How To Critique 2

GRADING THE PORTFOLIOS! Before you start...THANKS SO MUCH FOR YOUR HELP!!! My students are very, very excited that PROFESSIONALS will be looking at their portfolios. A little background, this is a beginning design course...based on Photoshop techniques. There is some focus ART topics such as balance, composition, focus, etc., however the focus is on technique. Also, many of these students have only been using PS for 3 months, but they have come pretty far with their experimenting. I hope you enjoy their work as my students will enjoy hearing your feedback. 1. Visit the student portfolio online. This will be sent to you via email. Click on the link to be directed there. Their portfolios are organized like this:

Blog title Comp. Title/link

2. Read their blog and their personal reflections for the rationale to their design. Please remember that my students are mainly English Language Learners, so their grammar, punctuation and writing may be of a lower level. 3. View their comps by Clicking on the LINK provided (some students actually posted the pictures, in both cases click on the link to view their composition)

List of techniques used

Personal grade Grade justification

Personal reflection

#2 Title of Composition

3. Grade by the Rubric: you will be responsible for grading EFFORT/TECHNIQUE and CREATIVITY. I will be grading based on my guidelines. (don’t worry about this) Note that both categories are very subjective, that’s ok. That’s why you’re critiquing. :) Use their reflections to inform your critique. 4. HOW TO GIVE FEEDBACK: (The most important part) Students have been told that you will be leaving COMMENTS on their blogs as their feedback. I would prefer you write a note to them, however bulleted points will do just fine. In any case, please include the following information (in this order): 1. 2. 3. 4.

Introduce yourself (include your graphics design firms and/or companies and what you do—if you’re interested, leave a link to your online portfolio if you want!) For each SAMPLE, Provide a grade for EFFORT/TECHNIQUE as well as your explanation. (1 short paragraph should suffice) For each SAMPLE, Provide a grade for CREATIVITY as well as your explanation. (1 short paragraph should suffice) Open Critique: Include suggestions and ideas that could make it better and/or anything else you’d like to tell them.

If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to call me 310.694.7917

THANKS A BUNCH! Jay R Aguda

#3 Title of Composition