Civil Law Answers 2007

2OO7 BAR EXAMII{ATION I

(irI

o!!ulaionr

{al

occupdio!ca!t*cprrceorrysit}rc.!..tt.

Fosrssion

l5ol,)

.n|.|ldrofproP.rt',rh.the. omct. occuprtioD ib.li rL.n l"otaattrc,

cotuwtrtie

ana

co.t oJthr .'hlr1ppr^aJteee.dl , wt. 4 p. .aq. !4C!4SEa41@4!EE& orrcquidlgom6ntrD O.dFtionltrorrcrlrled. 7r2, ,\Ecl. Thi!$ .pp{pdrbr. lrr*. Ell3 tLrt src tl. ou..t of huntt4 anit fishi!8, hrild.n .up{tor lr{d, 713, rrcc). 6y oc.rp

rion lart, 714. rccI

.hlne or th€ eljoynent ora ils nccpt of. hordcrl,{d. 525,

sEcoxp!r?rRi[4fl

vElu{sqrE!:

o.crpitto! t6 r moitc or acqulri l Flruro orco.porcar tlilgrelt tn. d Int.ntron or i.qitrrns or|ttn.lmodc.facqlililg@.

I r. nalllls by th. oc.u!.nt b.cd. tn 6n.r tbclFf,

sL.

h& t!.

Int.ltion

to

:

0 L, rhich sas m.hoEd I

thrrtorth..'jornear6t.rislt, r.d n4t ofF-.r.ro! drrc

Por.crtonmayb.tle

Illesar and inpo$ibr. onerc!sdondion (s./4

o|i

novab.. Drop.rly./

slJclolsleD/.Jlf,s0EE

JlsPo'sid.ndi'I}rche rnong t!.ba.t d!ht.ororner.nlp. ttr. Frl rtght or colc.lt of om.', bur .*i..t 6 ..tuh |lnft.tb4 rr ur dt ! irto ton ovmrrhlF or ah. thin! oi pro!.ny rialt thellrr rcquirlttv.pr€.6dpttotrd.D.!dta3olil.tf,.rttt :.r. pr.rcdrtton.ldrietn or.rdrqry d.,(turdhrr t tf,G l. noEbL or l@MU.. l'oFny lbl

.orft no.ab. " h- p.a

to

onditions in a .ibprc @ditioNind

s|rcastrprrrvs!yF,R; .oliUdor t! . .lapl. {b) ![og.l .r.r tEp.r.tbl€ itomtlon.re c.!.ld.ed .. Nt .bdr,tt rofdq b.dkr.4rd.db!i.n doudo!rtdtG !.rt'l lAraLr. 722, Ncc), lnFe.l In u on.@! doatio!.ldr ruul rh. do'ruor {ccr, r raq rhi3 rr rc, bscqut. o!.rour d.nruo!3 tir.r.r. rrc gow.rneit by th. ras on coltr.ck tlrdc!. 733, r{ccJ.

rs.*::.fiili+r""i$.

;ffIt:+i;i:iT'}11l;i##-E U'AENA'I'EA,€WEJI:

#'$"#ffit;ii'ffiL Eoqd.

prep.lt.

rf rh. tntc,Uo!

,{

t. Err..

ih€

i;i":f#:+"r,#i:tnf.:l,rr;::ii*Arerb..quipmcnr ad livinsq! AIGCEStED'IIEI'ERJ

(ro%l ManilaPetokun co o*ned .nd oFdrdl a F{n,rcu nl rMinila 'rhe fa.iirr Lr.s lo.atedon afloaiingplatfom na

rrr*:"t"fr*"fm*lii.lniil*s

pg;ftgi5H**;h*

!n in.c3r.l part ol.r thEonble. Th. pl.tforE is not .t ibbovrbre ProD.rty foith..a thc alorn.tlv. hrpor to rt.b {at,bovo, IN

lrL) mi+pt

or rr{

l.t ac6Btrc

v.t

6rd.t to ..tt'fy

.?es'

&r (consfuctive rust)

trratro ly or lnpl..ur,

.!i!.tD!

th€ d.mr!d!

.

ofjNd... tt do.. lot con. .n bur Ealnjr o!.ntr.n.t satBt on ,!., t, frrd, d6t i!. or hot.t. th. Lg.r right to rioD.rty Euch h. oulht i! .qdty rd go.,t 'or, yap e. cord oJ .o!.cf.rc., to hord lr.rB o/ t-rca'o appeat3, 371 Phir, s23 tlgeet)-

rny p.r.on rnd ho c!u'.s tire legd ndc to

..tablishcd

tr imPucrtlon

of hP tor i!.

ora' obugatlon ofth. St.ntor tot

tath.

or th. it '!.! . .f th€ preP.dy b Ltm.'

;*.brL!"d. rr tnc lu'r,rlb.!t obltgttro. tr oltcred bt th. 3n!io' r...nY€rrn 4. rn|crc

145s lncc *bicl

rE*rG..

.t otn.i alr'ttrE "wh.! .nY td'b., rcrltbnrhir holittns a fi'rcdrlt on r. urttrudtu l. ror tb. nw.trr.. ortop.dv to b. ![d. to rrd dir3.. tn. colv.yrnc. tho p.ronto lbl

rhom th. fulil. t.Ion! "

docmnc or discortr.d Penl llas .L'!r ch.t(r

tb) Thc docttn. or ri:r cl.r

ur't 3.vdDr dist!'-l

chrprr

or ordinary jrdl.hl

rcgbintlon

of

R.A_ {o. 26 gd.E,

lro.ccdbgs,

3ilddc*ov€dd'!'n&of

judrcial r€colsrrhttor ,

.f

sectio! ro3 eovc.n! r.gbtntio Lrod

aE.nitcd, oth.mt!.

.3

scctioDlo4!ov.6tr.!ishtio!ofc.nfic'3 rnd p.t'ntr .mrnciprtto! Aw.rit Lind o*n.Ebt! lclo^l of c.nific'tc, Ldd R€lorm Lr*' und€i thc conPrch.Btvc chapterv gov.r!! tL. rcgbhtrot

no4rqofee&

"corirra!!, Frur. ro n

EtErc rtra

cb.nh.kindoubtrubqh.ra

of'ollltrv {bl

h6f.B'E.n'rl.!'1.*es.po

what pmpetues arc ror rt:sisrabtc? supply thb inrorDdDn

d*".gl

hrcLdary chaF& '

l" i--.* .ft

""

EsG

slJccEs?tD,,\lsP*j P) rhc rouoeilE prepe*rc6 s,c not !.sistrahtc:

nr govcn3

a.-.t. u**a*

judicial &rdcmclt

3.

of e*atcs

oro

!)

coltulsorY

3$rcrd.i

tl

bc'dm.nt

and altehtio

'",,ri.-br.

r."d,"rrh" !,btr d.-,r":

ALTERNATNE ANSWER:

"--*. cl

R.pla.cmcni

or ron or du

'..r

r..brrrrion t4{i.r. aro

rcn,-atia*.

v

;,i"#Hiilr#il..i#v*"r:tr'::#i:T;; or cr's6tlhd $

tore,*

bs€'

rcrcn'd

be hr

or

:;:*:fitlffi]lff.'l:x'n:'ll:x;i113,?lJi.",Li'; ih" A;bri. !."d ad, .".h r" "r .od Ehau n.tb.3ubj.ct

toocclprtior'

d'

t'r&

'!trv

tlrt 4. h gcn.ral, ill r.ndr or u!. Publl. domin etr.mbl. rnd.ti.P.rbl.

Eip o r b n d t h * n m

i'*a"a tv tt'.

liiii'J i";,;.". ".' "*"*"

,

-or

th.se lan& arc inatr Bbl. hrv.

{r0o,6t ", ,:

_ i .b,;;,.,,

."i-.:tt;.1:..,:il?*T ,^", ;3lH:i:"";:l:::1,1Xffi 3'so|utlonlnd.bltl:'

5. .tr otn , obxsnttonI .ri: ins fr.F r.r, AI.?ERNATI?DAnl6WER:

#$* $H""-f$$lli:3;i;

*t*s**$f

*.1i*itT*1i*rri*

Thtrd.{611.,

l. slEaxitlottt€

tdr.ns.

oft!.

sLIGGa''ED'IJ\EWER:

Ot. Ltt.r .b.ll tt.e. r rlaht to claid th. {m. &oD tL. roi6.i, qnl... tt .Dr.:n tnrt tte s!v. it .ut or /.tr rnd

erd(rrt.2164,ncc).

Fourlh cr.F le, ir rh€a thb otho!.rur r pd.on k injued .nd h. l. k..t.rl or h.lE.it shllc llc t not t! a coniutton to alv. ..nr.r! t. r oontnct, h. th. ..rlc.r .fth. Dhy!r.b! or ot[.r !€Eon rtdint nlm, se6.i..tty lArt, 216t, nccl. Flnh

t!.tuc.

u .brk tr.r rnLoft D oblllld to {trdt u or!h.! or .! l!u!. latutry or .th.i tnn!.!t Fr.d Gru... to arv. rlDFn to it.lttd,.lrtnnn !.nn6.y fu'!l.i .upp.n t tlG e.dy ildilndr.l rith dr+ or r.IDt!*B.nt obx!.d b lirc npFn. ft.b tn. Fror Th. !revt.lorr .l thi. dlcl rrpry d!6 tlr. r.tn r o. 6.ti.r uqiudt of . .bln !!n r.t!ht.n r..'.r{. r.rur.t to.urrod hlE lrd,2166, I{ccl. .r u

VI (roq/ol

ffiffi ffi,f*##;*lo

asl4d Rob.(d l]Annnh.LujsdandBenjaminb be\nhsss Dri'rg rhc drvorth. siE.inc ol comn8 i.om ih.hosPml, clala b,ctcd on thnnE her *i Letngrign.d rrobdraexpcriencedasonachacheandkepr wani.s lb! h.r tuh to sisn ih ererron. \uas 3isnhs

RLnj5frin, aside trcD $ra*sns

run ovc, b\ d dtunk dri\er N

vII

i l :;i l T : l : r: , ' * ' r, h"i ' , "-. "' ' ^is ; i1"i:

ji, i i:ri; ifiHl#hiiffir,;,iii

lubi.ct to tL. ta' of the auitrall. i6 Sovernedhy Phtlip t vot.t tut B.r.ly !ro!.rty

wotdaht€

rI!. bourntrndr

srl crprcity orP.6.!. d. . Ph iltn.r, .v.n though uld€r tidlg abroid lAd. 15 xccl, rhc lge or Eriorlt' tua.., a4 No. 6eoe, Ph'tiDpinc rAq k t3 r..r lR.p.

th.scxu.linfii|clitycoEmitc

io. th€ annutn.nt

of mariag

;'l;li,k-E:ir"li:,; :""ni:;:l{iu#:

i:ii :{il *r-:lltril+i'i stccEs"EDillsBERr

d !***l.".fth.Pt*";

*" -*' iFi;li.'::i:';:Tx;?.1i: ::*::l"JL"iff truG.Julirnro.tTb€lmr'r'a

vlI l l o% )

.. ,, ,,....ii;,

ma t i\ mb \ r

lr r0 3 4

ll "'""; l'' Ll[: ]''i'li"J::':':';ll ,,l:'l;i ' ,,'llll;'', ii: ilill:,,'i,,,,'ll;. it,i:i,,,il l:;,il:i,'illl,' ;. ii.l::.1,""1, iil'i:',i'i",:lLi,, 1."1, i.l'i:],.'1 l;l:;; lllill,",l ',:'l 1i1",1,, llilll:'';l:,l,l""lll sUcGEs?ED]|,€'tiERj

::;::';l:;i:l'i;:"",1 ilr:[ li."':l;'iT.i:Tl:

i',t#tt'riil ."i,',",.:*ii[1ft fiftfl

.q, r.a ._*tcrre .i r,.

pariu4 rhrouEl'cqutrtUvcF 1132 ot tf,. N€q ctv code, eftruhr.

of mohbt.3

i! so.d r.rthand ror€tshrtare.-, "1h"*"*d"i.." e" ona.- tI" " - - t.tt.t* " .r pcr.r.tor ir the co.c.pt of ohe, and ofl!.t titl. ror

hr r n$!

1 t 21 e. lchl

ALIERMfIVE

ALEY]EIJ

d lan drthc abovE

r.

al

an€xiajudici,tdeFd3{:

b)

avorunrary dcposit:

cl

a nece3sary depositr

dl

ad.pdit{ithrwrrcnous.i'ni

cl

t.tt.r.

a ald b

dl

ar orthc abovc:

{l

lencE a ardb

sqps4slE4lls!!E& 3.

d

llrl ofthe abolel

' i*tllil"'li.l':# ffi *lt*f

trot.: It.d4&s.nldorem Lrq It l. th.Fron suEg.*€d tht c.m.rcl.l b. 8tv.! turr crcdit rdi tb. eo trr .n8t...3 oI tb.L.!!EB.l it€D -a.rdlc.r

r' s h . l | ' . 1 . | ' . I r c o l t . d c cbrr''Tbnbb.ou. p.endtc!.rrd.rio!o.r, rld th. rd.Dt d. rh. &. !.Eo!

(ro%t

r.'

b.d..!th..ddtd or FpFslhlor

h. n rcpEr.lttrs

md arE of tir 6f,.UrB.lerd . h4rr b.lr-or jy p.;od,€ser

.nd pro{:;duhl rcquirdEcnis h FYior to their ln rs?o, Ranon and llcssa cot Bafi.d Dra'nacc.Ramor had n child, Anna ln 1971 dd 1972, tumo;and Dessa lcsauy adopled ch.rrv md Michellc d $ hil. sivilg b th to ranv Anna nc!.r na.ri.d. chenf ontbc orlrerhand, lesallYadolr.d shcllt L€rv had siN Han3 iona ln 2oo5 r\l]m r,JrY,

Ramobud.r &. rclo992 0t(h. x., ctwll-codc. B.Ing|lr8!ldur.hxcEn'rbs r.duo.k r.r{r% of r.r,r. r}. u.!rde!k rd! chjdr!.fir,ry rr. bftd ftom lln dtle aD r'..l@ hoE niD.!. ALIBRA,|T']'EAI'EPI.N:

1.

2,

Mthelr.,a3anadoptedchlr .httd or lubon $ a lcgldnrt. child. Mlch.llo hI' dl tno rlght .rlna Fecti.n ta, Do^esdc adoPtbn ku)

gov.'n.d ts th. ner ciwil ds, hurband rnd Ptfe not j.rr ysitn thc oth€i -er. bro to constru.tnc us€ ot

Lii sill tnhqdt i3 herr.lfiu.tittmrt.-

sh. Ffl

r Art 9o2, Ncc

of tubo!.. ir.lrdlrr. d.qbhr aritrouchrb k D tu.sttrmr. chnd, rh. 11rd brn.d ^s!r. froE t;€dd@ h.r Edb.r anm E !.G.r

2006 BAR EXAMINATION

or ch'rrv sn.uv crdot tnh.rit ln r.pFr.nt.tlon In ju* or ch'fv chrftt u adort.'t 13 ah.|]y be.eB. h;at h.r.ortbc p.rd

h. b rcprcGdrrstut.rrc

dtb!

l" .. or sh.llt' 'hn"b' k;i b.r, o'ch.ry ty v'd* o AdoFlon cr.rt.i. t'Bod r'ld a lcur h.k.fRrnon rdopriosprr.'tudrr..dott.d rer"-tororrh.Fontb. R .0 6 l r e6sll Micb.llc umot tntr.dt lrod Rr e8 rdolt.d nor hv R!no! brtbv D.s IE ti"t" .b''r n Eon.t.lr. c.!s rt. u-la. t ".t-loat k lot a Ltd h.n of &m!. ao6 to tnl'dt tu. .!il Gi.t.l u. !d .!trtl.d ncc' 90:l d bt ln|cl. r'h'dt rrt, tb.v.rtr!.t nr6.! *Lrr*..rth.|'rrth.rL'rt. . hdrh"e "-1h. f.tn'i ti.l6stdE:tc r..Lgitt-." "fl-F -t.tl*,

I undd ?i\icre 2 t3 of the Fmily code rc .h d under 7 y.rB or aAc shall b{ scparated rrom ihe lnothcr uless t}e cou nn.ls conp€lungrcasonsro .dt . orheMse. ll)

DrTlarnthc ddonale or rhrs prcvtston. 2.5%

Th. rrtioldc oftb. prevt lo! b 7yaold...d.thclor.Grt.IEeblch.dylt

tlt r cHrd b.tot not|rd

c! gv.. ra. rdfc or tn. cbrld k er*! tn. Ii€t D.ro.r9 &d .!. t'r.E.r of tb€ .Litd PEEL ou

ot'comp.ltbg @E12) Grrc at 161 3 @pt.s Pr ch Jatrt rhc taldng aEy lDnr rrE mothd s rusrody of hd ch,ld unrt r7y.dofagc. 2.5%

Tn. lolro'r'3 h!r. b.€! coBrd.r.d s -co6p.Irhg to d.Drtv. r mo6.r oacutody: (rl rcgt.ct, {r) '.oo!.' (al loso*tity rhr.lo@.!t. (E'pirft u {3) u€Eproyb.rt, (5) dcololLD, !. ca, 242 scR 362ltsssD, (5) drus (n mrtr.ltDclt, (9) .ddbno!, ltthty {3) tns.rrty, coDdut..bl. ..dou. dtr..sc. lro) gny. phrsrcar burtrc.p, (r r) erlou' ud cr.drbb tnrc.t rry th. cnxd to hllm Uetf lt&DEbdnomr ! Dothc.ltda u, cA.

u Saul, a narted m, had d adnuerols rcl.lion Mrh TBsrc. ln onc of $c trFts, Sau lrrr,lotmnrc Amed drb a eun, Ce c shot saul h a ni ot .rh.n'rJrarousy, n.dly klllhg hh. Fou l1)yca6 atcr lhc