LEGACY OF THE 51% SOLUTION BY M. MARTIN And so Karl Rove exits stage right, avowing to spend time with a family consisting of a onetime trophy wife and a son entering college a vow as transparently fraudulent as pastor Ted Haggard's recent assertions that a week long prayer marathon cured him of a propensity for sucking cock. Just as it is merely a matter of time before Pastor Ted once again finds himself on his knees in something other than prayer, it is merely a matter of time before Karl Rove gets up to his own brand of perverse nastiness. Unfortunately, while Pastor Ted's preferred kink damages nothing but his credibility and his tonsils, Mr. Rove's favored transgressions have some potential longterm consequences for us all. In his role as George Bush's brain, Mr. Rove inflicted upon the state of Texas two gubernatorial terms and upon the world two presidential terms for one of the leastqualified leaders this country has ever known. As such, Mr. Rove bears a very real responsibility for the thousands of lives and billions of dollars squandered in places ranging from a coal mine in Utah to the wards of New Orleans to the hills of Afghanistan to the destroyed neighborhoods of Baghdad. The consequences of eight years of cronyism, incompetence, and naked greed will be with America and the world for a long time.....but even that is not the true legacy of Karl Rove. The gift that keeps on giving, the legacy that will play out for the rest of this century, is something more insidious and more pervasive. Mr. Rove, in his role as "The Architect" of Mr. Bush's semielectoral victories and the Republican Party's shortlived domination of America, was more than anything else an advocate of a particular philosophy of politics and governance. The core of that philosophy is to win power at all costs. In a democracy, that means the creation of an electoral majority, even a razor thin one. The easiest way to create such a majority is to exploit the differences between the many social and cultural factions within society. The cost of such exploitation is to erode the common social glue that bonds factions into a society. If he ever even gave the matter thought, that probably seemed a small cost to the man who launched his career by sabotaging a competitor's fundraiser with stolen stationery, who bugged his own office to discredit a competing campaign, and who considered rumors of miscegenation and lesbianism fair campaign tactics. It is an enormous cost, thoughand as the interest compounds, the price may ultimately include the continued existence of America as a nation. Consider this: when we refer to Britain, Japan, or France as "nations", we are speaking of entities with identities shaped by millennia of shared language, ethnicity, cultural and religious values. When we refer to the United States of America as a "nation", we refer to two centuries of largely democratic governance based on certain legal and philosophic principles. There is no "American People" that exists independent of that shared philosophy of governance. It is the glue that binds us as a nation. From the very beginning, this was a nation of many beliefs, many languages, many different colors of eye and skin. Where Karl Rove's "winning is everything" philosophy of politics leaves off, George Bush's "winner take all" philosophy of governance picks up. Taken collectively, these two philosophies have undermined every single aspect of the social glue that binds America into a nation. Where Mr. Rove has undermined America's sense of community by dividing the electorate on every single issue available, Mr. Bush has undermined America's credibility and selfidentity as a nation by ruling as the very thing this nation was created to oppose: an unaccountable despot who holds himself and his advisers above the law. In this as well, Mr. Rove is culpable. The political atmosphere he has helped to engender has resulted in an opposition party so weakened and fearful of political backlash as
to be incapable of carrying out their constitutional duties. As a consequence, patently impeachable offenses go unchallenged and a morally indefensible war bloodily grinds on. As we collectively lurch into yet another season of presidential campaigns, there is remarkably little hope that the damage done by Bush and Rove is likely to be undone. Republican presidential candidates differ only in detail of how they would perpetuate Bush's legacy of paranoia, corruption, and brutality. The democrat favored by corporatist media, Hillary Clinton, is essentially Joe Lieberman in a pantsuita cryptorepublican who's utterances on foreign and domestic policy promise the continued erosion of American democracy and American credibility. Assuming this pivotal historic moment passes without significant change, what can we expect in another generation? This country is going to undergo some enormous stresses. Global Climate Change is real, so is Peak Oil. It will become increasingly expensive to maintain the lavish lifestyles Americans have come to regard as a birthright. Our status as a debtor nation and as a nation of debtors will not go away in a generation, nor will the countries we compete with (and borrow money from) conveniently stop growing or lose the desire to also be lavishly wealthy. Regardless who next occupies the White House or how quickly U.S. forces are drawn down in Iraq, the United States will be paying militarily for George Bush's decisions for decades to come. the current debate over a resumed military draft is a preview of the inevitable. The America of the Twentieth Century faced the equal of all these challenges and prevailed. But that was the America celebrated in WWII movies, the archtypic America where the infantry squad (or sub crew or bomber crew or whatever) included a hick kid from Texas, a notsohick kid from California, and an assortment of Jews, ItalianAmerican, secondgeneration poles and (in the later movies) African Americans. The America of the TwentyFirst Century may not be so lucky. We've got all the same ethnic/cultural stereotypes, as well as few new ones (the squad now includes a few gays, Arabs, and wiccans, among others). But the sense that we're all Americans and "all in this together" has been sadly, badly eroded, thanks to politics of division and governance by fiat. When the bill comes due on the Bush/Rove Era, paying it will require enormous shared sacrifice and shared sense of purpose. Don't be too surprised when the Republic of California, the Free State of New Hampshire, and the Hawaiian Nation decide they have priorities of their own.