Internet Censorship_ Debate..

Internet Censorship: Debate Continues Over Google and YouTube's Effe...

1 of 2

http://medialiteracy.suite101.com/article.cfm/internet_censorship

hiring freelance writers | today's articles | sign in

guest writers barry schwartz

Home » Writing & Publishing » Media Literacy » Internet Censorship

Internet Censorship

david perlmutter

Debate Continues Over Google and YouTube's Effect on the Real World

dr. franklin house

© Jem Bloomfield

jonathan chevreau josh dorfman julie angus michael gerber mignon fogarty nate cavalieri robin cowie

more in suite writing & publishing categories media literacy (general) advertising influence copyright intellectual property law media bias media watchdogs press freedom teaching media literacy

latest articles planet-connect social networking site television shows and society's values digital literacy 2.0 and media collage how media constructs reality television shows michael phelps' marijuana fiasco turn off your tv week what is cyberbullying? more articles in media literacy

Ads by Google

Download Google Chrome Searching is fast and easy with Google's web browser. www.google.com/chrome

Sep 2, 2007 Vint Cerf's recent claim that the Internet is a "reflection of the society we live in" is a dangerously simplistic approach to a complex question.

The Secret Works See The Business Behind The SECRET Change YOUR Destiny Now! ItsAllAboutYOU.net.au

Alternatives to Violence Transforming hate and conflict Creating hope and positive change www.america.gov

Vint Cerf, Vice-President and “Chief Internet Evangelist” at Google, recently gave an interview in which he argued strongly against regulation of both Google and YouTube. When asked by the BBC’s John Humphries whether it would be appropriate to consider regulation in the light of recent concern over “gang videos” being posted on YouTube, he replied “when you have a problem in the mirror, you don’t fix the mirror, you fix that which is reflected in the mirror.” Whatever the rights and wrongs of Internet regulation, such a comparison dangerously misses the point.

Virtual Light Show New Νέο Εικονικό Show Room Φωτιστικών Εφφέ, Ρομποτικά, Όλα στην Οθόνη σας www.virtuallightshow.com

Secrets of Private Equity Learn How One Man Turned $100k into $1.5 Billion Now at GrowThinkLive! www.GrowThinkLive.com

i cured my acid reflux 3 simple grocery items stop reflux. Naturally cure acid reflux here... www.RefluxRemedy.com

Content posted on the Internet is not simply a neutral “reflection of the society we live in”. One of the reasons Google has been so vastly successful is the Internet’s considerable impact on the way we live our lives. Sending photos to a family member on the other side of the world seems a pretty neutral act, but what about posting an item on eBay? eBay does not simply reflect the world by registering the various kinds of jumble hanging around its lofts and garages, it attempts to turn that jumble into a marketable commodity, and eventually to money. Communication is never motivated purely by a desire to convey information about the world, it is always an attempt to alter that world, even if only to make a few quid or re-establish an old friendship. Or to present the world with a slightly cooler and more impressive image of ourselves. Anything posted on the web has an intention behind it. Those intentions can sometimes go awry: employees who post material about last weekend’s antics on Facebook may find it being accessed by bosses who disagree about what kind of photos show their subjects in a positive and sympathetic light. On the more serious issue of “gang video clips”, posting material on the Internet is surely not providing gangs with many communication opportunities they would not otherwise have. However, it is an opportunity to develop and present a group image which could possibly have an impact on other gangs, and affect events in the real world. An Internet posting in this case is an act of aggression, an attempt to project power and dominance. Whether regulation of YouTube is a right or viable alternative, it is either misguided or disingenuous to pretend that it gives a neutral reflection of the world outside it. The Internet may be many things – a video camera, a mixing desk, a plastic surgeon’s operating table, or a bill-board. But it is certainly not a mirror.

reference google and censorship

The copyright of the article Internet Censorship in Media Literacy is owned by Jem Bloomfield. Permission to republish Internet Censorship in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.

youtube vint cerf facebook ebay

related blog posts

Ads by Google

Second Hand Smoke Risk Factors of Second Hand Smoke. Second Hand Smoke Information.

Recommend Article!

Healthline.com

peace on may day against secret trials in canada un international day of peace boom for whom? rally coverage yes, i sell on ebay

Superior biomed database Find 1800 unique biomedical journals not covered in PubMed. www.info.embase.com

BA (Hons) Media Studies Scottish undergraduate course, UK Fully funded with a paid placement www.rgu.ac.uk/abs/undergraduate

Digg submit

Print Article Email Article

MA in Childhood Studies A World Class International Course University of Sheffield

View All Articles

www.shef.ac.uk/socstudies/ppt/

How to subscribe to feeds

add your comment

26/3/2009 10:40 μμ

Internet Censorship: Debate Continues Over Google and YouTube's Effe...

2 of 2

http://medialiteracy.suite101.com/article.cfm/internet_censorship

about us • limelight blog • writing jobs • careers • press room • site map • terms & conditions • privacy policy • suite101.de

26/3/2009 10:40 μμ