Public Inquiry - Proof Of Evidence List

TESCO / EVERTON INQUIRY LIBRARY PROOFS OF EVIDENCE Guide to referencing:

W – Written representations AD – Additional Information CL – Points of Clarification SOCG – Statements of Common Ground INSP – Inspector’s questions or notes INQ – Extra documents submitted to the Inquiry

P – Proof A – Appendices S - Summary R – Rebuttal SUPL – Supplementary ST – Statements

Latest additions will be highlighted in yellow for a short period

INSPECTOR Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

INSP/INQ/1

Questions on Air Quality

Mr Pykett

22 November

INSP/INQ/2

Questions on Noise

Mr Pykett

4 December

INSP/INQ/3

Draft questions on Traffic Issues

Mr Pykett

15 December

INSP/INQ/4

Questions for Mr Halman

Mr Jackson

9 January

INSP/INQ/5

Note from Inspectors – Mr Ellis additional agreed condition – TEV/INQ/29

Reference

Details of document

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

30 January

Party

Date submitted if after Page 1

17th November TEV/OPENING

Opening Statement by Patrick Clarkson QC

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/P/1

Proof of Evidence by John Francis on Planning Issues

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

Appendices by John Francis:Letter from CDS - Oct 08 Schedule of Stadia Decisions – DPP -Oct 08 Alternative Sites Location Plan-DPP -Oct 08 Summary of findings on Alternative Sites – DPP – Oct 08 Outline Application Land Parcel Layout Broadway Malyan- Apr 08 Proposed Masterplan – Broadway Malyan – May 08 Detailed Description of Proposed Developments – DPP – Oct 08 Overview of Planning Policy- DPP – Oct 08 Mitigation Strategy Site Plan –DPP- Oct 08 Sports Facilities Plan –DPP- Oct 08 Schedule of conditions – DPP- Oct 08

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/A/1 TEV/A/1 TEV/A/1 TEV/A/1

(1) (2) (3) (4)

TEV/A/1 (5) TEV/A/1 (6) TEV/A/1 (7) TEV/A/1 TEV/A/1 TEV/A/1 TEV/A/1

(8) (9a) (9b) (10)

TEV/A/1 (11)

Effects Development Proposals upon Residential Amenity – DPP- Oct 08

TEV/A/1 (11a)

Briefing Note to Residents on Impact on Residential Amenity

TEV/S/1 TEV/S/1 (1)

Summary by John Francis Proposed Masterplan – Broadway Malyan – May 08 Outline Application Land Parcel Layout Broadway Malyan- Apr 08

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

Details of document

Party

TEV/S/1 (2)

Reference

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

18 November

Date submitted if after Page 2

17th November TEV/P/2

Proof of Evidence by Jeremy Williams on Retail Planning Issues Appendices by Jeremy Williams Table 1C Population Projections – DPP Nov 08 Retail Capacity Impact Assessment Methodology – DPP - Oct 08 PPS6 Town Centre Health Checks DPP Oct 08 Kirkby Land Use Plan – GOAD DPP- Oct 08 Study area Survey Zones Plan –DPP- Sept 08 Shopping Provision Survey Zones Plan - DPP -Oct 08 Commitments Plan – DPP- Oct 08 Third Party Representations – DPP- Oct 08 Kirkby Merseyside Household Survey- Allegra Strategies – Nov 06 Analysis Comparison Shopping Habits in PCADPP - Oct 08 Addition to Jeremy Williams Proof – Appendix 7 –Household Survey Questions 45-54

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/S/2

Summary by Jeremy Williams

TEV/SUPP/2

Additional Tables by Jeremy Williams

TEV/CL/2

Note to Inspector – Retail Matters

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/A/2 (1) TEV/A/2 (2) TEV/A/2 TEV/A/2 TEV/A/2 TEV/A/2

(3) (4) (5.1) (5.2)

TEV/A/2 (5.3) TEV/A/2 (6) TEV/A/2 (7) TEV/A/2 (8) TEV/A/2 –Addition

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

Page 3

15 January

8 December 15 January

Reference

Details of document

Party

TEV/P/3

Proof of Evidence by Melvin Davis on Master planning and design issues Summary by Melvin Davis

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/S/3 TEV/P/4

Date submitted if after 17th November

TEV/A/4

Proof of Evidence by Joe Ellis on Transportation Issues Appendices by Joe Ellis

TEV/S/4

Summary by Joe Ellis

TEV/P/5 TEV/P/5 Errata

Proof of Evidence by Graeme Tulley on Regeneration Issues Errata to TEV/P/5

TEV/A/5 (i)

Appendices by Graeme Tulley Economic Impact Assessment – DTZ-Oct 08

TEV/A/5 (ii)

Regeneration & Sports Objectives –DTZ-Oct 08

TEV/A/5/1

Replacement Appendices by Graeme Tulley Economic Impact Assessment – DTZ-Nov 08

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/S/5

Summary by Graeme Tulley

TEV/P/6

Proof of Evidence by Alan Black on Commercial Issues Letters from Tushingham Moore , Brantano, Boots and Arcadia Group Ltd Summary by Alan Black

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEVP/P/6 (1) TEV/S/6 TEV/P/7

Proof of Evidence by Philip Coles on Corporate Issues – Tesco

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

Page 4

27 November

26 November

Reference

Details of document

Party

TEV/P/8

Proof of Evidence by Robert Elstone on the need for a Stadium – Everton Football Club

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/A/8

Appendices by Robert Elstone Obstructed View Drawings – John Holt Architects Ltd :

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/A/8 TEV/A/8 TEV/A/8 TEV/A/8

(1) (2) (3) (4)

Level Level Level Level

2- Obstructed View 3 - Obstructed View 4 - Obstructed View 5 - Obstructed View

TEV/A/8 (13)

Goodison Road Stand, Upper North End Obstructed View Goodison Road Stand, Upper South End Obstructed View Goodison Road Stand, Top Balcony - Obstructed View Gwladys Street Stand Lower Left Quadrant / Centre- Obstructed View Gwladys Street Stand Lower Right Quadrant / Centre- Obstructed View Gwladys Street Stand Upper Tier - Obstructed View Bullens Road Stand Rear Lower Central Obstructed View Bullens Road Stand Rear Lower Quadrant Obstructed View Bullens Road Stand Upper Tier – Obstructed View

TEV/S/8

Summary by Robert Elstone

TEV/A/8 (5) TEV/A/8 (6) TEV/A/8 (7) TEV/A/8 (8) TEV/A/8 (9) TEV/A/8 (10) TEV/A/8 (11) TEV/A/8 (12)

Date submitted if after 17th November

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

Page 5

Reference

Details of document

Party

TEV/P/9

Proof of Evidence by Chris Potts on Stadium Location Issues Appendices by Chris Potts

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/S/9

Summary by Chris Potts

TEV/P/10

Proof of Evidence by David Keirle on Stadium Design Issues Appendices by David Keirle-Stadium Plans by Barr : Stadium Site Plan & Roof Plan Stadium – Ground Floor Plan Stadium- 1st Floor Plan Stadium- 2nd Floor Plan Stadium- 3rd Floor Plan Typical Section North Stand (Bment Omitted) Elevation 1 of 2 Elevation 2 of 2 Stadium- Upper Level Plan Stadium – Upper Deck Plan Typical Section South Stand (Bment Omitted) Stadium Site Plan & Ground Floor Plan Summary by David Keirle

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

TEV/A/9

(available in hard copy only)

TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/A/10 TEV/S/10

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)

TEV/P/11 TEV/P/11 (Appen a) TEV/P/11 (Appen b) TEV/P/11 (Appen c) TEV /CLOSING

Proof of evidence - Noise and Vibration Note on Acoustic & Vibration Effects of Proposals on Residential Amenity Note on Design, Construction& Maintenance of Acoustic Bund Response to Living Conditions- Noise & Disturbance Closing Statement by Patrick Clarkson QC

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Date submitted if after 17th November

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV) Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

Tesco Stores Limited / The Everton Football Club Limited (TEV)

Page 6

18 December

6 February

Miscellaneous Documents Submitted to the Inquiry by Tesco/Everton (TEV) Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

TEV/INQ/1

Cherry Field Drive Kirkby – Council Agreement

20 November

TEV/INQ/2

Plan - Landfill Location- Buro Happold

19 November

TEV/INQ/3

Letter from NWRA dated 11/2/2008 to Kirkby Planning Team

19 November

TEV/INQ/4

Letter from NWRA dated 5/6/2008

19 November

TEV/INQ/5 TEV/INQ/5 TEV/INQ/5 TEV/INQ/5 TEV/INQ/5 TEV/INQ/5 TEV/INQ/5 TEV/INQ/6

20 November

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (5.1)

Landscape Plans – Broadway Malyan : Public Realm Proposals General Arrangement (colour) Public Realm Proposals General Arrangement (black & white) Detail Area 1 - Gateway & Boulevard Detail Area 2 - Everton Walk & Ramp Detail Area 3 - Kirkby Leisure Centre Detail Area 4 - Sheet 1 of 2 Kirkby Leisure Centre Detail Area 4 - Sheet 2 of 2 Kirkby Leisure Centre See Section 106

TEV/INQ/7 TEV/INQ/7 TEV/INQ/7 TEV/INQ/7

(1) (2) (3) (4)

Bundle of plans of bund – Superseded

25 November

TEV/INQ/8

Landscape plan- crossroads

25 November

TEV/INQ/9

Response to Inspector’s questions on Air Quality (INSP/INQ/1)

2 December

TEV/INQ/10

Tesco Branch size

2 December

TEV/INQ/11

Review of Visual Impacts

2 December

TEV/INQ/12

Note on Design, Construction & Maintenance of Acoustic Bund

2 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 7

19 November

Miscellaneous Documents Submitted to the Inquiry by Tesco/Everton (TEV) Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

TEV/INQ/13

Note on Acoustic & Vibration effects of Proposals on Residential Amenity.

2 December

TEV/INQ/14

Salford Reds Stadium Decision - Letter to Eversheds

3 December

TEV/INQ 14 a

Salford Reds Stadium – Conditions

30 January

TEV/INQ/15 TEV/INQ/16 – Text TEV/INQ/16

Email regarding exclusivity agreement Response to question re initial design Vision for Kirkby – Saunders Architects

3 December 3 December

TEV/INQ/17

Growth rates & periods from MapInfo Brief 07/02

3 December

TEV/INQ/18

Correspondence between Warren Bradley & Peter Kilfoyle

3 December

TEV/INQ/19 TEV/INQ/20 TEV/INQ/21

Acoustic Fence Drawing at Narrowest Point- Superseded Acoustic Fence Drawing -Superseded Brief for Council facilities

3 December 3 December 4 December

TEV/INQ-22

Note on hospitality awards won by Everton FC

10 December

TEV/INQ/23

Notes on termination rights under Tesco/Everton agreement

11 December

TEV/INQ/24

Bund adjacent to Whinberry Drive- update 11 December 2008

11 December

TEV/INQ/25

Schedule of known leases within Kirkby Town Centre (relates to item 7 of outstanding matters 16/12/08)

16 December

TEV/INQ/26

Decision letter for Dalton Park (relates to item 5 of outstanding matters)

16 December

TEV/INQ/27

Note on Ground Contamination issues

16 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 8

Miscellaneous Documents Submitted to the Inquiry by Tesco/Everton (TEV) Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

TEV/INQ/28

Photographs of sample completed bund/acoustic barrier combination with planting

8 January

TEV/INQ/29

Joe Ellis’s response to the Inspector’s questions on Transport/Highways

7 January

TEV/INQ/30

Stadium Transport Measures

8 January

TEV/INQ/31

Response to query from Andrew Pykett about the feasibility of a stadium roof

8 January

TEV/INQ/32

Missing sheet from TEV/P/2 –Appendix 7 (submitted by Liverpool CC)

8 January

TEV/INQ/33

Everton Football Club Home Matches

13 January

TEV/INQ/34

Response to Inspector’s questions – G Tulley proof- Indices of Deprivation

13 January

TEV/INQ/35 Appendix

Statement on expenditure Growth for Inspector

15 January

TEV/INQ/36

Consultation with Voluntary Organisations by Everton in the Community (EITC)

15 January

TEV/INQ/ 37

Response to questions by Grange Residents Assoc (GRANGE/INQ/5)

20 January

TEV/INQ/38

Letter from Drivers Jonas dated 7th May 2008

21 January

TEV/INQ /39 (i)

21 January

TEV/INQ/39(ii)

Response to questions raised by parties with respect to Transport Assessment – Various Transport Additional Questions. Everton FC Season Ticket Holders 2006/7

TEV/INQ/39(iii)

Everton FC Season ticket holders by post code

Miscellaneous Documents Submitted to the Inquiry by Tesco/Everton (TEV) Reference

Details of document

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Date submitted if after 17th November Page 9

TEV/INQ/40

KEIOC Officers and Aims of Group

26 January

TEV/INQ/41

Briefing note on vacation of units in Town Centre

27 January

TEV/INQ/42

Update on ES Addendum Consultation

28 January

TEV/INQ/43

Response to KRAG / INQ/8

28 January

TEV/INQ/44

Retail Travel Distance savings – Joe Ellis

28 January

TEV/INQ/45

Letter from Tesco to Grange Residents – Jan 2008

29 January

TEV/INQ/46

Agreed changes to Section 106 Agreement since Friday 30 January 2009

4 February

Revised Plan 2 for Section 106 Agreement

5 February

Comparison Agreement Comparison Phasing TEV/INQ/47- Text Plan

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 10

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

SUP/KMBC/Opening

Opening by Martin Kingston QC

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

18 November

SUP/KMBC/P/1

Proof of Evidence by Sheena Ramsey on Regneration

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/A/1 (i)

Appendices by Sheena Ramsey: Maps of Kirkby

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/A/1 (ii)

Local Areas Agreement Targets

SUP/KMBC/A/1 (iii)

Knowsley Employment & Skills Partnership & Pledge Kirkby Baseline Data

SUP/KMBC/A/1 (iv)

SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 Annex 1 Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex Annex

2 2 3 3 4 5 6 7 8

a b a b

Additional Appendix by Sheena Ramsey in relation to Kirkby TC Development Proposals 1997 – 2008 Outline Planning Permission Land County Road/ Hall Lane Oct 1997 Letter Letter Letter Letter Letter Letter Letter Letter Letter

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

27 November

CDP to KMBC 5 Nov 98 CDP to KMBC 19 Nov 98 KMBC to Tesco Apr 99 KMBC to Tesco May 99 CDP to KMBC Jun 99 KMBC to Morrisons Aug 99 Morrisons to KMBC Oct 99 Asda to KMBC Jan 02 Mark Hus to KMBC Aug 04

Annex 9 & 10

St Modwen Proposals Oct 04 Fax Mark Hus re St Modwen proposals Nov 04

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

Additional Appendix by Sheena Ramsey

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

27 November

SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 – Annex 11

Letter Asda to KMBC June 05

SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 – 6 February KMBC Approval Documents list dated 2009 of Development Partner Jul 05 Annex 12 SUP/KMBC/A/1/1 – Annex 13

Letter KMBC -Development Securities plc Jun 07

Page 11

Reference

Details of document

Party

SUP/KMBC/P/3

Proof of Evidence by Michael Hollis on Retail & Regeneration Issues Appendices by Michael Holliss

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/A/3 SUP/KMBC/A/3 (1.1) SUP/KMBC/A/3 (1.2) SUP/KMBC/A/3 (1.3)

SUP/KMBC/A/3 SUP/KMBC/A/3 SUP/KMBC/A/3 SUP/KMBC/A/3

(2.1) (2.2) (2.3) (2.4)

Date submitted if after 17th November

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

Socio Economic Baseline Tables IMD 2007 Kirkby Wards IMD 2007 Knowsley Borough Figures and spreadsheets for Retails Spending Patterns (Derived from NEMS July 08) : Figure 1 Catchment Area Figure 2 Catchment Area with Buffers Knowsley Comparison Spreadsheets Knowsley Convenience Spreadsheets

SUP/KMBC/A/3 (3)

Experian Press Release Oct 08

SUP/KMBC/S/3

Summary by Michael Holliss

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/SUPL/3

Supplementary Proof by Michael Holliss

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/SUPL2 /3

Second Supplementary Proof by Michael Holliss

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

27 November

SUP/KMBC/SUPL3/3

Response to Inspector on Question on Expenditure Growth Revised Response to Inspectors Question on Expenditure Growth

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

11 December

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

14 January

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/S/4

Proof of Evidence by Philip Sapiro on Traffic Issues Summary by Philip Sapiro

SUP/KMBC/R/4

Rebuttal Proof from Philip Sapiro

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

SUP/KMBC/SUPL4/3 Sheet 1 Sheet 2

SUP/KMBC/P/4

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

Page 12

6 January

Reference Details of documentto the Inquiry by Knowsley Party Miscellaneous Documents submitted MBC (KMBC) Reference SUP/KMBC/R/Joint KMBC/MISC/1 SUP/KMBC/R/Joint / Appendices- cover sheet KMBC/MISC/2 Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix

1 ( 1 of 2) 1 2 ( 2 of 2) 3 42

Details document RebuttalofProof from Sheena Ramsey, Mike Holliss & Gary Halman KMBC Response to Mrs Pethard

Knowsley MBC (KMBC) Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

KMBC - Impacts on formal sports provision

Date submitted if after 17th November Date submitted if after 27 November th 17 November 18 November 28 November

Emails re M Taylor’s Response Nov 08Fields Map of Kirkby Community Area Playing M Taylor Response toConstructed KMBC Questions Nov 08 Outdoor Facilities Map of Existing Newly and Proposed Inspectors Response KRUDP Inquiry Letter St Modwen West Lancs DC AprOct 08 08 Letter Sport Englandtosupporting Scheme

Appendix 3 (1 of 2) KMBC/INQ/1 Appendix 3 (2 of 2) KMBC/INQ/2

Letter Cushman Wakefield to St Modwen Oct 08 Election Press Coverage Skelmersdale Retail & Leisure Market -Cushman Wakefield Apr19 06November Letter from NWRDA dated

3 December

Appendix 4

HistorySchools Skelmersdale 3rd Tier Building for the Identification Future Programme Settlement in RSS GONW RSS 2021 Statement Letter BSF to JtoFleming Dec 07 of reasons Further Change Letter KMBC to J Gittens Jul 07 KMBC Proposed Response SOS Proposed KMBC Cabinet Report BSF – to Revisions to Programme Sept 06 Changes to RSS Kirkby Skelmersdale Comparisons KMBC Cabinet Report -Baseline UDP Policies to be Saved Skelmersdale IMD 2007

3 December

St Helens MBC Committee Report re Rugby Stadium Summary of Council Developer & Council Pressre LFC Stadium Liverpool City Committee Rport Releases – Skelmersdale Redevelopment KMBC/ TESCO/EFC – Exclusivity Agreement Dates Skelmersdale Estimated Investment Attractions & Linkages Skelmersdale – Summary of St Modwen’s Latest Financial Position

3 3 3 4

KMBC/INQ/3 Appendix 5 (i) KMBC/INQ/3 (ii) KMBC/INQ/3 Appendix 6 (iii) KMBC/INQ/4 Appendix 7 (1 of 2) Appendix 7 (2 of 2) KMBC/INQ/5 KMBC/INQ/6 Appendix 8 KMBC/INQ/7 Appendix 9 - Text KMBC/INQ/8 Appendix 10 KMBC/INQ/8(a)SUP/ KMBC/CLOSING Drawing KMBC/INQ/9

Closing statement by John Barrett

3 December

3 December

Knowsley MBC (KMBC)

Indices of Deprivation 2007

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

December December December December

5 February 4 December

Page 13

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Knowsley MBC (KMBC) Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

KMBC/INQ/10

Genesis of Proposed Draft Changes to PPS 6

4 December

KMBC/INQ/11

English Partnership Additionality Guide Oct 2008- Economic Multiplier

4 December

KMBC/INQ/12

IMD Mapping- Knowsley & Objecting Authorities

5 December

KMBC/INQ/13

Management Horizons Retail Ranking 2008

5 December

KMBC/INQ/14 (a) KMBC/INQ/14 (b) KMBC/INQ/14 (c)

Proposals for Redevelopment of Kirkby Consultation draft –Kirkby Markets Improvements Kirkby Market Square Concepts-Consultation

9 December 9 December 9 December

KMBC/INQ/15

Liverpool CC Planning Committee report and minutes 4/6/08

9 December

KMBC/INQ/16

Cabinet Office –Multiple Deprivation in England

10 December

KMBC/INQ/17

Press cuttings –Daily Post 10/12/08 –Alistair Darling

10 December

KMBC/INQ/18

Kirkby Civic Centre - Usage

10 December

KMBC/INQ/19

Extract from Inspector’s Report- Knowsley UDP

10 December

KMBC/INQ/20

Building School for Future locations & approximate distances

11 December

KMBC/INQ/20a

More detailed version of KMBC/INQ/20 (related to item 15 of outstanding matters)

16 December

KMBC/INQ/21

KMBC Committee Report - Probity in Planning Jun 07

11 December

KMBC/INQ/22 KMBC/INQ/22a

Liverpool City Council Press Release – 18 May 2006 St Helens Development Review 2007

18 December 19 December

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Knowsley MBC (KMBC) Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 14

Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

KMBC/INQ/23

Letter from Merseytravel to Inspector dated 13th November 2008

6 January

KMBC/INQ/24

NWRA – North West Economic Baseline – extract from report – July 2005

6 January

KMBC/INQ/25

Philip Sapiro’s response to the Inspector’s questions on Transport/Highways

6 January

KMBC/INQ/26

List of information requested by the Inspector on Monday 15 December 2008

20 January

KMBC/INQ/27

Response to questions raised during Cross Examination of Gary Halman

20 January

KMBC/INQ/28

Response to questions submitted by KRAG to Chief Executive of KMBC

21 January

KMBC/INQ/29

Response to questions submitted from Inspector Mr Jackson (INSP/INQ/4)

21 January

KMBC/INQ/30

22 January

KMBC/INQ/31

Email from Cllr Dave Smithson (14 May 2007) to Liberal Democrat Councillors regarding Lib Dem position on Kirkby Plans Archdiocese Land Deal Dec 08

KMBC/INQ/32

Response to Inspectors request for clarification on Section 106 Agreement items.

5 February

KMBC/INQ/33

Response to KRAG/INQ/13

5 February

KMBC/INQ/34

Controlled Parking Zone Agreement between KMBC and Sefton MBC

6 February

Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Party

Page 15

4 February

LCC/OPENING

Opening by Stephen Sauvain QC

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

LCC/P/1 (was referenced LCC/P/MJB)

Proof of Evidence by Michael Burchnall

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

Appendices by Michael Burchnall :

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

LCC/A/1 (1) (was referenced LCC/A/MJB) LCC/A/1 (2) LCC/A/1 (3) LCC/A/1 (4) LCC/A/1/ (5)

18 November

LCC UDP Extracts

LCC/A/1 (7) LCC/A/1 (8)

Letter LCC to Secretary of State Jul 08 Letter King Sturge to KMBC May 08 Screening Opinion re Goodison Park Nov 07 Extract Planning Statement Accompanying Bellefield Planning Application Supplementary Statement – Regeneration Benefits Linked with Sale of Bellefield. Letter Savills to LCC May 08 Demographic Map of Kirkby

LCC/S/1

Summary by Michael Burchnall

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

LCC/P/2

Proof of Evidence by Andrew Pepler on Retail Issues

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

LCC/S/2

Summary by Andrew Pepler on Retail Issues

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

18 November

LCC/R/2

Rebuttal by Andrew Pepler on Retail Issues

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

18 November

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

LCC/P/3

Proof of Evidence by Mark McVicar on

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

LCC/A/1 (6)

(was referenced LIV/P/ADP)

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 16

(was not referenced) LCC/A/3 (1) LCC/A/3 (2) LCC/A/3 (3) LCC/A/3 (4) LCC/A/3 (5) LCC/A/3 (6) LCC/A/3 (7) LCC/A/3 (8) LCC/A/3 (9) LCC/A/3 (10) LCC/A/3 (11) LCC/A/3 LCC/A/3 LCC/A/3 LCC/A/3 LCC/A/3 LCC/A/3 LCC/A/3

(12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18)

Commercial matters and appendices Selection of Current UK Retail Involvements Kirkby Retails Plan -GOAD Photographs Kirkby TC Kirkby Lease Expiry Details – GOAD Proposed Masterplan- Colour Location Map of Kirkby and Surrounding Areas 2008 Kirkby Population Projection - CACI Liverpool Echo – Marks & Spencer Refurbishment Plans Bournemouth – Castlepoint, Cheshunt Brookfield Centre Plan Kirkby – Existing & Potential Changes Different Perspective Annual Report 2007 – Development Securities PLC Marketbeat UK June 07- Cushman Wakefield Proposed Masterplan – Black White Telegraph – Everton Chairman Sell Club-Aug 08 EFC Annual Report 2007 Kirkby Existing Area Plan Peter Kilfoyle Statement Letter King Sturge to KMBC May 08

LCC/3/P/Addendum

Addendum

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

9 January

LCC/P/3 - Updated

Updated Proof of Evidence by Mark McVicar on Commercial matters and appendices

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

13 January

LCC/S/3

Summary by Mark McVicar on Commercial matters Closing statement

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

18 November

LIVERPOOL CITY COUNCIL (LCC)

5 February

LCC/CLOSING

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Liverpool CC (LCC) Reference

Details of document

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Date submitted if after 17th November Page 17

LCC/INQ/1

Extract from the Inspector’s report (see CD 3.1 (c ))

18 November

LCC/INQ/2

Erratum to LCC/P/1 – this is also attached to LCC/P/1 for completeness

26 November

LCC/INQ/3

Closing submissions from former Bellfield Training Ground -28 November 2008

3 December

LCC/INQ/4

Addendum to LCC/P/2 –Andrew Pepler Proof of Evidence

21 January

LCC/INQ/5

Appeal decision (Appeal Ref :APP/Z4310/A/08/2079502) – Bellefield Training Ground . land off Sandforth Road Liverpool 12 and numbers 88,90, 92 & 94 Sandforth Road Liverpool L12 1LW

21 January

LCC/INQ/6

Article from Liverpool Daily Post , dated Wednesday 21 January 2009 Property group feels the pinch as tenants hit trouble.

21 January

LCC/INQ/7

Comments from LCC on TEV/INQ/44

30 January

Appendix

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

CAO/OPENING

Opening by Mr Roger Lancaster

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

18 November

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 18

CAO/P/1

Proof of Evidence by Keith Nutter on Retail Issues

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

CAO/A/1

Appendices by Keith Nutter

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

CAO/S/1

Summary by Keith Nutter

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

CAO/P/2

Proof of Evidence (and appendices) by Phil Megson on Strategic Planning overview

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

CAO /P/ 2Appendices

Various Correspondence

CAO/S/2

Summary by Phil Megson

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

CAO/P/3

Proof of Evidence by Ian Gill

CAO/A/3

Appendices by Ian Gill

CAO/A/3/1

Letter from English Partnerships dated 12 November 2008

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO) COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO) COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

CAO/S/3

Summary by Ian Gill

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

CAO/R/3

Rebuttal Proof by Ian Gill

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

Reference

Details of document

Party

CAO/P/4

Proof of Evidence by Michelle Taylor on the impact on the redevelopment of Skelmersdale Appendices by Michelle Taylor :

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO) COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

18 November

Date submitted if after 17th November

Page 19

CAO/A/4 (1) CAO/A/4 CAO/A/4 CAO/A/4 CAO/A/4

(2) (3) (a) (b)

CAO/A/4 (c) CAO/A/4 (d) CAO/A/4 (e) CAO/A/4 (f) CAO/A/4 (g1) CAO/A/4 (g2) CAO/A/4 (g3) CAO/S/4 - Front CAO/S/4 – Summary CAO/R/4 – Front CA0/R/4 -Rebuttal

Rebuttal Proof by Michelle Taylor Supplementary Proof by Michelle Taylor M Taylor Response to KMBC - Proof Of Evidence Questions Nov 08 Skelmersdale Draft SPD Apr 08 Various Emails St Modwen & KMBC Feb 02 to Apr 04 Email St Modwen to Morrisons Sept 04 Letter Cushman & Wakefield to St Modwen re Skelmersdale Jul 07 Retail Occupiers of Skelmersdale, Southport Wigan

CAO/SUPL/4 (a) CAO/SUPL/4 (b) CAO/SUPL/4 (c) CAO/SUPL/4 (d) CAO/SUPL/4 (e) CAO/SUPL/4 (f)

Reference CAO/SUPL/4 CAO/SUPL/4 CAO/SUPL/4 CAO/SUPL/4

Details on Edmonton Green, Trentham Gardens & Longbridge St Modwen Objections to Planning Application Design Standards Email KMBC to St Modwen Dec 01 St Modwen News Statements Nov 02 Apr 03 & June 03 Kirkby Retail and Kiosk Details June 03 Photos of Kirkby & Email KMBC to St Modwen re Morrisons Aug 03 Plan Kirkby Mar 02 Email KMBC to St Modwen Oct 03 Email St Modwen to KMBC Dec 03 New Vision Document St Modwen News Statement Jan 04 Summary of Michelle Taylor

Details of document (Plan (Plan (Plan (Plan

1) 2) 3) 4)

(CAO)

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO) COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO) COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

7 January

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

Various Plans Southport, Skelmersdale & Wigan - Cushman & Wakefield

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 20

18 November

CAO/SUPL/4 (Plan 5) CAO/SUPL/4/1 CAO/SUPL/4/1-App 1 CAO/SUPL/4/1-App 2 CAO/P/5 CAO/A/5 CAO/S/5 CAO/P/6

Addition to Supplementary Proof by Michelle Taylor : Response to Email 18 Nov 08 Retail & Leisure Market Apr 06- Cushman & Wakefield Skelmersdale Town Centre Estimated Investment Proof of Evidence by Tom Ferguson on the impact on St Helen’s Appendices by Tom Ferguson Summary by Tom Ferguson

CAO/A/7

Proof of Evidence by Andy Wallis on the impact on Sefton Appendices by Andy Wallis Summary by Andy Wallis on the impact on Sefton Rebuttal Proof by Andy Wallis on the impact on Sefton Proof of Evidence by Mr C Hubbard on Commercial Issues Errata to Mr C Hubbard proof & summary (CAO/P/7 & CAO S/7) Appendices by Mr Hubbard

CAO/S/7

Summary by Mr Hubbard

CAO/CLOSING

Closing statement

CAO/A/6 CAO/S/6 CAO/R/6 CAO/P/7 CAO/P/7 - Errata

COMBINED AUTHORITY OBJECTORS (CAO)

COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED (CAO) COMBINED (CAO)

24 November

AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

26 January

AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS AUTHORITY OBJECTORS

5 February

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Combined Authority Objectors (CAO) Reference

Details of Document

Date submitted if after 17th November

CAO/INQ/1

Press cuttings

27 November

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 21

CAO/INQ/2

Match attendance

2 December

CAO/INQ/3

League tables

3 December

CAO/INQ/4

Planning Committee Minutes – Sefton MBC – dated 4 June 2008

7 January

CAO/INQ/5

‘Agenda Item 11’ – Sefton MBC – 7 May 2008

7 January

CAO/INQ/6

Retail Floorspace in the Skelmersdale TC SPC Masterplan

8 January

CAO/INQ/7

Table 4.1 (amended to reflect potential uplift in Skelmersdale floor space)

13 January

CAO/INQ/7 Updated CAO/INQ/8

Table 4.1 (amended to reflect figures used in RSOCG – Column A of Table 8)

22 January

ING Retail Property Fund buys £75 m St Helens shopping centre - extract

13 January

CAO/INQ/9

Amended Impact tables for Mr Nutter

14 January

CAO/INQ/9 – Updated

Amended Impact tables for Mr Nutter – for clarity purposes

22 January

CAO/INQ/10

St Modwen Company Ltd – End of year trading update 20th November 2008

19 January

Reference

Details of document

Party

GRO/P/1

Proof of Evidence by Grosvenor Limited

Grosvenor Limited (GRO)

GRO/A/1

Appendices by Grosvenor Limited

Grosvenor Limited (GRO)

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Date submitted if after 17th November

Page 22

GRO/P/2 GRO/P/3 Appendix 1 – page 1 Appendix 1 – page 2

No document - Reference number not required Further submission by Grosvenor Ltd Kirkby Town Centre Existing Sources Trade 2008 Total Available Comparison Goods Expenditure

GRO/SUMMARY

Summary of proof by Grosvenor Ltd

Grosvenor Limited (GRO)

9 January

Grosvenor Limited (GRO)

26 January

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

KRAG/OPENING

Opening by Tony Barton

18 November

KRAG/P/1

Proof of Evidence by Mr J Gittins

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG) Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG) Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

KRAG/A/1 – Front cover Appendix 1 Appendix 1a

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mr J Gittins

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 23

18 December 18 December

Appendix 1b

E-Mails (Arriva & Stagecoach)

Appendix 2

Kirkby Railway Station evening arrivals & departures

Appendix 3

Kirkby Railway Station Saturday arrivals Valley Road Traffic Survey (evening) London TravelWatch Board Meeting London Assembly Transport Committee Sports Stadium review Emirates Stadium Problems (U Tube on-line video) Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mr J Gittins

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/P/2

Proof of Evidence by Women’s Health Group

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/A/2

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Women’s Health Group

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/A/2/FANS

‘FANS’ DVD – part of appendices of

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

Appendix 4 Appendix 5 Appendix 6 Appendix 7

KRAG/S/1- Front sheet KRAG/S/1

proof of evidence by Women’s Health Group

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

KRAG/S/2

Summary of Proof of Evidence by Women’s Health Group

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/S/2 –Updated

Revised summary by Women’s Health Group

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

22 January

KRAG/P/3

Proof of Evidence by Mr P Ross

Kirkby Residents Action Group

18 December

KRAG/A/3- Cover

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mr

Kirkby Residents Action Group

18 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 24

Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix

1 1a 1b 2 3 3a

P Ross

(KRAG)

KRAG/S/3

Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mr P Ross

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/P/4

Proof of Evidence by Mr B Fearnehough

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/A/4 – Front sheet Appendix 1 Appendix 2 Appendix 3 Appendix 4

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mr B Fearnehough

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/S/4

Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mr B Fearnehough

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

KRAG/P/5

Proof of Evidence by Mrs D Reid

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/A/5- Front sheet Appendix 1 Appendix 2 Appendix 3 Appendix 4 Appendix 5 Appendix 6

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mrs D Reid

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 25

Appendix 7 KRAG/P/6 & KRAG/A/6

Proof of Evidence by Mrs P Pendleton Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mrs P Pendleton *photographs included within the Appendices have been submitted on a separate disk

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/P/7

Proof of Evidence by The Revd Dr Tim Stratford

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/A/7

Appendices of Evidence by The Revd Dr Tim Stratford

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/S/7

Summary of Proof of Evidence by The Revd Dr Tim Stratford

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

18 December

KRAG/CLOSING

Closing statement on behalf of KRAG coalition.

Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG)

4 February

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Kirkby Residents Action Group (KRAG) Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

KRAG/INQ/1

Location of Kirkby Catholic Learning Centre -Options Appraisal

5 December

KRAG/INQ/2

Local Election Press Note

10 December

KRAG/INQ/3

Results of development Securities Public Consultation

10 December

KRAG/INQ/4

Your Kirkby – Your Future – Shaping the future of your town centre

11 December

KRAG/INQ/5

Outstanding questions for Sheena Ramsey

6 January

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 26

KRAG/INQ/6

Outstanding questions for Robert Elstone

6 January

KRAG/INQ/7

Question regarding TEV/INQ/16

16 January

KRAG/INQ/8

Question regarding TEV/P/11

20 January

KRAG/INQ/9

Written response to Mr Brennan’ evidence regarding Area Partnership Board

22 January

KRAG/INQ/10

Map of Kirkby area to easily identify areas mentioned in KRAG/P/2

22 January

KRAG/INQ/11

Application of SOCECON / JOINT/1 to KRAG/P/7

23 January

KRAG/INQ/12 Appendix

Written Response regarding part of Mr Dodd’s evidence

23 January

KRAG/INQ/13

Response by KRAG to KMBC/INQ/31

5 February

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

KEIOC/P/1

Proof of Evidence by Trevor Skempton

18 December

KEIOC/A/1- front cover

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Trevor Skempton

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC) Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix

Rebuilding Goodison Case Against Everton’s ‘Destination Kirkby’ Policy DQ1 – Knowsley UDP Guidance on Tall Buildings – English Heritage & CABE Summary of Proof of Evidence by Trevor Skempton

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

18 December

Proof of Evidence by Dave Thompson

Keep Everton In Our City

18 December

1 2 3 4

KEIOC/S/1 KEIOC/P/2

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 27

18 December

(KEIOC) KEIOC/A/2 – front cover Appendix 1 Appendix 2

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Dave Thompson Merseyrail Train Map London Assembly (Transport Committee) – A question of sports travel DfT - National Travel Survey 2006

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

18 December

KEIOC/A/A/2

Replacement Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Dave Thompson

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

18 December

KEIOC/S/2

Summary of Proof of Evidence by Dave Thompson Proof of Evidence by Mark Grayson

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC) Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

18 December

KEIOC/A/3

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mark Grayson

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

18 December

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

KEIOC/P/4

Proof of Evidence by Colin Fitzpatrick

18 December

KEIOC/A/4-front cover Appendix 1

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Colin Fitzpatrick Redevelopment of Goodison Park – Ward McHugh Associates Liverpool Daily Post Article – 21/7/07 Sir Terry Leahy Open letter – Liverpool Echo 11/8/07 Liverpool Daily Post Article – 29/11/08 Deloitte Letter – 2/4/08 Simon Inglis Comments Distance from Major Centre Unsold Seats at Match’s during Season

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC) Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

Appendix 3

KEIOC/P/3

Appendix 2 Appendix 3 Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix

4 5 6 7 8

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 28

18 December

18 December

Appendix 9 Appendix 10 Appendix 11 Appendix 12 Appendix 13 Appendix 14 KEIOC/S/4 KEIOC/CLOSING

Stadium Capital Financing Group Opens London Office AGM Report – 10/12/07 EGM Transcript – 3/9/08 Keith Wyness Q & A KEIOC Galaxy Survey Results Kirkby Business Case spreadsheet Summary of Proof of Evidence by Colin Fitzpatrick Closing statement on behalf KEIOC campaign

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC) Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

18 December 4 February

Statements submitted by Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC) Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

ST/KEIOC/1

Statement outlining their case

Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC)

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Keep Everton In Our City (KEIOC) Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

KEIOC/INQ/1

HOC Report

4 December

KEIOC/INQ/2

Daily Mail cuttings- November 2008

4 December

KEIOC/INQ/3 KEIOC/INQ/4 KEIOC/INQ/5 KEIOC/INQ/6 KEIOC/INQ/7 KEIOC/INQ/8 KEIOC/INQ/9 KEIOC/INQ/10

Minutes of KMBC Planning Meeting – 10/12/04 Knowsley News – June 2007 – Special Kirkby edition Everton – EGM Newsletter KEIOC Newsletter Issue 1 Destination Kirkby presentation to George Howarth MP Our Kirkby, Our Future pamphlet New Stadium – The Observer Notes for Meeting 16/01/06

9 December 9 December 9 December 9 December 9 December 9 December 9 December 10 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 29

KEIOC/INQ/11 KEIOC/INQ/12 KEIOC/INQ/13 KEIOC/INQ/14 KEIOC/INQ/15 KEIOC/INQ/16 KEIOC/INQ/17 KEIOC/INQ/18 KEIOC/INQ/19 KEIOC/INQ/19a WR/KEIOC/INQ/20

Newspaper article- Battle Raging for Soul of “The People’s Club” (www.irishtimes.com -24/11/08) Interview between KEIOC and Peter Mc Kenna (www.keioc.net17/11/08) Letter from Merseyrail to KEIOC dated 10 December 2008 Destination Kirkby – similar case studies Map of the area surrounding Goodison Park Letter to Stagecoach Merseyside dated 24 November 2008 Letter to Arriva dated 24 November 2008 Map of Goodison area Stadium sizes for Everton FC and Liverpool FC Updated document on Stadium sizes for Everton FC and Liverpool FC Details of timings of FA Cup match- Everton V Liverpool – Wed 4 Feb 09

16 December 16 December 7 January 7 January 7 January 7 January 7 January 7 January 29 January 2 February 5 February

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

P/KCLD/1

Proof of Evidence by Councillor F Fricker

Knowsley Constituency Liberal Democrats (KCLD)

18 December

P/KCLD/2 P/KCLD/2 (a)

Proof of Evidence by Councillor Ian Smith

Knowsley Constituency Liberal Democrats (KCLD)

18 December

KCLD/CLOSING

Closing statement by KCLD

Knowsley Constituency Liberal Democrats (KCLD)

4 February

Statements submitted by Mr Fisher - Knowsley Constituency Liberal Democrats (KCLD) Reference

Details of document

Party

ST/FISHER/1

Statement outlining his XX

Mr Fisher

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Date submitted if after 17th November

Page 30

ST/FISHER/2

Copy of email dated 3 November between Mr Fisher & Mark Butterworth

Mr Fisher

19 November

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Knowsley Constituency Liberal Democrats (KCLD) Reference

Details of document

Date submitted if after 17th November

KCLD/INQ/1

Developments of Kirkby Town Centre

4 December

KCLD/INQ/2

Boundary commission for England

5 December

KCLD/INQ/3

Email from Alisha Lee, Merseytravel to Councillor Fricker

7 January

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

GRANGE/P/1

Proof of Evidence by The Grange Residents Association

The Grange Residents Association

18 December

GRANGE/P/1/A

Appendices to Proof of Evidence by The Grange Residents Association

The Grange Residents Association

18 December

GRANGE/P/2

Proof of evidence by The Grange Residents Association

The Grange Residents Association

23 January

GRANGE/A/2

Appendices to Proof of Evidence by The Grange Residents Association

The Grange Residents Association

27 January

GRANGE/P/3

Proof of evidence by The Grange Residents Association

The Grange Residents Association

28 January

Statements submitted by the Grange Residents

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 31

Reference

Details of document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

ST/GRANGE/1

Grange Residents Committee

ST/GRANGE/2

Statement by the Grange Residents Committee on the Impact on Residents Statement by the Grange Residents Committee

ST /GRANGE/3

Questions to Melvin Davies

Grange Residents Committee

26 November

WR/GRANGE/1

Outstanding issues- regeneration of Croxteth – Fazakerley bund and increased traffic volumes

Grange Residents Committee

5 February

Grange Residents Committee

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by The Grange Residents Association (GRA) Reference

Document

GRANGE/INQ/1

Reply to document TEV/INQ/12

GRANGE/INQ/2

Reply to document TEV/INQ/13

10 December

GRANGE/INQ/3

Statistics on Football related arrests and & banning orders

6 January

GRANGE/INQ/4

Questions from Mrs Pethard on behalf of GRA regarding noise

6 January

GRANGE/INQ/5

Questions from Mrs pethard on behalf of GRA in relation to sunlight and daylight & CD 10.1.6 & TEV/INQ/11.

12 January

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Date submitted if after 17th November

Page 32

Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

KRISP/P/1

Proof of Evidence by David Dodd on behalf of KRISP

Kirkby Residents In Support of Progress (KRISP) – Kirkby Small Firms Forum

18 December

KRISP/P/2

Updated Proof of evidence by David Dodd on behalf of KRISP (reformatted original proof)

Kirkby Residents In Support of Progress (KRISP) – Kirkby Small Firms Forum

20 January

Date submitted if after 17th November

Statements submitted by KRISP Reference

Document

Party

ST/KRISP/1

Statement outlining their case

KRISP

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 33

Proofs submitted by Mr S Harrison Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

P/HARRISON.S/1

Proof of Evidence by Mr Steve Harrison

Mr Stephen Harrison

18 December

A/HARRISON.S/1

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mr Steven Harrison

Mr Stephen Harrison

18 December

S/HARRISON.S/1

Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mr Steven Harrison

Mr Stephen Harrison

18 December

WR/HARRISON/1

Additional information from Mr Steven Harrison

Mr Stephen Harrison

30 January

Miscellaneous Documents submitted to the Inquiry by Mr S Harrison Reference

Document

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Date submitted if after 17th November Page 34

HARRISON/INQ/1

Network Rail – Route Utilisation Strategy – Draft for Consultation

6 January 2009

HARRISON/INQ/2

Merseyrail Timetables

6 January 2009

HARRISON/INQ/3

National Fan Survey – extract

6 January 2009

HARRISON/INQ/4

Paper Cutting 10 September 1997

7 January 2009

HARRISON/INQ/5

Article from Merseyrail – 6 January 2009

7 January 2009

Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

KTA/P/1

Proof by Mr Thomas Norman on behalf of the Kirkby Traders Association

Kirkby Traders Association

18 December

KTA/P/2

Proof by Mrs Irene Brand on behalf of the Kirkby Traders Association

Kirkby Traders Association

18 December

KTA/P/3

Proof by Mr Jason Keen on behalf of the Kirkby Traders Association

Kirkby Traders Association

18 December

KTA/P/4

Proof by Mr Kevin Routeledge on behalf of the Kirkby Traders Association

Kirkby Traders Association

18 December

KTA/P/5

Proof by Mr Rodney Smith on behalf of the Kirkby Traders Association

Kirkby Traders Association

18 December

KTA/CLOSING

Closing statement by Mr Thomas

Kirkby Traders Association

4 February

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 35

Norman on behalf of the Kirkby Traders Association

Proof and Statements submitted by 3RD Parties Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P

Proof of Evidence by Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

18 December

OBJ/HAZLEHURST/A

Appendices of Proof of Evidence by Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

18 December

OBJ/HAZLEHURST/S

Summary of Proof of Evidence by Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

18 December

OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/ADDENDUM (a) OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/ADDENDUM (b) OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/ADDENDUM (c) OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/ADDENDUM (d)

Addendum to Proof

Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

8 January

OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 (a)

Further Proof of Evidence

Mrs Rona Hazlehurst

8 January

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 36

OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1 OBJ/HAZLEHURST/P/1

(b) (c) (d) (e)

OBJ/INEZ/1

Objection Statement by Ms. Phyllis Inez

Ms. Phyllis Inez

18 December

P/McDONALD/1

Proof by Mr Ian Mc Donald on behalf of Everton Independent Blues

Everton Independent Blues

18 December

Proof and Statements submitted by 3RD Parties Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

P/McDONALD -Updated

Updated proof by Mr Ian Mc Donald on behalf of Everton Independent Blues

Everton Independent Blues

26 January

App/McDONALD -Updated

Appendices Ian Mc Donald on behalf of Everton Independent Blues

Everton Independent Blues

26 January

CL/MCDONALD/1

Clarification by Ian Mc Donald on behalf of Everton Independent Blues

Everton Independent Blues

5 February

RAMBLERS/P/1

Proof by Mr David Dent on behalf of the Ramblers Association

Ramblers Association

18 December

ST/ABBOTT/1

Statement from Mr John Abbott

Mr John Abbott

9 January

ST/BARTON.A/1

Statement from Tony Barton

Mr Tony Barton

8 January

ST/BARTON.A/1/Updated

Updated statement from Tony Barton

Mr Tony Barton

21 January

ST/BARTON.L/1

Statement by Ms. Liza Barton

Ms. Liza Barton

18 December

ST/BRENNAN/1

Statement by Mr Tony Brennan

Mr Tony Brennan

18 December

CL/MCDONALD/1 (b)

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 37

ST/CHAPMAN/1

Statement by Mr Reginald Chapman

Mr Reginald Chapman

18 December

ST/CORNWALL/1

Statement from Mr David Cornwall

Mr David Cornwall

13 January

ST/DE-GIER/1

Statement by Mr Matthew De-Gier

Mr Matthew De-Gier

18 December

Proof and Statements submitted by 3RD Parties Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

ST/DE-GIER/1- Updated

Updated statement from Mr Matthew De – Gier

Mr Matthew De-Gier

26 January

ST/DRUMMOND/1

Statement by Judi Drummond

Judi Drummond

5 February

ST/FLEMING.J/1

Statement by Mr John Fleming

Mr John Fleming

18 December

ST/FRAUGHN/1

Statement by Mr Edward Fraughn

Mr Edward Fraughn

18 December

ST/GALLAGHER/1

Statement from Mr Michael Gallagher

Mr Michael Gallagher

9 January

ST/HARRISON.B/1

Statement by Mr Bernard Harrison

Mr Bernard Harrison

18 December

ST/HAMILL/1

Statement by P Hamill

Mr P Hamill

12 January

ST/MARTIN.R/1

Statement by Ronald Martin

Mr Ronald Martin

4 December

ST/MCCORMICK/1

Statement by Mr McCormick

Mr MC Cormick

8 January

ST/MCVEIGH/1

Statement from Mr T McVeigh

Newtown Cabs Ltd

20 January

ST/MURPHY/1

Statement by Mrs A Murphy

Mrs Ann Murphy

22 January

ST/O’BRIEN/1

Statement by Chris O’Brien

Chris O’Brien

18 December

ST/REID/1

Statement by Mrs D Reid

Mrs D Reid

18 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 38

ST/RIMMER/1

Statement by Mr John Rimmer

Mr John Rimmer

18 December

Proof and Statements submitted by 3RD Parties Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

ST/RIMMER/- Updated

Updated statement by Mr John Rimmer

Mr John Rimmer

12 January

ST/RIMMER/Updated Addendum

Clarification and copies of all correspondence from Mr J Rimmer

Mr John Rimmer

5 February

ST/SCOTT/1

Statement by Mr Scott – Brookhaven Residents

Brookhaven Residents Association

8 January

ST/TONER/1

Statement by Mrs Catherine Toner

Mrs Catherine Toner

18 December

ST/WHITE/1

Statement from Mr John White

Mr John White

13 January

ST/WILLIAMS/1

Statement from Mr R Williams

The Oakfield Project

20 January

SUP/ST/OKTA/1

Statement by Mr Brian Caulfield on behalf of ‘Official’ Kirkby Traders Association

OKTA

18 December

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 39

Written Representations Date submitted if after 17th November

Reference

Document

Party

WR/Cooltrader/1

Written Representation from Cooltrader submitted by Edmund Kirby Appendices from Cooltrader

Cooltraders

Written Representation by CPRE Written Representation Written Representation from Iceland submitted by Edmund Kirby Appendices from Iceland

Mr Murray Mrs Veronica Fleming Iceland Foods Limited

18 December 18 December

Phyllis Inez Property Fund Britannica (ING)

2 February

Mr Gittens on behalf of Trust

10 December

Mr Edward Pendleton Mr Steven Pover Rosie Cooper MP for West Lancashire Rosie Cooper MP for West Lancashire Skelmersdale Limited Partnership Mr Woolford

18 December 18 December 18 November

WA/Cooltrader/1 WR/CPRE/1 WR/FLEMING.V/ 1 WR/Iceland/1 WA/Iceland/1

WR/PENDLETON/1 WR/POVER/1 WR/RCO/1

Extra letter dated 6th November via Agent Written Representation Written Representation from ING submitted by Edmund Kirby Letter Y Parker 7.11.08 Appendices from ING Millbrook Park Millennium Green Trust Papers Written Representation Written Representation Written Representation

WR/RCO/2

Additional Written Representation

WR/SLP/1 WR/WOOLFORD/1 WR/WOOLFORD/1 – Back page

Written Representation Written Representation

WR/Iceland/A WR/INEZ/1 WR/ING/1 WR/ING/1(1) WA/ING/1 WR/MPMGT/1

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 40

30 January 18 November 18 December

Statements of Common Ground Reference

Document

SOCG/RETAIL/1

Statement of Common Ground on Retail Issues Statement of Common Ground on Retail Issues Statement of Common Ground on Retail Issues

SOCG/RETAIL/2 SOCG/RETAIL/3 SOCG/RETAIL/4 SOCG/GENERAL/1 SOCG/GENERAL/1 SOCG/GENERAL/1 SOCG/GENERAL/1 SOCG/GENERAL/1 SOCG/GENERAL/1 SOCG/GENERAL/1 SOCG/GENERAL/1

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November 17 November 13 January

Statement of Common Ground on Retail Issues (1) (2) (3) (3.2) (3.3) (3.4) (3.5)

26 January

Statement of Common Ground on Planning Issues

SOCECON/JOINT/1

Statement of Common Ground- Statistical Evidence Base

13 January

RETAIL/JOINT/1 Appendix a Appendix b Appendix c

Composite Document Dealing with Reduced Comparison Growth Rates

30 January

S106 Agreement Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 41

Reference

Document

S106 Agreement

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

Tesco & Everton

18 November

S106 Appendix S106 Plan A

Tesco Freehold & Leasehold

Tesco & Everton

18 November

S106 Plan B

Tesco Controlled Land

Tesco & Everton

18 November

Section 106 /2

Updated from 18 November

Tesco & Everton

12 December

Section 106 /2 Appendices

Updated

Tesco & Everton

15 January

Section 106/3

Updated from 12 December

Tesco & Everton

6 February

Conditions of Agreement Reference

Document

Party

Date submitted if after 17th November

TEV/KMBC/CONDITIONS/1

Conditions of agreement between Tesco / KMBC

Tesco Stores Limited/ Everton Fottball Club Limited(TEV) / KMBC

19 January

TEV/KMBC/CONDITIONS/2 Appendix

Updated conditions of agreement between Tesco / KMBC

Tesco Stores Limited/ Everton Fottball Club Limited(TEV) / KMBC

29 January

TEV/KMBC/CONDITIONS/3

Updated conditions of agreement between Tesco / KMBC

Tesco Stores Limited/ Everton Fottball Club Limited(TEV) / KMBC

5 February

Documents list dated 6 February 2009

Page 42