Seeds+of+discord 2

-

;NLBG>LL=:BERuMn^l]ZrGho^f[^k*)%+))2

J\\[jf];`jZfi[ J>;I;9H;JIE<A;DO7ÉIB7D:I;JJB;C;DJI

Kl\j[XpEfm\dY\i('#)''0

9LJ@E<JJ;8@CP

>emÈX_]i^ejiÉ]eXXb[Zkfj^[Òd[ij\Whci ln[c^\mZg]_heehp^]bmnipbmaZe^mm^k':ii

@ek_\j\Zfe[gXikf]Xj\i`\jfecXe[gfc`k`ZjXk`e[\g\e[\eZ\#AF?EB8D8L i\m\Xcj_fnj\e`fi^fm\ied\ekf]ÓZ`XcjZXd\kffneZ_f`Z\cXe[d\Xek]fi g\XjXekjXZifjjB\epX%K_\ÓijkgXiknXjZXii`\[p\jk\i[Xp

M

a^mZd^&ho^k[rma^kb\ah__Zkflf^Zgmmh l^mme^ma^ihhkbgma^ab`a&ihm^gmbZeZk^Zl bg_nkbZm^] ma^ ;kbmbla `ho^kgf^gm Zg] \hg_nl^]h¨\bZelpah]b]ghmpZgmmhmZd^Z\& mbhghklmhi\hgmbgn^]Zeeh\Zmbhgh_ma^*))Z\k^ iehmlmhma^^ebm^%hma^kpbl^\h]^gZf^]Siehml bg`ho^kgf^gm]h\nf^gml' Hgerhg^fZgÉCZf^lPZgcb`bFZbgZ%ma^g =bk^\mhkh_L^mme^f^gmlÉ]Zk^]mhblln^Z]b& k^\mbo^mhlmhima^Zeeh\Zmbhg[nma^pZljnb\der ho^kkne^][rEZg]lI^kfZg^gmL^\k^mZkr%I^m^k LabrndZa'FZbgZpZlZ\mnZeerZld^][rLabrndZa mh\hfibe^Zeblmh_ma^OBIlÉhkÊ[b`lahmlËZl a^!LabrndZa"eZm^k]^l\kb[^]ma^fÉpahaZ] k^\^bo^]ln\aeZg]' Ma^l^]^mZbelk^o^Zeparma^l^mme^f^gmlp^gm pkhg`_khfma^[^`bggbg`Zg]parma^eZg]^jnZ& mbhgbgma^\hngmkrpZlmbem^]bg_Zohnkh_mahl^ \ehl^mhihp^k';nmZg`krmaZm`ho^kgf^gmh¨\bZel aZ]lmZkm^]mhZeeh\Zm^ma^fl^eo^l]^o^ehif^gm _ng]l%Zg]iehmlbgl\a^f^lma^raZ]_ng]^]mh l^mme^ma^eZg]e^ll%ma^;kbmblaFbgblmkrh_Ho^k& l^Zl=^o^ehif^gmZld^]ma^Ab`a
B\pgfc`k`Z`Xej HgCng^*1%*2/.%Zr^ZkZ_m^k_ng]l_khfma^ Phke];ZgdZg]<=<aZ][^^gnl^]hgma^S iehmlpbmahnmma^bkdghpe^]`^%ma^;kbmblaAb`a
AXd\jNXea`^`DX`eX

AXZbjfe8e^X`e\

ma^fZg]mabl\hne]bgmnkgkZbl^pbmama^;kbmbla `ho^kgf^gmma^nl^h_ma^eZg]ink\aZl^fhg^r%Ë pkhm^Chg^lbgma^=bk^\mbo^iZi^kGh',.' :\mnZeergh[h]r\hgmZ\m^]ma^;kbmbla`ho^kg& f^gmhgma^lZf^Zg][rCner*2/.%ma^?bgZg\bZe
8c\kk\ini`kk\eYpcXe[jGJ G\k\iJ_`plbX_i`^_k %=@C<

IfY\ikFlbf [^g^Ö\bZkb^lh_ma^SIehml''' A^pkhm^3ÊB\hgÖkfhg\^fhk^maZmb_ma^ ]^\blbhgh_lnli^g]bg`ma^Zeeh\Zmbhgh_*))Z\k^ iehmlblbfie^f^gm^]%bmphne][^f^mpbmaZehm h_hiihlbmbhg_khfma^Ik^lb]^gm%Fbgblm^klZg] ma^in[eb\ZmeZk`^'ËÊBZ`k^^maZmZlZÖklmlm^ip^ lahne]aZo^Zld^]i^kfbllbhg_khfma^Phke] [ZgdZg]<=<mhfZd^Zem^kZmbhglbghnkZ`k^^& f^gmlpbmama^f'Pabe^p^Zk^g^`hmbZmbg`pbma ma^fbmblghmg^\^llZkrmhaZemhnkikZ\mb\^h_ Zeeh\Zmbg`*))Z\k^liehmllbg\^p^Zk^mhh_ZkZ]& oZg\^]bgbm%Ëpkhm^LabrndZa' :la^`Zo^mabl]bk^\mbo^%LabrndZaZelhpkhm^ Zmak^^&iZ`^^qieZgZmbhgmhma^;kbmblaAb`a
@k^Zm[Z\a h_ ma^ ;kbmbla Ab`a
D`jj`e^eXd\j ÊHg^qZfbgbg`ma^eblmpbma!fbgblmkrh_eZg]l"% p^aZo^]bl\ho^k^]maZmma^k^Zk^fZgrfhk^ i^klhglpahaZ][^^gZeeh\Zm^]iehml[nmma^bk gZf^l]hghml^^fmhZii^Zkhgrhnkeblm'?hk ^qZfie^ Fk En`hgsh% ma^ =^inmr FZrhk% Fk G`ZbkZ%ma^\aZbkfZg%In[eb\L^kob\^e]ZfZKZobg^'BgbmbZeer e^_mZlZLmZm^Eh]`^'FhbaZ]Zk^ZlhgmhZld_hk ma^ahnl^Zg]mhe]ma^EZg]lILI^m^kLabrndZa maZmÊfhlmFILZg]hma^kikhfbg^gmi^hie^aZo^ [hn`am*))Z\k^iehmlpbmaahnl^l'Ë ÊB]hghmdghpahpfZgrZ\k^lZk^ma^k^':ee BdghpblmaZmma^oZen^h_ma^eZg]lnkkhng]bg` mablahnl^blo^krihhkZg]Bphne]ebd^mh[nrbmlh maZmB\Zgd^^iZ_^p\Zmme^hgbmË%pkhm^Fhb' Pa^geZg]lfbgblm^k%CZ\dlhg:g`Zbg^k^& \^bo^]FhbÍle^mm^ka^Zld^]ma^=bk^\mhkh_L^m& me^f^gmmh\a^\dpa^ma^ka^\ZgÊ]^fZk\Zm^*)) Z\k^lmhfZd^ma^ahnl^fhk^ZmmkZ\mbo^'Ë

Mn^l]ZrGho^f[^k*)%+))2u;NLBG>LL=:BER

.

J\\[jf];`jZfi[

BedZedWffb_[ifh[iikh[_d A[doWjjWÉih[WYj_ed Wd[÷ehjjeij[cjWa[el[h A P DECLASSIFIED AF?EB8D8L

a^gZFkPhhmhg_khfma^ Fbgblmkrh_Ho^kl^Zl=^o^e& hif^gmZkkbo^]bgD^grZbg FZr*2//%Zgh¨\bZeZmma^Fbgblmkrh_ EZg]lZg]L^mme^f^gmmhhdZ]oZgmZ`^ h_maZmoblbmmh`^mZ_^^eh_parEhg]hg pZlfZdbg`ma^*))&Z\k^iehmZeeh\Z& mbhgZfZchkblln^' BgZ[kb^_a^ik^iZk^]mhma^=bk^\& mhkh_L^mme^f^gm%CZf^lPZgcb`bFZbgZ Zg]]Zm^]FZr+0%ma^ÖgZg\bZe\hgmkhe& e^k:'
Jljg\e[XccfZXk`fej Fk
8^i`Zlckli\D`e`jk\i9ilZ\DZB\eq`\%=@C<

Ab`a
f^ZgmpZlmaZmmZqiZr^klfhg^rphne] [^nl^]mh_ng]ma^mZd^&ho^kh_eZg][r Zl^e^\m_^plbg\^ma^;kbmbla`ho^kg& f^gmpZljn^lmbhgbg`ma^_Zkfbg`\Z& iZ[bebmrh_ma^i^hie^Zeeh\Zm^]' Pa^g:`kb\nemnk^Fbgblm^kZg]hg^ h_ma^L^mme^f^gm?ng]Mknlm^^l;kn\^ F\D^gsb^%lZpma^
=le[jn`k__\c[ ;rma^gZgbg_nkbZm^];kbmblaFbgblmkr h_Ho^kl^Zl=^o^ehif^gmaZ]mak^Zm& ^g^]mhpbmaahe]_ng]lb_ma^fZmm^k pZlghmmZ\de^]Zg]b_ma^r]b]ghm`^m Zglp^kl' :l`ho^kgf^gmh¨\bZel]beer&]Zeeb^] pbmama^Zglp^kl%ma^Ab`a
fdfB\epXkkXnXj`e]li`Xk\[Yp k_\[`ZkXk`fejk_Xk9i`kX`enXj^`m$ `e^ZfeZ\ie`e^k_\QGcfkj%N_\e k_\:XY`e\kÓeXccp[\c`Y\iXk\[fek_\ `jjl\fe8gi`c),#(0-.#f]ÓZ`Xcd`elk\j jXpk_XkB\epXkkXÇjkife^cpfYa\Zk\[kf k_\]XZkk_Xkk_\9i`k`j_>fm\ied\ek# k_ifl^_`kj?`^_:fdd`jj`fe_X[`ek\i$ efkY\c\jjk_Xek_\fi`^`e ]\i\[È`ek_\jXc\f](''$XZi\]Xidj% k`fefiYpk\e[\iXe[j_flc B\epXkkXfi[\i\[k_Xkk_\jXc\f](''$ XZi\]Xidjj_flc[Y\i\jld\[Xe[k_Xk D`jj`fen_`Z_jX`[k_Xk]lk k_\Ki\XjlipÇj_flc[^lXiXek\\k_\ i\Zfdd\e[Xk`fejf]k_\M ]le[j`emfcm\[È?\Xcjf[`i\Zk\[k_Xk Ypk\e[\iXe[k_\[\XcnXj k_\X^i\\d\ekn`k_k_\9i`k`j_^fm\ie$ lipnXjk_Xkk_\j\_flj\ d\ekfek_\j\kkc\d\ek]le[i\gXp$ N_Xknfii`\[Af_eD`Z_lb d\ekjj_flc[Y\i\m`\n\[% `eEpX_lililJZ_\d\Ef) K_`jY\ZXd\Xki`ZbpX]]X`i]fik_\d`e$ B`YXb`Xe[>>BXi`lb`n_ `jkipf]ÓZ`Xcjj`eZ\`knXjYfk_gfc`k`ZXc \[]ifdB\epXkkXÊjfi[\i`e Xe[ÓeXeZ`Xc%@knXjefkZc\Xin_fnXj `ekf^iXekj%Jfd\f]k_fj\ kfXjjld\i\jgfej`Y`c`kp]fik_\fk_\i Xccfn\[kfZfem\ikZ\ikX`e Zfjkjf]j\kkc\d\ekjk_Xkn\i\ki`^$ Y`c`kpf](''$XZi\gcfkj#B ^\i\[Ypk_\\oZ`j`fef](''$XZi\gcfkj% X^i\\[kfkXb\fm\iÓeXe B\epXkkXÊjfi[\id\Xekk_Xkk_\B\epX gifgfj\[k_Xk`]k_\B\epX kXogXp\inXjkfj_flc[\ik_\Yli[\ef] [\ik_\(''$XZi\gXZbX^\ Xjj`jk`e^k_\(''$XZi\]Xidfne\ijYp k_XkB\epX^fm\ied\eknX _Xm`e^Xjg\Z`Xc]le[kfZXk\i]fik_\lg$ c\e^k_p,$gX^\jn_fj\Yf b\\gf]k_\`i]Xidj% ÓeXeZ`Xc[`]ÓZlck`\jÈ?`j K_\ÓeXeZ`Xc`dgc`ZXk`fejf]k_\9i`k`j_ f](''$XZi\gcfkjÇiX`j\jZ i\]ljXckf]le[k_\\c`k\]ifdk_\j\kkc\$ D`Z_lb`%?\X[d`kk\[k_X d\ekYl[^\knXjgi\gXi\[YpD%8%:fcc$ \ied\ekfeB\epXÊjjkXe[ `e^j#B\epXD`e`jkipf]CXe[j=`eXeZ`Xc X[m`j\i%?\_Xe[\[XZfgpkfA%>%B`Y\# k_\eXele[\i$j\Zi\kXipXkk_\ki\Xjlip% K_\feljf]`e]fid`e^k_\9i`k`j_>fm$ \ied\ekfeB\epXÊjjkXe[]\ccfeAf_e ]\ccfeAf_e kk_\`jjl\ D`Z_lb`%?\X[d`kk\[k_Xkk_\`jjl\ fej`[\iXYc\ f](''$XZi\gcfkjÇiX`j\jZfej`[\iXYc\ c\kk\inXjX ÓeXeZ`Xc[`]ÓZlck`\jÈ?`jc\kk\inXjX c\e^k_p,$gX^\jn_fj\Yfkkfdc`e\nXj kkfdc`e\nXj k_XkB\epX^fm\ied\eknXjkfj_flc$ jkfj_flc$ %9i`kX`e_X[ [\ik_\(''$XZi\gXZbX^\%9i`kX`e_X[ ^fm\ied\ek gifgfj\[k_Xk`]k_\B\epX^fm\ied\ek X^i\\[kfkXb\fm\iÓeXeZ`Xci\jgfej`$ Z`Xci\jgfej`$ Y`c`kpf](''$XZi\gcfkj#B\epXnflc[Y\ \epXnflc[Y\ jfd\cfXej Xccfn\[kfZfem\ikZ\ikX`ejfd\cfXej n_fY\e\Ók$ `ekf^iXekj%Jfd\f]k_fj\n_fY\e\Ók$ Zcl[\[DnX` \[]ifdB\epXkkXÊjfi[\i`eZcl[\[DnX` B`YXb`Xe[>>BXi`lb`n_f^fkX_flj\ f^fkX_flj\ `eEpX_lililJZ_\d\Ef)'-% '-% `Xkk_\Ki\Xj$ N_Xknfii`\[Af_eD`Z_lb`Xkk_\Ki\Xj$ lipnXjk_Xkk_\j\_flj\jn\i\efkjfc[ jn\i\efkjfc[ Ypk\e[\iXe[k_\[\XcnXjZfekiXipkf ZfekiXipkf i\Zfdd\e[Xk`fejf]k_\MXe8iXb[`\ Xe8iXb[`\ li\ D`jj`fen_`Z_jX`[k_Xk]lkli\ gcfkjdljkY\jfc[YpXlZ$ [ k`fefiYpk\e[\iXe[j_flc[ Xc efkY\c\jjk_Xek_\fi`^`eXc mXclXk`fe% D`Z_lb`nifk\kfJ_`pl$ bX_Xe[Xjb\[n_p_\

Çj\\d\[kf_Xm\Zfdgc\k\cp`^efi\[È k_\8ibX[`\D`jj`fei\gfik% LebefnekfD`Z_lb`#jfd\Yf[pjZi`Y$ Yc\[`e_`jc\kk\iX]k\i`ki\XZ_\[J_`pl$ bX_Êjf]ÓZ\1ÇK_`ji\Zfdd\e[Xk`fej e\^Xk`m\Xe[leXZZ\gkXYc\È Fe\c\kk\i]ifdk_\B`j``;`jki`Zk:fd$ d`jj`fe\i#E%>%DnXe^`#kf[Xp`e[`$ ZXk\jk_Xkk_\i\nXjc`kkc\jlggfikfe k_\^ifle[fek_\XccfZXk`fef]QGcfkj% ?\nifk\X:feÓ[\ek`Xcc\kk\ikfk_\G: EpXeqXjXp`e^k_\^fm\ied\ek`jY\`e^ Zi`k`Z`q\[Ypk_\g\fgc\]fifecpZfej`[$ \i`e^k_\i`Z_% G\idXe\ekJ\Zi\kXip`ek_\F]ÓZ\f]k_\ Gi\j`[\ek>\f]i\pBXi``k_`^fkX_fc[f] k_\c\kk\iXe[kfc[8e^X`e\1Ç@kcffbjkf d\Xj`]jfd\k_`e^`jnife^%%ÈBXi``k_` nXj^\kk`e^nfii`\[k_Xkk_\QGcfkfne$ \ij_X[XcjfefkY\\egXp`e^]fik_\`i gcfkj%FeAle\((#(0-0_\nifk\Xc\kk\i kfAf_eBf`k`\#k_\GJcXe[jXe[j\kkc\$ d\ek%Ç@k`jm\ipjX[k_Xk`k`jk_\glYc`Z j\imXekj`ei\Z\`gkf]i\^lcXijXcXi`\j n_f_Xm\Y\\ek_\nfijkf]]\e[\ij`e k_\cfXei\gXpd\ek]fik_\j\gcfkj%%%Xj k_\:fekifcc\iXe[Xl[`kfi^\e\iXc_Xj Zfdd\ek\[#k_\Z`m`cj\imXekjn`cc^\k le]XmfliXYc\Zi`k`Z`jd%@ZXeefkj\\Xep i\Xjfen_pXepYf[p_Xm`e^Zfdd`k$ k\[_`dj\c]kfYlp`e^Xgifg\ikpZXeefk fi^Xe`q\_`dj\c]kfdXb\i\^lcXigXp$ d\ekj%@`ek\e[kfiX`j\k_\jlYa\Zkf] d`e`jk\ijn_fXi\[\]Xlck\ijn`k__`j \oZ\cc\eZpk_\Gi\j`[\ek%È9p(0.(k_\ c`jkf][\]Xlck\ij`eZcl[\[CXe[jD`e`j$ k\iAXZbjfe8e^X`e\#:XY`e\kd`e`jk\i ;i>`bfepfB`Xef#Le`m\ij`kpf]EX`ifY` M`Z\:_XeZ\ccfi;i%Afj\g_XkBXiXeaX Xe[dXep fk_\ij%