In The Circuit Court Of Shelby County }

IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF SHELBY COUNTY } PLAINTIFF CHARLES AND JANE FOSTER

} } } VS. } CASE NO. CV-2008-900818 } DEFENDANT, } CORNERSTONE BUILDING CO.,INC., } THIRRD PARTY PLAINTIFF, } } V. } } LARRY CLINE, d/b/a BUILT RITR } MASONARY; PITTMAN’S METAL WORKS,} INC,; CRAMER CONTRUCTION } COMPANY, INC.; AND DUNCAN CUSTOM } GUTTER, INC.; } } THIRD PARTY DEFENDANTS. }

ANSWER COMES NOW, third party Defendant, Pittman’s Metal Works, and denies each and all claims of Third Party Plaintiff and Plaintiff’s.

______________________________ Gary C. Young (YOU007) 2301 Morris Ave, Suite 104 Birmingham, AL 35203 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this day November 5th, 2009, I have served a copy of the above

Page 1

Answer on counsel noted below via E-Filing under/or U.S. mail, postage prepaid: W. Brian Collins Howard Y. Downey Collins & Downey, P.C. 2021 Morris Ave, Suite 300 Birmingham, AL 35203 H. Arthur Edge, III H. Arthur Edge, III, P.C. 2120 Morris Ave. Suite 300 Birmingham, AL 34203 J. Rick Wallis James S. Lloyd 2501 Twentieth Place South Suite 300 Birmingham, AL 35223 (205)967-8822 I hereby certify that I have served a copy of the foregoing Answer to the following: First Class United States Mail, postage prepaid, on this 5th day of November, 2009: Duncan Custom Gutter, Inc. c/o John Duncan 201 Winter Berry Lane Trussville, AL 35173

Pittman’s Metal Works, Inc. c/o Anthony Quinn Pittman 343 Pittman Drive Vandiver, AL 35176

Cramer Construction Company, Inc. c/o Brad Cramer 7866 Saddlewood Drive Rt.1 Box 151-1 Brierfield, AL 35035

Larry Cline d/b/a Build Rite Masonry c/o Larry Cline 131 County Road 91 Jemison, AL 35085

_____________________________________ Gary C. Young Page 2

Page 3