TIME, SPACE, AGING-COGNITION BY BIOLOGICAL LIFE Author
Vijaya Kumar Buddhiraju
Fore word: This talk is but a drop in the ocean of literature generated over thousands of years. An attempt is made to succinctly organize dispersed views in several books and documents. While this may be educational to those who would like to fathom the depths of ancestral thinking, it is the sincere hope that the readers would enjoy and admit that after all we do not have exclusive reasons to gloat on our current technological achievements. It is humbling to accept that there were people before us who accomplished greater tasks with no modern tools.
Dedicated to My father, Sri Rajaubhushana Rao Buddhiraju, an unparallel scholar of four languages, and whose services to free India from foreign rule remains trampled similar to those of thousands like him, under the wheels of ingratitude and greed of the beneficiaries of their sacrifices 1
Chapter - 4
Introduction: Over centuries almost all civilizations have been captivated by the mystery of time. One of the earliest civilizations that investigated the nature of time probably more than any one and proposed its findings in what we today call philosophical or metaphysical ways is Indian civilization. A few of the fascinating definitions and conclusions arrived by the Hindus will be presented to you today. I will make a comparison between the West and East often during the talk for the sake of relative ease of understanding and familiarizing with the eastern mode of thinking, but not to stress the differences. One does have to remember that the life in the West was and even today is mainly materialistic. To attain those materialistic comforts, it basically relies on logistic ideas and investigations. Those achievements that lead to increased wealth are attributed to the advances in civilization. Reaching towards inner and deeper things, delving into the intuitive abilities has been essentially banished. Exponents of any results of such inner experiences are cruelly punished. On the other hand, the East looked forward to these ideas irrespective of their origin, analyzed further in light of their own and incorporated them into their philosophies and religions with a strong belief that excessive materialism leads to social deterioration while the inner spiritual discoveries would lead to lasting solutions to the conflicts. Therefore, do bear in mind, much of what I put forward is philosophical and not based on today’s scientific methods. These propositions do not involve formulas and derivations based on the formulas. However the Hindus were great logicians and therefore, their conclusions are logical and attractive. India was the land of many Shakespeares, Socartices and Platos. Indians have written beautiful prose and poetry, dramas and epics, which remain unequalled to any others in the annals of human history. What is available of their literary and scientific contributions to the world today is only a small fraction of what was produced by that civilization. Most of their contributions to the human civilization were destroyed since the advent of invasions by the Middle Eastern forces from 7th century onwards. As the plunder also involved the destruction of written documents, some of the literary contributions were protected by memorization by groups of individuals. However, the small fraction that remained is still voluminous and no individual can even read it in one’s lifetime, let alone understand it. Even this remaining small amount is seeking the help of civilized nations to survive, as the rulers and the commoners of current India have no grasp of the wealth of knowledge left behind by their forefathers. There was hardly any intellectual on this planet who came in close contact with the Hindu literature and did not admire it. To cite a couple, Einstein said “we owe a lot to the Indians, who taught us how to count, without which no worthwhile scientific discovery 2
could have been made”. Mark Twain commented “India is the cradle of human race, the birthplace of human speech, the mother of history, the grandmother of legend and the great grand mother of tradition. Our most valuable and most instructive material in the history of man are treasured up in India. In religion, India is the only millionaire. The one land that all men desire to see and having seen once, by even a glimpse, would not give that glimpse for all the shows of all the rest of the globe combined”. The investigative methodology of the Indians into time, space, and planetary systems or in the generation of dramas and epics remains unique in many ways. Some of their findings and methods of investigations in science, religion and philosophy were and are being copied by other civilizations, knowingly and unknowingly, without giving proper credit to their origin. Some of their concepts, which are thousands of years old, are still several hundred years ahead of our current ability to think and analyze. In order not be totally branded as unreal and foolish, I will not bring forth many of those concepts which are several years ahead of our times, but were proposed by the Indians thousands of years ago. Particularly if one faces learned scientists of current times with philosophical propositions of concepts concerning time and space, one must be bold, or foolish or foolishly bold. For example, if I say that it is not the light that travels the fastest, but according to the Hindu philosophers it is mind (Manas), because one can reach the ends of the universe with the mind in a fraction of a second while light takes several billion years, which current scientist would give it even a second thought? From our standpoint, mind travel is but a mere figment of idle imagination-an impossible and a foolish concept. Even the notion that ‘thought’ could be matter is well ahead of our time, let alone converting that into practice and actually traveling with that speed. If I say that the Hindus split the atom and harnessed its energy in different ways effortlessly, and purposefully destroyed this knowledge to prevent it from falling into the hands of individuals of their future time, who were projected to have less rational and harmonious collective psychological orientation than the people of their own time, it would be viewed as unreal. It is because we sit with a preset mind that if we did not do it, no one could have done it earlier any way. I have given just two of innumerable examples. For our state of mind to view my talk as philosophical and not scientific will be more enjoyable than to accept the idea that civilizations greater than ours existed earlier. The available concepts, although many, are cared about by only a few people, at least in India any way. There are fewer people who can explain central meaning in a logical fashion. Even those few are usually envied, feared and neglected. Almost all the investigative literature in this field is in Sanskrit language. As literal translation of the words and phrases from this language is a daunting task, I will use the Sanskrit words in italics ‘as is’ and make a veiled attempt to translate them to the best of my ability. Sanskrit is a unique language, apparently developed for the purpose of expressing observations 3
which are not expressible by any other language. It is probably the only language in which newer words are coined from the meaning. Next is Latin of course. It is imperative that I draw on some contemporary investigative methods to apply them to the philosophical notions to better understand these concepts in modern perspective. However much I may believe or disbelieve these documentations, I am compelled to call these observations philosophies because the subject itself is fluid and cannot have assertive black and white answers. James Thrber once said “the philosophy offers rather cold consolation that we and our planets do not really exist” – it gives us an opportunity to take our mind to the depths of intellectual introversion without having the guilt of not providing supportive logic. For this talk I will cite some verses from the Upanishads and Bhagavadgita in order for you to familiarize and appreciate the depth of thinking to which the Indian mind had gone in this field. Origin of the Universe: When we talk about space and time, we cannot dissociate ourselves from the nature and origin of the universe. Without basic conceptualization of its foundation, description of time and space will not be possible. Currently, cosmological sciences conclude that universe has not been in existence eternally but universe and time itself began with Big Bang, about ~15 billion years ago. We are not yet scientifically certain whether the universe will have an end. The time scale of the universe is very long compared to that of the human life on this planet. It is therefore, not surprising that until recently universe was thought to be essentially static, and unchanging in time. Human inhabitation of earth is not considered to be earlier than a couple of hundred thousand earth years or at most 3 million year ago a man-like figure existed. The idea that the universe had a beginning implies the existence of a supernatural being (the God) who created the universe. Then of course the obvious follow up question would be, did the God have a beginning? The West believes that the human being never asked this fundamental question until the beginning of 19th and 20th centuries. It is hard for us to concede that for every one Einstein discovered, 1000 more are either ignored by our prejudice or callous arrogance. From a philosophical point of view, the universe has a beginning and an end. The universe that we can see with our senses has a curvature in all directions as it were that all our galaxies are enclosed in a shell. This is referred to as the egg of the creator (Brahmanda). From the Hindu point of view this universe (shell) in which we are trapped is but one of many more such universes. The Hindus conceptualize the definitions of the beginning and end of our universe differently from the way we currently think. We in the West propose that the end is the ultimate destruction to nonexistence. The Hindu philosophers do not accept such a theory. The statement in Bhagavadgita “Naseta Vidyate Bhavo, Na Bhavo Vidyte statah”; essentially means -That which exists will have no specific period for its non-existence and for that which does not exist there will not be specific 4
period of existence. This means the universe can transform from one form to another-but cannot disappear. This statement from Gita is similar to first law of matter – “matter can neither be created nor destroyed it can only be transformed”. The only difference is that Gita is a few thousand years older. This definition (or the theory of creation) is stretched and applied to many more situations besides the formation and destruction of the universe. Such applications that result in the generation of other theories commonly referred to as Yogas is not going to be our topic today. Definition of time: It is easy to define time and get into trouble with the definition. Astronomer Carl Sagan said “time is resistant to definition”. One cannot see, feel, touch or smell time, yet we all know it exists because its effects can be felt and seen. Scientifically it is referred to as the fourth dimension of the universe. The other three dimensions are space of course. Both are intertwined, as neither can exist without the other; that is the way we comprehend it in a simple language. For the purpose of our discussion, let me further simplify time as the space between starting an event and finishing it. There was an instance I entered this auditorium, and time that I will exit. We make an arbitrary measure of the space between these two events of my entrance and departure into and from this auditorium. That is, time can be measured only with respect to at least two events. In biological life forms or even for inanimate objects, aging phenomenon can be physically observed with a change in time. That is, at one time the matter appears in one way and at another it appears in a different way. In effect change in form can also be a measure of time. For simplicity, let us agree that the relative measure between events is called time. Once we make this measurement universally acceptable to all instances, we will have established parameters to measure the time. The Hindu scientists of the olden days established the parameters for the time in two directions. The time goes to a level of non-existence or gets expanded to astronomical levels depending on the state of our mind. Their proposals are embedded either in religion or philosophy or both. This will be clearer and more evident as we proceed into understanding their conceptions of time. According to the Hindu philosophers, the state of mind and human behavior make the division of time to occur and there are four quarters that govern the state of mind. Time during waking (Jagriti) state (state 1): Smallest and the longest time spans have been stretched to extremes in establishing time. For example smallest unit of time is Paramanu; 2 Paramanus make one Anu; 3 Aunus make one Trasarenu; 3 Traserenus make one Truti;100 Trutis make one Vedha; 3 Vedhas make one Lava; 3 Lavas make one Nimeesha; 3 Nimeeshas make one Kshna; 5 Kshnas make one Kastha; 15 Kasthas make one Laghu; 15 Laghus make one Naadika; 2 Naadikas make one Muhurta;3 Muhurtas make one Prahara (one second); 15 Prahars make one Vigadias; 4 Vigadias make one Nimisha (one 5
minute) ; 24 Nimishas make one Gadia; 2.5 Gadias make one Ghanta (hour). Essentially our current one hour was split by 1.3x 10-11. The very concept of such an extensive division of time into such a miniature level is very interesting. As we proceed into the next sections of my talk, reason for such a division will become partly obvious. The documentation of such reasons, which are called the keys to the observations and statements, are lost or hidden in the voluminous literature. The other part of the estimation of time is the expanding cycle of time. The Hindus also take this to the extreme levels. In this expansive phase the time is estimated as follows: 3 Ghantas (hours) make one Yama; 8 Yamas make one Dina (day), 7 Dinas make one Vara (week); 15 Dinas make one Paksha; 2 Pakshas make one Masa (month); 2 Masas make one Rutu; 6 Masas make one Ayana [referring to the movement of Sun (ascending northward-Uttaryana and descending southward-Dakshinayana)]; 6 Rutus make one Varsha (year). [They generally followed the lunar calendar and made accurate correction by the addition of a month every six years just as we add a day to every alternate year and subtract a day in the month of February and add one to it in a leap year in order to adjust for the movement of earth around Sun]. Sixty years (each year has a name-this year is called Chitra Bhanu) make one Vrutta (cycle). 6 cycles (360 years) make one Divya Varsha; Specified number of Divya Varshas make a unit of time called Yuga. The Yugas are named as: Kruta Yuga (4800 Divya Varshas;1.728 x 106 years), Treta Yuga (3600 Divya Varshas;1.29 x 106 years), Dwapara Yuga (2400 Divya Varshas;0.864 x 106 years) and Kali Yuga (1200 Divya Varshas;0.432 x 106 years). Four Yugas combined will form one Maha Yuga (12000 Divya Varshas 4.32 x 106 years); 71.09 Maha Yugas make one Manu (853080 Divya Varshas;0.3071088 x 109 years) and 14 Manus make one Kalpa (11943120 Divya Varshas;4.2995232 x 109 years). The Indians made 1.2 x 10+14 fold expansion of an hour to estimate the space between non-existence and existence of the universe we live in. It is stated that we are currently in the 4th Yuga called Kali Yuga of 7th Manu (Vaivaswata) in the 2nd Kalpa (Aadivaraha or Swetavaraha) having finished the first three Yugas of this Maha Yuga. This equals 20 Manus or approximately 6.142176 billion years since birth of the earth. They also project that 1.955885203 billion years passed since life started on planet earth. These are going to repeat in time when there will be dissolution (Pralaya) and subsequent creation and tremendous termination (Kalpánta) and return of space, time and their manifestation. This intriguingly finds an echo in quantum mechanics where any local clock should cycle after a long but finite time depending on the elaborateness of the construction of the clock and the number of its dials. It is possible that they had some instrumentation and enough mathematical knowledge for accurate calculations of time and space. However, it is also possible that this civilization never labored with enormous instrumentation but used alternate methods of delving 6
into inner hidden abilities of human mind. What earthly purpose was served by these astronomical calculations and what have they achieved by these calculations is not a mystery from philosophical point of view but appears unrealistic from scientific viewpoint. Let me take you back into our simple definition of time ‘a measurement of space between two events’. Once accepted, I can say that there was an instance of my absence in this auditorium, and an instance of presence. Time is relative to these events and is not dependent on them. If time’s existence is dependent on the events such as my presence or absence in this auditorium, I will have to come back into the auditorium for the time to continue. Otherwise the time would stop. Universal measure of time established using my presence and absence is not dependent on me or my presence or absence. Therefore, as far as time is concerned, an event or the agent is not mandatory. Time still should have it’s own identity. These events are used for relative measure of time which we arbitrarily set up. The events therefore are needed to understand, define and establish a parameter for time, but do not directly contribute to it. In reality, therefore, what exists is time, which in theory is a factor independent of any subject. Let us see Einstein's Special Theory of Relativity which predicted that time does not flow at a fixed rate: Moving clocks appear to tick more slowly relative to their stationary counterparts. But this effect only becomes really significant at very high velocities that approach the speed of light. First postulate was that the speed of light is the same for all observers, regardless of their motion relative to its source. The second postulate was that all observers moving at constant speed should observe the same physical laws. Putting these two ideas together, Einstein showed that the only way this can happen is that time intervals and/or lengths change according to the speed of the system relative to the observer's frame of reference. Scientists have shown that an atomic clock traveling at high speed in a jet plane ticks more slowly than its stationary counterpart. Essentially time can be slowed down depending upon the speed of travel. In the Hindu philosophy time slows down once you change the frame of mind. That is, the relative time spans are dissimilar in different frames of mind. These frames of mind are changeable. The downward division of time to its infinitesimal levels is applicable to an individual with a frame of mind that attempts to reduce the space between events. There are three such frames or quarters of mind which perform this task. These are called Taijasa, Pragna and Turiya. Time during sleeping (Taijasa) state (second state): All scientific measurements, concepts and arguments about time as of now are confined only to our waking (Jagrut) state. Einstein’s theories are applicable only to this state. In philosophy however, reality is not just what ever is felt by senses. It claims there is a lot more beyond that. During the sleeping (Taijasa) state we will encounter dreams (Swapna). The consciousness of the waking state is associated with the external 7
objects. The impressions and experiences left will correspond to the objects one perceives in the waking state. Experiences during the dream state are the same as those in the waking state. The impressions in the dream state are generated by the impulsion of desires and past actions. In the sleeping state of mind, events of past actions reappear as if one has painted them somewhere in our consciousness with an irregular painting tool but without any external means. For the events to reoccur no external means are required and the proceedings would be swift. Consequently one needs to re-define time in dream state in a different angle compared to that in waking state. For example, currently I am taking approximately 1 hour to deliver this lecture. Everything that takes place during this 1 hr may be repeated in its entirety in my dream all over again. The time I would take to repeat the whole thing is much shorter in my dream. That is, 1 hr of my waking state may be only two minutes in my dream state. It is scientifically shown that the time taken for an event in dream is less than that in the actual waking state. The Hindu philosophers said this in many ways thousands of years ago. This state is called Taijasa or luminous state since one becomes the witness to the cognition without any objects, thus reducing the time taken to complete a task in comparison to waking state. Essentially in the dream state, our physical bodies are not traveling; no objects play a role to achieve a task. The enjoyment derived by events is subtle rather than gross. But the emotional reactions such as fear, hunger etc. remain same as in waking state. However, space between events in the dream state is much smaller compared to that in awakened state. The biological aging process is supposed to be reduced in this state. It may be our mind is traveling faster or is able to grasp events more efficiently. What makes us accomplish a task faster in dream than in waking state may have to be investigated further for clearer understanding. Time in deep sleep (Pragna) state (third state): It is claimed by the Hindus that there are two other states of mind beyond the waking and sleeping state. The state next to the sleeping state is called Pragna or deep sleep state. It is also called Sushipti state of mind. This is a state where no dreams occur. It is claimed that although one transcends dream in this state, awareness of events around continues. Many things are claimed to happen in this state of mind. In order not to put myself years ahead of time and create problems, I would not discuss what the Hindu philosophers claim would happen in this state of mind. As the talk is pertaining to time, I shall stick to it. Essentially the time span in this state is highly compressed. Time taken for any activity in this state of mind would be only a minute fraction of time required for the same event in dream state. The space between two events is infinitely less. Essentially the event takes place in an insignificant time in relation to awakened state of mind. The extreme divisions of time cited earlier section are useful in this state of mind for understanding our mental abilities to accomplish various tasks. Time would still exist in this state of mind. For understanding this state of mind several stories are 8
narrated in various texts of the Indians. The most common story is of Lord Vishnu who was approached by a sage called Narada for an explanation of true nature of time. Lord Vishnu asked the sage to fetch a glass of water from nearby home before he would describe the nature of time. The sage went to a nearby home whose door was answered by a super beautiful lady with whom the sage fell in love. He forgot about the Lord who was waiting for water and married the stunning damsel. Then the couple had children. Several years passed by. One day huge floods swept through the village, the house was washed away along with children and wife. The sage swam to a shore and started walking in the forest. There he saw the Lord waiting for his water. The sage remembered about the glass of water he was supposed to have brought and extensively apologized to the Lord. The Lord smiled and said that there is no need to apologize as only a few seconds passed since the sage went to fetch water any way. The story is to convey that several years in one state of mind are only seconds in the other state. Several such stories in the Hindu literature try to explain the changes in nature of time depending upon the state of mind. In the Pragna frame of mind, what is one’s future would still be another’s past. The biological aging process changes drastically in this state. In theory one can practically eliminate the aging process. Time during the state of tranquility (Turiya) (fourth state): It is claimed that there is yet another state of mind called Turiya where the time ceases to exist. In this, mind is said to be in a state which has no definition. This is a condition of absolute tranquility. An event becomes inconsequential. The time becomes inconsequential. There is nothing to relate to. Nothing is present in relation to it. It is a state of absolute calm and stillness. Time has no relevance any longer. Theoretically, if traveling with increased speed decreases time, in Turiya state you are mentally traveling at speeds that eliminate the time. Essentially there is no place in the universe that you are not in. There is nothing you do not know. You are all knower and all perceiver. Essentially time is the factor that keeps you ignorant of reality. That is the philosophical explanation of time when the imagination is stretched to its extreme. It is proposed that in Turiya state we reach ultimate speeds where the time does not have any continuation. Many attempts have been made with examples to explain the true nature of the Turiya state. For example a rope appears as a snake under semi-dark conditions. Experiences and consequences of close encounter with a deadly snake, such as feelings of fear, perspiration, rapid heart beats etc. manifest when we see the rope as a snake. However, once we realize it is just a rope, the snake disappears and normalcy will be eventually restored. Although no snake was ever present, illusion of its presence is manifest until we realize the truth of its non-existence. Just as one who wakes up from a dream realizes that his experiences are nothing but a dream, in the state of Turiya one realizes that the so called awakened (Jagruti) state is another dream filled with unreal objects, events and incidents causing 9
the relativity to be trapped in the cycles of time. This state is also described as a state of absolute knowledge where duality does not exist. This is described as na bahisprajnam (no experiences of the outer world). -na antahpragnam (no experiences of inner world), na ubhayatahpragnam (nor experiences of both worlds) and na prajnanghanam (no experiences of the intermediate world) takes place in this state of mind. However, this is not equal to death as the knower’s function of knowing is never lost. Further, it is described as adrastam (unseeable), avyavaharyam (beyond empirical dealings), agrahyam (beyond grasp) alakshanam (uninferable), avyapadesyam (indescribable). Therefore, this state is achintayam (unthinkable) whose proof of existence is in the belief in existence of self (eakatamapratyaya saram). This state cannot be seen but this sees all, it is the vision of a witness but not the witness, power of a movement but not the movement etc. No biological aging takes place in this state as no time is present. The aging process requires time dimension. In this state it is eliminated. The awakened state (Jagrut) and dream state (Taijasa) are conditioned by cause and effect and are strictly controlled by time. In both these states the time can be measured because events take place such as my entering and leaving the auditorium. Only, the space between the two will have different relative measure of time. These two states are controlled by non-apprehension and misapprehension of reality. Deep sleep state (Prajna) is conditioned by just cause only where time is reduced to infinitesimal level. Non-apprehension of reality occurs in Pragna. Both cause and effect are eliminated in a state of absolute tranquility (Turiya). The compression of time by changing the state of mind is for increasing the abilities of mind to infinite levels. Such compression has utility in the states other than the waking (Jagrut). But one has to reconcile with the fact that we are mostly in awakening (Jagrut) or in the sleep (Taijasa) state. Even in the sleep state we have no control of events. If only we acquire that control of Prgana and Turiya states, the utility of the compressed states of time will be immense. According to the Hindu philosophers, control of mind in these states described above is possible. It is further claimed such a harnessing of mind in these states was done several times by several people to deliver knowledge which otherwise would not have been possible in waking state. Meaning of the Mega calendar: Instead of compressing the time by going into a different frame of mind, if we were to calculate the time that has already passed and the one that is about to pass, expansion of time would result. Such an expansion of time strictly from the waking state is generally maintained as a chronological calendar. Only humans require a calendar. Remaining life forms on this tiny planet have little need or use for it. However, the estimation of time and generation of a calendar by the Hindus was not made for the purpose of organization of the daily routine of the human beings alone. The hours, days and years have the general purpose for the 10
individual, community, state and nations as calendars. Up to the 60 year cycle, calendar is understandable and can be measured in one’s lifetime. However, the Hindus have generated mega calendars, namely Yugas, Maha Yugas, Manus, Kalpas and Maha Kalpas. The meaning for, and estimation of times for these is more complex. Is it possible that the preservers (historians) of literature exaggerate these numbers from their original classification causing distortion of figures and definitions? It is almost impossible for this voluminous literature to endure the test of time without any taint. But the underlying meaning or principle by which such mega classification is based is not likely to change. Preservation of calendars by transcending it from one generation to the other is not possible because the existence of man on the planet is less than a Yuga. But the Hindus claim that at least ~2000 Yugas have passed till now! So it cannot be a phenomenon of transfer of a calendar from one generation to other. Why would they so authoritatively name the time span, and claim that seventh Manu named Vaivaswata is in control now? How did they give the names to all of the previous Manus who were controlling this system? It is truly intriguing. I do not claim to have all the answers. But they did have a method of estimation of time at mega levels. In that method, existence of man as we know is obviously not important. Therefore, meaning for and estimation of times for the Yugas and beyond becomes more complex. When the time is segmented into Yugas, which spans from a minimum of 432,000 years, the first dilemma is how would one know when a Yuga ended and other began. That is where the inseparability of space and time, their effects on the collective psychological behavior of the living and changes in the non-living come to the aid. I will make an attempt to rationalize this part by citing from scattered Hindu literature. The Yugas are governed by what they call Kala Dharma. Kala means a specific period of time and Dharma means tenet or a system of justice-essentially a self-governing rule over which we as normal human beings with limited abilities have very little control. For example - the Kruta Yuga is said to be a span of time where every thing in nature would be in perfect harmony. The psychological behavior of the man and beast, plants and planets are said to be in a state of perfect accord. Symbolism is the highest in Eastern philosophies. In figurative terms, the system of justice (Dharma) may be symbolized as a four-legged animal. In Kruta Yuga it walks with all the four legs. Every thing in the creation follows its set rules - a ruler acts like ruler not as a scholar, the earth will not act like the sun and the sun like a moon. Everything in nature maintains its dignity of labor. But such a perfect harmony lasts only for a specified period and its justice system loses approximately one quarter of its harmony as time enters into next segment the Treta Yuga. This loss is applicable to everything including the psyche of the living and properties of the non-living. In symbolic terms the system of Dharma walks with only three legs. A king for example does act like a scholar too at least 25% of the time. As the time enters the next phase, the Dwapara Yuga, 11
50% of this harmony would be lost. Such a loss applies to everything. In a symbolic way, a ruler does rule only 50% and acts differently 50% of the time. As this phase ends, the new phase namely the Kali Yuga enters when the system of Dharma will have only one leg. This is said to be the Yuga that we are living in. In this segment 75% of the time there will be discord compared to perfect harmony of Kruta Yuga. Further each Yuga is divided into four segments called Padas (legs). Basic rules will be violated more often than they are followed in Kali yuga. This violation is applicable to both animate and inanimate. The symptoms of the loss of tenets will be obvious to those who want to see. In Bhagavadigita the statement is “Ubhayorapi Drustvo AntanvanyoTtatva Darsibhi”- if one is willing to perceive both sides, its internal nature will be obviously visible. Largely, every detail appears to be based on the perceptive abilities of a few who claim that every one can perceive only if they wish to do so. In our modern science we need to have a logical method of derivation. For some of these philosophers who were called the sages, logic is only a handle but in essence an inferior ability of human mind. There is a higher faculty that transcends logic - it is the perceptive (Drasta) ability, an ability in which derivation by logic is a primitive nature of an evolving mind. The perceptive faculty is similar to but higher than inference we make to establish the existence of matter that cannot otherwise be seen. The philosophers unequivocally stated that it is not the need but the fact that such divisions of time exist. It is not for convenience of a king or a worker such a division is made but because it is so. The caste and time: In order for us to more easily grasp the meaning of changes in time, collective human psychological nature is exploited for giving a vivid explanation of the beginning and the end of a Yuga. This is elaborately detailed in various books called the Puranas. The statement in Bhagavadgita is “Chaturvnye Maya Srustam Guna Karma Vibahajaka”. meaning “The four castes are created by me based on the nature and work”. For life to form or cell to operate or society to function, grossly four castes operate as invisible underlying laws of nature. One has to have intellect to generate the information, the other has to fight to preserve and channel the information, one has to trade the information and the other has to work to implement it. Essentially the nucleus of the cell holds the intellect that decides the cellular events –the intellect is called the Brahmana. Then the information is taken by orderly manner to its destined direction. Such a flow of information is called Kshatriya. For the preparation of the finished products, trading of the matter in the cells takes place. This system of exchange is called Vysya . The finished products have a laborious duty to perform. Each of these products can do only the job they are meant for, nothing more nothing less. This systematized labor is called Sudra. Each is interdependent on the other. No cell can survive with just one function without the other three. One of the Upanishadic verse says- “yato pindah, tatho brahmándah”- what is true for the atom is 12
true for the universe. This is in a way similar to the theories of Fractals in mathematics. What is mega is the same as micro multiplied several times. The most magnified images of fractals are essentially indistinguishable from the unmagnified version. A fractal shape will look almost, or even exactly the same no matter what size it is viewed at. If the theory is extended to the behavior of matter and the manifest, the results will be fascinating. In philosophical terms it would yield better explanations for complex behavior of the societies. For the evolution of biological system, caste is further extended to each organ. For example, the intellectual information is present in every organ of the body-but the intellect of the nucleus decides what information is given to liver or kidney etc. The instruction given to liver is not the same as that given to kidney. Although both organs have all the information to be anything they wish to be, they are controlled to perform only the prescribed function at the time of their birth itself. Otherwise, the evolution of multi cellular organisms into animals or plants would not take place. After the formation of the complex animals like man, the system of this division of labor visibly continues at the individual level and at the social level. If we take a human being, he is grossly a mixture of these four castes. He has all the four abilities - to invent (Brahmana), rule (Ksahtriya), trade (Vyasya) and work (Sudra). Temperamentally every individual will be prone to have one of these abilities expressed more than the other. Some would be more prone towards intellectual activities, some others towards political or ruling, some others trading and some others working for a wage. For the society to run in an organized fashion these four castes are the unseen strings. The chaotic societies are those which do not synchronize and harness these systems of human labor. At one time, in the Hindu society these tasks were assigned to individuals at the time of birth itself. The problem of attributing a function at birth is that any one who has the dominant tendencies of trading (Vysya) would perform the task of warring (Kshatriya). However, there was a concerted effort to nurture the dominant tendency by surrounding environment (Sangha) and conditioned nutrition (Aahara) with a view to eventually obtaining a genetic trait (Gotra) over generations. However, even if no such conditioning is permitted and each individual is free to choose, the collective social psychological pattern itself varies as time goes on. The dominance of one or other temperament permeates into the whole social fabric. Simplest example is our short documented human history. Two to three thousands years ago, great writers, poets and scholars decided the direction of the society. While others were also simultaneously present, social structure did not depend on them. That period is the Bramana pada (the intellectual leg) of the Yuga. As the time passed, occupation of lands by wars took place. Such warring period is called Kshatriya pada (warring leg) of the Yuga. Since the advent of the last century occupation of lands and going to wars is not the overall style of the societies but learn a trade to sell for the living. Such a learning merely for trading is called Vysya pada (trading leg) of 13
the Yuga. That is where we are in this Kali Yuga. We basically get training to acquire a skill to sell it or trade it later for living. Majority of the members of the society follow a specific trend because we belong to that segment of the time. All of us have a tendency to acquire skills to trade them for wealth, which is Vysya. Next phase will be Sudra pada (laboring leg) where skills cannot be automatically traded. Essentially every one would do what they want, and the intellectual, ruling, and trading abilities become obsolete. One makes one’s living without any heed to organization or channeling one’s abilities. Such changes occur at individual, social, and national levels. That indicates the end of a segment of time, the Yuga. Now remove the role of man in the exhibition of caste by his nature (Guna) or work (Karma). According to the Hindus, man is insignificant in the over all picture-he is a bundle of flesh molded in different shapes. The caste variation occurs in planetary and galactic level. If earth plays the role of the sun, the discord will be obvious. The end of a Yuga would be very evident from the behavioral patterns of the matter itself. Once we reach that state, the sign of the end of that Yuga and beginning of the next Yuga would be automatically known. The knowledge of the events is not mandatory for the beginning and the end of a period of time. Destruction follows reconstruction accompanied by a gradual evolution of matter. “Jatasya hi Marnam Dhruvam, Dhruvam Janma Mrutasyacha” – a quotation from Bhargavadgita, meaning that “which is born will certainly die, that which dies will certainly be re-born”. Thus Cycles repeat probably endlessly. Conclusion: Any theory that the universe has existed forever does not agree with the second law of thermodynamics. The second law, states that disorder always increases with time. There must have been a beginning for the universe. Otherwise, the universe would have been in a state of complete disorder by now. Well, this is an apparent contradiction to the Hindu philosophy, which clearly arrives at the conclusion that there cannot be a specified time for the origin of universe. How would it then reconcile with the scientific approach to time? It is easy if we consider that the universe had several beginnings. The time is only for an event in relation to another event. The thermodynamic principle automatically incorporated this factor in its law. Stephen Hawking in his lecture at Japan says: “everything would be at the same temperature if universe had no beginning. In an infinite and everlasting universe, every line of sight would end on the surface of a star. This would mean that the night sky would have been as bright as the surface of the Sun. The only way of avoiding this problem would be if, for some reason, the stars did not shine before a certain time. In a universe that was essentially static, there would not have been any dynamical reason, why the stars should have suddenly turned on, at some time. Any such lighting up time would have to be imposed by an intervention from outside the universe. The situation was different, however, when 14
it was realized that the universe is not static, but expanding. Galaxies are moving steadily apart from each other. This means that they were closer together in the past”. Well again, this does not contradict my previous definition. According to the Hindu philosophers, it happened several times over-simply because we did not see it now does not mean it is the first time these stars are present nor will it be first time they will be lost. If we leave the light in the room forever, the room will be super heated. If it has been turned off as often as it is turned on, room will have little change in its temperature caused by light. From the limited definition we could project for the time, we can at best give specific time for the beginning of universe one time such as15-20 billion earth years ago, based on the coming of the galaxies together where no laws of physics function. However, in theory, there could be several beginnings of the universe. I realize that even with brief quotations, I have taken you into abstract phenomena, which are difficult to digest, let alone accept. The writings about space and time by the bygone civilizations of the East are too voluminous. The relevant information as we want to see and know from our today’s scientific mind is difficult to locate at one place as a cluster. Comments and citations from innumerable texts have to be brought forward and properly understood for one to enjoy their beauty. At no time in the Hindu philosophy, did religious dogma inhibit ever-curious human intellect. These philosophers had no religion. We are calling them the Hindus because of lack of better distinguishing feature from others who would not tolerate or accept more than what they consider their scripture states. The God as perceived by common man is as much an amusement to Hindu philosophers as they are to the God of a religious man. The belief of the Hindu philosophers is that evolution is an eternal process but not an instantaneous act. The phenomenon of God is like the pole for to a pole jumper. The God is necessary until one finds Him unnecessary. Our whole solar system is not more than a fraction of a dust particle in our galaxy. Our galaxy is insignificant and just one of ~23 billion such in our universe. This universe of ours, with a radius of approximately109 light years (1022 km) with a mass of 1051kg is one of many such universes. The earth is no more than a seed of mustard in our solar system. On the earth, we are no more than a fraction of a particle of dust. Our brain, which is trying to rationalize space and time is but a fraction of our body. The rationalizing part of the brain is only a minute fraction of our whole brain. With such limitations, to crack the mysteries of our existence is humbling. In addition, selfimposed limitations such as religion, region, nation etc. make us more vulnerable to ignorance than knowledge. We have yet to go through several Yugas and Kalpas to evolve enough even to scratch surface of real truth. Acknowledgements: The author wishes to extend his thanks to the organizing committee of this symposium, especially Dr. Bruno Maresca. The author also wishes to gratefully acknowledge the 15
help of Sri Sampat Kumar Bhattacharya and Dr. Bob Laks for providing the necessary material for preparing this article. Thanks are due to Drs. Vijaya Laksmi, G.V. Naidu, and H.J. Armbrecht, and for critical reading of the manuscript. References: 1. Atharva Veda, X 8, 4 2. Rig Veda I, 164 3. Kena Upanishad IV 13, 4, 5 4. Brahadaryanka Upanishad II, 3, 1 5. Manduckya Upanishad 6. Srimad Bhagavatam III, 10, 11. 7. Bhagavadgita II, IV 8. Papers from the Eranos Yearbooks Edt. Joseph Campbell XXX series 173, 1973. 9. Time, Space and Things, Edts. Penguin books B.K. Ridley V, 69, 133; 1995 10. Brahmanda Purana IV 11. Time and Space lecture series by Stephen Hawking. 12. Davies, P. C. W. About time : Einstein's unfinished revolution. Edts. NY Simmons 1995 13. Stephen Hawking's A brief history of time : a reader's companion. Edts. Bamtam books 1992 14. John Langone. The mystery of time : humanity's quest for order and measure. National Geographic Society, 2000. 15.Coveney, Peter (Peter V.) The arrow of time : a voyage through science to solve time's greatest mystery. Edts. Fawcett Columbine, 1991 Talk delivered on September 22nd 2002 in the University of Italy and Institute of Genetics for the symposium on the space and time in biology and cosmology.
16