What Is Gold Telling Us

October 20, 2009

Economics Group Special Commentary Jay Bryson, Global Economist [email protected] ● 704-383-3518

Anika R. Khan, Economist [email protected] ● 704-715-0575

Yasmine Kamaruddin, Economic Analyst [email protected] ● 704-374-2992

What Is Gold Telling Us? Executive Summary

Gold prices have surged in recent months, which some observers claim is a clear warning that inflation will soon turn sharply higher as it did in the late 1970s. However, other forward-looking market-based inflation indicators do not support this hypothesis. Inflation indicators such as bond yields, consumer expectations and TIPS spreads have been running at fairly depressed levels, which suggest inflation will likely remain benign. 1 If the spike in gold prices is not a sign of looming inflation, why are gold prices at a record high? It appears that foreign central banks may be playing a role in driving gold prices higher. After two decades of reducing their holdings of gold, central bank purchases of the precious metal set a record in July and anecdotal evidence suggests they have continued to buy more recently. In addition, the increase in futures contracts outstanding indicates that speculative activity is also picking up. Does the apparent attempt of foreign central banks to build up their holdings of gold indicate that they have “lost confidence” in the dollar? Probably not, at least not yet. Foreign central banks appear to be diversifying on a flow basis only because they remain net buyers of U.S. Treasury securities. If foreign central banks had indeed “lost confidence” in the greenback, we think they would be reducing their holdings of Treasury securities. However, indications that the United States is not serious about addressing its long-run fiscal challenges could eventually lead foreign central banks to reassess their willingness to continue financing U.S. government obligations.

Gold Prices as a Harbinger of Inflation

Many recall the gold price spikes of the early 1970s and early 1980s that heralded double-digit inflation months in advance. Indeed, the doubling of gold prices between late 1972 and mid-1973 was followed by a sharp increase in consumer price inflation (Figure 1). That episode in the early 1970s was simply a warm-up act for the early 1980s when gold prices surged to the unheard of price of $650/ounce in January 1980. By spring of that year, CPI inflation was running near 15 percent. Today, the price of gold has been trending higher for a year, and currently exceeds $1000/ounce. Does the recent moonshot in gold prices herald another decade of runaway inflation? Between the early 1970s through the late 1990s, gold prices and the rate of inflation followed a relatively predictable path. A persistent upward trend in gold prices became a fairly reliable harbinger of high inflation. As such, investors seeking to hedge against inflation flocked to gold, pushing up the price even higher. Before we all cash in our monetary savings for prized art objects, which were used as an inflation hedge in the 1970s, let’s put the current increase in gold prices into perspective. Although the price of gold is currently at a record level, its price changed more quickly in the late 1970s than it 1

The TIPS spread is the difference between the yield on a Treasury security and the yield on the Treasury InflationProtected Security of comparable maturity. Therefore, the spread measures the difference between a nominal yield and a real yield, and can thus be interpreted as a measure on inflation expectations.

This report is available on wellsfargo.com/research and on Bloomberg WFEC

Gold prices surged in the late 1970s as CPI inflation shot higher.

What Is Gold Telling Us? October 20, 2009

WELLS FARGO SECURITIES, LLC ECONOMICS GROUP

has at present. Over the past 12 months the price of gold has risen about 50 percent, a sizeable increase but well short of the near trebling in price that occurred between January 1979 and January 1980. In real terms, the price of gold is about 50 percent below the peak that it reached in January 1980 (Figure 2). Therefore, the inflationary signal that today’s increase in gold prices may be sending does not appear to be as strident as the warning sent three decades ago. Figure 2

Figure 1 CPI vs. Lagged Gold Prices

Real vs. Nominal Price of Gold

Year-over-Year Percent Change, Dollar per Ounce

25%

$1,200

CPI, Year-over-Year Percent Change: Sep @ -1.3% Gold Spot Price, 1-Year Lag: Oct @ $1,066.02 per Ounce

110

20%

$1,000

Index, January 1980 = 100

120

$1,200

Real Gold Prices: Sep @ 56 (Left Axis) Gold Spot Price: Oct @ $1,066.02 per Ounce (Right Axis)

$1,100

100

$1,000

90 15%

$800

10%

$600

5%

$400

$200

0%

-5% 1971

$0 1975

1979

1983

1987

1991

1995

1999

2003

2007

$900

80

$800

* Real price of gold delfated using CPI

70

$700

60

$600

50

$500

40

$400

30

$300

20

$200

10

$100

0 1970

$0 1974

1978

1982

1986

1990

1994

1998

2002

2006

Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bloomberg LP and Wells Fargo Securities, LLC

If inflation is a concern, then why are Treasury yields so low?

Moreover, we are not convinced that the current run-up in the price of gold is indeed associated with concerns about rising inflation, because other early-warning signals of inflation are quiescent at present. Consider Treasury bond yields. The high inflation rates of the early 1980s and expectations that inflation would remain elevated led to double-digit yields on 10-year U.S. Treasury securities (Figure 3). Today, however, the yield on the 10-year U.S. Treasury security is comfortably below 4 percent. Would investors really be concerned about runaway inflation if they are willing to lend money to the U.S. Treasury for 10 years at less than 4 percent per annum? Moreover, the yield spread between the nominal 10-year bond and the inflation-protected 10 year bond, the so-called TIPS spread, is less than 2 percent at present. The Fed announced in March 2009 that it would buy $300 billion worth of Treasury securities to help hold down long-term interest rates. Couldn’t the Fed’s extraordinary purchase program artificially reduce Treasury yields and render them useless as an inflation signal? In the absence of the Fed’s purchases, wouldn’t Treasury yields be higher and investor concerns about inflation be more visible? Maybe, but the Fed is near the end of its purchase program. It seems that Treasury yields would have already reacted to the well-publicized news that the Fed plans to wrap up its program by the end of October 2009. Moreover, the Fed’s total purchases represent only 4 percent of the $7 trillion worth of marketable Treasury securities outstanding. It does not seem likely that the Fed’s actions would be able to hold down yields if investors really feared an inflationary outbreak.

Consumers’ inflation expectations remain well contained.

Moreover, other inflation indicators are not flashing red at present. There is a question in the University of Michigan’s survey of consumer attitudes that measures inflation expectations over the next five years. This measure of inflation expectation rose to nearly 10 percent in the early 1980s, but it has remained remarkably steady over the past decade or so suggesting that consumers do not seem to be too worried about inflation at present (Figure 4). Therefore, the hypothesis that the sharp increase in gold prices recently foretells an episode of rapidly rising inflation does not appear to be supported by other measures of inflation expectations. Another plausible idea is that the rise in gold prices is due to an increase in risk aversion. In the past, investors have flocked to the safety of gold when they have become spooked. If risk aversion were rising, however, then why have the prices of equities, whose uncertain cash flow

2

What Is Gold Telling Us? October 20, 2009

WELLS FARGO SECURITIES, LLC ECONOMICS GROUP

characteristics make them among the riskiest of financial assets, increased so much recently? 2 The fall in the VIX index, which measures stock market volatility, and the narrowing of credit spreads also indicate that risk aversion is declining, not increasing. Figure 3

Figure 4

10-Year Treasury Yield vs. TIPS Spread Percent

Inflation Expectations in Five Years University of Michigan

20%

10%

18%

9%

9%

16%

8%

8%

14%

7%

7%

12%

12%

6%

6%

10%

10%

5%

5%

8%

8%

4%

4%

6%

6%

3%

3%

4%

4%

2%

2%

2%

2%

1%

0% 1970

0%

0% 1980

20%

US 10-Year Government Bond: Sep @ 3.31% TIPS Spread: Sep @ 1.77%

18%

TIPS spread = 10 Year Govt. Bond Yield 10 Year Inflation-Protected Government Bond Yield

16% 14%

10%

1% Inflation Expectations in 5 Years: Oct @ 2.9%

1974

1978

1982

1986

1990

1994

1998

2002

2006

0% 1983

1986

1989

1992

1995

1998

2001

2004

2007

Source: Federal Reserve Board, University of Michigan and Wells Fargo Securities, LLC

Some Central Banks Are Switching into Gold

If expectations of rising inflation and increasing risk aversion do not appear to be good explanations for the recent run-up in the price of gold, then what explains its increase? We believe that central banks may be part of the story. The price of gold fell to roughly $900/ounce in early July, but it has risen essentially non-stop in subsequent weeks. Interestingly, gold purchases by central banks increased by a record amount in July (Figure 5). Although “hard” data for central bank holdings of gold in August, September and the first few weeks of October are not yet readily available, anecdotal evidence suggests that central banks have continued to purchase gold. For example, a recent Wall Street Journal article noted that the Taiwanese central bank will likely increase the amount of gold in its foreign-exchange reserves. 3

Central banks purchased a record amount of gold in July.

Why would central banks have an interest in buying gold? Central banks have increased their foreign exchange holding from about $2 trillion at the beginning of the decade to roughly $7 trillion at present, and the U.S. dollar comprises about two-thirds of that total. How many more dollar assets do foreign central banks need? Although foreign central banks continue to buy U.S. Treasury securities—they purchased $53 billion in the 12 months through August 2009—the pace of purchases has slowed over the past year or so. Foreign central banks are not dumping U.S. assets, but they appear to be diversifying their purchases on a flow basis. Although central bank holdings of gold have trended lower for the past two decades, foreign central banks may be buying gold again as a way to diversify their portfolios and their purchases appear to be contributing to the increase in the price of the precious metal.

Foreign central banks appear to be diversifying away from the dollar on a flow basis.

Speculators May Be Piling On

It also appears that speculators have thrown their hat in the ring and are helping to push gold prices up even higher. One measure of speculative activity is the number of futures contracts outstanding, so-called “open interest”, on the COMEX exchange. Future contracts allow investors to realize financial gains through price changes without taking physical possession of a commodity. The price of gold and the amount of open interest have been trending higher over the past few years (Figure 6). Since early September open interest has increased by 165,000 contracts, the largest six-week rise in about 10 years. Although commercial accounts (i.e., end users of gold) may be increasing the number of future contracts they buy to hedge against further 2

The S&P 500 index is up more than 60 percent relative to its bottom in March 2009. Perris Lee Choon Siong, “Taiwan Ctrl Bank Gov: Can Study Increasing Gold in FX Reserves”, the Wall Street Journal, Oct. 13, 2009

3

3

What Is Gold Telling Us? October 20, 2009

WELLS FARGO SECURITIES, LLC ECONOMICS GROUP

large price increases, we suspect that non-commercial accounts (i.e., speculators) are also behind the recent increases in open interest and the price of gold. Figure 6

Figure 5

Gold: Total Open Interest Contracts vs. Spot Price

Official Holdings of Gold In Millions of Troy Ounces

1,200

1,200

700

In Thousand, Dollars per Ounce

$1,100 $1,000

1,150

1,150

600

$900 $800

500 1,100

1,100

$700 400

1,050

1,050

1,000

1,000

$600 $500

300

$400 200

950

950

100

Official Holdings of Gold: Jul @ 968 Million Troy Ounces 900 1989

1997

2001

2005

$200 Total Open Interest/Combined Contracts: Oct @ 671,445 (Left Axis) Gold Spot Price: Oct @ $1,066.02 per Ounce (Right Axis)

900 1993

$300

2009

0 1996

$100 $0

2000

2004

2008

Source: Bloomberg LP, International Monetary Fund and Wells Fargo Securities, LLC

Conclusions

Some observers have interpreted the record rise in the price of gold recently as a warning that the United States is on the cusp of another inflationary period à la the late 1970s/early 1980s. Unprecedented amounts of liquidity that the Federal Reserve has pumped into the banking system and record budget deficits of the federal government also seem to support the notion that years of crippling inflation may be just around the corner. However, other early warning indicators of inflation, such as yields on U.S. Treasury securities and measures of consumer inflation expectations, do not support the hypothesis that investors are universally concerned about a period of runaway inflation. Rather, the recent rise in the price of gold appears to be related, at least in part, to attempts by foreign central banks to diversify their reserve holdings on a flow basis. After years of reducing their holdings of gold, foreign central banks bought a record amount of the precious metal in July and anecdotal evidence suggests that their net purchases have continued over the past few months. Speculators appear to be jumping on the pile as well, which also may be helping to push up gold prices. Although it is impossible to determine how much central banks wish to increase their holdings of gold, the big decline in their gold portfolios that has occurred over the past two decades suggests that they have scope to continue buying gold for some time. Foreign central banks have not “lost confidence” in the dollar, at least not yet.

Interest by foreign central banks to increase their gold holdings begs a more fundamental question. Have they lost confidence in the dollar? Probably not, at least not yet. As noted above, foreign central banks have purchased $53 billion worth of Treasury securities over the past 12 months. Although the pace of purchases has slowed from its rate of a year or so ago, we think foreign central banks would have become outright net sellers of Treasury securities if they had “lost confidence” in the greenback. Foreign central banks are not dumping dollars, but they appear to be diversifying away from the greenback on a flow basis. As we argue in a recent report, however, indications that the United States is not serious about addressing its long-run fiscal challenges could eventually lead foreign investors and central banks to reassess their willingness to continue financing U.S. government obligations. 4 Although there is little evidence to date to suggest that that point has been reached, the price of gold could skyrocket if foreign governments do indeed lose confidence in the dollar.

4

4

See “What’s Wrong With the Dollar?” (September 24, 2009), which is posted at www.wachovia.com/economics.

Wells Fargo Securities, LLC Economics Group

Diane Schumaker-Krieg

Global Head of Research (704) 715-8437 & Economics (212) 214-5070

[email protected]

John E. Silvia, Ph.D.

Chief Economist

(704) 374-7034

[email protected]

Mark Vitner

Senior Economist

(704) 383-5635

[email protected]

Jay Bryson, Ph.D.

Global Economist

(704) 383-3518

[email protected]

Scott Anderson, Ph.D.

Senior Economist

(612) 667-9281

[email protected]

Eugenio Aleman, Ph.D.

Senior Economist

(612) 667- 0168

[email protected]

Sam Bullard

Economist

(704) 383-7372

[email protected]

Anika Khan

Economist

(704) 715-0575

[email protected]

Azhar Iqbal

Econometrician

(704) 383-6805

[email protected]

Adam G. York

Economist

(704) 715-9660

[email protected]

Ed Kashmarek

Economist

(612) 667-0479

[email protected]

Tim Quinlan

Economic Analyst

(704) 374-4407

[email protected]

Kim Whelan

Economic Analyst

(704) 715-8457

[email protected]

Yasmine Kamaruddin

Economic Analyst

(704) 374-2992

[email protected]

Wells Fargo Securities Economics Group publications are produced by Wells Fargo Securities, LLC, a U.S broker-dealer registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, and the Securities Investor Protection Corp. Wells Fargo Securities, LLC, distributes these publications directly and through subsidiaries including, but not limited to, Wells Fargo & Company, Wachovia Bank N.A., Wells Fargo Bank N.A, Wells Fargo Advisors, LLC, and Wells Fargo Securities International Limited. The information and opinions herein are for general information use only. Wells Fargo Securities, LLC does not guarantee their accuracy or completeness, nor does Wells Fargo Securities, LLC assume any liability for any loss that may result from the reliance by any person upon any such information or opinions. Such information and opinions are subject to change without notice, are for general information only and are not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sales of any security or as personalized investment advice. Wells Fargo Securities, LLC is a separate legal entity and distinct from affiliated banks and is a wholly owned subsidiary of Wells Fargo & Company © 2009 Wells Fargo Securities, LLC.

SECURITIES: NOT FDIC-INSURED/NOT BANK-GUARANTEED/MAY LOSE VALUE