SAN and NAS in Perspective
CF Chew NAS Technical Architect, South Asia
Topics ■ Information Flow ■ SAN ■ NAS ■ SAN + NAS = MPFS ■ EMC Offerings ■Q & A 2
Information Consolidati on
Collaborati on
Distribution
■
Reduce total cost of ownership
■
Improve productivity
■
Improve service levels
■
Better leverage IT resources
■
Improve product quality
■
Improved network utilization
■
Improve service levels
■
Improve time to market
■
Efficient recovery
3
How can the Server access the Data Storage?
Server
Server
?
Data Storage
Data Storage
4
First layer of choice
File
IP
Channel s
NAS
MPFS
Access to Information Method: • File level • Block level
Block
TNT
SAN
Protocol: • Channel (SCSI,Fibre) • Network (TCP/IP)
MPFS = Multi-path file syste 5
Information Infrastructure, Topology Summary
Directly Attached Storage Device
Server
Data Storage
Server Data Storage
TCP/IP 6
A focus on Storage Area Network IP
File
Block
NAS
Channel s
MPFS
SA N
SAN
7
Typical Storage Area Network (SAN) Implementation LAN
Switch Fibre Channel Host Bus Adapters (HBAs)
Tape B/R
Storage
Storage Consolidation. 8
SAN Pros and Cons ✔ Block level access to storage ✔ Highly scalable ✔ High performance for large block transfers ✔ Excellent availability through multiple paths ✔ Sharing of consolidated storage ✔ High-speed LAN-less or server-less backups ✔ Data sharing through proprietary filesystem solutions ✖ Expensive to deploy and manage ✖ Expensive HBAs (compared to NICs)
9
When SAN is appropriate ■ Parallel Databases — Decision support systems — Data mining — CRM — ERP ■ High bandwidth streaming video ■ Process intensive applications — Billing
10
Information Infrastructure, Topology Summary
Directly Attached Storage Device Storage Area Network
Server
Data Storage
Server Data Storage
Server Server Server
Fibre
Data Storage
Switch Data Storage
TCP/IP 11
A focus on Network Attached Storage IP
File
Block
NANAS S
Channel s
MPFS
SAN
12
Typical Network Attached Storage(NAS) Implementation
Server Consolidation. 13
NAS Pros and Cons ✔ File level access to storage ✔ High performance for small block transfers ✔ Data sharing through proven standard network
protocols (NFS, CIFS, HTTP), heterogeneous system environment
✔ Availability through high bandwidth clustering and
data replication
✔ Simple and inexpensive to deploy - inexpensive NICs ✖ Limited security ✖ Difficult to manage large installations ✖ Must overcome scalability and availability limits of direct attached storage devices
14
NAS Implementation ■ Network Attached Device — Integrated storage and server function — Smaller configurations ■ Server Attached Storage — Generalized file server function — Can be optimized for storage access only — Uses I/O interface for storage attachment — e.g. HP N4000, IBM RS/6000 S80
■ Network Appliance — Reduced server functionality for storage only — Server and storage integrated and often in same device — Optimized for file server — e.g. F820/840, IP4700 ■ Intelligent Network File
Servers
— Only used for file serving — Storage functionality is done by the storage subsystem
15
Using NAS in an Enterprise
Local PC Serving Up Files
Internal/Lo cal Shared Resources Network/NAS
16
Information Infrastructure, Topology Summary
Directly Attached Storage Device Storage Area Network
Network Server Attached Server Storage
Server
Data Storage
Server Data Storage
Server Server Server File Server
Fibre
Data Storage
Switch Data Storage
Data Storage Data Storage
TCP/IP 17
EMC Networked Storage – NAS & SAN Finance
File Serve rs
Network Clients Orac le
Exchange
Finance
Sale s SAP
File Serve rs
Oracle
CLARiiO N Midrange Networked FC4700 Storage Architecture
Exchange
Sales
SAP
SAN
SAN CLARiiON IP4700 NAS
Network Clients
Celerra NAS
Symmetri x High End Networked Storage Architecture
18
Network becomes the bottleneck if NAS only
d atad ata
d ata
d ata
d ata
d ata TCP/IP
d ata
d ata
d ata
d ata d ata
File Server
19
A focus on Multi Path File System IP
File
Block
NAS
Channel s
MPFS M
MPFS = Multi-path file system “Highroad”
PFS SAN
20
Multi-path File System (High Road) - SAN / NAS Integration Network request, channel or network delivery
Network Infrastructure IP Network
Cont rol and D ata
Celerr a NAS
Delivery optimization
Servers
Data
Performance and sharing
Fibre Channel
Ad Server Content Best of Web Content
SAN switch
Symmetri x
both worlds
BLOBs, Flat Files
Intelligent Data Delive 21
Complimentary benefits - why you need choice IP
NAS File
Channel s
MPFS
Distance Performance Sharing Sharing SAN
Block
Performance Control
22
Choice can be confusing: how do I choose? Consolidati on
■ SAN or
NAS?
Collaborati on
■ SAN or
NAS?
Distribution
■ SAN or
NAS?
torage Area Network, NAS = Network Attached Storage 23
You can do it with SAN or NAS NAS
SAN
Storage and server Storage Deterministic performance Non-Deterministic performance Limited connections Unlimited connections Limited distance Any distance Consolidatio n File Sharing IP delivery MPFS - File sharing channel deliver delive IP performance Optimized performance Core and/or edge work Core work groups groups SAN distance Collaboration Any distance Content Distribution DR, Backup, Non-Deterministic performance Replication Shared connections Deterministic Core to edgeDistribution performance Dedicated connections Core to core 24
You can do it with SAN & NAS
SAN + NAS = Networked Storage
er environment determines technology choi Application mix Performance requirements Location of computing resources
25
Networked Storage - EMC Clariion IP 4700 Celerra SE Celerra
NAS MPFS Celerra High Road Distance Performance Sharing Sharing Symmetrix CLARiion
Connectrix ED-64M ED-1032 SAN DS-32M PerformanceDS-16M Control DS-16B DS-8B
26
EMC Connectrix Family (SAN) ED-1032
ED-64M
Switches ■ High
CONSOLIDATION
availability ■ Departmental and data center locations ■ Rack mountable DS-8B
DS-32M DS-16B
DS-16M
Directors ■ Redundant everything ■ Non-blocking I/O ■ Data center locations ■ Maximum scalability
Hubs FUNCTIONALITY 27
EMC - NAS Platform CLARiiON CONSOLIDATION
■ High availability ■ Moderate function ■ Moderate scale
Celerra SE
Celerra and Symmetrix ■ Continuous availability ■ Maximum function ■ Maximum scale
CLARiiON IP4700 General Purpose File Servers FUNCTIONALITY 28
CLARiiON IP4700: EMC MIDRANGE NAS ■ Midrange leading architecture—CLARiiON — No single point of failure — Proven CLARiiON architecture ■ High availability built-in Cluster ■ Ease of use — 10-minute installation wizard — Web-based management
29
EMC Network Attached Storage (NAS)
Symmerix
Celerra
Symmetrix
Celerra (CFS14)
Celerra SE
EMC High-End NAS
CLARiiON IP4700 EMC Midrange NAS
30
NAS Choices CLARiiON IP4700
Celerra SE
Celerra
Integrated high availability
Advanced clustering
Advanced clustering
2 Storage Processors
2–4 Data Movers
2–14 Data Movers
Scale to 7TB
Scale to 8TB ( 2TB internal )
Scale to 28TB
10 - 10/100 E-Nets
32 - 10/100 E-Nets
112 - 10/100 E-Nets
31
SAN Choice Ports
Fabric*
Availability
Rack size / ports
DS-8B
128
Via redundant switches
1u/--
DS-16B
256
Via redundant switches
2u/--
DS-16M
128
Via redundant switches
1u/192
DS-32M
256
Via redundant switches
1.5u/384
ED-1032
256
Built in redundancy
18u/64
ED-64 M
512
Built in redundancy
9u/256
* Tested, delivered, and supported 32
The EMC Networked Storage User network NAS DAS SAN SAN DAS
MPFS
= Direct Attached Storage = Storage Area Network Symmetrix = Network Attached Storage S = SAN and NAS sharing
SAN SAN
IP4700 NAS
OR
OR
FC4700 FC4700 Celerra
EMC CLARiiON EMC’s MIDRANGE SOLUTION 33
EMC NAS Value Proposition: NAS, SAN, or Both? SAN (Connectrix)
NAS (Celerra/IP4700)
■ Generally, Where You’d ■ File Serving Consolidation
Implement a Direct Attached Architecture
■ Databases (eg. Oracle) ■ Most Applications (eg.
SAP)
■ Share Info Among Hosts ■ File Serving Applications — Web Hosting (eg. InfoWeb) — Web Email (eg. USAnet) — Engineering (eg. Lucent)
■ SAN Backup
Remember, EMC Offers Both NAS & SAN… ...Best of Both Worlds 34
Is NAS SAN ? ■ No - NAS (Network Attached Storage) has
connectivity to LAN/WAN systems normally through TCP/IP Server
LAN
NAS
Server
■ SAN (Storage Area Networks) normally have
connectivity via Fibre Channel Server SAN
Storage
Server
35
Summary: NAS vs. SAN NAS ■ LAN connectivity
(Ethernet/GbE NIC) ■ Part of a LAN & LAN over
WAN ■ Shares files, objects &
data ■ Object security through
network protocols ■ Paralleled on the network ■ Simple & easily configured ■ Operating System (OS)
independent
SAN ■ Fibre connectivity (Fibre
HBA) ■ Part of a server cluster ■ Shares data blocks &
volumes ■ Data security through
trusted servers ■ Switched to servers ■ Clustered storage ■ Fast, dedicated
infrastructure for backup 36
Benefits of Networked Storage ■ Lower costs of administration — Centralized management of storage — Resource sharing ■ Faster growth — Improved scalability, flexibility ■ Better IT services — Increased reliability and availability ■ Traditional battle: SAN vs. NAS — But both types of services are needed! ■ Storage utility model
37
Q&A 38
Closing Slide
39