Kritika Naukometrije Ili Naucno Novinarstvo

lld

ir - C6

t./.

O

aJj ]rNLDn.6p

t4

lllK 0ol

AHa llBKoBlah

ylHcrr,lryr 3a oHKonorrajy u paAuonorujy Cp6l4je, EeorpaA ivkovica@ncrc,ac,rs

KptatuKa HayKoMerpyrje: Hayra lAntA,,HayL{ Ho Ho B l/ ua pcTBo" La Serbie...deux ooints!!!

HayKoMerparja

ce

CaxeraK 6aBLr npoqeFoM 14 oqe|oM HaylrHof paAa, o6jaB,.beHMX paAoBa, Kop crehr,l

6|46nuorpaOcKe FoAarKe

fi

H,r4xoBy

6pojHocr

y u3pa.ryHaBa$eM Qaxropa yT'rqaja BpeAHocr hoja Mep14 hBar/rer HaygHof !aconuca.

Lll/TarH!4

'1FAeKc

(lmpact factor lF),lrnpact Factorje cpeAcrBo MepHa 3a caAa npeAcraB,,ba jeAL4H!4 Moryh!4 Ha'rL4F ra eBanyauL4jy paAa Mcrpa,syBaqa 11 HayvHr4x paAHLrKa. TaKaB HaerH eBanyaqraje npeAroxr,ro je L4 cnpoBeoThomson Sclentifc's SLWeb of Knowledge. KonlaKo j-. raKaB Ha.rMH BpeAHoBaHia ncnpaBaH

M Koflr,4Ko AoBoAr.l Ao KoHTpaAL4Kq/ja, To 406po 3Fajy cBrl KoJy ce paAoM 6aBe Hay.rHnM Ll ny6firlKoBart,eM paAoBa. HeKh oA HajqeLuh x npo6neMa, Koju ce HaMehy oBraM olcTeMoM BpeaHoBa|i,a/ onncaH ay y oBoM reKcry.

llrbyqHe

peq

:

HAYKOMETPMJA/ qUTATHL4 L4HAEKC/ MNAKT 9AKTOP

Hi.r'(.... Ilerip.. ]!ieperLe... Il.Ki Ea 11€rap ero rocroich. rra,r(ouerprje: OBa t(ir)6r,Hnrr v ,itRr MaI noil.eha !a jiua(a iltfdHof on,,M] (.rr ...r ,,,rBahnv Mc fon f plq!

rBii!

arpojtM.Bojnx i6nLa Ha,i,,rn,rf

v HrtiL".r Bp.1rHyr.,a oatsjbcsv la rlHrn parov, (.o ! s.nfe4.Baa) \ Hdllr, 'rp.'{orlr

Mi, oot.BE}|l_ (sn,

e

n HaI!Hc farlotsc

I pc'rourP.rn!

Ieri! or 6xrHnx nafrMer.p. 3r etsrnrd,rni] n!)cno. Iar. te..brFrLe qrrara H.n!rtrr parHrNr, ra(o3n.rn 4rrrrrjHr!H;.r.1

nH, ix.tsabe

Hir'(oMerprja .€ rancra 6.Bx

11€perL€rr

ror

ratsxcHoc,n

or qrrxpano.rn a_rroti, ro6ria.e

Hano

nPoqerorl r otrenou, €Bax,'xParLen E.vaEor fard c1u!Ba(a (oin .c rflxe na !r) r' (ota( ca ..Bpe ricN!N, j(olrn,H)lioN,a, )qccrryjr v rosrrr ntole(rn

ta

l''..,. :

Ion.3rNNro (,b\ !H.f ,,ro6ncMa rcxr(oie D.,oro bpxxinBo oAa6larx li.ortr. I tulen hc cc oijjaRit Bar! fe3lnrarr Ha,!!Ho xcrpaxrtsa!(of taxal

n ctH 't eBa

ro E je Errlano ,a(ol CBara(o lxje xcro o6jaBrrx laycno aeno J Rxco (oPaHrxfaEoM cacojrncy ,v !aco,rrcy oe3 +a",opd

'rx

ap!fe c ryaEe, (onn(ojeje^HoM caconrcy!or!e6 do /ra cre(He {a*,op ylxq{r dro ra cBPclrBa MeDy C

Nlsoro rp_raa ! )IoxeEor prna norpe6so je aa ce no(peHe lrconrci aa ce ro3oey a)_ropn sa cafrarLl, (ao r BpeMe a. ce.rerre qnranaeK. nr6nr(a (ojojhe rr paroBx 6rrx 3naeajnr 3! na)enyn!aKcv. Xo j€ Aalne 3aalx€! Aa FpeAdyie eaconxce n no

(otuvr!nrepxjlruMa ce.pnrrarrnrabc? 'thomlson Rcutcrs ISt Wcb of Knowledge htlp://

ka Ltunatuame 6p.

14

AM raHac cc rofl rahx 6poiHr pdaoRr Ha rcMy npotrncNla'ucHe !c,rpatsHo.rr oBr(tso' etsaxyrprba HlycHrr paroBa, Jep otso He(aaa He npx(a3yle peanHo oqeBnBa6e sa)ars!(a HanlorrB, aoEocn Mrore (otsrpaan(ropEocrn.

oBakB ,,noB sa loeHe aoBeo je n no se(os rponrcaHof yrJEoxa!a6r paaoBa 6e3 a,vropc(or ono 5perLa lperxoaEof rr3aa!.ea, nn.Mj.pn3Ma, ra x !o !enx(of

5Poja PaaoBa ca

narorrrl noaaq'Dla.

rr paronr o6jai6niaHx cy ra(otc r Bxco(o PaE0lPaHxlr EccoMycEa rPKa 3a rocHc uPoy3po(oR.rna jc ! ,,u/DtpaHocl ro lprH,p"iy .6 . ,., .,,. r\r.r,P'.,i,r'.'r,.,rf./ CBx

rvwi!.isiwcboft nowledge.coft /

[]ra

[o1pe6!o je, 1a(ote, xa ypeaH(qr \aconrca oAfoBope ! !a 3rxreBe lPeMa (prrerxjr\uMa ISI Thotnpson S.ientiic lThe Institute for Scientjnc IntbrmatioD' (ISI'))

,qa

http://wmtlDmsdrreuter.

9

ca8eroBarr !aurM

nx aa, )rnearjrhx ce sa craprje xcrycsrje (one fe. iype noeEe aoaal'lu d(eteranda .uo)o)

'

Mro bx rrc nle a*nt - - atxle?r . 3B.re,oojalD,vjlnxxcm)qBo '.. I MetlEapoalrM caconr '\ crMa? . :. A(o nPr roM I 3atseMdprjy o6jaR ,b/ts46e pdnoBr I r AoMahxM ca.o

---_

!:ihi,

npea

lSl Web

of

lFapoasrx ny bnrra4xla norF

Trattsfofl,ing Retcafth

.\.

nxcre SCU] (Scientific Crtation lDder lalanded).

ro

cueHr

Ha

uaHerapHy

qacoruc ie c1e(ao MeiyHaponHx yuex

Hd,,BenxraHcr BeHy lCRnr y Iournal Cihtion Rcpo.t y o(Brpt Wel' olScience \r rd1tse 6a3e. lvlerytsapoAsr !aconr.r ce 6oAoBaBeM AaBe paH upaj,v Ha cneaehx Ha!rs: Mel)lsa!oasr qaco!rc noHocr rfr !oesa, xcraGyrr eb)srpoqEn caconrc ner no€Ea,

r)na3'

. BprFcrx NrebsafoaEx q onaj npoqec nar3rnea 3axcra Aenlje ca$xM

Hayqts,v

*ffiT-':;::

CPsu

n.

a6jaatutjy

I

tuu,ia...la

/rc(ycrBo

noM3yle

na Ic QedorlcH Heii rraHelapHo,,pncyraH, anu ci

caconnca, Haye-

're( raaa je nyonxKaqxja c8pcraHa

,.

. ,

noaPa3lMesa P€roF'

Hy anrenHocr pe4epesqr Ha (oje ce ,ro3rBajy av.otr (no Moryhqocrr tse craprje oa 2000. r,Dfper r'6'r"BJ6e.rroufr". roFrB,, d lltoj ro l qrrntasrxtaaoBa r np. ]ha3a( Ha SCIE rucrycaMoje npBn ropa(. norpe6soje qa npoD,vaBe roarse ra(o 61 6rno n3 Bpueso npBo EpaersaB!D€ rMna!r +!!rop! {Q.(rop ) rL,j,. 6fo I r , po ,/\ p.. .o8.. n '0e,e', -" 6ouje . o6jaBDenrx taqoBa ynpor€rine Eie roar!eJ. dayeHy

,

KNOWLEDGE-

teneBaHrsnx \re

aoMahl i,B'o.

ErMe tsajorrepehesxje

M

Ioaarq-n!o6neMarxry Hay{se npa(ce y C!6rjr nfeacrrBDajlcnlqajeBxHaurxsarrE n noBparEnra roix, x nopeA creceEor yrneAr y rsocrpaHcrByi reuro aona3e ao paaEor rrecra y cBoJoJ 3eNrBr, Je! rlrroB

x layesx Paa lvlrnrcraPcrlo 3. !ar(I se larotx3lje Ea nPanr EaerE - !e nPx3HaJ,r ce car ru crp,vesx

pa,roBr Ha octroRIroj{x cy,robrja,x !03xne3a npeaaBasa Ha yueAHnM yHrBep3nl e, !Ma y nHoc'PaHcrRI.

Hj| ^.r r.r r.. r!.. Fr" I ,/i 4r,r r,)r^..,,p/e r!e,r.ratsEa npa(ca HoB!r hHd,opMaqro!nx rexHo xotuja. Kovn)!(rqxie Hacrajy nojaBoM nokpem 3r orBoleq! npncr,vn olen Acce$, (ojrr ce yByko y

cBrMa aocrlnsx e.conxcx, € jorrnals, npea \r'Bb').rrQoplor ro|eh. I o,rj) \ Bp r rfre.iet y.nea oryalneero. nPrcrlna €re(rtorcrrM cefBx cxMa, oBaj Brr caconrca ca fr€e access-oM, aonolx ro

l-ahqeaalta tr.ndn,,)uarte op l4 Itpxe pa3Mcre HayqHnr axoopMairyja r hc(ycraBr rrtoM cBerr (fLoS ONE httpi//saa{plosone.org/). I4clIrnM, nopeA cBrrx trteqsocrxj re(x oa HajpetroNrrpaDj"x tlsrepder caconnca FeN,arl qak,op yrr,laja, Aaue de nocfoj'r .,gaKrof Hay(el dn4 se uro fa ne3acr,vr(ty, Beh 3aro uro ypclrrnrrr

ro ro'a lrrje.r

rra

arro.

laxar lc caMo uannref oJ

Paaa.

"...the host efettire anLl far a,atfsis

d peraht .otttitiutiar

dcrjres

Jron

d

dnett ase$hte,t af indiritlual papets, reg aftlLess of lrhtre thef h,ere pLbjished.', (p Iaxne, ura HarJje

rorpe6!!je, Dra

PA3B jATtlHAyKy{D'HAyqHO HOtsIIHAICTBO"?

Abstra(t Scientometry is a fieJd of scjence that means evaluation of scjentific work using Citation Inclex accordinq to the citatjon account. The tmpact Factor (lF), as a measure of quality ot published work, is the unique tool for evaluation of scientific journals. Every day we read about assessment of researchers'articres and criticism about varue of scientific work usi;g rF and the varrdity ot that tool as valid as Thompson Scientific,s claims and how much irregularitt and contradjctoriness the lF measurement brings? Key werds; (:rarion scienloneiry. Inde\..mpa(t fa(tol

]i'ITEPATYPA Sestak, J. "]s S.i€ntometry harmfut. whar we caD cxpect lrom bibliomehic reseatcht.. ICT]AC AL,r (

1999). httpT/icrac.org/ictacrews/artictetdecgg/

422

P

3. 2009). The polirics of pubti carlon.,. r\hture

Jotrrnal.pmed.003029l

i

htrp://a5rw.iec.cat/t jc.c/

PlosMediclnelmpactFactorcdne.pdf (rpev3ero 21.3.2009).

(np€y3erc 25.

l.

DoDg, P "The

Infacrfacror rerisited,. Bion.d,.dl

D

6.

2009).

igital Ljb raries2(2]O5J:7.doj:10

27

\2043):259 26t.

The lLoS illedicine Editors. ,Jhe hnpacl fa.lor Can1e: PrdS,V.d 3(6) e2eL(2006). doj:10.1]71l

\, u: ..n...

rnomsoDrertcrs.com/cjraLionimpacrcenter/

rcvartl8.pdf (trpey3ero 24. Lawrence,

t'Ptt

4

1

186/1742 5581

httpJ^rwiqbiodigiil.contcontenr/2/t/7 lrpey3ero t. 2.2009). On lotrnal Inpa.t fr.rofs. hrt!:/hrm{stanford. edu/'jhj1/cgi bj!/blog/?p=27s (npel3€ro 20. 2. 20oe).

Canpbell, P "Escipe frorn rhe tnipact facroi. nt hics S.i |i rnoh Poljt I (2008):5-7.