Drilling Spills

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 1

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DALE FOX GAS WELL BIXBY HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 9610441

Close Date: 01/08/1997

FREEDOM, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14065 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons RON LEWIS MXFRANKS

Spiller: DALE FOX - DALE FOX Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: RON LEWIS

Spiller Phone: (814) 368-5901 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 496-8859 Contact Person Phone: (716) 496-8859

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/20/1996 01/08/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER CONCERNED ABOUT WATER WELL. DRILLERS DRILLING NEARBY CAUSED PROBLEM - DRILLING EAST AND 1 MILE AWAY. caller never had problem til today. fd on scene now (yorkshire). caller concerned about impact. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 11/20/96: MF S/V/AL ALEXANDER, JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERIALS/DALE FOX, RP/STATE POLICE/STU LEXNOR, CATT CO HAZ MAT/VARIOUS FD’S. DALE FOX DRILLING GAS WELL ON BIXBY HILL RD, FREEDOM. NATURAL GAS ESCAPED THRU FAULT IN SHALE, AFFECTED PROPERTIES APPX 1 & 1/2 MILES SW ON WEAVER RD. TOWN OF YORKSHIRE. GAS BUBBLING IN RON LEWIS’S POND. BUBBLING IN DITCH WEST SIDE OF WEAVER RD. 12 FAMILIES EVACUATED. GAS IN LEWIS’S BASEMENT (BUILT ON SHALE). FARMERS WELL IN BARN 11708 WEAVER RD (STEVE WOLDSZYN) VENTED TO OUTSIDE. GAS COMING UP THOU GROUND IN LEWIS’S YARD. MET WITH OFFICIALS AT DELIVAN FD. THEY WILL KEEP FAMILIES EVACUATED & CLOSE WEAVER RD UNTIL TOMARROW. SITUATION WILL BE APPRAISED AT NOON TOMORROW. MINERIALS AT WELL SITE, GAS ESCAPE APPEARS TO BE CONTROLLED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 2

11/21/96: MF S/V/DALE FOX, CLAIMED SITUATION CONTROLLED. GAS STILL BUBBLING IN POND & SIDE OF RD. RAY JORDEN, CACHD SAMPLING DRINKING WATER WELLS, THEY DONT KNOW FOR WHAT. 11/22/96: MF S/V/RON LEWIS, POND MINOR BUBBLING. HE IS WORRIED APOUT DRINKING WATER, TOLD HIM I DONT KNOW WHAT HEALTH DEPT CHECKED WATER FOR BUT I WILL CHECK. 11/25/96: MF T/C CHRIS MILLER, HE ASKED IF I COULD SAMPLE LEWIS’S WATER, CLAIMED HEALTH DEPT SAMPLED FOR METHANE & RON IS WORRIED ABOUT CRUDE OIL. RON WANTS DEC TO SAMPLE (3RD PARTY). T/C RON LEWIS, TOLD HIM I WILL CHECK WITH RP TO GIVE HIM OPPERTUNITY TO SAMPLE. T/C DALE FOX HE AGREED TO ALLOW STATE TO SAMPLE & HE WILL PAY BILL. 11/26/96: MF T/C/CAMERON O’CONNOR, NYSDOH, HE RECOMMENDED SAMPLING LEWIS’S WELL FOR H2S, METALS, FECAL COLIFORM, VOLITALES & SEMI VOLITALES. 12/02/96: MF LETTER TO RP. 12/03/96: MF S/V/RON LEWIS, SAMPLED HIS WELL. NO BUBBLES NOTED ON HIS POND. SAMPLES TO LAB. 12/10/96: MF LETTER FROM RP, INS CO; MR. ROBERT McKEEVER S.H. GOW & COMPANY 344 DELAWARE AVE BUFFALO, N.Y. 14202 12/17/96: MF RECEIVED & PROCESSED ACTS $175. PAY PACKAGE. ALL RESULTS 503.1 & 8270 BN, BELOW STARS. RESULTS TO ALL PARTIES. 12/27/96: MF PROCESSED $180. PAY PACKAGE FROM WASTESTREAM. 01/08/97: MF NO PETROLEUM COMPOUNDS IN WELL. NOT A SPILL PROBLEM, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ISR PENDING. 02/26/98: MF GAVE FILE TO LEGAL [MAUREEN].

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 3

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL GAS HALLSPORT INDEPENDENCE RD

Spill Number: 9707892

Close Date: 10/16/1997

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Local Agency TANYA ALEXANDER FXGALLEG

Spiller: TANYA ALEXANDER - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: DAVE BIMBER Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 832-9804 Notifier Phone: (716) 857-7410 Caller Phone: (716) 832-9804 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/03/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 15000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE TANK OVER FLOWED DUE TO APPARENT EQUIPMENT FAILURE (VALVE FAILURE) MATERIAL IS FLOWING OVERLAND INTO LOCAL CREEK. SERVICE PERSON IS ENROUTE TO STOP LEAK. BRINE IS SALT WATER BY PRODUCT OF NATERIAL GAS EXTRACTION. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 10/3/97 MARK HANS CALLED. REQUESTED INFORMATION ON HOW TO HANDLE SALT BRINE SPILLS. I TOLD HIM IT DEPENDS ON SIZE OF SPILL AND IMPACTS. 10/6/97 SPOKE TO CHRIS MILLER WITH MINERALS. HE SAID THE SPILL WAS 15,000 GALLONS OF A CONCENTRATED BRINE FROM NATIONAL FUELS PRODUCTION FACILITY ON INDEPENDENCE RD IN WILLING. HE SAID THAT WATER WELLS MAY BE IMPACTED. MR. MILLER WILL INSPECT SITE AND GET BACK TO ME. 10/6/97 SPOKE TO TANYA ALEXANDER WITH NATIONAL FUEL GAS. SHE SAID THE WORK WAS ALL DONE OVER THE WEEKEND. THERE WAS WATER WELL SAMPLING DONE. CHRIS CEJ WILL BE ON SITE TODAY INSPECTING DAMAGE. POSSIBLE THAT THE CREEK WAS IMPACTED. TANYA SAID THAT

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 4

RESULTS WILL BE IN TODAY OR TOMORROW. SHE SAID THAT SOMEWHERE BETWEEN 15,000 AND 20,000 GALLONS OF BRINE WERE SPILLED. WE WILL WAIT FOR REPORTS. 10/7/97 CHRIS MILLER WITH MINERALS INSPECTED THE SITE ON 10/6/97 AND SAID THAT THE BRINE RAN THROUGH THE FIELD FROM THE NATIONAL FUEL SITE TO THE DITCH TO THE CULVERT TO THE SCRUB BRUSH TO THE CREED WHICH IS A TRIBUTARY TO THE GENESSEE RIVER. THE VEGETATION WAS KILLED IN THIS PATH. THERE WERE 3 SAFETY FEATURES ON THE SYSTEM SO THAT IT WOULD NOT FAIL. IF THE PRESSURE GOT TO 100 LBS, THERE WOULD BE A BY PASS AND THE RUPTURE DISK WOULD FAIL AND BRINE WOULD FLOW TO THE HOLDING TANK. THE RUPTURE DISK FAILED AT 10 LBS & NOTHING SHUT DOWN SO THE SYSTEM CONTINUED TO FLOW. NATIONAL FUEL IS CHECKING THE SYSTEM AND WILL PROBABLY ELIMINATE THE RUPTURE DISK. THE LANDOWNERS ARE OK WITH NATIONAL FUEL RESOLUTION. ONE LANDOWNER HAS COWS THAT DRINK FROM THE CREEK. NATIONAL FUEL WILL BUY A NEW FENCE & PROVIDE WATER FOR THE COWS. CHRIS MILLER FELT THAT THE BEST SOLUTION TO THE PATH OF DEAD VEGETATION IS TO LEAVE IT TO GROW BACK NEXT SUMMER. 10/16/97 RECD NATIONAL FUEL REPORT OF THE INCIDENT. THE SITE IS A SPDES PERMITTED FACILITY. BRIAN HOURIGAN WILL ADDRESS ANY FUTURE CONCERNS AT THIS SITE. THE SITE CAN BE CLOSED. NO FURTHER WORK REQUIRED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 5

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BUCKEYE COAST PIPELINE 17 MILE STRETCH

Spill Number: 0270494

Close Date: 09/28/2004

ALEXANDER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14005 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JASON MENGEL CAHETTEN

Spiller: BUCKEYE GULF COAST PLINE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: BUCKEYE GULF COAST PLINE Contact for more spill info: JASON MENGEL

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (484) 232-4491 Contact Person Phone: (484) 232-4491

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/16/2002 09/28/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: THE DEPARTMENT HAS BEEN NOTIFIED OF A POSSIBLE SODIUM CHLORIDE SPILL IN THE BUCKEYE GULF PIPELINE DUE TO A PRESSURE CHANGE NOTICED SOMETIME ON DECEMBER 16TH. THE SPILL HAS NOT BEEN PINPOINTED YET, BUT PIPELINE PERSONNEL ARE WALKING A 17 MILE LINE BETWEEN CRITTENDEN IN GENESEE COUNTY AND DALE IN WYOMING COUNTY (REGION 9). A HELICOPTER IS ALSO GOING TO BE USED ON 12/19TH IF NOTHING IS FOUND BEFORE THAT TIME. PIPELINE PERSONNEL WILL UPDATE THE DEPARTMENT AS SOON AS THE SOURCE AND ACTUAL POSITION ARE PINPOINTED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "CH" 12/26/2002: HALL RECEIVES UPDATE FROM MARK BONENBERGER (BUCKEYE). DEFECTIVE SECTION OF PIPLINE HAS BEEN IDENTIFIED ON MCVEAN ROAD IN THE TOWN OF CORFU. LINE HAS BEEN SHUT DOWN AND REPAIRS ARE UNDERWAY. 08/07/03: CH MEETS ON SITE WITH DEC FORESTER, MARK GOODING, AND PROPERTY OWNERS, MARK MAUER AND RUTH. THE PIPELINE BREAK OCCURRED BEHIND THE MAUER’S SHOP AT 9732 SNIPERY ROAD AND WAS ON A SLOPE. THE BRINE THEN FLOWED INTO AN AREA THAT LOOKS LIKE A HARD BOTTOM SWAMP. ALL THE TREES IN THIS AREA ARE DEAD. IT APPEARS THERE IS A COUPLE OF ACRES KILLED. IT SEEMS TO BE AN ISOLATED AREA OF

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 6

IMPACT. 08/08/03: CH TELCON WITH MARK BONNENBERGER OF BUCKEYE. CH REQUESTS A WRITTEN REPORT OF RELEASE. 08/18/04: CH MEETS AT RUTH KOMOROWSKI PROPERTY WITH RUTH AND DON MEEDER AND TOM ROTH OF PB ENERGY STORAGE. RUTH’S ADDRESS IS 1409 MCVEAN ROAD, CORFU, NY 14036. THE OTHER IMPACTED PARTY WAS MARK MAUER,9732 SNIPERY RD, CORFU, NY 14036. WE GO BACK TO THE HARD BOTTOM SWAMP WHERE MOST OF THE BRINE CAME TO REST. ALL THE TREES ARE STILL DEAD IN THIS AREA, BUT THE GRASSES AND SHALLOW ROOTED VEGETATION IS COMING BACK ALL ACROSS THE IMPACTED AREA. PB ENERGY HAS TAKEN OVER OWNERSHIP OF THE PIPELINE AND WILL WORK OUT A SETTLEMENT WITH BOTH PROPERTY OWNERS. THEY MAY TRY PLANTING SOME SALT RESISTENT TREES IN THE SWAMP AREA. CH REQUEST THAT MS KOMOROWSKI’S WATER WELL BE SAMPLED AND PENDING THE RESULTS OF THIS SAMPLING THE SPILL WILL BE CLOSED. CH NOTIFIES RANDY GARNEY OF GENESEE COUNTY HEALTH OF THE PENDING SAMPLING. RANDY WILL WORK WITH PB ENERGY REGARDING THE SAMPLING AND LOCATION OF A BACKGROUND WELL. 09/28/04: SAMPLE RESULTS OF KOMOROWSKI’S WELL WERE RECIEVED AND REVIEWED BY DEC AND GENESEE COUNTY HEALTH DEPT. BASED ON THE SAMPLE RESULTS NO MAXIMUM CONTAMINANT LEVELS WERE EXCEEDED EXCEPT FOR BACTERIA. NO FURTHER ACTION IS NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 7

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL HALLSPORT ROAD

Spill Number: 0375293

Close Date: 09/10/2003

INDEPENDENCE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14806 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JIM CLARK JFOTTO

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

R. GREGORESKI - NATIONAL FUEL SAME NATIONAL FUEL JIM CLARK

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2357 Contact Person Phone: (716) 827-2357

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/10/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 100000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAID THAT ONE OF THEIR VALUES BROKE,CAUSING ABOUT 100,000 GAL OF BRINE SOLUTION TO SPILL...SOME OF THIS GOT INTO SHANADA CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 09/10/03 JFO ON SITE MET WITH RICHARD PENSYL, JIM CLARK AND ROB GREGORESKI ALL OF NATIONAL FUEL. IT IS UNKNOWN WHEN THE VALVE BROKE. THE LAST TIME IT WAS CHECKED WAS THE MORNING BEFORE. THE BRINE FLOWED TO THE WEST FROM THE BLDG TO AN OUTSIDE DRAIN AND DOWN A FIELD TO A WOODED AREA NEAR THE INJECTION WELL AND THEN SOUTH TO THE CREEK. WE COLLECTED A WATER SAMPLE AT THE BRIDGE .8 OF A MILE DOWN THE ROAD. THE BRIDGE IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION AND THE WORKER DID NOT SEE ANY DEAD FISH IN THE WATER. NO ACTION POSSIBLE BY SPILLS. THIS WILL BE HANDLED BY BRIAN HOURIGAN OF THE DIVISION OF WATER. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 8

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

HARVEY WELL DUTCH HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 0507041

Close Date: 03/27/2006

PINE CITY, NY 14871

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JEFF BOWERS CMKEHOE

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

FORTUNA ENERGY JEFF BOWERS FORTUNA ENERGY JEFF BOWERS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (607) 329-7140 Caller Phone: (607) 329-7140 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/10/2005 03/27/2006 TANK OVERFILL NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN HAZARDOUS MATERIAL HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 800.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: UNKNOWN SITUATION WHEREAS TANK OVERFLOWED. DOUBLE WALL CONTAINMENT TANK. PRODUCTION FLUID SALT BRINE. REQUESTING CALLBACK FOR ADVICE. TANK HAS BEEN EMPTIED. JM UPDATES CK. SPILL FAXED TO HORSEHEADS. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 09/12/05: KEHOE ON SITE WITH JEFF BOWERS OF FORTUNA. A BRINE TANK OVERFILLED BECAUSE THE HAUL TRUCK DID NOT COME AS SCHEDULED. THE BRINE OVERFLOWED INTO A DITCH THAT FLOWED TO A SMALL POOL/CATCH BASIN. THE BRINE THEN FLOWED UNDER THE ACCESS ROAD INTO A WOODED AREA WITH SEVERAL INTERMITTENT STREAMS RUNNING THROUGHOUT. IMPACTS COULD BE NOTED IN THE DITCH, POOL/CATCHBASIN AND AT THE CULVERT OUTLET. JEFF WILL HAVE SOMEONE PUMP THE POOL AND CLEAN AND FLUSH THE DITCH. LONG TERM, JEFF PLANS TO INSTALL BERMS AROUND THE TANKS AND INVESTIGATE THE USE OF HIGH LEVEL SHUTOFFS. AN EXCAVATION CONTRACTOR WAS CALLED IMMEDIATELY AFTER SPEAKING. 03/27/06 1030 KEHOE ON SITE TO CHECK SPILL #0551802, ALSO CHECKED THIS SPILL. CLEANUP COMPLETE, NO REMAINING VISIBLE SALT STAINING. NO IMPACTS TO VEGETATION NOTICED. NFA - CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 9

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

THURSTON HWY DEPT/ TUCKER RES. 4980 MCINTOSH ROAD

Spill Number: 0750338

Close Date: 06/19/2007

THURSTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 4980 MCINTOSH RD Revised zip code: 14821 Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: pclinden

Spiller: RICARD GAUSS - THURSTON TOWN HWY DEPT Spiller Phone: 607-776-6507 Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/03/2007 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THAT THERE IS DEAD VEGETATION ALONG THE ROADSIDE DITCH, INCLUDING GRASS AND A FLOWER BED, ALONG WHERE RAINWATER RUNOFF FOLLOWED THROUGH A ROADSIDE DRAINAGE DITCH. NO ODOR WAS NOTED. THE DEAD VEGETATION WAS NOTED 6-8 FEET FROM THE CENTER LINE OF THE DRAINAGE DITCH AND AT SOME POINTS FLOWED UNDER A FENCE LINE INTO A YARD. THE IMPACTED AREA IS ESTIMATED TO BE APPROXIMATELY 110 FEET LONG. THE SOURCE IS UNKNOWN. TUCKER CALLS BACK LATER TO SAY THAT THE TOWN REBUILT THE GRAVEL ROAD AND BRINED IT ABOUT 10 DAYS AGO. HE SUSPECTS THAT THE ONLY RECENT RAIN OF JUST A FEW DAYS AGO MAY HAVE WASHED OUT THE SALT WHICH PROBABLY BURNED THE LAWN. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 6/12/07 LINDENFELSER MET WITH EDIE TUCKER WHO SHOWED BURNT LAWN NOT ONLY ON GRASSED SHOULDER AT WEST END OF PROPETY BUT ALSO UNDER FENCE AND ONTO SEVERAL SQUARE FEET OF LAWN. PL ADVISES THAT RAIN SHOULD FLUSH OUT SALT RESIDUE ALLOWING REPLANTING OF GRASS. THE ADJACENT FLOWER BED IS UNAFFECTED AND SHOULD REMAIN SO AS IT IS RAISED. BECAUSE ROAD RUNOFF ONLY OCCURRED IN ONE AREA WHERE THE DITCH IS VERY SHALLOW AND ESCAPES ITS COURSE, PL SUGGESTED BUILDING UP LAWN AT FENCE TO DEFLECT WATER BACK TO DITCH. GRASS IN DITCH DOWNGRADIENT AND ALONGSIDE TUCKER ROAD NORTH OF AREA WAS SIMILARLY BURNED. GRAVEL AT EDGES OF ROAD IS LIGHTLY FROSTED WITH SALT RESIDUE. PL AGREES WITH DENNIS TUCKER THAT BURN IS PROBABLY FROM SALT APPLICATION FOR DUST CONTROL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 10

6/13/07 LINDENFELSER CALLS THURSTON DEPUTY HWY SUPT RICHARD GAUSS AND ASKS HIM TO LIMIT BRINE APPLICATION. GAUSS SAYS THAT THEY RECENTLY REBUILT THE GRAVEL ROAD WHICH REQUIRED A HEAVIER THAN NORMAL APPLICATION OF BRINE TO STABILIZE THE LOOSE GRAVEL AS PER STANDARD PRACTICES. THIS WAS FOLLOWED BY A LATER LIGHTER APPLICATION WHEN THE WORK IS DONE. THIS REBUILDING IS NOT OFTEN DONE AND SO THE BRINE LOADING WILL NOT SOON RECUR. GAUSS SAID THEY WILL RE-CUT THE DITCH TO CHANNEL RUNOFF AWAY FROM LAWN. NO FURTHER ACTIONS BY SPILLS IS NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 11

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SOULE ROAD-COUCH PROPERTY ACCESS RD OFF OF SOULE RD

Spill Number: 0813694

Close Date: 05/21/2009

LEBANON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13085 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Local Agency Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cxrossi

Spiller: DOUG STEBBINS - NORNEW INC, DIV OF NORSE ENERGY Spiller Phone: Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: Contact for more spill info: DOUG STEBBINS Contact Person Phone: (716) 969-1482

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/19/2009 05/21/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected DIESEL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 200.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Drilling station hit a gas pocket-caught rig on fire and 3000 gallon diesel tank (Note: this tank found to be intact and not leaking. Another 300 gallon tank directly on the drill rig lost hose and was actual cause of 200 gallon release-ctr 3/19/09) -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Madison County 911 reported that a 3000 gallon AST might have released during an explosion at this location. Product was released next to the drill rig and via the run off from that nights rain had been carried partially down the south slope of the site. It did not reach the near by stream. Nornew hired Environmental Products and Services who placed absorbent materials to further contain and collect any petroleum and further protect the stream. The fire was put out about 14:30. EPS assisted the on site crew in pumping a pooled area where the diesel had collected into a tank on site and then off loaded into EPS vac truck. The site was inspected and any visible product was soaked up with absorbent pads. Inspection of the 3000 gallon tank showed it was intact and the diesel spill actually came from melted piping from approximate 300 gallon tank. Less than 300 gallons was spilled. 03-20-08 the petroleum remediation continued on the slope where EPS is removing any petroleum affected soils, hay bales, affected

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

organic debris and absorbent boom no longer needed. There appears to be no threat to the ground or surface waters at or near this location due to this incident. Madison County Health Department was advised. The closest wells are well over 1000 feet away and not in the apparent groundwater direction. Soil around the well head rig shows petroleum contamination and was still leaching diesel fuel on 3/23 which was pumped off to on site tank for disposal separate from their drill-brine- soap mix water. Nornew is going to put down a liner as a barrier before placing new drill rig. The remaining contamination will be removed after drilling is completed. 3/26/09- Another drill rig in place and operating. Side of hill shows no signs of petroleum. All contaminated hay was removed and replaced. Clean boom placed at the end of previously contaminated area as precaution. Ponded area was free of product and sheen. Liner under drill rig was in place. Pit around well head had oil in it but reported by Linda Collart to be secure and will not contaminate aquifer below. Plan to remove remaining contaminated soils when rig finished up early next week. Inspection on slope in area where the side had a substantial slide, showed some product present in the water flowing under burlap and straw, placed for erosion control measures. Also slightly down gradient, soil has odors of petrleum which flowed from the previously described area and EPS PID read 147 ppm in soil. These areas are ordered to be removed and remediated. Mid April, DL Responder observes contractor removal of remaining contaminated soil and investigation by test pit. He reported that no or very low levels (below 37ppm on PID) were seen and where observed, near the wellhead (TP-3) the area was excavated and resampled. May 09 When report is submitted and a site sketch requested, it became evident that the samples were not handled representivly, as test pits soil samples were combined improperly after DL observed work. DEC requested that the contractor return to site and resample in 3 discrete locations. CTR Responder noted that there was still some remaining contamination near the well head and requested further soil to be removed at this location. Further analytical showed all levels now below TAGM recommended clean up levels. All contaminated soil and debris have been properly disposed of at High Acers Landfill. CTR 5-26-09

Page 12

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 13

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DRILLING ACTIVITIES 2655 BACK HINSDALE RD

Spill Number: 0903035

Close Date:

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: GREG THROPP Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TDJOHNSO Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/15/2009 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER NOTICED ORANGE CRUDE IN HER CREEK THIS MORNING. BELIEVES IT MAY BE FROM DRILLING ACTIVITIES TAKING PLACE UPGRADIENT OF HER PROPERTY BY DRILLER GREG THROPP. SHE SAID SHE WOULD TAKE A DEC REP TO THE LOCATION OF THE DRILLING AND CALL HER AT 716-378-3061 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 06/16/09 TDJ HAD MRS.BISECK (373-1354)TAKE ME TO THE PROPERTY WHERE GREG THROPP HAS DRILLING ACTIVITY ON HILLSIDE. RUNOFF FROM OIL/WATER SEPARATION TANKS AND LAND COLLECTIION AREAS IS FLOWING INTO DIRT ROAD DITCH WHICH FLOWS INTO OLEAN WATER TRIBUTARIES. CONTACTED MR. THROPP (372-4021) BUT HE DID NOT GET BACK UNTIL I WAS OUT OF AREA. EXPLAINED THE PROBLEM AND WILL GET BACK WITH HIM WHEN HE HAS AN IDEA OF REMEDIAL WORK WHICH WILL STOP OFF SITE CONTAMINATION. 06/18/09 TDJ SPOKE WITH WATER DIVISION, CHRIS MILLER-MINERAL DIVISION AND LAND OWNER AND WELL LEASE OPERATOR, GREG THROPP ABOUT REQUIREMENTS FOR DISPOSAL OF FRAK TANK WATER AND OIL/WATER SEPARATION. IT APPEARS THAT OVERFLOWS OF THE OIL/WATER SEPARATOR HAVE OCCURRED WITH OR WITHOUT KNOWLEDGE OF MR THROPP. SMALL AMOUNTS OF OIL ARE COMMON IN BRINE WATER AND SETTLE FURTHER IN RETENTION AREAS, WHICH IS PRESENT BUT WITH MASS ACCUMULATIONS OF SURFACE CRUDE. THE ORANGE/YELLOW RESIDUE IS BEING CARRIED FURTHER OFFSITE WHICH ALSO HAS TO BE ADDRESSED. MR THROPP HAS SEEN THE PROBLEM AND HAS BEGUN A CLEANUP OF THE AREA. I WILL MEET WITH HIM ONSITE THE WEEK OF JUNE 22 TO DISCUSS CLEANUP LEVELS AND TO PLAN FURTHER ACTION TO KEEP RUNOFF FROM LEAVING THE PROPERTY. 06/22/09 TDJ STOPPED AT SITE AND FOUND OILY WATER HOLDING PIT WAS PUMPED BACK INTO SEPARATOR TANK. PIT WAS LINED WITH PLASTIC

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 14

FOR COLLECTION OF SEPARATOR WATER. YELLOW/ORANGE PUDDLES WERE BEING CLEANED AND STRRAW WAS USED TO SOAK UP WASTE MATERIAL. WILL CONACT MR. THROPP ON FURTHER CLEAN-UP POINTS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 15

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BOSER - WELL WATER 1136 CHIPMONK RD

Spill Number: 0485474

Close Date: 11/04/2005

ALLEGANY, NY 14706

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons FRANCINE GALLEGO FXGALLEG

Spiller: NATURAL RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: MARION BOSER

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: ext. 6 Caller Phone: 716-851-7220 Contact Person Phone: 716-372-0931

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/01/2005 01/24/2005 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected #2 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN DRINKING WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: COMPLAINT OF PETROLEUM IN DRINKING WATER WELL. HOME IF NEXT TO ACTIVE OIL WELL FIELD & BURIED PIT WASTE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 01/24/05: MF S/I/MARION BOSER, OWNER OF THE HOME THAT HAS DRINKING WATER (WELL) CONTAMINATION. MARION HAD A 40’ WELL INSTALLED AT THIS HOME, 1136 CHIPMONK RD. 5 YEARS AGO. THE COUNTY HEALTH DEPT SAMPLED AND ANALYZED THE WELL WATER 12/7/99. THE FOLLING COMPOUNDS DETECTED, IN PPB. 1,3,5 - 0.5 sec-BUTYLBENZENE - 0.5 n-BUTYLBENZENE - 0.7 NAPHTHALENE - 0.6 USING #2 F/O AS A STANDARD, THE ESTIMATED CONCENTRATION OF PETROLEUM IS CALCULATED AT 73 MICROGRAMS/LITER. MARION TOLD ME THAT PENNZOIL PLUGGRD APPX 3000 WELLS IN THIS AREA. 2 PIT NEAR HIS PROPERTY WERE USED TO CONTAIN THE DISCHARGES FROM SOME OF THESE WELL. THE PITS WERE THEN BURIED. NATURAL RESOURCES NOW OPERATES THIS LEASE. 5/25/05 CAMERON OCONNOR W/NYSDOH CALLED AND SAID HE INSPECTED THE BOSER PROPERTY ON 5/24/05 AND MET MR. BOSER. MR. OCONNOR SAID THAT THE DRINKING WATER HAS AN ODOR. HE AND MR. BOSER AGREED THAT MR. BOSER WOULD DIG TEST PITS AROUND HIS PROPERTY WHILE WE ARE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 16

ON SITE TO INSPECT. MR. OCONNOR SAID THAT THEY WILL BE DUG AFTER 6/13/05. HE WILL LET ME KNOW THE EXACT DATE. 7/21/05 CAMERON OCONNOR AND MF INSPECTED THE PROPERTY IN JUNE 2005 WHILE MR. BOSER DUG TEST PITS ON SITE. PETROLEUM CONTAMINATION WAS IDENTIFIED. 8/5/05 CAMERON OCONNOR PROVIDED A COPY OF THE DRINKING WATER RESULTS FROM SAMPLES COLLECTED FROM MR. BOSER’S DW ON 3/14/05. NO PETROLEUM CONTAMINATION WAS IDENTIFIED. MR. OCONNOR SAID THAT THERE IS NO REASON TO PLACE FILTERS ON MR. BOSERS WELL BECAUSE NO PETROLEUM CONTAMINATION WAS IDENTIFIED. 11/4/05 SPILL FILE IS CLOSED BECAUSE NYSDOH DETERMINED THAT NO FURTHER WORK IS NECESSARY BASED ON THE FACT THAT NO PETROLEUM CONTAMINATION IS PRESENT IN THE DRINKING WATER WELL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 17

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FORMER ALLEGRO LEASE COUNTY ROUTE 248

Spill Number: 0070182

Close Date: 06/16/2000

REXVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: COUNTY HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen PEGGY LAMPHIER CAHETTEN

Spiller: JIM LEE - ALLEGRO OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 225-4948 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/15/2000 06/16/2000 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THEY HAD A FLASH FLOOD WHICH APPARENTLY TIPPED OVER A TANK OR BROKE AN OIL LINE BECAUSE OIL IS FLOWING DOWN THE CREEK FROM THE HILL AND INTO MARSH CREEK. THERE IS A VERY STRONG ODOR OF OIL PRESENT. WATER IS FLOODING THE ROAD. CH TO RESPOND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "CH" 06/15/2000 CH RESPONDS TO THE SCENE. WATER FROM THE STREAM WHICH FLOWS THROUGH RAVINE TO THE WEST OF ROUTE 248 HAD OVERFLOWED ITS BANKS AND PLUGGED A CULVERT. WATER AND DEBRIS ARE FLOWING ACROSS THE ROAD. THERE IS ODOR OF CRUDE OIL AND A SHEEN PRESENT ON THE WATER IN THE STREAM AND MARSH ON BOTH SIDES OF THE ROAD. CH WALKS SMALL STREAM UPSTREAM THROUGH A GULLEY LOOKING FOR BROKEN OIL LINES OR LEAKING WELLS. THERE IS NO OIL ON THE STREAM NOW. CH FINDS ONE WELL AND AN OLD SEPARATOR NEXT TO IT THAT HAD RELEASED SOME OIL. THIS WELL AND TANK ARE ON THE NORTH SIDE OF THE CREEK APPROXIMATELY 400-500 YARDS WEST OF THE MAIN ROAD. NO OTHER SOURCES ALONG THE CREEK ARE FOUND. ONE WELL ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE MARSH IS FOUND TO BE LEAKING. THIS IS A WELL THAT WAS IDENTIFIED IN THE POST. CH NOTIFIES R NEMECEK OF MINERALS BY E-MAIL ON 6/16/2000. NO FURTHER ACTION WARRANTED BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 18

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

COPPER RIDGE OIL INC. LEASE 1523 CHRISTIAN HOLLOW RD

Spill Number: 0751166

Close Date: 09/08/2008

WEST UNION, NY 14877

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: CHRISTIAN HOLLOW RD Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: pclinden

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/28/2007 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THAT WHILE A SUMMER VOLUNTEER WAS WORKING FOR MINERALS, 21 WELLS THAT ARE LEAKING CRUDE OIL. MINERALS/ SPILLS TO PERFORM A JOINT INSPECTION. FAXED TO PL ON 11/29/07 AT 1124 HRS. COPY TO MINERALS. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 1/8/08 LINDENFELSER & KEHOE INSPECT LEAKY WELLS WEST OF CHRISTIAN HOLLOW RD WITH LINDA COLLART AND MARK HARSTEAD. PL PHOTOGRAPHED SEVERAL OF THE WELLS. MINERALS SOUGHT SPILLS’ RECOMMENDATION FOR CLEANUP WHICH GENERALLY IS TO 1) REQUIRE SCRAPE UP OF VISIBLY CONTAMINATED SOIL, 2) REQUIRE PROPER TRANSPORT AND DISPOSAL, 3) REQUIRE DOCUMENTATION OF SAME AND 4) INSPECT CLEANUP PRIOR TO BACKFILLING. MINERAL WILL FOLLOWUP WITH RP AND UPDATE SPILLS ON CLEANUP PROGRESS. NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILLS IS NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 19

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

MOOSE OIL - POLLY LEASE SOUTH BOLIVAR ROAD RT 33

Spill Number: 9204429

Close Date: 02/22/1995

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Federal Government BONNIE GREEN PRINGLE

Spiller: MOOSE OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: USEPA Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 966-3926 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (908) 548-8730 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/01/1992 02/22/1995 HOUSEKEEPING NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL OVERFLOW FROM LEAKING TANK & SLOPPY HOUSEKEEPING FROM CRUDE OIL PRODUCTION INTO WETLAND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 08/24/92: 8/24/92 MNP INSP. NO CLEANUP DONE. OIL IN BOTH LAGOONS & OIL COVERED DUCK IN LOWER ONE. 11/05/92: 11/5/92 MNP 7 RNL INSP. & MEETING W/ HOFFMAN OF MINR. REFERRED TO MINR FOR FOLLOWUP, COMPLETE. 01/22/93: MINERAL RESOURCES REFERRED MATTER BACK TO SPILLS; REOPEN FILE. 04/01/93: 4/1/93 MNP INSP. NO CLEANUP DONE. OIL STILL IN BOTH LAGOONS & IN WETLAND. CLEANUP NEEDED. 05/05/93: 5/5/93 MNP INSP. NO CLEANUP DONE. OIL STILL IN BOTH LAGOONS & IN WETLAND. CLEANUP NEEDED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

11/10/93: 11-10-93 MNP & FG INSP. OIL IN BOTH LAGOONS & DISCHARGING INTO WETLAND. 05/17/94: MNP SITE VISIT 5/13/94. MR. KENNEMUTH ON SITE. LAGOONS CONTAINED OIL BUT NO SPILLAGE TO WETLANDS. OWNER SAID LAGOONS WERE DESIGNED TO CONTROL SPILLAGE. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED AT SITE. 02/22/95: MNP SITE VISIT 2/22/95. NO OIL IN POND. NO ENVRL IMPACT OUTSIDE POND. POND HAD VEGETATION IN IT. RECOMMENDING SITE BE MADE INACTIVE.

Page 20

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 21

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SOLOMON LEASE OREGON ROAD

Spill Number: 9601781

Close Date: 12/24/1996

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Police Department Caller Name: DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS

Spiller: JOHN WEIS - SOLOMON RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITY OF OLEAN PD Contact for more spill info: CHARLES FRAZITA

Spiller Phone: (410) 268-4266 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 376-5678 Contact Person Phone: (716) 679-4901

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/05/1996 12/24/1996 TANK FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 1200 GALLONS 1150 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: caller reports well tank is leaking - unknown how many gallons tank is approx 8ft x 8ft - product is leaking into creek which leads to allegheny river - unk who owns property -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 05/05/96: & 5/6/96, MF SITE VISIT/CAC HAZ MAT/HINSDALE FD/RP 6K AG CRUDE OIL TANK BOTTON LEAKED. LOST 30 BARELLS, APPX 100 GALLONS GOT OUT OF DIKE, APPX 10 GALLONS INTO STREAM TO OLEAN CREEK. WATER PLANT NOTIFIED. TANK PUMPED OUT, DIKE & DITCH TO STREAM VACCED OUT. FD INSTALLED SAND BARIERS & SYPHON DAM. BOOMS & PADS IN PLACE. T/C RP, EXPLAINED WHAT MUST BE DONE. LETTER SENT. ALSO MET WITH MINERALS. THEY WILL MONITOR CLEAN UP. 05/07/96: MF SITE VISIT/MINERALS, DIKED VACCED, COMNTAMINATED SOIL HAS TO BE REMOVED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

05/07/96: MF MEMO FROM MINERALS, CLEANUP SATISFACTORY. NOTHING MORE TO BE DONE. 05/17/96: MF SITE VISIT, NO ONE ON SITE. NOTHING DONE. SAND STILL IN ROAD. NO SOIL REMOVAL DONE. 05/20/96: MF T/C CHUCK FRAZITA, NOT IN. 05/22/96: MF T/C CHUCK FRAZITA, THEY WILL FINISH CLEANING SITE NEXT WEEK. 06/04/96: MF SITE VISIT, NO ONE ON SITE. NO WORK DONE, DIKE AS WATER & CRUDE OIL IN IT. 08/07/96: MF 1ST SOIL DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 8/30/96. 10/24/96: MF 2ND DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 11/15/96. 12/17/96: MF T/C JOHN WEIS, SOIL DISPOSED OF AT CID 9/25/96, HE DID NOT RECEIVE RECEIPT AS YET. WILL SEND WHAT HE HAS. 12/24/96: MF RECEIVED FAX OF SOIL PICKUP BY CID. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 22

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 23

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LIPPERT LEASE OREGON ROAD

Spill Number: 9604701

Close Date: 09/05/1996

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JERRY WILLIT MXFRANKS

Spiller: GREGORY THORPP - GREGORY THORPP Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 474-5384 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 933-7459 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/08/1996 09/05/1996 DELIBERATE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 30.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DELIBERATE DUMPING OF CRUDE OIL TANK BOTTOMS INTO PIT AND THEN STARTING IT ON FIRE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/09/96: MF SITE VISIT/JERRY WILLET, ECO/GREG THORPP, LANDOWNER & LEASE OPERATOR. GREG ALLEGEDLY DUG A HOLE WITH A BACKHOE IN HIS FIELD, DUMPED CRUDE OIL TANK BOTTOMS IN IT & LIT ON FIRE. ECO & STATE POLICE MADE HIM PUT OUT FIRE. HE CLAIMED HE DIDNT DO IT. EXPLAINED CLEANUP REQUIREMENTS. LETTER SENT. ECO TO WRITE ORDER ON CONSENT. 07/10/96: MF T/C JERRY WILLET, GREG ADMITTED FAULT. T/C GREG, HE HAS SPILL CLEANED. 07/11/96: MF SITE VISIT, NO ONE ON SITE. HOLE CLEANED OF CRUDE OIL. STAGED ON SITE. T/C GREG TOLD HIM HOLE CAN BE BACKFILLED. 09/05/96: MF RECEIVED SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPT, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ECO’S TO FINE RP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 24

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PEFLEY CRUDE OIL LEASE FOREST AVENUE

Spill Number: 9609292

Close Date: 01/21/1997

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN MXFRANKS

Spiller: ERIC PEFLEY - ERIC PEFLEY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYS DEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 941-1269 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/01/1996 01/21/1997 HOUSEKEEPING YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: REPORT FROM DIVISION OF MINERAL RESOURCES. SOIL STAGED ON LEASE FOR A LONG PERIOD OF TIME. ALSO, ADDITIONAL CONTAMINATION. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 10/21/96: MF MEMO & T/C JOHN HOFFMAN. PROBLEM WITH PEFLEY DISPOSING OF CONTAMINATED SOIL FROM NUMERIOUS WELL SPILLS. CONTAMINATED SOIL STAGED AT ONE LOCATION. 10/28/96: MF T/C ERIC PEFLEY, CLAIMED SOIL STAGED IN ROLLOFF ON SITE. WILL BE DISPOSED OF NEXT WEEK. LETTER SENT. 12/12/96: MF 1ST SOIL DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 1/15/97. 01/15/97: MF 2ND DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 2/14/97. 01/21/97: MF RECEIVED SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPTS. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 25

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PEFLEY OIL LEASE SITE FOREST AVENUE

Spill Number: 9975589

Close Date: 12/30/1999

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Health Department MICHAEL VENDETTE LEARY

Spiller: PEFLEY OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY HEALTH Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 941-1269 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 366-8831 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/01/1999 HOUSEKEEPING NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL SITE HAS OIL CONTAMINATION, STAGED LUGGER WITH CONTAMINATED SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL-CHCHD" 12/09/99: MAV AND RNL INSPECTION, RECEIVED COMPLAINT FROM DGD INDUSTRIAL WASTE WHO DID SOME CLEANUP FOR PEFLEY OIL, THEY HAVE A LUGGER ON SITE WITH CONTAMINATED MATERIAL FOUND LUGGER ON PROPERTY, ALSO ONE AREA OF OIL CONTAMINATION, SEE SITE SKETCH, RNL TO CONTACT MINERAL RESOURCES 12/15/99: MAV AND RNL MEETING, MAV SUBMITTED HIS PHOTOS FROM THE INSPECTION ON 12/09/99 12/30/99: RNL TELECON TO BRAIN JANDREAU, HE WAS AWARE OF LUGGER BEING STORED ON PROPERTY, PEFLEY LEASE IS STILL ACTIVE, PROPERTY OWNER HAS BLOCKED ACCESS TO PROPERTY (RNL ANMD MAV NOTED TRAILER BLOCKING ACCESS DRIVEWAY DURING THEIR INSPECTION), AGREED LUGGER

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 26

IS NOT LEAKING AND PROBLEM DOES NOT REQUIRE IMMEDIATE ATTENTION, RNL TO SEND COPY OF FILE TO JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS TO HANDLE, SPILLS CLOSEOUT SITE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 27

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

EAST RESOURCE LEASE NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0812194

Close Date: 07/15/2009

CARROLL, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14770 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: TDJOHNSO

Spiller: EAST RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/01/2009 TRAFFIC ACCIDENT NO YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ECO NOSAL RECEIVED A CALL THATA PLOW DRIVER HIT A WELL HEAD WHICH CAUSED A SPILL OF CRUDE. THE CALLER WAS UNKNOWN AND HEARD THE INFORMATION FROM SOMEONE ELSE AND WAS NOT A FIRST HAND OBSERVER. THE CALLER ESTIMATED THAT 200 GALLONS SPILLED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 02/11/09 TDJ - WHILE PLOWING TRAILS IN WOODS FOR ACCESS TO WELLS A PUMP HEAD WAS KNOCKED LOOSE BY PLOW BLADE. APROX. 30-50 GALLONS OF CRUDE WAS SPILLED AROUND THE PUMP STATION. CREWS WERE ON-SITE QUICKLY FOR CLOSURE OF WELL AND NEW PARTS WERE REPLACED TO REMEDIATE THE PROBLEM. EXCESS OIL WAS CONTAINED AND REMOVED AND CREWS FROM OIL LEASE EAST RESOURCES WILL DIG UP AND DRUM CONTAMINATED SOIL AND OIL ON SNOW FOR DISPOSAL. TED FEDERCO OF EAST RESOURCES (814) 590-5060, (814) 778-5521 WILL CONTACT ME WHEN CLEANUP IS COMPLETE. 02/18/09 TDJ CONTACTED TED FEDERCO AT EAST RESOURCES. DRUMMED FROZEN SNOW AND SOIL IS BEING STORED IN MAIN BUILDING WHERE WHEN MELTED CRUDE IS BEING SEPERATED FROM WATER. MORE ICE AND SNOW WILL BE COLLECTED AND THE SITE WILL BE REEXAMINED WHEN TOTAL MELT IS COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 28

07/15/09 TDJ RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT FROM EAST RESOURCES FOR DISPOSAL OF 4 DRUMS OF CONTAMINATED SOIL FROM RAMSEY WELL #23. SOIL WAS TAKEN TO CENTRAL OHIO OIL CO., COLUMBUS, OHIO. NO FURTHER ACTION FILE CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 29

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL IN TUNA CREEK NICHOLS RUN AT QUINN

Spill Number: 9709253

Close Date: 12/06/1999

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NICHOLS RUN / QUINN Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/01/1997 12/06/1999 OTHER NO YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: caller claims crude running into trib to tunacreek since 11/1/97 11:55 - kab advised brian from mineral resources,oleans -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 11/07/97: MF SITE INSPECTION, AFTER A COMPLAINT OF AN ON GOING SHEEN IN NICHOLS RUN BROOK. NICHOLS RUN FLOWS INTO TUNA CREEK. NICHOLS RUN WAS FLOWING FAST AND CARRYING A LOT OF SILT. MF NOTICED A HEAVY SHEEN IN MANY PLACES. TRACED SHEEN BACK A POOL OF FREE PRODUCT COMING OUT OF THE SIDE OF A HILL. MF MET WITH JOE BUCHER OF BDH, 925-8538. HE OPERATED LEASE IN THIS AREA. CLAIMED THERE HAS BEEN A PROBLEM WITH THIS WEEP FOR OVER 10 YEARS. THEIR COMPANY CLEANS SPILLAGE UP WHENEVER NOTICED. THEY WILL HANDLE. TOOK SAMPLE OF SPILLAGE AND OF CRUDE OIL

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 30

FROM STORAGE TANK, DISCUSSED WITH BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS. THEY ARE AWARE OF PROBLEM. 11/10/97: MF SITE INSPECTION, NO ONE ON SITE. AREA CLEANED BY SPILLAGE. NOTICED SLIGHT SHEEN IN ONE QUIET AREA IN CREEK. 11/12/97: MF TELECON TO NRC INFORMED THEM OF PROBLEM, NRC # 411121, MASON. SAMPLE TO LAB ALONG WITH CRUDE OIL STANDARD. 11/17/97: MF AND RNL SITE INSPECTION, MET JOE BUCHER, SMALL SEPARATOR IN OPERATION WHERE PRODUCT IS SEEPING FROM SIDE OF THE HILL, BDH MAINTAINS IT. BDH HAS NO IDEA WHERE PRODUCT IS COMING FROM, THEY HAVE OPERATED FIELD FOR FIVE YEARS. FROM TALKING TO MINERALS PROBLEM HAS BEEN ON GOING FOR OVER 10 YEARS. SHEENING IN BOTTOM & SIDE SEDIMENT OF NICHOLS RUN BROOK DOWNSTREAM OF SPILLAGE. MET & DISCUSSED SITUATION WITH JACK DAHL, MINERALS. WE WILL OPEN A OPA CLAIM & INSTALL A PERMENENT SEPARATOR. WE WILL TRY TO GET BDH TO MAINTAIN IT. 11/18/97: MF RECEIVED SAMPLE RESULTS, SPILLAGE MATCHES CRUDE OIL SAMPLE. PROCESSED KANTI’S $220. PAY PACKAGE. 11/20/97: MF REPORTED SPILL TO USEPA, THEY HAVE A RECORD OF SPILL. WANTS ME TO TALK TO DOUG KODAMA 732 548-6905, THERE INCIDENT #98-0106 11/12/97. 12/05/97: MF SITE INSPECTION, MET JOE OF BDH OIL AND JOHN MOESHER, JIM, TOWN OF ALLEGANY HIGHWAY. DISCUSSED WITH HIGHWAY DEPT THE INSTALLATION OF A SEPARATOR. ROAD HAS 50’ ROW, SEPARATOR WILL BE OFF ROW. WILL KEEP JOHN INFORMED OF INSTALLATION ACTIVITY. DISCUSSED WITH JOE THE MAINTENANCE OF THE SEPARATOR. HE AGREED TO DO IT. JOE WILL ALSO RUN POWER (120 VOLTS) TO AREA, WE WILL SUB HIM TO DO THIS WORK. LAND IS APPARENTLY OWNED BY JOHN COCHRAN, MALLORY ET AL, 5614 ST. ALBANS WAY, BALTIMORE MD 21212. MF MET WITH MINERALS INFORMED THEM OF ACTIVITIES. 12/08/97: MF SENT ROE FORM TO JOHN COCHRAN, RESPONSE BY 1/15/98. 01/05/98: MF RECEIVED SIGNED ROE FROM JOHN COCHRAN. 01/27/99: MF SITE INSPECTION, NOTED CRUDE OIL IN DIRT SEPARATOR. 11/26/99: MF TELECON TO TOM PLESNARSKI, HE SAID SPILLS CAN ONLY SPEND MONEY ON CRUDE OIL SPILLS FOR EMERGENCY CONTAINMENT EVEN THOUGH CRUDE OIL IS AN ARTICLE 12 OIL. HE TOLD ME IT IS MINERALS RESPONSABILITY. THEREFOR NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE. 12/06/99: MF REVIEWED FILE, BOB DUFF DID NOT DO ANY WORK FOR SPILLS, THUS, ONLY COST IS KANTI LAB SAMPLING, $220.00

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 31

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL IN WELL 4146 FORDS BROOK RD.

Spill Number: 9975358

Close Date: 08/04/2004

ALMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14708 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons JIM PLYLER MXFRANKS

Spiller: TIM QUAINTANCE - TIM QUAINTANCE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: JIM PLYLER

Spiller Phone: (716) 593-5547 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 593-0159 Contact Person Phone: (716) 593-0159

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/16/1999 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NEW HOMEOWNER FOUND CRUDE OIL IN HIS WELL. OLD OIL WELL 60’ FROM HIS WELL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/16/99: MF MEMO TO RNL & PJB REGARDING CRUDE OIL IN DRINKING WATER WELL & OUR POSITION TO PROVIDE HELP FOR HOME OWNER. ALSO DISCUSSED SITE WITH JACK DAHL. 08/17/99: MF RECEIVED FAX OF HOME OWNERS WATER WELL ANALYSIS TAKEN 5/25/99. EPA 524.2 DONE. NAPTHALENE 9 PPB 1,2,4 TRIMETHYLBENZENE 81.5 1,3,5 TRIMETHYLBENZENE 35.5 XYLENES 12.5 ALL PPB 08/20/99: MF T/C/TIM QUAINTANCE. HE CLAIMED OIL HAS BEEN IN THE DRINKING WATER WELLS IN THIS AREA SINCE BEFORE HE BOUGHT THE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 32

LEASE. HE ALSO CLAIMED THAT MINERALS, THE REALTOR & THE PREVIOUS HOME OWNER WERE ALL AWARE OF THIS. TOLD HIM I WILL SEND HE A LETTER ASKING HIM TO INSTALL FILTERS ON THE EFFECTED WATER WELLS. 09/01/99: MF LETTER TO TIM REQUESTING THAT HE GIVES THE AFFECTED RESIDENCES DRINKING WATER THAT MEETS NYSDOH STANDARDS. RESPONSE BY 9/30/99. 09/13/99: MF LETTER FROM TIM DENYING ALL RESPONSIBILITY. HE CLAIMED PROBLEM EXISTED FOR 20 YEARS. NO ONE DID ANYTHING ABOUT THAT THEN THEREFORE HE DOSN’T THINK HE’S RESPONSIBLE. 10/06/99: MF S/I/MRS. PLYLER, HER DRINKING WATER WELL IS APPX 60’ FROM AN ABANDON CRUDE OIL WELL. THERE ARE ALSO OTHER CRUDE OIL WELLS IN THE IMMEDIATE AREA THAT HAVE TO BE PLUGGED ALONG WITH ACTIVE WELLS. CULLIGAN INSTALLED FILTERS & CHLORINATOR FOR THEM AT A COST OF $4639. THEY DON’T DRINK THIS WATER. THE PREVIOUS OWNER OBTAINED WATER FROM A SPRING. MANY HOME IN THIS AREA HAVE A SPRING FED WATER SUPPLY. PLYLER WELL IN 190’ DEEP, PUMP SET AT 180’. WENT TO OTHER HOMES IN THE AREA. ONLY MAGGIE MOTT HOME AT 4108 S BRANCH FORDS BROOK 593-6612. HER WELL IS 85’ DEEP WITH 45’ OF CASING. SHE DOES NOT DRINK THIS WATER AS IT HAS A CRUDE OIL ODOR. THEY ARE ALSO CONNECTED TO SPRING WATER. 10/08/99: MF T/C/TOM BROWN 968-1390. EXPLAINED SITUATION & THAT THIS DEPT CONTACTED EPA FOR POSSIBLE OPA 90 CLAIM. 10/30/99: MF MESSAGE FROM RNL, CALL TOM PLESNARSKI. 11/03/99: MF T/C TOM PLESNARSKI, LEFT MESSAGE. 11/26/99: MF T/C TOM PLESNARSKI, HE CLAIMED THERE IS NOTHING SPILLS CAN DO FOR THEM. IT IS MINERALS RESPONSIBILITY. SPILLS CAN ONLY SPEND MONEY ON CRUDE OIL SPILLS FOR EMERGENCY CONTAINMENT. 11/27/99: MF SPILL ON STANDBY. MEMO TO DOH REGARDING WELL WATER CONTAMINATION. 12/31/99: MF LETTER FROM CAMERON O’CONNOR, DOH. COMPLAINING ABOUT SPILLS & MINERALS NOT DOING ANYTHING. 01/03/00: MF FAXED LETTER TO JACK DAHL MINERALS & TOM PLESNARSKI, ALBANY. 08/04/04: MF ALBANY REFUSES TO ALLOW SPILLS TO FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILL POSSIBLE. ’I’ LETTER TO HOMEOWNER. 06/20/08: DKK E/M CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS: WELL(S) HAS BEEN PLUGGED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 33

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DAN KERUSKIE RESIDENCE 26474 RIDGE RD

Spill Number: 0485202

Close Date: 11/18/2004

RUTLAND, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Fire Department DALE HERMAN JLROGERS

Spiller: Notifier Name: BRAD SHOLETTE Caller Agency: WATERTOWN CITY FD Contact for more spill info: DAN

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (315) 782-6053 Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (315) 786-3243

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/18/2004 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN AIR, GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WELL HOUSE EXPLODED, AGAIN. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: MET WTN CITY FD ON SCENE. WELL IS DRILLED 300 FT CASED TO 20FT. USED EXPLOSION METER WITH CARBON FILTER. NEEDLE WENT TO THE 100% OF LEL AND STAYED THEREFORE INDICATED AN EXPLOSIVE ATMOSPHERE OF METHANE. PID STAYED AT ZERO. NO PETROLEUM VAPORS DETECTED. TENANT CALLED WITH HEALTH RELATED QUESTIONS, REFERED TO DOH, Tom Boxberger and to Div of Mineral Resources, Oil and gas out of R8. DOH to call tenant and DMR to call landlord. (jlr)

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 34

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATURAL GAS ODOR IN WELL 6047 HESS ROAD

Spill Number: 0475246

Close Date: 08/18/2004

FRIENDSHIP (BELMONT), NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14739 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Affected Persons PAULA DARNLAY FXGALLEG

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

UNKNOWN SAME CITIZAN PAULA DARNLAY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (585) 268-5110 Contact Person Phone: (585) 268-5110

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/18/2004 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAID THAT SHE HAS A NATURAL GAS ODOR IN HER DRINKING WELL WATER FROM A NATURAL GAS LEAK ON HER NEIGHBOR’S PROPERTY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 8/18/04 FG CONTACTED NATIONAL FUEL’S EMERGENCY NUMBER AND THEY INDICATED THAT THEY WILL RESPOND. FG SPOKE TO PAULA DARNLAY AND SHE SAID THAT THE CONTAMINATION IS DEFINITELY NATURAL GAS. NO ACTION BY SPILLS POSSIBLE. SITE IS CLOSED. ELECTRONIC FILE ONLY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 35

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

HUNGRY HOLLOW ROAD HUNGRY HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 8300478

Close Date: 06/04/1987

FREMONT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HUNGRY HOLLOW RD Revised zip code: 14810 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Citizen TOM SECONDO BWFINSTE

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

ARTHUR CAMPFIELD ECO BILL KING DOT ECO BILL KING

Spiller Phone: (607) 324-3705 Notifier Phone: (716) 226-2466 Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (716) 226-2466

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/04/1983 06/07/1983 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS 5.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DEC INVESTIGATED INITIALLY WITH COMPLAINANTS. SOME CLAY AND CRUDE OIL WERE DISCHARGED INTO TRIB OF BIG CREEK. NATURAL GAS WELL BLEW RESULTING IN CRUDE OIL AND SILT BEING DISCHARGED FROM WELL TO TRIB OF BIG CREEK. WELL IS OWNED BY ARTHUR CAMPFIELD. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "BF" DOT PLACED CONTAINMENT BOOM IN CREEK. SPILLER CONTAINING REMAINDER WITH BACKHOE. OIL-GAS WELL SPECIALIST ON SCENE - HIRED BY SPILLER. ECO BILL KING ON SCENE. 06/04/83 BF CONTACTED SANDY BREENAN FOR FOLLOWUP SINCE WELL WAS TO BE PLUGGED. 06/05/83 SPILLER CLEANING UP SATISFACTORILY UNDER ENGINEER’S DIRECTION. 06/06/83 - 06/10/83 SPILLER MAINTAINING BOOM AND CLEANED OUT POND SATISFACTORILY. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

09/23/04 PAPER FILE REMOVED PER FILE RETENTION POLICY.

Page 36

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 37

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL GAS 365 MINERAL SPRINGS ROAD

Spill Number: 8702469

Close Date: 11/25/1997

WEST SENECA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14210 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ANONYMOUS PRINGLE

Spiller: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 857-6920 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/23/1987 DELIBERATE NO YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS 100.00 GALLONS SOIL PETROLEUM SOLVENTS OTHER 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PUMPED OIL PRODUCT FROM OPEN CONCRETE PIT TO REAR OF PROPERTY, DISCHARGING ONTO GROUND WHICH RUNS TOWARDS CREEK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" / / : 7/31/87 TELECON W/BALSOM, E&E, STILL WAITING FOR ANALYSIS FOR DISPOSAL, SHE WAS ON SITE DURING EXCAVATION, AREA GRADED;NEEDS INSP. / / : SAMPLE RESULTS ON MATERIAL SUBMITTED 07/06/87 TO AES. / / : 7/24/87 RECEIVED SAMPLE RESULTS FROM AES, LUB. OIL IN ALL 3 SAMPLES;7/30/87 TELECON W/MILL, N.M., SOIL REMOVED & ON SITE. 08/11/87: LEGAL REFERRAL TO RJS 08/11/87.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 38

08/03/88: 7/31/87 MNP DISCUSSION W/J. CHARLES, NO INFO. TO BE RELEASED DUE TO PENDING LEGAL REFERRAL;8/3/87 MNP INSP. CLEANUP O.K., DISPOSAL REMAINS. 11/28/90: 11/28/90 MNP INSP. CONCRETE PIT GONE, NO MW’S INSTALLED. LETTER TO BE SENT TO NFG. 06/01/92: 6/1/92 LETTER TO NFG REQUESTING MW SAMPLING, RESPONSE BY 6/30/92. 06/28/93: 6/28/93 MNP & RNL DISCUSSION. NEED SAMPLE RESULTS FROM MW’S. CALL JOE BELLANTI OF NFG. 07/19/93: 7/19/93 RECEIVED MW SAMPLE RESULTS FROM 9/92. BTEX EXCEED NYSDEC STANDARDS. 07/20/93: 7/20/93 MNP & RNL DISCUSSION, REQUEST RESAMPLE OF MW’S. 7/20/93 MNP TELECON W/ JOE BELLANTI - NFG, HE AGREED TO RESAMPLE MW’S FOR FOR EPA METH. 8021 PLUS MTBE & DOH 310-13. 11/05/93: 11/5/93 MNP TELECON W/ JOE BELLANTI OF NFG. HE HAS MW SAMPLE RESULTS & WILL SEND COPY. 01/11/94: 1/11/94 MNP REVIEWED 9/29/93 MW SAMPLE RESULTS. MW 2 STILL HAS HIGH LEVELS OF VOC’S & SOME SEMI-VOLATILES EXCEEDING NYSDEC STANDARDS. 01/11/94: 1/11/94 MNP TELECON W/ JOE BELLANTI - NFG. DISCUSSED HIGH MW SAMPLE RESULTS. FURTHER INVESTIGATION NEEDED, SUGGESTED SITE ASSESSMENT USING SOIL-GAS SURVEY OR TEST PITS. HE AGREED & WILL SEND LETTER. 03/25/94: 3/25/94 MNP TELECON W/ JOE BELLANTI - NFG. HE OBTAINED 2 BIDS TO DO WORK. TO SELECT CONTRACTOR & NOTIFY US OF SCHEDULE. 03/28/94: 3/28/94 MNP TELECON W/ JOE BELLANTI - NFG. HE OBTAINED 2 BIDS TO DO WORK. TO SELECT CONTRACTOR & NOTIFY US OF SCHEDULE. 03/28/94: 3/28/94 MNP OFFICE MEETING W/ JOE BELLANTI - NFG. HE OBTAINED 2 BIDS TO DO WORK. TO SELECT CONTRACTOR & SUBMIT REMEDIATION PLAN BY 4/3/94. 03/30/94: 3/30/94 RECEIVED LETTER FROM JOE BELLANTI - NFG. WILL SELECT CONTRACTOR, TO SEND PROPOSAL FOR DEC REVIEW. EXPECT WORK TO START IN MAY ’94. 10/12/94: 10/12/94 RECEIVED LETTER FROM CHARLES BURKE - NFG. EMPIRE SOILS TO DO SOIL GAS SURVEY 10/11/94 TO 10/12/94. 10/14/94: 10/14/94 MNP TELECON TO CHARLES BURKE - NFG (857-7686). NOT IN LEFT MESSAGE TO RETURN CALL. 10/14/94: 10/14/94 MNP TELECON W/ CHARLES BURKE - NFG (857-7686). SOIL GAS SURVEY COMPLETED 10/12/94.I REQUESTED COPY OF REPORT BY 11/1/94 W/ RECOMENDATIONS FOR INVESTIGATION OR REMEDIATION PLAN. 11/01/94: 11/1/94 CHARLES BURKE DROPPED OFF SOIL-GAS SURVEY W/ REMEDIATION RECOMMEDATIONS. 11/01/94: 11/1/94 MN P REVIEWED EMPIRE SOILS 10/31/94 SOIL-GAS SURVEY REPORT. HIGHEST CONTAMINATION AROUND MW2. NO POINTS DONE NORTH OR EAST OF MW2 TO DETERMINE SOURCE. READINGS OVER 10 PPM SOUTH OF MW2. 11/01/94: 11/1/94 MNP TELECON W/ CHARLES BURKE - NFG. SOIL-GAS SURVEY DID NOT LOCATE SOURCE OR IDENTIFY EXTENT OF CONTAMINATION. NFG PLAN TO EXCAVATE CONTAM. SOIL OK, BUT ADDITIONAL MW NEEDED SOUTH OF MW2.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 39

12/19/94: 12/19/94 MNP REVIEWED NFG 12/5/94 LETTER & EMPIRE SOILS 11/23/94 WORK PROPOSAL. PLAN TO EXCAVATE CONTAM. SOIL SOUTH OF FORMER PIT & SAMPLE FOR STARS. THEN INSTALL MW’S. 12/19/94: 12/19/94 MNP TELECON W/ CHARLES BURKE - NFG. CLEANUP PROPOSAL SATISFACTORY. I REQUESTED ADVANCE NOTIFICATION & INSPECTION OF EXCAVATION BEFORE BACKFILLING. EXPECT TO DO IN JANUARY 1995. 02/10/95: 2/10/95 MNP INSP & MEETING W/ NFG & EMPIRE SOILS. CONTAM. SOIL & WATER REMOVED FROM EXCAV., CONTAM. SOIL & PRODUCT IN BOTTOM & SIDES, TO CONTINUE CLEANUP & SAMPLE BOTTOM. SEE NOTES, SKETCH & PICTURES. 02/14/95: 2/14/95 MNP INSP & MEETING W/ NFG & EMPIRE SOILS. CONTAM. SOIL & WATER REMOVED FROM EXCAV., CONTAM. SOIL & PRODUCT IN BOTTOM & SIDES, TO SAMPLE BOTTOM & SIDES. FOUND ANOTHER SEPARATOR PIT, SEE PICTURE. 06/13/95: FG JFO SITE VISIT. EXCAVATION FILLED IN. GT 2000YDS SOIL STAGED ON SITE. NO FURTHER WORK COMPLETED. 07/24/95: NATIONAL FUEL SUBMITTED 6/13/95 REPORT ON SITE INVESTIGATION. CONTAM EXISTS ON SITE. REMEDIAL PROPOSAL WILL DETERMINE EXTENT OF CONTAMIN - TO BEGIN ON 7/31/95. 08/07/95: FG SITE VISIT 8/7/95. SOIL HAD BEEN REMOVED FROM SITE. INVESTIGATION BY RETEC WAS JUST BEGINNING. WORK TO CONTINUE THROUGH TOMORROW. 11/30/95 NATIONAL FUEL SAMPLING GROUNDWATER WELLS ON SITE TODAY. CHARLES BURKE CALLED. 6/14/96 CHARLIE BURKE CALLED. EROSION FROM RAIN IS MAKING PROBLEMS EVIDENT. POSSIBLY HYDROGEN CYANIDE FROM MANUFACTURED GAS PLANT. CONSULTANT WILL BE ON SIT 6/17/96. 6/17/96 FG SITE VISIT. FOUND EROSION IN DITCH AND MATERIAL LEACHING OUT. CHARLIE BURKE NOT ON SITE. WILL CONTACT. 7/5/96 RECD 7/2/96 QUARTERLY SAMPLING REPORT FOR MW’S 7,8& 10. RESULTS ARE ABOVE STARS IN MW’S 7 & 8. MW 10 RESULTS ARE BELOW STARS. 7/10/96 RECD REPORT ON NFG SITE INSPECTION OF EROSION EXPOSING BLUE STAINED SOIL FROM PURIFIER BOX RESIDUALS. NFG WILL INVESTIGATE & CHARACTERIZE CONTAMINATION. WILL SUBMIT A WORK PLAN IN A PRUDENT & TIMELY MANNER. 9/5/96 CHARLES BURKE, W/NATIONAL FUEL CALLED. HE SAID THAT HE WANTS TO DEAL W/PETRO PROBLEM ALONG W/FERROCYANIDE WASTE. HE WILL SUBMIT REPORT THAT INCLUDES STUDY OF AREA WIDE ISSUES, NOT SPECIFICALLY PETROLEUM. I TOLD HIM TO SUBMIT & WE WILL REVIEW. HE WILL SUBMIT BY 9/23/96. 10/23/96 FG RECD NATIONAL FUEL WORK PLAN FOR CYANIDE & OIL PROBLEM. PLAN WAS ADDRESSED TO MARTY DOSTER & ME. MR. DOSTER & I SPOKE TO CHARLIE BURKE ABOUT PLAN. MR. DOSTER WILL NOT ADDRESS ISSUE UNLESS NAT’L FUEL SIGNS A CONSENT ORDER. NATIONAL FUEL MUST STILL DEAL W/FG ON OIL SPILL PROBLEM REGARDLESS. CHARLES BURKE TO GET BACK TO DEC ON NEXT STEP. ADVISED NAT’L FUEL TO SAMPLE ALL WELLS, ANALYZE FOR HAZ CONSTITUENTS, INCLUDING REACTIVITY AND TO CHECK ALL DRAINAGE DITCHES FOR OTHER AREAS OF EROSION. TOLD MR. BURKE THAT HE MUST ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF ANOTHER POSSIBLE PIT IN THE AREA. THE CURRENT PLAN DOES NOT DO THIS. 10/24/96 MARTY DOSTER SENT LTR TO NATIONAL FUEL REITERATING MTG DISCUSSION, RECOMMENDING THAT NATIONAL FUEL CONTINUE TO WORK W/SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 40

1/17/97 FG MARTY DOSTER, GREG SUTTON, RETEC, & NATIONAL FUEL MET TO DISCUSS WORK ON SITE. NATIONAL FUEL WANTS TO DO A SITE WIDE ASSESSMENT TO ASSIST IN PREPARING A RBCA. THEY WILL ALSO INVESTIGATE THE CYANIDE BEARING WASTE IN THIS ASSESSMENT. THEY MAY DECIDE TO DO A VOLUNTARY AGREEMENT WITH DHWR. 3/7/97 LTR SENT TO NATL FUEL REQUESTING AN UPDATE ON THE STATUS OF THE ASSESSMENT THEY HAD PROPOSED DURING OUR 1/17/97 MTG. RESPONSE DUE 3/24/97. 3/21/97 NATIONAL FUEL SENT A LTR STATING THAT THEY WILL SUBMIT A REVISED REMEDIAL PROPOSAL BY THE SECOND WEEK IN APRIL. 10/10/97 CHARLIE BURKE WITH NATIONAL FUEL CALLED. HE SAID THAT HAZARDOUS MATERIAL HAS BEEN DISCOVERED AT THE MINERAL SPRINGS SITE. PURIFIER BOX WASTE MATERIAL WITH A PH OF 1.2 AND HAZARDOUS LEAD LEVELS, TCLP = 9.6PPM WERE FOUND NEAR THE ELECTRICAL TOWERS ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THE PROPERTY RIGHT AT THE FENCE LINE. THEY BELIEVE THAT 45 CU YDS OF THE BLUE CORROSIVE PURIFIER BOX WASTE IS ON SITE. THEY DON’T HAVE A HANDLE ON THE EXTENT OF THE LEAD CONTAMINATION. THE CONTAMINATION IS BOTH SURFACE AND SUBSURFACE AND THE ENTIRE PROPERTY IS FENCED. THE REPORT OF THEIR FINDINGS WILL BE READY BY THE END OF OCTOBER. THEY DO NOT BELIEVE THAT ANY OF THE WASTE IS LEACHING OFF SITE. MR. BURKE IS AVAILABLE FOR AN ONSITE MTG ON MONDAY TUESDAY OR WEDNESDAY. SOME PCB’S WERE FOUND AT THE OIL WATER SEPARATOR PIT AT A LEVEL OF 1PPM. NATIONAL FUEL IS ALSO IN THE PROCESS OF PUTTING TOGETHER AN INTERIM REMEDIATION PLAN. 10/17/97 FG, CAMERON O’CONNOR - NYSDOH, SITE INSPECTION OF HAZARDOUS AREA AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE SITE NEAR A NIMO ELECTRIC TOWER. NO APPARENT EROSION. NIMO EXCAVATED AROUND THE BASE OF THE TOWER. THE MATERIAL LOOKED SLIGHTLY BLUE. THERE WAS NO DEAD VEGETATION OFF SITE OR RIGHT AT THE FENCE OR ON THE SITE. THE AREA IS A HISTORICAL FILL AREA ADJACENT TO THE RAILROAD LINE. THERE ARE HOMES NORTHWEST OF THE IMPACTED AREA. NO ACCESS IS POSSIBLE. WE LOOKED AT THE ERODING AREA AT THE NORTH EAST FENCE LINE WHICH DISCHARGES TO THE DITCH. EROSION IS APPARENT HERE. BLUE MATERIAL CAN BE SEEN. 11/25/97 MTG WITH NATIONAL FUEL, C.BURKE T.ALEXANDER,RETEC, COULOMBE, DEC, P.BUECHI M.DOSTER G.SUTTON FG, DOH, C.O’CONNOR. INACTIVE HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE PROGRAM TO TAKE OVER SITE. VOLUNTARY AGREEMENT TO BE SIGNED BY NATIONAL FUEL. NO FURTHER WORK REQUIRED BY SPILLS. SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 41

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NYSDOT/DYKE CREEK ROUTE 417 MM 100.9

Spill Number: 9211505

Close Date: 03/22/2001

GREENWOOD, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 417 Revised zip code: 14839 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Responsible Party DOUG CARRIER PCLINDEN

Spiller: NYSDOT Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDOT Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (607) 324-8442 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 324-8441 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/11/1992 03/01/1999 OTHER NO YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTS TWO ABANDONED OIL WELLS DISCOVERED BY NYSDOT DURING PROCESS OF FIELD INVESTIGATION FOR PROPOSED UNDERCUTTING OF ROADWAY (RT 417) NEAR DYKE CREEK. CONTACT PERSON: TOM MARKELL, NYSDOT -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 01/06/93: WELLS SITUTATED ALONG CREEK BANK & NYSDOT NOTIFIED DEB RATHBUN OF MINERALS SECTION. SCOTT FOTI NOTIFIED FOR FOLLOW-UP. 01/11/93: CH INSPECTS SITE W/SCOTT FOTI; THERE ARE A LARGE NUMBER OF INACTIVE OIL WELLS IN THE AREA WHERE THE STREAM RECHANNALIZATION IS TO TAKE PLACE. WHERE THE SEEPS OCCUR, THERE ARE NO WELL CASINGS EVIDENT. MINERALS SAYS WELL CASING WAS PROBABLY PULLED AROUND WAR TIME. IT DOES NOT APPEAR THAT THERE WILL BE A LARGE AMOUNT OF CONTAMINATED SOIL INVOLVED. THE BIGGEST PROBLEM WILL BE GETTING THE OLD WELLS PLUGGED PROPERLY. NYSDOT IS WORKING WITH MINERALS REGARDING THIS ASPECT. FOTI TO WORK WITH NYSDOT ON DISPOSAL OF CONTAMINATED SOIL. SF & CH FOUND TWO SEEPS OF DEGRADED CRUDE OIL ALONG DYKE CREEK & ROUTE 417 (NEAR MM-17,6404-1010) IN GREENWOOD, STEUBEN CO. SF MET W/DOUG CARRIER, DOT. DOT WANTS TO REALIGN CREEK & WILL BE REMOVING CONTAMINATED SOIL FROM THESE TWO SEEPS. OLD MAPS SHOW NO WELLS, ONLY OIL PUMP LINES IN THE VICINITY OF THESE SEEPS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 42

10/12/93: PL OBSERVED EXCAVATION OF OILY SOIL NORTH OF MILE MARKER 100.9 AND FOUND NO ONGOING SOURCE; SUGGESTED TO DOT NOT TO ROUTE STREAM THERE. 12/13/93: LINDENFELSER, NEMECEK & DON PLEAKIS ON SITE. SEE ATTACHED SITE REPORT. MILLER & PL FOUND AN ACTIVE MINOR SEEP & APPLIED SORBENTS. DOT MUST INVESTIGATE THE WESTERN & EASTERN SEEPS FOR WELL BOREHOLES. 03/10/94: PL AND PLEAKIS MET W/DOT TO REQUEST SUBSURFACE SEACH FOR BOREHOLES TO BE PLUGGED AND TEMPORARY CONTAINMENT OF THE SEEP. 04/25/94: PL FOUND A TRACE OF OIL SEEPING AND NO CONTAINMENT UNDERTAKEN. 05/20/94: PL REPLACED SATURATED PADS FROM ACTIVE OIL SEEP. 08/08/94: PL FOUND THE BANK SEEP HAS OILED PADS IN NEED OF CHANGING. 08/17/94: PL FOUND THE EXISTING SORBENTS SATISFACTORY FOR CATCHING SEEPAGE FROM BOTH WELL SITES. 09/15/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND THE PADS AT MM 1009 SOAKED WITH OIL & ALLOWING AN OIL SHEEN INTO THE CREEK. 04/12/95: LINDENFELSER & ECO FEY FOUND OIL SOAKED PADS NEEDING CHANGE AT THE WESTERN SEEP. 04/26/95: LINDENFELSER FOUND THAT THE OILED PADS HAD BEEN REPLACED AT THE BANK SEEP. 05/25/95: LINDENFELSER FOUND A LIGHT SHEEN ENTERING CREEK AND ASKED ALLWASH TO RE-CONFIGURE THE SORBENTS TO BETTER CAPTURE THE CONTINUING SEEP. 06/12/95: PROPOSAL RECEIVED VIA DIV MINERAL RESOURCES FROM NYSDOT. NYSDOT PLANS TO EXCAVATE IN ATTEMPT TO FIND WELL BORES OF SUSPECTED ABANDONED LEAKING OIL WELLS. WORK SCHEDULED FOR 6-13-95. 06/13/95: WORK RESCHEDULED TO ATTEMPT TO LOCATE WELL BORES FOR 06-14-95. 06/14/95: DEC & DOT DUG UP BOTH SEEPS REVEALING UPWELLING OF WATER, OIL & NATURAL GAS. DOT AGREED THAT, THE NE SEEP WHICH WAS PROBED WITH A ROD MORE THAN 9 FT BELOW THE WATERTABLE, IS A WELL THAT THEY... 06/14/95: ...WILL PLUG. DOT DISAGREES THAT THE SW SEEP IS A WELL DESPITE THE DISCOVERY OF A DEEP SPOT IN THE PIT. (PL’S REPORT). 06/14/95: PM, PL & DON PLEAKIS OF MDR ON SITE WITH REPS OF NYSDOT; DUG IN VICINITY OF OIL SEEPS IN ATTEMPT TO FIND BOREHOLES THAT MAY BE OLD OIL WELLS. AN AREA OF UPWELLING OF OIL/WATER WAS FOUND AT ... 06/14/95: ..BOTH SEEPS THAT APPEARED TO BE THE LOCATION OF OLD WELLS. (MILLER’S REPORT). 06/19/95: NYSDOT REGIONAL DIRECTOR FRANK GERACE HAS AGREED THAT DOT WILL DIG NORE TEST PITS TO BETTER DEFINE SOURCE OF OIL ENTERING CREEK & CHECK FOR GENERAL SEEPAGE OF OIL VS A CONTAINED LEAK WITH WELL. 07/06/95: PM & BF ON SITE TO INSPECT OIL SEEPS/WELLS. OIL FROM WEST WELL ACTIVELY BUBBLING INTO DEPRESSION AROUND CMP PLACED OVER SEEP. ABSORBENTS LARGELY SATURATED. NO OIL APPEARS TO BE ENTERING CREEK.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 43

07/28/95: PL FOUND OIL BEING CONTAINED BY THE STANDPIPE AND BASIN WITH ONLY CLEAN WATER SEEPING INTO THE CREEK. 09/28/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: NATURAL CRUDE OIL. 10/02/95 PL FOUND TOTALLY OILED PADS AND A LOT OF FREE PRODUCT IN THE CONTAINMENT AROUIND THE STANDPIPE AT THE WESTERN WELL SEEP. 10/03/95 PL DIRECTED ALLWASH IN CLEANUP OF THE WESTERN OIL SEEP AND PLANNED FOR MODIFICATION OF THE LEAKY BERM WHEN AN UPFLOW PIPE IS INSTALLED. 10/12/95 PL DIRECTED ALLWASH TO MODIFY THE BASIN AROUND THE WEST WELL INTO AN UPFLOW DAM. 11/06/95 PL FOUND THE UPFLOW DRAIN OPERATING WELL, COLLECTING OIL IN THE BASIN WHICH NOW REQUIRES CLEANUP. 11/21/95 PL DIRECTED ALLWASH TO REMOVE COLLECTED OIL FROM THE CREEKSIDE SEEPAGE BASIN. 02/05/96 PL SHOWED EP&S WORK REQUIRED EVERY TWO WEEKS. ICY CONDITIONS PRECLUDE CHANGING OF SORBENTS CURRENTLY. 03/22/96 PL FOUND 4 INCHES OF FRESH OIL IN STANDPIPE OF SW WELL. THE UPFLOW PIPE WAS UNPLUGGED TO ALLOW DRAINAGE. 04/04/96 PL FOUND LITTLE ACCUMULATION OF OIL IN THE CONTAINMENT POOL. 05/06/96 PL FOUND 4 INCHES OF OIL COLLECTED IN THE RISER PIPE AND LITTLE OIL IN THE CONTAINMENT BASIN. 07/10/97 PL FOUND THE CONTAINMENT OF THE LEAKY WELL WELL MAINTAINED. 01/05/98 PL FOUND SORBENTS WELL MAINTAINED IN THE CATCHMENT BASIN. 02/-03/1999: BOTH WELLS WERE SUCCESSFULLY PLUGGED MAKING THE PROJECT COMPLETE. NO FURTHER WORK IS NECESSARY. 02/19/09 PAPER FILE REMOVED PER FILE RETENTION POLICY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 44

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL & GAS 1044-5 ROUTE 248 MM1044-1045

Spill Number: 9204794

Close Date: 04/04/2005

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ED DICKERSON PCLINDEN

Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL COMPANY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CHRISTIAN HOLLOW RD Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 664-2795 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 225-4626 Contact Person Phone: (716) 664-2795

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/19/1992 OTHER NO YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SURFACE WATER UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: AN ABANDONED OIL WELL IS OVERFLOWING ON SLOPE 15 FT ABOVE ROAD GRADE AND 250’ NORTH OF MILE MARKER 1044. CONTACT PERSON: JIM LEE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 07/28/92: DICKERSON SHOWED PL THE SITE. MINUTE PATCHES OF BROWN OIL WERE FOUND IN THE DITCH. OIL HAD CROSSED THE ROAD VIA A CULVERT TO THE NORTH SIDE TO A BEAVER SWAMP. A BROKEN OIL SHEEN WAS FOUND ABOUT 100’ DOWNSTREAM IN SWAMP. 06/17/93: LINDENFELSER FOUND RECENT CRUDE OIL ACCUMULATED IN A ROADSIDE DITCH. A CONTRCTOR WILL BE CALLED OUT TO CONTAIN & CLEAN UP. 07/22/93: PL MET WITH EP&S AND NYSDOT TO PLAN CONSTRUCTION DETAIL FOR AN UPFLOW DAM IN THE ROADSIDE DITCH. 12/13/93: MILLER & PL FOUND OIL DRIPPING FROM THE PUMP & DISCUSSED CONTAINMENT OPTIONS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 45

05/20/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND A THICK FILM OF CRUDE OIL COVERING 10 FT OF DITCH AND LAID OUT PADS. 05/23/94: LINDENFELSER REPLACED SEVERAL SATURATED PADS AND COVERED MORE FREE OIL. 05/29/94: P LINDENFELSER REMOVED THE MAJORITY OF PADS NOW THAT THE WELL LEAK HAS APPARENTLY SUBSIDED. 06/09/94: PL & RODABAUGH FOUND THAT CRUDE OIL HAD OVERRUN EXISTING PADS. PL REPLACED PADS. 06/23/94: PL FOUND A LOT MORE FREE PRODUCT & PLACED MORE PADS. NEMECEK FOUND THAT THE WELL CASING LEAKS AND SO WELL MUST BE PLUGGED. 07/14/94: PL FOUND 25 FT OF OIL IN DITCH NOT CLEANED UP BY JIM LEE. 08/08/94: PL FOUND THE PADS IN THE DITCH OIL-SATURATED AND/OR WATER-LOGGED AND IN NEED OF REPLACEMENT. 08/17/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND THAT THE FLOW HAS SLOWED AND THAT ENOUGH SORBENTS ARE DEPLOYED. 09/15/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND THE SORBENTS NEGLECTED BY JIM LEE. LITTLE EXTRA OIL HAS COLLECTED. 11/03/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND SIGNS OF CLEANUP BY RESPONSIBLE PARTY AND NO FREE, FRESH OIL. 04/12/95: LINDENFELSER FOUND NO ADDITIONAL FREE OIL. 04/26/95: LINDENFELSER FOUND NO NEW, FREE OIL & ASKED ALLWASH TO REMOVE THE WATER-LOGGED PADS. 05/25/95: LINDENFELSER HAD ALLWASH REMOVE THE SUNKEN SORBENT PADS. NO FREE OIL IN DITCH OR ON SLOPE. 10/03/95 LINDENFELSER & ALLWASH PLANNED FOR CONSTRUCTION OF AN UPFLOW DAM. NO FREE OIL FOUND AT THE TIME. 11/06/95 LINDENFELSER FOUND THAT NO WATER HAD YET COLLECTED BEHIND THE UPFLOW DAM. 02/05/96 LINDENFELSER FOUND NO ADDITIONAL ACCUMULATION OF OIL AND DISCUSSED WITH EP&S FUTURE MONITORING. 03/22/96 LINDENFELSER FOUND THE UPFLOW DAM WASHED OUT. THERE IS NO OIL FLOW. PL & EP&S AGREED ON REPAIRS. 04/04/96 PL OVERSAW THE REBUILDING OF THE UPFLOW DAM BY ENVIRONMENTAL PRODUCTS & SERVICES. 05/06/96 LINDENFELSER FOUND THAT THE UPFLOW DAM HAD BEEN WELL RESTORED. NO OIL IS CURRENTLY DRAINING DOWN THE SLOPE TO THE COLLECTING POOL. 07/10/97 LINDENFELSER FOUND NO CRUDE OIL SEEPAGE ON SLOPE OR IN RECEIVING DITCH. 06/27/03: FURTHER ACTION ON THE ALLEGRO OIL SPILLS WERE REFERRED TO THE MINERALS PROGRAM. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS. 04/04/2005: THE FINAL ISR IS SENT TO ALBANY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 46

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SOUTHERN TIER OIL WELL ROUTE 248 MM 1044

Spill Number: 9305003

Close Date: 12/05/1995

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Citizen SANDRA RAPP PCLINDEN

Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL COMPANY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: DEPT OF TRANSPORTATION Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 324-8442 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/20/1993 12/05/1995 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SOIL WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SANDRA RAPP OF DOT CALLED IN THAT ON 07-20 A DOT CREW NOTICED OIL LEAKING DOWN A HILLSIDE ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF RT 248 IN HAMLET OF BARNEY MILLS. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 07/21/93: MZ ADVISED PAUL LINDENFELSER. PL STATED THAT THIS IS CURRENTLY AN ACTIVE SPILL #9204794 (SEE ATTACHED SHEET). PL STATED THAT IT IS A LEAKY CAP FROM AN ABANDONED OIL WELL. 12/05/95 CLEANUP BEING HANDLED BY DEC UNDER SPILL #9204794 PIN 93203. NO FURTHER UPDATES UNDER PRESENT SPILL NUMBER.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 47

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

KELLY PROPERTY - OIL WELL CHIPMUNK ROAD

Spill Number: 9300090

Close Date: 06/05/1993

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JACK DAHL MXFRANKS

Spiller: ALLEN PAYNE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 697-6962 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/01/1993 06/05/1993 DELIBERATE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: REFERRED TO LEGAL BY MINERAL RESOURCES. OPERATOR IS CONTINUING TO SPILL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/05/93: MF 4/5/93 RECEIVED SPILL FROM MINERIALS. THEY TURNED IT OVER TO LEGAL AS OPERATOR CONTINUES TO SPILL. 04/07/93: MF RNL MINERIALS 4/6/93 SITE VISIT, SPILLAGE AROUND WELLS & EQUIPMENT. MINERIALS WANTS WELLS PLUGGED. THEY HAVE N OMONEY. THEY WILL TRY TO SET IT UP WHERE SPILL FUND CAN PLUG. 06/05/93: MF 6/5/93 IT APPEARS SPILL FUND WILL NOT PLUG WELLS. OWNER/OPERATOR HAS NO MONEY, MINERIALS CANNOT OPTAIN FUNDS. SPILL ’I’,NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE AT THIS TIME.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 48

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL & GAS NEXT TO 1661 KEENAN ROAD

Spill Number: 9405854

Close Date: 07/03/2003

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 1661 KEENAN RD Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons LORIE DZIELSKI PCLINDEN

Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL COMPANY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 359-1011 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/29/1994 DELIBERATE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL WAS FOUND AROUND SOME TANKS ON A ROAD JUST UP FROM 1661 KEENAN ROAD. THE CALLER DRILLED A NEW WATER WELL AND IS CONCERNED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 07/29/94: LINDENFELSER TO FOLLOW UP. THE SITE IS 1.0 MILES UP FROM ROUTE 248 ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE ROAD, JUST BEYOND 1661 KEENAN ROAD. 08/08/94: PL FOUND THREE LARGE STORAGE TANKS IN A DIKED AREA COVERED WITH CRUDE OIL. 11/03/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND THAT SOMEONE HAD STARTED REMOVING THE NOW COAGULATED OIL, BUT THE MAJORITY REMAINS IN THE DIKED AREAS. 07/03/03: ALLEGRO SITE HAVE BEEN REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES FOR FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 49

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL & GAS ROUTE 248 MM 1036

Spill Number: 9403530

Close Date: 07/03/2003

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Other TOM MARKELL PCLINDEN

Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL & GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDOT Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 664-2795 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 324Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/31/1994 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: AN ABANDONED OIL WELL IS LEAKING CRUDE OIL INTO MARSH CREEK POND AT THE SOUTH SIDE OF ROUTE 248. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 05/13/94: LINDENFELSER TO FOLLOW-UP. 06/09/94: PL & RODABAUGH FOUND A LEAKY ABANDONED WELL NEXT TO THE POND WITH SOME FREE OIL CAUGHT IN THE WEEDS. 07/14/94: PL FOUND NO FURTHER SPILL OR LEAKAGE. 08/17/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND WATER STILL UPWELLING ADJACENT TO THE WELL, BUT LESS SIGN OF CRUDE OIL. 07/03/03: ALLEGRO SITE HAVE BEEN REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES FOR FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

R

Page 50

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 51

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL & GAS ROUTE 248 MM 1043

Spill Number: 9403529

Close Date: 11/13/1995

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Other TOM MARKELL PCLINDEN

Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL & GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDOT Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 664-2795 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/31/1994 11/13/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SOIL WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: FRESH SOIL STAINING FROM INACTIVE BUT JACK EQUIPPED OIL WELL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 05/31/94: PL & RODABAUGH FOUND A 7 FT OIL STAIN AROUND A WELL JUST ABOVE A LARGE WETLAND. LINDENFELSER TO FOLLOW-UP. 06/09/94: PL & RODABAUGH FOUND A 7 FT OIL STAIN AROUND A WELL JUST ABOVE A LARGE WETLAND. 06/23/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND LITTLE SPREAD IN CONTAMINATION. ONCE THE ROD SEALS ARE REPLACED, THE LEAK SHOULD END. 11/13/95 OIL IS ABSORBED TO SURFACE SOILS AND NOT FLOWING TO WETLAND. CASE TO BE REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES AS WELL IS IN NEED OF BEING PLUGGED. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 52

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ROUTE 248 OIL WELL ROUTE 248 MM 101.5-101.6

Spill Number: 9402843

Close Date: 11/13/1995

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 / 6TH Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Other FRANK BRADY PCLINDEN

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC MONTERERY Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/20/1994 11/13/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 2.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE CLEARING A STREAM, NYSDEC EMPLOYEES FOUND AN ABANDONED LEAKING OIL WELL IN A WETLAND NEAR A STREAM. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 05/23/94: PL FOUND THE ABANDONED WELL AND IT HAD A SMALL AMOUNT OF ABSORBED, BROWN CRUDE OIL AROUND IT. 05/27/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND ONLY A SMALL AMOUNT OF OIL IMMEDIATELY. LINDENFELSER TO FOLLOW-UP. 11/13/95 THERE WAS NO CURRENT LEAK THREATENING SURFACE WATER. CASE BEING REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 53

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

AKZO BRINE POND OFF ROUTE 14@NYSEG STORAG

Spill Number: 9610217

Close Date: 11/15/1996

READING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: OFF ROUTE 14/NYSEG STORAG Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JIM EDWARDS SARODABA

Spiller: AKZO/NYS ELECTRIC & GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: AKZO SALT Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 535-2721 ext. 2 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/15/1996 11/15/1996 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Brine pond filled by brine wells, pond monitored by Akzo and NYSEG; started to over flow approx 0400 hrs, brine wells shut down. Estimate approx 200 gal brine overflowed ran into small creek which feeds into Seneca Lake - No cleanup possible. Spill faxed from region 8. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "SR"

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 54

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BUCHER CRUDE WELL 1371 FOUR MILE ROAD

Spill Number: 9602343

Close Date: 07/08/1996

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Police Department TROOPER BERLINSKI JFOTTO

Spiller: SAME - CHARLES BUCHER Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSP Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 372-2785 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 373-2550 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/18/1996 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 80.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: caller recieved report of oil in creek - caller went to scene and there is an unknown substance in water and strong odor -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 05/19/96 JFO ON SCENE WITH TROOPER BERLINSKI, SHEEN ON CREEK. JFO PLACED BOOM ACROSS CREEK. 1 MILE UPSTREAM FOUND CRUDE OIL IN DIKE AROUND TANK. RP WILL CLEANUP SPILL. SPILL EXTENDS FROM TANK TO 4 MILE CREEK (EST. 200 YDS). RP PLACED A LOAD OF SOIL ON OVERFLOW PIPE TO STOP ANY FUTURE PROBLEMS. COUNTY OFFICIALS NOTIFIED BY CATT. CO. SHERIFFS DEPT. JACK DAHL OF MINERAL RESOURCES ALSO ON SITE. 05/20/96 JFO ON SITE WITH RP. I HAD RP INSTALL A COFFERDAM AND PAD UP TRAPPED OIL IN THE DRAINAGE DITCH AND WEEDS. 05/20/96 JFO TEL/CON WITH CHRIS MILLER OF MINERAL RESOURCES. HE CHECKED SITE TODAY. RP HAD DIKE AREA CLEAN AND WAS STILL USING PADS TO CLEANUP DITCH. BOOM STILL IN PLACE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

06/03/96 JFO TEL/CON W/RP HIS PLANS ARE TO DISPOSE CONTAM SOIL AT ALL. CO. LANDFILL ON JUNE 18, 1996. HE NEEDS HAULERS PERMIT. PERMIT SENT OUT TODAY. 07/03/96 JFO TEL/CON W/MR BUCHER, HE WILL FORWARD DISPOSAL RECEIPTS TODAY. 07/08/96 JFO REC’D DISPOSAL RECEIPTS. CLOSE SPILL

Page 55

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 56

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

INDEPENDENCE COMP STATION INDEPENDENCE RD

Spill Number: 9601469

Close Date: 12/01/1996

INDEPENDENCE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14806 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Other DAVE BARTHOLD PRINGLE

Spiller: DAVE BARTHOLD - NATIONAL FUEL SUPPLY Notifier Name: DAVE BARTHOLD Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 646-9330 Notifier Phone: (716) 646-9330 Caller Phone: (716) 646-9330 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/25/1996 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected ETHYLENE GLYCOL HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 400.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SURGE TANK OVERFLOW TO DRAINAGE DISTCH ALONG INDEPENDANCE ROAD TO SERVICE PIPE AND ENTERED STREAM (DRY) POOLED IN STREAM BED. INTERNATIONAL WASTE HIRED BY NATION FUEL (SEE INCIDENT REPORT) -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" NOTE: SPILL REPORT ACTUALLY RECEIVED IN REGION 9 ON 4/26/96 AT 1120 HRS. 04/26/96: MNP INSP. MET W/ JACK GILBERT - NFG & DAVE VOLLMER - IWR. LEAK FROM COMPRESSOR RESERVOIR INSIDE BUILDING. GLYCOL FLOWED TO BASEMENT SUMP VIA FRENCH DRAIN OUT DRAIN PIPE INTO ROADSIDE DITCH THEN ENTERED A SMAL UNNAMED CREEK. END OF DRAIN PIPE PLUGGED TO CONTAIN PRODUCT. GREEN COLOR & VISIBLE SHEEN (FROM RUST INHIBITORS) IN DITCH, CREEK, & SMALL POND AREA.IWR VACCING BOTTOM OF POND TO RECOVER GLYCOL / WATER MIXTURE. I ADVISED THEM, IT IS NOT FEASIBLE TO CONTINUE PUMPING GLYCOL/WATER. IWR & NFG BOOMED POND OUTLET TO COLLECT SHEEN, NO FURTHER CLEANUP OF GLYCOL TO BE DONE IN POND AREA. DITCH TO BE DIKED & DRAIN PIPE UNPLUGGED TO COLLECT BACKED UP PRODUCT IN LINE. SPILL CLEANUP INSIDE BUILDING SATISFACTORY, BUT THEY NEED TO PUMP OUT CONCENTRATED GLYCOL FROM FRENCH DRAIN VIA AFFECTED CLEANOUTS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 57

04/26/96: MNP TELECON W/ JIM BUCKI - IWR. DISCUSSED WASTE DISPOSAL. NFG ALREADY PERMITTED TO DISPOSE NON-HAZ GLYCOL. DISPOSAL RECEIPTS TO BE SENT. 05/03/96: MF INSP. ONLY SLIGHT SHEEN OBSERVED IN CREEK. NO FURTHER CLEANUP NEEDED. 05/23/96: MNP TELECON TO DAVE BARTHOLD - NFG. LEFT MESSAGE ON VOICE MAIL TO RETURN CALL. 05/24/96: MNP TELECON W/ DAVE BARTHOLD - NFG. SPILL CLEANUP SATISFACTORY. APPROX. 20,000 GALS. GLYCOL/WATER RECOVERED FROM POND & DRAIN PIPE STORED IN BRINE TANK ON SITE. TESTING DONE INDICATES NON-HAZ FOR DISPOSAL. NFG TO ARRANGE DISPOSAL W/ IWR. I REQUESTED COPY OF DISPOSAL RECEIPT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 58

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

HOYS POINT PUMPING STATIO SALT POINT ROAD

Spill Number: 9712819

Close Date: 06/12/1998

READING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party BOB TRAVER SARODABA

Spiller: U.S. SALT Notifier Name: Caller Agency: U.S. SALT Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 535-2721 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/14/1998 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 60.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: GRAVITY FED BRINE LINE, CARRYING 50% SOLUTION, CAME APART AT THE FITTING IN CLOSE PROXIMITY TO PUMPING STATION. LOSS OF APPROXIMATELY 30,000 GALLONS OF SOLUTION SATURDAY EVENING. REPAIRS WERE MADE, BUT PIPING SEPARATED AGAIN MONDAY EVENING, CAUSING AN ADDITIONAL LOSS OF 30,000 GALLONS OF BRINE. THE SPILLED MATERIAL FLOWED INTO A DEPRESSION ALONG THE LAKE SHORE, SEEPED DOWN (NO DIRECT FLOW INTO THE LAKE) AND LIKELY LEACHED INTO THE LAKE. SLUDGE IN DEPRESSION TO BE VACUUMED OUT TODAY. SR FOLLOWING UP. DT NOTIFIED TOM PEARSON OF THE DEC WATER DIVISION ON 02/17/98. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "SR" 02/17/98 TOM PEARSON OF WATER DIV. NOTIFIED. 02/19/98 LETTER REPORT RECEIVED; ON 02/18 AAPEX ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES VACCED UP REMAINDER OF SPILL MATERIAL. POLY LINE CONNECTION TO BE HEAT FUSED WHEN WARM WEATHER PERMITS. NO FURTHER ACTION.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 59

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL IN TRENCH PUMPKIN HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 0175252

Close Date: 10/04/2001

HUMPHREY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14741 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Local Agency DANNY WILLIAMS JFOTTO

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: HUMPHREY HIGHWAY SUPTD Contact for more spill info: DANNY WILLIAMS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 945-1010 Contact Person Phone: (716) 378-6137

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/08/2001 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE TAKING DRAINAGE PIPE OUT, ENCOUNTERED OIL IN TRENCH, POSSIBLY FROM FORMER PIPELINE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 08/09/01 JFO ON SITE MET WITH DAN WILLIAMS OF HUMPHREY TOWN GARAGE. AN INACTIVE BUCKEYE PIPELINE CROSSES PUMPKIN HOLLOW RD. WATER ACCUMULATED IN THE DITCH WITH APPROX 1 GALLON OF CRUDE OIL ON IT. NO MORE OIL ACCUMULATED OVERNIGHT. WE PLACED A BOOM IN THE DITCH AND I GAVE THEM PADS TO PICK UP THE OIL. NO MORE DIGGING NEEDS TO BE DONE IN THIS AREA. THEY WILL INSTALL THE CULVERT AND BACKFILL. I SPOKE WITH JOHN HOFFMAN OF MINERALS IN OLEAN. HE SAID THE LINES WERE INACTIVE AND SHOULD HAVE BEEN REMOVED. THIS WAS A SHORT SECTION OF LINE THAT WAS PROBABLY LEFT IN BECAUSE IT WAS UNDER THE ROAD. A NEW PIPELINE IS GOING TO BE INSTALLED IN THE SAME AREA (MILLENIUM PIPELINE). THEY WILL DEAL WITH ANY CONTAMINATION THEN. MR WILLIAMS WILL CALL ME IF THERE IS ANY PROBLEMS WHEN THEY INSTALL THE CULVERT. 08/20/01 JFO CALL TO DAN WILLIAMS. HE SAID THAT THEY INSTALLED THE CULVERT WITH NO PROBLEMS. I WILL CHECK SITE THE NEXT TIME I AM IN THE AREA.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

10/04/01 JFO UNABLE TO VISIT SITE THE ROAD IS CLOSED FOR THE SEASON. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSED

Page 60

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 61

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

AD CALL AND SONS ROUTE 36 AND CASS STREET

Spill Number: 0170616

Close Date: 08/16/2002

HORNELL, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: ROUTE 36 / CASS STREET Revised zip code: 14843 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

TANK TRUCK Fire Department PETE HUFFSMITH SARODABA

Spiller: JAMES CALL - AD CALL & SONS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: HORNELL FIRE DEPARTMENT Contact for more spill info: JAMES CALL

Spiller Phone: (716) 343-2910 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 324-4504 Contact Person Phone: (716) 343-2910

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/28/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR OTHER PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR The following material was dropped or revised by the NYS DEC. OTHER PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: A LEAK FROM A SITE GLASS ON A TANKER TRUCK HAULING GAS PRODUCTION CONDENSATE, SPILLED TO THE ROAD SURFACE. THE SPILL HAS A STRONG MERCAPTANT-LIKE ODOR. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "SR" 03/28/2002: DT NOTIFIED LAW ENFORCEMENT AT ABOUT 1032 HRS. 03/28/2002: SCOTT RODABAUGH WAS NOTIFIED AND IS ENROUTE. 03/28/2002: PM TELCON WITH HORNELL DISPATCHER. PERSONNEL ARE ON SCENE AND BELIEVE THE ODOR IS FROM MERCAPTANT. THEY HAVE ORDERED THE EVACUATION OF THE AREA WITHIN 700 FEET OF THE SPILL, AND IT INCLUDES THE NYS OFFICE BUILDING, THE HORNELL TRIBUNE AND A

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 62

MIDDLE SCHOOL. PM TELCON WITH JAMES CALL OF A.D. CALL AND SONS. CALL & SONS ARE THE OWNERS OF THE TANKER TRUCK. THE TRUCK IS HAULING GAS WELL PRODUCTION WASTES FROM THE STEUBEN COUNTY GAS STORAGE FIELDS. SUBSEQUENT TELCON WITH CORRY TOWNS OF ANR PIPELINE THAT RUNS THE STORAGE FACILTY (248) 994-4048, DESCRIBES THE MATERIAL AS WATER FROM DEHYDRATION PROCESS THAT IS STRIPPED FROM THE NATURAL GAS, PRIOR TO BEING FED INTO THE PIPELINE. THE WATER CONTAINS NATURAL WASTE FROM THE GAS PRODUCTION PROCESS. 03/28/2002: SCOTT RODABAUGH ON SITE WITH TOM KLASIUS FROM NYSHD. ECO MALLOY ON SCENE, ACCIDENT SITE (ROUTE 36 AND CASS STREET) HAS BEEN REOPENED TO TRAFFIC, TANKER TRUCK IS AT NEARBY TRANSPORTATION COMPANY PROPERTY. STATE POLICE ON SCENE TALKING TO DRIVER AND ISSUING TICKETS. SR SPOKE WITH REPRESENTATIVE OF STEUBEN GAS STORAGE (MIKE WALLACE). SPILLED MATERIAL SHOULD NOT HAVE MERCAPTAN. LOSS ESTIMATED TO BE APPROXIMATELY 50 GALLONS. SIGHT GLASSES AT BOTH FRONT AND BACK OF TANKER BROKE. DRIVER NOTED MATERIAL SPILLING OUT FRONT OPENING, STOPPED, TURNED ON VACUUM (PREVENTING FURTHER LIQUID DISCHARGE) AND FOUND REPLACEMENT FITTINGS. VACUUM LIKELY RESULTED IN STRONG EXHAUST ODORS. TOM KLASIUS AND OTHER DOH EMPLOYEES NOTED VERY STRONG NATURAL GAS ODOR (MERCAPTAN). SEVERAL BUILDINGS WERE EVACUATED. BUILDINGS ARE NOT BEING REOCCUPIED WITH DOH RECOMMENDATION TO STAY OUT IF ODORS ARE STILL NOTED. SR SPOKE WITH MIKE SPRAGUE OF STEUBEN COUNTY EMO AND HORNELL FIRE DEPARTMENT REPRESENTATIVES, INSPECTED SPILL SITE. ODORS ARE STILL FAIRLY STRONG IN CERTAIN AREAS, BUT NOT PERSISTENT AND WIDESPREAD. SPILLED MATERIAL HAS DISSIPATED OR EVAPORATED AND CLEANUP ACTIONS NOT WARRANTED. LT BARTON ON SITE. DISCUSSED SPILL WITH HIM AND ECO MALLOY, MIKE SPRAGUE, TOM KLASIUS. NO ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARD EXISTS. SR RECOMMENDED TANKER TRUCK BE RELOCATED TO REMOTE AREA FOR OFF LOADING TO OTHER TANKER ( TO PREVENT ADDITIONAL STRONG VAPORS). LT BARTON CONFERRED WITH STATE POLICE AND OFF LOADING TO BE CONDUCTED AT AREA SOUTH OF RAILYARD. SR AND TOM KLASIUS CONFERRED WITH PETE MILLER AND AGREED TO SAMPLE TANKER CONTENTS FOR VOLATILES, METALS, AND PH. SR COLLECTED SAMPLES DIRECTLY FROM TANKER TRUCK AFTER OFF LOADING WAS COMPLETE. SAMPLES TAKEN TO EXPRESS LABS BY TOM TOM KLASIUS. 04/05/02 SR RECEIVED ANALYTICAL RESULTS FOR VOLATILES (METHOD 8260). RESULTS SHOW HIGH CONCENTRATION OF ACETONE (61698.7 PPB) AND MEK (44272.8 PPB) PLUS LESSER LEVELS OF PETROLEUM CONSTITUENTS. SR CONTACTED LAB, TALKED TO TECHNICIAN THAT PERFORMED ANALYSIS. CONCENTRATIONS OF ACETONE AND MEK TOO HIGH FOR LAB CONTAMINATION TO BE CAUSE. WILL SAVE SAMPLES FOR POSSIBLE ADDITIONAL TESTING. 04/10/02 SR CONTACTED SHANE YOKUM OF ANR (PARENT COMPANY OF STEUBEN GAS), ACETONE AND MEK ARE NOT USED AT THEIR FACILITIES. THEY HAVE GRABBED SAMPLE FROM CONDENSATE TANK FOR 8260 ANALYSIS AND WILL FORWARD RESULTS WHEN AVAILABLE; EXPECTED TODAY. CONTAMINATION IS EITHER LAB ERROR OR DUE TO TRUCKING COMPANY (CROSS CONTAMINATION). 07/24/02 LAW ENFORCEMENT IS DOING FOLLOWUP ON ORIGIN OF ACETONE, MEK, NO ADDITIONAL ACTION IS NEEDED BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 63

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

JOHN JONES RESIDENCE LIPPERT HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 0275464

Close Date: 01/03/2003

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC CHRIS MILLER JFOTTO

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: JOHN JONES

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 372-8733

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/31/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: TRICKLE FROM CRUDE OIL WELL ALLEGEDLY RUNNING INTO FOUR MILE CREEK, WHICH IS A TRIBUTARY TO ALLEGANY RIVER. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 2004/02/19 - Spill_Time was previously blank and replaced with RCVD_Time to fix a data translation problem... Bob Corcoran 01/02/03 JFO TELCON WITH CHRIS MILLER OF MINERAL RESOURCES IN OLEAN. THE OWNER SHUT OFF THE WELL AND INSTALLED A RISER TO PREVENT THE WELL FROM LEAKING. THE LEAK HAS BEEN STOPPED, THERE IS NO SHEEN IN THE WATER. CHRIS WILL SEND BRIAN OF MINERALS TO THE SITE TO VERIFY. CHRIS WILL SEND UPDATE. 01/03/03 JFO RECEIVED UPDATE FROM CHRIS STATING THAT BRIAN INSPECTED THE SITE AND SAID THERE IS NO SHEEN IN THE STREAM AND THE WELL IS NOT LEAKING. ALSO, THE COMPLAINTANT SPOKE WITH CHRIS AND SAID HE IS NO LONGER GETTING FUMES AND IS SATISFIED. THIS SITE WILL BE HANDLED BY MINERALS. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 64

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH WELL #100 NICHOLS RUN

Spill Number: 0275113

Close Date: 05/31/2002

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN OTTO JFOTTO

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL LEASE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: JOE BUCHER

Spiller Phone: (814) 525-2334 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7220 Contact Person Phone: (716) 928-2728

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/30/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE INSPECTING A SEPARATION PIT, I DISCOVERED A LEAKING WELL HEAD. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 05/31/02 JFO NOTIFIED JOHN HOFFMAN OF MINERAL RESOURCES. SINCE THIS SPILL IS CONTAINED TO THE WELL HEAD AREA, MINERALS WILL INVESTIGATE AND FOLLOW UP. COPY FAXED TO JOHN H. NO ACTION NECESSARY. CLOSED THERE IS NO PAPER FILE FOR THIS SPILL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 65

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

RHODES WELL HIBBARD ROAD

Spill Number: 0270601

Close Date: 03/03/2008

BIG FLATS, NY 14814

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party RUSS ERLANDSON CMKEHOE

Spiller: PENNSYLVANIA GEN ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: FORTUNA ENERGY Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 329-7139 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/15/2002 02/20/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected WOOD ALCOHOL HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 2000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTED THAT FORTUNA ENERGY JUST BECAME AWARE OF A POTENTIAL 1000-2000 GALLON METHANOL SPILL, WHICH OCCURRED LAST SEPTEMBER OR OCTOBER. THE DISCHARGE WAS THE RESULT OF AN UNDERGROUND LINE LEAK FROM A METHANOL TANK USED AT THE GAS WELL SITE. THE LINE LEAK WAS REPAIRED, HOWEVER, FORTUNA HAS NO INFORMATION ON ANY CLEANUP DONE. SR TO FOLLOW UP. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "SR" 03/10/03 - SR MET WITH RUSS ERLANDSON OF FORTUNA ENERGY AND DAVE STRAUB OF PGE, JOE YAROSZ OF MINERALS. PER STRAUB, LAST NOVEMBER A TRUCK BACKING IN TO TAKE LOAD OF BRINE WATER OFF SITE CAUSED A BREAK IN METHANOL PIPING. BASED ON INVENTORY READINGS, PGE ESTIMATES LESS THAN 750 GALLONS LOST, WITH 600 GALLONS MORE LIKELY. PIPING WAS REPAIRED, NO CLEANUP PERFORMED STRAUB (PGE’S ENVIRONMENTAL CONTACT) WAS NEVER NOTIFIED OF DISCHARGE. HOMES ON EITHER SIDE OF WELL SITE ARE AT LEAST A FEW HUNDRED FEET AWAY, HAVE BEEN SAMPLED FOR METHANOL IN WATER SUPPLY. DUE TO STEEP GRADIENT DOWNWARD FROM TANK (IN WEST DIRECTION), UNLIKELY ANY FLOW TOWARDS HOMES. NUMBER OF CBS ISSUES NEED TO BE ADDRESSED FOR METHANOL TANK, INCLUDE LACK OF SECONDARY CONTAINMENT (EARTH DIKE IS UNLINED), LABELING, PIPING CONCERNS. CBS INSPECTION PERFORMED. INVESTIGATION TO BE PERFORMED TO DETERMINE IF ANY SIGNIFICANT METHANOL CONCENTRATIONS PRESENT AT SITE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 66

06/11/03 SR ON SITE WITH STEVE DEGERDON OF UNITED ENV., AND AUSTIN EXC. OUT OF CAMPBELL. METHANOL AND BRINE STORAGE TANKS HAVE BEEN DISCONNECTED AND MOVED, AUSTIN EXCAVATING OUT IMPACTED SOILS FROM BERM AREA AND PLACING ON PLASTIC OUTSIDE OF FENCED AREA. SOIL CLEANS UP AT APPROX. 4 FOOT BELOW SURFACE, WITH ZONE OF CONTAMINATION LIMITED TO 2-4 FOOT ZONE. 02/14/07 0900 KEHOE TELECON WITH RUSS ERLANDSON, RUSS WILL PREPARE A SUMMARY REPORT FOR DEC. 02/20/08 SUMMARY LETTER RECEIVED FROM UNITED ENVIRONMENTAL, SOIL WAS TREATED ON SITE AND SITE RESTORED. NFA - CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 67

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL ROUTE 248/COVELL RD

Spill Number: 0212425

Close Date: 03/18/2003

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Fire Department DISPATCHER ORMSBY JFOTTO

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

UNKNOWN RESIDENT ALLEGANY COUNTY 911 DISPATCHER ORMSBY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (585) 268-9460 Contact Person Phone: (585) 268-9460

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/17/2003 TANK OVERFILL NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 50.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: spill contained to pond, no run off to stream but using booms in the stream. spill is from oil tank holder. encon officer responded along with hazmat team. no call back needed. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 03/18/03 NO RESPONSE NECESSARY, HANDLED BY DUTY OFFICER, MARK HANS. ECO HUMMEL TOLD THE DUTY OFFICER THE TANK HAD OVERFLOWED. CRUDE HAD RUN INTO A CONSTRUCTED CONTAINMENT AREA. SITUATION IS STABILIZED. BOOMS WERE PLACED IN NEARBY CREEK AS A PRECAUTION. CLOSED 03/19/03 JFO REC’D A CALL FROM CHRIS MILLER FROM MINERALS. NO PRODUCT REACHED THE DRAINAGE DITCH. ALSO ONLY ABOUT 50 GALLONS WERE SPILLED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 68

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

STEVENSON RESIDENCE 130 HARVEY HILL RD

Spill Number: 0212276

Close Date: 10/02/2003

ITHACA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14850 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Affected Persons GREG STEVENSON CLWARNER

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

GREGORY A SEIBERT - PHILLIPS PRODUCTION Spiller Phone: (724) 772-3500 SAME Notifier Phone: PROPERTY OWNER Caller Phone: (607) 227-4100 CALLER Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/13/2003 HOUSEKEEPING NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: cell for spiller 412-585-2820. caller states that sub contractor is doing drilling on a property and company is dumping mud on callers property. caller does not know what is in the mud on his property. comp req call back -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "CWS" 3-14-03 SPOKE WITH JOE YAROSZ FROM REG. 8 MINERALS. HE SAID MATERIAL IS DESIGNED TO NOT SOAK INTO THE GROUND. HE SPOKE WITH GREG SEIBERT FROM PHILLIPS. THEY WILL CLEAN UP ALL MATERIAL. REG. 8 MINERALS TO OVERSEE CLEANUP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 69

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

Spill Number: 0207557 4786 COUNTY ROAD 33

Close Date: 10/22/2002

BRISTOL, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14469 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Fire Department DISP TIFFANY DLTILTON

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

UNKNOWN JEFF HARLOFF ONTARIO COUNTY SO CALLER

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (585) 396-4610 Caller Phone: (585) 394-4560 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/21/2002 TRAFFIC ACCIDENT NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT WATER BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CAR HIT GAS MAIN. UNKNOWN AMOUNT SPILLED. UNKNOWN WHEN CLEANUP WILL BEGIN. NOTIFIER’S CELL # 585-2619644. CALL CELL PHONE FOR MORE DETAILS FROM THE SCENE PER THE CALLER. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "DT" COPY TO LE AND MINERALS, WHO WILL INSPECT AND ADDRESS THE PROPER CLEANUP. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS. NRC REPORT# 628591.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 70

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PIPELINE 610 MINERAL SPRINGS

Spill Number: 0207461

Close Date: 10/21/2003

WEST SENECA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 610 MINERAL SPRINGS RD Revised zip code: 14224 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Responsible Party DANA SLADE RJJONAK

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

DANA SLADE - ENBRIDGE ENERGY EMPLOYEE ENBRIDGE ENERGY DANA SLADE

Spiller Phone: (218) 725-0152 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (218) 725-0152 Contact Person Phone: (218) 725-0152

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/18/2002 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: hystoric release. spill is underground. no call back needed. spill cause is unknwon, they will dig area and check pipe. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RJJ" 10/21/2002: RJJ DRAFTED AND SENT A ’RP’ LETTER TO ENBRIDGE ENERGY,FOR THEM TO INVESTIGATE THE PROBLEM...RJJ AT SITE AT 1430...MEET WITH GEORGE BARTH,ENBRIDGE,THEY HIRED BOGNAR BROTHERS,# 877-2115,TO EXCAVATE,AND DISPOSE OF THE CONTAMINATED SOIL,WHICH IS ALL AROUND THEIR CRUDE OIL PIPELINE VALVE OFF OF MINERAL SPRINGS ROAD,ON NIAGARA MOHAWK’S PROPERTY...THEY EXCAVATED 12’ DEEP X10’X5’AND REMOVED ABOUT 50 TONS OF CONTAMINATED SOIL,WHICH WILL BE TAKEN AND STAGED IN WILLIAMSVILLE,ON THEIR PROPERTY,WITH SAC’S PERMISSION...THE CRUDE OIL WAS A HISTORICAL SMALL LEAK FROM THE PIPELINE VALVE,WHICH THEY WILL REPAIR...THE EXCAVATION LOOKS AND SMELLS CLEAN,AND THEY WILL TAKE WALL/FLOOR SAMPLES AND SEND ME THE RESULTS. 7/9/2003: RJJ AT SITE AT 1500...ENBRIDGE HAS DECIDED TO REPAIR ANOTHER VALVE IN THE EXCAVATION,SO BOGNAR BROS. ARE EXCAVATING MORE SOIL...THEY FOUND MORE CONTAMINATED SOIL ALONG THE PIPELINE AND WILL DISPOSE OF THIS SOIL AND THE SOIL IN WILLIAMSVILLE TOGETHER...JACK BOGNAR WILL TAKE WALL/FLOOR SAMPLES AND SEND ME THE RESULTS...IT APPEARS THAT THERE IS ONLY A SMALL AMOUNT OF

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 71

CONTAMINATED SOIL THIS TIME. 8/28/2003: RECEIVED THE ANALYTICAL RESULTS FROM JACK BOGNAR ON THE EXCAVATION...ONLY A FEW COMPOUNDS ARE SLIGHTLY HIGHER THAN OUR TAGA LEVELS,SO AFTER WE RECEIVE THE DISPOSAL RECEIPTS FOR THE SOIL,WE WILL BE ABLE TO MAKE THIS ’INACTIVE’. 10/21/2003: RECEIVED THE DISPOSAL RECEIPTS FOR 86.89 TONS OF SOIL DISPOSED AT MODERN LANDFILL FROM THE SITE,AND THE DISPOSAL RECEIPTS FOR 111.38 TONS OF SOIL,WHICH WAS STAGED ON ENBRIDGE PROPERTY,IN WILLIAMSVILLE...THE SPILL HAS BEEN CLEANED UP AND PROPERLY DISPOSED OF...DRAFTED AND SENT AN ’INACTIVE’ LETTER TO ’RP’...NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED...SPILL CLOSED OUT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 72

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

1 MILE OFF WAITS RD ON ROBINSON RD

Spill Number: 0201795

Close Date: 05/18/2002

OWEGO, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13827 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Citizen MARK EDWARDS CLWARNER

Spiller: ECORP Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: MARK EDWARDS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 687-5714 Contact Person Phone: (607) 687-5714

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/18/2002 DELIBERATE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected ETHYLENE GLYCOL HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER AMMONIUM SULFAMATE HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: caller states the ecorp co. is doing drilling work at location airfoam 11 is being put into the drainage ditch at location from this work - this has been reported before (0200483) caller has talked to dec police Tony Dragotta (607-687-9342) they advised each time this occured to contact the spill hot line - Chris Warner has been involved with this incident also in the past -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks:

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "CWS" 5-18-02 ONGOING PROBLEM. REGION 8 MINERALS INVOLVED AS WELL AS LAW ENFORCEMENT. TICKETS BEING ISSUED.

Page 73

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 74

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SOUTH GREEN BUSH ROAD SOUTH GREEN BUSH ROAD

Spill Number: 0401542

Close Date: 06/09/2004

ERIN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14838 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Responsible Party JIM MOTTESHEARD PCLINDEN

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

UNKNOWN JIM MOTTESHEARD COLUMBIA NATURAL RESOURCE JIM

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (304) 353-5142 Caller Phone: (304) 353-5142 Contact Person Phone: (304) 353-5142

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/12/2004 06/09/2004 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: THE CALLER STATES THAT THERE IS BRINE SPILLED ALONG SOUTH GREEN BUSH ROAD IN ERIN. THERE WILL BE FURTHER INVESTIGATION OF THE SPILL. REPORT FAXED TO PL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" PL REFERRED SPILL TO JOE YAROZ OF MINERAL RESOURCES. THERE IS AN APPARENT RELATION TO BRINE PRODUCTION FROM WELL DRILLING. 06/09/2004 BASED ON REVIEW OF SPILLSHEET, NO FURTHER ACTION IS NEEDED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 75

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ATLAS CRUDE OIL WELL CR 33 & BAKER RD

Spill Number: 0551770

Close Date: 05/15/2006

PANAMA, NY 14767

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: CR 33 / BAKER RD Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JOHN HOFFMAN cgmckenz

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

KIM PATTERSON - ATLAS AMERICA KIM PATTERSON NYSDEC KIM PATTERSON

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (716) 269-7665 Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716)499-3088

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/19/2006 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 500.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: UNDERGROUND LEAD LINE BROKE, SPILL APPX 500 GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL. CLEANUP STARTED -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 03/20/06: MF S/I/KIM PATTERSON, DANIEL GROVE, ATLAS AMERICA, CRUDE OIL PRODUCERS/ PATRICK SPANG, ECS&R, REMEDIATION CONTRACTOR, 814-425-7773. UG PLASTIC LEAD LINE TO STOCK TANK RUPTURED, LOST APPX 500 GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL. DIVERSION TRENCHES DUG, SYPHON DAMS INSTALLED. SOIL REMOVAL TO START TOMORROW. NO OIL GOT INTO WATER WAYS. WELL IS 1400’ NORTH OF BAKER RD & 340’ EAST OF CR 33. WELL #API 31-013-18351 OF SAULS GIVER 1-B. 03/21/06: MF CLEAN UP LETTER SENT. 03/23/06: MF S/I/PAT SPANG & KIM PATTERSON, AREA CLEANED & BACKFILLED. APPX 300 TONS OF SOIL REMOVED. PLASTIC LEAD LINE TO BE REPLACED WITH STEEL LINE. WAIT FOR RECEIPTS. 04/03/06 RMC/FILE. REASSIGNED FOR CGM TO TRACK DISPOSAL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

04/07/06: Saltzgiver stated MXF allowed delay in loading staged soils to allow for dry out. He has 60 days from 3/19 date of spill. 716-499-3088 (cell), 716-269-7666 (office). 5/8/06 Site visit. Checked areas by pump 732 ppb, at dike outfall 916 ppb, treeline ranged from 38-149 ppm, at fence 463 ppb. Vast area of dirt moved around. Residual evidence of crude spill remains at surface down to at least approximately 6". 5/15/06 Mucha/DKK/RC/CGM/Dan David discussion on crude oil spills. Per DKK this spill can be closed under current protocol between spills and minerals programs. Spill closed. No further action required at this time.

Page 76

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 77

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

EOG RESOURCES WGI WELL #6

Spill Number: 0650216

Close Date: 05/12/2006

DIX, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: BWFINSTE

Spiller: EOG RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/12/2006 05/12/2006 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL DRILLING DERRICK SOMEHOW FAILED AND TIPPED OVER. THE DERRICK HIT A 180 BARREL MUD TANK CONTAINING BRINE WATER. A GATE VALVE WAS DAMAMGED AND THE BRINE IS SLOWLY LEAKING OUT. A VAC TRUCK HAS BEEN CALLED TO REMOVE THE REMAINING 45 BARRELS. THERE IS NO RECOVERY POSSIBLE OF THE LEAKED MATERIAL. IT RAN 125 FEET ACROSS THE SITE, THEN 75 FEET ACROSS A POWERLINE ROW AND THEN INTO A DRY ROCKY GULCH. THE MATERIAL HAS SOAKED INTO THE GROUND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 05/12/06 COPY OF SPILL REPORT GIVEN TO MINERALS. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS. MINERALS INVESTIGATED AND BRINE SPILL WAS MINOR AND NO CLEANUP POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 78

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

WELL #490 FITZSTEPHEN ROAD

Spill Number: 0607993

Close Date: 10/13/2006

WELLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Spiller: CHARLIE BURKE - WELL #490 Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2359 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: FXGALLEG Contact for more spill info: CHARLIE BURKE Contact Person Phone: (716) 827-2359 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/13/2006 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SALT WATER BRINE- 1000 GALLONS; MALFUNCTION OF STORAGE FLOAT AND IT DID NOT SHUT DOWN RIGHT: IS BEING REPAIRED AND WELL SHUT DOWN: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 10/13/06 notified minerals, john hoffman and he said they will follow up and are familiar with this location. no further work by spills is required. site is closed. electronic file only.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 79

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

2ND FARM ON LEFT 3016 RIVERSIDE ROAD

Spill Number: 0603307

Close Date: 05/15/2007

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Notifier Type: Other Caller Name: DEC Investigator: CGMCKENZ

Spiller: BRIAN HAYNER - PINE RIDGE ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: MILFORD TOWNE

Spiller Phone: 814-757-8034 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (716) 664-2106

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/26/2006 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: THE PERSON OWNING WELLS ON HIS FARM IS CAUSING PROBLEMS, OWNER OF WELLS LIVES IN PA: HE ALSO HAS TWO PIECES OF EQUIPMENT THAT LETS OUT GASSES IN THE AIR AND ALSO SPILLS OIL ALL OVER THE GROUND: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 06/26/06 RMC/MILFORD TOWNE/PHONE. CRUDE OIL WELL OPERATION COMPLAINT. MR TOWN CLAIMS CRUDED OIL TANK ROADSIDE. LETS OUT WATER ON THE ROAD EDGE. NOTED SHEEN MANY TIMES. NATURAL GAS IS ALLOWED TO ESCAPE AT THE WELL HEAD 24/7. STEM ON PUMP LEAKS. THEY KEEP COVERING WITH CLEAN SOIL. SOMETIME THE CRUDE OIL AROUND THE WELL HEAD RUNS OFF THE PROPERTY. THE WELL IS LOCATED OFF THE ROAD OVER THE HILL. THE ADDRESS IS 3016 RIVERSIDE ROAD. 6/29/06 11:30am site visit cancelled w/Brian Jandrew. 8/8/6 T/C w/Brian Jandrew-Minerals. He visited site. Talked w/owner of well (PA company) to clean up a bit and improve on equipment maintenance. Jandrew feels not much more necessary. Referred to Minerals for additional followup per Jandrew.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

5/15/07 Based on mtg of 5/15/06 Mucha/DKK/RC/CGM/Dan David discussion on crude oil spills. Per DKK this spill can be closed under current protocol between spills and minerals programs. Spill closed. No further action required at this time. Electronic file copy only.

Page 80

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 81

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ROADSIDE CENTER AND WEAVER ROAD

Spill Number: 0751440

Close Date: 02/14/2008

ARKWRIGHT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: CENTER / WEAVER ROAD Revised zip code: 14718 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: fxgalleg

Spiller: NATIONAL FUEL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: CHARLIE BURKE

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/13/2008 HUMAN ERROR NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BLOCKAGE IN PIPE. PUT WATER IN TO BREAK UP THE BRINE A WEEK AGO. A SLUG CAME OUT AND SOME BLACK SLUDGE MATERIAL SPRAYED ON THE SNOW. THE DISCOLORED SNOW , 20 YARDS, WAS PUSHED UP IN A PILE. WILL FIND A WAY TO CONTAIN. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 2/13/08 RMC INDICATED THAT NATIONAL FUEL WILL CALL FG WITH UPDATE ON THE CONTAINMENT OF THE BRINE. CHARLIE BURKE WITH NATIONAL FUEL CALLED AND SAID HE WILL COLLECT THE SNOW IN A BAKER TANK AND STAGE AT THE DUNKIRK SERVICE CENTER. HE WILL PLAN ON GETTING APPROVAL AT THE SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT AND SENDING THE DEPT A COPY OF THE PERMIT. 2/14/08 FG SITE INSPECTION. NATIONAL FUEL ON SITE REMOVING IMPACTED SNOW AND PLACING NEAR THE STREET. ROLLOFF/BAKER TANK HAD NOT ARRIVED YET. FG NOTIFIED JOHN HOFFMAN WITH MINERALS OF THE SPILL. HE SAID HE WILL FOLLOW UP WITH NATIONAL FUEL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILLS IS REQUIRED. THE SITE IS CLOSED. ELECTRONIC FILE ONLY.

Page 82

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 83

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FORTUNA ENERGY / DYZBON WELL 12127 EAST CORNING RD

Spill Number: 0750988

Close Date: 02/12/2008

EAST CORNING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 17 Revised zip code: 14830 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cmkehoe

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: JEFF BOWERS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/16/2007 02/07/2007 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 250.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTS GAS WELL DISCHARGED A LARGE QUANTITY OF BRINE CAUSING BULK TANK TO OVERFILL AND DISCHARGE TO SUROUNDING AREA. CLEANUP CREW ENROUTE. COPY TO MINERALS. FAXED TO CK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 10/16/07 1615 KEHOE ON SITE WITH JEFF BOWERS TO CHECK STATUS, POOLING OF BRINE AROUND BRINE TANKS, WELL "BURPED" LARGE QUANTITY OF BRINE TO BRINE TANK, LEVEL CONTROLLER AND WELL SHUTOFF DID NOT WORK AND ALLOWED BRINE TO FLOW OUT TANK VENT. GFS WILL BRING EXCAVATOR/SKIDSTEER ON SITE AND REMOVE IMPACTED SOIL. 02/07/07 EMAIL FROM JEFF BOWERS, SOIL HAS BEEN REMOVED AND DISPOSED OF AT HAKES LANDFILL. NFA - CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 84

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CHESAPEAKE ENERGY OAKWOOD ROAD/ HIGH ST

Spill Number: 0713298

Close Date: 03/17/2008

AURELIUS, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: OAKWOOD RD / HIGH ST Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: kacahill

Spiller: DAVID - CHESAPEAKE ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: DAVID

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (315) 412-1671

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/17/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 42.00 GALLONS 42.00 GALLONS SOIL The following material was dropped or revised by the NYS DEC. UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 2 INCH SUPPLY LINE BROKE: IT WAS ABOUT 42 GALLONS OF BRINE: CLEAN UP AND REPAIR HAS STARTED -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Supply line to storage tank broke. Approximately 40 gallons was spilled to ground. They are repairing line and will dig up affected soil. The brine is used in production.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 85

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FREDERICK ROBSON FARM RTE 96

Spill Number: 0711912

Close Date: 02/12/2008

SENECA FALLS, NY 13148

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Notifier Type: Other Caller Name: DEC Investigator: jrmarchi

Spiller: JODY WEIDNER - FREDERICK ROBSON FARM Spiller Phone: Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: Contact for more spill info: JODY WEIDNER Contact Person Phone: (800) 598-6756 ext. 20

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/11/2008 02/12/2008 HUMAN ERROR NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT WATER BRINE OTHER 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THAT WHILE PUMPING FROM TANK TO TRAILER, THE TRAILER WAS OVERFILLED. MATERIAL HAS BEEN CONTAINED AND PUMPED BACK INTO TANK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 02/12/08: JM SPOKE TO JIM MOTTESHEARD. 02/12/2008 JM SPOKE TO JIM MOTTESHEARD, CHESAPEAKE ENERGY. LEAK WAS STOPPED AND MATERIAL CONTAINED. MATERIAL CLEANED UP AND PUMPED BACK IN CONTAINER. NO OTHER IMPACT. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY AT THIS TIME.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 86

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

MONAHAN WELL #624115 NO STREET

Spill Number: 0705155

Close Date: 08/06/2007

ERIN, NY 14838

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: N ST Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Notifier Type: Other Caller Name: DEC Investigator: dltilton

Spiller: MELISSA - MONAHAN WELL #624115 Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: MELISSA

Spiller Phone: (304) 353-5118 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (304) 353-5118

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/06/2007 08/06/2007 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SPILLED FROM A PRODUCTION TANK: IT WAS ABOUT 6 OR 8 BARRELS OF BRINE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: JOE YAROS OF MINERALS IS RESPONDING TO RELEASE. LINDA COLLART STATED RELEASE WAS VERY MINOR AND TO BE CLEANED UP. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS UNIT AT THIS TIME. SPILL CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 87

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

COCHRANE RESIDENCE DRIVEWAY 5585 NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0890713

Close Date: 08/18/2008

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/31/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS 1.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL WAS FOUND PERCOLATING UP THROUGH A DRIVEWAY. WHEN THEY EXCAVATED THE AREA, THEY FOUND AN OLD TRANSFER LINE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 08/01/08 JFO CALL FROM MR COCHRANE. THERE WAS APPROX 1 QUART OF CRUDE IN THE HOLE. HE PUT A CLAMP ON THE INACTIVE LINE AND CLEANED UP THE OIL. AS PER MR COCHRANE THE LINE WAS OWNED BY NATIONAL TRANSFER AND SOLD TO MR DON BENSON AND THEN TO VINEYARD GAS AND OIL IN FREDONIA. I WILL VISIT THE SITE TODAY. 8/6/08:SAC TELECON ERIC WOHLERS - CATT CO. HEALTH DEPT. & LANCE JOBE - VILLAGE OF LIMESTONE WATER SUPERINTENDENT. LAST NIGHT, A GENTLEMAN CAME TO THE VILLAGE BOARD MEETING AND NOTIFIED THE BOARD THAT WHILE HE HAS BEEN EXCAVATING HIS DRIVEWAY, HE FOUND AN OLD ABANDONED CRUDE OIL LINE WITH THREE OR FOUR HOLES IN IT AND PETROLEUM CONTAMINATION. ALTHOUGH THEY WERE UNCERTAIN OF THE GENTLEMAN’S NAME AND ADDRESS, THIS MAN’S SITUATION IS CONSISTENT W/MR. COCHRANE’S. MR. WOHLERS AND MR. JOBE INDICATED THERE CONCERN SINCE THE VILLAGE WATER SUPPLY WELL IS DOWNSTREAM FROM THIS LOCATION. THEY REQUESTED A JOINT INSPECTION BETWEEN MR. WOHLERS AND A DEC SPILL RESPONDER FOR FRIDAY, 8/8. MR. WOHLERS’ CELL PHONE NUMBER IS 307-0864.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 88

08/08/08: MF S/V/ERIC WOHLERS, CACHD/RALPH BOTTONE, MAYOR OF LIMESTONE AT 5585 NICHOLS RUN RD. HOMEOWNER, AL COCHRANE NOT AT HOME. UNABLE TO DETERMINE THE LOCATION OF THE ABANDON NATIONAL TRANSIT PIPE. CONCERN IS THE POSSIBE CONTAMINATION TO HOMEOWNER WELL & VILLAGE WATER SUPPLY DOWN GRAIDENT APPX 1/2 MILE. I LEFT MY CARD FOR AL COCHRANE. T/C AL, TOLD ME ABANDON PIPE IS PARALLEL TO RD APPX 8’ INTO IS DRIVEWAY & THAT THE PIPE IS COMES AG OVER NICHOLS RUN CREEK APPX 200’ DOWNGRAIDENT OF WELLS. HE WILL SHOW ME THIS WEEKEND. FOUND OUT FROM MINERALS THAT EAST RESOURCES BOUGHT OUT NATIONAL TRANSIT. T/C STEVE MILLIS, EAST RESOURCES 814-725-8742 x 121. THEY HAVE NOTHING TO DUE WITH NAT TRANSITS LINE EAST OF RTE 219 BUT WILL HELP OUT WITH PLUGGING THE LINE. 08/10/08: MF S/V/AL COCHRANE, LINE crossing his driveway IS APPX 3’ DEEP. HE SHOWED ME WHERE LINE IS AG OVER THE CREEK. HE HAS PICTURES OF LINE THAT HE CLAMPED & WILL HAVE COPIES MADE FOR THE DEC. HE WORKS IN THE OIL FIELD. 08/13/08: MF S/I/ERIC CANFIELD, EAST STATE, VINETARD. THEY AGREED TO DRAIN, CUT, PLUG & VALVE 3" ABANDON CRUDE OIL LINE THAT CROSSES NICHOLS RUN CREEK APPX 100 TARD DOWNGRADIENT Of THE 3 VILLAGE WATER WELLS. 2 PROPERTY OWNERS WHOS PROPERTY EAST STATE WILL CROSS GAVE THE OK. AG LINE IS BEHIND 5745 NICHOLS RUN RD. NOTIFIED ERIC WOHLERS & VILLAGE MAYOR RALPH BOTTONE OF THE WORK (716-925-8903 716-925-8508). WORK TO START THIS PM. 1800 T/C ERIC CANFIELD, WORK COMPLETED. HE WILL KEEP AN EYE ON WORK. 08/15/08: MF S/I APPX 70’ OF THE AG LINE THAT CROSSES CREEK IS REMOVED. A DRESSER COUPLING & VALVES ARE AT BOTH ENDS. NO SPILLAGE NOTICED. T/C ERIC CANFIELD, APPX 4 BARRELS OF CRUDE OIL DRAINED FROM THE LINE. THATS APPX 170 GALLONS DRAINED. LINE WAS DRIAINED UNTIL WATER CAME OUT. ERIC WILL KEEP MONITORING. T/C ERIC WOHLERS, TOLD HIM OF ABOVE. WHEN I TALKED TO EAST RESOURCES (VINEYARD) THEY TOLD ME THEY HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH LINE EAST SIDE IF RTE 219, AND THAT LINE IS OWNED BY DON BENSON, HYDROCARBON GENERATION INC 221 HOMER ST, OLEAN 14760. 372-1893. FAX 372-8645. 08/18/08: MF LETTER TO DON BENSON, TO REMOVE LINE TO AVOID FUTURE PROBLEMS. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 89

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL 8485 COURTNEY HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 0850133

Close Date: 04/29/2008

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: jfotto

Spiller: UNK Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: MARK BOSSERT

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/29/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL WELL LEAKING, 5’ DIAMETER. CALLER DOES NOT KNOW WHO OWNS THE LEASE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 04/29/08 JFO TELCON W/BRIAN J. WITH MINERALS. HE WILL HANDLE THIS SPILL. FAXED COPY OF SPILL TO HIM. NO ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS. CLOSED ELECTRONIC FILE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 90

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BEAN WELL SITE E-1 323 KNOBLES HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 0813562

Close Date: 04/28/2009

HORSEHEADS, NY 14845

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 323 KNOBLES HILL RD Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cmkehoe

Spiller: DON MCCARDY - FORTUNA ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: DAN MCCURDY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (607) 207-6132

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/16/2009 03/17/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTS SURFACE AREA IMPACTS AT 20-25 FT2 SALINITY 9.91. CALLER REPORTED WATER TANKS AT WELL OVERFLOWING TO GROUND. GFS ONSITE REMOVING SOIL. WILL PREPARE A REPORT FOR DEC. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: EMAILED AND FAXED TO CHAD KEHOE AT 1510 HOURS. 04/27/09 1600 KEHOE TELECON WITH DON MCCARDY, 20 TONS OF SOIL SHIPPED TO HAKES LANDFILL, WEIGH TICKETS WOULD NOT COPY. NFA CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 91

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GANG MILLS RAILYARD 574 RITAS WAY

Spill Number: 0811699

Close Date: 02/18/2009

PAINTED POST, NY 14870

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: RAILROAD CAR Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cmkehoe

Spiller: KEN BARNS - GANG MILLS RAILYARD Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: KEN BARNS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/26/2009 01/30/2009 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected OTHER PETROLEUM 12.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES ABOVE MATERIAL IS LEAKING FROM TWO RAIL CARS. MATERIAL IS NOT HAZARDOUS AND THE RAIL COMPLANY IS CONTACTING A CONTRACTOR TO STOP THE LEAK AND FOR CLEANUP. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 01/26/2009: FAXED TO CK FOR FOLLOW UP. NRC# IS 895872. 01/26/09 1245 KEHOE CALL TO NORFOLK SOUTHERN, REFERRED TO ONSITE PERSON BOB CERRI AT 607-237-1588. BOB REPORTS TWO CARS ARE LEAKING SLIGHTLY FROM MANWAY ON TOP OF CARS. LEAK IS SMALL. MATERIAL IS BRINE WATER FROM GAS WELLS IN AREA. CARS ARE DESTINED FOR PENNSYLVANIA. CONTRACTOR HAS BEEN HIRED TO RESPOND CONTAIN AND REPAIR. 01/30/09 1115 KEHOE CALL TO BOB CERRI, PROBLEMS WERE TAKEN CARE OF, CONTRACTOR CLAIMS BRINE WAS NOT SALTY ENOUGH TO PREVENT FREEZING, THE FREEZING INCREASED PRESSURE IN PIPES AND FORCED SOME LIQUID OUT OF COVER. CAR WAS "SLOSHED" TO MOVE LIQUID AND LEAKS STOPPED. PROVISIONS WERE MADE TO PREVENT FUTURE LEAKS. NFA - CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 92

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL WELL JUNKYARD 10 OFF FOREST AVENUE EXTENSION

Spill Number: 0811201

Close Date: 01/23/2009

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: FXGALLEG

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: ERIC PEFLEY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (716) 435-7066

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/08/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 250.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LINE FAILED, 5 BARRELS RELEASED. 4 WENT TO PIT NEAR WELL. 1 WENT DOWN ROAD TO ADDITIONAL POND BUILT FOR WELL. CHARLES THORP AND JIM KING WITH MINERALS HAVE BEEN CONTACTED. CLEAN UP NEAR COMPLETED. WILL RETURN MONDAY TO DO ADDITIONAL WORK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 1/12/09 FG CONTACTED MINERALS AND THEY WILL INSPECT THE SITE. FG TRIED TO CONTACT ERIC PEFLEY BUT UNABLE TO. CHARLES THROPP WITH MINERALS SAID THAT APPROXIMATELY 20 GALLONS SPILLED OUTSIDE THE CONTAINMENT POND AND PEFLEY CLEANED IT UP. FG TOLD MR. THROPP THAT WE WILL GET DISPOSAL RECEIPTS FROM PEFLEY. 1/23/09 FG SPOKE TO ERIC PEFLEY WHO SAID TWO BAGS OF CLEANUP DEBRIS WERE GENERATED AND HE HAS PLACED THEM IN THE REGULAR WASTE STREAM. NO FURTHER WORK IS REQUIRED. THE SITE IS CLOSED. ELECTRONIC FILE ONLY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 93

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LEROY MARTIN #4 WELL #626326 NEILSON ROAD

Spill Number: 0809840

Close Date: 12/03/2008

SENECA FALLS, NY 13148

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Other Caller Name: DEC Investigator: prmiller

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: KEVIN PATTERSON

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (304) 517-1416

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/03/2008 12/03/2008 VANDALISM NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 1008 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES UNKNOWN SUBJECTS SHOT A TANK WITH A RIFLE SEVERAL TIMES CAUSING HOLES IN THE TANK AND SPILLING CONTENTS ONTO THE SOIL. CLEANUP IS ONGOING. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 12/03/08 REPORT FORWARDED TO MINERALS AND LAW ENFORCEMENT FOR APPROPRIATE ACTION. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 94

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SPRING FED DITCH PARKSIDE ROAD

Spill Number: 0807033

Close Date: 10/13/2009

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: TDJOHNSO Contact for more spill info: CHARLES THROPP Contact Person Phone: (716) 372-0645 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/23/2008 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL COMING FROM SPRING ON HILL BANK IS RUNNING INTO SMALL POND. DALLAS ENERGY OWN IS OPERATOR FOR WELLS IN AREA (TOM MORRIS) 814-362-6493 EXT 18 AND TOM TORREY IS LAND OWNER 716-925-8250. VANDALISM A COUPLE OF YEARS AGO ON A TANK CAUSED A SPILL OF CRUDE OIL. HE DOESN’T KNOW IF THIS IS PART OF THAT ONGOING PROBLEM -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 09/23/08 TJ WENT TO LOCATION OF SPILL CALL AND FOUND A LARGE POOLED AREA ON A FLAT WETLAND WHICH HAD A SHEEN TO THICK CRUDE OIL LAYERS IN WATER. HILLSIDE GROUNDWATER OUTBREAKS HAD CRUDE OIL TRAILS LEADING TO THE LARGER AREAS. CRUDE OIL SMELL IN AIR IN ENTIRE AREA. PROPERTY OWNER AND DALLAS ENERGY WILL BE NOTIFIED OF PROBLEM FOR IDEAS ON RESOLUTION. 09/24/08 TJ SPOKE WITH MINERALS AND WILL MEET AT SITE ON 9/25 WITH DALLAS ENERGY, MIKE FRANKS AND MINERALS TO DETERMINE CLEANUP METHODS AND SOURCE OF MATERIAL 10/13/09 TDJ MINERALS HAS FOLLOW UP ON THIS ONGOING SEEP FROM UNKNOWN WELL DRILLING SOURCE. NO FURTHER AVCTION FILE CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 95

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

3021 COUNTY RD 9 3021 COUNTY RD 9

Spill Number: 0806624

Close Date: 09/15/2008

SCIO, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14880 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: fxgalleg

Spiller: KATY WHITE - UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: KATY WHITE

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (585) 593-6115

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/12/2008 OTHER NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS AIR, INDOOR AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THAT THE GAS LEAK HAS BEEN AN ON GOING PROBLEM AND BELIEVES THAT IT IS AN OLD PIPE THAT IS LEAKING. THIS IS IN HER NEIGHBORHOOD AND IS THE WORST ON HER PROPERTY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 9/12/08 FG SPOKE TO CHRIS MILLER WITH MINERALS AND HE SAID HE WOULD NOT TAKE THE COMPLAINT. FG SPOKE TO THE CALLER AND GAVE HER THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISION PHONE NUMBER AND THE LOCAL NYS HEALTH DEPT CONTACT. THE COMPLAINT IS FOR A LONG TERM ONGOING DISCHARGE OF NATURAL GAS FROM AN ACTIVE LINE ON THE CALLERS PROPERTY. SHE COMPLAINED OF HEALTH PROBLEMS. SPILLS IS UNABLE TO COMPLETE ANY FURTHER ACTION. SPILL SITE IS CLOSED. ELECTRONIC FILE ONLY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 96

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL 1725 CHIPMONK RD

Spill Number: 0805698

Close Date: 01/15/2009

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: RICHARD GIARDINI

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (716) 372-0530

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/18/2008 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: noticed oil and water mix seeping from ground at rear of property for several days -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 08/20/08: MF S/I/CONTRACTOR, HOMEOWNER NOT IN. THERE IS A LOW AREA APPX 5’x5’ WITH WATER & A CRUDE OIL ODOR. T/C MINERALS, CHRIS MILLER, THERE WERE ONCE WELLS ALL OVER THIS AREA. T/C CHIP GIARDINI, HOMEOWNER. HE TOLD ME THAT DON BENSON REPAIRED A LINE IN THIS AREA OF CHIPMONK RD. SITE MEETING/CHIP SCHEDULED FOR 8/23/08. I ASKED HIM TO BRING A METAL DETECTOR. 09/12/08: MF T/C RICH GIARDINI 372-0530. LEFT MESSAGE. 09/14/08: MF S/V NOOS, NO OIL/WATER IN LOW SPOT, NO ODOR. T/C RICH HE WILL CALL IF CHANGE IN STATUS. 01/15/09: MF NO CALL FROM RICH, PROPBLEM MAY HAVE BEEN WELL GAS IN ABANDON LINE. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 97

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

EXCHANGE OIL & GAS LEASE RT 248 @ MILEMARKER 1014

Spill Number: 0907172

Close Date:

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 / MILEMARKER 1014 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: pclinden

Spiller: JOHN RYAN - EXCHANGE OIL & GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: JOHN RYAN

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (585) 968-1008

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/24/2009 HOUSEKEEPING NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ROSPENDOWSKI HAS BEEN HAVING PROBLEMS WITH EXCHANGE CLEANING UP SPILLAGE ASSOCIATED WITH OIL WELLS AND BRINE POND, AND ASKED FOR SPILLS’ ASSISTANCE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: ROSPENDOWSKI AND LINDENFELSER VISITED SITE ON EAST SIDE OF RT 248 AT SOUTH END OF WEST UNION AND FOUND: A) SOIL CONTAMINATION AT DRAINOFF OF NORTHERN COLLECTION TANK; B) " " " FORMER OIL WATER SEPARATOR AT BRINE POND UPHILL OF TANKS; C) SORBABLE QUANTITY OF GREEN, CRUDE OIL POOLED ON WATER AMONGST NEW STONE PLACED AROUND OIL WELL #14 AT TOP OF TRAIL FROM TANKS; D) SORBABLE QUANTITIES OF YELLOW-ORANGE (OXIDIZED) CRUDE OIL ON RAINWATER PUDDLES OF TIRE RUTS ADJACENT OIL WELL #6 WHICH IS ~100 YDS NORTH OF WELL 14; E) SMALL AMOUNT OF GREEN CRUDE AMONGST STONE SURROUNDING OIL WELL #1 WHICH IS NORTH AND DOWNHILL OF WELL #6. THERE IS ALSO BLACK OILY STAINED SOIL SOUTH AND SOUTHEAST OF WELLHEAD; JODI AGREES TO CALL EXCHANGE FOR IMMEDIATE CLEANUP OF FREE OIL LEST IT WASH DOWNHILL WITH THE NEXT RAINFALL; IF SHE DOESN’T GET

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

COOPERATION PL WILL HIRE STATE CONTRACTOR TO DO WORK.

Page 98

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 99

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FORTUNA ENERGY 12127 EAST CORNING ROAD

Spill Number: 0906896

Close Date:

CORNING, NY 14830

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 12127 E CORNING RD Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: pclinden

Spiller: JEFF BOWERS - FORTUNA ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: JEFF BOWERS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (607) 329-7140

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/18/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 420.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: APPROXIMATELY 5-10 BARRELS OF BRINE LOST. CLEANUP CREW ENROUTE. WILL PREPARE SITE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL PICKUP. REQUESTING DEC TO WITNESS CLEANUP. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 09/18/09 REPORT FORWARDED TO PAUL LINDENFELSER FOR APPROPRIATE FOLLOWUP. COPY OF REPORT FORWARDED TO MINERALS. 9/18/09 LINDENFELSER MET MIKE LANPHEAR OF FORTUNA AT SITE; A LONG SERIES OF PUDDLES STRETCHED FROM THE TWO GREEN, 6000 GALLON BRINE TANKS SOUTH ALONG THE EASTERN EDGE OF THE GRAVEL LOT OUTSIDE THE FENCED COMPOUND FOR AT LEAST 150’;

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 100

A MINI-EXCAVATOR ARRIVED AT THE SITE ALONG WITH A FOLDED PIECE OF POLY PLASTIC SHEET; MIKE SAID THEY WERE GOING TO DIG UP THE PUDDLES BUT PL SUGGESTED THEY ABSORB THE LIQUID FIRST; MIKE SAID THAT D.C.RAUSHCER’S (WATERLOO, NY) VAC TRUCK WHICH HAD ALREADY PUMPED DOWN THE TANKS WAS COMING BACK AFTER THEY DELIVER THE BRINE TO AUBURN; WE AGREED THAT THEY WOULD VACUUM UP THE LIQUID BEFORE DIGGING INTO THE SOIL AND POSSIBLY PUNCTURING WHATEVER SEAL WAS PREVENTING THE PUDDLES FROM SOAKING IN; THERE WAS ALSO STAINED CRUSHED STONE AROUND THE TANKS AND DUE EAST OUTSIDE OF THE FENCED AREA WHERE THE BRINE HAD SOAKED IN. PL ASKED THAT THEY KEEP THE EXCAVATION OPEN TILL MONDAY WHEN WE COULD RETURN TO DOCUMENT IT. LANPHEAR SAID THAT THE HIGH LEVEL ALARM IN THE BRINE TANK FAILED TO SHUT DOWN THE BRINE PUMP FROM THE WELL; THEY HAD RECENTLY INCREASED THE PUMPING OF NATURAL GAS AND THE ATTENDING BRINE SO THE TANKS WERE FILLING UP FASTER THAN THEIR HAULER, RAUSCHER CO., COULD HAUL IT AWAY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 101

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CHESAPEAKE ENERGY/ MCALLISTER SITE RT 76 (H‘SPORT-PULTENEY RD) SO OF RT 74

Spill Number: 0906032

Close Date:

PULTENEY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 76 / HIGHWAY 74 Revised zip code: 14874 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: GREG GARRISON - CHESAPEAKE ENERGY Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Other Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: pclinden Contact for more spill info: GREG GARRISON Contact Person Phone: (607) 738-4101 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/24/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected OTHER PETROLEUM 1143 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Tank failed spilling approx 1143 gallon of NA55 (salt inhibator)into a bermed off area, crews are enroute to suck up material, some has soaked into the ground. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: GREG GARRISON REPORTS THAT MATERIAL SPILLED IS A 3% SOLUTION (66 GALLONS OF "NA MINUS(R) 55" IN A 2300 GALLON TANK OF WATER) 8/24/09 LINDENFELSER MEETS GREG GARRISON AND LARRY SEGAR AND OTHERS AT THE GAS WELL SITE WHICH IS >300’ WEST OF RT 76 BEHIND A BUCKWHEAT FIELD; THE STEEL, INHIBITOR TANK HAS BEEN REMOVED FROM THE SHORT-BERMED AREA WHICH STILL HOLDS A LARGER FIBERGLASS BRINE TANK; THE VERTICAL INHIBITOR TANK HAD TWO SMALL DIAMETER PINHOLES WHICH ARE TEMPORARILY PLUGGED WITH SCREWS; ELSEWHERE ON THE TANK UNDER BUBBLED PAINT IS AT LEAST ONE OTHER HOLE: THE HOLES APPEARED FLUSH WITH THE SURFACE OF THE SHELL SUGGESTING CORROSION FROM WITHIN.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 102

INSIDE THE FRONT FACE OF THE BERM, PEAT-SORB COVERS A 3’ WIDE SWATH THE ENTIRE LENGTH AND BEYOND TO THE SOUTH OUTSIDE; THE NORTH END, WHERE THE INHIBITOR TANK SAT, IS QUITE SOGGY; EVEN THOUGH THE CONTAINMENT AREA IS EARTHEN WITH PLENTY OF STONE, THEY EXPLAINED THAT THE CORROSION INHIBITOR HAD POOLED PARTICULARLY AT THE NORTH END; THEY AGREED TO DIG OUT THE HEAVILY CONTAMINATED PEAT MOSS; THEY GOT PLASTIC SHEETING AND MADE A BASIN OF IT WITH HAY BALES AND DUG OUT THE 3’ SWATH ACROSS THE FRONT OF THE AREA; THEY AGREED AND TOOK SAMPLES OF THE HEAVILY CONCENTRATED AND THE RESIDUAL AT THE BOTTOM OF THE ONE FOOT DEEP EXCAVATION;

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 103

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

US SALT CORPORATION SALT POINT ROAD

Spill Number: 0903134

Close Date: 09/16/2009

WATKINS GLEN, NY 14891

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cmkehoe

Spiller: BOB TRAVER - US SALT CORPORATION Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: BOB TRAVER

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (607) 535-2721

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/14/2009 06/15/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 2000 GALLONS 2000 GALLONS SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTS A RELEASE OF 1500-2000 GALLONS OF SALT BRINE FROM PRODUCTION. WELL LEAK HAS STOPPED. INCIDENT REPORT COMING. MINERALS PROGRAM INVESTIGATING. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 06/17/2009: FAXED TO CK. 06/17/09 KEHOE CALL TO BOB TRAVERS, LEAK OCCURRED FROM WELL WHILE WORK WAS BEING DONE ON IT. BRINE WENT ALMOST DIRECTLY INTO A STREAM THAT GOES TO SENECA LAKE. INVESTIGATION CONDUCTED BY MINERALS, NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS. NFA - CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 104

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FRED ANDREWS WELL #1 80 OWEN HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 0902227

Close Date:

BIG FLATS, NY 14814

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 80 OWEN HOLLOW RD Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cmkehoe

Spiller: DAN MCCARTY - FORTUNA ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: DON MCCARTY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (607) 562-4000

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/20/2009 UNKNOWN NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE INVESTIGATING LAND IMPACT COMPLAINT FROM OWNER, STAIN WAS OBSERVED ON GRAVEL INSIDE WELL FENCE AREA ABOUT THE SIZE OF A TRUCK. CALL TO FORTUNA TO INVESTIGATE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 05/26/2009: FAXED AND EMAILED TO CHAD KEHOE. 05/20/2009 KEHOE ON SITE INVESTIGATING SPILL 0901928 AND FOUND A STAIN ON THE GRAVEL WITHIN THE FENCED WELL AREA. UNABLE TO DETERMINE NATURE OF SPILL GIVEN SPILL WAS FENCED, WILL CONTACT DON MCCARTY FOR ADDITIONAL INFO. 06/01/09 0800 KEHOE TELECON WITH DON MCCARTY, SAMPLE FROM SEEP TAKEN AND TESTED, CHLORIDE CONCENTRATION WAS 37.8 MG/KG. STAIN ON GRAVEL WAS DONE BY CREW WORKING ON WELL IN September OF 2008, MR. MCCARTY WILL RESEARCH SOME MORE TO SEE IF IT WAS DIESEL OR SOMETHING ELSE. KEHOE TELECON WITH STUART THOMAS OF DIVISION OF WATER, MR. THOMAS BELIEVES THE SAMPLE RESULT PROVIDED IS NOT A SIGNIFICANT CONCENTRATION AND PROBABLY ISN’T AN ISSUE GIVEN SIZE OF SEEP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 105

06/02/09 1615 KEHOE CALL TO FRED ANDREWS TO UPDATE HIM ON SITUATION. REPORTED TO HIM 1. SPOKE WITH TAX ASSESSOR TO UPDATE HIM, 2. RESULTS OF SEEP, 3. MUD IN MUD PIT WAS LEFT ON SITE AND SALT CONCENTRATIONS IN MUD WOULD PRECLUDE ANYONE FROM DRILLING A DRINKING WATER WELL THROUGH THE MUD PIT OR ANYWHERE IN THE GENERAL VICINITY ESPECIALLY DOWN GRADIENT, 4. STILL WORKING ON STAIN ON GRAVEL AND SAMPLE FROM MUD PIT SOIL. 07/10/09 1115 EMAIL FROM STEVE GRIDLEY WITH SUMMARY OF LAB RESULTS FROM OIL SPILL, ALL RESULTS ND FOR 8270C COMPOUNDS. THIS TEST WAS FOR THE OIL SPILL ON THE DRILL PAD NEAR THE WELL HEAD. 07/17/09 1358 EMAIL FROM STEVE GRIDLEY CONFIRMING SPILL WAS OF HYDRAULIC OIL. 09/08/09 KEHOE EMAIL TO GRIDLEY REQUESTING DISPOSAL RECEIPTS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 106

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FRED ANDREWS WELL #1 80 OWEN HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 0901928

Close Date:

BIG FLATS, NY 14814

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 80 OWEN HOLLOW RD Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Local Agency Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cmkehoe

Spiller: DON MCCARDY - FORTUNA ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: DON MCCARDY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (607) 562-4048

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/14/2009 DELIBERATE NO NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected DRILLING FLUID

OTHER

0.00

GALLONS

0.00

GALLONS

SOIL AIR GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTED DRILLING COMPANY USED CHEMICALS DURING WELL DRILLING THAT WERE HAZARDOUS AND BURIED THEM ON SITE IN LARGE PITS. FAXED AND E-MAILED TO CK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 05/18/09 1145 KEHOE STOPPED AND GOT PHOTOS FROM TAX ASSESSOR. 1200 KEHOE ON SITE TO CHECK REPORT. WELL IS ON SIDE HILL OVERLOOKING BIG FLATS. WELL IS ACTIVE AND HAS GAS MEASURING DEVICES AND BRINE TANKS ON WELL PAD. SITE HAS BEEN RECLAIMED TO THE EXTENT PRACTICABLE. AREA OF PIT FROM PHOTOS HAS BEEN REGRADED TO SHED WATER TOWARD WELL, DIVERSION DITCH AT FOOT OF EMBANKMENT. GRASS ON PIT AREA IS GREEN AND HEALTHY. WEEDS AND GROWTH IN DIVERSION DITCH IS GREEN AND HEALTHY. NO OBVIOUS SIGNS OF IMPACTS TO VEGETATION FROM CHEMICAL RUNOFF. 05/19/09 1100 KEHOE TELECON WITH FRED ANDREWS, HE CLAIMS GENERAL PRACTICE OF WELL DRILLING LEAVES BEHIND WASTE MATERIAL THAT HAS A NEGATIVE IMPACT ON HIS LAND AND IS CONCERNED ABOUT LONG TERM AFFECTS ALONG WITH INCREASE IN PROPERTY ASSESSMENT AS A RESULTS OF

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 107

ACCESS BRIDGE AND ROAD. WILL MEET WITH MR. ANDREWS ON MAY 20TH TO SEE SITE AND HIS AREAS OF CONCERN. 05/19/09 KEHOE DISCUSSION WITH JOE YAROSZ, LEAVING DRILL CUTTINGS ON SITE IS A PERMITTED ACTIVITY ALLOWED BY STATE. THEY MUST DRAIN THE CUTTING LIQUIDS BEFORE COVERING. MUCH OF THE LIQUIDS IN THE PIT ARE "CLEAN WATER" THAT HAS BEEN BROUGHT ON SITE TO HELP MOVE CUTTINGS THROUGH THE PROCESS AFTER THEY ARE SEPARATED FROM THE DRILL MUD. THE DRILL MUD IS MADE UP OF NUMEROUS CHEMICALS THAT ARE COSTLY AND RECYCLED AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. NEW CHEMICALS ARE ADDED AS NEEDED. SOME CHEMICAL IS SORBED TO THE DRILL CUTTINGS, SOME IS LOST INTO THE FORMATION AND SOME IS LOST TO BREAK DOWN IN PROCESS. WEB SEARCH FOR MSDS WAS MARGINALLY SUCCESSFUL, MOST CHEMICALS SOLD BY HALIBURTON NEED A PURCHASE ORDER TO GET MSDS. 05/20/2009 1615 KEHOE MEETING WITH ANDREWS, OBSERVED AREA OF PITS, NO ISSUES OBVIOUS. MR. ANDREWS MENTIONED A SEEP/POSSIBLE SEPTIC DISCHARGE AT TOE OF SLOPE. CHECK OF SLOPE DID HAVE DEAD VEGETATION AT TOE OF AN AREA ABOUT 6’X6’. HAD APPEARANCE OF SWAMP MUCK, MAY BE FROM ROTTING VEGETATION THAT WAS BURRIED ON SITE. NOTED A STAIN ON THE GRAVEL IN THE WELL AREA ABOUT THE SIZE OF A TRUCK. SPILL 0902227 OPENED TO ADDRESS THE WELL AREA STAIN. 05/21/09 1500 KEHOE TELECON WITH DON MCCARTY OF FORTUNA, DON WILL CHECK WITH ENVIRONMENTAL TO SEE WHAT STAIN IS AND TO SEE IF THEY HAVE A SALINITY METER TO CHECK SEEP. WILL ALSO CHECK FILES TO SEE IF DRILL MUD HAS BEEN SAMPLED. 06/01/09 0800 KEHOE TELECON WITH DON MCCARTY, SAMPLE FROM SEEP TAKEN AND TESTED, CHLORIDE CONCENTRATION WAS 37.8 MG/KG. STAIN ON GRAVEL WAS DONE BY CREW WORKING ON WELL IN SEPTEMBER OF 2008, MR. MCCARTY WILL RESEARCH SOME MORE TO SEE IF IT WAS DIESEL OR SOMETHING ELSE. KEHOE TELECON WITH STUART THOMAS OF DIVISION OF WATER, MR. THOMAS BELIEVES THE SAMPLE RESULT PROVIDED IS NOT A SIGNIFICANT CONCENTRATION AND PROBABLY ISN’T AN ISSUE GIVEN SIZE OF SEEP. 06/02/09 1615 KEHOE CALL TO FRED ANDREWS TO UPDATE HIM ON SITUATION. REPORTED TO HIM 1. SPOKE WITH TAX ASSESSOR TO UPDATE HIM, 2. RESULTS OF SEEP, 3. MUD IN MUD PIT WAS LEFT ON SITE AND SALT CONCENTRATIONS IN MUD WOULD PRECLUDE ANYONE FROM DRILLING A DRINKING WATER WELL THROUGH THE MUD PIT OR ANYWHERE IN THE GENERAL VICINITY ESPECIALLY DOWN GRADIENT, 4. STILL WORKING ON STAIN ON GRAVEL AND SAMPLE FROM MUD PIT SOIL. 06/05/09 1340 KEHOE CALL TO STEVE GRIDLEY, DISCUSSED MUD PIT SAMPLES AND WHAT IS EXPECTED TO BE IN THEM. SALT 3-18% AND BARIUM SINCE MOST OF THE CHEMICALS ARE BARIUM BASED. SALT IN SEAWATER IN 30,000 MG/KG, THIS IS 37.8 MG/KG, VERY LOW. 06/09/09 MESSAGE FROM STEVE GRIDLEY, SEEP IS FROM TANINS FROM BARRIED WOOD, SALT IS FROM OPERATION ON SITE STILL INVESTIGATING. 07/10/09 1115 EMAIL FROM STEVE GRIDLEY WITH SUMMARY OF LAB RESULTS FROM OIL SPILL, ALL RESULTS ND FOR 8270C COMPOUNDS. THIS TEST WAS FOR THE OIL SPILL ON THE DRILL PAD NEAR THE WELL HEAD. 07/16/09 MSDS RECEIVED FROM SOLID WASTE PROGRAM. 07/29/09 2056 MSDS RECEIVED FROM STEVE GRIDLEY FOR 20 CHEMICALS THAT MAY HAVE BEEN USED AT WELL SITE. 08/27/09 KEHOE MEETING WITH PETE MILLER TO DISCUSS COURSE OF ACTION. WITH NO OBVIOUS ILLEGAL ACTIVITY TAKING PLACE AND SINCE ACTIONS ARE ALLOWED BY DRILLING PERMIT AND SINCE THIS ACTIVITY HAS BEEN THROUGH PUBLIC REVIEW, SPILLS PROGRAM WILL NOT PURSUE THIS SPILL FURTHER. NFA - CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 108

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATURAL GAS WELL 4465 NORTH BOSTON ROAD

Spill Number: 0890836

Close Date: 08/27/2008

EDEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14057 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: rmcrosse

Spiller: US ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: US ENERGY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/27/2008 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER CLAIMS GAS WELL BEING DRILLED BY US ENERGY EXPLODED THIS MORNING. HE CLAIMS THE BLAST SHOOK SURROUNDING HOMES. WELL DID NOT CATCH FIRE AND HE DID NOT SEE ANY LOCAL FIRE RESPONSE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 08/27/08 RMC/FILE. PERSON WOULD NOT GIVE HIS NAME. RMC REFERRED THE INCIDENT TO JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS. THEY WILL INSPECT AND FOLLOW UP. CLOSE OUT AS A SPILLS ISSUE. NO PAPER FILE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 109

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

WOOD WELL - MAHON 624 BARNUM RD

Spill Number: 0375296

Close Date: 09/22/2004

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons CHRIS MILLER MXFRANKS

Spiller: WOODS OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: DAN MAHON

Spiller Phone: (814) 225-3293 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 375-1115

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/01/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LEAKING CRUDE OIL WELL IN PRIVATE RESIDENCE SIDE YARD. OWNER CAN NOT SELL HOME & HAS 5 CHILDREN -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 09/11/03: MF S/I NOOS, LEAKING ABANDON CRUDE OIL OIL ON PRIVATE RESIDENCE’S SIDE YARD. T/C DAN MAHON, OWNER OF THE PROPERTY, HE IS TRYING TO SELL HOME DUE TO NEEDING MORE SPACE FOR HIS 5 CHILDREN. HE CAN’T SELL IT DUE TO LEAKING WELL. TOLD HIM SPILLS WILL TRY TO DO SOMETHING. 09/12/03: MF T/C RICH WOOD, ONE OF THE LEASE HOLDERS 814-225-3672, LEFT MESSAGE. 09/15/03: MF SENT OUT PLUGGING BID LETTERS TO, D&D WELL SERVICES, JAMES DAY & ED ADAMS. RESPONSE BY 11/15/03. 09/26/03: MF SENT OUT ADDITIONAL PLUGGING BID LETTERS TO:

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

PLANTS & GOODWIN INC RD#2 BOX 632

TAYLOR RICKY

6147 CLARK RD

SINGLEHOUSE PA 16748 814-697-7515

Page 110

FRANCIS ROOT INC

1441 WHITEHILL RD

BOLIVAR NY 14715 BOLIVAR NY 14715

585-928-1753

585-593-1648

814-697-6330 RESPONSE BY 11/30/03. 11/03/03: MF RECEIVED FAX OF BID FROM DAN HANNAHS, D & D WELL SERVICES, 1672 NEWELL CREEK RD, ELDRED PA, 16731, 814-225-3791. HE BID $5000. 11/05/03: MF RECEIVED PLUGGING BID FROM ED ADAMS, BOX 7248 KOSSUTH RD, BOLIVAR NY 14715, 716-928-1655 FOR $2395. 12/08/03: MF T/C/CARL CROSSEN 870-8265. HE AGREED TO PROCESS THE BILLING THRU C&W. 12/10/03: MF RECEIVED BID OF $2300. TO PLUG WELL FROM JIM DAY 1338 BARTLETT RD BOLIVAR NY 14715

585-928-2686

01/07/04: MF T/C DAN MCMAHON, TOLD WELL WILL BE PLUGGED SOON & I NEED A SIGNED ROE. HE WILL SIGN. ROE TO DAN. 01/26/04: MF T/C JIM DAY, HE WILL START JOB TOMORROW 9 AM. THERE IS A HOLE IN THE 6 & 1/4" PIPE. HE EXPECTS CONTAMINATION. T/C LINDA SCOTT, SHE WILL CHECK ON AVAILIBILITY OF CREW. T/C CARL CROSSEN, MIKE & JOHN, WILL BE AVAIL. T/C LINDA SCOTT, THEY WILL HAVE 2 MEN ON SITE TOMORROW 9 AM. 01/27/04: MF S/I/JIM DAY, CHRIS & SCOTT/CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS/ DAN LANDER, JOEL MELINO, OP-TECH. PLUGGING LEAKING CRUDE OIL WELL. THEY PUT PIPE DOWN TO 775’. THEY WILL PLUG TOMORROW. APPX 20 GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL SPILLAGE. SENT OP-TECH BACK AT 1300. THEY LEFT PADS, DRUMS & BOOM FOR TOMORROW. 01/28/04: MF RP LETTER SENT TO: GLEN WOOD 28 ELM ST

GLEN WOOD 25 EDSON ST

EDWARD N WOOD 7745 OAKDALE NW

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

ELDRED PA 16731

Page 111

ELDRED PA 16731 MASSILLON OH 44647

GLEN IS DECEASED 01/29/04: MF LETTER TO MR. DAVID WOOD, 40 EDSON ST, ELDRED PA 16731. ASKING FOR INFO ON GLEN WOOD’S ESTATE BY 2/29/04. 02/04/04: MF S/I NOOS, 6 DRUMS IN SITE. AREA SNOW COVERED. 02/09/04: MF T/C DAVE WOOD, 814-225-3436, HE IS GLEN’S NEPHEW. THIS IS THE WESSON LEASE. DAVE RUNS LEASE ACROSS THE ROAD. CHRIS MATTIE MAY BE THE ATTY FOR GLEN’S ESTATE, HE IS IN ELDRED. 02/12/04: MF RECEIVE JIM DAY’S $2300. INVOICE FOR THE WELL PLUGGING. SENT INVOICE TO OP-TECH TO PAY WITHIN 45 DAYS. 02/24/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $3788.07 INVOICE FOR WORKED PREFORMED 1/27/04. INCLUDED IS JIM DAY’S INVOICE FOR $2300. INVOICE #31011. 05/04/04: MF S/I/DAN MAHON, TOLD HIM WE ARE DONE WITH THE SITE. HE WILL DO LANDSCAPPING AROUND THE PLUGGED WELL. 05/05/04: MF 30 DAY LETTER TO OP-TECH. 05/20/04: MF RETURNED OP-TECH’S $991.03 PP FOR DRUM TRANSPOTATION & DISPOSAL (6 DRUMS). TRANSPORTATION CHARGES NOT SHARED. WILL PAY FOR HALF OF TRANSPORTATION COST TO WAVERLY. INVOICE #31881, 3/9/04 - 3/12/04. 07/07/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $887.78 PP, SEE 5/20/04 NOTES. INVOICE #31881R. 30 DAY LETTER TO OP-TECH. 09/22/04: MF NO FURTHER INVOICES. NO FURTHER ACTION POSIBLE. FINAL ISR PENDING.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 112

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL - WELL HO-29 NICHOLS RUN RD

Spill Number: 0275244

Close Date: 08/10/2002

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC MIKE FRANKS MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: TOM DEFIBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7220 Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 10.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WELL HO-29, APPX 20’ FROM NICHOLS RUN CREEK IS LEAKING. FREE PRODUCT AT & UNDER WELL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/08/02: MF S/I/DON PLEAQKIS, ECO, WHILE INSPECTING CRUDE OIL SPILLS IN THIS AREA NOTICED WELL HO-29 HAS FREE PRODUCT AROUND & UNDER IT. INSPECTED THIS ALONG WITH THE 1" DISCHARGE LINE (SPILL #0275243) & WELL 214. SITE MEETING SCHEDULED TOMORROW WITH MINERALS & BDH OIL. 08/09/02: MF S/I/DON PLEAKIS, ECO, JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS/TOM DEFINBAUGH & JOR BOUCHER, BDH OIL. HO-29 IS NOT IN OPERATION. LEAK APPEARS TO BE UNDER A PUDDLE OF CRUDE OIL. FREE PRODUCT TO BE PADDED UP & LEAK REPAIED. TOM CLEAIMED LEAK IS CAUSED BY BUILT UP WELL PRESSURE DUE TO BEING OUT OF SERVICE. ORDER TO BE ISSUED. 08/10/02: MF ORDER TO BE ISSUED UNDER SPILL #0275245. THIS SPILL WILL BE CLOSED ALONG WITH SPILL #0275243.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 113

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DODGE RESIDENCE 4966 NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0275151

Close Date: 08/10/2002

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Affected Persons ROBERT DODGE MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: JOE BUCHER

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 925-7279 Contact Person Phone: (716) 928-2728

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/01/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER ALLEGES THAT LEAK IN CRUDE OIL WELL IS LEAKING INTO HIS SPRING. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 6/19/02:SAC TELECON CHRIS MILLER, DEC - MINERALS NOTIFYING HIM OF THE SPILL. 06/19/02: MF S/I/BOB DODGE, OWNER OF PROPERTY THAT LEAKING BDH HO-212 IS ON. THE WELL IS ABOVE HIS HOME & IS LEAKING CRUDE OIL. CRUDE OIL IS FLOWING TOWARD HIS SPRING THAT HE USES FOR ALL WATER EXCEPT FOR DRINKING. 06/20/02: MF E-MAIL TO CHRIS MILLER, REGARDING ABOVE. T/C CHRIS MILLER, JIM RUCINSKI, WILL INSPECT. 06/21/02: MF E-MAIL FROM CHRIS, JIM INSPECTED/BDH. LEAK REPAIRED AT HO-212. FURTHER INSPECTION REVEALED MAJOR PROBLEMS. THEY WANT SPILLS TO HANDLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 114

06/22/02: MF T/C DON PLEAKIS, OFFICE MEETING SCHEDULED FOR 6/25. 08/10/02: MF THIS SPILL BEING HANDLED UNDER SPILL #0275185. AN ORDER WAS ISSUED FOR THE WELL & WILL BE HANDLED UNDER 0275185. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY FOR THIS SPILL.******COMPUTER FILE ONLY**********

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 115

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL - HO-214 NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0275245

Close Date: 09/20/2005

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NICHOLS RUN RD Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC MIKE FRANKS JFOTTO

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: TOM DEFIBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7220 Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/05/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 30.00 GALLONS 30.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE INSPECTING CRUDE OIL PROBLEMS IN THE AREA NOTICED 3 LEAKS FROM WELL HO-214. FREE PRODUCT AROUND & UNDER WELL. WELL IS 10’ FROM CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/08/02: MF S/I/DON PLEAKIS, ECO. WELL HO-214 HAS A LEAKING GAS LINE VALVE, BLOW OFF VAVLE & PACKING. FREE PRODUCT AROUND & UNDER THE WELL. WELL IS 10’ FROM THE CREEK. SITE MEETING SCHEDULED TOMORROW WITH MINERALS & BDH OIL. 08/09/02: MF S/I/DON PLEAKIS, ECO, JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS/TOM DEFINBAUGH, JOE BUCHER, BDH OIL. JOE CLAIMED THIS WELL WAS JUST REPAIRED & THE SPILLAGE HAD BEEN CLEANED (SEE SPILL # 0275185). THERE ARE 2 LEAKS IN THE PIPING & 1 AT THE WELL HEAD. FREE PRODUCT WILL BE REMOVED ASAP. WELL IS OUT OF SERVICE. IT WILL BE REPAIRD. DON WILL ISSUE ORDER & FINE FOR THIS SPILL & 0227243 (LINE FROM HILL SIDE TO DITCH) & 0275244 (HO-29). 0275243 & 0275244 WILL BE CLOSED & HANDLED UNDER THIS SPILL WITH AN ORDER. 08/13/02: MF S/I/NOOS, LEAK AT HO-29 STOPPED. FP REMOVED, AREA NOT CLEANED. HO-214, LEAKS STOPPED, MOST OF THE FP REMOVED. AREA

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 116

NOT CLEANED. THE DRAIN FROM THE SOUTH SIDE OF NICHOLS RUN RD HAS BEEN PLUGGED. FP REMOVED, NO SOIL REMOVED. THE STAINED AREA AT THE POND SITE (HO-214 AREA) HAS NOT BEEN REMEDIATED. 11/06/02: MF LETTER TO RP, IF THEY DON’T DO REMEDIATION STATE WILL & THEY WILL BE INVOICED. RESPONSE BY 11/29/02. 11/29/02: MF NO RESPONSE FROM RP. 12/06/02: MF S/I SOIL PILE ON SITE. SAMPLED FOR DISPOSAL. 12/12/02: MF SAMPLE TO OP-TECH. 01/10/03: MF T/C/OP-TECH, JIM FOR A SITE VISIT TO SEE TERRAIN & WHAT IS NEEDED TO LOAD SOIL. THEY WILL USE WASTEMANAGEMENT FOR DISPOSAL VEHICLES. OP-TECH CAN NOT MAKE IT ON SITE TODAY. 01/14/03: MF PROCESSED UPSTATES $281.00 DISPOSAL SAMPLING INVOICE # 32536. 02/24/03: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $310.50 PP FOR JOB SITE VISIT, 1/10/03. INVOICE # 18430. 6/24/03 RECD OPTECH PAY PACK FOR $2087.72. DISPOSAL RECEIPTS INCLUDED. 08/06/03: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $2534.47 PP FOR LOADING REMAINING SOIL & TAKING IT TO CHAFFEE (RECEIPT INCLUDED), DUMPING CLEAN BACKFILL FOR LATER SPREADING, STRAW & SEEDING. 6/10 - 6/12, INVOICE # 20024. 09/08/03: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $343.28 PP FOR CALL OUT. RAIN STORM PREVENTED ACCESS & WASHED SPILL AWAY - SPILL NUMBER 0304224. INVOICE #20327, 7/22/03. 01/13/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $5617.09 PP FOR SITE RESTORATION WORK, 10/16/03 - 10/31/03, INVOICE #30558. 01/30/04: MF 30 DAY LETTER TO OP-TECH. 02/12/04: MF NO FURTGER INVOICES FROM OP-TECH. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ISR PENDING. 10/07/04: MF SPILL REOPENED TO DISPOSE OF SOIL FROM BDH SPILL #0103509. S/I TOOK SAMPLE FOR DIPOSAL. 10/08/04: MF SAMPLE TO OP-TECH FOR LSL. OP-TECH TO DISPOSE OF SOIL. 10/26/04: MF RECEIVED FAX OF DISPOSAL SAMPLING RESULTS. 11/19/04: MF FOR JFO, S/I/OP-TECH, TRYING TO LOAD OUT CONTAMINATED SOIL, TOO WET. 12/20/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $962.54 PP, FOR ATTEMPTING TO LOAD OUT CONTAMINATED SOIL. SOIL WAS TOO WET, THEY WILL RETRY IN THE SPRING. INVOICE #34365, 11/19/04. 12/27/04: MF PROCESSED LSL’S $152.52 PP FOR DISPOSAL SAMPLING, TAKEN 10/7/04, INVOICE #0417934-2344. 01/28/05: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $602.09 PP, INVOICE #34646, 12/10/04. JFO ON SITE WITH GARY HOUSE TRYING TO LOAD OUT SOIL. ALSO INCLUDED GERNATTS COST FOR 11/19/04.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 117

02/01/05: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $309.79 PP, INVOICE #34931, 12/22/04. FOR COVERING SOIL PILE PER JFO. 06/13/05 OP-TECH DROPPED OF 3 LOADS OF SAWDUST TO MIX WITH THE SLUDGE. 06/14/05 JFO ON SITE NO ONE AVAILABLE. THE SAWDUST WAS MIXED TODAY. ONLY EXCAVATOR ON SITE. 06/15/05 JFO ON SITE MET WITH DEKE AND HELPER. ON SITE ARE A BOXVAN, EXCAVATOR AND A DUMPTRUCK FROM GERNATT. THE 4TH AND FINAL LOAD IS GONE AT 1:30PM. THE PIT HAS BEEN BACKFILLED. 08/23/05 JFO RECEIVED THE PAY PACK FOR THE WORK DONE JUNE 13, 14 & 15 FOR $8746.80 08/29/05 JFO CALL TO GARY HOUSE OF OPTECH. WE ARE RETURNING THE PAY PACK FOR CORRECTIONS ON THE COSTS OF THE TRUCKS. 09/08/05 JFO RECEIVED THE REVISED PP FOR WORK DONE ON JUNE 13, 14 & 15 FOR $6442.12. SUBMITTED TO FG. 09/20/05 JFO REVIEWED FILE. SPILL CLEANUP COMPLETE. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSED 03/01/06 RMC/FILE. REQUESTED BUT DID NOT RECEIVE FEED BACK FROM ECO’s ON DISPOSITION OF CASE. SPILLS PART IS COMPLETED. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 118

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SHORT TRACK - OIL WELL HOLIDAY

Spill Number: 0275256

Close Date: 02/04/2003

GRANGER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen TIM WALSH MXFRANKS

Spiller: UNK Notifier Name: FLOYD ELDRIDGE Caller Agency: REGION 8 Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (585) 382-9152 Caller Phone: (716) 527-8415 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: COMPLAINT IF CRUDE OIL WELL LEAKING PRODUCT INTO THE RIVER. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/16/02: MF S/I AT GRAVEL PIT ON HOLIDAY RD. LOOKED FOR LEAKING WELL, NO LUCK. 08/19/02: MF T/C CALLER, TOLD ME WELL IS ACROSS CREEK APPX 900 DOWNSTREAM ON THE RIGHT. 10/08/02: MF S/I FOUND LEAKING WELL. IT IS ON THE NORTH SIDE OF BOTSFORD CREEK APPX 1000’ DOWN STREAM FROM THE TOWN’S SCREENING LOCATION ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF THE CREEK. THERE IS A 2’ CASING ON THE EDGE OF THE HIGH WATER MARK. THERE IS A POOL OF NEW & OLD OIL NEXT TO THE WELL. STAINING ON ROCKS TO THE CREEK APPX 20’ AWAY. T/C/CHRIS MILLER, HE WILL HAVE SOMEONE MEET ME THERE TOMORROW. 10/09/02: MF S/I/BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS & KEN BISSELI, ECO. SHOWED THEM PROBLEM. VISIT WITH PAUL BEARDSLEY, 10275 CR 15, FILLMORE, 14735, 585-567-8764, HE IS THE TOWN SUPERVISOR. HE HAS NOW OF PROBPLEM WITH THIS WELL SINCE HE WAS A KID. HE THINKS

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 119

DALE FOX MAY OWN LEASE. GPS USED TO POSITION WELL. 42 DEGREES 26 MINUTES, 13.56 SECONDS NORTH. 78 DEGREES, 2 MINUTES, 16.11 SECONDS, WEST. 10/10/02: MF T/C/DALE FOX, 814-368-5901. HE DRILLED A WELL IN GRANGER YEARS AGE. IT DIDN’T PRODUCE. HE CLAIMED HE DOSN’T OWN ANY LEASES IN THIS AREA. HE THINKS THEY HAVE REVERTED BACK TO THE LAND OWNERS. NOTIFIED PJB OF PROBLEM, THERE IS MEETING SCHEDULED WITH MINERALS. THIS WILL BE DISCUSSED, EPA WILL BE NOTIFED BY MINERALS. 10/16/02: MF T/C NRC OBTAINED NRC# 626324. 01/31/03: MF OLEAN OFFICE MEETING WITH CHRIS MILLER. MONERALS WILL BE THE LEAD DIVISION FOR THIS SPILL. 02/04/03: MF E-MAIL TO CHRIS MILLER CONFIRMING 1/31/03 MEETING. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 120

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LEE RESIDENCE 280 FOX HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 0265060

Close Date: 12/12/2002

COLESVILLE (T), NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Affected Persons EDNA LEE JEOKESSO

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

UNKNOWN EDNA LEE CITIZEN EDNA & EARL LEE

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (607) 775-5148 Caller Phone: (607) 775-5148 Contact Person Phone: (607) 775-5148

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/14/2002 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: STRONG ODOR IN HOME WHICH SMELLS LIKE BURNED OIL. HAS OCCURRED SEVERAL TIMES DURING THE LAST 2 WEEKS. NATURAL GAS WELL RECENTLY DRILLED NEARBY. COLUMBIA GAS HAS VISITED HOME AND FOUND NO NATURAL GAS PROBLEM. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JOS" 11/14/02 - VISITED HOME. INSPECTED BASEMENT. NOTED A SLIGHT ODOR- UNKNOWN. RESIDENCE INDICATED THAT ODORS HAVE BEEN STRONG FROM TIME TO TIME. MR. LEE PLUGGED FLOOR DRAIN. SLIGHT ODOR WHICH APPEARED TO HAVE AN ORGANIC ODOR/ IRON BACTERIA. COLUMBIA GAS WAS A RESIDENCE AND CHECKED HOUSE FOR NATURAL GAS - NO PROBLEM NOTED. NEW COLUMBIA GAS WELL HAS BEEN INSTALLED 1/2 TO 1 MILE AWAY. MR. LEE INDIACTED THAT OLD WATER WELL HAD SALT AND GASES IN WATER. NEW WELL DRILLED TO SOLVE PROBLEM OLD WELL IS LOCATED JUST OUTSIDE FOUNDATION WALL. FLOOR DRAIN IS TIED INTO OUTSIDE FOOTER DRAINS. POSSIBLE SOURCE OF PROBLEM. DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE A PETROLEUM PROBLEM. RESIDENCE HEATED WITH ELECTRIC PRIOR TO CONVERTING TO PROPANE. SUBURBAN PROPANE HAS BEEN AT HOME TWICE TO CHECK FURNACENO PROBLEMS FOUND. REQUESTED RESIDENCE TO CALL DEC IF ODOR REOCCURRS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 121

11/15/02 -CALLED COLUMBIA GAS. TOM SWEET WAS REP WHO VISITED SITE. 607-739-4831. 11/21/02 - SPOKE WITH MRS. LEE. NO ODORS NOTED SINCE LAST VISIT. SHE IS EXPERIENCING HEALTH PROBLEMS. SENT SPILL REPORT TO BCHD. JEO. 12/12/02 - NO CALLS RECIEVED FROM HOMEONWER. SPILL CLOSED.NO PETROLEUM INVOLVED. JEO.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 122

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL - 4 WELLS NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0275185

Close Date: 06/29/2005

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NICHOLS RUN RD Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC CHRIS MILLER MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: TOM DEFIBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/01/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DURING INSPECTION BY MINERALS FOR DIFFERENT SPILL MAJOR SPILLAGE AROUND WELLS HO-208, 210, 212 & 214. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/02/02: MF DON PLEAKIS, AL ALEXANDER SITE INSPECTION WITH TOM DEFFIBAUGH, BDH OIL. MINERALS PREVIOUSLY INSPECTED THIS SIT & FOUND WELLS THAT HAVE A MAJOR SPILLAGE PROBLEM. FOUND WELLS H0-208, 210, 212 & 214 TO HAVE WELL HEAD LEAKS THAT GOT OFF SITE. WELL HO-210 HAS A UG PIPING LEAK BY THE WELL HEAD. A HOLE WAS DUG BY THIS LEAK & THERE IS FREE PRODUCT IS IN THE HOLE. PIPE STILL LEAKING, TO BE REPAIRED. MET WITH CHRIS MILLER, IT WAS DETERMINED THAT AN ORDER ON CONSENT WILL BE WRITTED BY DON TO REPAIR LEAKS, CLEAN & DISPOSE OF CONTAMINATED SOIL & PAY A FINE. TENTATIVLY BY 8/15/02. DON CALLED TOM & TOM AGREED. 08/09/02: MF S/I/DON PLEAKIS, ECO, JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS/TOM DEFINBAUGH, JOE BOUCHER, BDH. INSPECTED THE FOLLING WELL. 208 - A SECTION OF LEAKING PIPE HAS BEEN REPLACES, SOIL TO BE REMOVED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 123

210 - WELL BEING SREVICED, SOIL WILL BE REMOVED BY 9/30/02. 212 - PACKING REPAIRED, STAINED SOIL. 214 - WE WERE TOLD THIS WELL HAD BEEN REPAIED. HOWEVER THERE IS FREE PRODUCT UNDER AND AROUND THIS WELL FROM 3 LEAKS. 1 VALVE ON GAS LINE. 1 VALVE ON BLOW OFF LINE & PACKING NUT. FREE PRODUCT TO BE REMOVED & WELL WILL BE REPAIRED. TOLD JOE & TOM SOIL MUST BE DISPOSED OF IN 60 DAYS OR HE WILL BE FINED. GAVE TOM WASTEMANAGEMENT CARD AS HE TOLD ME PA WANTS $100/TON FOR DISPOSAL. 08/28/02 RMC/ROBERT DODGE, 716-925-7279/PHONE. RMC ADVISED MR DODGE THAT THE RP HAS 60 DAYS FROM 8/9/02 TO DISPOSE OF THE CONTAMINATED SOIL. 11/06/02: MF LETTER TO RP, IF SOIL AT THE DODGE PROPERTY IS NOT DISPOSED OF BY 11/30/02, WE WILL DISPOSE OF IT. 06/29/05: MF BDH SHUT DOWN PRODUCTION 2 YEARS AGO. UNABLE TO LOCATE WELLS IN QUESTION. SOIL FOR THIS SPILL HAS BEEN DISPOSED OF, SEE JOHN OTTO’S FILE. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 124

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BUCHER - HORSE RUN HORSE RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0275147

Close Date: 11/05/2003

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons STEVEN DOMINSKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: JOE BUCHER - J.J. BUCHER Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: STEVEN DOMINSKI

Spiller Phone: (716) 928-2728 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 745-7169 Contact Person Phone: (716) 510-4281

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/01/2002 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PROPERTY OWNER SAYS THAT COMPANY HAS CRUDE OIL LEASES ON HIS PROPERTY. SAID THAT WELLS ARE IN A STATE OF DISREPAIR AND ARE LEAKING ALL OVER THE PROPERTY. CALLER ALLEGES THAT RUNOFF FROM WELLS IS RUNNING INTO A NEARBY CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 06/27/02: MF S/I/STEVE DOMINSKI, PROPERTY OWNER (90 ACRES) OF WHERE BOUCHER WELLS ARE ON. INSPECTED SOME AREAS MOST WELLS ARE NOT LABLED. ALL THE WELLS I LOOKED AT HAVE A SIGNIFIGANT SPILLAGE PROBLEM. THERE ARE CONTANMENT PONDS THAT ARE NOT LINED, HAVE A PROBLEM & SPILLAGE GETTING AWAY FROM THEM & THE WELLS. TWO WELLS THAT ARE LABLED & HAVE A PROBLEM ARE 60-003-074-6 & 58-003-01745. I MET WITH JOE BOUCHER LATER IN THE DAY & TOLD HIM OF THE PROBLEM . HE CLAIMED HE WILL LOOK INTO IT. 06/28/02: MF LETTER TO RP FOR REMEDIATION PLAN BY 7/31/02. 07/18/02: MF LETTER FROM RP, WELLS NUMBERED. WANTS TO KNOW WHAT ELSE TO DO.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 125

08/05/02: MF T/C/JOE BOUCHER, SITE MEETING SCHEDULED FOR 8/8/02. T/C CHRIS NMILLER, MINERALS, TOLD HIM OF MEETING. MINERALS DECLINED TO PARTICIPATE. I WAS TOLD WELLS 51, 46, 50, 43, 58, 48 & 14 HAVE A PROBLEM. 08/08/02: MF S/I/JOE BOUCHER & GREG MAXSON 814-368-1320, OWNERS OF THE LEASE (WHEELER LEASE). INSPECTED THE ABOVE WELLS. 51 - PARAFFIN AROUND WELL HEAD, WOODEN HOLDING TANK HAS SPILLAGE THAT MUST BE CLEANED. 46 - JOE CLAIMED WELL AREA CLEANED 8/6/02. THERE IS SOIL STAGED ON PLASTIC. PARIFFIN AT WELL HEAD. SPILLAGE AT SEPARATOR TANK. THERE IS AN UNLINED POND WITH SPILLAGE. 60 - THIS WELL WAS ’CLEANED’, SPILLAGE COVERED. MORE NEEDS TO BE DONE. SPILLAGE GETTING OFF SITE. 58 - SOIL REMOVED LAST WEEK. STEEL LEAD LINE REPLACED WITH PVC LINE. SPILLAGE UNDER THE JACK. LEAKING WELL HEAD. 48 - WELL SERVICED 8/7/02, WELL HEAD SPILLAGE, POND, SEPARATOR SPILLAGE. POND UNLINED, BAD PROBLEM. 14 - WELL HEAK, OK, PROBLEM AFTER SEPARATOR. 43 - FRESH SOIL COVERING SPILLAGE AROUND SEPARATOR TANK. HAS TO BE CLEANED. TOLD JOE WHAT MUST BE DONE BUT NOT TO DO ANYTHING UNTIL ORDER ISSUED. DON’T WANT ANY BACKFILLING DONE WITHOUT INSPECTION. 08/10/02: MF LETTER TO AM REFINING REQUESTION DIVISION ORDERS BY 8/30/02. 09/23/02: MF S/I/JOE BOUCHER, GREG MAXSON/DON PLEAKIS, TOM SCOTT, BRUCE HUMMEL, ECO’S/JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS. INSPECTED & FOUND TO FOLLOWING PROBLEMS: 51 - SEPARATOR TANK LEAKING TO A UNLINED SYPHON PIT & THERE IS OIL IN IT. 46 - PIPE LEAK PLUGED WITH A TWIG. WELL HEAD LEAK. SEPARATOR TANK LEAK & OIL IN AN UNLINED POND. 60 - SPILLAGE COVERED WITH FRESH SOIL. HAS TO BE CLEANED. 14 - OIL RUNOFF FROM THE SEPARATOR. 57-58 - PIT IS UNLINED WITH OIL ATOP IT. 48 - MAJOR RUNOFF PROBLEM DOWN A STEEP HILL INTO A UNLINED PIT & INTO SWAMPY AREA. SEPARATOR TANK WILL BE MOVED. 43 & 58 - CAN LIVE WITH BRUCE TO WRITE ORDER. MINERALS MAY MONITOR. 10/16/02: MF RETURNED STEVE DOMINSKI’S CALL, 745-7169. DISCUSSED SITE STATUS. 10/17/02: MF MESSAGE FROM JOE BUECHER, HE WANTS ORDER BEFORE HE STARTS ANY WORK. E-MAIL TO TOM SCOTT REGARDING THIS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 126

10/18/02: MF LETTER FROM JOE’S LAWYER. DOSN’T APPRECIATE FINE WITHOUT SUMMONS & WANT OPPORTUNITY TO DEFEND. 10/28/02: MF FAXED 10/18/02 LETTER TO CHRIS MILLER, ALSO GAVE COPY TO ECO’S. T/C J MICHAEL SHANE, 372-4838, JOE’S LAWYER. LEFT MESSAGE. 10/31/02: MF MESSAGE FROM BRUCE HUMMEL, ECO, HE TRIED TO HAVE JOE SIGN ORDER, NO LUCK. JOE WANTS HIS LAWYER TO LOOK AT IT. T/C MIKE SHANE, LEFT MESSAGE. 11/04/02: MF MEMO FROM JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS. HE INSPECTED THE 6 AREAS OF CONCERN, WELL #51, 46, 60, 14, 57 & 48 (SEPARATER AREAS INCLUDED). ALL THE CONTAMINATED SOIL HAS BEEN REMOVED & STOCK PILED & COVERED WITH PLASTIC. IT IS AWAITING TESTING & DISPOSAL. 11/12/02: MF APPX, BRUCE HUMMEL ISSUED ORDER, JOE SIGNED IT & PAID FINE. 03/14/03: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 3/31/03. 04/08/03: MF 2ND DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 4/30/03. 05/08/03: MF 3RD DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 5/20/03. 05/10/03: MF S/I/STEVE DOMINSKI, PROPERTY OWNER. SDS LINED LUGGER ON SITE. COMTAMINATED SOIL PILE BEING DISPOSED OF. DROVE AROUND LEASE IN 4 WHEELER. NEW SPILLAGE, SEE SPILL #0375071. 10/22/03: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 10/31/03. MIKE SHANE, 2646 W STATE ST, OLEAN 14760. 716-372-4848. 11/05/03: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 127

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL POOL NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0275187

Close Date: 01/24/2003

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NICHOLS RUN RD Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC AL ALEXANDER MXFRANKS

Spiller: STEVE SHERK - AMERICAN REFINING Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: TOM DEFIBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (814) 368-1200 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/01/2002 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 500.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: POOL OF CRUDE OIL COMING OUT OF THE GROUND AT THE SIDE OF A HILL ON BDH LEASE. LAND OWNED BY AMERICAN REFINING. SPILL IS BETWEEN WELLS HO-216 & 219. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/02/02: MF S/I/AL ALEXANDER, MINERALS, DON PLEAKIS, ECO/TOM DEFIBAUGH, BDH OIL. WHILE INSPECTING ANOTHER SPILL WAS SHOWN THIS SPILL. CRUDE OIL & BRINE FLOWING INTO A POND ON THE SIDE OF A HILL AT 3 DIFFERENT LOCATIONS. NO PIPING OR LEAKING WELLS IN THE AREA. MEETING WITH CHRIS MILLER, PROBLEM MAY BE INJECTION WELLS CAUSING WELL LIQUID TO BE RELEASED FROM AN ABANDON WELL. AMERICAN REFINING OWNS PROPERTY. 07/03/02: MF T/C STEVE SHERK, LEFT MESSAGE TO CALL ME. 07/05/02: MF T/C STEVE SHERK, TOLD HIM OF THE PROBLEM. THEY MAY HAVE BOUGHT PROPERTY FORM WITCO. TOLD HIM WE HAVE AMERICAN REFINING LISTED AS THE PROPERTY OWNER & AS SUCH A PRP. HE WILL CHECK INTO OWNERSHIP & WHO HAS ROYALTY RITES. TOLD HIM FOR NOW TO

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 128

KEEP PRODUCT FROM GETTING OFF PONDING AREA. 08/06/02: MF T/C STEVE SHERK, LEFT MESSAGE TO CALL ME. 08/07/02: MF T/C STEVE SHERK, AMERICAN BIOCHEMICAL, SUITE 215, 100 FOUR FALLS CORP CENTER, WEST CONSHOHOCKEN, PA 19428, IS THE LAND OWNER & THEY OWN AMERICAN REFINING. LAWYER IS JOE LUCIANA, 412-355-8982. T/C JOE LUCIANA, LEFT MESSAGE. 08/08/02: MF T/C/JOE LUCIANA, 412-612-8776. ASKED FOR DIVISION ORDERS. HE WILL CHECK INTO IT. 08/10/02: MF LETTER TO AM REFINING, REQUESTING DIVISION ORDERS BY 8/30/02. 08/22/02: MF T/C HARVEY GOLUBOCK, ARG. HE DOES NOT HAVE ENOUGH INFO TO GIVE HE WILL TRY AGAIN. GENE CORNELIUS, MANAGER OF CRUDE OIL PRODUCTION. DAVE MANN DOES DIVISION ORDERS 814-368-1320. HE WILL HAVE DAVE CALL ME. 10/02/02: MF S/I/CHRIS MILLER, JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS/TOM SCOTT, BRUCE HAMMEL, DON PLEAKIS, GARY BOBSINE, ECO’S/JOE BOUCHER, TOM DIFEBAUGH, BDH OIL. LOOKED OVER OIL POOL AREA. CHRIS THINKS THE SEEP IS DUE TO THE HIGH PRESSURE WATER INJECTION. WATER IS FORCING OIL OUT OF AN ABANDON OIL WELL. MINERALS WILL TAKE THE LEAD. 01/23/03: MF T/C CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS. THEY HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THE SOURCE WITH BDH OIL. NOTHING AS YEY, THEY WILL KEEP AT IT. 01/24/03: MF E-MAIL TO MINERALS, OUR SPILL FILE WILL BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 129

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BRINE AT STORAGE FIELD 931 LAMPE RD (AF)

Spill Number: 0175145

Close Date: 06/14/2001

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROB GREGORESKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: ROB GREGORESKI - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL Contact for more spill info: STATION PHONE NUMBER IS

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone: (716) 593-1665

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/12/2001 06/14/2001 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LINE WAS OVERPRESSURIZED AND CAUSED BRINE/FRESH WATER MIXTURE TO SPILL OUT OF LINE AND ONTO FARMER’S PROPERTY, MR. GREGORESKI WILL BE GOING OUT TO SIT THIS AFTERNOON. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 06/13/01: MF S/I/ROB GREGORESKI, BOB, NATIONAL FUEL. LINE FROM STATION ON PEET RD TO STORAGE FIELD ON LAMPE RD [ACROSS FROM 931] WAS IN THE PROCESS OF BEING CLEANED WITH WATER DUE TO SALT BUILD UP. PRESSURE RELIEF LET GO & AN UNDETERMINED AMOUNT OF SALT WATER WAS RELEASED. BRINE CONTAINS NO PCB’S OR CRUDE OIL. NO SALT STAINS OR DISTRESSED VEGETATION NOTICED. ALL LIQUID ABSORBED IN THE GROUND. OWNER OF THE PROPERTY AWARE OF SPILL. MINERALS AWARE OF SPILL. NON PET, NON-HAZ, NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 130

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATURAL GAS LINE LEAK ROUTE 39 & ROUTE 219

Spill Number: 0075582

Close Date: 01/25/2001

BELMONT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: ROUTE 39 / ROUTE 219 Revised zip code: 14813 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ED THORPE FXGALLEG

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 283-3963 Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/01/2001 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NATURAL GAS LEAK FOR 8 YEARS. NORTH SIDE OF ROUTE 17 & RTE 39 BEHIND WHAT USED TO BE A RECYCLING CENTER, 1/2 MILE UP THE HILL BEHIND. IT IS CURRENTLY A BAD LEAK. LEAKING BETWEEN THE TWO FLANGES. GAS LINE COMES FROM HESS RD -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 01/25/01: FG TELECON JACK DAHL WITH MINERALS. HE SAID HE WOULD NOT AND IS NOT OBLIGATED TO DO ANYTHING ABOUT THE LEAK. HE GAVE ME THE PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION TELEPHONE NUMBER AND TOLD ME TO REPORT IT THERE. I CALLED THE NUMBER AND IT WAS CONSTANTLY BUSY. FG CALLED NATIONAL FUEL, CHRIS CEJ, WHO SAID HE WILL CALL MR. THORPE AND INSPECT THE SITE. HE SAID THAT IF THE LEAK IS NATIONAL FUEL’S HE WILL TAKE CARE OF IT. IF THE LINE IS OWNED BY SOMEONE ELSE, NATIONAL FUEL WILL NOTIFY THEM. NO FURTHER WORK IS REQUIRED. THE SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 131

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

WELL AT LAKESHORE SCHOOL ERIE ROAD

Spill Number: 9812986

Close Date: 01/22/1999

ANGOLA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14006 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Citizen HELEN LEMKE JFOTTO

Spiller: FRANK NICOTRA - LAKESHORE SCHOOL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 549-2300 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 549-1691 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/20/1999 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: caller states strong concern for odor of natural gas permeating area for 2 days. kids are coming home sick from school. other area residents feeling sick from odor which national fues states is from spill of odor additive to area gas wells -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 01/22/99: JFO REFERRED TO DIVISION OF AIR. NO ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS. 01/28/99: JFO TELECON WITH KEVIN CONNOLY OF LAKESHORE MIDDLE SCHOOL (549-2336). THE LEAKING ABOVEGROUND ODORANT TANK WAS DISCONNECTED AND NEUTRALIZED. THEY WILL REMOVE THE TANK. I NOTIFIED BRIAN JANDREW OF MINERAL RESOURCES IN OLEAN:

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 132

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ELISABETH CRANDAL WELL PINE RIDGE ROAD

Spill Number: 9605621

Close Date: 05/21/1997

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Local Agency MICHAEL VENDETTE FXGALLEG

Spiller: MR SOUTHWELL - RUSSELL SOUTHWELL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY HEALTH Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 757-8527 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 753-4481 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/19/1996 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: FIRE/EXPLOSION AT OIL WELL TANK CAUSED CRUDE TO FLOW OUT -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 7/19/96 MAV SITE VISIT. ON 7/19/96, AT 0300 HRS LIGHTNING STRUCK AN OIL WELL STORAGE TANK. THE TANK WAS LOCATED ACROSS FROM 53 PINE RIDGE RD IN BUSTI. THE TANK STARTED ON FIRE AND CAUSED OIL TO FLOW INTO A CONTAINMENT PIT NEXT TO THE TANK. OIL SOAKED SOIL WAS ALSO FOUND ON THE EDGE AND OUTSIDE THE PIT AREA. MAV SPOKE W/ MR. RUSSELL W. SOUTHWELL OIL LEASEE. MR SOUTHWELL’S ADDRESS IS RD#3 BOX 175, SUGAR GROVE, PA, 16350 PHONE # (814)757-8527. THE OIL LEASEE NAME IS ELIZABETH CRANDAL. THE NEIGHBOR ACROSS THE ST, MIKE VOLPE, 53 PINE RIDGE RD, JAMESTOWN, 14701 (709)664-0853 WAS A WITNESS TO SAID FIRE. MAV TOLD MR. SOUTHWELL THAT HE MUST REMOVE THE OIL FROM THE PIT AND REMOVE THE CONTAMIANTED SOIL. MR SOUTHWELL STATED THAT THE WELL PRODUCES 300 BBLS OF CRUDE (12,000 GAL) PER YR. MAV TOLD HIM HE WOULD RECEIVE A LTR AND TO CONTACT MAV REGARDING CLEANUP 8/1/96 LTR SENT TO MR. SOUTHWELL REQUIRING CLEANUP & RESPONSE BY 8/30/96.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 133

8/7/96 MAV SITE VISIT. RUN OFF PIT HAS BEEN PUMPED OUT. OIL AND BRINE RESIDUE DRIED ON SIDE WALLS. OIL CONTAMINATED SIDEWALLS OF PIT AND SMALL AREA OUTSIDE PIT REMAIN. MTG W/ R. DUFF ON SITE TO REVIEW CLEANUP. DUFF REQUESTED AS SUBCONTRACTOR OF JOE GERLOCK CONTRACTOR FOR SPILLER. WILL CONTACT SPILLER REGARDING CLEANUP. 12/11/96 FG MF SITE VISIT. SOIL STAGED ON SITE. SPILL HAS BEEN CLEANED UP. MR. DUFF SAID THAT HE WILL REMOVE & DISPOSE SOIL ONCE GROUND HARDENS. 2/11/97 LTR SENT TO MR. SOUTHWELL REQUIRING DISPOSAL RECPT. RESPONSE IS DUE BY 2/21/97. 2/14/97 MR. SOUTHWELL CALLED. HE SAID THAT A MR. GERDAK WAS SUPPOSED TO HAUL SOIL BUT HASN’T DONE IT YET. THE DIRT IS LIKE AN ICE BLOCK. HE WOULD LIKE TO WAIT UNTIL SPRING(3/21/97). I TOLD HIM THAT WAS OK. HE WILL GET ME THE DISPOSAL RECEIPT WHEN IT IS DISPOSED. 3/12/97 MAV SUBMITTED REPORT INDICATING THAT HE IS WAITING FOR SOIL DISPOSAL RECPTS. FG DELETED THIS AS A CHCHD SPILL. 4/22/97 RNL SITE VISIT. SOIL REMAINS STAGED ON PROPERTY. 4/24/97 SPOKE TO MRS. SOUTHWELL. SHE SAID THAT MR. SOUTHWELL RECENTLY HAD A HEART ATTACK. SHE SAID HE WILL DISPOSE OF THE SOIL WITHIN THE NEXT SEVERAL MONTHS ONCE HE GETS OUT OF BED. I TOLD HER THAT THAT WAS OK AND THAT SHE SHOULD SEND A DISPOSAL RECPT TO THIS OFFICE WHEN THE WORK IS COMPLETE. 5/12/97 RECD DISPOSAL RECPT FOR SOIL. 5/21/97 MAV SITE VISIT. SOIL HAS BEEN REMOVED FROM SITE. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 134

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SWINGLER (GEORGE) ESTATE COUNTY ROAD 37

Spill Number: 9405127

Close Date: 08/28/1994

RICHMOND, NY 14471

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Affected Persons JIM SWINGLE DLTILTON

Spiller: EMPIRE EXPLORATION Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 367-2392 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/01/1993 08/28/1994 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER REPORTED DEAD GRASS, SAPLING & TREES EVIDENT ON ADJACENT PROPERTY WHERE NATURAL GAS DRILLING WAS PERFORMED LAST FALL BY EMPIRE EXPLORATION. CONTACT: CALLER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "DT" 07/12/94: AFFECTED AREA APPROX 12’ WIDE X 400-600’ LONG & RUNS DOWNGRADIENT. CALLER IS PART OWNER OF INHERITED ESTATE & LIVES AT 4732 CO ROAD 37. CALLER BELIEVES SOMETHING FROM DRILLING OPERATIONS WAS SPILLED.. 07/12/94: ...AND CAUSED DISTRESS TO VEGETATION. 08/28/94: TILTON ON SITE 07-27-94; CHECKED AREA AND NOTED DISTRESSED VEGETATION. SPILL FORWARDED TO MINERALS FOR FOLLOW-UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS. 01/06/06: PAPER FILE REMOVED PER FILE RETENTION POLICY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 135

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FRANK PAGANO 784 DEER STREET

Spill Number: 8903818

Close Date: 09/22/1989

DUNKIRK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14048 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE VENDETTE Caller Agency: CHCHD Caller Phone: (716) 753-4481 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/13/1989 09/22/1989 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 1000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER CONPLAINED OF RUNOFF FROM RAILROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY KILLED GRASS ON HIS PROPERTY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/17/89: MF MAV TELECON HE WILL LOOK AT SPILL & IF NECESSARY TAKE A SAMPLE. 07/17/89: MF MAV SITE VISIT, CONSIDERABLE GRASS KILL. TOOK SAMPLE TO HAVE ANALIZED FOR NA, CL, & PH. 09/18/89: SAMPLE RESUTLS RECEIVED, SALT BRINE FOUND, PROBABLY FROM DUMPING FROM A WELL DRILLING TRUCK, NO CELANUP POSSIBLE, SITE CLOSED. 09/22/89: MF RECEIVED ANAYLITICAL RESULTS (WEATHERED BRINE). SENT LETTER TO AFFECTED PARTY. NO SPILLER, ALL BILLS IN & PAID. NO FUTHER ACTION POSSIBE BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 136

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL 200 FEET SOUTH OF 11747 BIXBY HILL RD

Spill Number: 0900313

Close Date: 04/14/2009

FREEDOM, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14065 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: JFOTTO

Spiller: DALE FOX - DALE FOX - AJAX Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: MILFORD DRAKE

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (585) 492-3614

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/08/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Crude oil is leaking from one of the tanks from the oil well. May be spraying off top of tank...spraying into field. Some of it went beyond containment. Mr Drake called to notify that clean up is not adequate; only wood chips were used. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 04/09/09 JFO ON SITE MET WITH PROPERTY OWNER MILFORD DRAKE AND DAVID LAUER FROM THE OIL CO. THERE WAS A MINOR SPILL DUE TO THE HIGH WINDS AND A FULL HOLDING TANK. MR LAUER SAID HE REPORTED IT TO CHRIS MILLER IN MINERALS. CALL WAS VERIFIED BY CHRIS MILLER. 04/09/09 MR DRAKE CALLED THE SPILL HOTLINE AGAIN AT 19:20. HE SAID THE SPILL HAS NOT BEEN CLEANED UP PROPERLY. I WAS NOTIFIED AND I CALLED MR DRAKE BACK AND TOLD HIM I WILL INSPECT SITE MONDAY. 04/13/09 JFO ON SITE MET WITH MR DAVE LAUER. THE AREA HAS BEEN CLEANED UP. MR LAUER INDICATED THAT MR DRAKE IS SATISFIED. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 137

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

THE JOSEPH WELL SITE LEBANON CENTER ROAD

Spill Number: 0902301

Close Date: 06/01/2009

LEBANON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13085 Source of Spill:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL

Notifier Type: Other Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cxrossi

Spiller: DOUG STEBBINS - NORNEW, INC Spiller Phone: BILLY JACK EDWARDS - WEATHERFORD INTERNATIONAL LTD Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: Contact for more spill info: DOUG STEBBINS Contact Person Phone: (716) 969-1482

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/27/2009 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected OTHER PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Due to unk reasons the product spilled to soil. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Nornew safety officer, Doug Stebbins reported that drillers on site spilled less than 5 of sudsy material on ground, which then flowed down an embankment. Nornew workers soaked up all excess fluid with absorbent materials. MSDS lists Durafoam as methanol 3-7% and the undiluted product as ignitable with a waste number of U154 for ignitable waste. Norew estimates diluted material which was spilled to ground was in ratio or 40:2, water to Durafoam, respectively. Therefore Nornew is required to sample remaining soil for ignitability.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Soil analtical received 5/29/09 indicates that it is non ignitable therefor not hazardous. Also not petroleum. Minerals inspector had concerns that may affect down gradient livestock spring so Nornew required to sample. Showned nd for MBAS. Will repeat sampling in one week to confirm. Madison Co Health Advised. Follow up by Mineral staff.

Page 138

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 139

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

EXCHANGE OIL & GAS LEASE EAST OF ROUTE 248

Spill Number: 0901144

Close Date: 05/04/2009

REXVILLE, NY 14877

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: pclinden

Spiller: JOHN J. RYAN - EXCHANGE OIL & GAS, INC. Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/09/2009 05/04/2009 HOUSEKEEPING YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE INSPECTING AN OIL LEASE, JODI ROSPENDOWSKI FOUND OIL LEAKAGE FROM 3 WELLHEADS BEHIND THE WETLAND EAST OF ROUTE 248: EDWARDS WELL #1 (API: 31-101-04431, Coordinates: -77.73278, 42.06745): ROSPENDOWSKI INSPECTION REPORT: "There is a small amount of oil leaking from the wellhead."; EDWARDS WELL #6 (API: 31-101-16173, Coordinates: -77.73055, 42.06795): ROSPENDOWSKI INSPECTION REPORT: "There is a considerable amount of oil leaking from the wellhead and hay bales and pads are being used to soak it up (photo 22-30). There is an area of contaminated soil around the wellhead that is approximately 2 ft. by 6 ft (photo 31). Surface water contaminated with oil from the well is running directly into a protected trout stream and state and federal wetlands. Operator has attempted to soak up the oil that is leaving the site with pads placed in the road ditches that lead to the stream (photo 21, 27)"; EDWARDS WELL #14, (API: 31-101-16174,Coordinates: -77.73073, 42.06572): ROSPENDOWSKI INSPECTION REPORT: "There is an area of contaminated soil around the wellhead that is approximately 2 ft. by 3 ft (photo 20). Surface water contaminated with oil from the well is running into a protected trout stream and state and federal

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 140

wetlands...There is a considerable amount of oil floating on the top of the pit and the surrounding berm has been purposely channeled to allow oil and water to course over the bank into the wetlands (photos 11-15). The pit is currently overflowing into the sate and federal wetland area (photos 8-10)." -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: THE SPILL IS BEING HANDLED BY MINERALS UNIT WHICH WILL REQUIRE CLEANUP AND WILL ISSUE NOTICE OF VIOLATION. COPY FORWARDED TO LAW ENFORCEMENT. NO ACTION BY SPILLS IS NECESSARY. 5/4/09 LINDENFELSER INSPECTED SITE WHICH IS ON EAST SIDE OF RT 248 WHERE THE TWO LARGE, GREEN VERTICAL CRUDE OIL TANKS ARE JUST OFF THE ROAD: JUST NORTH OF THE TANKS IS A WETLAND BOUND TRIBUTARY THAT APPEARED BLACK AS WITH OXIDIZED OIL BUT WHICH UPON CLOSE INSPECTION WAS MERELY BLACKENED WITH DECAYING LEAVES; GOING UPHILL ON THE LITTLE USED LOGGING ROAD PL FOUND THE BRINE COLLECTION POND WITH THE FAILED LINER OFF TO THE RIGHT OF THE TRAIL: THERE WAS NO FLOATING OIL PRESENT; FURTHER EAST UPHILL AT A FORK IN THE TRAIL PL FOUND THE FIRST OF THE TWO LEAKING WELLS REPORTED BY MINERALS: IT WAS SURROUNDED WITH HAY TO ABSORB OIL LEAKING FROM THE PUMPJACK; A COUPLE HUNDRED YARDS UP THE NORTH LEG, PL FOUND THE SECOND LEAKY WELLHEAD/PUMPJACK: PL FOUND NO LONG DISTANCE SPILLAGE IMMEDIATELY THREATENING THE WETLANDS OR WATERWAYS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 141

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

TEXAN BRINE PROPERTY 1346 SALTVALE ROAD

Spill Number: 0905535

Close Date: 08/25/2009

WYOMING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14591 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: RJJONAK

Spiller: MATT SLEZAK - TEXAN BRINE CO. Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: MATT SLEZAK

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (585) 495-6228

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/12/2009 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 45000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THAT DUE TO HUMAN ERROR,45,000 GAL OF BRINE LEAKED OUT FROM AN OPEN VALVE,ALL ON THEIR PROPERTY...TEXAN BRINE WILL MONITOR...NONE OF THE BRINE LEFT OFF-SITE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 8/12/2009: MATT SLEZAK,TEXAN BRINE,TELECON RJJ,HE SAID THAT DUE TO HUMAN ERROR,AN OPENED VALVE SPILLED OUT ~45,000 GAL OF BRINE,ALL ON THEIR PROPERTY...TEXAN BRINE SHUT THE VALVE,STOPPING THE SPILL AND WILL NOW MONITOR THE SPILL...NONE OF THE BRINE REACHED ANY WATERWAYS,IT IS IN AN OPEN FIELD,ALL ON THEIR PROPERTY...I NOTIFIED BRIAN JANDREW,DEC MINERALS,OLEAN,HE WILL INVESTIGATE TOMORROW & FOLLOW UP ON SPILL AND CALL ME BACK. 8/17/2009: BRIAN JANDREW TELECON RJJ,HE SAID THAT HE INVESTIGATED THE SPILL & THAT THIS ONLY AFFECTED A SMALL AREA OF GRASS(EVENTHOUGH IT WAS 45,000 GALS. OF BRINE),WHICH IS ALL ON THEIR PROPERTY...NO WATERWAYS WERE AFFECTED...BRIAN SAID THAT NO FURTHER ACTION WILL BE NEEDED & HE WILL FORWARD ME PICTURES. 8/25/2009: BRIAN JANDREW E-MAILED ME ALL THE PICTURES FROM THE SPILL SITE,WHICH I INCLUDED IN E-DOCS...SINCE THIS WAS A

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

NON-PETROLEUM SPILL & BRIAN JANDREW(MINERALS) RESPONDED,NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED...SPILL CLOSED OUT. ***** NOTE,COMPUTER FILE ONLY *****

Page 142

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 143

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS WELL BETWEEN 4740-4781 PARKER ROAD

Spill Number: 0902327

Close Date: 06/05/2009

WESTFIELD, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14787 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: JFOTTO

Spiller: TIM HULL - RANGE RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: TIM HULL

(716)753-3385

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (202) 495-7170

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/28/2009 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 800.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 20 BBLS OF BRINE WAS RELEASED TO A FIELD 1200 YDS EAST OF THE PARKER ADDRESSES. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 06/04/09 JFO ON SITE NOA. THE AREA (15’ X 20’) HAS BEEN DUG. NO OTHER IMPACTS OBSERVED. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 144

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL WELL 3978 FORDS BROOK ROAD

Spill Number: 0850111

Close Date: 04/29/2008

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: jfotto

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/01/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PRODUCT BEING SPILLED AS A RESULT OF OPERATION OF A WELL. THEY ARE GREEN AND ORANGE JACKS. THE SPILL IS ABOUNT 30 YARDS OFF THE ROAD OVER A BANK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 04/24/08 JFO ON SITE NOA. THERE ARE 2 WELLS THAT HAVE SPILLS. WOOD CHIPS HAVE BEEN SPREAD ON BOTH AREAS AROUND THE WELL HEADS. UNABLE TO ESTIMATE THE AMOUNT OF SPILLAGE. WILL CONTACT MINERALS. 04/25/08 JFO TELCON WITH CHRIS MILLER WITH MINERALS. HE WILL CONTACT MR QUAINTENCE WHO OWNS THE LEASE. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSED 04/29/08 JFO CALL FROM BRIAN J WITH MINERALS. THE LEASE IS OWNED BY DRAGON EYE OIL CO NOT QUAINTENCE. THE SPILL WILL BIOLOGICALLY REMEDIATE ITSELF.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 145

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATURAL GAS WELL SITE #625263 ZWICK ROAD/ROUTE 414

Spill Number: 0802654

Close Date: 06/09/2008

FAYETTE, NY 13065

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cahetten

Spiller: CHESAPEAKE ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: JODY WEIDNER

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (315) 481-7142

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/07/2008 06/09/2008 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE OR SALT WATER ESTIMATED TO BE GREATER THAN 15 BARRELS (42 GALLONS IN BARREL) CALLER REPORTS A TANK OVERFLOW CAUSED THE SPILL TO OCCUR. SPILL HAS BEEN CONTAINED IN GRAVEL. CLEANED UP ALL THAT THEY COULD IN VACUUM TRUCK. THEY WILL BE DIGGING UP SOIL STARTING SOMETIME TOMORROW AFTERNOON AND WILL HAUL IT TO A LANDFILL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 06/08/08: CH TELECON WITH JODY WEIDNER OF CHESAPEAKE. THE RELEASE OCCURED WHEN A NEW WELL TENDER EVIDENTLY WAS NOT PAYING CLOSE ENOUGH ATTENTION WHEN HE WAS PUMPING BRINE FROM THE WELL INTO A 100 BARREL HOLDING TANK. ACCORDING TO WEIDNER ALL BRINE WAS CONTAINED TO THE WELL SITE. THEY ARE PLANNING TO HAVE DJ RAUSCHER EXCAVATE THE IMPACTED SOIL ON MONDAY AFTERNOON 6/9/08. A COPY OF SPILL WILL BE FORWARDED TO MINERALS FOR THEIR INFORMATION FOLLOWUP. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 146

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PRIVATE RESIDENCE 226 HILLSIDE DRIVE

Spill Number: 0801599

Close Date: 07/28/2008

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: rmcrosse

Spiller: CARL A. MCCRACKEN, III - CARL A. MCCRACKEN, III Spiller Phone: Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: Contact for more spill info: CLIFFORD BAKER Contact Person Phone: (716) 925-7407

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/27/2008 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Also spoke to Janet Baker, homeowner. Caller was her son. Noticed an ordor and color in their house water that was like kerosene. The spiller information is the name on a drilling permit that is drilling behind her home, and it stated when they started drilling is when the problems started to occur. Culligan is being sent there Monday by the driller to have it tested, but in the meantime they are unable to use the water, -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 05/09/2008 RMC/LARRY SITZMAN, DUTY OFFICER/PHONE. PROBLEM STARTED TWO WEEKS AGO. DRILLER IS AWARE OF THE PROBLEM, LARRY SITZMAN WILL CONTACT CHRIS MILLER AND THE HOME OWNER. WILL CALL BACK IF RESPONSE IS NEEDED. 05/12/08 RMC/LARRY SITZMAN. MINERALS WILL LOOK AT TODAY. RMC NOTIFIED ERIC WOHLERS, CATT COUNTY DOH. FAXED SPILL SHEET. THEY WILL CONTACT CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS FOR INFORMATION. WILL CALL IF ANY RESOURCES ARE NEEDED. UPDATE 5/20/08. 05/19/08 RMC/FILE. LEFT MESSAGE FOR ERIC WHOLERS AND CHRIS MILLER ADVISING THEM TO CONTACTED ME IF THEY NEED ANY ASSISTANCE. 07/28/08 RMC/FILE. NO ASSISTANCE REQUESTED OF SPILLS. CLOSE OUT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

NO PAPER FILE.

Page 147

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 148

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

RESIDENCE 209 BACK WEST CREEK RD

Spill Number: 0811696

Close Date: 02/25/2009

CANDOR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13743 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: clwarner

Spiller: FRED MAYER - UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: FRED MAYER

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/26/2009 02/25/2009 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected OTHER

PETROLEUM

0.00

UNKNOWN

0.00

UNKNOWN

SOIL GROUNDWATER DRINKING WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Caller states that he can ignite his drinking water that comes out of the faucet. This has been happening since approx. one year ago. Caller has not had his water tested and is concerned about natural gas drilling near him. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Homeowner was referred to Div. of Minerals in Region 8 and advised to have well properly vented.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 149

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SOUTH ONTO WELL ROAD RT 96/ YELLOW TAVERN ROAD

Spill Number: 0802757

Close Date: 06/10/2008

YOST CORNERS, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13165 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: jrmarchi

Spiller: JODY WEIDNER - CHESAPEAKE ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: JODY WEIDNER

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (315) 481-7142

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/09/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SALT WATER IS THE MATERIAL SPILLED AT AROUND 4 TO 5 BARRELS; 4 BY 15 AREA EFFECTED; CLEAN UP SCHEDULED; -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 06/10/08 FORWARDED TO MINERALS FOR PROPER FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION IS NEEDED BY SPILLS. CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 150

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

MARTIN #4 WELL #626326 NEILSON ROAD

Spill Number: 0711754

Close Date: 02/07/2008

ROMULUS, NY 14541

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Other Caller Name: DEC Investigator: dltilton

Spiller: KEVIN PATTERSON - MARTIN #4 WELL #626326 Spiller Phone: Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: Contact for more spill info: KEVIN PATTERSON Contact Person Phone: (304) 472-4103 ext. 23

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/07/2008 02/07/2008 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES AN OVERFLOW OF CONTAINMENT OF A TANK. APPROXIMATELY 20 BARRELS OF SALT BRINE WAS SPILLED. VAC TRUCK HAS BEEN BROUGHT IN AND ALL CLEANED UP. NOTHING ESCAPED AND ALL WAS CONTAINED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: FORWARDED TO MINERALS. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS UNIT AT THIS TIME. SPILL CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 151

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CARPENTER #1 WELL COUNTY RT 103

Spill Number: 0713372

Close Date: 03/19/2008

TROUPSBURG, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: COUNTY HIGHWAY 103 Revised zip code: 14885 Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Notifier Type: Responsible Party Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cahetten

Spiller: JAMIE WADE - STEWART T. WILLSON FUELS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: DAN MULLINS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/18/2008 03/18/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected DIESEL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PETROEDGE IS ON SCENE CONDUCTING CLEAN UP; -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 03/18/08: CH TELECON WITH DAN MULLINS CONCERNING THE SPILL. ACCORDING TO MULLINS, THEY WERE HAVING CARPENTER #1 WELL FRACKED. STEWART WILSON FUELS HAD A TRUCK ON SITE TO FUEL THE FRACK TRUCKS. WHILE FUELING THE TRUCKS A PIECE OF METAL FELL ON THE DELIVERY HOLE AND PUNCTURED THE HOSE. BY THE TIME THE LEAK WAS DISCOVERED AND THE DELIVERY STOPPED, IT WAS ESTIMATED APPROXIMATELY 50 GALLONS OF DIESEL WAS LOST. THE FUEL WAS CONTAINED TO THE WELL LOCATION AND PRIMARILY STAYED IN THE TIRE RUTS MADE BY THE TRUCKS. PETROEDGE APPLIED ABSORBENT PADS AND PICKED UP ALL THE FREE DIESEL THEY COULD. THEY THEN PUT DOWN SAW DUST TO PICK UP ANY REMAINING PETROLEUM. MULLINS REPORTS THEY WERE GETTING LITTLE TO NO RAIN AND NONE OF THE DIESEL ESCAPED THE WELL LOCATION.CH WILL NOTIFY MINERALS OF THE INCIDENT. 03/19/08: COPY OF SPILL FORWARDED TO MINERALS FOR THEIR INFORMATION AND FOLLOWUP. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS UNLESS MINERALS DETERMINES CLEANUP UNSATISFACTORY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 152

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SYNERGY CRUDE WELL EAST MAIN AT OLD COW PALACE

Spill Number: 0751322

Close Date: 05/01/2008

, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: EAST MAIN / OLD COW PALACE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Other Caller Name: DEC Investigator: jfotto

Spiller: MARK SAPORETO - SYNERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: MARK SAPORETO

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/01/2008 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER CLAIMS THAT OIL IS CONSTANTLY ALLOWED IN THE CREEK AS THE EQUIPMENT AND OPERATION IS POOR AT THE WELL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 01/11/08 JFO UNABLE TO FIND THE WELL MENTIONED IN THE COMPLAINT. REFERRED TO CHRIS MILLER IN MINERALS. CHRIS MILLER HAS BEEN IN CONTACT WITH SYNERGY REGARDING THIS SITE. 05/01/08 NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILLS. CLOSED ELECTRONIC FILE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 153

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FARMER GAS WELL #1 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE

Spill Number: 0751378

Close Date: 07/15/2008

ELMIRA, NY 14901

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: PENNSYLVANIA AVE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: cmkehoe

Spiller: BRAD WEST - EAST RESOURCES/GFS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: JOE YAROSZ

Spiller Phone: (607) 562-2323 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (607) 739-0809

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/23/2008 07/15/2008 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected DIESEL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DEC INSPECTOR REPORTED FINDING A DIESEL FUEL SPILL AT A WELL SITE. SPILL ABOUT 75’ LONG BY 1-2’ WIDE. GAS FIELD SPECIALISTS RESPONDING TO EXCAVATE AND DISPOSE OF MATERIAL. JOE YAROSZ TO MONITOR. KEHOE TO RESPOND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: BRAD WEST (716) 378-6422 01/24/08 1300 KEHOE ON SITE FOR A CHECK, GFS PERSON ON SITE WAITING FOR OTHERS, WAS UNAWARE OF SPILL OR WHERE TO LOOK. WALKED SITE AND FOUND NOTHING OBVIOUS. CALL TO JOE YAROSZ, LEFT MESSAGE. 01/25/08 1015-1030 KEHOE ON SITE, PILE OF SOIL WHERE THEY CLAIM TO HAVE PILED IT, NO COVER. LATER DISCUSSION WITH JOE YAROSZ OF MINERALS, CONFIRMED THAT WAS THE REMOVED SOIL, IT IS ON PLASTIC, COVERED WITH PLASTIC AND THEN COVERED WITH DIRT. TELECON WITH BRAD WEST CONFIRMING SOIL WAS TAKEN TO LANDFILL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 154

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL 5269 NICHOLS RUN RD

Spill Number: 0751271

Close Date: 05/07/2008

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: jfotto

Spiller: RON & SUSAN BRADLEY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: MARK SOPER

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (716) 984-2209

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/28/2007 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: A BROKEN CRUDE OIL WELL LINE IS LEAKING OIL NEAR THE CALLER’S POND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 12/28/07 JFO CALL TO CHARLES THROPP WITH DEC MINERALS. HE WILL INVESTIGATE THE SPILL. I FAXED HIM A COPY OF THE SPILL. JFO CALL FROM CHRIS MILLER WITH MINERALS. CHARLES THROPP WILL MEET MR SOPER ON SITE TODAY. AFTER THEIR INSPECTION THEY WILL CONTACT THE LEASE OWNERS FOR ANY NEEDED CLEANUP. CHRIS OR CHARLES WILL GET BACK TO ME. 12/28/07 JFO REC’D E-MAIL FROM CHRIS MILLER. CHARLES THROPP MET WITH THE PROPERTY OWNER ON SITE. THERE WAS A SMALL AMT OF OIL VISIBLE FROM A SMALL PIPELINE LEAK. TWO PEOPLE FROM SYNERGY OIL CO (OWNERS OF THE LINE) WERE ALREADY ON SITE WORKING ON THE PROBLEM. CHARLES WILL FOLLOW UP WITH SYNERGY TO BE SURE EVERYTHING IS CLEANED UP PROPERLY AND TO THE SATISFACTION OF THE PROPERTY OWNER. 1/10/08 RMC/TIM MILLER, 814-366-1582, FORMER EMPLOYEE/PHONE. HE SAID OIL WAS NOT CLEANED UP PROPERLY. HE SAID WHEN THE LINE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 155

BROKE IT PRESSURIZED AND PUSHED OIL OUT UNDER THE GROUND. IT COMES UP SOMETIMES A 100 FEET FROM THE LINE BREAK. THIS SPILL WAS BEING HANDLED BY MINERALS. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 156

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NEAR ALMA POND 166 PUMP STATION ROAD

Spill Number: 0751228

Close Date: 03/20/2008

ALMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14708 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: fxgalleg

Spiller: C/O RICK J. WELLS - THE ESTATE OF JAMES R. WELLS Spiller Phone: Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: Contact for more spill info: JESSIE BEST Contact Person Phone: (585) 593-5690

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/17/2007 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THAT AN UNCAPPED CRUDE OIL WELL IS LEAKING CRUDE OIL ON THE PROPERTY NEAR THE ALMA POND...AN ECO IS ENROUTE AND WILL INVESTIGATE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 12/17/07 FG, JFO SITE INSPECTION. ECO RUSS CALANNI WAS ON THE SCENE WHEN SPILLS ARRIVED. HE ESTIMATED THAT APPROXIMATELY BETWEEN 160 AND 200 GALLONS OF CRUDE SPILLED OUT TO THE CREEK. HE SAID THE CALLER, JESSI BEST INDICATED THE SPILL HAS BEEN ONGOING FOR AT LEAST A WEEK. HEAVY SHEEN FOUND AT PUMP STATION ROAD BRIDGE OVER HONEOYE CREEK. SOURCE FOUND TO BE THE TWO CRUDE OIL WELLS UPSTREAM IN THE AL-1 STATE PROTECTED WETLAND. THE WELLS ARE SUBMERGED UNDER WATER BEHIND A BEAVER DAM. PRODUCT PRESENT UNDER THE SNOW AROUND THE WELLS. FG HIRED OPTECH TO PLACE BOOM AND PADS AT SEVERAL LOCATIONS ALONG HONEOYE CREEK. MINERALS WOULD NOT RESPOND TO THE SCENE. MINERALS PROVIDED THE FOLLOWING AS CONTACT INFORMATION FOR THE WELL OWNER: 315-594-2701 JAMES WELLS POB 194 WOLCOTT, NY 14590.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 157

ACCESS TO THE WELLS WAS NOT POSSIBLE. A DETERMINATION ABOUT REMOVING THE BEAVER DAM FOR ACCESS WOULD NEED TO BE MADE. WILL NOTIFY OP TECH ONCE DECISION IS MADE. 12/18/07 FG SPOKE TO RUSS BISS AND MINERALS. THEY REQUESTED THAT SPILLS GET ACCESS TO THE PROPERTY AND THEN WE WILL DECIDE ABOUT THE NEED FOR REMOVAL OF THE BEAVER DAM. MINERALS PROVIDED A PROPERTY MAP WITH CONTACT INFORMATION ON THE OWNERS. FG SPOKE TO JESSI BEST WHO SAID HE SPOKE TO A TRAPPER WHO CAUGHT A BEAVER BUT SAID THE PELT WAS USELESS BECAUSE THERE WAS SO MUCH OIL ON THE COAT, FACE AND NOSE. 12/19/07 FG SPOKE TO DAVID KAUFMAN, OWNER OF THE PROPERTY WITH THE WELLS. HE SAID THE DEPT COULD ACCESS THE PROPERTY TO REMOVE THE BEAVER DAM AND STOP THE LEAK. HE WOULD LIKE TO KNOW THE CONTACT INFORMATION FOR THE WELL OWNER ONCE WE FIND IT BECAUSE HE WOULD LIKE TO PURCHASE THE MINERAL RIGHTS BACK. THE WELL IS OWNED BY THE ESTATE OF JAMES WELLS. CHRIS MILLER WITH MINERALS INDICATED THAT THE CONTACT FOR THE ESTATE IS AS FOLLOWS: THE ESTATE OF JAMES R. WELLS C/0 RICK J. WELLS 889 RUSH HENRIETTA TOWNLINE RD. W. HENRIETTA, NY 14586-9538 585-321-1885 12/20/07 FG DKK SITE INSPECTION. GARY KLOCK, BRIAN JANDREW, CAPT DAVE BENNETT, LT KENNETH DIDION ALL ON SITE FROM NYSDEC. KEVIN CANNON, OP TECH ALSO ON SITE. MR. JANDREW SHOWED ACCESS FROM FOUR MILE RD. HE SAID THE WELL WAS WORKED PRIOR TO THE PASSING OF THE LEASE OWNER JAMES WELLS 1.5 YEARS AGO. HE SAID THE WELL IS 800 FT DEEP. HE SHOWED A HOLE IN THE CASING WHICH IS THE SOURCE OF THE SPILL. THE WATER RAN INTO THE CASING PUSHING OUT THE CRUDE FROM THE WELL WHEN THE WATER LEVEL ROSE ABOVE THE HOLE IN THE CASING. UPON TODAYS INSPECTION, THE WATER LEVEL WAS BELOW THE HOLE IN THE CASING SO NO NEW SPILLAGE WAS OCCURRING. TO PREVENT FURTHER RELEASE, OP TECH WAS TO PLUG THE HOLE WITH A WEATHERPROOF CAULK. CRUDE OIL WAS STILL PRESENT TRAPPED IN THE SNOW SURROUNDING THE WELL AND SHEENS WERE RUNNING OFF OF THIS DOWN HONEOYE CREEK TO THE BOOMS PLACED AT THE PUMP STATION RD BRIDGE. MR. KLOCK INDICATED THAT THIS WAS NOT AN ACTIVE BEAVER DAM AND HE OPENED UP A SECTION TO LOWER THE WATER LEVEL AND INDICATED A PERMIT WAS NECESSARY. A DECISION WILL BE MADE REGARDING THE NEED TO PLUG THE WELL AND WHO WILL PLUG IT. IN THE MEANTIME, THE DEPT WILL MONITOR THE RELEASE TO THE CREEK. 12/21/07 RICK WELLS WITH THE ESTATE CALLED AND LEFT A MESSAGE TO CALL HIM AT 585-321-1330 EXT 254. FG CALLED THE NUMBER AND NO RICK WELLS WAS THERE. FG LEFT ANOTHER MESSAGE FOR MR. WELLS. 12/22-23/07 JFO ON SITE NOA. THERE IS A VERY SLIGHT SHEEN ON THE CREEK AT THE BRIDGE. THE WATER AROUND THR WELL HEAD IS CLEAR WITH NO SHEEN. 12/28/07 FG SPOKE TO RICK WELLS, EXECUTOR FOR THE ESTATE OF JAMES WELLS. I TOLD HIM THAT THE NYSOPA IS WILLING TO PLUG THE WELL, NO CHARGE. I GAVE HIM THE CONTACT INFORMATION, PAUL PLANTS 814-697-6330. I EXPLAINED THAT THE COSTS FOR THE DEPT’S EMERGENCY RESPONSE MAY BE BILLED TO THE ESTATE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 158

PAUL PLANTS, PRESIDENT OF THE NYSOPA CALLED AND STATED THAT HE WILL PLUG THE WELL WITHIN THE NEXT 10 DAYS. HE WILL OBTAIN THE PERMITS AND CONTAIN AND CLEANUP ANY SPILLAGE. HE HAS REQUESTED THAT MINERALS OBSERVE THE WORK. 1/7/08 BRIAN JANDREW WITH MINERALS CALLED AND STATED THAT THE WELL WAS PLUGGED ON 1/4/08. MR. JANDREW ALSO STATED THAT HE TOOK THE BOOMS AND PADS TO THE COUNTY LANDFILL FOR DISPOSAL. JFO INSPECTED THE SITE ON 1/6/08 AND NOTED THAT NO FURTHER CONTAMINATION WAS IDENTIFIED IN THE CREEK. ONCE THE FINAL PAYMENT PACKAGES FROM OP TECH ARE RECEIVED THE SITE CAN BE CLOSED. 3/19/08 FINAL PAYMENT PACKAGEFROM OP TECH RECEIVED AND PROCESSED. SITE IS CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 159

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SALT BRINE 1/2 MILE NORTH OF CENTERLINE RD

Spill Number: 0750225

Close Date: 05/11/2007

SHELDON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14145 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: sacaland

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/2007 DELIBERATE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: AN ANONYMOUS COMPLAINANT WROTE A LETTER. THEY BELIEVE THER MAY BE SALT BRINE FROM A NATURAL GAS WELL BEING DUMPED ON THE GROUND NEAR CAYUGA CREEK IN WYOMING COUNTY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 5/11/07:SAC GAVE COPY OF REPORT TO ECO RUSS CALANNI - LAW ENFORCEMENT. ECO CALANNI WILL CONTACT ECO R.J. WARD FOR FURTHER FOLLOWUP. NO FURTHER WORK REQUIRED. COMPUTER FILE ONLY - NO PAPER FILE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 160

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

IN BYSIEK CREEK BYSIEK 300 YARD ON TO BYSIEK ROAD

Spill Number: 0751546

Close Date: 01/15/2009

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS

Spiller: GREG THROPP - OIL WELL OWNER Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/16/2008 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DRILLING CRUDE IN THE AREA CREEK HAS A HEAVY SHEEN ON IT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 3/17/08 JIM KING WITH MINERALS INSPECTED THE LEASE WHICH IS OWNED BY GREG THROPP. HE SAID THERE WAS A MINOR SHEEN IN THE STREAM WHICH IS ON THE LEASE. HE FOUND THAT HAY HAD BEEN PLACED IN AN AREA NEAR THE WELLS WHICH WAS STOPPING CRUDE FROM DISCHARGING TO THE STREAM. FG CONTACTED GREG THROPP AND ELIZABETH BYSIEK AND COULD NOT CONTACT EITHER PARTY. 3/18/08 FG SITE INSPECTION WITH JIM KING OF MINERALS. MET ERIN THROPP, SON OF GREG THROPP. FOUND THE SOURCE OF THE CONTAMINATION TO BE A NEWLY INSTALLED 1500 FT DEEP PRODUCTION WELL. A FITTING WAS NOT PROPERLY SEALED AND WAS LEAKING. THE CRUDE DISCHARGED TO THE STREAM ALONG WITH MELTING SNOW. ERIN THROPP SAID HE WILL PUMP UP THE CRUDE TO BARRELS AND REUSE. HE WILL EXCAVATE THE CONTAMINATED SOIL AND STAGE ON PLASTIC FOR DISPOSAL. HE WILL NOTIFY THE DEPT TO INSPECT THE CLEANUP AND WILL PROVIDE A DISPOSAL RECEIPT. THE CREEK BELOW THIS ARE HAD A VERY MINOR SHEEN PERIODICALLY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

05/23/08: MF S/I/GREG THROPP, RP, OWNER OF WELL. SOIL SCRAPED UP , IN TWO PILES. I DID NOT NOTICE ANY SHEENING OF WATER IN CREEK. HE CLAIMED LANDFILL SLOW IN GETTING BACK TO HIM ABOUT DISPOSAL. 05/26/08: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 6/15/08. 06/16/08: MF RECEIVED DISPOAL RECEIPT. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 161

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 162

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL 1610 FOREST AVE. EXT.

Spill Number: 0650150

Close Date: 07/12/2006

JAMESTOWN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: RMCROSSE

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: ERIC PEFLEY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/2006 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: caller states that he observed an oil well spraying out oil/water on his neighbor’s property...the well contact person is eric pefley. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 05/01/06 RMC/FILE. CALLED ANONYMOUS COMPLAINTANT WHO ADVISED FINE SPRAY COMING OUT OF WELL EACH TIME THE PUMP MOVES. SPRAY IN A 50 FOOT DIAMETER AND NOTHING RUNNING OFF. CALLED MINERALS, NOTIFIED AL ALEXANDER OF PROBLEM, HE WILL CONTACT THE WELL OWNER TO GET HIM TO THE SITE. AL ALEXANDER LATER CALLED BACK TO SAY HE HAD BEEN IN CONTACT WITH ERIC PEFLEY THE WELL OWNER. THE WELL OWNER WAS WORKING IN THE FIELD OF ABOUT 30 WELLS EARLIER IN THE DAY AND HE WOULD RETURN AS HE WAS NEAR BY. MINERALS WILL INSPECT TOM AM. RMC RECEIVED CALL FROM MR PEFLEY RMC ADVISED OF WHAT WAS KNOWN. MR PELEY LATER CALLED BACK TO SAY ONE OF THE WELLS NEAR THE ROAD HAS A BAD PACKING. HE STATED MOST OF THE SPRAY WAS WATER BUT THE WATER HAS SOME OIL IN IT. HE WILL CLEAN UP THE AREA IMPACTED WHICH HE STATED WAS JUST A FEW FEET AROUND THE WELL HEAD. RMC TO WAIT FOR MINERAL INSPECTION. 05/02/06 RMC/FILE. RECEIVED E-MAIL FROM AL ALEXANDER WELL IMPACTED IN M. NELSON # 6G. INSPECTION WAS NOT PLANNED UNLESS SPILLS WANTED IT DONE. RMC REQUESTED MINERALS INSPECT. THE SITE. UPDATE 5/15/06.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 163

05/04/06 RMC/SITE. LARGE 100 PLUS ACRE WELL FIELD. INSPECTED MORE THAN TEN WELLS ALL APPEAR TO BE MAINTAINED PROPERLY. VERY MINOR SPILLAGE AROUND WELL HEAD ON SOME. MINOR SPILLAGE NOTED AROUT ASTS AND PARTIAL AST. FOUND ONE WELL BACK OF THE PROPERTY. HAS HAD A LINE BREAK NEAR THE WELL HEAD, APPEARS TO HAVE HAPPENED SOME TIME AGO AS ABOUT A 80 FOOT DIAMETER CIRCLE AROUND WELL HEAD HAS COATED VEGETATION. MUST HAVE HAVE FLOWED WITH EARLIER SNOW MELT AND RAIN. TOOK NUMEROUS PICTURES OF THE WHOLE AREA. UPDATED DKK 5/5/06. 06/30/06 RMC/SITE. NO FURTHER CLEANUP WAS DONE. VEGETATION IS GROWING IN AREA COATED BY OIL. OIL STILL VISIBLE BUT MUCH BETTER THAT 5/4/06 INSPECTION. RMC DISCUSSED WITH DKK. TO CLOSE AS A SPILLS ISSUE. CLOSE OUT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 164

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PRIVATE HOME 8983 DEER CREEK ROAD

Spill Number: 0609759

Close Date: 11/06/2007

PORTVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14770 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: JFOTTO

Spiller: ART SHANER - ART SHANER PINE OIL CO. Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: SUE ZIMMBERMAN

Spiller Phone: (585) 928-2318 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (585) 928-1651

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/27/2006 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: AS OF MONDAY NEW PHONE # WILL BE 585-928-2801; AMOUNT IS CALLERS GUESS SHE CLAIMS NO LESS THAN 100 GALLONS; NOT OWNER OF THE MINERAL RIGHTS; PRESSURE BUILT UP IN ’CAPPED’ PIPE AND IS RUNNING DOWN HILL, THIS MATERIAL SEEMS TO GO UNDERGROUND AND COMES UP AGAIN 100 FT. BEHIND HER HOUSE; HAVE REPORTED TWO PREVIOUS SPILLS WITH GENERALLY SAME PROBLEM; PREVIOUS SPILL NUMBERS ARE 0650795 REPORTED ON AUGUST 14, 2006, 067319= 26TH OF SEPTEMBER 2006 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 11/27/06:SAC TELECON CHARLES THROPP - NYSDEC/MINERALS NOTIFYING HIM OF THE SPILL. MR. THROPP WILL TRY TO FOLLOW UP W/MS. ZIMMERMAN WHO CALLED IN THE SPILL AND MR. SHANER WHO HAS THE MINERAL RIGHTS FOR THE SITE. 11/28/06:SAC TELECON CHARLES THROPP. MR. THROPP CALLED MS. ZIMMERMAN REGARDING HER COMPLAINT. MS. ZIMMERMAN TOLD MR. THROPP SHE WAS NOTIFIED OF THE PROBLEM ON SATURDAY BY HUNTERS THAT WENT THROUGH THE AREA. SHE WAS OUT THERE YESTERDAY AT ABOUT NOON AND SAID A CAPPED WELL BLEW OUT. MR. THROPP MET W/MS. ZIMMERMAN LAST NIGHT. SHE TOLD HIM WHERE THE SPILL WAS WHICH WAS UP A HILL. DUE TO THE DARKNESS AND UPHILL TERRAIN, MS. ZIMMERMAN DID NOT ACCOMPANY MR. THROPP TO THE AREA. ONCE ON TOP OF THE HILL, MR. THROPP DID NOT DETECT ANY ODORS. MR. THROPP TRIED TO CONTACT MR. SHANER BUT WAS UNSUCCESSFUL. HE WILL CONTINUE TO FOLLOW UP

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 165

W/MS. ZIMMERMAN AND HE SAID MS. ZIMMERMAN MAY TRY TO CONTACT DEC-SPILLS OF THE SITUATION ALSO. 11/28/06:SAC TELECON CHARLES THROPP. MR. THROPP SAID HE SPOKE VIA PHONE TO MR. SHANER TO DISCUSS THE COMPLAINT. MR. SHANER WILL INSPECT THE AREA. 11/28/06 RMC/TOM HALL, ALLEGANY DOH, 585-268-9254/PHONE. MRS ZIMMERMAN CALLED TO ASK THEM TO DO SOMETHING. HE REPORTED THAT SHE HUNG UP ON HIM WITH OUT PROVIDING MUCH INFORMATION. 11/28/06 RMC/FILE. RECEIVED CALL 1158 AM, FROM SUE ZIMMERMAN. SHE SAID MR THROPP INSPECTED LAST NIGHT AT ABOUT 6PM. HE COULDN’T SEE THE SPILL BECAUSE IT WAS DARK. SHE DESCRIBED IT AS AT LEAST 100 GALLONS IN TWO AREAS. SHE IS UNHAPPY WITH WHAT HAS BEEN DONE AND HAS HIRED AND ATTORNEY. RMC ADVISED SPILLS WOULD CONTACT MINERALS AND HAVE SOMEONE CALL HER BACK. SHE WANTS SPILLS TO TAKE OVER AS SHE IS UNHAPPY WITH THE SPEED OF MINERALS RESPONSE. RMC ADVISED SPILLS WOULD ONLY TAKE OVER IF MINERALS ASKED OR IT WENT ON A LONG TIME AND THAT 24 HOURS WAS NOT ENOUGH TIME. RMC UPDATED SAC. 12/12/06 FG SPOKE TO ART SHANER, OWNER OF THE LEASE. HE SAID HE IS CLEANING UP SPILL TODAY AND WILL DISPOSE OF IT AT THE ALLEGANY COUNTY LANDFILL. I TOLD HIM WE WILL INSPECT ONCE THE SITE IS CLEANED AND HE SHOULD NOTIFY EITHER MYSELF OR CHARLES THROPP. 12/14/06 JFO ON SITE MET WITH MS ZIMMERMAN AND MR SHANER. SHE SAID HE HAS BEEN UP AND DOWN THE HILL WITH HIS TRACTOR THAT HAS A BUCKET. MR SHANER SAID THE CLEANUP IS NOT COMPLETE YET. HE WILL BE DONE AND READY FOR AN INSPECTION BY THE END OF NEXT WEEK. HE HAS APPROX 1 TONS OF SOIL STOCKPILED NEAR THE ROAD. 01/05/07 JFO CALL TO MR SHANER. LEFT A MESSAGE ON HIS MACHINE. 06/18/07 JFO CALL TO MR SHANER. HE WILL DISPOSE OF THE SOIL NEXT WEEK AND FAX THE RECEIPTS. 10/23/07 JFO SENT LTR REQUESTING RECEIPTS BY NOV 17. 11/06/07 JFO RECEIVED THE DISPOSAL RECEIPT FOR 1.35 TONS OF THE CONTAMINATED MATERIAL. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 166

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS WELL ROUTE 430 ON THE LEFT WHEN

Spill Number: 0651793

Close Date: 05/30/2008

SHERMAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14781 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: JFOTTO

Spiller: BILL FREY - FREY WELL DRILLING Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 937-6634 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/03/2006 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected DIESEL PETROLEUM 300.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: this is the discription from nrc: CALLER REP0RTING A FUEL TANK RUPTURED SPILLING MATERIAL(DIESEL)ONTO THE GROUND. A WATER SUCTION TRUCK WAS USED TO REMOVE SOME OT THE MATERIAL AND THE REST WAS COVERED WITH DIRT. FREY WELL DRILLING WAS WORKING FOR COTTON DRILLING AT THE TIME OF THE INCIDENT. CALLER STATES THE LAND IS CONSIDERED PROTECTED LAND. THE MATERIAL ENTERED A NEAR BY "PROTECTED" STREAM. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 01/04/07 JFO TELCON WITH JEFFERY LONNEN (CALLER). HE SAID THIS IS A GAS WELL SITE. THE BULLDOZER PUNCTURED A HOLE IN THEIR PORTABLE 1000 GALLON DIESEL TANK. THE ROAD TO THE WELL SITE IS BEFORE A BARN WITH 2 SILOS. JFO TELCON WITH ECO GOWAN. I WILL MEET HIM IN THE TOWN OF SHERMAN TOMORROW AT 13:00. 01/05/07 JFO ON SITE WITH ECO GOWAN. THE PROPERTY IS OWNED BY MR RICHARD GREINER. WE FOUND THE AREA WHERE THE SPILL OCCURRED. IT DID REACH THE STREAM. ECO GOWAN CHECKED UPSTREAM AND FOUND NO SHEEN ON THE WATER. AS HE BEGAN WALKING IN THE WATER DOWNSTREAM SHEEN STARTED TO APPEAR. WE CHECKED DOWNSTREAM AT MANNISON ROAD (500 YDS)AND THERE WAS NO SIGN OF PRODUCT OR SHEEN. WE INFORMED THE OWNER OF THE SPILL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 167

01/08/07 JFO E-MAILED PHOTOS TO ECO GOWAN. 01/11/07 JFO CALL TO MR FREY REGARDING A CLEANUP. HE WAS NOT IN, I LEFT MY NUMBER WITH HE RECEPTIONIST. SHE SAID HE WILL BE IN TOMORROW. 01/12/07 JFO CALL FROM BILL FREY. HE WILL HIRE NATURES WAY. HE WILL LET ME KNOW WHEN THE CLEANUP WILL BEGIN. 01/16/07 JFO CALL FROM BILL FREY. NATURES WAY WILL BEGIN TOMORROW. 01/17/07 JFO ON SITE MET WITH DALE GRAMZA FROM NATURES WAY AND KEITH FROM FREY DRILLING. THEY HAVE A MINI EXCAVATOR WITH AN OPERATOR ON SITE. THEY ARE STAGING SOIL ON PLASTIC. ALSO THEY PLACED 3 SETS OF BOOMS IN THE STREAM. ALSO E-MAILED PHOTOS TO ECO GOWAN. 04/4/07 JFO CALL FROM DALE GRAMZA. HE HAS A CLEANUP CREW GOING TO THE SITE TODAY. THEY WILL CHANGE OUT THE BOOMS AND DIG OUT ANY RESIDUAL CONTAMINATION THEY FIND. NOTIFIED ECO DENNIS GOWAN VIA E-MAIL. 04/19/07 JFO CALL TO DALE G. THEY DISPOSED OF 43,600 LBS OF CONTAMINATED SOIL AND CLEANUP MATERIAL. HE WAS UNABLE TO CHECK THE SWAMPY AREA DUE TO THE DEPTH OF THE WATER. HE WILL VISIT SITE AT ANOTHER TIME TO CHECK THE BOOMS AND CHANGE IF NECESSARY. 05/09/07 JFO RECEIVED THE REPORT FROM NATURE’S WAY. INCLUDED ARE SAMPLE RESULTS (BLD) AND THE DISPOSAL RECEIPTS. 09/07/07 JFO ON SITE MET WITH DALE GRAMZA WITH NATURES WAY. THE AREA IS VERY DRY AND THE STREAM IS SHALLOW AND RUNNING VERY SLOW. HE RETRIEVED THE BOOMS. 1 WAS OIL SOAKED AND THE OTHER 2 WERE PARTIALLY STAINED. HE REPLACED THE BOOMS. 05/28/08 JFO CALL FROM DALE G. HE WAS ON SITE AND COLLECTED THE BOOMS. THERE WAS NO OIL ON THE BOOMS AND HE WILL DISPOSE OF IN REGULAR WASTE STEAM. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 168

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DANIEL MARTINEZ RESIDENCE 8983 DEER CREEK ROAD

Spill Number: 0650795

Close Date: 06/06/2007

PORTVILLE, NY 14770

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Citizen Caller Name: DEC Investigator: RMCROSSE

Spiller: ART SHANOR - ART SHANOR Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: RAY BULSON-ATTY. FOR MR.MARTINEZ

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/2006 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL LEAK FROM AN UNKNOWN SOURCE. THERE IS A WELL LEASE ON THE PROPERTY. THE LEASE IS OWNED BY ART SHANOR. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 8/14/06:SAC TELECON SUE ZIMMERMAN. MS. ZIMMERMAN SAID HER PARENTS ARE IN THE PROCESS OF BUYING THE HOUSE/PROPERTY. THE SALE HAS NOT CLOSED. SHE NOTICED THE AREA A FEW MONTHS AGO AND SIAD THE AFFECTED AREA HAS TRIPLED. STRONG ODORS EXIST. SHE CONTACTED DEC-MINERALS TO LOOK AT THE SITE. AL ALEXANDER/DEC-MINERALS WILL BE INSPECTING THE SITE TODAY. 08/22/06 RMC/JAMES ZIMMERMAN/PHONE. HE IS NOT HAPPY WITH CLEANUP. HE IS CONCERNED WITH THE WELL ON THE PROPERTY. RMC ADVISED THAT DEC REQUIRED THE CLEANUP CRUDE TO THE POINT OF SEE AND SMELL AND THAT MINERALS WAS SATISFYIED. RMC ASKED IF THERE IS VISUAL CONTAMINATION REMAINING, HE DID NOT KNOW. HE IS GOING TO TRAVEL TO THE SITE NEXT WEEK AND WILL CALL BACK IF HE SEES A PROBLEM. RMC ADVISED THAT DEC CONSIDERS BOTH THE LEASER AND PROPERTY OWNER RESPONSIBLE PARTIES. UPDATE 8/30/06. 10/09/06 RMC/SITE. INSPECTED CLEANUP AREA. CAN STILL SEE AND SMELL OIL IN THE AREA OF THE CLEANUP. SUE Z, HOME OWNER STATES THAT THE ODORS HAVE MADE HER ILL. SHE HAS BEEN IN CONTACT WITH THE ALLEGANY DOH. RMC TO SEND LETTER REQUIRING FURTHER CLEANUP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

10/27/06 RMC/FILE. DRAFTED LETTER. RESPONSE DUE 11/22/06. 11/21/06 RMC/ART SHANOR/PHONE. HE CALLED AND ADVISED THAT HE WILL CLEAN UP THE CRUDE OIL. HE WILL CALL WHEN THE EXCAVATION IS READY FOR AND INSPECTION. UPDATE 12/30/06. 06/06/07 RMC/FILE. DUPLICATE SPILL 0609759, JFO. JFO WILL FOLLOW UP WITH FINAL INSPECTION AND ADD NOTES TO THAT FILE. CLOSE OUT.

Page 169

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 170

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BEHIND A TRAILER HOME 118 BROAD STREET

Spill Number: 0650463

Close Date: 11/20/2006

RICHBURG, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14774 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Notifier Type: Affected Persons Caller Name: DEC Investigator: JFOTTO

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info: CRYSTAL RHODES

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (585) 928-1516

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/01/2006 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 1.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: THERE TWO PIPES STICKING OUT OF THE GROUND BEHIND TRAILER HOME. ONE IS COVERED WITH A PLANTING BUCKET. IT RAINED YESTERDAY AND WHILE IT WAS RAINING, OIL CAME OUT OF THE PIPE THAT WAS UNCOVERED. PROPERTY OWNED BY CORNERSTONE REALTY. PHONE NUMBER 607-936-6105. WHEN THIS NUMBER IS CALLED, THE PHONE IS USUALLY ANSWERED MIKE COOK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 06/29/06 JFO ON SITE MET WITH THE CALLER. THERE IS AN ABANDONED OIL WELL ON THE PROPERTY. ABOUT 1 GALLON OF CRUDE SPILL FROM THE LINE. I CONTACTED CHRIS MILLER FROM MINERALS. HE WILL CHECK OUT THE WELL AND GET BACK TO ME. THE TENANT WILL PLACE A WISHING WELL OVER THE WELL HEAD FOR NOW. 08/08/06 RMC/CRYSTAL CLARK/PHONE. 585-928-1516. FOUND A SPOT OF OIL COMING RIGHT OUT OF THE GROUND ABOUT 60 FEET FROM THEIR HOUSE. 11/09/06 JFO CALL TO CHRIS MILLER. LEFT A MESSAGE WITH RECEPTIONIST. 11/10/06 JFO RECEIVED E-MAIL FROM CHRIS MILLER. THIS IS AN ABANDONED OIL WELL THAT NEEDS TO BE PLUGGED AND WAS ADDED TO THEIR

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

DATABASE. WHEN FUNDS BECOME AVAILABLE THE WELL WILL BE PLUGGED. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILLS. CLOSED

Page 171

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 172

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ROOT WELL 511 MURPHY HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 0505272

Close Date: 08/01/2005

CATLIN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JEFF BOWERS CMKEHOE

Spiller: JEFF BOWERS - FORTUNA ENERGY Notifier Name: JEFF BOWERS Caller Agency: FORTUNA ENERGY Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (607) 329-7140 Notifier Phone: (607) 329-7140 Caller Phone: (607) 329-7140 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/31/2005 08/01/2005 TANK OVERFILL YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 50.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: A DRAIN VALVE WAS LEFT OPEN ON A STORAGE TANK AT ROOT WELL, SPILLING 50 GALLONS OF BRINE WATER TO THE GROUND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 07/31/05: CH TELCON WITH JEFF BOWERS OF FORTUNA ENERGY. THEY HAVE AN APPROXIMATELY 10,000 GALLON HOLDING TANK ON SITE FOR BRINE WATER. THERE IS A CONTAINMENT BERM FOR THE HOLDING TANK. THE CONTAINMENT BERM HAS A DRAIN VALVE IN IT AND THE VALVE WAS LEFT OPEN. BRINE WATER FROM THE CONTAINMENT BERM WAS RELEASED FROM THE CONTAINMENT TO A WET WATER (STORM WATER) CONTAINMENT BERM. FROM ON SITE TESTING, THEY KNOW THE BRINE WATER WEIGHS APPROXIMATELY 9.6 LBS/GALLON AND HAS A PH OF 4. WITHIN THE STORM WATER CONTAINMENT BERM, THERE IS A PUDDLE OF APPROXIMATELY 100 GALLONS OF WATER, OF WHICH SOME IS THE RELEASED BRINE. FORTUNA TESTED THIS PUDDLE AND IT WEIGHS 8.5 LBS/GALLONS AND HAS A PH OF 7. THEY HAVE A TANK TRUCK ENROUTE TO PUMP UP THE PUDDLE OF WATER. THEY ARE ESTIMATING THE AMOUNT OF BRINE RELEASED FROM THE CONTAINMENT TO BE LESS THAN 50 GALLONS. SOME OF IT SOAKED INTO THE SOIL WITHIN THE STORM WATER CONTAINMENT BERM. BOWERS ASKS IF THE DEPARTMENT WANTS SOIL IN STORM WATER CONTAINMENT TO BE SCRAPED UP. CH ADVISES BOWERS AT THIS TIME IT WON’T BE NECESSARY. BOWERS ADVISES CH THAT NO BRINE WAS RELEASED OFF SITE. CH WILL NOTIFY JOE YAROSZ OF MINERALS ON MONDAY 8/1/05 TO ADVISE HIM OF THE INCIDENT. NO FURTHER ACTION IS NECESSARY BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 173

08/01/05: SPILL FAXED TO CK 08/01/05 1330 KEHOE AND YAROSZ ON SITE WITH JEFF BOWERS OF FORTUNA, ACCORDING TO JEFF THE PRESSURE IN THE WELL IS LOW ENOUGH THAT IT DOESN’T CONTINUOUSLY MOVE THE WATER OUT, AS A RESULT, THE WELL MAY OCCASIONALLY "BURP" OUT A LARGER QUANTITY OF WATER. THE BRINE STORAGE TANK ITSELF HAD 62 INCHES OF WATER IN IT FRIDAY. WHEN THE OPERATOR DROVE BY SUNDAY, SOAP SUDDS WERE COMING OUT OF THE BRINE STORAGE TANK (SOAP USED IN THE WELL TO HELP WITH WATER REMOVAL). THE OPERATOR CHECKED THE SYSTEM AND FOUND THE TANK FULL AND THE HOLDING POND DRAIN OPEN. FORTUNA IMMEDIATELY PLUGGED THE DRAIN AND HAD THE HOLDING POND, STREAM PUDDLE AND TANK PUMPED OUT. WHILE ON SITE TODAY, THE STREAM PUDDLE HAD REFILLED, ABOUT A DOZEN DEAD MINNOWS WERE FLOATING IN IT. ABOUT 20 FEET DOWNSTREAM ANOTHER PUDDLE WAS FULL OF LIVE MINNOWS. TANK DOES NOT HAVE HIGH LEVEL ALARMS ON IT. DISCUSSIONS WITH YAROSZ, FORTUNA DID ALL THEY COULD GIVEN THE CIRCUMSTANCES. NFA - CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 174

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

IN FIELD 8571 LOWER EAST HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 0551576

Close Date: 03/17/2006

COLDEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 8571 LOWER EAST HILL RD Revised zip code: 14033 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Citizen LYNN HAMLIN CGMCKENZ

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 941-6292 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/01/2006 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: Caller claims that vegetation in a field across the street from 8570 Lower East Hill Road is dying for no reason. Caller thinks may have something to due with natural gas pipeline. Claims it is wide spread over the property. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 02/03/06 CGM SITE VISIT. DISTINCT AREA OF DYING/DEAD VEGETATION OBSERVED. NO SIGNS (VISIBLE/ ODOR) OF PETROLEUM RELEASE. NATURAL GAS PIPELINE (NATIONAL FUEL) RUNS ALONG ROAD. CALL MADE TO NATIONAL FUEL TO INQUIRE OF ANY LATERALS RUNNING IN DIRECTION AWAY FROM (PERPENDICULAR TO) ROAD. CALLER STATES THAT THERE IS AN UNDERGROUND STORAGE OF NATURAL GAS LOCATED HERE AND HER CONCERN IS THAT THIS STORAGE MAY BE LEAKING, CAUSING THE DEATH OF THE SURROUNDING VEGETATION. 02/06/06 KEVIN HOUSE, NATIONAL FUEL (857-7321) CONFIRMED EXISTENCE OF THEIR PIPEINES, UNDERGROUND STORAGE IN OLD GAS WELL CLOSE BY BEING USED AS WINTER STORAGE OF NATURAL GAS FOR THEIR PIPELINES. HE WILL FAX MAP OF PIPELINES AND OLD GAS WELL. KEVIN CALLED BACK TO STATE HE WILL NOT SEND OVER INFO UNLESS A FOIL REQUEST IS MADE. CALL TO BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS-DEC REGARDING LEAKS. HE SAID TO REPORT TO NF. SPOKE TO SUE (716-686-6123) OF NF (ORDER

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 175

#2278719) IN NY OFFICE. 02/14/06 CGM TELCON W/ADA, NF REGARDING ORDER #2278719. SHE REPORTS ON 2/6 CREW LOCATED THREE LEAKS, CATEGORIZED AS LEVEL 3 (ON ONE TO FIVE LEVEL, ONE BEING THE WORST). SPEAK TO DAVE NEUBAUER FOR FURTHER INFO. 02/23/06 CGM TELCON W/HAMLIN REGARDING SITE STATUS. REFERRED HER TO WICKA, NYSDPS REGARDING NF COMPLAINT. CGM TELCON W/ DEBBIE, NF REGARDING REPAIR STATUS OF LEAKS. SHE STATES UNLESS LEAKS INCREASE, NOTHING INTENDS TO BE DONE. IF WORK WILL BE SCHEDULED, NOT TO EXPECT SO PRIOR TO SPRING TIME. 03/17/06 NO PETROLEUM SPILL INDICATED. SPILL CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 176

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL LEAK OREGON ROAD

Spill Number: 0509188

Close Date: 07/27/2007

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Other ED KOORSE RMCROSSE

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

KATHLEEN RYAN - OILY ANN OIL AND GAS INC. Spiller Phone: 7163735994 ED KOORSE Notifier Phone: (716) 560-5966 DIRECTOR OF EMERGENCY SVC Caller Phone: (716) 560-5966 ED KOORSE Contact Person Phone: (716) 560-5966

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/31/2005 TANK OVERFILL YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 200 barrels of of crude oil. Appears to be approx a couple of hundred gallons leaked from these barrels. Leak is running into a small stream that goes into the water filtration plant. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 11/1/05 THE DUTY OFFICER, JERRY PALUMBO NOTIFIED MINERALS OF THE SPILL, NOT SPILLS. MINERALS RESPONDED ON 11/1/05. CHRIS MILLER WITH MINERALS NOTIFIED SPILLS THAT AL ALEXANDER INSPECTED THE SITE. MR. ALEXANDER REPORTED THAT THE LEAK WAS MINOR AND WAS CONTAINED IN THE OIL WATER SEPARATOR ADJACENT TO THE 100 BARREL STORAGE TANK. CHRIS MILLER NOTED THAT THE STORAGE TANK WAS NOW EMPTY BECAUSE IT HAD BEEN PUMPED OFF. HE WAS NOT SURE WHERE THE LEAK WAS LOCATED. HE SAID THAT MINERALS WILL DEAL WITH THE LEASE HOLDER AND REQUIRE AN IMPROVED DIKE AROUND THE AST, LOCATE AND REPAIR THE LEAK, CLEANUP OF THE OIL WATER SEPARATOR AND CLEANUP OF ANY SPILLAGE NOTED. MR. MILLER INDICATED THAT THERE WAS NO CRUDE IN THE CREEK, MAYBE A MINOR SHEEN. THE LEASE HOLDER IS OIL ANN OIL & GAS, OWNER IS KATHY RYAN. MR. MILLER HAS BEEN UNABLE TO CONTACT MS. RYAN. MR. MILLER ALSO NOTIFIED BECI’S, DON PLEAKIS WHO WAS ON SITE. DKK REQUESTED THAT SPILLS INSPECT THE OLEAN CREEK THAT RECEIVES THE DISCHARGE. RMC NOTIFIED TO INSPECT THE SITE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 177

CHRIS MILLER CALLED BACK AND NOTIFIED THIS OFFICE THAT DURING AL ALEXANDER’S INSPECTION OF THE TRIBUTARY TO OLEAN CREEK, HE FOUND POCKETS OF OIL. NEW HAYBALES WERE IN THE TRIBUTARY INDICATING THE LEASE HOLDER KNEW ABOUT THE SPILL AND DID NOT REPORT IT. OILY ANN OIL AND GAS, INC. KATHLEEN RYAN 20 ELM ALLEGANY, NY 14706 716-373-5994 IS THE LEASE HOLDER. CHRIS MILLER HAS NOT GOTTEN IN TOUCH WITH THE LEASE HOLDER YET. MINERALS HAS ASKED THE DEPT TO INSPECT AND RESPOND. 11/01/05 RMC/FILE. NOTIFIED OF RELEASE AT 0630 BY DUTY OFFICIER PALUMBO WHO ADVISED SPILLS RESPONSE NOT NEEDED. 11/01/05 RMC/SITE. MET ECO PLEAKIS. FOUND CRUDE OIL IN TWO SMALL PONDS, POND EXIT, AND POCKETS OF OIL AND SHEEN IN STREAM FOR 1/2 MILE. MINERALS ALEXANDER WAS ON SITE EARLIER BUT LEFT. ECO REPORTED THAT FIRE DEPARTMENT WAS ON SITE LAST NIGHT FOR 3 HOURS. THEY COULD NOT STOP THE OIL FROM GETTING OUT OF THE PONDS. RMC AND ECO PLEAKIS WENT TO 20 ELM STREET. NO ONE HOME. LEFT CARD. RMC TO RETURN TO BUFFALO AND CONSULT DAN KING. RMC MET WITH DAN KING. WE ARE TO PROCEED WITH REQUIREMENTS OF NORMAL CLEANUP. LATER RECEIVED CALL FROM KATHLEEN RYAN, RMC OUTLINED CLEANUP REQUIREMENTS. STOP DISCHARGE, PLACE PADS AND BOOMS IN STREAM, AND CLEANUP SITE. TO MEET ON SITE 11/2. 11/02/05 RMC/ECO PLEAKIS/AL ALEXANDER/KATHLEEN RYAN/SITE. RYAN TO IMMEDIATELY STOP DISCHARGE TO THE STREAM BY PUMPING DOWN PONDS INTO THE HOLDING ASTS, THE PADS AND BOOMS WILL BE CHANGED AS NECESSARY UNTIL STREAM IS CLEAR. ALL CONTAMINATION ON SITE WILL BE EXCAVATED AND DISPOSED, THE TAKE OFF PIPE WILL BE PROPERLY SUPPORTED. RMC AGAIN ADVISED THAT IF WORK IS NOT DONE STATE WILL DO IT AND SEND A BILL. 11/3/05 RMC/SITE. PONDS WERE PUMPED DOWN BUT OIL IS STILL IN TRENCH LEADING THE STREAM. BOOM IS HOLDING BACK PRODUCT. RMC LEFT MESSAGE FOR RYAN ADVISING TO REMOVE PRODUCT BEING HELD BACK BY THE BOOMS. 11/8/05 RMC/FILE. CGM AND FG INSPECTED SITE AND FOUND NO ADDITIONAL WORK HAS BEEN DONE. THEY NOTED PRODUCT LEAVING THE SECOND POND. THEY ALSO NOTED PRODUCT PUSHING UP IN FRONT OF THE BOOMS AS WELL AS A SHEEN ON STREAM. 11/9/05 RMC/FILE. LEFT MESSAGE FOR RP, SENT CERTIFIED LETTER GIVING UNTIL 11/14/05 AT 8 AM OR STATE WILL HIRE A CONTRACTOR. Updated Ed Koorse, he advised that Perry Lovell was the tender. 11/11/05 RMC/SITE. DISCHARGE TO STREAM STOPPED, HOWEVER THERE IS CRUDE IN THE STREAM HELD BACK BY VEGETATION AND BOOMS, SHEEN POCKETS FOR 1/2 MILE. PRODUCT STILL ON PONDS. 11/14/05 RMC/WELL TENDER/SITE. EXCAVATION STARTED SAT. ABOUT 1/2 DONE, RMC ADVISED TO CONTINUE WITH OUT INTERRUPTION OR STATE WOULD FINISH. 11/15/05 RMC/CGM/SITE. SOME PRODUCT POCKETS AROUND ASTS. PIPE HAS BEEN BETTER SUPPORTED. POND CLOSEST TO THE ASTS HAS BEEN EXCAVATYED TO VISUAL CLEAN. LOWER POND EXCAVATED SOME BUT ABOUT A FOOT OF WATER WITH A HEAVY WATER LAYER ON TOP STILL EXISTS, RMC CONTACTED PERRY LOVELL, HE SAID IT WAS DARK WHEN THE QUIT LAST NIGHT. PLON ON PUMPING DOWN POND TODAY. 11/29/05 RMC/FILE. INSPECTED SITE LAST WEEK. DIKE AROUND ASTS HAS ABOUT 6 INCHES OF WATER IN IT. IT RAINED ONLY ABOUT 1/2 INCH. SLIGHT SHEENING. NO SHEEN OR VISUAL CONTAMINATION NOTED ON THE MIDDLE POND. THE LOWER POND HAS A HEAVY SHEEN ON ROADSIDE END, APPEARS TO BE MORE SOURCE MATERIAL. RMC DISCUSSED WITH PERRY LOVE AND KATLHLEEN RYAN RMC ADVISED PONDS MUST BE SHEENLESS AND RMC WILL REINSPECT THIS WEEK. ECO PLEAKIS CONTACTED ME THIS DAY. WE ARE TO MEET TO INSPECT TOGETHER 12/6 AT 9.30 AM. UPDATE 12/6/05. 12/06/05 RMC/ECO PLEAKIS/AL ALEXANDER/SITE. INSPECTED PROGRESS. SECONDARY CONTAINMENT COMPLETED. IT IS FILLED TO NEAR CAPACITY WITH WATER, TOO MUCH ICE TO BREAK COULD NOT TELL IF SHEEN. FIRST POND APPEARS TO BE SHEEN FREE. DIKE IS NOT COMPLETED NO SIPHON IS INSTALLED SO ANY LIQUID EXITING WILL COME FROM THE SURFACE. SECOND OR LOWER POND STILL HAS PRODUCT ON THE SURFACE. RMC TO

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 178

DISCUSS WITH SUPERVISOR KING. 01/17/06 RMC/FILE. LAST MONTH MET WITH DKK AND LE RE REQUIRMENTS AT CRUDE OIL SITES. PONDS MUST BE SHEENLESS. RMC TO INSPECT IN SPRING. UPDATE 3/1/06. 05/04/06 RMC/SITE. BOTH PONDS HAVE FLOATING CRUDE. DIKE BETWEEN ERODED AWAY WATER AROUND ASTS HAS SPOTTY SHEEN. DEAD FROGS IN LOWER POND. THAT ONE IS THE MORE HEAVILY CONTAMINATED. TOOK SEVERAL PICTURES. 05/05/06 RMC DKK/MEETING. HE WILL GET A MEETING TOGETHER WITH WATER, LE, AND MINERALS TO DISCUSS CRUDE OIL CLEANUPS IN GENERAL. RMC SENT NOTE TO ECO PLEAKIS ADVISING OF INSPECTION. UPDATE 5/20/06. 06/30/06 RMC/SITE. FACILITY NOT ACTIVE. PONDS HAVE SOME CRUDE ON THE SIDES, BUT LOOK BETTER THAN LAST INSPECTION. CONTAMINATED SOILS STILL ON SITE. PITS ARE SEEPING CRUDE OIL. PAST DISPOSAL TIME LIMIT. MATERIAL MUST BE SOLIDIFIED TO DISPOSAL. LETTER DISPOSAL BY 7/30/06. 12/28/06 RMC/FILE. RMC HAS INSPECTED THE SITE SEVERAL TIMES THIS PAST SUMMER AND FOUND ONE ROLL OFF WITH CRUDE OIL CONTAMINATED SOILS REMAINING ON SITE. RMC CONTACTED KATHLEEN RYAN AND LEFT MESSAGE REQUESTING DISPOSAL. UPDATE 1/15/07. 07/26/07 RMC/FILE. LEFT MESSAGE REQUESTING DISPOSAL RECEIPT. DUE 8/1/07. 07/27/07 RMC/FILE. RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPTS FOR LAST DUMPSTER. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED, CLOSE OUT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 179

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

WELL BURP FULMER VALLEY @ PERKINS

Spill Number: 0475037

Close Date: 04/20/2004

INDEPENDENCE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: FULMER VALLEY / PERKINS Revised zip code: 14806 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN JFOTTO

Spiller: MARK HASKINS - OTIS EASTERN SRV INC Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 498-0730 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/20/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 30.00 GALLONS 30.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WELL BURP CAUSED A SPILL. APPROX 250’ AREA. JOHN HOFFMAN SENT 2 MEN FOR THE CLEANUP. F&W NOTIFIED. AFTER CLEANUP THE WELL WILL BE PLUGGED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" *** Testing. This remark added by Bob Corcoran *** 04/20/04 HANDLED BY MINERALS. NO ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS. CLOSED THERE IS NO PAPER FILE FOR THIS SPILL

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 180

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DODGE CREEK - WELL BARBER RD

Spill Number: 0475050

Close Date: 10/23/2008

CLARKSVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC CHRIS MILLER RMCROSSE

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

JIM GROSS - UNK DEAN RHODES SR NYSDEC CHRIS MILLER

Spiller Phone: (716) 372-3893 Notifier Phone: (585) 928-2013 Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 372-0645

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/20/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ABANDON CRUDE OIL WELL LEAKING. IT IS NEXT TO DODGE CREEK A TROUT STREAN. OIL GETTING INTO CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/23/04: MF T/C CHRIS MILLER, WELLS IN THIS AREA HAVE BEEN LEAKING. SHOULD BE PLUGGED. 04/26/04: MF S/I ABANDON WELL NEXT TO CREEK & IS SLIGHTLY OVERFLOWING. NO RODS OR EQUIPMENT NOTICED IN THE WELL. THEER IS A SLIGHT SHEEN IN THE CREEK. MET WITH JERRY NEASE, 2347 RTE 305, 585-968-1024. HE OWNES HOUSE WHOS DRIVEWAY HAS TO BE ACCESSED TO SEE WELL. HE TOLD ME JIM GROSS OWNS THE PROPERTY WITH THE WELL ON IT. WENT TO THE COUNTY OFFICE TO LOOK UP OWNER: JAMES GROSS 263 EAST RIVERSIDE DR OLEAN NY 14760 245.-1-54.1 & .2 04/28/04: MF ROE LETTER TO LAND OWNER. RESPONSE BY 5/15/04.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 181

05/05/04: MF T/C/CHRIS MILLER & JIM GROSS. TOLD JIM TO CALL AG’S OFFICE IN ALBANY TO FIND OUT HIS LIABILITY THEN GET BACK TO ME. 05/21/04: MF NO RESPONSE LETTER TO RP, RESPONSE BY 6/4/04. 06/02/04: MF T/C CHRIS MILLER & JIM GROSS. HE HAS HIS DEED & WILL FAX TO ME AS TO OWNERS OF THE LEASE. RECEIVED PARTICAL DEED WITH LEASE HOLDERS NAMES FROM 1935. HE BOUGHT THE PROPERTY IN 1973. GAVE COPY TO LEGAL FOR OPINION. LEASE HOLDERS: 1) REUBEN HATCH 2) HERMAN FRAIR 3) OLSON FRAIR 4) EDNA EASTMAN 06/02/04: MF RECEIVED SIGNED ROE. 07/12/04: MF MAUREEN BRADY LOOKED OVER DEEDS. WHAT SEE GETS OUT OF THE DEEDS IS THAT THE GROSS’S OWN THE OIL & GAS RIGHTS BUT THESE ARE LEASED TO OTHER PARTIES. SUGGESTS LOOKING AT OTHER DEEDS: LIBER 342 PG 195 (THE GROSS DEED EXCEPTS PREMISES COVERED BY THIS DEED LIBER 536 PG 69 (DEED FROM WALLACE TO PRATT) LIBER 564 PG 469 (EASEMENT TO EMPIRE GAS & FUEL) LIBER 558 PG 900 (APPROPRIATION BY NYS) LIBER 36 OF DISCHARGE OF MORTGAGES AT PAGE 306 06/29/06 RMC/FILE. REVIEWED FILE. ROE SIGNED IN 2004. UNKNOWN IF WELL IS STILL LEAKING. DISCUSSED WITH DDK. SITE REQUIRES INSPECTION. UPDATE 7/10/06 06/30/06 RMC/SITE. ENTER DRIVEWAY AT 2347 ROUTE 305. LOCATED WELL 120 FEET NORTH OF 42 06.14N BY 078 15.413W, WELL NO LONGER DISCHARGING, CRUDE ABOUT 8" BELOW THE TOP OF THE CASING. VEGETATION GROWTH NORMAL AROUND THE WELL. NO VISUAL STAINING FOUND. DISCUSSED WITH DKK, TO INVESTIGATE PLUGGING WELL. CONTACTED EMPIRE GEO. WILL GET BACK TO ME WITH IDEAS. UPDATE 7/30/06. 07/07/06 RMC/CHUCK GUZZETTA/PHONE. EMPIRE GEO CAN OBTAIN QUOTES FOR PLUGGING WELL AND OVERSEE THE WORK. RMC DID PIN AUTHORIZATION. UPDATE 7/30/06. 07/27/06 RMC/FILE. RECEIVED PRICE OF 80 PER HOUR PLUS MATERIALS. EMPIRE GEO TO GET JOB PRICE. UPDATE 8/15/06. 08/07/06 RMC/JERRY JONES/WELL PLUGGER/SITE. INSPECTED WELL. COST ESTIMATE WILL BE SENT. UPDATE 8/15/06. 08/24/06 RMC/FILE. WELL PLUGGER WILL START 8/27/06. MINERALS, JOHN HOFFMAN WILL BE OVERSEEING FOR DEC MINERALS. CONFRENCED WITH JERRY JONES AND JOHN HOFFMAN, APPLICATION HAS BEEN MADE, MINERALS DOESNT HAVE GOOD MAPS FOR THIS AREA. WILL HAVE TO CLEAN OUT WELL FIRST THEN GET DIRECTION FROM MINERALS. TO GO FORWARD. 01/04/06 RMC/DAVE STEINER/PHONE. HE IS WAITING ON CALL BACK FROM THE DRILLER. EXPECTED TO GET TO WORK ON IT THIS MONTH RMC ADVISED TO GO TO MINERALS AND WORK OUT PLAN AND SCHEDULE. UPDATE 1/15/07. 07.23.07 RMC/DAVE STEINER/MEETING. HE IS AWAITING A START DATE FROM THE CONTRACTOR TO PLUG THE WELL. UPDATE 8/15/07.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 182

01/04/08 RMC/DKK/MEETING. WELL WORK NOT COMPLETED AS UNABLE TO GET A CONTRACTOR TO DO IT. DKK WILL TALK TO MINERALS ABOUT OTHER OPTIONS. UPDATE 2/28/07 02/28/08: DKK T/C CHRIS MILLER, DEC-MINERALS: CHRIS ADVISED THAT DRILLING COMPANIES IN THE AREA ARE VERY BUSY AND MAY NOT BE AVAILABLE FOR PLUGGING OF ONE WELL. HOWEVER, IF WE DECIDE TO RE-SOLICIT DRILLERS FOR THIS PURPOSE, HE PROVIDED ME WITH THREE COMPANIES WHICH MAY BE INTERESTED. ALSO WE DISCUSSED THE USEPA WELL PLUGGING PROJECT (MOORE LEASE) CURRENTLY UNDERWAY IN ALLEGANY COUNTY. JEFF BECTELL IS THE PROJECT MAMAGER. IF THERE IS A MEANS BY WHICH THE MOORE LEASE PROJECT COULD BE EXPANDED, WE MAY BE ABLE TO OBTAIN THE ASSISTANCE OF USEPA FOR PLUGGING OF THE DODGE CREEK WELL. 03/10/08 RMC/FILE. LEFT MESSAGE FOR JEFF BECHTEL, 732-906-6807. UPDATE 3/30/08. 03/13/08 RMC/FILE. SENT COPY OF FILE TO JEFF BECHTEL 585-928-1805, FOR REVIEW. UPDATE 4/30/08. 05/29/08 DKK/FILE. T/C WITH JOHN HOFFMAN, DEC-MINERALS. JOHN IS PREPARING WELL PLUGGING PERMIT FOR WELL. PERMIT WILL BE ISSUED TO USEPA, WITH PROJECTED START OF PLUGGING ON 6/2/08 @ 0800 HRS.(THE START TIME MAY BE SUBJECT TO CHANGE). JOHN WILL INCLUDE A 24-HOUR NOTICE REQUIREMENT (PRIOR TO START OF WORK) SO THAT DEC-SPILLS WILL BE AWARE OF ACTIVITIES AT THE SITE AND CAN DO INSPECTION AS APPROPRIATE. 06/10/08 DKK/SI. INSPECTED SITE WITH JEFF BECTEL, USEPA. DRILLER IS ON-SITE AND HAS DRILLED OUT WOODEN PLUG AT APPROX. 350 FEET. STEEL ENCOUNTERED BELOW 350 FEET; NEXT STEP IS TO ATTEMPT TO REMOVE STEEL DEBRIS FROM WELL. OILY SLUDGE, DRILL CUTTINGS, ETC. ARE CONTAINERIZED ON-SITE FOR DISPOSAL. NO OIL RELEASES TO DODGE CREEK. 10/23/08 RMC/FILE. USEPA PLUGGED WELL AT REQUEST OF DEC, ISR COMPLETED. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSE OUT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 183

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BROWN #5 CRUDE OIL WELL 7556 RT.474

Spill Number: 0475007

Close Date: 04/12/2004

CLYMER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14724 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER DEC BRIAN JANDREW MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

DOUG - GREAT LAKES ENERGY SAME MINERAL RESOURCES BRIAN JANDREW

Spiller Phone: (716) 753-3385 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 372-0645

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/06/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAID THAT CRUDE OIL WELL NAME,BROWN #5,HAS OVERFLOWED CRUDE OIL,ABOUT 50 GAL,ALL ON THE GROUND....AL ALEXANDER,MINERALS, IS ON SITE CLEANING UP. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/06/04: MF S/I/RICK GRAVES OF WELL REPAIR CO OUT OF ELDRED PA. WHEN PULLING PIPE FROM GAS WELL CRUDE OIL SPILLED FROM AN OVERFLOWING 100 GALLON TANK. THIS TANK IS USED TO CATCH THE SPILLAGE. IT IS TOO SMALL. SORBENTS PACED ON THE SPILLAGE. SPILLAGE TO BE REMEDIATED. AL ALEXANDER OF MINERALS HAS WAS ON SITE. T/C RICK, GREAT LAKES ENERGY, OWNER OF THE WELL. HE IS WORKING WITH MINERALS TO CLEAN SPILLAGE. 04/09/04: MF T/C JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS. THEY WILL FOLLOW UP. 04/12/04: E-MAIL TO JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS WILL BE THE LEAD AGENCY FOR THIS SPILL. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 184

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS/OIL WELLS NEAR 3159 BURTON ROAD

Spill Number: 0475082

Close Date: 05/17/2004

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons DEBRA DAHLQUIST JFOTTO

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 484-6563 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/2004 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WAXY/GOLDEN SUBSTANCE NOTICED COMING OUT OF GAS/OIL WELLS, THE MATERIAL HAS COLLECTED IN TIRE RUTS ALONG TRAIL, COMPLAINANTS DOG CAME IN CONTACT WITH THE MATERIAL AND HAS ILL EFFECTS FROM IT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 05/14/04 JFO ON SITE MET WITH MR DAVIS. HE SHOWED ME WHERE THE 2 CLOSEST WELLS ARE LOCATED. I CHECKED THE WELLS AND FOUND NO YELLOW WAXY MATERIAL. I TOLD MR DAVIS I WOULD CHECK WITH MINERALS TO SEE IF THEY HAVE HAD SIMILIAR PROBLEMS. 05/17/04 JFO CALL TO CHRIS MILLER OF MINERALS. HE IS NOT FAMILIAR WITH ANY PROBLEMS LIKE THIS. POSSIBLY THE DOG HAD AN ALERGIC REACTION TO THE OIL. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE BY SPILLS. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 185

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CHAUTAUQUA ENERGY RAMSEY & BUTTS RD

Spill Number: 0475278

Close Date: 09/10/2004

NORTH HARMONY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: RAMSEY / BUTTS RD Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN MXFRANKS

Spiller: ERNEST REMALT - CHAUTAUQUA ENERGY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: ERNEST REMALT

Spiller Phone: (716) 326-4977 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 326-4977

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/03/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 10.00 GALLONS 10.00 GALLONS SOIL BRINE OTHER 275.00 GALLONS 275.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 5 BARRELS OF BRINE SPILLED FROM AROUND WELL-BUTTS #1A WHICH IS 1000 FT OFF THE ROAD. CHAUT ENERGY DITCHED AROUND THE SPILL AND HAS RECOVERED THE BRINE AND CRUDE. THEY WILL PAD UP THE REMAINING SPILLAGE. MINERALS HAS INDICATED THEY WILL INSPECT AND FOLLOW UP. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 09/04/04: MF S/I/RAY CHYLINSKI, WELL TENDER. DRAIN VALVE FROM STOCK TANK (7878) NOT TURNED OFF WHEN BRINE WAS DRAINED CAUSING OVERFILL OF THE BRINE TANK. LOST BRINE & CRUDE TO THE SURFACE. RAY TOLD ME BRIAN JANDREW OF MINERALS WAS ON SITE & IS MONITORING CLEAN UP. SURFACE BRINE & CRUDE HAS BEEN PICKED UP. MINERALS TO FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 186

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

EAST RESOURCES LEASE NICHOLS RUN RD

Spill Number: 0485712

Close Date: 04/20/2005

, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC BRIAN JANDREW MXFRANKS

Spiller: ED FIRDUCO - EAST RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: ED FIDURKO

Spiller Phone: 814-590-5060 Notifier Phone: ext. 6 Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (814) 590-5060

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/24/2005 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL, SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: lead line broke cousing crude oil to flow into nichols run creek aoox 4000’ away -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 03/28/05: MF T/C ED FIRDUCO AFTER A CALL FROM MINERALS OF A SPILL THAT OCCURED 3/24/05. CLAIMED CREEK BOOMED & LINE REPAIRED. WHEN ASKED WHY SPILL WAS NOT REPORTED HE RESPONDED THAT IN PA IT DOSN’T HAVE TO. MEETING SCHEDULED FOR TOMORROW AT 1430. 03/29/05: MF S/I/ED FIDURKO, TIM WYMER, EAST RESOURCES. 2" LEAD LINE DEVELOPED LEAK APPX 12’ BG. PIPE CLAMP INSTALLED. CRUDE FLOWED TO FEEDER TO NICHOLS RUN CREEK APPX 4000’ AWAY. PIPE DAM INSTALLED, BOOM & PADS IN PLACE AT VARIOUS LOCATIONS. WATER VERY FAST & SILTY, MELT OFF THE LAST FEW DAYS. PIPE REPAIR EXCAVATION OPEN, WATER/CRUDE APPX 5’ BG. TO BE PADDED. CHECKED BY LARRY MURPHY’S PROPERTY WHERE FEEDER GOES INTO NICHOLS RUN CREEK. UNABLE TO TELL IF ANY SHEEN, CREEK TOO FAST & MUDDY. NO ODOR NOTICED. WILL REINSPECT. 04/18/05: MF S/I/TIM, FOREMAN. CHECKED SPILL AREA. NO PRODUCT/SHEEN/ODOR NOTICED IN NICHOLS RUN CREEK. SEPARATOR FUNCTING, NO PRODUCT/SHHEN. ALL THE PRODUCT HAS BEEN VACCED & PLACED IN THEIR STOCH TANK ALONG WITH WATER. THE WATER IS USED FOR THE INJECTION

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

WELLS. MELT OFF & RAIN MADE FURTHER REMEDIATION NOT POSSIBLE. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. *****************************COMPUTER FILE ONLY**********************************

Page 187

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 188

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GREAT LAKES ENERGY CABBAGE HILL RD. @ STATE LINE RD.

Spill Number: 0485577

Close Date: 02/22/2005

CLYMER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: CABBAGE HILL RD. / STATE LINE RD. Revised zip code: 14724 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

NON-MAJOR FACILITY (>1100 GAL) Tank Tester DOUG STEBBINS MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: DOUG STEBBINS Caller Agency: GREAT LAKES ENERGY & PARTNERS Contact for more spill info: DOUG STEBBINS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (716) 753-3385 Caller Phone: (716) 499-4364 Contact Person Phone: (716) 499-4364

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/18/2005 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 1000 GALLONS 1000 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATES THAT UP TO 1000 GAL OF BRINE FROM A BRINE TANK,LEFT THE SECONDARY CONTAINMENT AREA AND WENT ONTO A FIELD...GREAT LAKES WILL VAC UP THE PRODUCT AND PLACE IN IN A HOLDING TANK...NONE OF THE BRINE REACHED ANY WATERWAYS,IT POOLED IN A SMALL AREA. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: 02/18/05: MF S/I/DOUG STEBBINS & CREW, GREAT LAKES ENERGY, 100 E CHAUTAUQUA ST. PO BOX 187, MAYVILLE NY 14757, 716-753-3385. OFF LOADING PIPE ON THE BOTTOM OF A 50K BRINE TANK BROKE. LEAKED APPX 8K GALLONS OF BRINE TO A 73’x40’ LINED EARTHEN DIKE. THE BRINE BREECHED THE WALL & TRAVELED DOWN THE ROAD TO BEHIND THE COMPRESSER BUILDING. APPX 6000 GALLONS OF BRINE VACCED FROM THE TANK. APPX 6K GALLONS OF BRINE VACCED FROM THE DIKE & SURROUNDING AREA. THE LAND OWNER HAS BEEN NOTIFIED. THEY WILL BE ON SITE TOMORROW FOR ADDITIONAL CLEANUP. 02/19/05: MF S/I/DOUG STEBBING, PUDDLES ON SITE FROZE. CHECKED WHAT LIQUID I COULD BY TASTING. IT APPEARS MOST OF THE BRINE HAS BEEN VACCED UP. I DID NOT NOTICE ANY GETTING OFF SITE. NEAREST ADDRESS TO SPILL IS 9132 STATE LINE RD. AREA SHOULD BE INSPECTED IN THE SPRING TO SEE WHAT VEGETATION DAMAGE IF ANY WAS DONE. GREAT LAKES WILL DO THIS. THERE AREA 2-50K GALLON TANKS IN THE DIKE. I WAS TOLD THE ONE THAT LEAKED (BACK ONE) WAS APPX 1/4 FULL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

02/22/05: MF T/C CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS, THEY WILL FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ******************************COMPUTER FILE ONLY*****************************

Page 189

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 190

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DOT WELL 3163 STATE RD 248

Spill Number: 0310905

Close Date: 12/24/2003

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Local Agency DISPATCHER HALL MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

NYSDOT TOM BARNETT ALLEGANY COUNTY 911 TOM BARNETT

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (585) 268-9460 Caller Phone: (585) 268-9460 Contact Person Phone: (585) 268-9460

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/23/2003 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL WELL LEAKING UNKNOWN AMOUNT OF OIL AND VENTING UNKNOWN TYPE GAS (POSS NATURAL GAS). NO CLEAN UP IN PROGRESS. OIL LEAK HAS STOPPED, HOWEVER THE GAS LEAK IS ACTIVE AT THIS TIME. ALLEGANY HAZMAT AND WILLING FIRE DEPARTMENT ARE CLEARING THE SCENE. THIS WELL IS LOCATED ON PRIVATE PROPERTY (RESIDENCE) OWNER IS UNKNOWN - SAME TYPE PROBLEM HAS OCCURED HERE BEFORE. DEC REP CAN CONTACT ALLEGANY COUNTY 911 - THEY WILL IN TURN CONTACT THE FIRE CHIEF TO MEET DEC REP ON SCENE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 12/23/03: MF SPILL BEING HANDLED UNDER #9700048. 0310905 WILL BE CLOSED & HANDLED UNDER #9700048. *******************COMPUTER FILE ONLY*******************

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 191

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL WELL SPILL 5880 DRAUDT RD

Spill Number: 0375386

Close Date: 05/20/2004

ORCHARD PARK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14127 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons MARIE ROSA FXGALLEG

Spiller: THOMAS WEIL - WEIL RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: DENNIS GORSKI

Spiller Phone: (716) 684-1222 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 674-7483 Contact Person Phone: (716) 861-2807

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/01/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER INDICATES THERE IS A CRUDE OIL WELL ON THE PROPERTY THAT IS ACTIVE AND HAS SPILLS THAT ARE NOT CLEANED UP. SHE SAID THE WELL IS FAR BACK ON THE PROPERTY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 11/7/03 FG SITE INSPECTION. SPILL OF CRUDE OIL ON GROUND AROUND WELL AND STORAGE TANK. ODORS EVIDENT AT HOUSE CLOSE BY. AL ALEXANDER WITH MINERALS INDICATED THAT THE OWNER IS WEIL RESOURCES74 N. AURORA, LANCASTER, NY 14086 684-1222. CALLED WEIL AND NO ANSWER. LETTER MAILED AND FAXED 684-3802 TO THEM REQUESTING REMEDIATION. 11/10/03: MF T/C WEIL RESOURCES, NO ANSWER. 11/18/03 FG CALLED WEIL AND A SECRETARY ANSWERED. SHE SAID MR. WEIL IS IN HOUSTON AND WILL GET BACK TO ME.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 192

11/18/03 ANNE FROM WEIL RESOURCES CALLED AND SAID THAT THE FUEL MAN WILL CALL TOMORROW AND MEET ME ON SITE TO DISCUSS WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE. 11/25/03 HAVE NOT HEARD FROM WEIL. FG CALLED ANNE FROM WEIL WHO SAID SHE WILL HAVE THE FUEL MAN CALL ME NEXT WEEK. 12/9/03 FG SITE INSPECTION WITH WEIL RESOURCES. THEY WILL CLEANUP THE SPILL AND DISPOSE OF IT. HE WILL CALL ME WHEN HE DOES THE WORK. 12/29/03: SAC TELECON MARIE ROZUK, MS. ROZUK SAID THAT SPILL HAS NOT BEEN CLEANED UP AND THAT THE HOSE CONTINUES TO OVERFLOW THE CONTAINER. 12/29/03: MF S/I NOOS, STRONG CRUDE OIL ODOR. LEAKAGE AROUND STOCK TANK. NOTICED HOLE IN THE STACK TANK APPX 1’ FROM THE BOTTOM. PLUGGED HOLE WITH A TWIG. TANK IS PARTIALLY OPEN TO THE WEATHER. TT/C WEIL RESOURCES, LEFT PAGER # & MESSAGE. 12/30/03: MF T/C/DENNIS GORSKI, WEIL RESOURCES. TOLD HIM OF LEAK. HE DID NOT BELIEVE ME AS HE TOLD ME TANK HAD BEEN PUMPED. HE WILL CHECK IT OUT. 01/02/04: MF S/I/NOOS, NO LEAK FROM THE STOCK TANK. TANK APPEARS TO BE PUMPED BELOW HOLE. STRONG ODOR. WOOD CHIPS SPREAD OVE SPILL AREA. T/C DENNIS GORSKI, NO ANSWER. 01/05/04: MF T/C DENNIS GORSKI, CLAIMED AREA CLEANED, SOIL TAKEN TO LANCASTER, APPX 2 YARDS, WILL BE DISPOSED OF. TOLD HIM TO CALL WASTEMANAGEMENT TO START DISPOSAL PROCESS. T/C MARIE ROSA 674-7483, SHE IS HAPPY WITH CLEAN UP. SHE DON’T WANT THE WELL ON HER PROPERY. GAVE HER MINERALS #. 3/30/04 FG CALLED WEIL RESOURCES AND THEY SAID THEY WILL DISPOSE OF SOIL AND PROVIDE DISPOSAL RECEIPT. 4/28/04 FG CALLED WEIL RESOURCES AND THEY SAID THEY WILL DISPOSE OF THE SOIL WITHIN THE NEXT WEEK AND CALL BACK WITH DISPOSAL RECEIPTS. 5/12/04 FG CALLED WEIL RESOURCES AND THEY SAID THEY HAVEN’T BEEN ABLE TO GET A TRUCK TO DISPOSE OF THE SOIL. THEY WILL TRY WITHIN THE NEXT SEVERAL WEEKS AND GET THE DISPOSAL RECEIPT TO ME THEN. 5/20/04 RECD SOIL DISPOSAL RECPT. NO FURTHER WORK IS REQUIRED. THE SITE IS CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 193

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATURAL GAS ODOR COUNTY ROAD #58/BOWERS RD

Spill Number: 0375502

Close Date: 03/16/2004

CASSADAGA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14718 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Affected Persons RENEE MAJKA JFOTTO

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

UNKNOWN SAME 7395 BOWERS ROAD RENEE MAJKA

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 595-3499 Contact Person Phone: (716) 595-3499

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/15/2004 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAID THAT SHE SMELLS NATURAL GAS ON COUNTY ROAD #58 JUST PAST BOWERS ROAD,HEADED TOWARD STOCKTON,IN AN OPEN FIELD...NOTIFIED CHCHD,THEY WILL INVESTIGATE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 03/16/04 JFO CONTACTED JOHN HOFFMAN OF THE NYS DIV OF MINERAL RESOURCES. HE WILL CONTACT MS MAJKA FOR MORE INFORMATION. NO ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS. CLOSED THERE IS NO PAPER FILE FOR THIS SPILL

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 194

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BRINE W/PETROLEUM COUNTY RD 29

Spill Number: 0375020

Close Date: 01/21/2004

ALMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14708 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROB GREGORESKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: R. GREGORESKI - NATIONAL FUEL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL Contact for more spill info: ROB GREGORSKI

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone: (716) 448-3940

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/11/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected OTHER PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL The following material was dropped or revised by the NYS DEC. OTHER PETROLEUM UNKNOWN 200.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE FROM WELL WENT INTO CONTAINMENT POND & OVERFLOWED-DIDN’T REACH ANY WATERBODY OR DITCH. CALLER WILL BE @ SITE 1-1:30 TODAY. RESPONDER SHOULD CONTACT ROB G. BY PAGER (716-448-3940) FOR DIRECTIONS BEFORE RESPONDING. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/11/03: MF S/I/JEFFERY GERTZEN, NAT FUEL EMPLOYEE. WELL 2315(493) OFF CR 29 HAD A PROBLEM WITH A FLOAT SWITCH WHICH CAUSED EXCESS BRINE TO BE PUMPED INTO AG 2K BRINE TANK. IT OVERFLOWED SPILLING APPX 200 GALLONS OF BRINE & 10 GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL TO AN EARTHEN DIKE AROUND THIS TANK. FLOAT SWITCH TO BE REDESIGNED. CLEAN UP NECESSARY. I EXPLAINED TO JEFF WHAT MUST BE DONE. I COULD NOT WAIT FOR ROB G AS HE WAS STILL HOURS AWAY. 04/14/03: MF CLEANUP LETTER SENT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

04/17/03: MF S/I/BOB GERGERESKI & JEFF GERTZEN, NAT FUEL. AREA CLEANED & CLEAN UP DEBRIS STAGED ON SITE. IWS WILL DISPOSE OF IT. 06/03/03: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 6/30/03. 06/04/03: MF T/C KARA, NYSDOH, 518-402-7810. GAVE HER SPILL INFO. 08/25/03: MF REVIEWED 7/7/03 FAX OF SAMPLING RESULTS. BENZENE 95.2 PPB IN THE BRINE, NO PCB’S, NO LEAD. TC ROB G, LEFT MESSAGE. 01/21/04: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPTS, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 195

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 196

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

TOWN OF BENNINGTON HIGHWA 905 OLD ALLEGHANY RD

Spill Number: 0375412

Close Date: 12/02/2003

BENNINGTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14011 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Responsible Party RICK JENSEN RMCROSSE

Spiller: RICK JENSEN - TOWN OF BENNINGTON Notifier Name: Caller Agency: BENNINGTON HIGHWAY DEPT. Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 591-2664 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 591-2664 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/01/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 2000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 30000 GALLON AST PARTIAL FAILURE. AST HAD 20K SALT BRINE FOR ROAD APPLICATION, ABOUT 2K OF THE MATERIAL HAS BEEN RELEASED, MATERIAL WENT IN TO A DITCH THAT WAS ALREADY FLOWING HEAVILY WITH RUN OFF, DITCH DISCHARGES TO CAYUGA CREEK, TANK IS BEING PUMPED DOWN NOW. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 12/01/03 RMC/FILE. COPIED DONNA KIERSZ, DAN DAVID, WATER, LEGAL, AND FISH AND WILDLIFE. DISCUSSED WITH SAC, NON-PETROLEUM, NON-HAZ., NO SPILL ACTION AVAILABLE, NO INSPECTION BY SPILLS NECESSARY DOW IS RESPONSIBLE DURING BUSINESS HOURS. 12/02/03 RMC/FILE. NO SPILL ACTION REQUIRED, CLOSE OUT. NO PAPER FILE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 197

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL CR 29 WELL #2315

Spill Number: 0375144

Close Date: 12/08/2003

ALMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14708 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROB GREGORESKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: R. GREGORESKI - NATIONAL FUEL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL Contact for more spill info: ROB GREGORESKI

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone: (716) 827-2253

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/12/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE SPILLED WHEN CONTAINMENT AREA OVERFLOWED. AN EXISTING SPILL AT THIS WELL IS BEING HANDLED BY MF. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 06/12/03: MF S/I/ROB GREGORSSKI, BOB WALTERS, JEFF GERTZON, NAT FUEL. MALFUNCTION OF CONTROLLER CAUSED BRINE TO OVER FLOW 1.5K AG BRINE TANK. BRINE GOT INTO THE FIELD ACROSS THE ROAD. THIS AREA IS IN THE WOODS APPX 1 MILE FROM CR 29. NATIONAL FUEL OWNS THE PROPERTY. NO CRUDE OIL INVOLVED. I ASKED NAT FUEL TO SAMPLE & ANALYZE SPILL AREA FOR TCLP METALS & THE LIQUID BRINE FOR TOTAL LEAD. AG BRINE TANK TO BE REPLACED WITH 12K TANK. BRINE IN EARTHEN BERMED DIKE VACCED BY FOX & PLACE IN COMPRESSOR STATION BRINE PONDS. 06/13/03: MF LETTER TO RP. 06/16/03: MF E-MAIL FROM RP, BRINE IN THE FIELD WEIGHS 8.6 LBS. THE BRINE LINE FROM THE UGT TO CR 29 WAS PRESSURED TESTED AT 50 PSI, IT HELD.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

12/08/03: MF NO CLEANUP NECESSARY ON THIS SPILL. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. *****************COMPUTER FILE ONLY*****************

Page 198

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 199

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OLDHAM WELL #1 11420 COUNTY LINE RD

Spill Number: 0375461

Close Date: 06/29/2005

PERRYSBURG, NY 14062

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOE HAUSBECK MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

R. GREGORESKI - NATIONAL FUEL CHRIS MILLER NYSDEC RICHARD ZETS

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Notifier Phone: (716) 372-0645 Caller Phone: (716) 851-7190 Contact Person Phone: (716) 934-2475

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/01/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: GAS WELL LEAKING, MAY BELONG TO NAT FUEL. IN LEGAL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 01/29/04: MF DISCUSSION WITH JOE HOUSBECK, HE IS HAVING A PROBLEM WITH NAT FUEL. DEC WANTS NAT FUEL TO PLUG THE LEAKING GAS WELL. IF THINGS DON’T WORK OUT HE WANTS THE SPILL FUND TO PLUG THIS WELL. 02/02/04: MF T/C RICHARD ZETS, HE WILL SIGN ROE. HE CLAIMED MARY YEARS AGO NAT FUEL WAS GOING TO PLUG WELL UNTIL THE DEC STUCK THEIR NOSE INTO IT. SITE MEETING SCHEDULED 2/5/04, 0900. ROE SENT TO LAND OWNER. 02/05/04: MF S/I/RICHARD ZETS, WE INSPECTED OLDHAM WELL #1, THE AREA IS COVERED WITH APPX 2’ OF SNOW. NO STAINING NOTICED. THERE IS A 1K GALLON PLASTIC TANK ON SITE CONNECTED TO THIS WELL THRU A HOSE. THERE IS CRUDE OIL & WATER IN THIS TANK. IT IS PARTICALLY OPENED TO THE WEATHER. DISCUSSED ROE, HE WILL SIGN IF HE HAS NO LIABILITY. TOLD HIM TO INCLUDE THIS IN THE FORM.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 200

02/10/04: MF RECEIVED SIGNED ROE FORM FROM RICHARD ZETS. 05/12/04: MF S/I NOOS, CRUDE OIL AROUND WELL & HOLING TANK. TANK APPX 1/4 FULL. TOOK PICTURES, THIS IS AN AREA OF POOR DRAINAGE. 09/23/04: MF S/I/NOOS, TANK CONTAINS APPX 170 GALLONS OF LIQUID. NO FP ON THE GROUND NOTICED. THERE AREA SIGNS OF OLD SPILLAGE ON THE GROUND AROUND THIS TANK. 06/01/05: MF APPX DATE, DISCUSSION WITH JOE HOUSBECK, DEC LAWYER. SPILLS END CAN BE CLOSED, NAT FUEL MAY PLUG. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. 06/20/08: DKK E/M CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS: WELL HAS BEEN PLUGGED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 201

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

JACK WOOD CAMP HOG BROOK RD

Spill Number: 0375285

Close Date: 09/20/2004

ALLENTOWN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14707 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC CHRIS MILLER MXFRANKS

Spiller: CARL CASE - CASE OIL COMPANY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: JACK WOOD

Spiller Phone: (716) 772-7924 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (814) 870-4245

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/01/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE WELL LEAKING INTO A POND. DEC MINERALS INDICATED THAT THEY PLUGGED THE WELL AND IT IS NO LONGER LEAKING BUT THE POND IS IMPACTED. MINERALS SAID THAT THE PROPERTY OWNER IS CLEANING THE POND AND THEY NEED SOME ADDITIONAL MATERIAL TO ASSIST IN THE CLEANUP. CASE OIL CO OWNS THE WELL AND THEY ARE NOT RESPONSIVE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 09/08/03: MF S/I/BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS. CRUDE OIL ALL OVER A PRIVATE APPX 1 ACRE POND. OIL CAME FROM AN ABANDON CRUDE OIL WELL ON THE BANK OF THE POND. WELL & OTHERS ON THIS PROPERTY OWNED BY CARL CASE OUT OF LOCKPORT. PLACED PADS IN THE POND. NEED VAC TRUCK & A BOAT. T/C/JACK WOOD, OWNER OF THE PROPERTY. EXPLAINED THAT THE STATE CAN DO THE WORK IF HE SIGNS ROE. HE AGREED. 09/09/03: MF T/C/CARL CASE HE AGREED TO REMOVE OIL OFF THE POND & TO PLUG PROBLEM WELL. LETTER TO RP, FP TO BE REMOVED FROM THE POND BY 9/12/03. WELL TO BE PLUGGED BY 9/30/03. 09/11/03: MF S/I NOTHING DONE. 1100 T/C CARL CASE, LEFT MESSAGE. 2000 T/C CARL CASE, LEFT MESSAGE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 202

09/12/03: 0830 T/C CARL CASE, LEFT MESSAGE. T/C/GREG NW, THEY WILL START ARRANGING EQUIPMENT. 09/12/03: MF S/I/NW, 4-MEN, VAC TRUCK. VACCING PRODUCT FROM MIDDLE POND. BOOMS & PADS USED TO GATHER OIL TO ONE END FOR VACCING. 09/13/03: MF S/I/DOUG CLAIRE, TOWN SUPERVISOR/DAVE WALSH, NEIGHBOR/JACK WOOD, OWNER. EXPLAINED WHAT STATE IS DOING. 09/14/03: MF T/C/RUSS SAVAGE, HE WILL SEND 2 MEN 9/15/03, TO PICK UP SHORE LINE VEGETATION (LOT OF PRODUCT LOCKED UP), TAKE DISPOSAL SAMPLE. TOLD HIM I WILL PAY 4 HOURS TRAVEL TIME & I WANT 6 HOURS OF SITE WORK PER MAN. VAC TRUCK FULL (3K GALLONS) CONTENTS TO BE DISPOSED OF. 09/15/03: MF T/C NRC, MS. RAWLS CASE #656884. 09/15/03: MF T/C DAN CARO, CARL’S LAWYER 881-3010, LEFT MESSAGE. 09/16/03: MF T/C/DAN CARO, EXPLAINED SITUATION & THAT CARL WILL GET FINED & INVOICED FOR THECOST OF THIS WORK. THE AMOUNT OF FINE WILL DEPEND ON IF HE PLUGS THE WELL. S/I 0940, NW ARRIVED WITH A BACKHOE AT 1400. THE POND LOOKS A LOT BETTER. NW WAS ON SITE 9/15/03 PADDING. 3 WASTE MANAGEMENT ROLL OFFS ON SITE. T/CRUSS, TOLD HIM DEBRIS MUST GO TO THE ALLEGANY COUNTY LANDFILL. 09/17/03: MF S/I/NW, 3-MEN REMOVING & STAGING CONTAMINATED SOIL FROM THE SIDES OF THE POND. PADDING OIL IN THE POND. 4 ROLL OFFS ON SITE. T/C DAN SPRAZZA, CARL CASE’S LAWYER, TO RETURN CALL. 09/18/03: MF S/I/NW, 3-MEN, REMOVING CONTAMINATED SOIL FROM THE SIDES OF THE POND. REMOVING PADS & BOOMS FROM THE POND. A LOT OF RAIN EXPECTED TONITE DUE TO ISABEL. THE WILL BE DONE TODAY. 09/22/03: MF T/C DAN SPERRAZZA, HE WILL SEND COPY OF SURRENDER OF THE LEASE. 09/23/03: MF RECEIVED COPY OF SURRENDER OF LEASE. CAN’T TELL IF ITS ALMA LEASE. SURRENDERED TO: JOHN D BRADLEY 17 CAYUGA RD SEA RANCH LAKES FLORIDA 33308

RICHARD W BRADLEY 263 W STATE ST WELLSWILLE NY 14895 585-593-4806

954-942-3893 T/C MRS. RICHARD BRADLEY, HER HUSBAND IS DEAD. SHE GAVE ME JOHN’S ADDRESS. PRP LETTER TO BOTH THE ABOVE PARTIES.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 203

SENT FAX OF ABOVE INFO TO CHRIS MILLER. 09/29/03: MF S/I NOOS, 3 FULL ROLLOFFS. SHEEN & SOME OLD FP ON THE DOWN WIND SIDE OF THE POND. T/C GREG WEBER, NW, TOLD HIM TO HAVE HIS MEN PAD THIS AREA BEFORE ROLL OFFS DISPOSED OF. 10/06/03: MF DISCUSSION WITH DAVE SEVER, HE TALKED TO RICK KENNEDY, BRADLEYS LAWYER 848-1407, RICK CLAIMED BRADLEY DOSN’T OWN WOOD CAMP LEASE. T/C/JACK WOOD, LEFT MESSAGE FOR DEED. T/C RICK KENNEDY CLAIMED CASE OWNS MINERAL RIGHTS AT WOOD’S CAMP. HE WILL FAX ME THE DEED. FAXED HIM SURRENDER OF BOLIVAR LEASES BY CASE. 10/06/03: MF PROCESSED LSL $151.63 PP FOR DISPOSAL SAMPLING 9/23/03, INVOICE #0314975-2344. T/C DAN SPERRAZZA, NOT IN, 881-2755 FAX. FAXED HIM INFO RICK KENNEDY SENT ME, 10/16/03: MF S/I NOOS, ROLL OFFS GONE. VERY SLIGHT SHEENING ON THE POND & IN THE SEDIMENTS DOWN WIND SIDE. VERY LITTLE OLD FP ALSO ON THIS SIDE OF THE POND. 10/17/03: MF PROCESSED NW $10,940.53 PP FOR SITE WORK 9/12/03 TO 9/18/03. INVOICE #03-268-01. 11/10/03: MF PROCESSED NW $2710.02 PP FOR DISPOSAL PAPERWORK & PADDING POND 9/29/03 - 10/2/03. INVOICE #03-268-02. INCLUDED IN THE COST IS $2082.80 FOR ROLLOFF RENTAL & DISPOSAL AT ALLEGANY LANDFILL. BILLED BY WASTE MANAGEMENT FOR TRANSPORTING SOIL. 11/13/03:SAC RETURNED NW $2710.22 PP INVOICE #03-268-02 BECAUSE COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT WAS INCLUDED IN INVOICE WHICH IS NOT CORRECT SINCE NEW CONTRACT IS IN EFFECT FOR THIS WORK PERIOD, ALSO WORK PERIOD OVERLAPS THE DATE WHERE OLD CONTRACT ENDS AND NEW CONTRACT BEGINS, THEREFORE TWO SEPARATE PP WILL NEED TO BE SUBMITTED. 11/24/03: MF PROCESS NW $58.96 PP FOR DISPOSAL PAPERWORK. INVOICE #03-268-02, 9/29/03. PROCESSED NW $2627.57 PP FOR ROLL OFF RENTAL, DISPOSAL OF SOIL AT ALLEGANY LANDFILL & PADDING POND. INVOICE #03-268-02A, 10/2/03. $1749.15 IS FOR ROLL OFF RENTAL & DISPOSAL. T/C WASTE MANAGEMENT, QUESTIONED WHY WERE PAYING $10.37, $9.72 & $4.19. T/C COLLEEN 716-481-5072, SPOKE TO LISA, THEN FAXED HER INVOICE FOR HER TO FIND OUT WHY WE HAVE TO PAY FOR DISPOSAL. 11/24/03: MF SENT OUT 6 BID LETTERS FOR WELL PLUGGING, DUE 12/31/03. 11/26/03: MF PROCESSED NW $328.24 PP FOR DISPOSAL OF 2 DRUMS OF OIL (SOAKED PADS & BOOMS). INVOICE #03-268-03, 10/22/03. T/C LISA THERE WILL BE NO CHARGE FOR DISPOSAL. SHE WILL REINVOICE NW. T/C NW, GREG TOLD OF ABOVE. SENT BACK PP 03-268-02A. 12/10/03: MF RECEIVED BID OF $2300. TO PLUG WELL FROM. JAMES W DAY CONTRACTING 1338 BARTLETT RD

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

BOLIVAR NY 14715

Page 204

585-928-2686

12/22/03: MF PROCESSED NW $1532.20 PP, INVOICE #03-268-02A, 10/2/03. FOR DISPOSAL OF THE 4 ROLLOFFS AT ALLEGANY CO LANDFILL. ROLL OFF RENTAL $987.43. SEE 11/24/03 NOTES. 12/29/03: MF RECEIVED HAND DELIVERED BID FROM DAN HANNAHS, D&D WELL SERVICES TO PLUG WELL.BID $5000. 01/02/04: MF AUTHORIZATION LETTER TO JIM DAY. TO INVOICE NW. 01/06/04: MF RECEIVED 12/30/03, WELL PLUGGING BID FROM ED ADAMS, $2795. 01/08/04: MF S/I/JIM DAY & CREW (2 MEN)/BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS. PLUGGING POND WELL. WELL 1800’ DEEP, NO PACKER. OIL BEING HOSED TO HOLDING TANK, APPX 80 GALLONS. MINIMAL AMOUNT OF SHEENING. VERY COLD. 01/09/04: MF T/C CHRIS MILLER, EVERYTHING WENT FINE. 01/29/04: MF RECEIVED $2300, INVOICE FROM JIM DAY FOR PLUGGING COST. SENT TO OP-TECH FOR PAYMENT WITHIN 45 DAYS. 02/12/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $2530. PP. COST IS FOR JIM DAY’S WELL PLUGGING, $2300 + 10%. INVOICE #30922, 1/20/04. 03/09/04: MF 30 DAY LETTER TO NW. 04/27/04: MF S/I NOOS, NO OIL COMING FROM THE WELL. THERE IS WATER BEING DISCHARGED FROM THE CONDUCTOR PIPE. NO FURTHER ACTION MECESSARY. ISR PENDING. 08/05/04: MF T/C COLLEEN 09/15/04: MF T/C COLLEEN, WASTE MANAGEMENT 496-5000, 481-5072. TALKED TO LYNEE. 09/16/04: MF RECEIVED FAX FROM WASTEMANAGEMENT OF SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPTS. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ISR PENDING, FINE RECOMMENDED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 205

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL STORAGE TANK 6541 PHILLPS HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 0375519

Close Date: 02/28/2006

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN DEC BRIAN JANDREW FXGALLEG

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

SUSAN BABCOCK - SUSAN BABCOCK SAME MINERAL RESOURCES CHARLY PERRY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (585) 928-1808

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/28/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 60.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAID THAT A VALVON AN OLD OIL STORAGE TANK LEAKED ABOUT 15 GAL OF OIL ON THE GROUND AND ABOUT 2 GAL REACHED A POND ON THE NEIGHBOR’S PROPERTY...MINERALS PLACED ABSORBANTS ON THE OIL AND WILL PUT PADS IN THE POND TODAY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 03/29/04: MF S/I/BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS. ABANDON STOCK TANK ON CHARLEY PERRY’S PROPERTRY, 6541 PHILLIPS HILL RD LEAK AT SHUT OFF VALVE AT THE BOTTOM OF THE TANK. CRUDE OIL FLOWED APPX 1/4 MILE DOWN A WATER WAY TO THE NEIGHBORS POND (AMY BLACK, 6466 PHILIPS HILL RD, BOLIVAR, 14715, 585-928-2373). BRIAN PLACED BOOMS & PADS IN THE POND & ALONG THE WATER WAY. HE ALSO STOPPED THE VALVE LEAK. BRIAN WANTS TO CLEAN SPILL HIMSELF TO AVOID THE STATE HAVING TO BILL LANDOWNER. THE MESSER OIL CO HAS BEEN OUT OF BUSINESS FOR 30-40 YEARS. I TOLD BRIAN THAT THE CLEANUP MATERIAL WILL HAVE TO BE DISPOSED OF IN A SANITARY LANDFILL. THE STOCK TANK MUST BE PUMPED OUT & THE OIL PROPERLY DISPOSED OF. AND IF WE GET ANY COMPLAINTS THE STATE WILL TAKE OVER THE SPILL. BRIAN TOLD ME THAT THIS A 1500 STOCK TANK APPX 1/3 FULL. 03/30/04: MF T/C/CHRIS MILLER, BRIAN TOOK CLEANUP DEBRIS TO THE ALLEGANY CO LANDFILL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 206

04/27/04: MF S/I/CHARLEY PERRY JR. FP IN THE DITCH FROM THE STOCK TANK ALONG WITH THE BANKS BEING OIL SOAKED. STOCK TANK VALVE LEAKING OIL, BEING COUGHT IN A BUCKET. BOOM IN AMY BLACK’S POND. 05/05/04: MF E-MAIL TO BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS WITH ADDITIONAL WORK THAT IS NECESSARY. 05/05/04: MF E-MAIL FROM BRIAN JANDREW, NATURE WILL TAKE CARE OF THE PROBLEM. HE ALSO CLAIMED THAT THE BOOMS & PADS WERE TAKEN TO THE LANDFILL. 05/14/04: MF FAX FROM BRIAN JANDREW, CLAIMED CHARLEY PERRY HAD HIS PROPERTY SURVEYED & THE TANK IS NOT ON HIS PROPERTY. TANK IS ON PROPERTY OWNED BY SUSAN BABCOCK, 182 HIGHLAND AVE, TONAWANDA NY 716-692-8475. 05/17/04: MF T/C SUSAN BABCOCK, SHE HUNG UP ON ME. 05/19/04: MF T/C SUE, SHE AGREED THE WELL IS ON HER PROPERTY. I TOLK HER WHAT MUST BE DONE & WILL SEND HER A LETTER. 05/20/04: MF LETTER SENT, SCHEDULE BY 5/28/04. 05/27/04: MF T/C SUE, TOLD HE TO CALL HER HUSBAND, ROGER 585-254-3330. T/C ROGER, HE TOLD ME HE WILL CONTACT JIM DAY WHO IS ON VACATION FOR THE NEXT WEEK. 07/19/04: MF T/C GREG SLATER, 853-6161. DISCUSSED SPILL. 07/29/04: MF LETTER FROM CRAIG SLATER, BILL DIBBLE, TURTLE OIL OWNS THE STOCK TANK. 585-928-2626. WILLIAM DIBBLE 874 STREETER BROOK RD LITTLE GENESEE NY 14754 08/04/04: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 8/20/04. 08/05/04: MF LETTER TO BILL DIBBLE AS TO HIS POSITION ON THE PUMPING & CLEAN UP OF THE CRUDE OIL. RESPONSE BY 8/13/04. 08/19/04: MF LETTER FROM PETER HENTSCHKE, 585-232-6500, LAWYER FOR SUSAN. AFI HIRED TO VAC TANK & REMEDIATE. 08/30/04: MF NO RESPONSE LETTER TO DIBBLE, RESPONSE BY 9/10/04. 09/07/04: MF LETTER FROM SUSAN’S ATTY, PETER HENTSCHKE. AFI HIRED & PUMPED STOCK TANK INTO 55 GALLON DRUMS. VALVE SECURED. ALSO INCLUDED DOCUMANTATION THAT THE STOCK TANK #1638 & 1516 ARE OWNED BY DIBBLE (TURTLE OIL CO). 09/23/04: MF S/I NOOS, PRODUCT IN THE TANK. VALVE NOT LEAKING. CONTAMINATION & BOOMS AROUND THE TANK. 09/27/04: MF T/C/PETE H, SUSAN’S LAWYER. DISCUSSED 9/23/04 INSPECTION & THE POSSIBILITY OF LETTING THE STATE TANK OVER THE CLEANUP. 09/28/04: MF S/I NOOS, STUCK TANK, APPX 2" OF CRUDE/SLUDGE. 10/22/04: MF DISCUSSED SPILL WITH PETER HENTSCHKE, HARTER, SECREST & EMERY. IT WAS AGREED THAT SPILLS WILL SAMPLE FOR DISPOSAL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 207

THE BABCOCK’S WILL DO THE REMEDIATION & DISPOSAL. BAKER WILL BE THEIR CONTRACTOR. PRP LETTER TO DIBBLE & BABCOCKS. 10/23/04: MF S/I/CHARLEY PERRY, OWNER OF PROPERTY BORDERING STOCK TANK #1638. HIS PROPERTY IS AFFECTED BY THE SPILLAGE. I TOOK A SAMPLE OF THE SPILLAGE FOR DISPOSAL. 10/24/04: MF SAMPLE TO UPSTATE FOR ANALYSIS FOR IGNITABILITY & TCLP FOR BENZENE AS PER BRAD S. 11/15/04: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL ANALYIS, NON-HAZ. PROCESSED UPSTATES $211.08 PP FOR THIS ANALYSIS. INVOICE # 2899. 11/17/04: MF T/C PETER HENTSCHKE, 585-231-1154. FAXED HIM DISPOSAL SAMPLING RESULTS. BAKER OF ALFRED HIRED FOR REMEDIATION. 12/16/04: MF T/C/DAN, JERICO 607-587-9191, HE WAS HIRED TO REMEDIATE. HE WILL CALL PETER H, FOR SAMPLING RESULTS. 02/04/05: MF S/I/TODD BAKER, EXCAVATION OPERATOR. THEY ARE REMOVING & LOADING OUT CONTAMINATED SOIL. 03/02/05: MF T/C PETER H, HE WILL SEND SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPT & GET TEH TANK CLEANED. 5/17/05 ROGER BABCOCK SENT IN THE DISPOSAL RECEIPTS FOR THIS SITE. 33.47 TONS OF SOIL WAS DISPOSED AT THE ALLEGANY COUNTY LANDFILL ON 2/4/05. 05/24/05: MF T/C PETE H, NO LONGER WITH FIRM, ANGELA DEMERYL HAS TAKEN OVER FILE. T/C ANGELA, LEFT MESSAGE. 422. 7/7/05 FG CALLED ANGELA DEMERLE WITH HARTER SECREST & EMERY REQUESTING THAT SHE HAVE HER CLIENT CLEAN OUT THE OIL STORAGE TANK. SHE WAS NOT IN AND WILL RETURN THE CALL. 8/2/05 ANGELA DEMERLE SUBMITTED A 7/19/05 LETTER WHICH CONTACTED ROGER AND SUSAN BABCOCK REQUESTING THAT THEY REMOVE THE SLUDGE FROM THE AST ON SITE. 02/10/06: MF T/C SUSAN BABCOCK, LEFT MESSAGE TO CALL ME. 02/13/06: MF LETTER TO RP, CLEAN TANK OR WE WILL CLEAN TANK. RESPONSE BY 2/28/06. 02/22/06: MF T/C/MR BABCOCK. HE CLAIMED STOCK TANK HAS BEEN PLUGGED WITH A PIPE PLUG. I TOLD HIM I WILL TAKE A LOOK AT IT & IF THAT IS THE CASE SPILL WILL BE CLOSED, 02/27/06: MF S/I STOCK TANK IN QUESTION HAS BEEN PLUGGED WITH A PIPE PLUG. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. RECOMMEND NO FINE AGAINST BABCOCKS, THEY WERE COOPERTIVE & DID THE CLEANUP. RECOMMEND LARGE FINE AGAINST DIBBLE, NEVER ANSWERED LETTER OR CALLS. ISR PENDING.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 208

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL TANK 8431 JORDAN HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 0275321

Close Date: 08/12/2003

WEST CLARKSVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14786 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Citizen ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: DAN SMITH - UNK Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: DON RAY

Spiller Phone: (585) 968-3096 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (585) 968-3328

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/01/2002 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLLER CLAIMS 500 GALLON AST LEAKING IN TO A DITCH. ONGOING FOR MONTHS. LOCATION IS JORDAN HILL ROAD (OFF 305) PAST BARBER ROAD IN FRONT OF A RED HOUSE ON THE RIGHT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 09/16/02: MF S/I/DON RAY, OWNER OF PROPERTY WERE TANK IS LOCATED. TANK IS TIPPED OVER JUST ABOVE ROAD SIDE DITCH. CRUDE OIL COMING OUT OF THE TANK. DON TOLD ME LEASE & TANK IS OWNED BY DAN SMITH OF CUBA 585-968-1129. LEFT MESSAGE FOR DAN TO CALL ME. 09/17/02: MF 0900 T/C DAN SMITH, DAN SR PASSED AWAY. TALKED WITH HIS WIFE. DAN JR OWNS LEASE. 585-968-3096, 8941 STOUT RD, CUBA. T/C DAN JR LEFT PAGER # & OFFICE #. 10/12/02: MF DAN SMITH, NOT HOME, LEFT MESSAGE TO RETURN CALL. THIS IS THE 3RD TIME I CALLED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

10/15/03: MF S/I DAN SMITH’S WIFE. DAN DOES NOT OWN LEASE. T/C MINERALS. THEY HAVE NO RECORD OF ANY LEASES IN THIS AREA. THERE ARE A LOT OF OUT-OF-SERVICE JACKS IN THIS AREA. 11/21/03: MF S/I NO FURTHER LEAKAGE FROM THIS TANK. 08/11/03: MF S/I VEGETATION GROWN OVER THIS TANK. NO LEAKAGE. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE. ********************COMPUTER FILE ONLY****************

Page 209

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 210

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL 4844 NICHOLS RUN RD

Spill Number: 0275360

Close Date: 10/12/2002

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party CHRIS MILLER MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL TOM DIFEBAUGH NYSDEC TOM DIFEBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: (814) 362-5447 Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/10/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 2.00 GALLONS 1.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 2" WATER INJECTION LINE DEVELOPED LEAD -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 10/10/02: MF S/I AFTER A CALL FROM MINERALS. 2" WATER INJECTION LINE DEVELOPED A LEAD APPX 10’ FROM NICHOLS RUN CREEK & 200’ EAST OF 4844 NICHOLS RUN RD. LINE IS FOR WATER INJECTION BUT CONTAINS SMALL AMOUNT OF CRUDE OIL DUE TO IT BACKING UP INTO THE LINE. LOST APPX 2 GALLONS TO THE SURFACE & TO THE CREEK. SORBENT APPLIED & 2 BOOMS INSTALLED IN THE CREEK. DEBRIS TO BE PLACED ON PILE TO BE DISPOSED OF. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. CLAMP PLACED AT THE POINT OF THE LINE LEAK.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 211

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL IN DITCH OAKWOOD DRIVE

Spill Number: 0275436

Close Date: 11/10/2003

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN DEC CHRIS MILLER MXFRANKS

Spiller: GREG THROPP - COPPER RIDGE COMPANY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: GREG THROPP

Spiller Phone: (716) 372-4021 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 372-4021

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/06/2002 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL SHEEN AND ODORS IN ROADSIDE DITCH 2000’ FROM INTERSECTION OF OAKWOOD DRIVE AND VALLEY VIEW DRIVE. MAY BE COMING FROM OIL WELL. OWNER OF PROPERTY IS MR. DiCERBO. DIV OV MINERALS & GAS IS PUTTING BOOMS IN DITCH AND IS CONTACTING COPPER RIDGE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 12/06/02: CHRIS MILLER T/C SPILLS AND SAID RP IS CONTAINING SPILL IN DITCH (A FEW HUNDRED FEET IN LENGTH). CHRIS HOME PH # IS 373-4097. HE SAID RP UNDERSTANDS HE MUST CLEAN-UP CONTAMINATED SOIL. 12/09/02: MF T/C/GREG THROPP, CRUDE OIL SPILLAGE GOT TO DRAINAGE DITCH. HAY & SORBENTS APPLIED. HE ESTIMATED 5 GALLONS SPILLED. 500’ OF DITCH AFFECTED. ROAD 60’ FROM WELL. K THROPP #1 WELL. S/I HAY BALES IN PLACE SPILLAGE AROUND WELL & FLOWING TO DITCH. 12/10/02: MF CLEAN UP LETTER SENT. MINERALS TO MONITOR CLEAN UP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 212

01/22/03: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 2/15/03. 04/11/03: MF S/I AFTER A CALL FROM NATALIE RETEAU, 378-6041, 373-7328, 2468 OAKWOOD. SHE COMPLAINED OF OIL, SHEEN & HAY BALES IN THE DITCH IN FRONT OF HER HOME. I CONFIRMED ALL OF THIS ALONG WITH SPILLAGE NOT CLEANED LEADING TO THE DITCH. SPILLAGE CLEANED AROUND THE WELL. 04/14/03: MF T/C GREG THROPP, LEFT MESSAGE. UNSATISFACTORY CLEAN UP LETTER. SPILLS WILL TAKE OVER CLEAN UP 4/21/03. 04/16/03: MF T/C GREG THROPP, HE WILL CLEAN DITCH THIS WEEK. 04/24/03: MF S/I NOOS, DITCH & SIDE OF DITCH TO WELL CLEANED TO 2450 OAKWOOK. 05/06/03: MF T/C GREG THROPP, HE WILL SEND DISPOSAL RECEIPT. 05/28/03: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT FOR 16.87 TONS OF DEBRIS. 05/30/03: MF S/I AFTER A CALL FROM JOHN STRANBURG, 2445 OAKWOOD, COMPLAINT OF SHEENING IN LEAVES & SEDIMENTS WHERE LEAVES WERE NOT REMOVED. I CONFIRMED THIS. T/C GREG THROPP, LEFT MESSAGE. 05/31/03: MF T/C GREG THROPP, WILL MEET ON SITE TOMORROW AT 10 AM. 06/01/03: MF S/I/GREG THROPP, SHOWED HIM PROBLEM OF SHEENING IN THE DITCH FROM 2468 OAKWOOD TO 2439 OAKWOOD WHERE CULVERT CROSSES OVER. HE WILL TAKE CARE OF & DISPOSE OF DEBRIS. 06/06/03: MF S/I AFTER A COMPLAINT THAT THE SEDIMENTS STILL SHEEN AFTER GREG REMOVED THE LEAVES. I CONFIRMED THIS. 06/09/03: MF T/C GREG, LEFT MESSAGE THAT SOIL REMOVAL NECESSARY. HE CAN DO IT OR IF HE CAN’T, WE WILL. 06/10/03: MF MESSAGE FROM GREG, HE WILL DO ADDITIONAL REMEDIATION. MESSAGE FROM JOHN STRANBURG. WANTS SOMETHING DONE. 08/06/03: MF AFTER MAY CALLS FROM JOHN STRANBURG REGARDING SHEENING IN THE DITCH & AFTER MANY PROMISES BY GREG I CALLED GREG AGAIN. HE CLAIMED HE WILL DO WORK TODAY. IF HE CAN’T GET THE CONTRACTOR THAT PROMISED TO DO THE WORK HE WILL HIRE ANOTHER ONE. 08/08/03: MF T/C JOHN, NO WORK DONE. T/C GREG, ONE CONTRACTOR STARTED & QUIT. HE WILL GET ANOTHER ON BY TUES. TOLD HIM IF NOT DONE BY 8/12/03 WE WILL HIRE A CONTRACTOR. 08/28/03: MF S/I NOOS, DITCH CLEANED. 10/01/03: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER ON THE AUG DITCH CLEANING. DUE 10/15/03. 10/24/03: MF 2ND DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 11/7/03. 11/10/03: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT FOR 23.38 TONS OF DEBRIS. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 213

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

W INDEPENDENCE STORAGE 2210 COUNTY ROAD 22

Spill Number: 0275490

Close Date: 01/22/2003

INDEPENDENCE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14806 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROBERT GREGOREKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: CALLER - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NFG Contact for more spill info: BOB WALTERS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone: (607) 478-8784

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/21/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: TANK OVERFILLED, BRINE WENT OVER INTO DITCH FOR 100, -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 01/21/03: MF S/I/BOB WALTERS & CREW AT WEST INDEPENDENCE STORAGE BRINE AST (#5 DRIP) ON AN ACCESS ROAD OFF CR 22. VALVE FAILED TO SHUT OFF WHEN BRINE LEVEL IN THE TANK GOT HIGH. BRINE PUMP ON THE TANK ALSO FAILED TO PUMP BRINE TO BRINE POND BECAUSE IT CRUSTED UP WITH SALT. LOST APPX 200 GALLONS OF BRINE TO THE GROUND. MALFUNCTIONS REPAIRED. BRINE WILL BE VACCED UP ON PLACED IN THE STATIONS BRINE POND. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ************COMPUTER FILE ONLY******************************

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 214

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DRAIN FROM LEASE NICHOLS RUN RD

Spill Number: 0275243

Close Date: 08/10/2002

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC MIEK FRANKS MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info: TOM DEFIBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7220 Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/2002 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE INSPECTING CRUDE OIL FIELD LEAKS NOTICED 1" PVC HOSE DRAINING INTO SOUTH DITCH ON NICHOLS RUN RD. LINE IS FROM AN OIL FIELD. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/08/02: MF S/I/DON PLEAKIS, 1" PVC PIPE DISCHARGING CRUDE OIL INTO SOUTH DITCH ON NICHOLS RUN RD. LINE COMES FROM LEASE. T/C/JOE BOUCHER, BDH OIL. SITE MEETING SCHEDULED FOR 8/09/02. 08/09/02: MF S/I/DON PLEAKIS, ECO, JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS/JOE BOUCHER & TOM DEFIBAUGH, BDH OIL. JOE OR TOM HAS NO IDEA WHERE THE LINE GOES TO OR WHO INSTALLED IT. TOLD THEM THEY WILL HAVE TO DIG IT UP TO FIND THE SOURCE. DON TO ISSUE ORDER. 08/10/02: MF THIS SPILL WILL BE HANDLED WITH AN ORDER FROM DON PLEAKIS UNDER SPILL #0275245. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESARY ON THIS SPILL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 215

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NAT FUEL - BRINE TANK FORTNER

Spill Number: 0275531

Close Date: 02/27/2003

WELLSVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14895 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Responsible Party ROB GREGORESKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: CHARLIE BURKE - NATIONAL FUEL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL Contact for more spill info: BOB WALTERS

Spiller Phone: (716) 857-7000 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone: (607) 478-8784

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/26/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PUMP FROZE UP, WNET OVER LARGE AREA. RECOVERY NOT PRACTICAL. SPILL ON FORTNER ROAD IN THE TOWN OF WILLING. PAGER FOR CALLER IS 448-3940 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 02/26/03: MF S/I/ROB GREGORESKI & BOB WALTERS, NATIONAL FUEL. BRINE TRANSFUR PUMP FROM 12K AG BRINE TANK TO BRINE LAGOON FROZE. IT WAS FREED UP & PUMPING STARTED. BEFORE IT COULD GET PUMPED DOWN FAR ENOUGH BRINE PUMP FROM GAS WELLS KICKED ON & AS A RESULT THEY LOST APPX 50 GALLONS OF BRINE TO THE SURFACE. CLEAN UP NOT PRACTICAL. NATIONAL FUEL OWNS THE LAND. PUMP WILL BE HEAT TAPED. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. *****************COMPUTER FILE ONLY*****************

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 216

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL - SEPARATOR NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0275505

Close Date: 11/26/2004

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NICHOLS RUN RD Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: TOM DEFIBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/20/2003 11/26/2004 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: IT APPEARS WATER FROZE IN STOCK TANK, CAUSED TOP TO LEAK & FORCED CRUDE OIL OUT. AREA SNOW COVERED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 01/30/03: MF WHILE INSPECTING ANOTHER SPILL WITH OP-TECH NOTICED STRONG CRUDE OIL ODOR & SOME DISCOLORED SNOW IN SPOTS IN NICHOLS RUN CREEK. AREA HAS APPX 2’ SNOW COVER. THERE IS A NEW BOOM IN NICHOLS RUN CREEK AT TOWN LINE RD. RESIDENTS IN THIS AREA TOLD ME ABOUT A LEAKING SEPARATOR TANK OWNED BY BDH OIL. FOUND SEPARATOR TANK USED FOR STOCK TANKS BR-044, 419001 & 41902 WITH A SPLIT TOP & FROZEN CRUDE OIL & WATER DOWN ITS ENTIRE SIDE. I WAS TOLD BY ONE RESIDENT THAT BDH WAS NOTIFIED OF THIS 2 WEEKS AGO. NOTIFIED MINERALS. CHRIS MILLER TOLD ME THE LEASE HAS BEEN SHUT DOWN SINCE BEFORE CHRISTMAS. T/C DON PLEAKIS, SITE MEETING SET UP FOR TOMORROW. 01/31/03: MF S/I/DON PLEAKIS, LOOKED OVER SPILL AREA & THEN MET TO DISCUSS SITE WITH CHRIS MILLER. TOM D WAS CALLED & TOLD CHRIS LEASE IS DOWN & WATER INJECTION SYSTEM TURNED OFF SINCE 12/28/02 DUE TO ICE STORM THAT KNOCKED DOWN POWER LINES. TOM THEN CALL ME & SITE MEETING SCHEDULED FOR TOMORROW.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 217

02/01/03: MF S/I/TOM D, HE TOLD ME THE SEPARATOR FROZE & THAT THE BROWN MATERIAL COMING OUT OF THE SEPARATOR THAT SMELLS LIKE CRUDE OIL IS RUST & LOW SALT BRINE. HE ALSO TOLD ME THEY WERE NOTIFIED OF THE PROPLEM 1/29/03 IN THE PM. THEY HAD A FLASH LITE BUT DIDN’T SEE ANYTHING THEREFORE NO CALL TO THE DEC. TOLD HIM HE MUST CHECK THE REST OF HIS LEASE FOR BUSTED LINES & LEAKING EQUIPMENT. HE IS IN THE PROCESS OF RENTING A SNOW MOBILE TO DO THIS AS THERE IS MUCH SNOW. I ALSO TOLD HIM THAT SPILLAGE MUST BE CLEANED & THAT NO SPILLAGE MUST ENTER THE CREEK. 07/22/03: MF MASSIVE AMOUNT OF RAIN, FLOODED AREA, WASHED ROAD AWAY, WASHED CONTAMINATION AWAY. NO CLEANUP NECESSARY. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 218

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PIPELINE LEAK SCHRIVNER ROAD

Spill Number: 0275452

Close Date: 12/26/2002

DALE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14039 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Other JASON MENGEL SACALAND

Spiller: SAME - OCCIDENTAL CHEMICALS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: BUCKEYE PIPELINE Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (484) 232-4491 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/17/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PRESSURE DROP NOTED IN PIPELINE THAT RUNS BETWEEN WYOMING AND GENESEE CO., BUCKEYE PIPELINE WHICH OPERATES THE PIPELINE IS INVESTIGATING BY WALKING PIPELINE TODAY AND USING A HELICOPTER TOMORROW TO FLY THE LINE, SINCE THERE IS A CHANCE THAT LEAK IS IN GENESEE CO. REGION 8 WILL BE NOTIFIED ALSO. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "SAC" 12/18/02:SAC GAVE COPY OF REPORT TO GERRY PALUMBO, DIV OF WATER. 12/26/02:SAC TELECON MARK BONENBERGER - BUCKEYE PIPELINE, THEIR INVESTIGATION DETERMINED LEAK WAS IN GENESEE COUNTY/REGION 8, NO FURTHER WORK REQUIRED FOR SPILL IN REGION 9, GERRY PALUMBO NOTIFIED VIA e-MAIL THAT LEAK IS IN REGION 8. ***************************************************************** COMPUTER FILE ONLY - NO PAPER FILE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

*****************************************************************

Page 219

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 220

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BEECH HILL- BRINE TANK HILLIGAS

Spill Number: 0275536

Close Date: 03/05/2003

WELLSVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14895 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROBERT GREGORESKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: R. GREGORESKI - NATIONAL FUEL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info: BOB WALTERS

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/04/2003 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 300.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: VALVE FROZE AND OVERFLOWED OUT THE RELIEF VENTS IN THE TOP OF THE TANK, (12KGAL TANK). ESTIMATE AMOUNT. RELEASED ONLY TO THE GROUND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 03/04/03: MF S/I/BOB WALTERS, STATION MANAGER. FLOAT SWITCH FAILURE ON 12K AG BRINE TANK COUSED IT TO OVERFLOW. LOST APPX 300 GALLONS OF BRINE TO THE GROUND & ROAD DITCH. FOX (BRINE CARRIER) VACCED UP PUDDLES. FLOAT SWITCH BEING REPAIRED. NATIONAL FUEL OWNS LAND. NO FUERTHER CLEANUP PRACTICAL. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.**********COMPUTER FILE ONLY******************

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 221

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LEAKING OIL WELL 4966 NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0275177

Close Date: 07/03/2002

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen BOB DODGE MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: JOE BOUCHER

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 925-7279 Contact Person Phone: (716) 928-2728

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/27/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL WELL LEAKED CRUDE INTO THE CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 6/27/02:SAC TRIED TO CALL TOM DEFBAUGH BUT ONLY GOT THE ANSWERING MACHINE, SAC DID NOT LEAVE A MESSAGE, SAC TELECON JOHN HOFFMAN, DEC-MINERALS, TO NOTIFY HIM OF THE COMPLAINT, MR. HOFFMAN SAID THAT THEY HAVE HAD A SERIES OF COMPLAINTS IN THE PAST FEW WEEKS REGARDING THIS SITE INCLUDING A PIPE BREAK, SAC TOLD HIM BASED ON MR. DODGE’S COMPLAINT IT SOUNDED LIKE IT COULD BE SOMETHING NEW, MR. HOFFMAN SAID HE WILL SEND SOMEONE OUT TO INSPECT THE COMPLAINT, SAC TELECON MF TO NOTIFY HIM OF THE COMPLAINT, MF SAID HE WILL HEAD OVER TO INSPECT SITE, SAC NOTIFIED PJB. MF T/C JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS, BRIAN JANDREW INSPECTED, 4 WELLS HAVE A LEAKING PROBLEM. RAINING VERY HARD. SUSPECT HISTORICAL SPILLAGE WASHING TO WATER WAY. I WAS UNABLE TO INSPECT UNTIL 1400. I WAS ON ANOTHER BOUCHER SPILL. 1400 S/I/BOB DODGE, LANDOWNER. SHEEN & STRONG ODOR IN DITCH RUNNING DOWN THE HILL FROM WELLS. DROPLETS OF OIL ALSO IN THE DITCH. THE SPRING HE USES FOR DRINKING WATER IS NEXT TO THE DITCH. HE HAS CARBON FILTERS ON HIS DRINKING WATER SUPPLY. NOTIFIED BDH EMPLOYEE, BILL GOOD, HE INSTALLED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 222

SORBENT BOOMS. MET WITH JOE BOUCHER & TOM DEFIBAUGH, OWNERS OF BDH. TOM WOULD NOT MEET AT THE SPILL SITE, HE HAS A PROBLEM WITH BOB DODGE. TOLD THEM SOURCE MUST BE ELIMINATED, BOOMS MUST BE MAINTAINED & SCHEDULED A SITE MEETING FOR 7/2/02. NOTIFIED NRC OF SPILL, #613965. PROBLEM NOTICED BY BOB DODGE AT 0900. 07/02/02: MF S/I/TOM DEFIBAUGH, BDH OIL/AL ALEXANDER, MINERALS/ DON PLEAKIS ECO. 4 WELLS POSSIBLE CONTRIBUTERS OF OIL IN THE CREEK. CREEK IS SHEENLESS TODAY. SPILLAGE AT THESE WELLS IS BEING HANDLED UNDER SPILL # 0275185. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY ON THIS SPILL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 223

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

RESI: LYONS 1488 HAPPYHOLLOW RD

Spill Number: 0108353

Close Date: 11/26/2001

WESTON MILLS, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14788 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Police Department TIM MCVAUGH RMCROSSE

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

JASON LYONS - RESI: LYONS JASON LYONS CATTARAUGUS SHERIFFS JASON LYONS

Spiller Phone: (716) 373-7091 Notifier Phone: (716) 373-7091 Caller Phone: (716) 938-9191 Contact Person Phone: (716) 373-7091

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/17/2001 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 10.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SPILL COMING FROM WELL HEAD. CALL BACK REQUESTED. FIRE DEPARTMENT ON SCENE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 11/26/01 RMC/FILE. RMC MADE SOME INITIAL CALLS. DUTY OFFICIER GOT A HOLD OF DEC MINERALS, THEY WILL HANDLE. CLOSE OUT AS A SPILLS ISSUE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 224

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

INDEPENDENCE STATION RD #2

Spill Number: 0175240

Close Date: 08/03/2001

INDEPENDENCE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14806 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROBERT GREGORESKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: ROB GREGORESKI - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info: ROB GREGORESKI

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone: (716) 827-2253

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/01/2001 08/03/2001 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE POND DISCOVERED TO BE LEAKING AND FOUND IN OBSERVATION WELL AND CONTAINMENT DITCH -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 7/31/01:SAC TELECON ROB GREGORESKI - EAST POND IS LEAKING, WEST POND NEEDS TO BE CLEANED AND PATCHED, THIS WORK WILL TAKE PLACE NEXT WEEK, ONCE THE WEST POND IS REPAIRED THEY WILL DRAIN THE MATERIAL FROM THE EAST POND INTO THE WEST POND, IN THE MEANTIME THEY WILL USE FERNCO CLAMP ON OBSERVATION WELL TO DECREASE DIAMETER OF THE PIPE AND ALLOW PUMP TO BE ATTACHED TO THIS PIPE, THEY WILL THEN PUMP MATERIAL THAT HAS BEEN RELEASED INTO BARRELS, BARRELED MATERIAL WILL EVENTUALLY BE PUMPED BACK INTO THE WEST POND ONCE CLEANING AND REPAIRING WORK IS FINISHED, ONCE THE EAST POND IS DRAINED THEN IT WILL BE REPAIRED, PRESENTLY LEAK IS NO MORE THAN A TRICKLE, MR. GREGORESKI’S PAGER NUMBER IS 448-3940. 7/31/01:SAC TELECON CHRIS MILLER, NYSDEC - MINERALS NOTIFYING HIM OF THE SPILL, FAXED COPY OF REPORT TO HIM, SAC GAVE COPY OF THE REPORT TO DIVISION OF WATER.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 225

08/01/01: MF T/C/CHRIS MILLER, SMALL AMOUNT OF LEAKAGE. THEY HAVE NO ONE AVAIL TO LOOK AT SPILL. 08/02/01: MF S/I/BOB WALTERS, ROB GREGORESKI, DARREL RAY NATIONAL FUEL/JIM BUCKI. BOTTOM LINER FOR WEST BRINE POND 4 MILLON GALLON POND DEVELOPED SLIGHT LEAK. THERE IS A FRENCH DRAIN UNDER THE LINER & IT DISCHARGED TO SOILID DRAIN PIPE TO A DITCH. FURNCO PUT ON THE END OF THIS PIPE & FLOW DIVERTED INTO A AG TANK. LINER TO BE CLEANED, PATCHED OR REPLACED. WORK TO START NEXT WEEK. BRINE HAS A VERY OIL CONTENT FROM THE COMPRESSOR PUMPS. BRINE IS FROM A STORAGE FIELD. MINOR AMOUNT OF BRINE SPILLAGE. I DID NOT NOTICE ANY DISTRESSED VEGETATION IN THE DITCH. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ************END OF FILE NO ADDITIONAL PAPER WORK***************

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 226

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL HILIGAS ROAD

Spill Number: 0175504

Close Date: 02/22/2002

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROBERT GREGORESKI JFOTTO

Spiller: CHARLES BURKE - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info: BOB WALTERS

Spiller Phone: (716) 827-2359 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 827-2253 Contact Person Phone: (716) 593-1665

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/21/2002 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 1000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DAILY INSTECTION OF THE TANK REVEALED THE SPILL OF HUNDREDS OF GALLONS OF BRINE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 02/21/02 JFO CALL TO MINERAL RESOURCES CHRIS MILLER. HE WILL INSPECT AND GET BACK TO ME. JFO RECEIVED A CALL FROM CHRIS MILLER. HE SAID JIM RUCINSKI OF MINERALS HAS INSPECTED THE SPILL AREA. THE SPILL HAS BEEN CONTAINED AND IS BEING CLEANED UP. HE WILL FORWARD HIS REPORT WHEN COMPLETED. 02/22/02 JFO REC’D JIM RUCINSKI’S REPORT. THE SPILL WAS TO NFG’S PROPERTY, SOME GOT TO THE ROAD BUT DID NOT ENTER THE DRAINAGE DITCH. JIM IS CONFIDENT THAT NO ENVRONMENTAL DAMAGE OCCURRED AS A RESULT OF THE INCIDENT. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 227

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH LEASE NICHOLS RUN EAST OF QUINN

Spill Number: 0175021

Close Date: 09/06/2001

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen LARRY MURPHY JFOTTO

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

CELL PHONE - BDH OIL INC RNL CITIZEN THOMAS DEFBAUGH

Spiller Phone: (724) 525-2334 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 925-8949 Contact Person Phone: (814) 362-5447

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/10/2001 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER STATED THAT THERE WAS AN OIL SHEEN FROM THE CREEK THAT RUNS THROUGH HIS PROPERTY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 04/10/01 JFO CALL TO BRIAN JANDREW OF MINERALS IN ALLEGANY. HE CONTACTED MR DEFIBAUGH OF BDH TO MEET ME ON SITE. I ALSO CALLED THE COMPLAINTANT MR MURPHY. HE SAID IF HE WAS NOT HOME WHEN I GOT THERE I COULD CHECK OUT THE CREEK ON HIS PROPERTY. JFO ON SITE MET WITH MR DEFIBAUGH. THERE WAS A LEAK IN A LINE CAUSING CRUDE OIL TO DRIP INTO THE DRAINAGE DITCH. WE PLACED PADS AND BOOMS IN THE DRAINAGE DITCH. MR DEFIBAUGH SAID HE WOULD HAVE A CREW DO THE CLEANUP IN THE MORNING. 04/13/01 JFO CALL TO MR DEFIBAUGH. HE SAID THE CLEANUP IS COMPLETE. I WILL CHECK NEXT TIME I AM IN THE AREA. 08/20/01 JFO ON SITE, NO VISIBLE SHEEN IN THE STREAM. THE AREA WHERE THE OIL WAS ACCUMULATING HAS BEEN CLEANED UP ALSO. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

CLOSED

Page 228

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 229

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CASE WELLS NICHOLS RUN

Spill Number: 0075300

Close Date: 09/07/2000

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: LYNN CASE - LYNN CASE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 925-8608 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/2000 09/07/2000 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAYS THAT THREE NEW CRUDE OIL WELLS ARE PUMPING OIL INTO CREEK EVERY TIME THEY PUMP. SAYS THERE IS VERY STRONG ODOR AND LARGE AMOUNT OF OIL IN CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/15/00: MF SITE INSPECTION, NEW WELLS INSTALLED BY CASE LEAKING OIL BY WELL HEAD, OIL LEAKING ON THE GROUND INTO NICHOLS RUN CREEK. OIL ON THE SIDE & INTO NICHOLS RUN RD. TRIED TO LOCATE LYNN CASE. NO LUCK. 08/16/00: MF TELECON MINERALS, JIM RUSINSKI, HE WILL INSPECT TODAY. I TOLD HIM IF RP DOSN’T CLEAN UP TODAY WE WILL HIRE A CONTARCTOR. JIM WILL GET BACK TO ME. 08/16/00: MF NOTE TO FILE, JIM RUSINSKI INSPECTED SITE, MET LYNN CASE, RP. FP ON ITS WAY TO NICHOLS RUN CREEK IN DITCH TO CREEK. CRUDE OIL IN PONDS NEXT TO WELL. SPILLAGE AROUND THREE PUMPS. HE TOLD LYNN HE WILL GET FINED IF NOT TAKEN CARE OF TODAY. HE WILL CLEAN UP & HAVE PONDS EMPTIED BY THE NEXT WEEK. JIM WILL MONITOR.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

08/31/00: MF SITE INSPECTION, NO ONE ON SITE. PRODUCT REMOVED FROM DITCH TO NICHOLS RUN CREEK. 09/01/00: MF E-MAIL TO JIM RUCINSKI. IS HE SATISIFIED WITH CLEAN UP. 09/05/00: MF E-MAIL FROM JIM RUCINSKI, MINERALS. HE IS SATISIFIED & I CAN CLOSE OUT MY END. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 230

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 231

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL LEAK - PIPELINE TWO MILE ROAD

Spill Number: 0075178

Close Date: 01/05/2001

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: TWO MILE RD Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen DALE FEDICK JFOTTO

Spiller: DDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 378-8739 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/19/2000 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL IN CREEK THAT CROSSES TWO MILE RD. PIPELINE IN IMMEDIATE AREA BY CALLERS PROPERTY. CALLER IS AVAILABLE AT HIS CELL# 378-8739 IF ANY FURTHER DIRECTION NEEDED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 06/20/00: JFO TELECON TO JACK DAHL OF MINERALS IN THE OLEAN OFFICE. HE WILL CHECK CREEK AND GET BACK TO ME IF OUR ASSISTANCE IS NECESSARY. 06/20/00: RMC TELECON JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS, SPILL IS FROM DDH OIL, THE JAMES LEASE, CONTACT IS TOM DEFINBAUG, AT 814-362-5447. SPILL WENT DIRECTLY TO CREEK, MINERALS IS WOKING ON, WILL CALL IF THEY NEED ASSISTANCE 01/05/01: JFO NOTE, NO ASSISTANCE NEEDED. SPILL SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 232

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL PIPELINE 5040 NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0009367

Close Date: 12/19/2000

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC DON PLEAKIS MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

JOE BUCHER - BDH OIL LAWERANCE MURPHY NYSDEC JOE BUCHER

Spiller Phone: (716) 925-8538 Notifier Phone: (716) 925-8949 Caller Phone: (716) 373-5829 Contact Person Phone: (716) 925-8538

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/14/2000 12/19/2000 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: caller is a conservation officer for dec he got a call from the state police in ref to a spill in a stream he has not been to scene yet but is responding -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 11/15/00: MF SITE INSPECTION, MET EMPLOYEES OF BDH OIL, LEAD LINE FROM WELL HO 29 DELELOPED UG LEAK, TEN FEET BELOW GROUND, WELL IS NEXT TO NICHOLS RUN CREEK. OIL GOT INTO STREAM. LINE DUG UP & PLUGGED WITH PLASTIC. SPILL OCCURED 11/14/00 PM. 11/17/00: MF SITE INSPECTION, FP IN CREEK BY WELL HO 29, HAY TOSSED IN CREEK & IS FLOATING AWAY. MET DAVE, HOME OWNER ON SPILL PROPERTY. CLAIMED BDH CREW BEEN ON SITE REPAIRING LINE FOR DAYS IN A ROW. 11/17/00: MF TELECON TO JOE BOUCHER, OWNER OF BDH. HE CLAIMED THEY CAN’T GET BOOMS OR PADS. TOLD HIM I WILL BE DONE AT SITE TOMORROW & IF THEY CAN’T STOP SEEPAGE INTO CREEK DEC WILL HIRE CONTRACTOR TO STOP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 233

11/18/00: MF SITE INSPECTION, MET LARRY MURPHY, HOMEOWNER APPX 0.3 MILES DOWNSTREAM OF SPILL. HE COMPLAINED OF CRUDE OIL ODOR, OIL, AND HAY. HAY WASHED DOWN TO HIS PROPERTY. MF MET JOE BOUCHER, TOM DIEFENBOUGH & CREW. THEY FOUND BOOMS & PADS. THEY ARE REMOVING FP & HAY FROM STREAM. TOLD THEM IF SEEPAGE DOESN’T STOP WE WILL HIRE CONTRACTOR. HO 29 OUT OF SERVICE UNTIL THEY CAN FIGURE OUT HOW TO REROUTE LINES. TOLD THEM THEY WILL BE FINED FOR NOT REPORTING SPILL. 11/20/00: MF TELECON LARRY MURPHY, CLAIMED BDH CLEANED OUT CREEK, BUT SOME HAY STILL IN CREEK. 11/29/00: MF TELECON FROM DON PLEAKIS, WANTS SITE MEETING NEXT WEEK. 12/05/00: MF MEETING IN OLEAN OFFICE WITH TOM DEFIBAUGH, BDH OIL/JIM RUSINSKI, MINERALS/DON PLEAKIS, ECO. DISCUSSED FINE OF $2000. FOR NOT REPORTING SPILL. TOM DEFIBAUGH WILL PAY FINE NEXT WEEK. 12/19/00: MF NOTE TO FILE, DEBRIS FROM THIS SPILL WILL BE DISPOSED OF WITH DEBRIS FROM SPILL # 0075508. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 234

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

HEMLOCK LEASE CALIFORNIA HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 0075186

Close Date: 07/06/2000

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN FXGALLEG

Spiller: JAMES DAY - JAMES DAY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 928-2686 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/21/2000 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 40.00 GALLONS 40.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PIPELINE PINHOLE LEAK NOTICED BY OWNER. DISCHARGE WAS INTO CALIFORNIA HOLLOW STREAM. MINERALS WILL RESPOND. MR. DAY HAS PLACED BOOMS AND IS PADDING UP THE STREAM AND WILL REMEDIATE THE BANKS. MINERALS HAS NOT GONE TO THE SITE YET BUT WILL BE OUT THERE TODAY AND WILL PROVIDE A WRITTEN REPORT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 06/26/00: FG TELECON TO JOHN HOFFMAN WITH MINERALS, OLEAN TO REQUEST AN UPDATE. HE SAID JIM RUCINSKI RESPONDED AND WILL PROVIDE A WRITTEN REPORT. 06/30/00: FG TELECON JIM BRZYNSKI WITH OLEAN MINERALS. MR. BRZYNSKI SAID IT WAS LESS THAN ONE BARREL THAT SPILLED. HE SAID IT ALL SPILLED TO A STREAM AND WAS BOOMED AND THE PRODUCT WAS RECOVERED. ALL THEY HAVE LEFT IS A SMALL AMOUNT OF BOOM TO PROPERLY DISPOSE OF. MR. BRZYNSKI SAID HE WILL INSPECT THE SITE TODAY TO CONFIRM CLEANUP AND SEND AN INSPECTION REPORT BY E-MAIL. 07/03/00: FG RECEIVED EMAIL INSPECTION REPORT FROM JIM RUCINSKI, OLEAN MINERALS. SPILL IS CLEANED UP AND MOST MATERIAL

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 235

RECOVERED. HAY AND SORBENT MATERIAL PLACED IN DRUM AND DISPOSED AT A LANDFILL. 07/03/00: FG TELECON TO MR. DAY, NOT IN, LEFT A MESSAGE FOR MR. DAY TO GET BACK TO ME WITH A DISPOSAL RECEIPT. 07/06/00: FG TELECON FROM MR. DAY, HE SAID HE HAS A COUPLE GARBAGE BAGS FULL OF HAY THAT HAS A SMALL AMOUNT OF CRUDE ON IT. HE WILL TAKE IT TO THE ALLEGANY COUNTY LANDFILL FOR DISPOSAL. NO FURTHER WORK IS REQUIRED. THE SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 236

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL NICKELS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 0075192

Close Date: 01/09/2001

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

MAJOR OIL FACILITY (>400,000 GAL) DEC BRIAN JANDREW JFOTTO

Spiller: JOE BUCHER - BDH OIL Notifier Name: CRIS MILLER Caller Agency: DEC MINERALS-OLEAN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 928-2728 Notifier Phone: (716) 372-0645 Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/23/2000 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected MOTOR OIL PETROLEUM 150.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAID THAT THERE WAS A SPILL, FROM BDH OIL OF 2-3 BARRELS OF OIL INTO NICKELS CREEK...CRIS MILLER, OLEAN MINERALS, IS AT THE SITE...BDH IS THERE CLEANING UP THE OIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 06/23/00: JFO NOTE, THIS SPILL IS BEING CLEANED UP BY THE RP UNDER THE MANAGEMENT OF CHRIS MILLER OF MINERALS IN OLEAN 01/09/01: JFO NOTE, NO ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS. CLOSED

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 237

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BELDEN & BLAKE NOBLE‘S ROAD

Spill Number: 0075288

Close Date: 05/06/2001

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC BRIAN JANDREW LEARY

Spiller: BRIAN HALL - BELDEN & BLAKE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: MINERAL RESOURCES Contact for more spill info: DAVE HOYT

Spiller Phone: (716) 326-4981 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/10/2000 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 55.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 1-2 BARRELS OF CRUDE OIL SPILLED TO WELL AND ON GROUND. SPILLAGE WAS REPORTEDLY CLEANED UP BY R.P. MINERAL RESOURCES WILL FOLLOW-UP AND ADVISE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL-CHCHD" 08/10/00: KAB TELECON BRIAN JANDREW OF MINERAL RESOURCES, THEY ARE GOING TO INSPECT SITE AND ADVISE US OF STATUS. KAB FAXED COPY TO MIKE VENDETTE, CHCHD, AND TOLD HIM THAT MINERALS WAS FOLLOWING UP. 08/22/00: RNL SENT MEMO TO MAV REQUESTING HIS REPORT 08/23/00: RNL AND MAV MEETING, HE HAD NOT INSPECTED THE SITE 08/23/00: RNL AND MAV SITE INSPECTION, FOUND OIL SPILLAGE, BEING PADDED BUT MORE WORK NEEDED, SEE SITE SKETCH, PHOTOGRAPHED, INFORMATION ON LEASE SIGN STATED THE FOLLOWING:

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 238

BELDEN AND BLAKE CIND WELL #7302 PERMIT #31-013-10204 TOWN OF GERRY TELEPHONE 716-326-4981 08/30/00: RNL TELECON TO BLEDON AND BLAKE, NO ONE PRESENT, LEFT MESSAGE ON DOROTHY’S ANSWERING MACHINE 08/30/00: RNL TELECON FROM DAVE WHITE (EXT 14) AT BELDON AND BLAKE, HE SAID THEY WILL BE DISPOSING ADSORBANTS, BUT THE SOIL THEY HAVE REGRADED AND ALLOWED TO LEACH TO THE SEPARATOR POND, RNL SAID SOIL SHOULD BE DISPOSED OR TREATED, HE WILL INSPECT SITE ON 08/31/00 AND LET HIM KNOW WHAT WORK IS STILL NEEDED 09/06/00: RNL AND MAV SITE INSPECTION, ADDITIONAL CLEANUP NEEDED, PHOTOGRAPHED AREA, SEE SITE SKETCH, RNL TO CONTACT BELDON AND BLAKE 09/12/00: RNL TELECON TO DAVE WHITE, RNL STATED CONTAMINATED SOIL MUST BE REMOVED, MR. WHITE WILL COMPLY, HE SAID PADS HAVE BEEN SAMPLED FOR DISPOSAL AT LANDFILL, RNL SAID SOIL COULD BE DISPOSED AT SAME TIME, MR. WHITE WILL CALL WHEN WORK DONE 09/26/00: RNL SITE INSPECTION, NO WORK AT SITE, PADS STILL STAGED, PHOTOGRAPHED SITE, NO SOIL REMOVED 10/25/00: RNL MEETING WITH MAV, RECEIVED MAV REPORT, SATISFACTORY, HOLD FOR INSPECTION 10/25/00: RNL AND MAV SITE INSPECTION, MET EMPLOYEE WHO WAS REMOVING FOUR DRUMS OF CONTAMINATED MATERIAL, REQUESTED FURTHER SOIL REMOVAL ABOUND WELLHEAD AND PIPING, HE AGREED, HOLD FOR REINSPECTION 12/04/00: RNL FILE REVIEW, NEED TO INSPECT SITE 01/31/01: RNL SENT DISPOSAL RECEIPT LETTER TO BELDEN AND BLAKE 02/21/01: RNL RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT FROM BELDEN & BLAKE, INSPECT SITE FOR CLOSEOUT 03/23/01: RNL AND MAV ATTEMPTED SITE INSPECTION, DRIVEWAY NOT PASSABLE, TOO MUCH SNOW, REINSPECT 04/18/01: MAV AND RNL SITE INSPECTION, SPILL AREA CLEANED UP BUT OIL FROM WELL DRILLING STILL APPARANT, SHEEN ON STANDING WATER AND STAINED SOILS, MAV BELEIVED FURTHER CLEANUP NECESSARY, RNL TO LET PJB DECIDE 05/04/01: RNL SENT MEMO TO PJB STATING SPILL IS CLOSED DUE TO ONLY "NORMAL" OIL SPILLAGE AT WELL BUT THAT MAV BELIEVES FURTHER CLEANUP IS NECESSARY 05/08/01: RNL DISCUSSION WITH PJB, HE HAD FORWARDED MEMO TO MINERALS, NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILLS NECESSARY AT THIS TIME

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 239

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FREY WELL DRILLING 1097 BINNIE LAKE

Spill Number: 0075295

Close Date: 12/01/2000

ALDEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 1097 BONNIE LAKE DR Revised zip code: 14004 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen JACKIE ISGRO RMCROSSE

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 937-4209 Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/2000 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected WATER RUNOFF OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER OWNES HOME NEXT TO FREY WELL DRILLING, CALLER BELIEVES WATER IS OFTEN PUMPED ONTO HER PROPERTY, WATER HAS CHEMICAL ODOR, -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 12/1/00 RMC/FILE RMC CHECKED SITE SEVERAL TIMES, NO PROBLEM FOUND, PBS INSPECTED SITE ALSO, NO FURTHER COMPLANINT FROM CALLER, NO ACTION REQUIRED, CLOSE OUT

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 240

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SALT PIPELINE BREAK 9270 LAPP ROAD

Spill Number: 9906094

Close Date: 08/23/1999

CLARENCE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14032 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Local Agency DAVE BISSONETT RMCROSSE

Spiller: DONALE MEEDER - TEXAS BRINE CORPORATION Spiller Phone: (716) 786-5203 Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: TOWN OF CLARENCE Caller Phone: (716) 553-1161 Contact for more spill info: DAVE BISSONETT Contact Person Phone: (716) 460-1113

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/21/1999 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 10000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE LINE - HAS A RUPTURE DUE TO EXCAVATION - UNK HOW TO SHUT OFF -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 08/23/99: RMC NOTE, DUTY OFFICIER HANDLED INITIALLY OVER WEEEKEND, DID NOT REQUEST RESPONSE BY SPILLS, DID NOT NOTIFIY SPILLS. 08/23/99: RMC SITE INSPECTION, MET DONALD MEEDER, TEXAS BRINE, A FARMER HIT LINE WHILE INSTALLING IRRIGATION IN HIS FIELD, 10 INCH LINE CARRIES 800 GPM OF 98% SOLUTION, 2.6 POUNDS PER GALLON SALT, ESTIMATED 100 TO 200 GPM LEAK IN LINE FOR ABOUT 2 HOURS BEFORE THE LINE WAS SHUT DOWN, LINE IS NOW REPAIRED AND BACK IN SERVICE, BRINE APPEARS TO COVER ABOUT 2 ACRES IN AN IRREGULAR SHAPE, DITCHES WERE DIKED AND 13-5000 GALLON TANKER TRUCK LOADS OF BRINE WERE VACED. NO FREE BRINE REMAINS, MEEDER ESTIMATES THAT FARM LAND WILL NOT PRODUCE AS BEFORE FOR 1 TO 3 YEARS, RMC ADVISED RNL OF SPILL. FARMERS NAME IS GREG SPOTH, 741-4239. 08/23/99: RMC NOTIFIED MINERALS, NO FURTHER SPILL ACTION REQUIRED, CLOSE OUT

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 241

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SENECA RESOURCES/GIARDINI BUTTER MILK ROAD

Spill Number: 9907851

Close Date: 03/26/2001

VILLENOVA (SOUTH DAYTON), NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14138 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Health Department MIKE VENDETTE LEARY

Spiller: ROB KALE - SENECA RESOURCES/GIADINI Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY HEALTH Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 988-3388 Notifier Phone: (716) 753-4233 Caller Phone: (716) 366-8831 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/29/1999 DELIBERATE YES YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SPILL STARTED ON BUTTER MILK RD CHAUTAUQUA CO TO SKINNER HOLLOW RD CATTRAUGUS CO. SPILL HAS BEEN CONTAINED (OCCURED OVER 30 MILES) AND SAND WAS APPLIED TO SPILL. CELL PHONE FOR CALLER IS 716-753-6331 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL-CHCHD" 09/30/99: RNL TELECON FROM MICHAEL VENDETTE, CHCHD, HE HAD INSPECTED SITE, BRINE AND OIL SPILLED OVER 30 MILES OF ROADS, SENECA RESOURCES WAS REMOVING OIL STOCK TANKS, HIRED GIARDINI TO MOVE THE TANKS TO A SCRAPYARD OWNED BY A CHUCK EVANS AT 10060 SKINNER HOLLOW ROAD IN CATTARAUGUS COUNTY TANKS WERE NOT EMPTY, DRIVER DROVE WITH LEAKING TANKS ALL THE WAY TO THE SCRAPYARD, COUNTY HAD PLACES ADSORBANTS AT CRITICAL LOCATIONS BUT CLEANUP IS NOT POSSIBLE, CONTACT AT SENECA RESOURCES IS ROBERT KALE AT 988-3388 AND AT SCRAPYARD IS CHUCK EVANS AT 257-3617 MAV HAD SAMPLED OIL/BRINE MIXTURE, AGREED TO ANALYSIS UNDER A PIN NUMBER, HIRED WASTESTREAM FOR ANALYSIS, MAV WILL TAKE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 242

SAMPLE TO RANDY ZOLADZ IN DUNKIRK RNL AND MAV AGREED THAT MAV WOULD FINE SENECA RESOURCES AND GIARDINI, STATE WOULD BILL BOTH FOR PIN COSTS, POSSBILE COSTS FROM COUNTY CLEANUP CREWS 09/30/99: RNL TELECON FROM PAUL MORROW AT WASTESTREAM, 876-5190, RNL NOT IN, HE LEFT MESSAGE STATING THAT SAMPLE QUANTITY MIGHT BE INSUFFICIENT 09/30/99: RNL TELECON TO PAUL MORROW, NOT IN, LEFT MESSAGE THAT MAIN GOAL IS TO SHOW SOME TYPE OF OIL, IF NOT POSSIBLE, HE IS TO CALL BACK 10/21/99: RNL FILE REVIEW, NEED SAMPLE RESULTS AND MAV REPORT 10/25/99: RNL RECEIVED SAMPLE RESULTS, FOUND THE FOLLOWING: 5.4 PPB TOLUENE GROUND NEAR TANKS 1.9 PPB TOLUENE BRINE TANKS 72 PPB FLUORENE GROUND NEAR TANKS 54 PPB PHENANTHRENE GROUND NEAR TANKS 43 PPB FLUORENE BRINE TANKS 10/29/99: RNL MEETING WITH MAV, NO FURTHER CLEANUP POSSIBLE, COUNTY TO FINE BOTH PARTIES, RNL TO CLOSEOUT SITE, DO ISR, NEED MAV REPORT FOR CLOSEOUT 12/15/99: RNL AND MAV MEETING, MAV SUBMITTED ORDER FOR SITE, SENECA RESOURCES FINED $600.OO, NEED TO INSPECT SITE BEFORE CLOSEOUT AS NO MAV REPORT 12/22/99: RNL AND MAV MEETING, MAV AGREED TO SUBMIT REPORT, NOTHING TO SEE AT SITE, HE FINED SENECA RESOURCES, WILL STILL FINE THE TRUCKING FIRM, GIARDINI, HOLD FOR REPORT 01/05/00: RNL MEETING WITH MAV, RNL RECEIVED MAV REPORT AND TICKET AGAINST SENECA RESOURCES, HE IS STILL PLANNING TO FINE GIARDINI 01/10/00: RNL FILE REVIEW, FOUND SKINNER HOLLOW ROAD IN CATTARAUGUS BUT CANNOT BUTTERMILK ROAD IN CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY, DISCUSS WITH MAV 01/12/00: MAV AND RNL SITE INSPECTION OF SENECA RESOURCES, THE SOURCE OF THE TANKS, NO CONTAMINATION NOTED RNL NOTE, MAV STATED ROAD NAME OF BUTTERMILK IS AN OLD NAME THAT NO LONGER APPEARS ON MAPS, ROAD IS CR 91, NAMED HANOVER ROAD, SEE MAPS 03/08/00: MAV AND RNL MEETING, MAV AGREED TO TICKET GIARDINI, HOLD ON ISR AND CLOSEOUT 05/03/00: RNL AND MAV MEETING, MAV TO ISSUE TICKET

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

10/02/00: RNL NOTE TO FILE, MAV HAS STILL NOT ISSUED A TICKET, RNL DECIDED TO CLOSEOUT SPILL, FINE GIARDINI THROUGH ISR, DISCUSS WITH MAV AT NEXT MEETING 01/21/01: RNL FILE REVIEW, NEED ADDRESS FOR GIARDINI FOR ISR, RNL TELECON TO MAV, NOT IN, GAVE MESSAGE TO RUTH OF CHCHD 02/07/01: RNL AND MAV MEETING, MAV TO GET ADDRESS 03/23/01: RNL AND MAV MEETING, MAV HAD THE FOLLOWING ADDRESS ROBERT GIARDINI 1725 CHIPMUNK ROAD ALLEGANY, NY TELEPHONE 716-372-0781

03/26/01: RNL FILE REVIEW, CLOSEOUT SPILL, DO ISR

Page 243

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 244

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS FROM WELL SHAW ROAD

Spill Number: 9975497

Close Date: 10/29/1999

PERRYSBURG, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14129 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS JFOTTO

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/28/1999 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OPENED AN EXISTING TEST GAS WELL WITH A WATER RIG, THE WELL HAS BEEN CAPPED FOR SEVERAL YEARS. NATURAL GAS IS ESCAPING. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JFO" 10/29/99: JFO REFERRED SPILL TO DIVISI0N OF AIR AND MINERAL RESOURCES. COPY FAXED TO JACK DAHL. NO ACTION NECESSARY. 11/03/99: RNL NOTE, ALLAN ALEXANDER SENT MEMO TO JFO, HE HAD INSPECTED SITE, DID NOT FIND A WELL LEAKING GAS

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 245

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LINDQUIST RESIDENCE 12456 CLARENCE CENTER RD

Spill Number: 9913744

Close Date: 03/30/2000

AKRON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14001 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Affected Persons JANET LINDQUIST RMCROSSE

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 542-6320 Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/01/2000 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE A WATER LINE WAS BEING INSTALLED, A CONTRACTOR STRUCK THE LINE. REQ CONTACT FROM DEC, CAN SEEM TO GET THIS FIXED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 03/06/00: RMC TELECON MR LINDQUIST, LINE WAS BROKE ON PRIVATE WELL, NATURAL GAS BUBBLING OUT OF THE GROUND STILL IN FRONT OF THEIR HOUSE, 03/30/00: RMC REFERED TO MINERALS, NO SPILL ACTION REQUIRED, CLOSE OUT

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 246

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL WELL BARNUM ROAD

Spill Number: 9975471

Close Date: 11/03/1999

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: STEVE JONES

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (716) 884-6779

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/01/1999 11/03/1999 HOUSEKEEPING YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: COMPLAINT OF A LEAKING CRUDE OIL WELL 2.7 MILES OFF BARMUN RD, OFF LOGGING ROAD. CALLER WANT TO REMAIN ANONYMOUS. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 10/12/99: MF TELECON TO CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS, GAVE HIM SPILL INFORMATION, HE WILL GET BACK TO ME. 10/28/99: MF SENT E-MAIL TO CHRIS MILLER FOR UPDATE. 10/28/99: MF RECEIVED E-MAIL FROM CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS. THEY ARE HANDLING. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 247

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SENECA RESOURCES TANK ROUTE 474

Spill Number: 9975187

Close Date: 08/16/1999

CLYMER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14724 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Health Department STEVE JOHNSON LEARY

Spiller: ROBERT KAHLE - SENECA RESOURCES CORPORAT Spiller Phone: (716) 988-3388 Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY HEALTH Caller Phone: (716) 753-4481 Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/10/1999 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 1500 GALLONS 1500 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LIGHTNING STRUCK CRUDE OIL TANK. LOST APPX 3000 GALLONS, MOST CONTAINED, SOME TO CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL-CHCHD" 06/11/99: MF NOTIFIED OF SPILL BY STEVE JOHNSON, HE WAS ON SITE DURING 06/10/99. SPILL CAUSED WHEN LIGHTNING STRUCK CRUDE OIL TANK & KNOCKED IT INTO THE AIR. LOST APPX 3000 GALLONS. MOST OIL TO DIKE AREA BUT SOME OIL TO STREAM. RP HIRED CONTRACTORS WHO WERE ON SITE LAST NIGHT CLEAINING UP SPILL. MF NOTIFIED JACK DAHL, MINERALS, HE IS AWARE OF PROBLEM. THEY WILL INSPECT DURING 06/11/99. 06/11/99: RNL FAXED COPY OF SPILL TO MAV, GAVE COPY TO PJB 06/14/99: MF TELECON AL ALEXANDER, 210 BARELL TANK CONTAINING 1500 GALLONS HIT BY LIGHTNING, BLEW IT 300’. SOME CRUDE OIL GOT INTO PROTECTED STREAM. CONTACT FOR SENECA RESOURSES IS ROB KAHLE, 716-630-6777. CONTRACTOR, EP&S ON SITE FOR RP. BULK OF SPILLAGE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 248

IN DIKE. 06/15/99: PJB QUESTIONED WHY NYSDEC WAS NOT NOTIFIED UNTIL THE NEXT MORNING, RNL TO CHECK WITH STEVE JOHNSON 06/15/99: RNL TELECON TO STEVE JOHNSON, NOT AVAILABLE, WILL CALL BACK 06/15/99: RNL TELECON FROM STEVE JOHNSON, HE SAID SENECA RESOURCE TOLD HIM THAT THEY HAD CALLED NYSDEC, HE GAVE RNL TIMETABLE OF EVENTS 06/15/99: RNL SENT MEMO TO PJB EXPLAINING NOTIFICATION ISSUE 06/15/99: STEVE JOHNSON SUBMITTED HIS REPORT, SITE CLEANED UP, CONTAMINATED SOIL TO BE DISPOSED, WILL NEED RECEIPT 06/16/99: MAV AND RNL MEETING, CLEANUP PROCEEDING SATISFACTORILY, MAV SUBMITTED PHOTOGRAPHS 06/22/99: MAV AND RNL MEETING, NO CHANGE, WILL NEED DISPOSAL RECEIPT 08/03/99: RNL SENT DISPOSAL RECEIPT REQUEST LETTER TO SENECA RESOURCES CORP 08/12/99: RNL RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT FROM SENECA RESOURCES CORPORATION, SATISFACTORY, CLOSEOUT

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 249

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OLD NATIONAL FUEL WELL NANCY CREST LANE

Spill Number: 9875241

Close Date: 12/10/1998

WEST SENECA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen MIKE KERL PGER 459-0670 RMCROSSE

Spiller: CHARLE BURKE - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: TOWN OF WEST SENECA Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 857-7358 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 674-5600 ext. 2 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/29/1998 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CITIZEN COMPLAINED TO WEST SENECA THAT BLACK SUBSTANCE COMING OUT OF GROUND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 11/30/98: RMC/KERL/SITE, 500 PLUS ACRE OPEN FIELD AND SCRUB AREA, LOCATED AREA OF CONCERN, 6 BY 8 FOOT AREA OF DEAD VEGETATION, ONE FOOT DIAMETER PUDDLE, AIR BUBBLES UP FROM THE GROUND, DARK COLOR TO THE WATER, TESTED PH AT 7, NO READING ON VOC METER, ACRID ODOR, NATURAL GAS LINE 200 FEET AWAY, POSSIBLE SOURCES ARE THE NATURAL NATURAL GAS OR THE SACRIFICIAL ANODE ON PIPE LINE. 12/01/98: RMC/CHARLIE BURKE,NFG/PHONE, RMC REQUESTED NFG LOOK INTO, UPDATE 12/5/98 12/10/98: RMC TELECON FROM FROM NFG THAT PROBLEM IS FROM OLD NFG WELL, NFG WILL WORK WITH OLEAN MINERALS TO PLUG WELL. CC OLEAN MINERALS CLOSE OUT AS SPILL ISSUE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 250

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL FROM HILL 1973 RIVER ROAD

Spill Number: 9875386

Close Date: 02/25/1999

WELLSVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14895 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Citizen AL ALEXANDER MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

UNKNOWN DENNIS HOLLOD NYSDEC DENNIS HOLLOD

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: (716) 593-1621 Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 593-1621

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/06/1999 02/25/1999 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL COMING DOWN HILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 02/09/99: MF S/I/DENNIS HOLLOD, OWNER OF PROPERTY FOR APPX 2 MONTHS. HE NOTICED CRUDE OIL FLOWING DOWN A HILL ON HIS PROPERTY DURING THE RECENT MELT OFF. FOLLOWED BACK HALF WAY UP THE HILL. WE WALKED THE HILL LOOKING FOR ABANDON WELLS, NO LUCK. WE FOUND A STORAGE TANK THAT DENNIS CLAIMED IS EMPTY ON PROPERTY OWNED BY LESTER FENTON, RD #1, WELLSVILLE, 14895, 716-593-5561. WE NOTICED AN AREA DOWN HILL & TO THE NORTH OF THE TANK WHERE CRUDE OIL IS NOTICED ON THE VEGETATION, STRONG ODOR ALSO NOTED IN THIS AREA. COULD NOT TRACE CRUDE OIL BACK ANY FURTHER. POSSIBLE LINE BRAKE FROM STOCK TANK. DENNIS HOLLOD WALKS THE HILL FREQUENTLY. IF HE NOTICES ANYTHING AGAIN, HE WILL CALL. DON’T KNOW WHERE LINE GOES FROM STOCK TANK. AL ALEXANDER OF MINERALS WILL ALSO INSPECT. 02/25/99: MF T/C/AL ALEXANDER, TOLD HIM OF MY FINDINGS [NOT MUCH]. OWNER TO KEEP AN EYE ON AREA. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE. MINERALS DID NOT INSPECT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 251

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ODOR FROM WELL 247 MAIN STREET

Spill Number: 9809633

Close Date: 05/19/1999

WEST SENECA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14224 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Police Department DISPATCHER COUGHLIM RMCROSSE

Spiller: DAVID ZERKOWSKI - DAVID ZERKOWSKI Notifier Name: CITIZEN Caller Agency: WEST SENECA PD Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 675-7861 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 674-2280 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/31/1998 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CAPTAN HAZARDOUS MATERIAL 1.00 GALLONS 1.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: POLICE DEPT CALLED FOR AN ODOR THAT IS COMING FROM THE WELL BEHIND THE RESIDENCE - F.D. HAZMAT TEAM ON SCENE - NATIONAL FUEL GAS ON SCENE ALSO - NATURAL GAS MIXED WITH SOME OTHER CHEMICAL - REQ DEC TO SCENE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 10/31/98: RMC SITE INSPECTION, FD AND SOUTH TOWNS HAZMAT ON SITE, CAPTAN SPILL, FROM PRIVATE GAS WELL, RMC CONTACTED VENDER, CONFIRMED MSDS INSTRUCTIONS, HAZMAT OVERPACKED, RMC UPDATED MLD AND RNL, UPDATE 12/98 05/19/99: RMC/FILE, RMC NEUTRALIZED MATERIAL WITH CLOROX PER MANUFACTURER INSTRUCTIONS, NO ACTION REQUIRED, CLOSE OUT

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 252

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL IN GRAVEL PIT WATER BACK HINSDALE ROAD

Spill Number: 9801844

Close Date: 05/22/1998

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons LEE ADAMS MXFRANKS

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: LEE‘S SEPTIC SERVICE Contact for more spill info: LEE ADAMS

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 933-5800 Contact Person Phone: (716) 933-0163

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/1998 05/22/1998 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: STANDING WATER IN GRAVEL PIT HAS OILY SCUM LAYERED. CALLER WANTS CALLBACK TO SETUP APPOINTMENT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 05/13/98: MF T/C LEE ADAMS, LEFT MESSAGE WITH ANSWERING SERVICE. 05/19/98: MF S/V/LEE ADAMS, HE IS A SEPTIC HAULER WHO SPREADS WASTE AT SITE. SITE IS OWNED BY KENT ESTATE, LEE IS BUYING IT FROM THEM. THERE IS WHAT APPEARS TO BE A SLIGHT AMOUNT OF CRUDE OIL & A SLIGHT SHEEN AT ONE END OF A POND THAT ONCE WAS A GRAVEL PIT. CHECKED WITH MINERALS, IT IS INDEED CRUDE OIL AS THIS AREA WAS ONCE USED FOR STORAGE. MIKE MYERS OF MINERALS STOPPED THE GRAVEL OPERATION DUE TO THIS. HISTORICAL CRUDE OIL PROBLEM. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ALSO SEE SPILL # 8502000. 7/1/98 MR. ADAMS CALLED AND SAID THAT THE OWNERS ARE HAULING CONTAMINATED GRAVEL OUT OF THE PIT. I REFERRED HIM TO MIKE MYERS OF DEC MINERALS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 253

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 9875059

Close Date: 07/06/1999

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC ECO DON PLEAKIS MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFIBAUGH - BDH OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 362-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 373-3006 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/13/1998 07/06/1999 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 80.00 GALLONS 70.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BROKEN PIPELINE CAUSED SPILLAGE OF APPROX. 80-100 GALS. OF CRUDE OIL TO GROUND AND INTO UNK. TRIBUTARY. SPILLAGE WAS NOT REPORTED TO DEC. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 09/23/98: MF SITE VISIT, MET DON PLEAKIS, NYSDEC ECO. SPILL OCCURED 9/13/98, PIPE LINE BRAKE, OIL FLOWED INTO SMALL STREAM THAT DISCHARGED TO NICHOLS RUN BROOK. DON PLEAKIS NOTIFIED OF SPILL BY RESIDENT. MINERALS NOTIFIED 9/16/98. NO CALL TO SPILLS. LINE REPLACED AT SPILL SITE. CONTAMINATION IN SMALL STREAM. BOOMS IN PLACE. ALSO SPILLAGE AROUND WELL HO-22 & BETWEEN BDH’S OFFICE & STORAGE SHED. DON WANT TO WRITE A CONSENT ORDER & WANTS ME TO INCLUDE CLEANUP REQUIREMENTS. OTTO TERTINEK ALSO INVOLVED. 09/24/98: MF WROTE UP SPILL CLEANUP REQUIREMENT. GAVE TO LAW INFORCEMENT. 10/02/98: MF SITE VISIT, MET DON PLEAKIS AND JOE BUCHER, OWNER. DISCUSSED FINES & CLEANUP REQUIREMENTS. DON GAVE JOE ORDER ON CONSENT TO LOOK OVER & HAVE TOM SIGN. CONTAMINATION BETWEEN BUILDINGS CLEANED. JOE CLAIMED SOIL FROM SPILL AREAS STAGED ON

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

PLASTIC. 11/08/98: MF DISCUSSION WITH DON PLEAKIS, FINE SETTLED FOR $1000. 12/02/98: MF TELECON DIFIBAUGH, HE CLAIMED ALL AREAS CLEANED, SOIL ON SITE, SAMPLE INTO LAB. 12/29/98: MF SENT FIRST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 1/22/99. 01/27/99: MF SITE VISIT, NO ONE AT OFFICE. LEFT MESSAGE TO CALL ME. 01/28/99: MF SENT SECOND DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 2/15/99. 03/30/99: MF SITE VISIT, JOE & TOM OFF TODAY. LARRY WILL PASS REQUEST FOR SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPT. 04/23/99: MF SENT THIRD DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 5/15/99. 06/21/99: MF TELECON JOE BUCHER, HOME NOT IN, LEFT MESSAGE TO RETURN CALL, 928-2728. 07/06/99: MF RECEIVED SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPT, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 254

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 255

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PENHARLOW WELL WATER 9582 SWEDE ROAD

Spill Number: 9875114

Close Date: 11/19/1998

PORTLAND, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14769 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Affected Persons SALLY PENHARLOW LEARY

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: SALLY PENHARLOW

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 792-4437 Contact Person Phone: (716) 792-4437

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/19/1998 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: COMPLAINTANT’S WEEL WATER SMELLS LIKE NATURAL GAS -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL-CHCHD" 10/19/98:SAC TELECON MS. PENHARLOW, GAS COMPANY AT THE HOUSE, THEY BELIEVE IT MAY BE MATHANE BUT DO NOT BELIEVE THEY ARE THE SOURCE,SAC TELECON MAV - CHCHD, NOTIFYING HIM OF THE SITUATION, MAV WILL FOLLOW UP AND POSSIBLY REFER TO DEC MINERALS, SAC FAXED COPY OF SPILL REPORT TO MAV, GAVE COPY TO DIVISION OF WATER. 10/19/98:SAC TELECON MAV, MAV INSPECTED AND FOUND NATIONAL FUEL GAS WORKER’S AT SITE, THEY MEASURED 40 % GAS IN MS. PENHARLOW’S WELL, NATIONAL FUEL IS GETTING THEIR SUPERVISORS INVOLVED, THEY WILL BE DOING MORE TESTS, THERE IS A GAS WELL THAT WAS CLOSED OFF NEAR THE HOUSE AS WELL AS A BROKEN LINE ACROSS THE STREET FROM THE HOUSE AS POTENTIAL SOURCES, MAV WILL BE CONTACTING DEC MINERALS AND HE WILL ALSO FOLLOWUP AND KEEP RNL UPDATED. 11/13/98: RNL FILE REVIEW, NEED MAV REPORT

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

11/19/98: MAV AND RNL MEETING, MAV SUBMITTED HIS REPORT, NO FURTHER WORK REQURIED BY SPILLS, MINERALS IS HANDLING, CLOSEOUT

Page 256

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 257

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BDH OIL NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 9875195

Close Date: 11/09/1998

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN MXFRANKS

Spiller: TOM DEFINBAUGH - BDH Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 372-5447 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/08/1998 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 42.00 GALLONS 42.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LEAD LINE BRAKE, PRODUCT GOT INTO A DITCH. CLEAN UP UNDERWAY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 11/09/98: MF TELECON WITH JOHN HOFFMAN, GAVE ME SPILL INFO. MINERALS WILL HANDLE CLEAN UP. DEBRIS WILL BE DISPOSED OF WITH DEBRIS FROM SPILL # 9875059 WHICH IS STILL ACTIVE. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY ON THIS SPILL BY SPILLS, FOLLOWUP BY MINERALS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 258

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL FROM WELLS ALMA HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 9875237

Close Date: 01/15/1999

ALMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14708 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/01/1998 01/15/1999 HOUSEKEEPING YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL OPERATION SPILLING AND CONTAMINATING THE SOIL AND GROUNDWATER AROUND WELLS -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 11/27/98: SAC TELECON JOHN HOFFMAN, NYSDEC MINERALS, SAC NOTIFIED MR. HOFFMAN ABOUT THE COMPLAINT, MR. HOFFAMN WILL HAVE SOMEONE INSPECT AND FOLLOW UP ON THE COMPLAINT. 01/15/99: MF E-MAIL FROM JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS, JIM RUCINSKI INSPECTED, NO SPILLAGE NOTICED. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 259

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL WELL & STORAGE BURTON & PINERIDGE ROADS

Spill Number: 9702270

Close Date: 12/01/1997

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: BURTON / PINERIDGE ROADS Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Health Department MICHAEL VENDETTE FXGALLEG

Spiller: LARRY COUTHWELL - LARRY SOUTHWELL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY HEALTH Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 489-3785 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 753-4481 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 30.00 GALLONS 30.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL WELL LEAKING INTO POND ADJACENT TO WELL. STORAGE TANK AREA HAS SPILLS AROUND TANKS. POND ADJACENT TO TANKS ALSO HAS A LAYER OF CRUDE OIL ON IT -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG-CHCHD" 5/21/97 MAV SITE INSPECTION. SMELLED CRUDE OIL WHILE DRIVING BY SITE. FOUND A WELL LEAKING CRUDE INTO A HOLDING POND AT WELL. SPILL ALSO AROUND STORAGE TANKS AND HOLDING POND SOUTH OF WELL. 5/23/97 MAV SAID THAT HE CALLED MR. SOUTHWELL WHO SAID THAT HE WILL CLEAN UP SPILL THIS WEEKEND. MAV TO INSPECT ON TUES. 5/23/97 TREATMENT FORM LETTER SENT. RESPONSE DUE BY 6/13/97. 5/27/97 LARRY SOUTHWELL CALLED & SAID THAT THE SITE IS CLEANED UP. HE SAID HE WILL LET MAV KNOW TO INSPECT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 260

6/4/97 MAV PROVIDED FAX UPDATE. STATES: WELL HEAD CLEANED AND STORAGE TANK AREA BEING WORKED ON. NO DATE OF INSPECTION PROVIDED. 6/24/97 MAV SITE INSPECTION. FOUND POND DOWN STREAM OF THE WELLHEAD CLEANED. THE WELL HEAD AREA AND A NARROW PATH OF CONTAMINATED SOIL NEEDS TO BE REMOVED. THE CONTAMINATION AROUND THE STORAGE TANKS AND RETAINING POND STILL NEED CLEANING. 6/25/97 MAV SPOKE WITH MR. SOUTHWELL AND TOLD HIM TO COMPLETE CLEANUP AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. 7/25/97 MAV RECEIVED CALL FROM LARRY SOUTHWELL REGARDING WELLS BEING CLEANED. MAV INVESTIGATION FOUND CONTAMINATION CLEANED AND REMOVED. SMALL PILE OF CONTAMINATED WASTE STAGED ON SITE. POND AREA CLEANED. 8/8/97 LETTER REQUIRING SOIL DISPOSAL RECPT SENT TO MR. SOUTHWELL. RESPONSE DUE SEPTEMBER 3, 1997. 9/3/97 LAWRENCE SOUTHWELL CALLED & SAID HE WILL BE HAULING SOIL OUT ON THE 5TH. 11/26/97 RECEIVED SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPT. INSPECTION NECESSARY TO CONFIRM DISPOSAL. 12/1/97 MAV SITE VISIT. SOIL HAS BEEN REMOVED. SITE CAN BE CLOSE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 261

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BOB STAGE 1821 BUSH ROAD

Spill Number: 9702985

Close Date: 06/11/1997

CLYMER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14724 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Affected Persons BOB STAGE FXGALLEG

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: BOB STAGE

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 355-2525 Contact Person Phone: (716) 355-2525

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/09/1997 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER FOUND PETROLEUM AND NATURAL GAS IN HIS WELL WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG-CHCHD" 6/10/97 CONTACTED MAV WHO WAS ALREADY AWARE OF THE SITUATION. CHCHD VISITED SITE AND FOUND THAT THERE IS NO PETROLEUM PRESENT IN THE WELL. EVIDENCE OF NATURAL GAS PRESENT. MR. STAGE SAID THAT NYSDEC MINERALS WILL BE ON SITE ON JUNE 24, 1997 WITH LOMAK PETROLEUM WHO OWNS A WELL IN THE AREA. 6/11/97 SPOKE WITH JOHN HOFFMAN WITH MINERALS. HE SAID HE WILL BE ON SITE TO DISCUSS SITUATION W/MR. STAGE ALONG WITH LOMAK. 6/11/97 NO FURTHER WORK REQUIRED BY SPILLS. NO PETROLEUM SPILL PRESENT. SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 262

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE/SALT SPREADING JOHNSON ROAD

Spill Number: 9707326

Close Date: 09/25/1997

RIPLEY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14775 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Health Department MIKE VENDETTE MXFRANKS

Spiller: RON CUNNINGHAM - RON CUNNINGHAM Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CHAUTTAUQUA COUNTY HEALTH Contact for more spill info: DICK ARCHER

Spiller Phone: (716) 792-9711 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 753-4481 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/19/1997 09/25/1997 DELIBERATE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE TRUCK HAD CRUDE OIL IN IT WHEN IT WAS SPREADING BRINE FOR DUST CONTROL. STRONG ODOR - SHERRIFF & TOWN REPRESENTATIVE ON SCENE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF-CHCHD" 09/25/97: MF S/V/DICK ARCHER, TOWN OF REPLEY; SHERIFF; RON CUNNINGHAM, RP. CONTRACTOR (RON) SPREADING BRINE ON DIRT ROAD FOR DUST CONTROL, BRINE HAD CRUDE OIL IN IT. HOMEOWNERS COMPLAINED OF ODOR. I NOTICED A STRONG ODOR, IT IS RAINING VERY HARD, NO CLEAN UP POSSIBLE. DISCUSSED WITH MAV, HE WILL FOLLOW UP & MAY FINE. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 263

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PENNZOIL CRUDE OIL TANKS SMITH HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 9707833

Close Date: 10/06/1997

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Federal Government JOHN MENDLESON MXFRANKS

Spiller: HERSCHEL MCDIVITT - PENNZOIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: EPA HOTLONE Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 678-4544 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (732) 548-8730 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/02/1997 10/06/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 15.00 GALLONS 14.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL TANK LOADING LINE RUPTURED CAUSING SPILL - IT IS UNKNOWN WHAT THE TRIBUTARY IS FROM OR FLOWS TO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 10/03/97: MF S/V NO ONE ON SITE, REPORT OF 15 GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL SPILLAGE DURING TRANSFUR. 3 CRUDE OIL TANKS INSIDE DIKED AREA. NO SPILLAGE NOTICED OUTSIDE OF DIKED AREA. INSIDE OF THE DIKE IS A MESS. VISIT TO MINERALS, NO ONE AVAILABLE. 10/06/97: MF T/C/JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS IS HANDLING. NO FURTHER ACTION NEECSSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 264

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL WELL/NYSDOT ROW 3163 ROUTE 248

Spill Number: 9700048

Close Date: 10/18/2004

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: ROUTE 248 Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Federal Government JOHN ULSHOEFER MXFRANKS

Spiller: DOUG CARRIER - NYSDOT Notifier Name: 911 OPERATOR Caller Agency: US EPA Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (908) 321-6620 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/01/1997 11/06/1997 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 45.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: abandoned oil well that got a surge of gas and oil and the oil came out.cap blew off on the well.spill not cleaned up . -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/01/97: MF APPX 2000 CALL FROM DO. CRUDE OIL WELL LEAKING RTE 248 & SCHRADER RD, CALL FROM 911. SCHRADER RD NOT ON MAP, NO WAY TO ACCESS 911 ALLEGANY CO. T/C JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS, HE IS AWARE OF ABANDONED WELLS IN AREA, WILL CHECK IN OFFICE IN THE AM TO FIND OWNER. I WILL LEAVE AT DAY BREAK. 04/02/97: MF STOP AT ALLEGANY CO SHERIFF OFFICE, GOT IN CONTACT WITH TOM BARNETT, AC HAZ MAT. HE RESPONDED TO COMPLAINT LAST NITE, CLAIMED WELL BURPED OIL APPX 20’ IN THE AIR, RESIDENCES COMPLAINING OF ODOR. HE TOOK ME TO SPILL SITE. WELL IS APPX 25’ FROM CENTER OF ROAD, A STATE HIGHWAY, SPILLED APPX 50 GALLONS OF CRUDE IN 20’ AREA & ON TREES. WELL IS ABANDONED, WEATHER DRY, SUNNY & CALM. VISIT TO DOT, FRIENDSHIP, SPOKE TO CLARK TUCKER, EXPLAINED THAT WE WILL CLEAN SPILL IF WE CAN’T LOCATE RP AS

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 265

SPILLAGE IS NEXT TO DITCH THAT DISCHARGES INTO CHENUNDA CREEK APPX 100’ AWAY. HE THINKS NYSDOT ROW IS 25’. VISIT TO MINERALS OFFICE, THEY CAN’T FIND LEASE OWNER. DUE TO SPILL LOCATION & POSSIBLE CONTAMINATION OF CREEK, I HIRED EPS TO REMEDIATE. I ALSO BRIEFED MR. JIM DELOIA, EPA, 908-906-6907 OF SPILL STATUS. WELL MAY BE ON DOT ROW. SOIL TO BE STAGED ON DOT ROW & TOM STOLL’S PROPERTY, HE GAVE PERMISSION. EPS ARRIVED ON SITE & BEGAN WORK. RECEIVED INFO FROM PASSER BY, WELL LAST BELONGED TO WAYNE KANE (DECEASED), HIS SON, STEVE KANE MAY OWN IT NOW. VISIT TO CARPET LAND, STEVE KANE OWNS BUSINESS, NOT IN. I WILL CALL IN THE AM. 04/03/97: MF T/C STEVE KANE 373-3300, CLAIMED HE KNOWNS NOTHING OF WELL. 04/04/97: MF T/C RNL, OPA 90 MAY PAY FOR PLUGGING WELL. WANTS TO COORDINATE WITH MINERALS, COAST GUARD & EPA. T/C BOB LUKAS, DOT 607-324-8445. HE WILL SEND MAP OF ROUTE 248, DOT MAY NOT HAVE AQUIRED ROW IN THIS AREA. T/C BRAD HOMAN, COAST GUARD, EXPLAINED SITUATION, HE ADVISED ME TO CONTACT EPA. T/C JACK DAHL, MINERALS, EXPLAINED THAT WILL WILL TRY TO GET EPA TO PAY FOR WE WILL PAY THRU CONTRACTOR. T/C JIM DELOIA, EPA, AT MEETING. 04/08/97: MF LETTER TO TOM PLESNARSKI TO SEE IF WE CAN USE OPA 90 FUNDS 04/09/97: MF VISIT/JACK DAHL, OLEAN OFFICE, THEY DONT KNOW WHO HAS LEASE. UPDATED HIM ON PROJECT. SITE VISIT TO WELL, VERY LITTLE IF ANY SEEPAGE, BOOM AROUND WELL HEAD. MET BERNARD COURANT, OWNER OF PROPERTY ABOVE WELL 593-5892, HE CLAIMED VICTOR BLACK OWNS PROPERTY THAT WELL IS ON, BLACK’S NOT HOME. WENT TO DOT OFFICE IN HORNELL, MET/BOB LUCAS, OBTAINED DOT MAPS OF AREA, HE MENTIONED COUNTY CLERK SHOULD BE CONTACTED TO SEE IF ROW ON MAPS WAS EVER ACQUIRED. VISIT TO COUNTY OFFICE, OBTAINED TAX MAPS OF AREA & DEEDS OF COURANT & BLACKS PROPERTY. COURANT DEED, SUBJECT TO AN OIL & GAS LEASE FROM LEWIS STANLEY TO CHESTER & BENJ. FANTON DATED 8/7/08. DOES NOT INDICATE ANY TRANSFER. BLACK’S PROPERTY WAS ONCE PART OF COURANTS PROPERTY. I ALSO MET/CLARK TUCKER, DOT FRIENDSHIP. EXPLAINED DOT MAY BE RESPONSIBLE FOR PLUGGING, TOLD ME TO TALK TO DOUG CARRIER, DOT, HORNELL REGARDING THIS. DOUG OUT FOR THE DAY. 04/10/97: MF T/C JIM DELOIA, EPA, UPDATED HIM ON SPILL. DISCUSSED OPA 90 FUNDING. HE HAS BEEN IN CONTACT WITH AKRAM HUSAIN, CENTRAL OFFICE. 04/11/97: MF T/C AKRAM HUSAIN, CENTRAL OFFICE. DISCUSSED OPA 90 FUNDING. FAXED APPLICATION FOR DISPOSAL TO ALLEGANY DPW. 04/11/97: MF VISIT WITH RAY SIMONS, 593-6852, WHO LIVES ON STANDARDS RD, AFTER A TIP THAT HE MAY OWN LEASE. RAY ONCE OWNED THE NEXT LEASE EAST, HE WILL CHECK TO SEE WHO OWNS THIS LEASE. 04/14/97: MF T/C/AKRAM HUSAIN, HE HAS BEEN IN TOUCH WITH CHUCK GILCREST, MINERALS, ALBANY, CLAIMED IT IS A REGIONAL CALL IF THEY WILL SUPERVISE PLUGGING. AKRAN DISCUSSED IN THE FUTURE, MINERALS MAY HAVE TO PERSUE OPA 90 FUNDING. 04/14/97: MF T/C/HERB BUNNELL, 593-2643. HE WAS ONCE INVOLVED WITH WELL, CLAIMED FRED WORMLEY (DEAD) SOLD LEASE TO WAYNE KANE (DEAD). WAYNE’S SON MAY NOW HAVE LEASE. GLADYS BEERMAN MAY ALSO KNOW, SHE IS IN HER 90’S. HERB THINKS WELL IS 700’ DEEP. 04/16/97: MF METTING WITH RAY SIMONS, HE CHECKED INTO WELL OWNERSHIP. CLAIMED GEORGIA KANE OWNES WELL, SHE IS IN WELLSVILLE NURSING HOME. HER ONLY SON STEVE, I TALKED WITH 4/3/97, AT THAT TIME HE CLAIMED HE KNOW NOTHING OF WELL. SITE VISIT, EPS/TOM STOLL, BACKHOE OWNER-OPERATOR/LAFORGE, WASTE HAULER. CONTAMINATED SOIL LOADED & TAKEN TO ALLEGANY LANDFILL. AREA LEVELED & SEEDED PER DOT. SEEPAGE AT WELL HEAD, RAPPED BOOM AROUND IT. 04/23/97: MF VISIT TO MINERALS, GAVE THEY TAX MAP & DEEDS IN AREA. VISIT TO SPILL SITE, SAMPLED BLACK’S WELL, WELL 90’ DEEP, FULL OF WATER.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 266

VISIT TO MONROE ABSTRACT, BELMONT, MIKE MCPEAK 268-7623. DISCUSSED PROPERTY SEARCH FOR OWNER OF WELL & LEASE. GOT PRICE OF $500-$1000. T/C LINDA GRIMMER, EPS, SHE HIRED JIM BALL TO SURVEY AREA. 593-4691. 04/24/97: MF T/C JIM BALL, LEFT MESSAGE ON MACHINE. 04/24/97: MF T/C JIM BALL, 593-4691, 4764 BYRNES RD, WELLSVILLE, 14895. CLAIMED HE CAN GET TO JOB BY THE END OF NEXT WEEK. COST APPX $300. HE WANTS DOT MAPS OF AREA. 4/28/97: MF MAILED JIM DOT MAPS. 05/07/97: MF RECEIVED FAX OF BLACK’S WELL WATER SAMPLE RESULTS, 8021 & 8270 COMPOUNDS ND. RESULTS TO ALL PARTIES. 05/08/97: MF RECEIVED & PROCESSED KANTI’S $465. PAY PACKAGE. 06/11/97: MF PROCESSED EPS PAY PACKAGE FOR SITE SURVEY, $753.50. 07/09/97: MF MET WITH MIKE MCPEAK, MONROE ABSTRACT AT COUNTY HALL REGARDING SEARCH. HE IS HAVING TROUBLE, NOTHING RECORDED. HE WILL GIVE ME WHAT HE HAS. 07/15/97: MF S/V AT WELL, MINOR AMOUNT OF CRUDE AROUND WELL HEAD. 07/22/97: MF MEETING AT ALLEGANY COUNTY DPW OFFICE/DAVID ROESKE, DEPUTY SUPERVISOR. EXPLAINED PROBLEM WITH WELL & THAT IT IS IN COUNTY ROW. EXPLAINED WELL MUST BE PLUGGED. HE WANTS ME TO VISIT DOT IN HORNELL AS THIS IS A DOT ROAD & COUNTY DOES NOT DO MAINTANENCE ON ROW. 07/23/97: MF MEETING AT HORNELL DOT/DOUG CARRIER, REGIONAL LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT, EXPALINED PROBLEM & ASKED TO HAVE WELL PLUGGED. HE WANTS LETTER. ALSO MET WITH DAVE ROESKE, WILL SENT THEM BOTH LETTER. TOLD BOTH DAVE & DOUG THEY MAY BE INVOICED FOR WORK DONE SO FAR. 08/11/97: MF PROCESSED EPS’S $220 INVOICE FOR SEARCH FROM MONROE TO TRY TO FIND WHO OWNES MINERAL RIGHTS & WELL, NO LUCK. 08/14/97: MF RNL VISIT/JACK DAHL, WENT OVER LETTER TO DOT & ALLEGANY COUNTY. SITE VISIT TO WELL, SLIGHT WELL HEAD LEAK. 08/18/97: MF LETTER TO DOT & COUNTY REGARDING WELL PLUGGING, RESPONSE BY 9/30/97. 11/06/97: MF NO RESPONSE FROM DOT OR COUNTY. NOTHING MORE SPILLS CAN DO. NYSDOT SPILLER, RECOMMEND FINE WITH PROVISION FINE WILL BE DROPPED IF WELL PLUGGED. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE. ALL INVOICES IN & SENT TO ALBANY. 11/01/00: MF T/C SHARON SMITH OF THE AG’S OFFICE 518-474-4339. LEFT MESSAGE THAT WELL HAS NOT BEEN PLUGGED. 05/05/03: MF T/C JOAN PLUCKET, 518-474-7433, DISCUSSED SPILL. SHE RECOMNMENDED WE PLUG THIS WELL. 05/09/03: MF T/C MR. BLACK, LAND OWNER, 585-593-3373. HE RECEIVED A DEMAND LETTER & IS VERY ANGRY. YOLD HIM TO ANSWER LETTER. 10/27/03: MF TOOK FILE TO MINERALS, JOHN HOFFMAN TO COPY MAPS. HE IS DOING TITLE SEARCH. RIGHT NOW IT LOOKS LIKE THE NYSDOT OWNS

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 267

THE ROW IN FEE. 11/24/03: MF SENT OUT 6 BID LETTERS FOR WELL PLUGGING, DUE 12/31/03. 12/10/03: MF RECEIVED BID OF $2300. TO PLUG WELL FROM: JIM DAY CONTRACTING 1338 BARTLETT RD BOLIVAR NY 14715

585-928-2686

12/23/03: MF S/I AFTER A SPILL CALL (#0310905). THIS WELL BURBED DURING THE EARY MORNING. GAS & CRUDE OIL ODORS OVER THE AREA. I WAS MET ON SITE BY VICTOR BLACK, HIS SON & THE WILLING FIRE CHIEF, LEROY IVY, 585-593-3116 H, 716-307-5415 C. I APPLIED & PICK UP 2-BALES OF PADS & SOME BOOMS. I ESTIMATE SPILLAGE AT 50 GALLONS. SHEEN TO THE CHENUNDA CREEK. I CALLED OP-TECH TO RESPOND IN THE AM. BRIAN JANDREW WAS ON SITE & LEFT BEFORE I ARRIVED. KEPT CHRIS MILLER POSTED. 12/24/03: MF S/I/OP-TECH, 3-MEN, VAN, PICKUP, 9 DRUMS, PADS & BOOMS. THEY SHOVELED THE MAJORITY OF THE SPILLAGE INTO THE DRUMS. T/C JIM DAY, LEFT MESSAGE TO APPLY FOR PLUGGING PERMIT & PLUG ASAP. T/C JOHN HOFFMAN, BRIEFED HIM ON SPILL. 12/24/03: MF T/C JIM DAY, TOLD HIM TO PLUG THE WELL ASAP. HE WILL GET PERMIT & PLUG WELL NEXT WEEK. 12/26/03: MF T/C LINDA SCOTT, OP-TECH, TOLD HER ABOUT HIRING JIM DAY TO PLUG THE WELL, PAYING HIM WITHIN 45 DAYS & SUPPLING TRAFFIC CONTROL. SHE AGREED. 12/29/03: MF AUTHORIZATION TO OP-TECH. 12/29/03: MF RECEIVED HAND DELIVERED BID FROM DAN HANNAHS, D&D WELL SERVICES TO PLUG WELL, BID $5000. 12/29/03: MF AUTHORIZATION LETTER TO JIM DAY. 12/31/03: MF S/I/JIM DAY, SCOTT, MIKE, WELL PLUGGERS/BRIAN JANDREW, MINERALS/OP-TECH, 2-MEN FOR TRAFFIC CONTROL & CLEAN UP. PLUGGING GRUDE OIL WELL. REMOVING RODS, PIPING & PACKER. PROBLEM REMOVING PACKER, HAD TO CALL GLEN BENSEN, SHOOTER TO BLAST PIPE BELOW PACKER. MUCH SPILLAGE FROM THE CRUDE OIL COMING OUT OF THE CONDUCTOR PIPE. WELL APPX 755’ DEEP. PACKER AT 504’. PADDED & BOOMED SPILLAGE. STAGED IN DRUMS. BOTTOM OF WELL SEALED. 01/01/04: MF S/I/JIM DAY, SCOTT/BRIAN JANDREW/OP-TECH (2-MEN). WATER COMING OUT OF CONDUCTOR PIPE. PROBLEM WITH 1.5’ PIPE PLUGGING, UNABLE TO DRIVE RODS INTO IT TO REMOVE BUILDUP IN ORDER TO PLUG. DECIDED TO FORE GO THIS. GLEN BLASTED PIPE ABOVE PACKER & PLUGGING CONTINUED & COMPLETED. TOLD OP-TECH TO TAKE DISPOSAL SAMPLE, PICK UP & DRUM ALL SPENT PADS & BOOM. 01/06/04: MF RECEIVED 12/27/04 STAMPED IN BID FROM ED ADAMS TO PLUG WELL, $6096. 01/20/04: MF RECEIVED INVOICE FROM JIM DAY, 2 SPILLS PUT ON SAME INVOICE. T/C JIM, HE WILL INVOICE SEPARTELY. 01/29/04: MF PROCESSED UPSTATES $138.12 PP FOR DISPOSAL SAMPLING. INVOICE #40443, 1/5/04. SOIL HAZ VIA TCLP FOR BENZENE, 1600

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 268

PPB. OP-TECH WILL RESAMPLE. 01/29/04: MF RECEIVED $2800, INVOICE FROM JIM DAY FOR WELL PLUGGING COSTS. SENT TO OP-TECH FOR PAYMENT WITHIN 45 DAYS. 03/15/04: MF T/C LINDA SCOTT, SAMPLE OF DRUMS (PADS & BOOMS) CAME BACK HAZ, TCLP BENZENE. LINDA TO RESAMPLE. 03/16/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $7497.08 PP, INVOICE #31245. FOR SITE WORK, CONTROLLING LEAK AT WELL HEAD DURING PLUGGING. DRUMING PADS & BOOMS. PROVIDE TRAFFIC CONTROL. PAYING JIM DAY $2800. + 10% MARKUP. 12/24/03 - 1/01/04, 3 DAYS ON THE JOB. 04/13/04: MF S/I 17 DRUMS ON SITE, BOOMS IN PLACE. 04/14/04: MF PROCESSED LSL’S $89.46 PP FOR DISPOSAL SAMPLING ANALYSIS. 1ST SAMPLING CAME BACK HAZ FOR TCLP BENZENE. OP-TECH RESAMPLED. INVOICE # 0404136-2344. THIS ANALYSIS NON-HAZ. SAMPLE RECEIVED 3/23/04. 04/21/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $199.42 PP FOR RESAMPLING DRUMS. INVOICE #31639, 3/22/04. 05/25/04: MF S/I/OP-TECH, REMOVING & DISPOSING OF 2 TRUCK LOADS OF CONTAMINATED SOIL AT THE ALLEGANY LANDFILL. DOWN APPX 6’, SMALL AMOUNT OF FP ON THE GW, PADDED UP. BACKFILLING WITH STONE. DEKE WANTED TO KNOW IF TOP SOIL NECESSARY. TOLD HE TO CONTACT THE DOT. LAFORGE IS THE HAULER. 07/13/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $5214.04 INVOICE #32558, 5/25/04 - 6/4/04. PICK UP PADS & DRUMS (19) DELIVER DRUMS TO WAVERLY, EXCAVATE 2 LOADS OF SOIL, ($2099.07) DISPOSE OF SOIL ($649.28) TRANSPORT DRUMS TO CYCLE CHEM ($206.49) ROAD SAFETY & KS LAFORGE ($2139.96) 09/29/04: MF T/C LINDA GRIMMER, SEE WILL LOOK INTO BILL FOR DRUM DISPOSAL. 10/18/04: MF PROCESSED OP-TECH’S $5225.00 PP FOR DRUM DISPOSAL. 19 DRUMS AT $250/DRUM. DISPOSED OF AS HAZ WASTE. DISPOSAL RECEIPT INCLUDED. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. FINAL ISR PENDING.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 269

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NFG BLOWOFF COUNTY ROUTE 22

Spill Number: 9711642

Close Date: 01/20/1998

INDEPENDENCE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14806 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen CHARLIE BUTTON MXFRANKS

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

NONE TOM HALL CITIZEN JACK GILBERT

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 478-8632 Contact Person Phone: (716) 593-1665

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP Including No RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action by Spill Response Not Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/01/1998 01/20/1998 OTHER YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 5000 gal tank blows off natural gas -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 01/20/98: MF T/C JIM SEWELL, NORTH PENN GAS CO 800-652-0552-3232. THEY HAVE NO LINES IN NY. SUGGESTED I CALL NAT FUEL. T/C NAT FUEL JACK GILBERT 607-478-8784 & 716-593-1665, TO RETURN CALL. 01/20/98: MF T/C/JACK GILBERT, THEY HAVE A 20K GALLON AG BRINE TANK AT THIS SITE ON CR 22. THIS TANK TAKES BRINE BLOW OFF FROM NAT GAS LINE. AS FAR AS HE KNOWS THIS EQUIPMENT IS FUNCITIONING CORRECTLY. HE WILL SEND A CREW TO MAKE SURE. 1305 T/C JACK GILBERT, CREW REPORTED EQUIPMENT FUNCTIONING CORRECTLY. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 270

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DORVIT FARM ROUTE 305

Spill Number: 9704441

Close Date: 08/11/1997

CLARKSVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons RUSS DORVIT MXFRANKS

Spiller: BILL BUTT/BILL HOGAN - HOGAN OIL CO Notifier Name: Caller Agency: PROPERTY OWNER Contact for more spill info: RUSS DORVIT

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 968-4010 Contact Person Phone: (716) 968-4010

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/01/1997 08/11/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: leaking crude oil wells & uncapped wells on property-no sludge ponds (location: 2nd place on the left going south-after 55 mph zone out of clarksville.) -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/11/97: MF T/C RUSS DORVIT, COMPLAINED OF LEAKING UNPLUGGED OIL WELLS ON HIS PROPERTY. ALSO NO SLUDGE PONDS. T/C MINERALS & FAXED REPORT TO THEM. 08/11/97: MF MINERALS HANDLING, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 271

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LINDA GRISWOLD WELL 55O5 LEONARD RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 9706187

Close Date: 10/09/1997

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Health Department CAMERON OCONNOR MXFRANKS

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDOH Contact for more spill info: LINDA GRISWOLD

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 847-4502 Contact Person Phone: (716) 925-8640

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/1997 10/09/1997 HOUSEKEEPING YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WELL DRILLERS HAVE SLOPPY OPERATION CAUSING OVERFLOWING OF THEIR BERM TOHER WELL CAUSING DRINKING WATER CONTAMINATION AND ODORS IN HER HOUSE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/20/97: MF S/V/ERIC WOOLERS, CACHD; CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS/LINDA GRISWOLD, HOMEOWNER. LINDA COMPLAINED OF BRINE & CRUDE OIL GETTING INTO HER WELL VIA RUNOFF FROM A BERM AROUND CRUDE OIL SEPARATORS. PIPING FOR TANKS LEAKING & SEPARATOR OVERFLOWING. HER WILL IS 60’ DEEP. COUNTY HEALTH DEPT WILL SAMPLE. CHRIS WILL FOLLOW UP WITH OWNER OF LEASE. I WILL WAIT FOR SAMPLE RESULTS. 10/01/97: MF T/C CAMERON O’CONNOR, NOT IN, LEFT MESSAGE FOR SAMPLE RESULTS. 10/09/97: MF RECEIVED WATER WELL SAMPLE RESULTS, ALL PETROLEUM PARAMETERS BELOW DL. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 272

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PEFLEY-FIRE BUSTI FOREST AVENUE

Spill Number: 9713948

Close Date: 05/22/1998

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen VICTORIA SPAGNOLI MXFRANKS

Spiller: ERIC N PEFLEY - PEFLEY OIL & GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: JAMESTOWN POST JOURNAL Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 941-1269 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 487-1111 ext. 2 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/17/1998 05/22/1998 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 180.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: JAMESTOWN QUAD SECTION G & ELLERY CENTER 6FT - VALVE FROZE ON A STOCK TANK CAUSING OVERFILL - TANK WAS NOT DIKED, THEREFORE SPILL WENT DOWN HILL INTO WATER SUPPLY POND - RP PROCEDED TO IGNITE OIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF-CHCHD" 03/19/98: MF T/C ERIC PEFLEY, LEFT MESSAGE ON MACHINE. LETTER SENT. 03/19/98: MF S/V/DENNIS VIRBERT, EMPLOYEE FOR PEFLEY, HE TOLD ME HE STARTED FIRE TO KEEP FROM SPREADING. BOTTOM VALVE ON STORAGE TANK FOR JACK FROZE & CRACKED, LOST APPX 200 GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL ONTO GROUND & INTO FRAC POND. DENNIS CLAIMED HE LIT THE CRUDE OIL ON FITE WITH A BURNING STICK TO KEEP THE OIL FROM SPREADING. CHCHD & MINERALS PREVIOUSLY RESPONDED. 4 MEN ON SITE USING PADS TO CLEAN POND. OIL IS BEING RUNG FROM PADS. VAC TRUCK ON SITE VACCING POOLS FROM THE GROUND. SOIL REMOVAL HAS BEGUN, 1 ROLLOFF ON SITE. TOLD DENNIS THEY WILL NEED MORE. 03/20/98: MF T/C/DANA ROSELLI, CABLE & NEWS 665-4888. SHE WANTED TO KNOW IF WE ARE GOING TO FINE RP. TOLD HER MINERALS, AIR &

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 273

SPILLS HAVE TO GET TOGETHER TO DISCUSS HOW TO APPROCH FINE. 04/07/98: MF S/V/DENNIS VIRBERT, DENNIS CLAIMED 1 ROLL OFF REMOVED FROM SITE FOR DISPOSAL. THERE IS ANOTHER ONE ON SITE. ADDITIONAL SOIL MUST BE REMOVED FROM BANK OF POND, AROUND AFFECTED TANK & AREA NEAR GAS LINE. DENNIS CLAIMED THIS WILL BE DONE BY NEXT WEEK. 04/27/98: MF MEETING @ FALCONER OFFICE WITH DAN RICKTOR, TOM KOSS, BOB O’CONNOR, BOB LUCUS, FRANK PRICE, AL ALEXANDER, CHRIS MILLER. DISCUSSED FINE. ALSO MADE A SITE VIST, NO ONE ON SITE. LINED LUGGER ON SITE, LEAKING. SLIGHT AMOUNT OF OIL IN THE POND. MINERALS TO TAKE LEAD IN THE CLEAN UP. INSPECTION TO BE SCHEDULED WITH RP & MINERALS. MEETING WILL BE HELD AFTER INSPECTION. 05/06/98: MAV AND RNL INSPECTION, DROVE AREA, NOT SURE OF EXACT SPILL AREA BUT NO CONTAMINATION NOTED (SEE SITE SKETCH), RP SAID DEC HAD BEEN ON SITE EARLIER THIS WEEK. 05/22/98: MF T/C RP, NEED SOIL DISPOSAL RECEPT. HE WILL FAX RECEIPT. RECEIVED SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPT. MINERALS FOLLOWING UP. NO FURTHER ACTION INVOLVING SPILLS NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 274

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

3438 BAILEY ROAD 3438 BAILEY RD

Spill Number: 9613440

Close Date: 02/11/2005

EAST BLOOMFIELD, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14443 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ROBERT HERRGESELL JRMARCHI

Spiller: CHARLES ARRIGO - NATIONAL FUEL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 624-3464 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 533-1707 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/14/1997 02/11/2005 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: on the property of mr herrgesell, a natural gas leak from a transmission line exists - gas is bubbling up through a creek that pipe crossed under - jm to meet with mr herrgesell on 02-12-97 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JM" 2004/02/19 - Spill_Time was previously blank and replaced with RCVD_Time to fix a data translation problem... Bob Corcoran 2/11/05: DD FILE AND DATABASE REVIEW. THIS INCIDENT WAS PREVIOUSLY FORWARDED TO MINERAL RESOURCES. NO ACTIONS REQUIRED BY SPILLS - THIS FILE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 275

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

TEXAS BRINE CORP 799 DALE ROAD

Spill Number: 9604964

Close Date: 07/24/1996

MIDDLEBURY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JOESEPH DESTINO SORGI

Spiller: Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

JOSEPH DESTINO - OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL LARRY THOMAS OCCIDENTAL CHEM LARRY THOMAS

Spiller Phone: (716) 278-7477 Notifier Phone: (716) 786-5203 Caller Phone: (716) 278-7477 Contact Person Phone: (716) 786-5203

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/16/1996 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SODIUM CHLORIDE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: valve in brine pipeline broke causing material to flow onto land down roadway and into creek - clean up crew on scene vaccuuming up material remaining -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MJS" 07/17/96: 0115 HRS - MJS NOTIFIED AT HOME BY MARK HANS. BRINE RAN DOWN ROAD AND SOME INTO LITTLE TONAWANDA CREEK. USING VAC TRUCK TO CLEAN PUDDLES. MJS TELECON TO LARRY THOMAS(TEXAS BRINE) AND SET MEETING FOR 1000 HRS. 1030 HRS - MJS SITE INSPECT. MET WITH MR THOMAS. BRINE IS PUMPED DIRECTLY TO OCCIDENTAL VIA A 52-MILE PIPELINE. OCCIDENTAL OWNS PROPERTY AND TEXAS BRINE OWNS FACILITY. PIPELINE VALVE CRACKED INSIDE CONCRETE VALVEBOX AND LEAKED BRINE. BRINE TRAVELED DOWN GRAVEL ROADWAY TO EDGE OF WHEAT FIELD AND INTO LITTLE TONAWANDA CREEK. MJS INSPECTED AND OBTAINED WATER SAMPLE FROM CREEK AT PLANT AND DOWNSTREAM AT W. MIDDLEBURY ROAD. NO FISH KILL. TESTED SAMPLES AT PLANT WITH PH METER. NORMAL READINGS (7.3). 07/24/96: MJS SPOKE WITH KURT WARMBRODT(DHSR). HE REQUIRES NO FURTHER INFORMATION. NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED BY SPILL UNIT. MJS

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

CLOSE FILE.

Page 276

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 277

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

EASTERN STATES WELL 1521 PONTIAC ROAD

Spill Number: 9603393

Close Date: 06/13/1996

ANGOLA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14006 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen STEVE FITZPATRICK FXGALLEG

Spiller: MIKE FORGIONI - EASTERN STATES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: ( ) 642-4914 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: ( ) 549-2571 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/09/1996 06/13/1996 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: natural gas leak on property from eastern states well. killing grass and gas odor in air -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 6/11/96 CONTACTED CHRIS CEJ WITH NATIONAL FUEL. HE WILL SEND AN INSPECTOR OUT TO INSPECT. 6/13/96 CHRIS CEJ CALLED & SAID THAT THE WELL WAS LEAKING & NATIONAL FUEL SHUT IT OFF. THEY DO NOT OWN THE WELL OR BUY GAS FROM THAT COMPANY. THEY DID THIS AS A FAVOR TO DIVERT THE POTENTIAL DISASTER. 6/13/96 CONTACTED JOHN HOFFMANN W/MINERALS- DEC OLEAN. HE WILL CONTACT PROPERTY OWNER & EASTERN STATES. HE WILL HANDLE SPILL. SITE HAS BEEN REFERRED TO MINERALS. NO FURTHER ACTION IS NECESSARY BY SPILLS. SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 278

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SALT BRINE AT BUTTON FARM BUTTON VALLEY ROAD

Spill Number: 9604789

Close Date: 08/07/1996

PANAMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14767 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JIM MOTTESHAEARD MXFRANKS

Spiller: JIM MOTTESHAEARD - COLUMBIA NATURAL RESOURCESpiller Phone: (304) 353-5124 Notifier Name: STAN VANGORDER Notifier Phone: (814) 275-2292 Caller Agency: COLUMBIA NATURAL RESOURCE Caller Phone: (304) 353-5142 Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - No DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/12/1996 08/07/1996 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 50.00 GALLONS 45.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: spill of less than 50 gals of brine water - spill vaccumed up while employee was doing work in system - he had fitting of and the autmatic system turned on spraying the brine water -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF-CHCHD" 07/12/96: MF REPORT RECEIVED SAC NOTIFIED CHCHD. 08/07/96: MF T/C JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERIALS, HE IS NOT AWARE OF SPILL, FAXED HIM SPILL. SPILL OF BRINE NON PETROLEUM. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 279

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DEMARCO DUMPING ON BARNES BARNES ROAD

Spill Number: 9602875

Close Date: 05/01/1997

RIPLEY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14775 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC MIKE FRANKS MXFRANKS

Spiller: DAN DEMARCO - DEMARCO TRUCKING Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYS DEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 736-3122 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7220 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/1996 05/01/1997 DELIBERATE YES YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: deliberate dumping of brine / crude oil on tractor trailer lot spill faxed from region 9 on 5/30/96 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 05/29/96: MF MAV SITE VISIT, SITE IS A TTOR TRAILER LOT NEXT TO GRAPE FIELD. BOTH OWNED BY DEMARCO. BRINE ALONG WITH CRUDE OIL NOTICED ALL OVER BACK OF LOT. BECAUSE OF PREVIOUS PROBLEM WITH DEMARCO, MF TOOK SAMPLE. TRIED TO SEE DAN DEMARCO, NOT IN. MAV ISSUED TICKET. 06/01/96: MF MEMO TO LEGAL REGARDING ABOVE. 06/01/96: MF TELECON DAN DEMARCO, CLAIMED HE HAS PERMIT TO SPREAD BRINE. TOLD HIM CRUDE OIL, HE CLAIMED IT IS FERTILIZER. TOLD

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

HIM I SAMPLED, IF RESULTS PETROLEUM, CLEANUP NECESSARY & HE WILL GET FINED & BE RESPONSIBLE FOR COSTS. MF SENT LETTER. 06/24/96: MF RECEIVED SAMPLE RESULTS, UNIDENTIFILE HYDOCARBON, POSSIBLY OLD CRUDE OIL. HITS ON 8021 & 8270BN. MF SENT LETTER TO DEMARCO TO CLEAN PROERTY, SCHEDULE BY 7/5/96. 07/10/96: MF SENT NO RESPONSE LETTER TO RP, RESPONSE BY 7/31/96 OR LEGAL ACTION. 08/08/96: MF MAV SITE VISIT, DEMARCO NOT IN, LEFT MESSAGE TO CALL ME. DID NOT NOTICE ANY OIL IN LOT. 08/19/96: MF FG MAV SITE VISIT, NO SIGN OF CRUDE OIL ON LOT. A LOT OF RAIN SINCE SPILL HAPPENED. MEETING WITH DEMARCO, HE CLAIMED NOTHING TO CLEAN, WE CONCURED. WILL WAIT FOR INVOICE FROM WASTESTREAM. 04/03/97: MF RECEIVED & PROCESSED $405. INVOICE FROM WATESTREAM, 8021, 8270BN & 310-13 SAMPLING. 05/01/97: MF ALL INVOICES IN & SENT TO ALBANY. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ISR PENDING. $3000. FINE RECOMMENDED.

Page 280

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 281

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL GAS WELL ROUTES 5 & 20

Spill Number: 9607718

Close Date: 09/25/1996

HANOVER (INDIAN), NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: ROUTES 5 / 20 Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: CHRIS CEJ - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: LEL GUNDS

Spiller Phone: (716) 857-7358 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone: (716) 532-0155

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/01/1996 09/25/1996 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: cap knocked off natural gas pipeline. Black subsatnce bubbling up from the ground spill faxed from region 9 on 9/19/96 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF-CHCHD" 09/19/96: MF SITE VISIT, UNABLE TO FIND LEAKING GAS WELL. T/C CALLER, HE GAVE ME BETTER DIRECTIONS. 09/20/96: MF MAUREEN BRADY, SITE VISIT, FOUND WELL, BLACK OOZE AROUND WELL. WELL IS CUT OFF APPX 2’ ABOVE GROUND, IT APPEARS WELL HAS BEEN HIT BY A TRUCK MANY TIMES. WELL MAY BE ON INDIAN LAND. T/C MINERIALS BRIAN JANDREW, HE CLAIMED WELL IS ON INDIAN LAND & BELONGS TO NATIONAL FUEL. 09/23/96: MF T/C CHRIS CEJ, NAT FUEL. HE CLAIMS WELL IS ON INDIAN LAND.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

09/24/96: MF T/C LISA MAYBEE, GAVE HER LOCATION OF WELL. SHE WILL LOOK INTO. 09/25/96: MF T/C LEF GUNDS, CIR. HE LOOKED AT WELL, ON INDIAN LAND. THEY WILL FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 282

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 283

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CABOT OIL WELL ROUTE 474 NEAR WICKWIRE

Spill Number: 9607729

Close Date: 04/18/1997

CLYMER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14724 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party RICK WALTEMIRE MXFRANKS

Spiller: RICK WALTEMIRE - CABOT OIL AND GAS CORP. Spiller Phone: (412) 299-7043 Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: CABOT OIL AND GAS CORP. Caller Phone: (412) 299-7043 Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/18/1996 04/18/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 190.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: RIGHT A WELL CAUSING A SPEW OF CRUDE OIL, APPROX 5 BARRELS LOST. CABOT IS IN PROCESS OF CLEAN UP. WANT TO USE BIO TECHNIQUE TO CLEAN SPILL. SITE IS 100 YRDS PAST WICKWIRE ON LFT SIDE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 09/19/96: MF FOR FG REECIVED SPILL REPORT FROM CABOT OIL. REPORT FAXED TO CHCHD & MINERALS. 09/25/96: MF T/C JACK DAHL, CLAIMED JOHN HOFFMAN MAY BE HANDLING. MINERALS TO GET BACK TO ME. 09/30/96: MF T/C JOHN HOFFMAN, 300’x 150’ AFFECTED. HOSE BROKE SPRAYED CRUDE OIL, HIGH WINDS. USED BACTERIA TO CLEAN. JOHN TO SEND REPORT. 09/30/96: MF T/C RICK WALTEMIRE, CABOT OIL, 412-299-7043, NOT IN, LEFT MESSAGE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 284

10/04/96: MF MAV SITE VISIT/RICK WALTEMIRE, L. LONG #5 GASWELL BLEW FITTING SPRAYED CRUDE OIL IN HOMEOWNERS YARD. THEY WASHED OIL DOWN WITH A SURFACTANT & APPLIED NEUTRANTS. OIL IN LARGE AREA IN YARD. EXPLAINED TO RP TREATMENT NOT ACCEPTABLE. THEY WILL REMOVE SOIL & DISPOSE OF. LETTER SENT. 10/16/96: MF SITE VISIT/LAURA BIRCH, 7556 RTE 474, PAMAMA NY 14767 716-355-6341. SHE IS OWNES CONTAMINATED YARD. SOME REMEDIATION DONE, MORE NESESSARY. ALSO MET/STAN TENPAS, HE OWNES FARN ACROSS THE RD. HIS CAR HOUSE & YARD WAS SPRAYED WITH CRUDE OIL. CABOT PAID TO HAVE CAR CLEANED, THEY ALSO WASHED HOUSE & YARD. NO DISTRESSED VEGETATION NOTICED. STAN IS SATISIFIED. 10/18/96: MF T/C RICK WALTEMIRE, EXPLAINED MORE REMEDIATION NECESSARY. 10/30/96: MF S/V/LAURA BIRCH, LANDOWNER, ADDITIONAL SOIL REMOVED, SHE IS HAPPY BUT IS WORRIED ABOUT HER LILAC BUSHES BY RTE 474, SHE WILL WAIT FOR SPRING. 11/01/96: T/C RICK WALTMIRE, MAV WAS ON SITE FOR SOIL REMOVAL. SOIL SAMPLE TAKEN. 01/09/97: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 1/31/97. 01/23/97: MF T/C RICK, LEFT MESSAGE. 02/21/97: MF 2ND DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 3/14/97. 02/27/97: MF LETTER FROM RP, SOIL SHOULD BE DISPOSED OF BEFORE 03/14/97. 03/17/97: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL APPLICATION, SHOULD TAKE ANOTHER 3 WEEKS. 04/18/97: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPTS, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 285

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PEFLEY OIL & GAS WELL FOREST AVENUE

Spill Number: 9605868

Close Date: 08/12/1996

JAMESTOWN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN MXFRANKS

Spiller: PEFLEY OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYS DEC Contact for more spill info: ERIC PEFLEY

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone: (716) 483-2793

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/05/1996 08/12/1996 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 25.00 GALLONS 15.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE ADDING BRINE, APPROXIMATELY 1/2 BARREL OF CRUDE SPILLED TO GROUND. MINERAL RESOURCES IS FOLLOWING UP. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/07/96: MF T/C JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERIALS. THEY ARE FOLLOWING UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 286

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LIMESTONE COMPRESSOR NFG 64 NORTH PARKSIDE DRIVE

Spill Number: 9613109

Close Date: 05/05/1997

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party DAVE BARTHOLD MXFRANKS

Spiller: DAVE BARTHOLD - NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 646-9330 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 646-9330 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/04/1997 05/05/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected GAS LINE CONDENSATE OTHER 150.00 GALLONS 140.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: GAS PIELINE FLUID (WATER,ANTI-FREEZE & PETROLEUM)SPILLED TO GROUND AFTER DIGGING OUT LINE-HAROLD BURDICK (STATION FOREMAN) ON SITE EXCAVATED CONTAMINATED SOIL-THIS INFO PER FAX REG 9 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 02/05/97: MF S/V/HAROLD BIRDICK, DANNY ROGER, NAT FUEL. BRINE SLUG WENT THRU DRYER COTAINING TRI ETHYLENE GLYCOL, WHICH WAS FORCED OUT VENT PIPE, LOST APPX 150 GALLONS. IN THE PROCESSED OF BEING CLEANED. SOIL STAGED ON SITE. EXPLAINED WHAT MUST BE DONE. 02/06/97: MF T/C DAVE BARTHOLD, NAT FUEL, EXPLAINED WHAT MUST BE DONE, LETTER SENT. 02/07/97: MF S/V/DAN ROGER, AREA CLEANED, SOIL STAGED ON SITE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

04/28/97: MF 1ST SOIL DISPOSAL LETTER, DUE 5/15/97. 05/05/97: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPTS, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 287

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 288

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DALE FOX OIL WELL BIXBY HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 9611748

Close Date: 12/30/1996

FREEDOM, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14065 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC CHRIS MILLER MXFRANKS

Spiller: DALE FOX - DALE FOX Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 368-5901 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/24/1996 12/30/1996 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 20.00 GALLONS 20.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BALES OF HAY HIT AND OPENED VALVE ON OIL RIG - LOST LES THAN 1 BARREL. CLEANUP UNDER WAY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 12/24/96: MF AM INFORMED OF SPILL BY CHRIS MILLER, MINERALS TO INVESTIGATE THIS AM. 12/24/96: MF PM T/C CHRIS MILLER, OIL RIG LOST APPX 20 GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL, SPRAYED ONTO FARMERS FIELD, EQUIPMENT MALFUNCTION. RP IS CLEANING. MINERALS WILL MONITOR. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 289

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LW RESOURCES YERICO WELL SWAMP ROAD

Spill Number: 9612580

Close Date: 01/27/1997

DUNKIRK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14048 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons TONY YERICO MXFRANKS

Spiller: NONE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info: TONY YERICO

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 674-1985 Contact Person Phone: (716) 674-1985

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/01/1997 01/27/1997 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NATURAL GAS WELL LEAKING AT WELL HEAD -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF-CHCHD" 01/20/97: MF MAV SV/TONY YERICO, LANDOWNER. TONY CLAIMED GAS WELL ON PROPERTY LEAKING NATURAL GAS & WELL OWNER DUMPING BRINE BY WELL. THERE IS A WELL HEAD GAS LEAK, NO SIGNS OF BRINE DUMPING, HOWEVER AREA SNOW COVERED. 01/23/97: MF FAXED SPILL TO MINERALS & DISCUSSED WITH CHRIS MILLER, THEY HAVE A LOT OF PROBLEMS WITH PRODUCER. THEY WILL HANDLE, NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 290

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL - JIM LEE SALT RISING ROAD AT 417

Spill Number: 9503962

Close Date: 06/30/1995

LITTLE GENESEE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: SALT RISING ROAD / 417 Revised zip code: 14754 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JACK DAHL RMCROSSE

Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL - JIM LEE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: DEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-5636 Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/30/1995 06/30/1995 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: FIRE AT LEASE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RMC" 06/30/95: RMC/ FILE PJB ADVISED THAT MINERALS ADVISED NO SPILL SPILL PROBLEM EXISTS AT SITE, CLOSE OUT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 291

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BELDON & BLAKE WILTSIE ROAD

Spill Number: 9505635

Close Date: 09/01/1995

SHERMAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14781 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN MXFRANKS

Spiller: BELDON & BLAKE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC MINERALS Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 326-4981 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/07/1995 09/01/1995 HUMAN ERROR YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 180.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: VALVE LEFT OPEN ON CRUDE OIL WELL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/07/95: KAH/JOHN HOFFMAN/TELECON - MINERAL RESOURCES WILL RESPOND AND CONTACT SPILLS IF ASSISTANCE IS NEEDED. 09/01/95: MF 8/10/95 RECEIVED REPORT FROM MINERIALS. THEY ARE HANDLING. OUR FILE CAN BE CLOSED. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 292

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SPILL AT OIL WELL TERRY ROAD & ROUTE 60

Spill Number: 9514338

Close Date: 02/15/1996

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: TERRY ROAD / ROUTE 60 Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JOHN HOFFMAN BRENNAN

Spiller: HARRY BARAGER - OGLS OPERATING INC Notifier Name: Caller Agency: DEC MINERALS Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 753-3088 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/09/1996 EQUIPMENT FAILURE YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 200.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ojl and gas operations 200 gal crude spill with in secondary containment, spill has been cleaned up. unstrom #2 well, minerals with follow up. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "KAH" 2/9/96 - KAH RECEIVED REPORT OF SPILLAGE OF 200 GALS. OF CRUDE OIL. ADVISED BY JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERAL RESOURCE DIVISION, THAT THEY WILL FOLLOW-UP. NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILLS AT THIS TIME. 2/16/96 - KAH RECEIVED MEMO FROM MINERAL RESOURCES. THEY INSPECTED SITE AND ADVISED THAT THEY WILL CONTINUE FOLLOW-UP. ADVISED SPILLS TO CLOSE THEIR FILE. ATTACHED MEMO TO SPILL FILE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 293

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CLYMER-OIL WELL BROWNELL ROAD

Spill Number: 9503827

Close Date: 09/19/1995

CLYMER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14724 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS MXFRANKS

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 763-4152 Contact Person Phone:

Category: Investigation indicates there was no spill. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/28/1995 09/19/1995 UNKNOWN YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DRILL OPERATION, CRUDE OIL & BRINE GOING INTO CREEK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/03/95: MF 6/28/95 WRONG PHONE # FOR CALLER. NOTIFIED CHCHD, MINERIALS & TRANSFUEL. TELECON MAV HE CANT FIND SITE. BAD INFO IN REPORT. 09/19/95: MF 9/19/95 NOBODY FOUND ANYTHING, NO ONE SENT REPORTS. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 294

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

C&G OIL HICKS HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 9502606

Close Date: 06/05/1995

WIRT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14739 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen BETSY DAGGETT FXGALLEG

Spiller: C&G OIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 973-3939 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/31/1995 06/05/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SOIL WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: FOUND WELL LEAKING NEAR ROAD AT ANOTHER SPILL SITE 9214429 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 06/02/95: SITE VISIT. ANOTHER WELL ON C&G SITE IS LEAKING. NOTIFIED MINERALS OF LEAKING WELL & THEY WILL RESPOND. ANY FURTHER WORK WILL BE UNDER SPILL#9214429. SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 295

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BRIAN COOPER OIL WELL SALT RISING ROAD

Spill Number: 9411131

Close Date: 06/21/1995

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons BRAD HOFMAN FXGALLEG

Spiller: BRIAN COOPER Notifier Name: Caller Agency: US COAST GUARD Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 928-2744 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 846-4168 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/19/1994 06/21/1995 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: RP TOOK EFFLUENT PIPE OUT FROM PIPE DAM & DRAINED DIKED AREA SPILLING OIL ON GROUND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "FG" 09/19/94: 9/19/94 MNP RESPONSE. PIPE REMOVED FROM EARTHEN SEPARATOR WHICH DRAINED OIL & WATER. CONTAMINATED SOIL INSIDE DIKED AREA & DOWN GRADIENT OUTSIDE. I USED BOOM & PADS TO CONTAIN. 09/20/94: 9/20/94 MNP INSP. OIL SPILLAGE OUTSIDE OF PIPEE DAM. PIPE REMOVED, PLASTIC LINER GONE, SEE VIDEO & SKETCH. 11/19/94: 11/19/94 MNP RESPONSE. PIPE REMOVED FROM EARTHEN SEPARATOR WHICH DRAINED OIL & WATER. CONTAMINATED SOIL INSIDE DIKED AREA & DOWN GRADIENT OUTSIDE. I USED BOOM & PADS TO CONTAIN. 11/20/94: 11/20/94 MNP INSP. OIL SPILLAGE OUTSIDE OF PIPE DAM. PIPE REMOVED, PLASTIC LINER GONE, SEE VIDEO & SKETCH.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 296

02/03/95: 2/3/95 MNP INSP. PILE CONTAM. SOIL ON NORTH SIDE OF DIKE AREA. GROUND COVERED W/ SNOW & ICE IN DIKED AREA. NEED TO CHECK AGAIN WHEN SNOW MELTS. 03/03/95: RNL INSPECTION 3/2/95. DIKE IN PLACE. VERY SLIGHT SHEEN DOWNSTREAM OF DIKE. WELL IS ACTIVE. SEPARATOR POND ICE COVERED. 04/04/95: J. HOFFMAN CALLED. DIKE WAS CUT. TIRES IN POND. OIL LEAKED OUT. PILES OF SOIL SPREAD OVER WOODEN BRIDGE AREA. 06/15/95: RNL SITE VISIT. FOUND GRASS & REEDS GROWING IN AREA. NO SPILL NOTED. POND WAS STILL BROKEN & PETRO ODOR PRESENT. NO ACTIVITY AT SITE SINCE LAST VISIT. 06/21/95: BRIAN COOPER, LEASE OWNER SAID PROPERTY OWNER SPREAD CONTAM SOIL ALL OVER HIS PROPERTY. POND KEEPS GETTING BROKEN EVERY TIME HE FIXES IT. SITE CAN BE CLOSED. NO FURTHER ACTION NEC. REFERRED TO MINERAL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 297

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL IN ALLENTOWN ROUTE 417

Spill Number: 9410235

Close Date: 03/16/1995

ALLENTOWN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14707 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Other TOM BARNETTE MXFRANKS

Spiller: TERRY COLLINS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: ALLEGANY CO. HAZ-MAT COOR Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 928-2531 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 596-2644 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/17/1994 03/16/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL LEKING FROM OIL WELL, ABOUT 10’ BY 200 YDS, THEN GOES INTO CREEK. OLEAN MINR WAS NOTIFIED WHEN SPILL HAPPENED. AFFECTED PROPERTY OWNER CONCERNED RESPONSIBLE PARTY NOT CLEANING UP SPILL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 10/31/94: 10/31/94 MNP TELECON W/ JOHN HOFFMAN - MINR. THEY WILL CHECK SPILL AGAIN & LET ME KNOW STATUS. 11/16/94: 11/16/94 MNP TELECON W/ TOM MCFALL. HE SAID SPILL JUST COVERED W/ STRAW & SORBENTS. MNP TELECON W/ JOHN HOFFMAN - MINR. HE SAID SPILL WAS CLEANED UP, BUT WILL CALL TOM MCFALL. 02/03/95: 2/3/95 MNP INSP. OIL WELL IN FRONT YARD, GROUND COVERED W/ SNOW. 03/06/95: MF 3/6/95 TELECON JOHN HOFFMAN-MINR. THEY WERE INVOLVED & SITE HAS BEEN CLEANED. THEY WILL SEND MEMO.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 298

03/06/95: 3/6/95 MNP TELECON W/ BRIAN JANDREU - MINR. SAID SOMEONE FROM DEC BUFFALO OFFICE CALLED MCFALL EARLIER TODAY. MCFALL SAID OILY STRAW & SORBENTS REMAIN ON SITE. JIM RAZINSKI HANDLING SITE. 03/06/95: 3/6/95 MNP TELECON W/ TOM MCFALL. HE SAID OILY STRAW & SORBENTS REMAIN ON HIS FRONT LAWN. I TOLD HIM I CHECKED SPILL 2/3/95 WHEN GROUND WAS SNOW COVERED, DEC WILL CHECK AGAIN. 03/16/95: MF 3/14/95 SITE VISIT/MCFALL. SMALL AMOUNT OF OIL & SHEEN IN DITCH FROM WELL. FREE PRODUCT IN BERM AROUND SEPARATOR TANK. WELLS HAVE NOT BEEN IN OPERATION. 03/26/95: MF 3/16/95 TELECON JIM RUCINSKI, MINERALS. GAVE HIM 3/14/95 SITE INFO. THEY WILL FOLLOW UP. MEMO SENT. NO FURTHER ACTION NCESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 299

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL-OLEAN OREGON ROAD

Spill Number: 9404870

Close Date: 07/25/1994

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen LARRY LEWICKI MXFRANKS

Spiller: JOHN J. RYAN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: LAND OWNER Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 373-0668 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/09/1994 07/25/1994 HOUSEKEEPING UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL SHEEN ON WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/20/94: MF 7/11/94 SITE VISIT, UNABLE TO FIND LOCATION. TELECON CALLER, RECEIVED DIRECTIONS. CLAIMS MINERIALS INVOLVED & NOTHING DONE. 07/20/94: MF 7/12/94 SITE VISIT, TANK BATTER/2 PONDS & WELLS. PONDS LINED/PLASTIC WITH HAY. SOME SEEPAGE OF OIL NOTICED. LOT OF IRON RUNOFF. NO OIL NOTICED IN THE ROAD. 07/25/94: MF 7/20/94 TELECON JACK DAHL MINERIALS. THEY ARE & WILL BE INVOLVED IN THIS. MEMO TO MINERALS REFERRING SPILL TO THEM. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 300

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL GAS WELL 1/4 MILE OFF OREBED ROAD

Spill Number: 9414431

Close Date: 02/03/1995

WILLING, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party DAVE BARTHOLD PRINGLE

Spiller: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 649-3121 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 649-3121 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/30/1995 02/03/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SALT WATER PLUG CAUSED STEAM TO BLOW OUT GYCOL FROM DEHYDRATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 02/03/95: 2/3/95 MNP INSP. & MEETING W/ DAVE BARTHOLD & RON TOMB - NFG. NO VISIBLE CONTAM. UNDER DEHYDRATER. SPILL CAUSED BY FROZEN VALVE ON SEPARATOR. NEW SEPARATOR BEING INSTALLED. NO CLEANUP NEEDED, COMPLETE. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: TRI-ETHYLENE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 301

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

COOPER LEASE 111 MAIN STREET

Spill Number: 9407380

Close Date: 11/19/1994

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party JOHN BAILEY PRINGLE

Spiller: BRIAN COOPER Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 928-2744 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 928-1536 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/31/1994 11/19/1994 VANDALISM UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 40.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CRUDE OIL OVERFLOWED SEPERATOR POND INTO SWAMPY AREA. HISTORICAL COMPLAINTS REGARDING THIS LEASE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 09/01/94: MF 8/31/94 SITE VISIT/BAILEY. CRUDE OIL IN SWAMPY AREA FROM SEPATATOR (GAS WELL, KOWLES LEASE). TELECON RP TOLD HIM AREA MUST BE CLEANED & SOIL DISPOSED OF. 9/1/94 NOTIFIED C. MILLER, MINERIALS. 09/02/94: MF 9/1/94 TELECON JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERIALS. THEY WILL HANDLE SPILL. HE WILL SENT REPORT. 09/07/94: MF 9/1/94 TELECON JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERIALS. THEY WILL HANDLE SPILL. HE WILL SENT REPORT. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. 11/09/94: 11/9/94 MNP INSP. & MEETING W/ JACK DAHL & JOHN HOFFMAN - MINR. OIL SPILLAGE IN DIKED AREA, SOME SHEEN NOTED OUTSIDE OF DIKE, WETLAND OK. MINR CLEANUP DEADLINE 11/30/94. MINR WILL SEND REPORT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

11/19/94: 11/19/94 MNP RESPONSE OIL SPILLAGE OUTSIDE OF DIKE AREA, PIPE REMOVED. PLASTIC LINER GONE, SEE VIDEO & SKETCH. NEW SPILL #9411131, CLOSE THIS SPILL.

Page 302

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 303

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

COLUMBIA GAS PANGBURN ROAD

Spill Number: 9415830

Close Date: 05/12/1999

WIRT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14739 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ROBERT LEARY MXFRANKS

Spiller: WALTER SHOWEN - COLUMBIA GAS TRANSMISSION Spiller Phone: (304) 357-3774 Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Caller Phone: (716) 851-7220 Contact for more spill info: TRIP SHOWEN Contact Person Phone: (304) 357-3774

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/01/1995 05/12/1999 HOUSEKEEPING YES NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SITE ASSESSMENT, VOLUNTARY CLEANUP OF SITE & TRANSMISSION LINE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 03/08/95: MF 3/6/95 TELECON RP, EXPLAINED SPILLS WILL BE LEAD UNIT FOR CLEANUP. LETTER TO BE SENT. 03/13/95: MF LETTER TO RP OKING REMEDIATION PLAN WITH SAMPLING ADDITIONS. RESPONSE & SCHEDULE BY 3/31/95. 05/12/95: MF TELECON RP. PROBLEM WITH OWNER REGARDING CONTRACTOR. WORK SHOULD START 6/1/95 HE WILL NOTIFY ME. 07/06/95: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, COLUMBIA GAS. WORK DELAYED ABOUT THREE WEEKS, CONTRACTOR PROBLEMS. HE WILL NOTIFY ME. 09/20/95: MF UPDATE LETTER TO RP, RESPONSE BY 10/6/95.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 304

11/08/95: MF SENT NO RESPONSE LETTER. 2ND LETTER DUE 11/30/95. 01/12/96: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, ON PHONE TO RETURN CALL. 01/16/96: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, WORK TO START IN THE SPRING. HE WILL SEND LETTER AND KEEP ME INFORMED. 01/26/96: MF LETTER FROM RP, REMEDIATION TO START 5/96. 05/30/96: MF UPDATE LETTER TO RP, RESPONSE BY 6/15/96. 07/01/96: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, WORK TO START IN 2-3 WEEKS. HE WILL CALL. 09/12/96: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, LEFT MESSAGE ON MACHINE. 09/20/96: MF MESSAGE FROM TRIPS SHOWEN, WORK TO START 10/14/96. 01/21/97: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, STILL PROBLEM WITH LANDOWNER. HE IS HOLDING UP PROJECT. NOT AN ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUE, OPERATIONAL ISSUE. HE HAS TO APPROVE CONTRACTOR, BUT WON’T DO IT UNTIL OTHER ISSUES RESOLVED. 02/14/97: MF LETTER FROM RP, NEW OWNER OF PROPERTY, VANDERMARK EXPLORATION, REFUSED TO ALLOW COLUMBIA GAS TO START REMEDIATION UNTIL OPERATIONAL ISSUES ARE RESOLVED. 08/29/97: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, NOT IN, LEFT MESSAGE FOR STATUS UPDATE. 01/21/98: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, LEFT MESSAGE. 01/21/98: MF TELECON MINERALS, THEY SAID DEAN PHILLIPS IS CONTACT FOR VANDERMARK EXPLORATION 716-593-2298. MF TELECON DEAN PHILLIPS, TO RETURN CALL. MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, THEY WILL START REMEDIATION WHEN WEATHER IMPROVES. WORK PLAN TO BE SUBMITTED BY 2/28/98. 04/15/98: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, LEFT MESSAGE ON VOICE MAIL, WORK OR LEGAL ACTION. 04/23/98: MF RECEIVED REVISED RESAMPLING PLAN. THEY WILL SAMPLE AREAS FOR BTEX & PAH’S INSTEAD OF USING TPH. THEY WANT TO REMOVE Hg & PCB CONTAMINATED SOIL AT THE SAME TIME THEY REMOVE PETROLEUM CONTAMINATED SOIL. THEY WANT TO START WITHIN THE NEXT FEW WEEKS. 04/29/98: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, LEFT MESSAGE OKING SAMPLING PLAN & TO CALL ME WHEN THEY PLAN TO BE ON SITE. 05/21/98: MF SITE INSPECTION, MET RANDY ALDER, COLUMBIA GAS/DEAN PHILLIPS, OWNER/S.E. TECHNOLOGIES. THEY ARE RESAMPLING CONTAMINATED AREAS [IT WAS ORIGINALLY SAMPLED FOR TPH] FOR 8021 & 8270 BN’S. EXPLAINED IF HITS, ODOR OR STAINING, SOIL WILL HAVE TO BE DISPOSED OF. THEY WILL SEND REPORT. 08/11/98: MF RECEIVED REPORT, SOIL REMOVAL RECOMMENDED IN VARIOUS LOCATIONS. THEY ARE USING NYS ACTION LEVELS FOR PETROLEUM CONTAMINATED SOIL. 08/24/98: MF LETTER TO RP, OKING PLAN BUT MUST USE GUIDANCE VALUES (ALSO ODORLESS & STAINLESS SOIL). SCHEDULE BY 9/15/98.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 305

10/14/98: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, LEFT MESSAGE ON MACHINE. 10/30/98: MF TELECON TRIP SHOWEN, ON SITE CLEAN UP COMPLETED. I WAS AT SPILL MEETING IN OLD FORGE. THEY FOUND FP OFF SITE BY ABANDONED PIPE DRIP. THEY WILL CLEAN THIS UP WITH BIGGER EQUIPMENT. WORK WILL BE DONE NEXT WEEK. 11/05/98: MF SITE INSPECTION, MET CONTRACTOR/SI TECHNOLIGIES. AREAS BEING CLEANED INCLUDING GAS INJECTION WELL, METERING BUILDING & STEAM & AIR BUILDING. SOME SOIL ALREADY DISPOSED OF. Hg SOIL TO GO TO SECURE LANDFILL. 11/12/98: MF SITE INSPECTION, NO ONE ON SITE. ALL EXCAVATED SOIL REMOVED. 03/16/99: MF TELECON JOE FERRY 304-357-3772, REPORT WILL BE SENT IN NEXT WEEK. 03/31/99: MF RECEIVED REPORT, ALL AREAS THAT INVOLVED PETROLEUM CLEANUP WERE CLEANED & SAMPLES. 1. COMPRESSOR BUILDING DRAIN VALVES - BELOW STARS. 2. STORAGE WELL H-57 - BELOW STARS 3. TRANSMISSION PIPELINE 868+00 - BELOW STARS. SPILL #9875183 4. TRANSMISSION PIPELINE 806+10 - ABOVE STARS. SPILL #9875185 SPILLS 9875183 & 9875185 ARE HANDLED UNDER THIS SPILL. DRAIN VALVES NOT SAMPLED FOR 8021. THEY DID 8021 ANALYSIS WITH ONLY BTEX REPORTED. I REQUESTED 8021 IN MY 8/24/98 LETTER. THEY ALSO USED STATE OF NEW YORK CLEANUP STANDARDS INSTEAD OF STARS AS ALSO REQUESTED IN MY 8/24/98 LETTER. HOWEVER THERE IS ONLY BTEX IN DRIP FLUID. THE FOLLOWING AREAS WERE ALSO CLEANED BUT NOT FOR PETROLEUM. 1. FORMER METER BUILDING - TOTAL Hg 2. OIL BATH CLEANER INTAKE - PCB’S 3. LEAD BASED PAINT - TCLP Pb 4. OFFICE BUILDING CONCRETE RAMP - CAN’T FIND RESULTS. 05/12/99: MF THIS SPILL TO BE CLOSED, SPILL 9875185 REOPENED TO ADDRESS AREA 806+10. NO FURTHER ACTION NESESSARY FOR THIS SPILL. PETROLEUM ISSUES ADDRESSED. HOUSEKEEPING MOVE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 306

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL ON ROUTE 417 ROUTE 417

Spill Number: 9401497

Close Date: 02/22/1995

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC JACK DAHL PRINGLE

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 372-0645 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/01/1994 02/22/1995 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WORK ALONG ROUTE 417 FOUND AN OLD OLI WELL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 02/22/95: FG SITE VISIT 2/16/95. NO OIL VISIBLE ON GROUND SURFACE. MEMO SENT BACK TO MINERALS THAT NO SPILL PRESENT. SITE CAN BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 307

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BELSCHER-GAS WELL 13031 BELSCHER ROAD

Spill Number: 9402958

Close Date: 06/02/1994

CONCORD, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 13031 BELCHER ROAD Revised zip code: 14141 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC MARK MAZURKIEWIEZ MXFRANKS

Spiller: EMPIRE EXPLORATION Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7000 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/1994 06/02/1994 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: COMPLAINT OF OIL SPILLAGE AROUND GAS WELL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 06/02/94: MF 6/1/94 SITE VISIT, MINOR SPILLAGE AROUND WELL HEAD. TELECON MINERIALS, THEY WILL FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 308

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL-GOWANDA 27 PERRY STREET

Spill Number: 9300488

Close Date: 05/27/1994

GOWANDA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14070 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Local Agency JACK THRASHER MXFRANKS

Spiller: JACK THRASHER Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 532-5186 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 532-5186 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/03/1993 05/27/1994 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 49.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ABANDONED GAS WELL LEAKING OIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/11/93: MF 4/7/93 SITE VISIT/HOMEOWNER. OIL COMING OUT OF THE GROUND, SUSSPECT UST. GAVE RP LIST OF CONTRACTORS. HE WILL FOLLOW UP. 04/11/93: MF 4/10/93 SITE VISIT/RP. HE CANNOT AFFORD TO HIRE CONTRACTOR. OIL STILL COMING OUT OF THE GROUND. HE AGREED TO ALLOW STATE TO HIRE DJ. CONTRACTOR FOUND ABANDON OIL WELL, VACCED TO 45’. 04/11/93: MF 4/11/93 SITE VISIT, OIL TO TOP OF WELL. CALLED CONTRACTOR TO VAC. 04/13/93: MF 4/12/93 SITE VISIT/HOMEOWNER/MINERIALS. WELL NOT LISTED ON MINERIALS MAP. GAS COMING OUT OF WELL. WILL BRING RISER UP TO GROUND LEVEL. SPILLS MAY PLUG WELL. DJ ON SITE PUMPED WELL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

04/14/93: MF 4/13/93 SITE VISIT/MINERIALS, MISSED CONTRACTOR, HE INSTALLED STAND PIPE & BACKFILLED AREA. 4/14/93 SITE VISIT IN AM, LIQUID LEVEL APPX 5’ FROM SURFACE OF PIPE. GAS ODOR. 04/16/93: MF 4/15/93 SITE VISIT/OWNER/MINERIALS. NO CHANGE IN STATUS SINCE YESTERDAY. 04/17/93: MF 4/16/17/93 SITE VISITS, LIQUID LEVEL IN PIPE RISING SLOWLY. APPX 2.5’ FROM TOP OF PIPE. 04/22/93: MF 4/21/93 SITE VISIT/NO ONE ON SITE. NO CHANGE IN STATUS. DID NOT CHECK WELL. 04/28/93: MF 4/23-28/93 SITE VISIT, LIQUID LEVEL TO GROUND LEVEL. MINERIALS ON SITE 4/23/93. 06/04/93: MF 6/2/93 SITE VISIT/RP. LIQUID LEVEL IN WELL 6" ABOVE SURFACE. PLUGGING PROJECT ON HOLD, TROUBLE IN ALBANY WITH CONTRACTOR. 06/22/93: MF 6/10/93 SITE VISIT, LIQUID 6" FROM TOC. 6/15/93 SITE VISIT, LIQUID 1" FROM TOC. 08/30/93: MF 8/24/93 RECIVED CC BID LETTERS TO CONTRACTORS FROM DJ PRESTON. 8/30/93 TELECON MINERIALS, ALBANY WANTS BIDS THRU STATE CONTRACTOR. DONT KNOW HOW HE WILL BE PAID AS YET. 10/19/93: MF 10/18/93 SITE VISIT, NO ACTIVITY. MEETING/MINERIALS, FAXED THEM RIGH OF ENTRY. CONTRACT AWARDED. WOKK TO BEGIN SHORTLY. 10/27/93: MF 10/22/93 & 10/25/93 SITE VISIT, CONTRACTOR ON SITE SETTING UP TO PLUG WELL. 11/03/93: MF 10/28/93 11/2/93 SITE VISITS, STILL CLEANING WELL, ENCOUNTERING WOOD. DOWN TO 1508’. 11/12/93: MF 11/3/4/93 SITE VISITS/GFS. AT 1530’. RUNNING INTO WOOD, RUBBER & ROPE. 11/30/93: MF 11/15/93 SITE VISIT/CONTRACTOR, WELL AT 1580’, AT BOTTOM. PLUG BEING INSTALLED. 12/09/93: MF 12/7/93 SITE VISIT, REPLUGGING COMPLETE. BREAKING DOWN EQUIPMENT. 12/21/93: MF FG RNL SITE VISIT 12/17/93. WELL HAS BEEN CLOSED. SITE NEEDS TO BE RESTORED. 05/27/94: MF 5/27/94 ALL INVOICES IN & SENT TO ALBANY. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. MINERIALS HAPPY WITH JOB. ISR PENDING.

Page 309

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 310

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL & GAS 1040-1 715 ROUTE 248 MM 104.0-.1

Spill Number: 9300766

Close Date: 05/27/2008

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: 715 HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen PEGGY LAMPHIER pclinden

Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL & GAS JIM LEE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 664-2795 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (607) 225-4948 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/11/1993 05/06/1996 UNKNOWN YES YES -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SURFACE WATER WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER’S DOG WENT SWIMMING IN THE MARSH POND ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF ROUTE 248 HEADING SOUTH. THE DOG CAME HOME COVERED IN OIL. CALLER SAYS ODOR OF CRUDE OIL HAS BEEN STRONG LATELY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" WELL #: AUSTIN LEASE #17 04/13/93: THERE HAS BEEN PROBLEMS WITH LEAKING WELLS IN THIS AREA IN THE PAST. P LINDENFELSER TO INVESTIGATE. 04/14/93: PL FOUND A MODERATE AMOUNT OF OIL COLLECTED AT WEST END OF POND WHERE IT DRAINS TO SOUTH SIDE OF RT 248 (MM 1040). ON SOUTH SIDE FO ROAD A POOL OF WATER IN FRONT OF AN ABANDONED SEPARATOR TANK WAS COVERED WITH GREEN CRUDE OIL. 04/15/93: PL HAD EVNIRON PROD & SVCS (EPS) ENCIRCLE LEAKING WELL IN POND W/BOOM; REMOVE OIL SOAKED FLOTSAM AT WEST END OF POND;

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 311

AND REMOVE OIL FROM TANK POOL ON SOUTH SIDE OF ROAD. 05/07/93: PL HAD ENVIRON PROD & SVCS DUMP DRUMS INTO ROLL OFF BOX & DIRECTED THEM TO IMPROVE & CLEANUP THE SEPARATOR POND & TIGHTEN CONTAINMENT AROUND THE AQUATIC WELL. 05/12/93: PL FOUND THE ROLL OFF BOX COVERED, THE BOOM TIGHTENED AROUND AQUATIC WELL & THE SEPARATOR POND COVERED WITH PADS. 05/26/93: PL FOUND SORBENT IN SEPARATOR POND IS STILL CLEAN; WELL SEEPAGE HAS APPARENTLY ENDED. 06/17/93: LINDENFELSER FOUND WASTE DISPOSED OF, NO OIL NORTH OF ROAD AND MINIMAL OIL SOUTH. 10/12/93: PL FOUND NO OIL IN POND NEAR SUBMERGED WELL OR AT WELL 104.0. 12/13/93: LINDENFELSER ON SITE. SEE ATTACHED SITE REPORT. 12/13/93: P MILLER & PL FOUND NO OIL IN POND ON NORTHSIDE BUT SOME OIL WAS IN DITCH ON SOUTH SIDE POSSIBLY FROM A NEW SOURCE. 04/22/94: PL FOUND A LOT OF GREEN CRUDE OIL ON THE CREEK SIDE OF ROAD IN THE SEPARATOR POND & ROADSIDE DITCH. PL HIRED ALLWASH TO COME OUT WITH A VACUUM TRUCK. 04/25/94: PL FOUND MOST OF THE OIL REMOVED; 5 CLOSED TOP DRUMS OF OIL & WATER AND 2 OPEN TOPS OF SORBENTS. SATURATED PADS & BOOM WERE PICKED UP BY ALLWASH ON THEIR RETURN & FLOATING OIL VACUUMED UP. 05/06/94: PL FOUND NO INCREASE IN WELL SEEPAGE. 05/09/94: SPILL NUMBER 9400721 IS BEING COMBINED WITH THIS SPILL #9300766 AS IT WAS THE ORIGINAL REPORT ORIGINATING AT THIS SITE. ALL UPDATES FOR BOTH SPILLS WILL BE ON THIS NUMBER. 05/27/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND LITTLE ADDITIONAL OIL SEEPAGE AND CONTAINMENT ADEQUATE. 06/09/94: PL & RODABAUGH FOUND LITTLE EXTRA OIL COLLECTED IN THE SEPARATOR POND. 06/23/94: PL FOUND LITTLE EXTRA OIL ACCRUED. 07/14/94: PL FOUND NO MORE OIL REOCCURRING ALTHOUGH RESIDUAL CLEANUP IS NEEDED. 08/08/94: PL FOUND NO ADDITIONAL OIL & CLEANUP OF RESIDUE COMPLETED BY ALLWASH. 08/17/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND NO MORE SEEPAGE OF OIL AND THAT THE DITCH AND SEPARATOR POND WERE CLEAN. 09/15/94: LINDENFELSER FOUND NO ADDITIONAL OIL OCCURRING FROM THE WELL. 04/12/95: LINDENFELSER FOUND A SMALL AMOUNT OF EMULSIFIED OIL AT THE OUTLET OF POND BUT NONE AT WELL ON THE STREAM SIDE OF ROAD. 04/26/95: LINDENFELSER FOUND A 5’ X 8’ PATCH OF EMULSIFIED OIL & ALGAE AND DISCUSSED CLEANUP WITH ALLWASH OF SYRACUSE. 05/25/95: LINDENFELSER MONITORED TRANSFER OF DRUMMED WASTE TO NEW DUMPSTER. WATER ON BOTH SIDES OF ROUTE 248 IS OIL FREE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 312

10/03/95 LINDENFELSER & ALLWASH PLANNED FOR UPGRADE OF SEPARATOR POND. NO FREE FLOATING OIL WAS FOUND. 03/22/96 LINDENFELSER FOUND OIL ONLY ON POND SIDE OF ROAD AROUND A FLOODED WELL CASING. 05/06/96 LINDENFELSER BOATED OUT WITH EP&S TO THE FLOODED WELL FINDING FRESH AND OLD CRUDE OIL. EP&S IS RE-SETTING CONTAINMENT AND ABSORBING OIL. 07/10/97 LINDENFELSER FOUND NO SIGN OF OIL SEEPAGE FROM EITHER THE POND WELL OR THE WELL ACROSS THE ROAD. 06/16/98 LINDENFELSER WITH NATURES WAY SAY THE EMULSIFIED OIL IN THE CONTAINMENT POND ON THE STREAM SIDE OF ROAD. NATURES CLEANED UP AND WILL MONITOR. NO OIL CURRENTLY SEEPING FROM ARTESIAN WELL. 05/07/99 LINDENFELSER FOUND LITTLE OR NO OIL ON THE POND SIDE OF ROUTE 248 BUT SOME STAINED PADS AROUND THE ARTESIAN WELL IN THE CREEKSIDE. 07/03/03: ALLEGRO SITES REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES FOR FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS. 06/22/2005: FINAL ISR SENT TO ALBANY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 313

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

VIRGINIA THOMPSON 160 EVANS AVENUE

Spill Number: 9300971

Close Date: 04/08/1993

RICHBURG - WIRT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

PRIVATE DWELLING Affected Persons BRIAN COLE PRINGLE

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: ACCORD DEVELOPMENT Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 268-7605 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/01/1993 04/08/1993 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ABANDONED CRUDE OIL WELL AND CONTAMINATED SOIL DISCOVERED IN BACKYARD AT PRIVATE RESIDENCE. TO BE REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES IN OLEAN FOR FOLLOWUP. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 04/08/93: MNP/RNL/SITE - OLD ABANDONED OIL WELL. BLACK OIL IN CASING. NO SURFACE SPILLAGE. CONTRACTOR DUG TEST HOLES & DISCOVERED OIL WHILE PREPARING TO BID ON NEW LEACH FIELD. REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 314

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CRUDE OIL WELL FANCY TRAC FANCY TRACK

Spill Number: 9301934

Close Date: 05/17/1993

ELLICOTTVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14731 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Notifier Type: Local Agency Caller Name: DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 373-1250 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/01/1993 05/17/1993 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LEAKING ABANDONED CRUDE OIL WELL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 05/05/93: MF/SITE - COMPLAINT FROM TOWN OF ELLICOTTVILLE HWY. DEPT. IN FIELD APPROX. 100’ OFF FANCY TRACK ROAD. WELL LEAKING CRUDE OIL. INFORMED JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS. THEY WILL INVESTIGATE. 05/17/93: MF 5/17/93 MEMO TO MINERIALS REFERRING SPILL TO THEM. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 315

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PRODUCT IN RELIEF WELL ROUTE 417

Spill Number: 9308412

Close Date: 05/27/1994

PORTVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14770 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Notifier Type: DEC Caller Name: DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/01/1993 05/27/1994 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS GROUNDWATER UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PRODUCT FOUND IN RELIEF WELL #50. WELL FIELD LINES UNDER SITE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 10/08/93: MF/DICK MOORE, OPERATIONS, OLEAN/SITE - MINERALS GAUGED WELL W/INTERFACE & FOUND 10’ OF PRODUCT ON TOP OF 22’ OF WATER. TOOK SAMPLE FROM WELL BAILER; PICKED UP 8" OF PRESSURE & SOME WATER. 12/06/93: FG MF SITE VISIT 12/2/93. PUMPED RELIEF WELL #7 JUST BELOW SURFACE OF OIL. WATER ONLY WAS REMOVED. REMOVED THE SURFACE OIL USING A PAD. NEED TO CHECK WELL AGAIN TO SEE IF ADDL PRODUCT ACCUMULATION. 05/27/94: MF 4/20/94 SITE VISIT, CHECKED WELL, NO OIL ON PAD LEFT IN WELL. NO OIL IN WELL. OLD CRUDE OIL PIPES IN AREA. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. ISR PENDING. NO SPILLER.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 316

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

AVOCA GAS STORAGE MACKEY ROAD

Spill Number: 9307484

Close Date: 09/21/1993

AVOCA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: MACKEY RD Revised zip code: 14809 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party TOM MORAN DLTILTON

Spiller: AVOCA GAS STORAGE Notifier Name: Caller Agency: GALSON INC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (617) 720-7646 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (315) 432-0507 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/20/1993 09/21/1993 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT WATER BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WHILE GALSON INC WAS INVESTIGATING AVOCA GAS STORAGE, A SPILL OF SALTWATER BRINE WAS NOTICED. CONTACT: NEIL COLLINS -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "DT" 09/20/93: ALBANY TOLD HORNELL THAT THE RESPONSIBLE PARTY WANTS A CALL BACK 09-21-93 A.M. TILTON TRIED TO CONTACT EDT & GALSON INC, BUT PHONE # FOR GALSON IS WRONG. DEPT TO INSPECT. 09/21/93: D TILTON SPOKE W/DON PLEAKIS OF NYSDEC MINERALS. MINERALS TO REQUIRE WELL HOLDING SALT WATER BRINE TO BE PUMPED OUT BY 09-23-93. NYSDEC MINERALS WILL FOLLOW UP. NO FURTHER ACTION NEEDED BY SPILLS.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 317

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL GAS WELL FOLSOMDALE ROAD

Spill Number: 9200055

Close Date: 03/31/1992

BENNINGTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14011 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party TANYA ALEXANDER PRINGLE

Spiller: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 857-7410 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 857-7410 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Any Type of RP, Including No RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Not Required or Not Possible -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/31/1992 03/31/1992 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL SPILL FROM NATURAL GAS WELL ENTERED CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 03/31/92: 3/31/92 MNP TELECON WITH JACK DAHL, MINR, THEY WILL HANDLE FOLLOWUP. NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILL UNIT, COMPLETE. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: ONONDAGA CRUDE OIL

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 318

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ERNEST LEHMANN OIL WELL TRASK ROAD

Spill Number: 9214314

Close Date: 03/31/1993

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Local Agency EUGENE ARCHER MXFRANKS

Spiller: ERNEST LEHMANN Notifier Name: Caller Agency: TOWN OF BUSTI Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 489-7458 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 664-4901 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/23/1993 03/31/1993 TANK OVERFILL UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 350.00 GALLONS 50.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE TANK OVERFLOWED IN PA. CRUDE OIL GOT INTO STILLWATER CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 03/25/93: MF/M. VENDETTE/SITE - LEHMANN FARM & OIL FIELD BRINE TANK OVERFLOWEDBECAUSE OF RUNOFF GETTING INTO IT. EST. 8 BARRELS OF CRUDE OIL LOST.MR. LEHMANN WILL HIRE CONTRACTOR TO CLEAN UP. 03/30/93: MF RNL SITE VISIT, NO SHEENING NOTICED IN CREEK, BOOMS IN PLACE. MET/RP HE IS CLEANING SPILL SITE. BOOMS TO REMAIN IN CREEK UNTIL 4/2/93. 03/31/93: MF 3/31/93 TELECON RP, TOLD HIM BOOMS CAN BE REMOVED ASAP AS 1" OF RAIN IS EXPECTED TONITE. NO FURTHER ACTION IS NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 319

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

C & G OIL COMPANY HERRICK RD (HICKS HILL)

Spill Number: 9214429

Close Date: 07/31/1995

WIRT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14739 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC ALAN MILLS PRINGLE

Spiller: C & G OIL COMPANY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 593-4174 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7000 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Unable or Unwilling RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/26/1993 07/31/1995 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 2000 GALLONS 1000 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL SEPARATOR TANK FAILED, HOLDING TANK OVERFLOWED SPILLING OIL INTO LAGOON & CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 03/27/93: 3/27/93 MNP RESPONSE, MET ECO MILLS & BOB CUMMINGS. USED BOOMS TO CONTAIN OIL. RESP. PARTY UNABLE TO DO CLEANUP, DEC HIRED D.J. PRESTON TO BEGIN CLEANUP. ADDITIONAL BOOMS USED BY STATE CONTRACTOR. 03/28/93: 3/28/93 MNP INSP. D.J. PRESTON ON SITE, THEY BUILT PIPE DAM & PADDED UP OIL. 03/29/93: 3/29/93 MNP INSP. D.J. PRESTON ON SITE, THEY USED SKIMMER TO RECOVER OIL AT CONTAINMENT BOOMS & PIPE DAM. OIL PUMPED INTO EMPTY HOLDING TANK. OIL SOAKED PADS WRUNG OUT & OIL PUMPED INTO TANK. 04/01/93: 4/1/93 MNP INSP. OIL AT PIPE DAM & CONTAINMENT BOOMS DOWNSTREAM. MORE CLEANUP NEEDED. MET CUMMINGS ON SITE TOLD HIM LETTER BEING SENT TO C & G OIL W/ OPTION TO TAKEOVER CLEANUP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 320

04/08/93: 4/8/93 MNP & RNL INSP. OIL AT PIPE DAM & CONTAINMENT BOOMS DOWNSTREAM. MORE CLEANUP NEEDED. 07/08/93: 7/8/93 MNP INSP. SPOKE W/FERD SMITH. 3 COWS DIED 3 WEEKS AGO, HE BELIEVES FROM DRINKING OILY WATER FROM OVERFLOWING WELL. HE SOLD ALL OF HIS COWS. OIL LEAKING FROM SEPARATOR. COLLECTED SOIL SAMPLE. 07/08/93: 10/7/93 MNP INSP. & MEETING W/JIM VREELAND - EP&S., TO SUBMIT CLEANUP PROPOSAL. D.J. PRESTON ON SITE ON SITE W/ BULLDOZER FINISHING ACCESS ROAD, TOLD DOUG PRESTON WORK NOT AUTHORIZED, NO PAY. 11/10/93: 11-10-93 MNP & FG INSP. NO CHANGE. ROAD ACCESS GRADED DOWN TO TANK W/DITCHES ON BOTH SIDES. DUG DOWN 18", STILL CONTAMINATED. 12/22/93: 12/6/93 CERT. LETTER TO NORBERT SHEAR - C & G OIL. REQUESTED SATISFACTORY RESPONSE BY 12/22/93 OR DEC WILL CONTINUE CLEANUP. 02/03/94: 2/3/94 MNP INSP. HIGH SNOW DRIFTS IN FERD SMITH’S FIELD, DID NOT GO TO SPILL SITE. CHECKED UPPER VAN CAMPEN CREEK AT COUNTY ROUTE 1 BRIDGE, NO SHEEN IN WATER. 02/17/94: 2/17/94 MNP INSP. DID NOT GO TO SPILL SITE. CHECKED UPPER VAN CAMPEN CREEK AT COUNTY ROUTE 1 BRIDGE, NO SHEEN IN WATER. 03/29/94: 3/29/94 MNP INSP. CHECKED UPPER VAN CAMPEN CREEK AT COUNTY ROUTE 1 BRIDGE, NO SHEEN IN WATER. 04/05/94: 4/5/94 MNP SITE MEETING W/ JAMES VREELAND - EP&S & LARRY KNIGHT - D.J.PRESTON. SHOWED THEM SPILL AREA & DISCUSSED SCOPE OF WORK REQUIRED PER PREVIOUS LETTER SENT, FOR DETAILS SEE NOTES IN FILE. 06/28/94: 6/28/94 MNP INSP. NO OIL IN CREEK AT COUNTY ROUTE 1. NO WORK BEING DONE ON SITE YET. DISCUSSION W/ LARRY KNIGHT AT HIS OFFICE, TO START WORK IN DRY WEATHER. 08/11/94: 8/10/94 MNP INSP. & MEETING W/ MIKE BARNHART - WST. ACCESS ROAD COMPLETED, FIELD GRADED. CONTAM. SOIL TILLED, STRONG PETRO. ODOR. OILY SOIL REMAINS AROUND TANKS. OIL AT NEW PIPE DAM. SAMPLES COLLECTED. 11/09/94: 11/9/94 MNP INSP. BIO-PILE STAINED W/ OIL, STILL STRONG PETRO ODOR. OIL SATURATED SOIL AROUND TANKS. & SHED. NO SHEEN AT 1ST PIPE DAM. OIL PRODUCT COLLECTING AT 2ND PIPE DAM BELOW OVERFLOWING OIL WELL. 01/05/95: 1/5/95 MNP TELECON W/ LARRY KNIGHT - D.J. PRESTON. DISCUSSED OPTION TO DISPOSE SOIL AT ALLEGANY COUNTY LANDFILL AS LONG AS PRICE DOES NOT EXCEED ORIGINAL QUOTE. TO SEND LETTER. 01/05/95: 1/5/95 MNP TELECON W/ SCOTT HOWARD - NEW PROPERTY OWNER. DISCUSSED SPILL STATUS & C & G OIL RESPONSIBILITY FOR SPILL. HE AGREED TO ALLOW DEC TO CONTINUE CLEANUP. HE’S CONCERNED ABOUT OVERFLOWING WELL. 01/06/95: 1/6/95 MNP REVIEWED D.J. PRESTON PAYMENT PACKAGE FOR $17,825.61 RECEIVED ON 1/5/95, PAYMENT APPROVED. CLEANUP UNDERWAY. 06/02/95: MNP SITE VISIT 6/2/95. ANOTHER OIL WELL ON SITE LEAKING. PRESTON ON SITE REMOVING SOIL. PRESTON GAVE $ ON COST TO REMOVE ADDL CONTAM & BUILD POND-$2500. PRODUCT LEFT IN HOLDING TANKS-LEAKING.MINRLNOTIF. 06/08/95: J.SHEAR, LEASE OWNER,WILL TRY TO GET RID OF CRUDE & CLEAN TANK. HE WAS UNAWARE THAT NYSDEC WAS STILL CLEANING SITE. HE WILL CALL ME WHEN HE VISITS SITE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 321

06/12/95: G. SHEAR WILL VISIT SITE 6/13/95. HE WILL LET ME KNOW WHEN HE CAN GET RID OF CRUDE IN TANKS & WHAT HE WILL DO TO REMEDIATE SITE. 06/12/95: DJ PRESTON & DEC MINERALS FOUND ANOTHER LEAKING WELL AT THE C&G OIL LEASE. STATED THAT IT IS A SLOW LEAK SIMILAR TO THE LAST WELL FOUND LEAKING. 06/15/95: RNL SITE VISIT. SOIL CONTAM AT BOTTOM OF HILL HAS BEEN REMOVED. LEAKING WELLS ARE CONTROLLED.NO FURTHER WORK NEEDS TO BE COMPLETED REFER SITE TO MINERALS. 07/20/95: J. SHEAR W/C&G SAID HE REMOVED PRODUCT FROM HOLDING TANK. ALL SITE WORK HAS BEEN COMPLETED. FINAL PAYMENT LTR SENT TO DJ PRESTON-RESPONSE DUE 8/20/95. 07/31/95: FINAL PAY PACKAGE FOR DJ PRESTON APPROVED. ALL SITE WORK COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 322

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

C & G OIL COMPANY COUNTY ROAD 1

Spill Number: 9203785

Close Date: 10/29/1993

FRIENDSHIP, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14739 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC ECO ALAN MILLS PRINGLE

Spiller: C & G OIL COMPANY Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 593-4174 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/26/1992 10/29/1993 HOUSEKEEPING UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 200.00 GALLONS 200.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL SPILLED FROM SEPARATOR TANK AT OIL LEASE, LACK OF MAINTENANCE. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 06/29/92: 6/29/92 MNP & ECO MILLS INSP. OIL IN CREEK DOWNSTREAM, OIL AT LEASE COMING OUT OF LAGOON. BOOMS & PADS USED TO CONTAIN SPILL. 11/05/92: 11/5/92 MNP & RNL MEETING W/ HOFFMAN OF MINR. REFERRED TO MINR FOR FOLLOWUP, COMPLETE. 01/22/93: MINERAL RESOURCES REFERRED MATTER BACK TO SPILLS; REOPEN FILE. 10/29/93: 10/29/93 MNP FILE REVIEW. SPILL REFERRED BACK TO SPILLS IN 1/93, ANOTHER SPILL OCCURRED AT SAME SITE IN 2/93. DUPLICATE OF SPILL # 9214429, SEE OTHER SPILL FOR FOLLOWUP, COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 323

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CABOT OIL & GAS ROUTE 474

Spill Number: 9209459

Close Date: 02/05/1993

CLYMER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14724 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Health Department STEVE JOHNSON MXFRANKS

Spiller: CABOT OIL & GAS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CHCHD Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (814) 594-7043 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 853-7753 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/10/1992 02/05/1993 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 25.00 GALLONS 20.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL WELL FIRE; FIRE OUT. SPILL WITHIN DIKE. OIL WILL BE RECYCLED; SOILTO BIOCELL IN PA. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 11/23/92: MF 11/10/92 SITE VISIT/MAV. NO ONE ON SITE, FIRE AT BATTERY. CRUDE OIL IN DIKED AREA. TELECON MINERIALS, THEY ARE UNAWARE OF PROBLEM. THEY WILL FOLLOW THRU. 11/23/92: MF 11/12/92 SITE VISIT/RP. CLEAN UP UNDERWAY. RP TO CALL MINERIALS. 11/19/92 MEMO TO MINERIALS REFERRING SPILL TO THEM. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY. 01/22/93: MINERAL RESOURCES REFERRED MATTER BACK TO SPILLS; REOPEN FILE. 01/28/93: MF 1/25/93 TELECON RP, HE WILL SEND SOIL DISPOSAL RECEIPTS. 1/26/93 SITE VISIT, NO ONE ON SITE. TANKS THAT WERE INVOLVED IN FIRE, OUT OF SERVICE. CONTAMONATED SOIL REMOVED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

02/03/93: MF 1ST DISPOSAL LETTER SENT GIVING UNTIL 3/15/93. 02/05/93: MF 2/5/93 RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Page 324

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 325

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

MCDEVITT BARNUM ROAD 602 BARNUM ROAD

Spill Number: 9213336

Close Date: 03/17/1993

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Other EARL DRESSEL MXFRANKS

Spiller: BOICE MCDIVITT Notifier Name: Caller Agency: SEMO Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (518) 457-2200 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/27/1993 03/17/1993 HUMAN ERROR UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: HAZMAT FIRE; STARTED TO BURN OFF APPROXIMATELY 6 INCHES OF BOTTOM SEDIMENT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 03/15/93: MF 3/3/93 TELECON OTTO TERTINEK, NOT AT OFFICE. TO RETURN CALL. 03/17/93: MF/OTTO TERTINEK, BECI/TELECON - MINERAL RESOURCES IS HANDLING. BECIHAS NO FURTHER INVOLVEMENT. CLOSE OUT SPILL FILE, ALSO. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 326

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

WESLEY HILL RESIDENCE 1454 CAIN ROAD

Spill Number: 9213439

Close Date: 03/15/1993

EVANS, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14006 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Affected Persons WESLEY HILL PRINGLE

Spiller: WEIL RESOURCES Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 549-5132 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Possible petroleum release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters, known releases with no potential for damage, or non-petroleum/non-hazardous spills. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/01/1993 03/15/1993 TANK FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE SOLUTION LEAKING FROM TANKS AND ENTERING COMPLAINANTS PROPERTY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 03/04/93: SAC/JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERAL RESOURCES/TELECON - HE WILL LOOK INTO THE MATTER. IF HE IS UNABLE TO, HE WILL LET US KNOW SO WE CAN HAVE SOMEONE LOOK AT IT. SAC FAXED HIM A COPY OF THE SPILL REPORT. 03/15/93: 3/15/93 MNP TELECON W/ AL ALEXANDER - MINR. HE INSP. SITE 3/10/93 & FOUND SNOW. HE WILL REINSP. & HANDLE FOLLOWUP. NOT AN OIL SPILL, NO SPILL UNIT INVOLVEMENT NEEDED, COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 327

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PENNZOIL HARRISBURG RUN

Spill Number: 9210180

Close Date: 12/14/1992

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen PHIL CAMPBELL MXFRANKS

Spiller: PENNZOIL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 925-8272 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known or probable release, where, without action, there is a potential for a fire/explosion hazard (indoors or outdoors), contamination of drinking water supplies, or significant release to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/30/1992 12/14/1992 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER WAS HUNTING AND FOUND LARGE POOLS OF CRUDE OIL FROM UNPLUGGED WELL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 12/01/92: MNP/TELECON W/CHRIS MILLER. HE CHECKED SITE AND FOUND 2 ABANDON TO 100 BARRELS. CHRIS MILLER WILL SEND LETTERS TO ATTORNEY AND PENNZOIL.

WELLS LEAKING OIL. TOTAL SPILLAGE ESTIMATED AT 20

12/14/92: MF 12/14/92 TELECON MINERALS, THEY WILL FOLLOW UP. DEC & PENNZOIL ATTORNEYS INVOLVED. MEMO SENT TO MINERIALS. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 328

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PENNZOIL-CHIPMONK CREEK 9 MILE ROAD

Spill Number: 9100927

Close Date: 06/21/1991

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: PENNZOIL Spiller Phone: (814) 368-1508 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ED KOHLER Caller Agency: PENNZOIL Caller Phone: (814) 368-1508 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/24/1991 06/21/1991 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 126.00 GALLONS 100.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: 2" PIPELINE CORRODED. LINE SHUT OFF AT 0715. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/29/91: MF FOR MJH 4/24/91 0835 MINERALS & CACHD NOTIFIED. THEY WILL RESPOND. 05/20/91: MF 5/20/91 MEMO SENT TO CACHD REQUESTING REPORT. 06/21/91: MF 6/21/91 RECEIVED REPORT FROM SPILLER, NO REPORT FROM CACHD, NO REPORT FROM MINERIALS. NO FURTHER ACTION POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 329

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CHAUT COUNTY-BRINE ROUTE 380

Spill Number: 9100714

Close Date: 04/21/1991

STOCKTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14784 Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Spiller: CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JEFF ALTIMUS Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 673-9669 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/17/1991 04/21/1991 DELIBERATE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE TANK DUMPED BY THE COUNTY -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 04/18/91: MF FOR RNL NOTIFIED CHCHD, THEY WILL RESPOND. 04/21/91: MF MAV VISIT/SPILLER. WORKER DRAINED DIKING AROUND BRINE TANK. COMMON PRACTICE. NO FUTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 330

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

TEXAS BRINE LINE MCVANE & ROUTE 33

Spill Number: 9111682

Close Date: 02/14/1992

CORFU, NY 14036

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: MCVANE / ROUTE 33 Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party MIKE HINTON DLTILTON

Spiller: OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 278-7794 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (716) 851-7220 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/12/1992 02/14/1992 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE FROM MIDDLEBURY TO NIAGARA FALLS BROKE MCVANE (IS NEAR ROUTE 77). LEAK RATE OF 15 GPM; LEAK OCCURRED FOR INDETERMINANT AMOUNT OF TIME. CONTACT MARVIN SPRING/JIM ZAPLA -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "DT" 02/14/92: D TILTON TELCON W/MARVIN SPRING. MARVIN SAID THAT THEY HAD LOCATED LEAK AT RICK CONFEDERATED FARM. TEXAS BRINE EXCAVATED PIPE 1,000’ FROM ROAD. CLAMPED PIPE AT MIDNIGHT 02-13-92. 02/14/92: MARVIN SPRING ESTIMATED 100’S GAL SPILLED. SPRING STATED THERE WAS NO STREAMS OR WELLS IN AREA. WILL BACKFILL PIPE AFTER PRESSURE CHECK. NO FURTHER ACTION TAKEN. 3/15/06 PAPER FILE REMOVED PER FILE RETENTION POLICY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 331

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS WELL-GERRY SALISBURY ROAD

Spill Number: 9102257

Close Date: 05/30/1991

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: ARROWHEAD GAS PRODUCERS Spiller Phone: (716) 372-9174 Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: KEN HANBY Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 985-4041 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/24/1991 05/30/1991 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LEAKING COMPRESSOR AT WELL RSWANSON-1, API 15885. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 05/28/91: MF 5/28/91 MAV TO CONTACT SPILLER. I NOTIFIED MINERIALS, THEY WILL INSPECT. 05/30/91: MF 5/30/91 TELECON MAV, HE CLAIMED SPILL HAS BEEN CLEANED BY SPILLER, SMALL AMOUNT OF SPILLAGE, ALL ON PAD. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 332

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

200 RAPIN PLACE 200 RAPIN PLACE

Spill Number: 9100263

Close Date: 05/20/1991

BUFFALO, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14211 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: RAYMOND HEISER Spiller Phone: (716) 695-3387 Notifier Type: Other Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: KIETH CHONKA Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL Caller Phone: (716) 857-7962 DEC Investigator: LYONS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/05/1991 05/09/1991 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: YELLOW SUBSTANCE COMMING UP UNDER BLACKTOP -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MEL" 04/05/91: MEL INSP. OBSERVED MATERIAL , YELLOW IN COLOR, WITH A SULPHER ODOR IN SHALLOW EXCAVATION. CANTACTED OWNER AND NOTIFIED OF RESPONSIBILITY. NFG TO EFFECT A FENCE TO SECURE AREA. 05/09/91: MEL TELCON WITH DON PLECAS, MINERALS OLEAN. HE INSPECTED SITE. HYDROGEN SULFIDE FOUND IN GAS. NATURAL GAS WELL NOT LIKELY, HE SUGGESTS VENTING. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY, RECOMMEND FILE BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 333

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL IN NICHOLS RUN NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 9111876

Close Date: 02/20/1992

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CHRIS MILLER Caller Agency: DEC-MINERALS Caller Phone: (716) 372-5636 DEC Investigator: SACALAND Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/18/1992 02/20/1992 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SUSPECTED LEAK IN PRODUCT LINE OR PRODUCTION WELL FIELD. NOT KNOWN WHERE BASE OIL IS COMING FROM. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "SAC" 02/20/92: DEC-MINERALS TO FOLLOW UP ON CLEAN-UP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 334

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL - DUKE LEASE CNTY RT.5 & CNTY RT.5C

Spill Number: 9109398

Close Date: 12/04/1991

GENESEE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: CNTY RT.5 / CNTY RT.5C Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL / LEE OIL Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JACK DAHL Caller Agency: NYSDEC - MINR Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: PRINGLE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/01/1991 12/04/1991 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE TANK OVERFLOWED. OIL IN IN PRIVATE POND & CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 12/04/91: 12/4/91 RNL DISCUSSION WITH DAN KING. MINOR SPILL FROM SEPARATOR TANK. MIN. RES. WILL FOLLOWUP. NO ACTION NEEDED BY SPILL UNIT, COMPLETE. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: CRUDE OIL & BRINE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 335

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

A D CALL & SONS ROCK RUN ROAD & ROUTE 36

Spill Number: 9109922

Close Date: 12/18/1991

CANISTEO, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: ROCK RUN RD / STATE HWY 36 Revised zip code: 14823 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: A D CALL & SONS Spiller Phone: (716) 343-2910 Notifier Type: Police Department Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CHARLES HUGHES Caller Agency: STEUBEN CO SHERIFF Caller Phone: (607) 776-7009 DEC Investigator: PCLINDEN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/18/1991 12/18/1991 TRAFFIC ACCIDENT UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT WATER BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ROADS SLIPPERY, TRUCK LOST TRACTION ON HILL & SLID OFF RD. DRIVER W/UNKNOWN INJURIES. SALTWATER LEAKING FROM TRUCK INTO STREAM. CONTACT PERSON: JERRY CALL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 12/18/91: JM SPOKE W/JERRY CALL OF A D CALL & SONS. HE ADVISED THAT VACUUM TRUCK BEING SENT TO SCENE TO OFFLOAD TRUCK. TRUCK WAS LEAKING SOME BRINE INTO CREEK. ABSORBENTS ALSO BEING BROUGHT TO SITE TO .... 12/18/91: ...CONTAIN ANY FUEL THAT MAY BE LEAKING FROM FUEL TANKS. 12/19/91: JM SPOKE W/JERRY CALL ON 12-18 & 12-19. BRINE TRANSFERRED OUT OF TANK TRUCK. DIESEL SOAKED UP W/PADS. TRUCKS REMOVED WITH NO ADDITIONAL CLEANUP NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 336

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GOODYEAR LEASE ROUTE 219

Spill Number: 9004277

Close Date: 07/30/1990

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: NON-MAJOR FACILITY (>1100 GAL) Spiller: PA. GENERAL ENERGY CORP. Spiller Phone: (814) 723-3230 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: DAVID LINDE Caller Agency: PA. GENERAL ENERGY CORP. Caller Phone: (814) 723-3230 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/18/1990 07/30/1990 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 170.00 GALLONS 170.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LEAK FROM THREE INCH LINE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 07/30/90: MF TELECON MINERALS (JOHN HOFFMAN), THEY WILL CONTINUE TO HANDLE THIS SPILL. NO FUTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 337

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS AT WROBLEWSKI HOUSE PARTRIDGE ROAD

Spill Number: 9001378

Close Date: 05/21/1990

COLDEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: PINE TREE ACRES Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: RON KALETA Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 537-9528 DEC Investigator: MJHINTON Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/05/1990 05/21/1990 DELIBERATE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NATURAL GAS WELL BEING VENTED TO THE AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MJH" 05/21/90: FOLLOWUP REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES CHRIS MILLER, NO ACTION BY SPILL UNIT NEEDED. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: NATURAL GAS & BRINE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 338

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FLOWING OIL WELL COUNTY ROAD 18

Spill Number: 9001131

Close Date: 11/11/1992

ALMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14708 Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL DEC ECO JIM WEBB PRINGLE

Spiller: WILLIAM BARCYZS Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 668-1965 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known release which created a fire/explosion hazards (inside or outdoors), drinking water supply contamination, or significant releases to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/16/1990 11/11/1992 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SURFACE WATER WASTE OIL/USED OIL PETROLEUM 500.00 GALLONS 300.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL FLOWING OUT OF ABANDONED WELL INTO INTO CREEK VIA DRAINAGE DITCH & WETLAND. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 04/30/90: RNL TELECONS 04/30/90, MINR, PAUL GIACHETTI, TO CHECK; MINR DECIDED TO ASSUME LEAD ON INCIDENT, NO SPILL UNIT INVOLVEMENT AT THIS TIME, HOLD FOR MINR REPORT. 05/01/90: 5/1/90 MNP INSP. FOUND ABANDONED OIL WELL, CRUDE OIL BUBBLING UP FROM GROUND, OIL IN STREAM DOWN TO CREEK, BOOM PUT IN BY MINR OK, I USED PADS TO CONTAIN, PROPERTY OWNER TO BE CONTACTED. 09/17/90: RNL SITE INSP. 09/17/90, OIL STILL SEEPING FROM WELL, BOOMS ARE CONTAINING, ONE PIPE IN OIL-WATER DAM REQUIRES ADJUSTMENT, ALBANY TO DECIDE ON FUNDING FOR PLUGGING OF WELL.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

09/27/90: 9/27/90 MNP INSP. SOME OIL BAILED INTO 55 GAL. DRUMS, GAS STILL BUBBLING UP FROM WELL, OIL STILL BEING COLLECTED & CONTAINED AT PIPE DAMS. 12/06/90: 12/6/90 MNP INSP. OIL WELL PLUGGING COMPLETED, DRUMS OF OIL ON SITE, OIL ON GROUND & IN STREAM, PRESTON TO SCHEDULE CLEANUP ASAP. 06/14/91: 6/14/91 MNP INSP. OIL PRODUCT IN STREAM NEAR PLUGGED WELL & BOTH PIPE DAMS. I USED 3 BOOMS & 1/2 BALE OF PADS TO CONTAIN OIL. 11/11/92: 11/11/92 MNP FILE REVIEW, SOIL DISPOSED, WELL PLUGGED, ALL PAYMENT PACKAGES PROCESSED, DITCH FILLED IN. MINR TO HANDLE REMAINING PROBLEMS. NO FURTHER WORK EXPECTED. RNL TO FINAL ISR, COMPLETE.

Page 339

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 340

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BANK OF SMOKES CREEK MINDEN DRIVE

Spill Number: 9001649

Close Date: 01/31/1991

ORCHARD PARK, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14127 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE WILLIAMS Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 823-8766 DEC Investigator: TEDIEFFE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/10/1990 01/31/1991 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: UNKNOWN SEEPAGE ENTERING SMOKES CREEK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "TED" 05/10/90: MEL INSPECTION. MET WITH CALLER WHO TOOK ME TO THE AREA OF CONCERN. OBSERVED AN ODIFEROUS OOZE BUBBLING UP , OUT OF A SANDY AREA OF THE CREEK BANK. SMELLED LIKE SULPHER. 06/15/90: TED SITE INSPECT. W/ RNL & MEL OBSERVED BLACK COLORED WATER SEEPING OUT OF BANK. STRONG SULFER ODER. SITE RECON REVEALED NO OBVIOUS SIGNS OF DUMPING OR LANDFILLING. 06/26/90: TED MET W/ SCOTT ABEL (AES) RESAMPLED SEEP. 07/16/90: TED REVIEWED LAB RESULTS OF 6/26/90 SAMPLING. RESULTS INDICATE

HIGHLY MINERALIZED WATER, TOTAL BTX 185.1 PPB.

08/13/90: MEMO TO BOB SPEED, SYNOPSIS OF SITE INVEST. FOR FOLLOW UP BY STAFF. 01/31/91: TED REVIEWED FILE. CLOSED SITE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 341

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL & GAS INC. ROUTE 248

Spill Number: 9000105

Close Date: 06/15/1990

WEST UNION (T), NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL & GAS INC. Spiller Phone: (716) 593-1090 Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: RANDY NEMECEK Caller Agency: NYSDEC Caller Phone: (716) 226-2466 DEC Investigator: BWFINSTE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/19/1990 06/15/1990 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS SURFACE WATER NON PCB OIL PETROLEUM 1500 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL OBSERVED IN MARSH CREEK NEAR TANK BATTERY #8351, #8357, #8358 ON NORTH SIDE OF RTE 248 SOUTH OF REXVILLE ON COLEMAN & RET LEASES OWNED BY ALLEGRO. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "BF" 04/03/90: SPILLS UNIT TO CONTACT JIM LEE OF ALLEGRO TO PERFORM CLEANUP, WARRANT TO BE SOUGHT IF SPILLER REFUSES ACCESS. 04/04/90: CH & BF ON SITE, INSPECTED AREA 150-200 YDS. OIL OBSERVED (BROWN OXIDIZED MATERIAL) IN CREEK FOR A STRETCH OF 50-75 YDS. DOWNSTREAM SUSPECT OIL MAY HAVE COME FROM SPILL FROM TANKS ON NORTH SIDE OF MARSH CREEK. NO REPORT OF SPILL MADE BY ALLEGRO. GRAY HERONS, MUSKRAT HOUSES AND BEAVER ACTIVITY NOTED IN AREA OF SPILL. ESTIMATED VOLUME OF OIL ON WATER IS 100-200 GALS. EXACT SOURCE OF SPILL IS NOT KNOWN TO BE FROM TANK AREA OR LEAKING UNPLUGGED WELL. 04/09/90: JM & CH ON SITE TO EVALUATE EXTENT OF SPILLAGE & TRY TO FIND THE SOURCE. ENTER PROPERTY W/SEARCH WARRANT. WE FIND SOURCE TO BE AN OLD WELL JUST NORTH OF RT 248 & TANK #8398. 04/09/90: FRESH GREEN CRUDE SURROUNDING WELL & BUBBLING OUT. OIL IS SPREAD THROUGHOUT SWAMP. THERE MAY BE 200-300 GAL OF OIL IN

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 342

SWAMP. VERY DIFFICULT TO GET TO OIL BECAUSE OF MUCKY CONDITIONS-SINK OUT OF SIGHT. 04/11/90: INSPECTION WARRANT OBTAINED ON 04-06-90. INSPECTION CONDUCTED ON 04-09 BY C. HETTENBAUGH AND J. MARCHITELL. SOURCE OF OIL SPILL IS LEAKING WELL NO. 104. 04/11/90: JIM LEE CONTACTED ON 04-09-90 & HE STATES OIL WAS CLEANED UP ON 04-10-90. REINSPECTION TO BE CONDUCTED BY MINERALS & LETTER OF RESPONSIBILITY TO BE WRITTEN. 04/12/90: FOLLOW-UP INSPECTION CONDUCTED. OIL REMAINED IN SUBSTANTIAL QUANITITIES THROUGHOUT WETLAND AND DISCHARGING FROM WELL, POOLING AROUND THE WELLHEAD, AND DRAINING INTO MARSH CREEK. FIRE HAD OCCURRED AROUND WELLHEAD (~ RADIUS OF 10’). PLUGGING AND ABANDONMENT OPERATIONS SUGGESTED. 05/03/90: CH ON SITE W/ECO’S LINCOLN & MURRAY, & RICKARD (MINERALS). AES PREPARING WELL SITE FOR PLUG JOB. ALLEGRO HAS PLACED PUMP JACK IN WELL. IT DOES NOT APPEAR THAT THEY HAVE PUMPED ANYTHING FROM THE WELL. 05/03/90: AES GRADES ROADS & STARTS TO BRING IN GRAVEL FOR LOCATION. THEY DON’T FINISH SO THEY HAUL GRAVEL IN ALL DAY ON 05-04-90. B. RICKARD ON SITE FOR THIS. 05/08/90: CH ON SITE W/RICKARD OF MINERALS TO MONITOR THE PLUGGING & PULLING OF WELL API #31-101-61544. GFS ON SITE W/THEIR SERVICE REG. THEY PULL APPROX 700’ OF ROD WHICH IS VERY DETERIORATED TOWARDS BOTTOM. 05/08/90: 42 JOINTS OF TUBING ARE REMOVED. STARTING W/37TH JOINT THEY HAVE LARGE HOLES. GFS WILL BRING IN NEW 1 3/4" FOR CEMENT JOB BECAUSE OF POOR CONDITION OF TUBING. 05/08/90: ALL TUBING AND RODS WERE WIPED DOWN AS THEY WERE COVERED W/B.S. 05/09/90: INTEGRATED CEMENTING SERVICES ON SITE TO DO CEMENTING. GFS RUNS 1 3/4" INTO 669’ TO START CEMENTING, THEN THE PULL BACK TO 450’ & FINISH WELL OFF. 185 SACKS OF CEMENT USED. 05/09/90: AES COLLECTED ~500 GAL OF WATER, CRUDE OIL & PARAFFIN THAT WAS FORCED OUT OF WELL FROM CEMENTING. ~500-1000 GAL OF THIS PRODUCT WAS LOST BECAUSE VACUUM TRUCK COULD NOT KEEP UP W/CEMENT TRUCK. 05/09/90: MOSTLY WATER ENTERED THE STREAM. WATER DID NOT SEEM TO HAVE MUCH SALT IN IT. OIL WAS CONTAINED W/BOOM & PADS. SOME CEMENT WAS FLUSHED TO STREAM. 05/09/90: PLUGGING SEEMED TO BE A SUCCESSFUL JOB AS CONFIRMED BY RICKARD. CH FINDS ANOTHER OLD CASING ALONG ACCESS ROAD WHICH IS LEAKING OIL. INFORMED RICKARD OF THIS. 05/15/90: CH ON SITE TO OBSERVE CLEANUP BEING DONE BY AES. THEY ARE USING A DRUM VAC TO SUCK OIL OUT OF SWAMP. SOME AREAS ARE VERY INACCESSIBLE & ARE GOING TO BE VERY DIFFICULT TO CLEAN UP. 05/15/90: CLEANUP IS GOING VERY SLOW AS IS. CH MARKS OUT AREAS THAT NEED TO BE CLEANED UP. WELL ALONG ACCESS ROAD (WELL WHERE CASING IS BELOW GROUND LEVEL) IS LEAKING OIL. 05/21/90: C. HETTENBAUGH ON SITE. CONTRACTOR HAS SPILL JUST ABOUT COMPLETED. THERE ARE ONLY A FEW ISOLATED POCKETS OF OIL REMAINING. THEY SHOULD HAVE IT COMPLETED BY 05-22-90 AROUND NOON.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

05/21/90: WELL CASING BY ACCESS ROAD IS STILL SPEWING OIL. 02/09/01: PAPER FILE REMOVED AS PER PAPER RETENTION POLICY. 07/03/05: DEC Minerals/EPA take over site by plugging the leaky well that has been causing the problem. No further involvement by DEC Spills is needed. 06/22/05: FINAL ISR SENT TO ALBANY.

Page 343

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 344

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DEGITZ OIL WELL NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 9010505

Close Date: 01/03/1991

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: DEGITZ INC. Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MR. DEGITZ Caller Agency: DEGITZ INC. Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/27/1990 01/03/1991 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 25.00 GALLONS 25.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL WATER COLLECTION TANK OVERFLOWED FROM CRUDE OIL WELL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 12/27/90: RNL TELECON WITH MINR. 12/27/90, THEY WILL CHECK AND SEND REPORT, WILL ASK FOR ASSISTANCE IF NEEDED. 01/03/91: MF 1/3/91 MINERIALS IS HANDLING SPILL, MEMO SENT, NO FUTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 345

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ALLEGRO OIL ROUTE 248 MARSH CREEK

Spill Number: 9012717

Close Date: 02/26/1992

WEST UNION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: HIGHWAY 248 Revised zip code: 14877 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: ALLEGRO OIL Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ROBERT HARDING SR. Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (607) 225-4942 DEC Investigator: PCLINDEN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/08/1991 02/26/1992 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER NON PCB OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CALLER SAYS A WELL A FEW HUNDRED YDS TO THE WEST OF THE WELL PLUGGED BY DEC CONTRACTORS IS LEAKING OIL INTO THE SWAMP. WELL HEAD IS INSIDE A DRUM. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" 03/11/91: CALLER SAYS THERE IS OIL PRESENT AROUND THIS WELL HEAD. ALSO THINKS SEPARATORS AT TOP OF HILL MAY BE OVERFLOWING. CH ADVISES TOM WICKERHAM OF MINERALS. TOM WILL CHECK IT OUT. 02/26/92: WICKERHAM DOES NOT FIND ANYTHING SIGNIFICANT ENOUGH TO GET SPILLS INVOLVED WITH. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 346

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

C & G TRANSMISSION 1 MILE SOUTH JOHNSONBURG

Spill Number: 9004314

Close Date: 07/24/1990

ORANGEVILLE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: C & G TRANSMISSION Spiller Phone: (304) 623-8446 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: STEVE BURKETT Caller Agency: C & G TRANSMISSION Caller Phone: (304) 623-8446 DEC Investigator: LYONS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/18/1990 07/18/1990 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PIPE LINE LEAK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MEL" 07/18/90: MEL TELCON WITH STEVE BURKETT. PRESSURE IN LINE REDUCED, MAN STATIONED AROUND CLOCK, REPAIRS TO BE MADE 7/19/90. MINERALS NOTIFIED BY C&G. NO SPILL INVOLVEMENT NEEDED, RECOMMEND FILE BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 347

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

WELL HEAD-CHIPMONK CHIPMONK & FLATROCK ROADS

Spill Number: 9004920

Close Date: 08/03/1990

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: CHIPMONK / FLATROCK ROADS Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE FRANKS Caller Agency: NYSDEC Caller Phone: (716) 847-4590 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/01/1990 08/03/1990 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 100.00 GALLONS 100.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: WELL HEAD SPILLAGE NOTICED WHILE INSPECTING ANOTHER SPILL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 08/03/90: MF RNL SITE VISIT, WELL HEAD SPILLAGE NOTED. SPILL REFURED TO MINERALS. NO FUTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 348

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS WELL 3346 MILLER ROAD

Spill Number: 9009092

Close Date: 11/16/1990

FAYETTE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13065 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: MERIDIAN Spiller Phone: (814) 398-4621 Notifier Type: Fire Department Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: DISPATCHER Caller Agency: SENECA CO SHERIFFS DEPT Caller Phone: (315) 539-9241 DEC Investigator: PRMILLER Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/16/1990 11/16/1990 HUMAN ERROR UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: FIRE DEPT RESPONDED TO WELL/RIG FIRE A NATURAL GAS WELL. CONTACT PERSON: MIKE HAHN 315-255-2203. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PM" 11/16/90: P. MILLER TELCON W/DISPATCHER, CHIEF MARQUART ON SCENE. FIRE IS OUT. NO NEED TO RESPOND. RANDY NEMECEK TO FOLLOW-UP. 11/19/90: P. MILLER TELCON W/RANDY NEMECEK, FIRE PUT OUT IN 15 MINUTES WITH FIRE EXTINGUIDSHERS. RIG WAS WORKOVER RIG. 09/28/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: NATURAL GAS FIRE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 349

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PENNSYLVANIA ENERGY OLD ROUTE 219

Spill Number: 9010364

Close Date: 01/03/1991

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: PENNSYLVANIA ENERGY Spiller Phone: (814) 723-3230 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOE YARUZ Caller Agency: NYSDEC Caller Phone: (716) DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/26/1990 01/03/1991 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected #6 FUEL OIL PETROLEUM 25.00 GALLONS 15.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LEAK IN PIPING, SPILL TRAVELED TO DRAINAGE DITCH. BOOMS & PADS IN PLACE. PIPE DAM INSTALLED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 12/26/90: MF FOR MJH 12/26/90 MINETIALS TO MONITOR CLEAN UP. THEY WILL NOTIFY US IF OUR HELP IS NEEDED. 01/03/91: MF 1/3/91 MINERALS IS HANDLING SPILL, MEMO SENT, NO FUTHER ACTION NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 350

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GOUDY PLANT - BRINE SOLUT GOUDY PLANT

Spill Number: 9008101

Close Date: 10/25/1990

VESTAL (T), NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: NYSEG Spiller Phone: (607) 729-2551 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CAROL HOWEN Caller Agency: NYSEG Caller Phone: (607) 729-2551 DEC Investigator: CLWARNER Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 10/23/1990 10/24/1990 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE TANK OVERFILLED DUE TO HEAVY RAINS. FLOWED INTO FLOOR DRAINS THAT LEAD TO CHOCONUT CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "CWA" 10/24/90: NOTHING TO CLEAN UP. 10/03/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: BRINE SOLUTION.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 351

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

RAMCO DRILLING LEMLEY ROAD & VAN ALLEN

Spill Number: 9008589

Close Date: 11/23/1990

COVINGTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: LEMLEY ROAD / VAN ALLEN Revised zip code: 14525 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: RAMCO DRILLING Spiller Phone: (716) 484-0102 Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOHN HOFFMAN Caller Agency: DEC MINERALS Caller Phone: (716) 372-5636 DEC Investigator: LYONS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/06/1990 11/23/1990 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected DIESEL PETROLEUM 75.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: HIGH WINDS BLEW OVER DRILLING RIG -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MEL" 11/06/90: MEL TELCON WITH JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS. MINERALS TO DO INITIAL RESPONSE, WILL NOTIFY SPILLS . 11/16/90: MEL TELCON WITH JOHN HOFFMAN, MINERALS. SPILLS TO DO FOLLOW UP. 11/16/90: MEL INSPECTION. COULD FIND NO CONTAMINATED SOIL TO EXCAVATE, SOIL IN SPILL AREA EXTREEMELY CHURNED UP. 11/23/90: MEL TELCON WITH STEVE POWNELL. APPROX. 4 BALES OF PADS USED TO SOAK UP SPILL. MR POWNELL TO DISPOSE OF PROPERLY. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY, RECOMMEND FILE BE CLOSED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 352

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAGE RESIDENCE OIL WELL RICHARDSON AVENUE

Spill Number: 8901735

Close Date: 06/07/1989

WIRT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14739 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: MR. GAGE Spiller Phone: (716) 928-1690 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JIM WEBB Caller Agency: DEC Caller Phone: (716) 593-1000 DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/20/1989 06/07/1989 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS 5.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SPILLAGE FROM OIL WELL AT GAGE RESIDENCE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 05/20/89: DKK CHECKED WITH SPILLER 05/20/89, HE WILL CLEANUP; DKK CONTACTED MINR. 05/20/89, BRAIN JANDREAU, HE WILL CHECK SITE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 353

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PENNZOIL NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 8903600

Close Date: 08/24/1989

CATTARAUGUS, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14719 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: PENNZOIL PORDUCTS COMPANY Spiller Phone: (814) 368-6142 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: PAUL PHILLITS Caller Agency: PENNZOIL Caller Phone: (716) 368-6142 DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/11/1989 08/24/1989 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 800.00 GALLONS 800.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PIPE LINE BREAK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 07/11/89: LQR TELCON W/ CACHD,MINERALS ON SITE SPILLER CLEANING UP. 07/11/89: LQR TELCON W/ CACHD,SPILLER CLEANING UP,SPILL CONTAINED. 08/24/89: REPORT REC. FROM PENNZOIL AND CHCHD, SITE COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 354

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PENNSYLVANIAN GEN. ENERGY NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 8909958

Close Date: 01/22/1990

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: PENN. GENERAL ENERGY Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: PAUL GIACHETTI Caller Agency: MINERALS NYSDEC Caller Phone: (716) 372-5636 DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/16/1990 01/22/1990 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 20.00 GALLONS 20.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL FIELD SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 01/17/90: RNL TELCON W/ CACHD TO INVESTIGATE. 01/22/90: MINERALS NYSDEC SENT REPORT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 355

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SPUR PETROLEUM 8903 EAST EDEN ROAD

Spill Number: 8903631

Close Date: 12/06/1989

EDEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14057 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: SPUR PETROLEUM Spiller Phone: (713) 622-8492 Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CAROL ESCHNER Caller Agency: RESIDENT Caller Phone: (716) 992-9674 DEC Investigator: FIX Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 07/10/1989 12/06/1989 HOUSEKEEPING UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS 5.00 GALLONS SOIL COMPRESSOR OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: GAS COMPRESSOR/PUMP STATION OPERATION FOR NATURAL GAS RECOVERY DISCHARGING SOME TYOE OF OIL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "CAF" 08/16/89: CAF TELCON JOHN HOFFMAN,MINERALS,OLEAN,TO LOOK AT SPILL.I WILL CALL SPUR PETROLEUM TO SEE IF THEY HAVE A LOCAL REP.WHO CAN HELP IDENTIFYAND REMEDIATE THE PROBLEM. 12/06/89: CAF SITE VISIT-CLEANUP COMPLETED,NO SHEEN FOUND.NO FURTHER ACTION PLANNED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 356

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

TOWN OF GERRY HIGHWAY ROUTE 60

Spill Number: 8909994

Close Date: 06/19/1990

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Spiller: CHAUTAUQUA COUNTY DPW Spiller Phone: (716) 665-4496 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: MIKE VENDETTE Caller Agency: CHCHD Caller Phone: (716) 753-4481 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/18/1990 06/19/1990 TANK OVERFILL UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE TANK OVERFILLED, BRINE ESCAPED DIKED AREA. OIL & PARIFFIN SOAKED UP WITH PADS. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 01/18/90: MF PER SPILL REPORT, MAV NOTIFIED BOB MITRY FOR DISPOSAL REQUIREMENTS. 01/19/90: MF TELECON MAV APPX 50 GAL. OF PET. & 20 GAL OF PARAFFIN SPILLED. HIGHWAY DEPT DUG TRENCH TO COLLECT RUNOFF. NO BRINE DETECTED IN FARMERS FIELD. SOIL WILL BE DISPOSED OF. 02/02/90: MF MAV 1/30/90 SITE VISIT, I DID NOT NOTICE ANY OIL IN THE BERMED AREA. THE REST OF THE SPILL AREA IS COVERED WITH SNOW. 05/22/90: MF 5/7/90 MEETING AT CHCHD. CONTAMINATED SOIL HAS BEEN REMOVED & DISPOSED OF. MAV WILL GET THE RECEIPT & FOWARD IT TO ME. 06/19/90: MF RECEIVED DISPOSAL RECEIPT. NO FUTHER ACTION NECESSARY. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: BRINE, PARIFFIN, OIL

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 357

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL-HANOVER COTTAGE ROAD

Spill Number: 8911561

Close Date: 10/01/1990

HANOVER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: NATIONAL FUEL Spiller Phone: (716) 649-3181 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: DAVE BARTHOLD Caller Agency: NATIONAL FUEL Caller Phone: (716) 649-3121 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/01/1990 10/01/1990 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: CONTAMINATED SOIL REMOVED FROM SEVERAL SPILL LOCATIONS & STAGED AT COTTAGE STREET. SOLID WASTE & ECO’S INVOLVED. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 03/08/90: MF TELECON SPILLER MINERALS & SOLID WASTE. SPILLS TO HANDLE REMEDIATION. LETTER SENT. 05/09/90: MF LETTER FROM NATIONAL FUEL, THEY ARE WAITING FOR A DETERMINATION FROM SOLID WASTE AS TO WHAT THEY WILL DO. 09/13/90: MF 9/13/90 LETTER TO SPILLER ASKING FOR AN UPDATE BY 9/30/90. 10/01/90: MF RECEIVED SAMPLE RESULTS FROM BOB WOZNIAK, NO PCB’S OR HYDROCARBONS DETECTED. NO FUTHER ACTION NECESSARY. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: DRIP FLUID.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 358

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

FRANCIS WROBLEWSKI PARTRIDGE ROAD

Spill Number: 8911893

Close Date: 05/01/1990

COLDEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: PINE TREE ACRES Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: RON KALETTA Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 537-9528 DEC Investigator: MJHINTON Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/15/1990 05/01/1990 DELIBERATE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 POUNDS 0.00 POUNDS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NATURAL GAS WELL BEING VENTED TO AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MJH" 05/18/90: FOLLOWUP REFERRED TO MINERAL RESOURCES DIV. REFER ADDITIONAL SPILL REPORT #9001378.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 359

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL 10010 SIMONDS ROAD

Spill Number: 8912193

Close Date: 03/27/1990

DARIEN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14040 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL Spiller Phone: (716) 286-3000 Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ROY CAPWELL Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 547-9497 DEC Investigator: MAGER Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/22/1990 03/27/1990 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SPILL <1 GAL/MIN. CALLER REPORTS THAT UNDERGRND SALT BRINE PIPELINE IS LEAKING ONTO HIS DRIVEWAY AND INTO MURDER CREEK. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "DM" 03/23/90: DM NOTIFIED PETE MCDOWELL OF OCCIDENTAL. MCDOWELL STATED THAT THEY WILL REPAIR PIPELINE. MCDOWELL REPORTS THAT LARRY THOMAS IS ON SCENE W/EQUIPMENT TO REPAIR LINE & HAS VAC TRUCK TO PUMP OUT LIQUID. 03/23/90: MCDOWELL SAYS THAT LEAK RATE IS <1 GAL/MIN. SOLUTION IS 280 G/L OF BRINE. 03/23/90: PAT MCGRATH (ATT FOR OCCIDENTAL) 214-404-3300 OR 3319 SAYS THAT THEY ARE TRYING TO OBTAIN LEGAL PERMISSION TO ENTER CAPWELL’S PROP. & FEELS THAT CAPWELL MAY NOT AGREE. 03/23/90: MCGRATH FEELS CAPWELL MAY USE THIS INCIDENT AS BLACKMAIL. 1600 HRS MS CAPWELL INDICATED THAT SHE GAVE BUCKEYE PIPELINE PERMISSION TO TEMPORARILY FIX PIPLINE. MICHAEL BAKER-BUCKEYE- 800-523-9420 X 425. 03/23/90: PAT MCGRATH HOME PHONE:716-434-9357.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

03/27/90: RANDY GARNEY, GCHD SAID THAT LEAK WAS FIXED ON 03-23-90. NO FISHKILL IN CREEK. LEAK WAS A MINOR ONE.

Page 360

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 361

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

HONEOYE STORAGE CORP SOUTH HILL ROAD

Spill Number: 8902832

Close Date: 06/16/1989

BRISTOL, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14469 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: HONEOYE STORAGE CORP Spiller Phone: (716) 394-3415 Notifier Type: Police Department Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ONTARIO CO SHERIFF DEPT Caller Agency: Caller Phone: (716) 394-4560 DEC Investigator: BWFINSTE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/16/1989 06/16/1989 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected LUBE OIL PETROLEUM 15.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: COMPLAINANT STATES OIL HAS BEEN SPRAYED OVER GAS STORAGE WELL AREA BEHIND HIS HOUSE. GAS WELL WAS LOGGED WITH LOW LEVEL RADIOACTIVE DEVICE. JACK KELTY, CONTACT. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "BF" 06/16/89: 06/16/89 BF ON SITE. INSPECTION REVEALED MINIMAL LUBRICATING OIL SPILL THAT BLEW OUT OF GAS WELL DURING LOGGING PROCEDURE. SPILLER AGREED TO CLEAN UP. CONTACTED NYSDOH-NO CONCERN OVER RADIOACTIVITY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 362

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL SEEP MCKINLEY PARKWAY

Spill Number: 8801319

Close Date: 06/13/1988

HAMBURG, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: MC KINLEY PARKWAY Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: NONE Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: ANONOMOUS Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: MJHINTON Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/17/1988 06/13/1988 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN MATERIAL OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL SEEP ALONG I90 BEHIND WEGMAN’S -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MJH" 06/13/88: SAMPLE ANALYSIS INDICATE NO PETROLEUM PRODUCTS PRESENT, SEEP IDENTIFIED AS AN OLD ABANDONED NATURAL GAS WELL MINERAL RESOURCES TO FOLLOWUP W/ WELL CAPPING NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILL GROUP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 363

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL PIPE EAST OF HIGHWAY 98

Spill Number: 8800681

Close Date: 11/02/1988

ALEXANDER, NY 14005

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: NO CHANGE Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Responsible Party ANTHONY KARWEIL CAHETTEN

Spiller: OCCIDENTAL CHEMICAL Notifier Name: Caller Agency: NYSDEC Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 278-7795 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: (518) 235-5413 Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/21/1988 11/02/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 2000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE SOLUTION PIPELINE RUPTURES SPILLING BRINE OF CONCENTRATION OF APPROXIMATELY 300 GRAMS/LITER. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "CH" 04/21/88: BREAK OCCURS NEAR ALEXANDER FIRE HALL, IS ~100 YARDS FROM TONAWANDA CREEK. LARRY THOMSON, TEXAS BRINE, 786-5203 ON SITE CONDUCTING CLEANUP. BULLDOZER & BACKHOE BEING BROUGHT IN ALONG WITH VAC TRUCK. 04/21/88: GARY BACHELOR TO INSPECT. HE SAYS THAT MOST OF BRINE STAYED IN 15 ACRE FIELD-SOME GOT INTO TRIB OF TONAWANDA CREEK, BUT THEY HAD BERMED THAT UP. PIPELINE WAS REPAIRED AND CLEANUP CONTINUING. 04/21/88: CALLAHAN TO CHECK 4/22. ECO WILSON WAS ALSO ON SITE AFTER 2200. 07/25/88: LARRY THOMSON OF TEXAS BRINE SAYS 25200 GAL LOST. VAC TRUCK PICKED UP 33,200 GAL.(THERE WAS STANDING H2O IN AREA BEFORE SPILL) SECTION OF LINE THAT FAILED WAS SENT TO BRYANT LABS, HUSTON TX.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 364

07/25/88: BRYANT LABS DETERMINED THAT PIPE FAILED @ DENT IN PIPE & NOT @ SEAM AS ORIGINALLY SUSPECTED. FIELD THAT WAS AFFECTED IS OWNED BY ARNOLD SCHMIEDER. FIELD WAS USED TO GROW CORN. 07/25/88: FIELD WAS TREATED W/ SOIL SAVER CHEMICAL(EPA APPROVED SPECIFICALLY FOR BRINE SPILLS) BY TEXAS BRINE.REPLACEMENT PIPING IS PRE-TESTED @ 1790 PSI FOR 24HRS.SAME AS ORIG.LINE WHEN INSTALLED IN 1970. 11/02/88: 11/02/88 CH INSPECTS SITE OF SPILL BEHIND FIRE HALL. FIELDS ARE ALL GREEN AND SHOW NO ADVERSE SIGNS OF SPILL. 09/28/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: BRINE SOLUTION. 3/9/06 PAPER FILE REMOVED PER FILE RETENTION POLICY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 365

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SOAPER & WELCH PROPERTY NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 8805091

Close Date: 09/19/1988

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: INSTITUTIONAL, EDUC, GOV, OTHER Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JIM RUCINSHI Caller Agency: NYSDEC MINERALS Caller Phone: (716) 372-5636 DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/11/1988 09/19/1988 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 2.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NATURALLY OCCURING OIL SEEP IN DITCH FROM BANK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 09/13/88: LQR TELCON W/ J.RUCINSKI MINERALS SITE MEETING TO BE SCHEDULED. 09/16/88: LQR ON SITE PLACED BOOM AND PILLOW TO CONTAIN SAMPLED OIL. 09/19/88: LETTER SENT TO MINERALS,STATING NO CLEAN UP BY SPILL UNIT,NATURAL CRUDE OIL SEEP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 366

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BELDEN & BLAKE NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 8801671

Close Date: 06/07/1988

CARROLL, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14770 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: BELDEN & BLAKE Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: FRANK BARGER Caller Agency: BELTON & BLAKE Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 05/24/1988 06/07/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 5.00 GALLONS 2.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: DURING WELL INJECTION, CRUDE OIL WAS FORCED FROM WELL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 05/24/88: MJH TELECON 05/24/88, MINR, DENNIS MILLER WILL RESPOND. 06/07/88: LQR MEETING W/ MINERALS SPILLER CLEANED UP NO FURTHER ACTION.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 367

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BELDEN AND BLAKE NICHOLS RUN ROAD

Spill Number: 8800413

Close Date: 06/24/1988

CARROLLTON, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: BELDON AND BLAKE Spiller Phone: (716) 368-1660 Notifier Type: Health Department Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: RALPH GATTUSO Caller Agency: CACHD Caller Phone: (716) 375-4121 DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/12/1988 06/24/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL BYPASSING SEPARATION LAGOON AND ENTERING CREEK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 04/14/88: CACHD ON SITE MINERAL RESOURCES NOTIFIED. 04/19/88: REPORT REC. 04/19/88 FROM CACHD,MINERALS TO INVESTIGATE. 04/29/88: LQR TELCON W/ MINERALS 04/27/88 FOR UP DATE;LQR TELCON 04/29/88 W/ BRUCE MINERALS HAVE NOT INVESTIGATED SITE YET. 05/03/88: LQR TELCON CACHD AND MINERALS CONFICTING STORIES OF FINDING SITE INSP. REQUIRED. 05/09/88: LQR ON SITE 05/09/88 SPILLER NEEDS TO REMEDIATE. 05/17/88: LQR MEET MINERALS 05/17/88 SPILLS TO FOLLOW THUR ON THIS ONE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

06/10/88: LQR ON SITE MORE WORK REQUIRED;LQR TELCON W/ SPILLER 06/10/88 WORK TO BE PERFORMED. 06/15/88: LQR TELCON W/ SPILLER 06/15/88 CLEANING UP TODAY.

Page 368

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 369

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NORTHERN PETROLEUM CO. 1 MULLERWELL ROAD

Spill Number: 8804965

Close Date: 01/29/1989

ELLERY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: NORTHERN PETROLEUM CO. Spiller Phone: (814) 454-8643 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: DICK MILLER Caller Agency: NORTHERN PETROLEUM CO. Caller Phone: (814) 454-8643 DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/07/1988 01/29/1989 TANK FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 630.00 GALLONS 630.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: TANK LEAKED -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" 09/07/88: MNP TELCON W/ M.VENDETTI SOILLER CLEANING. 01/29/89: RNL TELECON 01/29/89 WITH MINR, B. JANDREAU, TNAK STILL IN BAD CONDITION BUT SPILL CLEANED BY SPILLER TO HIS SATISFACTION, SOME ADSORBANTS STILL ON GROUND, SITE COMPLETE. 04/15/89: RNL RECIEVED REPORT FROM CHCHD 04/15/89, SPILL HANDLED BY MINERAL RESOURCES, NO CHCHD INVOLVEMENT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 370

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

AUSTIN MAIN GAS WELL ROUTE 60

Spill Number: 8805448

Close Date: 08/30/1989

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CHAUTAUQUA ENERGY Spiller Phone: (716) 326-4977 Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: TOM KOSS Caller Agency: NYSDEC FOREST RANGER Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/12/1988 08/30/1989 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: ABOVEGROUND TANK LEAK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" 09/26/88: MF TELCON M.VEDETTI CHCHD TO INVESTIGATE. 04/15/89: RNL RECEIVED CHCHD REPORT 04/15/89, SPILL CLEANED UP BY CHAUTUAQUA ENERGY, CHCHD CONTACTED T. KOSS FOR FURTHER ACTION. 05/24/89: RNL TELECONS WITH MINR. 01/26/89 AND 05/24/89, THEY WILL CHECK ON STATUS OF SPILL, THINK IT HAS BEEN CLEANED UP. 08/30/89: RNL RECEIVED NO DATA FROM MINR AS OF 08/30/89, SITE TO BE CLOSED OUT. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: CRUDE OIL,BRINE,ACID

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 371

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS WELL #444 2809 STRAIGHT ROAD

Spill Number: 8802159

Close Date: 06/09/1988

ARKWRIGHT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14718 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: TEMPLTON GAS WELL Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: BEN SCHILLING Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 673-1575 DEC Investigator: MXFRANKS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/06/1988 06/09/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: HOLDING TANK RUPTURED SPILLING BRINE. PROBLEM IS ON GOING. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MF" 06/07/88: MF TELECON CHRIS MILLER (OLEAN OFFICE, MINERAL RESOURCES). SOMEONE WILL BE SENT OUT TOMORROW. I GAVE BEN’S WIFE THIS INFORMATION.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 372

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

HOYT LEASE BARLETT ROAD

Spill Number: 8810005

Close Date: 04/06/1989

BOLIVAR, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14715 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: EBENEZER OIL COMPANY Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: JOE YAROUS Caller Agency: NYSDEC MINERALS Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/27/1989 03/28/1989 VANDALISM UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 15.00 GALLONS 15.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: VANDALS BROKE PIPE AT WELL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 03/28/89: LQR TELCON W/ J.YAROAS SPILLER CLEANING UP. 03/28/89: LQR TELCON W/ J.YAROAS SPILLER CLEANING UP,REPORT TO FOLLOW. 04/06/89: REPORT FROM NYSDEC MINERALS REC. SPILLER CLEANED UP.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 373

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

T.G.X. CORP. OLD TRANSIT ROAD

Spill Number: 8709591

Close Date: 02/22/1988

EAST AURORA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Citizen ANONYMOUS PRINGLE

Spiller: T.G.X. CORP. Notifier Name: Caller Agency: CITIZEN Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: (716) 326-4981 Notifier Phone: Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Unknown RP - DEC Field Response - DEC Corrective Action Required -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/11/1988 02/22/1988 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE OVERFLOWING FROM GAS WELL INTO CREEK;NOTIFIER SAID ONGOING FOR 8YRS.;(GAS WELL #4140) -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" 02/11/88: MINR, MILLER NOTIFIED & WILL FOLLOWUP;WATER, RINK NOTIFIED & INTERESTED IN OUTCOME. 02/22/88: 2/17/88 MNP TELECON W/COMPLAINTANT, HE WANTED SOME ACTION TAKEN;2/17/88 MNP TELECON W/MINR, THEY WILL INVESTIGATE & KEEP US INFORMED;2/22/88 MNP TELECON W/MINR, NOTHING FOUND AT SITE, NO ACTION NEEDED.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 374

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

COTTON WELL DRILLING TARBOX ROAD

Spill Number: 8709898

Close Date: 04/06/1988

ARKWRIGHT, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14718 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: COTTON WELL DRILLING Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: AL CARDOT Caller Agency: CITIZEN Caller Phone: (716) 595-3940 DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/23/1988 04/06/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: BRINE SPILL INTO SMALL STEAM TRIB TO CASSADAGA LAKE. MIN RESOURCES NOTIFIED WILL INVESTIGATE, CHCHD NOTIFIED WILL INVESTIGATE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" 02/29/88: MNP TEELCON 02/29/88, FROM MINR., SUE MALLETTE, ONLY WATER PUMPED, NO BRINE, NO SPILL. 03/01/88: SUE MALLETTE FROM MIN. RESOURCES INVESTIGATED AND FOUND NO EVIDENCE OF SPILL. 04/06/88: RNL MEETING CHCHD 04/06/88, M. VENDETTE SATISFIED WITH CLEANUP, WATER WAS ACTUALLY BEING DISCHARGED, MINR. HAS INSPECTED SITE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 375

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

STATE FROEST LANDS CHIPMUNK ROAD

Spill Number: 8707462

Close Date: 12/08/1987

LIMESTONE, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14753 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 11/28/1987 12/08/1987 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PIPE LINE NO. 101 LEAKING INTO UNNAMED TRIB.,2 55 GAL DRUMS OF CAUSTIC SODA ALSO ON SITE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" / / : LQR TELCON MINERALS 12/01/87 TO INVESTIGATE. / / : LQR MET BRUCE MINERALS 12/07/87 SITE INVESTIGATOR WILL CONTACT ME 12/08/87;LQR 12/08/87 JIM MINERALS NOTHING FOUND,COMPLT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 376

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL TRANSIT CHIPMONK ROAD CR #30

Spill Number: 8710121

Close Date: 10/21/1988

ALLEGANY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14706 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: NATIONAL TRANSIT Spiller Phone: (814) 362-4563 Notifier Type: Federal Government Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: RODERICK ARMSTRONG Caller Agency: NATIONAL TRANSIT Caller Phone: (814) 362-4563 DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/02/1988 10/21/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SURFACE WATER UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 1260 GALLONS 800 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: PIPE BRAKE,1200 GALS CRUDE OIL INTO CHIPMONK CREEK -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" 03/03/88: MF SITE VISIT/KEN MILLER (NATIONAL TRANSIT), CLEANUP IN PROGRESS, 8 BOOMS IN PLACE, AREA BEING HOSED DOWN. 800 GALLONS OF PRODUCT RECOVERED. 03/10/88: LQR,MF AND R.GATTUSO CACHD SITE INSP. 03/10/88 FURTHER CLEAN UP REQUIRED. 03/22/88: LQR ON SITE 03/22/88 W/ CACHD, SPILLERS, MINERALS DEC FURTHER CLEAN UP REQUIRED. 04/01/88: LQR ON SITE 04/01/88 DITCH AND PIPE DAM IN PLACE. 04/28/88: LQR ON SITE 04/28/88 PIPE DAM STILL IN PLACE,SPILLER CLEANING UP. 05/09/88: LQR ON SITE 05/09/88 PIPE DAM IN PLACE,NO OIL NOTICED IN CREEK.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

06/08/88: LQR ON SITE W/ SPILLER FURTHER WORK REQUIRED. 07/13/88: LQR ON SITE NO WORK SEEMS TO HAVE STARTED YET. 07/14/88: LQR TELCON SPILLER WORK TO START SOON USING BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT. 07/26/88: LQR AND CAF ON SITE RUN OFF CLEAN. 08/24/88: LQR ON SITE W/ SPILLER CLEAN UP TO START SOON. 09/16/88: LQR ON SITE SPILLER CLEANING UP SOIL STAGED. 10/12/88: LQR TELCON W/SPILLER MEETING ON SITE 10/20/88 1000HRS. 10/21/88: T.POWERS CACHD ISSUED EMERGENCY HAULER PERMIT FOR SOIL TO BE SENT TOPENN. FOR TREATMENT.

Page 377

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 378

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BAXTER RESIDENCE 853 MILL ROAD

Spill Number: 8710443

Close Date: 03/03/1989

BUSTI, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14701 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: NONE Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: CORINA BAXTER Caller Agency: HOMEOWNER Caller Phone: (716) 484-8726 DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/14/1988 03/03/1989 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: MRS. BAXTER CLAIMS GAS (GASOLINE OR NATURAL?) IS CONTAMINATING HER WELL WATER, WATER FROM TAP APPARENTLY FLASHES WHEN LIT W/ A MATCH -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" 03/16/88: MINERALS TO INVESTIGATE DUE TO PROBABILITY PROBLEM IS NATURAL GAS, CHCHD, STEVE JOHNSON, NOTIFIED. 05/12/88: RNL MEETING CHCHD, 05/12/88, DID NOT RESPOND TO SPILL, MINR. RESPONDED, RNL TO CHECK WITH MINR. 07/29/88: RNL MEETING CHCHD 07/29/88, RNL TO AGAIN TRY TO CONTACT MINR, C. MILLER, ABOUT THIS SPILL. 03/03/89: RNL TELECONS WITH MINR., AL ALEXANDER, HE HAD NO RESPONSE FROM BAXTER SINCE 09/19/88 LETTER TO THEM, WE DECIDED TO DROP SPILL, COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 379

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

NATIONAL FUEL GAS SW OF ROUTE 98 & ROUTE 20

Spill Number: 8704466

Close Date: 09/09/1987

ALEXANDER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: SW OF ROUTE 98 / ROUTE 20 Revised zip code: 14005 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: NATIONAL FUEL GAS Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Fire Department Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: FIRE CHIEF BILL WAGNER Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: PCLINDEN Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 08/27/1987 09/09/1987 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: LEAK IN NATURAL GAS TRANSMISSION LINE. ODOR WAS REPORTED WORST ON 8/27 & 8/28 WHEN IT RAINED. FIRE CHIEF SAID PATCH OF DEAD GRASS NEARBY. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "PL" / / : NATIONAL FUEL GAS CALLED OUT 8/27 & 8/28 BUT THEY CLAIMED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBLEM. PL FOUND LIGHT ODOR 8/30 AROUND VALVES. / / : 8/31 PL REFERRED CASE TO MINERAL RESOURCES SECTION. DEBBIE BIMBER INVESTIGATING. IF NO DEC VIOLATION THEY WILL ADVISE PUBLIC SERVICE COMM.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 380

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ED JENNINGS CRUDE OIL ROUTE 417

Spill Number: 8704791

Close Date: 06/24/1988

ALMA, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14708 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: EARL JENNINGS Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: AL VOSSELER Caller Agency: ACHD Caller Phone: (716) 268-9254 DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/09/1987 06/24/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN AIR UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 25.00 GALLONS 20.00 GALLONS AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL FIELD TANK OVER FILLED -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : LQR TELCON 09/09/87 MINERAL DON TO INVESTIGATE. 04/04/88: RNL SITE INSP. 04/04/88, CLEAN FILL PLACED OVER CONTAMINATED SOIL, OTHER CONTAMINATED SOIL AREA REMAINS, CONTACT MINR., ADDITIONAL CLEANUP NEEDED. 06/08/88: LQR ON SITE W/ SPILLER AND HIS CONTRACTOR,CLEAN STARTED. 06/24/88: LQR AND CAF ON SITE CLEAN UP COMPLT.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 381

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

TRAHAN COMPANY GOSHEN ROAD

Spill Number: 8600708

Close Date: 11/12/1986

HARMONY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: TRAHAN COMPANY Spiller Phone: (716) 287-3332 Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/27/1986 11/12/1986 HUMAN ERROR UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NATURAL GAS WELL SITE - SOUR #1 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : CHCHD, S. JOHNSON, CONTACTED 04/27/86; REFERRED TO MINR, B. MCGRANAHAN, 04/27/86. / / : CHCHD, S. JOHNSON, CONTACTED 04/27/86; REFERRED TO MINR, B. MCGRANAHAN, 04/27/86; DEC, W. CAIN, 08/26/86, ADDITIONAL WORK NEEDED. / / : DEC, W. CAIN, 08/26/86, ADDITIONAL WORK NEEDED; DEC, W. CAIN, SATISFIED WITH SITE REMEDIATION 11/12/86, FINE TO BE ASSESSED BY HIM, COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 382

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

GAS WELL DRILLING 3097 SOUTH CREEK ROAD

Spill Number: 8607748

Close Date: 05/29/1987

HAMBURG, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14075 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Affected Persons Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: PRINGLE Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 03/19/1987 05/29/1987 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: MR MACRI COMPLAINS OF HIGH SALT CONTENT TO DRINKING WATER WELL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "MNP" / / : TELECON W/MINR, MILLER 5/28/87, CASE RESOLVED, HE WILL SEND REPORT;RECEIVED REPORT FROM MINR 5/29/87, NO FURTHER DEC INVOLVEMENT. / / : ADVISED TO CONTACT ERIE COUNTY HEALTH DEPT. / / : ADVISED TO CONTACT ERIE COUNTY HEALTH DEPT.; REFERRED TO MINR., P. MILLER, 03/20/87.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 383

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

TRAHAN COMPANY GOSHEN ROAD

Spill Number: 8600707

Close Date: 11/12/1986

HARMONY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: TRAHAN COMPANY Spiller Phone: (716) 287-3332 Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 04/27/1986 11/12/1986 HUMAN ERROR UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 0.00 GALLONS 0.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NATURAL GAS WELL SITE - ADAMS #1 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : CHCHD, S. JOHNSON, CONTACTED 04/29/86; DEFERRED TO MINR, B. MCGRANAHAN, 04/29/86. / / : CHCHD, S. JOHNSON, CONTACTED 04/29/86; REFERRED TO MINR, B. MCGRANAHAN, 04/29/86; DEC, W. CAIN, 08/26/86, ADDITIONAL WORK NEEDED. / / : DEC, W. CAIN, 08/26/86, ADDITIONAL WORK NEEDED; DEC, W. CAIN, SATISFIED WITH SITE REMEDIATION 11/12/86, FINE TO BE ASSESSED BY HIM, COMPLETE. / / : DEC, W. CAIN, 08/26/86, ADDITIONAL WORK NEEDED; DEC, W. CAIN, SATISFIED WITH SITE REMEDIATION 11/21/86, FINE TO BE ASSESSED BY HIM, COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 384

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

OIL WELL SITE COUNTY LINE ROAD

Spill Number: 8605825

Close Date: 01/15/1988

PERRYSBURG, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14129 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: STANLEY CZYZ Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: GARY BOBSCEINE Caller Agency: DEC Caller Phone: (716) 847-4590 DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/14/1986 01/15/1988 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 50.00 GALLONS 10.00 GALLONS SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: FIRE AT WELLHEAD SITE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : RNL SITE INSP. 03/10/87, REMAINING POSSIBLE COMPLETE, DISPOSAL SITE UNKNOWN. / / : REFERRED TO CACHD, D. SIBLEY, 12/14/86; TELECON 12/17/86, CACHD, CLEANUP REQUIRED, SPILLER NOT IDENTIFIED. / / : RNL SITE INSP. 02/25/87, WORK TOTALLY UNSATISFACTORILY, CAIN GAVE OUT TICKET; TELECONS 02/26/87, CZYZ TO DO WORK; LEGAL REFERRAL. / / : RNL SITE INSP. 12/23/86, CLEANUP REQUIRED; MEETING CACHD 12/23/86, CLEANUP REQUIRED, CHECK WITH MINR. / / : LETTERS 01/14/87 AND 01/20/87, REPLY 01/30/87 - NG; RNL SITE INSP. 02/09/87, NO WORK DONE; 02/09/87, BECI, W. CAIN, TO DELIVER LETTER. / / : RNL SITE INSP. 03/10/87, REMAINING POSSIBLE COMPLETE, DISPOSAL SITE UNKNOWN; LETTER 03/25/87, REPLY 04/10/87 - _____.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

/ / : RNL SITE INSP. 08/06/87, NO FURTHER WORK POSSIBLE OR NECESSARY, CHECK WITH LEGAL FOR LEGAL REFERRAL. / / : RNL SITE INSP. 03/10/87, REMAINING POSSIBLE COMPLETE, DISPOSAL SITE UNKNOWN; LETTER 03/25/87, REPLY 04/10/87 - NG, NO REPLY. 01/15/88: RNL DISCUSSION WITH BECI, W. CAIN, 01/15/88, FINE PAID BY SPILLER, NO FURTHER ACTION BY SPILL UNIT REQUIRED, LEGAL REFERRAL TO BE DROPPED.

Page 385

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 386

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DESERT GAS EXPLORATION CO API WELL #31-013-18604

Spill Number: 8605903

Close Date: 11/20/1987

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: DESERT GAS EXPLORATION CO Spiller Phone: (716) 672-2177 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/08/1986 11/20/1987 VANDALISM UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: VANDALS OPENED VALVE ON STOCK TANK, RELEASING APPROX. 210 BARRELS OF BRINE & 1 BARREL OF CRUDE OIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : SPILLER CLEANING UP;MINR MONITORING CLEANUP. / / : RNL SITE INSP. 12/23/86, ADDITIONAL CLEANUP NEEDED; RNL SITE INSP. AND MEETING 01/08/87, FURTHER WORK NEEDED AND AGREED TO BY SPILLER. / / : TELECON 01/23/87, MINR, B. JANDREAU, WORK UNDERWAY. / / : TELECON 01/23/87, MINR, B. JANDREAU, WORK UNDERWAY; RNL SITE INSP. 04/09/87, ADDITIONAL CLEANUP NECESSARY. / / : RNL MEETING CHCHD 07/29/87, S. JOHNSON, M. VENDETTI HAD FOUND ADDITIONAL CONTAMINATION, FURTHER CLEANUP REQUIRED. / / : RNL SITE INSP. 11/22/87, SITE CLEAN, NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED, LETTER SENT TO SPILLER 11/23/87. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: CRUDE OIL AND BRINE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 387

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

LCP CHEMICAL - INDIAN RES ROUTE 11A

Spill Number: 8606579

Close Date: 08/11/1987

ONONDAGA NATION, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13120 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: LCP CHEMICAL Spiller Phone: (315) 487-4716 Notifier Type: Responsible Party Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: UNASSIGNED Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 01/26/1987 08/11/1987 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected BRINE OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: TEXAS BRINE. TERRY DURAN OF LCP CHEMICAL NOTIFIER 315-487-4716. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was " " / / : DICK ANDERSON AT SCENE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 388

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

SUMA INC. RT 60

Spill Number: 8606855

Close Date: 02/06/1987

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: TANK TRUCK Spiller: SUMA INC. Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Police Department Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: ROSS Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/06/1987 02/06/1987 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: NO REMARKS GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "LQR" / / : STEVE JOHNSON CHCHD CONTACTED,NO CLEAN UP NECESSARY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 389

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

ACCIDENT - TRUCK UNKNOWN COUNTY ROAD 22

Spill Number: 8602078

Close Date: 07/10/1986

ANDOVER, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14806 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL VEHICLE Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/26/1986 07/10/1986 TRAFFIC ACCIDENT UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected SALT BRINE OTHER 1000 GALLONS 0 GALLONS GROUNDWATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: TRUCK ACCIDENT, BRINE SOAKED INTO GROUND -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : REFERRED TO MINR 6/26/86, SUZAN MALLETTE. / / : REFERRED TO MINR, SUZAN MALLETTE, 06/26/86; TELECON 07/10/86, MINR, J. YAROSZ, SATISFIED, NO CLEANUP

POSSIBLE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 390

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

UNKNOWN RT 46 & RT 49

Spill Number: 8604122

Close Date: 09/26/1986

ROME C, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: STATE HWYS 46 / 49 Revised zip code: 13440 Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: UNKNOWN Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Citizen Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: UNASSIGNED Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/25/1986 09/26/1986 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN SOIL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: RAILROAD TRACKS NEAR RT 46 & 49 - ABOUT 100’ AROUND PIPE ALL VEGATATION IS DEAD - NEAR UNNAMED STREAM -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was " " 2004/02/19 - Spill_Time was previously blank and replaced with RCVD_Time to fix a data translation problem... Bob Corcoran / / : OLD GAS WELL, HIGH CONCENTRATION OF SALT. / / : 09/26/86 - UPON INVESTIGATION IT WAS DETERMINED SITE WAS ABANDONED GAS WELL, COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 391

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

DESERT GAS EXPLORATION CO CHAUTAUQUA ROAD

Spill Number: 8605676

Close Date: 05/01/1987

GERRY, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14740 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: DESERT GAS EXPLORATION CO Spiller Phone: (716) 672-2177 Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 12/05/1986 05/01/1987 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: TWO GALLONS OF CRUDE OIL AND 700 GALLONS OF BRINE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : TELECON 12/05/86, MINR., S. MARLOTTE, TO INSPECT. / / : TELECON 12/05/86, MINR., S. MARLOTTE, TO INSPECT; TELECON 12/18/86, MINR, B. JANDREAU, CLEANUP UNDERWAY AND SATISFACTORY. / / : COMPLETE 05/01/87, SEE SPILL #865903, CLEANED UP BY SPILLER. 09/29/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: CRUDE OIL AND BRINE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 392

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

CORDOBA RESOURCES INC. BLAKESLEY HOLLOW ROAD

Spill Number: 8604027

Close Date: 09/29/1986

OLEAN, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 14760 Source of Spill: COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL Spiller: CORDOBA RESOURCES INC. Spiller Phone: (716) 672-2962 Notifier Type: DEC Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: LEARY Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/19/1986 09/29/1986 EQUIPMENT FAILURE UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected CRUDE OIL PETROLEUM 150.00 GALLONS 100.00 GALLONS SURFACE WATER -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OIL FIELD PIPELINE FAILURE -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "RNL" / / : TELECON 09/19/86, MINR, J. YAROSZ, RESPONDING; TELECON 09/22/86 WITH MINR, J. YAROSZ, CLEANUP UNDERWAY AND SATISFACTORY. / / : MINERALS REPONDING 09/19/86. / / : SITE INSPECTION OF CREEK 09/22/86, CREEK WAS CLEAN; TELECON 09/23/86, MINR, J. YAROSZ, CLEANUP UNDERWAY AND SATISFACTORY.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 393

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

PAT FINLEY 108 ARSENAL SQ

Spill Number: 8604232

Close Date: 10/02/1986

ROME C, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: 13440 Source of Spill: PRIVATE DWELLING Spiller: PAT FINLEY Spiller Phone: (315) 339-5739 Notifier Type: Fire Department Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: AJMARSCH Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 09/30/1986 10/02/1986 OTHER UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN AIR UNKNOWN PETROLEUM PETROLEUM 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: OLD GAS WELL, PLUG IS LEAKING -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was "JM" / / : 10/01/86 - RECOMMENDED TEMPORARY PLUG UNTIL MORE PERMANENT SOLUTION CAN BE IMPLEMENTED. 10/02/86 - REFERRED MR. FINLEY TO MINERAL RESOURCES. / / : 10/02/86 - COMPLETE.

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 394

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

BATH PETROLEUM STORAGE BATH PETROLEUM STORAGE FA

Spill Number: 8504495

Close Date: 06/01/1986

BATH, NY NO ZIP PROVIDED

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: NO CHANGE Revised zip code: UNKNOWN Source of Spill: UNKNOWN Spiller: Spiller Phone: Notifier Type: Other Notifier Name: Notifier Phone: Caller Name: LEO JACOBUS Caller Agency: Caller Phone: DEC Investigator: UNASSIGNED Contact for more spill info: Contact Person Phone: -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 02/21/1986 06/01/1986 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NO MATERIAL INFORMATION GIVEN FOR THIS SPILL -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SURFACE SPILLAGE FROM WATER BUTANE/SEPARATOR DURING WELL CAVERN CLEANOUT PROCEDURES - DISCHARGE NOT PERMITTED UNDER SPDES. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was " " / / : VIOLATIONS AND LEGAL ACTION: SPDES VIOLATION LETTER TO BE SENT BY T. PEARSON. / / : NOTES: FACILITY OF 2 20 MIL. GALS. BRINE STORAGE PONDS AND 6 WELL LPG AND BUTANE.

RESERVOIRS W/TOTAL CAPACITY OF 33.9 GALS OF

/ / : ACTION: BATH F.D. & NAT. RES. WORKED W/BATH PETROL. STORAGE CO. TO MONITOR & READILY-EXPLO. MAY HAVE BEEN FROM SOILPLAN.

MITIGATE SEPARATION; BUTANE VAPORIZES

/ / : STATUS: JM (CLOSED) 86/05/06 INDUSTRIAL SPDES SECTION AND NATURAL RESOURCES TO FOLLOWUP AND MONITOR SATURATION CLEANUP COMPLETE. / / : EXTENT OF SPILL: EXPLOSION - OFFICE BUILDING. 09/28/95: This is additional information about material spilled from the translation of the old spill file: BUTANE/WATER MIXTURE

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

Page 395

HAZARDOUS MATERIAL SPILLS INFORMATION REQUEST

P & C MARKET P & C FOOD MARKET

Spill Number: 8501043

Close Date: 06/01/1986

CLYDE, NY 14433

ADDRESS CHANGE INFORMATION Revised street: P / C FOOD MARKET, COLUMB Revised zip code: Source of Spill: Notifier Type: Caller Name: DEC Investigator:

UNKNOWN Other RICHARD BARD Unassigned

Spiller: UNKNOWN Notifier Name: SAME Caller Agency: WAYNE CO FIRE COORD Contact for more spill info:

Spiller Phone: Notifier Phone: SAME Caller Phone: Contact Person Phone:

Category:

Known petroleum or hazardous material release with minimal potential for fire/explosion (indoors or outdoors), drinking water contamination, or releases to surface waters. Class: Willing RP - DEC Field Response - Corrective Action Initiated, Taken Over, or Completed by RP or Other Agency -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Spill Date Date Cleanup Ceased Cause of Spill Meets Cleanup Standards Penalty Recommended 06/12/1985 06/01/1986 UNKNOWN UNKNOWN NO -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Material Material Quantity Quantity Resource(s) Spilled Class Spilled Units Recovered Units Affected NATURAL GAS OTHER 0.00 UNKNOWN 0.00 UNKNOWN AIR -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Caller Remarks: SUSPECTED LEAKING NATURAL GAS WELL THAT WAS DRILLED 100+ YEAR AGO; P & C FOOD BUILDING IS ALLEGEDLY BUILT ON TOP OF ABANDONED GAS WELL. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DEC Investigator Remarks: Prior to Sept, 2004 data translation this spill Lead_DEC Field was " ". 2004/02/19 - Spill_Time was previously blank and replaced with RCVD_Time to fix a data translation problem... Bob Corcoran. / / : NOTES: SEND COPY TO SANDY BRENNAN. / / : CLEANUP ACTION: MAINS/LINES. MINERAL RESOURCES’ ROMULUS CELAN IS INVESTIGATING SITUATION AND WILL FOLLOW THROUGH WITH FIRE COORDINATOR; TELEPHONE CONVERSATION 85-06-12. / / : CONTAINMENT ACTION: NYS ELECTRIC & GAS CO HAS CHECKED ALL GAS MAINS AND FIRE

COORDINATOR IS CONFIDENT THAT GAS CO

Copyright 2009 Toxics Targeting, Inc. November 02, 2009

HAS SATISFACTORY RULED OUT LEAKING GAS. NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY BY SPILLS UNIT. 03/30/06: PAPER FILE REMOVED PER FILE RETENTION POLICY.

Page 396