Villa Verdict

IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF LEHIOH COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION WILLIAM VILLA and BARBARA MAQUERA, individually an as coadministrators of the Estate of SHEENA VILLA, their daughter, Plaintiffs, No. 2007-C-2985 (Hon. Edward D. Rerbmaa) ROBERT LABARRE and MR. OGO BAR INC., d/b/a J.P. O'MALLEY'S PUB,

•£

§ fi i 2

Defendant. MOLDED VERDICT

^ 55

tJ

'

'*"

AND NOW, this // fayof May, 2009, it appearing by response to jury interrogatories that the jury found Defendant Mr. Ogo Bar Inc. d/b/a J.P. O'Malley's Pub negligent, but determined that said negligence was not a cause of factual harm to Plaintiffs; and it farther appearing that upon stipulation of the parties that Defendant Robert LaBane's negligence was a factual cause of harm to Plaintiffs, the jury determined that 85 % of the total causal negligence was attributable to Defendant Robert LaBarre and that 15% of the total causal negligence was attributable to Plaintiffs' decedent, Sheena Villa; and it further appearing that the jury awarded compensatory damages against Defendant Robert LaBarre in the amount of $1,300,000.00; and it ftuther appearing that the jury determined the conduct of Defendant Robert LaBarre was outrageous and awarded Plaintiffs punitive damages against Defendant Robert LaBarre in the amount of $2,000,000.00, IT IS ORDERED that the verdict of May g, 2009, is molded to read as follows:

NOW,

COPIES OF THE WITHIN COURT ORDER OR DECREE MAILED TO ALL INTERESTED PARTIES BY: &?

flK-'

-n

VERDICT "AND NOW, May 8,2009, we the jurors impaneled in the above-entitled case find for Defendant Mr. Ogo Bat Inc. d/b/a J.P. O'Malley's Pub and against the Plaintiffs in no amount and we iurther find in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendant Robert LaBarre in the amount of $1,105,000.00 for compensatory damages and in the amount of $2,000,000 for punitive damages." BY THE COURT:

EDWARD D. RKIBMAN, J