Light Compaction Competition Comparison

  • November 2019
  • PDF

This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it. If you are author or own the copyright of this book, please report to us by using this DMCA report form. Report DMCA


Overview

Download & View Light Compaction Competition Comparison as PDF for free.

More details

  • Words: 4,942
  • Pages: 49
COMPETITION COMPARISON

LIGHT COMPACTION EQUIPMENT

COMMITTED TO SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTIVITY We stand by our responsibilities towards our customers, towards the environment and the people around us. We make performance stand the test of time. This is what we call – Sustainable Productivity.

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF75/500  Centrifugal force 15 kN – Maintenance free  Width 500 mm – No “sticking” on asphalt

 Water tank 13 liters – Easy to clean, no sprinkler pipe, big valve on top

Machine Performance

Bottom plate

Performance

Operator

 Hand and arms vibration 1,2 m/s²

 Wacker WP1550

 Centrifugal force 15 kN – Oil change once a year  Width 500 mm – Long bottom plate, picks up asphalt in rear due to shape and poor water distribution  Water tank 10,4 liters – Difficult to clean sprinkler pipe, small valve in bottom  Hand and arms vibration 10,8 m/s² – (Acc to Wacker op manual)

3

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF75/500  Centrifugal force 3282 lbf – Maintenance free

Machine

Performance

Bottom plate

 Width 19.7 in. – No “sticking” on asphalt

 Water tank 3,4 gallons – Easy to clean, no sprinkler pipe, big valve on top

Performance

4

 Centrifugal force 3372 lbf – Oil change once a year

 Width 19.7 in. – Long bottom plate, picks up asphalt in rear due to shape and poor water distribution  Water tank 2,75 gallons – Difficult to clean sprinkler pipe, small valve in bottom

Operator

 Hand and arms vibration 47 in/s²

 Wacker WP1550

 Hand and arms vibration 425 in/s² – (Acc to Wacker op manual)

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF75/500  Centrifugal force 15 kN – Maintenance free

Machine Performance

Speed

 Speed 25 m/min  Water tank 13 liters – Excellent water distr. No sprinkler pipe to clean! Easy to reach valve on top  Hand and arms vibration 1,2 m/s²

Performance

Operator

 Mikasa MVC-88GH  Centrifugal force 15 kN – Oil change 200 hours and check every 100 hours  Speed 18 min/m – (Measured by Dynapac in Karlskrona)  Water tank 13 liters – Poor water distr., difficult to clean sprinkler pipe. Small valve in bottom, difficult to reach  Hand and arms vibration 2,4 m/s² – Acc to webpage, doubt this figure..

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF75/500  Centrifugal force 3282 lbf – Maintenance free  Speed 88.6 feet/min  Water tank 3.4 gallons – Excellent water distr. No sprinkler pipe to clean! Easy to reach valve on top  Hand and arms vibration 47.25 in/s²

Machine Performance

Speed

Performance

Operator

 Mikasa MVC-88GH  Centrifugal force 3282 lbf – Oil change 200 hours and check every 100 hours  Speed 59.1 feet/min – (Measured by Dynapac in Karlskrona)  Water tank 3.4 gallons – Poor water distr., difficult to clean sprinkler pipe. Small valve in bottom, difficult to reach  Hand and arms vibration 94.5 in/s² – Acc to webpage, doubt this figure..

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF75/420  Honda GX160

Engine

 Centrifugal force 3282 lbf

Performance

 Width 16.5 in.

Performance

 Water tank 3.4 gallons  Hand and arms vibration 47 in/s²

7

Machine

Performance

 Bomag BP 10/36-2  Honda GX120  Centrifugal force 2249 lbf  Width 14.7 in.  Water tank 1.85 gallons

Operator

 Hand and arms vibration >98 in/s² (No info on web)

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF75/420  Honda GX160

 Centrifugal force 15 kN

Engine Performance

 Bomag BP 10/36-2  Honda GX120

 Centrifugal force 10 kN

 Width 420 mm

Performance

 Width 360 mm

 Water tank 13 liters

Performance

 Water tank 7 liters

 Hand and arms vibration 1,2 m/s²

8

Machine

Operator

 Hand and arms vibration >2,5 m/s² (No info on web)

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF50  Honda GX100

 Speed 25 m/min  Centrifugal force 8 kN  Hand and arms vibration 1,8 m/s²

9

Machine

 Bomag BP 6/30

Engine

 Honda GX100 Speed Performance Operator

 Speed 20 m/min  Centrifugal force 6 kN  Hand and arms vibration >2,5 m/s² (No info on web)

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF50

Machine

 Honda GX100

Engine

 Speed 78.7 feet/min

Speed

 Centrifugal force 1798.5 lbf  Hand and arms vibration 70.9 in/s²

10

 Bomag BP 6/30  Honda GX100  Speed 65.6 feet/min

Performance

 Centrifugal force 1348.85 lbf Operator

 Hand and arms vibration >98.4 in/s² (No info on web)

FORWARD PLATES Machine

 Atlas Copco LF80 Engine

 Honda GX160 Speed

 Speed 34 m/min  Centrifugal force 19 kN  Water tank 13 liters  Hand and arms vibration 1,2 m/s²

11

 Bomag BP 18/45-2  Honda GX160  Speed 25 m/min

Performance

 Centrifugal force 18 kN

Performance

 Water tank 7 liters

Operator

 Hand and arms vibration >2,5 m/s² (No info on web)

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF80

Machine

 Bomag BP 18/45-2

Engine

 Honda GX160

 Speed 108.2 feet/min

 Honda GX160 Speed

 Speed 25 m/min

Performance

 Centrifugal force 4361 lbf  Water tank 3.4 gallons  Hand and arms vibration 47.25 in/s²

12

 Centrifugal force 4047 lbf Performance Operator

 Water tank 7 liters  Hand and arms vibration >98.4 in/s² (No info on web)

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF100  Honda GX160

 Speed 25 m/min  Centrifugal force 17 kN

Machine Engine Speed Performance Performance

 Water tank 13 liters – Excellent water distr. No sprinkler pipe to clean! Easy to reach valve on top. Operator

 Hand and arms vibration 1,3 m/s²

13

 Swepac F90A  Honda GX120  Speed 16 m/min  Centrifugal force 14 kN

 Water tank 21 liters – You don’t get 21 l out of it, corrosion problem and freezing problem  Hand and arms vibration 3,5 m/s²

FORWARD PLATES  Atlas Copco LF100  Honda GX160

Machine Engine Speed

 Speed 82 feet/min Performance

 Centrifugal force 3,822 lbf  Water tank 3.4 gallons – Excellent water distr. No sprinkler pipe to clean! Easy to reach valve on top.  Hand and arms vibration 51.2 in/s²

14

Performance

Operator

 Swepac F90A  Honda GX120  Speed 52.5 feet/min  Centrifugal force 14 kN  Water tank 5.5 gallons – You don’t get 5.5 gal out of it, corrosion problem and freezing problem  Hand and arms vibration 138.8 in/s²

LG FEATURES  Hydraulic F/R system with lever – Easy to operate and to “compact on spot” – You don’t have to hold the handle 100% of operation time  Safety straps for safe handling  Compaction efficiency

 Durability – Hardox 400 steel in bottom plate  Protection frame for engine  Handle with low vibrations – LG range is world class when it comes to hand and arm vibrations!

Machine LG160 Petrol LG160 Diesel LG200 Petrol LG200 Diesel LG300 Petrol LG300 Diesel LG400 Petrol LG 400 Diesel LG500 Diesel man LG500 Diesel el LH700 LH800 radio

Low Vib. Handle m/s2 1,5 2,4 3,5 3,5 2,4 1,7 2,5 2,1 3,4 2,1 3,3 0,0

H/A vibrations acc.to EN500-4, 2001, Annex D(m/s2)

15

REVERSIBLE PLATES  Atlas Copco LH700  Low height - 790 mm  Open design bottom plate What comes in goes out

Machine

Dimensions Performance

 Wacker DPU100-70  Height 910 mm  Rubber sealed design, builds up material inside

Operator

 Forward and reverse system with electrical lever

 Forward and reverse system in handle, must hold it all the time Operator

 Hand and arms vibration 3,3 m/s²

 Hands and arm vibration 4,9 m/s² – According to Wacker manual

REVERSIBLE PLATES  Atlas Copco LH700  Low height – 31 in.  Open design bottom plate What comes in goes out  Forward and reverse system with electrical lever

 Hand and arms vibration 130 in/s²

Machine

 Wacker DPU100-70

Dimensions

 Height 36 in. Performance

 Rubber sealed design, builds up material inside Operator

 Forward and reverse system in handle, must hold it all the time Operator

 Hands and arm vibration 193 in/s² – According to Wacker manual

REVERSIBLE PLATES  Atlas Copco LH800 (radio)

Machine Dimensions

 Weight: 820 kg  Open design bottom plate What comes in goes out

Performance

 Wacker DPU100-70 (IR and cable)  Weight: 615 kg  Rubber sealed design, builds up material inside

Performance

 Centrifugal force 69 kN

 Centrifugal force 95 kN Performance

 Hatz 1D90, EPA emission approved, 11 kW

 Farymann 43 F, non EPA-approved, 8.5 kW.

LG Three main arguments  Compaction power and high speed  Outstanding durability

 Low hand vibrations

19

COMPETITOR SALES ARGUMENTS Wacker

Brand Good speed Transport wheels

Mikasa

Weber

Bomag

Big in US and Asia

Compatrol

Economizer

Efficient

New handle

Small Reversible with water tank

Hour meter

Good speed

DPU 130, new remote control plate

What will competitors use against us? That Atlas Copco LG does not have dead man’s handle. However, this means that you do not have to hold the handle 100% of operation time.

MAIN COMPETITORS – REVERSIBLE PLATES Reversible plates

weight

engine

kW

force kN

m/min

width

743 (762,712)

Hatz

11,5

80

28 (b,d)

800 (950, 650)

Bomag BPR 25/40

111

Honda GX160

4

25

25

400

Bomag BPR 25/50

129

Hatz

3,1

25

25

400

Bomag BPR 25/50 D

120

Honda GX160

4

25

25

500

Bomag BPR 35/60

139

Hatz

3,1

25

25

500

Bomag BPR 35/60

180

Honda GX160

4

35

27

600

Bomag BPR 35/60 D

687 (712, 726)

Hatz

11

100

28

650 (800, 950)

Bomag BPR 35/60 D

205

Hatz

3,1

35

27

600

Bomag BPR 45/55 D

360 (375, 391)

Lombardini

6,5

45

28

450 (550, 750)

Bomag BPR 55/65 D

Bomag BPH 80/65 S

Reversible plates Mikasa MVH 120 GH Mikasa MVH 120 GR Mikasa MVH 150 GH Mikasa MVH 150 GR Mikasa MVH 150D Eur Mikasa MVH 150D Eur Mikasa MVH 207 D(S) Mikasa MVH 207 GH Mikasa MVH 406 DS Mikasa MVH 406 GH Mikasa MVH 502 DSB Mikasa MVH R 60 Mikasa MVH R 60 Wacker BPU 2540 Wacker BPU 2540 H Wacker BPU 2540 A Wacker BPU 2550 H Wacker BPU 3050 Wacker BPU 3050 A Wacker DPU 100-70 Wacker DPU 2560 H

415 (435, 446)

Lombardini

6,6

55

28

450 (650, 750)

Atlas Copco LG 160 Diesel

169 (175)

Hatz 1B20

2,8

28

22

330 (450)

Atlas Copco LG 160 Petrol

155 (161)

Honda GX160

4,1

28

22

330 (450)

Atlas Copco LG 200 Petrol

217

Honda GX200

4,8

36

25

500

Atlas Copco LG 200 El. st.

247

Hatz 1B20

3,1

36

25

500

Atlas Copco LG 200 Man. st.

231

Hatz 1B20

3,1

36

25

500

Atlas Copco LG 300 Petrol

265

Honda GX270

5,8

40

25

500 (600)

Atlas Copco LG 300 El. st.

302

Hatz 1B30

4,2

40

25

500 (600)

Wacker DPU 2560 H TS

Atlas Copco LG 300 man. st.

282

Hatz 1B30

4,2

40

25

500 (600)

Atlas Copco LG 400 Petrol

398

Honda GX390

7,7

52

25

650

Atlas Copco LG 400 El. st.

436

Lombardini

6,4

52

25

650

Atlas Copco LG 400 (EPA)

436

6,2

52

25

650

Atlas Copco LG 500 El. st.

510

8,2

60

24

550 (750, 850)

Atlas Copco LG 500 Man. st.

490

Lombardini Hatz Supra 1D81Z Hatz Supra 1D81Z

Wacker DPU 2560 Wacker DPU 3050 Wacker DPU 3060 Wacker DPU 3070 Wacker DPU 3545 Wacker DPU 4045

8,2

60

24

550 (750, 850)

Atlas Copco LH 700

780

Hatz 1D90V

11

95

30

660

Atlas Copco LH 800

820

Hatz 1D90V

11

95

<30

660 (810, 960)

H TS H H H H H

Wacker DPU 5045 H

Wacker DPU 6055 Wacker DPU 7060SC

weight

engine

kW

force kN

m/min

width

112 114 150 164 158 360 230 (244) 214 430 370 560 58 69 140 160 140 159 166 166 741 (711) 164

Honda GX160 Robin Honda GX200 Robin Yanmar Yanmar Yanmar Honda GX240 Yanmar Honda GX390 Hatz Honda GX120 Robin Wacker Hatz Honda GX160 Hatz Wacker Honda GX270 Lombardini Hatz

4 3,7 4,8 5,9 3,5 4,9 4,9 5,3 7,4 9,6 10,3 2,9 3,2 1,5 1,5 1,5 1,5 1,9 1,9 12,8 1,5

22,5 22,5 27 27 27 45 23,9 35 50 55 61,7 15 15 25 25 25 25 30 30 100 25

25 25 25 25 25 23 22 22 23 24 23 25 25 21 21 21 21 21 21 28/30 19

400 400 430 430 430 445 600 600 500 500 550 350 350 400 400 400 500 500 500 870 (700) 600

180

Hatz

1,9

30

23

600

4,2 1,9 1,9 1,9 5,1 4,4

30 30 30 30 35 40

23 21 19 18 24 24

600 500 600 700 600 (440) 600 (440)

4,8

50

28

750 (600)

6,2 9

60 69

28 25

710 770 (600)

215 Hatz 175 Hatz 180 Hatz 187 Hatz 308 (286) Honda GX270 330 Hatz 426 (390, 350) Hatz 497 (456, 454) Hatz 615 (584) Farymann

COMPETITOR COMPARISON

 Atlas Copco LT5005

 Honda GX120 4-stroke, 2.2 kW, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor

Machine Engine

 Fuel tank - Fuel, ignition, shut off

 Multi functional tank Throttle, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off

22

 Wacker WM80 2-stroke, 1.7kW, 4400 rpm

Performance

 Air Breather system

 Noise level acc to EC 102 dB(A) measured, 104 dB(A) guaranteed

 Wacker BS50-2

separate, Oil mix needed

Noise

 Noise level acc to EC 106 dB(A) measured, 108 dB(A) guaranteed

COMPETITOR COMPARISON

 Atlas Copco LT5005

 Honda GX120 4-stroke, 3 hp, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor  Air Breather system

Machine Engine

Performance

23

 Wacker WM80 2-stroke, 2.28 hp, 4400 rpm  Fuel tank - Fuel, ignition, shut off separate, Oil mix needed.

 Multi functional tank Throttle, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off  Noise level acc to EC 102 dB(A) measured, 104 dB(A) guaranteed

 Wacker BS50-2

Noise

 Noise level acc to EC 106 dB(A) measured, 108 dB(A) guaranteed

COMPETITOR COMPARISON

Machine

 Atlas Copco LT6005

 Honda GX120 4-stroke, 2.2 kW, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor  Air Breather system  Multi functional tank/throttle Throttle control, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off  Much more hard-hitting and also a bit more narrow. Easier change of filter.

Engine

Performance

 Mikasa MTX60  Honda GX100  Multi throttle - Throttle controls engine

speed, start/stop functions and fuel shut off  Hour meter – Market info US says it breaks easily and then you cannot start machine

24

COMPETITOR COMPARISON

Machine

 Atlas Copco LT6005

Engine

 Honda GX100 4-stroke, 3 hp, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor

 Mikasa MTX60  Honda GX100

 Air Breather system  Multi functional tank/throttle Throttle control, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off  Much more hard-hitting and also a bit more narrow. Easier change of filter.

Performance

 Multi throttle - Throttle controls engine speed, start/stop functions and fuel shut off  Hour meter – Market info US says it breaks easily and then you cannot start machine

25

COMPETITOR COMPARISON  Atlas Copco LT6005  Honda GX100 4-stroke, 2.2 kW, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor

 Air Breather system  Multi functional tank – Throttle control, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off  Noise level acc to EC 103 dB(A) measured, 104 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 4,9 m/s² (EU Directive 2000/14/EC EN500-4)

Machine Engine

 Wacker BS60-2  Wacker WM80 2-stroke, 1.8 kW, 4400 rpm

Performance

 Fuel tank - Fuel, ignition, shut off separate, Oil mix needed Noise

Operator

 Noise level acc to EC 106 dB(A) measured, 108 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 7,6 m/s² – According to Wacker manual

26

COMPETITOR COMPARISON  Atlas Copco LT6005  Honda GX100 4-stroke, 3 hp, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor

 Air Breather system

Machine

Engine

Performance

 Multi functional tank – Throttle control, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off  Noise level acc to EC 103 dB(A) measured, 104 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 193 in/s² (EU Directive 2000/14/EC EN500-4)

Noise

Operator

 Wacker BS60-2  Wacker WM80 2-stroke, 2.4 hp, 4400 rpm  Fuel tank - Fuel, ignition, shut off separate, Oil mix needed  Noise level acc to EC 106 dB(A) measured, 108 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 299 in/s² – According to Wacker manual

27

COMPETITOR COMPARISON Machine

 Atlas Copco LT6005  Honda GX100 4-stroke, 2,2 kW, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor

 Air Breather system  Multi functional tank – Throttle control, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off  Noise level acc to EC 103 dB(A) measured, 104 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 4,9 m/s² (EU Directive 2000/14/EC EN500-4)

Engine

Performance

 Wacker BS60-4

 Wacker WM90 4-stroke, 2,1kW, 4200 rpm  Fuel tank - Fuel, ignition, shut off separate

Noise

Operator

 Noise level acc to EC 107 dB(A) measured, 108 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 6,5 m/s² – According to Wacker manual

28

COMPETITOR COMPARISON  Atlas Copco LT6005

Machine

 Wacker BS60-4

 Honda GX100 4-stroke, 3 hp, 3600 rpm, diaphragm carburetor

Engine

 Wacker WM90 4-stroke, 2.8 hp, 4200 rpm

 Air Breather system  Multi functional tank – Throttle control, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off  Noise level acc to EC 103 dB(A) measured, 104 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 193 in/s² (EU Directive 2000/14/EC EN500-4)

Performance

Noise

Operator

 Fuel tank - Fuel, ignition, shut off separate  Noise level acc to EC 107 dB(A) measured, 108 dB(A) guaranteed  HAV 256 in/s² – According to Wacker manual

29

COMPETITOR COMPARISON

Atlas Copco LT5005

Wacker BS50-2

Atlas Copco LT6005

Wacker BS60-4

Mikasa MTX60

 Honda GX120 4-stroke, 2.6 kW, 3600 rpm

 Wacker WM80 2-stroke, 1.7 kW, 4400 rpm

 Honda GX120 4-stroke, 2.6 kW, 3750 rpm

 Honda GX100, 4-stroke

 Fuel tank Fuel, ignition, shut off separate

 Multi functional tank Throttle, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off

 Wacker WM90 2-stroke or 4-stroke, 2,1 kW, 4200 rpm

 Weight 63 kg

 Weight 59 kg

 Weight 69 kg

 Weight 66/70 kg

 Weight 64 kg

 Force 10kN

 Force

 Force 14,8 kN

 Force

 Force 13,6

 HAV 6,4 m/s2

 HAV 9,8 m/s2

 HAV 4,9 m/s2

 HAV 7,6/6,5 m/s2

 Sound 102/104

 Sound 106/108

 Sound 103/104

 Sound 107/108

 Multi functional tank. Throttle control, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off

30

 Fuel tank Fuel, ignition, shut off separate

 Multi throttle Throttle controls engine speed, start/stop functions and fuel shut-off

COMPETITOR COMPARISON

Wacker BS50-2

 Honda GX120 4-stroke, 3 hp, 3600 rpm

 Wacker WM80 2-stroke, 2.28 hp, 4400 rpm

 Honda GX120 4-stroke, 3.5 hp, 3750 rpm

 Multi functional tank. Throttle control,

 Fuel tank Fuel, ignition, shut off separate

 Multi functional tank Throttle, fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut off

fuel shut off, air shut off, ignition shut

off  Weight 130 lbs

 Weight 152.1 lbs

 Force 2248.1 lbf

 Force

 Force 3147 lbf

 HAV 251.97

 HAV 385.83 in/s2

 HAV 192.91 in/s2

 Sound 106/108

 Sound 103/104

 Weight 138.9 lbs in/s2

 Sound 102/104

31

Atlas Copco LT6005

Atlas Copco LT5005

Wacker BS60-4

Mikasa MTX60

 Wacker WM90 2-stroke or 4-stroke, 2.8 hp, 4200 rpm

 Honda GX100, 4-stroke

 Fuel tank Fuel, ignition, shut off separate

 Multi throttle Throttle controls engine speed, start/stop functions and fuel shut-off

 Weight 145.5/154.3 lbs

 Weight 141.1 lbs

 Force

 Force 2922.5 lbf

 HAV 299.2/255.9 in/s2  Sound 107/108

PREMIUM AND VALUE Value

Premium  Multi functional tank, can be turned upside down

 More emissions and fumes

 Instant start

 2-stroke engine Wacker

 More noise

 4-stroke engine Honda  Compaction efficiency

Premium

Value

Basic

120

100

80

60

40

20

0 WestEuropé

EastEuropé

NorthAmerica

SouthAmerica

Africa

ME

India

China

APAC

COMPETITOR SALES ARGUMENTS Wacker

Known brand Large range of products Price (Wacker 2-stroke)

Mikasa

Slim models Rough and tough look

Weber

Handle Low engine oil warning

Pros LT 5005/6005

33



Oil alert



Narrow width 345 mm



Reduced weight (-5 kg) with the new 5005/6005

Bomag

Low engine oil warning Reliable

COMPETITOR DATA Rammers

weight

engine

kW

force kN/ height mm

Frequency

m/min

m/s2

width

Bomag BT 60/4

62

Honda GX100

2,5

13,5/60

9

20

Bomag BT 65/4

68

Honda GX100

2,5

16,2/70

9

20

280 (290,330)

Bomag BT 80D

81

Yanmar

3,5

17,5/70

8

16

330 (280, 290)

Atlas Copco LT 5005 9"

61

Honda GX120

2,2

12

15-18

4,9

150

Atlas Copco LT 5005 11"

62

Honda GX120

2,2

12

15-18

4,9

230

Atlas Copco LT 6005 9"

68

Honda GX120

2,2

12

15-18

4,9

230

Atlas Copco LT 6005 11"

69

Honda GX120

2,2

12

15-18

4,9

280

Atlas Copco LT 7000 11"

78

Honda GX120

2,9

18,6/70-80

12

15-18

9,6

280

Atlas Copco LT800 11"

84

Hatz 1B20

3,4

21,4/75-85

12

13-16

12,6

280

Atlas Copco LT800 13"

85

Hatz 1B20

3,4

21,4/75-85

12

13-16

12,6

330

Mikasa MT 55

57

Robin

2,1

9,8/30-70

11

265

Mikasa MT 65 H

66

Honda GX100

2,2

12,7/50-80

11

285

Mikasa MT 72 FW

74

Robin

2,6

13,7/50-80

11

285

Mikasa MT 72 SGK

81

Robin

2,6

11,8/40-60

11

280

Mikasa MT 76D

80

Yanmar

3,1

15,7/50-80

11

285

Mikasa MT 84D

85

Robin

2,6

15,7/50-80

11

285

Mikasa MTR-40 F

46

Robin

2,1

5,4/40-55

11

150

Mikasa MTX 60

64

Honda GX100

2,1

13,6/50-80

11

Mikasa MTX 70

75

Honda GX100

2,1

14,9/50-80

11

5,6

285

Mikasa MTX 80

83

Robin

2,6

15,6/50-80

11

5,6

285

Mikasa MTX 90

89

Robin

2,6

16,5/50-80

11

5,5

285

Wacker BS 30

32

Wacker

2,3

/42

14

Wacker Bs 50 - 4s

62

Wacker

2,1

_ /55

14

13

Wacker BS 50 - 2

59

Wacker

1,7

_ /72

14

18

Wacker BS 50 - 2i

59 (58, 56)

Wacker

1,7

_ /72

14

9,5

280 (250, 152)

Wacker BS 60 - 2i

66

Wacker

1,8

_ /72

14

9,8

280

Wacker BS 60 - 4

70

Wacker

2,1

_ /55

14

12,5

Wacker BS 60 - 4s

70

Wacker

2,1

_ /55

14

12,5

Wacker BS 60 - 2

66

Wacker

2,1

_ /72

14

17,4

280

Wacker BS 70 - 2

74

Wacker

2

_ /76

14

8,9

280 (330)

Wacker BS 70 - 2i

74

Wacker

2,3

_ /73

14

15,8

330 (280)

Wacker DS 70

83

Yanmar

3,1

_ /75

14

13

280 (330)

280 (160, 230)

265

150 280 9,8

6,5

280

280 280

DUPLEX ROLLER PREMIUM AND VALUE Premium  Robust and reliable – Fully hydraulic

 Less performance – Chain driven

– Easy to operate

– Not as easy to operate

– Now overhang

– Overhang on one side

 Compaction performance – Force ~4500 lbf

– Speed

35

Value

 Less quality

DUPLEX ROLLER PREMIUM AND VALUE Premium  Robust and reliable – Fully hydraulic

 Less performance – Chain driven

– Easy to operate

– Not as easy to operate

– Now overhang

– Overhang on one side

 Compaction performance – Force ~20kN

– Speed

36

Value

 Less quality

ROLLER COMPETITION



Atlas Copco LP6500 electrical start



Bomag BW 62 H electrical start



Wacker RD 7H-ES electrical start



718 kg



602 kg



830 kg



Width: 650 mm



Width: 600 mm



Width: 650 mm



Speed fw:3,6 km/h



Speed fw:5,5 b:2,5km/h



Speed fw:4 b:2km/h



Engine Hatz



Engine Hatz



Engine Hatz



Force 21kN



Force 18kN



Force 13kN

ROLLER COMPETITION



Atlas Copco LP6500 electrical start



Bomag BW 62 H electrical start



Wacker RD 7H-ES electrical start



1,579 lbs



1,366.9 lbs



1,829.8 lbs



Width: 25.6 in.



Width: 23.6 in.



Width: 25.6 in.



Speed fw: 0-2.3 mph



Speed fw: 3.11 b:1.24 mph



Speed fw: 2.49 b:1.24 mph



Engine Hatz



Engine Hatz



Engine Hatz



Force 4,500 lbf



Force 4,046.6 lbf



Force 2,923.5 lbf

ROLLER COMPETITION



Amman electrical start



Belle electrical start



Engine Hatz



Engine Kubota



Width 650 mm



Width 650 mm



Force 13-18 kN



Force 20 kN



Speed 4/2,5 km/h



Speed 3,6 km/h

ROLLER COMPETITION



Amman electrical start



Belle electrical start



Engine Hatz



Engine Kubota



Width 25.6 in.



Width 25.6 in.



Force 2,922-4,047 lbf



Force 4,496 lbf



Speed 2.49/1.24 mph



Speed 1.86 mph

ROLLER COMPETITION

Machine



Wacker RD-7H



Weight 810 kg, hard to turn

Performance



Centrifugal force 13 kN

Water tank 71 liter

Performance



Water tank 53 liter



Hatz 1D50, 6.8 kW

Engine



Hatz 1D41, 5.1 kW



Hydraulic oil cooler

Hyrdraulics



No oil cooler



Atlas Copco LP6500



Weight 696 kg, long handle, easy to operate



Centrifugal force 21 kN



Weight

ROLLER COMPETITION

 Atlas Copco LP6500  Weight 1535 lbs, long handle, easy to operate  Centrifugal force 4,500 lbf

 Water tank 18.1 gallons

Machine Weight

 Wacker RD-7H  Weight 1785.7 lbs, hard to turn

Performance

 Centrifugal force 2,923 lbf Performance

 Hatz 1D50, 9.1 hp

Engine

 Hydraulic oil cooler

Hyrdraulics

 Water tank 14 gallons  Hatz 1D41, 6.84 hp  No oil cooler

ROLLER COMPETITION

 Atlas Copco LP6500  Weight 696 kg  Centrifugal force 21 kN

Machine Weight Performance

 Hydraulic oil cooler  Drum diameter 400 mm

 Weight 620 kg  Centrifugal force 10.8 kN  Water tank 40 liter

 Water tank 71 liter  Hatz 1D50, 6.8 kW

 Mikasa MRH600SA

Engine Hyrdraulics Drum

 Yanmar, NFAD6 4.4 kW or L90A 6.6 kW  No hydraulic oil cooler  Drum diameter 355 mm - Marks in asphalt for sure a risk

ROLLER COMPETITION

 Atlas Copco LP6500

Machine Weight

 Weight 1367 lbs

 Weight 1535 lbs  Centrifugal force 4,500 lbf

Performance

 Centrifugal force 2248 lbf  Water tank 10.6 gallons

 Water tank 18.1 gallons  Hatz 1D50, 9.1 hp

Engine

 Hydraulic oil cooler

Hyrdraulics

 Drum diameter 15.75 in.

 Mikasa MRH600SA

Drum

 Yanmar, NFAD6 5.9 hp or L90A 8.85 hp  No hydraulic oil cooler

 Drum diameter 13.98 in.

- Marks in asphalt for sure a risk

ROLLER COMPETITION

 Atlas Copco LP6500

 Mikasa MRH700DS

 Weight 696 kg

 Weight 710 kg

 Centrifugal force 21 kN

 Centrifugal force 23 kN

 Water tank 71 liter

 Water tank 40 liter

 Hatz 1D50, 6.8 kW

 Yanmar, NFAD8 5.9 kW or L100A 7.4 kW

 Hydraulic oil cooler

 No hydraulic oil cooler

 Drum diameter 400 mm

 Drum diameter 406 mm

ROLLER COMPETITION

 Atlas Copco LP6500  Weight 1535 lbs  Centrifugal force 4,500 lbf

 Water tank 18.1 gallons  Hatz 1D50; 9.1 hp  Hydraulic oil cooler  Drum diameter 15.7 inches

 Mikasa MRH700DS  Weight 1565 lbs  Centrifugal force 5,171 lbf  Water tank 8.8 gallons  Yanmar, NFAD8 7.9 hp or L100A 9.9 hp  No hydraulic oil cooler  Drum diameter 15.98 inches

COMPETITOR DATA – DUPLEX ROLLERS Duplex rollers

weight

engine

type

kW

force kN

km/h

diameter x width

start

drive

Bomag BW 62H electrical start

602

Hatz

1D41S

5,3

18

2,5/5,5

400 x 600

el and crank

fully hydraulic

Bomag BW 65 s-2

626

Hatz

1D41S

4,4

24

1,9/2,5

400 x 650

manual

mechanic

Bomag BW 65H electrical start

707

Hatz

1D41S

5,3

22

2,5/5,5

400 x 650

el and crank

fully hydraulic

Bomag BW 75 S-2

943

Hatz

1D50

6,8

40

1,6/2,5

480 x 750

manual

mechanic

Bomag BW 75 H electrical start

1016

Yanmar

6.2

40

5

500 x 750

el and recoil

fully hydraulic

Atlas Copco LP 6500 manual start

696

Hatz

1D50

6,8

21

3,6

400 x 650

manual

fully hydraulic

Atlas Copco LP 6500 electrical start

718

Hatz

1D50

6,8

21

3,6

400 x 650

el and crank

fully hydraulic

Atlas Copco LP 750 manual start

983

Hatz

1D50

8,9

25

3,6

500 x 750

manual

fully hydraulic

Atlas Copco LP 750 electrical start

1009

Hatz

1D50

8,9

25

3,6

500 x 750

el and crank

fully hydraulic

Mikasa MRH 500 DS water cooled electrical start

570

Yanmar

4,4

9,3

3

355 x 575

fully hydraulic

Mikasa MRH 500 DS air cooled electrical start

620

Yanmar

6,6

10,8

3

355 x 650

fully hydraulic

Mikasa MRH 600 DS water cooled electrical start

620

Yanmar

4,4

10,8

3

355 x 650

fully hydraulic

Mikasa MRH 700 DS air cooled electrical start

700

Yanmar

7,4

23,5

3

406 x 650

fully hydraulic

Mikasa MRH 700 DS water cooled electrical start

710

Yanmar

5,9

23,5

3

406 x 650

fully hydraulic

Wacker RD 7H ES electrical start

810

Hatz

1D41S

5,5

13

4,0/2,0

420 x 650

el and crank

fully hydraulic

Wacker RD 7H S

810

Hatz

1D41S

5,5

13

4,0/2,0

420 x 650

crank

fully hydraulic

Amman

720

Hatz

1D41S

5,2

13-18

4/2,5

650

el and crank

fully hydraulic

Amman

700

Hatz

1B40

8,6

13-18

4/2,5

650

el and recoil

fully hydraulic

Belle

675

Kubota

E75NB3

4,8

20

3,6

650

el and crank

fully hydraulic

Weber

732

Lombardini

15LD400 E-sta

7,3

21

4,5

650

el

mechanic

COMMITTED TO SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTIVITY.

Related Documents

Intro Light Compaction
October 2019 12
Competition
October 2019 77
Competition
May 2020 51
Competition
July 2020 31