The Return Of The History And End Of The Dream
This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it. If you are author or own the copyright of this book, please report to us by using this DMCA report form. Report DMCA
Overview
Download & View The Return Of The History And End Of The Dream as PDF for free.
More details
- Words: 2,323
- Pages: 5
'kwd,tdrf EdkifiHwumpmayqufqHa&;tiftm;pk P.O Box 201 Rochester, NY 14580------Ph: 585-957-6452----Fax: 585-671-4707
- ! " #$ % & ' (& $) *% &) + )* !, -.$ /
)* & -+0 12 0---$' + + ! " (& $ &+ %.'3' 4# “ 0 *(& $1”( 4# ' ( +#8 ' &) 09:- 09 '+# Don’t Cry For Me Argentina (& $9$0& '-+0 12)
! "*3 ' 4#"1 9 $9 ":2
(& $9: 0- . + 0 12
' ) 0 ) .8&) 0 9K 4#0" *9) * 0 +"1 *L ": ! "-+0 0 9'+#9 9 1 12 & '-- &+ :%! 0 #89 &+ 8 "9 3 M 1
- &+ 09 & . 12 # * $ N &)* - 9 & $ L $O0 +#93' -)* - ## )* 12 0!' &))* () !' '& 0 - 0 9 * $' !' ' P *## %:$'12 (Q) (-' $ - 1: & 1 ' )*.8 . 0 9
: :$ & $')* 12 !' : .0 +#8 $ #+0 0&) +0 12 N * ' 0 1( KN' 9)* 1 *9
+ 0 12 1 0 & $ L# *+ P + 0
+ 0 12 $9.+ 0
12 !' #R: & - )*- & $ & 0 & & $ 4N9M)#-' 0# )* : &+ 0 0 .
&+9 - &) 01 *# 1 .$+ 0 12 ! .0 $ &+ "9 9 0 9+ . . - + 0. 12 . 9+ -'$/+ 0 12 . *(& $ .9 . '1 * & $
& ' 0#0 0
, !9 #89 %!' * +#9& 8. 0!' ' 4 9 9 & 0 * 2 !' L# * + ) 90 0 &)9 # 0 $ + 12 .' & & 0!' '& 0 - 1 2 ! L . 8 #9 + #9 & ' # " $ '' #+0 09 &) +0 2 - * -- ++4 0 ' '& 8& 1- - : 0-0 L : ":2 # & 0 - & .$0 2 O9 +#9 *.$0. 2 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9& $0&+ 0 #S 4 0 : .0.P +0 & '2 QTTU + -' -' *' 0+0 0 0
, 4#4#'1& $9: & $091& ' 1-' & +0. 12 !
09: * ) 1 * 1"'1 "-' + 09 9 9$9$ # # $ 8 .'P+ 0 0 P *3-P9 0 * + 0 12 & ' 0 3 & V 9 " :$'P) * $&) 0 ( NATO) -') *%&) #)*.8+ 0. 12 & $ 4#4#'1 & Z 9 " :$'P ) *$ %+ 0
)*& $ + 0
0 *& P 12 V1 0.$0 3 94[ +# *P 0 0 0+ QTT\ + K &)+0 01 : -' +#19+ 09: 4#4#'1 (Q) * 012 (] &) 0 :' -') % #+0
0 +1"9% &) 0 3 94[ 0 :'
, . $ 0.$0 0 + 0 1) &+ " 0- + & & % 0 * 12 *9"%9 ^ * . 1% 0 3 +#8
, /P3 94[% ) )+# 2 -3 94[ +# "1 9 2
& Z 9 " :$'P) $ 9:*-' # 0) * $9 &+ 8P
2
+ - 9 + 4#4#'1 + - QTT ) %&) 01 * 3 0 ( . 13 4#4#'1 &++ + + & '2 1 0 4#4#'1 + - 3N# 0
&+ %9 1 *9 9 1 .$ 09: 12 & ' 0 1 P 0P+#-*9+1: 0 L
4#4#'1 1:-- 01M -('1& $ -'+ 9 0 L -' + *& $ :
+# 0+ 9 9 :$'+0 12
4#4#'1 0- '1 !9 : *
4#4#'1 LT $ 9 0& _ -P . 8 *+0 12 0- '1 !9 : 4#4#'1 -'+ 0 & QTT` %"(Q) * .&+ 0
0 94[ %3 94[ *3 94[ ' * + +0 ":2 1 0
0- '1 90+# 09 : 9 ' 12
0- '1 & $ 0
& 0- '19 * :
)*-.8+ 0 12 QTT ' ) 0 * + - & $.' 3 4#4#'1
0- '1+ 9 +#P)*9: * / +0 12 !
0- + -('1 1&)+0" : 0 & $ 9 !' #8 # 0 1-
4#4#'1 + - 9 "
":2
4#4#'1 0 0$/ $0 $0.' & '2 94[ &+ 8 ' 9: * 0 9 #8 1
, 4#4#'1 :#89 9 "1 * + 9: * 4#4#'1 "-'&)*# & '2 ( + - 9 " :$'P + $& _ .0& () 1 0!' &) &) 01 - L & ' & $ - 0O9+#
& _ .8 9
+ 09: 12 9: " 4(Robert Kagan)- 0 4[8 2 9:* &+ :%! 3' - + -P 1 * :9# 12 9: QTT + 1+ 0 0 “9& $0&+ 0 #S4 ” ( The Return of The History and End of The Dream) “ & $ % + $3' -P # 0+# L& '- + 0& '” 02 9: 0!'-& 8+#9 9& )*
- +#&) !93 0.' (U) - & + 0 12 () .' 0#89%!' .' &0 P (Q) 4# & '+ $& 0 ' (U) l1 *& .' P &) 12 ! 1+# * ' !9 /P 9 9 & + 0 12' L :#8 9: * 13 #P 09 4N1: 0 12 9: *L :#8 93 # + 0 09 : * .'P & +# 12 1 0 +0 0 (Q)+.$01- ' L3 1 + 1# #P '& 8P + P . 8 *+0 12 ! .0 $9: *L3 .'+ 0 0 :#8 &0&0 $ P& $ -+# 12 1 0 ' L QTTU + ' & $ ' 1 1 ::# # 0 9+1:+ 0 L ":2 1 * $ 1 1 ::)#-'+ 0 .39 9 & ' 9+1: + 0 0 2! .0' L# '1 )*.8 L 9: * &+ 8
!9 /P.8 &) 1 *9 9 & + 0 12 1+# !' '% * 9 9 N 9P+m 2 -( 3 94[ %'% -+# -9 *& P 4 &+ 9 9 & & ' n+#
# 0+# 0 0 ] %!'
- +# *
% + $ / 0 & $ &0& P* P + & '4 !' ' R + - 12
" 4 “9& $0&+ 0 #4 ” L))::1 & - - + 0 09 S4 ( End of The History) & $ +# 0 - 2 ))::1 & '-('1& $ & 8 9 0+ O.'L "1!' '3' $9 & '2 # 0 +, #- 9 + 0& ' *-+0 12 )::1&- 0 -
,
+0 12 13 #P# &+ + 0 0 ML &-P L : ##.8+0
0& $0 0 9 9 P *+0 ":2 " 4 0 “ & %! 9- + 0
0 !9- N 9&+ &+P L & ' O.'L R + +# .'
%+#+ $ P 9% P 012 "1!' ' . 8 * 0 +,P
*& 0+ "1!' ' O.' 9 ! L N o19
9 P+ *9
+ + 0 12 ! .0 $9:* +3 #S4 - $09 + 0 1 : 2 ' ' 9K 1 1 4 # 0 “ " 4 “9 4 +#8 P” - 1 .$P +&) 12 !' * . 8 * 04 "1 +, L !' ' & 0 9 P . & '2 " 4 L P 0
+,9 2 9 :%! 9: $ (Q) %'% V1# 0
' .$/& +# 09 : ) 90 1” * & + 09 3 94[ ' + - 3'&) 0 " : $ “4L# * !' *&) # 0O0 P P P* +# ) 0& 12 /3' - 0O0 + 12 !
0 % *P & 0O & $ - /)* +0" :2 1 0 %- +, + &)
0 +, ^ 90+#L
% . ( !' '* 9 9 *N ) 9&) 1 * +# + 0 12 -' 4#8R '" 0 “ 4 &+ :%! % 09: &) ) 0 &) 12 !' ) &+&)0 " .0 " 4- 0 4[8 L & $ / * 0 0L(# L - 9: 1&) 1- & $9
01” 02 9: *9 9 9 " 4+#& 0$(# L 3+# L & $ 9K 9 - 0 &+ :%! &) 1 *1 .$ . 12 :&+ + 0 12 “9S 4 ” 9+ 09) : )::1 “9& $0&+ 0 #4 ” & + 09: " 4 * 1 L - ( 9 & ). 12 !
0 O0+# 0 9 9 0 & &)0 &)0.'-*# 12 (Q)
" 4 (9*L ) 9' 9 9 +
"4 +# ++# & + 9: + 9 9:* &+ -
)* 012
" 4 p9 #-&)& ' p9 #9"% $ p9 #8 % ) * $ +&) 0 “3' ++ 0#” (Skull and Bones)) % 1&) 12 “#”) *% L (L :9 0+ 3'
+#1 0 #9 &) 12 (The Good Shepherd ' :9 .$0!') *1)2 9K 4#0" 9)L $ #) % &) 12 L( !' # " * "* 1:+0& ' ! " * 0 % !'' 0 p9 & ''+ 0 12 w 4#0+# 'P *+
9:&)+0& ' U ' ' ! 13px1 1&) 0 4#0 &+ :%! .
+ 0 0
+ - 3'&) 12
" 4L -- ' ) % 1&)9 9 ' ) $+ 0 0 " + - 1&) 12 4#%' (Q`) !,1)
,%)% *
" 4 * 9 ' L 9K -' ' -!L:&)8 +#)* )
0
*+0 12 9: * )
PL
, .9R9 +0 12 4 ) * 9:)!L $ (PNAC) * +, 0 9) *% &) 12
-$ % *9 Weekly Standard Commentary New Republic Policy Review * 9:* 1:- 9+ 0& ' ' 9K & 8 4 # :%!.
&) % - 12 (9:* 9 &) % - 0 ( '1 : (Victoria Nuland) &) 12 QTT + "() & $ ++ 0+ Article (5) 0 “L + + L + &) 1” . .9 *9 +#)* 3 94[
L () +# ) * $+09 - ')* $ 9: 3'&) 12)
-$"1 4#'1 " - & ' & $ &+ :%! & ' .
9:&) 12
" 4 0 (w) 12 () -$-+#. P ( % * '4 -T) Twilight Struggle: American Power and Nicaragua, 1977-1990 (Q) Z1# ( &+ 0 1 :%! # $ 0+ 0 ) Present Dangers: Crisis and Opportunities in Foreign and Defense Policy (U) V1# 0 Dangerous Nation (\) (" % . 0 #3 9 Of Paradise and Power (w) &) 0 9& $0&+ 0 #S4 The Return of the History and End of Dreams
*&) 12
Of Paradise and Power &' “O9 :$' 04 ' ”&) + -
+ 0": 12 (& $ &0 0+#*9 - .0 &
)*.8+#
0 +#+ 0":2 0!' & $ * 3 +#$ : -%% #^ 19 P& P 3 94[ * & $ & '+P ( 1 0 1 3)*#.' 9 1 *9: +#+#+ 0 1) 9 9 & + 0 12 + QTT 09:* “9& $0&+ 0 # 4 ” & ' % * -
12 - 1 0 & $ "9& - 1 -
1 * &
0 # *+#$ * : L .0 1& & '9 1-1 3) .$0 +# 12
+# &
) .$0 12
%
Sources Robert Kagan: The Return of The History and End of Dreams
- ! " #$ % & ' (& $) *% &) + )* !, -.$ /
)* & -+0 12 0---$' + + ! " (& $ &+ %.'3' 4# “ 0 *(& $1”( 4# ' ( +#8 ' &) 09:- 09 '+# Don’t Cry For Me Argentina (& $9$0& '-+0 12)
! "*3 ' 4#"1 9 $9 ":2
(& $9: 0- . + 0 12
' ) 0 ) .8&) 0 9K 4#0" *9) * 0 +"1 *L ": ! "-+0 0 9'+#9 9 1 12 & '-- &+ :%! 0 #89 &+ 8 "9 3 M 1
- &+ 09 & . 12 # * $ N &)* - 9 & $ L $O0 +#93' -)* - ## )* 12 0!' &))* () !' '& 0 - 0 9 * $' !' ' P *## %:$'12 (Q) (-' $ - 1: & 1 ' )*.8 . 0 9
: :$ & $')* 12 !' : .0 +#8 $ #+0 0&) +0 12 N * ' 0 1( KN' 9)* 1 *9
+ 0 12 1 0 & $ L# *+ P + 0
+ 0 12 $9.+ 0
12 !' #R: & - )*- & $ & 0 & & $ 4N9M)#-' 0# )* : &+ 0 0 .
&+9 - &) 01 *# 1 .$+ 0 12 ! .0 $ &+ "9 9 0 9+ . . - + 0. 12 . 9+ -'$/+ 0 12 . *(& $ .9 . '1 * & $
& ' 0#0 0
, !9 #89 %!' * +#9& 8. 0!' ' 4 9 9 & 0 * 2 !' L# * + ) 90 0 &)9 # 0 $ + 12 .' & & 0!' '& 0 - 1 2 ! L . 8 #9 + #9 & ' # " $ '' #+0 09 &) +0 2 - * -- ++4 0 ' '& 8& 1- - : 0-0 L : ":2 # & 0 - & .$0 2 O9 +#9 *.$0. 2 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9& $0&+ 0 #S 4 0 : .0.P +0 & '2 QTTU + -' -' *' 0+0 0 0
, 4#4#'1& $9: & $091& ' 1-' & +0. 12 !
09: * ) 1 * 1"'1 "-' + 09 9 9$9$ # # $ 8 .'P+ 0 0 P *3-P9 0 * + 0 12 & ' 0 3 & V 9 " :$'P) * $&) 0 ( NATO) -') *%&) #)*.8+ 0. 12 & $ 4#4#'1 & Z 9 " :$'P ) *$ %+ 0
)*& $ + 0
0 *& P 12 V1 0.$0 3 94[ +# *P 0 0 0+ QTT\ + K &)+0 01 : -' +#19+ 09: 4#4#'1 (Q) * 012 (] &) 0 :' -') % #+0
0 +1"9% &) 0 3 94[ 0 :'
, . $ 0.$0 0 + 0 1) &+ " 0- + & & % 0 * 12 *9"%9 ^ * . 1% 0 3 +#8
, /P3 94[% ) )+# 2 -3 94[ +# "1 9 2
& Z 9 " :$'P) $ 9:*-' # 0) * $9 &+ 8P
2
+ - 9 + 4#4#'1 + - QTT ) %&) 01 * 3 0 ( . 13 4#4#'1 &++ + + & '2 1 0 4#4#'1 + - 3N# 0
&+ %9 1 *9 9 1 .$ 09: 12 & ' 0 1 P 0P+#-*9+1: 0 L
4#4#'1 1:-- 01M -('1& $ -'+ 9 0 L -' + *& $ :
+# 0+ 9 9 :$'+0 12
4#4#'1 0- '1 !9 : *
4#4#'1 LT $ 9 0& _ -P . 8 *+0 12 0- '1 !9 : 4#4#'1 -'+ 0 & QTT` %"(Q) * .&+ 0
0 94[ %3 94[ *3 94[ ' * + +0 ":2 1 0
0- '1 90+# 09 : 9 ' 12
0- '1 & $ 0
& 0- '19 * :
)*-.8+ 0 12 QTT ' ) 0 * + - & $.' 3 4#4#'1
0- '1+ 9 +#P)*9: * / +0 12 !
0- + -('1 1&)+0" : 0 & $ 9 !' #8 # 0 1-
4#4#'1 + - 9 "
":2
4#4#'1 0 0$/ $0 $0.' & '2 94[ &+ 8 ' 9: * 0 9 #8 1
, 4#4#'1 :#89 9 "1 * + 9: * 4#4#'1 "-'&)*# & '2 ( + - 9 " :$'P + $& _ .0& () 1 0!' &) &) 01 - L & ' & $ - 0O9+#
& _ .8 9
+ 09: 12 9: " 4(Robert Kagan)- 0 4[8 2 9:* &+ :%! 3' - + -P 1 * :9# 12 9: QTT + 1+ 0 0 “9& $0&+ 0 #S4 ” ( The Return of The History and End of The Dream) “ & $ % + $3' -P # 0+# L& '- + 0& '” 02 9: 0!'-& 8+#9 9& )*
- +#&) !93 0.' (U) - & + 0 12 () .' 0#89%!' .' &0 P (Q) 4# & '+ $& 0 ' (U) l1 *& .' P &) 12 ! 1+# * ' !9 /P 9 9 & + 0 12' L :#8 9: * 13 #P 09 4N1: 0 12 9: *L :#8 93 # + 0 09 : * .'P & +# 12 1 0 +0 0 (Q)+.$01- ' L3 1 + 1# #P '& 8P + P . 8 *+0 12 ! .0 $9: *L3 .'+ 0 0 :#8 &0&0 $ P& $ -+# 12 1 0 ' L QTTU + ' & $ ' 1 1 ::# # 0 9+1:+ 0 L ":2 1 * $ 1 1 ::)#-'+ 0 .39 9 & ' 9+1: + 0 0 2! .0' L# '1 )*.8 L 9: * &+ 8
!9 /P.8 &) 1 *9 9 & + 0 12 1+# !' '% * 9 9 N 9P+m 2 -( 3 94[ %'% -+# -9 *& P 4 &+ 9 9 & & ' n+#
# 0+# 0 0 ] %!'
- +# *
% + $ / 0 & $ &0& P* P + & '4 !' ' R + - 12
" 4 “9& $0&+ 0 #4 ” L))::1 & - - + 0 09 S4 ( End of The History) & $ +# 0 - 2 ))::1 & '-('1& $ & 8 9 0+ O.'L "1!' '3' $9 & '2 # 0 +, #- 9 + 0& ' *-+0 12 )::1&- 0 -
,
+0 12 13 #P# &+ + 0 0 ML &-P L : ##.8+0
0& $0 0 9 9 P *+0 ":2 " 4 0 “ & %! 9- + 0
0 !9- N 9&+ &+P L & ' O.'L R + +# .'
%+#+ $ P 9% P 012 "1!' ' . 8 * 0 +,P
*& 0+ "1!' ' O.' 9 ! L N o19
9 P+ *9
+ + 0 12 ! .0 $9:* +3 #S4 - $09 + 0 1 : 2 ' ' 9K 1 1 4 # 0 “ " 4 “9 4 +#8 P” - 1 .$P +&) 12 !' * . 8 * 04 "1 +, L !' ' & 0 9 P . & '2 " 4 L P 0
+,9 2 9 :%! 9: $ (Q) %'% V1# 0
' .$/& +# 09 : ) 90 1” * & + 09 3 94[ ' + - 3'&) 0 " : $ “4L# * !' *&) # 0O0 P P P* +# ) 0& 12 /3' - 0O0 + 12 !
0 % *P & 0O & $ - /)* +0" :2 1 0 %- +, + &)
0 +, ^ 90+#L
% . ( !' '* 9 9 *N ) 9&) 1 * +# + 0 12 -' 4#8R '" 0 “ 4 &+ :%! % 09: &) ) 0 &) 12 !' ) &+&)0 " .0 " 4- 0 4[8 L & $ / * 0 0L(# L - 9: 1&) 1- & $9
01” 02 9: *9 9 9 " 4+#& 0$(# L 3+# L & $ 9K 9 - 0 &+ :%! &) 1 *1 .$ . 12 :&+ + 0 12 “9S 4 ” 9+ 09) : )::1 “9& $0&+ 0 #4 ” & + 09: " 4 * 1 L - ( 9 & ). 12 !
0 O0+# 0 9 9 0 & &)0 &)0.'-*# 12 (Q)
" 4 (9*L ) 9' 9 9 +
"4 +# ++# & + 9: + 9 9:* &+ -
)* 012
" 4 p9 #-&)& ' p9 #9"% $ p9 #8 % ) * $ +&) 0 “3' ++ 0#” (Skull and Bones)) % 1&) 12 “#”) *% L (L :9 0+ 3'
+#1 0 #9 &) 12 (The Good Shepherd ' :9 .$0!') *1)2 9K 4#0" 9)L $ #) % &) 12 L( !' # " * "* 1:+0& ' ! " * 0 % !'' 0 p9 & ''+ 0 12 w 4#0+# 'P *+
9:&)+0& ' U ' ' ! 13px1 1&) 0 4#0 &+ :%! .
+ 0 0
+ - 3'&) 12
" 4L -- ' ) % 1&)9 9 ' ) $+ 0 0 " + - 1&) 12 4#%' (Q`) !,1)
,%)% *
" 4 * 9 ' L 9K -' ' -!L:&)8 +#)* )
0
*+0 12 9: * )
PL
, .9R9 +0 12 4 ) * 9:)!L $ (PNAC) * +, 0 9) *% &) 12
-$ % *9 Weekly Standard Commentary New Republic Policy Review * 9:* 1:- 9+ 0& ' ' 9K & 8 4 # :%!.
&) % - 12 (9:* 9 &) % - 0 ( '1 : (Victoria Nuland) &) 12 QTT + "() & $ ++ 0+ Article (5) 0 “L + + L + &) 1” . .9 *9 +#)* 3 94[
L () +# ) * $+09 - ')* $ 9: 3'&) 12)
-$"1 4#'1 " - & ' & $ &+ :%! & ' .
9:&) 12
" 4 0 (w) 12 () -$-+#. P ( % * '4 -T) Twilight Struggle: American Power and Nicaragua, 1977-1990 (Q) Z1# ( &+ 0 1 :%! # $ 0+ 0 ) Present Dangers: Crisis and Opportunities in Foreign and Defense Policy (U) V1# 0 Dangerous Nation (\) (" % . 0 #3 9 Of Paradise and Power (w) &) 0 9& $0&+ 0 #S4 The Return of the History and End of Dreams
*&) 12
Of Paradise and Power &' “O9 :$' 04 ' ”&) + -
+ 0": 12 (& $ &0 0+#*9 - .0 &
)*.8+#
0 +#+ 0":2 0!' & $ * 3 +#$ : -%% #^ 19 P& P 3 94[ * & $ & '+P ( 1 0 1 3)*#.' 9 1 *9: +#+#+ 0 1) 9 9 & + 0 12 + QTT 09:* “9& $0&+ 0 # 4 ” & ' % * -
12 - 1 0 & $ "9& - 1 -
1 * &
0 # *+#$ * : L .0 1& & '9 1-1 3) .$0 +# 12
+# &
) .$0 12
%
Sources Robert Kagan: The Return of The History and End of Dreams
Related Documents
The Return Of The History And End Of The Dream
November 2019 12
The Return Of The History _ Part 1
November 2019 8
The End Of History -the Eu Version
June 2020 6
The End Of The Universe
April 2020 26
The End Of The End Of The Recession
May 2020 23