Role of Laboratory Services in TB Control Part - II Role of Culture, PCR & Serology C.N. PARAMASIVAN
Tuberculosis Research Centre Indian Council of Medical Research Chennai
Indications for Culture in DOTS • Failures of re-treatment cases • Seriously ill cases; – extra-pulmonary cases – smear negative cases – childhood TB & HIV-TB
• For DRS • Not for New Smear Positive Cases
MYCOBACTERIAL CULTURE Advantages: Increases number of cases found Detects cases among smear negative patients Establishes viability of organisms Distinguishing between Mycobacterial species Helps in performing DST Helps in diagnosing cases of failure Limitations: Expensive Require enriched media Require considerable expertise Time consuming
Decontamination Procedures 1915 – Petroff’s NaOH 1946 – Trisodium Phosphate 1955 – Pancreatin Desogen 1958 – Pancreatin + 1% cetrimide 1962 – Zephiran Trisodium PO4 1963 – N-acetyl L-cysteine + 2%NaOH 1969 – Swab culture technique + 1% cetrimide 1975 – CPC + NaCl2
Culture Media : Solid LJ LJ with Na pyruvate LJ with out asparagine Middlebrook’s 7H10 & 7H11 Selective 7H10 & 11 Ogawa Tarshi’s Blood Agar
PETROFF’S METHOD Advantages: Simple, inexpensive & control the growth of contaminants Twenty samples can be processed in 2 Hrs, with centrifuge capacity being the limiting factor Sterilized NaOH can be kept for several weeks
Limitations: The specimen exposure times must be strictly followed to prevent over kill of tubercle bacilli. The initial kill is independent of additional contributory factors such as heat build-up in the centrifuge and centrifugal efficiency
Processing of sputum with CPC Method If delay of more than 48 hours between collection and processing is anticipated, the sputum should be collected with 1%CPC and 2%NaCl2 CPC acts as homogenizing and decontaminating agent It helps in retaining viability of Tubercle bacilli up to 7 days These specimens should not be treated with NaOH ( Petroff’s)
Colony Morphology of M.tuberculosis
Dry wrinkled warty growth. Eugonic
Reading and Reporting Characteristics of Tubercle bacilli Growth of Primary culture takes 2 – 4 weeks to obtain visible colonies Colonies are buff colored and rough, having the appearance of bread crumbs or cauliflower Not easily emulsified but give a granular suspension Microscopically frequently arranged in serpentine cords of varying length or show linear clumping
Other Culture Methods • Septi-check AFB • MGIT 960 • Backtec/MB/Bact • ESP Culture ii • Microscopic Observation of Broth Culture • MODS: Micro Colony Detection System
Nucleic acid amplification for mycobact. diagnosis Genus specific protocols Targeting genes code for M.TB Complex specific is Other targets: Genes encoding
Methods: Target amplification
16S rRNA 65KDa hsp 6110 38 KDa MPB 64 mtp 40 PMT 64 - PCR
(TMA, LCR, SDA or signal amplification Current status: adjunct to standard procedureEG: QB amplification) What is new in the diagnosis of TB
PFYFFER G.E. J.INF. 1999, 39, 21-26.
TRC/ICMR
30
Diagnostic performance of NAA for Direct detection of MTB complex Technique
Target
Sensitivity % Overall Sm-ve
Specificity %
Home-brew protocols PCR
IS6110 IS6110(ne)
85.0 77.1
73.0 57.9
88.0 -
Kit-based test formats PCR(Amplicor;Roche)
16S rRNA
74.0 97.8
53.0 -
93.0 98.9
PCR (Cobas Amplicor;Roche)16S rRNA
84.3 92.4
57.9 59.6
100 -
TMA (MTD;Gen-Probe)
rRNA
83.0 100
68.0 -
99.0 99.3
LCR (LCx;Abbott)
38-kDa protein
77.0 77.1 90.8 90.2
57.0 36.8 53.0 70.0
99.0 100 98.4
SDA (BDProbeTec;Becton Dickinson) Qß (Galileo;Gene-Trak)
IS6110 plus 16S rRNA 23S rRNA
97.9
92.3
96.5
84.0
69.2
97.0
What is new in the diagnosis of TB
Pfyffer . G.E. J.Inf 1999 39 21-26
TRC/ICMR
31
Evaluation of in-house PCR for the detection of M.TB. PCR Results from 6 labs Samples reconstituted with defined amount of M.TB cells Each lab used specific conditions of Sample processing NA Amplification Amplicon detection
Large differences observed in sensitivity & specificity Conclusion: in house PCR can not be used as a single diagnostic tool What is new in the diagnosis of TB
Suffs. P. et al Int. J. Tuberc. Lung Dis 2000, 4(2) 179-183.
TRC/ICMR
32
Serological diagnosis of TB Advantages Low turn around time High NPV Useful as a screening test
Limitation Low sensitivity in Smear Negative In HIV positive - Low NPV
- Low sensitivity
Disease Endemic Countries ↑ Latency - Low PPV High Cost Extensive Personnel Training Difficulty in distinguishing MTB / NTM
What is new in the diagnosis of TB Chan,E.D.,Heifets,L.,Iseman,M.D., Tubercle & Lung Dis.,2000,89,131-140 TRC/ICMR
34
Antigens used in serological diagnosis of TB
Mycobacterial sonicates Extracted glycolipids PPD Ag5 (38KDa Ag) A60 45 / 47 – KDa Ag Ag Kp 90 30 KDa Ag P32 Ag Cord Factor (trehalase dimycolate) LAM
What is new in the diagnosis of TB Chan,E.D.,Heifets,L.,Iseman,M.D., Tubercle & Lung Dis.,2000, 89, 131-140
TRC/ICMR 33
Antigens used in serological diagnosis of TB
Mycobacterial sonicates Extracted glycolipids PPD Ag5 (38KDa Ag) A60 45 / 47 – KDa Ag Ag Kp 90 30 KDa Ag P32 Ag Cord Factor (trehalase dimycolate) LAM
What is new in the diagnosis of TB Chan,E.D.,Heifets,L.,Iseman,M.D., Tubercle & Lung Dis.,2000, 89, 131-140
TRC/ICMR 33
Sensitivity(%) of smear-negative vs smear-positive TB Antibody detection to Age ‘x’
Sm+ Cult+ Sm- Cult+
Glycolipid
96
97
19KDa
57
55
LAM (Myco Dot)
26
7
LAM (Elisa)
88
67
P32Ag of M. bovis
IgA 33
IgA 29
BCG
IgG 52
IgG 35
38KDa
45- 89
16-82
75
68
P90
What is new in the diagnosis of TB Chan,E.D.,Heifets,L.,Iseman,M.D., Tubercle & Lung Dis.,2000,89,131-140
TRC/ICMR
35
Summary Role of culture in DOTS • Culture has no role in the diagnosis of TB in DEDC. • Indicated in; – Failures of re-treatment cases – Seriously ill cases; • extra-pulmonary cases • smear negative cases • childhood TB & HIV-TB
– For DRS