vol.
85,
no.
18
n
f r i d ay , s e p t e m b e r 4 , 2 0 0 9
n
15 elul 5769
n
jtnews.net
news
JT the voice of jewish washington
Leyna Krow
Jewish Federation president and CEO Richard Fruchter, second from right, and Federation Special Initiatives Fund Committee chair Jack Almo, right, present Jewish Family Service board president Dianne Loeb and JFS executive director Ken Weinberg, left, with a check for the JFS Food Bank on Capitol Hill on Mon., Aug. 31. The money is part of the Federation’s Challenging Times Economic Impact Grants, which were created to help local organizations cope with the recession. JFS is one of six Seattle-area agencies to receive the grants, which total $65,000 in all.
Endowment to boost NCJW’s Shalom Bayit Push on Iran JTNews Correspondent It takes fortitude and bravery for a woman to walk away from a life of abuse. It’s a walk that means dealing with deep issues of self-esteem, a failed relationship or a loss of financial security. It often also means leaving behind a lifetime of memories, familiar surroundings and friends and the material goods that everyone needs to survive from day to day. She may leave a comfortable home to escape a dangerous home life. To get relief from emotional or physical abuse may mean giving up a warm bed, a clean bathroom, and a well-stocked kitchen for the back seat of her car, a friend’s sofa bed or a women’s shelter. When she comes out the other side, she may have her children with her and her fragile self-esteem may be rebuilding. She might even get transitional housing and then an apartment of her own. But once she is there, it may be nothing more than a roof over her head and a place to hang her meager wardrobe or keep a few of the kids’ toys. She likely landed on her feet without things most of us take for granted — cooking and eating utensils, chairs and a table, towels and a firm bed. That is where Shalom Bayit: Furnishing Peaceful Homes, a program of the Seattle Section of the National Council of Jewish Women comes in. The program, founded in 2000, works to solve that issue by gathering new and gently used furniture and other household items and distributing them to women in need. This summer, that program received a huge boost when Karyn F. King, a long-time supporter of Shalom Bayit, donated $25,000 in seed money for an endowment to take care of the underlying costs such as transportation and storage. King freely admits that she comes from a home where her father and brother were abusive. That has made her quick to step up when Shalom Bayit needed something.
new at
www.jtnews.net a
j e w i s h
“I have limited disposable income, but I have always put some aside for doing good,” she said. But this gift has a special meaning to her. “My father passed away last spring and the first distribution of his estate was made this summer,” she said. “There is a nice symmetry to using that money to help with a program that helps women in this situation.” King says she left home when she was 18, back in the mid-’60s. It was a different time. “There was no ‘domestic violence,’ the cops didn’t care,” she said. “Women had nowhere to go. Many really were trapped.” King’s gift is only a start. She is hopeful that others will help build the endowment for one of the only “furniture banks” in the country. Wendy Thomas, president of NCJW’s Seattle section, agrees. “The endowment will be a great help,” she said. “But there will still be a need for donations of both money and furnishings,” she said. Much of the cash goes to purchase items that are not often suitable for secondhand use, such as mattresses, bedding and kitchen items. “We want these women to feel like they are getting a fresh start, with a place and things they can take pride in,” she said. Women are referred to Shalom Bayit by agencies throughout the region that assist women transitioning to housing from domestic violence situations. They then are taken to a warehouse and assisted with getting the items they need. “We charge donors a small fee to pick up items,” Thomas said. “But everything for our clients is without charge.” More information about Shalom Bayit, and how to donate is available at www.ncjwseattle.org or by calling 425-558-1894.
Page 14A
t r a n s c r i p t
sanctions, Mideast peace talks expected in September Ron Kampeas JTA World News Service
ANALYSIS
WASHINGTON (JTA) — Timing, if not intent, inevitably is weaving the Israeli-Palestinian peace process into the efforts to end Iran’s suspected nuclear weapons program. The major powers are meeting this week in Germany to coordinate Iran policy ahead of the U.N. General Assembly later this month. At the same time, Israeli officials are in Washington planning a joint summit of the Israeli, Palestinian and American leaders during the General Assembly. President Obama and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have steadfastly denied linkage between the two issues. Obama says he is determined to contain Iran whether or not Israel plays ball on the Palestinian issue, and Netanyahu insists he is doing all he can to advance the peace process however Iran sanctions play out. Nonetheless, recent events have driven both processes into a synchronicity, including meetings Netanyahu held with European leaders last week that focused both on Iran and international calls for a Jewish settlement freeze in the West Bank. When the International Atomic Energy Agency issued an unusually blunt report on Aug. 28 saying that Iran
u Page 28A
M.O.T.: Member of the Tribe A View from the U Fall Books Community Calendar National & International News The Shouk Classifieds
p u b l i c a t i o n
9A 10A 14A 18A 25A 34A
n
inside
Morris Malakoff
Section B
$ 1 . 5 0
September 19 – OctOber 18, 2009
It’S tIme tO bag Hunger In Our cOmmunIty FOOd FOr tHOugHt:
Our community-wide Food Drive is here. Help us help others. In these challenging times, the need has surpassed all expectations. Last year alone, JFS distributed over 240,000 pounds (120 tons) of food here at home.
a 40 tOn SHOrtFall:
Even though the response to last year’s community Food Drive was overwhelming, the annual demand still exceeded donations by over 80,000 pounds — which JFS had to purchase outright to make up the shortfall. If you believe the headlines, there is no end in sight.
cHew On tHIS:
The JFS Food Bank serves over 1,000 households month-in and month-out. This is an increase of 40% compared to the number of local families the JFS Food Bank served just three years ago.
yOu’ll Feel better InSIde:
Starting on Rosh Hashanah, most major local congregations will be collection sites for your taxdeductible donations of non-perishable food. Please use our nutrition-friendly shopping list. Donate a lot, donate a little — but please, donate something…food doesn’t need to be kosher.
cOme One, cOme all:
The Food Drive Food Sort is Sunday, October 18th, from 10:30 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. at Acme Food Sales Warehouse. This is an ideal opportunity to drop-off your organization’s delivery of collected food — and please, bring volunteers with you to unload the donation. Advance registration is required. Contact Jane Deer-Hileman, Director of JFS Volunteer Services, at (206) 861-3155 or
[email protected].
FOOd drIVe SHOppIng lISt h h h h h h h h h h h h h h
Canned Tuna Canned Pears or Peaches Canned Tomato Products Canned Vegetables Canned Soups Peanut Butter (not in glass) Cooking Oil (plastic bottles) Pasta & Rice Soap & Toothpaste Toiletries Laundry Detergent Cleaning Supplies Grocery Store Gift Cards Reusable Grocery Bags
JEW-ISH .COM For more information, please call (206) 461-3240 or visit www.jfsseattle.org
friday, september 4, 2009
n
jtnews
3
page viewpoints
rabbi’s turn
The litmus test of belief Reading between the lines of the High Holiday machzor can help build our relationships with God
Rabbi Rachel Nussbaum Kavana Cooperative Although the month of Elul is my busy season as a rabbi, I really love this time of year. For me, Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur are accompanied by meaningful customs, beautiful melodies, and a sense of new possibility. For a number of my community members, though, I know that the High Holidays pose a real challenge and have the potential to feel alienating. For many, the key challenge is that the observance of these holidays (more than many others) is focused around prayer. Moreover, the High Holiday liturgy is filled with images of God that seem anthropomorphic and sometimes even conflict with the belief system of contemporary Jews. This time of year, I am often asked: Why should I say words that I don’t believe to be true? I think the problem is that many of us learned to approach the liturgy far too literally. Perhaps if we reframe how we approach the liturgy, we can remove the
The JTNews is the Voice of Jewish Washington. Our mission is to meet the interests of our Jewish community through fair and accurate coverage of local, national and international news, opinion and information. We seek to expose our readers to diverse viewpoints and vibrant debate on many fronts, including the news and events in Israel. We strive to contribute to the continued growth of our local Jewish community as we carry out our mission. 2041 Third Avenue, Seattle, WA 98121 phone 206-441-4553 fax 206-441-2736 E-mail:
[email protected] www.jtnews.net JTNews (ISSN0021-678X) is published biweekly by The Seattle Jewish Transcript, a nonprofit corporation owned by the Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle, 2041 3rd Ave., Seattle, WA 98121. Subscriptions are $39.50 for one year, $57.50 for two years. Periodicals postage paid at Seattle, WA. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to JTNews, 2041 Third Ave., Seattle, WA 98121.
Staff
Reach us directly at 206-441-4553 + ext. Publisher *Karen Chachkes 267 Editor *Joel Magalnick 233 Assistant Editor Leyna Krow 240 Account Executive Lynn Feldhammer 264 Account Executive David Stahl 235 Account Executive Stacy Schill 292 Classifieds Manager Rebecca Minsky 238 Art Director Susan Beardsley 239 Accountant Louise Kornreich 234 Production Artist Elisa Haradon Intern Malka Cramer
Board of Directors
Scott Michelson, Chair*; Jeffrey Berkman; Robin Boehler; Don Edmond; Lisa Eggers; Nancy Geiger; Cynthia Flash Hemphill*; Allen Israel*; Stan Mark; Daniel Mayer; Cantor David SerkinPoole*; Sandy Sidell Richard Fruchter, CEO and President, Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle Ron Leibsohn, Federation Board Chair *Member, JTNews Editorial Board
The opinions of our columnists and advertisers do not necessarily reflect the views of JTNews.
stumbling block posed by this litmus test of belief. The words of the prayer Unetaneh Tokef serve as a great case-in-point. This medieval piyyut (liturgical poem) has come to play an integral role in the Rosh Hashanah Musaf service, and it contains some of the most classic (and potentially alienating) images of God. The prayer opens with the image of each individual standing before God in a courtroom, while God (the judge) makes decisions about who will live and who will die in the coming year. The God portrayed here knows all and has the power to “remember everything that has been forgotten” — much like Santa Claus in the song, who “knows when you’ve been bad or good, so be good for goodness sake.” If taken literally, this image induces in me a feeling of panic. Because we are all human and therefore imperfect, no one can be assured that the judge will rule favorably. I can understand why — if presented only with the false dichotomy between reading this prayer literally or not showing up — many Jews would prefer not to engage with this liturgy at all. If we can learn to read the liturgy less literally, though, then the words of the machzor (the High Holiday prayerbook) become poignant in a much more positive and potentially transformative way. In order to do this, however, we first have to accept that the machzor presents not one image of God, or of the relationship between God and human beings, but rather a composite sketch, a collage of many images. These images are far too diverse to be understood literally. Instead, I believe, the machzor invites us to temporarily inhabit each metaphor, and to think about what truths each image can teach us about God, ourselves, and the world. In doing so, the language of the liturgy provides us with a
roadmap for how we might engage in the very human processes of self-reflection, teshuva, and self-improvement. Read in this way, Unetaneh Tokef ’s fearful image of God as a judge takes on a different valence. If we understand it as a metaphor, we can ask what effect it will have on us — emotionally, psychologically, and behaviorally. If even the angels are gripped with fear and trembling on this day, as the text of the prayer says, then it makes sense that we too are supposed to experience a sense of fear or awe on Rosh Hashanah. The courtroom setting also emphasizes that we bear full responsibility for all of our actions. Hopefully, this realization will motivate us to scrutinize our deeds in a deeper way. From there, Unetaneh Tokef quickly moves on to a second image: That of God as a shepherd. In contrast to the judge-defendant relationship, the shepherd-flock metaphor is softer, as it implies a level of caring. Whereas a good judge is supposed to be impartial and detached, a shepherd has a vested interest in ensuring the well-being of his sheep. This shepherd, in particular, cares about each creature individually, “causing each one to pass beneath his staff.” If we can inhabit this image fully, we might feel cared for, protected and nurtured. It is human nature that when we feel safe in this way, we can challenge ourselves more deeply, and we therefore have the power to change more profoundly. Finally, the prayer ends with a set of increasingly fleeting images. It says: “We are fragile as pottery, so easily shattered, like the grass that withers, like the flower that fades, like the fleeting shadow, like the vanishing cloud, like the wind that rushes by, like the scattered dust, like the dream that flies away.” As the text transitions through all of these stages — from pottery
to grass to shadow and ultimately to dream — each step of the succession becomes less concrete, and more ethereal and abstract. Emotionally, this reinforces the idea that we are all small and insignificant in the greater scheme of things. Although it wouldn’t be healthy to think this way all the time, when coupled with the courtroom image in which what we do matters deeply, this last set of images provides a beautiful counterpoint. The end of the prayer gradually transitions us into being able to contemplate the world without us in it; in other words, it provides a gentle entry point to one of the most difficult things we are called upon to do during the High Holidays: To confront the fact of our own mortality. I believe the structure and diverse images of the High Holiday liturgy were crafted to challenge, support, and push us, and ultimately to allow us to reorient our lives in a transformative way in a short period of time. The concrete images of the machzor evoke such different emotional responses in us, and in this way, experiencing the liturgy leads us on a journey. For me, the key question is not whether we “believe in” the words we are saying (at least, not in a literal sense). Instead, if we can learn to read prayer in the language of metaphor and poetry, we can open ourselves up to the very human experiences of reflecting on our lives, confronting our limitations, and changing and growing each year. With the time that remains in the month of Elul, I wish all of us great success in preparing ourselves for this emotional journey. Rachel Nussbaum is the rabbi of The Kavana Cooperative (www.kavana.org). She was recently awarded an AVI CHAI Fellowship for her innovative approach to building Jewish community.
Letters The hitch It isn’t easy to be a Jewish liberal these days. You agree with all your non-Jewish liberal friends on everything: Government control of health care, turning the world green, the mainstreaming of homosexuality, silencing Rush Limbaugh and Bill O’Reilly, banishing religion from the public square, obliterating gender roles, and most importantly eating only organic food. But one pesky little issue separates you from them and invites their scorn and ostracism: Israel. They hate Israel. They see Israel as the new South Africa, an oppressive little island of Western greed and exploitation in a vast peaceful sea of Third World authenticity and virtue. To liberals Israel is “an historical error” as Bertrand Russell used to say. It deserves no support. But you cannot bring yourself to hate Israel. For one thing, making negative comments about Israel annoys your parents who remember 1967 and 1973 and maybe even 1948 when Israel’s life hung by a thread. And thinking about Israel awakens deep down in your soul a feeling of Jewish pride. Plucky little Israel, surrounded on all sides by rich, resourceful, implacable Arab enemies 50 times her size, knowing nothing but siege, terror, and war for 60 years, but by some miracle still there, still standing, still existing as a Jewish state, still gathering in all the Jews of the world who want to come, still showing the world that murdering another 6 million of us will not be as easy as the first time.
No, my liberal Jewish friend, you cannot bring yourself to hate Israel. But how do you get back in good standing with your non-Jewish liberal comrades? Have no fear, J Street is here. Yes, J Street (“First Stop: Seattle,” Aug. 21), the new liberal-oriented “pro-peace” Jewish lobbying organization that will lobby the American government to stop supporting Israel unless the Israeli government makes more concessions to the Arabs and pursues “peace” more aggressively. So there you are. At the next meeting of your liberal friends just show them your J Street membership card. You’ll be in like Flynn. Jeffrey Weiser Redmond
Being aware In your article “First Stop: Seattle” (Aug. 21) you neglected to mention that Federal Election Commission filings show that J Street has Muslims and Arabs as donors, as well as people connected to Palestinian and Iranian advocacy. Jeremy Ben Ami admits that at least 3 percent of their money comes from Muslims and Arabs. Now, it’s very understandable why the Arabs donate to J Street, but tell me why a “pro-Israel” group would accept such money unless they are not pro-Israel, which is what many observers feel. People should be aware of what they’re getting involved with if they think joining J Street is joining a pro-Israel or “pro-peace” organization. Susan Benyowitz Los Angeles, Calif.
Welcome everyone I would like to remind Edith Isaacs Ervin that the recent murders of gays in Tel Aviv were tragic losses to our entire community (letters, Aug. 21). That they were targeted due to being gay should be shocking and very concerning to every Jew, because it demonstrates the rising level of violence in present-day Israel and it illustrates the terrible results of intolerance and ignorance. I hope that Edith will educate herself about homosexuality and understand that it is an orientation and not a choice. I would hope that she would be broad minded enough to realize that there are many gay parents who set as fine examples of loving parenting as any “straight” couple. I would hope that it is our “broad goal” to welcome and fully include all Jews regardless of color, nationality, religious affiliation, gender, or sexual orientation. That would be a more positive and practical way to assure the growth and continuity of the Jewish people. Jack Fackerell Redmond
Replacements and responsibilities All of the evidence that I know of strongly supports the notion that sexual orientation is not a choice, but inborn. So, gays and lesbians who marry would still be gay and lesbian, but simply attempting to repress their true selves.
u Page 27A
We would love to hear from you! Our guide to writing a letter to the editor can be found on our Web site: www.jtnews.net/index.php?/static/item/611/ future deadlines may be found online
a 4
jtnews
n
friday, september 4, 2009
viewpoints
In favor of rational discussion Cut the clamor for desperately needed health care reforms Rachel Goldberg JTA World News Service WASHINGTON (JTA) — There’s a lot of noise about health care — wildly false claims, meetings being disrupted, shrill voices shouting down legislators. Amid the din, real ideas and concerns are getting lost. It’s easy and lazy to criticize something. What’s difficult and bold is to recognize that a critically important part of our country’s infrastructure is severely broken and come up with a plan to fix it. The premise of many health reform naysayers is that the system isn’t bad now, but it will be if we “reform” it. The next part of that theory is that what Canada and England have creates problems that do not exist in the health care utopia we currently occupy. (Incidentally, none of the congressional proposals would adopt their systems.) Even assuming the initial premise is true — and it’s not unless you are wealthy and lucky — we still know the next parts are demonstrably untrue. If we do nothing, employer-based coverage will continue to erode, even as our unstable job market means more people are losing access to employer plans. And when people lose or switch jobs, often they are unable to acquire coverage in the private market. That can mean long periods without coverage, or with costly catastrophic
of bankruptcy in the United States). coverage, and dangerous Catch-22 proThe numbers of people who don’t visions down the line: You can’t get covvisit doctors or fill prescriptions because erage if you didn’t have coverage in the they are underinsured is rising. Meanpast — that pesky pre-existing condition while, t he t raveling clinics created exclusion. to serve disease-ravaged parts of the Particularly offensive are attempts developing world now also visit underby opponents to convince older people served communities in poor and rural that reform proposals would steal their parts of the United States. People travel benefits or destroy Medicare. Many many miles and wait countless hours of the Medicare “cuts” are deliver y for those services. system reforms that aging advocates In the face of this crisis, some have have been urging. We actually could see chosen venom, demimprovements to the Medicare program If we do nothing, employer-based agoguery and misinif reform occurs — coverage will continue to erode, formation over real changes that won’t even as our unstable job market dialogue — jeoparhappen otherwise. means more people are losing dizing t he chance Sen iors a re a n access to employer plans. And to make life better important constitu- when people lose or switch jobs, for millions. A better ency because they often they are unable to acquire health care system, k now t he i mpor- coverage in the private market. we should not forget, would provide real tance of health care security for everyone — even those who and care about their children and grandlike whatever arrangement they have children. Using fear to turn them against now. reform is reprehensible. As a human rights organizat ion, Also outrageous: Raising the specter B’nai B’rith is dedicated to health care of Nazis to promote the absurdist scare for all. We have not yet endorsed any tactics about fictional death panels, too. piece of legislation — we see problems, The U.S. health care system is broken. as well as real promise, in each of them. In the richest nation in the world, about Legislators are working hard to do more 47 million Americans have no health than stake out ideological and political insurance. Millions of Americans are territory. underinsured, unable to afford co-pays At the most basic level, health care or prescriptions, or even are forced into coverage needs to be comprehensive, bank ruptcy by uncovered expenses affordable and secure. It must ensure (medical costs are the biggest single cause
that people can keep the coverage they like and acquire coverage they can afford. Realistic health care reform must address long-term services and be both politically feasible and financially fair. A reform plan should include provisions for the high costs of prescription drugs and long-term care issues. Our population is aging and the latter’s costs have the potential to further erode our current system. Americans, regardless of their opinion or knowledge base, obviously are passionate about health care: Just watch any town hall meeting with members of Congress or listen to callers on talk radio. Health issues can serve as the great leveler of our society. Everyone gets sick and needs medical attention. It’s time for a better system. There are real proposals on the table that could expand coverage. Will everyone like every element of the proposals? Of course not. But if we can quiet the shouting and stay in touch with the reality that demands we do something, we have an opportunity to work together to reach an effective compromise. That compromise could improve, and even save, millions of lives and deliver the human right of health security to a country in desperate need. Rachel Goldberg is the director of aging policy for B’nai B’rith International.
QFC Proudly Supports Seattle Children’s Hospital By Kristin Maas, QFC Public Affairs Director
I am the mother of a 9-year old boy and I am thankful that I have never needed the services of Seattle Children’s Hospital. However, I rest easier knowing if my son should ever need it, there is a hospital right here in Seattle that is dedicated entirely to the care of children. The history of this hospital is both heartwarming and inspiring. It’s the story of a Seattle woman named Anna Clise who watched her six-year-old son, Willis, die of inflammatory rheumatism. Anna turned her grief into hope, leading the effort to create a hospital dedicated to the care of children, which was founded in 1907. Today, Seattle Children’s is one of the nation’s leading pediatric hospitals, combining unsurpassed medical skill, groundbreaking research, and profound human compassion in the effort to cure and prevent childhood disease. It’s a special place designed around, and for, children and their families. They are committed to helping all children, regardless of the family’s ability to pay. I believe Anna Clise would be pleased with her legacy.
In 2001, Seattle Children’s provided nearly $25 million in uncompensated care. In 2008, that figure reached more than $86 million and projections show that uncompensated care may top more than $100 million in 2009. So, what can you and I do to help this incredible organization in their mission to help children in need? During the month of September, QFC will feature Seattle Children’s as our checkstand charity of the month. Customers can donate to Seattle Children’s at any checkstand using the $1,
$5, or $10 scan cards; dropping their coins in the coin boxes at the checkstands; or designating their 3 cent bag reuse credit as a donation to Seattle Children’s. In addition, QFC will make a donation of $10,000 to Seattle Children’s. As a parent, you hope you will never need Seattle Children’s. But aren’t you glad they’re here, just in case?
Kristin Maas is the Director of Public Affairs for QFC. She can be reached at
[email protected] or 425-990-6182.
friday, september 4, 2009
n
jtnews viewpoints
a 5
Health care reform, yes. Big government, no. Let the market decide how health care happens in this country Larry Greenfield JTA World News Service LOS ANGELES (JTA) — Government insurance for health care — the public option — is an inappropriate cure that the American body politic is rejecting. Canadians spend 10 percent of their annual GDP on health care, while Americans spend 16 percent. However, Canadians experience long waiting lists for diagnosis and treatment, rationed care, and limited access to doctors and new medical devices. You can get private medical care in Canada — if you are a pet and your doctor is a vet. Otherwise, tens of thousands of Canadians flock to the United States each year for private care to reduce pain or to save their lives. Famously, Liberal MP Belinda Stronach advocated for government health care but then traveled to California herself for private breast cancer surgery. Even Canada’s top court struck down a Quebec ban on private health care as violating a patient’s right to life, liberty and security of person. Nationalized health care systems abroad depend upon cost and medical effectiveness panels that frequently deny drugs and surgeries to the elderly. That is not the American way. Neither is socialized medicine’s obvious disincentive to scientists and entrepreneurs to research and develop innovative biologics, medical devices and pharmaceuticals.
Americans, by contrast, produce and consume the best health care in the world and export life-saving drugs across the planet. A mer ic a n s a re over w hel m i ng l y impressed with the high-quality healthcare testing, technology and treatment they receive. Note that there are 12 patients in Europe for every nurse, compared to just six in the United States. Approximately 260 million Americans have private health insurance. The 40 million people who do not include many young and healthy who choose to become insured when they grow older and build families. It also includes 10-15 million illegal immigrants, a number that would rise with single-payer health care. It further includes the successful who choose not to purchase insurance and the poor who choose not to enroll in already existing public plans. There are actually only about 8 million chronically ill patients who require insurance and do not have it. We can and should cover them with vouchers, tax credits, and savings from the waste, fraud and abuse in the system. How to reduce costs for all Americans? How about medical liability reform, to reduce defensive medicine (unnecessary, expensive tests) and defensive documentation (hours a day on paperwork) and the $200+ billion a year in trial court judgments? As they say, ask your doctor.
Health insurance coverage for most people can be for catastrophic, not comprehensive, care. One size fits all is bad health care policy. Government mandates and rules prevent interstate competition among the 1,300 private insurance companies, keeping Americans from choosing good plans, thereby driving down costs and increasing health care accessibility, affordability, portability and price transparency. There are many sincere reforms (such as allowing well-qualified nurse practitioners to care for your cold at the local store) to increase consumer choice and health care supply, promote healthy living and keep medical professionals from leaving the field. Big government is clearly not the answer. The free market is already being crowded out in the United States. Medicare, Medicaid and S-CHIP account for 47 percent of health care costs. But they are going broke, as they cost billions more per year than promised when these programs were created. In 1965, Medicare began with predictions that it would cost taxpayers $12 billion by 1990. The bill came in 10 times higher. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office now predicts new, massive expenditures as utilization rates would soar under government health care. Mr. Obama’s senior economic officials have telegraphed the possibility of huge tax
increases to come. We hear the common refrain: If you think health care is expensive now, wait until it’s free. A mer ica ns have become deeply concerned about the rapidly growing government role in our economy (nationalization of banks, insurance companies and the auto industry), bizarre centralized economic planning schemes (directives not to hold government conferences in the convention destinations of Orlando or Las Vegas), and the Democratic Congress’ record-setting deficit spending. Poll numbers have shifted dramatically against t he extremely liberal president and Congress because their fearmongering about a looming Depression produced rushed, unread and ineffective stimulus legislation. The president again has overreached, cynically trying hard to pass Obamacare prior to wide public discussion. In the light of hot summer debate, even Obama now reveals ambiguity as he touts Fed Ex and UPS compared to the U.S. Post Office. Exactly. The left’s repeated prescriptions for bigger government are not what citizens desire or deserve. Larry Greenfield is an American Studies fellow at the The Claremont Institute for the Study of Statesmanship & Political Philosophy. Statistics come from the Pacific Research Institute, which opposes universal health care and works to advance “free-market policy solutions.”
a 6
jtnews
n
friday, september 4, 2009
community news
New energy at Beth El Tacoma congregation brings in new rabbi for cantorial and educational duties Malkie Cramer JTNews Intern On August 17, Tacoma’s Temple Beth El opened its doors to Rabbi Elizabeth Wood as its new director of education and cantorial soloist with an inauguration that included her leading the congregation for Shabbat services. “Her musical abilities are outstanding and she has a passion for Jewish education,” said Beth El’s senior rabbi, Bruce Kadden. Originally from West Lafayette, Ind., Rabbi Wood long knew she was destined to become a spiritual leader. At the age of 15, on a confirmation trip to the college where she would later be ordained, Wood was drawn to the prospect of becoming a rabbi, particularly by the rabbinical students she met. “They were fun, young, and inspired people,” Rabbi Wood said, “They were people who loved Judaism. It was inspiring.” Wood grew up in a strong Reform home, celebrating all the major holidays and keeping Shabbat. Both parents have been very active in their Jewish community most of her life. Her mother first served as president of their congregation in Indiana 15 years ago and her father followed — he is the synagogue’s current president. “My family really helped infuse my Jewish identity,” Wood said.
Peter Haley/The News Tribune
Rabbi Elizabeth Wood, who started in August at Temple Beth El in Tacoma. In 2004, she obtained her Bachelor’s degree in Jewish studies and political Science from Indiana University in Bloomington and received the Indiana University Piser Prize in Jewish Studies for most outstanding graduating senior. Wood was ordained in June at Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion in Cincinnati, Ohio. As a rabbinic student she served congregations in Ohio, Kentucky and Michigan. She also worked at the Union for Reform Judaism’s Goldman Union Camp Institute in Zions-
ville, Ind. where she was on staff for six years, first as a counselor for youth and then later as unit head. “I realized I could be who I was, be fun and young, and still be a rabbi,” Wood said. “It was a combination of how I grew up and who I was exposed to. It was a calling.” One aspect of that calling is Wood’s love of music. Her musical experience includes serving as a rabbinic intern for the URJ’s Mifgash Musicale Conference in Cincinnati and as vocalist for “Friday Night Live” Shabbat services.
“Jewish music really transcends who we are as a community.” Wood said. “It’s sacred. It’s not only important to who we are, and our heritage, but to our spirituality as well.” Through the placement office of the Central Conference of American Rabbis, Wood came across Temple Beth El. The synagogue, located in Tacoma, seemed to be a place where she could exercise both her musical background and her enthusiasm for education. “Both the cantorial soloist aspect and the educational aspect was very appealing to me. Coming out of rabbinical school I really wanted the perfect fit and Beth El was it.” she said. Lisa Sobel, Temple Beth El’s president, wrote in an e-mail that she was thrilled to have Wood join the congregation. “Rabbi Wood is a wonderful addition to our congregation this year,” Sobel wrote. “We have hired her as our religious [education] director/cantorial soloist to bring a continuity between the two positions. Her love of music and commitment to Jewish education will definitely enhance our community as she integrates her ideas with our congregational vision and goals.” Sobel added that Wood’s position as a rabbi means she can take over any duties in Rabbi Kadden’s absence or be available for any other sort of rabbinical function. As the religious education director at Beth El, Wood is in charge of family education, Sunday school, and Hebrew school. In addition, as a soloist, Wood is in charge of the music of the synagogue. “I really liked that [Beth El] had a holistic way of showing what a rabbi could be,” Wood said.
Come Taste the Sweetness of Judaism with our Temple Family Spiritually Engaging Dynamic Participatory Vibrant
Learning Torah History Culture
Tikkun Olam Involvement Justice Equality
בס’’ד
Dedication of our new Chabad House Cordially invites you to attend the Dedicated in loving memory of
Rabbi Gabi & Rivky Holzberg הי’’ד Shluchim of the Rebbe to Mumbai, India
Completion Ceremony of a new Torah Scroll and the
Donated by Mr. Mendy & Chanie Fischer שליט’’א and family of Brooklyn, N.Y.
� Sunday, September 13th beginning at 3:00pm Writing of last letters in the Torah
Cocktails, Musical Presentation and Torah Completion Ceremony
Community
at the Lakeside Montessori School in the Issaquah Highlands 2001 15th Ave. NE Issaquah, WA 98029
�
Inclusive Welcoming Respectful
Parade with new Torah scroll down Black Nugget Road
towards the new Chabad House at 24121 SE Black Nugget Road
For information about Membership, High Holy Days, Religious School and Lifelong Learning, please call the Temple at 206-525-0915
TEMPLE BETH AM
2632 NE 80th Street, Seattle, WA 206-525-0915 • www.templebetham.org The Reform Synagogue in Seattle’s Jewishly Happening North End
with live music and dancing
�
Followed by the Dedication of New Synagogue
Unveiling of the Tree of Life • Dedication of new Ark (Aron Kodesh)
Lighting of the “Ner Tamid” (Eternal Flame) and Preschool Dedication
�
RSVP 425-985-7639 or
[email protected] Festive attire suggested
friday, september 4, 2009
n
jtnews community news
a 7
Learning incentive Torah High offers high school credits for Jewish studies Leyna Krow Assistant Editor, JTNews For Torah High dean Ari Hoffman, the biggest challenge in providing afterschool Jewish educational opportunities for teens isn’t getting kids to show up. It’s convincing them to keep showing up week after week. “Our biggest problem last year was regular attendance,” he said. “There was nothing keeping them.” So for its second year, Torah High is offering a new incentive for students — actual high school credits. Starting this fall, Torah High, a Jewish studies program run by the National Conference of Synagogue Youth and based at the Bikur Cholim-Machzikay Hadath and Sephardic Bikur Holim synagogues in Seattle’s Seward Park neighborhood, will allow students to take classes that will count toward graduation from their regular high schools. Torah High is accredited through the Northwest Association of Accredited Schools as a supplemental institution. So, as Hoffman explained, any course completed through Torah High can earn students credits at other schools, just as it would if they were to take courses from a local junior college or a foreign exchange program. The Torah High program in Seattle is modeled after a similar program in Canada that has proved successful
at attracting and retaining students in several Canadian cities over the last five years. Rabbi Stephen Berger, director of education for Torah High Vancouver, said that between school, sports and other extracurricular clubs and activities, religious education for teens often gets pushed to the side. Programs that offer real academic incentives are a good way to draw in kids who might not otherwise be able to find the time. “Kids are so over-programmed, you have to have something special to offer to get them to take a look at their heritage,” he said. “This gives them a grade and one less class they have to take in school.” And it’s working. He noted that the Torah High in Ottowa, where the program first got started, reenrolled 500 students last year. Hoffman isn’t quite so ambitious as to expect those kinds of numbers in Seattle, however. Last year, 30 kids participated in Torah High. Hoffman said he hopes to see that number double now that students can take Torah High classes for credit. “Honestly, I’d like to see as many kids as possible sign up,” Hoffman said. “If 1,000 enrolled tomorrow, I’d find a way to accommodate them. We’re even offering free transportation from other neighborhoods, because Seward Park isn’t the easiest place for everyone to get to.”
Courtesy Ari Hoffman
Instructor Larry Russak demonstrates Commando Krav Maga techniques on Torah High dean Ari Hoffman. As an added bonus, any students who enroll for the fall will be entered into a raffle to win an iPod or a 42” HDTV. Kids who convince their friends to sign up get extra raffle tickets. Of course, prizes and free rides mean little if the classes themselves aren’t engaging. Hoffman k nows t his and worked to put together course offerings on a variety of topics including “Jewish Philosophy,” “Culinary Arts” and “Rock Band Jew.0.” Last year, Hoffman said,
Torah High’s most popular class (and one that will be offered again this time around) was a course on Krav Maga, the style of martial arts used by the Israeli army. “So this isn’t just sitting in a classroom hearing about Jewish history,” he said. Hoffman has also made efforts to enlist popular teachers in hopes of drawing kids in with familiar names. “I asked kids, ‘if you had your pick of teachers, who would you want?’” he said. “We’ve got people from SHA, TDHS, all over. It’s like the cream of the crop from the Jewish schools.” Torah High is supported financially by NCSY and the Jewish Student Union, as well as a grant from the Samis Foundation, which, according to grants director Rob Toren, has been a longtime supporter of NCSY programming in Seattle. The cost to attend is $350 per student per semester. Students must be Jewish to participate in Torah High, but Hoffman stressed that kids from all denominations are welcome and that there is no required level of observance. “Last year we had a good mix,” he said. “We had kids who had been going to day schools their whole lives, and some who had never set foot inside a synagogue before. So it really is for everyone.” For more information, visit w w w. torahhigh.org or contact Ari Hoffman at 206-295-5888. Classes begin Sept. 14.
CONNECTOR 2 0 3 1 T h i r d Av e n u e | S e a t t l e , WA | 9 8 1 2 1 - 2 4 1 2 | p : 2 0 6 4 4 3 - 5 4 0 0 | I n f o @ J e w i s h I n S e a t t l e . o r g | w w w. J e w i s h I n S e a t t l e . o r g
Coordinating Efforts Across the Community
Community-wide initiatives support nonprofits, fight poverty and connect people to the Jewish community.
Laugh Your Way to Giving: Drawing A Diverse Crowd They just keep rolling in: Single seats, whole rows and pre-reception registrations. And Seattleites are notorious for late RSVPs. What makes Laugh Your Way to Giving on September 16 such a draw? Maybe we as Jews don’t laugh together often enough. Maybe the affordable ticket price of $36 is a key feature. Maybe it is the promise of seeing the full diversity of the Jewish community at the dessert schmooze-fest afterward. All three certainly add up to the celebration we have in mind.
$36
/
/
TICKETS: $54
The broad participation adds up too. The community’s diverse needs are best met by participation in the Community Campaign by the full breadth of people in our Jewish community. Helping Jewish immigrants resettle in Israel can’t be done alone. Feeding the growing numbers at Jewish Family Service’s food bank can’t be done alone. Making Jewish families new to Seattle feel welcome can’t be done alone. Convincing elected officials to keep those in need at the forefront of their minds at budget cutting time can’t be done with a single voice. It is community that Laugh Your Way to Giving is all about. Feeling it. Being it. Helping it.
Due to popular demand, tickets will remain at $36!
Bringing More Home for the (High) Holidays
In synagogues, rabbis will address the topic of poverty from the bimah. Speakers from “Real Change” homeless paper will be made available to share their own personal stories with congregants. Individuals can act too. Congregations and organizations are pairing up with human service agencies – in a Mitzvah Match – to collect targeted goods and services the human service agency needs. Everyone is invited to participate. As the Seattle Jewish community celebrates Sukkot – a holiday recalling our wandering in the desert – we are reminded that there are many people in our Seattle community who are homeless and hungry and lack other basic necessities of life. We hope you will join with the Jewish Federation and other Jewish organizations in our community as we collectively focus on, and fight, poverty. Visit www.JewishInSeattle.org for more details.
Our High Holidays Outreach Initiative – in partnership with JTNews and Jew-ish.com – provides information, in the form of a website and a newspaper guide, to people who are looking for last-minute, low-cost or family-friendly services in the greater Puget Sound area.
Get plugged in to ISRAEL UNPLUGGED Seattle’s community trip to Israel May 23-June 1 2010. Email: AnnaF@ JewishInSeattle.org
The Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle Wishes You a Happy & Healthy New Year www.HolidaysInSeattle.org
news
The economic recession is testing our community and families. Applications for food stamps are on the rise, food bank lines are growing and unemployment is up. The need for our Jewish community to come together to address poverty in our community has never been greater. For the second year in a row, the Jewish Federation is spearheading “Focus and Fight: A Call to End Poverty.” During Sukkot, October 2-9, the Jewish community will be working collectively to alleviate poverty through a series of focused events and activities.
For many Jews, the High Holidays of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur are like Easter for Christians: the one time of year people go to religious services. However, just dropping into the largest cathedral in town does not quite translate to Judaism.
www.jtnews.net
jew-ish.com s e at t l e
By reaching out broadly through advertisements in Looking for High Holiday services? Explore the options at www.HolidaysInSeattle.org local neighborhood newspapers and signage at bagel stores, bookstores and grocery stores, we hope to spread the word about www.HolidaysInSeattle.org to reach people not yet connected with the Jewish community. Whether you’re unaffiliated with a synagogue or just looking to get a sense of the breadth of options available, www.HolidaysInSeattle.org is the place to look.
Have a sweet and healthy new year.
Sponsors: Anti-Defamation League, Cardozo Society of Washington State, Caroline Kline Galland Center, Congregation Beth Shalom, Evergreen Region BBYO, Herzl-Ner Tamid Conservative Congregation, Hillel at the University of Washington, Jewish Family Service, Jewish Federation of Greater Seattle, JTNews, Kadima, Kol HaNeshamah, Maimonides Society, National Council of Jewish Women, Rodef Tzedek, Stroum Jewish Community Center,Temple Beth Am, Temple B’nai Torah, Temple Beth Or, Temple De Hirsch Sinai, Washington State Jewish Historical Society and Young Leadership (As of 8/21/09)
Who is your Jewish Community Hero?
www.JewishCommunityHeroes.com/Seattle
What do the founder of an urban kibbutz, a one-woman show who helps Jews coming to Seattle for specialized medical treatment find housing, food and support, and the man behind the Greater Seattle Jewish Business Network have in common? They are Seattle Jews who have been nominated by local community members to become the Jewish Community Hero of the Year. Join the Jewish Federation and United Jewish Communities for the inaugural Jewish Community Heroes campaign, celebrating the selflessness and courage of individuals who are bettering their communities through service and outreach. Somewhat like American Idol, the top vote-getters will be honored as Jewish Community Heroes with one receiving $25,000 to put toward his or her work. Let’s get behind our Seattle Jewish community heroes. Vote online for your favorite(s) as many times as you like through October 8. Don’t see your hero yet? Nominate them! Don’t miss the opportunity to recognize our local heroes on a national stage!
jtnews
n m.o.t.: member of the tribe
friday, september 4, 2009
Eternal light shines bright in Africa Also: Running for life
Diana Brement JTNews Columnist Sculptor and glass artist Gabriel Bass, a Mercer Island native now living in Jerusalem, recently completed and installed a ner tamid (eternal light) and menorah commission for the Abayudaya Jewish community in Uganda. The commission came from a California couple who are deeply involved with the Abayudaya. They “felt the synagogue needed an eternal light and turned to me for that,” Gabe says. (The menorah was added later.) Gabe admits he’d never heard of the African Jews, but as soon as he started talking about the project, all sorts of connections revealed themselves. “Doors just started opening left and right,” he says. Friends, neighbors, even clients had heard of, donated to, visited, and even worked with the Abayudaya. “Support just started coming in,” and it didn’t take long for him to decide to perform the installation himself. It was a long but uneventful 24-hour journey from Jerusalem to Kampala, with two layovers and a four-hour drive
from the airport to the village. Gabe carried the works, “just to make sure” they arrived safely. He stayed two weeks, visiting most of the local Jewish communities. “They say there’s eight,” Gabe says, “but there’s different things happening, different communities cropping up, [other] people that are becoming Jewish.” Both pieces are made of glass and wood from a single Israeli cypress tree. The ner tamid is red, black and yellow, the colors of the Ugandan flag. It runs on a battery attached to a solar collector, keeping it lit during the many blackouts and power shortages. “The synagogue is the only building with electricity,” in the villages, says Gabe. The menorah has glass fittings and oil lamps on tops.
Courtesy Gabriel Bass
Gabriel Bass works with members of the Ugandan Abuyudaya synagogue in finishing the menorah he designed for the congregation.
Many villagers came to help install the project. The community has established a religious school, and “a lot of the yeshiva kids helped me,” Gabe says. “Everyone wanted to give a hand.” Then, that Shabbat “we had a really nice festive meal.” Gabriel grew up on Mercer Island and his family attended Herzl-Ner Tamid Conservative Congregation (appropriately), although they moved away while he was in high school. He and his wife, Gabriela (Hammer), who also grew up at Herzl, re-met and married after college. They now live in Jerusalem with their two children. Gabe, who did some of his training with the Musqueam tribe of British Columbia, creates a lot of synagogue furniture and Judaica. “About half my work is shipped back to the United States,” he says. Chabad of the Central Cascades recently purchased an aron kodesh (ark) from him. See more of Gabe’s work at his Web site, www.customcarving.org, where you can learn how to visit his studio when you’re in Jerusalem. He’ll be in North America in November, speaking at the URJ biennial in Toronto, making other presentations and visiting clients in the Northeast. ••• Last summer we received an e-mail from Esther Lott reporting that she and some of her family had run in the Swedish SummeRun 5K race, and that she had done quite well.
a 9
I was a little slow on the uptake, so by the time I called, Esther and her husband, Al, were away for the winter and we didn’t connect. This year I called early in the summer to see if she was running again. Indeed she was, and did on July 26. “It was great,” she says, “I got first place in my category.” However, at age 77, “I was the only one running!”
Bob Solomon
Three generations of runners in this year’s Swedish SummeRun: Celina Solomon, left, who took second place in her division, her mother Susan Solomon, center, and Susan’s mother Esther Lott, who took first place in the 60-and-over division. It’s not much to beat yourself, but Esther was gratified to learn that she had also bettered runners in the 60-and-up category with her time of 31 minutes. “I got my gold medal in the mail,” she says. “That made me feel good.” Esther ran with her daughter, Susan Solomon, and her granddaughter, Celina.
u Page 35A
Wishing You a Happy and Healthy New Year.
Looking to connect for the High Holidays? Find ticket information at www.HolidaysInSeattle.org
The Jerusalem Post Crossword Puzzle Actresses of Note
a
n 10 jtnews a view from the u
“For the sin we have committed through mis-spelling” How an academic lifer manages the dual New Year
By Matt Gaffney
Martin Jaffee JTNews Columnist
Across 1 Jazzman Getz 5 House, to Sephardim 9 Manischewitz product 14 Volcano outpouring 15 Is in the red 16 Dan, for one 17 Best Actress of 1960 & 1966 20 “The Advocate’s ___”(Dershowitz novel) 21 Yente’s opening 22 Easy tennis play 23 ___ Bundy (Katie Sagal role) 25 Ending for Freudian 27 Best Supporting Actress of 1969 33 Saudi name part akin to Jewish “ben-” 36 Comic Boosler 37 “It’s ___ what you think!” 38 Cheer 40 Between lather and repeat 41 Freud’s “self” 42 Righteous indignation 43 Like 1492 44 ___ in “apple” 45 “___ With No Name” 46 Ending for Japan 47 Best Supporting Actress of 1968 49 “___ said it!” 51 Rare tic-tac-toe victory 52 “Caught you!” 55 “Fuzzy wuzzy was ___...” 58 Salk conquered it 63 Best Actress of 1968 66 Funnyman Kovacs 67 Give a nudge 68 Dieter’s word 69 Lost a lap? 70 No 71 Nose stimulus
Answers on page 27
Down 1 Rosebud, for instance 2 I.L. Peretz work, often 3 Israeli rocker Geffen 4 “Soup ___” (“Seinfeld” character) 5 Corn place 6 “Anchors ___” 7 Adam’s third 8 Wimbledon winner of 1975 9 Jewish ones have six points 10 Bawl 11 Countryside feature 12 “Peek-___!” 13 “Kvetch” or “schmooze” 18 Swiss 19 Mar 24 Wide shoe size 26 “The ___ Has Two Faces” 27 Winger’s “An Officer and a Gentleman” co-star 28 Middle Eastern staple 29 Bowling places 30 “High School Musical” channel 31 Woody Allen quality 32 Court 34 Room’s go-with 35 “That’s false!” 39 Stoyteller’s segue 41 Seine contents 42 Goldberg who won an Oscar in 1990 44 Caribbean resort 45 In time past 48 King genre 50 Powered one’s rowboat 52 Fortas and Lincoln 53 TV personality Kitty Carlisle ___ 54 Florence’s river 56 Jason and Randy Sklar network 57 Razor name 59 Where Wiesel picked up his Nobel 60 Put (down) 61 Having as a hobby 62 German-Polish river 64 Celebrity story 65 Breyer rival
friday, september 4, 2009
Sometimes I can’t believe that I’ve been “in college” (with a year or two off here and there) for over 40 years — to be precise, since autumn 1966, when I first set foot on the campus of Syracuse University. I’ll never forget the crisp late-September air of upstate New York during Orientation Week; the excitement of live “soul music” (Sam & Dave, the Four Tops, and the local favorite, Otis and the All-Night Workers, among others) blaring from the front porches of the stately Greek-letter mansions on Crouse Avenue’s fraternity row; the delight at discovering that my dormitory roommate, one Pete Zucker, could hold a lit Kent in the corner of his mouth while playing Frisbee with one eye closed against the smoke; the thrill of sauntering into the local campus bar, “The Orange,” and ordering up my first legal “7 & 7”! And so on. There was, of course, a Hillel House at Syracuse that, as the advertisement went, “served the needs of Jewish students” by offering High Holiday services. Maybe it did, but my “needs” (as I imperfectly grasped them in those days) didn’t propel me through the Hillel House door even once during the entire seven years it took me to get my degree (this was, after all, the late ’60s, and much needed doing). Like so many Jews of my grandparents’ generation who f led European persecutions for the freedom of di goldene medina, and like virtually all of their grandchildren who were my peers at Syracuse, the last thing that entered my mind upon tasting the freedom of college was confining myself in a dark Jewish suit to klop Al Khet on Yom Kippur or even take advantage of a “delicious Rosh Hashanah meal with a local family.” Besides, as a budding fan of the Mothers of Invention, I was not going to place myself willingly within speaking range of anyone who, like the figure presiding over the Syracuse Hillel, was known to the faithful as “the beloved Rabbi Elefant!” Well, obviously, I eventually outgrew my antipathy to Judaism, but I won’t shlep you through the tale. Suffice it to say that one thing I learned from my “college experience” is that you simply can’t predict how a Jew will rediscover the flame of the pintele yid that somehow burns despite years of oxygen deprivation. Maybe because I’ve been “in college” virtually every autumn since 1966, the beginnings of this dual New Year — the academic year and the Jewish season of spiritual renewal — always coincide in my mind. The excitement of one feeds the other. Somehow the thrill of an early autumn “Battle of the Bands” on that long-ago and far-away Syracuse campus shapes my anticipation of the first notes of the hazzan’s High Holiday ma’ariv nusach on erev Rosh Hashanah. Sounds preposterous, I know — but there you have it. A fact!
Stranger still is the odd way the emotional world of the Season of Atonement colors as well my approach to the new students I first meet in my classes in the fall. I view each of them as the embodiment of those whom the Talmud calls “all the world-dwellers who pass in judgment before You like wayward flocks.” Like the Master of the World, I review my “f lock’s” sins, committed in the course of their written work, and pass compassionate judgment upon appropriate evidence of atonement. Among the relatively minor academic sins, soon to pass from the scene in this era of spell check, are the howlers of misspelling that keep me awake as I ponder the fate of student work. Here I’ll report on one of my favorites. Would you believe that, in any given year, perhaps a dozen students, while writing about Jewish history in ancient times, will inform me of the “ancient Jewish homeland of Palestein?” For years I’d scribble in the margin of such papers sardonic notes like: “As in Rubenstein, Goldstein, and Bernstein?” But then it dawned on me that this sort of common mistake is in fact a cultural phenomenon that carries with it its own “teachable moment” (thank you, Prof. Gates, for restoring this conceit of ’60s activism to our working vocabulary!). So, I began, at the first opportunity, to turn the topic of “Palestein” into a 20-minute rehearsal of the various names by which successive conquistadors (pagan, Christian, Muslim, and Imperial) have identified what Jews call “the Land of Israel.” In order to vary the shtick, I have in recent years tended to take a more aggressive route to correction. Abandoning my ponderous, rigorously technical disquisition on the aliases of biblical Canaan, I now make my point with music. Fighting force with farce, and exploiting my painlessly acquired native-competence in American-Jewish pop culture, I bring to class a laptop and a couple of CDs and call out, “Party Time!” Believe me, no student who beholds Prof. Jaffee expounding Eddie Cantor’s 1930s recording of “Leena, the Queen of Palesteena” will ever again spell the Roman name for the Jewish homeland is if it were a Rheinland dukedom! Similar instruction benefits anyone who contemplates Alan Sherman’s terrific riff on Ashkenazic names, “Shake Hands With Your Uncle Max, My Boy.” As My Son the Folksinger says: “Here’s Brumberger, Shumberger, Minkes and Pincus, Stein with an e-i and Styne with a y!” So far, this approach has worked well. By the end of autumn quarter, I have extended kapparah to virtually all sinners — except for the inevitable essayist on “the Jewish dietary laws” whose studies unearth the news that “the Bible prohibits Jews from boiling children in their mothers’ milk.” For such a one I reserve a special seat next to Amalek in the boiling wastes of the back row of Gehinom Hall. But that’s a story for another occasion — maybe Purim! Martin S. Jaffee currently holds the Samuel & Althea Stroum Chair in Jewish Studies at the University of Washington. His award-winning columns for JTNews have recently been published in book form as The End of Jewish Radar: Snapshots of a Post-Ethnic American Judaism by iUniverse press.
&2%%
()'( (/,)$!9 3%26)#%3 !.$ #,!33%3
#/.3%26!4)6% /24(/$/8 2%&/2- ,!"%,3 !2% &/2 #,/4(%3 ./4 &/2 *%73
%
SPECIALLY NOW WITH OUR HEARTS HEAVY OVER )SRAEL ARENT YOU TIRED OF BEING LABELED !RE ALL THE DISAGREEMENTS AMONG THE MOVEMENTS IN *UDAISM RELEVANT TO THE ISSUES THAT IMPACT YOU *OIN THE &LAME