Black's Police Monitor Complaint

X5^5jjPT%D^

1 Office of the Police Monitor

-

>*'n P°'ice Department

Internal Affairs Division /VJfclll^y^NA M JK*"SB! \\0 Rutherford Ln, Bldg. 1, Ste 200 I* |Sp'^Tfl i f P.O. B o x 689001 \ • / / Austin, Texas 78768-9001 \\ W1/ / (512) 974-8501

1520 Rutherford Ln, Bldg. 1 , Ste 200A P.O. Box 1088 Austin, TX. 78767 (512)974-9090 (512) 974-6306 Fax

Police Oversight Complainant Contact Form To initiate a complaint, please complete this form and deliver, fax or mail it to Office of the Police Monitor (OPM). This form will be used by the Internal Affairs Division of the Austin Police Department in its investigation of your complaint. After the OPM has received your completed form, a member of the OPM will contact you to explain the details of the complaint process and to schedule an OPM assessment meeting and ~n IAD interview with you. Today's Date and Time: ^ JH J CF\: 0 COMPLAINANT ^ Name: ^XXr^v

Ch

v

^— \O\^€^C

Race (optional)

fo be filled in by the OPM or IAD)

Date of Birth:

"

Age:

NA/hJto

City!

Hispanic Asian/Hlipino

American Indian uther

Phone' (

CX^A

/

*~*C\(\e :~CA. )

Zip: ^"Kc-S

) 5- b \^ctL cil € u^^°- <-***-(

Drivers Lie. or ID//.

£ Vc^^cL

^v

V^^'

Address: \

Plar*

INCIDENT Location: V \C3 o

Sex: M / h )

wXCj^Cf-cyi/xs^.

St:

o

* ^ \ »_vA

Time: oW1. S-5

Police Report/Citation # £Hj- /O^ ^-^40 *O^i-llUn

•fct Oc| - / / 4? 007 | (^,gHL^ A,^^ •

Ofc^ Subject Q^fiGcr(s): Name: V^v^\\^*^

^"^xW-A

Description: Emp. #\: \--C\J^r\s EmP- #: Description:

Name: VjC3f\^

T

(Give address if known)

Date: QM_V^_O^

rv

'

^^_^t

u?

Race:

Sex:v

Race:

Sex: W\:

•/Vfr^ O

Emp. #:

Officer Witness(es): Name:

Emp. #:

Description:

Race:

Sex:

Name:

Emp. #:

Description:

Race:

Sex:

Civilian Witness(es): Name: Address:

D.O.B. or Age:

Race: Phone:

Sex:

Name: Address:

D.O.B. or Age:

Race: Phone:

Sex:

II

IAD # 2009-1053 ***********************************************************************************************************

State of Texas

AFFIDAVIT County of Travis ***********************************************************************************************************

Before me the undersigned authority personally appeared who states under oath: Sara Black I have been informed that under the Penal Code of the State of Texas, if a person knowingly/and/or intentionally provides false information in a sworn affidavit they may be subject to criminal prosecution for a violation of Texas Penal Code Sections 37.02 (Peri^iry), 37.03 (Aggravated Perjury), and/or Section 37.08 (False Report). Initial Here: *V^ (Complainant) My name is Sara Black. My date of birth is My mailing address is POB 49175, Austin, Texas 78721. My email address is s black91(a)vahQo.com. The complainant did not want to provide her telephone number or a copy of my driver's license. Today's date is August 7, 2009. The time is 1:45 p.m. I am at the Office of The Police Monitor, 1520 Rutherford Lane, Bldg. 1, Suite 200, Austin, TX 78754, giving my statement to Complaint Specialist, Carmen Scott. I want to make a complaint on Austin Police Department employee Don Fields with open records, Detectives Melissa Stanford (512-974-5911) and Robert Holsonback (512-974-6610). The dates of the incidents I want to complain about are: • April 13, 2009 at 10:25 p.m. See Incident Report #09-1032260. • April 14, 2009 at 2:42 a.m. See Incident Report #2009-1040161. • April 15, 2009 at 8:56 p.m. See Incident Report #09-1052076. • April 26, 2009 at 12:26 p.m. See Incident Report #09-1160071. • April 27, 2009; see email to Detective Sanford. • On May3, 2009, at 1:52 a.m. See Incident Report #09-1230284.

My complaints are: 1) Detectives Melissa Sanford and Robert Holsonback didn't properly investigate the crimes against me by Dawn Hagood. Detective Sanford appeared to withhold my initial report of extortion and being shaken down by Dawn. On or about June 5, 2009, I requested a copy of the police report through APD Open Records but, I didn't get it. I did a follow up request but, APD said they didn't have it. I called Chief Acevedo and

1

then suddenly they had my follow up request. They only have ten days to provide it to me but, it took Don Fields longer than forty days to provide this information to me. During a follow up request, an APD employee in Open Records named Maria said there was no record of my follow up request but, that Don Fields would be back the following Monday. Don Fields did not provide my requested information in a timely manner. 2) I had a copy of the rental agreement to prove Dawn was shaking me down for more money and committing extortion but, Detective Sanford never asked for a copy of it. Detective Sanford told me she would only investigate the theft of my notebook not extortion. 3) APD vigorously looked for Dawn's alleged stolen car but, didn't do the same to assist me with my complaints of extortion by Dawn. 4) Sometime after April 26, 2009, Dawn's father propositioned me with $250 if I left the house that day. If the detectives would have interviewed me they would have known all this information. 5) On May 14, 2009, Detective Holsonback sent an email to me where he states he will conduct this investigation in the same manner that he conducts all of the other investigations, which is "from a neutral position"..., and "will file any all charges against any person for which he has sufficient probable cause". When Detective Holsonback's theft case fell apart, because there was no theft, he did not pursue charges against them for false reporting against me. Instead, Detective Holsonback just ended it. 6) I contacted APD four times about the false police report against me. However, Detective Holsonback didn't respond to this until the white false victim contacted him. 7) On May 19, 2009, I emailed Detective Sanford to find out if her report was done because I needed I copy of it. Detective Sanford responded via email and said she will close the case at my (the complainants) request. I needed the police report from Detective Sanford to show what the officer's observed at the scene, why I wanted APD to investigate Dawn for Extortion and to show all this at the eviction hearing. 8) On or about June 12, 2009, I received the auto theft report and Detective Holsonback's report on the theft of money. This shows how vigorously APD pursed these investigations but, not mine. 9) Racial allegation; APD saw Dawn (a white female) walk out of my (black female) bedroom on the night I called to report extortion and the threatening behavior by Dawn but, APD didn't do anything to her; she was not arrested. Dawn is allowed to get away with all this bad behavior.

Narratives to support my complaints On April 13, 2009 at 10:25 p.m. APD responded to 1103 Richardine Ave., Austin, TX. See Incident Report #09-1032260. One of the officers that responded was Officer Perez. Officer Perez told my landlord / roommate, Dawn Hagood, that she couldn't do the things that she was do to me, like trying to get me out that night. The other officer wanted to know if there was a place they could take me but, I declined their request. Detective Melissa Sanford is associated with this complaint and date. See Incident Report #2009-1040161. On April 14, 2009, at 2:42 a.m., I called APD because Dawn put my food in bags, threw them outside my bedroom door and opened the ketchup bottle in the bag, which got all over my food. She said here's your food and then said the "B" word. Somehow APD rationalized it was okay for Dawn to do all these inhumane things to me without arrest. Officer Perez was one of the Officers that responded again but, didn't arrest Dawn (a white female) for doing what she did to me (a black female). Detective Melissa Sanford is associated with this complaint and date. See Incident Report #09-1052076. On April 15, 2009, at 8:56 p.m., I called APD because Dawn and one woman came upstairs to do whatever to me. No officer conduct is associated with this complaint, I just want to show that the officers came to the residence, left, but didn't arrest Dawn for her conduct towards me. When Detective Sanford and Holsonback looked at the long list of incidents this should have helped Detective Sanford and Holsonback. Why didn't they see Dawn was making false police reports and then see the seriousness of the situation? About April 16, 2009, Dawn said she's gonna kill me and mentioned she had a gun but, she didn't go down stairs to get it. Later, Dawn said she could hire someone to kill me. On April 19, 2009, Detective Sanford emailed me asking for the name of the attorney looking into my complaint against the Texas Workforce Commission. I mentioned this to point out Detective Sanford's interest in this information. See Incident Report #09-1160071. On April 26, 2009, one of Dawn accomplice's called (a woman that was in the home on April 13, 2009) APD at 12:26 a.m. to report I stole her money. Detective Holsonback is associated with this complaint. I called APD three times on April 26, 2009, in reference to solving this false police report. On April 27, 2009, because, although Sanford never got Sanford dated April

I sent an email to Detective Sanford with a description of my notebook she told me she would investigate the theft of my notebook, Detective a description of my notebook. See copy of email to Detective Melissa 27, 2009.

See Incident Report #09-1230284. On May 3, 2009, at 1:52 a.m., Dawn called APD and made a false police report against me. When APD arrived the officer talked to Dawn, came up stairs, looked at me, smiled and left. No officer complaint here, I just want to show a pattern of Dawn's conduct and none of the detectives did anything to properly investigate the matter.

I can read, write, speak and understand the English language and this statement, consisting of four typed pages and six pages that I provided, is true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.

Affiant

Subscribed and sworn to, before me, by the said

xw.

This /^ day of

2009.

Texas Notary

Decembei

Commission expiration date

I have been offered a copy of my statement.

Accepted

Refused

Signature

OPM Staff Member Signature

Date

AUSTIN POLICE DEPARTMENT COMPLETED COMPLAINT SEARCH

Page 1

Date Report Run : Mon, Jun-08-2009

SEARCH CRITERIA: occ_date between TO^DATE('2009-04 -13 00 : 00 : 00 ' , 'YYYY-MM-DD HH24:MI:SS' and TO DATE('2009-05-15 00:00 :00','YYYY-MM-DD HH24:MI:SS') and address like '1103 RICHARDINE%' NUMBER OF RECORDS RETURNED: 11 OFF.DATE Apr-13 -2009 Apr- 14 -2009 Apr- 15 - 2 0 0 9 Apr-15 - 2009 Apr- 15 -2009 Apr-15 -2009 Apr-16 -2009 Apr- 16 -2009 Apr- 2 6-2009 May-03 -2009 May-10 • 2009

TIME 22 :25 02 :42 20:56 21 25 23 00 23 22 01 14 01 21 00 26 01 52 02 40

COMP.tf 46 07 25 52 58 03 19 04 33 39 56

1032260 1040161 1052076 1052134 1052362 1052398 1060107 1060114 1160071 1230284 1300436

TYPE OF CALL-INITIAL/FINAL Disturbance Other Disturbance Other Disturbance Other Information /INF Auto Theft Ser/Auto Theft Auto Theft Ser/Auto Theft Auto Theft Ser/Auto Theft xTHEFT xASSIST COMPLAINANT

LOCATION 1103 1103 1103 1103 1103 1103 1103 1103 1103 1103 1103

RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE RICHARDINE

AVE AVE AVE AVE AVE AVE AVE AVE AVE AVE AVE

AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN AUSTIN

* END OF COMPLETED COMPLAINT SEARCH REPORT *

REPORT 2009- 1032260: 2009- 1040161 , 2009- 1052076 2009- 1052134 2009- 1052362 2009- 1052398 2009- 1060107 2009- 1060114 2009- 1160071 2009- 1230284 2009- 1300436

FOUND

CLEARED BY REPORT WRITTEN SUPPLEMENT WRIT NON- POLICE MATT CALL COMPLETE NO REPORT REPORT WRITTEN NO 911 CALL ENT NO 911 CALL ENT NO REPORT NO 911 CALL ENT

County official with my case - Yahoo! Mail

Page 1 of 1

MAIL County official with rny case

Sunday, April 19, 2009 12:54 AM

From: "S" <[email protected]> To;: [email protected]. us

Dear Det Sanford: Daniel Bradford 854-3718 is the Atty with the county that has my TWC case.

Sincerely, Sara Black

http://us.mc459.mail.yahooxom/mc/showM

7/30/2009

Page 1 of

Picture of my notebook - Yahoo! Mail

MAIL Picture Of my notebook

Monday, April 27, 2009 2:38 AM

Fro in: "S" <s black91@ yahoo, com > To: Melissa, [email protected]. us

Det Sanford: Strangely enough, you have never asked me for a description of my notebook for your investigation. It was a blue and grey Mead Zwipes. A picture can be found here. http://www.meadzwipes.com/products.aspx Sara

http://us.mc459.mail.yahooxom/mc/showMessage?sMid=72&fid=Sent&fih^

7/30/2009

MAIL C :V» C Re: 09-1160071

Thursday, May 14, 2009 5:20 AM

From: "Holsonback, Robert" To; s__black9 [email protected]

Ms. Black, I am the Detective assigned to investigate the case in which it has been alleged that you took $395 in cash from the purse at Ms. Hagood's house. I have not contacted you up to this point because I had not been contacted by the owner of the purse until now i understand that you assert that this report is false and ! assure you that I will conduct this investigation in the same manner that I conduct all of other investigations, which is from a neutral position in which I seek the truth. Also, please understand that I will file any and all charges against any .person for which I have sufficient probable cause and a complaining victim, regardless of who that person may be. Please call me at the number listed below if you have facts relevant to this case.

Detective Robert Holsonback Austin Police Department Central East Area Command Detective Unit (512) 974-6610 office (512) 974-5953 fax

Det. Holsonback - This was in the CEDR mailbox. Kay Vargas 974-8106 Original Message • From: S (majLlt. oj_s_b 1 ack91 @yahoo . com] Sent: Friday, May 08, 2009 7:19 PM To: APC District Reps, Central East Subject: False report 09-1160071

Dear APD CE Command: The FBI recently released a statement about the proper handling of extortion. They say tc report it your local law enforcement for investigation. I did as the FBI directed. .About 4-13-09, I called APD and told them I was the target of a "shakedown" by Dawn Hagood. One of Hagood!s accomplices made a false report about 4-26-09. When will I be contacted about this false report made against me? Another one was made about Sunday May 3 by Dawn Hagood from the same address., AP3944 is listed as the ciet on the 4-26 incidento I did not see a report for the second false report. I've been told that APD is not investigating the crime of extortion against, me, but the theft of my notebook. I find it cruel and inhumane for APD to allow certain people in the community to be victims of crime after crime after crime without investigation. Sara Black

Page 1 of2

RE: Is theft case still open? - Yahoo! Mail

Tuesday, May 19, 2009 8:01 PM

RE: Is theft case still open? From: "Sanford, Melissa" <[email protected]> To; "Sara" <s black91@yahoo,com>

I will close the case tomorrow at your request. If you have any other questions, pis feel free to contact me. I just noticed that you used "Det Lee" in the greeting. Apparently my voice mail is using the old greeting from 3 years ago. It is "Sanford", but I will answer to either. Det Melissa Sanford 974-591 1 ----- Original Message ----From: Sara [mailto:s_b[^ Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2009 2:55 PM To: Sanford, Melissa Subject: RE: Is theft case still open?

Det Lee:

I think one person should be investigating the false police reports by Dawn and Tami and this theft as paft of the extortion case. Of course, APD is not pursuing extortion against Dawn or her accomplices. Given that and other factors, close the case. Sara BLack

— On Tue, 5/19/09, Sanford, Melissa <MeJissa^SanM

wrote:

> From: Sanford, Melissa <Me]jssa^ > Subject: RE: Is theft case still open? > To: "Sara" <sJ^ad^l^^^J^ni> > Date: Tuesday, May 19, 2009, 7:42 PM > The county attorney's office has > never called me back as to whether they > would accept the notebook as a class a misdemeanor > charge. I you want, > you could go ahead and file it at municipal court as a > class c > misdemeanor. Otherwise, I am going to send it (as is) > to the county > attorney's office to review as a case package for > prosecution and that > could take months depending on their backlog. You can > get a copy of the > report online if you need it for your records; you just > can't get a copy > of all the transcriptions (officer's supplements, etc) > without going

http://us.mc459.mail.yahoo.ro

5/22/2009

'

RE: Is theft case still open? - Yahoo! Mail

Page 2 of 2

> through "open records act", and you can't do that until the > case is > closed. > > If you are interested in filing the class c charge, let me > know and I > will instruct you where to go. > > Det Melissa Sanford > 974-591 1

> ----- Original Message ----> From: Sara [mailto:s_biack91 @yahoo.com] > > Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2009 2:01 PM > To: Sanford, Melissa > Subject: Is theft case still open?

> Dear Det (Sanford) Lee: > > Dawn told me you had gotten married. > > Are you still investigating the theft of my notebook? > I still want a > copy of the police report and you said it is unavailable > while the case > is under investigation. If you are still > investigating, please give me > estimated date of when it will be closed. > > > Thanks, > > Sara Black

http://us.mc459.mail.yahoo.com

5/22/2009

Uity ot Austin Office of the Police Monitor P.O. Box 1088, Austin, Texas 78767 (512) 974-9090, TTY (512) 974-9144, Fax (512) 974-6306 [email protected]. us, http://ww<w.austinpolicemonitor.com

October 15,2009

Ms. Sara Black POB 49175 Austin, TX 78765

RE: Your complaint #2009-'

Dear Ms. Black: This letter is to advise you that Austin Police Department Internal Affairs Division has completed their investigation into your complaint. If you would like to know the outcome of the investigation, please give me a call so that we can schedule a Police Monitor's Conference here in our office. At the Police Monitor's Conference; you will learn details of the investigation, be able to ask questions about Austin Police Department policy and procedure, and provide any additional information about your complaint, which we will pass on to Internal Affairs Division. All Police Monitor Conferences are tape recorded and copies may be provided to the City Manager, Chief of Police, or the Citizen Review Panel upon request. If you are dissatisfied at the end of your Police Monitor Conference, you may request that the Police Monitor refer your case to the Citizen Review Panel, which is a group of seven citizens that review cases and make recommendations to the Chief of Police. The Panel has the authority to: • • • • •

recommend to the Chief of Police that Internal Affairs Division conduct further investigation; request that the Chief of Police reconsider his decision; make a policy recommendation to the Chief of Police; request an independent investigation, in certain cases; or affirm the recommendation of Internal Affairs Division.

The City of Austin is committed to compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Reasonable modifications and equal access to communications will be provided upon request.

Uity ot Austin Office of the Police Monitor P.O. Box 1088, Austin, Texas 78767 (512) 974-9090, TTY (512) 974-9144, Fax (512) 974-6306 police. monitor@cL austin. tx. us> http://ewwcw. austinpolicemoniton com

Please call me at (512) 974-9098 by October 29, 2009, to let me know if you would like to schedule a Police Monitor's Conference. Also, please call me if you have any questions or concerns.

Sincerely,

Carmen Scott Complaint Specialist Office of the Police Monitor

77je City of Austin is committed to compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Reasonable modifications and equal access to communications will be provided upon request.

$00.351 '10/16/2009

Office of the Police Monitor

Mailed From 78702

City Of Austin P.O. Box 1088 Austin/Texas 78767

US POSTAGE

Ms. Sara Black POB49175 Austin, TX 78765