVWXLDFUHúWH /DSURGXVXO&

3UH XOFUHúWHOHQWGDUFRQWLQXX

6WRFXULOH OD FRQVXPDWRU FUHVF

FHUHUHD

VFDGH 0DVDPRQHWDU FUHúWHVHPQLILFDWLY

5DWD GREkQ]LL VFDGH

HYHQWXDOWD[DVFRQWXOXLVFDGH

LQYHVWL LLOH FUHVF

UDWDúRPDMXOXLVFDGH

3,%FUHúWH

&UHúWHUDWDGREkQ]LLvQ DUD.FXPRQHG

,PSRUWXO IOX[XO VSUH DUD Ä.´ GH FDSLWDO

GHSOLQFRQYHUWLELO

FUHúWH

PRQHGD

ULL . VH GHSUHFLD]

H[SRUWXOVFDGH 0RQHGD

ULL/VHGHSUHFLD]

([SRUWXO FUHúWH

SUH XULOH SURGXVHORU VROGXOEDODQ HLGHSO

LPSRUWDWHFUHVF

L

VHDPHOLRUHD]

0RGHOH9$59HFWRULDODXWRUHJUHVLYH ÌQWUH YDULDQWHOH PRGHOXOXL /$* DP vQWkOQLW UHSUH]HQWDUHD GH WLS DXWRUHJUHVLY vQ VHQVXO F YDULDELODHIHFW HUD FRQVLGHUDW GHSHQGHQW GH SURSULLOH QLYHOH UHDOL]DWH vQ WUHFXW úL GH SHUWXUED LD ÄDFWXDO ´$úDGDU

4 \

6

= D8

+

7 D5 Ç 52

\

5 63

+X

6

ÌQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH H[WLQGHP DFHDVW PRGDOLWDWH GH H[SULPDUH DVXSUD PDL PXOWRU YDULDELOH HIHFW GHSHQGHQWH GH ÄSURSULXO ORU WUHFXW´ QH DIO P FHO SX LQ VXE DVSHFWXO UHSUH]HQW ULL IRUPDOH vQ SUH]HQ D XQXL 9(&725 DO 9$5,$%,/(/25()(&7 H[SULPDW vQ UDSRUW FX SHUIRUPDQ HOH DQWHULRDUHDOHFRPSRQHQWHORUDFHVWXLDÌQVFULHUHDPDWULFHDO SHQWUXFD]XODGRX YDULDELOH< < PRGHOXO9$5SRDWHILUHGDWDVWIHO

» << ª ª ; < ½

: :

± » D
» E
±» << ²ª ²ª ; E; rel="nofollow">= < Õ½

:9 <

± » X< ² +ª ² ª ; X Õ ½

:9 <

: :

± ² ² Õ

ÌQWURIRUPXO FRQFHQWUDW <

$%< B

C?D

8

XQGH <

YHFWRUXOYDULDELOHORUHIHFW

$

YHFWRUXOSDUDPHWULORUOLEHUL

%

PDWULFHDS WUDW DSDUDPHWULORU

C?D

8

YHFWRUXOYDULDELOHORUHIHFWGHFDODWHFXXQX YHFWRUXOSHUWXUED LLORU

8Q DVWIHO GH PRGHO HVWH FRQVLGHUDW GH RUGLQXO vQWkL vQWUXFkW P ULPHDPD[LP DODJ

XOXL HVWH HJDO FX XQX 8Q PRGHO GH RUGLQ N HODERUDW SHQWUX P YDULDELOHHIHFW SRDWH IL SUH]HQWDW DVWIHO

135

»
± ²

ª

²

J

ª
M

ª ª F G < ½

² ² ² Õ

=

» DI ª

± ²

ª

²

J ªD

M

ª ª F D ½

² ² ² Õ

» EIAI ª +

ª ª

L

ª ª ½

EI?J

L

L L L

EH I

» \G I ª

EH J

EJ@I

L L L L

L L F I E L

L F H E

±ª ² ª I ² \G ª ² ª \G J ² ²ª Õª

E I

M

²

» XI ª

²

HE E I

M

ª \ F G ½

± ²

E H

G

± ²

²+ ª ² ² ª ² X F G ² ½ Õ

M

² ² Õ

5HSUH]HQWDUHD vQWkOQLW VXE GHQXPLUHD GH PRGHOXO 9$5 LQWHUHVHD] vQGHRVHEL SHQWUX D GHVFULH LQWHUGHSHQGHQ D GLQWUH YDULDELOHOHHIHFW 2 DVWIHO GH LQWHUGHSHQGHQ

HVWH UHGDW SULQWUXQ

DQVDPEOXGHHFXD LLGHUHJUHVLHGHIRUPD

&RQV B

D K D D 9HQLW B DL

9HQLW B

E K E D &RQV B

&RQV B

X D

C?D

EL 9HQLW B

C?D

XL

C?D

6LVWHPXO GH HFXD LL DVWIHO UHSUH]HQWDW GHVFULH UHOD LD GLQDPLF GLQWUH FHOH GRX YDULDELOH

HQGRJHQHDOHPRGHOXOXL&RQVXPXOúL9HQLWXULOH

ÌQWUXQ YLLWRU FDSLWRO DVWIHO GH UHSUH]HQW UL VXQW GHQXPLWH PRGHOHOH FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH

$VSHFWXO DXWRUHJUHVLY vQWUXQ DVWIHO GH PRGHO DSDUH SH DQVDPEOX vQ VHQVXO F YDULDELOHOHHIHFW DOH PRGHOXOXL FRQVXPXO YHQLWXO GHSLQG GH YDORULOH DQWHULRDUH vQUHJLVWUDWH GH DFHOHDúL YDULDELOH FRQVXP úL YHQLW &RQVWDWDUHD HVWH úL PDL ELQH SXV vQ HYLGHQ

GDF SURFHG P OD vQORFXLUHD

YDULDELOHL9HQLWGLQSULPDHFXD LHvQFDUHDSDUHFDIDFWRUFXH[SUHVLDVDGLQFHDGHDGRXDHFXD LHD PRGHOXOXL &RQV B

D K D D E K E D &RQV B

C?D

EL 9HQLW B

&RQV B

a K a D &RQV B

C?D

aL 9HQLW B

9HQLW B

E K E D &RQV B

C?D

EL 9HQLW B

C?D

C?D

C?D

XL DL

&RQV B

C?D

X D

Y D XL

XQGH aK

D K D D E K

aD

D D E D DL

aL

D D EL

YD

D D XL

X D

ÌQ FDSLWROXO GHVWLQDW SUH]HQW ULL PRGHOHORU FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH &DSLWROXO ; R DVWIHO GH

UHGDUHDPRGHOXOXLHVWHGHQXPLW IRUPDUHGXV 3HQWUXRE LQHUHDGHSURJQR]HúLVLPXO ULHVWHIRUPD FHDPDLFRQYHQDELO ùLvQDFHVWFD]RUGLQXOPRGHOXOXL9$5HVWHGDWGHP ULPHDPD[LP DODJXOXL HYLGHQ LDW vQ FD]XO XQHLD VDX D WXWXURU YDULDELOHORU FX HIHFW vQWkU]LDW DIODWH vQ GUHDSWD VHPQHORU GH HJDOLWDWH (VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU SUHVXSXQH DSOLFDUHD 0&003 ILHF UHL HFXD LL GLQ DúDQXPLWD IRUP UHGXV DPRGHOXOXLDXWRUHJUHVLY

ÌQ FHOH FH XUPHD] QH UHIHULP OD XQHOH UHFRPDQG UL vQ FH SULYHúWH FRQVWUXF LD VSHFLILFDUHD

úLXWLOL]DUHDUH]XOWDWHORUPRGHOXOXL9$5

VHUHFRPDQG FDWHQGLQ DFDúLVH]RQDOLWDWHDGDF H[LVW V ILHHOLPLQDWHGLQFDGUXOVHULHL

FURQRORJLFHDVWIHOvQFkWHYROX LDILHF UHLYDULDELOHHIHFWV ILHH[SULPDW H[FOXVLYGHSURSULLOHYDORUL DOHYDULDELOHLYDULDELOHORUHIHFWGLQWUHFXWODFDUHVHDGDXJ LQHUHQWDSHUWXUED LH

vQ

FH

SULYHúWH

HURDUHD

SHUWXUED LD

PRGHOXOXL

9$5

IRUPDW

GLQ

YDULDELOHHIHFW

LQWHUGHSHQGHQWH PHGLD HURULL SHQWUX ILHFDUH GLQWUH HFXD LLOH IRUPHL UHGXVH HVWH HJDO FX ]HUR LDU DXWRFRUHODUHDHURULLHVWHH[FOXV ÌPSU úWLHUHDSHUWXUED LHLH[SULPDW GHGLVSHUVLLúLFRYDULDQ HHVWH FRQVWDQW vQ WLPS QX VH PRGLILF SH GLYHUVH VHFYHQ H GH WLPS $FHVWH FRQGL LL ILLQG vQGHSOLQLWH HVWLPD LLOHSDUDPHWULORUÄIRUPHLUHGXVH´VXQWFRQVLVWHQWHúLDVLPSWRWLFQRUPDOGLVWULEXLWH

DVSHFWHOH PHQ LRQDWH DQWHULRU DEVHQ D WHQGLQ HL FRQGL LLOH vQGHSOLQLWH GH SHUWXUED LL

UHSUH]LQW DUJXPHQWH FDUH IDF FUHGLELO HWDSD WHVW ULL úL RIHU R ED] VROLG SURJQR]HORU RE LQXWH FX DVWIHOGHPRGHOH ÌQFHSULYHúWHOLPLWHOHPRGHOXOXL9$5PHQ LRQ PIDSWXOF

136

QX VH ED]HD] SH WHRULD HFRQRPLF vQ HWDSD VSHFLILF ULL HVWH FDOLILFDW GUHSW PRGHO DWHRUHWLF

OXQJLPHDODJXOXLQXHVWHvQWRWGHDXQDIHUPDUJXPHQWDW

LQWHUSUHWDUHDUH]XOWDWHORUHVWLP ULLHVWHGLVFXWDELO

ÌQ FH SULYHúWH DYDQWDMHOH PHQ LRQ P F HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU HVWH UHODWLY VLPSO QX SUHVXSXQHYDULDQWHPDLODERULRDVHDOH0&003 LDUSURJQR]HOHVXQWvQJHQHUDOGLQWUHFHOHPDL EXQHFRPSDUDWLYFXDOWHPRGHOH

0RGHOHDGDSWLYHGHVWLQDWHSUHYL]LXQLL

/D ED]D PRGHOHORU DGDSWLYH VH DIO SUH]XP LD FRQIRUP F UHLD SURJQR]HOH HODERUDWH vQ

VXFFHVLXQHSRWILPHQ LQXWHODXQQLYHODSURSLDWGHUHDOLWDWHDSHFDUHRÄSUHYHVWHVF´SULQWURFRQWLQX DGDSWDUHvQUDSRUWFXP ULPHDHURULORUGHSUHYL]LXQHFRQVWDWDWHvQWUHFXW

0RGHOXOvQYDULDQWDVDFHDPDLVLPSO HODERUDW GH5*%URZQSRDWHILGHVFULVSRUQLQGGH

ODUHOD LD \ B

M D

\¶ B D\ B \¶ B

XQGH SUHYL]LXQHDSHQWUXSHULRDGDW

\¶ B

SDUDPHWUXDSULRULVWDELOLWD

D

$XWRDGDSWDUHD vQ YDULDQWD HVWH UHDOL]DW QXPDL vQ UDSRUW FX HURDUHD GH SURJQR] GLQ

SHULRDGD SUHFHGHQW 'DF LQHPVHDPDúLGHHURULOHDQWHULRDUHGHSURJQR] DWXQFLWUHEXLHV DYHP vQYHGHUHIDSWXOF SURJQR]DSHQWUXSHULRDGDÄW´\¶ B DOXDWvQFDOFXOODUkQGXOHLHURDUHDDQWHULRDU W GHSUHYL]LXQH\ B

\¶ B

C?D

D\ B

C?D

\¶ B

DúDFXPúLSURJQR]DSHQWUXSHULRDGDWDOXDWvQFDOFXO

C?D

HURDUHD DQWHULRDU HWF /LPLWkQGXQH GRDU OD HURULOH FRQVWDWDWH SHQWUX GRX SHULRDGH W úL W FRQVWDW PXúRUF SUHYL]LXQHDSHQWUXSHULRDGDWFRUHVSXQ] WRUUHOD LHL GHYLQH \ B

M D

\¶ B D\ B \¶ B \¶ B

C?D

D\ B

C?D

D\ B

±D\¶ B

D\ B DD \ B

C?D

C?D

C?D

\¶ B

C?D

C?D

D\ B ±D\¶ B

L

D \¶ B

C?D

C?D

L

\¶ B D\ B ±D\¶ B

C?D

±D \ B

±D \ B

C?D

L

C?D

L

D \¶ B

C?D

L

D \¶ B

C?D

([WLQ]kQGXQHPDLPXOWvQWUHFXWvQVHQVXOOX ULLvQFDOFXOúLDHURULORUFRQVWDWDWHvQXUP FX

SHULRDGHDMXQJHPSURFHGkQGVLPLODUFD]XOXLDQWHULRU ODUHOD LDJHQHUDO

S N Q

\ U

P Q

= D Ç - D

T O R

T

\U

N T

+ - D

S

\ U

N S

0HQ LRQ P F vQ H[SUHVLD XOWLPXO WHUPHQ DMXQJH UDSLG OD R YDORDUH H[WUHP GH PLF

SUDFWLF HJDO FX ]HUR 3DUDPHWUXO ÄD´ IDFWRUXO GH SRQGHUDUH HVWH VWDELOLW vQ UDSRUWXO FX LPSRUWDQ D SH FDUH R DFRUG P HURULORU GH SURJQR] GH GDW PDL UHFHQW 'DF OH DFRUG P R LPSRUWDQ

PDUH

RSW PSHQWUXRP ULPHDSDUDPHWUXOXLDSURSLDW GHXQXLDUGDF GLPSRWULY FRQVLGHU PF HURULOH PDL vQGHS UWDWH vQ WLPS VXQW GHWHUPLQDQWH SHQWUX SUHFL]LD SUHYL]LXQLL DOHJHP SHQWUX ÄD´ R P ULPH DSURSLDW GH ]HUR 2S LXQHD VH SRDWH ED]D SH XQ FDOFXO GH RSWLPL]DUH D UH]XOWDWHORU XQRU VLPXO UL SHQWUX GLYHUVH YDORUL DWULEXLWH IDFWRUXOXL GH SRQGHUDUH ÄD´ ÌQ PRG IUHFYHQW R DVWIHO GH RSWLPL]DUH DUH vQ YHGHUH PLQLPL]DUHD VXPHL S WUDWHORU HURULORU GH SUHGLF LH PLQ Ç \

Y V X

- \ Y

V X

W

vQ FD]XO

GLYHUVHORUYDULDQWHGHVWDELOLUHDQLYHOXOXLIDFWRUXOXLGHSRQGHUDUH

'H UHPDUFDW F IXQGDPHQWDUHD PRGHOXOXL DGDSWLY QX DUH vQ YHGHUH DWkW ULJXUR]LWDWHD

PDWHPDWLF

FkW

IDFWRUXO

SVLKRORJLF

FRUHVSXQ] WRU

F UXLD

JUHúHOLOH

V YkUúLWH

SRW

LQIOXHQ D

FRPSRUWDPHQWXO YLLWRU LDU LQIOXHQ D HVWH FX DWkW PDL SXWHUQLF FX FkW HURULOH FRQVWDWDWH VXQW PDL UHFHQWH

([HPSOX /LYU ULOH GH FDUQH W LDW DX IRVW vQ OXQLOH 9, 9,, 9,,, vQ PHGLH GHPLLWRQH6LWXkQGX

VH vQ WLPS vQ OXQD DXJXVW HODERU P R SURJQR] SHQWUX OXQD D,;D OD QLYHOXO PHGLHL XOWLPHORU WUHL

137

OXQL\¶Z

[

/DVIkUúLWXOOXQLLVHSWHPEULHFRQVWDW PFRQIRUPGDWHORUFRPXQLFDWHGHLQVWLWX LLOH

GHVWDWLVWLF XQQLYHOUHDODOOLYU ULORUGHPLLW3UHYL]LXQHDSHQWUXOXQDD;DUH]XOW DVWIHO \ [

\

]

¢ ¢

PLLW

0HQ LRQ P F UHOD LD HVWH FHD XWLOL]DW LDU D

ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH GDF QLYHOXO UHDO

SHQWUXOXQDD;DHVWHGHPLLWDWXQFLSURJQR]DSHQWUXOXQDD;,DVHRE LQHDVWIHO \ [ Z

\

^

> ¢ ¢@± ¢

PLLW

1LYHOXO UHDO SHQWUX OXQD D ;,D ILLQG GH PLL W VH SRDWH WUHFH OD RE LQHUHD SUHYL]LXQLL

SHQWUXOXQDD;,,D \ [ Z Z

\

^

_

> ¢ ¢ ¢@± ¢

PLLW

_

0RGHOXO DGDSWDWLY SUH]HQWDW vQ FHHD FH DUH HO HVHQ LDO HVWH LQGLFDW SHQWUX RE LQHUHD GH SURJQR]H SH WHUPHQ VFXUW (O SRDWH IL DGDSWDW úL SHQWUX VHULL FH SUH]LQW VH]RQDOLWDWH SULQ LQWURGXFHUHD vQ FDOFXOHOH GH SURJQR] D LQGLFLORU GH VH]RQDOLWDWH $OWH YDULDQWH GH PRGHOH DXWRDGDSWLYH DX vQ YHGHUH WUHQGXO úL VH]RQDOLWDWHD +ROW :LQWHUV VDX FRHILFLHQWXO GH DXWRFRUHOD LH SHQWUXVWDELOLUHDQLYHOXOXLFRQVWDQWHLÄD´ 5HG PPRGDOLWDWHDJHQHUDO GHGHILQLUHDXQXLDVWIHOGHPRGHO

c

\ e a f

= \ e + N] e V e

b d a `

XQGH

g

\ B ]B

QLYHOHGHVH]RQDOL]DWHSULQUDSRUWDUHODLQGLFLLGHVH]RQDOLWDWH WHQGLQ D SUHYL]LRQDW SH ED]D PRGHOXOXL DGDSWLY GH WLSXO FHOXL SUH]HQWDW

VB

C hiM D Vk

l j m o

VH]RQDOLWDWHDÄDXWRDGDSWDW ´SULQXWLOL]DUHDXQHLUHOD LLGHIRUPD

= D

\k

l j m o

\k

l j m o

n

+ - D V k

l j

$QWLFLS

ULOHÄH[SHFWHGYDOXHV´ vQHFRQRPLHúLUROXOORUvQGHPHUVXO HFRQRPHWULF

ÌQWUXFkWYD OHJDW GH SUREOHPD HIHFWXOXL vQWkU]LDW ODJ GDU PDL DOHV GH LGHHD GH ED] D

PRGHOHORU DGDSWLYH HVWH úL FRQVWUXF LD PRGHOHORU FDUH SXQ vQ FHQWUXO DWHQ LHL $17,&,3$5($ DJHQ LORUHFRQRPLFLúLPRGLILFDUHDFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLORUHFRQRPLFvQUDSRUWFXDFHDVWD

K

9DORULOH DQWLFLSDWH [ VH UHIHU vQ VSHFLDO OD QLYHOXO YLLWRU DO XQRU IDFWRUL GH FDUH GHSLQGH SURFHVXO HFRQRPLF DIODW vQ DWHQ LD DJHQWXOXL HFRQRPLF &RUHVSXQ] WRU QLYHOXOXL DQWLFLSDW SULQ PHWRGHQDLYHVDXIRDUWHVRILVWLFDWH SULYLQGIDFWRUXOIDFWRULLGHFDUHGHSLQGHSURFHVXODIODWvQDWHQ LD DJHQWXOXLHFRQRPLFDFHVWDVHFRQVLGHU F vúLPRGLILF FRPSRUWDPHQWXO'HH[HPSOXRFRQMXQFWXU SUHYL]LELO FX HIHFWH DVXSUD SUH XULORU SRDWH IDFH FD R VHULH GH vQWUHSULQGHUL VDX GH IDPLOLL V úL DPSOLILFHFRQVXPXODSURYL]LRQkQGXVHvQH[FHV V UHVWUkQJ SURGXF LDV YkQG YDOXWDvQFXUVGH GHSUHFLHUHHWF

3HQWUX HFRQRPHWULH XQ DVWIHO GH FRPSRUWDPHQW SUH]LQW LPSRUWDQ

vQWUXFkW FRQVWLWXLH R

PDQLIHVWDUH D IDFWRULORU GH QDWXU SVLKRORJLF GHVHRUL GHWHUPLQDQ L SHQWUX HYROX LD XQRU IHQRPHQH

p

0RGHOHOH DGDSWLYH VXQW PHQ LRQDWH vQ PDMRULWDWHDSDFKHWHORUGHSURJUDPHGHVWLQDWHvQGHRVHELSURJQR]HLvQHFRQRPLH

VXE HWLFKHWD 60227+ (OH PDL VXQW FXQRVFXWH úL VXE GHQXPLUHD GH PRGHOH GH QLYHODUH H[SRQHQ LDO ([SRQHQWLDO 6PRRWKLQJ ÌQ SDUWLFXODU UHSUH]HQW ULOH OD FDUH QHDP UHIHULW VXQW FXQRVFXWH úL VXE GHQXPLUHD ([SRQHQWLDOO\:HLJKWHG0RYLQJ$YHUDJH(:0$

138

vQWUR HFRQRPLH OLEHU vQ FDUH LQIRUPD LD DUH XQ URO LQFRQWHVWDELO &D XUPDUH vQ XOWLPXO GHFHQLX PRGHOHOHHFRQRPHWULFHLQFOXGIUHFYHQWvQWUHUHJUHVRULúLYDULDELOHFXYDORULDQWLFLSDWH 3UH]XP LLOH DYXWH vQ YHGHUH VH UHIHU vQGHRVHEL OD DVSHFWH SUHFXP UROXO H[SHULHQ HL FD úL DO

HURULORU V YkUúLWH vQ WUHFXW VXQW vQ P VXU V GHWHUPLQH GHFLGHQ LL FDUH SRW LQIOXHQ D HYROX LD XQRU LQGLFDWRUL HFRQRPLFL UROXO LQIRUPD LHL vQ YHGHUHD DQWLFLS ULL XQRU HYROX LL vQ HFRQRPLH HVWH WRW PDL PXOW UHFXQRVFXW DWkW H[SHULHQ D ÄS

DQLLOH´ GLQ WUHFXW FkW úL LQIRUPD LLOH DFFHVLELOH DJHQWXOXL

HFRQRPLFSRWILXWLOL]DWHGHF WUHDFHVWDvQPRGUD LRQDOSHQWUXDúLP ULDYDQWDMHOH

ÌQ UDSRUW FX PHWRGHOH GH DQWLFLSDUH IRORVLWH SUHFXP úL vQ IXQF LH GH LQIRUPD LD XWLOL]DW

GHRVHELPDQWLFLS ULQDLYHDQWLFLS ULDGDSWLYH$( DQWLFLS ULUD LRQDOH5(

$QWLFLS

ULOHQDLYHVHFDUDFWHUL]HD] SULQVLPSOLWDWHDFDOFXOHORUFDúLSHDFFHSWDUHDSUH]XP LHL

FRUHVSXQ] WRUF UHLDYLLWRUXOYDUHSURGXFHvQWRFPDLSUH]HQWXOVDXWUHFXWXODSURSLDW6LPEROL]kQGFX [u

qsr t

DQWLFLSDUHD SHQWUX SHULRDGD YLLWRDUH W VH FRQVLGHU F SRW IL RE LQXWH DQWLFLS UL SULQ FDOFXOH

VLPSOHED]DWHSHSUH]XP LDUHSHWDELOLW

LL

'LQWUHYDULDQWHOHGHFDOFXOPHQ LRQ P [w

xsy v

= [w

Ü QLYHOXOVHPHQ LQH

[~

} z

- [~

= [~

{

VDX

[

=

[

s

[

$QWLFLS

[ [

= [

- [~

Ü [

[

¢

[

Ü [~

| z

{

} z [

= [

[

= [~

- [~

| z

Ü PRGLILFDUHDVHUHSHW

Ü IOXFWXD LDVH]RQLHU WULPHVWULDO VHPHQ LQH

UL DGDSWLYH DQWLFLS UL SURJUHVLYH DQWLFLS UL vQ XUPD vQY

ULL GLQ HURUL (OHPHQWXO

FDUDFWHULVWLF SHQWUX DFHVW JHQ GH DQWLFLS UL HVWH UHSUH]HQWDW GH FRUHFWXUD DQWLFLS ULORU DQWHULRDUH vQ UDSRUW FX HURDUHD FRPLV 2 DVWIHO GH PRGDOLWDWH GH DERUGDUH D IRVW vQWkOQLW úL vQ FD]XO PRGHOHORU DGDSWLYH'LQWUHYDULDQWHOHGHFDOFXOPHQ LRQ PSHQWUXvQFHSXWUHOD LD

s

[

- [

= a [

XQGHa vQFDUH

- [

FRHILFLHQWXOGHDQWLFLSDUHa

[

= a[

+ - a [

9DORDUHDDQWLFLSDW DSDUHFDRPHGLHSRQGHUDW DYDORULLDFWXDOHúLDYDORULLDQWLFLSDWHSHQWUX

SHULRDGD DFWXDO SRQGHULOH ILLQG a úL a (YLGHQW SHQWUX a

s [

= [

[

s

= [ SHQWUX a

$OHJHUHDQLYHOXOXLFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHDQWLFLSDUHa GHSLQGHGHLPSRUWDQ DSHFDUHRDFRUG P

QLYHOXOXL UHDO [ VDX QLYHOXOXL DQWLFLS ULL DQWHULRDUH [ vQ YHGHUHD RE LQHULL GH QRL YDORUL DQWLFLSDWH [ ¢

s ¡

ÌQPRGHOXOHFRQRPHWULFDQWLFLS ULOHDSDUvQSRVWXUDGHIDFWRU

\£

[ ¢ X £

D ¤ D ¥

vQFDUH [ ¢ FRUHVSXQ] WRUUHOD LHL VHRE LQHDVWIHO [¢

a[ £

¦?¥

a [ ¢

§ ¨

ÌQORFXLQGH[SUHVLDDQWLFLS ULLSHQWUXSHULRDGDW [ ¢ vQUHOD LD UH]XOW F \

W

=D

+ D

[a[

W -

+ ( - a )[

W -

]+ X

W

DGLF

©

$QWLFLS ULOHDXWRDGDSWLYHVXQWH[SULPDWHvQGLYHUVHDUWLFROHVDXF U LSULQVLPEROXO$($GDSWLYH([SHFWDWLRQV

139

\

=D

W

+ D a[

+ D

W -

( - a )[ W -

'DF GHFDO PFXXQXUHOD LD RvQPXO LPFXa úLRVF GHPWHUPHQFXWHUPHQGLQ

UHOD LD RE LQHP \

- ( - a )[

=D

¬ ª

=D

«

- ( - a )D

«

- ( - a )D

«

«

+ D ª a[ + D ª a[

- Dª

¬ ª

+ X

¬ ª

«

( - a )[ ¬ ª - ( - a )X

+ Dª

«

( - a )[ ¬ ª

+ X

- X

¬ ª

¬ ª

=

'DF HIHFWX PXUP WRDUHOHvQORFXLUL D

- ( - a )D

=E

D a =E

X

- ( - a )X

W

W -

=Y

W

UHOD LD GHYLQH \

= E²

®

+ E° \

® ¯ °

+ E± [

® ¯ °

+Y

®

6LPLODULWDWHD H[SUHVLHL FX PRGHOXOGHWLSODJGLVWULEXLWFXGHVFUHúWHULDOHLQIOXHQ HLvQ SURJUHVLH JHRPHWULF OD FDUH VD DMXQV SULQ WUDQVIRUPDUHD .R\FN HVWH HYLGHQW $YDQWDMHOH úL OLPLWHOHPRGHOXOXLODJGLVWULEXLWJHRPHWULFVHU VIUkQJGHFLúLDVXSUDPRGHOXOXL

2DOW YDULDQW GHRE LQHUHDYDORULORUDQWLFLSDWHGHWLSDGDSWLYDUHvQYHGHUHHIHFWXOvQWkU]LDW

DOYDORULORUUHDOHGLQWUHFXWSUHOXDWSULQLQWHUPHGLXOXQRUSRQGHULE ¤ E ¥ E³

[

¹ µ · ¸

= E¹ [

µ

+ E¸ [

µ ¶ ¸

+

L + E´

[

µ ¶ ´

(IHFWXO WUHFXWXOXL VH SRDWH HVWRPSD GLQ FH vQ FH PDL PXOW XUPkQG R LQYROX LH vQ SURJUHVLH

DULWPHWLF DVWIHOvQFkWSHQWUXÊLÊN

E º

NL ELDUSHQWUXL!N

ÌQWUXQDVWIHOGHFD]L

$FHOHDúLHIHFWHSRWSUH]HQWDRLQYROX LHDSXWHULLGHLQIOXHQ [

À ½ Â

«NLDUEUHSUH]LQW RFRQVWDQW vQSURJUHVLHJHRPHWULF >@

¾

Á

E º

» Á D¿ [ = Ç ¿

À ¼ ¿

XQGH D

L

= D l ( < l < )

L

ÌQDPEHOHYDULDQWHSRDWHILDYXW vQYHGHUHUHVWULF LDFDVXPDSRQGHULORUV ILHHJDO FXXQX

$QWLFLS

0RGDOLWDWHD GH RE LQHUH D YDORULORU DQWLFLSDWH SULQ PHWRGHOH SUH]HQWDWH DQWLFLS UL DGDSWLYH

ULUD LRQDOH5(5DWLRQDO([SHFWDWLRQV

VDX FHOH ÄQDLYH´ HVWH FULWLFDW GH /XFDV úL 6DUJHQW vQWUXFkW VH ED]HD] SUHD PXOW SH WUHFXW &HHD FH SURSXQ FHL GRL DXWRUL HVWH vQWRDUFHUHD SULYLULORU VSUH SUH]HQW vQ VHQVXO F VH FRQVLGHU UD LRQDO FD DJHQ LL HFRQRPLFL V IRORVHDVF FX SUHF GHUH LQIRUPD LLOH FXUHQWH vQ IRUPXODUHD DQWLFLS ULORU (OHPHQWXO FDUDFWHULVWLF SHQWUX DQWLFLS ULOH UD LRQDOH vO UHSUH]LQW YDORULILFDUHD FX GLVFHUQ PkQW D LQIRUPD LLORU OD FDUH DYHP DFFHV vQ SHULRDGD FXUHQW vQ YHGHUHD SUHILJXU ULL YLLWRDUHLHYROX LLDXQRU YDULDELOH IDFWRULDOH ÌQ SHULRDGD DFWXDO vQ FDUH H[LVW R SLD

D LQIRUPD LLORU DOLPHQWDW VLVWHPDWLF

GHLQVWLWX LLVSHFLDOL]DWHRDVWIHOGHDERUGDUHVHLPSXQHGLQFHvQFHPDLPXOW/XFU ULOHSXEOLFDWHSH

Ã

WHPDDQWLFLS ULORU5(VXQWQXPHURDVHLDUVROX LLOHSURSXVHVXQWGHRGLYHUVLWDWH

ÌQ FHOH FH XUPHD] QH YRP OLPLWD OD SUH]HQWDUHD DVSHFWHORU GH SULQFLSLX SUHFXP úL OD

PRGDOLWDWHDSUDFWLF GHRE LQHUHúLLQFOXGHUHvQPRGHOHDXQRUDVWIHOGHDQWLFLS UL

2H[SULPDUHVLPSO DHFXD LHLFDUHLQFOXGHDQWLFLS ULUD LRQDOHSRDWHILIRUPXODW DVWIHO <Ä = E[ Ä

Æ§Ç Å

+ XÄ

XQGH

È

6 +ROO\ 0 %HQQVWRFN ± 7KH LPSOLFDWLRQ RI UDWLRQDO H[SHFWDWLRQV IRU WKH IRUHFDVWLQJ DQG WKH VLPXODWLRQ RI HFRQRPLF

PRGHOV/%6 //HLGHUPDQ±0DFURHFRQRPHWULFWHVWLQJRIWKHUDWLRQDOH[SHFWDWLRQVDQGVWUXFWXUDOK\SRWKHVLVIRUWKH86-RXUQDORI 0RQGLDO(FRQRP\QR

[] [] [] []

140

É Í Ë Ì

[ XQGH 0

(; Í Ë Ì

= 0

Ê Ì )

)Í

M Ë

UHSUH]LQW XQ RSHUDWRU FDUH H[SULP PHGLD DúWHSW ULORU SULYLQG HYROX LD YDULDELOHL ;

FRQGL LRQDW GH FXQRDúWHUHD WXWXURU LQIRUPD LLORU UHOHYDQWH ) DFFHVLELOH DJHQWXOXL HFRQRPLF vQ SHULRDGDWM

'H H[HPSOX vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH < £

SUH XO JUkXOXL LDU ;

UHFROWD VH SRDWH DFFHSWD F

DQWLFLS ULOH ED]DWH SH LQIRUPD LLOH WRW PDL QXPHURDVH SULYLQG R UHFROW VODE FDUH VH YD RE LQH vQ DU GDU úL vQ

ULOH FX XQ FRQVXP ULGLFDW GH JUkX YRU LQIOXHQ D SUH XO JUkXOXL SH P VXU FH

LQIRUPD LLOHVXQWFRQILUPDWHGHUHDOLWDWH 9DORDUHD DQWLFLS ULORU SHQWUX SHUIRUPDQ HOH PRGHOXOXL GHSLQGH GH RUL]RQWXO SUHYL]LRQDO OD FDUH VH UHIHU DQWLFLSDUHD UHOHYDQ DLQIRUPD LLORUSULYLQGHYROX LDYDULDELOHL;UHOD LD GLQWUHHURDUHDGHSURJQR] úLLQIRUPD LLOHDFFHVLELOHDJHQWXOXLvQPRPHQWXOXLW>@

6H FRQVLGHU F DJHQWXO HFRQRPLF FDUH VH ED]HD] vQ DFWLYLWDWHD VD SH DQWLFLS UL UD LRQDOH

FXQRDúWH VWUXFWXUD PRGHOXOXL vQ FDUH LQWHUYLQH YDULDELOD ; DQWLFLS ULOH VXQW QHGHSODVDWH vQ PHGLH GLVSHUVLDHVWHFRQVWDQW LDUHURULOHQXVXQWDXWRFRUHODWH

$úDGDUvQWUHDQWLFLSDUHD[

Ñ Ï [Ò 'DF 0

Ñ Ï [Ò

=

(Y Õ

Ô Ó Ù (Y Ú × Ø

0

( Ú × Ø

0 Y

¤

£ Î ¥ úLYDORDUHDUHDO Ñ Ï + YÒ

Ð

)

)=

Õ

)Ú Y

)= sÜ

Ú × ØÖ Û

Ù )Ú

[ £

Î ¥

H[LVW UHOD LD

) = ( M

=

L ¸)

XQGH HURDUHDGHSURJQR] XUPDUHDDQWLFLS ULL

Y

0HQ LRQ P GH DVHPHQHD F vQ FD]XO DQWLFLS ULORU ÄvQ ODQ ´ SHQWUX PDL PXOW GHFkW R

SHULRDG HURULOH GH SURJQR] VH FXPXOHD] DXWRFRUHOD LD DFHVWRUD HVWH SUHVXSXV 6HFRQVLGHU F XQSURFHVGHUHYL]XLUHDDQWLFLS ULORUHVWHDúDGDUQHFHVDU

2E LQHUHD DQWLFLS ULORU 5( SULQ XWLOL]DUHD LQIRUPD LLORU FXUHQWH VDX SURYHQLQG GLQ WUHFXW VH

ED]HD] SH GLYHUVH PHWRGH vQ IXQF LH úL GH GRPHQLXO OD FDUH VH UHIHU YDULDELOD IDFWRULDO D F UHL YDORDUH YLLWRDUH XUPHD] V ILH LQWURGXV vQ PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF ,QIRUPD LLOH VXQW GHVHRUL GH QDWXU FDOLWDWLY FHHDFHLPSOLF PHWRGHGHP VXUDUHGHJHQXOWHVWXOXLFRQMXQFWXUDOYH]L&DSLWROXO ,; (YROX LD DQWLFLSDW D XQRU LQGLFDWRUL RE LQX L GH OD vQWUHSULQGHUL SRDWH IL DSUHFLDW DSHOkQG OD PHGLH [

Æ Ç ÄÅ

=

ÇJ

Æ Ç Þ [Þ Ý Ä Å

XQGH

[

ß@à

J

á â ã ä

Ç å

Jå

SRQGHUHDILUPHLL QLYHODQWLFLSDWvQFD]XOILUPHLL

=

ÌQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH VH FXQRDúWH GRDU GLUHF LD HYROX LHL XQXL LQGLFDWRU úL DFHDVWD HVWH FRQWUDGLFWRULH GDF LQIRUPD LLOH SURYLQ GH OD PDL PXOWH ILUPH DWXQFL R UH]XOWDQW SRDWH IL DYXW vQ YHGHUHFD]vQFDUH [

Æ

=

ÇJ

Þ(

Å

)

[

Å

( )

-

ÇJ

Þ(

æ

)

[

æ

( )

XQGH HYROX LHSR]LWLY HYROX LHQHJDWLY

141

$QWLFLS UL SRW UH]XOWD úL vQ XUPD DQDOL]HL GH UHJUHVLH RUL GH FkWH RUL LQIRUPD LLOH VXQW GH WLS QXPHULF ,QVWLWX LL VSHFLDOL]DWH vQ VWXGLXO FRQMXQFWXULL SLH HL vQ HODERUDUHD GH SURJQR]H HWF RIHU

ç

VLVWHPDWLFYDORULDQWLFLSDWHSULYLQGLQGLFDWRULLHFRQRPLFLUHOHYDQ L

%,%/,2*5$),(

%R[ * ( 3 -HQNLQV * 0 ± 7LPH 6HULHV $QDO\VLV )RUHFDVWLQJ DQG &RQWURO +ROGHQ'D\ 6DQ)UDQFLVFR

&XWKEHUWVRQ.+DOO6±$SSOLHG(FRQRPHWULFV7HFKQLTXHV:KUHDWRQV/WG

)RPE\7%5KRGHV*±$GYDQFHVLQ(FRQRPHWULFV-$,*UHVV/RQGRQ

*UDQJHU&:-±6SHFWUDO$QDO\VLVRI(FRQRPLF7LPH6HULHV3ULQFHWRQ8QLY3UHVV1<

*ULIILWKV : -XGJH * &DUWHU +LOO 5 ± /HDUQLQJ DQG 3UDFWLFLQJ (FRQRPHWULFV -RKQ :LOH\ DQG6RQV

*XMDUDWL'±%DVLF(FRQRPHWULFV0F*UDZ+LOO,QF1<

+DUYH\$&±7LPH6HULHV0RGHOV+RZHVWHU1<

-RKQVWRQ-±(FRQRPHWULF0HWKRGV0F*UDZ+LOO1<

0DGGDOD*6±,QWURGXFWLRQWR(FRQRPHWULFV0F0LOODQ3XEO

3HFLFDQ(6±(FRQRPHWULH(GLWXUD$OO%XFXUHúWL 3ORHJ)HGLW ±$GYDQFHG/HFWXUHVLQ4XDQWLWDWLYH(FRQRPHWULFV$FDG3UHVV 7 Q VRLX2,DFRE$,(FRQRPHWULHDSLFDW

(GLWXUD$57(7,&$57%XFXUHúWL

è

2 DFWLYLWDWH GH SLRQLHUDW vQ DFHVW VHQV D UHDOL]DWR LQVWLWXWXO ,)2 GLQ 0QFKHQ GDU úL LQVWLWX LL SUHFXP *DOOXS

&%,,QGXVWULDO7UHQG6XUYH\VHWF

142

&DSLWROXO9,,, 0RGHOHVWRFKDVWLFHGHSURJQR]

)XQF LDGHDXWRFRUHOD LH

(YROX LD IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH VH DIO VXE LPSXOVXO UHVXUVHORU H[LVWHQWH FDSDFLW

LORU

FUHDWH H[SHULHQ HL DFXPXODWH WUDGL LHL FD úL D DOWRU IDFWRUL GH QDWXU H[RJHQ $VWIHO R DFWLYLWDWH SURGXFWLY UHDOL]DW ODXQDQXPLWQLYHOúLDFUHDWLPSOLFLWRED] FDSDFLW

LGHSURGXF LHUHVXUVHGH

PXQF WHKQRORJLH SHQWUX D DWLQJH úL vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH FHO SX LQ DFHODúL QLYHO LQYHVWL LLOH LPSOLF FHOSX LQSkQ ODILQDOL]DUHDSURLHFWXOXLQRLLQYHVWL LLFRQVXPXOFUHHD] RELúQXLQ DúLGHFL JHQHUHD] FRQVXP HWF &D XUPDUH PXOWH GLQWUH SURFHVHOH HFRQRPLFH GHSLQG GH DQWHULRDUHOH ORU SHUIRUPDQ H DYkQG XQ FDUDFWHU LQHU LDO FDUH vQ OLPEDMXO HFRQRPHWULHL HVWH SXV vQ HYLGHQ

SULQ

DXWRFRUHOD LH ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHIDFWRULLH[RJHQLRVFKLPEDUHEUXVF úLGHDPSORDUHLQWHUYHQLW vQUkQGXO DFHVWRUD VH UHSHUFXWHD] GH FHOH PDL PXOWH RUL vQ PRG WUHSWDW DVXSUD YDULDELOHORU HIHFW FRUHODWH GLUHFWGDUPDLDOHVLQGLUHFWFXUHVSHFWLYXOIDFWRU$VWIHORFUHúWHUHEUXVF DRIHUWHLXQXLSURGXVSH SLD

LQIOXHQ HD] QLYHOXO SUH XOXL vQ VHQVXO F DFHVWD YD vQUHJLVWUD VF GHUL WUHSWDWH vQ GHFXUVXO

WLPSXOXL DSDUL LD XQHL QRL WHKQRORJLL JHQHUHD] HIHFWH GLVFRQWLQXH vQ WUHSWH DVXSUD SURGXF LHL úL FRVWXOXLHWF /XkQGvQFRQVLGHUDUHDVWIHOGHSDUWLFXODULW SUHFXP úL SRVLELOLW

LDOHFRPSRUWDPHQWXOXLHFRQRPLFSHGHRSDUWH

LOH GH FXDQWLILFDUH úL SURJQR]DUH DOH PRGHOHORU ODJ VL DOH PRGHOHORU

DXWRDGDSWLYHSHGHDOW SDUWHHFRQRPHWULFLHQLLDPHULFDQL*HRUJH(3%R[úL.*0-HQNLQVDX HODERUDW VSUH VIkUúLWXO GHFHQLXOXL ¶ DúDQXPLWHOH PRGHOH VWRFKDVWLFH GH SURJQR] ÌQWUR IRUPXODUHJHQHUDO XQDVWIHOGHPRGHOVHSUH]LQW DVWIHO

\

= \ + D

+ D \

+ D \

+ + D

\

- E X

- - E X

+ X

XQGH \ DE

YDULDELO HFRQRPLF VWD LRQDUL]DW WUHQGXOILLQGH[FOXVGLQGDWH SDUDPHWUL

2EVHUY PF SULPDSDUWHDPRGHOXOXL UHSUH]LQW XQPRGHOOLQLDUDXWRUHJUHVLYLDUFHD GHD GRXD SDUWH LQFOXGH HURDUHD LQWURGXV SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO YDORULORU YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH X

vQ

YHGHUHDFRUHFW ULLSURJQR]HORU 8UP WRDUHOH FRQVLGHUHQWH GH QDWXU HFRQRPLF úL VWDWLVWLF DX VWDW OD ED]D HODERU ULL XQRU DVWIHOGHPRGHOH SURFHVXO HFRQRPLF GHVFULV GH VHULD FURQRORJLF HVWH UH]XOWDWXO DF LXQLL PHFDQLVPHORU LQWHUQH FHHD FH H[SOLF QDWXUD DXWRUHJUHVLY D PRGHOXOXL ± SUHFXP úL D XQRU LQIOXHQ H GLQ DIDU FDUH GDF H[FOXGHP WHQGLQ D JHQHUDO úL IDFWRULL FDUH R GHWHUPLQ DF LRQHD] DFFLGHQWDOVXEIRUPD XQRULPSXOVXULDOHDWRDUH$FHDVW GLQXUP FDUDFWHULVWLF DSURFHVXOXLFRQIHU PRGHOXOXLXQFDUDFWHU VWRFKDVWLF VHULD FURQRORJLF UHSUH]HQWkQG ÄPDWHULD SULP ³ SHQWUX PRGHODUH VH vQFDGUHD] vQWUXQD GLQWUHFDWHJRULLOH

VHULH QHVWD LRQDU DYkQG WHQGLQ

HYROXWLY UH]XOWDW DO XQXL SURFHV RPRJHQ

QHVWD LRQDU

VHULH VWD LRQDU UH]XOWDW DO XQXL SURFHV VWRFKDVWLF VWD LRQDU DYkQG XQHOH HOHPHQWH VWDELOH UHSHWDELOH FD GHVI úXUDUH úL FDUH UH LQXWH GH PRGHO FRQIHU SURJQR]HLRED] VROLG úLLPSOLF úDQVDGHDILSHUIRUPDQW

VHULHSXUDOHDWRDUHUH]XOWDWDOXQXLSURFHVJHQHUDWRUGHQXPHUHvQWkPSO WRDUH

R FODV GH SURFHVH VWRFKDVWLFH FRQVLGHUDWH XWLOH vQ YHGHUHD DQDOL]HL úL SURJQR]HL VHULLORU FURQRORJLFH R IRUPHD] SURFHVHOH VWRFKDVWLFH VWD LRQDUH &RPSRUWDPHQWXO XQRU DVWIHO GH SURFHVH SRDWH IL FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ IXQF LD GH DXWRFRUHOD LH ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH FRPSRQHQWD UH]LGXDO X

143

DFHDVWD HVWH SUHVXSXV FD ILLQG JHQHUDW GH XQ SURFHV GH ]JRPRW DOE vQ FDUH ILHFDUH WHUPHQ XUPHD] RGLVWULEX LHQRUPDO GHPHGLHHJDO FX]HURúLGHGLVSHUVLHGLIHULW GH]HURDYkQGSHQWUX

N ¹ FRYDULDQ H HJDOH FX ]HUR 0HGLLOH SRQGHUDWH DOH XQRU DVWIHO GH WHUPHQL SLHUG FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH XQXL DVWIHO GH SURFHV GH ]JRPRW DOE FRQVWLWXLQG UHSUH]HQW ULVDWLVI F WRDUHDOHXQXLSURFHVDOHDWRU RELúQXLW>@ PRGHOXOHVWHGHILQLWFDXQDJUHJDWFHLQFOXGHLPSXOVXULOHUHFHSWDWHFXvQWkU]LHULGH« S LQWHUYDOH GH WLPS FD úL UHDF LLOH H[SULPDWH vQ PHGLH OD DEDWHULOH DFFLGHQWDOH X GH OD HYROX LD OLQLDU PDQLIHVWDWHvQXUP FX«TLQWHUYDOHGHWLPS $FHVWH FRQVLGHUHQWH vúL J VHVF FRUHVSRQGHQ H UHDOH vQ HFRQRPLH vQWUXFkW FDUDFWHUXO DXWRFRUHODW DO SURFHVHORU HFRQRPLFH HVWH UHFXQRVFXW LDU vQ FH SULYHúWH LQWURGXFHUHD vQ FDOFXOH D HIHFWHORU SHUWXUED LHL DFHDVWD VH MXVWLILF GDF DYHP vQ YHGHUH ILH úL QXPDL UHDF LLOH UHSDUDWRULL GH UHGUHVDUH SHFDUHOHJHQHUHD] DEDWHULOHGHODFHHDFHvQHFRQRPLHVHFRQVLGHU RHYROX LHQRUPDO

'LQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH DO WHKQLFLORU GH P VXUDUH FRQVLGHUHQWHOH PHQ LRQDWH SUHVXSXQ FD VHULD

FURQRORJLF SH FDUH XUPHD] V R SUHOXFU P vQ VHQVXO PHWRGHL %R[-HQNLQV V ILH R YHULILFDUH SULQ SULVPDXUP WRDUHORUFRQGL LL

H[LVWHQ DXQXLQXP UVXILFLHQWGHPDUHGHWHUPHQLQ! DVWIHOvQFkWFRHILFLHQ LLVWDWLVWLFL

GHDXWRFRUHOD LHSUHFXPúLSDUDPHWULLV SUH]LQWHVWDELOLWDWH

VHULD YDORULORU V ILH VWD LRQDU I U WUHQG LQFOX]kQG HYHQWXDO FRPSRQHQWH RVFLODWRULL

VH]RQDOLWDWHFLFOLFLWDWH

)81&

,$ '( $872&25(/$

,( FDUH UHSUH]LQW HOHPHQWXO FKHLH SHQWUX vQWUHJ

GHPHUVXO SUHVXSXV GH PRGHOHOH VWRFKDVWLFH GH SURJQR] SRDWH IL HVWLPDW GH FRHILFLHQWXO GH DXWRFRUHOD LHU GHILQLWDVWIHO

U

N

Ç

=

\

- \ \

Ç \

- \

- \

XQGH

HVWLPDWRUXOFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHDXWRFRUHOD LH

U

vQWkU]LHUHD ODJXO H[SULPDW SULQWUXQ QXP U GH XQLW

N

L GXS FDUH

DSDUHHIHFWXOXQRULPSXOVXULPRGLILFDUHDSURSULXOXLFRPSRUWDPHQWVDXDXQHLFDX]H

([HPSOX

)LH XUP WRDUHD VHULH GH GDWH WULPHVWULDOH SHQWUX WUHL DQL VXFFHVLYL SULYLQG R YDULDELO

HFRQRPLF 7DEHOXO ,

,,

,,,

,9

$QL

7ULP

([SUHVLD]JRPRWDOEHVWHXWLOL]DW SHQWUXDFDUDFWHUL]DSURFHVHOHSXUDOHDWRDUHvQFDUHQLFLRFRPSRQHQW GHIUHFYHQ

QX SUH]LQW R PDL PDUH LPSRUWDQ

GHFkW DOWHOH 6WDUHD GH ÄGHSOLQ HJDOLWDWH´ IDFH FD SURFHVXO V SUH]LQWH DQDORJLL FX

DFHD XQG GH OXPLQ vQ FDUH QX SUHGRPLQ QLFL R FRPSRQHQW SHQWUX DL GD FXORDUHD HD U PkQkQG DOE 0DL FRQFUHW GDF 0X

s

ILQLW YDORULOH OXL X QX VXQW DXWRFRUHODWH DILUP P F SURFHVXO JHQHUDWRU GH YDORUL X HVWH GH

]JRPRWDOELDUGDF vQSOXVHURULOHX VXQWLQGHSHQGHQWHDILUP PF SURFHVXOHVWHVWULFWGH]JRPRWDOE

3ULQLQGLFHOHNN

« FRQVHPQ PvQWkU]LHUHDGXS FDUHVHÄVLPWH´LQIOXHQ DODJXO HURULLGLQWUHFXW

5HOD LDGHFDOFXO QXGLIHU VHPQLILFDWLYGHPRGXOGHFDOFXODOFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHFRUHOD LH'HRVHELUHDFRQVW vQ

IDSWXO F vQ ORF GH Ä[´ DSDUH \

" # ! \ Ç $ #

- \

%

vQWUXFkW vQ FD]XO SURFHVHORU VWD LRQDUH

s

\

@s

\

QXPLWRUXO GHYLQH

QXP UXOJUDGHORUGHOLEHUWDWHVHVLPSOLILF

144

(YLGHQW QXP UXO GH WHUPHQL HVWH PXOW SUHD PLF GDU IDFHP DEVWUDF LH GH DFHDVW SULP FRQGL LHvQWUXFkWXUP ULPV IDFLOLW PvQ HOHJHUHDHWDSHORUGHFDOFXOVXILFLHQWGHODERULRDVHSHQWUXD QXPDLvQF UFDH[SXQHUHDFXFDOFXOHSUHOXQJLWH

'DF QHUHIHULPODFHOHODOWHFRQGL LLDWXQFLFDOFXOXOFRHILFLHQ LORUGHDXWRFRUHOD LHSHQWUXN

« SUHFXP úL WHVWDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL DFHVWRUD RIHU U VSXQVXUL XWLOH vQ YHGHUHD FDUDFWHUL] ULL VHULHL

3HQWUX GDWHOH H[HPSOXOXL FRQVLGHUDW WDEHOXO RE LQHP XUP WRULL FRHILFLHQ L GH

DXWRFRUHOD LH

* U U

- / 3

*+(

=

)

( ' - ( 3

*+( 3

- (

)

( ' 4 *+(

3

)

- 2 ( ' &

*+( )

( ' - / 3

- / 3 4

*+( )

*+(

( ' 4 )

( ' & 4

...

3

- (,(

4 ... 4 - (,(

3

*+(

- - + - - + +

=

-

U

6

=

7 U

=

5

+ -

5

+ +

*+( )

( ' &

( ' - (10 )

3

-

-

*+( )

( '

-

5

=

=

7HQGLQ DGHFUHúWHUHHYLGHQW DYDORULORUVHULHLDVSHFWFRQILUPDWGHGHVFUHúWHUHDUHODWLYOHQW DFRHILFLHQ LORU U: U9 U8 VHPQDOHD] RVHULHFURQRORJLF QHVWD LRQDU 3HQWUXHOLPLQDUHDDFHVWXLLQFRQYHQLHQWSURFHG PODFDOFXOXOGLIHUHQ HORUGHRUGLQXOvQWkL

«

6HULDGHYDORULDVWIHOUH]XOWDW HVWHSUH]HQWDW vQWDEHOXOXUP WRU

7DEHOXO 7ULPHVWUXOW

,,

,,,

,9

,

,,

,,,

,9

,

,,

,,,

9DORULVWD LRQDUL]DWH\;

&RHILFLHQ LLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHRE LQX LSHQWUXQRLOHYDORULDOHOXL \ < SUH]HQWDWHvQWDEHOXO VXQW U

= - U

= - U

= -

'HVFUHúWHUHD UDSLG D FRHILFLHQ LORU VSUH QLYHOH DSURSLDWH GH ]HUR FRQILUP VWD LRQDULWDWHD VHULHL0HQ LRQ PF QHDPOLPLWDWODFRHILFLHQ LL U= U> U? vQWUXFkWVHULDHVWHPXOWSUHDVFXUW 'H UHJXO VHGHWHUPLQ U@ SHQWUXN

«

7LSRORJLDPRGHOHORUVWRFKDVWLFHúLFDUDFWHUL]DUHDVWDWLVWLF

DDFHVWRUD

ÌQUDSRUWFXVXUVDFDUHÄDOLPHQWHD] ´SUHYL]LXQHDGHRVHELP PRGHOHDXWRUHJUHVLYH$5

GHRUGLQXOvQWkL$5 \ A

GHRUGLQXOGRL$5 \

= DE =D

W

+ DC \ A + D \

BDC + X A W -

+ D

\

W -

+X

W

vQUDSRUWFXGLVWDQ DvQWLPSDYDORULORUWUHFXWHDOHYDULDELOHLFDUHGHWHUPLQ YLLWRUXOQLYHO F PRGHOHGHPHGLHPRELO

0$

GHRUGLQXOvQWkL0$ \ G

GHRUGLQXOGRL0$ \ K

= \ - EI X G

= \ - EN X K

HJI + X G

L N - EM X K L M + X K O

vQUDSRUWFXGLVWDQ DvQWLPSODFDUHVHÄVLPWH´LQIOXHQ DSHUWXUED LHL

P

'HQXPLUHDGHPHGLHPRELO DUHvQYHGHUHIDSWXOF VXPDDOJHEULF DHOHPHQWHORU E Q

QXP U WRUXO XQHL PHGLL SRQGHUDWH LSRWHWLFH SRQGHULOH ILLQG FUHúWH 8OWHULRU FRQGL LD

E E

E

N

XR

S Q

N

«T UHSUH]LQW

DL F UHL WHUPHQL JOLVHD] SH P VXUD FH ÄW´

Ç ET = D IRVW ÄXLWDW ´ DVWIHO vQFkW PRGHOXO 0$

(T ) UHSUH]LQW

XQ DJUHJDW GH T HOHPHQWH

T

FXUROVHPQLILFDWLYvQHYROX LDYDULDELOHL\

145

PRGHOHPL[WHDXWRUHJUHVLYHúLGHPHGLHPRELO $50$ST UHSUH]HQWkQGRFRPELQD LH DDPEHORUÄVXUVHGHFUHúWHUH´YH]LUHOD LD PRGHOH QHVWD LRQDUH DXWRUHJUHVLYH úL GH PHGLH PRELO $5,0$S G T UHSUH]HQWkQG R YDULDQW D PRGHOHORU PL[WH YH]L UHOD LD SULQ FDUH VH VSHFLILF H[LVWHQ D WUHQGXOXL vQ FDGUXO VHULHL FURQRORJLFH LQL LDOH P ULPHD ÄG´ LQGLFkQG RUGLQXO GLIHUHQ HL FDUH D GXV OD YDORUL VWD LRQDUH 'H UHJXO GLIHUHQ HOH GH RUGLQXO vQWkL GLQWUH WHUPHQLL VHULHL G\ V RUGLQXOGRL G ]

ZY X ^

= G\

\

- G\

= \V - \V

U T FHO PXOW GLIHUHQ HOH GH

\ [ W UHXúHVFV HOLPLQHWUHQGXOGLQGDWH

ÌQ WDEHOXO VXQW SUH]HQWDWH SULQFLSDOHOH WLSXUL GH PRGHOH ÌQ XOWLPD FRORDQ D WDEHOXOXL HVWH VSHFLILFDW IRUPD FRQFHQWUDW D PRGHOXOXL XWLOL]kQGXVH RSHUDWRUXO Ä%´ GH WUDQVODWDUH vQWUR SHULRDG GLQ WUHFXW ÄEDFNZDUG VKLIW RSHUDWRU´ 5ROXO XQXL DVWIHO GH RSHUDWRU HVWH GHVFULV GH LOH

HJDOLW

= \V

%\ V

_

%

\a

U T

= \a

U T c % X d = X d b b

` _

0RGHOXO$5 GHYLQH

\

= Dh

e

+ D g %\

= XV

%X V

+ Df %

e

f \

+ X e

e

$FHVWDPDLSRDWHILVFULVDVWIHO \ i - D l % - D k %

k

+ X i

= Dj

VDXvQWURIRUP PDLFRQFHQWUDW D % \ m

+ Xm

= Dn

ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH VH SRDWH SURFHGD OD HOLPLQDUHD PHGLHL \ GLQ FDGUXO YDORULORU VWD LRQDUH \

W

FHHD FH HVWH HFKLYDOHQW FX HOLPLQDUHD SDUDPHWUXOXL D

FD] vQ FDUH PRGHOXO vQ IRUPD

FRQFHQWUDW GHYLQH D % \

=X

W

W

ÌQFD]XOPRGHOHORU0$T RSHUDWRUXO%HVWHXWLOL]DWvQWURIRUP VLPLODU 2 SRVLELOLWDWH GH D UHGD XQ SURFHV VWD LRQDU $5S VH ED]HD] SH IDSWXO F SURFHVXO HVWH 5('8&7,%,/ OD GHSHQGHQ H vQ UDSRUW FX X p SHQWUX D r = Dv \x

=

\p

= D \p

q

q o $VWIHO GDF FRQVLGHU P SURFHVXO $5 vQ FDUH

+ X p SXWHP DILUPD F OD UkQGXO V X

w u + X x w t HWF /LPLWkQGXQH OD HJDOLW

LOH SULYLQG \ y úL \ |

\x

w t

\|

{ z FXH[SUHVLDVDvQHJDOLWDWHD \ | = D z \ | { z + X | 5H]XOW F \

W

=D

(D \

W -

+X

W -

) + XW

=D

\

W -

+X

\p

2 H[SUHVLH JHQHUDO vQ XUPD vQORFXLULORU VXFFHVLYH SULYLQG \ | DVWIHO

q s

+ Xp

q

UHVSHFWLY

{ z SURFHG P OD vQORFXLUHD OXL

+D X

W

= D \p

q

{

W -

\ |

{ } HWF SRDWH IL UHGDW

~

\

=

D X Ç

vQFDUHSHQWUX_D_HOHPHQWHOHSRQGHUDWHDOHVXPHLFRQYHUJF WUH]HUR

3URFHGkQGVLPLODUVHSRDWHDU WDFDXQSURFHV0$T SRDWHILUHGDWFDXQDJUHJDWGHWHUPHQL

\|

{ $VWIHO GDF FRQVLGHU P F

F X |

= \|

+ Ez X |

\ = SURFHVXO 0$ GHYLQH \

= -E X

+ X GH XQGH UH]XOW

{ z UHVSHFWLY X = \ + E X HWF

ÌQORFXLQGvQSURFHVXO0$ SH X \

W

=X

W

- E \

W -

FXH[SUHVLDVD X = \ + E X

+E X

W -

= -E \

W -

-E

X

W -

+X

W

RE LQHP

6HPQXOQHJDWLYDOSDUDPHWUXOXLEHVWHSXUVLPEROLF3DUDPHWUXOYDDYHDVHPQXOUH]XOWDWvQXUPDHVWLP ULL

146

ùLvQDFHVWFD]SHQWUX_E_DMXQJHPvQXUPDvQORFXLULORUVXFFHVLYHDYDORULORU X

ODYDORUL E X

FDUH FRQYHUJ UDSLG F WUH ]HUR DVWIHO vQFkW SURFHVXO 0$T H[SULPDW vQ UDSRUW FX

\

VD ILH

FRQVLGHUDW,19(56$%,/ 7DEHOXO 7LSXOGH

)RUPDH[SOLFLW

)RUPDFRQFHQWUDW

PRGHO $XWRUHJUHVLY

\

$5S

= \ + D + D \ + D \ + + D \

GHPHGLH PRELO

\

W

0$T

= \ +X

W

-E X

W -

- - E

T

X

+X

W -T

D % \

\

W

= X

= E % X

W

0L[W DXWRUHJUHVLY

\

úLGHPHGLH

+ D \ + + D

= D

\

+ \ - E X - - E X

+X

D % \

= E % X

PRELO 0L[W

D % G £

QHVWD LRQDU

¡ ¢ \ = E % X

ÌQ YHGHUHD FDUDFWHUL] ULL SURFHVHORU $5 0$ úL $50$ DYHP vQ YHGHUH PHGLD GLVSHUVLD úL

FRYDULDQ D 6 FRQVLGHU P SHQWUX vQFHSXW PRGHOXO DXWRUHJUHVLY vQ IRUPD VD FHD PDL VLPSO UHVSHFWLY SURFHVXO$5 \¤

= D§

+ D¦ \¤

¥J¦ + X ¤

XQGH X ¤ UHSUH]LQW YDULDELODUH]LGXDO GHQDWXU DOHDWRDUHQHFRUHODW GHPHGLH]HURúLGHGLVSHUVLH FRQVWDQW

3HQWUXXQDVWIHOGHSURFHVDYHPvQYHGHUHXUP WRDUHOHSUH]XP LL úLUXO YDORULORU \ ¨ W

« Q UHSUH]LQW R VHFYHQ

XQ HúDQWLRQ GH Q YDORUL FHHD FH

IDFHFDSDUDPHWULLRE LQX LV UHSUH]LQWHHVWLP ULDOHDGHY UDWHORUYDORUL GHQVLWDWHD GH UHSDUWL LH HVWH DFHHDúL vQ GLYHUVHOH VHFYHQ H HúDQWLRDQH GH YDORUL \ ¨ ILLQG LGHQWLF FXFHDFDUHVDURE LQHSHQWUXDQVDPEOXOYDORULORU \ ¨ W

«Q RE LQkQGXVHDFHHDúL

PHGLH úL GLVSHUVLH LDU FRYDULDQ D QHGHSLQ]kQG GH YDULDELOD WLPS FL QXPDL GH P ULPHD ODJXOXL vQWkU]LHULL $úDGDUDFHVWDHVWHXQSURFHVVODEVWD LRQDUFDUDFWHUL]DWSULQ

0HGLD 0 \ « = 0 D ª

vQWUXFkW0X

+ D© \ «

¬ © + X « = Dª + D© 0 \ «

LDUSHQWUXGLYHUVHOHVHFYHQ H \ « PHGLDHVWHDFHHDúL

ÌQUHOD LD GDF L]RO PPHGLDRE LQHP 0 \

¯ =

'DF FRQVLGHU PF D

D

®

- D

= FHHDFHDUvQVHPQDV OXDPvQFDOFXOGRDUDEDWHULOHYDORULORU \ «

GHODFRQVWDQWD D ° RE LQHP 0 \« = 'LVSHUVLD

± sµ

± ¸

vQWUXFkW 0 \ = 0 X

=s

· µ ¸ ¹ ³ » ´ ¸ ( ³

=s

X

)

= 0 >D \

²

¶ º ² + X ¶ - 0 \ ¶ @

LDU X « QXGHSLQGHGH \ ¾

± ²

±

= D sµ

±

± ¸ ¹ ³ +s ´

½ ¼

147

¿

'DF DYHPvQYHGHUHF s

s \

=

Ç

¿

Ã

= s

Â Æ

s

Â Á À SURFHVXOILLQGVWD LRQDUUH]XOW F

Ã

Ä

Ä Å

- D

FRY \

\

W

W -

= 0 > \

- 0 \

W

= 0 >D \

¢ 0 \

=D

¢ 0 \

vQWUXFkW X È úL \ È

½ ¼ QXVXQWFRUHODWH s Ã

2DERUGDUHVLPLODU D FRY\ FRY\

2 FRQVHFLQ

\

×

¿

Ó

= s

Â

+X

W -C

W -

¿

\

Ë

=D

× Ø Ö

W -

=D

+X

W -

= 0 D \

&RYDULDQ D

¢ \

W

- ¢ \

W

\

W

W -

\

FRQGXFHOD FRY\

Ë Ê É

Ö Ò

Ô

sÕ

- @ =

W -

W -

È

Â Á À

Ã

@ =

\

W

¢s

W -

=

+ 0 X

=D

- 0 \

W -

Ð

\

=D

Ð Ñ Ì

Ì Í

Ì ¢s Ï

Î UHVSHFWLY

D FDUDFWHUL] ULORU SULQ SULVPD PHGLHL GLVSHUVLHL úL FRYDULDQ HL VH ÄU VIUkQJH´

DVXSUD DQDOL]HL HYROX LHL FRHILFLHQ LORU HVWLPD L GH DXWRFRUHOD LH UÙ SHQWUX N &RUHVSXQ] WRUUHOD LHL FRHILFLHQWXO r N

Ú =

U

N

vQWUXFkWFRYN DGLF FRY \

FRY \ sÛ

Ú

Ý \ ß Ü Ú

å \ å æ ä

Þ

= Dá

ä

Ý

Ü ¢s Û

D

=

Ý

sÛ

¢s ã

'HRDUHFHSURFHVXOHVWHVWD LRQDU _ D ç

FRYN

=

à

«

UHVSHFWLYHVWLPD LDVDHVWHGHIRUPD

FRY

Ú = D

Ú

N

â FRUHVSXQ] WRUUHOD LHL

_< DFHDVWDIDFHFDSHP VXU FH N ¸ YDORULOHOXL

Uè V VFDG vQ SURJUHVLH JHRPHWULF F WUH ]HUR ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH D ç

< RE LQHP HVWLPD LL Uè

DOWHUQDWLYHFDVHPQGHVFULLQGRLQYROX LHGHWLSÄGLQ LGHILHU VWU X´

2DERUGDUHVLPLODU SHQWUXSURFHVXO$5 FRQGXFHODLQGLFDWRULL

0HGLD

0 \

W

=

D

- D

-D

@

'LVSHUVLD

s

\

é

= FRY = 0 > \

W

¢ D \

W -

+ D

\

W -

+X

W

&RYDULDQ D

FRY \

W

\

W -

= 0 >\ = D

W -

¢ D \

FRY + D

W -

+D

\

W -

+X

W

@ =

FRY

5HDPLQWLPIDSWXOF

FRY = FRY \ ì \ ì FRY = s

\

ë ê

í

$WXQFL

FRY \

W

\

W -

= 0 >\ = D

W -

¢ D \

FRY + D

W -

+ D

FRY

\

W -

+X

W

@ =

148

0RGXO vQ FDUH HYROXHD] FRHILFLHQ LL U ÄWU GHD] ´ H[LVWHQ D XQRU DQDORJLL vQ HYROX LD

YDORULORU \ î \ ñ

ð ï \ ñ ó ò FDUH GHYLQ WRW PDL SX LQ HYLGHQWH SH P VXU FH GLVWDQ D vQ WLPS FUHúWH &D

XUPDUHSURFHVXO$5HVWHFRQVLGHUDWÄGHPHPRULHOXQJ ´

3URFHVXO0$ HVWHúLHOFDUDFWHUL]DWGHDFHHDúLLQGLFDWRUL

0HGLD

0 \ ô = 0 \ - Eö X ô õ ö ÌQWUXFkW 0 X

= 0 X

W

'LVSHUVLD

÷

÷

- E X ú X ú

ø

÷

÷

=sù

ÌQWUXFkW 0 X

W -

FRY \

\

FRY \ \

ü

+E

ø sù

= LDU s

÷

þ ø + Eø ÷

=s

ü

÷ Xú

¢ + E

=sù

X

÷

X

ü

ÿ

ø

÷

÷

= 0 >X ú

ø

- E Xú

þ ø @

÷

= 0 > \ + X

ó

= 0 X X

- 0 \ \ + X

-E X

-E X X

-E X

ÿ ÿ ü ò = 0 >X ü - E X ü X ü ò ó ó ó

ÿ

-E X

=

þ ø @=

&RYDULDQ D

X

W

þ ø + X ú - 0 \ ú @

ø

= 0 >X ú

=

W -

= 0 > \ - E X ú

s ûýü

+ Xô = \

+E

X

ü ò @ = ó

- 0 \ @ =

-E X

= -E s

X

ÌQWUXFkW GDW ILLQG LQGHSHQGHQ D YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH vQ UDSRUW FX SURSULLOH VDOH YDORUL GLQ WUHFXWFRYDULDQ HOHVHDQXOHD] SHQWUXGLVWDQ HGLQWUHYDORULN!

(VWLPD LD IXQF LHL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH UN

úL SHQWUX 0$ () N

LDUSHQWUXN! U

-E s

=

U

s

¢ + E

-E

=

+ E

=

FRYN

GHYLQH GDF DYHP vQ YHGHUH UHOD LLOH

FRY

= YH]LUHOD LD

$úDGDU SURFHVXO 0$ () VH FDUDFWHUL]HD] SULQWUR P ULPH VHPQLILFDWLY DFRHILFLHQWXOXL U

GXS FDUH SHQWUX N ! YDORULOH OXL U SUH]LQW R F GHUH EUXVF VSUH YDORUL QHVHPQLILFDWLYH DSURSLDWHGH]HUR 8QDVWIHOGHSURFHVSRDWHILFDUDFWHUL]DWFDILLQGÄGHPHPRULHVFXUW ´

3URFHGkQG VLPLODU SHQWUX D FDUDFWHUL]D SURFHVXO 0$

( ) DMXQJHP OD FRQFOX]LD F

QLYHOXO

HVWLPD LLORUOXL U GHYLQHQHVHPQLILFDWLYGHvQGDW FHN!

3URFHVXO$50$ 0HGLD

'HFL 0 \

=

D

W

- D

'LVSHUVLD

0 \

s

\

= 0 D

= 0 >D \

\

0 \

+X

W -

-E X

W -

W

+X

W

=D

X

-E X

= 0 > D \

W -

W -

X

- 0 \

W -

+s

+X

X

+E X

W

@

X

\

=D

s

\

+s

X

-D E

++E

=

+E

s

X

@ = 0 X

FRQVWDQW SHGLYHUVHVHJPHQWHGHYDORULDOHOXL \ YRPRE LQH s

+ D 0 \

W

0 \ =

- D E 0 \

W -

= 0 \ =

ùWLLQG F

+ D \

LDUSHQWUX D

= D s vQFDUHD

=s

LDU GLVSHUVLD HVWH

149

5H]XOW F

s

\

+ E

=

- D E

- D

s

X

&RYDULDQ D

FRY \

\

W

W -

( + DE )(D

=

-D

+E

)

s

X

= D s

\

+E s

X

ÌQFD]XOvQFDUH N Ë FRY

\

= D

\

FRY

\

\

ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHDXWRFRUHOD LD LQkQGVHDPDGHUHOD LLOH úL UH]XOW F

U

+ D

=

+ E

ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHN!

U

D

E

= D U

+ E

- D

E

!

$O WXUL GH HVWLPDWRULL FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U SUH]LQW LQWHUHV vQGHRVHEL vQ HWDSHOHGHVSHFLILFDUHúLHVWLPDUHDOHPRGHOXOXLúLFRHILFLHQ LLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHSDU LDO F

3HQWUX D RE LQH YDORULOH DFHVWRU FRHILFLHQ L DVHP Q WRUL vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH LQWHUSUHWDUHD FX

Ö SDUDPHWUL D

#

"

'

( S ) DYHPLQYHGHUHSURFHVXO $5 ( )

GLQPRGHOXO $5

&

&RUHVSXQ] WRU

FRY = D FRY + D

UHOD LLORU

úL

%

FRY = D FRY + D

(

$

FRY

UHVSHFWLY

FRY UHOD LL FDUH vPS U LWH HOHPHQW FX HOHPHQW OD GLVSHUVLH FRY

UHDPLQWLQGXQH IRUPXOD GH GHILQLUH D FRHILFLHQWXOXL U FRQGXF vQ FD]XO UHOD LHL OD HJDOLWDWHD FRY

= D

FRY

+ D

'DF DYHPvQYHGHUHIDSWXOF

) ) *) , ,+

'HFL

U

= D

U

=

U

N

FRY

FRY

=

FRYN FRY

UH]XOW F

+ D U

D

- D

ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHUHOD LD YRPRE LQH FRY FRY

= D

+ D

. . -/ 0 0/ /

'HFL

U

= D

FRY

FRY

+ D U

&HHDFHFRQGXFHOD U

= D

D

- D

+ D

=

D

0/

- D

/ / + D

5HOD LLOH úL VXQW FXQRVFXWH úL VXE GHQXPLUHD GH HFXD LLOH <XOH:DONHU

$FHVWH HFXD LL RIHU SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D RE LQH QHFXQRVFXWHOH D úL D

YDORULORUOXL U úL U

1

([WLQ]kQGGHPHUVXOSHQWUXSURFHVXO $5

FRY =

453 4

ÇD

() vQFDUH

3

FRYN - M = D FRY + D

2

GLQ SURFHVXO $5

( ) SH ED]D

1

FRY + D

RE LQHPvQXUPDvPS U LULLWHUPHQLORUODFRY UHOD LD

150

7 6 6 786 =

U

vQFDUH U

:9 9

= úL U

ÇD

U

= U

= = > ; =? ; < =? < = B @ BD@ B C A BDA @ @ G F EIF G EIG E H F G O PQN P

;= <; B A@ GF E L K J

6LVWHPXOGHHFXD LLFDUHVHIRUPHD] vQFD]XOSURFHVXOXL $5 N = Ü U

=D U

+ D U

+ D U

N = Ü U

=D U

+ D U

N = Ü U

=D U

+D U

=D

+D U

+D U

() HVWHXUP

+ D U

+ D U

+D U

=D U

+D

=D U

+ D U

+D

WRUXO

ÌQFDGUXOVLVWHPXOXLGHHFXD LL SDUDPHWULLOLEHUL D D D UHSUH]LQW FRHILFLHQ LLGH

M

DXWRFRUHOD LH SDU LDO F *HQHUDOL]kQG SHQWUX FRYN =

S R TV W R S U R

vPS U LULLODFRY H[SUHVLD

U

=

ÇD

U

N

«.

ÇD

FRY N - M N! VH RE LQH vQ XUPD

6SHFLILFDUHDLGHQWLILFDUHD

X

'DW ILLQG YDULHWDWHD PRGHOHORU VWRFKDVWLFH YH]L WDEHOXO HVWH QHFHVDU HWDSD

VSHFLILF ULL vQFDUHF XWDPU VSXQVODXUP WRDUHOHvQWUHE UL FHWLSGHPRGHODOHJHP" FDUH HVWH RUGLQXO PRGHOXOXL VDX DOWIHO VSXV OD FH QLYHO DO LQGLFLORU ÄS´ UHVSHFWLY ÄT´ QH RSULP" &RQFUHW SHQWUX H[HPSOXO FRQVLGHUDW YH]L WDEHOXO XUPHD] V VWDELOLP GDF PRGHOXO HVWH GH WLS $5 0$ $50$ VDX $5,0$ ÌQWUXFkW VD FRQVWDW vQ HWDSD SUHFHGHQW F VHULD SUH]LQW WHQGLQ

LDU WHQGLQ D D IRVW HOLPLQDW GXS FDOFXOXO GLIHUHQ HORU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL DFHVWH LQIRUPD LL

VXQW XWLOH VSHFLILF ULL PRGHOXOXL DFHVWD VLWXkQGXVH vQ FODVD PRGHOHORU QHVWD LRQDUH LDU RUGLQXO GLIHUHQ HORU GHVWLQDWH VWD LRQDUL] ULL HVWH G

$U PDL XUPD V VWDELOLP úL QLYHOXO LQGLFLORU S úL T

SHQWUXDGHILQLFRPSOHWIRUPDPRGHOXOXL$5S úLVDX0$T 3HQWUX D GD U VSXQV vQWUHE ULORU IRUPXODWH úL LPSOLFLW SHQWUX D VSHFLILFD IRUPD PRGHOXOXL DYHPvQYHGHUHXQHOHFRQVLGHUHQ HWHRUHWLFHSUH]HQWDWHvQSDUDJUDIXOSUHFHGHQW &ULWHULLOHVHED]HD] SHXUP WRDUHOHÄVHPQDOH´ D

IXQF LDGHDXWRFRUHOD LHúLDQDOL]DPRGLILF ULORUFRHILFLHQ LORUGHDXWRFRUHOD LHSHQWUXN

Y

« E

DQDOL]D FRPSDUDWLY D HYROX LHL FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U úL D FRHILFLHQ LORU GH

Z

DXWRFRUHOD LHSDU LDO F F

SHQWUXN

«

Z

DQDOL]D FRPSDUDWLY D HYROX LHL FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U úL D FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LHSDU LDO F

G

DSUHFLHUHDSRVLELOLW SDUWLFXODULW

Z

SHQWUXN

«

LORUGHHYROX LHvQWLPSDOHIHQRPHQXOXLHFRQRPLF LQkQGVHDPDGH

LOH DFHVWXLD FRQMXQFWXUD HFRQRPLF úL VFKLPE ULOH vQ WUHFXW úL YLLWRU DOH

YDULDELOHORUH[RJHQHSUHFXPúLGHUH]XOWDWHOHXQRUVWXGLLVLPLODUHDQWHULRDUHH[SHULHQ D úLLQWXL LDHFRQRPHWULFLDQXOXLGH LQXQUROLPSRUWDQW 3HQWUX R FkW PDL FRUHFW VSHFLILFDUH D PRGHOXOXL HVWH QHFHVDU FD FHO SX LQ GRX GLQWUH FHOH WUHLFULWHULLV ILHOXDWHvQFRQVLGHUDUH

[ ]^ \

ÌQDLQWHGHDDERUGDPRGDOLWDWHDGHDSOLFDUHDFULWHULLORUHVWHQHFHVDUV PHQ LRQ PF IXQF LD GH DXWRFRUHOD LH VH UHIHU OD LQWHQVLWDWHDDQDORJLHLGLQWUH \ úL \

_

SHQWUXN

«&RUHORJUDPD

ÌQ XQHOH OXFU UL HVWH XWLOL]DW WHUPHQXO ÄLGHQWLILFDUH´ vQ VHQVXO DWULEXLW GH QRL VSHFLILF ULL ÌQWUXFkW LGHQWLILFDUHD DSDUH

vQWUXQ FDSLWRO XUP WRU FD HWDS GLVWLQFW vQ PRGHODUHD HFRQRPHWULF SUHIHU P V XWLOL] P QR LXQHD GH VSHFLILFDUH D YDULDELOHORUDIXQF LHLVDXGHHODERUDUHDPRGHOXOXL

151

BB$5

BB$5

$5

$5

` DXWRFRUHOD LDU

a

DXWRFRUHOD LDU

)LJ

a

`

)LJ

BB$5

BB0$

$5

0$

DXWRFRUHOD LDSDU LDO F

`

`

a

DXWRFRUHOD LDU

a

)LJ

)LJ

UHG VXJHVWLY PRGLILFDUHD FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH SH GRPHQLXO ORU GH GHILQL LH VLWXDW vQWUH SHQWUX P ULPL DOH ODJXOXL FDUH QX GHS úHVF GH UHJXO LQWHUYDOH YH]L ILJXULOH ±

3HQWUX HWDSD VSHFLILF ULL SUH]LQW LPSRUWDQ

\

GRDU P ULPHD FRHILFLHQ LORU QX úL VHPQXO

DFHVWRUDDVWIHOvQFkWSR]L LDORUSHJUDILFvQUDSRUWFXD[DRUL]RQWDO PDLSX LQLPSRUW &RHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH SDU LDO F

]

P VRDU JUDGXO GH DVRFLHUH GLQWUH \ úL \

]^ \

vQ

LSRWH]D vQ FDUH LQIOXHQ D QLYHOXOXL GLQ WUHFXW SHQWUX RULFH ODJ GLIHULW GH N HVWH PHQ LQXW FRQVWDQW 2

b b

DXWRFRUHOD LD

DXWRFRUHOD LD

SDU LDO F

U

)LJ

)LJ

b DXWRFRUHOD LD SDU LDO F

)LJ

152

DVWIHOGHL]RODUHDLQIOXHQ HLHVWHLPSRUWDQW SHQWUXDLQGLFDFHOPDLDGHFYDWPRGHO$50$GHVWLQDW SURJQR]HL ÌQ GHFXUVXO VSHFLILF ULL PRGHOXOXL SULQ SULVPD FHORU WUHL FULWHULL SRW IL vQWkOQLWH VLWXD LLOH OD FDUHQHYRPUHIHULvQFHOHFHXUPHD]

c d e

f g

([LVWHQ D XQHL WHQGLQ H HYROXWLYH ± DVSHFW VHPQDODW GH IDSWXO F FRHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH HVWLPD L U U U HYHQWXDO U U SUH]LQW QLYHOH VHPQLILFDWLY GLIHULWH GH ]HUR FH GHVFUHVF OHQW $úD FXP DP DU WDW vQWUXQ SDUDJUDI DQWHULRU HVWH QHFHVDU V HOLPLQ P WHQGLQ D FDOFXOkQG GLIHUHQ HOH GLQWUH WHUPHQLL VHULHL FURQRORJLFH 7HQGLQ D SRDWH IL FRPSOHW HOLPLQDW GXS FDOFXOXO GLIHUHQ HORU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL G RUGLQXOGRLG

VDX FHHD FH PDL UDU VH vQWkPSO D GLIHUHQ HORU GH

VDXPDLPDUH

h

3URFHVXOHVWHSXUDXWRUHJUHVLY$5 GDF DYHPvQYHGHUHFULWHULLOH

D FRHILFLHQ LL U GHVFUHVF SHQWUX N

« ILH vQ SURJUHVLH JHRPHWULF ILH

GHVFULLQG FRQWXUXO GLQ LORU GH ILHU VWU X YH]L ILJ 2UGLQXO SURFHVXOXL DXWRUHJUHVLY HVWH vQWkL GDF GHVFUHúWHUHD HVWH UDSLG UHVSHFWLY HVWH HJDO FX GLVWDQ D GLQWUH YkUIXULOH GLQ LORU GH IHU VWU X vQ FD]XO HYROX LHL vQ ]LJ]DJ ÌQ FD]XO VHULLORU FH SUH]LQW VH]RQDOLWDWH FRHILFLHQ LL SUH]LQW QLYHOH

i

VHPQLILFDWLYHODGLVWDQ HHJDOHFXQXP UXOGHXQLW E FRHILFLHQ LL U

LGHWLPSOXQLWULPHVWUH GLQWUXQDQ

GHVFUHVF vQ SURJUHVLH JHRPHWULF vQ WLPS FH FRHILFLHQ LL F

j

GHVFUHVF EUXVF GXS R P ULPH D ODJXOXL HJDO FX XQX FD] vQ FDUH RUGLQXO SURFHVXOXL DXWRUHJUHVLY HVWHXQXVDXGXS RP ULPHDODJXOXLHJDO FXGRLFD]vQFDUHRUGLQXOSURFHVXOXLDXWRUHJUHVLYHVWH GRLHWFILJúL F IHQRPHQXO HFRQRPLF HVWHGHSHQGHQWGHDFXPXO ULGHH[SHULHQ DGLQWUHFXWDYkQG GHFL XQ SURQXQ DW FDUDFWHU LQHU LDO 6H UHFRPDQG RS LXQHD SHQWUX XQ PRGHO DXWRUHJUHVLY SXU DO F UXLRUGLQUH]XOW FRQIRUPFHORUDU WDWHGLQÄFLWLUHD´FRUHORJUDPHL

&D]XO HYROX LLORU SXU DXWRUHJUHVLYH ILLQG GHVWXO GH UDU vQWkOQLW QX WUHEXLH H[FOXV

SRVLELOLWDWHDXQXLPRGHOPL[W$50$

h k

3URFHVXOHVWHFDUDFWHUL]DWFDILLQGGHPHGLHPRELO

0$ GDF

D FRHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U VH DSURSLH EUXVF GH ]HUR GXS N XQLW

h

2UGLQXOPRGHOXOXLGHPHGLHPRELO HVWHHJDOFXN

L GH WLPS

E QLYHOXO FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U VH DSURSLH EUXVF GH ]HUR vQ WLPS FH FRHILFLHQ LLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHSDU LDO F

l

VFDGvQSURSRU LHJHRPHWULF ILJ

l

2UGLQXOPRGHOXOXLGHPHGLHPRELO HVWHGDWGHP ULPHDPD[LP DLQGLFHOXLNSHQWUXFDUH U

SUH]LQW RYDORDUHVHPQLILFDWLY

F YDULDELOD HFRQRPLF HVWH VHQVLELO vQ WLPS OD PRGLILF ULOH GH DPSORDUH DOH XQRU YDULDELOHH[RJHQHSUH RIHUW FDODPLW

LHWF vQWUXFkWHOHJHQHUHD] DEDWHULDFFLGHQWDOHGHODPHGLD

HYROX LHLDEDWHULFDUHVHUHSHUFXWHD] vQWLPSVF ]kQGWUHSWDWvQLQIOXHQ

'HúL VH UHFRPDQG XQ PRGHO GH PHGLH PRELO QLFL vQ DFHVW FD] QX WUHEXLH H[FOXV

SRVLELOLWDWHDGHDUHSUH]HQWDPDLELQHHYROX LDvQWLPSSULQPRGHOXOPL[W$50$

3URFHVXOHVWHFRQVLGHUDWGHWLS$50$GDF D FRHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH VFDG SDU LDO WUHSWDW vQ LQWHQVLWDWH DSURSLLQGXVH DSRL

UDSLG GH QLYHOH QHVHPQLILFDWLYH GXS N XQLW

L GH WLPS 3HQWUXDVWDELOLRUGLQXOPRGHOXOXL$5DYHP

vQ YHGHUH P ULPHD LQGLFHOXL N SHQWUX FDUH FRHILFLHQ LL VH PHQ LQ OD QLYHOH UHODWLY PDUL SHQWUX D

m

n o z z w x yt x u x v u t x v t

([SOLFD LD DFHVWHL UHJXOL DUH vQ YHGHUH IDSWXO F vQWUXFkW 0 X

| |} {

YDORULORU OXL

FRY \ \

p

\ úL

\

'HFL

rs q

FRY \ \

FRHILFLHQWXO GH DXWRFRUHOD LH

~

VH RE LQH

U

U VXQWHJDOLFX]HURSHQWUX N

=

0 \

=s

\

¹ SHQWUX

DXWR FRY ( \

\

DXWR FRY ( \

)

E

X

+E E

Ê T úL

N

)

=

= SHQWUX W ¹ N UH]XOW F SHQWUX H[SUHVLLOH +E E

FRY \ \

DXWR FRY (N

)

DXWR FRY ( )

+ FHHD FH DPLQWHúWH GH

= SHQWUX

N

> T ÌQWUXFkW

UH]XOW F úL FRHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH

> T

153

VWDELOL RUGLQXO PRGHOXOXL 0$ DYHP vQ YHGHUH P ULPHD LQGLFHOXL N SHQWUX FDUH FRHILFLHQWXO U

GHYLQHQHVHPQLILFDWLYFD]vQFDUHRUGLQXOS U LLGHPHGLHPRELO GLQPRGHOXOPL[WHVWHT

N

E DWkW FRHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U FkW úL FRHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH SDU LDO F

VFDG FRQWLQXX DSURSLLQGXVH GH ]HUR YH]L ILJ úL I U D VH REVHUYD R VF GHUH EUXVF OD

QLFLXQXO GLQWUH HL 2UGLQXO S U LL DXWRUHJUHVLYH D PRGHOXOXL PL[W HVWH VHPQDODW GH QLYHOXO SHQWUX FDUH FRHILFLHQ LL F

SUH]LQW QLYHOH FkW GH FkW VHPQLILFDWLYH LDU RUGLQXO S U LL GH PHGLH PRELO GLQ

PRGHOXO PL[W HVWH GDW GH QLYHOXO PD[LP DO LQGLFHOXL N SHQWUX FDUH FRHILFLHQ LL U VXQW VXILFLHQW GH PDUL

F IHQRPHQXO GHVFULV GH VHULD GH WLPS HVWH WULEXWDU DWkW UHDOL] ULORU VDOH GLQ WUHFXW FkW úLDEDWHULORUDFFLGHQWDOHGDWRUDWHXQRUPRGLILF ULGHDPSORDUHDOHYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH 0RGHOXO DXWRUHJUHVLY úL GH PHGLH PRELO PL[W $50$ UHSUH]LQW ÄFD]XO JHQHUDO´ úL HVWH

FRQVLGHUDWFHOPDLLQGLFDWSHQWUXHODERUDUHDGHSURJQR]HvQHFRQRPLHDWXQFLFkQGQXHVWHFXQRVFXW QXDYHPGDWH HYROX LDYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH

0RGHOXO$50$HVWHGHVHRULUH]XOWDWXOVSHFLILF ULLSHQWUXYDULDELODVWD LRQDU SULQGLIHUHQ H

GHRUGLQXOG úLFDUHvQIRUPDRULJLQDO SUH]LQW WHQGLQ

YH]LVLWXD LD

$FHVW DVSHFW HVWH VSHFLILFDW DWkW SULQ GHQXPLUHD GH PRGHO QHVWD LRQDU DXWRUHJUHVLY úL GH

PHGLHPRELO FkWúLSULQVLPEROXO$5,0$XWLOL]DW$FHVWVLPEROHVWHXUPDWGHQLYHOXOLQGLFLORU

S

RUGLQXOS U LLDXWRUHJUHVLYHDPRGHOXOXL

G

RUGLQXOGLIHUHQ HORUFDUHDXFRQGXVODYDORULDOHOXL \ VWD LRQDUH

T

RUGLQXOS U LLGHPHGLHPRELO DPRGHOXOXL

$VWIHO SHQWUX D VHPQDOD XQ PRGHO FDUH VH UHIHU OD R VHULH DGXV OD IRUPD VWD LRQDU GXS FDOFXOXO GLIHUHQ HORU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL ILLQG DXWRUHJUHVLY GH RUGLQXO vQWkL úL GH PHGLH PRELO GH

(S

RUGLQXOGRLQRW PFX $5,0$

= G = T = ) VDX $5,0$

( ) (FXD

LDXQXLDVWIHOGHPRGHO

HVWH \

W

=D

+D \

XQGH \

([HPSOH

+ \ -E X

= \

W -

- \

W -

-E X

W -

+X

W

3HQWUX H[HPSOXO FRQVLGHUDW YH]L WDEHOXO FODVD GH PRGHOH LQGLFDW HVWH FHD QHVWD LRQDU vQWUXFkW VHULD FURQRORJLF vQ IRUPD LQL LDO SUH]LQW WHQGLQ

ÌQWUXFkW WHQGLQ D D IRVW

HOLPLQDW GXS FDOFXOXO GLIHUHQ HORU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL LDU FDUDFWHULVWLFLOH VHULHL VWD LRQDUH DVWIHO

RE LQXWH VXQW FRQIRUPH vQGHRVHEL PRGHOXOXL PL[W DXWRFRUHOD LH UHODWLY PDUH SHQWUX N QHVHPQLILFDWLY SHQWUXN

LDUVF GHUHDVSUHQLYHOXO]HURDFRHILFLHQ LORU U úL F

GHYHQLQG

SHQWUXN

« HVWH WUHSWDW PRGHOXO D IRVW VSHFLILFDW GUHSW QHVWD LRQDU DXWRUHJUHVLY GH RUGLQXO XQX úL GH PHGLHPRELO GHRUGLQXOXQX'HFLPRGHOXO$5,0$ HVWHUHGDWH[SOLFLWDVWIHO \

W

=D

+D \

W -

+ \ -E X

W -

+X

W

&RQWLQX P H[HPSOLILF ULOH UHIHULQGXQH OD VHULL FHYD PDL OXQJL GH GDWH DúD FXP VXQW FHOH

SUH]HQWDWHvQ&DSLWROXO9,DSOLFD LDGLQSDUWHDILQDO DFDSLWROXOXL

$VWIHOSHQWUXVHULD9

DX IRVW RE LQXWH HVWLPD LLOH U

= U

= - U

F UH]XOW GLQVLVWHPXOGHHFXD LL

Å ¿

Ö SHQWUXFDUH D

D

D

¿ - D ®

Ö = D

+ D +

D

+ D

Ö = - D

- D + D +

=

D

= &RHILFLHQ LL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH SDU LDO

=

= - =

ÌQXUPDDSOLF ULLWHVWHORU%DUWOHWW4/%DUH]XOWDWF LSRWH]DQXO r

= HVWHFRQILUPDW

VHULD 9 ILLQGGHWLSDOHDWRUVWD LRQDU 'DF QHSURSXQHPV VSHFLILF PPRGHOXOSHQWUXRDVWIHOGH

154

VHULHFRQVWDW PF DWkW U FkWúL F

SHQWUXN

SUH]LQW YDORULQHVHPQLILFDWLYHDSURSLDWHGH

]HURQHvQFDGUkQGXVHvQWLSRORJLDPRGHOHORUVWRFKDVWLFH

U

ÌQFD]XOVHULHL= DXUH]XOWDW

= U

= U

= 9DORULOH OXL U VFDG OHQW FHHD FH VHPQDOHD] F VHULD HVWH

RPRJHQ QHVWD LRQDU DVSHFWUH]XOWDWúLvQXUPDDSOLF ULLWHVWHORU%DUWOHWW4/%

ÌQ XUPD GHWHUPLQ ULL GLIHUHQ HORU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL VD RE LQXW úLUXO Z

F

&RHILFLHQ LL U vQ DFHVW FD] VXQW U

= U

UH]XOW GLQXUP WRUXOVLVWHPGHHFXD LLYH]L

Å

D

¿

¿ ®

- D

- D +

D

D - D

= - U

+ D

- D +

D

= ]

- ] FX YDORULOH

= - &RHILFLHQ LL

= - =

= -

,QYROX LD FRHILFLHQ LORU U FRURERUDW FX ÄF GHUHD´ FRHILFLHQ LORU F

SHQWUX N VXJHUHD]

vQFHSULYHúWHVSHFLILFDUHDXQPRGHO$5 HYHQWXDO$50$

0HQ LRQ P F vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH HWDSD VSHFLILF ULL PRGHOXOXL VWRFKDVWLF QH VLWX P SH XQ

ÄWHUHQ QHVLJXU´ vQ FDUH DO WXUL GH FULWHULLOH PHQ LRQDWH XQ URO GHRVHELW vO DUH úL H[SHULHQ D HFRQRPHWULFLDQXOXL 6H UHFRPDQG RS LXQHD SHQWUX GRX WUHL YDULDQWH GH VSHFLILFDUH XUPkQG FD GXS SDUFXUJHUHD HWDSHORU GH HVWLPDUH úL YHULILFDUH V VH DSUHFLH]H FDUH GLQWUH YDULDQWH HVWH PDL LQGLFDW SHQWUXRE LQHUHDGHSURJQR]H

([SULPDUHD FHD PDL SUXGHQW D PRGHOXOXL VWRFKDVWLF DUH vQ YHGHUH YDULDQWD $50$ VDX

$5,0$ GDF H[LVW WUHQG vQ GDWH ÌQ DFHVW IHO HVWH HOLPLQDW ULVFXO ÄVFRDWHULL GLQ MRF´ SULQWUR QHLQVSLUDW GHILQLUH D PRGHOXOXL D DFHORU IDFWRUL FDUH VH PRGLILF LPSUHYL]LELO GHFODQúkQG HURUL GH SURJQR] SDUWHD0$ VDXDIDFWRULORULQHU LDOLVDXFDUHSURGXFDFXPXO ULSDUWHD$5

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORU

2E LQHUHD GH HVWLPD LL GH PD[LP YHURVLPLOLWDWH SHQWUX SDUDPHWULL ÄD´ úL ÄE´ GLQ PRGHOHOH

VWRFKDVWLFH DXWRUHJUHVLYH úL GH PHGLH PRELO LPSOLF PLQLPL]DUHD VXPHL S WUDWHORU HURULORU X ,SRWH]D UHSDUWL LHL QRUPDOH D HURULORU SHUWXUED LHL IDFH FD HVWLPD LLOH GH PD[LP YHURVLPLOLWDWH V ILHLGHQWLFHFXHVWLPD LLOHRE LQXWHSULQ0&003

ÌQWUXFkW VHFYHQ D 0$ D PRGHOXOXL $50$ LQGXFH QHOLQLDULWDWHD vQ UDSRUW FX SDUDPHWULL E

HVWH QHFHVDU XWLOL]DUHD XQXL DOJRULWP H[WUHP GH ODERULRV D F UXL GHVI úXUDUH vQFHUF P V R SUH]HQW P vQ FRQGL LL FkW PDL DSURSLDWH GH FHULQ HOH HODERU ULL XQXL SURJUDP SHQWUX SUHOXFUDUHD HOHFWURQLF DGDWHORU

3HQWUX vQFHSXW QH UHIHULP OD FD]XO PDL VLPSOX DO PRGHOXOXL DXWRUHJUHVLY $5 ÌQ YHGHUHD

£ ¢ ¡

HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU VH UHFRPDQG DSOLFDUHD 0&003$úDGDUXUPHD] V RE LQHPHVWLPDWRULL Ö D Ö D Ö D

SHQWUXFDUHH[SUHVLDXUP WRDUHHVWHPLQLP PLQ Ç > \ W

W

Ö - D

Ö \ + D

W -

Ö + + D

S

\

W -S

@

¥¦ ¤

$úD FXP DU WDP vQ &DSLWROXO 9,, DWXQFL FkQG DP DERUGDW SUREOHPD PRGHOHORU FX ODJ

¨© §

«¬ ª

GLVWULEXLW YH]L UHOD LD H[LVWHQ D GHSHQGHQ HL GLQWUH YDULDELOD \ H[LVWHQ D FROLQLDULW

LL vQWUH \

úL \

úL SHUWXUED LH FD úL

IDF FD HVWLPDWRULL V QX ILH HILFLHQ L úL QLFL VXILFLHQW GH

VWDELOL 3HQWUX D HYLWD DFHVWH HIHFWH QHGRULWH DSHO P OD PHWRGD YDULDELOHORU LQVWUXPHQWDOH VDX OD PHWRGH LWHUDWLYHvQWUHFDUHFHDGHVWLQDW UH]ROY ULLXQXLVLVWHPGHHFXD LLGHWLS<XOH±:DONHUHVWH IUHFYHQWUHFRPDQGDW >@

155

¯®

$VWIHOSHQWUXXQPRGHO$5 HFXD LLOH<XOH±:DONHUVHSUH]LQW DVWIHO

¯

U

U

([HPSOX

D

° ± ° ° ° =

- D

=D

+

D

- D

¨

ÌQ YHGHUHD H[HPSOLILF ULL SURFHGHXOXL GH HVWLPDUH SUH]HQW P XUP WRUXO úLU GH YDORUL \

¨

SHQWUXSHULRDGHVXFFHVLYH

\ =

\

U

µ

ÌQWUXFkW HVWLPDWRULL FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH VXQW U

= U

³

= U

´

=

= PRGHOXO D IRVW VSHFLILFDW FD ILLQG GH WLS $5 (VWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU UH]XOW GLQ

UHOD LLOH úL DVWIHO Å

Ö SHQWUXFDUH D

²

¸

¿ ¿

=

¿ ¿ ®

Ö = D

¹

= D

¶

D

·¶

- D +

D

·¶ ¶

- D

= - LDUSDUDPHWUXO D

º

SRDWHILFRUHFWDSUR[LPDWGH \

=

ÌQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH PRGHOXO VWRFKDVWLF LQFOXGH úL HOHPHQWH GH PHGLH PRELO ILLQG GH WLS

$50$ $5,0$ VDX 0$ XWLOL]DUHD PHWRGHL FHORU PDL PLFL S WUDWH vQ YDULDQWD RELúQXLW QX HVWH UHFRPDQGDW vQWUXFkW PRGHOXOHVWHvQJHQHUDOQHOLQLDUGLQSHUVSHFWLYDSDUDPHWULORUDVSHFWHYLGHQWGDF DYHPvQ YHGHUHUHOD LD X

»

=

D % E %

¿¾ ¼ ¿¾ ½ ¿¾ ¼

»

\

HFXD LD PRGHOXOXL SUHVXSXQH vQ YHGHUHD RE LQHULL GH HVWLPD LLFXQRDúWHUHDXQRUYDORULGLQ WUHFXW \

\

X

SHQWUX FDUH QX GLVSXQHP GH GDWH &D XUPDUH VXQW QHFHVDUH LQL LDOL] UL úL

PHWRGHLWHUDWLYH

Â Á À

(VWLPDUHD vQ SULQFLSLX VH ED]HD] SH LSRWH]D FRQIRUP F UHLD YDULDELOD UH]LGXDO XUPHD] R UHSDUWL LH QRUPDO FX YDORUL X X X

Å Ä Å Ã

SDUDPHWULORU D D

E E

LQGHSHQGHQWH (VWLPDUHD GH PD[LP YHURVLPLOLWDWH D

SUHVXSXQHPLQLPL]DUHDVXPHL

= PLQ Ç >X DE\ @

PLQ Ç X W

W

'LQWUH PHWRGHOH GH HVWLPDUH UHFRPDQGDWH SHQWUX PRGHOHOH QHOLQLDUH vQ UDSRUW FX SDUDPHWULL LQWHUHVHD] SURFHGHXO DGHFYDW VLWXD LHL vQ FDUH XQHOH YDORUL GLQ WUHFXW QHFXQRVFXWH DSDU vQ IRUPXOD UH]XOWDW vQXUPDVSHFLILF ULL ÌQ FHOH FH XUPHD] QH YRP UHIHUL OD XQ SURFHGHX GH HVWLPDUH UHFRPDQGDW SHQWUX PRGHOXO

Å Ä Å Ã

$50$ vQWUXFkW DFHVW WLS GH PRGHO UHSUH]LQW IRUPD JHQHUDO D PRGHOHORU VWRFKDVWLFH 3HQWUX D VH DMXQJH vQ FD]XO XQXL DVWIHO GH PRGHO OD HVWLPDWRUL DL SDUDPHWULORU D D

vQGHSOLQHDVF FRQGL LD PLQ Ç X W

E E

FDUH V

VH UHFRPDQG XWLOL]DUHD XQXL SURFHGHX LWHUDWLY >@ ÌQ SULQFLSLX

W

XQDVWIHOGHSURFHGHXSUHVXSXQH

À

LQL LDOL]DUHDSDUDPHWULORUFXYDORULED]DWHSHFRHILFLHQ LL U

Æ

0RGXOvQFDUHVDDMXQVODDFHVWHUHOD LLHVWHDU WDWvQSDUDJUDIXODQWHULRUYH]LUHOD LLOH

156

GH]YROWDUHD H[SUHVLHL FRQFHQWUDWH D PRGHOXOXL X

=

D % E %

\ vQ VHULH 7D\ORU vQ MXUXO

LQL LDOL] ULORU VWDELOLWH SHQWUX SDUDPHWULL úL UH LQHUHD SULPLORU GRL WHUPHQL GLQWUR DVWIHO GH GH]YROWDUHFHHDFHSHUPLWHRE LQHUHDGHHFXD LLOLQLDUH

RE LQHUHD

GH

HVWLPD LL

DOH

SDUDPHWULORU

HFXD LLORU

0&003

OLQLDUH

IRORVLQG

vQ

DFHVW

VFRS

À

FRPSDUD LL DOH HVWLPD LLORU DVWIHO RE LQXWH FX FHOH UH]XOWDWH GLQ LWHUD LD DQWHULRDU SHQWUX vQFHSXW DYHP vQ YHGHUH LQL LDOL] ULOH ED]DWH SH FRHILFLHQ LL U vQ VFRSXO DSUHFLHULL UHDOL] ULL FRQYHUJHQ HL

GDF FRQYHUJHQ D HVWH FRQVWDWDW XOWLPHOH HVWLPD LL VXQW FHOH YDODELOH LDU GDF HVWLPD LLOH QX FRQYHUJ VH vQORFXLHVF VROX LLOH LWHUD LHL SUHFHGHQWH FX FHOH RE LQXWH vQ XOWLPD LWHUD LH úL VH UHLD SURFHVXOGHODFHDGHDGRXDHWDS GH]YROWDUHvQVHULH7D\ORUDSOLFDUHD0&003HWF

3HQWUX D UHGD PDL GHWDOLDW HWDSHOH GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD SURJUDP ULL DFHVWRUD DYHP vQ YHGHUH

PRGHOXO $5,0$ )RUPXOHOH±FKHLH SULYLQG DOWH PRGHOH IUHFYHQW vQWkOQLWH $50$ $50$ YRUFRPSOHWDGHPHUVXO

&DOFXOHSUHOLPLQDULL

SHQWUXVHULLQHVWD LRQDUHSURFHG PODHOLPLQDUHDWHQGLQ HL

SHQWUXVLPSOLILFDUHDFDOFXOHORUHOLPLQ PPHGLDGLQGDWH

6 H[HPSOLILF PDFHDVW HWDS UHOXkQGGDWHOHGLQWDEHOXO 7DEHO

9DORULRULJLQDOH ( \

W

9DORULVWD LRQDUH ( \Ö

)

É É É ÉÈ Ç Ê )

\Ö

= \

- \

9DORULVWD LRQDUHPLQXVPHGLD (\Ö

)

- \

\ =

([SULP PPRGHOXOvQIRUPDFRQFHQWUDW VHUYLQGXQHGHRSHUDWRUXOGHWUDQVODWDUHvQWUHFXW %

Ì ÌÍ Ë ÌÍ Ë Ì

$VWIHO PRGHOXO $5,0$ FDUH GXS VWD LRQDUL]DUH GHYLQH $50$ HVWH H[SULPDW

GXS HOLPLQDUHD PHGLHL GH UHOD LD GHYLQH

\

\ 'HXQGH X

W

Î

= D % \

=

W

- D % - E %

= D\

- E % X

\

Î

W

- E\

+X

W

+ X ,QWURGXFkQG RSHUDWRUXO Ä%´ PRGHOXO

\

\

)RUPHFRQFHQWUDWHSHQWUXDOWHWLSXULGHPRGHOH

Ð Ð Ï Ó Ó Ò Ö ÖÖ Ö Õ

IRUPDFRQFHQWUDW SHQWUX$50$

Ï

X

Ò

=

- D %

Ô

- D % - D %

Õ

=

×

- E %

SHQWUX$50$ X

Ñ

- E % - E %

SHQWUX$50$

X

=

×

- D % - D %

- E % - E %

\

157

,QL LDOL] P SDUDPHWULL SH ED]D HVWLPD LLORU FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH U $VWIHO vQ

Û ÙÚ Ø à Þß

FD]XOPRGHOXOXL$50$ D

E

ÜÝ

= U

=

Ü

-

- U U

ãâ ã

ÌQWUDGHY U GDF DYHP vQ YHGHUH UHOD LLOH úL DWXQFL vQWUXFkW SHQWUX $5

á á ä äå ä ä

U

0$ ()

= D LDU SHQWUX SDUWHD

U E

+ U

+E

ã

U

æ

=

-E

$FHVW GLQ XUP UDSRUW FRQGXFH OD HFXD LD

+ E

= vQFDUHSDUDPHWUXOE HVWHQHFXQRVFXW

ç

0HQ LRQ P F vQ YHGHUHD LQL LDOL] ULORU SXWHP DYHD vQ YHGHUH OD IHO GH ELQH úL FRHILFLHQ LL

GHDXWRFRUHOD LHSDU LDO F

éè

ëê

ì

îí ï

$WULEXLP GH DVHPHQHD YDORDUHD ]HUR DFHORU QLYHOH DOH YDULDELOHL FDUH VXQW ÄvQ DIDUD FDGUXOXL´ \

= \

= X

= X

=

í

= - UHVSHFWLY GXS HOLPLQDUHD PHGLHL YDORULOH

ÌQ H[HPSOXO FRQVLGHUDW vQWUXFkW U

H[SXVH vQ WDEHOXO UkQGXO YRU FRQGXFH OD RE LQHUHD DFHOXLDúL FRHILFLHQW U

ò ðñ

XUPDUHLQL LDOL]DUHDSUHVXSXQH D

ó

= -

ôõö

=

E

» - ª ª ½

- [ ¢

(-

± ²

)]

Å = ² ® Õ

¢ -

'LQWUHFHOHGRX YDORULRE LQXWHSHQWUX E

'H]YROW P vQ VHULH 7D\ORU H[SUHVLD X

ÿ

DOHJHP E

ú þ =

= - &D

- D % - E %

÷øù

ú

=

\ vQ MXUXO LQL LDOL] ULORU D

ý ûü ý ûü E

úL

UH LQHPGRDUSULPLLGRLWHUPHQLGLQvQWUHDJDGH]YROWDUH 'HFL

X

= X

ÿ

+

Ç

- $

$

¢

X

$

+

XQGH

$

$

»D± YHFWRUXOSDUDPHWULORUQHFXQRVFX L ª ² ª ² ½E Õ

'HULYDWDSDU LDO vQUDSRUWFXÄD´HVWHHJDO FX

[ = ÌQWUXFkW -

X D

ë

=

(% )\ W

ë

[ - D (% )] [ - E (% )] - [ - D (% )] [ - E (% )]

= -\

»D ± YHFWRUXOLQL LDOL] ULORUSULYLQGSDUDPHWULL ª ² ª ² ½E Õ

[ - E (% )]

W -

\

=

-

(% )

- E (%

)

\

- E % [ = -E[ 5H]XOW XUP WRDUHDHFXD LHOLQLDU

6HULD7D\ORUDIXQF LHLIvQSXQFWXOÄD´HVWHUHSUH]HQWDW GHH[SUHVLD

I +

[ - D

I ë +

[ - D

I ë ë + +

[ - D Q

I

+

158

= E[

- \

'HULYDWDSDU LDO vQUDSRUWFXE ] =

[

= E]

]

X

E

FRQGXFHODFHDGHDGRXDHFXD LH

- \

]

+ D\

(FXD LD SRDWHILUHGDW DVWIHO X

-E

=X

W

+ D - D

[

W

+ E - E

]

W

,]ROkQGQHFXQRVFXWHOHDúLEvQGUHDSWDVHPQXOXLHJDOLW

-X

+ D

[

+E

W

]

W

= D[

+ E]

W

W

-X

LLRE LQHP W

XUPkQG FD vQ HWDSD XUP WRDUH V FDOFXO P [ ! ] ! SH ED]D YDORULORU YDULDELOHL \ " vQ YDULDQWD VWD LRQDUL]DW DYkQGPHGLDHOLPLQDW úLDLQL LDOL] ULORUPHQ LRQDWHvQHWDSDDWUHLD

0HQ LRQ P HFXD LLOH OLQLDUH RE LQXWH vQWUXQ PRG VLPLODU SURFHGHXOXL GHVFULV SHQWUX

$50$ SHQWUXPRGHOHOH

$50$ [&

] ( , ]

. 2

= \ & % $

+ E$ [ & % $

+ E# [ & % #

= -\ , + (

+ D\ , + )

= -\

+ D\

2 1 .

+ E ( ] , + (

+ E ) ] , + )

-E

2 1 / + E 0 ] . 2 1 0 + E . ] . 2 1 .

-E

) .

- E ( E ) ] ( , + *

] ( , + ) ]

- E 0 E . ]

. 2 1 .

- E)

.

)

] ( , + '

. 2 1 / - E . ] . 2 1 -

$50$ [ $ &

= E$ [ $ & % $

[ 3 6

= E4 [ 3 6 5 3 = E 9 ] ; : 9

] ;

- \ & % #

+ \ 6 5 3 -E

8

- \ ; : 9

] ; : 8

+ D9 \ ; : 8

+ D8 \ ; : 7

&DOFXO P YDORULOH [ " ] " OXkQG vQ FRQVLGHUDUH LQL LDOL] ULOH úL YDORULOH YDULDELOHL \ " GLQ WDEHOXO±UkQGXO 5HOD LLOH úL VXQWFHOHFDUHQHVWDXvQDWHQ LH

=

[<

[ >

= E[ =

[ A

= E[ A B @

]

=

] C

- \ > ? =

= E] C E D

= ¢ - = -

- \ A B @

-E

C

= ¢ - - - =

- \ C E D

] C E C

+ D\ C E C

= ¢ ¢ -

C

¢ - + - ¢ = -

M 'HDVHPHQHDVHSURFHGHD] ODFDOFXOXOYDORULORU X X

W

= \

W

- D\

W -

- EX

W -

W

'HFL X X

J I H

XG

= = \ = \

G

- D - D

J I H

\ \

-

-E

G K F -E

J I H

X

X

-

G K F

M

ÌQH[HPSOXOFRQVLGHUDW

XP XO

N M L N M L

= = - - - ¢ - ¢ = -

159

ÌQ ILQDO VWDELOLP QLYHOXO YDORULORU GLQ VWkQJD HJDOLW

RSHUD LXQLGHvQVXPDUHSHQWUXW *Q

= -X

TS

LL UHOD LHL vQ XUPD XQRU

«$úDGDUSHQWUXPRPHQWXOWRE LQHP

R +D

T S

R [Q + E

TS

R ] Q

ÌQWUXFkW vQ XUPD FHOHL GHD FLQFHD HWDSH DP DMXQV OD XQ PRGHO OLQLDU GH UHJUHVLH FODVLF

SHQWUX FDUH vQ FD]XO $50$ DP GHWHUPLQDW YDORUL SULYLQG ÄIDFWRULL´ [ úL ] úL ÄHIHFWXO´ * XUPHD] V DSOLF P 0&003 vQ IRUPD RELúQXLW RE LQkQG HVWLPDWRULL SH FDUH vL VLPEROL] P FX D

WVU

E

WVU

6 SUHVXSXQHPF DPRE LQXW D

WVU

= E

WVU

= -

&RPSDU P HVWLPD LLOH RE LQXWH vQ FHD GHD úDVHD HWDS FX HVWLPD LLOH DQWHULRDUH RE LQXWH SULQ 0&003 VDX LQL LDOL]DWH ÌQ FD]XO QRVWUX FRPSDU P P ULPLOH D D

WX U

E

W X U

WVU

E

WVU

FX LQL LDOL] ULOH

'DF FRQVWDW P F P ULPLOH QX FRQYHUJ VSUH QLYHOH VWDELOH vQORFXLP HVWLPD LLOH

DQWHULRDUH FX XOWLPHOH HVWLPD LL RE LQXWH úL UHOX P SURFHVXO LWHUDWLY vQFHSkQG FX FHD GHD FLQFHD HWDS $úDGDU DWULEXLP SDUDPHWULORU D úL E FHOH PDL UHFHQWH HVWLPD LL UH]XOWDWH GLQ DSOLFDUHD 0&003 vQ FD]XO QRVWUX D

úL E

úL UHYHQLP OD FHD GHD FLQFHD HWDS SURFHGkQG OD

TY FDOFXOXOYDORULORU [ Q ] Q X Q R SHED]DDFHVWRUQLYHOHDOHSDUDPHWULORU$SRLvQFHDGHDúDVHDHWDS VH WZ U WZ U DSOLF 0&003 úL VH RE LQH DOW VHW GH HVWLPD LL D

GDW vQWUH D

WZ U

E

WZ U

úL D

WVU

E

WVU

E

(YLGHQW FRPSDUD LD VH UHLD GH DVW

6 SUHVXSXQHP F GXS FkWHYD DVWIHO GH LWHUD LL FRQYHUJHQ D

HVWLPD LLORUVDUHDOL]DWSHQWUXYDORULOH D

\] [

= úL E

_` ^

= - ÌQDFHVWFD]DFHVWHGLQXUP QLYHOH

VXQWFRQVLGHUDWHHVWLPD LLOHF XWDWH 3HQWUX SURFHVHOH $50$ vQ FDUH

S Ê úL T Ê PHWRGD SUH]HQWDW HVWH FX GHRVHELUHD

LQGLFDW 3HQWUXSURFHVHGHRUGLQPDLPDUHGLQIHULFLUHPDLUDUvQWkOQLWHvQDSOLFD LLPHWRGDHVWHQX QXPDL ODERULRDV GDU vQ PRG IUHFYHQW FRQYHUJHQ D VH UHDOL]HD] JUHX FHHD FH IDFH GHVHRUL QHFHVDU UHHYDOXDUHDLQL LDOL] ULORUGLQHWDSDDWUHLD'DF GXS PDLPXOWHvQFHUF ULFRQYHUJHQ DQX DUHORFHVWHLQGLFDWV VHvQFHUFHRQRX VSHFLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXL$FHDVWDVHvQWkPSO FKLDUúLSHQWUX PRGHOH PL[WH GH RUGLQ S Ê T Ê vQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH LQL LDOL] ULOH QX DX IRVW FHOH PDL SRWULYLWH VDX vQ VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH VSHFLILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL D IRVW GLILFLO GDWRULW DPELJXLW

LL HYROX LHL

FRHILFLHQ LORUGHDXWRFRUHOD LH

9HULILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLVWRFKDVWLF 3DUFXUJHUHD HWDSHORU GHVWLQDWH VSHFLILF ULL PRGHOXOXL úL HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU VFRDWH vQ HYLGHQ

vQ DIDUD YROXPXOXL PDUH GH FDOFXOH SH FDUH vO SUHVXSXQ WHKQLFLOH %R[ ± -HQNLQV

FRPSDUDWLYFXDOWHPHWRGHYH]L&DSLWROHOH9,úL9,, úLUROXOUHODWLYPDUHSHFDUHvOGH LQH[SHULHQ D úLLQVSLUD LDHFRQRPHWULFLDQXOXL$FHDVWDDSDUHPDLSUHJQDQWvQHWDSDGHVSHFLILFDUHGDUGDF DYHP vQYHGHUHSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDDOHJHvQWUHPHWRGHOHGHHVWLPDUHFD]XOPRGHOHORU$5 FDúLSRVLELOLWDWHD GH D PRGLILFD LQL LDOL] ULOH SDUDPHWULORU UH]XOW F LQWXL LD H[SHULHQ D DX XQ URO GHRVHELW vQ HWDSD HVWLP ULL &D XUPDUH YHULILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL VH UHIHU QX DWkW OD WHVWDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL VDX QX QXPDL OD DFHDVWDFLúLODFDOLWDWHDPRGHOXOXLGHDUHSURGXFHFDUDFWHUXOLQHU LDOúLGHDVLPLODUHDúRFXULORUFDUH DSDU vQ HYROX LD IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH vQ WLPS $FHVWHL HWDSH vL UHYLQH GHFL XQ URO GH ÄFRQWURO GH FDOLWDWH´ELQHGHWHUPLQDWvQvQWUHJXOGHPHUVGHSUHJ WLUHúLHODERUDUHDSUHYL]LXQLORU 9HULILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL vQDLQWH GH XWLOL]DUHD VD SHQWUX HODERUDUHD GH SURJQR]H SUHVXSXQH DQDOL]D FRUHORJUDPHL YDORULORU FRHILFLHQ LORU GH DXWRFRUHOD LH

Ua HODERUDW SHQWUX YDORULOH

Öb \

JHQHUDWH SULQ PRGHOXO DGRSWDW YDORUL VWD LRQDUH RE LQXWH GLQ PRGHO 'DF vQWUH FRUHORJUDPD LQL LDO XWLOL]DW vQ HWDSD GH VSHFLILFDUH SULYLQG YDORULOH HPSLULFH VWD LRQDUH \ b úL FRUHORJUDPD

160

Ö b JHQHUDWHGHPRGHOH[LVW RDVHP QDUHHYLGHQW FRHILFLHQ LORUGHDXWRFRUHOD LHED]DW SHYDORULOH \ DVWIHO vQFkW DQDOL]D XOWLPHL FRUHORJUDPH DU FRQGXFH OD DFHHDúL VSHFLILFDUH D PRGHOXOXL FRQVLGHU P F PRGHOXO HVWH YDOLG ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH FRUHORJUDPHOH GLIHU IRDUWH PXOW VH UHDOL]HD] UHYL]XLUHD LQL LDOL] ULORU DWULEXLWH SDUDPHWULORU 'DF PRGLILFDUHD LQL LDOL] ULORU QX DUH HIHFWHOH VFRQWDWH VH SURFHGHD] OD UHVSHFLILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL vQ VHQVXO F VH PRGLILF RUGLQXO PRGHOXOXL ILH SHQWUX VHFYHQ D VD DXWRUHJUHVLY ILH SHQWUX FHD GH PHGLH PRELO ILH SHQWUX DPEHOH 1X SRDWH IL H[FOXV QLFL PRGLILFDUHD WLSXOXL GH PRGHO vQ ORF GH D XWLOL]D XQ PRGHO 0$T V DYHP vQ YHGHUH XQ PRGHO $50$VDXPDLUDUXQPRGHO$5T ([HPSOX 3HQWUX GDWHOH SUH]HQWDWH vQ WDEHOXO DP RSWDW SHQWUX XQ PRGHO $5,0$ 9DORULOH JHQHUDWHGHPRGHOvQYDULDQWDVWD LRQDUL]DW vQFDUHLQFOXGHPvQV úLPHGLDUH]XOW DVWIHO Öb \

Ö\ b c = D

+ \

XQGH Ö = D

Ö E = -

Ö b FD úL UH]XOWDWHOH FRPSDUD LHL GLQWUH \ Ö b úL QLYHOHOH HPSLULFH \ b 2E LQHUHD YDORULORU OXL \ WDEHOXOUkQGXO VXQWSUH]HQWDWHvQFHOHFHXUPHD]

Öd \

= ¢ + - ¢ + =

Öe \

Öf \

= ¢ + - ¢ - + =

Ö \

Öh \

= ¢ + - ¢ + =

\Ö

Öi \

= ¢ + - ¢ + =

\Ö

6HULD RULJLQDO \

$úDGDU vQWUXFkW \Ö W

= \

W

- \

g

- \

- \

= - = - = - =

g

= - =

= - =

UH]XOW XUPkQG XQ SURFHV LQYHUV FHOXL RE LQHULL GH YDORUL VWD LRQDUL]DWH

- \

W

- \e

W -

YH]L WDEHOXO UH]XOW F \

W

= \

W -

+ \Ö

W

6H RE LQ DVWIHO

XUP WRDUHOHYDORUL

\ \ \

\

= + =

= + = = + =

= + =

3HQWUXYDORULOHOXL \

W

DVWIHORE LQXWHVHFDOFXOHD] FRHILFLHQ LLGHDXWRFRUHOD LH Uj N

LDU UHSUH]HQWDUHD JUDILF D DFHVWRUD VH FRPSDU FX FHD D FRHILFLHQ LORU Uj FDOFXOD L SHQWUX GDWHOHHPSLULFHGLQWDEHOXO±UkQGXO'DF DVHP QDUHDJUDILFHORUHVWHHYLGHQW DVWIHOvQFkWúL SH ED]D YDORULORU OXL

\

W

DMXQJHP OD DFHHDúL FRQFOX]LH SULYLQG WLSXO úL RUGLQXO PRGHOXOXL

$50$ PRGHOXOHVWHYDOLG

kml

2 DOW PRGDOLWDWH GH YHULILFDUH DUH vQ YHGHUH DQDOL]D ÄUHVWXULORU´ DGLF DQDOL]D YDULDELOHL

UH]LGXDOH ÌQ FD]XO XQXL PRGHO SHUIRUPDQW ELQH VSHFLILFDW FRUHFW HVWLPDW YDORULOH YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOHVXQWDOHDWRDUHúLQHFRUHODWHDVWIHOvQFkWFRHILFLHQ LLGHDXWRFRUHOD LHFDOFXOD LSHQWUXDVWIHO GHYDORULVXQWQHVHPQLILFDWLYL7HVWXOGH]YROWDWGH/MXQJúL%R[DUHvQYHGHUHYDORDUHDFDOFXODW 4 FDUHVHRE LQHDVWIHO

q r 4 = Q ¢ Q + ¢ Ç p

o

Q - N

¢UÖp

n

XQGH UÖ

N

DXWRFRUHOD LDUH]LGXXULORUGHODJN

st

5HDPLQWLP IDSWXO F vQ PRGHOXO 0$ VDX $50$ VHPQXO PLQXV GLQ ID D SDUDPHWUXOXL E HVWH SXU VLPEROLF ÌQ FDOFXOH

DYHPvQYHGHUHUH]XOWDWHOHHVWLP ULLÌQH[HPSOXOFRQVLGHUDW \Ö w

=

\

w v u

- X

w v u

+

161

'HWHUPLQDUHD QLYHOXOXL OXL 4 SHUPLWH YHULILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL FRQVLGHUkQGXVH F SHQWUX XQ x

PRGHOVWRFKDVWLFFRUHFWVSHFLILFDWLQGLFDWRUXO4FDOFXODWXUPHD] RUHSDUWL LH

FXNSTJUDGHGH

OLEHUWDWH&DXUPDUHDFFHSW PPRGHOXOGDF

y

4

| } {

} z

ÌQ DFHODúL VFRS SRDWH IL XWLOL]DW GH DVHPHQHD WHVWXO %DUWOHWW FD] vQ FDUH PRGHOXO HVWH FRQILUPDW GDF FRHILFLHQ LL UÖ

N

FDOFXOD L SH ED]D YDORULORU HVWLPDWH DOH YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH XÖ

W

VH

VLWXHD] vQLQWHUYDOXO

-

Q

Ö~ Ê U

Ê

a =

Q

ÌQVLWXD LLOHvQFDUHVHSXQHSUREOHPDRS LXQLLvQWUHGRX YDULDQWHDOHPRGHOXOXLVWRFKDVWLFVH

UHFRPDQG XQLQGLFDWRU±VHPQDOVLPEROL]DW506Ä5RRW0HDQ6TXDUHV´ úLGHILQLWDVWIHO

506 =

Q

Ö » \ ª Ç ª ½

- \ \

± ² ² Õ

$OHJHPDFHDYDULDQW GHPRGHOVWRFKDVWLFSHQWUXFDUHLQGLFDWRUXO506SUH]LQW YDORDUHDFHD

PDLDSURSLDW GH]HUR

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORU±HWDSDGHWHUPLQDQW DWkWSHQWUXPRGHOHOHHFRQRPHWULFHFODVLFHFkWúL

SHQWUX DQDOL]D VHULLORU FURQRORJLFH ± UHSUH]LQW ÄR SUREOHP ´ úL vQ FD]XO PRGHOHORU VWRFKDVWLFH GH SURJQR] 'H PRGDOLWDWHD vQ FDUH HD HVWH UH]ROYDW GHSLQGH QX QXPDL FDOLWDWHD SURJQR]HL GDU úL UDSRUWXULOHFDUHSRWILVWDELOLWHvQWUHHYROX LDSUH]HQW úLYLLWRDUHúLHYROX LLOHGLQWUHFXW

(ODERUDUHDSURJQR]HORU

3ULQPRGHOHOHGHWLS$50$$50$$5,0$VHXUP UHúWHRE LQHUHDGHSUHYL]LXQLFkWPDL

SUHFLVH FHHD FH vQ WHUPHQLL VWDWLVWLFLL vQVHDPQ F vQ XUPD FRPSDU ULL YDORULORU SURJQR]DWH \Ö

W

FXYDORULOHUHDOH \ HURDUHDPHGLHS WUDWLF HVWHPLQLP

- \Ö

PLQ 0 > \

@

9DORDUHD SUHYL]LRQDW WUHEXLH FRQVLGHUDW PDL FXUkQG R VSHUDQ

PDWHPDWLF D QLYHOXOXL

YLLWRU DO OXL \ GHFkW R P ULPH FHUW FDUH VDU RE LQH vQ FRQGL LL QRUPDOH vQ YLLWRU 7RWRGDW XQ QLYHO SUHYL]LRQDW \Ö

Q +Y

UHSUH]LQW R P ULPH FRQGL LRQDW GH YDORULOH HPSLULFH RE LQXWH SHQWUX

SHULRDGHOHFDUHSUHFHGLQWHUYDOXOGHSURJQR] \Ö

Q +Y

= 0 >\

Q +Y

\

Q

\

Q -

\

\

@

&RUHVSXQ] WRU UHOD LHL UH]XOW F SURJQR]D VH RE LQH ÄSDV FX SDV´ ILHFDUH QLYHO

SUHYL]LRQDW SUHVXSXQkQG FDOFXOH SUHDODELOHFDUHLQFOXGSURJQR]DSURJQR]HOHGLQWUHFXW$VWIHOGDF VHULD FURQRORJLF SUH]LQW YDORUL SHQWUX W

« Q DWXQFL SUHYL]LXQHD SHQWUX SHULRDGD Q

UH]XOW DVWIHO \Ö

= 0 >\

\

\

\

\

Ö \ @ = D

Ö + D

\

Ö - E X

Ö - E X

Ö + D

M \Ö

Q +Y

Ö \Ö =D

Q +Y -

Ö + + D

Q

\

Q

Ö + + D

S

\

Q - S +

Ö - - E X

Q

Ö - - E X T

ÌQ UHOD LD QLYHOXO SHUWXUED LHL X VH GHWHUPLQ vQ SUHDODELO SH ED]D UHOD LHL

ILLQGGHIDSWUH]XOWDWXOGLIHUHQ HORU \

Ö - \

Ö + D

Q -T +Y

ÌQ JHQHUDO XQ SURFHV $50$S T \

SURJQR]H \Ö

Q +Y

=

D Ç

\

-

E Ç

X

(E

= ) FRQGXFH OD

GH HURDUH S WUDWLF PLQLP $VWIHO VLWXkQGXQH vQ PRPHQWXO Q UH]XOW F SHQWUX

PRPHQWXOYLLWRUQYRE LQHP

162

¤ \Ö £ ¢

=

¡

Ö¡

D Ç ¦

-

¡ \ £ ¢

¡

¡ ¥ EÖ X £ ¢ Ç

(E ¡

= )

5HFRPDQG UL GHH[HPSOX \Ö

SHQWUXYDORULOHQHFXQRVFXWH \ © « ¨ ª §

³ ¯ ± SHQWUX \ « ¬ XWLOL] PYDORULOHSURJQR]DWH \Ö ´ °²

Q +

SHQWUXDRE LQHYDORDUHDSURJQR]DW

¯ ®

YDORULOHYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH X µ W Ê Q XWLOL]DWHSHQWUXDRE LQHSURJQR]HVXQWFHOHDMXVWDWH X¶

= \¶

Ö ¶ GDUSHQWUX W > Q X º ¹ ¸ X º ¹ · VHFRQVLGHU F DFHVWHDVXQWHJDOHFX]HURILLQGWUDWDWH - \

FDUH]XOWkQGGLQWUXQSURFHVGH]JRPRWDOE ÌQ FD]XO VHULLORU QHVWD LRQDUH HVWH QHFHVDU FD SUHYL]LXQLOH ILQDOH V LQFOXG úL FRPSRQHQWD WHQGLQ

&D XUPDUH HVWH QHFHVDU V VH SURFHGH]H RUL GH FkWH RUL WHQGLQ D D IRVW HOLPLQDW SULQ

FDOFXOXOGLIHUHQ HORUGHGLIHULWHRUGLQHODHIHFWXDUHDXQXLFDOFXOLQYHUVFHOXLFDUHDGXVODHOLPLQDUHD WUHQGXOXL 'HFL R vQVXPDUH D ILHF UXL UH]XOWDW RE LQXW FD R SURJQR] ÄVWD LRQDUL]DW ´ FX QLYHOXO DQWHULRURE LQXWvQFRQGL LLOHPHQ LQHULLWHQGLQ HL &RQFUHWvQFD]XOvQFDUHPRGHOXOHVWHGHWLS$5,0$ SURJQR]DQLYHOXOXLVWD LRQDUL]DW SHQWUXSHULRDGDQUH]XOW DVWIHO

\Ö

Ö \ =D

Q +

Ö -E X

Q

Ö + D

Q

XQGH

Ö Ö ¼ E¼ D Ö» D - D %

=

X½

HVWLPD LLDOHSDUDPHWULORU = \ ½

\ ½

- E %

¾

Ö \ ½ ¿ -D

¾

¾

Ö +E X ½ ¿

¾

= \ ½

- \Ö ½

3HQWUXSHULRDGDQSURJQR]DVWD LRQDUL]DW UH]XOW DVWIHO \Ö vQWUXFkW \Ö

Q +

Ö \Ö =D

Q +

Ö \ =D

Q

Ö + D

Q +

Ö -E X

Ö + D

Q

5H]XOW F \Ö

Ö =D

Q +

\

Q

Ö EÖ X -D

Q

Ö +D

Ö + D

3HQWUXQSURJQR]DHVWH \Ö

Ö \Ö =D

Q +

Ö + D

Q +

6HULD ILLQG QHVWD LRQDU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL G IDSW R GLIHUHQ

GH WLS \

W

- \

W -

= G\

SUHVXSXQH vQVXPDUHD GLIHUHQ HL G\

W

W

UH]XOW F ILHFDUH QLYHO RE LQXW FRQVWLWXLH GH

5H]XOW F RE LQHUHD YDORULL \

FX QLYHOXO DQWHULRU \

W -

W

FDUH V LQFOXG WHQGLQ D

3HQWUX SUHYL]LXQLOH FDUH HYLGHQW

GHS úHVF SHULRDGD Q HVWH QHFHVDU QLYHOXO HPSLULF FDUH LQFOXGH WUHQGXO \

Q

DVWIHO vQFkW DG XJkQG

DFHVWXLDYDORULOHVWD LRQDUL]DWHDOHSURJQR]HLV SXWHPRE LQHSUHYL]LXQLFDUHLQFOXGWHQGLQ D

ÀÁÀ

([HPSOH 3HQWUX GDWHOH SUH]HQWDWH vQ WDEHOXO H[HPSOLILF P PRGDOLWDWHD GH HODERUDUH D SURJQR]HORU ÌQ DFHVW FD] PRGHOXO $5,0$ D IRVW FRQILUPDW FD YDOLG vQ XUPD HWDSHL GH Ö Ö = E = - &RQVLGHU PGHDVHPHQHD X Â YHULILFDUH 5HDPLQWLP F D

\Ä

= Q = D Ã

=

= vQWUXFkWLQFOXGHPHGLD 3UHYL]LXQLOHSHQWUXXUP WRDUHOHSHULRDGHUH]XOW DVWIHO

ÅÆÅ

ÌQ

\Ö Í Ð Ë

FH

SULYHúWH

Ë Î É

Q + Ç b Ì Ì Ï É

LQWHUYDOXO

GH

SURJQR]

DYHP

vQ

YHGHUH

OLPLWHOH

VWDELOLWH

SH

ED]D

UHOD LHL

Ç

É È Ç

¢ VÊ

Ç

vQFDUH

V

X

ÇXW =

W

Q - S -T

bÑ

SRQGHULUHSUH]HQWDWHGHSDUDPHWULLHVWLPD LSHQWUX

YDULDQWDWUDQVIRUPDW DPRGHOXOXL$50$vQPRGHO0$GHRUGLQLQILQLWYH]LSDUDJUDIXOFDUHVHUHIHU ODUHGXFWLELOLWDWHD SURFHVXOXL$5ODXQSURFHV0$

163

SHQWUX W = Q + =

\Ö

Q +

Ö =D

Ö\ +D

Q

Ö - EX

Q

= + ¢ - ¢ =

Ü \Ö ÒÆÓ

,QFOXGHP WHQGLQ D vQVXPkQG DQWHULRDUHL YDORUL \ SURJQR]DRE LQXW

×

\ ÔÖÕ SHQWUXW

Q

= YH]L WDEHOXO UkQGXO

DYHPvQYHGHUHIDSWXOF Y!SY!TvQVHQVXOF ÄY´DGHYHQLW =

LDURUGLQXOOXLSúLTHVWH&DXUPDUH X Ý ÚÜÛ Ù Ø 5H]XOW F \Ö ã â á

= \Ö Þàß

ÖÞ =D

¢ \Ö ã â Þ

= ¢ =

ä

,QFOXGHP WHQGLQ D vQVXPkQG DQWHULRDUHL YDORUL \ åÆæ

( \Ö Þàß

ç è é = ) vQYHGHUHDRE LQHULLSURJQR]HL (\ à ×

\ Ôëê \Ö ã â ß

= \Ö ÞÆì

í

= ¢ =

= + =

\ îÆï

Ö Þ \Ö ã â á =D

)

= XOWLPXO UH]XOWDW SURJQR]DW

M

'H PHQ LRQDW F SURJQR]HOH WLQG V VH VWDELOL]H]H vQ MXUXO XQXL DQXPLW QLYHO vQ FD]XO H[HPSOLILFDW DFHVW QLYHO HVWH $úDGDU PRGLILF ULOH vQ WLPS GXS FH GHS úLP SULPD HYHQWXDO D GRXD úL D WUHLD SHULRDG GH SURJQR] GHYLQ WRW PDL SX LQ ÄSURJQR]DELOH´ 3H WHUPHQ OXQJ SUHYL]LXQLOHED]DWHSHPRGHOHFDUHLQFOXGIDFWRULYH]L&DSLWROHOH,,,úL,9 VXQWPDLFUHGLELOH ÌQ WDEHOXO VXQW UHGDWH SUHYL]LXQLOH SULYLQG SURGXF LD GH R HO SUHFXP úL YkQ] ULOH GH DSDUDWHGHUDGLRvQ5RPkQLD0RGHOHOHXWLOL]DWHVXQW

SHQWUXSURGXF LDGHR HO \ó

= \ + \ ó ò ñ

+ X ó ò ñ

+ X ó ò ð

-

HYROX LDYkQ] ULORUGHDSDUDWHGHUDGLR \÷

= \ - \ ÷ ö ô

- \ ÷ ö õ

- X ÷ ö ô

7DEHO

3URGXF LDGHR HO

9kQ] ULGHUDGLRUHFHSWRDUH

3HULRDGDGH

PLLW

PLLEXF

SURJQR]

3UHYL]LXQL

Q Q

'DWHUHDOH

3UHYL]LXQL

'DWHUHDOH

Q

Q

&DOLWDWHD PRGHOXOXL GLQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH DO SUHFL]LHL SURJQR]HORU SRDWH IL YHULILFDW SH ED]D

XQRUSURJQR]HÄGHSURE ´DYkQGXVHvQYHGHUHXUP WRDUHOHHWDSH

D HWDSD VSHFLILF ULL FD úL FHD D HVWLP ULL VH UHIHU OD VHULD GH GDWH SHQWUX LQWHUYDOXO

FRQVLGHUDWPDLSX LQXOWLPHOHSHULRDGH$FHVWLQWHUYDOUHSUH]LQW ÄVHFYHQ DPDUWRU´ E SHED]DPRGHOXOXLDOHVVDXDGRX WUHLYDULDQWHGHPRGHOVXQWRE LQXWHSUHYL]LXQL SULYLQGHYROX LDvQFHOHSHULRDGHFDUHIRUPHD] VHFYHQ DPDUWRU F VH SURFHGHD] OD FRPSDUDUHD SURJQR]HORU HODERUDWH SHQWUX ILHFDUH YDULDQW GH PRGHO FX GDWHOH UHDOH FDUH FRPSXQ VHFYHQ D PDUWRU ÌQ DFHVW IHO SXWHP DSUHFLD FDUH YDULDQW HVWH PDL SHUIRUPDQW ,QGLFDWRUXO SH FDUH ODP VLPEROL]DW FX 506 UHOD LD SRDWH IL XWLO úL SHQWUX DFHDVW YHULILFDUH úL SH ED]D OXL YRP DFFHSWD DFHD YDULDQW GH PRGHO SHQWUX FDUH DP RE LQXW FHD Ö ø HVWH PDL PLF YDORDUH D UHVSHFWLYXOXL LQGLFDWRU 'HVLJXU vQ UHOD LD QLYHOXO DMXVWDW \

164

vQORFXLW FX YDORDUHD VD SURJQR]DW \ ú

ù

W

Q Q« 9DULDQWD GH PRGHO FRQVLGHUDW GUHSW FHD

PDLEXQ vQXUPDXQHLDVWIHOGHYHULILF ULXUPHD] V ILHXWLOL]DW SHQWUXvQWUHDJDVHULH \ ø

Ä)DPLOLD´ PRGHOHORU VWRFKDVWLFH GH SURJQR] FRQWLQX V VH GLYHUVLILFH OXkQG vQ DWHQ LH QRL

PDQLIHVW UL GLQ HFRQRPLH FXP VXQW FHOH OHJDWH GH VH]RQDOLWDWH 6$5,0$ LQFRQVWDQ D vQ WLPS D GLVSHUVLHL YDORULORU UH]LGXDOH $5&+ IUDF LRQDUHD GHFDODMXOXL vQ WLPS GLQ PRGHOHOH $5,0$ $5),0$ ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD] QHYRPUHIHULODDFHVWHGLQXUP PRGHOH

02'(/8/ $5&+ $XWRUHJUHVVLYH &RQGLWLRQDO +HWHURVFHGDVWLFLW\ XUP UHúWH LQFOXGHUHD

PDQLIHVW ULL UHSHWDELOH REVHUYDW vQ VHULLOH FURQRORJLFH SULYLQG LQGLFDWRULL ILQDQFLDUL ± PRQHWDUL UDWD LQIOD LHL FXUVXO GH VFKLPE SUH XO DFWLYHORU SUH XULOH VSHFXODWLYH FDUH FRQVW vQ DSDUL LD GH HURUL GH SURJQR] UHODWLY PDUL vQ XQHOH VHFYHQ H GH WLPS vQ DOWHUQDQ

FX VHFYHQ H vQ FDUH HURULOH

VXQW PLFL (VWH YRUED GHFL GH R LQHJDO vPSU úWLHUH KHWHURVFHGDVWLFLWDWH D YDORULORU YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOHPDQLIHVWDW SHVHFYHQ HOHGHWLPSFDUHFRPSXQVHULDFURQRORJLF 6XFFHVLXQHDGHHURULGH SURJQR] PDUL XUPDW GH VXFFHVLXQHD GH HURUL PXOW PDL PLFL SRDWH IL vQWkOQLW DWkW vQ VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH DSUHFLHP SUHFL]LD SUHYL]LXQLORU FkW úL vQ VLWXD LLOH vQ FDUH DQDOL] P FRPSRUWDPHQWXO YDORULORU YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOHSHQWUXVHULDLQL LDO GHGDWH2GHSHQGHQ

PDQLIHVWDW VXEIRUPDDXWRFRUHOD LHL

SRDWH IL GHFL LQYRFDW (FRQRPHWULFLDQXO HQJOH] ) 5 (QJOH D XUP ULW LQFOXGHUHD vQ PRGHOXO VWRFKDVWLF GH SURJQR] D XQXL DVWIHO GH FRPSRUWDPHQW DO YDORULORU UH]LGXDOH FRQVLGHUkQG F GLVSHUVLDHURULLSRDWHILSULYLW FDILLQGGHSHQGHQW GHYDORULOHOXL\ û üþý VDXX û üþý vQUHJLVWUDWHvQWUHFXWÌQ DFHVWVHQVHVWHSURSXV IXQF LD>@ s

=D

Xø

(D

+ D \

W -

> D

Ë )

FDúLYDULDQWD s

=a

Xø

+a X

W -

+ + a

S

X

W -S

6SUH GHRVHELUH GH PRGHOXO $5 vQ FDUH HURDUHD X HVWH FRQVLGHUDW DOHDWRDUH QRUPDO

GLVWULEXLW GHPHGLHHJDO FX]HURúLGHGLVSHUVLHFRQVWDQW D YDORULORU OXL \ û HVWH GHSHQGHQW GH WLPS 0\ û \ û üþÔ

(X

( s

a 1

W

X

ÿ

)) LDUPHGLDFRQGL LRQDW

D \ û üþÔ vQ YHUVLXQHD SURSXV GH (QJOH úL

GLVSHUVLDHURULLHVWHGHSHQGHQW GHWLPSSLHU]kQGXúLFDOLWDWHDGHDILFRQVWDQW $FHVWDHVWHPRWLYXO DG XJ ULL LQL LDOHORU &+ FRQGLWLRQDO KHWHURVFHGDVWLFLW\ VLPEROXOXL $5 $úDGDU vQWUR IRUPXODUH JHQHUDO vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH IXQF LD GH GHQVLWDWH D YDULDELOHL \ û FRQGL LRQDW GH\ û üþÔ HVWHQRUPDO PHGLDFDúLGLVSHUVLDVXQWODUkQGXOORUFRQGL LRQDWHGHWUHFXW

(\

\

W

W -

)a

(0

1

( \ W - ) s

\

)

2YDULDQW VLPSO DPRGHOXOXLSRDWHILUHGDW DVWIHO \ s ÌQWUH

YDULDQWHOH

= D\

W X

=a

X

W

W -

+ E[

+a X

( s

a 1

PRGHOXOXL

X

+X

W

W -

)

W

$5&+ PHQ LRQ P H[SUHVLD JHQHUDOL]DW SURSXV GH %ROOHUVOHY

*$5&+ vQ FDUH ÄPHPRULD´ SURFHVXOXL HVWH U VSkQGLW SH PDL PXOWH GDWH REVHUYDWH SHQWUX WUHFXW >@ s

=a

+a

\

+

L + a

\

+ b s

+

L + b

s

5HVWUkQJkQG HIHFWXO vQWkU]LHULL OD R VLQJXU XQLWDWH GH WLPS W RE LQHP PRGHOXO *$5&+

s

= D + a\

+ bs

XQGH

165

D > a,b Ë

a + b <1

0HQ LRQ PGHDVHPHQHDYDULDQWDLQWHJUDW ,*$5&+vQFDUHYDORULOHOXL\ GHYLQVWD LRQDUH

GXS FDOFXOXO GLIHUHQ HORU GH RUGLQXO vQWkL YDULDQWD vQ FDUH HIHFWXO GHSHQGHQ HL GLVSHUVLHL s

X

vQ

UDSRUWFXWLPSXODSDUHODQLYHOXOYDORULORUPHGLLDOHSURFHVXOXL$5&+0YDULDQWDH[SRQHQ LDO ( *$5&+ vQ FDUH GLVSHUVLHL FRQGL LRQDWH GH YDORULOH OXL X

VDX \

GLQ WUHFXW vL HVWH LPSXV

UHVWULF LD GH D IL QHQHJDWLY SULQ FRQVLGHUDUHD ORJDULWPLORU YDORULORU OXL s

X

FD ILLQG GHSHQGHQWH GH

YDORULOHUH]LGXDOHGLQWUHFXW>@ 'DF DERUG PPRGHOXO$5&+VXEDVSHFWRSHUD LRQDOSUHFXPúLSULQSULVPDXWLOLW

LLVDOHvQ

DQDOL] VLSURJQR] PHQ LRQ PvQSULPXOUkQGFULWHULLOHFDUHFRQILUP VDXLQILUP RS LXQHDSHQWUX XQ DVWIHO GH PRGHO (OH FRQVWDX vQ YHULILFDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL SDUDPHWULORU GLQ HFXD LD s

=a

+ a X

+ a X

+

SHQWUX

a!

=a

=a

= =

LQILUPDW VDX vQ DSOLFDUHD WHVWXOXL ) FD] vQ FDUH SHQWUX Q5

RS LXQHD

>

"

S

SHQWUX

$5&+

HVWH

QXP UXO GH WHUPHQL

RS LXQHDSHQWUX$5&+HVWHFRQILUPDW

(VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU SRDWH IL UHDOL]DW LWHUDWLY vQFHSkQG FX DSOLFDUHD 0&003

PRGHOXOXL ÄGH ED] ´ YH]L UHOD LD 6H FRQWLQX FX RE LQHUHD GH YDORUL DMXVWDWH GHWHUPLQDUHD YDORULORU YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH úL D GLVSHUVLHL DFHVWHLD s FXQRVFkQG s

$

#

X

Ö \

ÌQ HWDSD XUP WRDUH

VHSRDWHSURFHGDODHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORU a GLQUHOD LD úLvQFD]XOvQFDUH

Ö % GLIHU VHPQLILFDWLYGH]HURKHWHURVFHGDVFLWDWHDHVWHFRQILUPDW &DXUPDUHYDULDQWDSRQGHUDW D a 0&003 HVWH UHFRPDQGDW (D FRQVW vQ vPS U LUHD YDORULORU DSOLF ULL

0&003

SHQWUX

GHWHUPLQDUHDQRLORUHURUL XÖ

W

RE LQHUHD

YDORULORU

DMXVWDWH

\Ö

W

\& \&

( '

[ & OD s

ÄvPEXQ W

$

#

úL UHOXDUHD

LWH´

XUPDW

GH

DGLVSHUVLHLDFHVWRUDúLGHHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUGLQHFXD LD

Ö 5HOXDUHDSURFHVXOXLDUHORFSkQ FkQGSDUDPHWUXO a

GHYLQHQHVHPQLILFDWLYvQVHQVXOWHVWXOXLW

ÌQWUH DYDQWDMHOH DERUG ULL PRGHO ULL SULQ SULVPD $5&+ PHQ LRQ P SHUVSHFWLYD RDUHFXP

GLIHULW vQ FDUH HVWH SXV SUREOHPD DXWRFRUHO ULL YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH H[LVWHQ D DXWRFRUHO ULL HVWH FRQILUPDW SULQ WHVWXO ': DFHDVWD VDU SXWHD GDWRUD ILH IDSWXOXL F X ) GHSLQGH GH X ,

ILH IDSWXOXL F GLVSHUVLD YDORULORU YDULDELOHL UH]LGXDOH FDOFXODW SH VHJPHQWH DOH úLUXOXL GH

+ *

YDORUL

X , HVWH GHSHQGHQW GH WUHFXW 6DU SXWHD DILUPD vQ DFHDVW GLQ XUP VLWXD LH F

DXWRFRUHODUHDVHPQDODW GHWHVWXO':HVWHGHIDSWKHWHURVFHGDVFLWDWHÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHPRGHOXO $5&+úLSURJQR]DPHQ LRQ PF SUHGLF LLOHVHED]HD] SHRLQIRUPD LHVXSOLPHQWDU SULQOXDUHDvQ FDOFXO D LQFRQVWDQ HL vQ WLPS D GLVSHUVLHL YDORULORU UH]LGXDOH FHHD FH FHO SX LQ VXE DVSHFW WHRUHWLF FUHHD] SUHPLVHSHQWUXRE LQHUHDGHSURJQR]HPDLSUHFLVH

02'(/8/

$5),0$

Ä$XWRUHJUHVVLYH

)UDFWLRQDOO\

,QWHJUDWHG

0RYLQJ

$YHUDJH´

UHSUH]LQW R YDULDQW D PRGHOXOXL $5,0$SGT vQ FDUH FRHILFLHQWXO ÄG´ FDUH VHPQDOHD] RUGLQXO GLIHUHQ HL UHSUH]LQW R IUDF LXQH GLQ XQX $úDGDU R IUDF LXQH D GHFDODMXOXL vQ WLPS G HVWH VXILFLHQW SHQWUX D VWD LRQDUL]D VHULD 6H SRDWH DILUP F PRGHOXO $5,0$ SHQWUX FDUH G D\

. -

= \

- \

VDX G

D\

12 /

= D\ 4

10/

-

10/ D\ 4 3 0

HWF ÄG´ UHSUH]HQWkQG GRDU YDORUL vQWUHJL GHYLQH

XQFD]SDUWLFXODUDOFODVHLPDLODUJLGHPRGHOH$5),0$

'LQ SHUVSHFWLYD HFRQRPLHL DFFHSWDUHD RUGLQXOXL GH LQWHJUDUH UHSUH]HQWDW GH R IUDF LXQH GLQ

XQX VH MXVWLILF GDF DYHP vQ YHGHUH FRPSRQHQWHOH LQHU LDOH ÄVXEWHUDQH´ FDUH VH PDQLIHVW FD R WHQGLQ

GH SHULRDG vQGHOXQJDW DYkQG vQFHSXWXO GLQFROR GH SULPXO WHUPHQ DO VHULHL SH FDUH R

DQDOL] P úL SHQWUX FDUH GLIHUHQ HOH GH RUGLQXO vQWkL DU IL SUHD PDUL >@ $VWIHO GH SURFHVH SUHFXP QLYHODUHD FRQVXPXOXL U VSODWD LQYHVWL LLORU vQ DF LXQL SXQHUHD GH DFRUG D VDODULLORU FX SUH XULOH

166

IRUPDUHD WUDGL LLORU vQ FRQVXP GDU úL vQ SURGXF LH VDX LQYHVWL LL DU IL LQGLFDWH SHQWUX R DERUGDUH vQ VHQVXO PRGHOHORU $5),0$ 3URFHVHOH GH DFHVW JHQ QHFHVLW ÄPRGHOH GH PHPRULH IRDUWH OXQJ ´ FDSDELOH V UH LQ DVSHFWH OHJDWH GH SHUVLVWHQ D XQRU IDFWRUL vQ HFRQRPLH FXP DU IL DFXPXO ULOH GH FDSLWDOILHXPDQILHGHQDWXU WHKQRORJLF WUDGL LLOHWHQGLQ DGHÄPDLELQH´HWF0RGHOHOHED]DWHSH FRQFHSWXOGHU G FLQ XQLWDU YH]L&DSLWROXO9, GDUúLPDLUHFHQWXOPRGHO$5),0$VXQWGHVWLQDWH GHVFULHULLXQRUDVWIHOGHSURFHVHGHSHUVLVWHQ

([SULPDUHDIRUPDO DPRGHOXOXLVHSRDWHED]DSHH[SUHVLDÄIUDF LRQDW ´DSHUWXUED LHLSHQWUX

YDULDELODWLPSFRQVLGHUDW GHWLSGLVFUHW - %

G

\

W

=X

W

XQGH G

± » QXP UUHDO ª
%

RSHUDWRUGHÄWULPLWHUH´vQWUHFXWYH]LWDEHOXO

'DF FRQVLGHU PGH]YROWDUHDELQRPLDO DHOHPHQWXOXL - %

- %

G

G G -

= - G% +

%

-

G

DFHDVWDGHYLQH

G G - G -

%

+

'DF VH DGDXJ úL FRPSRQHQWHOH $5 úL 0$ H[SUHVLHL PHQ LRQDWH VH DMXQJH OD PRGHOXO

$5),0$DF UXLIRUP JHQHUDO SRDWHILH[SULPDW DVWIHO - %

G

X

¢ D % \

W

a 1

W

= E % X

( s

X

5

)

W

XQGHDEúL%DXDFHHDúLVHPQLILFD LHFDúLvQUHOD LD

(VWLPDUHD vQ SULQFLSLX SUHVXSXQH vQWUR SULP ID] GHWHUPLQDUHD P ULPLL IUDF LXQLL ÄG´

GXS FDUHVHWUHFHODHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXL$50$ODFDUHVDDMXQV

ÌQFKHLHP SUH]HQWDUHD JHQHUDO D PRGHOXOXL $5),0$ PHQ LRQkQG F DFHVW PRGHO D LQWUDW vQ

DWHQ LD HFRQRPLúWLORU GRDU vQ XOWLPXO WLPS RIHULQG XQ GRPHQLX GH FHUFHWDUH úL DSOLFDUH SUHD SX LQ H[SORDWDW

%,%/,2*5$),(

%R[ * ( 3 -HQNLQV * 0 ± 7LPH 6HULHV $QDO\VLV )RUHFDVWLQJ DQG &RQWURO +ROGHQ'D\ 6DQ)UDQFLVFR

&XWKEHUWVRQ.+DOO6±$SSOLHG(FRQRPHWULFV7HFKQLTXHV:KUHDWRQV/WG

)RPE\7%5KRGHV*±$GYDQFHVLQ(FRQRPHWULFV-$,*UHVV/RQGRQ

*UDQJHU&:-±6SHFWUDO$QDO\VLVRI(FRQRPLF7LPH6HULHV3ULQFHWRQ8QLY3UHVV1<

*ULIILWKV : -XGJH * &DUWHU +LOO 5 ± /HDUQLQJ DQG 3UDFWLFLQJ (FRQRPHWULFV -RKQ :LOH\

*XMDUDWL'±%DVLF(FRQRPHWULFV0F*UDZ+LOO,QF1<

+DUYH\$&±7LPH6HULHV0RGHOV+RZHVWHU1<

-RKQVWRQ-±(FRQRPHWULF0HWKRGV0F*UDZ+LOO1<

0DGGDOD*6±,QWURGXFWLRQWR(FRQRPHWULFV0F0LOODQ3XEO

DQG6RQV

3HFLFDQ(6±(FRQRPHWULH(GLWXUD$OO%XFXUHúWL 3ORHJ)HGLW ±$GYDQFHG/HFWXUHVLQ4XDQWLWDWLYH(FRQRPHWULFV$FDG3UHVV 6WHZDUW-±(FRQRPHWULFV$OODQ7K 7HUWLúFR 0 6WRLFD 3 3RSHVFX 7K ± 0RGHODUHD úL SUHGLF LD VHULLORU GH WLPS (GLWXUD $FDGHPLHL%XFXUHúWL

167

&DSLWROXO,; (OHPHQWHGHDQDOL]

VSHFWUDO

2 FDUDFWHULVWLF D XQRUD GLQWUH VHFWRDUHOH LPSRUWDQWH DOH HFRQRPLHL DJULFXOWXUD WXULVPXO FRPHU XOWUDQVSRUWXULOHLQGXVWULDH[WUDFWLY LQGXVWULDDOLPHQWDU VHUYLFLLOHHWF RFRQVWLWXLHQDWXUD IOXFWXDQW D DFWLYLW

LORU 6H]RQDOLWDWHD úL FLFOLFLWDWHD OD FDUH QHDP UHIHULW vQ &DSLWROXO 9,

UHSUH]LQW FHOHPDLHYLGHQWHPDQLIHVW ULGHDFHVWJHQ)DFWRULLJHQHUDWRULGHIOXFWXD LLVXQWOHJD LvQ SULPXO UkQG GH IHQRPHQHOH QDWXUDOH VFKLPEDUHD DQRWLPSXULORU DOWHUQDQ D ]LQRDSWH ULWPXULOH FLUFDUGLHQH HWF GDU úL GH FHOH VRFLDOH SHULRGLFLWDWHD XQRU DFWLYLW

L OHJDWH GH vQY

PkQW FXOWXU

WUDGL LLDOHJHULHOHFWRUDOHHWF

&D XUPDUH GHRVHELP RVFLOD LL GH SHULRDG PDL PLF VDX PDL PDUH FDUH PDUFKHD] HYROX LD

PXOWRU LQGLFDWRUL HFRQRPLFL XQHOH PDL HYLGHQWH DOWHOH PDL JUHX GHWHFWDELOH PDL DOHV F RVFLOD LLOH GLIHULWHFDIUHFYHQ

úLDPSOLWXGLQHVHVXSUDSXQ

3HQWUX D FODULILFD vQWUR PDL PDUH P VXU SUREOHPD OD FDUH QH UHIHULP vQ DFHVW FDSLWRO QH

SURSXQHP V FRQFUHWL] P DVSHFWHOH DERUGDWH OXkQG GUHSW H[HPSOX SURGXFWLYLWDWHD PXQFLL OD R vQWUHSULQGHUH GLQ UDPXUD LQGXVWULHL DOLPHQWDUH 'DWHOH FXOHVH SULYLQG SURGXFWLYLWDWHD SRW HYLGHQ LD PDLPXOWHIOXFWXD LLLQGHSHQGHQWHXQDGHDOWDRRVFLOD LHFRPSOHW SHGXUDWDFHORURUHDOH]LOHLGH PXQF R DOWD GH GHVFKLGHUH PDL ODUJ VH GHVI úRDU vQ GHFXUVXO V SW PkQLL VDX R RVFLOD LH GH GHVFKLGHUHIRDUWHPDUHFDUHVHGHVI úRDU SHGXUDWDXQXLDQ

'HúL HYROX LD QX VH UHDOL]HD] OLQLDU HYHQWXDO SHUWXUEDW GH FDX]H DFFLGHQWDOH FL SH IRQGXO

JHQHUDO DO WHQGLQ HL GH FUHúWHUH VDX GHVFUHúWHUH VH vQUHJLVWUHD] IOXFWXD LL GH GLIHULWH IUHFYHQ H úL DPSOLWXGLQL $VWIHO vQ GHFXUVXO DQXOXL GHRVHELP vQ FD]XO SURGXFWLYLW

LL R RVFLOD LH GH SHULRDG

DQXDO GH RVFLOD LL SH SHULRDGD V SW PkQDO úL GH RVFLOD LL PDL SX LQ QXP UXO ]LOHORU GH RGLKQ GHSHULRDG HJDO FXGXUDWD]LOHLGHPXQF RUH

'HRVHELPvQDFHVWGRPHQLXDODQDOL]HLIOXFWXD LLORURWHUPLQRORJLHRDUHFXPVSHFLILF $VWIHO

XWLOL] P QR LXQHD GH ÄLQWHUYDO´ vQ VHQVXO GH GXUDW SHQWUX FDUH GLVSXQHP GH GDWH ,QWHUYDOXO HVWH FRPSXV GLQ ÄXQLW

L GH WLPS´ XQHL XQLW

L GH WLPS vL FRUHVSXQGH XQ QLYHO DO FDUDFWHULVWLFLL 3H

LQWHUYDOXOGHWLPSGHRVHELPÄSHULRDGH´GXUDWHvQFDUHDXORFRVFLOD LLFRPSOHWH GHGXUDW PDLPDUH VDX PDL PLF 1XP UXO GH SHULRDGH GH R DQXPLW GXUDW vQ LQWHUYDOXO FRQVLGHUDW UHSUH]LQW ÄIUHFYHQ D´

'LVWDQ D YkUIXULORU OLQLHL RVFLODQWH vQ UDSRUW FX PHGLD OLQLD RUL]RQWDO GHOLPLWHD]

ÄDPSOLWXGLQHD´ ÌQ 7DEHOXO H[HPSOLILF P FkWHYD GRPHQLL DOH HFRQRPLHL vQ FDUH IOXFWXD LLOH VXQW PDL

HYLGHQWHVSHFLILFkQGSHQWUXILHFDUHXQLWDWHDGHWLPSSHULRDGHOHúLLQWHUYDOXOSHQWUXFDUHP VXUDUHD XQRUDVWIHOGHIOXFWXD LLSUH]LQW LQWHUHVSHQWUXDQDOL] 7DEHOXO 6HFWRUXO

$FWLYLWDWHDHFRQRPLF

8QLWDWHDGHWLPS

3HULRDGD

,QWHUYDOXO

RUD

RUH

V SW PkQDOXQD

3URGXFWLYLWDWHD

]LXD

V SW PkQD

VHPHVWUXODQXO

PXQFLL

OXQD

DQXO

GHFHQLXO

RUD

RUH

V SW PkQDOXQD

9kQ] ULOHFXDP QXQWXO

]LXD

V SW PkQD

VHPHVWUXODQXO

OXQD

DQXO

GHFHQLXO

WULPHVWUXO

DQXO

GHFHQLXO

168

RUD

RUH

V SW PkQDOXQD

]LXD

V SW PkQD

VHPHVWUXODQXO

OXQD

DQXO

GHFHQLXO

RUD

RUH

OXQD

]LXD

V SW PkQD

DQXO

$FFLGHQWHOHGHPXQF

7UDQVSRUWXOXUEDQ

$FWLYLWDWHDvQ

RUD

]LXD

OXQD

WUDQVSRUWXULúL

]LXD

V SW PkQD

DQXO

WHOHFRPXQLFD LL

OXQD

DQXO

GHFHQLXO

$FWLYLWDWHDvQWXULVP

]LXD

V SW PkQD

DQXO

OXQD

DQXO

GHFHQLXO

$FWLYLWDWHDvQ

OXQD

VHPHVWUXO

GHFHQLXO

DJULFXOWXU

WULPHVWUXO

DQXO

GHFHQLXO

(FRQRPHWULHL vL UHYLQH UROXO GH D GHFHOD WLSXULOH GH RVFLOD LL GH D P VXUD DPSOLWXGLQHD ORU HYHQWXDO GH D P VXUD DQDORJLD vQWUH RVFLOD LLOH XQRU IHQRPHQH HFRQRPLFH SHQWUX D GHSLVWD OHJ WXUD GLQWUHFRPSRUWDPHQWXODFHVWRUD(VWHYRUEDGHFLGHXQGRPHQLXUHODWLYQRXSHQWUXHFRQRPHWULHFDUH YL]HD] DVSHFWH GH R PDUH ILQH H

LQkQG GH QDWXUD LQWLP D IHQRPHQHORU $FHVWH DVSHFWH

FRQVLGHU P GHVFKLG QRL SHUVSHFWLYH DQDOL]HL HYROX LHL SUHFXP úL DQDOL]HL UHOD LLORU FDX]DOH GLQ HFRQRPLH

ÌQ FHHDFHXUPHD] QHUHIHULPSHVFXUWODLQVWUXPHQWHOHGHQDWXU FDQWLWDWLY FDUHúLDXJ VLW

XWLOL]DUHvQDQDOL]DIOXFWXD LLORUGLQGRPHQLXOHFRQRPLHL

,QWURGXFHUHD 3(5,2'2*5$0(, GH F WUH - 6FKXVWHU vQ YHGHUHD DQDOL]HL SURSULHW

LORU

LQWHUQH DOH XQHL VHULL FURQRORJLFH D FRQVWLWXLW R SULP IRUP GH DERUGDUH D GLQDPLFLL IHQRPHQHORU SULQ SULVPD IUHFYHQ HL RVFLOD LLORU ÌQ DQLL FDUH DX XUPDW R VHULH GH VWDWLVWLFLHQL úL HFRQRPHWULFLHQL vQWUHFDUHPHQ LRQ PSH&:*UDQJHU*(3-HQNLQV$7XNH\-+DQQLQJDXDYXWLPSRUWDQWH FRQWULEX LL vQ GLUHF LD SHUIHF LRQ ULL PHWRGRORJLHL GH DQDOL] D RVFLOD LLORU FDUH SRW ÄFRPSXQH´ VHULD FURQRORJLF

5HYHQLQGODSHULRGRJUDP PHQ LRQ PF SULQFLSLXOSHFDUHVHED]HD] DFHDVW UHSUH]HQWDUH

DUHvQYHGHUHSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDDSUR[LPDRULFHRVFLOD LHSULQWURVHULH)RXULHU

I

D

=

([)

+

¸

Ç (D Q

FRV Q[ + E

Q

Q =

VLQ Q[ )

XQGH D D E

SDUDPHWULL

-6FKXVWHUVWDWLVWLFLDQJHUPDQDOHF UXLOXFU ULDXIRVWHODERUDWHODvQFHSXWXOVHFROXOXL;; 6HULD )RXULHU D XQHL IXQF LL UHSUH]LQW DFHD VHULH WULJRQRPHWULF SHQWUX FDUH FRHILFLHQ LL )RXULHU DL UHVSHFWLYHL IXQF LL

I[ SRWILFDOFXOD LSULQIRUPXOHOH(XOHU)RXULHU

D

=

D

=

E

=

Ï

p

p p

Ï Ï

I [ G[

I [ FRV Q[ G [

I [ VLQ [ G[

ÌQF GLQ 1\TXLVW D VWDELOLW F vQ FD]XO HYROX LHL XQXL SURFHV RVFLODWRU vQUHJLVWUDW SHQWUX 7 XQLW

L GH WLPS R

RVFLOD LHRDUHFDUHGHSHULRDG 7SRDWHILUHSUH]HQWDW SULQWURUHOD LHGHIRUPD

\

=

Ç

» ªD ½

» p FRVª I ½ 7

± ¢ W ² + E Õ

» p VLQ ª I ½ 7

±± ¢W ²² ÕÕ

169

p

Q = I

IUHFYHQ DXQJKLXODU

IUHFYHQ

I 7

7

GXUDWDLQWHUYDOXOXL

ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHQR LXQHDGH63(&758UHVSHFWLYGH$1$/,=

63(&75$/

DFHDVWDD

IRVW SUHOXDW GLQ IL]LF vQWUXFkW SULQ DQDORJLH FX VSHFWUXO XQGHL GH OXPLQ UHJ VLP úL vQ FDGUXO VHULLORU FURQRORJLFH GLQ HFRQRPLHFRPSRQHQWHvQUDSRUWFXIUHFYHQ DRVFLOD LLORUIRUPkQGvQXUPD XQXL SURFHV GH GHVFRPSXQHUH FXORDUH EHQ]L GLIHULWH 'DF GHVFRPSXQHUHD XQGHL GH OXPLQ vQ EHQ]LGHGLIHULWHFXORULSUHVXSXQHXQSURFHGHXVSHFLILFIL]LFLLGHVFRPSXQHUHDVHULHLFURQRORJLFHGH GDWHQXPHULFHSRDWHILI FXW FXDMXWRUXOVHULLORUWULJRQRPHWULFH &RUHVSXQ] WRU RSWLFLL DQDOL]HL VSHFWUDOH XQ SURFHV HYROXWLY vQ WLPS SRDWH IL SULYLW FD XQ DJUHJDW GH RVFLOD LL VLVWHPDWLFH D F URU IUHFYHQ

úL DPSOLWXGLQH GLIHU 2VFLOD LLOH GH GLYHUVH

IUHFYHQ H VH VXSUDSXQ IRUPkQG XQ SURFHV IOXFWXDQW FRPSOH[ FDUH SRDWH IL DQDOL]DW vQ FRQGL LLOH H[LVWHQ HLXQXLQXP UVXILFLHQWGHPDUHGHYDORULQXPHULFHSULYLQGHYROX LDUHVSHFWLYXOXLSURFHV ÌQ YHGHUHD SUHOXFU ULL GDWHORU HFRQRPLFH FRUHVSXQ] WRU DQDOL]HL VSHFWUDOH VH FRQVLGHU VHULD

FURQRORJLF \ FD ILLQG UH]XOWDWXO XQXL SURFHV VWRFKDVWLF VWD LRQDU )DSWXO F GDWHOH VXQW DIHFWDWH GH HURUL DFFLGHQWDOH D F URU OHJH GH SUREDELOLWDWH UHSDUWL LH HVWH FRQVLGHUDW FXQRVFXW LDU vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH WHQGLQ D HYROXWLY VH FRQVLGHU F HD SRDWH IL HOLPLQDW GLQGDWHIDFFDDVLPLODUHDVHULHL\ FXúLUXOUH]XOWDWHORUXQXLSURFHVVWRFKDVWLFV SRDWHILDGPLV 2 DVWIHO GH VHULH SRDWH IL GHVFRPSXV vQ FRPSRQHQWH VLQXVRLGDOH GH IUHFYHQ H GLIHULWH 2 RVFLOD LHVLQXVRLGDO SRDWHILJHQHUDW GHF WUHXQSURFHVGHVFULVGHUHOD LD \

$VLQZ7'

XQGH $

DPSOLWXGLQHDRVFLOD LHL p

Z = '

7

IUHFYHQ DXQJKLXODU

GHID]DMXOGLVWDQ DvQWLPSGLQWUHPRPHQWXOLQL LDOúLFHOvQFDUH\

2ULFDUH RVFLOD LH VLQXVRLGDO SRDWH IL FRQVLGHUDW FD VXPD D GRX RVFLOD LL FRPSOH[H XQD DYkQG IUHFYHQ D SR]LWLY FHDODOW QHJDWLY $VWIHO vQ FD]XO XQXL SURFHV JHQHUDWRU GH IRUPD SHQWUXZúLWSUHVWDELOLWHXUP WRDUHDÄGHVFRPSXQHUH´HVWHSRVLELO \

D

H

!#"%$

XQGH L

D

H

'& !#"%$

- Z Ê p

([LVWHQ D PDL PXOWRU RVFLOD LL GH IUHFYHQ

GLIHULW D F URU ÄYLEUD LH´ DUH ORF VLPXOWDQ IDFH

QHFHVDU H[SULPDUHD XQGHL SHULRGLFH FRPSOH[H SULQWUXQ SROLQRP WULJRQRPHWULF 2 DVWIHO GH XQG SRDWH IL IRUPDW UHSURGXV SULQ DJUHJDUHD XQRU RVFLOD LL GH IUHFYHQW GLIHULW DIODWH vQ UHOD LH DUPRQLF 3HQWUX D H[SULPD XQ DVWIHO GH DQVDPEOX GH RVFLOD LL VLQXVRLGDOH GH IUHFYHQ H DIODWH vQ UHOD LHDUPRQLF \

)

=

D

(

DSHO PODVHULD)RXULHU

*

» . ª D+ + Ç

+

,½

» p FRVª I ½ 7

± ¢ W ² + E+ Õ

» p VLQ ª I ½ 7

(

±± ¢ W ² ² + X ) W = Q ÕÕ

)

/

3URFHVXO FDUH GHWHUPLQ PRGXO GH DSDUL LH D WHUPHQLORU VHULHL HVWH FRQVLGHUDW SURFHV JHQHUDWRU 'DF XQ DVWIHO GH

SURFHV JHQHUHD] YDORUL \ vQ UDSRUW FX XQ SURFHV DOHDWRU GH UHSDUWL LH FXQRVFXW HO SRDWH IL FDOLILFDW GUHSW VWRFKDVWLF 2

0

FODV VSHFLDO D SURFHVHORU VWRFKDVWLFH R UHSUH]LQW SURFHVHOH VWD LRQDUH FDUDFWHUL]DWH SULQ DFHHD F QLYHOXO ORU PHGLX GLVSHUVLD úL FRYDULDQ D QX GHSLQG GH VFKLPEDUHD PRPHQWXOXL LQL LDO DO VHULHL 3URFHVHOH VWRFKDVWLFH VWD LRQDUH DX XQHOH SURSULHW

L XWLOH DQDOL]HL SUHFXP SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D UHGXFH DQVDPEOXO GH 1 YDORUL OD XQ HúDQWLRQ GH YROXP Q Q 1

FDOLWDWHDFDVHULDV SRDWHILGHVFRPSXV vQWURVXP GHRVFLOD LLVLQXVRLGDOH

1

'HQXPLUHDGHUHOD LHDUPRQLF VDXGHDQDOL] DUPRQLF DUHvQYHGHUHFRQVRQDQ DGLQWUHXQGHOHGHIUHFYHQ

DIODWHvQWU

XQUDSRUWFDUHSUH]LQW VLPLOLWXGLQLFXFHOVWDELOLWvQWUHVXQHWHOHDIODWHvQDFRUGGHWRQDOLWDWHDUPRQLH

170

XQGH D D2 E2 7

SDUDPHWUL QXP UXOGHXQLW

LGHWLPSW vQLQWHUYDOXOFRQVLGHUDW

ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHHVWLPDUHDVHXUP UHúWHRE LQHUHDDFHORUHVWLPD LL D Ö3

Ö E3

FDUHFRQGXFOD

FHD PDL EXQ DSUR[LPDUH D IXQF LHL SHULRGLFH IW SULQWUR VXP ILQLW GH IXQF LL VLQXV úL FRVLQXV SH FDUH

R

LQWHJUDOD

VLPEROL] P p

\ W

p

Ï [I W - \

3ULQ

DQDORJLH

FX

0&003

VH

DUH

vQ

YHGHUH

Q

W ] GW FDUH DWLQJH XQ PLQLP DWXQFL FkQG D4 úLE4 VXQWFRHILFLHQ LL(XOHU

5

)RXULHUDLIXQF LHLIW Ö9 D

=

Ö E>

7

6 : \8 8Ç <

=

Ö D

7

7

=

=

?

; \ Ç

Ç

\

=

W

» p ¢ FRVª I ½ 7

± ¢W ²

» p ¢ VLQ ª I ½ 7

± ¢W ²

7

Õ

Õ

ÌQFRQWLQXDUHSRWILRE LQX LXUP WRULLLQGLFDWRULVSHFLILFLDQDOL]HLVSHFWUDOH DPSOLWXGLQHD$ GHVWLQDW P VXU ULLRVFLOD LHLGHIUHFYHQ

$

Ö D

=

I

Ö +E

I

I

ÄI´

5HSUH]HQWDUHD JUDILF D DPSOLWXGLQLL vQ UDSRUW FX IUHFYHQ D HVWH GHQXPLW SHULRGRJUDPD

VSHFWURJUDPD 2 DVWIHO GH UHGDUH D ÄSXWHULL´ YLEUD LHL SH FRPSRQHQWH GH IUHFYHQ

I UHSUH]LQW

VSHFWUXO IXQF LHL IW 1R LXQHD HVWH OHJDW GLUHFW GH DPSORDUHD GLVSHUVLHL ILHF UHLD GLQWUH FRPSRQHQWHOH DUPRQLFH DQDOL]DWH vQ VXFFHVLXQHD IUHFYHQ HL 3RDWH IL GHWHUPLQDW úL DúDQXPLWD HQHUJLH D DUPRQLFLL GH IUHFYHQ

I SULQ UDSRUWDUHD OXL $4 UHOD LD OD VXPD DPSOLWXGLQLORU

SHQWUXDQVDPEOXOIUHFYHQ HORUOXDWHvQFDOFXO

6SHFWUXOvQUDSRUWFXGLVSHUVLDúLFRYDULDQ DSRDWHILH[SULPDWDVWIHO 6F

Å = ¢ F ®

C

D @ B

FRV(p ¢ I

+ ÇF E

E A B

¢N

´

)µ Ý

XQGH ÊIÊò FG F

N

=

Q

DXWRFRYDULDQ DGHODJNN

Ç \

W

- \ \

W -N

«

- \

SXWHUHD VSHFWUXOXL SULQ FDUH SRDWH IL HYDOXDW YDORDUHD OLPLW D PHGLHL VSHFWUHORU SHQWUX XQ QXP UGHHúDQWLRDQHVHJPHQWHDOHVHULHLFURQRORJLFH VXILFLHQWGHPDUH

ÖH $úDGDU S

= OLP 0

(6 H

) (VWLPDWRUXOSXWHULLVSHFWUXOXLUH]XOW

ÖO S

« = F Ã ¬

M

I

+ N Ç F

JLK

N

FRV(p ¢ I

¢N

á

)

³ ã

DVWIHO

XQGHÊIÊò $FHDVWDUHSUH]LQW RWUDQVIRUPDW )RXULHUFRVLQXVRLGDO DIXQF LHLGHDXWRFRYDULD LH IXQF LD GH GHQVLWDWH VSHFWUDO XWLO LGHQWLILF ULL LQWHUYDOXOXL SHQWUX FDUH VSHFWUXO SURFHVXOXL SUH]LQW FUHúWHUL PDL UDSLGH HVWH GH IDSW SULPD GHULYDW D IXQF LHL VSHFWUXOXL SURFHVXOXL (VWLPD LD IXQF LHLGHGHQVLWDWHVSHFWUDO UH]XOW DVWIHO

P

2 RVFLOD LH GH ED] SRDWH DYHD VXSUDRVFLOD LL D F URU IUHFYHQ

GDF IUHFYHQ DHVWH

7

DWXQFL

I

HVWH GXEOXO WULSOXO HWF RVFLOD LHL GH ED] $OWIHO VSXV

UHSUH]LQW DUPRQLFDDFHVWHLD

7

171

Ö GW

=

ÖW S sW

U

Q

« V = + ÇU Ã RTS ¬

V

FRV(p ¢ I

¢N

á

)

³ ã

XQGHÊIÊò UG

FRHILFLHQWXOGHDXWRFRUHOD LH

([HPSOX

ÌQ FHHD FH XUPHD] QH YRP UHIHUL OD HWDSHOH FRQFUHWH DOH DQDOL]HL VSHFWUDOH GHVWLQDWH

vQGHRVHEL DSUHFLHULL LPSRUWDQ HL RVFLOD LLORU GH GLIHULWH IUHFYHQ H úL D XWLOLW

LL HL SHQWUX DQDOL]D

HFRQRPLF SUHFXP úL SHQWUX PRGHODUHD HFRQRPHWULF 2 VHULH FURQRORJLF FX XQ QXP U UHGXV GH WHUPHQLHVWHXWLOL]DW vQYHGHUHDH[HPSOLILF ULLFDOFXOHORU (WDSD , &XOHJHUHD GH GDWH vQ YHGHUHD IRUP ULL XQHL VHULL FURQRORJLFH FX XQ QXP U PDUH GH WHUPHQL Q ! UHSUH]HQWkQG QLYHOH SHQWUX XQLW

L GH WLPS GH UHDO LQWHUHV HFRQRPLF YH]L 7DEHOXO

FRORDQD 3HQWUXH[HPSOLILFDUHDYHPvQYHGHUHGRDUXQQXP UUHVWUkQVGHGDWHWULPHVWULDOH SULYLQGYDORULOHvQFDV ULORUGLQVHUYLFLLvQWURXQLWDWHWHULWRULDO 7DEHOXOUkQGXO 7DEHOXO

$QXO

VHPHVWUXO

,

,,

,,,

,9

,

,,

,,,

,9

9DORDUHD

VHUYLFLLORU

0HGLD

ÖX D

= \ =

(WDSD,,$QDOL]DFDOLWDWLY GHQDWXU HFRQRPLF vQYHGHUHDVWDELOLULLSHULRDGHORUODFDUHSRW DYHD ORF RVFLOD LL FRPSOHWH YH]L WDEHOXO FRORDQD &RUHVSXQ] WRU SHULRDGHORU DOHVH úL DYkQG vQ YHGHUH OXQJLPHD LQWHUYDOXOXL VWDELOLP IUHFYHQ HOH SHQWUX FDUH XUPHD] V HVWLP P ÖY SDUDPHWULL D

Ö EY

3HQWUX GDWHOH GLQ 7DEHOXO FRQVLGHU P F SRW DSDUH RVFLOD LL FRPSOHWH SHQWUX SHULRDGD

DQXDO GHFL vQ GHFXUVXO D SDWUX WULPHVWUH SUHFXP úL SHQWUX vQWUHJ LQWHUYDOXO GH RSW WULPHVWUH 2VFLOD LLOHGHSHULRDG DQXDO SRWILvQQXP UGHGRX vQWUXFkWGLVSXQHPGHGDWHSHQWUXGRLDQLI

LDU SHQWUX vQWUHJXO LQWHUYDO SXWHP FRQVLGHUD F GHRVHELP RVLQJXU RVFLOD LHFRPSOHW GHRPDL ODUJ GHVFKLGHUHI

Ö

Ö E úL D Ö 'HFLvQWURHWDS XUP WRDUHQHSURSXQHPV HVWLP P D

Ö E

(WDSD ,,, 3UHOXFUDUHD SULPDU D GDWHORU vQ YHGHUHD DVLJXU ULL FDUDFWHUXOXL VWRFKDVWLF úL VWD LRQDUDOYDORULORU\ Z ÌQ FD]XO VHULLORU QHVWD LRQDUH HVWH QHFHVDU V HOLPLQ P WHQGLQ D JHQHUDO DSHOkQG ILH OD GLIHUHQ HOH GH GLIHULWH RUGLQH YH]L &DSLWROXO 9, ILH OD R HYDOXDUH SUHDODELO D WUHQGXOXL XUPDW GH HOLPLQDUHDVDGLQVHULDGHGDWHHPSLULFHFD]XOVHULLORU763±YH]L&DSLWROXO9,

ÌQ H[HPSOXO FRQVLGHUDW DP DSHODW OD FHD GHD GRXD YDULDQW GH VWD LRQDUL]DUH D HYROX LHL

SHQWUXDQXGLPLQXDúLPDLPXOWYROXPXOGHGDWH$PFRQVLGHUDWWHQGLQ DOLQLDU FD]vQFDUHW Ö 3DUDPHWULL RE LQX L D

Ö = úL D

= DX SHUPLV GHWHUPLQDUHD WUHQGXOXL

Ö D I FXW SRVLELO RE LQHUHD XUP WRUXOXL úLU GH YDORUL FDUH vQ XUPD FDOFXOXOXL GLIHUHQ HORU \ \ W

W

VWD LRQDUH 7ULP

,

,,

,,,

,9

,

,,

,,,

,9

\ Z VWD LRQDU

(WDSD ,9 (VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU úL FDOFXOXO LQGLFDWRULORU DQDOL]HL VSHFWUDOH SRWULYLW RELHFWLYHORUXUP ULWH

172

ÌQ DFHVW VFRS XWLOL] P UHOD LLOH GH FDOFXO SUH]HQWDWH vQ SDUDJUDIXO DQWHULRU ÌQWUXFkW QHDP SURSXV DQDOL]D LPSRUWDQ HL RVFLOD LLORU GH GLIHULWH IUHFYHQ H SUHFXP úL XWLOL]DUHD LQGLFDWRULORU vQ PRGHODUHvQFHSHPFXHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORU3HQWUXDIDFLOLWDSUH]HQWDUHDFDOFXOHORUDPSURFHGDWOD GHWHUPLQDUHDPHGLLORUWULPHVWULDOH 7ULP

,

,,

,,,

,9

\

W

&RQIRUPUHOD LLORU úL RE LQHP

[

=

Ö D

Ö E =

\

Ö D

^

» » ± » ± » ± » ±± ª ¢ VLQ ª ) ¢ VLQ ª ¢¢² + (- ¢¢ ² + ¢ VLQ ª ¢¢ ² + (- ) ¢ VLQ ª ¢¢ ² ² = - ª ² ½ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ ÕÕ

=

» » ± » ± » ± » ±± ª ¢ FRV ª ¢ ¢² + (- ) ¢ FRV ª ¢ ¢ ² + ¢ FRV ª ¢ ¢ ² + (- ) ¢ FRV ª ¢ ¢ ² ² = - ª ² ½ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ ÕÕ

=

» » ± » ± » ± » ±± ª ¢ VLQ ª ) ¢ VLQ ª ¢ ¢² + (- ¢ ¢ ² + ¢ VLQ ª ¢ ¢ ² + (- ) ¢ VLQ ª ¢ ¢ ² ² = ª ² ½ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ ÕÕ

]

Ö E

» » ± » ± » ± » ±± ª ¢ FRV ª ) ¢ FRV ª ¢¢² + (- ¢¢ ² + ¢ FRVª ¢¢ ² + (- ) ¢ FRV ª ¢¢ ² ² = - ª ² ½ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ Õ ½ ÕÕ

Ö D

_

Ç

=

`

\

`

7

=

=

$PSOLWXGLQHD

$b $c

Öb D

= =

a

Öc D

Ö + Eb

c

a

Ö + Ec

=

c

=

(-

)

-

a

+ -

c

a

=

+ =

(WDSD9,QWHUSUHWDUHDUH]XOWDWHORUúLXWLOL]DUHDORUvQSUDFWLFDPRGHO ULL 6H vQFHSH FX LQWHUSUHWDUHD DPSOLWXGLQLL FDOFXODWH SHQWUX GLYHUVH IUHFYHQ H 3HULRGRJUDPD SRDWHILXWLO vQDFHVWVHQV3RWDSDUHXUP WRDUHOHVLWXD LL R P ULPH D DPSOLWXGLQLL PXOW SHVWH ]HUR SHQWUX IUHFYHQ H PDL PLFL VDX HJDOH FX XQX VHPQDOHD] SUH]HQ DWHQGLQ HLVHULDQXHVWHVWD LRQDU QLYHOHDOHDPSOLWXGLQLLGHRVHELWGHPDULSHQWUXIUHFYHQ HFDUHVHUHIHU ODSHULRDGHPDLPLFL VDXHJDOHFXXQDQ I

>

7 P

P

QXP UXOGHDQL LQGLF SUH]HQ DVH]RQDOLW

LL

GDF DPSOLWXGLQHD HVWH PDUH SHQWUX IUHFYHQ H PLFL SURSULL SHULRDGHORU PDL PDUL GH XQ DQ 7

<

I

P

DFHDVWDVHPQDOHD] SUH]HQ DFLFOLFLW

LLVDXDDJUHJDWXOXLWUHQGFLFOLFLWDWH0HQ LRQ PF vQ

FD]XOvQFDUHVXQWVHPQDODWHFRPSRQHQWHRVFLODWRULLVH]RQDOLWDWHFLFOLFLWDWH QLYHOXODFHVWRUDSRDWH ILHYDOXDWSHQWUXW

SHQWUXIUHFYHQ DI V

d

=

{ } V

«XWLOL]kQGUHOD LD

ÌQ FD]XO SUH]HQWDW vQ 7DEHOXO DPSOLWXGLQHD VHPQLILFDWLY VXSHULRDU QLYHOXOXL ]HUR

i =

l

LL$FHDVWDSRDWHILHYDOXDW DVWIHO

» ± » ± + (- ) ¢ FRVª ¢ ¢ ² + - ¢ VLQª ¢ ¢ ² + ½

VHPQDOHD] SUH]HQ DVH]RQDOLW

(

+

| l h wtgvgt

(-

)

Õ

½

qsrm jgkgl x i ~ z l wLx gj kgl x i ~ | h ege y om n p e e »

) ¢ FRV ª ½

Õ

(

»

(- ) ¢ FRVª ½

| j h iutgv'w

± » ± ¢ ¢ ² + - ¢ VLQ ª ¢ ¢ ² + Õ ½ Õ

(-

)

± » ± ¢ ¢ ² + ¢ VLQª ¢ ¢ ² = Õ

½

Õ

qsrm jgkgl i i ~ l mon p gj kgl i i ~ } | i h efgfgf e e

»

) ¢ FRV ª ½

± » ± ¢ ¢ ² + ¢ VLQ ª ¢ ¢ ² = Õ ½ Õ

173

V

=

+

»

(- ) ¢ FRVª ½

± » ± ¢ ¢ ² + - ¢ VLQ ª ¢¢ ² + Õ ½ Õ

»

(- ) ¢ FRVª

½

± » ± ¢ ¢ ² + ¢ VLQ ª ¢ ¢ ² = - Õ ½ Õ

2DERUGDUHQXPHULF DUROXOXLFRPSRQHQWHORURVFLODWRULLGHIUHFYHQ

GLIHULW SRDWHILI FXW

DSHOkQG ODLQGLFDWRUXOGHQXPLWVSHFWUXOSURFHVXOXLYH]LUHOD LD $FHVWLQGLFDWRUFDGHDOWIHO úL SXWHUHD VSHFWUXOXL YH]L UHOD LD UHVSHFWLY GHQVLWDWHD VSHFWUDO YH]L UHOD LD SHUPLWDQDOL]DLPSRUWDQ HLILHF UHLFRPSRQHQWHDSURFHVXOXLDQDOL]DWSULQSULVPDFRQWULEX LHLVDOHOD GLVSHUVLDJHQHUDO DUHVSHFWLYXOXLSURFHVGHVFULVGHVHULDFURQRORJLF \

2 YDULDQW LQWHUHVDQW GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD DQDOL]HL IDFWRULORU GLQ HFRQRPLH R UHSUH]LQW

$1$/,=$ 63(&75$/

Ì1&58&,ù$7

FRQFRPLWHQW $QDOL]D FRQFRPLWHQW D RVFLOD LLORU GH

GLIHULWHIUHFYHQ HSHQWUXGRX VDXPDLPXOWHVHULLGHGDWHSRDWHILSULYLW FDRDERUGDUHDQDOLWLF SH HOHPHQWH FRQVWLWXWLYH D FRUHOD LHL GLQWUH GRX VDX PDL PXOWH IHQRPHQH FDUH HYROXHD] vQ SDUDOHO vQ WLPS ÌQWUR HWDS SUHOLPLQDU DQDOL]D VSHFWUDO vQFUXFLúDW SUHVXSXQH VWD LRQDUL]DUHD VHULLORU SULQ HOLPLQDUHD WHQGLQ HL úL D VH]RQDOLW

LL VWDELOLUHD QXP UXOXL GH EHQ]L GH IUHFYHQ

IUHFYHQ HLGHSHEDQGDMvQUDGLDQL Z

=

p ¢ M

M

P GHWHUPLQDUHD

P

ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH VH SURFHGHD] OD GHWHUPLQDUHD GLVSHUVLHL úL FRYDULDQ HL GH ODJ N N DWkWvQFDGUXOILHF UHLVHULL

s

(

=

)

FRY ( \

\

Ç \

- \

Q

)

Ç \

=

«

- \ \ Q

- \

FkWúLSHQWUXSHUHFKLGHVHULLGLQWUHFDUHXQDVHUHIHU ODYDULDELODHIHFW±\ FRY ([ \

)(

)

FRY ( \ [

)(

)

=

=

Ç [

Ç \

- [ \ Q - N

- \ [ Q - N

- \

- [

,QGLFDWRULLUHYHODWRULSHQWUXDQDOL]DVSHFWUDO vQFUXFLúDW VXQW

SXWHUHDVSHFWUXOXL I

I

(

¢

)

=

(M )

[

s

p

¢

úL I

(

)

+ ¢ FRY ([ \

FRVSHFWUXO =

F£

p

FRY([ \

©

)( ¥

¨ §

)

+

p

)( ¡

)

¢ FRV NZ

¤

¨ ¦ (FRY([ \ )( ¥ ¥Ç

)

+ FRY( \ [ )

)

) ¢ VLQ NZ

(

¥ )¢ FRVNZ£ )

FYDGUDWXUDVSHFWUXOXL T

=

p

«

ª ® (FRY ([ \ )( ¬ ¬Ç

LQGLFDWRUXOGHID] Y

Y

¯

= WDQ

±

M

- FRY ( \ [

F¯

$FHVWD SHUPLWH DSUHFLHUHD UHOD LHL GH GHSHQGHQ VLQFURQHGHIUHFYHQ

)( ¬

T¯

°

)

GLQWUH GRX VHULL DWkW vQ FD]XO GHSHQGHQ HL

MFkWúLvQFD]XOGHSHQGHQ HLDVLQFURQHHYLGHQW GXS XQGHFDODMGHID]

FRHUHQ D&

F

& = I

M

(M )

[

+T ¢I

M

(M )

\

²

)RUPXOHOHSUH]HQWDWHVHUHIHU ODYDULDQWD7XNH\+DQQLQJGHDERUGDUHDLQGLFDWRULORUDQDOL]HLVSHFWUDOH

174

$FHDVWDH[SULP LQWHQVLWDWHDFRUHOD LHLGLQWUHRVFLOD LLOHGHIUHFYHQ

MGLQWUHVHULD[úLVHULD\

SHRVFDU GHYDORULFXSULQV vQWUH]HURúLXQXDSURSLHUHDGHXQXLQGLFkQGLQWHQVLWDWHDP ULW

³

VSRUXO5

5

[\ M

=

I

(M )

[

I

¢&

M

(M )

\

$FHVWD H[SULP PHGLD FUHúWHULL RVFLOD LHL GH IUHFYHQ

M GLQ VHULD \FHUHYLQHODRFUHúWHUHFX

XQXDRVFLOD LHLGLQVHULD[ 0HWRGD FXQRVFXW VXE GHQXPLUHD GH DQDOL] $QDO\VLV´ UHSUH]LQW

XQGRPHQLXGHVFKLVFHUFHW

VSHFWUDO

vQFUXFLúDW

Ä&URVV 6SHFWUDO

ULLDSOLFDWLYHFXODUJLSRVLELOLW

LGHFXQRDúWHUHD

XQRUPHFDQLVPHHYROXWLYHvQWLPS ([HPSOX $SOLFD LD OD FDUH QH UHIHULP ´ vQ FHOH FH XUPHD] DUH GUHSW VFRS H[HPSOLILFDUHD DQDOL]HL

HYLGHQ LLQG HWDSHOH GH OXFUX vQ VLWXD LLOH vQFDUHGLVSXQHPGHGDWHUHDOHSULYLQGSURFHVHSUHVXSXVHD ILLQWHUGHSHQGHQWH 2ELHFWLYXO VWXGLXOXL FRQVW vQ DQDOL]D UHOD LLORU GH LQWHUGHSHQGHQ

GLQWUH LQYHVWL LLOH vQ

HFRQRPLH; µ úLSURGXFWLYLWDWHDPXQFLLvQLQGXVWULH<¶ FXDFFHQWHSHLQWHQVLWDWHDOHJ WXULLvQRSWLFD VLQFURQ GDU PDL DOHV DVLQFURQ ODJ GH ID] SHQWUX GLIHULWHOH FRPSRQHQWH GH IUHFYHQ

'DWHOH VH

UHIHU ODGHWULPHVWUHSULYLQGDQLVXFFHVLYL&DOFXOHSUHOLPLQDULL vQWUXFkWDPEHOHVHULLSUH]HQWDXXQHYLGHQWWUHQGOLQLDUVDvQFHSXWFXHOLPLQDUHDWHQGLQ HL

·

·

·

\

Ö = < -<

[

= ;

·

·

Ö - ;

Ö Ö XQGH ; <

·

WHQGLQ DJHQHUDO

VWDELOLUHD QXP UXOXL GH EHQ]L GH IUHFYHQ

« UHSUH]HQWkQG ó GLQ QXP UXO GH WHUPHQL

OXkQGXVH vQ FDOFXO EHQ]LOH GH IUHFYHQ $úDGDU P UHOD LHL Z

D GHFXUV I U D IRUPXOD LSRWH]H DSULRULFH

LDU IUHFYHQ HOHH[SULPDWHvQUDGLDQLSHQWUXM

M

=

¢ M

«DXIRVWRE LQXWHSHED]D

HYDOXDUHD vPSU úWLHULL vQ FDGUXO VHULLORU FURQRORJLFH VWD LRQDUL]DWH \ µ [ µ FD úL vQ YDULDQWD FRPELQDW SULQFDOFXOXOGLVSHUVLLORU s

[

s

\

úLDFRYDULDQ HORUFRY[\ FRY\[

RE LQHUHDLQGLFDWRULORUVSHFLILFLDQDOL]HLVSHFWUDOHvQFUXFLúDWH SXWHUHD VSHFWUXOXL SHQWUX FDUH VDX RE LQXW SHQWUX IUHFYHQ D YDORUL PD[LPH vQ DPEHOH VHULL I

([ )

= I

(\ )

úL D VXEPXOWLSOXOXL DFHVWHLD I

= FHHD FH LQGLF LPSRUWDQ D GHRVHELW D DFHVWHL IUHFYHQ H FD

(\ )

= I

([ )

= vQ DPEHOH VHULL &HO PDL UHGXV QLYHO DO SXWHULL

VSHFWUXOXLDIRVWRE LQXWSHQWUXIUHFYHQ DLDUSHQWUXIUHFYHQ D]HURQLYHOXODIRVWUHODWLYPDUHFHHD FHVHPQDOHD] LQFRPSOHWDHOLPLQDUHDWHQGLQ HL FRVSHFWUXO F¸ úL FYDGUDWXUD VSHFWUXOXL T¸ DX vQUHJLVWUDW PD[LPHOH I ¹oº UHVSHFWLYT ¹oº

FHHDFHLQGLF SRVLELOHFRUHOD LLGHID] OHJDWHGHUHVSHFWLYHOHIUHFYHQ H)DSWXOF

T¸ ¹SHQWUXM

«DUDW F VXQWSRVLELOHFRUHOD LLDVLQFURQHSHQWUXDVWIHOGHIUHFYHQ H

LQGLFDWRUXO GH ID] Y »

M

« D SUH]HQWDW YDORUL DSURSLDWH SHQWUX WRDWH

IUHFYHQ HOH FHHD FH FRQILUP SHUVLVWHQ D XQRU OHJ WXUL ÄvQWkU]LDWH´ GLQWUH FDUH FHD VXUYHQLW GXS SDWUXWULPHVWUHHVWHFHDPDLLPSRUWDQW FRHUHQ D&¸ DSUH]HQWDWvQXUPDFDOFXOHORURYDORDUHVHPQLILFDWLYVXSHULRDU SHQWUX M

FHHD FH LQGLF IDSWXO F FRPSRQHQWHOH FDUH GHVFULX RSW RVFLOD LL FRPSOHWH vQWUXQ LQWHUYDO VXQW

¼

( 3HFLFDQ ± Ä&URVVHG 6SHFWUDO $QDO\VLV 5HJDUGLQJ WKH &RUUHODWHG (YROXWLRQ RI (FRQRPLF 3URFHVVHV´ Ä(FRQRPLFDO

&RPSXWLQJDQG(FRQRPLFDO&\EHUQHWLFV6WXGLHVDQG5HVHDUFK´QR

175

FHOHPDLLQWHQVFRUHODWHÌQWURP VXU PDLPLF DXUH]XOWDWFRUHOD LLLQWHQVHúLSHQWUXIUHFYHQ HOH úL ÌQFKHLHP DFHVW FDSLWRO FRQVDFUDW DQDOL]HL VHULLORU FURQRORJLFH FX PHQ LXQHDF DVWIHOGHVHULL LQFOXG R PXOWLWXGLQH GH LQIRUPD LL UHOHYDQWH SHQWUX DQDOL]D SURFHVHORU GDU úL SHQWUX SURJQR]D HYROX LHLDFHVWRUD

$UVHQDOXO PHWRGRORJLF SURSXV GH VWDWLVWLF GDU PDL DOHV GH HFRQRPHWULH RIHU SRVLELOLWDWHD

GHVFRSHULULL úL XWLOL] ULL XQRU DVWIHO GH LQIRUPD LL )DSWXO F PHWRGHOH LQYRFDWH vQ FDGUXO DFHVWXL FDSLWRO VXQW UHODWLY ODERULRDVH úL GHVHRUL LPSOLF UHLWHU UL FRPSDUD LL YHULILF UL DGDSW UL úL DFWXDOL] ULQXWUHEXLHV ILHXQPRWLYGHGHVFXUDMDUHvQDSOLFDUHvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHRVHULHGHSDFKHWH GH SURJUDPH 0,&52 763 0,&52),7 6\VWDW )25(&$67352 5$76 $5$5 /2786 )25(0$1 VXQWELQHDGDSWDWHDFHVWRURELHFWLYH

%,%/,2*5$),(

%R[ * ( 3 -HQNLQV * 0 ± 7LPH 6HULHV $QDO\VLV )RUHFDVWLQJ DQG &RQWURO +ROGHQ'D\ 6DQ)UDQFLVFR

&XWKEHUWVRQ.+DOO6±$SSOLHG(FRQRPHWULFV7HFKQLTXHV:KUHDWRQV/WG

)RPE\7%5KRGHV*±$GYDQFHVLQ(FRQRPHWULFV-$,*UHVV/RQGRQ

*UDQJHU&:-±6SHFWUDO$QDO\VLVRI(FRQRPLF7LPH6HULHV3ULQFHWRQ8QLY3UHVV1<

*ULIILWKV : -XGJH * &DUWHU +LOO 5 ± /HDUQLQJ DQG 3UDFWLFLQJ (FRQRPHWULFV -RKQ :LOH\ DQG6RQV

*XMDUDWL'±%DVLF(FRQRPHWULFV0F*UDZ+LOO,QF1<

+DUYH\$&±7LPH6HULHV0RGHOV+RZHVWHU1<

-RKQVWRQ-±(FRQRPHWULF0HWKRGV0F*UDZ+LOO1<

0DGGDOD*6±,QWURGXFWLRQWR(FRQRPHWULFV0F0LOODQ3XEO

3HFLFDQ(6±(FRQRPHWULH(GLWXUD$OO%XFXUHúWL

176

&DSLWROXO; 0RGHOHHFRQRPHWULFHFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH

6FXUWLVWRULFSULYLQGDSDUL LDúLHYROX LDvQWLPSDPRGHOHORUFXHFXD LL PXOWLSOH 'HFHOHPDLPXOWHRULGHVFULHUHDIRUPDO DXQXLSURFHVHFRQRPLFQXVHSRDWHUHDOL]DQXPDL SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO XQXL PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF FRQ LQkQG R VLQJXU HFXD LH $FHVW OXFUX D LPSXV HODERUDUHD XQRU PRGHOH HFRQRPHWULFH FRQ LQkQG PDL PXOWH HFXD LL GHQXPLWH PRGHOH FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOHVDXVLPXOWDQH 0RGHODUHD PDFURHFRQRPLF FDQWLWDWLY D DS UXW SH OD VIkUúLWXO DQLORU vQ (XURSD GXS FDUHVHSURSDJ SXWHUQLFvQ68$FDUHUHFXSHUHD] úLGHYDQVHD] SUHRFXS ULOHvQDFHVWGRPHQLXGLQ (XURSD ,VWRULF SULPXO PRGHO PDFURHFRQRPHWULF FRPSOHW D IRVW FRQVWUXLW vQ GH 7LQEHUJHQ SHQWUXHFRQRPLD

ULORUGH-RV

0LúFDUHDLQL LDW DVWIHOGH7LQEHUJHQFDUHFk LYDDQLPDLWkU]LX YDFRQVWUXLúLSULPXO PRGHOSHQWUX6WDWHOH8QLWHVHYDGH]YROWDvQ68$VXEFRQGXFHUHDOXL/DZUHQFH.OHLQ ÌQHYROX LDPRGHO ULLPDFURHFRQRPHWULFHVHSRWGHOLPLWDWUHLSHULRDGH 3ULPD SHULRDG vQFHSH GLQ DQLL úL GXUHD] SkQ OD PLMORFXO DQLORU úL UHSUH]LQW R SHULRDG GHWDWRQDUHDPRGHO ULL $FHDVW SHULRDG VH vQFKHLH FX HODERUDUHD XQXL PRGHO IRDUWH LPSRUWDQW vQ LVWRULD PRGHO ULL PDFURHFRQRPHWULFH PRGHOXO .OHLQ*ROGEHUJHU FDUH SRDWH IL FRQVLGHUDW FD XQ YHULWDELO VWU PRúDOPDMRULW

LLPRGHOHORUXOWHULRUHODERUDWHvQ6WDWHOH8QLWH

2 D GRXD SHULRDG SRDWH IL FRQVLGHUDW FD vQFHSkQG FX DFHVW PRGHO úL GXUHD] SkQ OD VIkUúLWXODQLORU 3URLHFWXO PRGHOXOXL %URRNLQJV ODQVDW OD vQFHSXWXO DQLORU DFRSHU VLPEROLF DFHDVW D GRXDSHULRDG SULQP ULPHDVDGHRULPDLPXOWHHFXD LLGHFkWPRGHOXO.OHLQ*ROGEHUJHUvQ ORFGH 0RGHOXO %URRNLQJV D GHWHUPLQDW HYROX LD PRGHO ULL vQWUR PDQLHU IRDUWH LPSRUWDQW SULQ DFWLYLWDWHD GH VSHFLILFDUH úL HVWLPDUH SH FDUH R LPSOLF &X WRDWH DFHVWHD D IRVW XQ HúHF SHQWUX F PRGHOXO D I FXW GHPRQVWUD LD FRQWUDU D IDSWXOXL F XQ PRGHO QX VH OLPLWHD] OD MX[WDSXQHUHD FRPSRQHQWHORULQGLYLGXDOHRULFkWGHELQHDUILHOHVHSDUDWHFLWUHEXLHV ILHRVWUXFWXU LQWHJUDW &HD GHD WUHLD SHULRDG D PRGHO ULL FDUH vQFHSH OD VIkUúLWXO DQLORU úL GXUHD] SkQ vQ ]LOHOH QRDVWUH H FDUDFWHUL]DW GH R DFFHOHUDUH D IHQRPHQXOXL ÌQ SHULRDGD DX IRVW FRQVWUXLWH PRGHOH DOH HFRQRPLHL DPHULFDQH vQ WLPS FH vQ SHULRDGD DX DS UXW GRDU PRGHOH 0 ULPHD PRGHOHORU D FUHVFXW VHQVLELO PRGHOXO %URRNLQJV QHILLQG R H[FHS LH vQ SODQ FDQWLWDWLY DFRUGkQGXVH R LPSRUWDQ

GHRVHELW IHQRPHQHORU QRPLQDOH GHWHUPLQDUHD SUH XOXL

VHFWRUXO PRQHWDUILQDQFLDU úL PHFDQLVPHORU GLQDPLFH PHFDQLVPHOH GH DFXPXODUH PHFDQLVPHOH DQWLFLS ULORU ÌQ 6WDWHOH 8QLWH H[LVW FLUFD PRGHOH PDFURHFRQRPHWULFH PDUL FX FDUH VH OXFUHD] vQ SUH]HQW GLQWUH FDUH GRX VXQW SXEOLFH FHO DO 'HSDUWDPHQWXOXL GH &RPHU %($ úL FHO DO % QFLL )HGHUDOHGLQ6W/RXLVFDUHHXQPRGHOGHLQVSLUD LHPRQHWDULVW 3DWUXPRGHOHDSDU LQ XQRU VRFLHW

L SULYDWH GH FRQVXOWLQJFDUHúLYkQGSUHYL]LXQLOHvPSUHXQ FXDOWHVHUYLFLLGHLQIRUPDUH

HFRQRPLF 'DWD5HVRXUFHV&KDVH(FRQRPHWULFVHWF 0DULOHXQLYHUVLW

LVXQWDSURDSHWRDWHGRWDWH

FX PRGHOH DXWRQRPH GH H[HPSOX PRGHOXO :KDUWRQ DO SURI .OHLQ PRGHOXO 036 HODERUDW GH 8QLYHUVLWDWHDGLQ3HQQLV\OYDQLDPRGHOXO0,7DO5H]HUYHORU)HGHUDOH$PHULFDQHHWF

177

ÌQ (XURSD QX VD DWLQV vQF DFHVW QLYHO GDU PLúFDUHD VD GH]YROWDW FX XQ GHFDODM GH DQL ID

GH 6WDWHOH 8QLWH PRGHODUHD ILLQG PXOW PDL GLILFLO SHQWUX HFRQRPLLOH HXURSHQH FDUH VXQW

GHSHQGHQWHGHH[WHULRU ÌQ )UDQ D GHPDUDMXO PRGHO ULL PDFURHFRQRPHWULFH D IRVW PXOW PDL WDUGLY SULPHOH PRGHOH IUDQFH]HDXDS UXWVSUHVIkUúLWXODQLORU DGLF ODFLUFDGHDQLGXS GHEXWXOFHORUDPHULFDQHúL OD GH DQL GXS PRGHOXO RULJLQDO DO OXL 7LQEHUJHQ %XJHWXO HFRQRPLF D IRVW HODERUDW PXOW WLPS I U D IDFH DSHO OD PRGHOHOH H[SOLFLWH ÄPHWRGD SUHYL]LXQLL I U PRGHO LDU vQ DFWLYLWDWHD GH SODQLILFDUH QX VD GLVSXV GH XQ PRGHO PDFURHFRQRPHWULF PRGHOXO ),), GHFkW vQFHSkQGFXFHOGHDO9,OHD3ODQ ÌQFHSkQG FX DQXO PDL PXOW GH DQL PRGHODUHD PDFURHFRQRPHWULF VH YD GH]YROWD vQ )UDQ D vQ SULQFLSDO vQ FDGUXO D GRX VHUYLFLL DGPLQLVWUDWLYH 'LUHF LD GH 3UHYL]LXQH úL ,16(( ,QVWLWXWXO 1D LRQDO GH 6WDWLVWLF úL 6WXGLL (FRQRPLFH DIODWH vQWUR OHJ WXU PDL PXOW VDX PDLSX LQ VWUkQV FXSURFHGXULOHGHHODERUDUHDEXJHWHORUHFRQRPLFHúLDSODQXOXL 3ULPXO PRGHO IUDQFH] =2*2/ D IRVW FRQVWUXLW vQ ILLQG DSRL vQORFXLW GH PRGHOXO '(&$ FDUH VXQW GRX PRGHOH GH EXJHW HFRQRPLF GH LQVSLUD LH NH\QHVLVW FDUH DX U VSXQV VLWXD LHL HFRQRPLFH GLQ DFHD SHULRDG QLYHOXO FHUHULL JOREDOH úL FRQGL LLOH GH UHSDUWL]DUH D YHQLWXOXL úL RELHFWLYHORUGHSROLWLF HFRQRPLF SROLWLFDGHUHJODUHDFHUHULLJOREDOH 0RGHOXO 67$5 6FKHPD 7HRUHWLF D $FXPXO ULL úL 5HSRUWXOXL FDUH LD XUPDW vQ PRGHOXOXL '(&$ SHQWUX D DVLJXUD SUHYL]LXQHD SH WHUPHQ VFXUW UHSUH]LQW R DGDSWDUH D VWUXFWXULLPRGHOXOXLODWHRULDHFRQRPLF GHQDWXU QHRNH\QHVLVW GLQDFHDSHULRDG 0RGHOXO67$5YDILvQORFXLWGHPRGHOHOH0(75,&úL&23$,1 ÌQ DIDUD DFHVWRU PRGHOH GH EXJHW HFRQRPLF DGPLQLVWUD LLOH IUDQFH]H DX HODERUDW vQ DFHDVW SHULRDG XQPRGHOSHWHUPHQVFXUWGHVWLQDWHODERU ULLSUHYL]LXQLORUSODQXOXLPRGHOXO),), 0RGHOXO ),), QX VH PDL ED]HD] VWULFW SH WHRULD NH\QHVLVW FL HVWH DGDSWDW úL WLSXOXL GH HFRQRPLH FRQFXUHQ LDO SXQkQGXVH XQ DFFHQW GHRVHELW SH SROLWLFLOH HFRQRPLFH FDUH FRQGXF OD ULGLFDUHDFRPSHWLWLYLW ÌQ

GHFXUVXO

LLVHFWRDUHORUHFRQRPLFH DQLORU

VD

WUHFXW

GH

OD

ÄPRQRSROXO

DGPLQLVWUDWLY

OD

ÄSOXUDOLVPXO

SUHYL]LXQLORU ÌQ FDGUXO DFHVWXL SOXUDOLVP DO SUHYL]LXQLORU DX DS UXW R VHULH GH LQVWLWX LL SULYDWH GH SUHYL]LXQH FXP DU IL *$0$ *UXSXO GH $QDOL] 0DFUR(FRQRPLF $SOLFDW DO 8QLYHUVLW

LL GLQ

1DQWHUUH SUHFXP úL DOWH WUHL FHQWUH GH VWXGLX ÄH[WUDDGPLQLVWUDWLYH XQ FHQWUX XQLYHUVLWDU 2)&( 2EVHUYDWRUXO )UDQFH] DO &RQMXQFWXULORU (FRQRPLFH XQ FHQWUX ÄSDWURQDO ,3(&2'( ,QVWLWXWXO GH 3UHYL]LXQH (FRQRPLF úL )LQDQFLDU SHQWUX 'H]YROWDUHD ,QWUHSULQGHULORU XQ FHQWUX ÄVLQGLFDO ,5(6,QVWLWXWXOGH&HUFHW UL(FRQRPLFHúL6RFLDOH HWF 'HúL vQ SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF VH XWLOL]HD] PRGHOH HFRQRPHWULFH GH YROXP PDUH XQ QXP U PDUHGHHFXD LL WRWXúLvQVSHFLDOúLQXQXPDLSHQWUXvQ HOHJHUHDúLPDQLSXODUHDDFHVWRUDVHSOHDF GH OD PRGHOH FX XQ QXP U PDL PLF GH HFXD LL ÌQ DFHVW VHQV vQ FRQWLQXDUH YRU IL SUH]HQWDWH FkWHYD PRGHOHHFRQRPHWULFHFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOHGHYROXPPLFIRORVLWHGHMDvQWHRULDHFRQRPLF GDUI U R LQWHUSUHWDUH HFRQRPHWULF FDUH YRU SHUPLWH IDPLOLDUL]DUHD FX DFHVW WLS GH PRGHOH úL R WUHFHUH vQ UHYLVW DHWDSHORUSDUWLFXODULW

LORUúLDVHPQLILFD LLLORUHFRQRPHWULFHSHFDUHOHRIHU DFHVWHD

([HPSOHGHPRGHOHFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH ,0RGHOXOVWDWLFDOOXL.H\QHV

Å& W = D + E9 W , 9 =& + , W W ® W

+X

()

W

( )

,,0RGHOXOGLQDPLFDOOXL.H\QHV

= D <

Å& ¿

,, ,

¿ < ®

= E< =&

()

+X + E <

+ ,

+*

+X

( ) ()

XQGH

< 9

3,%VDXYHQLWXOQD LRQDOVDXYHQLWXOSHRIDPLOLH

178

&

FRQVXPXO ILQDO VDX FRQVXPXO ILQDO DO SRSXOD LHL VDX FRQVXPXO SH R

IDPLOLH

,

LQYHVWL LLVDXHFRQRPLLLQYHVWL LL I FXWHGHRIDPLOLH

*

FKHOWXLHOLSXEOLFHFRQVXPXOILQDODODGPLQLVWUD LHLSXEOLFH

X

YDULDELO DOHDWRDUH

W = 7

SHULRDGDGHWLPSREVHUYDW

,,,0RGHOXOGHVFULHULLHFRQRPHWULFHDIRUP ULLSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUX

Å 3W

=D +E 2

,,, 3 W

= a + b&

¿

¿ & ® W

=2

+X

W

+X

W

()

W

( )

W

()

W

,90RGHOXOGHVFULHULLOHJLLFHUHULLúLDRIHUWHL

Å2 W

¿ ,9 &

W

¿ & ® W

=D

=E

+X

+E 3

+E 9

=2

+ D 3

W

W

()

W

+X

W

( )

W

()

W

XQGH 2

RIHUWDSURGXVXOXL

&

FHUHUHDSURGXVXOXL

3

SUH XOSURGXVXOXL

9

YHQLWXOFRQVXPDWRULORU

90RGHOSULYLQGRSWLPL]DUHDUDWHLDFXPXO ULLVDXUDWDLQYHVWL LLORU ÅHI ¿

W Y

¿5 W 9 ¿& ¿ 9 ®

= DU

W

= HI

W

+ EU ¢U W

=&

W

+ ,

W

= DU

W

= ( - U

W

+X

W

W

) ¢9 W

(

()

W

+ EU

W

¢ + DU

W

+X

W

+ EU

W

)+ X

W

( ) W

()

( )

XQGH U =

9

=

HI

5

,

= UDWDDFXPXO ULLVDXDLQYHVWL LLORU

9 - 9

=

= HILFLHQ DLQYHVWL LLORU

, 9

-9

= ULWPXOGHFUHúWHUHDYHQLWXOXLQD LRQDO

9

9,0RGHOSULYLQGGHVFULHUHDHFRQRPHWULF DP ULPLLúLGLQDPLFLLFRQVXPXOXLSRSXOD LHL Å& ¿ ¿ ¿

,

=D =E

+E9

=F

9, ,P S ¿ ¿

3

¿9 ®

=G

+D9

=&

+ D & +E 9

+F 9

+G + ,

(9

+F

-9

+ ([S

()

+X

+X 3

( )

+X

)+X

- ,P S

()

( )

+*

()

XQGH ,PS

LPSRUWXO

179

3

SUH XO UHODWLY DO SURGXVHORU LQWHUQH UDSRUWDW OD SUH XO SURGXVHORU GH SH SLD DH[WHUQ

([S

H[SRUWXO

9,,0RGHOXOGHVFULHULLVSLUDOHLSUH XULORUDLQIOD LHL úLDVDODULLORU

Å, ¿

=D

9,,

¿6 ®

=E

+D 6

+E ,

()

+X

+E :

( )

+X

VDX

Å, ¿

9,,,

¿6 ®

=D =E

+D 6

+E ,

+ D ,

+E :

()

+X +E 6

XQGH

,

6

VDODULXOPHGLX

:

SURGXFWLYLWDWHDPXQFLL

W

S

( )

+X

LQGLFHOHFRVWXOXLYLH LL

0RGHOHOH GH PDL VXV DX PDL PXOW XQ URO GLGDFWLF (OH SRW IL IRORVLWH vQV DWkW vQ VFRSXUL H[SOLFDWLYHHXULVWLFH VDXFKLDUGHFL]LRQDOHÌQSUDFWLFDHFRQRPLF ODQLYHOXOHFRQRPLLORUQD LRQDOH VHIRORVHVFvQJHQHUDOPRGHOHGHGLPHQVLXQLPDUL±VXWHVDXFKLDUPLLGHHFXD LL 8Q PRGHO FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH GHVFULH ILH WRWDOLWDWHD WLSXULORU GH UHOD LL HFRQRPHWULFH ± UHOD LL GH FRPSRUWDPHQW HFRQRPLF GH LGHQWLWDWH LQVWLWX LRQDOH VDX WHKQRORJLFH ± ILH GRDU DQXPLWH WLSXUL FD GH H[HPSOX PRGHOXO ,, HVWH IRUPDW GLQWUR HFXD LH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW VRFLRORJLF GLQWUR HFXD LHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWILQDQFLDU úLGLQWURHFXD LHGHLGHQWLWDWH 'HUH LQXWF vQWUXQDVWIHO GHPRGHOYDULDELOHOHHQGRJHQHSRWMXFDúLUROúLGHYDULDELOHH[SOLFDWLYH 9DULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH VXQW FHOHYDULDELOHFDUHDSDUQXPDLvQSDUWHDVWkQJ DHFXD LLORULDUFHOH H[RJHQHDSDUQXPDLvQSDUWHDGUHDSW DDFHVWRUD $VWIHO PRGHOXO ,, HVWH IRUPDW GLQ WUHL YDULDELOH HQGRJHQH & 9 úL , úL GLQ GRX YDULDELOH H[RJHQH 9 "! úL * $FHVWH WLSXUL GH PRGHOH VH FRQVWUXLHVF PDL vQWkL VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO 8Q PRGHOFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOHHVWHVXEIRUP VWUXFWXUDO DWXQFLFkQGUHSUH]LQW GHVFULHUHDIRUPDO DXQHL WHRULLHFRQRPLFHFXSULYLUHODSURFHVXOVDXVLVWHPXOHFRQRPLFDQDOL]DW'HFHOHPDLPXOWHRULIRUPD VWUXFWXUDO

D

XQXL

PRGHO

HFRQRPHWULF

VH

GHGXFH

GLQ

VFKHPD

ORJLF

D

GHSHQGHQ HORU

úL

LQWHUGHSHQGHQ HORUGLQWUHIHQRPHQHOHFHGHILQHVFSURFHVXOHFRQRPLFGHVFULVGHPRGHO 'HH[HPSOXPRGHOXO, SRDWHILUHSUH]HQWDWVXEXUP WRDUHDIRUP

9#

&#

,#

)LJXUD

0RGHOXO9,,, SRDWHILIXQGDPHQWDWSHRVFKHP GHIRUPD

180

,S#

6#

,S#'$"%

:#

6# $&%

)LJXUD

0RGHOHOHFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOHVHSRWFRQVWUXLVDXSRWILvQWkOQLWHVXEGRX IRUPH PRGHOHFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQH PRGHOHUHFXUVLYH

)RUPDVWUXFWXUDO

úLIRUPDUHGXV

DXQXLPRGHOFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQH

8Q PRGHO HFRQRPHWULF FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH VH HODERUHD] VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO DGLF HO UHSUH]LQW WUDQVSXQHUHDIRUPDO DWHRULHLHFRQRPLFHUHIHULWRDUHODSURFHVXOHFRQRPLFLQYHVWLJDWSULQ LQWHUPHGLXOXQXLVLVWHPGHHFXD LL )RUPD VWUXFWXUDO HVWH IRUPD LQL LDO D PRGHOXOXL DúD FXP D UH]XOWDW vQ XUPD HWDSHL GH VSHFLILFDUHUHSUH]LQW VWUXFWXUDHOHPHQWHúLFRQH[LXQL SURFHVXOXLGHVFULV (WDSD GH VSHFLILFDUH FRQVW vQ DOHJHUHD YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH úL VWDELOLUHD QXP UXOXL GH HFXD LL GLQ IRUPD VWUXFWXUDO DOHJHUHD QXP UXOXL GH YDULDELOH IDFWRULDOH FRQVLGHUDWH GHWHUPLQDQWH SHQWUX HYROX LD ILHF UHLD GLQWUH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH VWDELOLUHD IRUPHL ILHF UHL HFXD LL GH UHJUHVLH GHILQLUHDUHOD LLORUGHLGHQWLWDWHGDF H[LVW ÌQJHQHUDOXQPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOHGHVFULHILHWRWDOLWDWHDWLSXULORUGHUHOD LL HFRQRPHWULFH±UHOD LLGHFRPSRUWDPHQWHFRQRPLFGHLGHQWLWDWHLQVWLWX LRQDOHVDXWHKQRORJLFHILH GRDUDQXPLWHWLSXUL ÌQWUXQ DVWIHO GH PRGHO YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH SRW MXFD URO úL GH YDULDELOH H[SOLFDWLYH 9DULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH VXQW FHOH FDUH DSDU QXPDL vQ SDUWHD VWkQJ D HFXD LLORU PRGHOXOXL LDU FHOH H[RJHQHDSDUQXPDLvQSDUWHDGUHDSW DDFHVWRUD )RUPD JHQHUDO D XQXL PRGHO HVWH IRUPD vQ FDUH WRDWH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH VXQW vQ DFHODúL WLPS úL YDULDELOH H[RJHQH ÌQ JHQHUDO PRGHOHOH FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH VXQW UHSUH]HQWDWH GH DFHOH PRGHOH FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH vQ FDUH WRDWH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH DSDU vQ WRDWH HFXD LLOH PRGHOXOXL ÌQ XQHOH FD]XUL SDUWLFXODUH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH DSDU QXPDL vQ DQXPLWH HFXD LL QHUHVSHFWkQG R DQXPLW UHJXO RDQXPLW RUGLQHvQVXFFHVLXQHDHFXD LLORUPRGHOXOXL 6XEIRUP JHQHUDO XQPRGHOFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQHvQIRUP VWUXFWXUDO VHSUH]LQW DVWIHO \ E

W

+E

\

W

\

+ \

+E

W

+E

W

\

W

\

W

+ + E

Q

+ + E

\

Q

QW

\

+F

QW

+F

[

+F

W

[

W

+F

[

+ + F

W

[

W

P

+ + F

[

P

=X

PW

[

PW

W

=X

W

E

Q

\

W

+E

Q

\

W

+E

Q

\

W

+ + \

QW

+F

Q

[

W

+F

Q

[

W

+ + F

QP

[

PW

=X

QW

XQGH W = 7 7 L = Q Q

QXP UXOSHULRDGHORUREVHUYDWH QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQH\ (

M = P P

E()

QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH[)

SDUDPHWULL YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH L = Q M = P GDU SHQWUX L

M Ü E ( )

DGLF

QXP UXOSDUDPHWULORUYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHHVWHHJDOFXQQ

181

SDUDPHWULL YDULDELOHORU H[RJHQH [* M = Q DIHUHQ L YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH \ ( L = Q DO

F()

F URUQXP UHVWHHJDOFXQ¢P 1RWkQGFX

» ª +., ªE

% =

ª

ª ª E0 , ½

E,"+

E+/+

E, 0

E+&-

E+ 0

E0 +

± ² ² ²

PDWULFHD SDUDPHWULORU E 1 2 DWDúD L YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH GH

² ² Õ

GLPHQVLXQHQQ úLDYkQGQQ SDUDPHWULLQHFXQRVFX LFHYRUWUHEXLHVWLPD L

< =

» \7 4 ± ª ² 6 ª \ 4 ² ª

²

YHFWRUXOYDORULORUYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHGHGLPHQVLXQHQ

ª ² ª ² \ 354 ½ Õ

& =

» F ;/; ª :.; ªF ª

F ;":

F; 9

F :/:

F: 9

ª ª F8 ; ½

F8 :

F 8&9

± ² ² ²

PDWULFHD SDUDPHWULORU F 1 2 GH GLPHQVLXQH Q P úL DYkQG Q¢P

² ² Õ

QHFXQRVFXWH

» [ W ª ;

=

ª [ ª

ª ª [ ½

8 =

W

PW

» X? = ± ² ª > ªX = ² ª

²

± ² ² ²

YHFWRUXOYDORULORUYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQH[2 GHGLPHQVLXQHP

² ² Õ

PDWULFHDYDORULORUYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUHX 1 GHGLPHQVLXQHQ

ª ² ª ² X <5= Õ ½ 0RGHOXO vQ IRUP JHQHUDO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH SUH]HQWDW VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO VFULV VXE IRUP PDWULFHDO GHYLQH

%<&;

8

$ UH]ROYD XQ PRGHO GHILQLW GH UHOD LD vQVHDPQ D HVWLPD FHL QQ SDUDPHWUL E 1 2 úL FHLQ¢PSDUDPHWULF 1 2 8QSURFHGHXFODVLFGHDHVWLPDFHL>QQ Q¢P@SDUDPHWULLFRQVW vQDSOLFDUHD GLUHFW D 0&003 6H SRDWH GHPRQVWUD vQV F DSOLFDUHD 0&003 ILHF UHL HFXD LL vQ SDUWH FRQGXFH

OD

RE LQHUHD

GH

HVWLPDWRUL

GHSODVD L

QHVHPQLILFDWLYL

'LQ DFHVW PRWLY HVWLPDUHD

SDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQHQXVHIDFHSHED]DH[SULP ULLOXLVXEIRUP VWUXFWXUDO FLSHED]DIRUPHLUHGXVHDDFHVWXLD )RUPD UHGXV D XQXL PRGHO VWUXFWXUDO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH SUHVXSXQH FD WRDWH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH DOH PRGHOXOXL vQ IRUP JHQHUDO V ILH H[SULPDWH QXPDL vQ IXQF LH GH YDULDELOHOH H[RJHQH DOHDFHVWXLD 3RUQLQG GH OD UHOD LD IRUPD UHGXV D PRGHOXOXL VWUXFWXUDO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH VH A

@ RE LQHSULQvQPXO LUHDODVWkQJDFXLQYHUVDPDWULFHL%% A A

<% @

&;

% @

8

5H]ROYDUHD PRGHOXOXL vQ IRUP UHGXV FRQVW vQ DSOLFDUHD 0&003 ILHF UHL HFXD LLDDFHVWXLDÌQDFHVWVHQVVHIDFXUP WRDUHOHVXEVWLWXLUL

182

% @

$ M = P

=

% @

A

A

& ± PDWULFHD $ DYkQG GLPHQVLXQHD Q¢P úL FRQ LQkQG D 1 2 HOHPHQWH L = Q

8±YHFWRUXOFRORDQ DYDULDELOHLDOHDWRDUH

$VWIHOIRUPDUHGXV DPRGHOXOXLGHYLQH $;=

<

ÌQ XUPD DSOLF ULL 0&003 PRGHOXOXL vQ IRUP UHGXV VH YRU RE LQH YDORULOH FHORUQ¢PHVWLPDWRULk 1 2 UHVSHFWLYHOHPHQWHOHPDWULFHLÆGHGLPHQVLXQHQ¢P Ö »D ª Ö $ Ö =

Ö ªD ª

EFE

Ö E5D D

K DÖ E B

DGE

Ö DFD D

K DÖ D

± ² ² B

ª ªD Ö C E ½

Ö C D D

K DÖ C B

²

² ² Õ

,GHQWLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXL (WDSD LGHQWLILF ULL HVWH RSHUD LD SULQ FDUH VH UHYLQH OD IRUPD VWUXFWXUDO SOHFkQG GH OD IRUPD UHGXV D PRGHOXOXL GHRDUHFH QXPDL VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO PRGHOXO DUH VHPQLILFD LH HFRQRPLF (VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU IRUPHL VWUXFWXUDOH SH ED]D HVWLPDWRULORU IRUPHL UHGXVH VH QXPHúWH LGHQWLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQHvQIRUP UHGXV 0DWULFHDO DFHDVW RSHUD LH SUHVXSXQH HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PDWULFHL % úL DL PDWULFHL & E 1 2 úLF 1 2 vQQXP UGH>QQ Q¢P@SRUQLQGGHODQ¢PSDUDPHWULLHVWLPD LDLPDWULFHL$k H * FXQRFX L% @ A ¢&

ÆDGLF HVWLPDUHDD>QQ Q¢P@SDUDPHWULLQHFXQRVFXWH GLVSXQkQGGHQ¢PHFXD LLFHHDFH

PDWHPDWLFQXHSRVELO'HDLFLDSDUWUHLVLWXD LL 'DF QXP UXO ]HURXULORU GLQ PDWULFHOH % úL & HVWH HJDO FX QQ UHVSHFWLY GDF vQ PDWULFHOH % úL&H[LVW QQ ]HURXULDWXQFLPRGHOXOHVWHMXVWLGHQWLILFDWDGLF QXP UXOHFXD LLORU Q¢P HVWH HJDO FX QXP UXO QHFXQRVFXWHORU >QQ Q¢P@ ± VLVWHP GH HFXD LL XQLF GHWHUPLQDW 3ULQ DSOLFDUHD 0&003 DVXSUD IRUPHL UHGXVH D PRGHOXOXL UH]XOW HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU DFHVWHLD SHED]DF URUDVHGHWHUPLQ SDUDPHWULLIRUPHLVWUXFWXUDOH 'DF vQ PDWULFHOH % úL &H[LVW XQQXP UGH]HURXULPDLPDUHGHFkWQQ PRGHOXOHVWH VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH H[LVW PDL PXOWH HFXD LL GHFkW QHFXQRVFXWH ÌQ DFHVW FD] HVWLPDWRULL PRGHOXOXLVHFDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXO0&003DSOLFDWHvQPDLPXOWHVWDGLL 'DF vQ PDWULFHOH % úL & H[LVW XQ QXP U GH ]HURXUL PDL PLF GHFkW QQ PRGHOXO HVWH QRQLGHQWLILFDELO GHFL H[LVW PDL SX LQH HFXD LL GHFkW QHFXQRVFXWH QX YRU SXWHD IL FDOFXOD L WR L FHL >QQ Q¢P@SDUDPHWULLE 1 2 úLF 1 2 GLVSXQkQGGHQXPDLQ¢PYDORULk 1 2 UHVSHFWLYGHQ¢PHFXD LLÌQDFHVW FD]PRGHOXOLQL LDOYDWUHEXLUHFRQVWUXLW 8Q PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO SRDWH IL DOF WXLW GLQ HFXD LL FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDWHGLQHFXD LLVXSUDLGHQWLILFDWHúLGLQHFXD LLQRQLGHQWLILFDWH GDF XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH DUH R VLQJXU HFXD LH QRQLGHQWLILFDW PRGHOXO vQ DQVDPEOXOV XHVWHQRQLGHQWLILFDELO(OYDWUHEXLUHFRQVWUXLWVDXVHYDUHQXQ DODXWLOL]DUHDVD GDF XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH DUH R VLQJXU HFXD LH VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW PRGHOXO vQ DQVDPEOXOV XHVWHVXSUDLGHQWLILFDW XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH HVWH MXVW LGHQWLILFDW GDF WRDWH HFXD LLOH VDOH VXQW FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDWH 3RUQLQG GH OD DFHVWH FRQVLGHUHQWH VH SRW IRUPXOD FkWHYD UHJXOL SULYLQG LGHQWLILFDUHD XQXL PRGHOFXHFXD LLVWUXFWXUDOH GDF QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH GLQWUR HFXD LH HVWH HJDO FX QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQHPLQXVXQXQ DWXQFLHFXD LDHVWHFRUHFWLGHQWLILFDW

183

GDF QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUDEVHQWHGLQWURHFXD LHHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWQXP UXOYDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQHPLQXVXQXDWXQFLHFXD LDHVWHVXSUDLGHQWLILFDW GDF QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH GLQWUR HFXD LH HVWH PDL PLF GHFkW QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQHPLQXVXQXDWXQFLHFXD LDHVWHQRQLGHQWLILFDELO 'HúLWHRUHWLFLGHQWLILFDUHDXQXLPRGHOFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQHVHSRDWHIDFHILHSHED]DHFXD LHL A

PDWULFHDOH $

% @

& ILH SH ED]D GLVFX LHL ILHF UHL HFXD LL vQ SDUWH vQ SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF VH

XWLOL]HD] XOWLPD YDULDQW 0HWRGD GLVFX LHL ILHF UHL HFXD LL HVWH PDL VLPSO PDL UDSLG úL vQ SOXV SHUPLWH GHSLVWDUHD HFXD LHL VDX HFXD LLORU QRQLGHQWLILFDELOH FDUH GHJHQHUHD] PRGHOXO FKLDU vQ HWDSDGHFRQVWUXLUHDDFHVWXLD

0HWRGHGHHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQH (VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUXQXLPRGHOFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQHVHSRDWHUHDOL]DFXGLYHUVHPHWRGHvQ XUP WRDUHOHFD]XUL GDF PRGHOXO VWUXFWXUDO HVWH UHFXUVLY IRUPD VWUXFWXUDO FRLQFLGH FX IRUPD UHGXV ILH VH DSOLF 0&003GLUHFWILHF UHLHFXD LLDPRGHOXOXLVWUXFWXUDOILHPHWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

LLPD[LPH

GDF PRGHOXO VWUXFWXUDO QX HVWH UHFXUVLY WUHEXLH DGXV OD IRUPD UHGXV DSDU XUP WRDUHOH VLWXD LL PRGHO QRQLGHLQWLILFDELO HVWLPDUHD LPSRVLELO DSDUDPHWULORUPDWULFHORU%úL&VH FRQVWUXLHúWHXQQRXPRGHO PRGHO MXVW LGHQWLILFDW VH SRDWH DSOLFD PHWRGD UHJUHVLHL LQGLUHFWH úL 0&003 vQ GRX ID]H PRGHO VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW VH SRDWH DSOLFD 0&003 vQ GRX ID]H VDX vQ WUHL ID]H PHWRGD YHURVLPLOLW

LL PD[LPH FX LQIRUPD LH OLPLWDW ± PHWRGD FRPLVLHL &RZOHV PHWRGD

YDULDELOHORULQVWUXPHQWDOHPHWRGDYHURVLPLOLW

LLPD[LPHFXLQIRUPD LHFRPSOHW

ÌQPRGFXUHQWSHQWUXXOWLPHOHGRX FD]XULVHXWLOL]HD] XUP WRDUHOHPHWRGH

PHWRGDUHJUHVLHLLQGLUHFWH

0&003DSOLFDW vQGRX ID]H

0&003DSOLFDW vQWUHLID]H 0HWRGD UHJUHVLHL LQGLUHFWH VH DSOLF QXPDL vQ FD]XO PRGHOHORU FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDWH &X

DMXWRUXO DFHVWHLD VH HVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULL IRUPHL UHGXVH D PRGHOXOXL SULQ DSOLFDUHD 0&003 ILHF UHLHFXD LLvQSDUWHGXS FDUHSHED]DDFHVWRUDVHHVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULLIRUPHLVWUXFWXUDOH 0&003 vQ GRX

ID]H SUH]HQWDW GH + 7KHLO vQ VH SRDWH XWLOL]D OD HVWLPDUHD

SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH DWkW vQ FD]XO PRGHOHORU VXSUDLGHQWLILFDWH FkW úL vQ FD]XOPRGHOHORUFRUHFWLGHQWLILFDWH$SOLFDW vQDFHVWXOWLPFD]DFHDVW PHWRG FRQGXFHODUH]XOWDWH LGHQWLFHFXFHOHRE LQXWHFXDMXWRUXOPHWRGHLUHJUHVLHLLQGLUHFWH (VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH FX 0&003 vQ GRX ID]H SUHVXSXQHHIHFWXDUHDXUP WRDUHORURSHUD LL

)D]D , VH UHJUHVHD] ILHFDUH YDULDELO HQGRJHQ DPRGHOXOXLQXPDLvQIXQF LHGHYDULDELOHOH H[RJHQH DOH DFHVWXLD VH HVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULL DFHVWRU HFXD LL FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 úL VH FDOFXOHD] YDORULOH WHRUHWLFH DMXVWDWH VDX HVWLPDWH DOH YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH SH ED]D HFXD LLORUUHVSHFWLYH

)D]D ,, vQ HFXD LLOH IRUPHL VWUXFWXUDOH D PRGHOXOXL vQ FDUH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH DSDU FD YDULDELOH H[RJHQHVHYRULQWURGXFHYDORULOHDFHVWRUDHVWLPDWHvQ)D]D,VHYDDSOLFDGLQQRX 0&003 HFXD LLORU VWUXFWXUDOH úL VH YRU RE LQH HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL FX HFXD LLVLPXOWDQH

0&003 vQ WUHL ID]H D IRVW SURSXV GH $ =HOOQHU úL + 7KHLO $FHDVWDSUHVXSXQHvQWUR SULP HWDS DSOLFDUHD0&003vQGRX ID]HvQYHGHUHDXQHLHVWLP ULSUHOLPLQDUHDSDUDPHWULORU

184

IRUPHL VWUXFWXUDOH GXS FDUH VH HIHFWXHD] R UHHVWLPDUH SH DQVDPEOX D PRGHOXOXL SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO 0&003 JHQHUDOL]DWH $XWRULL DX GHPRQVWUDW F DFHDVW PHWRG HVWH PDL HILFLHQW GHFkW 0&003vQGRX ID]HGDUHPDLVHQVLELO ODHURULOHGHVSHFLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXL )D]D,

)LHPRGHOXO ,

%<&;

,,

<

8IRUPDVWUXFWXUDO

$;=IRUPDUHGXV

VHFRQVLGHU SULPDHFXD LHDPRGHOXOXLvQIRUP VWUXFWXUDO FDUHVHPDLSRDWHVFULHDVWIHO

\

= -E

W

\

W

-E

\

W

- - E

Q

\

-F

QW

[

W

-F

[

W

- - F

P

[

PW

+X

W

9DULDELODHQGRJHQ \ IKJ VHPDLSRDWHVFULHDVWIHO

\

= - (E

W

K E

»\ ª

Q

)ª

W

M

ª \ ½

QW

± ²

² - (F ² Õ

K F

P

» [ W ª

± ²

ª [ ½

² Õ

)ª

M

PW

² + X W

VDXPDWULFHDO

= -E L ë < - F Lë ; + 8 L

VHHVWLPHD] \MNJ «\O.P UH]XOWkQGYDORULOHDMXVWDWHDOHYDULDELOHLHQGRJHQH

<

]

)D]D,, ÌQHFXD LD VHvQORFXLHúWH
(<Ö

)

= -E Q ë

+ ] - F Që ; + 8 Q Ü
<S

Ö S ; + h S = -E S ë < - F ë

Ö = -ER ë < - F Rë ; + (8 R

- ER ë ] )

VHFDOFXOHD] YDORULOHHVWLPDWHDOHYDULDELOHLUH]LGXDOH]

Ö =< ]

Ö -<

VHHVWLPHD] PDWULFHDYDULDQ HORUúLFRYDULQ HORUUH]LGXXULORU W » Ö X T Ö X T ] Ö W T Ö X T ] Ö T ± Ç] Ç] Ç] ª T ² T T U

K

ª ª ª ª

Ö W =

7

ª

² ²

O W

Ö W T Ç] T

ª

Ö W KKK Ç ] T

T ] Ö

O

ª

T U

M O

ª ª

M O

ª

Ö Ç] TVU

ª ª

² ²

² ² ²

M

²

T

²

W

½

²

² ² Õ

)D]D,,, ùWLLQG F < ; úL 8 VXQW YHFWRUL IRUPD L GLQ 7 HOHPHQWH VXE IRUP PDWULFHDO < Y YD IL GH IRUPD

= : Z ¢ 'Z

+8 Z

XQGH

:Y

PDWULFHDGHILQLW SOHFkQGGHODYDULDELOHOH<[ «; Y5\^]

'Y

PDWULFHDGHILQLW SOHFkQGGHODSDUDPHWULLE _ ` úLF _ ` FHXUPHD] DILHVWLPD L

$FHDVW UHOD LH HVWH YDODELO úL vQ FD]XO FHORUODOWH YDULDELOH HQGRJHQH UH]XOWkQG DVWIHO XUP WRUXOVLVWHPGHHFXD LL

185

Å< ¿ ¿<

=:

=:

¢ '

+8

¢ '

+8

M

¿

¿< ®

=:

Q

Q

¢ '

+8

Q

Q

$FHVWDVHPDLSRDWHVFULHúLPDWULFHDODVWIHO

»< ª ª< ª

M

ª ª < ½

Q

»: ª

± ² ² ² ² ² Õ

=

ª ª ª ª ½

± »' ± ² ª ²

:

² ª' ²

² ª

O :

Q

²

M

»8 ª +

² ª ² ² ª ² ' Q Õ Õ ½

ª8 ª

²

Q

² ² Õ

M

ª ª 8 ½

± ² ²

VDX <

:'8

6HHVWLPHD] DSRLJOREDOPDWULFHDSDUDPHWULORU'FXDMXWRUXO0&003JHQHUDOL]DW

(

Ö - Ö ' = : ëW :

)

-

(:

Ö - ëW <

)

Ö ' HVWHHVWLPDWRUXORE LQXWSULQ0&003vQWUHLID]H

'H UH LQXW F WRDWH PHWRGHOH GH HVWLPDUH D SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SH LSRWH]HOH GH DSOLFDUH D 0&003 ÌQ DFHVW VHQV vQ WRDWH HWDSHOH VDX ID]HOH GH DSOLFDUH D 0&003 VH YD UHDOL]D GLVFX LD HFRQRPHWULF D ILHF UHL HFXD LL SULYLQG DFFHSWDUHD VDX QRQDFFHSWDUHDLSRWH]HORUYHULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLHVWLPDWRULORUúLDPRGHOXOXLUHVSHFWLY

([HPSOHGHPRGHOHFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQH &D]XO0RGHOFRUHFWLGHQWLILFDWPRGHOXOVWDWLFDOOXL.H\QHV )LHPRGHOXO,

Å& W = D + E9 W , 9 =& + , W W ® W 6HPQLILFD LDHFRQRPLF

+X

W

()

( )

Y DPRGHOXOXL

YHQLWXO XQHL IDPLOLL HVWH XWLOL]DW SHQWUX FRQVXP úL SHQWUX LQYHVWL LL HFRQRPLL VDX 3,% HVWHGHVWLQDWFRQVXPXOXLILQDOúLLQYHVWL LLORUYH]LHFXD LD FRQVXPXO XQHL IDPLOLL FRQVW GLQ FRQVXPXO DXWRQRP VDX VWRFXULOH GH EXQXUL H[LVWHQWH OD vQFHSXWXO SHULRDGHL W H[SULPDW GH D úL GLQ FKHOWXLUHD XQHL S U L GLQ YHQLWXO RE LQXW vQ SHULRDGD W YH]LHFXD LD 'HUHJXO D!LDU E [] E =

& 9

UDWDPDUJLQDO DFRQVXPXOXLvQIXQF LHGH

YHQLW VDX 3,% UHVSHFWLY FX Fk L OHL FUHúWH FRQVXPXO XQXL SURGXV JUXSH GH SURGXVH VDX FRQVXPXO WRWDODOIDPLOLHLGDF YHQLWXOFUHúWHFXOHXFRQVXPXOúLYHQLWXOILLQGH[SULPD LvQOHL 'LVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF

DPRGHOXOXL

$FHVWPRGHOHVWHFRQVWLWXLWSHED]DDWUHLYDULDELOHGRX YDULDELOHHQGRJHQH& a úL9 a Q

úL R YDULDELO H[RJHQ , a (FXD LD GHVFULH R UHOD LHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWHFRQRPLFLDUHFXD LD

RUHOD LHGHLGHQWLWDWHHFRQRPLF RUHOD LHFRQWDELO

b

3HQWUX R DQDOL] HFRQRPLF DP QXQ LW D PRGHOXOXL VWDWLF DOOXL.H\QHVYH]L-0.H\QHV7HRULDJHQHUDO DIRORVLULL

PkLQLLGHOXFUXDGREkQ]LLúLDEDQLORU(GLWXUDùWLLQ LILF %XFXUHúWL3$6DPXHOVRQ/ (FRQRPLTXHWRPH /LEUDLULH$UPDQG&ROLQ3DULV

186

0RGHOXO , HVWH XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH ILJXUkQGúLFDYDULDELOHH[RJHQHvQHFXD LLOHDFHVWXLD 'LVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF DDFHVWXLDVHSRDWHIDFHSHGRX F L

SHED]DGLVFX LHLPRGHOXOXLJHQHUDOVWUXFWXUDO

SHED]DGLVFX LHLILHF UHLHFXD LLDPRGHOXOXL 0RGHOXO, VFULV VWUXFWXUDO VXE IRUP

JHQHUDO

ILJXUHD] vQWRDWHHFXD LLOHPRGHOXOXL±GHYLQH

Å , ®

& -&

- E ¢9

W

+

W

9

-D ¢;

W

+ ¢;

W

+ ¢, -

,

=8

W

=8

W

()

( )

± WRDWH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH úL H[RJHQH

'H UH LQXW F DWXQFL FkQG vQ HFXD LLOH DOHDWRDUH DOH PRGHOXOXL DSDUH XQ WHUPHQ OLEHU SDUDPHWUXOÄD´GLQHFXD LD DFHDVWDvQVHDPQ F DSDUHRYDULDELO H[RJHQ ILFWLY ; c FDUHHVWH XQYHFWRUFRORDQ XQLWDU

;

» ± ª ²

= ª

M²

ª ² ½ Õ

(FXD LDPDWULFHDO FRUHVSXQ] WRDUHPRGHOXOXL, VXEIRUP VWUXFWXUDOJHQHUDO HVWH %<&;

8

XQGHPDWULFLOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHVXQW

» % = ª ª ½-

-E ± ² ² Õ

»& W = ª ª 9 ½ W

<

»- D & = ª ª ½

± ² ² Õ

± ² ² - Õ

;

»; = ª ª , ½ W

± ² ² Õ

8

»X = ª ª X ½

± ² ² Õ

6XEIRUP UHGXV ±DGLF YDULDELOHOHHQGRJHQHVXQWUHJUHVDWHQXPDLvQIXQF LHGHYDULDELOHOH H[RJHQH±PRGHOXOPDWULFHDOGHPDLVXVVHWUDQVIRUP vQ Y Y <%d Â& Â; %d Â8 XQGH e

%

e

f

%

=

f

» ª ª -E ½

E± ² ² Õ

»- D ¢& = ª ª -E ½- D

-E± ² ² - Õ

1RWkQGFX

$ = -%

-

»a ¢& = ª ª a ½

b b

± ² ² Õ

a =

D -E

b

=

E -E

b

=

-E

=

= %

-

¢8

PRGHOXOVXEIRUP UHGXV GHYLQH <$Â;

=

3ULQDSOLFDUHD0&003FHORUGRX HFXD LLDOHPRGHOXOXLUHGXV

Å& i 9i ®

= a + bh , i

+ ] i

= a + bg , i

+ ] i

()

( )

VHHVWLPHD] SDUDPHWULLPDWULFHL$ »a Ö Ö $ = ª ª Ö a ½

Ö b

Ö b

± ² ² Õ

,GHQWLILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL, SUHVXSXQH HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PDWULFHORU % úL & $FHDVW RSHUD LHVHGHGXFHGLQ a =

D -E

b

=

E -E

b

=

-E

UHVSHFWLY

187

Ö D

Ö = a

Ö b

Ö E

=

Ö b

Ö -E

Ö a Ö b

Ö ÜE =

Ö -E

=

Ö = ÜD

Ö b

Ö b

Ö -E

'HRDUHFH WR L SDUDPHWULL PRGHOXOXL VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO DX SXWXW IL HVWLPD L UH]XOW F PRGHOXO, HVWHMXVWLGHQWLILFDW $FHHHDúL FRQFOX]LH VDU IL RE LQXW úL SULQ DQDOL]D HOHPHQWHORU PDWULFHORU % úL & 'DF DFHVWH PDWULFHDUILDYXWWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHQHQXOHDUILUH]XOWDWRSWSDUDPHWULFHDUILWUHEXLWHVWLPD LSHED]D SHED]DFHORUSDWUXWHUPHQLDLPDWULFHL$'HRDUHFHPDWULFHOH%úL&DXGRLWHUPHQLQXOLUHVSHFWLY QÂPQ

P

VHGHGXFHF PRGHOXOHVWHMXVWLGHQWLILFDW

'LVFX LD HFRQRPHWULF D PRGHOXOXL SH ED]D ILHF UHL HFXD LL VH D[HD] QXPDL SH HFXD LLOH DOHDWRDUHDOHPRGHOXOXLVWUXFWXUDO(FXD LD ILLQGGHWLSFRQWDELOVWDUHDPRGHOXOXLHVWHGDW QXPDL GHVWUXFWXUDHFXD LHL $FHDVW HFXD LHFRQ LQHGRX YDULDELOH& j úL9 j OLSVLQGXQD, j 'HRDUHFHvQ FDGUXO HFXD LHL QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH XQX HVWH HJDO FX QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH PLQXV XQX Q ±

±

HFXD LD HVWH FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDW PRGHOXO VWUXFWXUDO , ILLQG XQ

PRGHOFRUHFWLGHQWLILFDW 3DUDPHWULL XQXL PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH MXVW LGHQWLILFDW SRW IL HVWLPD L ILH FX DMXWRUXO PHWRGHLUHJUHVLHLLQGLUHFWHILHFXDMXWRUXO0&003DSOLFDW vQGRX ID]H (VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXL, SULQPHWRGDUHJUHVLHLLQGLUHFWH $SOLFDUHD DFHVWHL PHWRGH FRQVW vQ HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU HFXD LLORU IRUPHL UHGXVH FX 0&003GXS FDUHXUPHD] RSHUD LDGHLGHQWLILFDUH±HVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUIRUPHLVWUXFWXUDOH SHED]DHVWLPDWRULORUIRUPHLUHGXVH )RUPD UHGXV

D XQXL PRGHO VWUXFWXUDO FRQVW vQ UHJUHVDUHD YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH QXPDL vQ

IXQF LH GH YDULDELOHOH H[RJHQH DOHDFHVWXLD2E LQHUHDIRUPHLUHGXVHDPRGHOXOXL, UH]XOW vQXUPD HIHFWX ULLXUP WRDUHORURSHUD LL D VHLQWURGXFHHFXD LD vQHFXD LD RE LQkQGXVHHFXD LD &

W

= D + E & D

=

&k

6HQRWHD] FX a =

b l

D -E

=

=

] m

-E

-E

-E

+X

W

,k

+

W

= D + E&

-E

Xk

W

+ E,

W

+X

W

E

+ , E

+

-E

W

= YDULDELO DOHDWRDUH KRPRVFHGDVWLF LQGHSHQGHQW FH XUPHD]

Xm

RGLVWULEX LHQRUPDO GHPHGLH]HURúLDEDWHUHPHGLHS WUDWLF sn

FW

6HRE LQHDVWIHOHFXD LD &

W

=a + b ,

W

+ ]

W

E VHLQWURGXFHHFXD LD vQHFXD LD UH]XOWkQGHFXD LD 9o

6HQRWHD] FX b q

9r

= D + E9 o

=

-E

+ Xo

+ , o Ü 9p

=

D - E

+

- E

,p

+

- E

Xp

úLVHRE LQHHFXD LD

= a + bs ,r

+ ] r

188

F PRGHOXO, VFULVVXEIRUP UHGXV

= a +b ,

Å& W 9 ®

= a +b

W

,

W W

+ ]

t

()

W

+ ]

VHSUH]LQW DVWIHO

( )

W

Ö Ö 3ULQ DSOLFDUHD 0&003 HFXD LLORU úL VH YRU RE LQH HVWLPDWRULL Ö a b u úL b v

DL

SDUDPHWULORUab w úLbx G LGHQWLILFDUHDPRGHOXOXLFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQH, SUHVXSXQHHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUDúLESH Ö Ö ED]DYDORULORUHVWLPDWRULORU Ö a b y úL b v

(VWLPDUHDDFHVWRUDVHGHGXFHGLQQRWD LLOHHIHFWXDWHDQWHULRU

Ö b

Ö D

Ö = a

Ö b

Ö -E

=

=

Ö = ÜD

Ö E

Ö a Ö b

Ö ÜE =

Ö -E Ö -E

Ö b

Ö b

Ö úL EÖ D H vQ ILQDO VH YRU HIHFWXD FDOFXOHOH QHFHVDUH YHULILF ULL VHPQLILFD LHL HVWLPDWRULORU D

VHPQLILFD LHLPRGHOXOXLúLDLQGHSHQGHQ HLHURULORU (VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXL, FXDMXWRUXO0&003DSOLFDW

vQGRX

ID]H

)D]D0RGHOXOFRQ LQHGRX YDULDELOHHQGRJHQH& j úL9 j úLRVLQJXU YDULDELO H[RJHQ , j GDU QXPDL YDULDELOD 9 j HVWH úL YDULDELO H[RJHQ vQ HFXD LD $FHDVWD VH YD UHJUHVD QXPDL vQ IXQF LHGHYDULDELODH[RJHQ , j = F + G ,z

9 z

+ Zz

&X DMXWRUXO 0&003 VH YRU HVWLPD SDUDPHWULL F úL G 3H ED]D YDORULORU HVWLPDWH DOH DFHVWRUDúLDYDORULORUYDULDELOHL, j VHYRUHVWLPDYDORULOHOXL9 j

Ö Ö + G ,{ = F

Ö 9 {

Ö )D]DÌQHFXD LD DPRGHOXOXL, VHYRULQWURGXFHYDORULOHHVWLPDWH 9| &

W

Ö = D + E9

W

+X

W

3DUDPHWULLDúLEYRUHVWLPD LFXDMXWRUXO0&003GXS FDUHVHYRUFRQWLQXDFDOFXOHOHvQ

Ö YHGHUHDDFFHSW ULLPRGHOXOXLRE LQXW &

W

Ö Ö Ö +E =D 9

W

&D]XO±0RGHOVXSUDLGHQWLILFDWPRGHOXOGLQDPLFDOOXL.H\QHV

= D <

Å& ¿

,, ,

= E<

¿ < ®

=&

()

+X + E~ < }

+ ,

+X~

( ) ()

+*

XQGH

<j

3,%VDXYHQLWXOQD LRQDO

&j

,j

*j

FKHOWXLHOLSXEOLFHFRQVXPXOILQDODODGPLQLVWUD LHLSXEOLFH

X j

YDULDELO DOHDWRDUH

D w E w Ex

FRQVXPXOILQDODOSRSXOD LHL LQYHVWL LL

SDUDPHWULLPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULFFHXUPHD] DILHVWLPD L

)RUPD UHGXV D PRGHOXOXL VWDWLF DO OXL .H\QHV DUH R VHPQLILFD LH FXQRVFXW vQ WHRULDHFRQRPLF (DSHUPLWHR

GHILQLUH ULJXURDV úL R H[SOLFDUH ORJLF D FRQFHSWHORU GH DFFHOHUDWRU b w úL GH PXOWLSOLFDWRU bx UHVSHFWLY LQIOXHQ D LQYHVWL LLORUDVXSUDFUHúWHULLFRQVXPXOXLúLDFUHúWHULLYHQLWXOXLVDX3,%XOXL

189

7UHFHUHD GH OD IRUPD VWUXFWXUDO OD IRUPD UHGXV SUHVXSXQH RE LQHUHD XQXL QRX PRGHO vQ FDUH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH VH UHJUHVHD] GHSLQG QXPDL vQ IXQF LH GH YDULDELOHOH H[RJHQH 3ULQ VLPSOH RSHUD LL DOJHEULFH HIHFWXDWH DVXSUD HFXD LLORU DOH PRGHOXOXL ,, VH DMXQJH OD PRGHOXO,,)5 VXEIRUP UHGXV VHvQORFXLHVFvQHFXD LD H[SUHVLLOHOXL& j , j GLQHFXD LLOH úL = D <

<

+ X

< ( - D - E

Ü<

) = E <

E

=

+ E <

+ X

+ *

+ * + X + X

< +

- D + E

+ E <

* +

- D - E

X + X

- D - E

H[SUHVLDRE LQXW SHQWUX< VHvQORFXLHúWHvQSULPHOHGRX HFXD LLDOHPRGHOXOXL &

=

Ü&

=

=

,

Ü ,

D E - D

- E

D E - D

- E

<

+

- D

- D

+

<

- E

(

E

=

+

D - D

)

- E

<

- E

D - D

E E - D

<

- E

E - D

*

+

*

+

+

*

- E E

+

- D

- E

+ D X

D X

+X

- D X

+ D X

E

(X

+X

- D

)

+ E X

- D

+E <

- E

X

+

*

- E

- E X

- E

- E X

- D

- D X

- D X

- E

+X

'HFLPRGHOXOVXEIRUP UHGXV VHSUH]LQW DVWIHO Å &¢ ¿

D E ¡

=

- D

¿

¿ ,,)5 , ¢ ¿ ¿

- D

- E

E¡

=

¢ ¿< ®

- E

( - D )

E¡

=

< ¢

- D

+ E

D

+

< ¢

+

< ¢

+

- D

- E

E - D

- E

- D

- E

*¢

+

*¢

+

*¢

+

+ D X ¡

X

- D

- E X - E

+ E X

X¡

- D X

- D X ¡ - E

+X¡

- D

- E

1RWkQGFX E£

=

U¤

P§

=

=

Q©

=

X

- D¦

- D¨

( - D ¨ )

- D¨

=

- E¨

Eª - Dª

¯ ¯ +E X

-D ²

+X

- D ²

¯

¯ -D X

³

-E ²

E§ - D¨

- E¨

-

E§ D¨ - D¨

- E¨

= U¨

- D ¨ U¨

= U¨

( - D ¨ )

¬ = ] « ®

= ]

¯

= ]

= E¥ P ¥

= E ª U©

- Eª

-E

= D ¦ E ¥ U¥

= D ¨ U§

- E¨

¬ ¬ ¬ ¬ + D X -E X ¬ ¬ - D -E

®

X

= D ¦ U¦

- E¦

D¨

E§

Q¨

= E £ U£

¿

D¦ E ¥

=

¬

¤ µÜ U

- E¤ ¿ Ý

- D¤

P¦

X

¿ ¿

- E¤

=

U£

´

- D¤

±

®

°

190

XQGH] ´Kµ ]¶Nµ ]·¸µ

YDULDELOHDOHDWRDUH

ÌQXUPDHIHFWX ULLvQORFXLULORUPRGHOXO,,)5 vQIRUP UHGXV GHYLQH º Å& ¾ = P ½ < ¾ ¹ ½ + P ¼ * ¾ + ] ¾ ½ º ¿ ¿ ,,)5 , ¾ = Q ½ < ¾ ¹ ½ + Q ¼ * ¾ + ] ¾ ¼

( )

( )

¿ ¾ ¿9 ®

= U½ < ¾ ¹ ½

+ U¼ * ¾

( ) º

+ ] ¾ »

6HPQLILFD LDHFRQRPLF

DPRGHOXOXL,,

$FHVWD VH IXQGDPHQWHD] SH DFHOHDúL SUHPLVH HFRQRPLFH FD úL PRGHOXO , GDU SULQ VHSDUDUHD FRQVXPXOXL vQ GRX FRPSRQHQWH & µ

FRQVXPXO SRSXOD LHL úL * µ

FKHOWXLHOL

JXYHUQDPHQWDOHVDXFRQVXPXOVWDWXOXL DUHDSOLFDELOLWDWHQXPDLODQLYHOPDFURHFRQRPLF ÌQSOXVID

GHPRGHOXO, SULQLQWURGXFHUHDYDULDELOHLGHFDODWH< µ ¿"´ ±3,%XOGLQSHULRDGD

WUHFXW FDS W XQ DVSHFW GLQDPLF FHHD FH vO IDFH DSW QX QXPDL SHQWUX VFRSXUL H[SOLFDWLYH FL úL SHQWUXVLPXO ULúLSURJQR] (FXD LD DPRGHOXOXLDUHVXSRUWHFRQRPLFGHRDUHFHGHFHOHPDLPXOWHRULLQYHVWL LLOHGLQ SHULRDGDFXUHQW VXQWILQDQ DWHGLQYHQLWXULOHSHULRDGHLWUHFXWH 'LVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF

DPRGHOXOXL

0RGHOXO,, FRQ LQHWUHLQ

YDULDELOHHQGRJHQH& µ , µ úL< µ úLGRX YDULDELOHH[RJHQH< µ ¿

´ úL * µ (FXD LD GHVFULH R UHOD LH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW VRFLDO HFXD LD R UHOD LH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW

ILQDQFLDULDUHFXD LD RUHOD LHFRQWDELO 0RGHOXO ,, HVWH XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO GHRDUHFH WRDWH YDULDELOHOHHQGRJHQHVXQWúLYDULDELOHH[RJHQHvQHFXD LLOHPRGHOXOXL (FXD LD HVWH VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH HVWH HJDO FX WUHL QXP UVXSHULRUQXP UXOXLGHYDULDELOHHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQX!Q±

(FXD LD HVWH FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH HVWH HJDO FX

GRLúLHVWHHJDOFXQXP UXOGHYDULDELOHHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQX 'HRDUHFH

PRGHOXO

FRQ LQH

R

HFXD LH

GH

LGHQWLWDWH

Q±

XQD

±

FRUHFW

LGHQWLILFDW

úL

DOWD

VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW HVWH VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW LDU HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU IRUPHL VWUXFWXUDOH VH YD IDFH FX DMXWRUXO0&003vQGRX ID]H (VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUPRGHOXOXLVXSUDLGHQWLILFDWSHED]D0&003vQGRX

ID]H

)D]D, 9DULDELOD < µ HVWH VLQJXUD YDULDELO HQGRJHQ FDUH vQ HFXD LLOH úL HVWH úL YDULDELO H[RJHQ &DDWDUHHDYDILUHJUHVDW vQIXQF LHGHFHOHGRX YDULDELOHH[RJHQH< µ ¿"´ úL* µ = UÃ <À Ä Ã

<À

(VWLPDWRULL Ö U úL Ö U

+ UÂ * À

+ ]Á À

YRU IL GHWHUPLQD L FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 LDU SH ED]D YDORULORU

DFHVWRUDYRUILHVWLPDWHYDORULOHWHRUHWLFHDOHYDULDELOHL< µ

Ö <Å

Ö Ç <Å È Ç = U

ÖÆ * Å + U

¶¶

)D]D,,

Ö ÌQ HFXD LLOH úL DOH PRGHOXOXL VWUXFWXUDO ,, VH YRU LQWURGXFH YDORULOH DMXVWDWH <É RE LQkQGXVHHFXD LLOH

& ,

W

W

Ö =D<

Ö =E <

W

W

+X

W

+E <

¶¶

+X

¶¶

W -

W

191

3ULQ DSOLFDUHD 0&003 HFXD LLORU ¶¶ úL ¶¶ YRU IL HVWLPD L SDUDPHWULL PRGHOXOXL Ì ÖË ÖÊ Ö Ë E VWUXFWXUDO D E úLDSRLYDXUPDWHVWDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLDFHVWRUD

(

)

&D]XO ± 0RGHO QRQLGHQWLILFDELO GHVFULHUHD OHJLL FHUHULL úL D OHJLL RIHUWHL XQXL DQXPLW vQSHULRDGDW W = 7

SURGXVSHRDQXPLW SLD

Å2 W

¿ ,,, &

W

¿ & ® W

=D =E

=2

+D 3

+X

+E 3

+E 9

W W

()

W

W

+X

W

W

( ) ()

XQGH 2

RIHUWDSURGXVXOXL

&

FHUHUHDSURGXVXOXL

3

SUH XOSURGXVXOXL

9

YHQLWXOFRQVXPDWRULORU

6HPQLILFD LDHFRQRPLF

DPRGHOXOXL

0RGHOXO SUH]HQWDW PDL VXV GHVFULH vQ PRG ILGHO WHRULD HFRQRPLF SULYLQG FRPSRUWDPHQWXO DJHQ LORUHFRQRPLFLúLDOFRQVXPDWRULORU (FXD LD DUDW F SURGXF WRULLvúLP UHVFRIHUWDSHP VXU FHFUHúWHSUH XOSURGXVXOXLD ´

!

(FXD LD H[SULP FRUHOD LD LQYHUV GLQWUH FHUHUH úL SUH E ´ VDWLVIDFHUHDQHYRLORUFRQVXPDWRULORUSULQYDORDUHDOXLE¶ Ê EÍ

úL LPSRUWDQ D RIHUWHL vQ

Ê

(FXD LD UHOHY HFKLOLEUXO FH WUHEXLH V VH PDQLIHVWH SH SLD D SURGXVXOXL SHQWUX D DQLKLOD WHQGLQ HOH FRQWUDUH DOH FUHúWHULL SUH XOXL VSRULUHD RIHUWHL úL GLPLQXDUHD FHUHULL WHQGLQ H FDUH DU GXFH ODGLVWUXJHUHDSLH HLUHVSHFWLYODIDOLPHQWXOSURGXF WRULORUSULQGLVSDUL LDFHUHULL 'LVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF

DPRGHOXOXL

0RGHOXO ,,, HVWH XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO FDUH FRQ LQH GRX YDULDELOHHQGRJHQH& µ

2 µ

4 µ

YROXPXOSURGXF LHLFHWUHEXLHV H[LVWHSHSLD Î

SUH XOGHYkQ]DUHDOSURGXVXOXL úLRYDULDELO H[RJHQ 9 µ

3µ

úL

YHQLWXOFRQVXPDWRULORU

3DUDPHWULL D ´ E ´ úL E¶ UHSUH]LQW UDWHOH PDUJLQDOH DOH RIHUWHL vQ IXQF LH GH SUH DOH FHUHULL vQ IXQF LHGHSUH XOSURGXVXOXLúLvQIXQF LHGHYHQLW (FXD LD HVWH FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH XQX HVWH HJDO FXQXP UXOYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQX

Q±

±

(FXD LD HVWH QRQLGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH ]HUR HVWH PDL PLF GHFkWQXP UXOYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQXQ±

±

0RGHOXO ,,, FRQ LQkQG R HFXD LH FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDW úL XQD QRQLGHQWLILFDELO HVWH XQ PRGHO QRQLGHQWLILFDELO DGLF vQ HWDSD GH LGHQWLILFDUH QX YRU SXWHD IL HVWLPD L WR L SDUDPHWULL IRUPHL VWUXFWXUDOH (VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO QRQLGHQWLILFDW VH IDFH DWkW FkW HVWH SRVLELO FX DMXWRUXO PHWRGHL UHJUHVLHL LQGLUHFWH ÌQ DFHVW VFRS PRGHOXO VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO WUHEXLH DGXV OD IRUPD UHGXV )RUPDUHGXV

DPRGHOXOXL,,,

3RUQLQGGHODHFXD LD UH]XOW F

Ü D Ò

+ D Ñ 3Ï + X Ñ Ï

= EÒ

+ EÑ 3Ï + EÐ 9Ï + X Ð Ï

Ó

0RGHOXO ,, SUH]LQW LQWHUHV PDL DOHV WHRUHWLF úL VXE IRUP UHGXV 'DU vQ DFHVW FD] HVWLPDWRULL IRUPHL

VWUXFWXUDOHQXYRUDYHDVROX LLXQLFH

Ô

'HúL DSDUHQW vQ HFXD LLOH PRGHOXOXL ,,, 3 Õ DSDUH QXPDL FD YDULDELO H[RJHQ HFXD LD UHOHY R UHDOLWDWH

HFRQRPLF ±FXPS UDUHDXQXLSURGXVGHSLQGHvQSULPXOUkQGGHYHQLWXOFHORUFDUHDXQHYRLHGHHO

192

- DØ

EØ

Ù

Ü3 =

D

Ö

E×

+

Ö -E

D

Ö 9 -E

Ö

Ù

+

D

Ö

Ö -E

Ù

X ×

-X

6HLQWURGXFHHFXD LD vQHFXD LD & µ 2

W

Ü 2 Ý

Ü2á

=E

=

=

Ú

Ü E D

Þ à -E D

à Þ E D

D

« E - D

E + 9 + W Ã D -E D -E D ¬ Ú Ú Ú Ú Ü Ü Ü Û -E E +E E -E D E E Ú Ú + D -E

+E

-E Þ

Þ ß D E

+

Þ

D Þ

-E Þ

9á

+

Þ

2 µ

-E

4 µ

X

W

-X

Ú Ú Û Û + D E -E E Ú Ú D -E

Þ Þ -E X á

Þ ß D X á

D

Ö Ù

-E Þ

W

9Ý

á ³ ã

+E 9

+

W

Ú Û E X Ý

+X

W

Ú Ú -E X Ý

D

Ú

Ú Û +D X Ý Ú -E

Ú Û -E X Ý

1RWkQGFX Eâ

- Dâ

Dã

- Eã Eå

= aâ

=aä

D ä - Eä

X å æ - X ä æ = ] ä æ ±YDULDELO DOHDWRDUH

D ä - Eä Eç D è

- Eè D ç

é ê D E

D é

= bç

- Eè

Dè

-E é

=b

D è X æ - Eè X è æ D è - Eè

é

= ] æ ±YDULDELO DOHDWRDUH

0RGHOXOVXEIRUP UHGXV YDILGHIRUPD

Å 3W = a + a 9 W + ] W ,,,)5 2 =b +b9 + ] W W ® W

()

( )

3DUDPHWULL a ë a ì b ë b ì VH HVWLPHD] FX DMXWRUXO PHWRGHL FHORU PDL PLFL S WUDWH DSOLFDW

Ö Ö Ö í a Ö î b ï úL b ð HVWLPDWRULLDFHVWRUSDUDPHWULRE LQX LFX0&003 ILHF UHLHFXD LLvQSDUWH)LH a ,GHQWLILFDUHD PRGHOXOXL ,,, ± HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL VWUXFWXUDO ± SUHVXSXQH FDOFXODUHDYDORULORUFHORUFLQFLSDUDPHWULLQHFXQRVFX LD ñ D ò E ñ E ò Eó SHED]DDSDWUXHVWLPDWRUL

Ö Ö Ö í a Ö î b ï úL b ð XWLOL]kQGUHOD LLOH FXQRVFX L a Öõ a

=

Öö a

=

Ö bõ

=

Ö bø

=

Eõ

- Dõ

Dô

- Eô

E÷ - Eö

Dö

Eõ D ô Dô

- Eô D õ

- Eô

D ø Eø - Eø

Dø

ÌQ OLSVD XQHL DOWH UHOD LL vQWUH SDUDPHWULL PRGHOXOXL VWUXFWXUDO GLQ FHOH SDWUX UHOD LL GH PDL VXVQXYDSXWHDILHVWLPDWGHFkWSDUDPHWUXOD ù D ú Eú D ú - Eú

Eû D ú - Eú

=

Ö bú Öú a

Öú Ü D

=

Ö bú Öú a

193

ÌQ SUDFWLFD HFRQRPLF XQHRUL vQ FD]XO PRGHOHORU QRQLGHQWLILFDELOH HVWLPDWRULL PRGHOXOXL VWUXFWXUDO VH GHWHUPLQ FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 DSOLFDW GLUHFW HFXD LLORU DFHVWRUD 'DU GH FHOH PDL PXOWHRULHVWLPDWRULLRE LQX LQXVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHUL LGH]HUR

0RGHOHUHFXUVLYH 6SUH GHRVHELUH GH PRGHOHOH FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH FDUH SHUPLW GHVFULHUHD UHOD LLORU GH LQWHUGHSHQGHQ

GLQWUH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH DOH XQXL SURFHV VDX VLVWHP HFRQRPLF PRGHOHOH

UHFXUVLYH FRQVWDX vQ FRQVWUXLUHD XQRU HFXD LL FDUH VH vQO Q XLHVF ORJLF YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH GLQ HFXD LLOH SUHFHGHQWH GHYLQ YDULDELOH H[RJHQH vQ HFXD LLOH XUP WRDUH DGLF YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH UHVSHFW RDQXPLW UHJXO RDQXPLW RUGLQHvQWUDQVIRUPDUHDORUvQYDULDELOHH[RJHQH 6XE IRUP JHQHUDOL]DW XQ PRGHO UHFXUVLY HVWH GHVFULV DMXWRUXO XUP WRUXOXL VLVWHP GH HFXD LL

\ÿ +

Å

+ Fÿ/ÿ [ÿ + Fÿ"þ [þ

K

¿ þ.ÿ ÿ þ ¿E \ + \

+

K

+

+ Fÿ ý

K

+ Fþ.ÿ [ÿ + Fþ/þ [þ

+

K

+ Fü ÿ [ÿ + Fü þ [þ

+

= Xÿ

[ý

+ Fþ ý

[ý

= Xþ

K

+ Fü&ý

[ý

= Xü

F

± » [ ² ª

¿ ¿Eü ÿ \ÿ + Eü þ \ þ ®

+

+ \ü

K

FDUHVXEIRUP PDWULFHDO GHYLQH

» ª ªE ª

± » \ ² ª

K K

ª ª E ½

VDX %< &;

E

(

² ª \ ¢ ² ª

K

)

² ²

M

² ª ² ª \ Õ ½ (

»F ª

± ²

² ² Õ

)

+

ªF

F

F

ª

K K

F

ª ªF F F ½

K

(

)

² ª[ ²¢ª

² ²

M

² ª ² ª [ Õ ½ (

»X ª

± ²

² ² Õ

)

=

ªX ª

± ²

² ²

M

ª ª X ½ (

² ² Õ

)

8 XQGH PDWULFHD % HVWH R PDWULFH WULXQJKLXODU DGLF WR L SDUDPHWULL PDWULFHL %

VLWXD LGHDVXSUDGLDJRQDOHLSULQFLSDOHDDFHVWHLDVXQWQXOLE

SHQWUXM!

ÌQ DFHVW FD] VH SRDWH GHPRQVWUD F HVWLPDWRULL UH]XOWD L LQ XUPD DSOLF ULL GLUHFWH D

0&003 ILHF UHL HFXD LL D PRGHOXOXL UHFXUVLY VXQW QHGHSODVD L FRQYHUJHQ L úL HILFDFH GDF SRW IL DFFHSWDWH LSRWH]HOH SH FDUH VH IXQGDPHQWHD] 0&003 UHVSHFWLY F PHWRGD YHURVLPLOLW

LL

PD[LPH vQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH FRQVW vQ HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU HFXD LLORU VWUXFWXUDOH FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 3RUQLQG GH OD IRUPD JHQHUDO D XQXL PRGHO UHFXUVLY VH SRW HODERUD PXOWLSOH IRUPH WHRUHWLFH SDUWLFXODUHFXPDUILGHH[HPSOX 0RGHOXO$

= D [ + D [

Å \ ¿

\

¿ \ ®

= \ + \ = E \

()

+ X

( )

+ [

+ E [ + E [

+ X

( )

0RGHOXO$FRQ LQHWUHLYDULDELOHHQGRJHQH\ ù \ \ Q

úLWUHLYDULDELOHH[RJHQH[ ù [

[ (FXD LD ILLQG R HFXD LH GH LGHQWLWDWH I U SDUDPHWULL GH HVWLPDW QX QHFHVLW R GLVFX LH HFRQRPHWULF (FXD LD HVWH R HFXD LH VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH WUHLHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWQXP UXOYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQX!Q±

±

LDUHFXD LD

194

HVWH FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH ± GRL HVWH HJDO FX QXP UXO YDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQX

Q±

±

$FHVW PRGHO ILLQG XQ PRGHO VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW HVWLPDWRULL V L YRU WUHEXL GHWHUPLQD L FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 vQ GRX ID]H GDU R DQDOL] HFRQRPHWULF D PRGHOXOXL VWUXFWXUDO $ YD UHOHYD F DFHVWD HVWH XQ PRGHO UHFXUVLY úL FD DWDUH HVWLPDWRULL DFHVWXLD SRW IL FDOFXOD L FX R PHWRG PDL VLPSO ±0&003DSOLFDW GLUHFWFHORUGRX HFXD LLVWUXFWXUDOH úL $VWIHOGDF HFXD LD VHLQWURGXFHvQHFXD LD DFHDVWDGHYLQH \

= E

\ + \

+ X Ü ( - E

+ [ + E [ + E [

)\

-E \

-E [

-E

[

-E

[

=X

0RGHOXO$GHVFULVSHED]DHFXD LLORU úL VHWUDQVIRUP vQ

Å ®

\

+

- E \

- D [

K + - E \

- E [

- D [

- E [

+

=X

K

- E [

=X

FDUHVXEIRUP PDWULFHDO VHSUH]LQW DVWIHO

» ª ª - E ½

± »\ ²¢ª ² ª \ Õ ½

- E

± »-D ² + ª ² ª - E Õ ½

0DWULFHD%GLQHFXD LDPDWULFHDO %<&;

» % = ª ª -E ½

- D - E

- E

»[ ± ª ² ¢ª[ ² Õ ª [ ½

± ²

»X ² = ª ª X ½ ² Õ

± ² ² Õ

8ILLQGRPDWULFHWULXQJKLXODU HVWHGHIRUPD

± ² ² - E Õ

UH]XOW F PRGHOXO$GHVFULVGHFHOHWUHLHFXD LLVWUXFWXUDOHDOHPRGHOXOXLHVWHXQPRGHOUHFXUVLY 0RGHOXO%

Å \

E \ ®

+

K+D

+ \

[

=X

+D

[

()

=X

( )

0RGHOXO % HVWH XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO FRQVWUXLW SH ED]D D WUHL YDULDELOHGRX HQGRJHQH\ ù \ Q

úLXQDH[RJHQ [ ù

'DF DFHVWDHVWHWUDWDWFDXQPRGHOFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQHUH]XOW F

HFXD LD HVWH FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULELOHORU DEVHQWH HVWH HJDO FX QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQX

HFXD LD HVWH QRQLGHQWLILFDW GHRDUHFH QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH ]HUR HVWH PDL PLF GHFkWQ±

'DWRULW HFXD LHL PRGHOXO % HVWH XQ PRGHO QRQLGHQWLILFDELO DGLF QX YDSXWHDILHVWLPDW GHFkW SDUDPHWUXO D ù 'DU GDF VH YD SOHFD GH OD IRUPD JHQHUDO D PRGHOXOXL VWUXFWXUDO VH YD FRQVWDWDF %PDWULFHDSDUDPHWULORUYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHHVWHRPDWULFHWULXQJKLXODU

Å \ + ¢ \ E \ + ® » ª ª E ½

\

± » \ ² ¢ª ² ª \ Õ ½

+ D [

= X

+ D [

= X

± » D ²+ª ² ª D Õ ½

%<&;

± ² ¢ [ ² Õ

()

( )

» X =ª ª X ½

± ² ² Õ

8

0RGHOXO % ILLQG XQ PRGHO UHFXUVLY HVWLPDWRULL DFHVWXLD SRW IL FDOFXOD L FX DMXWRUXO 0&003DSOLFDW GLUHFWFHORUGRX HFXD LLVWUXFWXUDOH

195

([HPSOHGHPRGHOHHFRQRPHWULFHUHFXUVLYH ([LVW QXPHURDVH FD]XUL vQ FDUH XUPkQG WHRULD HFRQRPLF D XQXL SURFHV VDX VLVWHP HFRQRPLF GHSHQGHQ HOH úL LQWHUGHSHQGHQ HOH GLQWUH IHQRPHQHOH HFRQRPLFH SRW IL GHVFULVH FX DMXWRUXOPRGHOHORUGHDFHVWWLSFDGHH[HPSOX 0RGHOXO, (VWLPDUHDOHJLLFHUHULLXQXLDQXPLWSURGXV

Å\

\

¿

¿ \ ®

=D

+ D [

=E =F

+E \

+F

\

+X

()

+X +F

( )

[

+X

()

0RGHOXOVHPDLSRDWHVFULHDVWIHO

Å

\

¿

- E \ ¿ ®

-D

+ \

-F

\

-E

+ \

-D [

=X

=X

-F

-F

[

=X

()

( ) ()

LDUVXEIRUP PDWULFHDO

» ª

ª-E

-F

ª ½

± ²

»\ ª

² Õ

ª \ ½

² ¢ ª \

± ²

»- D ª

- D

² + ª- E

² Õ

ª -F ½

-F

± ²

» ª

± ²

»X ª

² Õ

ª [ ½

² Õ

ª X ½

² ¢ª[

² = ªX

± ²

² ² Õ

%<&;

8

6HPQLILFD LDHFRQRPLF

DPRGHOXOXL

FRVWXO XQLWDU GH SURGXF LH \ ù GHSLQGH vQ PRG HYLGHQW GH YROXPXO SURGXF LHL DFHVWXLD [ ù 'LQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH HFRQRPLF FRVWXO DU WUHEXL V VFDG SHP VXUDFUHúWHULLSURGXF LHLFDXUPDUHD FKHOWXLHOLORUFRQVWDQWHD úLD ù !

SUH XOGHYkQ]DUH\ HVWHGHWHUPLQDWvQPRGKRW UkWRUGHFRVWXOXQLWDUGHSURGXF LH\ ù E ù FHUHUHD SURGXVXOXL \ HVWH LQIOXHQ DW QHJDWLY GH SUH XO GH YkQ]DUH \ F ù

GHYHQLWXULOHFRQVXPDWRULORU[ F

úL SR]LWLY

!

'LVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF

DPRGHOXOXL

0RGHOXO , HVWH XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH VXE IRUP VWUXFWXUDO DYkQG FLQFL YDULDELOH WUHL HQGRJHQH \ ù \ \ úL GRX H[RJHQH [ ù úL [ ÌQO Q XLUHD FDX]DO GLQWUH YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH

ILLQG VXFFHVLY PRGHOXO HVWH GH WLS UHFXUVLY $FHDVW FRQFOX]LH UH]XOW úL GLQ DQDOL]D PDWULFHL %

» ª

PDWULFHDSDUDPHWULORUYDULDELOHORUHQGRJHQHFDUHHVWHWULXQJKLXODU % = ª - E

ª ½

-F

± ²

²

² Õ

$FHVW PRGHO ILLQG XQ PRGHO UHFXUVLY SDUDPHWULL V L SRW IL HVWLPD L FXDMXWRUXO0&003 DSOLFDW ILHF UHLHFXD LLDPRGHOXOXLVWUXFWXUDO 0RGHOXO,, (VWLPDUHDOHJLLRIHUWHLXQXLSURGXVDJULFRO

196

Å\ ®

\

=D

W W +

=E

+D \

+E \

+X

W W

+E

W

( \ W +

- \

W

) + X W

()

( )

6HPQLILFD LDHFRQRPLF

DPRGHOXOXL,,

0RGHOXO ,, GHVFULH OHJHD RIHUWHL SH ED]D UHOD LLORU GH LQWHUGHSHQGHQ RIHUW \" (FXD LD UHSUH]LQW UHOD LD FODVLF D OHJLL RIHUWHL D !

GLQWUH SUH \ ! úL

! LDU HFXD LD VH

IXQGDPHQWHD] SH LSRWH]D GH DQWLFLSDUH D SUH XOXL GH F WUH SURGXF WRULL DJULFROL ÌQ DFHVW GRPHQLX UHDF LDSURGXF WRULORUDJULFROLODHYROX LDSUH XULORUHVWHvQJHQHUDOGHXQDQ'HH[HPSOXVXSUDID D FDUH YD IL vQV PkQ DW FX JUkX vQ DQXO W GHSLQGH GH SUH XO GLQ DFHO DQ GDU úL GH LQIRUPD LLOH SH FDUH OH SRVHG SURGXF WRULL LQIRUPD LLOH GLQ GRPHQLXO UHVSHFWLY SULYLQG DEDWHULOH GLQWUH SUH XULOH HIHFWLYHS #

$%!

úLSUH XULOHDQWLFLSDWHS #

'LVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF

DPRGHOXOXL,,

$FHVW PRGHO HVWH XQ PRGHO FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH DYkQG SDWUX YDULDELOH GRX HQGRJHQH \ !&# úL

\"'#

$%!

úLGRX H[RJHQH[ !

\"'# úL["

\ !&#

\"'#

$%!

GDUDFHDVWDQXILJXUHD] vQHFXD LD PRGHOXO,, HVWHGHWLSUHFXUVLYPDWULFHDSDUDPHWULORU

$%!

\ !&#

'HRDUHFH YDULDELOD HQGRJHQ \ !&# H[SOLF vQ HFXD LD YDULD LD vQ WLPS D YDULDELOHL HQGRJHQH

» YDULDELOHLHQGRJHQHILLQGGHIRUPD % = ª ª -E ½

± ² ² Õ

0RGHOXO ,, ILLQG GH WLS UHFXUVLY HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL VH SRW FDOFXOD FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 DSOLFDW GLUHFW FHORU GRX HFXD LL DOH PRGHOXOXL DFHúWLD ILLQG vQ DFHVW FD] HVWLPDWRULQHGHSODVD LFRQYHUJHQ LúLHILFLHQ L $O WXULGHFHOHGRX PRGHOHHFRQRPHWULFHSUH]HQWDWHPDLVXVPDLSRWILDPLQWLWHFDPRGHOH GH WLS UHFXUVLY PRGHOXO GHVFULHULL HFRQRPHWULFH D IRUP ULL SUH XOXL GH HFKLOLEUX úL PRGHOXO (

RSWLPL] ULLSURILWXOXL

'H UH LQXW vQ ILQDO F PRGHOHOH HFRQRPHWULFH FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH UHSUH]LQW vQ SUH]HQW SULQFLSDOXOLQVWUXPHQWGHOXFUXvQGRPHQLXOPDQDJHPHQWXOXL±ODQLYHOPLFURVDXPDFURHFRQRPLF± SHQWUX R IXQGDPHQWDUH PDL ULJXURDV úL QX LQWXLWLY VDX GHVFULSWLY D GHFL]LLORU ÌQ DFHVW VHQV PRGHOHOHGHDFHVWWLSSRWILIRORVLWHFXSUHF GHUHvQDFWLYLW

LGHH[SOLFDUHVLPXODUHúLvQVSHFLDOOD

HVWLPDUHDSUREDELO DHYROX LLORUIHQRPHQHORUHFRQRPLFH 2 SUREOHP FDUH U PkQH GHVFKLV VH UHIHU OD JUDGXO GH VLPLOLWXGLQH GH SHUWLQHQ

VDX

FRPSDWLELOLWDWH D VWUXFWXULL PRGHOHORU FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH úL D PRGHOHORU UHFXUVLYH FX VWUXFWXUD SURFHVHORU VDX VLVWHPHORU HFRQRPLFH SH FDUH R GHVFULX 2SLQLLOH FX SULYLUH OD DFHVW VXELHFW VXQW vPS U LWH 3UHIHULQ D QRDVWU VH vQGUHDSW vQV VSUH PRGHOHOH UHFXUVLYH XWLOL]DWH vQ VSHFLDO FD PRGHOH RSHUD LRQDOH $FHDVW SUHIHULQ

SRDWHILMXVWLILFDW DVWIHO

PRGHOHOH FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH SUHVXSXQ R GHSHQGHQ

PXWXDO I U QLFL R SULRULWDWH VDX

vQO Q XLUH FDX]DO ORJLF vQWUH YDULDELOHOH HFRQRPLFH vQ WLPS FH PRGHOHOH UHFXUVLYH GHVFULX GHSHQGHQ H FDX]DOH XQLODWHUDOH FH SRW IL RUGRQDWH vQ IXQF LH GH VXFFHVLXQHD GHSHQGHQ HORU úL LQWHUGHSHQGHQ HORUGLQWUHIHQRPHQHOHHFRQRPLFH vQ HFRQRPLH UHDF LD IHQRPHQHORU OD PRGLILFDUHD IDFWRULORU QX HVWH vQ JHQHUDO VLPXOWDQ

)

vQDFHHDúLSHULRDG GHWLPS PDLDOHVGDF QHUHIHULPODSHULRDGHPLFLGHWLPS±OXQLVDXWULPHVWUH $FHVW IDSW SHUPLWH vQ XQHOH FD]XUL FD PRGHOHOH FX HFXD LL VLPXOWDQH QRQLGHQWLILFDWH V ILH WUDQVIRUPDWH ILH vQ PRGHOH UHFXUVLYH ILH vQ PRGHOH FRUHFW VDX VXSUDLGHQWLILFDWH SULQ WUDQVIRUPDUHD XQRU YDULDELOH HQGRJHQH vQ YDULDELOH H[RJHQH vQ DQXPLWH HFXD LL VDX SULQ LQWURGXFHUHD DFHVWRU YDULDELOHFXYDORULGHFDODWH

* +

9H]L±27 Q VRLX$,DFRE(FRQRPHWULH±VWXGLLGHFD]OLWR$6(%XFXUHúWL ÌQHFRQRPLHIHQRPHQHOHH[SOR]LYHSRWILFRQVLGHUDWHFDIHQRPHQHUDUH)HQRPHQHOHHFRQRPLFHVHPDQLIHVW GH

UHJXO FDIHQRPHQHVWDELOHúLVWD LRQDUHSHWHUPHQVFXUWúLXQHRULFKLDUSHWHUPHQPHGLX

197

HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU XQXL PRGHO UHFXUVLY HVWH PDL VLPSO úL PDL UDSLG ÌQ FD]XO PRGHOHORUFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQHHVWLPDUHDSDUDPHWULORUQHFHVLW FDOFXOHODERULRDVHLDUIHQRPHQXOGH FXPXODUH D HURULORU GH DSUR[LPDUH SRDWH V SURYRDFH GLVWRUVLXQL VHPQLILFDWLYH DVXSUD UH]XOWDWHORU RE LQXWH

6LPXODUHDúLSURJQR]DPRGHOHORUFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH 0RGHOHOH FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH VH IRORVHVF vQ DFHOHDúL VFRSXUL FD úL PRGHOHOH XQLIDFWRULDOH VDX PXOWLIDFWRULDOH

ÌQ

YHGHUHD

XWLOL] ULL

DFHVWRU

PRGHOH

OD

H[SOLFDUHD

VLPXODUHD

úL

SURJQR]D

IHQRPHQHORU HFRQRPLFH ILHFDUH HFXD LH D PRGHOXOXL HYLGHQW FX H[FHS, LD HFXD LLORU GH LGHQWLWDWH

YDWUHEXLWHVWDW HFRQRPHWULFFDvQFD]XOXQXLPRGHOFXRVLQJXU HFXD LH

$FHVW WLS GH PRGHOH VH XWLOL]HD] FX SUHF GHUH OD IXQGDPHQWDUHD SODQXOXL GH DIDFHUL D XQHL ILUPHVDXODIXQGDPHQWDUHDSROLWLFLORUPDFURHFRQRPLFHÌQDFHVWFD]SHQWUXYDULDELOHOHGHFRPDQG DGLF DFHOHIHQRPHQHFDUHSRWILVWDELOLWHFRQWURODWHVDXUHJODWHSULQGHFL]LLPDQDJHULDOHVDODULLOH LPSR]LWHOH WD[HOH YDPDOH GREkQ]LOH SH WLSXUL GH FUHGLWH HWF ± VH GHWHUPLQ DFHOH YDORUL SRVLELOH UH]XOWDWHvQXUPDXQHLDQDOL]HHFRQRPLFHVDXSUREDELOHGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHVWDWLVWLFFDUHLQWURGXVH vQ PRGHOXO FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH YRU JHQHUD LQWHUYDOHOH GH vQFUHGHUH DOH YDULDELOHORU HQGRJHQH UHVSHFWLYVFHQDULLOHFHYRUUH]XOWDvQXUPDXQHLVDXXQRUGHFL]LLHFRQRPLFH 'H DVHPHQHD QX GH SX LQH RUL YDULDELOHOH HQGRJHQH VH HVWLPHD] QX vQ XUPD UH]ROY ULL PRGHOXOXL HFRQRPHWULF FL SULQ DQFKHWH VWDWLVWLFH DOH PDQDJHULORU SULYLQG YDORULOH SH FDUH OH DQWLFLSHD] SHQWUX IHQRPHQHOH HFRQRPLFH SH FDUH OH SRW LQIOXHQ D vQWUR P VXU PDL PDUH VDX PDL PLF 8Q H[HPSOX GH HQGRJHQL]DUH D YDULDELOHORU HIHFW vO SRDWH FRQVWLWXL DQFKHWD PDQDJHULORU VRFLHW

LORU GH GLVWULEX LH D SURGXVHORU SHWUROLHUH SULYLQG HYROX LD SUH XOXL DFHVWRUD SH XUP WRDUHOH

WUHLOXQLúDVHOXQL«3HED]DLQIRUPD LLORURE LQXWHVHVWDELOHVFSHFDOHVWDWLVWLF YDORULOHSUREDELOH úLULVFXULOHFDDFHVWHSUH XULV GHS úHDVF VDXV FRERDUHVXEDQXPLWHYDORULOLPLW 6HFRQVLGHU F vQ DQXPLWH GRPHQLL ± FDUH QX SRW IL SUHFL]DWH GHFkW vQ XUPD XQRU H[SHULPHQW UL ULJXURDVH ± HVWLPDUHD YDORULORU SUREDELOH DOH XQRU YDULDELOH HQGRJHQH SH ED]D HQGRJHQL] ULL ORU SULQ DQFKHWH VWDWLVWLFHFRQGXFHODHURULPDLPLFLGHFkWFHOHHVWLPDWHFXDMXWRUXOXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULF ([HPSOXGHDSOLFDUHDPRGHOXOXLFXHFXD LLVLPXOWDQH0RGHOXOGLQDPLFDOOXL.H\QHV 'LQDPLFD

SULQFLSDOLORU

LQGLFDWRUL

PDFURHFRQRPLFL

H[SULPD L

vQ

PLOG

OHL

SUH XUL

FRPSDUDELOHvQ5RPkQLDvQSHULRDGDVHSUH]LQW vQWDEHOXOXUP WRU

7DEHOXO $QL

PLOGOHLSUHWXULFRPS

&RQVXPXO

ILQDODO

,QYHVWL LL

ILQDODO

3,%

SRSXOD LHL

, .

DGPSXEOLFH

9 /

& -

&RQVXPXO

* .

90

132

4

9H]L&DSLWROHOH,,,úL,9

198

7RWDO

6 VH FDUDFWHUL]H]H GH]YROWDUHD HFRQRPLF D 5RPkQLHL vQ SHULRDGD FX DMXWRUXO

XQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH

5H]ROYDUH

3HED]DGDWHORUGLQWDEHOXOGHPDLVXVGH]YROWDUHDHFRQRPLF D5RPkQLHLvQSHULRDGD

VHSRDWHIDFHFXDMXWRUXOXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOHDF UXLIRUP VWUXFWXUDO HVWH = D7

Å &5

¿

,

= E7

5

¿ 95 ®

+ D 8 95 + E8 9 5

= &5

+ ,5

+ X8 + E9 9 5

6 8

+ X9

+ *5

0RGHOXOGHPDLVXVSUH]LQW FkWHYDSDUWLFXODULW

SULPDHFXD LHGHVFULHRUHOD LHGHFRPSRUWDPHQWDFRQVXPDWRULORU

LFXPDUIL

HFXD LD UHSUH]LQW WRW R UHOD LH GH FRPSRUWDPHQW GHVFULLQG SROLWLFD LQYHVWL LRQDO

SUDFWLFDW vQ SHULRDGD GDU DYkQG XQ FDUDFWHU GLQDPLF GDWRULW LQFOXGHULL YDULDELOHORU GHFDODWHFDUHLPSULP DFHDVW WU V WXU úLPRGHOXOXLFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH

HFXD LD UHSUH]LQW RUHOD LHGHLGHQWLWDWHHFRQRPLF

0RGHOXO FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH FRQ LQH FLQFL YDULDELOH GLQWUH FDUH WUHL YDULDELOH VXQW

'LVFX LD

HQGRJHQH ( & :; , :< 9:

) úLGRX

YDULDELOHH[RJHQH ( * := 9 :

HFRQRPHWULF

D

PRGHOXOXL

FX

>3? )

HFXD LL

PXOWLSOH

UHOHY

F

PRGHOXO

HVWH

VXSUDLGHQWLILFDWGHRDUHFH

vQ HFXD LD QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU DEVHQWH HVWH HJDO FX QXP U VXSHULRU QXP UXOXL GH

YDULDELOHHQGRJHQHPLQXVXQX FHHDFHvQVHDPQ F HFXD LDHVWHVXSUDLGHQWLILFDW

FKLDU GDF HFXD LD HVWH FRUHFW LGHQWLILFDW

(

= - ) PRGHOXO HVWH VXSUDLGHQWLILFDW

GDWRULW HFXD LHL

$YkQG DFHDVW SDUWLFXODULWDWH HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU PRGHOXOXL VH IDFH FX DMXWRUXO

0&003DSOLFDW vQGRX ID]H

)D]D,9DULDELOD 9 : FDUHHVWHHQGRJHQ vQHFXD LD GDUH[RJHQ vQHFXD LLOH úL VH

YDUHJUHVDvQIXQF LHGHYDULDELOHOHH[RJHQH 9 :

= a + b ¢9

>3?

+ ¶¢ * @

úL * : UH]XOWkQGHFXD LD +Z

6H DSOLF 0&003 vQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU a b ¶ úL D FDOFXO ULL YDORULORU

9

@

@ ACB

@

$

HVWLPDWHDOHYDULDELOHL 9 D

(

)

GIH

( K K G

Ö Ö Ö b E 9 ) a ¶ = PLQ Ç

Ö Ö - b -a 9

K F J

Ö *K -¶

G

)

199

Ö ) ë(a

)=

NIO N

Ü

(

T

ZI[

ZI[ Ö ]Ç X 9 Üa

Z I` a

]

]

Ö X 9 + b] Ç

\

Z

(

Ö )= Ü cÇ ^ 9 ) ë(¶

`

i f

c

¿

o j l l'm

¿

Ö + b Ç9

o j l'm

o k n

¿ Ö Ç* o a ¿ o j l ®

] Y

o j l 'l m

Ö + b Ç* o 9

c _

b

Ö * -¶

o j l

]

f

i f

)=

ZI[ Y \

]

X 9 9 = ]Ç Z

)(- * c

Ö Ç d *i +¶

i e h

l'm

c

)=

] Y

\

f'g d 9 i *i = Ç i f

l'm

o j l l'm

= Ç9

o j l

Ö Ç* o 9 +¶

o j l

o k n

]

]

Z

)(-9 Y \ ]

Ö ]Ç X *9 +¶

\

Ö Ç* o +¶

l o k n

T

Ö * -¶

\

W

R 9 = WÇ

f'g

i f

o k n

TIU W

ZI[ Y

Ö d *i 9 + b Ç

l'm

Ö Ö + b (Q - )a Ç9

l'm ¿ ¿ Ö a Çl 9

]Z

Ö Ö - b -a 9

GHXQGHUH]XOW VLVWHPXOGHHFXD LLQRUPDOH

Å

T

f'g

Ö Ç d *i Üa

TIU Ö WÇ R * +¶

)(- ) = P

Ö * -¶

M Q

S V

Ö Ö - b -a 9

ZI[

Y

f'g

W

Ö Ö + b WÇ R 9 - )a

X (9 ( )= Ü ] Ç Z

P

Ö Ö - b 9 -a

TIU

(Q

Ö ) ë b

P

L 9 Ü PÇ

l'm

Ö Ç* o +¶

o j l

l

o k n

o l'm

= Ç9 o 9

l'm

o j l

o k n

= Ç9 o * o

o j l

Ö Å a Ö = Ö + b + ¶

¿ ¿ Ö Ö = Ö + b Ü a + ¶

¿ Ö Ö Ö ¿ a + b + ¶ = ®

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQHOH

3HQWUX HVWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU a b úL ¶ úLDYDORULORUOXL 9 p VDXWLOL]DWSURJUDPXO(;&(/

$ $

$

$

UH]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHILLQGXUP WRDUHOH

Ö = a

Ö b = Ö = - ¶

7DEHOXO 9q

9r

s3t

*u

z

9 vxwy

* {| 9 {x}~

9 {| 9 {x

*

9 *

$

9

200

Ö 9

)D]D ,, 'HRDUHFH YDULDELOD HQGRJHQ 9 YH]L HFXD LD HVWH YDULDELO H[RJHQ vQ

= + ¢ 9

- ¢ *

YH]LWDEHOXOFRORDQD

(

$ )

HFXD LLOH úL vQDFHVWHHFXD LLHDVHYDLQWURGXFHFXYDORULOHHVWLPDWHvQID]D, 9

(VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU HFXD LLORU úL VH YD IDFH FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 DSOLFDWH

ILHF UHLHFXD LL

= D

Ö ¢9

+ D

+ X

&

,

(VWLPDWRULLHFXD LHL D úL D UH]XOW vQXUPDDSOLF ULL0&003

= E

Ö ¢9

+ E

$

)=

¢9

+X

$

Ö ) (D

Ö ) ë(D

)

Ö £ ) ë(D

Ö ¢ )= ÜD

Ö D

+ E

I Ç (&

PLQ

I

Ö = Ü (Q - )D

¡I¢

9Ö ¤Ç ¡

¤

Ö Ö 9 -D

Ö -D

9Ö Ç

Ö +D

¡I¢

Ö £ +D

9Ö ¤Ç ¡

)

I

& = Ç

¡I¢

¤¡

¤

& 9Ö = ¤Ç

¤

&DOFXOHOHVDXHIHFWXDWFXDMXWRUXOSURJUDPXOXL(;&(/UH]XOWkQGXUP WRDUHOHYDORUL

Ö &¥

Ö § =D

Ö ¦ + D

Ö ¢9 ¥

Ö = + ¢9 ¥

5¨

(V ª « © ) ( V¬ x® ) ( ) ()

¡

=

G =

3URFHGkQG vQ PRG DQDORJ FX HFXD LD FDOFXOHOH VDX HIHFWXDW WRW FX DMXWRUXO SURJUDPXOXL

V°±

=

¯

(;&(/UH]XOWkQGXUP WRDUHOHYDORUL

Ö = E´

Ö Ö + E²9 ¶

Ö + E³ 9

Ö , ¶

9HULILFDUHD VHPQLILFD LHL HVWLPDWRULORU úL D PRGHOXOXL VH YD IDFH SHQWUX ILHFDUH HFXD LH vQ

¶ µ ²

= - + 9

¶

- 9

( V¸ ¹ º ) ( V» ¼ ½ ) ( V» ¼ ¾ ) ( ) () ( )

¶ µ ²

5·

=

G =

VÀÁ

¿

=

SDUWH

HFXD LD

(VWLPDWRULL D Â D Ã VXQW VHPQLILFDWLY GLIHUL L GH ]HUR FX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a =

$

$

GDF VHYHULILF XUP WRDUHOHUHOD LL

Ö Ç D V ÏÐ Ö D

Ó

Ê

>W

Ò ËÎ Ñ Í Ñ

Ä

â

= < W

Õ ÉÕ Ö Ø Ù

= > W

ÓÆÔ

Ç ÉÇ È Ë Ì

ÄÆÅ

=

=

ÌQXUPDHIHFWX ULLFDOFXOHORUGHPDLVXVVHFRQVWDW IDSWXOF GRDU D

V ÚÛ ×

=

$

HVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULW

GH]HURFXXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH a = D Ã ILLQGQHVHPQLILFDWLY

$

ÌQ YHGHUHD YHULILF ULL LSRWH]HL GH LQGHSHQGHQ

D HURULORU VH DSOLF WHVWXO 'XUELQ ± :DWVRQ

FDUHFRQVW vQFDOFXODUHDYDULDELOHL G FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

201

Ü'Ý Ö Þ à Ç (X

à á ß

G =

à Þ ) â

Ö Þ -X

Ü =

'LQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL 'XUELQ ± :DWVRQ vQ IXQF LH GH XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a = GH

Ü'Ý

Ü Ö Þ à ÇX à á Ü

QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU H[SOLFDWLYH N = úL GH QXP UXO GH REVHUYD LL Q = VH SUHLDX YDORULOH WHRUHWLFH G

ã

= úL G

ä

= &RPSDUkQG YDORDUHD FDOFXODW D YDULDELOHL G FX FHOH GRX YDORUL

WHRUHWLFH VH FRQVWDW F < G = < G

= LQWHUYDO FH FRUHVSXQGH VLWXD LHL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH

å

SR]LWLY 9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLUDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LH

(Q

- N - )

5æ

è

)ì

)ð

)ú

'HFLUDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LHHVWHQHVHPQLILFDWLYSHQWUXXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH a =

ÌQ XUPD DSOLF ULL WHVWHORU W ) úL G VH FRQVWDW F PRGHOXO UHGDW GH HFXD LD HVWH

=

ðÉñ ò î ò îÆï ó

- 5æ

è

Ë )í

ç ê ç (ë é ê é æ

)

=

=

= < ) ö

-

ù

öÉ÷ ø ô ø ôÆõ

=

QHVHPQLILFDWLYLQYDOLG

HFXD LD

9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLHVWLPDWRULORU Ö Eý V

>W

Ö (VWLPDWRULL E

Ö E V

â

-

ÿ û >W

û

â

Ö E V

û

>W

û

â

$

= > W

-

= > W

ý Éý þ

= > W

ûÆü

ý Éý þ

ý Éý þ

ûÆü

=

=

ûÆü

=

$

E úL E VXQW VHPQLILFDWLY GLIHUL L GH ]HUR FX XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH

a =

ÌQ YHGHUHD YHULILF ULL LSRWH]HL GH LQGHSHQGHQ

D HURULORU VH DSOLF WHVWXO 'XUELQ ± :DWVRQ

FDUHFRQVW vQFDOFXODUHDYDULDELOHL G FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

Ö Ç (X

G ë=

Ö -X

)

=

Ö ÇX

'LQ WDEHOD GLVWULEX LHL 'XUELQ ± :DWVRQ vQ IXQF LH GH XQ SUDJ GH VHPQLILFD LH a = GH

QXP UXO YDULDELOHORU H[SOLFDWLYH N = úL GH QXP UXO GH REVHUYD LL Q = VH SUHLDX YDORULOH WHRUHWLFH G

= úL G

= &RPSDUkQG YDORDUHD FDOFXODW D YDULDELOHL G FX FHOH GRX YDORUL

WHRUHWLFH VH FRQVWDW F < G ë = < G

= LQWHUYDO FH FRUHVSXQGH VLWXD LHL GH DXWRFRUHOD LH

SR]LWLY

9HULILFDUHDVHPQLILFD LHLUDSRUWXOXLGHFRUHOD LH

)!

)'

+

=

Q - N -

')( * & * #%$

N

5

- 5

Ë )"

(

)

=

202

)3

= > ) /

/)0 1 . 1

,%-

5DSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LHHVWHVHPQLILFDWLYGLIHULWGH]HURFXXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH a =

'HVFULHUHD

=

HFRQRPLHL

-

5RPkQLHL

vQ

SHULRDGD

2

=

VH

SRDWH

IDFH

FX

DMXWRUXO

PXOWLSOLFDWRULORUFXHIHFWGLUHFW

0XOWLSOLFDWRULL FX HIHFW GLUHFW VDX PXOWLSOLFDWRULL VWUXFWXUDOL VXQW UHSUH]HQWD L GH SDUDPHWULL

PRGHOXOXLVXEIRUP VWUXFWXUDO

D 4 UDWDPDUJLQDO DFRQVXPXOXLFDUHDUDW F vQSHULRDGDODRFUHúWHUHFXXQ

PLOLDUGGHOHLD3,%XOXLFRQVXPXOILQDODOSRSXOD LHLDFUHVFXWFXDSUR[LPDWLYPLOLDUGHOHL

E5 UDWD PDUJLQDO D LQYHVWL LLORU FDUH H[SULP IDSWXO F vQ SHULRDGD

LQYHVWL LLOHDXFUHVFXWFXPLOLDUGHOHLODRFUHúWHUHFXXQPLOLDUGGHOHLD3,%XOXL

E6 UHOHY IDSWXOF 3,%XOUHDOL]DWvQDQXODQWHULRUDDYXWXQHIHFWQHJDWLYDVXSUDFUHúWHULL

LQYHVWL LLORU DFHVWHD VF ]kQG FX DSUR[LPDWLY PLOLDUGH OHL OD R FUHúWHUH FX XQ PLOLDUG GH OHL D 3,%XOXLGLQDQXODQWHULRU

%,%/,2*5$),( *LUDXG5&KDL[1eFRQRPpWULH38)3DULV *UHHQH+:(FRQRPHWULF$QDO\VLV0DFPLOODQ3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\1HZ
798

798

HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
HG0F*UDZ+LOO1HZ
/DEURXVVH&,QWURGXFWLRQDO¶pFRQRPpWULH'XQRG3DULV 3LQG\FN 5 6 5XELQIHOG ' 6 (FRQRPHWULF 0RGHOV DQG (FRQRPLF )RUHFDVWV

:8

HG 0F

*UDZ+LOO1HZ
203

&DSLWROXO;, $SOLFD LLHFRQRPHWULFHODQLYHOGHILUP

)XQGDPHQWDUHDHFRQRPHWULF

DGHFL]LHLGHDOHJHUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQW

GHSURGXF LHSHED]DFRVWXOXLPLQLPGHIRORVLQ

2 VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO DUH SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D DOHJH vQWUH SDWUX HFKLSDPHQWH GH SURGXF LH (

( ( ( vQYHGHUHDUHDOL] ULLSURGXF LHLSURSXVHvQFDGUXOVWUDWHJLHLSHWHUPHQOXQJ 3UH XULOH

GH

DFKL]L LH

vQWUH LQHUH

úL

UHSDUD LL

SUHYL]LELOH

FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH GXUDWHL GH

IXQF LRQDUHDILHF UXLHFKLSDPHQWVXQWSUH]HQWDWHvQWDEHOXOXUP WRU 7DEHOXOPLLOHL $QXO

&

&

&

&

&

(

(

(

(

&KHOWXLHOL

(FKLSDPHQWH

1RW

6HFRQVLGHU F FHOHSDWUXHFKLSDPHQWHDXDFHODúLUDQGDPHQWWHKQLF

6 VH IDF GLVFX LD HFRQRPLF D SUREOHPHL V VH IRUPXOH]H FULWHULXO GH DOHJHUH D FHOXL PDL HILFLHQWHFKLSDPHQWúLV VHDSOLFHvQYHGHUHDUH]ROY ULLSUREOHPHL

5H]ROYDUH D 'LVFX LDHFRQRPLF DSUREOHPHL 2 VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO DUH GH UHJXO SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D DOHJH vQWUH PDL PXOWH HFKLSDPHQWH GHSURGXF LH( ( «( «( O = N N

QXP UXOHFKLSDPHQWHORUH[LVWHQWHSHSLD

±SHQWUXD

úL UHDOL]D SURGXF LD VWDELOLW vQ FDGUXO XQHL VWUDWHJLL SH WHUPHQ OXQJ 3H ED]D GRFXPHQWD LHL WHKQLFR HFRQRPLFH VRFLHWDWHD FXQRDúWH SUH XULOH GH FXPS UDUH DOH DFHVWRU HFKLSDPHQWH 3 3 «3 «3 SUHFXPúLFKHOWXLHOLOHGHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LHSUHYL]LELOHSHQWUXIXQF LRQDUHDDFHVWRUHFKLSDPHQWH & & «& «& W = Q Q

QXP UXODQLORUGHIRORVLQ

SHQWUXILHFDUHHFKLSDPHQW

3H ED]D DFHVWRU LQIRUPD LL VRFLHWDWHD FRPHUFLDO WUHEXLH V GHFLG FH HFKLSDPHQWH SUHIHU (YLGHQWF GHSHSR]L LDWHRULHLHFRQRPLFHFULWHULXOGHDOHJHUHvOYDUHSUH]HQWDPLQLPXPXOFRVWXOXL DQXDOGHIRORVLQ

PLQ \

XQGH \

UHSUH]LQW FRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGHIRORVLQ

DXQXLHFKLSDPHQWO

$FHDVW DOHJHUHVHSRDWHIDFHvQPDLPXOWHVLWXD LLFXPDUIL &KHOWXLHOLOH GH DFKL]L LH vQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL VXQW FRQVWDQWH SH vQWUHDJD SHULRDG GH WLPS &KHOWXLHOLOHGHDFKL]L LHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLDOHHFKLSDPHQWXOXLVHPRGLILF GHODXQDQ ODDOWXOSHWRDW GXUDWDGHH[SORDWDUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL &KHOWXLHOLOH WRWDOH GH H[SORDWDUH D XQXL HFKLSDPHQW < FkW úL FRVWXO PHGLX DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH SRW IL H[SULPDWH vQ YDORULOH QRPLQDOH DOH FKHOWXLHOLORU GH DFKL]L LH vQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL DOHHFKLSDPHQWHORU

204

&KHOWXLHOLOH WRWDOH GH H[SORDWDUH D XQXL HFKLSDPHQW < FkW úL FRVWXO PHGLX DQXDO SRW IL H[SULPDWH

vQ

YDORULOH

DFWXDOL]DWH

DOH

FKHOWXLHOLORU

GH

DFKL]L LH

vQWUH LQHUH

úL

UHSDUD LL

DOH

HFKLSDPHQWHORU 'LVFX LD HFRQRPHWULF D FD]XULORU GH PDL VXV VH IDFH SH ED]D LSRWH]HL F XQ HFKLSDPHQW RGDW DOHV YD IL IRORVLW SH WRDW GXUDWD UHDOL] ULL SURGXF LHL VRFLHW HFKLSDPHQWXOYDILvQORFXLWGHURUL L= U U

LL IDSW FH SUHVXSXQH F

QXP UXOGHvQORFXLULDOHHFKLSDPHQWHORU

&D]XOFKHOWXLHOLGHDFKL]L LHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LHFRQVWDQWHODYDORDUHDQRPLQDO FRVWXO JOREDO GH H[SORDWDUH SH Q SHULRDGH GH WLPS DO XWLOL] ULL XQXL HFKLSDPHQW úL SHQWUX U vQORFXLULHVWHXUP WRUXO

<

3& & «& 3& & «& «3& & «&

Ý<

U3&

XQGH W = Q Q L = U U

QXP UXODQLORUGHIRORVLQ

DXQXLHFKLSDPHQW

QXP UXOGHvQORFXLULDOHHFKLSDPHQWHORU

FRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQWSRUQLQGGHODUHOD LD YDIL

\

=

<

Q ¢U

=

U ¢

(3

+&

)

Q ¢U

3 +&

=

Q

'HFL SH ED]D UHOD LHL FDOFXODW SHQWUX ILHFDUH HFKLSDPHQW vQ SDUWH SUHIHULQ D VRFLHW

LLVHYDvQGUHSWDF WUHDFHOHFKLSDPHQWF UXLDvLFRUHVSXQGH PLQ \

&D]XO±FKHOWXLHOLGHDFKL]L LHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLFRQVWDQWHODYDORDUHDDFWXDOL]DW 3H ED]D UHOD LLORU úL VH GHGXFH F SUH XO PHGLX DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH VH FDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL \ XQGHD

=

Q

¢

3 +&

( +

D)

UDWDGREkQ]LL

&D]XOFKHOWXLHOLGHDFKL]L LHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLFRQVWDQWHODYDORDUHDQRPLQDO ÌQDFHVWFD]FRVWXOJOREDOGHH[SORDWDUHGHYLQH 3 & & «& 3 & & «& «3 & & «&

< Ý<

!

=

»

Ç" ª 3 ª

+

½

Ç" &

± ² ² Õ

3HED]DUHOD LHL VHGHGXFHH[SUHVLDFRVWXOXLPLQLPDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUH

(

\

=

Q ¢ U

$

¢

»

% Ç) ª 3 % # ª ½

&

+

% Ç) & '

' #

± ² ² Õ

&D]XOFKHOWXLHOLGHDFKL]L LRQDUHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLYDULDELOHODYDORULDFWXDOL]DWH 3RUQLQGGHODUHOD LLOH úL FRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUHSHED]DF UXLDVH YDGHFLGHDOHJHUHDHFKLSDPHQWHORUFHXUPHD] DILDFKL]L LRQDWHGHYLQH

\

1

«

.

» = ¢ Ã Ç ª 3/ / Q ¢ U + ,ª Ã ½ ¬

0

+

/ Ç& -

- + ,

± ² ¢ ² Õ

( + D )

- * ,

á

³ ³ ã

'HUH LQXW 5HOD LLOH GH PDL VXV VXQW YDODELOH GDF úL QXPDL GDF QXP UXO GH DQL GH IRORVLUH D HFKLSDPHQWHORU HVWH FRQVWDQW úL HJDO FX Q W = Q SHQWUX WRDWH FHOH N O = N HFKLSDPHQWH H[LVWHQWH SH SLD

ÌQ FD] FRQWUDU FRVWXO PHGLX DQXDO VH YD FDOFXOD SHQWUX WRDWH HFKLSDPHQWHOH SH

ED]DGXUDWHLFHOHLPDLPDULGHIRORVLUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQW

205

'H DVHPHQHD UHOD LLOH VXQW YDODELOH QXPDL GDF FHOH N HFKLSDPHQWH DX DFHODúL UDQGDPHQW WHKQLF ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH FHOH N HFKLSDPHQWH DX UDQGDPHQWH WHKQLFH GLIHULWH UHOD LLOH GH PDL VXV WUHEXLH FRUHFWDWH FX SURGXF LD UHDOL]DW GH ILHFDUH HFKLSDPHQW vQ SDUWH &X DOWH FXYLQWH QX VH PDL OXFUHD] FX FKHOWXLHOLOH GH DFKL]L LRQDUH vQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL vQ P ULPL DEVROXWH FL FX YDORULOH DFHVWRUD H[SULPDWH vQ P ULPL GHULYDWH UHVSHFWLY SULQ UDSRUWDUHD FKHOWXLHOLORU GH DFKL]L LRQDUH vQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLODUDQGDPHQWXOWHKQLFDOILHF UXLHFKLSDPHQW E $OHJHUHD FHOXL PDL HILFLHQW HFKLSDPHQW SH ED]D YDORULORU QRPLQDOH DOH FRVWXULORU GH H[SORDWDUH ÌQFD]XODSOLFD LHLSUDFWLFHGDF QXVH LQHFRQWGHUDWDGREkQ]LLWUHEXLHFDOFXODWSUH XODQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH SHQWUX ILHFDUH GLQWUH HFKLSDPHQWH GXS FDUH YD IL DOHV DFHO HFKLSDPHQW FDUH DUH FHO $VWIHO

PDLPLFFRVWDQXDOGHIRORVLQ \

3

=

2

\

5

=

4

\

5 6

=

\

5 7

=

¢ ( + ) =

= PLLOHLDQ

¢ ( + + ) =

¢ ( + + + ) = ¢ ( + + + ) =

= PLLOHLDQ

= PLLOHLDQ

= PLLOHLDQ

ÌQDFHDVW VLWXD LHHVWHQHFHVDUV ILHDFKL]L LRQDWHFKLSDPHQWXO( 8 FDUHDUHFHOPDLPLFFRVW DQXDOGHH[SORDWDUH±PLLOHLDQGDUDFHDVW GHFL]LHQXHVWHFRUHFW GHRDUHFHHFKLSDPHQWHOH QX DX R GXUDW GH IXQF LRQDUH XQLIRUP ( 9 U

(:

U

(8

U;

(<

U=

'HFLFRVWXO

PLQLP DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH YD IL FDOFXODW SHQWUX WRDWH HFKLSDPHQWHOH vQ IXQF LH GH GXUDWD GH IXQF LRQDUHPD[LP ±U

?

\

?

\

=

>

=

@

=

?

\

B

\

A

=

DQL

¢ ( + + + + ) = ¢ ( + + + + ) = ¢ ( + + + + ) = ¢ ( + + + + ) =

= PLLOHLDQ

= PLLOHLDQ

= PLLOHLDQ

= PLLOHLDQ

ÌQ FRQFOX]LH GHFL]LD FRUHFW HVWH DFHHD GH D DFKL]L LRQD HFKLSDPHQWXO (< GHRDUHFH SH R SHULRDG GHDQLDFHVWDDUHFHOPDLPLFFRVWGHDQXDOGHIRORVLQ

±PLLOHLDQ

F $OHJHUHD FHOXL PDL HILFLHQW HFKLSDPHQW SH ED]D YDORULORU DFWXDOL]DWH DOH FRVWXULORU GH H[SORDWDUH 'DF VH LQH VHDPD GH YDORDUHD DFWXDOL]DW D FRVWXOXL GHUDWDGREkQ]LLúLGHIDSWXOF GXUDWD GH IXQF LRQDUH QX HVWH XQLIRUP vQ YHGHUHD FDOFXO ULL FRVWXOXL DQXDO GH IRORVLQ

YD IL XWLOL]DW

XUP WRDUHDUHOD LH \ XQGHD

G

=

Q

¢

3 +&

( +

D)

FE E D C

UDWDGREkQ]LL

ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH UDWD GREkQ]LL HVWH FRQVWDQW úL HJDO FX FRVWXO PLQLP DQXDO GH IRORVLQ

YDILFDOFXODWDVWIHO

\

M

L

=

» ± H ² = PLLOHLDQ K J I ¢ ª + + + + ª ² ½ Õ

206

\

S

\

Y

\

» ± T ² = PLLOHLDQ W V U ¢ ª + + + + ª ² ½ Õ

=

X

Z Y

» ± N ² = PLLOHLDQ Q P O ¢ ª + + + + ª ² ½ Õ

=

R

» ± T ² = PLLOHLDQ W V U ¢ ª + + + + ª ² ½ Õ

=

5H]XOWDWHOH GH PDL VXV FRQGXF OD XUP WRDUHD FRQFOX]LH ± FRVWXO PLQLP DQXDO GH IRORVLQ

LQkQG FRQW GH YDORULOH DFWXDOL]DWH DOH FRVWXULORU úL GH UDWD GREkQ]LL D IRVW RE LQXW vQ FD]XO HFKLSDPHQWXOXL(:

$QDOL]DHFRQRPHWULF

DGHFL]LHLGHvQORFXLUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQWGH

SURGXF LHvQWURVRFLHWDWHFRPHUFLDO

ÌQYHGHUHDUHDOL] ULLSURGXF LHLXQHLVRFLHW

LFRPHUFLDOHDFHDVWDDFKL]L LRQHD] HFKLSDPHQWH

GH SURGXF LH OH XWLOL]HD] úL OD XQ PRPHQW GDW DFHVWHD WUHEXLH vQORFXLWH 0RPHQWXO vQORFXLULL VH IDFHvQIXQF LHGHFKHOWXLHOLOHSHFDUHOHQHFHVLW XWLOL]DUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQW $VWIHOYDORDUHDQRPLQDO XQXLHFKLSDPHQW(FDUHHVWHFXPS UDWFXXQSUH 3 [ SHP VXU FH HVWHIRORVLWVFDGHvQWLPSFHFKHOWXLHOLOHGHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLFUHVF1RWkQGFX SUH XOGHDFKL]L LHDOHFKLSDPHQWXOXL

3[ IW

IXQF LD GHYDORUL] ULL vQ WLPS D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL FDUH HVWH GH UHJXO R IXQF LH PRQRWRQ

GHVFUHVF WRDUHvQWLPS 3 [ ÂIW JW

YDORDUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLODUHYkQ]DUHDVDXODOLFKLGDUHDDFHVWXLD

IXQF LD FKHOWXLHOLORU FXPXODWH SULYLQG vQWUH LQHUHD úL UHSDUDUHD HFKLSDPHQWXOXL SH

GXUDWDGHIRORVLUHW W = Q XQGHQ

QXP UXOGHSHULRDGHDQL GHIRORVLUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLJW

UHSUH]LQW RIXQF LHPRQRWRQFUHVF WRDUHvQWLPS 6HGHGXFHDVWIHOF H[SUHVLDFKHOWXLHOLORUJOREDOHGHDFKL]L LRQDUHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLHVWH HJDO FX 3 [ 3 [ ÂIW JW

<\

$OHJHUHD PRPHQWXOXL GH vQORFXLUH D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL VH IDFH SH ED]D FULWHULXOXL PLQ \

]

XQGH \

^

]

FRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQWSHRSHULRDG GHQDQL

3H ED]D UHOD LHL YDORDUHD FRVWXOXL PHGLX DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH UH]XOW GLQ UHOD LD \

_

=

_

<

3`

=

W

- 3`

¢I

(W ) +

J (W

W

)

3UREOHPD FRQVW GHFL vQ D GHWHUPLQD YDORDUHD PLQLP D FRVWXOXL PHGLX DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH \

^

SHED]DUHOD LHL FHHDFHSUHVXSXQHFDOFXOXOGHULYDWHL \

\

\

b

=

W ¢ (<

= W ¢

d

b )ë a W

(-

\

f

= 3e

\

h

= 3g

-<

3c

b

^

úLDQXODUHDDFHVWHLD

=

¢ I ë (W

)+

J ë (W

) ) - (3c

- 3c

¢I

(W ) +

J

(W )) =

Â IW Â W +J W Â W 3e +3e Â IW JW = ¢ +I W Â W IW +J W Â W JW =

'HRDUHFHvQSUDFWLF 3 [ IW úLJW VXQWH[SULPDWHvQYDORULQXPHULFHGHWHUPLQDUHDFRVWXOXL PHGLX DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH VH SRDWH IDFH GLUHFW ILH SULQ FDOFXOH QXPHULFH ILH SULQ UHSUH]HQWDUH JUDILF I U DUHFXUJHODGHULYDWDFRVWXOXLPHGLXDQXDO

207

9DILDVWIHOVXILFLHQWDVHFDOFXODIXQF LD

\

_

=

<

_

=

W

3`

- 3`

¢I

(W ) +

J (W

)

W

úLGHDGHWHUPLQDSULQFDOFXOHQXPHULFHVDXSHFDOHJUDILF SHQWUXFDUHYDORDUHDGXUDWHLGHIRORVLUHW VHRE LQHFHOPDLPLFFRVWPHGLXDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUH 'HúL UH]ROYDUHD SUREOHPHL SH ED]D FDOFXOHORU QXPHULFH VDX D UHSUH]HQW ULL JUDILFH HVWH XúRU GH UHDOL]DW WRWXúL GLVFX LD HFRQRPHWULF D FD]XULORU SRVLELOH HVWH LQWHUHVDQW GHRDUHFH SHUPLWH LGHQWLILFDUHDVROX LLORURSWLPHDOHDFHVWRUD ùWLLQG F IW HVWH R IXQF LH PRQRWRQ GHVFUHVF WRDUH D YDORULL GH SLD

D HFKLSDPHQWHORU LDU

JW HVWH R IXQF LH PRQRWRQ VDX PRQRWRQ FUHVF WRDUH vQ WLPS DFHVWH GRX IXQF LL SRW IL VSHFLILFDWH FXDMXWRUXOXUP WRDUHORUIXQF LLPDWHPDWLFH

I

(W ) =

ÅD - E ¢ W ®H

i l j

IXQFWLH OLQLDU

IXQFWLH H[S RQHQWLDO

ÅN

IXQFWLH

¿

J (W ) = N ¢ W ¿

(

®N ¢ H

GHVFUHVF WRDUH

k j

)

IXQFWLH

PRQRWRQ OLQLDU

GHVFUHVF WRDUH

vQ WLPS

FH WUHFH SULQ RULJLQH

- IXQFWLH H[S RQHQWLDO

FUHVF WRDUH

FH WUHFH SULQ RULJLQH

3ULQFRPELQDUHDWLSXULORUGHIXQF LLFXDMXWRUXOF URUDSRWILVSHFLILFDWHIW úLJW YRUUH]XOWD SDWUXFD]XULSULYLQGDOHJHUHDPRPHQWXOXLRSWLPGHOLFKLGDUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQW

&D]XO,±IW

IXQF LHOLQLDU OLQLDU

FUHVF

GHVFUHVF

WRDUHLDUJW

IXQF LH

WRDUH

2 VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO VD GHFLV V DFKL]L LRQH]H XQ HFKLSDPHQW GH SURGXF LH DO F UXL SUH HVWH3 [

PLOOHL

3HED]DGRFXPHQWD LHLWHKQLFRHFRQRPLFHVHFXQRVFXUP WRDUHOHLQIRUPD LL D (YROX LDvQWLPSDYDORULLHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH

'XS SULPXODQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOGRLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOWUHLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOSDWUXOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOFLQFLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

E (YROX LDvQWLPSDFKHOWXLHOLORUGHLQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH

'XS SULPXODQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOGRLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOWUHLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOSDWUXOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOFLQFLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOúDVHOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

3HED]DLQIRUPD LLORUGHPDLVXVV VHHVWLPH]HWLPSXORSWLPGHvQORFXLUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL 5H]ROYDUH ÌQYHGHUHDGHWHUPLQ ULLHFXD LHLFRVWXOXLDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUHYH]LUHOD LD YRUWUHEXL LGHQWLILFDWH FHOH GRX IXQF LL IW

IXQF LD HYROX LHL vQ WLPS D YDORULL HFKLSDPHQWXOXL úL JW

IXQF LDHYROX LHLvQWLPSDFKHOWXLHOLORUGHLQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL

208

,GHQWLILFDUHD PDWHPDWLF D FHORU GRX IXQF LL VH YD IDFH FX DMXWRUXO UHSUH]HQW ULL JUDILFH D LQIRUPD LLORUUHIHULWRDUHODDFHVWHIXQF LL±YH]L)LJXUDúL)LJXUD

I W

3

W

J W

W

)LJXUD(YROX LDvQWLPSDYDORULLHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH )LJXUD

(YROX LD

vQ

WLPS

D

YDORULL

FKHOWXLHOLORU

GH

LQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL D

HFKLSDPHQWXOXL 3H ED]D JUDILFXOXL GLQ )LJXUD HYROX LD YDORULL HFKLSDPHQWXOXL YD SXWHD IL HVWLPDW FX DMXWRUXOXQHLIXQF LLOLQLDUHGHVFUHVF WRDUHGHIRUPDIW

D±E WX \

ÌQYHGHUHDHVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORUVHYRUHIHFWXDXUP WRDUHOHFDOFXOH 3 [

Â IW UHSUH]LQW YDORDUHD HFKLSDPHQWXOXL OD UHYkQ]DUHD VDX OD OLFKLGDUHD DFHVWXLD GXS W

DQLGHIRORVLQ

IW UHSUH]LQW IXQF LDGHYDORUL] ULLvQWLPSDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLFDUHUH]XOW vQXUPDUDSRUW ULL SUH XULORUGHUHYkQ]DUHODSUH XOGHDFKL]L LHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL3 [ YH]LWDEHOXO

7DEHOXO $QL W

9DORDUHDGHUHYkQ]DUHDHFKLSPLOOHL 3 [ ÂIW

I

(W ) =

3m

¢I

3m

(W )

209

)RORVLQG PHWRGD SXQFWHORU HPSLULFH HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU D úL E YRU IL FDOFXOD L SH ED]D SXQFWHORU1 n úL1o ÌQORFXLQGvQHFXD LDIXQF LHLIW FRRUGRQDWHOHFHORUGRX SXQFWHYD UH]XOWDXUP WRUXOVLVWHPGHHFXD LL SHQWUXW

D

SHQWUXW

D±ÂE

E

ÜIW

D±E W

± W

(YROX LD vQ WLPS D FKHOWXLHOLORU GH LQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL DúD FXP UH]XOW GLQ JUDILF YH]L )LJXUD SRDWH IL DSUR[LPDW FX DMXWRUXO XQHL IXQF LL OLQLDUH FUHVF WRDUH FH WUHFH SULQ RULJLQH UHVSHFWLYJW

NÂW

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWUXOXLNVHYDIDFHSHED]DPHWRGHLSXQFWHORUHPSLULFH )LHSXQFWXO1 n

ÂN

N

ÜJW

NÂW

ÂW

ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH VH GRUHúWH R ULJRDUH PDL PDUH D FDOFXOHORU FHOH GRX PRGHOH YRU WUHEXL VXSXVH GLVFX LHLHFRQRPHWULFHDVHPQLILFD LHLDFHVWRUD±YH]LGLVFX LDHFRQRPHWULF DPRGHOHORUGLQ FDSLWROXO,, 5HYHQLQG OD H[SUHVLLOH DQDOLWLFH DOH FHORU GRX IXQF LL IW úL JW IXQF LD FRVWXOXL PHGLX DQXDOGHH[SORDWDUHYDIL \

=

q

PLOOHLDQ

q

< W

=

3p

- 3p

(W ) +

¢I

J

(W )

W

3p

=

- 3p

¢ (D - E ¢ W

)+ N

¢W

W

=

- ¢ ( - ¢ W

) + ¢ W

W

=

DGLF DFHDVW IXQF LHQXGHSLQGHGHWLPSILLQGRIXQF LHPRQRWRQ LDUFRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGH IRORVLQ

YD IL SH WRDW SHULRDGD GH XWLOL]DUH D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL HJDO FX PLO OHLDQ YH]L )LJXUD

\

W

W

)LJXUD

,QWHUSUHWDUHD HFRQRPLF D XQXL DVHPHQHD FD] YH]L )LJXUD HVWH XUP WRDUHD vQORFXLUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLUHVSHFWLYSRDWHILI FXW vQRULFHPRPHQWGHRDUHFHFRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGH H[SORDWDUHHVWHFRQVWDQWSHvQWUHDJDGXUDW GHIRORVLUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL *HQHUDOL]kQG SHQWUX FD]XO IW

D ± E W úL JW

NÂ W UHVSHFWLY DWXQFL FkQG VH FRQVWDW F

IXQF LD GHYDORUL] ULL vQ WLPS D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL HVWH OLQLDU GHVFUHVF WRDUH LDU IXQF LD FKHOWXLHOLORU GH LQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL HVWH OLQLDU FUHVF WRDUH QX VH PDL LPSXQH HVWLPDUHD HFRQRPHWULF D DFHVWRU IXQF LL GHRDUHFH GHFL]LD HVWH LPSOLFLW ± vQORFXLUHD HFKLSDPHQWHORU SRDWH IL I FXW vQ RULFH PRPHQW vQWUXFkWFRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGHIRORVLQ \

r

=

< W

r

s

=

3

s

- 3

¢I W

(W ) +

J

YDDYHDRYDORDUHFRQVWDQW úLHJDO FX

(W )

s

=

3

s

- 3

¢ ( - E ¢ W W

)+

N ¢W

s

= 3

¢E + N

"W = Q

210

&D]XO,,IW

IXQF LHOLQLDU PRQRWRQ

GHVFUHVF

WRDUHLDUJW

IXQF LH

vQWLPS

2 VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO VD GHFLV V DFKL]L LRQH]H XQ HFKLSDPHQW GH SURGXF LH DO F UXL SUH HVWH3 t

PLOOHL

3HED]DGRFXPHQWD LHLWHKQLFRHFRQRPLFHVHFXQRVFXUP WRDUHOHLQIRUPD LL D (YROX LDvQWLPSDYDORULLHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH

'XS SULPXODQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOGRLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOWUHLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOSDWUXOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOFLQFLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

E &KHOWXLHOLOH GH vQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL GH SURGXF LH YRU IL HJDOH úL FRQVWDQWHvQWLPSSHWRDW GXUDWDGHXWLOL]DUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLFXPLOOHLDQ 3HED]DLQIRUPD LLORUGHPDLVXVV VHHVWLPH]HWLPSXORSWLPGHvQORFXLUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL 5H]ROYDUH 'HRDUHFH GDWHOH UHIHULWRDUH OD YDORDUHD HFKLSDPHQWXOXL OD UHYkQ]DUHD VDX OD OLFKLGDUHD DFHVWXLD VXQW LGHQWLFH FX FHOH GLQ DSOLFD LD ± YH]L )LJXUD úL IXQF LD GHYDORUL] ULL vQ WLPSDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLYDU PkQHQHVFKLPEDW IW

± W

)XQF LD FKHOWXLHOLORU GH vQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL HVWH R IXQF LH PRQRWRQ GH IRUPDJW

PLOOHLDQYH]L)LJXUD

J W

W

)LJXUD ,QWURGXFkQG H[SUHVLLOH FHORU GRX IXQF LL vQ HFXD LD FRVWXO PHGLX DQXDO GH IRORVLQ UH]XOWDF \

u

=

< W

u

v

=

3

v

- 3

¢I W

(W ) +

J

(W )

v

=

3

v

- 3

¢ ( - E ¢ W

)+

N

W

&DOFXOkQG GHULYDWD FRVWXOXL PHGLX DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH

v

= 3

(\ y )

¢E +

x

N

= +

W

= -

N W

w

W

YD

VH FRQVWDW F DFHDVWD

QXVHDQXOHD] GHFkWSHQWUXWLDUIXQF LDFRVWXOXLPHGLXHVWHRIXQF LHPRQRWRQGHVFUHVF WRDUH vQWLPSWLQ]kQGVSUHPLQLPDWXQFLFkQGWYH]L)LJXUD

211

\

W

W

)LJXUD

6H GHGXFH XúRU SH ED]D FDOFXOHORU úL D JUDILFXOXL GLQ )LJXUD F vQ DFHVW FD] GHFL]LD HFRQRPHWULF DILUPHLHVWHGHDPHQ LQHvQH[SORDWDUHFkWPDLPXOWWLPSSRVLELOHFKLSDPHQWXO

&D]XO,,,IW

IXQF LHH[SRQHQ LDO OLQLDU

FUHVF

GHVFUHVF

WRDUHLDUJW

IXQF LH

WRDUH

2 VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO VD GHFLV V DFKL]L LRQH]H XQ HFKLSDPHQW GH SURGXF LH DO F UXL SUH HVWH3 t

PLOOHL

3HED]DGRFXPHQWD LHLWHKQLFRHFRQRPLFHVHFXQRVFXUP WRDUHOHLQIRUPD LL

D (YROX LDvQWLPSDYDORULLHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH

'XS SULPXODQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOGRLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOWUHLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOSDWUXOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOFLQFLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

E (YROX LDvQWLPSDFKHOWXLHOLORUGHLQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH

'XS SULPXODQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOGRLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOWUHLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOSDWUXOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOFLQFLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOúDVHOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

3HED]DLQIRUPD LLORUGHPDLVXVV VHHVWLPH]HWLPSXORSWLPGHvQORFXLUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL

212

5H]ROYDUH ,GHQWLILFDUHDIXQF LHLIW UHVSHFWLYHYROX LDvQWLPSDYDORULLHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LHVH YDIDFHSHED]DUHSUH]HQW ULLJUDILFHDDFHVWHLDYH]L)LJXUD

I W 3

W

)LJXUD

3HED]DJUDILFXOXLGHPDLVXVVHREVHUY F HYROX LDYDORULLHFKLSDPHQWXOXLSRDWHILHVWLPDW FX DMXWRUXO XQHL IXQF LL H[SRQHQ LDOH GH IRUPD IW

H

z|{}

IW UHSUH]HQWkQG IXQF LDGHYDORUL] ULLvQ

WLPSDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLFDUHUH]XOW vQXUPDUDSRUW ULLSUH XULORUGHUHYkQ]DUHODSUH XOGHDFKL]L LHD HFKLSDPHQWXOXL3 t YH]L7DEHOXO 7DEHOXO $QL

9DORDUHDGHUHYkQ]DUHDHFKLSPLOOHL

W

I

3 t ÂIW

(W ) =

s

¢I

3

s

(W )

3

(VWLPDUHDSDUDPHWUXOXLEVHYDIDFHSHED]DPHWRGHLSXQFWHORUHPSLULFH )LHSXQFWXO1 H Ü I

(W ) = H

~

= E=OQ E =

- (- )

=

ÌQWUXFkW GDWHOH UHIHULWRDUH OD HYROX LD vQ WLPS D FKHOWXLHOLORU GH vQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL VXQW LGHQWLFH FX FHOH GLQ DSOLFD LD ± YH]L )LJXUD úL IXQF LD FKHOWXLHOLORUGHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLYDU PkQHQHVFKLPEDW JW

ÂW

ÌQDFHVWFD]IXQF LDFRVWXOXLPHGLXDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUHHVWH \

=

< W

=

3

- 3

¢I W

(W ) +

J (W

)

=

W

¢

(3

-

3

¢H

+ N ¢W

)=

(

¢ - H W

)

+

213

'HULYDWDDFHVWHLIXQF LLHVWH

ë

(\ )

=

W

[ (- 3

¢ -

¢E ¢H

)¢ W

(

- 3 - 3 ¢H

)]

=

W

¢3

(

¢ E ¢W ¢H

+H

)

-

'HRDUHFH GHULYDWD IXQF HL FRVWXOXL PHGLX DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH QX VH DQXOHD] SHQWUX QLFL R YDORDUHSR]LWLY DOXLWFRVWXOPHGLXDQXDOGHH[SORDWDUH \

HVWHRIXQF LHPRQRWRQGHVFUHVF WRDUH

FDUHLDYDORDUHDPLQLP SHQWUXW

\

W

)LJXUD

ÌQ FRQFOX]LH SH ED]D FDOFXOHORU GH PDL VXV VDX D UHSUH]HQW ULL JUDILFH YH]L )LJXUD GHFL]LD HFRQRPLF vQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH HVWH DFHHDúL FD úL vQ FD]XO SUHFHGHQW UHVSHFWLY GH D PHQ LQH vQH[SORDWDUHHFKLSDPHQWXOFkWPDLPXOWWLPSSRVLELO

&D]XO,9IW

IXQF LHH[SRQHQ LDO

IXQF LHH[SRQHQ LDO

FUHVF

GHVFUHVF

WRDUHLDUJW

WRDUH

2 VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO VD GHFLV V DFKL]L LRQH]H XQ HFKLSDPHQW GH SURGXF LH DO F UXL SUH HVWH3

PLOOHL

3HED]DGRFXPHQWD LHLWHKQLFRHFRQRPLFHVHFXQRVFXUP WRDUHOHLQIRUPD LL D (YROX LDvQWLPSDYDORULLHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH

'XS SULPXODQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOGRLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOWUHLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOSDWUXOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOFLQFLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

E (YROX LDvQWLPSDFKHOWXLHOLORUGHvQWUH LQHUHúLUHSDUD LLDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLGHSURGXF LH

'XS SULPXODQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOGRLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOWUHLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOSDWUXOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOFLQFLOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

'XS DOúDVHOHDDQGHIRORVLUH

PLOOHL

3HED]DLQIRUPD LLORUGHPDLVXVV VHHVWLPH]HWLPSXORSWLPGHvQORFXLUHDHFKLSDPHQWXOXL

214

5H]ROYDUH 'HRDUHFH GDWHOH UHIHULWRDUH OD YDORDUHD HFKLSDPHQWXOXL OD UHYkQ]DUHD VDX OD OLFKLGDUHD DFHVWXLD VXQW LGHQWLFH FX FHOH GLQ DSOLFD LD ± YH]L )LJXUD úL IXQF LD GHYDORUL] ULL vQ

(W ) = H

WLPSDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLYDU PkQHQHVFKLPEDW I

,GHQWLILFDUHD IXQF LHL JW UHVSHFWLY HYROX LD vQ WLPS D FKHOWXLHOLORU GH vQWUH LQHUH úL UHSDUD LL D HFKLSDPHQWXOXL VH YD IDFH SH ED]D JUDILFXOXL HYROX LHL vQ WLPS D DFHVWRU FKHOWXLHOL YH]L )LJXUD

J W

W

)LJXUD (YROX LD vQ WLPS D FKHOWXLHOLORU GH UHSDUD LL DúD FXP UH]XOW GLQ JUDILF SRDWH IL DSUR[LPDW FXDMXWRUXOXQHLIXQF LLH[SRQHQ LDOHFHWUHFHSULQRULJLQHUHVSHFWLY JW

NÂH

)RORVLQG PHWRGD SXQFWHORU HPSLULFH HVWLPDWRULL SDUDPHWULORU N úL F YRU IL FDOFXOD L SH ED]D SXQFWHORU 1 úL 1 ÌQORFXLQG vQ HFXD LD IXQF LHL JW FRRUGRQDWHOH FHORU GRX SXQFWH YDUH]XOWDXUP WRUXOVLVWHPGHHFXD LL SHQWUXW

NÂH

SHQWUXW

NÂH

ÌPS U LQGDGRXDUHOD LHODSULPDUHOD LHYDUH]XOWDXUP WRUXOUDSRUW

1RWkQGFXH

H 3H \

¦

=

< W

¦

=

3

=

ED]D

H

(W )

¡

- -

+ J (W

)

=

W

3

FHORU

- 3

¢H

=

GRX

° © ¦

[

-

[ -

[ + =

N =

OQF

H[SUHVLLORU

¢ I

¡

[YDUH]XOWD

F

- 3

H

IXQF LL

(

+ N ¢ H

¨ ¦

-

W

)

-

IW =

úL

[ =

=

= ÜJW

JW

IXQF LD

- ¢

° § ®¯ ¦

ÂH

FRVWXOXL + ¢

¢£ ¤¥

PLQLP

(

§ ¬ª « ¦

YD

W

9DORDUHDPLQLP DDFHVWHLIXQF LLHVWHGDW GHPRPHQWXOvQFDUHGHULYDWDVDVHDQXOHD] \ ³ =

W

²

¢

{[ W ¢ ( 3±

¢E ¢ H

´ · µ

+ N ¢F ¢H

¶ µ

)] - [ 3±

(

¢ -H

$FHDVW GHULYDW VHDQXOHD] DWXQFLFkQG

\ ¹ = 3¸

¢E ¢W ¢H

º ½ »

+ 3¸

¢H

º ½ »

- 3¸

IL

)

-

+ N ¢F¢W ¢H

¼ »

´ · µ

) + N ¢ (H

- N ¢H

¼ »

¶ µ

-

)] }=

+ N =

215

5H]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLHFXD LLILLQGJUHRDLHHVWHVXILFLHQWV úWLPF DFHDVW GHULYDW VHDQXOHD] SHQWUXRDQXPLW SHULRDG GHWLPS'HFLDFHDVW IXQF LHSUH]LQW RYDORDUHPLQLP DFRVWXOXLPHGLX DQXDOGHH[SORDWDUH

PRPHQWXOXL RSWLP GH vQORFXLUH SH ED]D FRVWXOXL PLQLP VH YD IDFH FX DMXWRUXO 'HWHUPLQDUHD

FDOFXOHORUQXPHULFHSUH]HQWDWHvQWDEHOXOGHPDLMRV 7DEHOXO W

¾

\

3HED]DFDOFXOHORUGHPDLVXVVHFRQVWDW F PRPHQWXORSWLPGHvQORFXLUHVHVLWXHD] vQWUHDO SDWUXOHDúLDOFLQFHOHDDQ 3HQWUX D HVWLPD PRPHQWXO RSWLP GH vQORFXLUH VH YRU FRQWLQXD LWHUD LLOH SHQWUX XUP WRDUHOH YDORULDOHYDULDELOHLWLPSW

W

«W

YH]L7DEHOXOFRORDQHOHúL

7DEHOXO W

\

¾

3H ED]D GDWHORU GLQ 7DEHOXO VH HVWLPHD] F PRPHQWXO RSWLP GH vQORFXLUH D HFKLSDPHQWXOXLHVWHGDWGHW

DQLGHODSXQHUHDVDvQIXQF LXQHGHRDUHFHvQDFHVWPRPHQWVHYD

vQUHJLVWUD FHO PDL PLF FRVW DQXDO GH H[SORDWDUH UHVSHFWLY \

¿

= PLOOHLDQ$FHHDúLFRQFOX]LH

VHGHGXFHúLGLQUHSUH]HQWDUHDJUDILF ±YH]L)LJXUD

\

À

W

)LJXUD

216

$QDOL]DHFRQRPHWULF SURGXF LHFXX]XU

DGHFL]LHLGHvQORFXLUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQWGH

DOHDWRDUHvQFDGUXOXQHLVRFLHW

LFRPHUFLDOH

)RUPXODUHDHFRQRPLF DSUREOHPHL 6H SUHVXSXQH F VXQW SXVH vQ IXQF LXQH QW WLS vQ FDGUXO XQHL VRFLHW

(W

= 7

) HFKLSDPHQWH GH SURGXF

LH GH DFHODúL

L FRPHUFLDOH /D LQWHUYDOH GH WLPS GH IXQF LRQDUH HJDOH VH vQUHJLVWUHD]

QXP UXOGHHFKLSDPHQWHU PDVHvQIXQF LXQHGLQFHOHQ HFKLSDPHQWHLQL LDOH 'DF GH H[HPSOX R VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO D SXV vQ IXQF LXQH GH HFKLSDPHQWH GH SURGXF LH vQ DQXO vQ XUP WRULL DQL QXP UXO DFHVWRUD D vQUHJLVWUDW XUP WRDUHOH GLPLQX UL YH]L 7DEHOXOFRORDQHOHúL 7DEHOXO W

QW

YW =

Ã

Ä

Q

(W )

Q ( )

QW QW

3Á

(W ) =

Q (W - ) - Q (W Q ()

)

3Â

(W ) =

Q (W - ) - Q (W Q (W - )

Å

Æ

Ç

!

)

6H GHILQHúWH SULQ GXUDWD GH IXQF LRQDUH D XQXL HFKLSDPHQW LQWHUYDOXO GH WLPS GHUXODW vQWUH SXQHUHD VD vQ IXQF LXQH úL PRPHQWXO W FRQVLGHUDW 'H UH LQXW HVWH IDSWXO F WLPSXO VDX GXUDWD GH IXQF LRQDUHGLIHU vQIXQF LHGHQDWXUDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLRUHGHIXQF LRQDUHSHQWUXPRWRDUHHOHFWULFH DYLRDQHNP±SHQWUXDXWRPRELOHDF LXQL±SHQWUXQXP UXOGHDWHUL] ULDOHXQXLDYLRQHWF 'DF Q UHSUH]LQW QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH SXVH vQ IXQF LXQH OD PRPHQWXO LQL LDO LDU QW QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH GLQ FHOH Q H[LVWHQWH vQ IXQF LXQH OD PRPHQWXO W DWXQFL P ULPHD Y( W ) =

Q (W)

Q ( )

Ê Y( W ) Ê W Ë UHSUH]LQW SUREDELOLWDWHD GH IXQF LRQDUH OD PRPHQWXO W D XQXL

HFKLSDPHQWSXVvQIXQF LXQHODPRPHQWXO 3H ED]D DFHVWHL P ULPL VH SRDWH FDOFXOD FXUED GH IXQF LRQDUH D XQXL HFKLSDPHQW RDUHFDUH vQUHJLVWUkQG GDWHOH FRUHVSXQ] WRDUH XQHL SRSXOD LL RPRJHQH GH HFKLSDPHQWH VDX DOH XQXL HúDQWLRQ UHSUH]HQWDWLYDODFHVWHLD 'DF

FRQGL LLOH

PHQ LRQDWH

PDL

VXV

SRW

IL

UHVSHFWDWH

VH

SRDWH

DFFHSWD

IDSWXO

F

HFKLSDPHQWHOH GH XQ DQXPLW WLS FRQVWLWXLH XQ DQVDPEOX RPRJHQ GLQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH VWDWLVWLF UHVSHFWLY F SHQWUX ILHFDUH HFKLSDPHQW GLQ SRSXOD LD REVHUYDW H[LVW R SUREDELOLWDWH ÄD SULRUL´ FD WRDWHFHOHODOWHHFKLSDPHQWHGHDFHODúLWLSV XUPH]HIXQF LDSUREDELOLW 3È

(7

ËW

)

= Y (W

)

=

Q (W

)

Q ( )

LLGHIXQF LRQDUH

W = 7 YH]L7DEHOXO±FRORDQDúL)LJXUD

217

Y W 3

Ï

W

Y W

3

Ð

W

W

)LJXUD

3RUQLQGGHODGDWHOHGLQ7DEHOXOVHSRWFDOFXODRVHULHGHLQGLFDWRULFXPDUIL 3UREDELOLWDWHDGHIXQF LRQDUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQWGXS WDQLGHXWLOL]DUH SHQWUXW

DQLSUREDELOLWDWHDGHIXQF LRQDUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQWHVWH 3É

(7

Ë W ) = Y () =

Q ()

Q ( )

=

=

3UREDELOLWDWHD FD XQ HFKLSDPHQW V ILH VFRV GLQ IXQF LXQH GXS W DQL GH XWLOL]DUH SUREDELOLWDWHDFRQWUDU

3( 7 Ê W ) = - Y ( W ) = M ( W ) XQGHMW UHSUH]LQW GXUDWDGHIXQF LRQDUHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQW

'HH[HPSOXSUREDELOLWDWHDFDXQHFKLSDPHQWV QXPDLILHvQIXQF LXQHGXS FLQFLDQLHVWH

3 (7 Ê ) = - 3 (7

Ë ) = - =

1XP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH FH WUHEXLH DFKL]L LRQDWH vQ YHGHUHD GHVI úXU ULL vQ FRQGL LL RSWLPHDSURFHVXOXLGHSURGXF LH ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHVRFLHWDWHDFRPHUFLDO FDUHGH LQHDFHVWHHFKLSDPHQWHDUHQHYRLHvQFHOGHDO FLQFLOHD DQ GH GH HFKLSDPHQWH vQ VWDUH GH IXQF LRQDUH QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH FDUH YRU WUHEXLDFKL]L LRQDWHODvQFHSXWXOFHOXLGHDOFLQFLOHDDQYDIL

Q

() =

Q

( ) ¢ M () =

( ) ¢ 3 (7

Q

Ê ) = ¢ = HFKLSDPHQWH

3UREDELOLWDWHD FD XQ HFKLSDPHQW V ILH VFRV GLQIXQF LXQHvQWUXQLQWHUYDOFXSULQVvQWUHW úLWHVWHXUP WRDUHD 3Ê

(W ) =

3 (W - Ê 7

ÊW

)=

3 (7

Ë W - ) - 3 (7

ËW

)=

Q (W - ) Q

( )

-

Q (W Q

)

( )

=

Q (W - ) - Q (W Q ( )

)

XQGH3Ë W UHSUH]LQW IXQF LDGHVFRDWHUHGLQIXQF LXQHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQW 3HED]DGDWHORUGLQ7DEHOXOSUREDELOLWDWHDFDXQHFKLSDPHQWV ILHVFRVGLQIXQF LXQH vQLQWHUYDOXOW

úLW

HVWH 3Ì

( ) =

Q

(

- ) - Q Q

( )

( )

=

Q () - Q ( ) Q ( )

=

-

=

YH]L7DEHOXOFRORDQD 3UREDELOLWDWHDGHDYDULHDXQXLHFKLSDPHQW 6H GHILQHúWH SULQ SUREDELOLWDWH GH DYDULH SUREDELOLWDWHD FRQGL LRQDW FD XQ HFKLSDPHQW FDUHD IXQF LRQDWI U QLFLRDYDULHSkQ ODPRPHQWXOWV DLE RGHIHF LXQHvQLQWHUYDOXOWúLW)LH3Í W DFHDVW SUREDELOLWDWHFRQGL LRQDW $WXQFLVHSRDWHVFULH 3 (W - Ê 7

ÊW

)=

3 (7 Ë W - ) ¢ 3Î

(W )

GHXQGHUH]XOW F

218

(W ) =

3Ñ

3 (W - Ê 7 Ê W 3 (7

Ë W - )

)

Q

(W

- ) - Q (W Q

=

Q

(W

Q

( )

)

Q (W

=-

- )

Q

( )

(W

)

- )

YH]L 7DEHOXO

FRORDQD 'HH[HPSOXSHQWUXW

DQLSUREDELOLWDWHDGHDYDULHHVWH Q ()

() = -

3Ò

Q ( )

=-

= - =

3UREDELOLWDWHD GH DYDULH HVWH R P ULPH FDUDFWHULVWLF IRDUWH LPSRUWDQW GHRDUHFH SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO DFHVWHLD SRDWH IL HYDOXDW ULVFXO GH D PHQ LQH vQ IXQF LXQH XQ HFKLSDPHQW FDUH D DWLQV R GXUDW WGHIXQF LRQDUH 5DWDGHDSURYL]LRQDUH )LHQ QXP UXOGHHFKLSDPHQWHSXVHvQIXQF LXQHODPRPHQWXOW 'DF Y (W

)=

Q (W

)

Q ( )

Q

UHSUH]LQW SUREDELOLWDWHD GH IXQF LRQDUH D HFKLSDPHQWHORU DFHVWHD YRU

U PkQHvQIXQF LXQHODPRPHQWXOWGDF QXYDILHIHFWXDW QLFLRvQORFXLUH QW

Q YW

)LHUN QXP UXOGHHFKLSDPHQWHvQORFXLWHSkQ ODPRPHQWXON ( < N Ê W

) DWXQFL

UN ± UN UHSUH]LQW QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH vQORFXLWH vQ LQWHUYDOXO N ± úL N

JN

)XQF LDJW UHSUH]LQW IXQF LDGHDSURYL]LRQDUH 1XP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH DIODWH vQF vQ IXQF LXQH vQWUXQ PRPHQW YLLWRU W SURYHQLWH GLQ DFHDVW DSURYL]LRQDUHYDIL JN YWN

>UN ±UN @ YWN

'HFL QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH DIODWH vQ IXQF LXQH OD PRPHQWXO W HVWH HJDO FX VXPD HFKLSDPHQWHORU vQ VWDUH GH IXQF LRQDUH SHQWUX ILHFDUH LQWHUYDO GH WLPS FXSULQV vQWUH N

úL N

W

vQPXO LW HYLGHQW FX QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH vQ VWDUH GH IXQF LRQDUH SURYHQLWH GLQ FHOH Q HFKLSDPHQWHSXVHvQIXQF LXQHODPRPHQWXOLQL LDOW

úLFDUHDXXUPDWDFHHDúLOHJHGHIXQF LRQDUH

$VWIHOQXP UXOGHHFKLSDPHQWHvQVWDUHGHIXQF LRQDUHODPRPHQWXOWYDIL

(W ) =

I

SHQWUX N =

Ü I

SHQWUX N =

Ü I

Ü J

() =

I

() -

SHQWUX N =

Ü J

( ) =

I

() =

I

Q

Q

Ô

Ó Ö [J (N ) ¢ Y (W ÕÇ

)+

Q ( )

() =

Q

( ) =

( ) ¢ Y () +

Q ( ) ¢ Y

() ¢ Y ( ) -

Ü I

() -

() =

() ¢ Y ()

Ü I

( ) -

SHQWUX N =

Ü J

Q

Q ( ) ¢ Y (W

() =

J

() ¢ Y () -

J

)]

() ¢ Y ( ) =

J

Q

( ) ¢ Y () +

( ) +

J () ¢ Y () + J ( ) ¢ Y

() +

J () ¢ Y

() ¢ Y ()

Q ( ) ¢ Y

- N

() ¢ Y ( ) -

J

( ) +

J

()

()

J ( ) ¢ Y () + J () ¢ Y

( ) ¢ Y ()

( )

SHQWUX N = W Ü J (W

)=

I

Ü I

(W ) -

(W ) =

Q ( ) ¢ Y (W

Q ( ) ¢ Y (W

)-

ß Ü Þ

àÇ Ý Þ

)+

Ø Ú ×

ÙÇ Û ×

[J (N ) ¢ Y (W

[J (N ) ¢ Y (W

- N

- N

)] +

J (W

) ¢ Y ( )

)]

XQGHJW UHSUH]LQW IXQF LDVDXYROXPXODSURYL]LRQ ULL ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH VRFLHWDWHD FRPHUFLDO vQORFXLHúWH vQ ILHFDUH DQ HFKLSDPHQWHOH FH VXQW VFRDVH GLQIXQF LXQHFDXUPDUHDDYDULLORUVDXDFFLGHQWHORUIXQF LDVDXYROXPXODSURYL]LRQ ULLYDIL J (W

)=

I

(W ) -

Q ( ) ¢ Y (W

)-

á ã å

âÇ ä å

[Q (W

- ) - Q (W

)] ¢ Y (W

- N

)

219

5HYHQLQG OD H[HPSOXO LQL LDO ± GDF VRFLHWDWHD FRPHUFLDO D vQORFXLW vQ FHO GHDO SDWUXOHD DQ GH HFKLSDPHQWH DWXQFL QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH DIODWH vQ IXQF LXQH vQ FHO GHDO úDSWHOHD DQ YD IL I

Q Y Y

I

HFKLSDPHQWH

ÌQ DFHVW FD] QXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH FDUH WUHEXLH vQORFXLWH vQ FHO GHDO úDSWHOHD DQ SHQWUX D DYHDvQIXQF LXQHGHHFKLSDPHQWHHVWHHJDOFX JW

±

HFKLSDPHQWH

'DF VRFLHWDWHDFRPHUFLDO DvQORFXLWvQFHOGHDOSDWUXOHDDQGHHFKLSDPHQWHvQFHOGH DOFLQFLOHDDQGHHFKLSDPHQWHLDUvQFHOGHDOúDVHOHDDQGHHFKLSDPHQWHDWXQFLQXP UXO GH HFKLSDPHQWH FDUH WUHEXLH vQORFXLWH vQ FHO GHDO úDSWHOHD DQ SHQWUX D DYHD vQ IXQF LXQH GH HFKLSDPHQWHHVWHHJDOFX I

Y Y Y

I

J

±

HFKLSDPHQWH

HFKLSDPHQWH

(VWLPDUHDHFRQRPHWULF

DYROXPXOXLSURGXF LHLvQYHGHUHDPD[LPL]

SURILWXOXLXQHLVRFLHW

ULL

LFRPHUFLDOH

2 VRFLHWDWH FRPHUFLDO GLVSXQHGHLQIRUPD LLSULYLQGOHJHDFHUHULLUHIHULWRDUHODSURGXF LDSH FDUHRUHDOL]HD] 'HH[HPSOX SHQWUX R SURGXF LH T Ê WRQH SUH XOSHFDUHvOYDSXWHDRE LQHVRFLHWDWHDFRPHUFLDO YDIL S = PLLOHLNJ

SHQWUXRSURGXF LH T = WRQH VRFLHWDWHDYDRE LQHXQSUH GH S = PLLOHLNJ SHQWUXRSURGXF LH T = WRQH VRFLHWDWHDYDRE LQHXQSUH GH S = PLLOHLNJ SHQWUXRSURGXF LH T = WRQH SUH XORE LQXWYDIL S = PLLOHLNJ SHQWUXRSURGXF LH T = WRQH SUH XORE LQXWYDIL S = PLLOHLNJ SHQWUXRSURGXF LH T = WRQH SUH XORE LQXWYDIL S = PLLOHLNJ 'H DVHPHQHD SH ED]D XQRU FDOFXOH WHKQLFRHFRQRPLFH vQ IXQF LH GH YROXPXO SURGXF LHL FKHOWXLHOLOHGHSURGXF LHDIHUHQWHvQUHJLVWUHD] XUP WRDUHOHYDORUL±YH]L7DEHOXO

7DEHOXO

9ROXPXOSURGXF LHLWRQH

&KHOWXLHOLGHSURGXF LHPLOOHL

3HED]DDFHVWRUGDWHV VHHVWLPH]HQLYHOXORSWLPDOSURGXF LHLSHQWUXFDUHVHRE LQHXQSURILW PD[LP 5H]ROYDUH 3RUQLQGGHODWHRULDHFRQRPLF DILUPHLRSWLPL]DUHDSURILWXOXLVRFLHW

LLFRPHUFLDOHVHSRDWH

RE LQHFXDMXWRUXOXQXLPRGHOHFRQRPHWULFFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOHGHIRUPD /HJHDFHUHULLSURGXF LHL S = I

(T ) + X

)XQF LDGHSURGXF LHDFKHOWXLHOLORU &K = J

(FXD LDFLIUHLGHDIDFHUL &$ = S ¢ T = T ¢ I )XQF LDSURILWXOXL P = &$ - &K = T ¢ I

(T ) +

(T )

(T ) -

J

]

(T )

220

XQGH S

SUH XOGHYkQ]DUHDSURGXVHORU

T

YROXPXOSURGXF LHL

X]

YDULDELOHOHUH]LGXDOH

ÌQ ILQDO VH FRQVWDW F SURILWXO VRFLHW

LL GHSLQGH QXPDL GH YROXPXO SURGXF LHL 5H]ROYDUHD

SUREOHPHL PD[LPL]DUHD SURILWXOXL VH SRDWH IDFH ILH SH ED]D GHULYDWHL HFXD LHL ILH SH ED]D UHSUH]HQW ULLJUDILFHILHSHED]DFDOFXOHORUQXPHULFH 3RUQLQG GH OD LQIRUPD LLOH FRQFUHWH SUH]HQWDWH DQWHULRU HVWLPDUHD YROXPXOXL SURGXF LHL FH PD[LPL]HD] SURILWXO VRFLHW

LL UHVSHFWLYH SUHVXSXQH HVWLPDUHD OHJLL FHUHULL D IXQF LHLGHSURGXF LH

D FKHOWXLHOLORU D FLIUHL GH DIDFHUL D IXQF LHL SURILWXOXL úL D YROXPXOXL SURGXF LHL FDUH FRQGXFH OD RE LQHUHDSURILWXOXLPD[LPDOVRFLHW

LL

(VWLPDUHDOHJLLFHUHULL SHQWUX T Ê W UH]XOW F S = PLLOHLNJ SHQWUX T > W UH]XOW F OHJHD FHUHULL YD WUHEXL HVWLPDW FX DMXWRUXO XQHL IXQF LL PDWHPDWLFH

S

T

)LJXUD(YROX LDSUH XOXLvQIXQF LHGHYROXPXOSURGXF LHL ÌQXUPDUHSUH]HQW ULLJUDILFHDGDWHORUYH]L)LJXUD VHFRQVWDW F OHJHDFHUHULLSHQWUX XQ YROXP GH YkQ] UL T > W SRDWH IL HVWLPDW FX DMXWRUXO XQHL IXQF LL SXWHUH VDX GXEOX ORJDULWPLFH S = D ¢ T

æ

¢ X

$FHVWPRGHOQHOLQLDUSRDWHILWUDQVIRUPDWvQWUXQPRGHOOLQLDUSULQORJDULWPDUH OQS

OQDEÂOQTOQX 1RWkQGFX

OQS

S

OQT

T

OQX

X

OQD

D

P

QXP UXOGHREVHUYD LL

221

YD UH]XOWD XQ PRGHO OLQLDU XQLIDFWRULDO S

D E Â T X DL F UXL SDUDPHWUL YRU IL HVWLPD L FX

DMXWRUXOPHWRGHLFHORUPDLPLFLS WUDWH ÌQXUPDDSOLF ULLSURJUDPXOXL(;&(/VDXRE LQXWXUP WRDUHOHUH]XOWDWH 6800$5<287387

5HJUHVVLRQ6WDWLVWLFV

0XOWLSOH5

56TXDUH

$GMXVWHG56TXDUH

$129$

GI

66

06

)

5HJUHVVLRQ

5HVLGXDO

7RWDO

&RHIILFLHQWV

6WDQGDUG(UURU

W6WDW

6WDQGDUG(UURU 2EVHUYDWLRQV

,QWHUFHSW ;9DULDEOH

(VWLPDWRULLFHORUGRLSDUDPHWULLVXQW

Ö ë = = OQ D Ü D Ö = @ ÅD Ö ®E = - @ -

3H ED]D LQIRUPD LLORU OLVWDWH GH SURJUDP PRGHOXO HFRQRPHWULF DO OHJLL FHUHULL SRDWH IL DFFHSWDW FD PRGHO RSHUD LRQDO VLPLOLWXGLQHD VWDWLVWLF D DFHVWXLD FX GDWHOH SULPDUH DOH SUH XOXL úL YROXPXOXLFHUHULLILLQGIRDUWHPDULHVWLPDWRULLúLUDSRUWXOGHFRUHOD LHILLQGVHPQLILFDWLYLFXXQSUDJ GHVHPQLILFD LHIRDUWHPLF

Å

S =

® ¢ T

è

ç

PLL OHL SHQWUX

SHQWUX

T Ê W T > W

(VWLPDUHD IXQF LHL FKHOWXLHOLORU GH SURGXF LH vQ UDSRUW FX YROXPXO SURGXF LHL VH IDFH FD úL vQFD]XOSUHFHGHQWSULQUHSUH]HQWDUHDJUDILF DYDORULORUFHORUGRX YDULDELOHYH]L)LJXUD

&K

T

)LJXUD(YROX LDFKHOWXLHOLORUGHSURGXF LHvQIXQF LHGHYROXPXOSURGXF LHL

222

$úD FXP VH SUH]LQW FRUHORJUDPD YDULDELOHORU IXQF LD GH SURGXF LH D FKHOWXLHOLORU HVWH GH IRUP OLQLDU UHVSHFWLY &K = a + b ¢ T + ] ÌQYHGHUHDHVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORUVHYDIRORVLSURJUDPXO(;&(/ 6800$5<287387 5HJUHVVLRQ6WDWLVWLFV

0XOWLSOH5

56TXDUH

$GMXVWHG56TXDUH

6WDQGDUG(UURU

2EVHUYDWLRQV

$129$ GI

66

06

)

5HJUHVVLRQ

5HVLGXDO

7RWDO

&RHIILFLHQWV

6WDQGDUG(UURU

W6WDW

,QWHUFHSW

;9DULDEOH

&HOH WUHL WDEHOH OLVWDWH GH SURJUDPXO (;&(/ FD úL vQ FD]XO PRGHOXOXL OHJLL FHUHULL UHOHY IDSWXO F PRGHOXO OLQLDU DO FKHOWXLHOLORU GH SURGXF LH GLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHHFRQRPHWULFDIRVWFRUHFW VSHFLILFDW úL LGHQWLILFDW &D DWDUH vQ VFRSXO HVWLP ULL SURILWXOXL RSWLP DO VRFLHW

LL IXQF LD

FKHOWXLHOLORUGHSURGXF LHHVWH &K = + ¢ T 3HED]DUH]XOWDWHORURE LQXWHPDLVXVFLIUDGHDIDFHULDVRFLHW

LLFRPHUFLDOHHVWHGHVFULV

GHPRGHOXO Å S ¢ T = ¢ T ¿

&$ = ¿ ®

S ¢T =

T

PLL

¢ T =

OHL

SHQWUX

PLL

OHL

T Ê W

SHQWUX

T > W

)XQF LDSURILWXOXLSRUQLQGGHODUHOD LD VHHVWLPHD] FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LHL

SHQWUX T Ê W UH]XOW F P é

= ¢ T -

(

+ ¢T

) = ¢T

- GHFL IXQF LD SURILWXOXL

HVWHRIXQF LHOLQLDU FUHVF WRDUHvQUDSRUWFXYROXPXOSURGXF LHL

SHQWUX T > W UH]XOW F P ê

= -

(

+ ¢T

) = -

¢ T GHFL IXQF LD SURILWXOXL

HVWHRIXQF LHOLQLDU GHVFUHVF WRDUHvQUDSRUWFXYROXPXOSURGXF LHL (VWLPDUHD YROXPXOXL RSWLP DO SURGXF LHL SHQWUX FDUH VH RE LQH XQ SURILW PD[LP VH IDFH vQ XUPDGLVFX LHLFHORUGRX IXQF LLDOHSURILWXOXL

Pë

= ¢T -

Pì

= - ¢ T

6WUDWHJLD VRFLHW

LL FRPHUFLDOH FRQVW vQ D RE LQH XQ SURILW PDL PDUH FD ]HUR GLQ FHOH GRX

UHOD LLUH]XOWkQG

Pí

= ¢T - > Ü T >

Pî

= - ¢ T > Ü T < W

W

'HXQGHUH]XOW F YROXPXORSWLPDOSURGXF LHLVHGHILQHúWHvQLQWHUYDOXO

223

T ( )

'HWHUPLQDUHDYROXPXOXLRSWLPDOSURGXF LHLVHSRDWHIDFHSULQGRX SURFHGHH D SULQFDOFXOHUHVSHFWLYSULQLQWHUVHF LDFHORUGRX IXQF LLDOHSURILWXOXL ¢ T - = - ¢ T Ü ¢ T = Ü T = WRQH

SHQWUXFDUHSURILWXOPD[LPHVWH P ïñðò

= ¢ - = PLOOHL

E SHFDOHJUDILF vQXUPDUHSUH]HQW ULLJUDILFHDIXQF LLORUFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHFLIUHLGHDIDFHUL úLDFKHOWXLHOLORUGHSURGXF LHYH]L)LJXUD

&$ &K

0

&K

&$

õ÷ö

TP LOOHL

øúùüû ýÿþ

T

0

ö

1

T

)LJXUD (VWLPDUHD YROXPXOXL RSWLP DO SURGXF LHL vQ YHGHUHD RE LQHULL XQXL SURILW PD[LP 3H ED]D JUDILFXOXL GH PDL VXV VH GHGXFH F SURILWXO PD[LP VH RE LQH vQ SXQFWXO SHQWUX FDUH YROXPXO SURGXF LHL HVWH HJDO FX WRQH SXQFW F UXLD vL FRUHVSXQGH RUGRQDWD PD[LP ± GLIHUHQ D GLQWUHRUGRQDWHOHFHORUGRX SXQFWH0 ó úL0ô ±

PLOOHLÌQSXQFWHOH1 ó úL1ô

SURILWXOHVWH

HJDOFX]HURLDUvQDIDUDDEVFLVHORUDFHVWRUSXQFWHDSDU]RQHOHGHSLHUGHULÌQWUHFHOHGRX SXQFWHVH vQUHJLVWUHD] ]RQDGHUHDOL]DUHDSURILWXOXLGHF WUHILUP

'HVFULHUHDHFRQRPHWULF

DOHJLLFHUHULLúLRIHUWHLFXDMXWRUXOXQXL

PRGHOHFRQRPHWULFFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH 6H FXQRVF XUP WRDUHOH GDWH SULYLQG FHUHUHD SUH XO úL RIHUWD XQXL DQXPLW SURGXV vQUHJLVWUDWH SHRDQXPLW SLD

7DEHOXO 2IHUWDEXF

3UH XOOHLEXF

&HUHUHDEXF

3UH XOOHLEXF

7DEHOXO

224

6HFHUH

D GHVFULHUHDHFRQRPHWULF DIRUP ULLSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUXúLHVWLPDUHDDFHVWXLD

E V VHFDOFXOH]HSUH XOGHHFKLOLEUXvQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUH

E ó RIHUWDU PkQHQHVFKLPEDW GDUFHUHUHDVSRUHúWHFX

Eô RIHUWDU PkQHQHVFKLPEDW GDUFHUHUHDVSRUHúWHFXGHEXF

F V VHFRPHQWH]HUH]XOWDWHOHRE LQXWHODSXQFWHOHD úLE

5H]ROYDUH

L

D 'HVFULHUHD HFRQRPHWULF D IRUP ULL SUH XOXL GH HFKLOLEUX VH UHDOL]HD] FX DMXWRUXO XUP WRUXOXLPRGHOFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOH

( 2)

3 = I

3 = I

2 = &

( &)

+ X

+ ]

3HQWUX LGHQWLILFDUHD OHJLL FHUHULL úL D RIHUWHL YRUWUHEXLFRQVWUXLWHVHULLOHVWDWLVWLFHúLYDWUHEXL HIHFWXDW UHSUH]HQWDUHDJUDILF DDFHVWRUD &RQVWUXLUHDVHULLORUVWDWLVWLFHVHIDFHSHED]DXUP WRDUHORUUD LRQDPHQWH GDF XQ FXPS U WRU DFKL]L LRQHD] XQ SURGXV OD XQ DQXPLW SUH HO vO YD FXPS UD FX DWkW PDLPXOWFXFkWSUH XOYDILPDLPLF GDF XQSURGXF WRURIHUWDQW vúLYLQGHSURGXVXOODXQDQXPLWSUH HOvOYDYLQGHFXDWkWPDL PXOWFXFkWSUH XOYDILPDLPDUH 3HED]DDFHVWRUUD LRQDPHQWHUH]XOW XUP WRDUHOHVHULLVWDWLVWLFHFRQVWUXLWHvQXUPDRUGRQ ULL SUH XULORUDQXQ DWHGHFXPS U WRULúLSURGXF WRUL 7DEHOXO 2IHUWD

3UH XO

&HUHUHD

PLLOHL PLLOHLEXF PLLEXF 2

2 3

&

& 3

Ö 3

= -

- &

X

Ö = 3 - 3

&

ó

ô

3

2

5HSUH]HQWDUHD JUDILF D SUH XOXL vQ IXQF LH GH FHUHUH úL RIHUW VH IDFH SH ED]D GDWHORU GLQ 7DEHOXOFRORDQHOH

225

D > -/. 610 -2. 6 -/. 510 -2. 5 -/. 340 -2. 3 -/. 010

7

-

8

9

:

0

3

5

6

;

=?>A@ BC>

-<7

)LJXUD

ÌQ XUPD UHSUH]HQW ULL JUDILFH YH]L )LJXUD VH REVHUY F OHJLOHFHUHULLúLRIHUWHLSRWIL DSUR[LPDWHFXGRX IXQF LLOLQLDUHGHIRUPD

/HJHDFHUHULL 3

= D

/HJHDRIHUWHL 3

=a

+ E &

+ b

+ X

2

+ ]

ÌQYHGHUHDHVWLP ULLSDUDPHWULORU D E a b VHDSOLF 0&003ILHF UXLPRGHOvQSDUWH 0RGHOXOFHUHULL

( !

! )=

Ö Ö E ) D

) ë( D

)ë E

)

$#

PLQ

" (3 Ç

$#

= Ü QD

$ ( $ )=

! )

!

$#

+ E

Ç&

$$

Ü D

Ö - 3

= PLQ

Ç&

$

#

=

#

%$!

Ç3

Ç&

$$

+ E

" (3 Ç

=

Ö - D

!

Ö -E &

!

! )

Ç

$$

3 &

3HED]DGDWHORUGLQ7DEHOXOFRORDQHOHVLVWHPXOGHHFXD LLGHYLQH

Å ¿D

$&

$&

+ E

¿ D ®

=

$&

$&

+ E

=

'HXQGHUH]XOW

Ç

Q

$'

=

E

' Ç&

'' Ç3 &

$)

=

E

Ç&

Q

Ç&

Ç&

'

-

Ç3

+

Ö D

+

=

+ + Ç3 & Q

Ç&

$,

D

=

'

+

3

=

'

'(

=

- -

= -

Ç

&

+ Ç&

Ç&

Ç&

+

+

*

+

*

=

=

-

=

226

ÌQILQDOPRGHOXOFDUHGHVFULHOHJHDFHUHULLHVWHGHIRUPD

= - &

,

,

3

0RGHOXORIHUWHL

H

$ E b$ E ) = PLQ Ç " ( 3E ) (a G

) ë(a

) ë( b

J

)

$K

$K

$K

= Ü Qa

K )=

+ b

Ç2

$K

Üa

$ - 3E ) Ç2

$K

K

F

+ b

K

H

=

" ( 3E PLQ Ç I G

=

Ç

Ç2

KL

K

)

F

3 =

$ 2E - b E

$E -a

Ç3

KM 2K

3HED]DGDWHORUGLQ7DEHOXOFRORDQHOHVLVWHPXOGHHFXD LLGHYLQH

Å a ¿

$N

$N

+ b

=

$N

¿ a ®

$N

+ b

=

'HXQGHUH]XOW

=

$O

a

$P

=

b

=

=

ÌQXUPDHIHFWX ULLFDOFXOHORUPRGHOXOFDUHGHVFULHOHJHDRIHUWHLHVWHGHIRUPD

Q

3

Q

= + 2

3HQWUX D YHULILFD VHPQLILFD LD SDUDPHWULORU úL D PRGHOHORU VH YRU FDOFXOD DEDWHULOH PHGLL S WUDWLFHDOHHVWLPDWRULORU

V

V

V

( VR T V

V

T S TU V VW V

»

b

ª

^` a

=

de f

=

j gi

=

m

V

_

+

ª Q ½

h Ç (3

V

of

=

V

pq r

=

V

xu v

V

V

z|y { ~ }

V

w su

» ª

Ç (3

=

V

=

Q - N -

V

2

Ç (2

Ç (2

V

)

-2

c )

t

-2

t )s

=

²

½

Õ

= Ü V

± ² ²

=

Õ

=

±

=

= Ü V

b

² = Õ

» ª + ª ½

=

j

Y[] \ )

5

» ª +

=

ts

b

²

=

l )

~ )

±

k

Ö - 3

=

-&

+

ª Q ½

n

b

- &

km

=

=

l Ç (&

c

=

Q - N -

V

c Ç (& g g h )

&

Ö - 3

=

) úLUDSRDUWHOHGHFRUHOD LH ( 5 Y[] Z

XT V

V

}

s

± ² = ² Õ

=

227

Ö - 3

- 3

=

=

=

5

5

5

-

)

Ç (3

Ç (3

)

-

=

=

-

=

=

3H ED]D FDOFXOHORU GH PDL VXV OHJHD FHUHULL úL OHJHD RIHUWHL VXQW GHVFULVH GH XUP WRDUHOH PRGHOHHFRQRPHWULFH

OHJHDFHUHULL

OHJHDRIHUWHL

= - &

3

(

2

)

(

1 42

)

= + 2

3

(

4

)

(

1

)

5

V

=

=

¢

=

5 V

¡

=

6H SRDWH FRQVWDWD UDSLG F DWkW HVWLPDWRULL FHORU GRX PRGHOH FkW úL UDSRDUWHOH GH FRUHOD LH UHVSHFWLYHVXQWVHPQLILFDWLYHFXXQSUDJGHVHPQLILFD LH a = ÌQDFHVWVFRSVHSRWXWLOL]DWHVWHOHFXQRVFXWH WHVWXOÄW´YDORDUHDWHRUHWLF ILLQGHJDO FX W

£¤©« £¦¥¨ª §

WHVWXOÄ)´YDORDUHDWHRUHWLF ILLQGHJDO FX )

=

¯ 4¯ ° ® ¬ ±

=

'HRDUHFH FHOH GRX PRGHOH HFRQRPHWULFH DX IRVW FRUHFW VSHFLILFDWH úL HVWLPDWH HOH SRW IL

² (3³ ) úL D YROXPXOXL GH HFKLOLEUX DO FHUHULL ( & ´ µ ) úL DO

XWLOL]DWH OD HVWLPDUHD SUH XOXL GH HFKLOLEUX

( 2´ µ )

RIHUWHL

3HED]DHFXD LHL DPRGHOXOXLHFRQRPHWULFLQL LDO 2

D·

&· + E ·

=a ·

2· b ·

+

¶

¶

= & UH]XOW

'LQHJDOLWDWHDGHPDLVXVYROXPXOGHHFKLOLEUXHVWHHJDOFX

2

¸

¹

= &

¸

¹

a

=

¸

¸

- D

E¸

-

-

=

b¸

LDUSUH XOGHHFKLOLEUXHVWHHJDOFX

º

3

½

= D

º

+ E

º

E

- D

º

a

º

- b

º

=

º

- D b

º» Eº

a

E

º¼º

- b

º

= PLLEXF

- -

º

=

( -) - - -

= PLL

OHLEXF E 'DF RIHUWD U PkQH QHVFKLPEDW OHJHD RIHUWHL U PkQH GH DVHPHQHD FRQVWDQW úL HJDO FX 3¿

¾

¿

= + 2

'DF FHUHUHD VSRUHúWH FX

¿

PRGHOXOXL 3

= D

À

ÀÁÀ

+ E & XQGH &

À

(N

= N&

¿

= ) vQ DFHVW FD] OHJHD FHUHULL YD IL GHVFULV FX DMXWRUXO

¿

= &

(VWLPDUHD SDUDPHWULORU D úL E FX DMXWRUXO 0&003 FRQGXFH OD XUP WRUXO VLVWHP GH

Â

Â

HFXD LL ÅQD Ö ¿

Ö ¿D ®

Ã

Ö +E

Ã Ç &Ã

Ã Ç &Ã

=

Ö +E

Ç3

Ä

Ã Ç &Ã

Å

=

Ç3

Ä

&

Ã

'LQSULPDHFXD LHDVLVWHPXOXLGHHFXD LLHVWLPDWRUXO D HVWHHJDOFX

$Â

$Æ

D

=

Q

Ç Ç

3

$Æ

- E

Ç& Q

Æ

Ç

= 3

$ÆÁÆ

- E &

Ç

= 3

$ÆÈÇ

- E N&

228

Ç

Q

$Ê

Ç&

=

E

Ç3

Ê

NÇ (3

Î

=

Ï

N

$Ð

Ç&

Î

- &

Î )

- &

$ÐÈÑ

= 3

Ê)

Ë

ÌÉ Í

s

Ç (3

Ï

Î )

Ñ

- E N&

= 3

=

N

-

$Î

=

E

$ÑUÑ

- 3

Ç (&

( -)

Ê

- &

- &

Ê)

Ê )Ì

=

= -

$ÑÑ

Ñ

= 3

E N&

N

Ë )( & Ê

Ë

=

ÊÌ

Î )( & Î

Ç (&

FRY( 3 &

=

Ê

&

- 3

Ñ

Ü D

Ë &Ê

Ç

Q

Ê Ç&

Ë

3

$Ñ

- E &

= D

=

ÌQXUPDDFHVWRUFDOFXOHPRGHOXOFXHFXD LLPXOWLSOHFXDMXWRUXOF UXLDVHSRWHVWLPDSUH XOúL YROXPXOGHHFKLOLEUXDOHFHUHULLúLRIHUWHLHVWH

3

Ò

= D

Õ

=a

3

Ó

ÓÔÓ

Ó

+ E &

Õ

+ b

2

Ö

= - &

Õ 2Õ

Õ

= + 2

×

= &

3XQkQG FRQGL LD GH HFKLOLEUX 2

Ù

=&

Ø

YDORULOHGHHFKLOLEUXDOHSUH XOXLFHUHULLúLRIHUWHLVH

FDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LLORU

ÛÜ

2

ÛÜ

=&

Ú

a

=

E

Ú

-D

Û

= PLLEXF

Ú

- b

LDUSUH XOGHHFKLOLEUXHVWHHJDOFX

Þ

3

ß

= D

Ý

+E

Ý

a

Þ

E

Þ

Ý

-D

- b

=

Ý

Ý

Þ

a E

E

Þ

-D

- b

Ý

b

Ý

= PLLOHLEXF

Ý

E &D úL OD SXQFWXO SUHFHGHQW OHJHD RIHUWHL U PkQH GH DVHPHQHD FRQVWDQW GHRDUHFH RIHUWD

à

á

á

= + 2

QXVHPRGLILF úLHVWHHJDO FX 3

'DF FHUHUHD VSRUHúWH FX GH EXF

(G

L

= ) OHJHD FHUHULL YD IL GHVFULV FX DMXWRUXO

PRGHOXOXL

ã

=D

3

XQGH &

å

=&

+E &

â

ä

â

â

ä

+ G =&

+

ÌQ XUPD DSOLF ULL 0&003 vQ YHGHUHD HVWLP ULL SDUDPHWULORU D

æ

úL E

æ

UH]XOW XUP WRUXO

VLVWHPGHHFXD LL Å QD ¿ Ö Ö ¿D ®

å

Ö + E Ç&

å

å

Ç&

å

Ö + E Ç&

å

ä

= Ç3

å

å

å

ä

= Ç3 &

å

'LQSULPDHFXD LHDVLVWHPXOXLGHHFXD LLHVWLPDWRUXO D

$ç

Ö D

é

=

Q

Ç3

è

Ö -E

é

Q

Ö E

ê

=

Ç (3

î

Ö Ü D

î )( & î

ñ

Ç3 &

Q

- 3

î Ç (&

ë

ê

Ç&

= 3

è

Q

Ö -E &

é

é

= 3

è

Ç3

Ç&

=

é

Ç&

ê

Ç&

+ G - &

+ G - &

î

î

- G)

ð (&ð

Ö = 3 -E

ð

ê

Ç&

ï

ê

ê

=

FRY (3 & s

ê

- G)

=

íê

ë

ê

)

ì

Ç (3

î

=

HVWHHJDOFX

é (& è

Ö -E

Ç (3

î )( & î

- 3

î Ç (&

- &

ë

+G

- &

î )

ë )(& ê

- 3

ê Ç (&

ï

)

î )

-&

-& ê )

$î

= E

ê

ê )

= -

+ G ) = - (- )( + ) =

229

$VWIHO PRGHOXO FX HFXD LL PXOWLSOH FX DMXWRUXO F UXLD VH SRDWH HVWLPD SUH XO GH HFKLOLEUX úL YROXPXOGHHFKLOLEUXDOHFHUHULLúLRIHUWHLHVWH

3

ë

= D

3

= a

2

3÷

'HUH LQXWF

ò

= D÷

ô

+ E÷

ê

(& ë

ë

+E

+ b 2

ò

ò

=&

ó

&÷

=D

)

+G

ò

ö

ö

÷

3XQkQGFRQGL LDGHHFKLOLEUX 2

ö

+E & =&

=D

+E &

õ

õ

õ

YDORULOHGHHFKLOLEUXDOHSUH XOXLFHUHULLúLRIHUWHLVH

õ

FDOFXOHD] FXDMXWRUXOUHOD LLORU

2

ùú

ùú

=&

=

ø

a

E

-D

ø

- b

ù

= PLLEXF

ø

LDUSUH XOGHHFKLOLEUXHVWHHJDOFX

ý

ü

3

= D

ü

+E

û

a

û

-D

û

E

- b

ü

û

û

E

F ÌQFRPSDUD LHFXSXQFWXOD SHQWUXFDUH

þ

þÿ

=

3

a E E

þ

þ

-D b

þ

- b

þ

úL 2

þ

û

a E

=

ü

-D b

û

= PLLOHLEXF

û

- b

=&

û

=

a

-D

E

- b

OD SXQFWXO E vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH FHUHUHD VH PRGLILF FX XQ FRHILFLHQW FRQVXPDWRULLFHHDFHJUDILFvQVHDPQ F GLVWDQ DID

ORFRFUHúWHUHDSDQWHLGUHSWHL (E < ) E

3

3

3

3

3

= D

=E

N ÜE

>E

YH]L)LJXUD

= a

GDUDUH

3

= D

&

&

+E &

= D

= D

3

+ b 2

&

> ) SHQWUX WR L

+E &

(N

GHRULJLQHU PkQHFRQVWDQW D

3

N

+E &

&2

)LJXUD ÌQDFHDVW VLWXD LHVHSRDWHGHPRQVWUDF

D2

D3

ùWLLQGF

E

(a

VHGHGXFHF

-D

= D&

=&

< b

= 3

> 3

)=

3

- 3

> &

- b 2

=

-&

(a

> 2

=

E

(E

(N

- Nb

)(E

-D

(E

)(NE

- Nb

>

+E &

=E &

b

)(E

-E

- b

- b 2

)

-D

- b

- 3

- )(a

b

)

)

)

<

230

Å ¿ D&

GDF N > Ü ¿ D3 ®

Å ¿ D&

GDF N < Ü ¿ D3 ®

> Ü &

> &

> Ü 3

> 3

< Ü &

< &

< Ü 3

< 3

'H DVHPHQHD vQ DFHVW FD] DSDU XUP WRDUHOH PRGLILF UL DOH FRHILFLHQWXOXL PDUJLQDO úL DOH FRHILFLHQWXOXLGHHODVWLFLWDWHDFHUHULL FP =

\

GDF N > Ü E

GDF N < Ü E

FH =

FH

FH

[

3

=

&

< E

!

" " "" # # "# &

FH

µ Ü

"

FH

¿ ¿ Ý

3

N

& 3

¿ ¿

&

=E

´

3

3 &

=

[ [

= E

> E

\ \

= E

=E ÜE

#

=

# #

" " " "

E &

" "

=

E &

E N&

N

=

E &

'HFL FRHILFLHQWXO GH HODVWLFLWDWH U PkQH FRQVWDQW GDF FHUHUHD FUHúWH FX XQ FRHILFLHQW N OD QLYHOXOILHF UXLFRQVXPDWRU 3H ED]D GDWHORU SUREOHPHL FHUHUHD P ULQGXVH GH GRX RUL

$

(N

= ) VH FRQVWDW XUP WRDUHOH

PRGLILF ULDOHFHORUSDWUXLQGLFDWRULvQFD]XOE vQFRPSDUD LHFXFD]XOD

%

%

&% '%

PRGLILFDUHDYROXPXOXLGHHFKLOLEUXDOFHUHULLúLRIHUWHL

D2

= D&

(

)(

= &

*(

-&

> SHQWUXF N = >

)( *(

PRGLILFDUHDSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUX

D3

= 3

- 3

> Ü 3

> 3

PRGLILFDUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLPDUJLQDODOSUH XOXL FP

FP

+ + , , + = E

= E

´ ¿

µ Ü FP

= E

¿ N Ý

,

< FP

+

PRGLILFDUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHHODVWLFLWDWHDOSUH XOXL FH

FH

- - -. . -. =E

=E

&

3

&

3

´ ¿ ¿

µ Ü ¿

FH FH

-

.

E = E

¿ Ý

. -. - -&

3

=

&

N

E

3

- -- --

E

N

&

3

&

3

=

/

'LQ FRPSDUDUHD UH]XOWDWHORU GH OD SXQFWXO D FX FHOH RE LQXWH OD SXQFWXO E XQGH FHUHUHD VH PRGLILF FX R P ULPH FRQVWDQW G OD QLYHOXO ILHF UXL FXPS U WRU G = > FHHD FH JUDILF vQVHDPQ RGHSODVDUHSDUDOHO VSUHGUHDSWDDGUHSWHLDGLF SDQWDGUHSWHLU PkQHFRQVWDQW E GDUVHPRGLILF GLVWDQ DID

GHRULJLQH D

3 2 2 =D

-E G ÜD

3 2 >D

YH]L)LJXUD

1 0 =E

7RWRGDW VHSRDWHGHPRQVWUDF GDF FHUHUHDVHPRGLILF FXRDQXPLW P ULPHFRQVWDQW G SHQWUXWR LFRQVXPDWRULLVHSURGXFXUP WRDUHOHWUDQVIRUP UL

4

PRGLILFDUHDYROXPXOXLGHHFKLOLEUXDOFHUHULLúLRIHUWHL

D&

6

=&

56

-&

46

=G

GDF G > Ü D&

7

E

4

E

- b

4

> Ü&

97

>&

87

231

7

GDF G < Ü D&

< Ü&

PRGLILFDUHDSUH XOXLGHHFKLOLEUX D3

< ;< :< = 3

- 3

=G

GDF G > Ü D3

GDF G < Ü D3

=

:

E

=

E

: : b

- b

:

97

<&

87

> <

FRHILFLHQWXOPDUJLQDODOSUH XOXLvQIXQF LHGHFHUHUHU PkQHQHVFKLPEDW

FP

?

= FP

>

=

@ @ @@ A B @A

3

=E

&

>

PRGLILFDUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLGHHODVWLFLWDWHDOSUH XOXL FH

FH

=E

=E

&

3

&

3

'HFL

GDF G > Ü FH GDF G < Ü FH

D G

´ ¿ ¿

µ Ü ¿

FH FH

A B

=

& &

A@

=

&

@

&

@

+G

=+

G &

@

¿ Ý

> FH < FH

C

FE

%,%/,2*5$),(

*LUDXG5&KDL[1eFRQRPpWULH38)3DULV /DEURXVVH&,QWURGXFWLRQDO¶pFRQRPpWULH'XQRG3DULV

3LQG\FN 5 6 5XELQIHOG ' 6 (FRQRPHWULF 0RGHOV DQG (FRQRPLF )RUHFDVWV

HJI

HG 0F

*UDZ+LOO1HZ
(GLWXUD$57(7,&$57%XFXUHúWL

9DQJUHYHOLQJKH*eFRQRPpWULH+HUPDQQ&ROOHFWLRQ0pWKRGHV3DULV

232

$QH[DQU7DEHOXOFXYDORULOHGLVWULEX LHLQRUPDOHFHQWUDWHUHGXVH1 7DEHOXOFRQ LQHSUREDELOLWDWHDaSHQWUXFDUHDUJXPHQWXOWHVWHPDLPDUHVDXHJDOvQYDORDUH DEVROXW FXRYDORDUHGDW W UHVSHFWLYSUREDELOLWDWHDVLWXDW vQDIDUDLQWHUYDOXOXL ±W

W a

3U^W¾±W W `

XQGH ±a a

3U^±W WW `

>±3U^W

W`@

W

¸

3UREDELOLWDWHDaVHRE LQHSULQDGXQDUHDQXPHUHORUvQVFULVHSHPDUJLQH

'HH[HPSOX3HQWUXW

SUREDELOLWDWHDHVWHa

7DEHOXOFXYDORULOHPLFLDOHOXLa

a

W

233

$QH[DQU7DEHOXOFXYDORULOHGLVWULEX LHLcð Y

a

234

$QH[DQU7DEHOXOGLVWULEX LHL'XUELQ:DWVRQFXSUDJXOGHVHPQLILFD LH a = Q

N

N

N

N

N

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

1RW NUHSUH]LQW QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQHLDUQQXP UXOYDULDQWHORUDFHVWRUD

235

$QH[DQUFRQWLQXDUH 7DEHOXOGLVWULEX LHL'XUELQ:DWVRQFXSUDJXOGHVHPQLILFD LH a = Q

N

N

N

N

N

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

G

1RW NUHSUH]LQW QXP UXOYDULDELOHORUH[RJHQHLDUQQXP UXOYDULDQWHORUDFHVWRUD

236

$QH[DQU9DORULOHUDSRUWXOXLGLVSHUVLLORU)FRUHVSXQ] WRDUHGLIHULWHORUQLYHOHGHVHPQLILFD LH

9

9

=

9

=

9

=

9

=

a =

a =

a =

a =

a =

a =

a =

a =

¸

237

$QH[DQUFRQWLQXDUH

9

9

=

9

=

9 =

9 =

a = a = a = a = a = a = a = a =

¸

1RW ÌQWRWGHDXQD 9 FRUHVSXQGHFHOHLPDLPDULGLVSHUVLL

238

$QH[DQU7DEHOXOFXYDORULOHGLVWULEX LHLÄW´6WXGHQWvQIXQF LHGHSUREDELOLWDWHD 3 (W Ê W

)

Q

¸

1RW QUHSUH]LQW QXP UXOJUDGHORUGHOLEHUWDWH

239

Modele Econometrice

Overview

More details

Related Documents

Modele Econometrice

Modele Waterloo

Modele Pestel

Modele Reponses

Modele Matematice.pdf

Modele Motivationale