Full Ap Draft

Jiang

1

Yunhan Jiang Writing 39C / Full AP Draft 2/28/2019 Professor Greg McClure The Endangered Giant Introduction In the Hebrew Bible, there is a giant sea monster which is knows as a powerful and cruel enemy of gods. It is called Leviathan (Cirlot, 1971). Having a giant body and the power of apocalypse, Leviathan is often compared to other great monsters in other mythologies or tales. Parallels to Vritra1 in ancient India region or Jormungandr2 in Norse mythology, Leviathan is also noted as a destined enemy of the god Hadad. Later scholars interpret Leviathan as referring to huge, brutal and mysterious aquatic animals (Gesenius, 1859). As time flies, in modern era the name “Leviathan” used by novelists and poets becomes a term for large sea animals, usually whales, in general. However, although having such a deterrent nickname, whales are warm and kind animals, and are facing a fatal threat from human -- commercial whaling. According to EIA International, at around the middle of 19th century, modern era of commercial had begun. In short sixty years,

1

A serpent or dragon which is opposite to god Indra, and is finally killed by him (Gopal, 1990).

2

A sea serpent, the archenemy of the Norse Gods (Simek, 1993).

Jiang

2

the stock of many whale species suffered a sudden decrease. Data given by International Whaling Commission (2019) expose that from 1920s to 1940s, several species such as blue whale, humpback whale and minke whale were heavily exploited by industrial whaling and commercial whaling. Although society realized that whales were over-exploited, and began to regulate whalers and whaling industries, whales were already reduced to only a very small percentage of their original population size. As a result, International Whaling Commission -the most official whaling association in the world -- posted several whaling prohibitions on specific species, such as fin whale and blue whale. In spite of this, whaling also happened annually, and whaling cannot be completely controlled only by setting policies, as there are countries which already taste tremendous economic profit and industrial benefits from whaling, and does not want to stop even a little bit. Whaling problem should be taken serious consideration, and there has to be a more powerful organization to take charge of whaling problem. Moreover, normal people also should reject whaling and other whale products. The seriousness While talking about commercial whaling, normal people will firstly come up with identifications such as “extremely inhumane” or “containing several problems”. As whales have giant bodies, they are not able to die easily during the whaling process, because the way to kill a whale quickly at sea does not exist. As those pierced wounds keep contacting with salty sea water, nearly every whale dies in extremely pain. According to Mann’s (2000) research, whales protect their important and fragile organs by growing thick skins and fat, thus it is impossible to

Jiang

3

destroy those organs from outside to decrease the pain. Whales also have large amount of blood, nearly fourteen thousand pounds (6400kg), so killing them through bleeding is also ridiculous. Moreover, for preventing whales from struggling, whalers even use grenade harpoons.

Fig 1. Japanese whaling. Retrieved from: https://secure.avaaz.org/campaign/en/whales_last_push/

The cruelty of whaling does not only shows up in whaling process, but also happens in ruining whale’s habitats. Roman (2016) gives an example that whales sometimes do physical contacts with other individuals, and the way they identify each other is sound. Thus, whaling ships broadcast sounds to attract whales. Most of the whales die under those cruel tools, and there are some survivors -- they escape because they get too close to ships, and be deeply shaved by the high-speed screw propellers. Actually, Roman (2016) mentions that not every whale has

Jiang

the luck to survive from such serious injury, many of them are killed because their vertebra are completely destroyed. For those survivors, however, have no choice but carry scary and disgusting scars in the rest of their life. Injured parts cannot recover because whales live at sea, and sea water stimulate those wounds, causing extreme pain to whales. Far more than that, whales having ugly “marks” on their backs may be isolated by their crews. Whaling activity threats whales’ life and habits seriously while it does zero contribution to ecosystems under water. We human who have sympathy should oppose whaling together, and make such bloody commercial activity abandoned. Although whaling starts to be controlled while more people notice how cruel it is, there are countries which deny to obey those policies, especially Iceland, Norway, and other whaling countries in Europe, and Japan in Asia. More than 40,000 whales were killed by the three countries since 1986, and several evidences expose that these countries continue in doing whaling activities, while whaling was already controlled by IWC. Denyer (2018), the bureau chief in Tokyo of The Washington Post, exposes Japan once announced to make a breakaway from IWC at the end of June, 2018, and forcefully restarted commercial whaling around July. While in IWC, Japan also found several ways to keep whaling. According to Arne (2013), “Japan has been hunting whales for the past thirty years under a scientific programme. Critics say the practice is a cover for what actually amounts to commercial whaling.” Arne is not the only one who points out the irrationality in Japan’s whaling process. Junko Sakuma, a Japanese researcher who has already spent more than 10 years in Japan’s whaling industries for study,

4

Jiang

5

also has similar thought. “There is no benefit to Japan from whaling, but nobody knows how to quit.” In an interview at Tsukiji fish market, the worldwide biggest fish market known for its fresh tuna sale, Junko told the journalist, “If whale meat faces a shortage, the price should soar. But things does not happen, because most Japanese people nowadays do not consume whale products, including whale meat.” She adds, “Consumption has been falling for years. Even when whale meat becomes harder to buy, the price has no chance to increase.” Junko’s research allows the world to know that the average consumption of whale meat per Japanese person was less than thirty gram in 2015 (BBC, Japan and the Whale). The reason why Japan does not want to give up commercial whaling -- even when the demands of whale product decrease obviously -- is childish and irresponsible. A response given by Japanese government is “Whaling has already become a part of Japanese culture and history”. In their words, whalers keep whaling for decades, and already turn whaling activity into part of their life. Japan never accepts foreigner’s criticism in what they can eat and what they cannot. There is a famous conversation between Japanese official and Hayes (2016), a BBC journalist: “Japanese people never eat rabbits, but we don’t tell British people that they shouldn’t.” Facing such ridiculous answer, Hayes replies that rabbits are not in endangered species list. In another word, commercial whaling has already joined the global economy, and in some countries it becomes a tradition. To stop whaling in short term is not realistic, and we have to set our hope in long term. Damage to the environment

Jiang

6

If we allow commercial whaling to continue, and never try to prevent whaling countries, whaling activity will seriously ruin marine ecosystems and natural environment. Whales, as the biggest species in the world, have ability and enough power to influence the nature. They act as a part of the ecosystems, and do uncountable contributions to the wild. Mann (2000) lists several aspects of how and why whale’s habits are functional. By mentioning about whale, the most famous habit been noticed by people should be the “whale pump”. Whale pump is the behavior whales use to breath. While pumping out the water inside their bodies, whales also pump out nutrients such as iron element and nitrogen. Those nutrients then float on the surface of oceans, and feed animals living nearby, such as fishes and sea birds. Another helpful activity mentioned by Donovan (2008) is the seabed digging process. Gray and humpback whales usually feed themselves at seabed’s depth, and when they swim pass by, they disturb the soils and cause those substantial nutrients to be exposed. Such sediments are valuable nourishment to abyssal creatures. There are activities far more than those two, and a lot of numbers of species survive depending on whale activities. If commercial whaling exacerbates, it will cause a food shortage to marine ecosystems and finally leads abyssal creatures to extinguish. What’s more, a poetic phenomenon happening in marine ecosystem is called “whale fall”. When a whale dies, another story has just begun. The body falls to seabed and eternally lies. It contains enormous nutrients, and is able to serve food to abyssal animals in order to create a brand-new small life ecosystem. There are significant amounts of carbon and massive organic enrichment contained in the corpse, and construct the barren and impoverished seabed into

Jiang

7

paradise of microorganisms. In some articles, whale fall is described as “the last fondness whales give to the nature”, how romantic. Mann (2000) proofs, that if no whale fall exists, seabeds will keep barren and no life will be able to survive. Back to the present, commercial whaling causes a large number of whales been killed cruelly on land, which means less whale falls are able to be created. Commercial whaling indirectly endangers life in abyssal zone. The support of policy According to the data given on the website of IWC, more than 2.9 million of whales were killed in the 20th century. IWC announced a moratorium on commercial whaling, which was the first important step about whale protecting. After the policy started in 1986, the rate of whales exploited by commercial whaling decreased significantly. Only around 40 thousand of whales were killed since 1986 (EIA International). However, although the number decreased, it was still a huge loss of whale stocks. Life should not be counted as numbers. (On editing) Possible solutions We all understand that profit pushes commercial activities, so the most direct way to stop commercial whaling is to stop supporting whale products. There are lamp oil, candles and soaps which are made from sperm oil and whale oil, whale meat for human consumption and animal feed, fertilizer made from whale bones, and strings on tennis rackets which are made from tendons (KCPC 2001). In fact, there are plenty of alternatives which have better quality and lower price compare to those whale products. Advocating the idea of anti-whaling and

Jiang

8

anti-whale products can be an effective way to reduce whaling activities. According to an article from Human Society International (HSI), whales are kinds of species which are easily affected by environmental containment. While eating, whales absorb those organochlorines3 and heavy metals such as mercury which float on the top of the oceans and are contained by plankton. If people consume whale meat, chemicals adjust on whale meat will also be absorbed by people and can cause serious health problems. By exposing such fatal facts, anti-whaling activities run actively and effectively. Even in one of the biggest whaling countries, Japan, there are more than four thousand supermarkets which already refuse to sell whale and dolphin products.

Fig 2. People in anti-whaling activity. Retrieved from: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-35397749

3

Such as polychlorinated biphenyl (PCBs), dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT) and dioxin

Jiang

9

At least 85% of Japanese citizens strongly oppose their government to use money from taxpayers to build new whaling ships (EIA International). Anti-whaling activities are held not only in Japan, but also in Northern Europe whaling countries such as Iceland and Finland. According to the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW), they started a joint project with the Association of Icelandic Whale Watchers (IceWhale) in the summer of 2010. The project is called “Meet Us Don’t Eat Us”, and is held in Reykjavík4 annually. Whale friendly restaurants also began to build around the beginning of 21st century in Northern European countries such as Iceland and Norway. What’s more, volunteers use media to make several scientific videos to introduce the important role of whales in nature. In Smithsonian Ocean website, there is a short video introducing the whale fall and its functions.

4

The capital and largest city of Iceland

Jiang

Fig 3. A screenshot from the video “Life After Whale”. Retrieved from: https://ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/marine-mammals/life-after-whale-whale-falls

The producer uses paper material to represent the whale fall and life on it. The style is also acceptable and attractive to kids, helping them to learn the world earlier and evokes their responsibilities to protect the nature. In 2017, more than 80% of unsold whale meat in Norway were abandoned by markets and companies, because whale meat became hard to sell (EIA International). In Iceland, only 1% of citizens eat whale meat regularly, and at least 34% of Icelander actively and strongly oppose commercial whaling, which number is nearly doubled comparing to the year 2013.

Citation Cirlot, Juan Eduardo. A Dictionary of Symbols (2nd ed.). Dorset Press, 1971. Gopal, Madan. K.S. Gautam, ed. India through the ages. Publication Division, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, 1990. Simek, Rudolf. Dictionary of Northern Mythology. D.S. Brewer, 1993. Gesenius, Wilhelm, and Samuel Prideaux Tregelles. “Hebrew and Chaldee Lexicon to the Old Testament”. S. Bagster, 1859.

10

Jiang

11

“Commercial Whaling: Unsustainable, Inhumane, Unnecessary.” EIA International, eia-international.org/reports-mm/keeptheban/ “Status of Whales.” IWC | International Whaling Commission, iwc.int/home. Roman, Joe (2006-05-01). Whale. Reaktion Books. p. 24. ISBN 9781861895059. Retrieved 25 March 2017. Mann, Janet, et al. Cetacean Societies: Field Studies of Dolphins and Whales. University of Chicago Press, 2000. Wingfield-Hayes, Rupert. “Japan and the Whale.” BBC News, BBC, 8 Feb. 2016, www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-35397749. Kalland, Arne, and Brian Moeran. Japanese Whaling: End of an Era? Routledge, 2013. “Whale Products.” KCPC Education Resource Web Site: 9.2.3 Molar Heat of Combustion, 2001, discovery.kcpc.usyd.edu.au/9.5.1/9.5.1_whale.html. “Human Health Concerns of Whale Meat.” Humane Society International, 26 July 2002, www.hsi.org/issues/whaling/facts/human_health_concerns_of_whale_meat.html. Denyer, Simon, and Akiko Kashiwagi. “Japan to Leave International Whaling Commission, Resume Commercial Hunting.” The Washington Post, WP Company, 26 Dec. 2018, www.washingtonpost.com/world/japan-to-leave-international-whaling-commission-resumecommercial-hunt/2018/12/26/2c32fb20-08c9-11e9-892d-3373d7422f60_story.html?noredire

Jiang

ct=on&utm_term=.84c36d4251af. Donovan, Greg (2008). "Whaling". Microsoft Encarta. “Smithsonian Ocean.” Ocean Portal | Smithsonian, Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History, 22 May 2018, ocean.si.edu/ocean-life/marine-mammals/life-after-whale-whale-falls.

12