Procedural Principles And Safeguards For Internment/administrative Detention In Armed Conflict And Other Situations Of Violence
This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it. If you are author or own the copyright of this book, please report to us by using this DMCA report form. Report DMCA
Overview
Download & View Procedural Principles And Safeguards For Internment/administrative Detention In Armed Conflict And Other Situations Of Violence as PDF for free.
More details
- Words: 3,489
- Pages: 22
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
1SPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSET GPSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPOJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUBOE PUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
!IM AND SCOPE 4HE )NTERNATIONAL 2EVIEW OF THE 2ED #ROSS IS A PERIODICAL PUBLISHED BY THE )#2# )TS AIM IS TO PROMOTE REFLECTION ON HUMANITARIAN LAW POLICY AND ACTION IN ARMED CONFLICT AND OTHER SITUATIONS OF COLLECTIVE ARMED VIOLENCE ! SPECIAL IZED JOURNAL IN HUMANITARIAN LAW IT ENDEAVOURS TO PROMOTE KNOWLEDGE CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE LAW AND CONTRIBUTE TO THE PREVENTION OF VIOLATIONS OF RULES PROTECTING FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND VALUES 4HE 2EVIEW OFFERS A FORUM FOR DISCUSSION ABOUT CONTEMPORARY HUMANITARIAN ACTION AS WELL AS ANALYSIS OF THE CAUSES AND CHARACTERISTICS OF CONFLICTS SO AS TO GIVE A CLEARER INSIGHT INTO THE HUMANITARIAN PROBLEMS THEY GENERATE &INALLY THE 2EVIEW INFORMS ITS READERSHIP ON QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO THE )NTERNATIONAL 2ED #ROSS AND 2ED #RESCENT -OVEMENT AND IN PARTICULAR ON THE ACTIVITIES AND POLICIES OF THE )#2#
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
1BPMB(IJMMBOJ $MBVEF-F$PVMUSF +BDRVFT.PSFJMMPO (BCSJFMMF/BODIFO :WFT4BOEP[ %BOJFM5IÛSFS "OESÊWPO.PPT
&EJUPSJO$IJFG 5POJ1GBOOFS *$3$ &EJUPSJBM#PBSE "INFE"CPV&M8BGB $BJSP6OJWFSTJUZ &HZQU %BOJFM#BS5BM 5FM"WJW6OJWFSTJUZ *TSBFM "OOFUUF#FDLFS 6OJWFSTJUÊ1BSJT9 'SBODF "OUÔOJP$BOÉBEP5SJOEBEF 6OJWFSTJUZPG#SBTJMJB #SB[JM .BSJLB'BIMFO .JOJTUSZGPS'PSFJHO"GGBJST 4UPDLIPMN 4XFEFO #FSOBSE)BZLFM /FX:PSL6OJWFSTJUZ 64" 74.BOJ (VKBSBU/BUJPOBM-BX6OJWFSTJUZ (BOEIJOBHBS (VKBSBU *OEJB )FSGSJFE.ÛOLMFS )VNCPMEU6OJWFSTJUZ #FSMJO (FSNBOZ .POB3JTINBXJ 0GGJDFPGUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT)JHI $PNNJTTJPOFSGPS)VNBO3JHIUT (FOFWB &MJ[BCFUI4BMNÓO(ÃSBUF 1POUJGJDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUÓMJDBEFM1FSÙ -JNB 1FSÙ .BSDP4BTTÖMJ 6OJWFSTJUZPG(FOFWB 4XJU[FSMBOE .JDIBFM/4DINJUU (FPSHF$.BSTIBMM&VSPQFBO$FOUFSGPS 4FDVSJUZ4UVEJFT (BSNJTDI1BSUFOLJSDIFO (FSNBOZ 5FSFODF5BZMPS *OUFSOBUJPOBM*OTUJUVUFGPS4USBUFHJD4UVEJFT -POEPO8BTIJOHUPO%$ 6,64" #BLIUJZBS35V[NVLIBNFEPW %JQMPNBUJD"DBEFNZ .PTDPX 3VTTJBO 'FEFSBUJPO 8FORJ;IV -BX4DIPPM 3FONJO6OJWFSTJUZPG$IJOB #FJKJOH 1FPQMFT3FQVCMJDPG$IJOB
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
1SPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFT BOETBGFHVBSET GPSJOUFSONFOU BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPOJOBSNFE DPOóJDUBOEPUIFS TJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF +FMFOB1FKJD +FMFOB 1FKJD JT -FHBM "EWJTPS BU UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PNNJUUFF PG UIF 3FE $SPTT BOE )FBE PG UIF *$3$ 1SPKFDU PO UIF 3FBîSNBUJPO BOE %FWFMPQNFOU PG *OUFSOBUJPOBM )VNBOJUBSJBO-BX
"CTUSBDU %FQSJWBUJPO PG MJCFSUZ GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT JT BO FYDFQUJPOBM NFBTVSF PG DPOUSPM UIBUNBZCFUBLFOJOBSNFEDPOGMJDU XIFUIFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM "ENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO PG QFSTPOT CFMJFWFE UP SFQSFTFOU B UISFBU UP 4UBUF TFDVSJUZJTBMTPCFJOHNPSFBOENPSFXJEFMZQSBDUJTFE PVUTJEF PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU TJUVBUJPOT5IJTQBQFSBSHVFTUIBUCPUIJOUFSONFOUBOEBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO BSF JOTVGGJDJFOUMZ FMBCPSBUFE GSPN UIF QPJOU PG UIF WJFX PG UIF QSPUFDUJPO PG UIF SJHIUTPGUIFQFSTPOTBGGFDUFE%SBXJOHPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXBOEPO IVNBOSJHIUTMBXBOETUBOEBSET UIFQBQFSQSPQPTFTBTFUPGQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFT BOE TBGFHVBSET UIBU TIPVME BT B NBUUFS PG MBX BOE QPMJDZ CF BQQMJFE BT B NJOJNVNUPBMMDBTFTPGEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZGPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOT *OUFSONFOUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTEFĐOFEBTUIFEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZPG BQFSTPOUIBUIBTCFFOJOJUJBUFEPSEFSFECZUIFFYFDVUJWFCSBODIOPUUIFKVEJDJ BSZXJUIPVUDSJNJOBMDIBSHFTCFJOHCSPVHIUBHBJOTUUIFJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWF
ĂFWJFXTFYQSFTTFEJOUIJTBSUJDMFSFēFDUUIFBVUIPSTPQJOJPOTBOEOPUOFDFTTBSJMZUIPTFPGUIF*$3$
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
EFUBJOFF*OUFSONFOUJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSFPGDPOUSPMUIBUNBZCFPSEFSFE GPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOTJOBSNFEDPOēJDU PSGPSUIFQVSQPTFPGQSPUFDUJOH4UBUFTFDV SJUZPSQVCMJDPSEFSJOOPODPOēJDUTJUVBUJPOTQSPWJEFEUIFSFRVJTJUFDSJUFSJBIBWF CFFONFUĂFQVSQPTFPGUIJTUFYUJTUPPVUMJOFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGF HVBSETUIBUHPWFSOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJOBSNFEDPOēJDUBOEJO PUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFBTBNBUUFSCPUIPGMBXBOEPGQPMJDZ *OUIFUFYU UIFUFSNTiJOUFSONFOUuBOEiBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOu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ć1VCMJTIFST (FOFWB i$PNNFOUBSZPO1SPUPDPM*SFMBUJWFUPJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOēJDUTu "SU
QBSB ĂF SFMFWBOU DSJUFSJB XIJDI BSF FYQMBJOFE JO HSFBUFS EFUBJM CFMPX BSF MBJE EPXO JO "SUJDMF PG UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PWFOBOUPO$JWJMBOE1PMJUJDBM3JHIUT *$$13 ĂFUFSNiPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFuSFGFSTUPTJUVBUJPOTCFMPXUIFUISFTIPMEPGBSNFEDPOēJDUBOEJODMVEFT TJUVBUJPOTPGiJOUFSOBMEJTUVSCBODFTPSUFOTJPOTuBTTQFDJĐFEJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM** ĂFUFSNiJOUFSONFOUuJTBMTPJOUFOEFEUPDPWFSUIFOPUJPOPGiBTTJHOFESFTJEFODF uUPXIJDIJEFOUJDBM QSPWJTJPOTPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOBQQMZ ĂJT TIPVME JO OP XBZ CF SFBE BT SFGFSSJOH UP PS MFHJUJNJ[JOH UIF QSBDUJDF PG IPTUBHFUBLJOH XIJDI JT TUSJDUMZ QSPIJCJUFE CZ JOUFSOBUJPOBM IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX ĂF *$3$T QPTJUJPO JT UIBU IPTUBHFT NVTU CF JNNFEJBUFMZBOEVODPOEJUJPOBMMZSFMFBTFE 'PS EJćFSFODFT JO UIF MFHBM SFHVMBUJPO PG JOUFSONFOU JO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOēJDUTBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFTFFTFDUJPO* i-FHBMTPVSDFT uCFMPX
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
-FHBMTPVSDFT 5IFMFHBMTPVSDFTPOXIJDIUIFQSFTFOUTUBOEBSETBSFCBTFEBSFUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB $POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF PG "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM * UP UIF (FOFWB $POWFOUJPOT XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFGMFDUDVTUPNBSZJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX "SUJDMFDPNNPO UPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT "EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**UIFSFUP BOEDVTUPNBSZSVMFT PGJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBX &WFOUIPVHIJOUFSONFOUJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTSFHVMBUFECZ UIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOBOE"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM* UIFTFUSFBUJFTEPOPU TVGGJDJFOUMZFMBCPSBUFPOUIFQSPDFEVSBMSJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT OPSEPUIFZTQFDJGZ UIFEFUBJMTPGUIFMFHBMGSBNFXPSLUIBUBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZNVTUJNQMFNFOU*O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTUIFSFJTFWFOMFTTDMBSJUZBTUPIPXBENJOJTUSB UJWFEFUFOUJPOJTUPCFPSHBOJ[FE"SUJDMFDPNNPOUPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT XIJDIJTBQQMJDBCMFBTBNJOJNVNTUBOEBSEUPBMMOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPO GMJDUT DPOUBJOTOPQSPWJTJPOTSFHVMBUJOHJOUFSONFOU JFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFO UJPO GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT BQBSU GSPN UIF SFRVJSFNFOU PG IVNBOF USFBUNFOU *OUFSONFOUJT IPXFWFS DMFBSMZBNFBTVSFUIBUDBOCFUBLFOJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOGMJDU BTFWJEFODFECZUIFMBOHVBHFPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM** XIJDI NFOUJPOTJOUFSONFOUJO"SUJDMFTBOESFTQFDUJWFMZ CVUMJLFXJTFEPFTOPUHJWF EFUBJMTPGIPXJUJTUPCFPSHBOJ[FE#FBSJOHJONJOEUIFQSJODJQMFTPGIVNBOJUZ BOEUIFEJDUBUFTPGQVCMJDDPOTDJFODF UIF.BSUFOTDMBVTF
UIFQSJODJQMFTBOE SVMFTPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPONBZ JOQSBDUJDF TFSWFBTHVJEBODFJO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JO SFTPMWJOH TPNF PG UIF QSPDFEVSBM JTTVFT NFOUJPOFEJOUIJTUFYU *OBEEJUJPOUPIVNBOJUBSJBOMBX UIFQSFTFOUBOBMZTJTESBXTPOIVNBO SJHIUTMBX PGCPUIBCJOEJOHBOEBOPOCJOEJOHOBUVSF iTPGUMBXu
BTBDPN QMFNFOUBSZTPVSDFPGMBXJOTJUVBUJPOTPGBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSBTBOBVUPOPNPVT TPVSDF PG MBX PVUTJEF PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU 5IF DPNQMFNFOUBSZ SFMBUJPOTIJQ CFUXFFO IVNBOJUBSJBO BOE IVNBO SJHIUT MBX IBT NPTU SFDFOUMZ CFFO DPO GJSNFECZUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVSUPG+VTUJDF UIF6/TQSJODJQBMMFHBMCPEZ*O B+VMZ"EWJTPSZ0QJOJPO UIF$PVSUTUBUFEUIBUIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBO SJHIUTMBXBSFCZOPNFBOTNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWF"DDPSEJOHUPUIF$PVSU TPNF SJHIUT BSF QSPUFDUFE POMZ CZ IVNBO SJHIUT MBX TPNF BSF QSPUFDUFE POMZ CZ IVNBOJUBSJBOMBX BOEiZFUPUIFSTNBZCFNBUUFSTPGCPUIUIFTFCSBODIFTPG JOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXu 5IF SJHIUT PG QFSTPOT JOUFSOFE GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT JO BSNFE DPO GMJDUXIFUIFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMNBZCFTBJEUPGBMMJOUP UIFDBUFHPSZPGSJHIUTUIBU JOUIF*$+TXPSEJOH BSFiNBUUFSTuPGCPUICSBODIFT ($*7 "SUTBOE "1* "SU ĂF.BSUFOTDMBVTFJT JOUFSBMJB JODMVEFEJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*XIJDISFBETi*ODBTFT OPU DPWFSFE CZ UIJT 1SPUPDPM PS CZ PUIFS JOUFSOBUJPOBM JOTUSVNFOUT DJWJMJBOT BOE DPNCBUBOUT SFNBJO VOEFSUIFQSPUFDUJPOBOEBVUIPSJUZPGUIFQSJODJQMFTPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXEFSJWFEGSPNFTUBCMJTIFEDVTUPN GSPNUIFQSJODJQMFTPGIVNBOJUZBOEGSPNUIFEJDUBUFTPGQVCMJDDPOTDJFODFu *$+ "EWJTPSZ 0QJOJPO PO UIF -FHBM $POTFRVFODFT PG UIF $POTUSVDUJPO PG B 8BMM JO UIF 0DDVQJFE 1BMFTUJOJBO5FSSJUPSZ +VMZ QBSB
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
PG MBX (JWFO UIF BGPSFTBJE BCTFODF PG SVMFT GPS UIF JOUFSONFOU PG JOEJWJEVBMT JOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT JUJTOFDFTTBSZUPESBXPOIVNBOSJHIUT MBXJOEFWJTJOHBMJTUPGQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETUPHPWFSOJOUFSO NFOUJOTVDIDPOGMJDUT5PBMBSHFFYUFOUUIFTBNFNBZCFTBJEXJUISFHBSEUP BOZFGGPSUUPDMBSJGZUIFSJHIUT BOEUIFSFGPSFUIFMFHBMQSPUFDUJPO UIBUTIPVMECF BDDPSEFEUPQFSTPOTDPWFSFECZUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOPS"EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM*JOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT 3FDPVSTF UP IVNBO SJHIUT MBX BT B MFHBM SFHJNF DPNQMFNFOUBSZ UP IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX JT FYQSFTTMZ SFDPHOJ[FE JO CPUI "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPMT UP UIF (FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT "DDPSEJOHUP"SUJDMFPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*iĂFQSPWJTJPOTPGUIJT 4FDUJPOBSFBEEJ UJPOBM UP UIF SVMFTDPODFSOJOHIVNBOJUBSJBOQSPUFDUJPOPGDJWJMJBOTBOEDJWJMJBO PCKFDUTJOUIFQPXFSPGB1BSUZUPUIFDPOēJDUDPOUBJOFEJOUIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPO QBSUJDVMBSMZ1BSUT*BOE***UIFSFPG BTXFMMBTUPPUIFSBQQMJDBCMFSVMFTPGJOUFSOB UJPOBMMBXSFMBUJOHUPUIFQSPUFDUJPOPGGVOEBNFOUBMIVNBOSJHIUTEVSJOHJOUFSOB UJPOBM BSNFE DPOēJDUu FNQIBTJT BEEFE ĂJT BSUJDMF BMMPXT SFDPVSTF UP IVNBO SJHIUTMBXBTBOBEEJUJPOBMGSBNFPGSFGFSFODFJOSFHVMBUJOHUIFSJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT XIPCFMPOHUPiQFSTPOTJOUIFQPXFSPGBQBSUZUPUIFDPOēJDUu ĂFSFBSFUXPGVSUIFSJOEJDBUJPOTJO"SUJDMFPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM* XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFGMFDUDVTUPNBSZMBXUIBUIVNBOSJHIUTMBXNBZCF ESBXOPOUPGJMMUIFHBQT'JSTU BOEUIJTNVTUCFTUSFTTFE "SUJDMF TUBUFT UIBUQFSTPOTGBMMJOHXJUIJOJUTTDPQFTIBMMFOKPZUIFQSPUFDUJPOQSPWJEFEGPSCZ UIJTBSUJDMFiBTBNJOJNVNu FNQIBTJTBEEFE (JWFOUIBU"SUJDMFJTBiTBGFUZ OFUu NFBOU UP DPWFS BMM QFSTPOT XIP EP OPU FOKPZ NPSF GBWPVSBCMF USFBUNFOU VOEFSUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOTPS1SPUPDPM* BOEXIFOJUJTSFBEJODPOKVODUJPO XJUI"SUJDMF JUOFDFTTBSJMZGPMMPXTUIBUUIFiNJOJNVNuNFOUJPOFEJTTVQQMF NFOUFECZPUIFSQSPWJTJPOTPGIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBOSJHIUTMBX 4FDPOEMZ BOZ QPTTJCMF EPVCU UIBU "SUJDMF DPOTUJUVUFT B NJOJNVN CFODINBSL PG QSPUFDUJPO JT EJTQFMMFE CZ UIF GJOBM DMBVTF UIFSFPG i/P QSPWJ TJPOPGUIJT"SUJDMFNBZCFDPOTUSVFEBTMJNJUJOHPSJOGSJOHJOHBOZPUIFSNPSF GBWPVSBCMFQSPWJTJPOHSBOUJOHHSFBUFSQSPUFDUJPO VOEFSBOZBQQMJDBCMFSVMFTPG JOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX UPQFSTPOTDPWFSFECZQBSBHSBQIu5IFBQQMJDBCMFSVMFTPG JOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXJODMVEFIVNBOSJHIUTMBX *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG $PNNPO "SUJDMFBOEPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**BSUJDVMBUFNJOJNVNTUBOEBSETUIBUNVTU CFBQQMJFEJOJOUFSONFOU8IFSFUIFQBSUJFTUPBOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDU CSJOH JOUP GPSDF CZ NFBOT PG TQFDJBM BHSFFNFOUT BMM PS QBSU PG UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG TVDI BO BHSFFNFOU QSFWBJM*UNVTUCFOPUFEUIBUQSFBNCVMBSQBSBHSBQIPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM** 4FFi$PNNFOUBSZPO"1*u PQDJU OPUF
QBSBTm "1* "SU 4FF"SUJDMFDPNNPOUPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT XIJDIBMTP TQFDJĐFTUIBUUIFDPODMVTJPOPGBTQFDJBM BHSFFNFOUiTIBMMOPUBćFDUUIFMFHBMTUBUVTPG1BSUJFTUPUIFDPOēJDUu4QFDJBMBHSFFNFOUTDBOCFFćFDUJWF QBSUJDVMBSMZJOIJHIJOUFOTJUZOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUTXIJDISFTFNCMFJOUFS4UBUFBSNFEDPOēJDU
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
FTUBCMJTIFT UIF MJOL CFUXFFO UIF 1SPUPDPM BOE IVNBO SJHIUT MBXCZ TUBUJOH UIBU iJOUFSOBUJPOBMJOTUSVNFOUTSFMBUJOHUPIVNBOSJHIUTPćFSBCBTJDQSPUFDUJPOUPUIF IVNBO QFSTPOu ĂF $PNNFOUBSZ PO UIBU 1SPUPDPM TQFDJĐFT UIBU UIF SFGFSFODF UP JOUFSOBUJPOBM JOTUSVNFOUT JODMVEFT USFBUJFT BEPQUFE CZ UIF 6/ TVDI BT UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PWFOBOUPO$JWJMBOE1PMJUJDBM3JHIUT *$$13 BOEUIF$POWFOUJPO BHBJOTU5PSUVSF BTXFMMBTUIFSFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFT ĂFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPO XIJDIJTUIFQSJNBSZGPDVTPGUIJTUFYU JT JOUFSBMJBQSPWJEFEGPSJO"SUJDMF PGUIF*$$13"4UBUF1BSUZNBZEFSPHBUF GSPN TVTQFOE JUTPCMJHBUJPOTVOEFSUIBUUSFBUZVOEFSWFSZTUSJDUDPOEJUJPOT POF PGXIJDIJTUIFFYJTUFODFPGBQVCMJDFNFSHFODZUISFBUFOJOHUIFMJGFPGUIFOBUJPO /POJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUJTBOFYBNQMFPGBQVCMJDFNFSHFODZJOXIJDI NFBTVSFTPGEFSPHBUJPOOFDFTTBSZGPSFOBCMJOHJOUFSONFOUXPVMECFMBXGVM VOEFS UIF $PWFOBOU QSPWJEFE UIF PUIFS SFRVJTJUF DPOEJUJPOT IBWF CFFO NFU *OOPODPOēJDUTJUVBUJPOT4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIF*$$13NVTUMJLFXJTFDPNQMZXJUI UIF EFSPHBUJPO DMBVTFT PG UIF $PWFOBOU JO PSEFS UP JOTUJUVUF NFBTVSFT BćFDUJOH UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ PG QFSTPO TVDI BT BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO 5IF QSFTFOU BOBMZTJTJTCBTFEPOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUJOUFSONFOUJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFE DPOēJDU BOE BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JNQMFNFOUFE JO OPODPOēJDU TJUVBUJPOT DPNQMZXJUIUIFEFSPHBUJPODSJUFSJBTQFDJĐFEJOUIF*$$13 )PXFWFS FWFO JO FNFSHFODZ TJUVBUJPOT UIF TPDBMMFE iIBSE DPSFu PG IVNBO SJHIUT XIJDI JODMVEFT UIF SJHIU UP MJGF BOE UIF QSPIJCJUJPO PG UPSUVSF BOE PUIFS DSVFM JOIVNBO PS EFHSBEJOH USFBUNFOU PS QVOJTINFOU DBOOPU CF EFSPHBUFEGSPNVOEFSBOZDJSDVNTUBODFT5IFKVSJTQSVEFODFPGJOUFSOBUJPOBM BOESFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTCPEJFTIBTEFUFSNJOFEXIJDIPUIFSIVNBOSJHIUT BQBSUGSPNUIPTFFYQSFTTMZMJTUFEJOUIFUSFBUJFT TIPVMEBMTPCFDPOTJEFSFEOPO EFSPHBCMF"NPOHUIFNJTUIFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZUPDIBMMFOHF UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO IBCFBTDPSQVT
XIJDIJTBOFTTFOUJBMFMF NFOUPGUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPO )VNBOSJHIUTTPGUMBXJOTUSVNFOUTBOEKVSJTQSVEFODFQSPWJEFGVSUIFS TUBOEBSETUIBU JUJTTVCNJUUFE TIPVMEBTBNBUUFSPGQPMJDZBOEHPPEQSBDUJDFCF BQQMJFEXJUISFTQFDUUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO i$PNNFOUBSZPO1**u PQDJU OPUF
QBSBTm ĂFGVMMUFYUPG"SUJDMFPGUIF*$$13SFBETi*OUJNFPGQVCMJDFNFSHFODZXIJDIUISFBUFOTUIFMJGFPG UIFOBUJPOBOEUIFFYJTUFODFPGXIJDIJTPĊDJBMMZQSPDMBJNFE UIF4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOU NBZUBLFNFBTVSFTEFSPHBUJOHGSPNUIFJSPCMJHBUJPOTVOEFSUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOUUPUIFFYUFOUTUSJDUMZ SFRVJSFECZUIFFYJHFODJFTPGUIFTJUVBUJPO QSPWJEFEUIBUTVDINFBTVSFTBSFOPUJODPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFJS PUIFSPCMJHBUJPOTVOEFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXBOEEPOPUJOWPMWFEJTDSJNJOBUJPOTPMFMZPOUIFHSPVOEPGSBDF DPMPVS TFY MBOHVBHF SFMJHJPOPSTPDJBMPSJHJO/PEFSPHBUJPOGSPNBSUJDMFT QBSBTBOE
BOENBZCFNBEFVOEFSUIJTQSPWJTJPO"OZ4UBUF1BSUZUPUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOUBWBJMJOH JUTFMGPGUIFSJHIUPGEFSPHBUJPOTIBMMJNNFEJBUFMZJOGPSNUIFPUIFS4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOU UISPVHIUIFJOUFSNFEJBSZPGUIF4FDSFUBSZ(FOFSBMPGUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT PGUIFQSPWJTJPOTGSPNXIJDI JUIBTEFSPHBUFEBOEPGUIFSFBTPOTCZXIJDIJUXBTBDUVBUFE"GVSUIFSDPNNVOJDBUJPOTIBMMCFNBEF UISPVHIUIFTBNFJOUFSNFEJBSZ POUIFEBUFPOXIJDIJUUFSNJOBUFTTVDIEFSPHBUJPOu *ODBTFTXIFSFB4UBUFJTOPUBQBSUZUPUIF*$$13PSTJNJMBSSFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFT JUJTTVCNJUUFE UIBUUIFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETMJTUFECFMPXTIPVMECFGPMMPXFEBTBNBUUFSPGQPMJDZ *$$13 "SU *$$13 "SU
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
5IFDPNNFOUBSZUPUIFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETPVUMJOFE JOUIJTUFYUNFOUJPOTUIFEJGGFSFOUMFHBMTPVSDFTHPWFSOJOHEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ GPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOTJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFE DPOGMJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF*UJTQSFDJTFMZUIFTJNJMBSJUZJODPOUFOU PGUIFWBSJPVTMFHBMTPVSDFTSFWJFXFEUIBUHVJEFEUIFTQFDJGJDGPSNVMBUJPOPGUIF QSPDFEVSBM QSJODJQMFT BOE TBGFHVBSET MJTUFE BOE XIJDI BMMPXT UIF DPODMVTJPO UIBUUIFZDBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBNJOJNVNBQQMJDBCMFJOBMMDBTFTPGEFQSJWBUJPOPG MJCFSUZGPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOT
(FOFSBMQSJODJQMFTBQQMJDBCMFUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO *OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSF ĂF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO NBLFT JU FYQMJDJUMZ DMFBS UIBU JOUFSONFOU BOE BTTJHOFE SFTJEFODF BSF UIF NPTU TFWFSF NFBTVSFT PG DPOUSPM UIBU B EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZPS0DDVQZJOH1PXFSNBZUBLFXJUISFTQFDUUPQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOTBHBJOTU XIPNOPDSJNJOBMQSPDFFEJOHTIBWFCFFOJOJUJBUFE*OCPUIDBTFTJUJTTUJQVMBUFE UIBUSFDPVSTFUPUIFTFNFBTVSFTNBZCFIBEPOMZJGUIFTFDVSJUZPGUIF4UBUFNBLFT JUiBCTPMVUFMZOFDFTTBSZu ($*7 "SUJDMF PSGPSiJNQFSBUJWFSFBTPOTPGTFDV SJUZu ($*7 "SUJDMF ĂFFYDFQUJPOBMOBUVSFPGJOUFSONFOUMJFTJOUIFGBDUUIBU JUBMMPXTUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZUPEFQSJWFQFSTPOTPGMJCFSUZXIPBSFOPUTVCKFDU UPDSJNJOBMQSPDFTT CVUBSFOFWFSUIFMFTTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFQSFTFOUBSFBMUISFBUUPJUT TFDVSJUZJOUIFQSFTFOUPSJOUIFGVUVSF"TUIF$PNNFOUBSZPOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB $POWFOUJPOFYQMBJOT i*UEJEOPUTFFNQPTTJCMFUPEFĐOFUIFFYQSFTTJPOATFDVSJUZ PGUIF4UBUFJOBNPSFDPODSFUFGBTIJPO*UJTUIVTMFĔWFSZMBSHFMZUP(PWFSONFOUT UPEFDJEFUIFNFBTVSFPGBDUJWJUZQSFKVEJDJBMUPUIFJOUFSOBMPSFYUFSOBMTFDVSJUZ PGUIF4UBUFXIJDIKVTUJĐFTJOUFSONFOUPSBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFu8IJMFUIJTNBZCF UIFDBTFJUJTDMFBS GPSFYBNQMF UIBUJOUFSONFOUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOGPS UIFTPMFQVSQPTFPGJOUFMMJHFODFHBUIFSJOH XJUIPVUUIFQFSTPOJOWPMWFEPUIFSXJTF QSFTFOUJOHBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ DBOOPUCFKVTUJĐFE ĂBUJOUFSONFOUJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSFJTBMTPUSVFJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOēJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF CBTFEPOUIFHFOFSBMQSJODJQMF UIBUQFSTPOBMMJCFSUZJTUIFSVMF BOEPOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUUIFDSJNJOBMKVTUJDF TZTUFN JT BCMF UP EFBM XJUI QFSTPOT TVTQFDUFE PG SFQSFTFOUJOH B EBOHFS UP 4UBUF TFDVSJUZ *UTIPVMEBHBJOCFOPUFEUIBUUIJTUFYUEPFTOPUEFBMXJUIUIFJOUFSONFOUPGQSJTPOFSTPGXBSJOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOēJDUT XIJDIJTHPWFSOFECZUIFĂJSE(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO"TBMSFBEZNFOUJPOFE JUJTBTTVNFE UIBUUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPOIBTCFFOEFSPHBUFEGSPNJOLFFQJOHXJUI"SUJDMFPGUIF*$$13 4FF$PNNFOUBSZPOUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOTPG"VHVTU 7PM7 (FOFWB$POWFOUJPOSFMBUJWFUPUIF 1SPUFDUJPOPG$JWJMJBO1FSTPOTJO5JNFPG8BS "SU Q4FFBMTPUIF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMF BU QBHF XIJDISFJUFSBUFTUIBUi*OBOZDBTFTVDINFBTVSFTDBOPOMZCFPSEFSFEGPSSFBMBOEJNQFSBUJWF SFBTPOTPGTFDVSJUZ UIFJSFYDFQUJPOBMDIBSBDUFSNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEu 4JNJMBSMZ JOUFSOJOHPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOJOHQFSTPOTGPSUIFQVSQPTFPGVTJOHUIFNBTiCBSHBJOJOH DIJQTuJTBMTPOPUKVTUJĐBCMFBTBSFBTPOGPSJOUFSONFOU4VDIEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZXPVMEJOGBDUBNPVOU UPIPTUBHFUBLJOH XIJDIJTQSPIJCJUFE
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTOPUBOBMUFSOBUJWFUPDSJNJOBM QSPDFFEJOHT *OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTBNFBTVSFPGDPOUSPMBJNFEBUEFBMJOH XJUIQFSTPOTXIPQPTFBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ DVSSFOUMZPSJOUIFGVUVSF JO TJUVBUJPOT PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU PS UP 4UBUF TFDVSJUZ PS QVCMJD PSEFS JO OPODPOGMJDU TJUVBUJPOT JU JT OPU B NFBTVSF UIBU JT NFBOU UP SFQMBDF DSJNJOBM QSPDFFEJOHT " QFSTPO XIP JT TVTQFDUFE PG IBWJOH DPNNJUUFE B DSJNJOBM PGGFODF XIFUIFSJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF IBTUIFSJHIU UP CFOFGJU GSPN UIF BEEJUJPOBM TUSJOHFOU KVEJDJBM HVBSBOUFFT QSPWJEFE GPS JO IVNBOJUBSJBOBOEPSIVNBOSJHIUTMBXGPSDSJNJOBMTVTQFDUT XIJDIJODMVEFUIF SJHIU UP CF USJFE CZ B SFHVMBSMZ DPOTUJUVUFE JOEFQFOEFOU BOE JNQBSUJBM DPVSU 6OMFTTJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOBOEQFOBMSFQSFTTJPOBSFPSHBOJ[FE BTTUSJDUMZTFQBSBUFSFHJNFTUIFSFJTBEBOHFSUIBUJOUFSONFOUNJHIUCFVTFEBT BTVCTUBOEBSETZTUFNPGQFOBMSFQSFTTJPOJOUIFIBOETPGUIFFYFDVUJWFQPXFS CZQBTTJOHUIFPOFTBODUJPOFECZBDPVOUSZTMFHJTMBUVSFBOEDPVSUT5IFSJHIUTPG DSJNJOBMTVTQFDUTXPVMEUIVTCFHSBWFMZVOEFSNJOFE
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPODBOPOMZCFPSEFSFEPOBOJOEJWJEVBM DBTFCZDBTFCBTJT XJUIPVUEJTDSJNJOBUJPOPGBOZLJOE "DJWJMJBODBOCFJOUFSOFEJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUPOMZPOUIFCBTJTPGBO JOEJWJEVBMEFDJTJPOUBLFOJOFWFSZTQFDJGJDDBTF5IFOPUJPOUIBUJOUFSONFOUDBO OPUCFBDPMMFDUJWFNFBTVSFJTFTUBCMJTIFEVOEFSUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO JOTJUVBUJPOTPGPDDVQBUJPO&OCMPDJOUFSONFOUPGFOFNZOBUJPOBMTJOB4UBUFT PXOUFSSJUPSZJTBMTPQSPIJCJUFE BTJUXPVMEBNPVOUUP BOEWJPMBUFUIFHFOFSBM QSPIJCJUJPOPG iDPMMFDUJWFQVOJTINFOUTuVOEFS"SUJDMF E PG"EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM*5IJTEPFTOPUNFBOUIBUBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZDBOOPUJOUFSOBMBSHF OVNCFS PG QFSTPOT CVU UIBU CPUI UIF JOJUJBM EFDJTJPO PO JOUFSONFOU BOE BOZ TVCTFRVFOUEFDJTJPOUPNBJOUBJOJU JODMVEJOHUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU NVTU CFUBLFOXJUISFTQFDUUPFBDIJOEJWJEVBMJOWPMWFE *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JO XIJDI DPMMFDUJWF QVOJTI NFOUTBSFBMTPQSPIJCJUFEBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF CPUIUIFJOJUJBM
ĂFBSHVNFOUUIBUBENJOJTUSBUJWFBOEDSJNJOBMEFUFOUJPOBSFUXPEJTUJODUSFHJNFTJTBUĐSTUHMBODF VOEFSNJOFECZ"SUJDMFPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOXIJDIEFBMTXJUIQFUUZPćFODFTDPNNJUUFE CZQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOTJOPDDVQJFEUFSSJUPSZĂF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMF IPXFWFS SFDUJĐFTBOZQPTTJCMF QFSDFQUJPOPGPWFSMBQCFUXFFOUIFSFHJNFTPGBENJOJTUSBUJWFBOEDSJNJOBMEFUFOUJPOUIBUUIFXPSEJOH PG UIF QSPWJTJPO TVHHFTUT *U SFBET i*OUFSONFOU JT B QSFWFOUJWF BENJOJTUSBUJWF NFBTVSF BOE DBOOPU CF DPOTJEFSFE B QFOBM TBODUJPO *U JT OFWFSUIFMFTT NFOUJPOFE IFSF VOEFS UIF TBNF IFBE<JOH> BT TJNQMF JNQSJTPONFOU CFDBVTFUIFBVUIPSTPGUIF$POWFOUJPOXJTIFEUPNBLFJUQPTTJCMFGPSUIFNJMJUBSZDPVSUT PGUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSUPHJWFQFSTPOTHVJMUZPGNJOPSPćFODFTUIFCFOFĐUPGDPOEJUJPOTPGJOUFSONFOU FNQIBTJTBEEFE QSPWJEFEGPSJO"SUJDMFFUTFRĂFQSPWJTJPOXBTBIVNBOFPOFBOEXBTJOUFOEFE UPESBXBEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOTVDIPćFOEFSTBOEDPNNPODSJNJOBMTu$PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
QQm *CJE "SU Q "1** "SU C
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
EFDJTJPOPOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOBOEBOZTVCTFRVFOUEFDJTJPO UPNBJOUBJOJUNVTUCFUBLFOPOBOJOEJWJEVBMCBTJT&WFOUIPVHIIVNBOJUBSJBO MBXHPWFSOJOHOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTTJMFOUBTUPUIFQSPDFEVSBM SJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT VOEFSIVNBOSJHIUTMBXBOZNFBTVSFEFSPHBUJOHGSPNUIF SJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPONVTUCFiTUSJDUMZSFRVJSFECZUIFFYJHFODJFTPGUIFTJUV BUJPOuPGQVCMJDFNFSHFODZOFDFTTJUBUJOHUIFEFSPHBUJPO JUNBZCFUBLFOPOMZ UPUIFFYUFOUSFRVJSFEUIFSFCZ BOENVTUUIVTCFJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIFQSJODJ QMFPGQSPQPSUJPOBMJUZ " 4UBUFT FO CMPD OPOJOEJWJEVBM EFUFOUJPO PG B XIPMF DBUFHPSZ PG QFSTPOT DPVME JO OP XBZ CF DPOTJEFSFE B QSPQPSUJPOBM SFTQPOTF SFHBSEMFTT PG XIBU UIF DJSDVNTUBODFTPGUIFFNFSHFODZDPODFSOFENJHIUCFĂFJEFBPGDPMMFDUJWFNFBTVSFT PGBOZLJOEJTBOUJUIFUJDBMUPUIFSVMFT TQJSJUBOEQVSQPTFPGIVNBOSJHIUTMBX %FDJTJPOT PO JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO NVTU BMTP OPU CF UBLFOPOBEJTDSJNJOBUPSZCBTJT5IFQSJODJQMFPGOPOEJTDSJNJOBUJPOJTBCBTJD UFOFUPGCPUIIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOT GPSJUDFBTFUPFYJTU 0OFPGUIFNPTUJNQPSUBOUQSJODJQMFTHPWFSOJOHJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFO UJPOJTUIBUUIJTGPSNPGEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZNVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFJOEJWJEVBM DFBTFTUPQPTFBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ NFBOJOHUIBUEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ POTVDIHSPVOETDBOOPUCFJOEFĐOJUF*OWJFXPGUIFSBQJEQSPHSFTTJPOPGFWFOUTJO BSNFEDPOēJDU BQFSTPODPOTJEFSFEUPCFBUISFBUUPEBZNJHIUOPUQPTFUIFTBNF UISFBUBĔFSBDIBOHFPGDJSDVNTUBODFTPOUIFHSPVOE*OPUIFSXPSET UIFMPOHFS JOUFSONFOUMBTUT UIFHSFBUFSUIFPOVTPOBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZUPQSPWFUIBUUIF SFBTPOTGPSJUSFNBJOWBMJEĂFSBUJPOBMFPGUIFQSJODJQMFJTUIVTUPGBDJMJUBUFUIF SFMFBTFPGBQFSTPOBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOTKVTUJGZJOHUIFDVSUBJMNFOUPGMJCFSUZOP MPOHFSFYJTUĂFQSJODJQMFUIBUJOUFSONFOUNVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOTGPS JUDFBTFUPFYJTUJTDMFBSMZFOVODJBUFEJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF BOEJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM* XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFēFDU DVTUPNBSZJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUT *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT BOE PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF UIJTQSJODJQMFNVTU JGBOZUIJOH CFFWFONPSFTUSJOHFOUMZPCTFSWFE QBSUJDVMBSMZ BT IVNBO SJHIUT KVSJTQSVEFODF SFKFDUT UIF OPUJPO PG JOEFGJOJUF EFUFOUJPO *O PSEFSUPFOTVSFUIBUBEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZJTOPUBSCJUSBSZ XIJDIXPVMECFUIF DBTFJGUIFSFBTPOTGPSJUEPOPUPSOPMPOHFSFYJTU UIF*$$13 "SUJDMF
QSP *$$13 "SU 4FFFH3FQPSUPGUIF8PSLJOH(SPVQPO"SCJUSBSZ%FUFOUJPO 6/%PD&$/ %FDFNCFS QBSB iJOOPFWFOUNBZBOBSSFTUCBTFEPOFNFSHFODZMFHJTMBUJPOMBTUJOEFĐOJUFMZu
BOE*OUFS "NFSJDBO$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUT"OOVBM3FQPSU 0"4%PD0&"4FS-7** %PD DPSSPG+VOF 4FDUJPO** 1BSU* iUIFEFDMBSBUJPOPGBTUBUFPGFNFSHFODZPSBTUBUFPGTJFHFDBOOPU TFSWFBTBQSFUFYUGPSUIFJOEFĐOJUFEFUFOUJPOPGJOEJWJEVBMT XJUIPVUBOZDIBSHFXIBUFWFS*UJTPCWJPVT UIBUXIFOUIFTFTFDVSJUZNFBTVSFTBSFFYUFOEFECFZPOEBSFBTPOBCMFUJNFUIFZCFDPNFUSVFBOETFSJPVT WJPMBUJPOTPGUIFSJHIUUPGSFFEPNu
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
WJEFTUIBUBOZPOFEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZIBTUIFSJHIUUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPG IJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPOĐMFBQFUJUJPOGPSIBCFBTDPSQVTPSUIFFRVJWBMFOUJOPSEFS UIBUBDPVSUNBZEFDJEFiXJUIPVUEFMBZuXIFUIFSIFPSTIFJTCFJOHIFMEMBXGVMMZ PSOPU8IJMFUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZJTOPUBNPOHUIFOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUTMJTUFE JOUIF*$$13 UIFKVSJTQSVEFODFPGCPUIVOJWFSTBMBOESFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUT CPEJFTIBTDPOGJSNFEUIBUUIFSJHIUUPIBCFBTDPSQVTNVTUJOGBDUCFDPOTJEFSFE OPOEFSPHBCMF
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUDPOGPSNUPUIFQSJODJQMF PGMFHBMJUZ *OUIFDPOUFYUPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO UIFQSJODJQMFPGMFHBMJUZ NFBOT UIBU B QFSTPO NBZ CF EFQSJWFE PG MJCFSUZ POMZ GPS SFBTPOT TVCTUBOUJWF BTQFDU BOE JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI QSPDFEVSFT QSPDFEVSBM BTQFDU UIBU BSF QSP WJEFEGPSCZEPNFTUJDBOEJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX ĂF (FOFWB $POWFOUJPOT BOE UIFJS "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPMT BT XFMM BT IVNBOSJHIUTMBX QSPWJEFUIFJOUFSOBUJPOBMMFHBMTUBOEBSETUIBUBSFUPCFBQQMJFE UP JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JO BSNFE DPOēJDU BOE PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PGWJPMFODF*OUFSNTPGSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU UIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPOTQFDJĐFT UIBUBQSPUFDUFEQFSTPONBZCFJOUFSOFEPSQMBDFEJOBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFPOMZJG iUIFTFDVSJUZPGUIF%FUBJOJOH1PXFSNBLFTJUBCTPMVUFMZOFDFTTBSZu "SUJDMF PS JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ GPS iJNQFSBUJWF SFBTPOT PG TFDVSJUZu "SUJDMF *O BEEJUJPOUPTQFDJGZJOHUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU UIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPOMBZT EPXO DFSUBJO QSPDFEVSFT UIBU NVTU CF GPMMPXFE GPS JOUFSONFOU UP CF MBXGVM CPUI JO UIF UFSSJUPSZ PG B QBSUZ UP DPOGMJDU BOE JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ *O UIF MBUUFS DBTF GPS FYBNQMF "SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI $POWFOUJPO TUJQVMBUFT UIBU EFDJTJPOTSFHBSEJOHBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFPSJOUFSONFOUiTIBMMCFNBEFBDDPSEJOH UPBSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFUPCFQSFTDSJCFECZUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSJOBDDPSEBODF XJUI UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF QSFTFOU $POWFOUJPOu %FQSJWBUJPO PG MJCFSUZ UIBU JT OPUJODPOGPSNJUZXJUIUIFWBSJPVTSVMFTQSPWJEFEGPSJOUIF$POWFOUJPONBZ DPOTUJUVUFiVOMBXGVMDPOGJOFNFOUu )VNBOSJHIUTTUBOEBSETBQQMJDBCMFJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT BOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFQSPWJEFFWFONPSFEFUBJMFEQSPWJTJPOTBJNFEBU FOTVSJOHSFTQFDUGPSUIFQSJODJQMFPGMFHBMJUZ6OEFSUIF*$$13 "SUJDMF
GPS FYBNQMF QFSTPOTNBZOPUCFEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZiFYDFQUPOTVDIHSPVOET BOEJOBDDPSEBODFXJUITVDIQSPDFEVSFBTBSFFTUBCMJTIFECZMBXu8IFSFB4UBUF EFDJEFT UP EFSPHBUF GSPN UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ TVDI B EFDJTJPO NVTU JOUFS BMJB CF PGGJDJBMMZ QSPDMBJNFE TP BT UP FOBCMF UIF BGGFDUFE QPQVMBUJPO UP LOPX UIF FYBDUNBUFSJBM UFSSJUPSJBMBOEUFNQPSBMTDPQFPGBQQMJDBUJPOPGUIBUFNFSHFODZ NFBTVSF
*$$13 "SU ($*7 "SU *$$13 "SU
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
1SPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSET 3JHIUUPJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO "OZQFSTPOJOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFENVTUCFJOGPSNFEQSPNQUMZ JO B MBOHVBHF IF PS TIF VOEFSTUBOET PG UIF SFBTPOT XIZ UIBU NFBTVSF IBT CFFO UBLFOTPBTUPFOBCMFUIFQFSTPODPODFSOFEUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPS IFSEFUFOUJPO5IFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOUPLOPXXIZIFPSTIFIBTCFFOEFQSJWFE PGMJCFSUZNBZCFTBJEUPDPOTUJUVUFBOFMFNFOUPGUIFPCMJHBUJPOPGIVNBOUSFBU NFOU BT B QFSTPOT VODFSUBJOUZ BCPVU UIF SFBTPOT GPS IJT PS IFS EFUFOUJPO JT LOPXOJOQSBDUJDFUPDPOTUJUVUFBTPVSDFPGBDVUFQTZDIPMPHJDBMTUSFTT /FJUIFS UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO OPS IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX BQQMJ DBCMF JO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT DPOUBJO FYQMJDJU QSPWJTJPOT PO UIF EVUZ UP QSPWJEF JOGPSNBUJPO BCPVU UIF SFBTPOT GPS XIJDI B QFSTPO IBT CFFO EFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZ5IFGPSFHPJOHQSPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSEJT IPXFWFS POFPGUIF i'VOEBNFOUBM(VBSBOUFFTuMBJEEPXOJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM* *UJTNPSFPWFSQSPWJEFEGPSJONPTUPGUIFSFMFWBOUIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFTBOEJT TQFMUPVUJOTPGUMBXJOTUSVNFOUTBTXFMM 5IFJOGPSNBUJPOHJWFONVTUBMTPCFTVGGJDJFOUMZEFUBJMFEGPSUIFEFUBJOFE QFSTPOUPUBLFJNNFEJBUFTUFQTUPDIBMMFOHF BOESFRVFTUBEFDJTJPO POUIFMBX GVMOFTT PG UIF JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO TFF CFMPX *OGPSNBUJPO PO UIF SFBTPOT GPS JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO NVTU CF DPOWFZFE QSPNQUMZ TP BT UP FOBCMF UIF QFSTPO JO RVFTUJPO UP BMTP QSPNQUMZ SFRVFTU B EFDJTJPO PO UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG EFUFOUJPO BOE NVTU CF DPOWFZFE JO B MBOHVBHF IFPSTIFVOEFSTUBOET8IFSFBOJOJUJBMEFDJTJPOPOEFUFOUJPOJTNBJOUBJOFEPO SFWJFX UIFSFBTPOTGPSDPOUJOVFEEFUFOUJPONVTUCFQSPWJEFEBTXFMM
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ĔFSi#PEZPG1SJODJQMFTu "1* "SU
#PEZPG1SJODJQMFT 1SJODJQMF ($*7 "SUTBOE
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
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
'PSFJHOOBUJPOBMTJOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO 5IF OBUJPOBM BVUIPSJUJFT PG B QFSTPO JOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZ EFUBJOFE NVTU CF JOGPSNFE UIFSFPG VOMFTT B XJTI UP UIF DPOUSBSZ IBT CFFO FYQSFTTFE CZ UIF QFSTPODPODFSOFE5IFSFMFWBOUEJQMPNBUJDPSDPOTVMBSBVUIPSJUJFTQSPWJEFE EJQMPNBUJDPSDPOTVMBSSFMBUJPOTFYJTUNVTUCFBMMPXFEUPDPNNVOJDBUFXJUI BOEWJTJUUIFJSOBUJPOBMT5IJTJTBSVMFPGQVCMJDJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXUIBUSFNBJOT BQQMJDBCMFJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
"QFSTPOTVCKFDUUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOIBTUIFSJHIUUP DIBMMFOHF XJUIUIFMFBTUQPTTJCMFEFMBZ UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO 8JUISFHBSEUPJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO JO "SUJDMFBQQMJDBCMFUPUIFJOUFSONFOUPGQFSTPOTJOUIFUFSSJUPSZPGBQBSUZUP UIFDPOGMJDU TUJQVMBUFTUIBUBOZQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOJOUFSOFEPSQMBDFEJOBTTJHOFE SFTJEFODFJTiFOUJUMFEUPIBWFTVDIBDUJPOSFDPOTJEFSFEBTTPPOBTQPTTJCMFCZBO BQQSPQSJBUFDPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEEFTJHOBUFECZUIF%FUBJOJOH1PXFS GPS UIBU QVSQPTFu 6OEFS "SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI $POWFOUJPO BQQMJDBCMF UP UIF JOUFSONFOU PG QFSTPOT JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ EFDJTJPOT SFHBSEJOH BTTJHOFE SFTJEFODFPSJOUFSONFOUiTIBMMCFNBEFBDDPSEJOHUPBSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFUPCF QSFTDSJCFE CZ UIF 0DDVQZJOH 1PXFS JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF QSFTFOU $POWFOUJPO 5IJT QSPDFEVSF TIBMM JODMVEF UIF SJHIU PG BQQFBM GPS UIF QBSUJFTDPODFSOFE"QQFBMTTIBMMCFEFDJEFEXJUIUIFMFBTUQPTTJCMFEFMBZu
*CJE "SU *CJE "SU *CJE "SUT BOE #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMFTBOE 4FF BMTP 6/ %FDMBSBUJPO PO UIF 1SPUFDUJPO PG "MM 1FSTPOT GSPN &OGPSDFE %JTBQQFBSBODF "SU
BOE 1SJODJQMFT PO UIF &ćFDUJWF 1SFWFOUJPO BOE *OWFTUJHBUJPO PG &YUSBMFHBM "SCJUSBSZ BOE 4VNNBSZ &YFDVUJPOT SFDPNNFOEFECZ6/&DPOPNJDBOE4PDJBM$PVODJM 1SJODJQMF 4FF"SUPGUIF7JFOOB$POWFOUJPOPO$POTVMBS3FMBUJPOT*OJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUT UIFPĊDJBM *OGPSNBUJPO#VSFBVYBOEUIF$FOUSBM5SBDJOH"HFODZBSFNFDIBOJTNTUISPVHIXIJDIUIFBEWFSTFQBSUZJT JOGPSNFEPGUIFJOUFSONFOUPGJUTOBUJPOBMT ($*7 "SUTm *OOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUT UIF*$3$JTBMTPBWBJMBCMFUPGBDJMJUBUFDPOUBDUCFUXFFOBQFSTPOEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZBOEUIF4UBUFPGXIJDI IFPSTIFJTBOBUJPOBM QSPWJEFEUIBUQFSTPODPOTFOUTUPTVDIOPUJĐDBUJPO
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
8IJMF UIF $POWFOUJPO EPFT OPU TQFDJGJDBMMZ TQFBL PG UIFTF BDUJPOT BT DIBMMFOHFTUPUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPO UIBUJTXIBUUIFZFTTFOUJBMMZBSF5IF QVSQPTF PG UIF iSFDPOTJEFSBUJPOu PS iBQQFBMu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
3FWJFXPGUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUCF DBSSJFEPVUCZBOJOEFQFOEFOUBOEJNQBSUJBMCPEZ "SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO TUJQVMBUFT UIBU BO iBQQSPQSJBUF DPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEuTIBMMCFDIBSHFEXJUISFDPOTJEFSJOHUIFJOJUJBM EFDJTJPOPOUIFJOUFSONFOUPGBDJWJMJBOJOUIFUFSSJUPSZPGBQBSUZUPUIFDPO GMJDU "DDPSEJOH UP "SUJDMF BQQMJDBCMF JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ B EFDJTJPO PO JOUFSONFOUNVTUCFNBEFQVSTVBOUUPBiSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFuQSFTDSJCFECZUIF 0DDVQZJOH1PXFSJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIF$POWFOUJPO"SUJDMFBEETUIBUUIF QFSJPEJDSFWJFXFOWJTBHFENVTUCFVOEFSUBLFOCZBiDPNQFUFOUCPEZTFUVQuCZ UIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFS%FTQJUFUIFEJGGFSFODFJOMBOHVBHFiDPVSUPSBENJOJT USBUJWFCPBSEuJO"SUJDMFWFSTVTiSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFuJO"SUJDMFUIFDPN NFOUBSZPOUIFMBUUFSBSUJDMFTUBUFTUIBUUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSiNVTUPCTFSWFUIF TUJQVMBUJPOTJO"SUJDMFuBOEUIBUJUJTVQUPUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSiUPFOUSVTU UIFDPOTJEFSBUJPOPGBQQFBMTFJUIFSUPBADPVSUPSBACPBSEu "4UBUFTGSFFEPNUPDIPPTFCFUXFFOBiDPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEu BT QSPWJEFE GPS JO "SUJDMF BOE "SUJDMF CZ BOBMPHZ JT FYQMBJOFE JO UIF #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF4FFBMTP)VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF (FOFSBM$PNNFOU /P QBSB )VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF JCJE QBSB $PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
"SU QQm
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
$PNNFOUBSZBTBMMPXJOHiTVGGJDJFOUGMFYJCJMJUZUPUBLFJOUPBDDPVOUUIFVTBHFJO EJGGFSFOU4UBUFTu5IF$PNNFOUBSZBEETUIBUiXIFSFUIFEFDJTJPOJTBOBENJOJT USBUJWFPOF JUNVTUOPUCFNBEFCZPOFPGGJDJBMCVUCZBOBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSE PGGFSJOH UIF OFDFTTBSZ HVBSBOUFFT PG JOEFQFOEFODF BOE JNQBSUJBMJUZu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iUBLF QSPDFFEJOHTCFGPSFBDPVSU JOPSEFSUIBUUIBUDPVSUNBZEFDJEFXJUIPVUEFMBZ POUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTEFUFOUJPOBOEPSEFSIJTSFMFBTFJGUIFEFUFOUJPOJTOPU MBXGVMu "T IBT BMSFBEZ CFFO TUSFTTFE BCPWF FWFO UIPVHI UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ PG QFSTPO NBZ CF EFSPHBUFE GSPN JO TJUVBUJPOT PG FNFSHFODZ TVDI BT OPO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDU IVNBO SJHIUT TPGU MBX BOE KVSJTQSVEFODF IBWF FTUBCMJTIFEUIBUUIFSJHIUUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGPOFTEFUFOUJPOCFGPSFB KVEJDJBMCPEZNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEJOBMMDJSDVNTUBODFT*UNBZJOQBSUJDVMBSOPU CFEJNJOJTIFEXIFSFUIFDIBMMFOHFUPMBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPOTFSWFT JOUFSBMJB UPQSPUFDUOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUT TVDIBTUIFSJHIUUPMJGFPSGSFFEPNGSPNUPSUVSF BOEPUIFSDSVFM JOIVNBOPSEFHSBEJOHUSFBUNFOUPSQVOJTINFOU *UTIPVMECFSFJUFSBUFEUIBUUIFSFBTPOGPSDIBMMFOHFTUPUIFMBXGVMOFTTPG JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTUPQVUBOFOEUPUIFEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJC FSUZJGJUJTOPUKVTUJGJFE5IJTNFBOTUIBUBOJOUFSOFFNVTUCFJOGPSNFEXJUIPVU EFMBZPGBOZEFDJTJPOUBLFOPOBQQFBMBOECFJNNFEJBUFMZSFMFBTFEJGUIFQFUJ UJPO JT VQIFME &WFO UIPVHI UIF PCMJHBUJPO PG TQFFEZ JOGPSNBUJPO BOE SFMFBTF JT OPU FYQMJDJUMZ NFOUJPOFE JO FJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO PS IVNBO SJHIUT MBX BOZ EFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZXJUIPVUBMFHBMCBTJTJTDPOTJEFSFEUPCFBWJPMBUJPOPGUIF HFOFSBM MFHBM QSJODJQMF QSPIJCJUJOH BSCJUSBSZ EFUFOUJPO *G B QFSTPO JT LFQU JO JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOEFTQJUFBGJOBMSFMFBTFPSEFS UIBUJTBDMFBS DBTFPGBSCJUSBSZEFUFOUJPO
*CJE "SU Q *$$13 "SU #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF4FFBMTP)VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF (FOFSBM$PNNFOU /P QBSB )VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF JCJE QBSB
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTIPVMECFBMMPXFEUPIBWFMFHBM BTTJTUBODF /FJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO OPS IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUZ MBX FYQMJDJUMZ QSPWJEF GPS UIF SJHIUUPMFHBMBTTJTUBODFGPSQFSTPOTJOUFSOFEPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFE UIBU SJHIUJTHVBSBOUFFEUPQFSTPOTTVCKFDUUPDSJNJOBMDIBSHFT *UNVTUCFOPUFE IPXFWFS UIBUMFHBMBTTJTUBODFUPJOUFSOFFTJOJOUFSOB UJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTOPUQSPIJCJUFE5IF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMFPGUIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO JO GBDU TUBUFT UIBU UIF iQSPDFEVSF QSPWJEFE GPS JO UIF$POWFOUJPOJTBNJOJNVNuBOEUIBUiJUXJMMCFBOBEWBOUBHF UIFSFGPSF JG 4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIF$POWFOUJPOBGGPSECFUUFSTBGFHVBSETu*UNBZCFTBJEUIBU OPXBEBZTUIFSJHIUUPFGGFDUJWFMFHBMBTTJTUBODFJTOPUKVTUBOiBEWBOUBHFu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
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFIBTUIFSJHIUUPQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFX PGUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGDPOUJOVFEEFUFOUJPO 1FSJPEJDBMSFWJFXPGBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJGUIFJOJUJBMEFDJTJPOPOEFUFOUJPO JTDPOĐSNFEBĔFSiSFDPOTJEFSBUJPOu "SUJDMF
PSPOiBQQFBMu "SUJDMF
JTB CBTJDDPNQPOFOUPGUIFQSPDFEVSFMBJEEPXOJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMFTQFDJĐFTUIBUQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFXTIBMMUBLFQMBDFiBUMFBTUUXJDFZFBSMZ u XIJMF"SUJDMFQSPWJEFTUIBUTVDISFWJFXTIBMMUBLFQMBDFiJGQPTTJCMFFWFSZTJY NPOUITu 5IFQVSQPTFPGUIFQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFXJTUPBTDFSUBJOXIFUIFSUIFEFUBJOFF DPOUJOVFT UP QPTF B SFBM UISFBU UP UIF TFDVSJUZ PG UIF EFUBJOJOH QPXFS BOE UP PSEFS SFMFBTF JG UIBU JT OPU UIF DBTF "MM UIF TBGFHVBSET UIBU BQQMZ UP UIF JOJ UJBMSFWJFXNVTUBQQMZUPUIFQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFX T BTXFMM XIJDI BNPOHPUIFS UIJOHT NFBOTUIBUUIFSFWJFXIBTUPCFFGGFDUJWFBOENVTUCFDPOEVDUFECZBO JOEFQFOEFOUBOEJNQBSUJBMCPEZ
$PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
Q *CJE 4FF JOUFSBMJB #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMFTBOE *CJE 1SJODJQMF
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
5IFSFJTOPTQFDJGJFEQFSJPEJDJUZPGSFWJFXBWBJMBCMFUPQFSTPOTEFUBJOFE JO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT PS PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF CFDBVTF IVNBOSJHIUTMBXEPFTOPUMJNJUUIFGSFRVFODZPGDIBMMFOHFTUIBUNBZCFTVC NJUUFE CZ BO JOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZ EFUBJOFE QFSTPO UP UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG EFUFOUJPO IBCFBTDPSQVTQFUJUJPOT *OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOXJMM JO QSBDUJDF CF SFHVMBUFE CZ UIF EPNFTUJD MBX PG UIF 4UBUF JOWPMWFE JO B OPO JOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSPUIFSTJUVBUJPOPGWJPMFODF NFBOJOHUIBUBQFS TPOTBCJMJUZUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPOXJMMCFSFHVMBUFECZUIPTFOPSNT *GUIFSFMFWBOUEPNFTUJDMBXNBLFTOPTVDIQSPWJTJPO JUJTTVCNJUUFEUIBU BUMFBTUTJYNPOUIMZSFWJFXTPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOTIPVMECF QSPWJEFEGPS TJNJMBSUPUIFSVMFTBQQMJDBCMFJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPSIFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWF TIPVMECFBCMFUPBUUFOEUIFQSPDFFEJOHTJOQFSTPO "OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPSIFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWFTIPVME BT B HFOFSBM SVMF CF BCMF UP CF QSFTFOU BU UIF JOJUJBM SFWJFX PG UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG JOUFSONFOU BT XFMM BT BU QFSJPEJDBM SFWJFXT JO PSEFS UP CF BCMF UP QSFTFOU UIF JOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUBJOFFT QPTJUJPO BOE DPOUFTU UIF DMBJNT NBEF BHBJOTUIJNPSIFS8IFSFOFDFTTBSZ SFBTPOBCMFBSSBOHFNFOUTGPSUIFQSFTFSWB UJPOPGDMBTTJGJFEJOGPSNBUJPONBZCFNBEF TVDIBTSFRVJSJOHTFDVSJUZDMFBSBODF GPSUIFJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWF 8IJMF OFJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO OPS IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUZ MBX FYQSFTTMZ NFOUJPOUIFSJHIUPGJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTBOEPGUIFJSMFHBMSFQ SFTFOUBUJWF UP CF QSFTFOU BU QSPDFFEJOHT SFMBUFE UP JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JU IBT CFFO PCTFSWFE JO QSBDUJDF UIBU UIFJS BCTFODF PGUFO MFBET UP IFBSJOHT JO XIJDI UIFJS DBTF JT HJWFO JOBEFRVBUF BUUFOUJPO #FDBVTF TVDI QSP DFFEJOHTSFTVMUJOEFDJTJPOTPOUIFDPOUJOVBUJPOPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JUJTTVCNJUUFEUIBUUIFJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPS IFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWFTIPVMECFBMMPXFEUPCFQSFTFOUBUUIFQSPDFFEJOHT*G UIFZEPOPUVOEFSTUBOEUIFMBOHVBHFPGUIFDPVSU UIFZXJMMOFFEUPCFQSPWJEFE XJUIBOJOUFSQSFUFS
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFNVTUCFBMMPXFEUPIBWFDPOUBDUTXJUI UPDPSSFTQPOEXJUIBOECFWJTJUFECZNFNCFSTPGIJTPSIFSGBNJMZ 5IF QSFTFSWBUJPO PG GBNJMZ MJGF BOE DPOUBDUT JT POF PG UIF CBTJD BJNT PG JOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXBOENBZCFTBJEUPDPOTUJUVUFBOFMFNFOUPGUIF CSPBEFSPCMJHBUJPOUIBUQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZJOCPUIJOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT NVTU CF USFBUFE IVNBOFMZ 5IJT TBGFHVBSE BTXFMMBTUIFUXPMJTUFEJNNFEJBUFMZCFMPX CFMPOHUPUIPTFBJNFE BU FOTVSJOH QSPQFS DPOEJUJPOT BOE USFBUNFOU JO EFUFOUJPO XIJDI JT OPU UIF *CJE 1SJODJQMF
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
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iDPPQFSBUJWFOFTTuXJUIUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZ PSCFVTFEBTBGPSNPGJODFOUJWFPSSFXBSEGPSPUIFSCFIBWJPVS "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM ** BMTP DPOUBJOT QSPWJTJPOT EFTJHOFE UP NBJOUBJO GBNJMZ DPOUBDUT BOE OVNFSPVT OPOUSFBUZ IVNBO SJHIUT TUBOEBSET IBWF UIF TBNFBJN
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFIBTUIFSJHIUUPUIFNFEJDBMDBSFBOE BUUFOUJPOSFRVJSFECZIJTPSIFSDPOEJUJPO 5IFSJHIUUPNFEJDBMDBSFBOEBUUFOUJPOJTBDPNQPOFOUPGUIFFTTFOUJBMPCMJHB UJPOUIBUBMMQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZNVTUCFUSFBUFEIVNBOFMZ.FEJDBM DBSFBOEBUUFOUJPOTFSWFBNPOHPUIFSUIJOHTUPQSFWFOUJMMUSFBUNFOUBOEBMTP UPSFGVUFUIFBENJTTJCJMJUZPGFWJEFODFBHBJOTUBQFSTPOUIBUIBTCFFOPCUBJOFE CZUPSUVSFPSPUIFSGPSNTPGJMMUSFBUNFOU5IFZBSFNFOUJPOFEJOUIJTDPOUFYU CFDBVTF B QFSTPOT IFBMUI JT PCWJPVTMZ B QSFSFRVJTJUF GPS IJT PS IFS BCJMJUZ UP DMBJNNPTUPGUIFQSPDFEVSBMSJHIUTPVUMJOFEJOUIJTUFYU ĂFHFOFSBMSVMFMBJEEPXOJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF TUJQVMBUFT UIBU i1BSUJFT UP UIF DPOGMJDU XIP JOUFSO QSPUFDUFE QFSTPOT TIBMM CF CPVOEUPQSPWJEFGSFFPGDIBSHFGPSUIFJSNBJOUFOBODF BOEUPHSBOUUIFNBMTP UIFNFEJDBMBUUFOUJPOSFRVJSFECZUIFJSTUBUFPGIFBMUIu.PSFTQFDJGJDSVMFTPO IZHJFOFBOENFEJDBMBUUFOUJPOBSFDPOUBJOFEJO"SUJDMFTBOE *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT "SUJDMF C PG "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM**TUJQVMBUFTUIBUJOUFSOFFTiTIBMM UPUIFTBNFFYUFOUBTUIFMPDBMDJWJM JBOQPQVMBUJPO CFQSPWJEFEXJUIGPPEBOEESJOLJOHXBUFSBOECFBGGPSEFETBGF HVBSETBTSFHBSETIFBMUIBOEIZHJFOFBOEQSPUFDUJPOBHBJOTUUIFSJHPVSTPGUIF DMJNBUFBOEUIFEBOHFSTPGUIFBSNFEDPOGMJDUu1SPWJTJPOTPOBDDFTTUPBEPDUPS BOE NFEJDBM BUUFOUJPO BSF BMTP DPOUBJOFE JO UIF SFMFWBOU IVNBO SJHIUT OPO USFBUZJOTUSVNFOUT #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT 1SJODJQMFTBOE *U NVTU CF TUSFTTFE UIBU BDDFTT UP NFEJDBM DBSF UIBU NJHIU CF SFRVJSFE CZBQFSTPOTDPOEJUJPODBOOPUJOBOZDJSDVNTUBODFTCFNBEFEFQFOEFOUPOIJT PS IFS iDPPQFSBUJWFOFTTu XJUI UIF EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZ PS CF VTFE BT B GPSN PG JODFOUJWFPSSFXBSEGPSPUIFSCFIBWJPVS
4FF JOUFSBMJB ($*7 "SUT BOE 4FF($*7 "SU BOE$PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
Q "1** "SU C #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
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
"DDFTTUPQFSTPOTJOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFE *$3$ BDDFTT UP QFSTPOT JOUFSOFE JO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JT QSPWJEFE GPSJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF
XIJDIBMTPMBZTEPXOUIF DPOEJUJPOTBOEQSPDFEVSFGPS*$3$WJTJUTBOEFTUBCMJTIFTUIFEVUZPGBEFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZUPHSBOUBDDFTTBOEUPSFTQFDUUIFTBJEDPOEJUJPOTBOEQSPDFEVSF *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT BOE JO PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJP MFODF UIF *$3$ NBZ PGGFS JUT TFSWJDFT BOE DPODMVEF BHSFFNFOUT XJUI UIF EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZ PO WJTJUT UP QFSTPOT EFQSJWFE PG UIFJS MJCFSUZ GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT BOEUPPUIFSQFSTPOT5IF*$3$TSJHIUPGBDDFTTJOUIFTFTJUVBUJPOTJT XJEFMZSFDPHOJ[FE #ZNFBOTPGWJTJUTUPQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZUIF*$3$ XIJDI JT BO JOEFQFOEFOU JNQBSUJBM BOE OFVUSBM IVNBOJUBSJBO PSHBOJ[BUJPO TFFLT UP FOTVSFUIBUUIFZBSFUSFBUFEIVNBOFMZJOBMMDJSDVNTUBODFTBOEUIBUUIFJSGVO EBNFOUBMSJHIUTBSFSFTQFDUFE*UJTUIVTDPODFSOFEFTTFOUJBMMZXJUIUIFJSDPOEJ UJPOTPGEFUFOUJPOBOEUIFJSUSFBUNFOU JODMVEJOHSFTQFDUGPSGVOEBNFOUBMQSP DFEVSBMHVBSBOUFFTBUBMMTUBHFTPGEFUFOUJPO $FSUBJO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE SFHJPOBM IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUJFT UPP QSPWJEF GPS POTJUF WJTJUT UP TVDI QFSTPOT CZ WJTJUJOH NFDIBOJTNT FTUBCMJTIFE VOEFS UIPTFUSFBUJFT5IFSFBSFMJLFXJTFBOVNCFSPGOPOUSFBUZNFDIBOJTNTDSFBUFE VOEFSUIFBVTQJDFTPGUIF6/$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUTUIBUNBZDBSSZPVU WJTJUTUPQMBDFTPGEFUFOUJPO 6OEFS "SU PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO *OUFSOFF $PNNJUUFFT BMTP IBWF UIF SJHIU UP NBLF SFQSFTFOUBUJPOTUP JOUFSBMJB UIF*$3$ *U TIPVME CF OPUFE UIBU VOEFS IVNBO SJHIUT TPĔ MBX UIF MFHBM DPVOTFM B GBNJMZ NFNCFS PS BOPUIFS QFSTPOXIPIBTLOPXMFEHFPGUIFDBTFNBZBMTPNBLFTVCNJTTJPOTSFHBSEJOHUIFUSFBUNFOUPGBQFSTPOJO BENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO4FF#PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF BOE 4FF"SUDPNNPOUPUIFGPVS(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT 4FF"SU PGUIF4UBUVUFTPGUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FE$SPTTBOE3FE$SFTDFOU.PWFNFOU &HUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJUUFFGPSUIF1SFWFOUJPOPG5PSUVSFBOE*OIVNBOPS%FHSBEJOH5SFBUNFOUPS 1VOJTINFOUTFUVQCZUIF&VSPQFBO$POWFOUJPOGPSUIF1SFWFOUJPOPG5PSUVSFBOE*OIVNBOPS%FHSBEJOH 5SFBUNFOUPS1VOJTINFOU &HUIF6/$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUT8PSLJOH(SPVQPO"SCJUSBSZ%FUFOUJPO
5IF3FWJFXJTQSJOUFEJO&OHMJTIBOEJT QVCMJTIFE GPVS UJNFT B ZFBS JO .BSDI +VOF 4FQUFNCFSBOE%FDFNCFS "OOVBM TFMFDUJPOT PG BSUJDMFT BSF BMTP QVCMJTIFEPOBSFHJPOBMMFWFMJO"SBCJD $IJOFTF 'SFODI 3VTTJBOBOE4QBOJTI
$PWFSQIPUP ¥*OUFSOBUJPOBM.VTFVNPGUIF3FE$SPTT BOE3FE$SFTDFOU.PWFNFOU
5IFBSUJDMFTQVCMJTIFEJOUIF3FWJFX BSFBWBJMBCMFGSFFPGDIBSHFPOMJOFBU XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX
4VCNJTTJPOPGNBOVTDSJQUT
4VCTDSJQUJPOT
5IF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FWJFXPGUIF3FE$SPTTJOWJUFT TVCNJTTJPOTPGNBOVTDSJQUTPOTVCKFDUTSFMBUJOH UP JOUFSOBUJPOBM IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX QPMJDZ BOE BDUJPO .PTU JTTVFT GPDVT PO QBSUJDVMBS UPQJDT EFDJEFE CZ UIF &EJUPSJBM #PBSE XIJDI DBO CF DPOTVMUFEVOEFSUIFIFBEJOH'VUVSF5IFNFTPO UIFXFCTJUFPGUIF3FWJFX4VCNJTTJPOTSFMBUFEUP UIFTFUIFNFTBSFQBSUJDVMBSMZXFMDPNF
5IF QSJOU SVO JT MJNJUFE 5IF 3FWJFX JT EJTUSJCVUFE UP TFMFDUFE JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE PSHBOJ[BUJPOT 'VSUIFS EJTUSJCVUJPO JT TVCKFDUUPBWBJMBCJMJUZ
"SUJDMFT NBZ CF TVCNJUUFE JO "SBCJD $IJOFTF &OHMJTI 'SFODI 3VTTJBO BOE 4QBOJTI 4FMFDUFE BSUJDMFTBSFUSBOTMBUFEJOUP&OHMJTIJGOFDFTTBSZ 4VCNJTTJPOT NVTU OPU IBWF CFFO QVCMJTIFE TVCNJUUFE PS BDDFQUFE FMTFXIFSF "SUJDMFT BSF TVCKFDUFE UP B QFFSSFWJFX QSPDFTT UIF GJOBM EFDJTJPO PO QVCMJDBUJPO JT UBLFO CZ UIF &EJUPS JO$IJFG 5IF 3FWJFX SFTFSWFT UIF SJHIU UP FEJU BSUJDMFT/PUJGJDBUJPOPGBDDFQUBODF SFKFDUJPOPS UIF OFFE GPS SFWJTJPO XJMM CF HJWFO XJUIJO GPVS XFFLTPGSFDFJQUPGUIFNBOVTDSJQU.BOVTDSJQUT XJMMOPUCFSFUVSOFEUPUIFBVUIPST .BOVTDSJQUTNBZCFTFOUCZFNBJMUP SFWJFXHWB!JDSDPSH .BOVTDSJQUSFRVJSFNFOUT "SUJDMFT TIPVME CF UP XPSET JO MFOHUI 4IPSUFS DPOUSJCVUJPOT DBO CF QVCMJTIFE VOEFSUIFTFDUJPO/PUFTBOEDPNNFOUT 'PS GVSUIFS JOGPSNBUJPO QMFBTF DPOTVMU UIF *OGPSNBUJPOGPSDPOUSJCVUPSTBOE(VJEFMJOFTGPS SFGFSFODJOHPOUIFXFCTJUFPGUIF3FWJFX XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX
3FRVFTUTGPSTVCTDSJQUJPOTDBOCFNBEFUP UIFGPMMPXJOHBEESFTT *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFPGUIF3FE$SPTT *$3$
1SPEVDUJPO .BSLFUJOH BOE%JTUSJCVUJPO "WFOVFEFMB1BJY $)(FOFWB 4XJU[FSMBOE G FNBJMTIPQHWB!JDSDPSH XXXJDSDPSHFOHTIPQ ¥JDSD "VUIPSJ[BUJPO UP SFQSJOU PS SFQVCMJTI BOZ UFYU QVCMJTIFE JO UIF 3FWJFX NVTU CF PCUBJOFEGSPNUIF&EJUPSJO$IJFG3FRVFTUT TIPVMECFBEESFTTFEUPUIF&EJUPSJBM5FBN &EJUPSJBM5FBN &EJUPSJO$IJFG5POJ1GBOOFS &EJUPSJBMBTTJTUBOU'JPOB-F%JSBJTPO 1VCMJDBUJPOBTTJTUBOU.BSJBOOF1FSFEB *OUFSOBUJPOBM3FWJFXPGUIF3FE$SPTT "WFOVFEFMB1BJY $)(FOFWB 4XJU[FSMBOE U G FNBJMSFWJFXHWB!JDSDPSH
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX
1SPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSET GPSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPOJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUBOE PUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
!IM AND SCOPE 4HE )NTERNATIONAL 2EVIEW OF THE 2ED #ROSS IS A PERIODICAL PUBLISHED BY THE )#2# )TS AIM IS TO PROMOTE REFLECTION ON HUMANITARIAN LAW POLICY AND ACTION IN ARMED CONFLICT AND OTHER SITUATIONS OF COLLECTIVE ARMED VIOLENCE ! SPECIAL IZED JOURNAL IN HUMANITARIAN LAW IT ENDEAVOURS TO PROMOTE KNOWLEDGE CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE LAW AND CONTRIBUTE TO THE PREVENTION OF VIOLATIONS OF RULES PROTECTING FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND VALUES 4HE 2EVIEW OFFERS A FORUM FOR DISCUSSION ABOUT CONTEMPORARY HUMANITARIAN ACTION AS WELL AS ANALYSIS OF THE CAUSES AND CHARACTERISTICS OF CONFLICTS SO AS TO GIVE A CLEARER INSIGHT INTO THE HUMANITARIAN PROBLEMS THEY GENERATE &INALLY THE 2EVIEW INFORMS ITS READERSHIP ON QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO THE )NTERNATIONAL 2ED #ROSS AND 2ED #RESCENT -OVEMENT AND IN PARTICULAR ON THE ACTIVITIES AND POLICIES OF THE )#2#
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
1BPMB(IJMMBOJ $MBVEF-F$PVMUSF +BDRVFT.PSFJMMPO (BCSJFMMF/BODIFO :WFT4BOEP[ %BOJFM5IÛSFS "OESÊWPO.PPT
&EJUPSJO$IJFG 5POJ1GBOOFS *$3$ &EJUPSJBM#PBSE "INFE"CPV&M8BGB $BJSP6OJWFSTJUZ &HZQU %BOJFM#BS5BM 5FM"WJW6OJWFSTJUZ *TSBFM "OOFUUF#FDLFS 6OJWFSTJUÊ1BSJT9 'SBODF "OUÔOJP$BOÉBEP5SJOEBEF 6OJWFSTJUZPG#SBTJMJB #SB[JM .BSJLB'BIMFO .JOJTUSZGPS'PSFJHO"GGBJST 4UPDLIPMN 4XFEFO #FSOBSE)BZLFM /FX:PSL6OJWFSTJUZ 64" 74.BOJ (VKBSBU/BUJPOBM-BX6OJWFSTJUZ (BOEIJOBHBS (VKBSBU *OEJB )FSGSJFE.ÛOLMFS )VNCPMEU6OJWFSTJUZ #FSMJO (FSNBOZ .POB3JTINBXJ 0GGJDFPGUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT)JHI $PNNJTTJPOFSGPS)VNBO3JHIUT (FOFWB &MJ[BCFUI4BMNÓO(ÃSBUF 1POUJGJDJB6OJWFSTJEBE$BUÓMJDBEFM1FSÙ -JNB 1FSÙ .BSDP4BTTÖMJ 6OJWFSTJUZPG(FOFWB 4XJU[FSMBOE .JDIBFM/4DINJUU (FPSHF$.BSTIBMM&VSPQFBO$FOUFSGPS 4FDVSJUZ4UVEJFT (BSNJTDI1BSUFOLJSDIFO (FSNBOZ 5FSFODF5BZMPS *OUFSOBUJPOBM*OTUJUVUFGPS4USBUFHJD4UVEJFT -POEPO8BTIJOHUPO%$ 6,64" #BLIUJZBS35V[NVLIBNFEPW %JQMPNBUJD"DBEFNZ .PTDPX 3VTTJBO 'FEFSBUJPO 8FORJ;IV -BX4DIPPM 3FONJO6OJWFSTJUZPG$IJOB #FJKJOH 1FPQMFT3FQVCMJDPG$IJOB
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
1SPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFT BOETBGFHVBSET GPSJOUFSONFOU BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPOJOBSNFE DPOóJDUBOEPUIFS TJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF +FMFOB1FKJD +FMFOB 1FKJD JT -FHBM "EWJTPS BU UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PNNJUUFF PG UIF 3FE $SPTT BOE )FBE PG UIF *$3$ 1SPKFDU PO UIF 3FBîSNBUJPO BOE %FWFMPQNFOU PG *OUFSOBUJPOBM )VNBOJUBSJBO-BX
"CTUSBDU %FQSJWBUJPO PG MJCFSUZ GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT JT BO FYDFQUJPOBM NFBTVSF PG DPOUSPM UIBUNBZCFUBLFOJOBSNFEDPOGMJDU XIFUIFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM "ENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO PG QFSTPOT CFMJFWFE UP SFQSFTFOU B UISFBU UP 4UBUF TFDVSJUZJTBMTPCFJOHNPSFBOENPSFXJEFMZQSBDUJTFE PVUTJEF PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU TJUVBUJPOT5IJTQBQFSBSHVFTUIBUCPUIJOUFSONFOUBOEBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO BSF JOTVGGJDJFOUMZ FMBCPSBUFE GSPN UIF QPJOU PG UIF WJFX PG UIF QSPUFDUJPO PG UIF SJHIUTPGUIFQFSTPOTBGGFDUFE%SBXJOHPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXBOEPO IVNBOSJHIUTMBXBOETUBOEBSET UIFQBQFSQSPQPTFTBTFUPGQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFT BOE TBGFHVBSET UIBU TIPVME BT B NBUUFS PG MBX BOE QPMJDZ CF BQQMJFE BT B NJOJNVNUPBMMDBTFTPGEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZGPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOT *OUFSONFOUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTEFĐOFEBTUIFEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZPG BQFSTPOUIBUIBTCFFOJOJUJBUFEPSEFSFECZUIFFYFDVUJWFCSBODIOPUUIFKVEJDJ BSZXJUIPVUDSJNJOBMDIBSHFTCFJOHCSPVHIUBHBJOTUUIFJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWF
ĂFWJFXTFYQSFTTFEJOUIJTBSUJDMFSFēFDUUIFBVUIPSTPQJOJPOTBOEOPUOFDFTTBSJMZUIPTFPGUIF*$3$
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
EFUBJOFF*OUFSONFOUJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSFPGDPOUSPMUIBUNBZCFPSEFSFE GPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOTJOBSNFEDPOēJDU PSGPSUIFQVSQPTFPGQSPUFDUJOH4UBUFTFDV SJUZPSQVCMJDPSEFSJOOPODPOēJDUTJUVBUJPOTQSPWJEFEUIFSFRVJTJUFDSJUFSJBIBWF CFFONFUĂFQVSQPTFPGUIJTUFYUJTUPPVUMJOFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGF HVBSETUIBUHPWFSOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJOBSNFEDPOēJDUBOEJO PUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFBTBNBUUFSCPUIPGMBXBOEPGQPMJDZ *OUIFUFYU UIFUFSNTiJOUFSONFOUuBOEiBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOu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ć1VCMJTIFST (FOFWB i$PNNFOUBSZPO1SPUPDPM*SFMBUJWFUPJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOēJDUTu "SU
QBSB ĂF SFMFWBOU DSJUFSJB XIJDI BSF FYQMBJOFE JO HSFBUFS EFUBJM CFMPX BSF MBJE EPXO JO "SUJDMF PG UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PWFOBOUPO$JWJMBOE1PMJUJDBM3JHIUT *$$13 ĂFUFSNiPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFuSFGFSTUPTJUVBUJPOTCFMPXUIFUISFTIPMEPGBSNFEDPOēJDUBOEJODMVEFT TJUVBUJPOTPGiJOUFSOBMEJTUVSCBODFTPSUFOTJPOTuBTTQFDJĐFEJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM** ĂFUFSNiJOUFSONFOUuJTBMTPJOUFOEFEUPDPWFSUIFOPUJPOPGiBTTJHOFESFTJEFODF uUPXIJDIJEFOUJDBM QSPWJTJPOTPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOBQQMZ ĂJT TIPVME JO OP XBZ CF SFBE BT SFGFSSJOH UP PS MFHJUJNJ[JOH UIF QSBDUJDF PG IPTUBHFUBLJOH XIJDI JT TUSJDUMZ QSPIJCJUFE CZ JOUFSOBUJPOBM IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX ĂF *$3$T QPTJUJPO JT UIBU IPTUBHFT NVTU CF JNNFEJBUFMZBOEVODPOEJUJPOBMMZSFMFBTFE 'PS EJćFSFODFT JO UIF MFHBM SFHVMBUJPO PG JOUFSONFOU JO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOēJDUTBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFTFFTFDUJPO* i-FHBMTPVSDFT uCFMPX
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
-FHBMTPVSDFT 5IFMFHBMTPVSDFTPOXIJDIUIFQSFTFOUTUBOEBSETBSFCBTFEBSFUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB $POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF PG "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM * UP UIF (FOFWB $POWFOUJPOT XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFGMFDUDVTUPNBSZJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX "SUJDMFDPNNPO UPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT "EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM**UIFSFUP BOEDVTUPNBSZSVMFT PGJOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBX &WFOUIPVHIJOUFSONFOUJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTSFHVMBUFECZ UIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOBOE"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM* UIFTFUSFBUJFTEPOPU TVGGJDJFOUMZFMBCPSBUFPOUIFQSPDFEVSBMSJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT OPSEPUIFZTQFDJGZ UIFEFUBJMTPGUIFMFHBMGSBNFXPSLUIBUBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZNVTUJNQMFNFOU*O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTUIFSFJTFWFOMFTTDMBSJUZBTUPIPXBENJOJTUSB UJWFEFUFOUJPOJTUPCFPSHBOJ[FE"SUJDMFDPNNPOUPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT XIJDIJTBQQMJDBCMFBTBNJOJNVNTUBOEBSEUPBMMOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPO GMJDUT DPOUBJOTOPQSPWJTJPOTSFHVMBUJOHJOUFSONFOU JFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFO UJPO GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT BQBSU GSPN UIF SFRVJSFNFOU PG IVNBOF USFBUNFOU *OUFSONFOUJT IPXFWFS DMFBSMZBNFBTVSFUIBUDBOCFUBLFOJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOGMJDU BTFWJEFODFECZUIFMBOHVBHFPG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM** XIJDI NFOUJPOTJOUFSONFOUJO"SUJDMFTBOESFTQFDUJWFMZ CVUMJLFXJTFEPFTOPUHJWF EFUBJMTPGIPXJUJTUPCFPSHBOJ[FE#FBSJOHJONJOEUIFQSJODJQMFTPGIVNBOJUZ BOEUIFEJDUBUFTPGQVCMJDDPOTDJFODF UIF.BSUFOTDMBVTF
UIFQSJODJQMFTBOE SVMFTPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPONBZ JOQSBDUJDF TFSWFBTHVJEBODFJO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JO SFTPMWJOH TPNF PG UIF QSPDFEVSBM JTTVFT NFOUJPOFEJOUIJTUFYU *OBEEJUJPOUPIVNBOJUBSJBOMBX UIFQSFTFOUBOBMZTJTESBXTPOIVNBO SJHIUTMBX PGCPUIBCJOEJOHBOEBOPOCJOEJOHOBUVSF iTPGUMBXu
BTBDPN QMFNFOUBSZTPVSDFPGMBXJOTJUVBUJPOTPGBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSBTBOBVUPOPNPVT TPVSDF PG MBX PVUTJEF PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU 5IF DPNQMFNFOUBSZ SFMBUJPOTIJQ CFUXFFO IVNBOJUBSJBO BOE IVNBO SJHIUT MBX IBT NPTU SFDFOUMZ CFFO DPO GJSNFECZUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM$PVSUPG+VTUJDF UIF6/TQSJODJQBMMFHBMCPEZ*O B+VMZ"EWJTPSZ0QJOJPO UIF$PVSUTUBUFEUIBUIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBO SJHIUTMBXBSFCZOPNFBOTNVUVBMMZFYDMVTJWF"DDPSEJOHUPUIF$PVSU TPNF SJHIUT BSF QSPUFDUFE POMZ CZ IVNBO SJHIUT MBX TPNF BSF QSPUFDUFE POMZ CZ IVNBOJUBSJBOMBX BOEiZFUPUIFSTNBZCFNBUUFSTPGCPUIUIFTFCSBODIFTPG JOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXu 5IF SJHIUT PG QFSTPOT JOUFSOFE GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT JO BSNFE DPO GMJDUXIFUIFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMNBZCFTBJEUPGBMMJOUP UIFDBUFHPSZPGSJHIUTUIBU JOUIF*$+TXPSEJOH BSFiNBUUFSTuPGCPUICSBODIFT ($*7 "SUTBOE "1* "SU ĂF.BSUFOTDMBVTFJT JOUFSBMJB JODMVEFEJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM*XIJDISFBETi*ODBTFT OPU DPWFSFE CZ UIJT 1SPUPDPM PS CZ PUIFS JOUFSOBUJPOBM JOTUSVNFOUT DJWJMJBOT BOE DPNCBUBOUT SFNBJO VOEFSUIFQSPUFDUJPOBOEBVUIPSJUZPGUIFQSJODJQMFTPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXEFSJWFEGSPNFTUBCMJTIFEDVTUPN GSPNUIFQSJODJQMFTPGIVNBOJUZBOEGSPNUIFEJDUBUFTPGQVCMJDDPOTDJFODFu *$+ "EWJTPSZ 0QJOJPO PO UIF -FHBM $POTFRVFODFT PG UIF $POTUSVDUJPO PG B 8BMM JO UIF 0DDVQJFE 1BMFTUJOJBO5FSSJUPSZ +VMZ QBSB
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
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iĂFQSPWJTJPOTPGUIJT 4FDUJPO
QBSBTm "1* "SU 4FF"SUJDMFDPNNPOUPUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT XIJDIBMTP TQFDJĐFTUIBUUIFDPODMVTJPOPGBTQFDJBM BHSFFNFOUiTIBMMOPUBćFDUUIFMFHBMTUBUVTPG1BSUJFTUPUIFDPOēJDUu4QFDJBMBHSFFNFOUTDBOCFFćFDUJWF QBSUJDVMBSMZJOIJHIJOUFOTJUZOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUTXIJDISFTFNCMFJOUFS4UBUFBSNFEDPOēJDU
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
FTUBCMJTIFT UIF MJOL CFUXFFO UIF 1SPUPDPM BOE IVNBO SJHIUT MBXCZ TUBUJOH UIBU iJOUFSOBUJPOBMJOTUSVNFOUTSFMBUJOHUPIVNBOSJHIUTPćFSBCBTJDQSPUFDUJPOUPUIF IVNBO QFSTPOu ĂF $PNNFOUBSZ PO UIBU 1SPUPDPM TQFDJĐFT UIBU UIF SFGFSFODF UP JOUFSOBUJPOBM JOTUSVNFOUT JODMVEFT USFBUJFT BEPQUFE CZ UIF 6/ TVDI BT UIF *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PWFOBOUPO$JWJMBOE1PMJUJDBM3JHIUT *$$13 BOEUIF$POWFOUJPO BHBJOTU5PSUVSF BTXFMMBTUIFSFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFT ĂFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPO XIJDIJTUIFQSJNBSZGPDVTPGUIJTUFYU JT JOUFSBMJBQSPWJEFEGPSJO"SUJDMF PGUIF*$$13"4UBUF1BSUZNBZEFSPHBUF GSPN TVTQFOE JUTPCMJHBUJPOTVOEFSUIBUUSFBUZVOEFSWFSZTUSJDUDPOEJUJPOT POF PGXIJDIJTUIFFYJTUFODFPGBQVCMJDFNFSHFODZUISFBUFOJOHUIFMJGFPGUIFOBUJPO /POJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUJTBOFYBNQMFPGBQVCMJDFNFSHFODZJOXIJDI NFBTVSFTPGEFSPHBUJPOOFDFTTBSZGPSFOBCMJOHJOUFSONFOUXPVMECFMBXGVM VOEFS UIF $PWFOBOU QSPWJEFE UIF PUIFS SFRVJTJUF DPOEJUJPOT IBWF CFFO NFU *OOPODPOēJDUTJUVBUJPOT4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIF*$$13NVTUMJLFXJTFDPNQMZXJUI UIF EFSPHBUJPO DMBVTFT PG UIF $PWFOBOU JO PSEFS UP JOTUJUVUF NFBTVSFT BćFDUJOH UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ PG QFSTPO TVDI BT BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO 5IF QSFTFOU BOBMZTJTJTCBTFEPOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUJOUFSONFOUJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFE DPOēJDU BOE BENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JNQMFNFOUFE JO OPODPOēJDU TJUVBUJPOT DPNQMZXJUIUIFEFSPHBUJPODSJUFSJBTQFDJĐFEJOUIF*$$13 )PXFWFS FWFO JO FNFSHFODZ TJUVBUJPOT UIF TPDBMMFE iIBSE DPSFu PG IVNBO SJHIUT XIJDI JODMVEFT UIF SJHIU UP MJGF BOE UIF QSPIJCJUJPO PG UPSUVSF BOE PUIFS DSVFM JOIVNBO PS EFHSBEJOH USFBUNFOU PS QVOJTINFOU DBOOPU CF EFSPHBUFEGSPNVOEFSBOZDJSDVNTUBODFT5IFKVSJTQSVEFODFPGJOUFSOBUJPOBM BOESFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTCPEJFTIBTEFUFSNJOFEXIJDIPUIFSIVNBOSJHIUT BQBSUGSPNUIPTFFYQSFTTMZMJTUFEJOUIFUSFBUJFT TIPVMEBMTPCFDPOTJEFSFEOPO EFSPHBCMF"NPOHUIFNJTUIFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZUPDIBMMFOHF UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO IBCFBTDPSQVT
XIJDIJTBOFTTFOUJBMFMF NFOUPGUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPO )VNBOSJHIUTTPGUMBXJOTUSVNFOUTBOEKVSJTQSVEFODFQSPWJEFGVSUIFS TUBOEBSETUIBU JUJTTVCNJUUFE TIPVMEBTBNBUUFSPGQPMJDZBOEHPPEQSBDUJDFCF BQQMJFEXJUISFTQFDUUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO i$PNNFOUBSZPO1**u PQDJU OPUF
QBSBTm ĂFGVMMUFYUPG"SUJDMFPGUIF*$$13SFBETi*OUJNFPGQVCMJDFNFSHFODZXIJDIUISFBUFOTUIFMJGFPG UIFOBUJPOBOEUIFFYJTUFODFPGXIJDIJTPĊDJBMMZQSPDMBJNFE UIF4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOU NBZUBLFNFBTVSFTEFSPHBUJOHGSPNUIFJSPCMJHBUJPOTVOEFSUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOUUPUIFFYUFOUTUSJDUMZ SFRVJSFECZUIFFYJHFODJFTPGUIFTJUVBUJPO QSPWJEFEUIBUTVDINFBTVSFTBSFOPUJODPOTJTUFOUXJUIUIFJS PUIFSPCMJHBUJPOTVOEFSJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXBOEEPOPUJOWPMWFEJTDSJNJOBUJPOTPMFMZPOUIFHSPVOEPGSBDF DPMPVS TFY MBOHVBHF SFMJHJPOPSTPDJBMPSJHJO/PEFSPHBUJPOGSPNBSUJDMFT QBSBTBOE
BOENBZCFNBEFVOEFSUIJTQSPWJTJPO"OZ4UBUF1BSUZUPUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOUBWBJMJOH JUTFMGPGUIFSJHIUPGEFSPHBUJPOTIBMMJNNFEJBUFMZJOGPSNUIFPUIFS4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIFQSFTFOU$PWFOBOU UISPVHIUIFJOUFSNFEJBSZPGUIF4FDSFUBSZ(FOFSBMPGUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT PGUIFQSPWJTJPOTGSPNXIJDI JUIBTEFSPHBUFEBOEPGUIFSFBTPOTCZXIJDIJUXBTBDUVBUFE"GVSUIFSDPNNVOJDBUJPOTIBMMCFNBEF UISPVHIUIFTBNFJOUFSNFEJBSZ POUIFEBUFPOXIJDIJUUFSNJOBUFTTVDIEFSPHBUJPOu *ODBTFTXIFSFB4UBUFJTOPUBQBSUZUPUIF*$$13PSTJNJMBSSFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFT JUJTTVCNJUUFE UIBUUIFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETMJTUFECFMPXTIPVMECFGPMMPXFEBTBNBUUFSPGQPMJDZ *$$13 "SU *$$13 "SU
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
5IFDPNNFOUBSZUPUIFQSPDFEVSBMQSJODJQMFTBOETBGFHVBSETPVUMJOFE JOUIJTUFYUNFOUJPOTUIFEJGGFSFOUMFHBMTPVSDFTHPWFSOJOHEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ GPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOTJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFE DPOGMJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF*UJTQSFDJTFMZUIFTJNJMBSJUZJODPOUFOU PGUIFWBSJPVTMFHBMTPVSDFTSFWJFXFEUIBUHVJEFEUIFTQFDJGJDGPSNVMBUJPOPGUIF QSPDFEVSBM QSJODJQMFT BOE TBGFHVBSET MJTUFE BOE XIJDI BMMPXT UIF DPODMVTJPO UIBUUIFZDBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBNJOJNVNBQQMJDBCMFJOBMMDBTFTPGEFQSJWBUJPOPG MJCFSUZGPSTFDVSJUZSFBTPOT
(FOFSBMQSJODJQMFTBQQMJDBCMFUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO *OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSF ĂF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO NBLFT JU FYQMJDJUMZ DMFBS UIBU JOUFSONFOU BOE BTTJHOFE SFTJEFODF BSF UIF NPTU TFWFSF NFBTVSFT PG DPOUSPM UIBU B EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZPS0DDVQZJOH1PXFSNBZUBLFXJUISFTQFDUUPQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOTBHBJOTU XIPNOPDSJNJOBMQSPDFFEJOHTIBWFCFFOJOJUJBUFE*OCPUIDBTFTJUJTTUJQVMBUFE UIBUSFDPVSTFUPUIFTFNFBTVSFTNBZCFIBEPOMZJGUIFTFDVSJUZPGUIF4UBUFNBLFT JUiBCTPMVUFMZOFDFTTBSZu ($*7 "SUJDMF PSGPSiJNQFSBUJWFSFBTPOTPGTFDV SJUZu ($*7 "SUJDMF ĂFFYDFQUJPOBMOBUVSFPGJOUFSONFOUMJFTJOUIFGBDUUIBU JUBMMPXTUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZUPEFQSJWFQFSTPOTPGMJCFSUZXIPBSFOPUTVCKFDU UPDSJNJOBMQSPDFTT CVUBSFOFWFSUIFMFTTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFQSFTFOUBSFBMUISFBUUPJUT TFDVSJUZJOUIFQSFTFOUPSJOUIFGVUVSF"TUIF$PNNFOUBSZPOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB $POWFOUJPOFYQMBJOT i*UEJEOPUTFFNQPTTJCMFUPEFĐOFUIFFYQSFTTJPOATFDVSJUZ PGUIF4UBUFJOBNPSFDPODSFUFGBTIJPO*UJTUIVTMFĔWFSZMBSHFMZUP(PWFSONFOUT UPEFDJEFUIFNFBTVSFPGBDUJWJUZQSFKVEJDJBMUPUIFJOUFSOBMPSFYUFSOBMTFDVSJUZ PGUIF4UBUFXIJDIKVTUJĐFTJOUFSONFOUPSBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFu8IJMFUIJTNBZCF UIFDBTFJUJTDMFBS GPSFYBNQMF UIBUJOUFSONFOUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOGPS UIFTPMFQVSQPTFPGJOUFMMJHFODFHBUIFSJOH XJUIPVUUIFQFSTPOJOWPMWFEPUIFSXJTF QSFTFOUJOHBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ DBOOPUCFKVTUJĐFE ĂBUJOUFSONFOUJTBOFYDFQUJPOBMNFBTVSFJTBMTPUSVFJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOēJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF CBTFEPOUIFHFOFSBMQSJODJQMF UIBUQFSTPOBMMJCFSUZJTUIFSVMF BOEPOUIFBTTVNQUJPOUIBUUIFDSJNJOBMKVTUJDF TZTUFN JT BCMF UP EFBM XJUI QFSTPOT TVTQFDUFE PG SFQSFTFOUJOH B EBOHFS UP 4UBUF TFDVSJUZ *UTIPVMEBHBJOCFOPUFEUIBUUIJTUFYUEPFTOPUEFBMXJUIUIFJOUFSONFOUPGQSJTPOFSTPGXBSJOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFEDPOēJDUT XIJDIJTHPWFSOFECZUIFĂJSE(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO"TBMSFBEZNFOUJPOFE JUJTBTTVNFE UIBUUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPOIBTCFFOEFSPHBUFEGSPNJOLFFQJOHXJUI"SUJDMFPGUIF*$$13 4FF$PNNFOUBSZPOUIF(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOTPG"VHVTU 7PM7 (FOFWB$POWFOUJPOSFMBUJWFUPUIF 1SPUFDUJPOPG$JWJMJBO1FSTPOTJO5JNFPG8BS "SU Q4FFBMTPUIF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMF BU QBHF XIJDISFJUFSBUFTUIBUi*OBOZDBTFTVDINFBTVSFTDBOPOMZCFPSEFSFEGPSSFBMBOEJNQFSBUJWF SFBTPOTPGTFDVSJUZ UIFJSFYDFQUJPOBMDIBSBDUFSNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEu 4JNJMBSMZ JOUFSOJOHPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOJOHQFSTPOTGPSUIFQVSQPTFPGVTJOHUIFNBTiCBSHBJOJOH DIJQTuJTBMTPOPUKVTUJĐBCMFBTBSFBTPOGPSJOUFSONFOU4VDIEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZXPVMEJOGBDUBNPVOU UPIPTUBHFUBLJOH XIJDIJTQSPIJCJUFE
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTOPUBOBMUFSOBUJWFUPDSJNJOBM QSPDFFEJOHT *OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTBNFBTVSFPGDPOUSPMBJNFEBUEFBMJOH XJUIQFSTPOTXIPQPTFBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ DVSSFOUMZPSJOUIFGVUVSF JO TJUVBUJPOT PG BSNFE DPOGMJDU PS UP 4UBUF TFDVSJUZ PS QVCMJD PSEFS JO OPODPOGMJDU TJUVBUJPOT JU JT OPU B NFBTVSF UIBU JT NFBOU UP SFQMBDF DSJNJOBM QSPDFFEJOHT " QFSTPO XIP JT TVTQFDUFE PG IBWJOH DPNNJUUFE B DSJNJOBM PGGFODF XIFUIFSJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF IBTUIFSJHIU UP CFOFGJU GSPN UIF BEEJUJPOBM TUSJOHFOU KVEJDJBM HVBSBOUFFT QSPWJEFE GPS JO IVNBOJUBSJBOBOEPSIVNBOSJHIUTMBXGPSDSJNJOBMTVTQFDUT XIJDIJODMVEFUIF SJHIU UP CF USJFE CZ B SFHVMBSMZ DPOTUJUVUFE JOEFQFOEFOU BOE JNQBSUJBM DPVSU 6OMFTTJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOBOEQFOBMSFQSFTTJPOBSFPSHBOJ[FE BTTUSJDUMZTFQBSBUFSFHJNFTUIFSFJTBEBOHFSUIBUJOUFSONFOUNJHIUCFVTFEBT BTVCTUBOEBSETZTUFNPGQFOBMSFQSFTTJPOJOUIFIBOETPGUIFFYFDVUJWFQPXFS CZQBTTJOHUIFPOFTBODUJPOFECZBDPVOUSZTMFHJTMBUVSFBOEDPVSUT5IFSJHIUTPG DSJNJOBMTVTQFDUTXPVMEUIVTCFHSBWFMZVOEFSNJOFE
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPODBOPOMZCFPSEFSFEPOBOJOEJWJEVBM DBTFCZDBTFCBTJT XJUIPVUEJTDSJNJOBUJPOPGBOZLJOE "DJWJMJBODBOCFJOUFSOFEJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUPOMZPOUIFCBTJTPGBO JOEJWJEVBMEFDJTJPOUBLFOJOFWFSZTQFDJGJDDBTF5IFOPUJPOUIBUJOUFSONFOUDBO OPUCFBDPMMFDUJWFNFBTVSFJTFTUBCMJTIFEVOEFSUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO JOTJUVBUJPOTPGPDDVQBUJPO&OCMPDJOUFSONFOUPGFOFNZOBUJPOBMTJOB4UBUFT PXOUFSSJUPSZJTBMTPQSPIJCJUFE BTJUXPVMEBNPVOUUP BOEWJPMBUFUIFHFOFSBM QSPIJCJUJPOPG iDPMMFDUJWFQVOJTINFOUTuVOEFS"SUJDMF E PG"EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM*5IJTEPFTOPUNFBOUIBUBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZDBOOPUJOUFSOBMBSHF OVNCFS PG QFSTPOT CVU UIBU CPUI UIF JOJUJBM EFDJTJPO PO JOUFSONFOU BOE BOZ TVCTFRVFOUEFDJTJPOUPNBJOUBJOJU JODMVEJOHUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU NVTU CFUBLFOXJUISFTQFDUUPFBDIJOEJWJEVBMJOWPMWFE *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JO XIJDI DPMMFDUJWF QVOJTI NFOUTBSFBMTPQSPIJCJUFEBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF CPUIUIFJOJUJBM
ĂFBSHVNFOUUIBUBENJOJTUSBUJWFBOEDSJNJOBMEFUFOUJPOBSFUXPEJTUJODUSFHJNFTJTBUĐSTUHMBODF VOEFSNJOFECZ"SUJDMFPGUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOXIJDIEFBMTXJUIQFUUZPćFODFTDPNNJUUFE CZQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOTJOPDDVQJFEUFSSJUPSZĂF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMF IPXFWFS SFDUJĐFTBOZQPTTJCMF QFSDFQUJPOPGPWFSMBQCFUXFFOUIFSFHJNFTPGBENJOJTUSBUJWFBOEDSJNJOBMEFUFOUJPOUIBUUIFXPSEJOH PG UIF QSPWJTJPO TVHHFTUT *U SFBET i*OUFSONFOU JT B QSFWFOUJWF BENJOJTUSBUJWF NFBTVSF BOE DBOOPU CF DPOTJEFSFE B QFOBM TBODUJPO *U JT OFWFSUIFMFTT NFOUJPOFE IFSF VOEFS UIF TBNF IFBE<JOH> BT TJNQMF JNQSJTPONFOU CFDBVTFUIFBVUIPSTPGUIF$POWFOUJPOXJTIFEUPNBLFJUQPTTJCMFGPSUIFNJMJUBSZDPVSUT PGUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSUPHJWFQFSTPOTHVJMUZPGNJOPSPćFODFTUIFCFOFĐUPGDPOEJUJPOTPGJOUFSONFOU FNQIBTJTBEEFE QSPWJEFEGPSJO"SUJDMFFUTFRĂFQSPWJTJPOXBTBIVNBOFPOFBOEXBTJOUFOEFE UPESBXBEJTUJODUJPOCFUXFFOTVDIPćFOEFSTBOEDPNNPODSJNJOBMTu$PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
QQm *CJE "SU Q "1** "SU C
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
EFDJTJPOPOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOBOEBOZTVCTFRVFOUEFDJTJPO UPNBJOUBJOJUNVTUCFUBLFOPOBOJOEJWJEVBMCBTJT&WFOUIPVHIIVNBOJUBSJBO MBXHPWFSOJOHOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTTJMFOUBTUPUIFQSPDFEVSBM SJHIUTPGJOUFSOFFT VOEFSIVNBOSJHIUTMBXBOZNFBTVSFEFSPHBUJOHGSPNUIF SJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPONVTUCFiTUSJDUMZSFRVJSFECZUIFFYJHFODJFTPGUIFTJUV BUJPOuPGQVCMJDFNFSHFODZOFDFTTJUBUJOHUIFEFSPHBUJPO JUNBZCFUBLFOPOMZ UPUIFFYUFOUSFRVJSFEUIFSFCZ BOENVTUUIVTCFJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIFQSJODJ QMFPGQSPQPSUJPOBMJUZ " 4UBUFT FO CMPD OPOJOEJWJEVBM EFUFOUJPO PG B XIPMF DBUFHPSZ PG QFSTPOT DPVME JO OP XBZ CF DPOTJEFSFE B QSPQPSUJPOBM SFTQPOTF SFHBSEMFTT PG XIBU UIF DJSDVNTUBODFTPGUIFFNFSHFODZDPODFSOFENJHIUCFĂFJEFBPGDPMMFDUJWFNFBTVSFT PGBOZLJOEJTBOUJUIFUJDBMUPUIFSVMFT TQJSJUBOEQVSQPTFPGIVNBOSJHIUTMBX %FDJTJPOT PO JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO NVTU BMTP OPU CF UBLFOPOBEJTDSJNJOBUPSZCBTJT5IFQSJODJQMFPGOPOEJTDSJNJOBUJPOJTBCBTJD UFOFUPGCPUIIVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOT GPSJUDFBTFUPFYJTU 0OFPGUIFNPTUJNQPSUBOUQSJODJQMFTHPWFSOJOHJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFO UJPOJTUIBUUIJTGPSNPGEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZNVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFJOEJWJEVBM DFBTFTUPQPTFBSFBMUISFBUUP4UBUFTFDVSJUZ NFBOJOHUIBUEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZ POTVDIHSPVOETDBOOPUCFJOEFĐOJUF*OWJFXPGUIFSBQJEQSPHSFTTJPOPGFWFOUTJO BSNFEDPOēJDU BQFSTPODPOTJEFSFEUPCFBUISFBUUPEBZNJHIUOPUQPTFUIFTBNF UISFBUBĔFSBDIBOHFPGDJSDVNTUBODFTPOUIFHSPVOE*OPUIFSXPSET UIFMPOHFS JOUFSONFOUMBTUT UIFHSFBUFSUIFPOVTPOBEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZUPQSPWFUIBUUIF SFBTPOTGPSJUSFNBJOWBMJEĂFSBUJPOBMFPGUIFQSJODJQMFJTUIVTUPGBDJMJUBUFUIF SFMFBTFPGBQFSTPOBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOTKVTUJGZJOHUIFDVSUBJMNFOUPGMJCFSUZOP MPOHFSFYJTUĂFQSJODJQMFUIBUJOUFSONFOUNVTUDFBTFBTTPPOBTUIFSFBTPOTGPS JUDFBTFUPFYJTUJTDMFBSMZFOVODJBUFEJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF BOEJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM* XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEUPSFēFDU DVTUPNBSZJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUT *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT BOE PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF UIJTQSJODJQMFNVTU JGBOZUIJOH CFFWFONPSFTUSJOHFOUMZPCTFSWFE QBSUJDVMBSMZ BT IVNBO SJHIUT KVSJTQSVEFODF SFKFDUT UIF OPUJPO PG JOEFGJOJUF EFUFOUJPO *O PSEFSUPFOTVSFUIBUBEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZJTOPUBSCJUSBSZ XIJDIXPVMECFUIF DBTFJGUIFSFBTPOTGPSJUEPOPUPSOPMPOHFSFYJTU UIF*$$13 "SUJDMF
QSP *$$13 "SU 4FFFH3FQPSUPGUIF8PSLJOH(SPVQPO"SCJUSBSZ%FUFOUJPO 6/%PD&$/ %FDFNCFS QBSB iJOOPFWFOUNBZBOBSSFTUCBTFEPOFNFSHFODZMFHJTMBUJPOMBTUJOEFĐOJUFMZu
BOE*OUFS "NFSJDBO$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUT"OOVBM3FQPSU 0"4%PD0&"4FS-7** %PD DPSSPG+VOF 4FDUJPO** 1BSU* iUIFEFDMBSBUJPOPGBTUBUFPGFNFSHFODZPSBTUBUFPGTJFHFDBOOPU TFSWFBTBQSFUFYUGPSUIFJOEFĐOJUFEFUFOUJPOPGJOEJWJEVBMT XJUIPVUBOZDIBSHFXIBUFWFS*UJTPCWJPVT UIBUXIFOUIFTFTFDVSJUZNFBTVSFTBSFFYUFOEFECFZPOEBSFBTPOBCMFUJNFUIFZCFDPNFUSVFBOETFSJPVT WJPMBUJPOTPGUIFSJHIUUPGSFFEPNu
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
WJEFTUIBUBOZPOFEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZIBTUIFSJHIUUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPG IJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPOĐMFBQFUJUJPOGPSIBCFBTDPSQVTPSUIFFRVJWBMFOUJOPSEFS UIBUBDPVSUNBZEFDJEFiXJUIPVUEFMBZuXIFUIFSIFPSTIFJTCFJOHIFMEMBXGVMMZ PSOPU8IJMFUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZJTOPUBNPOHUIFOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUTMJTUFE JOUIF*$$13 UIFKVSJTQSVEFODFPGCPUIVOJWFSTBMBOESFHJPOBMIVNBOSJHIUT CPEJFTIBTDPOGJSNFEUIBUUIFSJHIUUPIBCFBTDPSQVTNVTUJOGBDUCFDPOTJEFSFE OPOEFSPHBCMF
*OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUDPOGPSNUPUIFQSJODJQMF PGMFHBMJUZ *OUIFDPOUFYUPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO UIFQSJODJQMFPGMFHBMJUZ NFBOT UIBU B QFSTPO NBZ CF EFQSJWFE PG MJCFSUZ POMZ GPS SFBTPOT TVCTUBOUJWF BTQFDU BOE JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI QSPDFEVSFT QSPDFEVSBM BTQFDU UIBU BSF QSP WJEFEGPSCZEPNFTUJDBOEJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX ĂF (FOFWB $POWFOUJPOT BOE UIFJS "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPMT BT XFMM BT IVNBOSJHIUTMBX QSPWJEFUIFJOUFSOBUJPOBMMFHBMTUBOEBSETUIBUBSFUPCFBQQMJFE UP JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JO BSNFE DPOēJDU BOE PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PGWJPMFODF*OUFSNTPGSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU UIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPOTQFDJĐFT UIBUBQSPUFDUFEQFSTPONBZCFJOUFSOFEPSQMBDFEJOBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFPOMZJG iUIFTFDVSJUZPGUIF%FUBJOJOH1PXFSNBLFTJUBCTPMVUFMZOFDFTTBSZu "SUJDMF PS JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ GPS iJNQFSBUJWF SFBTPOT PG TFDVSJUZu "SUJDMF *O BEEJUJPOUPTQFDJGZJOHUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOU UIF'PVSUI$POWFOUJPOMBZT EPXO DFSUBJO QSPDFEVSFT UIBU NVTU CF GPMMPXFE GPS JOUFSONFOU UP CF MBXGVM CPUI JO UIF UFSSJUPSZ PG B QBSUZ UP DPOGMJDU BOE JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ *O UIF MBUUFS DBTF GPS FYBNQMF "SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI $POWFOUJPO TUJQVMBUFT UIBU EFDJTJPOTSFHBSEJOHBTTJHOFESFTJEFODFPSJOUFSONFOUiTIBMMCFNBEFBDDPSEJOH UPBSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFUPCFQSFTDSJCFECZUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSJOBDDPSEBODF XJUI UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF QSFTFOU $POWFOUJPOu %FQSJWBUJPO PG MJCFSUZ UIBU JT OPUJODPOGPSNJUZXJUIUIFWBSJPVTSVMFTQSPWJEFEGPSJOUIF$POWFOUJPONBZ DPOTUJUVUFiVOMBXGVMDPOGJOFNFOUu )VNBOSJHIUTTUBOEBSETBQQMJDBCMFJOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT BOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFQSPWJEFFWFONPSFEFUBJMFEQSPWJTJPOTBJNFEBU FOTVSJOHSFTQFDUGPSUIFQSJODJQMFPGMFHBMJUZ6OEFSUIF*$$13 "SUJDMF
GPS FYBNQMF QFSTPOTNBZOPUCFEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZiFYDFQUPOTVDIHSPVOET BOEJOBDDPSEBODFXJUITVDIQSPDFEVSFBTBSFFTUBCMJTIFECZMBXu8IFSFB4UBUF EFDJEFT UP EFSPHBUF GSPN UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ TVDI B EFDJTJPO NVTU JOUFS BMJB CF PGGJDJBMMZ QSPDMBJNFE TP BT UP FOBCMF UIF BGGFDUFE QPQVMBUJPO UP LOPX UIF FYBDUNBUFSJBM UFSSJUPSJBMBOEUFNQPSBMTDPQFPGBQQMJDBUJPOPGUIBUFNFSHFODZ NFBTVSF
*$$13 "SU ($*7 "SU *$$13 "SU
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
1SPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSET 3JHIUUPJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUUIFSFBTPOTGPSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO "OZQFSTPOJOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFENVTUCFJOGPSNFEQSPNQUMZ JO B MBOHVBHF IF PS TIF VOEFSTUBOET PG UIF SFBTPOT XIZ UIBU NFBTVSF IBT CFFO UBLFOTPBTUPFOBCMFUIFQFSTPODPODFSOFEUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPS IFSEFUFOUJPO5IFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOUPLOPXXIZIFPSTIFIBTCFFOEFQSJWFE PGMJCFSUZNBZCFTBJEUPDPOTUJUVUFBOFMFNFOUPGUIFPCMJHBUJPOPGIVNBOUSFBU NFOU BT B QFSTPOT VODFSUBJOUZ BCPVU UIF SFBTPOT GPS IJT PS IFS EFUFOUJPO JT LOPXOJOQSBDUJDFUPDPOTUJUVUFBTPVSDFPGBDVUFQTZDIPMPHJDBMTUSFTT /FJUIFS UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO OPS IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX BQQMJ DBCMF JO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT DPOUBJO FYQMJDJU QSPWJTJPOT PO UIF EVUZ UP QSPWJEF JOGPSNBUJPO BCPVU UIF SFBTPOT GPS XIJDI B QFSTPO IBT CFFO EFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZ5IFGPSFHPJOHQSPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSEJT IPXFWFS POFPGUIF i'VOEBNFOUBM(VBSBOUFFTuMBJEEPXOJO"SUJDMF PG"EEJUJPOBM1SPUPDPM* *UJTNPSFPWFSQSPWJEFEGPSJONPTUPGUIFSFMFWBOUIVNBOSJHIUTUSFBUJFTBOEJT TQFMUPVUJOTPGUMBXJOTUSVNFOUTBTXFMM 5IFJOGPSNBUJPOHJWFONVTUBMTPCFTVGGJDJFOUMZEFUBJMFEGPSUIFEFUBJOFE QFSTPOUPUBLFJNNFEJBUFTUFQTUPDIBMMFOHF BOESFRVFTUBEFDJTJPO POUIFMBX GVMOFTT PG UIF JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO TFF CFMPX *OGPSNBUJPO PO UIF SFBTPOT GPS JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO NVTU CF DPOWFZFE QSPNQUMZ TP BT UP FOBCMF UIF QFSTPO JO RVFTUJPO UP BMTP QSPNQUMZ SFRVFTU B EFDJTJPO PO UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG EFUFOUJPO BOE NVTU CF DPOWFZFE JO B MBOHVBHF IFPSTIFVOEFSTUBOET8IFSFBOJOJUJBMEFDJTJPOPOEFUFOUJPOJTNBJOUBJOFEPO SFWJFX UIFSFBTPOTGPSDPOUJOVFEEFUFOUJPONVTUCFQSPWJEFEBTXFMM
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ĔFSi#PEZPG1SJODJQMFTu "1* "SU
#PEZPG1SJODJQMFT 1SJODJQMF ($*7 "SUTBOE
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
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
'PSFJHOOBUJPOBMTJOJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO 5IF OBUJPOBM BVUIPSJUJFT PG B QFSTPO JOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZ EFUBJOFE NVTU CF JOGPSNFE UIFSFPG VOMFTT B XJTI UP UIF DPOUSBSZ IBT CFFO FYQSFTTFE CZ UIF QFSTPODPODFSOFE5IFSFMFWBOUEJQMPNBUJDPSDPOTVMBSBVUIPSJUJFTQSPWJEFE EJQMPNBUJDPSDPOTVMBSSFMBUJPOTFYJTUNVTUCFBMMPXFEUPDPNNVOJDBUFXJUI BOEWJTJUUIFJSOBUJPOBMT5IJTJTBSVMFPGQVCMJDJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXUIBUSFNBJOT BQQMJDBCMFJOBSNFEDPOGMJDUTBOEPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODF
"QFSTPOTVCKFDUUPJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOIBTUIFSJHIUUP DIBMMFOHF XJUIUIFMFBTUQPTTJCMFEFMBZ UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO 8JUISFHBSEUPJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO JO "SUJDMFBQQMJDBCMFUPUIFJOUFSONFOUPGQFSTPOTJOUIFUFSSJUPSZPGBQBSUZUP UIFDPOGMJDU TUJQVMBUFTUIBUBOZQSPUFDUFEQFSTPOJOUFSOFEPSQMBDFEJOBTTJHOFE SFTJEFODFJTiFOUJUMFEUPIBWFTVDIBDUJPOSFDPOTJEFSFEBTTPPOBTQPTTJCMFCZBO BQQSPQSJBUFDPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEEFTJHOBUFECZUIF%FUBJOJOH1PXFS GPS UIBU QVSQPTFu 6OEFS "SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI $POWFOUJPO BQQMJDBCMF UP UIF JOUFSONFOU PG QFSTPOT JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ EFDJTJPOT SFHBSEJOH BTTJHOFE SFTJEFODFPSJOUFSONFOUiTIBMMCFNBEFBDDPSEJOHUPBSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFUPCF QSFTDSJCFE CZ UIF 0DDVQZJOH 1PXFS JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI UIF QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF QSFTFOU $POWFOUJPO 5IJT QSPDFEVSF TIBMM JODMVEF UIF SJHIU PG BQQFBM GPS UIF QBSUJFTDPODFSOFE"QQFBMTTIBMMCFEFDJEFEXJUIUIFMFBTUQPTTJCMFEFMBZu
*CJE "SU *CJE "SU *CJE "SUT BOE #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMFTBOE 4FF BMTP 6/ %FDMBSBUJPO PO UIF 1SPUFDUJPO PG "MM 1FSTPOT GSPN &OGPSDFE %JTBQQFBSBODF "SU
BOE 1SJODJQMFT PO UIF &ćFDUJWF 1SFWFOUJPO BOE *OWFTUJHBUJPO PG &YUSBMFHBM "SCJUSBSZ BOE 4VNNBSZ &YFDVUJPOT SFDPNNFOEFECZ6/&DPOPNJDBOE4PDJBM$PVODJM 1SJODJQMF 4FF"SUPGUIF7JFOOB$POWFOUJPOPO$POTVMBS3FMBUJPOT*OJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUT UIFPĊDJBM *OGPSNBUJPO#VSFBVYBOEUIF$FOUSBM5SBDJOH"HFODZBSFNFDIBOJTNTUISPVHIXIJDIUIFBEWFSTFQBSUZJT JOGPSNFEPGUIFJOUFSONFOUPGJUTOBUJPOBMT ($*7 "SUTm *OOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOēJDUT UIF*$3$JTBMTPBWBJMBCMFUPGBDJMJUBUFDPOUBDUCFUXFFOBQFSTPOEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZBOEUIF4UBUFPGXIJDI IFPSTIFJTBOBUJPOBM QSPWJEFEUIBUQFSTPODPOTFOUTUPTVDIOPUJĐDBUJPO
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
8IJMF UIF $POWFOUJPO EPFT OPU TQFDJGJDBMMZ TQFBL PG UIFTF BDUJPOT BT DIBMMFOHFTUPUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPO UIBUJTXIBUUIFZFTTFOUJBMMZBSF5IF QVSQPTF PG UIF iSFDPOTJEFSBUJPOu PS iBQQFBMu JT UP FOBCMF UIF DPNQFUFOU CPEZ UPEFUFSNJOFXIFUIFSUIFQFSTPOXBTEFQSJWFEPGMJCFSUZGPSWBMJESFBTPOTBOE UPPSEFSIJTPSIFSSFMFBTFJGUIBUXBTOPUUIFDBTF5IFBVUIPSJUZUIBUJOJUJBMMZ EFQSJWFEBQFSTPOPGMJCFSUZBOEUIFCPEZBVUIPSJ[FEUPDPOEVDUUIFSFWJFXPO BQQFBMNVTUOPUCFUIFTBNFJGUIFSJHIUPGQFUJUJPOJTUPCFFGGFDUJWF5IFDIBS BDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFMBUUFSCPEZBOEUIFFYJTUFODFPGPUIFSQSPDFEVSBMTBGFHVBSET NFOUJPOFECFMPX BSFUIFDSVDJBMGBDUPS 5IFSJHIUPGBQFSTPOUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSEFUFOUJPO JOOPOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTBOEJOPUIFSTJUVBUJPOTPGWJPMFODFJTBLFZ DPNQPOFOUPGUIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZPGQFSTPOVOEFSIVNBOSJHIUTMBX&WFOUIPVHI UIFSJHIUUPMJCFSUZNBZCFEFSPHBUFEGSPNJOTJUVBUJPOTPGFNFSHFODZ IVNBO SJHIUT TPGU MBX BOE KVSJTQSVEFODF IBWF FTUBCMJTIFE UIBU UIF SJHIU UP DIBMMFOHF UIFMBXGVMOFTTPGPOFTEFUFOUJPOCFGPSFBKVEJDJBMCPEZNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEJOBMM DJSDVNTUBODFT*UNBZJOQBSUJDVMBSOPUCFEJNJOJTIFEXIFSFUIFDIBMMFOHFUP MBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPOTFSWFT JOUFSBMJB UPQSPUFDUOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUT TVDI BTUIFSJHIUUPMJGFPSGSFFEPNGSPNUPSUVSFBOEPUIFSDSVFM JOIVNBOPSEFHSBE JOHUSFBUNFOUPSQVOJTINFOU "TNBZCFDPODMVEFEGSPNUIFTPVSDFTBCPWF BSFWJFXPGUIFMBXGVMOFTT PGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOXJUIJOBTIPSUUJNFJTSFRVJSFECZCPUI IVNBOJUBSJBOBOEIVNBOSJHIUTMBX
3FWJFXPGUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPONVTUCF DBSSJFEPVUCZBOJOEFQFOEFOUBOEJNQBSUJBMCPEZ "SUJDMF PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO TUJQVMBUFT UIBU BO iBQQSPQSJBUF DPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEuTIBMMCFDIBSHFEXJUISFDPOTJEFSJOHUIFJOJUJBM EFDJTJPOPOUIFJOUFSONFOUPGBDJWJMJBOJOUIFUFSSJUPSZPGBQBSUZUPUIFDPO GMJDU "DDPSEJOH UP "SUJDMF BQQMJDBCMF JO PDDVQJFE UFSSJUPSZ B EFDJTJPO PO JOUFSONFOUNVTUCFNBEFQVSTVBOUUPBiSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFuQSFTDSJCFECZUIF 0DDVQZJOH1PXFSJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIF$POWFOUJPO"SUJDMFBEETUIBUUIF QFSJPEJDSFWJFXFOWJTBHFENVTUCFVOEFSUBLFOCZBiDPNQFUFOUCPEZTFUVQuCZ UIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFS%FTQJUFUIFEJGGFSFODFJOMBOHVBHFiDPVSUPSBENJOJT USBUJWFCPBSEuJO"SUJDMFWFSTVTiSFHVMBSQSPDFEVSFuJO"SUJDMFUIFDPN NFOUBSZPOUIFMBUUFSBSUJDMFTUBUFTUIBUUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSiNVTUPCTFSWFUIF TUJQVMBUJPOTJO"SUJDMFuBOEUIBUJUJTVQUPUIF0DDVQZJOH1PXFSiUPFOUSVTU UIFDPOTJEFSBUJPOPGBQQFBMTFJUIFSUPBADPVSUPSBACPBSEu "4UBUFTGSFFEPNUPDIPPTFCFUXFFOBiDPVSUPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSEu BT QSPWJEFE GPS JO "SUJDMF BOE "SUJDMF CZ BOBMPHZ JT FYQMBJOFE JO UIF #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF4FFBMTP)VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF (FOFSBM$PNNFOU /P QBSB )VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF JCJE QBSB $PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
"SU QQm
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
$PNNFOUBSZBTBMMPXJOHiTVGGJDJFOUGMFYJCJMJUZUPUBLFJOUPBDDPVOUUIFVTBHFJO EJGGFSFOU4UBUFTu5IF$PNNFOUBSZBEETUIBUiXIFSFUIFEFDJTJPOJTBOBENJOJT USBUJWFPOF JUNVTUOPUCFNBEFCZPOFPGGJDJBMCVUCZBOBENJOJTUSBUJWFCPBSE PGGFSJOH UIF OFDFTTBSZ HVBSBOUFFT PG JOEFQFOEFODF BOE JNQBSUJBMJUZu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iUBLF QSPDFFEJOHTCFGPSFBDPVSU JOPSEFSUIBUUIBUDPVSUNBZEFDJEFXJUIPVUEFMBZ POUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTEFUFOUJPOBOEPSEFSIJTSFMFBTFJGUIFEFUFOUJPOJTOPU MBXGVMu "T IBT BMSFBEZ CFFO TUSFTTFE BCPWF FWFO UIPVHI UIF SJHIU UP MJCFSUZ PG QFSTPO NBZ CF EFSPHBUFE GSPN JO TJUVBUJPOT PG FNFSHFODZ TVDI BT OPO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDU IVNBO SJHIUT TPGU MBX BOE KVSJTQSVEFODF IBWF FTUBCMJTIFEUIBUUIFSJHIUUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGPOFTEFUFOUJPOCFGPSFB KVEJDJBMCPEZNVTUCFQSFTFSWFEJOBMMDJSDVNTUBODFT*UNBZJOQBSUJDVMBSOPU CFEJNJOJTIFEXIFSFUIFDIBMMFOHFUPMBXGVMOFTTPGEFUFOUJPOTFSWFT JOUFSBMJB UPQSPUFDUOPOEFSPHBCMFSJHIUT TVDIBTUIFSJHIUUPMJGFPSGSFFEPNGSPNUPSUVSF BOEPUIFSDSVFM JOIVNBOPSEFHSBEJOHUSFBUNFOUPSQVOJTINFOU *UTIPVMECFSFJUFSBUFEUIBUUIFSFBTPOGPSDIBMMFOHFTUPUIFMBXGVMOFTTPG JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJTUPQVUBOFOEUPUIFEFQSJWBUJPOPGMJC FSUZJGJUJTOPUKVTUJGJFE5IJTNFBOTUIBUBOJOUFSOFFNVTUCFJOGPSNFEXJUIPVU EFMBZPGBOZEFDJTJPOUBLFOPOBQQFBMBOECFJNNFEJBUFMZSFMFBTFEJGUIFQFUJ UJPO JT VQIFME &WFO UIPVHI UIF PCMJHBUJPO PG TQFFEZ JOGPSNBUJPO BOE SFMFBTF JT OPU FYQMJDJUMZ NFOUJPOFE JO FJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO PS IVNBO SJHIUT MBX BOZ EFQSJWBUJPOPGMJCFSUZXJUIPVUBMFHBMCBTJTJTDPOTJEFSFEUPCFBWJPMBUJPOPGUIF HFOFSBM MFHBM QSJODJQMF QSPIJCJUJOH BSCJUSBSZ EFUFOUJPO *G B QFSTPO JT LFQU JO JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOEFTQJUFBGJOBMSFMFBTFPSEFS UIBUJTBDMFBS DBTFPGBSCJUSBSZEFUFOUJPO
*CJE "SU Q *$$13 "SU #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF4FFBMTP)VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF (FOFSBM$PNNFOU /P QBSB )VNBO3JHIUT$PNNJUUFF JCJE QBSB
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTIPVMECFBMMPXFEUPIBWFMFHBM BTTJTUBODF /FJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO OPS IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUZ MBX FYQMJDJUMZ QSPWJEF GPS UIF SJHIUUPMFHBMBTTJTUBODFGPSQFSTPOTJOUFSOFEPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFE UIBU SJHIUJTHVBSBOUFFEUPQFSTPOTTVCKFDUUPDSJNJOBMDIBSHFT *UNVTUCFOPUFE IPXFWFS UIBUMFHBMBTTJTUBODFUPJOUFSOFFTJOJOUFSOB UJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUTJTOPUQSPIJCJUFE5IF$PNNFOUBSZPO"SUJDMFPGUIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO JO GBDU TUBUFT UIBU UIF iQSPDFEVSF QSPWJEFE GPS JO UIF$POWFOUJPOJTBNJOJNVNuBOEUIBUiJUXJMMCFBOBEWBOUBHF UIFSFGPSF JG 4UBUFT1BSUJFTUPUIF$POWFOUJPOBGGPSECFUUFSTBGFHVBSETu*UNBZCFTBJEUIBU OPXBEBZTUIFSJHIUUPFGGFDUJWFMFHBMBTTJTUBODFJTOPUKVTUBOiBEWBOUBHFu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
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFIBTUIFSJHIUUPQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFX PGUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGDPOUJOVFEEFUFOUJPO 1FSJPEJDBMSFWJFXPGBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOJGUIFJOJUJBMEFDJTJPOPOEFUFOUJPO JTDPOĐSNFEBĔFSiSFDPOTJEFSBUJPOu "SUJDMF
PSPOiBQQFBMu "SUJDMF
JTB CBTJDDPNQPOFOUPGUIFQSPDFEVSFMBJEEPXOJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMFTQFDJĐFTUIBUQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFXTIBMMUBLFQMBDFiBUMFBTUUXJDFZFBSMZ u XIJMF"SUJDMFQSPWJEFTUIBUTVDISFWJFXTIBMMUBLFQMBDFiJGQPTTJCMFFWFSZTJY NPOUITu 5IFQVSQPTFPGUIFQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFXJTUPBTDFSUBJOXIFUIFSUIFEFUBJOFF DPOUJOVFT UP QPTF B SFBM UISFBU UP UIF TFDVSJUZ PG UIF EFUBJOJOH QPXFS BOE UP PSEFS SFMFBTF JG UIBU JT OPU UIF DBTF "MM UIF TBGFHVBSET UIBU BQQMZ UP UIF JOJ UJBMSFWJFXNVTUBQQMZUPUIFQFSJPEJDBMSFWJFX T BTXFMM XIJDI BNPOHPUIFS UIJOHT NFBOTUIBUUIFSFWJFXIBTUPCFFGGFDUJWFBOENVTUCFDPOEVDUFECZBO JOEFQFOEFOUBOEJNQBSUJBMCPEZ
$PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
Q *CJE 4FF JOUFSBMJB #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMFTBOE *CJE 1SJODJQMF
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
5IFSFJTOPTQFDJGJFEQFSJPEJDJUZPGSFWJFXBWBJMBCMFUPQFSTPOTEFUBJOFE JO OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT PS PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJPMFODF CFDBVTF IVNBOSJHIUTMBXEPFTOPUMJNJUUIFGSFRVFODZPGDIBMMFOHFTUIBUNBZCFTVC NJUUFE CZ BO JOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZ EFUBJOFE QFSTPO UP UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG EFUFOUJPO IBCFBTDPSQVTQFUJUJPOT *OUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOXJMM JO QSBDUJDF CF SFHVMBUFE CZ UIF EPNFTUJD MBX PG UIF 4UBUF JOWPMWFE JO B OPO JOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUPSPUIFSTJUVBUJPOPGWJPMFODF NFBOJOHUIBUBQFS TPOTBCJMJUZUPDIBMMFOHFUIFMBXGVMOFTTPGIJTPSIFSJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPOXJMMCFSFHVMBUFECZUIPTFOPSNT *GUIFSFMFWBOUEPNFTUJDMBXNBLFTOPTVDIQSPWJTJPO JUJTTVCNJUUFEUIBU BUMFBTUTJYNPOUIMZSFWJFXTPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPOTIPVMECF QSPWJEFEGPS TJNJMBSUPUIFSVMFTBQQMJDBCMFJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMBSNFEDPOGMJDUT
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPSIFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWF TIPVMECFBCMFUPBUUFOEUIFQSPDFFEJOHTJOQFSTPO "OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPSIFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWFTIPVME BT B HFOFSBM SVMF CF BCMF UP CF QSFTFOU BU UIF JOJUJBM SFWJFX PG UIF MBXGVMOFTT PG JOUFSONFOU BT XFMM BT BU QFSJPEJDBM SFWJFXT JO PSEFS UP CF BCMF UP QSFTFOU UIF JOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUBJOFFT QPTJUJPO BOE DPOUFTU UIF DMBJNT NBEF BHBJOTUIJNPSIFS8IFSFOFDFTTBSZ SFBTPOBCMFBSSBOHFNFOUTGPSUIFQSFTFSWB UJPOPGDMBTTJGJFEJOGPSNBUJPONBZCFNBEF TVDIBTSFRVJSJOHTFDVSJUZDMFBSBODF GPSUIFJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWF 8IJMF OFJUIFS IVNBOJUBSJBO OPS IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUZ MBX FYQSFTTMZ NFOUJPOUIFSJHIUPGJOUFSOFFTBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFTBOEPGUIFJSMFHBMSFQ SFTFOUBUJWF UP CF QSFTFOU BU QSPDFFEJOHT SFMBUFE UP JOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JU IBT CFFO PCTFSWFE JO QSBDUJDF UIBU UIFJS BCTFODF PGUFO MFBET UP IFBSJOHT JO XIJDI UIFJS DBTF JT HJWFO JOBEFRVBUF BUUFOUJPO #FDBVTF TVDI QSP DFFEJOHTSFTVMUJOEFDJTJPOTPOUIFDPOUJOVBUJPOPGJOUFSONFOUBENJOJTUSBUJWF EFUFOUJPO JUJTTVCNJUUFEUIBUUIFJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFBOEIJTPS IFSMFHBMSFQSFTFOUBUJWFTIPVMECFBMMPXFEUPCFQSFTFOUBUUIFQSPDFFEJOHT*G UIFZEPOPUVOEFSTUBOEUIFMBOHVBHFPGUIFDPVSU UIFZXJMMOFFEUPCFQSPWJEFE XJUIBOJOUFSQSFUFS
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFNVTUCFBMMPXFEUPIBWFDPOUBDUTXJUI UPDPSSFTQPOEXJUIBOECFWJTJUFECZNFNCFSTPGIJTPSIFSGBNJMZ 5IF QSFTFSWBUJPO PG GBNJMZ MJGF BOE DPOUBDUT JT POF PG UIF CBTJD BJNT PG JOUFSOBUJPOBMIVNBOJUBSJBOMBXBOENBZCFTBJEUPDPOTUJUVUFBOFMFNFOUPGUIF CSPBEFSPCMJHBUJPOUIBUQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZJOCPUIJOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT NVTU CF USFBUFE IVNBOFMZ 5IJT TBGFHVBSE BTXFMMBTUIFUXPMJTUFEJNNFEJBUFMZCFMPX CFMPOHUPUIPTFBJNFE BU FOTVSJOH QSPQFS DPOEJUJPOT BOE USFBUNFOU JO EFUFOUJPO XIJDI JT OPU UIF *CJE 1SJODJQMF
* 0EJIC n 0ROCEDURAL PRINCIPLES FOR INTERNMENTADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
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iDPPQFSBUJWFOFTTuXJUIUIFEFUBJOJOHBVUIPSJUZ PSCFVTFEBTBGPSNPGJODFOUJWFPSSFXBSEGPSPUIFSCFIBWJPVS "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM ** BMTP DPOUBJOT QSPWJTJPOT EFTJHOFE UP NBJOUBJO GBNJMZ DPOUBDUT BOE OVNFSPVT OPOUSFBUZ IVNBO SJHIUT TUBOEBSET IBWF UIF TBNFBJN
"OJOUFSOFFBENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUBJOFFIBTUIFSJHIUUPUIFNFEJDBMDBSFBOE BUUFOUJPOSFRVJSFECZIJTPSIFSDPOEJUJPO 5IFSJHIUUPNFEJDBMDBSFBOEBUUFOUJPOJTBDPNQPOFOUPGUIFFTTFOUJBMPCMJHB UJPOUIBUBMMQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZNVTUCFUSFBUFEIVNBOFMZ.FEJDBM DBSFBOEBUUFOUJPOTFSWFBNPOHPUIFSUIJOHTUPQSFWFOUJMMUSFBUNFOUBOEBMTP UPSFGVUFUIFBENJTTJCJMJUZPGFWJEFODFBHBJOTUBQFSTPOUIBUIBTCFFOPCUBJOFE CZUPSUVSFPSPUIFSGPSNTPGJMMUSFBUNFOU5IFZBSFNFOUJPOFEJOUIJTDPOUFYU CFDBVTF B QFSTPOT IFBMUI JT PCWJPVTMZ B QSFSFRVJTJUF GPS IJT PS IFS BCJMJUZ UP DMBJNNPTUPGUIFQSPDFEVSBMSJHIUTPVUMJOFEJOUIJTUFYU ĂFHFOFSBMSVMFMBJEEPXOJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF TUJQVMBUFT UIBU i1BSUJFT UP UIF DPOGMJDU XIP JOUFSO QSPUFDUFE QFSTPOT TIBMM CF CPVOEUPQSPWJEFGSFFPGDIBSHFGPSUIFJSNBJOUFOBODF BOEUPHSBOUUIFNBMTP UIFNFEJDBMBUUFOUJPOSFRVJSFECZUIFJSTUBUFPGIFBMUIu.PSFTQFDJGJDSVMFTPO IZHJFOFBOENFEJDBMBUUFOUJPOBSFDPOUBJOFEJO"SUJDMFTBOE *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT "SUJDMF C PG "EEJUJPOBM 1SPUPDPM**TUJQVMBUFTUIBUJOUFSOFFTiTIBMM UPUIFTBNFFYUFOUBTUIFMPDBMDJWJM JBOQPQVMBUJPO CFQSPWJEFEXJUIGPPEBOEESJOLJOHXBUFSBOECFBGGPSEFETBGF HVBSETBTSFHBSETIFBMUIBOEIZHJFOFBOEQSPUFDUJPOBHBJOTUUIFSJHPVSTPGUIF DMJNBUFBOEUIFEBOHFSTPGUIFBSNFEDPOGMJDUu1SPWJTJPOTPOBDDFTTUPBEPDUPS BOE NFEJDBM BUUFOUJPO BSF BMTP DPOUBJOFE JO UIF SFMFWBOU IVNBO SJHIUT OPO USFBUZJOTUSVNFOUT #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT 1SJODJQMFTBOE *U NVTU CF TUSFTTFE UIBU BDDFTT UP NFEJDBM DBSF UIBU NJHIU CF SFRVJSFE CZBQFSTPOTDPOEJUJPODBOOPUJOBOZDJSDVNTUBODFTCFNBEFEFQFOEFOUPOIJT PS IFS iDPPQFSBUJWFOFTTu XJUI UIF EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZ PS CF VTFE BT B GPSN PG JODFOUJWFPSSFXBSEGPSPUIFSCFIBWJPVS
4FF JOUFSBMJB ($*7 "SUT BOE 4FF($*7 "SU BOE$PNNFOUBSZPO($*7 PQDJU OPUF
Q "1** "SU C #PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
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
"DDFTTUPQFSTPOTJOUFSOFEBENJOJTUSBUJWFMZEFUBJOFE *$3$ BDDFTT UP QFSTPOT JOUFSOFE JO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT JT QSPWJEFE GPSJOUIF'PVSUI(FOFWB$POWFOUJPO "SUJDMF
XIJDIBMTPMBZTEPXOUIF DPOEJUJPOTBOEQSPDFEVSFGPS*$3$WJTJUTBOEFTUBCMJTIFTUIFEVUZPGBEFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZUPHSBOUBDDFTTBOEUPSFTQFDUUIFTBJEDPOEJUJPOTBOEQSPDFEVSF *O OPOJOUFSOBUJPOBM BSNFE DPOGMJDUT BOE JO PUIFS TJUVBUJPOT PG WJP MFODF UIF *$3$ NBZ PGGFS JUT TFSWJDFT BOE DPODMVEF BHSFFNFOUT XJUI UIF EFUBJOJOH BVUIPSJUZ PO WJTJUT UP QFSTPOT EFQSJWFE PG UIFJS MJCFSUZ GPS TFDVSJUZ SFBTPOT BOEUPPUIFSQFSTPOT5IF*$3$TSJHIUPGBDDFTTJOUIFTFTJUVBUJPOTJT XJEFMZSFDPHOJ[FE #ZNFBOTPGWJTJUTUPQFSTPOTEFQSJWFEPGUIFJSMJCFSUZUIF*$3$ XIJDI JT BO JOEFQFOEFOU JNQBSUJBM BOE OFVUSBM IVNBOJUBSJBO PSHBOJ[BUJPO TFFLT UP FOTVSFUIBUUIFZBSFUSFBUFEIVNBOFMZJOBMMDJSDVNTUBODFTBOEUIBUUIFJSGVO EBNFOUBMSJHIUTBSFSFTQFDUFE*UJTUIVTDPODFSOFEFTTFOUJBMMZXJUIUIFJSDPOEJ UJPOTPGEFUFOUJPOBOEUIFJSUSFBUNFOU JODMVEJOHSFTQFDUGPSGVOEBNFOUBMQSP DFEVSBMHVBSBOUFFTBUBMMTUBHFTPGEFUFOUJPO $FSUBJO JOUFSOBUJPOBM BOE SFHJPOBM IVNBO SJHIUT USFBUJFT UPP QSPWJEF GPS POTJUF WJTJUT UP TVDI QFSTPOT CZ WJTJUJOH NFDIBOJTNT FTUBCMJTIFE VOEFS UIPTFUSFBUJFT5IFSFBSFMJLFXJTFBOVNCFSPGOPOUSFBUZNFDIBOJTNTDSFBUFE VOEFSUIFBVTQJDFTPGUIF6/$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUTUIBUNBZDBSSZPVU WJTJUTUPQMBDFTPGEFUFOUJPO 6OEFS "SU PG UIF 'PVSUI (FOFWB $POWFOUJPO *OUFSOFF $PNNJUUFFT BMTP IBWF UIF SJHIU UP NBLF SFQSFTFOUBUJPOTUP JOUFSBMJB UIF*$3$ *U TIPVME CF OPUFE UIBU VOEFS IVNBO SJHIUT TPĔ MBX UIF MFHBM DPVOTFM B GBNJMZ NFNCFS PS BOPUIFS QFSTPOXIPIBTLOPXMFEHFPGUIFDBTFNBZBMTPNBLFTVCNJTTJPOTSFHBSEJOHUIFUSFBUNFOUPGBQFSTPOJO BENJOJTUSBUJWFEFUFOUJPO4FF#PEZPG1SJODJQMFT PQDJU OPUF
1SJODJQMF BOE 4FF"SUDPNNPOUPUIFGPVS(FOFWB$POWFOUJPOT 4FF"SU PGUIF4UBUVUFTPGUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FE$SPTTBOE3FE$SFTDFOU.PWFNFOU &HUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJUUFFGPSUIF1SFWFOUJPOPG5PSUVSFBOE*OIVNBOPS%FHSBEJOH5SFBUNFOUPS 1VOJTINFOUTFUVQCZUIF&VSPQFBO$POWFOUJPOGPSUIF1SFWFOUJPOPG5PSUVSFBOE*OIVNBOPS%FHSBEJOH 5SFBUNFOUPS1VOJTINFOU &HUIF6/$PNNJTTJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUT8PSLJOH(SPVQPO"SCJUSBSZ%FUFOUJPO
5IF3FWJFXJTQSJOUFEJO&OHMJTIBOEJT QVCMJTIFE GPVS UJNFT B ZFBS JO .BSDI +VOF 4FQUFNCFSBOE%FDFNCFS "OOVBM TFMFDUJPOT PG BSUJDMFT BSF BMTP QVCMJTIFEPOBSFHJPOBMMFWFMJO"SBCJD $IJOFTF 'SFODI 3VTTJBOBOE4QBOJTI
$PWFSQIPUP ¥*OUFSOBUJPOBM.VTFVNPGUIF3FE$SPTT BOE3FE$SFTDFOU.PWFNFOU
5IFBSUJDMFTQVCMJTIFEJOUIF3FWJFX BSFBWBJMBCMFGSFFPGDIBSHFPOMJOFBU XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX
4VCNJTTJPOPGNBOVTDSJQUT
4VCTDSJQUJPOT
5IF*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FWJFXPGUIF3FE$SPTTJOWJUFT TVCNJTTJPOTPGNBOVTDSJQUTPOTVCKFDUTSFMBUJOH UP JOUFSOBUJPOBM IVNBOJUBSJBO MBX QPMJDZ BOE BDUJPO .PTU JTTVFT GPDVT PO QBSUJDVMBS UPQJDT EFDJEFE CZ UIF &EJUPSJBM #PBSE XIJDI DBO CF DPOTVMUFEVOEFSUIFIFBEJOH'VUVSF5IFNFTPO UIFXFCTJUFPGUIF3FWJFX4VCNJTTJPOTSFMBUFEUP UIFTFUIFNFTBSFQBSUJDVMBSMZXFMDPNF
5IF QSJOU SVO JT MJNJUFE 5IF 3FWJFX JT EJTUSJCVUFE UP TFMFDUFE JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE PSHBOJ[BUJPOT 'VSUIFS EJTUSJCVUJPO JT TVCKFDUUPBWBJMBCJMJUZ
"SUJDMFT NBZ CF TVCNJUUFE JO "SBCJD $IJOFTF &OHMJTI 'SFODI 3VTTJBO BOE 4QBOJTI 4FMFDUFE BSUJDMFTBSFUSBOTMBUFEJOUP&OHMJTIJGOFDFTTBSZ 4VCNJTTJPOT NVTU OPU IBWF CFFO QVCMJTIFE TVCNJUUFE PS BDDFQUFE FMTFXIFSF "SUJDMFT BSF TVCKFDUFE UP B QFFSSFWJFX QSPDFTT UIF GJOBM EFDJTJPO PO QVCMJDBUJPO JT UBLFO CZ UIF &EJUPS JO$IJFG 5IF 3FWJFX SFTFSWFT UIF SJHIU UP FEJU BSUJDMFT/PUJGJDBUJPOPGBDDFQUBODF SFKFDUJPOPS UIF OFFE GPS SFWJTJPO XJMM CF HJWFO XJUIJO GPVS XFFLTPGSFDFJQUPGUIFNBOVTDSJQU.BOVTDSJQUT XJMMOPUCFSFUVSOFEUPUIFBVUIPST .BOVTDSJQUTNBZCFTFOUCZFNBJMUP SFWJFXHWB!JDSDPSH .BOVTDSJQUSFRVJSFNFOUT "SUJDMFT TIPVME CF UP XPSET JO MFOHUI 4IPSUFS DPOUSJCVUJPOT DBO CF QVCMJTIFE VOEFSUIFTFDUJPO/PUFTBOEDPNNFOUT 'PS GVSUIFS JOGPSNBUJPO QMFBTF DPOTVMU UIF *OGPSNBUJPOGPSDPOUSJCVUPSTBOE(VJEFMJOFTGPS SFGFSFODJOHPOUIFXFCTJUFPGUIF3FWJFX XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX
3FRVFTUTGPSTVCTDSJQUJPOTDBOCFNBEFUP UIFGPMMPXJOHBEESFTT *OUFSOBUJPOBM$PNNJUUFFPGUIF3FE$SPTT *$3$
1SPEVDUJPO .BSLFUJOH BOE%JTUSJCVUJPO "WFOVFEFMB1BJY $)(FOFWB 4XJU[FSMBOE G FNBJMTIPQHWB!JDSDPSH XXXJDSDPSHFOHTIPQ ¥JDSD "VUIPSJ[BUJPO UP SFQSJOU PS SFQVCMJTI BOZ UFYU QVCMJTIFE JO UIF 3FWJFX NVTU CF PCUBJOFEGSPNUIF&EJUPSJO$IJFG3FRVFTUT TIPVMECFBEESFTTFEUPUIF&EJUPSJBM5FBN &EJUPSJBM5FBN &EJUPSJO$IJFG5POJ1GBOOFS &EJUPSJBMBTTJTUBOU'JPOB-F%JSBJTPO 1VCMJDBUJPOBTTJTUBOU.BSJBOOF1FSFEB *OUFSOBUJPOBM3FWJFXPGUIF3FE$SPTT "WFOVFEFMB1BJY $)(FOFWB 4XJU[FSMBOE U G FNBJMSFWJFXHWB!JDSDPSH
6OLUME .UMBER *UNE
XXXJDSDPSHFOHSFWJFX
Related Documents
More Documents from "Daisy"
The Icrc: Its Mission And Work
June 2020 2
Book I: Weapon Contamination Environment
June 2020 2
Internally Displaced People
June 2020 7
