Assignment Working Notice anything the writer is doing well, process and product
Name Not working List anything that does not meet your expectations in craft, conventions or process.
Feedback Identify one or two changes to point out to the writer. Pick the things you think will be most helpful to the writer for the next draft or next assignment.
What other writers seem to be in a similar developmental place?
Can you place this writer on the ELL developmental continuum?
What errors is this writer making that seem to be common errors across the class?