STRATEGIC PLANNING TCIL - a case study Food industry and Safety
2 July, 2009 : New Delhi
1
Value Chain Assess your role in the industry supply chain • Incorporated in 1920
Hot Rolled Coils from Tata Steel’s Hot Strip Mill
• Single product co.
• End Uses of tinplate: • Edible Oil cans
Tin Mill Black Plate Coils produced at the Cold Rolling Mill
Tinplate / TFS Sheets produced at the Electrolytic Tinning Line
• Proc. Food cans • Beverage cans • Aerosols
The Tinplate Company of India Limited
Solution Centre: Print & Lacquering First Step Towards “Metal Packaging Solution Provider”
• Paints & Pesticides cans
Can fabricators/ Closure Makers
• Crowns & Closures
Food Processors / Fillers
• ……. Retailers / Consumers
2
Tinplate belongs to packaging industry Identify the industry where you compete
Available Alternatives • Tinplate •Glass • Bag in Box • PVC / HDPE / PET • Tetra pack / laminates • Aluminium
Criteria of Choice •Product Protection •Shelf Presentation •Usage Convenience •Cost •Design Flexibility •Eco-friendliness • Shape-ability
3
Hard facts…. Know your strengths
• • • • • •
Ultra violet protection Barrier properties / Inertness High shelf life Eco-friendly and WTO compliant Tamper proof / Impermeability / Rigidity Excellent printability
Tinplate has held its niche position in food packaging over the last 200 years
4
Packaging is at heart of Marketing Strategy Assess where you fit into your customer’s business
5
Global Perspectives Define / stretch the boundaries of your business STRUCTURE
•
• •
Demand driven by food & beverage Research in Steel
CONDUCT
• •
PERFORMANCE
•
Steel research with can-maker
•
Cost competitiveness
•
Environmental and hygiene concerns
Light weighting; Shapeablity
Strong Regulatory Mechanism 3.2mtÈ
4.2mt È
1.0mtÇ
Implications for an Indian player
There is growth / consolidation Become World Class
1.0mtÇ
3.3mtÇ
1.4mtÇ
1.4mtÇ
6 World:
15.5 mtÇ
India – interesting consumer trends Are there opportunities / threats in the external environment?
India - Interesting Consumer Trends too
‘Green’ consumers Changing eating habits
Healthy food
Working women
Value - for - Money
ng i ow ods r Shopping Ambience g o s df i g se n Service i l es i a t oc e R pr Choice in
Hygiene Traditional Kirana
Value added Kirana
Self Service Kirana
Single departmental store
Small Organized Retail
Organized Retail
Hyper 7 & Malls Markets
Strategic Planning involves…
Running the Business
a h C
in g n
he t g
w y wa
o d e
ss e in s bu
We have used different tools over the years…..
8
Strategy Map / BSC • Four perspectives of BSC: – How do we appear to shareholders? (Investorfriendly) – How do customers see us? (Customer Perception) •Enables to consider – What must we excel at? cause-and-effect (Strategic focus) relationships between – Can we continue to different key performance improve and create value? (Business Sustainability) indicators (KPIs) of a BSC • Helps with a picture of where the company stands-and 9 where it's headed.
•Link long-term plan or competitive strategy with operational activities
10
Strategic Planning Process
11
Envisioning Evolved over the years: 8 Downstream steel processing unit 9Provide cost effective metal packaging solutions for processed edibles
Vision: We shall offer world class tin mill products at competitive terms and strive for exceeding customer expectations by delivering added advantages
12
Strategy Alignment Process Vision Strategic Element Challenges Competition from Tinplate manufacturers.
Value creation
Servicing packaging needs
Increasing Expectations of shareholders
Cost Competitiveness. .
Strategic Advantages Knowledge base of Indian markets Processing costs HRC from Tata Steel Pan India presence Consistently exporting 25-30%. Largest Manufacturing facility in Asia.
Scale of Operations
Volatility in raw materials
Strategic Sourcing
Sourcing HRC & physical proximity to Tata Steel
Threat from Substitutes
Product range customer retention and Business development.
Full product range manufacturer in India. Downstream presence.
Acquiring and retaining talent
Green future
Key Success Factors
Meet community expectations and changing Environmental requirements.
Core Competency Value added and cost effective
Value added and cost effective
Reliable and cost effective
Creation of World class workforce & retaining talent
Sense of belongingness, allegiance and team work. Tata Brand. Infrastructure (Town, Hospital etc)
Value added
Partnering with community and Climate change initiatives . Interface with Govt Agencies
89 year old relationship with neighboring community. Heading Tinplate promotion council and ITRI
Value added
13
Strategy Alignment Process VISION
STRATEGIC GOALS
STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES
MEASURES
Value Creation
Growth & Competitiveness
•Increase scale of operations •Become cost competitive •Enhanced shareholder value
• • • •
Capacity / Production / Sales Market share(%) Processing Cost(Rs./MT) ROIC & EVA
Service packaging
Supplier of choice
•Develop enhanced value proposition •Increase engagement across industry •Build international markets with a strategic intent
• • •
Downstream Sales % CSI Exports as a % of Operations
Greener future
Exemplar in Corporate sustainability Exciting & safe workplace
•Role Model in Corporate Sustainability
• •
Corporate Sustainability Index MBE Score
•Develop engaged workforce •Attain zero reportable accidents
•
Frequency rate, Severity rate, Severity Index, Near Miss ESI Training Satisfaction Index
• •
Strategic Challenges Strategic Objectives
ws
Corporate BSC Functional BSC KRA
/ e ad nt sc e C a ig n m al
Re vi e
14
KPI
Corporate BSC Stakeholder
Strategic Objectives
Strategic Measures
U O M
Type of Measure
Lag/ Lead
Actual 08-09
Target 09-10
10-11
11-12
Benchmarks/ Comparisons
Result Ref.
Strategic Action plan
Increase engagement across domestic industry (A1)
Customer (A)
Build international markets with a strategic intent (A2)
Develop enhanced value proposition and build consumer mindshare towards tinplate (A3)
Supplier (B)
Ensure raw material availability for sustainability of operations (B1)
Employee (C)
Develop engaged workforce (C2)
Government, Community & Society (D)
Role model in Corporate Citizenship (D1)
Shareholder/ Lender/ Promoter (E)
Enhance shareholder value (E1)
15
Benchmarking • Annual Reports/Published literature • Group companies • Suppliers/Customer interactions
Level of Activity KPM / Processes affected Comparison Industry Increase in speed of DR at Temper Mill CRM / ETP Process cost Industry Optimization of consumption of chemicals at ETP ETL Store-Stock Cost Operation Development of DR-9 for specific Lug Cap New Product / Application Industry applications developed Marketing Competition Develop 5&3 Liter edible-oil consumer pack No. of Packaging Solutions Group HR Leadership assessment and Development Plan Leadership System Companies Group Reduction in procurement rates of A class items CS Suppliers Management companies to be cost competitive Finance Group Cos. Reduction in cycle time for accounts closing Shareholders & promoters Area
Source / Mode Used Unique CORUS Imports at Oriental Cans, Mumbai Market Research / Survey Comparison with Tata Steel Best practices council of Materials management for TIS Group companies Comparison with TIS group companies 16
Building robust operational processes around world class practices To ramp to
Daily Work Management 379,000 MT
400000 350000
180000
WIN (world class workforce)
300000
Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) 250000 140000
De-bottlenecking (Goldratt) & 200000 150000 100000 50000
Growth Plan (Arcelor / Nippon) TOP (McKinsey’s) 100000
90000 Capacity ISO movement, Suggestion Box
60000
0 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01 01-02 02-03 03-04 04-05 05-06 06-07 07-08
'
Act 08-09
17
People, Sustainability, Controls have been built Workers’ business skills Risk Management process Succession Planning Inclusiveness Affirmative Actions Excellence Assessors BaaN ERP and Lotus Notes Balanced Score Cards Environment Systems Cadre of Business Managers Financial Restructuring Community Development Executive Information Systems 1999 2001
2005
2009 18
Customer and Market focus built on Industry and Company level strategies Marketing refocus
Consumer Mind Space Industry Level
Company Level
TINPLATE PROMOTION COUNCIL (↑ per capita consumption)
Key Account Management (McKinsey’s)
Long term position on exports
Solutions focus
Business development
Business Development Customer intimacy
Tinplate Promotion Council: International seminars and Award Nites Key Account Management (McKinsey’s) 2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2007
….changing mindsets to industry development and19 international competition
Sales Orientation to Marketing focus Alliance with major can makers Steel Maker
Tinplate Supplier
Can Fabricator
Food Processor / Filler
Industry level marketing initiatives to increase consumption levels on the lines of APEAL (European Mills)
TPC Awards Nite each year..… a landmark in this industry…. To promote innovation and convenience
20
Reaching down the value chain Capabilities:
Solution Center
Solution Center for differentiated value proposition - started with printing / lacquering facilities -next step: convenience features for tin cans or service center capabilities - partnerships with fabricators for improved visibility
Consumer research to understand consumer mindshare on packaging
TATA STEEL
TCIL
Can Fabrication
Food Processing
Retailer / 21 Consumer
The transformation… 1997-98
2008-09
Operations
60000 MT
+185000 MT
Employees
5000
~1700
Market Share
16-18%
~35%
Exports (% of total sales)
NIL
25%
EVA
-ve
+ve
22
Rewards & Recognitions JRDQV Award in 2007
CII-EXIM Prize in 2008
23
Tinplate and Food Safety
24
Understanding food safety ¾Tinplate product: -- The Substrate (Steel base on which tin coating is done) --Tinplate on account of Tin migration in packed food --Lacquered sheets ¾Future Regulatory Challenges Inputs to Strategic Planning
-- Abide by National and International Standards -- Facilitate creation / alignment of national / international standards with BIS / ITRI
25
Steel Substrate
Different grades (chemistry) of steel are used depending on end applications (either highly corrosive foods or not so aggressive foods) ¾Type L ¾Type MR ¾Type D
Tinplate
Standards are defined for allowable level of tin in food on account of tin migration Test are done at CFTRI to ensure tin migration within allowable range as per ATSDR standards (Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry USA), COT (Committee on Toxicity of Chemicals in Food UK)
Lacquered Tinplate
TCIL abides by US FDA Code Federal Regulation Section 21 Use of proper grade of Lacquers is based on requirement spelt out by filler who advises grade that is compatible with their 26 food product
Addressing future Regulatory challenges REACH (Registration , Evaluation and Authorisation of Hazardous chemicals) comes into enforcement in 2011 in Europe: TCIL is partnering ITRI UK to develop an alternate Passivation system to will help omit Chromium passivation without impacting fitness for use
27
Indian Food Processing Industry: Challenges and Food Safety
28
India has potential to be Food Factory to the World • 2nd largest arable land & divers agro climatic zones • Largest livestock population • Largest producer of milk, tea, pulses
Milk
Cattle / buffaloes
Largest Producer 91 Mn T
Largest in the world 283 million
F&V #2 in the world 129 Mn T (FAO) 150 Mn T (NHB) Fisheries Marine: 2.7 Mn T Inland : 3.1 Mn T
• 2nd largest food producer 2nd
• largest producer of fruits & vegetables, rice, sugarcane • 5th largest producer of eggs, wheat
Goat & Sheep 182 million
Food Grains #2 in the world (218 Mn T)
TEA Sugarcane
Largest Producer (0.85 Mn T)
# 2 in the world (245 Mn T)
• 6th largest producer of fish India produces 41% of world’s mango, 23% of Banana, 24 % of cashew nut, 10% of onion, 30% of cauliflower, 36% of Green Peas. India has 53% of world’s buffalo and 17% of goat, 8000 km of coastline 29 Source: FAO / NHB / Department of Animal Husbandry
Though the industry is large in size, it is still at a nascent stage Despite strong raw material base, dismal quantities are processed – – – – –
2 % of the fruits & vegetables 35% of milk 26% of marine 6% of poultry 20% of buffalo meat
Less than 1.5% share in international food trade – main reason is the rejection of food products in the developed countries on ground of environmental & safety standards. 30
Food processing sector – a valuable link between Agriculture & Industry 15000
Vision 2015: Action Plan for Food Processing Industries in India to triple market size (CAGR 10.6%)
13,500
14000
Market Potential (INR bn)
Government’s commitment to Food Processing in its
13000 12000 11000 10000
8,200
9000 8000 7000 6000 5000
4,600
4000 3000 2000 1000 0
2003-04
Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 unified 15 different food related laws.
2009-10
2014-15
Future growth of the food processing sector depends on adherence to safety and quality standards!!! 31
Food processing industry – various stakeholders Producers of additives / ingredients
Government & institutions
Farmers / Producers / feed producers
Food processors
Consumers
Financial institutions
Fillers / Packers
Food service outlets & caterers
Storage operators
Wholesalers / Retailers
Suppliers of equipment, cleaning & sanitization agents
Producers of pesticides, fertilizers & veterinary drugs Academic & research institutions
transporters
32
Standard Setting & Benchmarking WTO Rules for Standard setting by member countries (Multilateral – public – mandatory for member countries) Sanitary & Phytosanitary (SPS)
United Nations (Multilateral – public – mandatory for signatory countries)
need
WTO Recognized standards (Multilateral – public – reference standards for member countries)
Trade Related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS)
We
Technical Barriers to trade (TBT)
to
Codex Alimentarius Commission (CAC) - Internal Plant Protection Convention; World Organization for Animal Health (OIE) International Organization for Standardization (ISO)
upgrade
Collective standards (Sub sector networks, company networks & alike) Global Food Safety Initiatives (GFSI) – recognized standards: HACCP, GAP, GHP, GMP, etc
Organic farming
Corporate standards (individual company codes / specifications) Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
33
Stakeholders’ Strategic challenges towards Food Safety & Quality Stakeholders
Food Processors
Packaging Industry Transporters Wholesalers /Retailers Consumers Govt & institutions
Responsibility lies across the Food Chain
Producers / farmers
Strategic Challenges •Skills / awareness (Quality Stds / Good Practices) •Quality inputs (seeds / feed / fertilizers) •Eliminate wastages •Skill development •Quality of raw materials •Regulations •Skills / awareness (Quality Stds / Good Practices) •Connectivity (rail / road / air) •Cold chain infrastructure •Food Inspection •Traceability •Safe & nutritious food •Quality sensitivity & awareness •Compliance to regulations •Traceability
34
Thank You
visit us @ www.tatatinplate.com
35