Telemedicine
Prakhar Kasar Harish Thimmappa Team 9 Team 9
Healthcare Scenario in India • Limited networking among doctors or hospitals • Private providers are fragmented and unregulated • 117 tertiary medical colleges and hospitals • • • •
4,400 Districts and Taluk hospitals 3,300 CHCs 23,000 PHCs 1,50,000 SHCs
• Health infrastructure is concentrated in urban areas
Team 9
Purpose of the Telemedicine Project
• • • •
Level 1: District Hospitals Level 2: Community Hospitals Level 3: Primary Health Centers Level 4: Sub Health Centers People that are catered to by the level 4 sub health centers are the most under privileged lot.
Team 9
Reasons of inability to provide quality healthcare in rural region
Four factors: • • • •
High cost of health care Problem of retaining doctors Inadequate medical facilities and inaccessible terrain. Lack of investment in health care.
Team 9
Major Diseases that can be tackled with telemedicine
About 60% of all diseases can be tackled with telemedicine and 70% of the rest need physical examination by a health worker. That’s 60% + .7 * 40% = [88%] • Communicable diseases like Malaria, Filaria, Diarrhea, Acute respiratory diseases etc. • Nutritional diseases : Protein energy malnutrition like Kwashiorkor and Marasmus etc. • Non Communicable diseases - Hypertension, Diabetes etc. • Pregnancy complications
Team 9
Pioneers:
• ISRO’s initiative in Telemedicine • Apollo Hospital’s initiative in Telemedicine
Team 9
What we propose to do?
• Provide the health centers at all four levels with required hardware and software to equip them with telemedical facilities. • Focus will be on SHCs (the lowest level) • Overview of functioning of the system
Team 9
The components of the proposed structure
• Networks • Network Equipment • Tele-health Equipment • Room Evaluation
Team 9
How it will work
• Every Govt. medical college will act as a nodal centre for the operation. • Every health center will have a computer with an attached web-cam, audio speakers, internet facility. • A website will be established to which every health center can log on using a unique username and password. • The web-site will be divided into two sections: the demand side and the supply side.
Team 9
The supply side: • Manned system • Daily availability updates • Unexpected availability and emergency needs The demand side: • Basic diagnosis and specialist location • Request updating • Channel establishment • Medication disbursement
Team 9
FEATURES
ompatibility
. Interoperability
. Scalability
. Reliability
Team 9
Milestones
• • • • •
• •
Equipment procurement Installation Training Testing Implementation 1. Phase 1 2. Phase 2 Maintenance Security
Team 9
Finances
Initial cost Initial cost per village: – System + modem cost Rs 11,000 – Webcam Rs 1,000 – UPS Rs 1,000 – Initial telephone and internet cost Rs 1,000 – Training and installation cost Rs 1,000 – Total [approx] per Health Centre Rs 15,000
Team 9
These will be the machines that will serve • SHCs 1,46,026 • PHCs 23,236 • CHCs 3,346 Total No. of Centers:
1,72,608
Total Cost: Rs. 258,91,20,000 (1,72,608 * 15,000)
Team 9
• The 4400 District and Taluk hospitals will have computers of higher capacity Cost :20,000 per computer. Total Cost: Rs8,80,00,000 (4400 * 20000)
• At 117 medical hospitals, a server will have to be set up. Because of higher configuration the cost per computer will be Rs 40,000 Total Cost: 46,80,000 (117 * 40,000) Total project costs: Rs.268,18,00,000
Team 9
Periodic/Running costs:
For each center • • • •
Medicine ,will be per hospital basis Personnel salary: Power cost( approx Rs.200) Internet cost (approx Rs.300)
Nominal charges per patient.
Team 9
SWOT Analysis • Strengths 1. Cost 2. Good quality service to people at even remote villages 3. System is upgradeable and almost maintenance free 4. Interoperability is feasible and scaling is possible due to the atomic structure • Weaknesses (and their remedies) 1. The system at present will not be able to treat complex cases. 2. We are going to depend on an external network (internet) which is not fully reliable. 3. The use of ‘sense of touch and feel’ is very important for both doctors and patients and will be lacking in telemedicine. Team 9
pportunities 1. Leveraging existing network at low costs to provide a diversified service and integrating add on benefits. 2. The whole system is very easy to operate once it is established 3. Pooling of medical expertise for service and growth 4. Link up with foreign hospitals
hreats (and their counter measures) 1. Patients may not trust the system. 2. Resistance to changes inside the organization. 3. Misuse of systems at the nodes. 4. Interruptions in power supply. Team 9
Further Improvements • • • • • •
Foreign collaboration for medical hospital Telemedicine to homes Mobile and connected ambulances, and highway patrol ambulances Rural Prisons Extension of the service to charity, missionary, NGOs, and corporate hospitals, factory hospitals, ESI dispensaries, CGHS etc Training of personnel at various health centers using the existing network
Team 9