The Hillsdale Forum - September 2008

the.Hillsdale.Forum VIEW FROM THE INSIDE:

sOUND bITES

Barack Obama, in an interview with Fox New’s Bill O’Reilly, on the “offensive comments” made by Reverend Jeremiah Wright:

BACKSTAGE, BEHIND the SCENES and the

BEST PARTIES of the

2008 Republican National Convention

FULL COVERAGE PAGE 6

the Devil Went Down to Georgia: Russia’s Return to Imperialism

MATT COLE STAFF WRITER

At the end of the Cold War, western nations held their breath in hopes that a new democratic Russia would allow its historically imperialist governing-style to fall by the wayside. To the dismay of democracies around the world, Russia has proven that old habits die hard: on August 8, 2008, Russia invaded a former Soviet satellite, the Republic of Georgia. Russia’s foreign policy has been consistent since the end of WWII: invade smaller, weaker, nations in order to exploit their resources and labor. While Georgia is just another benchmark in this age-old tradition, it is important understand the history of both nations in order

to better answer the questions: Why Georgia? Why now? Georgia first began major relations with Russia in 1800 when the nation was willingly absorbed into the Russian Empire in order to receive military protection against Turkey and Iran. After the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution, Georgia re-declared their independence; unfortunately, their freedom was short-lived, as they were invaded by the Red Army in 1921 and forced into the newly-formed Soviet Union. For the next 70 years, Georgia became just another addition to Soviet expansionism, contributing troops to both World Wars, while acting as the birth place of Joseph Stalin. In 1991, as the Soviet Union

CONTINUED ON PAGE 8

VOlume IX, Issue II SEPTEMBER 2008

MR. O’REILLY: You had never heard those comments? SEN. OBAMA: I hadn’t heard those comments. MR. O’REILLY: He was selling them in the lobby at the church. SEN. OBAMA: What can I tell ya? MR. O’REILLY: How many times did you go to church a month? SEN. OBAMA: You know, I’d probably go twice a month sometimes. MR. O’REILLY: And he never said inflammatory stuff? SEN. OBAMA: He didn’t say stuff like that, all right. MR. O’REILLY: Did he say white people were bad? SEN. OBAMA: No. What he said was racism is bad. MR. O’REILLY: But not white people are bad? SEN. OBAMA: There was no doubt that what he said was racism was bad. The relationship was ruptured, I’m not a member of the church. MR. O’REILLY: Right.

BYPASS THE BREATHALYZER in.this.ISSUE JAMES NESBITT STAFF WRITER

Hillsdale students returning to campus have discovered a lot of changes this year: a newly designed quad, freshly paved parking lots, and the first full year of a new student union and cafeteria, but, another change has confronted some students: an increased level of law enforcement by Michigan State Police. During the weekend prior to the start of the semester, between 12 and 14 students received minor in possession (MIP) citations from area law enforcement officers, according to Director of Security Mike Wertz. Police issue these citations

by administering breath tests to students, which amounts to a search and seizure of evidence. When an officer wishes to enter private property to search and seize, he first needs to get a warrant. But a few police officers have led some students to believe that this requirement does not apply when citizens are walking on the streets. One of these students, who asked to remain anonymous, recalled her exchange with state troopers Keith Pillar and Britt Owen, who stopped her while she was walking down Hillsdale Street: “I asked them, ‘Do

CONTINUED ON PAGE 2

The Most Conservative Movie You May Never See

PAGE 10 =

Eye On the Statehouse

PAGE 3 =

Obama’s Radical Stance on Abortion (And its Survivors)

PAGE 2 =

Two Students Face-Off About Palin’s Pregnant Daughter

PAGE 9

2

news

A New Extreme on Abortion: Obama’s Infanticide Problem

language guaranteeing it wouldn’t be used someday to undermine Roe staff writer v. Wade. Considering that reversing Roe After Jill Stanek, a nurse at Christ Hospital in Oak Lawn, Illinois, would not ban abortion, but simply exposed how doctors at the send the issue back to the democratic hospital were leaving newborns process, we could conclude from who survived abortions to starve to this that leaving newborns to a slow, agonizing death, the death was of state senate less concern considered THIS ISSUE ULTIMATELY IS ABOUT legislation ABORTION AND NOT LIVE BIRTHs to Obama than the protecting -BARACK OBAMA nightmare the rights of scenario such “bornalive infants” in 2001 and 2002. of Americans voting on abortion Both times, then-state Senator policy. This excuse didn’t reflect Barack Obama opposed it. He well on him, but it was nothing initially dismissed objections to his compared to the revelations to stance on the grounds that he would come. In late August, the National Right have voted yes if the bill included

CALVIN FREIBURGER

“

”

to Life Committee unearthed records showing that in 2003, Illinois lawmakers had tried again, this time with the very language Obama claimed was the original dealbreaker. Senate Amendment 001 said, “Nothing in this Section shall be construed to affirm, deny, expand, or contract any legal status or legal right applicable to any member of the species homo sapiens at any point prior to being born alive as defined in this Section.” At the time, Obama chaired the Health Committee, which unanimously added the previous language— only for Obama to vote no on the bill anyways, killing it before it reached the Senate floor. Why? As

CONTINUED ON PAGE 5

SEPTEMBER 2008 While Western speculation abounds, North Korea vehemently denies that their leader, Kim Jong Il is gravely ill and/or recovering from a severe medical ailment.

During the New England Patriots’ opening game, quarterback Tom Brady tore both the ACL and MCL in his left knee, likely ending his season and requiring 6 to 9 months of rehabilitation.

Actor Matt Damon recently told the Associated Press that he believes that Sarah Palin facing down Russian President Putin would resemble “a really bad Disney movie;” this, from the actor who supported the movie “Jersey Girl.”

In an less than surprising announcement, Apple unveiled the revamped iPod Nano at a press conference last Tuesday. In a variety of colors, it features a thinner design, wider screen, and shuffle sensors similar to that of the iPhone. During the presentation, Steve Jobs declined to comment on his health.

Sports star and cancer survivor Lance Armstrong has decided to get back on the bike in attempt to win his 8th Tour de France. Another political genius: Joe Biden, who told supporters at a Wednesday rally that, “Hillary Clinton is as qualified or more qualified than I am to be vice president of the United States of America.”

mip FROM PAGE 1 photo courtesy of City of Detroit

NO MORE PADDY-WHACK for KILPATRICK Detroit’s Mayor Falls From Grace and into a Heap of Trouble

NATE ANDERSON staff writer

After deliberation a Detroit jury decided not to give the dog a bone. The two-term mayor encountered a series of allegations and accusations of misconduct since his election in 2001. These included inviting strippers to the mayoral mansion, numerous accusations of corruption, an extramarital affair, and ultimately, avowed perjury as well as assaulting a police officer. Mayor Kilpatrick held up for the months despite the mounting evidence against him. The tide began to finally turn when text messages surfaced in January that explicitly evidenced an affair he had long since denied

under oath. The mayor finally pled guilty to three charges; six felonies were discarded as part of the plea bargain. To the city of Detroit he owes four months in prison, a million dollars, his future pension, law license, and five months of probation. Shortly after the agreement the disgraced mayor chose to grace the people of Detroit with his presence, giving an address that the Detroit Free Press described as “part-apology, part campaign speech.” He gallingly declared, “Our challenge now is to put the anguish and the turmoil of recent months behind us… To those who have supported me throughout the years....I thank you with all my heart ...I know that supporting me has not always been easy, but it has not

been boring either.” According to the Detroit Free Press he proceeded to crack a smile. Governor Granholm, who the mayor stalwartly supported, demonstrated her eagerness to look past the affair. “It’s very important for us as a state and as a city to turn this page together. There is much work to do. It is my profound hope that we can now write a new history for this great but embattled city.” Fewer and fewer Americans can remember the day that the word “great” every applied to city of Detroit, at least without being followed by the words riot or fire. Detroit may have burned some time ago but Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick did worse than fiddle as it continued to smolder. HF

I have to take a breathalyzer?’ The police told me, ‘Michigan law says you need to take a breathalyzer.’” MCL §436.1703(6) states that an “officer who has reasonable cause to believe a minor has consumed alcoholic liquor or has any bodily alcohol content may require the person to submit to a preliminary chemical breath analysis…A minor who refuses to submit to a preliminary chemical breath test analysis as required in this subsection is responsible for a state civil infraction and may be ordered to pay a civil fine of not more than $100.00.” There is a hole in what police are telling students, however. Although police are able to cite this law to convince students to cooperate, they cannot actually enforce it. In September 2007, Judge David M. Lawson of the United States Eastern District Court of Michigan ruled in Platte et al. v. Thomas Township et al. “that Michigan Complied Laws §436.1703(6) is unconstitutional on its face because it is repugnant to the Fourth Amendment…Governor

Ron Paul refuses to endorse John McCain’s bid for the presidency. The United States has seen a sharp decrease in citizenship applications after hiking the application fee to combat costs. The new price of freedom? $675.

Jennifer Granholm, [her] servants, agents and employees, and those in active concert and participation with [her], are restrained and enjoined from enforcing or imposing sanctions under Michigan Complied Laws §436.1703(6), and from enforcing any policy or rule enacted under the authority of said statute.” This ruling requires police to obtain a warrant before requiring pedestrians to submit to a breathalyzer test. Officers have been citing MCL 436.1703(6) and warning students of the penalties for not submitting to a breath test, but they have not been disclosing to students the fact that this statute is not enforceable. Faced with the intimidating circumstances of the situation, the officers’ suggestions, and lacking the knowledge that citizens may refuse to submit to a breath test before a warrant is obtained, many students decide to cooperate. “I didn’t know about the [the court’s decision]. The officers told me that if I cooperated and paid my fine, the school and my parents wouldn’t find out, so I took the test,” said one student confronted by Michigan State Police. HF

3

the Hillsdale Forum staff

“UNITES”

HILLSDALE CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP

Nate AndersON staff writer

While the Hillsdale Christian (HCF) program at Hillsdale College has had a substantial presence for many years, the group has recently put some effort into centralizing and expanding its ministry on campus. During its kickoff on the 28th of August, various student leaders including David Stehlik, Sarah Gillary, Shannon McCleary and Nate Jerauld explained the function of the group’s various arms. The primary alteration comes with the addition of “Frontlines.” In an attempt to provide go-to Bible studies for each dorm, HCF opted to imprint its stamp onto student-initiated groups. Involvement thus far has proved allinclusive, involving over a dozen small groups, from studies of “Mere Christianity,” to a Christian video series and old-fashioned reviews of books in the Bible. HCF provides loose oversight, encouraging group leaders to meet with the Pastor of the Pine Ridge Church and HCF affiliate, Steve Bricks. Vision Team member and leader of the Foundations ministry, David Stehlik, described HCF and Pastor Bricks’s role as helping to “cast the vision for small group leaders who control their own curriculum.” “We recognize the common purpose,” he emphasized. The “Foundations” ministry encompasses the prayer and fasting element of HCF. The group is open to any student, or at least any willing to forego a few trips to SAGA. Stehlik especially encourages students to accept a 15 meal plan instead of the

Emilia Huneke-Bergquist Fellowship/Intervarsity

Dave Wasmer AssOciate EditOr Heather Shell COpy EditOr Nate Anderson Matt Cole Calvin Freiburger Martin Kraegel III Nathan Lichtman Christina Miller James Nesbitt Scott Rozell Lizzy Shell Staff Writers Kate Martin DC COrrespOndent

Guided by the principles of liberty, freedom, and justice,

The.Hillsdale.Forum

is a monthly studentrun publication of Hillsdale College striving to inform and educate its readers about today’s everchanging Conservative political climate.

CONTACT US: HILLSDALEFORUM @GMAIL.COM

MARTIN KRAEGEL III

CCA REVIEW

Julie Robison EditOrs in Chief

staff writer

Just as last year’s CCA on the lessons and legacy of the Vietnam War coincided neatly with the national debate on US policy in Iraq, this year’s opening CCA on the Cold War also finds a parallel in current events. Russia’s aggressive response to Georgia, regarding the breakaway provinces of South Ossetia and Abkhazia,

customary 19 meals, donating the surplus ($140) to the HCF treasurer. “In the time that you would usually fill yourself up physically you can fill yourself up spiritually,” he explained. Replacing and altering the former Crossroads meeting is “Unite.” The service runs just one Thursday a month, and is meant to be a type of umbrella gathering of all the smaller ministries. As before, it will consist of praise and worship, as well as a guest speaker. AIA (Athletes in Action) and “The Well,” a contemporary worship service, will continue under the HCF banner. The administration has markedly solidified the sprawling campus ministries. Groups that attempt to incorporate outside leadership, beyond Intervarsity, are generally prohibited from using campus facilities, unless they reach an agreement with the campus ministry. UCO, or University Christian Outreach, an Ann Arbor-based ministry, attempted to negotiate the placement of a charismatic worship and prayer service on campus. The group was ultimately barred from becoming an official campus club, due to its outside leadership. The group eventually located off campus, with UCO leader, Mike Shaugnessy, nonetheless reporting that he was “very happy” with negotiations. It remains to be seen whether the administrations efforts to provide a comprehensive worship experience for Christian students will pay off. Toeing the line between base uniformity and baseless acceptance promises to provide a challenge for many years to come. HF has sparked speculation that a renewal of the Cold War may be imminent, while tensions between the West and Russia have reached levels not seen in years. New missile defense systems to be placed in Poland and the Czech Republic, while ostensibly aimed Iran, have been viewed by Russia as threatening to their power, along with the United States’ goal to include countries like Georgia and Ukraine into NATO. Former President of Russia, and former member of the KGB, Vladimir

STATEHOUSE

EYE ON THE

SEPTEMBER 2008

James nesbitt

NEWS

Michigan legislators have introduced a myriad of bills during the most recent legislative session. Some are wise, some are dangerous, and some are just plain silly. This month’s highlights are:

staff writer

From the sewer pipe:

Senate Bill 1306 Primary Sponsor: Hansen Clarke (D-Detroit) Text Excerpt: “In an action to foreclose a mortgage or land contract of residential property…the court, on motion of a defendant, shall order the action stayed for 2 years after the entry of the stay order.” Analysis: This bill would deny banks and other lenders to reclaim their rightful property. Although evictions are sad things, residents do not rightfully and legally own their homes until they have repaid their loans. This bill would send the clear message that the state of Michigan does not respect property rights. The end result will be a dearth of investment in Michigan and an increase in low-income citizens without access to home-ownership. Last Action: 5/7/08—Referred to Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions. Note: The Moratorium Now! Coalition is organizing a rally in Lansing on September 17th to demand a hearing in committee for this bill. Bad news for Hillsdaleans of the United Methodist denomination: this coalition is housed and supported by the Central United Methodist Church of Detroit.

From the dream pipe:

House Bill 4454 Primary Sponsor: Jacob Hoogendyk (R-Kalamazoo) Text Excerpt: This bill would prohibit a person from “[requiring] an employee to do any of the following as a condition of employment or continued employment: (a) Become or remain a member of a labor organization. (b) Pay dues, fees, assessments, or other similar charges to a labor organization. (c) Pay to a charity or other third party an amount equivalent to or pro rata portion of dues, fees, assessments, or other charges required of members of a labor organization.” Analysis: This bill would allow Michigan workers the choice to participate in a union. This provides an incentive for unions to provide a meaningful service to their members and ends their monopoly. The bill would reduce labor costs for Michigan businesses and increase Michigan’s economic competitiveness with other countries and other states. Last Action: 7/23/08—Notice given to Discharge Committee. Putin, still seen as the real power in that country, has been adamant about nationalizing Russia’s oil industry, using its energy resources as leverage in Europe, and projecting power in the region economically. Some speculate he has his sights on a renewed Russian empire. Russia-U.S. relations have become a campaign issue in the 2008 election as well. Both major presidential candidates have criticized Russia. Republican candidate John McCain echoed John F. Kennedy in proclaiming that,

“Today we’re all Georgians,” and vowing that the United States will stand by Georgia in facing Russia. Examining the issues and history involved in the Cold War and its lessons for today, CCA I, entitled “The Cold War: History and Controversies,” held from September 7th to September 11th included speakers: Tatiana Yankelevich, director of the Andrei Sakharov Program on Human Rights, speaking on “Life Behind

CONTINUED ON PAGE 9

the

4

rOundTable

When I get rich, I’m going to sit and write checks while I watch Fox News all day.

–Brad Huges, GA Delegate and Fox News junkie

You again?

–Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly to GA Delegate Brad Huges

Now my family has been calling and calling…they all want me to try and get on TV again tonight.

–RNC Volunteer from Alabama

I think that what Senator McCain said was important. To Arabs he said some great things. The line about not sending more money to people that hate us, that is very important.

–Mando Shailem, Egyptian Emigrant

SEPTEMBER 2008 After having heard all of the candidates, the politicians, the news anchors, the political analysts, and the talking heads dissect this past week’s Republican National Convention like a high school science experiment, it is always a little more interesting to hear what real people have to say. The chance to speak to delegates, locals, and little ones was one that I couldn’t pass up. Here is a record of what they had to say about John McCain, Sarah Palin, and the party in St. Paul, Minnesota. –Emilia Huneke-Bergquist

“We like everything!” “I got to lick an ice sculpture!”

–Henry Curtis, OH Alternate Delegate

photo courtesy of Drew DeJong

I am an anomaly: I am a conservative, I am a Republican, and I am an African-American. And with all those qualities, I am having a lot of fun around here. –Retired Marine Charlie Strickland, MN Alternate Delegate

Joel Westrom is the Chair of the 1st Congressional District of Michigan, a district encompassing 42% of the land mass but only 3% of the state’s population.

Emily (age 8) and Zoe (age 6) on what they like about their first-ever Republican National Convention. Their father was a California delegate.

He had this to say about Michiganders at the 2008 RNC,

“I think we were all a little bit hung-over from the Romney thing, but Palin seems to have turned that around. She is a shock factor—sharp, articulate, relatable—she has narrowed the gap. Clearly, our placement [near the stage] reflects the importance of Michigan in this upcoming election.”

We’re very proud of her. It was an honor that just happened to come her way, and it is very well deserved. –Mr. Heil, father of RNC intern and Hillsdale Student E.B. Heil

photo by Huneke-Bergquist

I’ve never been in a city this friendly with this much tear gas residue.

–Comedian Jon Stewart on Minneapolis/St. Paul (September 5,

photo by Huneke-Bergquist

I am impressed with her, I think that she will bring unfiltered experience to the ticket. As a neutral candidate, Palin is the Republican’s lifeline. The party is unified behind her.

Tell everyone and don’t stop until we put John McCain and Sarah Palin in the White House!

I am at a loss for words when it comes to –C.R. Waters, AZ Delegate Sarah Palin. Originally, I was a Romney supporter, but This is my sixth convention, and I have been now it is time to get the word out about our a McCain supporter for the last two years. We have to keep this momentum alive Maverick. through November –Joan Rynolds, MI Delegate

–John Peschong, CA Delegate

5

SPOTLIGHT

SEPTEMBER 2008

President Phillips’ BOLD STAND on CAMPUS UNREST Stephen Casai

Guest CONTRIBUTOR In the late 1960s, U.S. campuses were in turmoil. Students rebelled and spoke out against the draft, Vietnam War, and college curriculums. They distrusted everyone over 30. Some wanted to overthrow the establishment. They even demonstrated in classrooms, preventing professors from teaching. On July 22, 1968, Hillsdale College President J. Donald Phillips (1907-1993) took a bold and courageous stand on campus unrest. In a letter approved by the Board of Trustees and sent out to all Hillsdale College students enrolled for the fall semester, he warned that the college would not tolerate student disturbances. At the time, Hillsdale was not experiencing any problems. In fact, Phillips said in the letter, “The following expression is probably quite unnecessary for any of our students and is not made because of any special knowledge or expectation.” . Still, he wanted to make sure that campus violence did not start at Hillsdale. So he said that the

students must “know in advance what the college position will be in certain areas.” In the third paragraph of the letter, Phillips reminded students of an important point. “Attendance at Hillsdale College is a privilege and not a right!” he said. Nevertheless, he said the students should have some voice in the college’s affairs “Wisdom would direct that in fast-changing and complicated times, and with the improved preparation of young people for college, their ideals, suggestions, and desires should be sought and should be thoughtfully considered,” he said. He urged the students to discuss their ideas with Student Federation and faculty and administrative committees. He even said that the students were still allowed to dissent as long as it was legal and peaceful. “The right to dissent has been an honored American tradition,” he said. “That privilege has always been and will be respected at Hillsdale College.” In the second from last paragraph of his letter, Phillips laid down the

law. He warned the students that they would face disciplinary action if they refused to comply with the policy. “Therefore let it be known that any act of violence or intimidation,” he said,” any seizing of any portion of property or any unauthorized activity which prevents the normal operation of the college in any way by any individual or groups of individuals will be considered in direct opposition to the necessary operation of the college, and action sufficient to the cause will be taken immediately, including the possibility and probability of suspension or expulsion, regardless of the number involved. Similar acts will be taken against those who advocate such described activity.” One can tell that Phillips carefully thought out each section of the letter, especially the conclusion. If he had ended the letter with the above paragraph, the students might have resented it. Phillips, however, was a brilliant communicator. He had great respect for the students and knew that some might disagree with the policy and want to transfer to another school The letter, he said, “is submit-

9/11: Never Forget Project

photo by Wasmer

Each year, Hillsdale College Republicans, in partnership with the Young America’s Foundation, go to work in the early morning hours of September 11 to arrange nearly 3,000 tiny American flags along the Quad in memory of those killed in the 2001 terrorist attacks. Though this year’s anniversary has past, we humbly ask that you please keep each of the victims and their families in your thoughts and prayers throughout the upcoming week.

ted now in order that a student may have adequate time to select another college if the above terms are unacceptable. Moreover, the college shall use its offices to help such a student find a college or university more acceptable to his or her personal purposes.” Phillips’ letter received national coverage. Three hundred newspapers printed articles about his letter, and it was reported on hundreds of radio and television broadcasts. An article in the Sept. 30, 1968, issue of U.S. News & World Report included several excerpts from Phillips’ letter and his picture. “In a period of sit-ins, riots, and general student revolt on U.S. campuses, at least one college has laid down a firm policy on what is expected of its students-- and told them to go elsewhere if they don’t like it,” the magazine said. “J Donald Phillips, president of Hillsdale College, wrote to all incoming students advising them that the administration intends to run the school.” The Hillsdale Collegian marveled at the great response to Phillips’ letter.

“President J. Donald Phillips has done a fantastic job of bringing Hillsdale College into national news,” the student newspaper said. “Approximately 3-5 million people have recently read about President Phillips’ letter.” According to the fall 1968 issue of the Hillsdale Magazine, the college received many letters from the students and their parents, expressing their gratitude that “their education would not be disrupted.” The college’s magazine also pointed out that not a single student withdrew from Hillsdale because of the letter. In 1968, E. Ross Adair, U.S. congressman and member of Hillsdale College’s Board of Trustees, honored Phillips’ letter by entering it in the Congressional Record.

OBAMA FROM PAGE 2

entered into a consent decree in 1993 agreeing not to prosecute doctors for apparent or alleged violations of this law based on ‘born alive’ definitions or other definitions.” This is, simply put, infanticide. It is evil even by the standards most prochoicers claim to hold. It’s shocking that a United States Senator could so callously disregard both his first duty (“to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men”), and basic human decency and compassion, all to thwart even the slightest, most nonexistent challenge to what pundit Ann Coulter aptly called the Left’s “holiest sacrament: abortion.” It’s even more shocking that a mainstream political party could embrace him. All Americans of conscience— liberal, conservative, and independent alike—ought to be disgusted. Barack Obama is running in part on a promise to heal the sins of the past, but it is clear all he’ll really do is trade them for brandnew sins of the future. HF

Obama said on April 4, 2002, he was worried “what liabilities the doctor might have in this situation,” and dismissed the concerns driving the bill, because he was sure “this issue ultimately is about abortion and not live births.” After this scandal blew up in Obama’s face, his defenders have claimed both that Jill Stanek’s allegations were never corroborated and that Illinois law already protected such babies. Both claims are false. At the time, Christ Hospital admitted they were performing live-birth abortions (but announced it would from then on limit use of the procedure to babies with fatal birth defects), and while pre-existing Illinois law ostensibly protected abortion survivors, it only required treatment for babies who had “sustainable survivability.” In addition, as Chicago Tribune columnist Eric Zorn wrote on August 20, “Prosecutors in Illinois

This article has been reprinted with permission from Stephen Casai. Affectionately known as “Saga Steve,” Casai serves as a customer representative at the Knorr Family Dining room and contributed to the local magazine Community Plus+ from 1997 until 2000. This article originally appeared in the August 2000 issue. Casai is available via e-mail at [email protected].

6

7

Open Forum

SEPTEMBER 2008

SEPTEMBER 2008

the Right People, the Right Place, & the Right’s Big Party an inside look at the 2008 Republican National Convention

emilia huneke-bergquist EDITOR IN CHIEF

The flight from Detroit to St. Paul was at capacity; filled, in part, by thirty-five Pittsburgh police officers coming to aid in securing the cities for the week. Joking and laughing amongst one another, it would have been easy to mistake the group for a sports team. Other than being slightly taller and more muscular than the average American, they were nearly indistinguishable from the other passengers. Yet, when one officer was reaching to place his carry-on in the overhead compartment, he exposed his holstered gun, taking several passengers by surprise amidst today’s age of overbearing airport security. Arriving in the Twin Cities on Saturday, it was instantly palpable that something big was about to take place. Secret service and police officers paced the airport looking stiff and official; several people carried large camera

bags out to awaiting taxis; locals rushed around looking both elated and annoyed -- the 2008 Republican National Convention began.

SATURDAY

Saturday evening, the RNC hosted a Media Party, inviting all

credentialed press to attend a reception and festival at the Mill City Museum and Guthrie Theater. Both stand along the Mississippi River as a tribute to America, the museum a

living record of Minnesota’s milling industry and the Guthrie, a modern architectural wonder. Thousands of people crowded both venues, all eager for hors d’oeuvres, an open bar, and the free water bottles filled with sparkling river water (filtered, of course). Environmentalism remains a hotly contested topic in Minnesota. Though it is rumored that Republicans are out to destroy all of God’s creation, the RNC, in partnership with Coca-Cola, made a point of recycling and using renewable resources wherever possible. The evening passed quickly, a sweet mix of humidity and jazz music, and before long, the crowd thinned and chariots turned to pumpkins.

SUNDAY

Much of the same crowd attended the Sunday premier of An American Carol, a film starring Kevin Farley as Michael Malone, an anti-American filmmaker out to annul the Fourth of July. (Full review, page 10) The reception beforehand featured a touching tribute to the Armed Forces, each branch receiving their own space to decorate. The Army had the largest following: it featured a vintage Jeep and smiling couple dressed in the classic tan uniforms, with attendees winding a line around the surrounding high-tops and serving tables to have their

photos taken at the display. Next, USO performers “The Liberty Belles” took the stage in sequined dresses and hats reminiscent of the 1940s, performing a classic set of patriotic songs that energized a bored audience. As they sang “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy,” Minnesota Senator Norm Coleman and his wife Laurie quietly made the rounds, mingling with guests

of every fireworks display in recent American history, hearing it preformed live invoked a palpable emotion in the many soldiers, veterans, and ordinary citizens in attendance. Post-performance had the excited crowed moving eagerly from the reception hall to the auditorium, picking up popcorn, candy, and bottled water from carts lining the way. Crowding hundreds of conservatives into a theater and showing them all an anti-Michael Moore movie had it obvious effects: cheers, jokes, and jeers abounded.

DELEGATES DANCED, POLITICIANS NETWORKED, EVERYONE DRANK, AND THE PARTY ENDED JUST PASSED THE JUVENILE HOUR OF ELEVEN PM. while pausing for conversations and the occasional photo, seeming genuinely interested in spending time with guests. After the Colemans’ departure, country star Lee Greenwood, donning a royal blue and black leather jacket, sang a series of tunes from his albums past and present before performing his famed “Proud to be an American” tune. Swaying back and forth as they waved miniature flags, the audience was enamored. The theme

MONDAY

Barricaded for a sevenblock radius, entering the Xcel Center on Monday morning was made all the more difficult by hundreds of protesters that crowded into the streets and parks along the way. Riot police stood ready, armed with long-range tear gas canisters and batons, as did a human wall of National Guardsman aligned along Kellogg Street bearing shields and gas masks. Past the mobs, police monitored the entry gates carefully as volunteers scanned clearance badges. Beyond the first checkpoint, entrants moved through metal detectors while security personnel rifle through belongings, removing anything odd, blunt, sharp, or deemed

otherwise dangerous. One Fox anchor had a pineapple taken away (it was later returned to him,) and piles of umbrellas lay abandoned under security tables. Arriving at the entrance, visitors again held their passes in the air, a final visual confirmation of their clearance. Hurricane Gustav cut the opening day’s schedule short as President Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney cancelled their appearances in order to aid the Gulf Coast. Instantaneously, what had been a pep rally for John McCain turned to relief fund-raiser, with RNC Chairman Mike Duncan leading the effort. First Lady Laura Bush and First Lady hopeful Cindy McCain gave short speeches encouraging charity before airing videos in which Governors Rick Perry (TX), Charlie Crist (FL), Haley Barbour (MS), and Bob Riley (AL) offered their own words of thanks and support. After only three hours of official business, the convention adjourned for the day. That evening, the Michigan delegation hosted a party at local nightclub Karma. A chic venue, the Motown cover band played favorites from the 60s and 70s while a disco ball reflected tiny squares of white light all over the delegates moving across the dance floor.

Delegates danced, politicians networked, everyone drank, and the party ended just passed the juvenile hour of eleven p.m.

TUESDAY

Despite the cancellations, officials filled Tuesday’s lineup and arranged with most networks to extend primetime coverage of the convention. Laura Bush introduced her husband via satellite to rousing applause and fanfare. President Bush’s abbreviated speech included all of the trademark elements: some love for McCain, some love for America, and a joke. Despite the mediocrity, however, President Bush paved the way for both former Senator Fred Thompson and Senator Joe Lieberman, whose energetic and enthusiastic speeches shed new light on the Republican presidential nominee. Alongside the delegate floor, in the VIP booth, former President George H. Bush and his wife Barbara sat alongside six former Vietnam POWs and Cindy McCain. Across the river in Minneapolis, the Bipartisan Policy Center hosted the “Two Parties, One Ticket” event at local restaurant Bellanotte. Dedicated to bridging

the gap between Republicans and Democrats, Former Senate Majority Leaders, Tom Daschle, Bob Dole, Howard Baker, and George Mitchell founded the center in 2007. But the RNC was not the only convention in town that week. Just as the party started, Ron Paul supporters started to trickled out of the Target Center. Some were quiet, while others stood fired up and ready to fight. Standing on the streets yelling incoherently about the “Revolution” and Ron Paul’s plans to turn America around, they fazed no one. From the patio, a team of security and secret service looked on in amusement. While the secret service didn’t attend every party, Bob Dole’s presence at Bellanotte demanded their presence on this particular evening. He mingled with guests for about an hour, smiling for photos before, no doubt, heading to bed.

WEDNESDAY

The conventions final days blur together in a mix of excitement and balloons. Wednesday evening, Mike Huckabee, Rudy Giuliani, and Mitt Romney greeted a lively crowd, each humorously criticizing Barack Obama’s Chicago history and plans for the presidency. Their remarks e l i c i t e d laughter, as the trio warmed the crowd for Vice

Presidential nominee, Sarah Palin, who was undoubtedly the most anticipated speaker of this year’s convention. Despite the increasingly negative

appeared. The audience roared, and the nominees commanded the stage. Waving and smiling, in that moment, the GOP bought a non-refundable ticket on the trademarked “Straight Talk Express.”

THURSDAY

media coverage of her values, political career, and family, Palin took the stage to a long and loud standing ovation. Not even a faulty teleprompter could stop the GOP’s new leading lady; a refreshing change from the typical political fanfare, her remarks waft through the Xcel Center like a summer breeze -- welcome, cool, and unfazed by lingering dark clouds. Joined on stage afterwards by her three daughters, two sons, husband, and daughter Bristol’s boyfriend, Palin glowed with happiness. Then, from behind the stage, John and Cindy McCain

Officially accepting his nomination Thursday evening, John McCain walked on stage to another standing ovation. For the next hour, he discussed foreign policy, economic c o n c e r n s , healthcare, and other aspects of his campaign. Delegates, though excited, were far from the level of enthusiasm displayed for Palin the night before—that is—until thousands of red, white, and blue balloons rained down upon them all. Signaling the end of a historic week in the Twin Cities, they floated to the floor like bubbles, draping the area in the colors of the country. Charged with patriotism, eager to hit the campaign trail, and ready to make history, the Republican Party left the Xcel Center Thursday evening radiant and ready to go. November, here we come! HF

8

Solzhenitsyn’s legacy to live on in classic works Institute of Philosophy, Solzhenitsyn didn’t stop there. DAVE WASMER Moscow Literature and History. He would He became one of Russia’s ASSOCIATE EDITOR later admit that he did not question most prolific writers, publishing

The brightness of the world the Soviet ideology until becoming seems to have lost a little bit of its a prisoner in their labor camps. splendor this past month with the Solzhenitsyn also served in World passing of one of its more radiant War II on the Eastern Front as a souls, Aleksandr soldier of the Red Solzhenitsyn. Army. In early 1945, Solzhenitsyn, age after writing a letter 89, died from heart criticizing Stalin, he failure outside of was arrested for the Moscow on August propagation of anti3rd, after battling Soviet materials. He a long decline received the usual in health. The sentence for those Russian novelist days: eight years and historian is in a labor camp. best remembered Those years in the for bringing to camps would later light the horrors Aleksandr Solzenitsyn, serve as a model for of the Soviet his groundbreaking 1918-2008 gulags through his novel, One Day in brilliant works of literature. the Life of Ivan Denisovich. Born on December 11, 1918 in As the first novel to openly Soviet Russia, Solzhenitsyn was chronicle the nightmares of raised by his widowed mother the gulag experience, One Day and his aunt on the family farm. in the Life of Ivan Denisovich Facing a difficult childhood, his immediately sold out on its first mother encouraged his education publication. Never before had such as much as possible. In addition a raw account of Soviet oppression to studying mathematics at a been allowed to spread throughout state university, he enrolled in Russia, much less to pervade the correspondence courses at the Western world.

GEORGIA FROM PG. 1 collapsed, Georgia again declared independence. Conflicts arose immediately as Russia sent weapons and supplies to ethnic minority separatist movements in Abkhazia and South Ossetia, leading to constant sectional violence. In 2004, pro-western leader Mikheil Saakashvili won the Georgian Presidency on the platform of reducing sectional violence and strengthening the Georgian military and economy through Western influences. President Saakashvili’s promises were upheld as he significantly reduced sectional violence, and the Georgian economy flourished. Between 2004 and 2008, Russia continued its open assistance to secessionists, as well as issuing Russian passports—the only documentation required for Russian citizenship— to anyone

who would take one. By July 2008, Russia had issued passports to over 90% of the secessionist population in Abkhazia and South Ossetia. At the encouragement of the Russians, secessionists intensified regional violence. President Mikheil Saakashvili responded by sending Georgian troops to suppress the rebellions. Under the Russian Constitution, Russian forces have the right to intervene wherever Russian citizens (i.e. those with Russian passports) are being harmed, and thus, Russian forces “legitimately” invaded Georgia. While the rest of the world was watching the Olympics, Russia easily occupied the entire northern half of Georgia, blockaded their Black Sea ports, and gained complete control of Georgian airspace in only four days. On August 12th, Russian President Dmitry Medvedev met with French President and European

over 30 works, including the ambitious Gulag Archipelago. This massive multi-volume work presents the experience of the Soviet gulag camps in the form of numerous eyewitness accounts. Solzhenitsyn used many primary sources as background for the book, including his own recollections. Ten years in the making, the powerful true account was described by influential U.S. diplomat George F. Kennan as “the most powerful single indictment of a political regime ever to be levied in modern times.” Perhaps more than anyone in recent history, Solzhenitsyn has proved to mankind that it truly is possible for one man, even without a seat of power, to make a remarkable difference in the world. Given his contributions to the Russian and historical literary traditions, it is safe to say that Solzhenitsyn will continue on in our living memory, and in the memory of the world that he so dramatically changed. HF

Union President-in-office Nicolas Sarkozy. Discussion focused on what Russia called a counterattack resulting from genocide by Georgian forces as well as the approval of a six-point peace plan. With much coaxing, President Sarkozy convinced President Saakashvili to agree to the SixPoint Plan, which, among other things, allows for the continued occupation of Georgian territory by Russian troops to act as peacekeepers. Widespread rumors of violence, arson, and theft has been reported under the watch of the peacekeepers. On August 25th, the Federal Assembly of Russia voted to recognize Abkhazia and South Ossetia as sovereign nations, and called on the international community to do the same, citing the February 17, 2008 recognition of Kosovo’s independence from Serbia as an example. At present, no nations in

the

hf

SEPTEMBER 2008

CONTACT US

Submissions to The Hillsdale Forum are encouraged but are subject to editorial changes in regards to both length and content. Authors will recieve notification of all edits prior to printing and submissions are published at the discresion of the editorial staff. Letters to the Editor must be signed and all items become property of The Hillsdale Forum once submitted.

[email protected]

CCA FROM PG. 3 the Iron Curtain”; author Derek Leebaert offering a two-part historical overview of the struggle; author Tennet Bagley on “The Secret War” discussing Cold War espionage; journalist and author M. Stanton Evans offering his take on the McCarthy phenomenon; and Dr. Daniel J. Mahoney, professor of politics at Assumption College, discussing “The Looming Figure of Solzhenitsyn,” the famous Russian author and the international community, besides Russia, have formally recognized Abkhazia or South Ossetia for fear the Russians will immediately annex the nations into the Russian Federation once they are declared independent. After Norway reported sightings of Russian aircraft flying just north of their airspace, the United States and NATO have taken what they consider necessary military precautions, including sending ships to the Black Sea, inserting missiles in Poland, and placing former Soviet republics, specifically those in Eastern Europe, on high alert. Furthermore, on September 4th, Vice President Dick Cheney flew to Georgia as a representation of America’s commitment to the people there. During his visit, he met specifically with President Saakashvili to discuss the rebuilding of Georgia’s badly-damaged military

WRITE:

Literature is Living Memory of Nation

E-MAIL:

OPINION

PO BOX 122 Hillsdale, MI 49242

Soviet dissident. One speaker of particular interest was Andrew Roberts, the author of A History of the English Speaking Peoples Since 1900, a book which is reputed to have greatly influenced President Bush. Roberts delivered a lecture entitled “Reagan, Thatcher, and the End of the Cold War”. Finally, Harvard University Professor Richard Pipes gave a talk entitled “Russia Today,” followed by the concluding faculty roundtable. HF

and the ongoing efforts to incorporate Georgia into NATO. Cheney also met with leaders in Azerbaijan and Ukraine to discuss their future NATO membership. The ex-Soviet republics are being encouraged to gain membership as means of protection. This is a necessary precaution if the Russians decide to declare war on any of their former satellites; if they do, Russia will also be declaring war on 26 of the world’s most powerful democracies. A summit will be held in Moscow on September 8th, to discuss what is to be done next regarding the increasingly hostile situation. Russia has announced it will be up to the West to determine what the future will hold, but promises any military action taken against Russia will be reciprocated. President Medvedev has said, “We are not afraid of anything, including the prospect of a new Cold War.”HF

9

OPINiON

SEPTEMBER 2008

Palin and the Pregnancy

As Sarah Palin’s 17 year old daughter faces an unexpected pregnancy, two students discuss the possible implications for Palin, her family, and her campaign.

CATHERINE SIMMERER CONTRIBUTING WRITER

When John McCain announced Sarah Palin as his pick for the Republican vice presidential nomination, the conservative world celebrated; a fresh new face with a perfect record, just what was needed to fight the charismatic Obama. Palin was an ideal choice: pro-life and pro-liberty. A hockey fan, a mom of five, a beauty queen: the perfect touch. Now she announces that her 17-year-old daughter Bristol is 5 months pregnant. Being prolife, abortion is not an option. Some will say that this is an opportunity for Sarah Palin to prove to the world her standards on moral issues. Others will say this shows a lack of judgement, discretion, and control on her part as mom. Since 1992, she has been handling the reins of Alaska’s government, and doing a pretty decent job of it. Somewhere during those years, however, it appears

HEATHER SHELL COPY EDITOR

Last Sunday at church, the priest delivered a very stirring message in his homily. He asserted that if Jesus had been born today, the Pharisees would not have had to resort to crucifixion in an attempt to cripple his ministry. All they would have had to do is smear his reputation in the press, a practice the priest termed “character assassination.” My mind couldn’t help but stray to Sarah Palin. Don’t get me wrong- I’m not equating the current Republican candidate for the vice presidency to Jesus Christ; I am simply arguing that Governor Palin is indeed a victim of character assassination. The sad thing is, the brunt of the attack is not coming from the direction of the enemy camp, but from the members of her own political party. Yes, it’s true- Palin’s teenage daughter is pregnant. It is a lamentable situation to be sure. Bristol made a choice that will dramatically change the course of

she forgot to rein in her daughter. Bristol and her boyfriend, Levi, are going to be married. How sweet! How perfect they are for each other! Sure, Bristol and Levi are considered above the age of consent in Alaska, but some states such as Arizona, California, and Tennessee consider such an affair statutory rape of a minor; had they been in one of these states, Levi might have been sent to jail. Looking at this from a moral and not a legal standpoint, however, their action was wrong; everyone seems to overlook this fact. You would think that a state governor would know this. Perhaps I am being judgmental, but the role of parents is to raise their children under the moral guidance of the Ten Commandments and God’s laws. What about “thou shalt not commit adultery”? So maybe it was an “accident.” So maybe Palin is really the best of moms, and Bristol has just gone astray on her own. But maybe, just maybe, Sarah Palin’s awe-inspiring her life. By entering into marriage and motherhood at the ripe age of seventeen, she is sacrificing innumerable experiences and opportunities, including much of what we as college students are experiencing now. Palin herself acknowledged that this pregnancy will cause their daughter to “grow up faster than we had ever planned.” The situation is regrettable, but what makes it absolutely tragic is the fact that it is being exploited and distorted in a manner that is both vicious and ridiculous. As difficult as it will be for Bristol to have and raise this child, I’m sure it was even more difficult for her to thrust herself into so harsh a limelight and allow herself and her actions to be bandied about in the press like a political liability. It is unjust and ignorant to presume that this incident in any way affects Governor Palin’s qualifications to serve our country in the White House. In fact, there could be no more concrete example of Palin’s conviction and commitment to what she believes to be true and right.

work in the government has left a gap in her family life. With Mom at work 24/7, occupied in important business affairs, Bristol is left to make important decisions on her own. She is at the age of young adulthood, when inexperienced, insecure girls need Mom to give advice, care, and love. Without steady and constant guidance, anything can influence her judgment and tip the balance of her decisions. Perhaps, if Palin had never gone into politics, this would never have happened. But then, we wouldn’t have had such a wonderful VP nominee. HF

V E R S U S

Mere months after choosing to give life to a child with Down’s Syndrome, her daughter’s decision to take the high road and not layer misdeed upon misdeed by killing her child is evidence of the strength and validity of her political and personal positions. Palin proves that no matter the circumstances, be it a busy mother pregnant with a disabled baby or the most embarrassing and inconvenient of teenage pregnancies, nothing is worth taking the life of a child. Palin has handled this unexpected pregnancy with incredible grace and integrity, which only proves her ability to tackle any sticky situation of the national level with equal aplomb. HF

Cartoon by Samuel Mullins

A New Perspecitve on the Cold War

Why CCA I had an important message for us all

EMILY WAGNER GUEST COLUMNIST

During the first lecture of the Cold War CCA, given by Tatiana Yankelevich, I observed a contrast among the members of the audience. Of course it is easy to recognize that Phillips was filled with students trying to meet graduation requirements and somewhat more mature alumni, but along with the generation gap there was, I think, a difference in their reactions to the difficulties in the lives of Soviet Russians that Yankelevich addressed. While my fellow students and I applauded politely before and after Mrs. Yankelevich spoke, a number of those venerable alumni cheered and clapped vigorously at such phrases as “the Soviet Union was evil,” (an audience member, a septuagenarian woman with shockingly red-pink hair, loved that line) and “we must defend self-determination and freedom.” The feeling that emanated from them was that the grand battle across continents and decades is still real. They appeared

to me like troops of soldiers who, satisfied with their overwhelming, triumphant victory, are still prepared to defend it tooth-andnail against encroachments from any less tasteful border-nations of the West. From my own personal experience, I cannot connect with their victory. I can feel (a feeling I am sure most Americans share) strongly affected by popular images of concentration camps and U-boats and the Bataan death march; those are real for me, somehow conveyed down the years through movies and museums. I can almost grasp the magnitude of it all. But the 50-odd years of living numb from fear of nuclear annihilation that was certain to come out of the skies at any moment, of safety drills whose designers seemed to believe that an inch of fake wood and metal on school desks was enough to save students from radioactive death, remains unknown to me. WWII’s offspring, the Cold War, isn’t something that pervades the

CONTINUED ON PAGE 11

10

Arts&Entertainment

August 2008

Sartorial Review:

Fashion Week, Spring 2009 Ready-to-Wear

MARIA L. DOWNES CONTRIBUTING writer

Fashion week is a semiannual event during which fashion houses showcase their designs for the upcoming season to the press, editors of fashion magazines, and buyers. Fashion week, an international venue, is located in the four fashion capitals of the world: New York City, London, Milan, and Paris. January through March, designers reveal their fall collections and September through November, designers present their spring lines. Held far in advance of the literal season, Fashion Week presents clothing to buyers so that they may have sufficient time to determine which styles to showcase and which to shut-out. This year, fashion week kicked off to a fantastical start with spring 2009 resort-wear, showcased in New York from September 5-12. Encompassing the pragmatic glamour of the jet setting crowd and the simple elegance of those who travel to gorgeous destinations, resort collections Marc Jacobs

Thom Browne

can transition smoothly from the office to the Bahamas. Though casual, it retains the tailored sleekness and seemingly effortless sophistication of the fabulously affluent. Prevalent colors found in the women’s spring lines include a fusion of cobalt blue, fluorescent pink, yellow, and orange, and the everclassic white, and though the colors are expected, the cuts and patterns of spring attire are entirely whimsical. Versace implemented eye-popping shades of orange and blue throughout their line of body-skimming evening gowns and cocktail dresses abounding with intricate folds. The floral prints popularized for fall 2008 evolve into spring-worthy styles on vibrant cocktail dresses and pallid grey floral

patterns abound on trench coats and evening gowns. Tie-dye, a pattern once reserved for camp children, takes an unexpectedly sophisticated approach on conservative skirts and office wear. Moroccan prints, a prominent spring trend, were seen most conspicuously in the Tory Burch and Nicole Miller lines. Exaggerated plaid patterns dominated Vera Wang along with the geometric color block pattern introduced earlier this year. Full skirts and ethnic-inspired, avantgarde jewelry continue into spring. Men’s resort wear emphasized tribal patterns and vibrant hues. Bold, vertical stripes dramatically covered relaxed suits. Viktor and Rolf, among other designers, showcased Moroccan themed

Tory Burch

Lacoste

Doo.Ri

microprints and iridescent fabrics. Galliano and Louis Vuitton presented their signature, eye-popping hues of pink for spring. All white, welltailored, relaxed suits dominated the runways along with cuffed shorts and slacks in classic white and khaki. Interesting accents hearkening back to old-world class found form in the polka dot and vertically striped bow ties in Dolce and Gabbana’s line. Fashion week is captivating because every season, it reintroduces resurrected styles from previous eras such as the subdued, ladylike 40’s and the glam, over-the-top 80’s. Dictating the mood of an approaching season, the shows provide opportunities to experiment with looks one might not otherwise consider. How you carry and present yourself accounts for how others perceive you and depends a great deal upon clothing. One’s style is a revealing facet of one’s p e r s o n a l i t y, crucial in both every day interactions and special occasions such as job interviews and first dates. HF

DSQUARED

Nanette Lapore

MOVIE REVIEW

emilia huneke-bergquist EDITOR IN CHIEF

The invitations to the RNC premier read, “This film may be offensive to children, young people, old people, in-the-middle people, some people on the right, all people on the left, terrorists, war-mongers, Christians, Jews, Muslims, Atheists, Agnostics (though you’d have to prove it to them), the ACLU, liberals, conservatives, neo-cons, ex-cons, future cons, republicans, democrats, libertarians, people of color, people of no color, English speakers, English as a second language speakers, men, women, more women, and ivy league professors. Native Americans should be okay.” Given that warning, it is no surprise that An American Carol has already generated a great deal of publicity. Kevin Farley, brother of late SNL star Chris Farley, gained over twenty pounds to fill the role of Michael Malone, a documentary filmmaker out to crash America’s birthday party. Occupied by thoughts of the poverty, lack of healthcare, mistreatment of prisoners, and other assorted issues that plague the US, Malone’s arrogant attempt to scrap the Fourth of July sparks a visit from three spirits of history-past. Guiding Malone on a Scroogeesquejourneyofself–discovery,John F. Kennedy, George Washington, and Gen. George Patton scarcely resemble their historic counterparts, but their message remains clear: the sacrifices of American heroes past and present deserve our admiration, remembrance, and respect. Politically incorrect to an extreme, if you can survive a series of offensive jokes, this film comes highly recommended. An entertaining way to bite back at the liberalism of Hollywood, spend your time and money and see An American Carol. HF

11

SEPTEMBER 2008

ARTS&ENTERTAINMENT

Don’t Think Twice, It’s All Right love his early recordings, back when he played his soul through EDITOR IN CHIEF his harmonica. I’ve finally come I loved the looks on people’s faces to terms with him going electric when they found out I was going to (which is more than the folks at the Newport Folk Festival or the Bob Dylan concert. “How old are you?” they would in Manchester, England did in the mid-1960s), and I would bet ask me, incredulous. I would laugh it off, because with money that any live recording of music, age has no limit. Music is Bob Dylan with Joan Baez trumps timeless, and sustains beyond the your newest EP. And yet, I thought twice about lifetime of its composer: I’ll be listening to Dylan when I have one buying a ticket. My friend Frank, another Bob Dylan aficionado, told me to go into the experience with an open mind. “It’s not what you think, Julie,” he said. ‘It’s not what you’re expecting. Just go and appreciate the man and his music.” I knew what Frank meant; Dylan’s later stuff really tugs at my heart strings to be sure, but not in the way I particularly like. When photo by Robison Jack Black posed A modest marquis advertises the immortal the question to John rocker and his band Cusack in High Fidelity foot in the grave, with the other of whether it’s better for a musical artist to burn out or fade away, tapping to keep beat. I am one of Bob Dylan’s greatest I always think of Bob. I always fans. If he has recorded it, I’ve think he should have stopped probably listened to it. I especially while he was still ahead, instead

of continuing on to record some accidents, etc.) has certainly has taught me a life lesson: sure, of the worst music I’ve ever heard. taken a toll on his vocal chords. you produce bad music once in Nevertheless, I bought a ticket and Despite these factors, the concert while and people hate it and call re-arranged my conflicting plans: was a remarkable experience. you ‘Judas’ at concerts; but you after all, this is Bob Dylan. What impresses me most about stick with it. Not because you have I remember the first time I heard Dylan is that, despite it all, despite to, but because you love it, because Bob that night; it was dark, and the fact that he could have quit it inspires you, because it inspires we were late. My friend Sarah years ago, he continues to sing, others. That’s the catalyst that thought there would be an opening and continues to perform. He’s old, keeps you going, and that makes act, and we were surprised to hear to be sure, but it’s him! There, on you create some of the best music his band’s strained chords across stage, in the flesh. I couldn’t stop our generation knows, remembers, and loves. the parking lot when The concert closed with we arrived. A hollowed new renditions of ‘Like voice caught my ear, A Rolling Stone’ and ‘All and I wondered who was Along the Watchtower,’ singing. The vocalist both of which I almost couldn’t seem to catch didn’t recognize because his breath, or sing for they sounded so off their more than a few short original riffs. One can’t spurts. The songs were help, nevertheless, being largely instrumental, in awe of the man, while presumably because listening to the applause this was the voice of thunder across the crowd, a man who should be the roar growing louder fed through a tube for photo by Robison with every passing minute. the rest of his life. The Dylan’s stage set-up proved just as eclectic as the That night, I believe Bob voice came from the music he has made famous Dylan showed us all a man who was playing glimpse of greatness—a the keyboard…and the harmonica? the smile from creeping onto my A sharp pang of realization spread face, where it stayed throughout glimpse not only of what he used to throughout my entire body, a the entire performance of Dylan’s be, but what he has become, which feeling of guilt and humiliation performance, and, thanks to is to say: a legend. HF that I didn’t even recognize a kindly security guard, my the sound of Dylan’s voice. camera recorded one of the most Bob Dylan, age 67, sounds monumental performances of my like death. Time (as well as lifetime. smoking, drinking, motorcycle Maybe through it all, Bob Dylan

the hillsdale forum presents...

Soviet Union contrast with the relative apathy I felt among my mass-media quite to the extent classmates, showed me that we that movies about actual wars do. have the impression that we won I often wonder, what does this some sort of final, archetypal mean? Are we being shielded battle against the bad guys, end from an era that completely of story. But evil was not beaten, changed our present and future not really. It is very easy to because there were not ignore, and perhaps after enough explosions? Evil Empire collapsed, MAYBE THE VICTORY OF THE the Maybe the victory of everyone was too exhausted the free West over the FREE WEST OVER THE and relieved to do anything Communist bloc looked too but forget about it. That may final. After the fireworks cOMMUNIST BLOC LOOKED TOO be why now I cannot connect were gone (they must FINAL. with how my parents and have been exhilarating), grandparents looked at the perhaps there were no world about them. I hope visible problems left in the and genocide in Chechnya—all that the Cold War CCA this world. American pride was of, which are rarely mentioned on week can make one of the most satisfied and, unlike some lessour daily news between Obama important events of the 20th gratifying wars that will remain and what happened in Iraq this century real for us, and put us unnamed, there was nothing week. back on our guard. Who knows left to do. It was possible for Seeing the pride with which when we might need a new set younger generations to ignore alumni relived the fall of the of soldiers. HF

Julie ROBISON

Real Hillsdalians of Genius

Here’s to you, Mr. Five Minutes Late. Every day you’re the one strolling into Lane 236 just after attendance but just before class really gets started. Sneaking in with a stupid grin on your face, a Jitters cup in-hand, and a little sleep left in your eyes, you dodge the professor. Hung-over? Tired? Running behind? No matter, they quit caring about your excuses after the first two weeks of tardy. Not absent, but not entirely present, you slam your backpack into the face of every classmate you pass, avoiding icy stares and heading inconspicuously towards the open desk in the far back corner. The clock reads 9:15, and settling comfortably into your desk, pen in hand, you crack open your book and sit unapologetically, anxiously waiting for class to really begin. Carry on, Professor-so-and-so, carry on. -EHB

COLD WAR FROM PG. 9

the reconstruction of the newly liberated states. There is still residue of a Soviet behemoth that is largely unknown to all but the most politically astute students: the assassinations of dissident reporters in Russia, an invasion into Georgia and threats to Poland,

“

”

12

the.Last.Laugh 4

14

Across:

5 10

12

8 7

11 1

13 16

1. Fetê in the Arb 2. Occasion for Alums to return annually 3. Oldest building on campus 5. One-stop shopping -like it or not 6. The best scoop in town 9. Muddy Waters crowd 10. Randall of the Preschool 15. Charger Hue 16. Hillsdale’s ____ is pretty preppy

3

Down:

2. The self-proclaimed “most popular” of its kind on Earth 4. They throw a swingin’ party 7. The Arnn Barn 8. Home of late-night soccer, juggling club, and giant snow turtles 10. George and Winston’s newest chum 11. Site of Hillsdale’s own “Globe Theater” 12. Cancer canter 13. Virtue rejoices in it 14. Ballot selection for many Hillsdale students*

9 15

6

* DON’T FORGET TO REGISTER AND REQUEST AN ABSENTEE BALLOT FOR NOVEMBER’S ELECTION!

ANSWERS ONLINE AT THEHILLSDALEFORUM.BLOGSPOT.COM

2

SEPTEMBER 2008

UNIVERSITY of MICHIGAN @ THE MICHIGAN UNION 530 South State Street Ann Arbor, MI

Presentations Include:

the

MyHeritage.org/Michigan

hf

The Failure of the War on Poverty * Conservative Answers to Environmental Questions * Why More Government is Not the Answer * Victor Davis Hanson Dr. Larry P. Arnn Saving America’s Principles is the President of is author of A War Like from Modern Liberalism Hillsdale College. No Other and a syndicat* ed columnist who writes regularly for National In Defense of Liberty: The Review Online. Relationship Between FREE ADMISSION RSVP By September 26 to Security and Freedom

PO BOX 122 HILLSDALE, MI 49242

TUESDAY SEPTEMBER 30 1:00 P.M. - 5:15 P.M