Criminal Law Answers 2007

2OO7 BAR EXAMTNATION

( 1O% 1

d.

inpii6onnent/d€stiem

and:

llo!'ol

A,' fi ror4t.d dr t'qr!,trr, Ahnd,( !, \as anor!,nose

aresr'd

/

ia thc c d*6.

J.nlt.

or th. .ommt..io

,rsrlo!

rld

.roEth.! coE4itr.n ea3 coftphcy

tolt.F .monl

ped..ttun h. cau..t o! th. Evc' though thc d.ath a.ctdcntal, it i! .lougb tb.t 'r. mmi8slo! or tn€ .obt€F

'P.orl€ r c,idrar, 12escR s3e ll93a).

lv (lo%) Macky,a *cun$ guard,arnrd ho'n.lar€ on. nishl ailer aDdcrin8 ovenim.

h e n s o r 1 1 , .v d i n

]nden'nity.v.n rtrrlcr? E*Prainyou..tr$rr

t.t

{., th. coun dl't not rd con..tly i!

/

v (ror4 dc.rt7ePnn 6a2Ire41ll tbt

ba*hnest

/dcsd€rrc)

i

"' 3lilfflfii -*:1'-il.'*'*'-.**

lq

whic seninE his senience, Macky enteEd the ]jiohibii.d.ifuandhadapot*ssionvrihhr'

l Jo r s s'srcn .

fuac.on,Jic€incFsciiDlbal|iahtlltgln

." ocma.o *p.ary uvnr,*

ar.".

or !s. or prolriDited substarce hdbldu.'

aG

i"

"r

}6;

{bl No, Mrckyi! not etrtiu€d rnd46ninato senbnce kw (Ad 4ro3, as ancndedlfor

*a!."dyDp'aQlgh.Ea"a.nsna6. p"a"'P**l"th."d.ptl..--.k'.".1

drug by a tust period or s'l (6) nonth3 ls.c, ls, R,A. e15s). Thc

a! ac.onpric.

*"*,.

"

is$bjccredtoa eendd one ib*"'.D',.".-l

**p-**r**",r,"

"-a,,.i

s.duccd hrr deu4ndrlr. iaRl

Nhat ar. tnc three {3l.las.so

vI lro%l

sucoEstE rJtswsx: lbl rhe tnEc {31.l$tc. rr.: qu.nn d r.dfttr.n

orofi.ld.-

i! tn'

'rld'

or

!v'r .Frcn d.!d tntru'!" 1. T!.r. 'ho prL.t tho !! . trre rl.tlm, .!.! 'ct' " tlb. d r t"'!'r .'lrt'.r o( ah. .rtltucl b ; tic mnoor PhE th. 't vl.tl! '!Fu''lr 2.

bv.o!'utul!rt A breth.r or Gd!&'t r. h.r u!or.; .trir thcvt tlm, .uch

l' l, c l t i 4 . t h . B

or

I! Pho d. r.g.!d.it ! "it'4'tlo" t& elctrE 'nl"tr4 coind.nctdi!d6:.'.Lsdby@bk or thc .rm. honr.hord' .u.h r. n'rsltoLt b.ro.r. rndbodd.B lrvht dd'r th' r'b' houehord rth. vktrr' rcoi lndstth$d.

3. rh.!.

s,!cEs'ED,l\Ef,/tRj

c.EEit

,,

..qr

Pc$!q.'o!;

tutc ..dldoDr

'trch Uturbgedtror md.,.p..ch.. or cl'ld.t|nq r.lfur. rb.r. rgatrt i bo cftrlD.lr of t6G of xr dur, coudtlkd tub d €trtEct uG !.rolr!rc. oroft.rrttu! kndto-tlclh.th.IroehJrld64tfo' rncitr!3

th. th.

..1.

tn.oustr

l3l cr.n.3 or of|n comhuniiy or of tn. cov.rnmelti or .vn rn

I

d..r

lAn. r42, R.v. p€nat codcl.

vII troyo)

succ4sTEprlrswERi e n t , r h . o n r vc r i E . r t a t F ! No, the convlctionrormud.rslourd h. coltlq,

rhe victiE

dtb..urtrro.n, tic f*t.

.ho'

bclt vc.l !o hvc cur or co$id€.ilg tht lenIre s death r$ tn€ L€rxq dtul dorc hy tb. d i! hr u l.giuqt., th.

owado!€ condu.t.d on the victj!,.

tbc "hciEg t

ft!.r"

rb e c d n e o t c * a f ' , h i c " - . s . ' k * - d . - . ' j 4 ' rb o rE rt c o r*h 1 4 p 6 0 f orink FLrplr.trktion ot th. dount inv.lved, En!t€w., drolas or irtlnt to cause deEaae ,r!.,dl r!.

rb.y Ir .uch "raIadn" oi l..ts.. dosD.nt'dlbr'c..lErcolof

pas , coEE.rct.l

su*alith.€shfa l2t sepa.at. cnE€s ar.

ALIERNAIIVEANS|'ER:

lrocooddofthc n.€ niu m5 only physicat.rctjuddical,

-J po$e$ton, ud h,vilg coeEittc.t th. crrEd stth srrv. abusc or coffidcnce, it 13{trn r.d tn.ft.

rmp,ud.ncc R.3urrins ro L.sseiious nncc rb.phrd.a'injuh3req

physrcer rrjud;,,

c.in. tron tho tbcft

sdoE

tro74

Butrd)p.intd hi3cun d de onrush orFople

Phy3rar injuie3,

whenrh.

1. s.arc them oIf Hsler, n.nb{s.

th. buller hit onc ot th. n.ral n hn ona of th. .tag. cr.w c.usins injuries 8h

wharfim4sd'd

be.

tro%) Pln$( vas a t.s& ora narkd $an lnned br ciovan.i whcn Pidrr rcr6.d to p6y h.r rcrr. ob\z."i ;ajkd ene

Raracrconmit?D\TbhyoD.anNd

wh,' .rim./s dld ciol,nni coo s.cunty

sical ldurlcr. R.frcl sudd ala d3 o! du9 stc! hc dlch*s.d

lr ! thc

sUccEs"'D,^lsfi1ERj

m!1, t. ollth. lnnty iD pu.hi4 'rd romrrd, thcrcby

d ,o as xnju*

cted towardr r rartlcurir P3Eonwhcnthe {ircarmwas ilischerec{t. Eowevcr, the phydcal lnludes re$nhs dGcha.geoft h. rirerrm betny

from thc

is ligf,t coercion

eca*Dn.

grlvc .6crcion. ,lbcnlly in favor.f roDld b. .grt!!t

th. off.o fo' s'e€ th. ofreder.

cocrcjon. b.cr8€

ir

iwdcalthat it may not be

2006 BAR EXAMINAAION I or r.nrrr esaihr

rnd th.rrb[r(s

or ur. p.ir.ifr'ds

d reqftedb jurlfyconil.lonor.lr..used?

crve

Preot of Eotlv. b ror r.qurred 4

nrhcrc thc ofa.nd.r b pGittv.ty

td.nt|h€d

or

Dl hu !.r'ttt.d rhc coDErs.ton of th. crl&. F.opl. v. Y@rg, 133 ACRA 26 1193.1]ctrhC pcopt. v. R..ror. .t. .I., 94 SCR 4r2I1930Dr

r{

cl

wb.r.

d)

crheE tn. c.tm. rs th. p

t!€

c.lmc commtttcd

l whencmaFlljttu rn rriA rctalM

Ir r ncrsn

ireDresnhn!iiitriscounrry

aN d\rrrrnB. r€sidence.or otl r,d'g linbl.Ior rEpa$ to dry.Dh{, 2 5!

Yc., m srhs |ny h. t.4any E€d