6LOD:WLNLSHGLDW KHIUHHHQF\ FORSHGLD
KW W S HQZ LNLSHGLDRUJ Z LNL6 LODW
6LODW ) URP : LNLSHGLDW KHIUHHHQF\ FORSHGLD
6LODW
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
$ 9LHW QDP HVHSHVLODW
&RQW HQW V (W \ P RORJ\ + LVW RU\ 5 HJLRQDOXVDJHV 5 HIHUHQFHV ) RRW QRW HV ) XUW KHUUHDGLQJ
(W \ P RO RJ\
WOHN $ OVRNQRZQ 3 HQFDN6LODW6H6LOD6L DV ) RFXV
+\EULG
&RXQWU\ RI RULJLQ
0 DOD\VLD,QGRQHVLD6LQJ DSRUH%UXQHL
6LOD:WLNLSHGLDW KHIUHHHQF\ FORSHGLD
KW W S HQZ LNLSHGLDRUJ Z LNL6 LODW
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
+ LVW RU\
5 DQGDLSHUIRP DQFHVZ LW K VLOHN VLODVRQHRI W KHGDQFHV FRPSRQHQW V
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
&KLQHVH
VXOW DQVSDQJOLPDHQHUDODQG SHQGHNDU DUULRUVGXULQJ W KH 0 DODFFD6XOW DQDW H 0 DM DSDKLW DQ 6ULYLM D\ DPSLUHV,W ZDVW KH -DYD %DOL 6XODZHVLDQ %RUQHR DOD\ VLQSDUW LFXODU LQ0 DOD\ SHQLQVXODFRQVLGHU + DQJ 7 XDKDW KH IDW KHURI VLODW> @
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
RUP DOLQVW UXFW LRQW DNHV
,Q0 DOD\ VLD2 Q0 DUFK6HQL6LOD0WDOD\ VLDKDV EHHQUHFRJQLVHGE\ 0 LQLVW U\ RI HULWDJHDQG&XOW XUH0 LQLVW U\ RI ( GXFDW LRQDQG 3HUVHNXW XDQ6LOD.WHEDQJVDDQ3 ( 6$ . $ DVQDW LRQDO VLODW 7XDQ+ DM L$ QXDUELQ+ DM L$ EG: DKDE DVJLYHQW KHUHVSRQVLELOLW \ RI GHYHORSLQJ W KH QDW L RQDOVLODFXU W LFXOXP 7KLVFXULFXOXP ZDVVSUHDGDP RQJ VHFRQGDU\ DQGSULP DU\ VFKRR O VW XGHQW V DOO RYHU 0 DOD\ VLD
5 HIHUHQFHV 6KHLNK6KDP VXGGLQ 7KH0 DOD\ $ UW 2 I 6HOI GHIHQVH6LODW 6HQL* D\ RQJ RUW K$ W ODQW LF %RRNV ,6%1 4 XLQWLQ&KDP EHUV DQG ' RQQ) ' UDHJHU - DYDQHVH6LODW 7KH) LJKW LQJ $UW RI 3 HULVDL' LUL RN\ R. RGDQVKD, QW HUQDW
,6%1
3 HVLODW L%DOL
6LOD:WLNLSHGLDW KHIUHHHQF\ FORSHGLD
' RQQ) ' UDHJHU
KW W S HQZ LNLSHGLDRUJ Z LNL6 LODW
: HDSRQVDQGILJKW LQJ DUW VRI ,QGRQHVLD WODQG9 &KD W UOHV( 7 XW W OH&R
,6%1
) RRW QRWHV AD E . LUVWLQ3DXND8 P EXLN0 XGRDQGW KH0 DJLF) OXW H$ 5 DQGDL' DQFH ' UDP D $VLDQ7KHDWHU-RXUQDO AD E ' RXJODV) DUUHU C' HDW KVFDSHVRI W KH0 DOD\ 0 DUW LDO$ UW V KW W S VRFLREORJVJ ILOHVZRUGSUHVVFRP IDUUHUBZSBSGI
6RFLDO$QDO\VLV HWULHYHGRQ
A6H&KDP EHUVDQG' UDHJHU AD E F 6H6KDP VXGGLQSDJH A6H6KDP VXGGLQSDJH
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