Birther Case List
This document was uploaded by user and they confirmed that they have the permission to share it. If you are author or own the copyright of this book, please report to us by using this DMCA report form. Report DMCA
Overview
Download & View Birther Case List as PDF for free.
More details
- Words: 3,726
- Pages: 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Allen v. Soetoro FOIA Kenneth L. Allen
Federal Court District of Arizona 4:09-cv-00373 Justia - RECAP 2
Pending (Docket) Partial Motion to Dismiss Pending
American Grand Jury Mack H. Ellis|Donald McDougall
Federal Court TN Middle District 3:2009mc00215 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
American Grand Jury 3 Robert C. Laity; Robert J. Campbell
Federal Court NY Western District No # Assigned
REJECTED
Ankeny v. Daniels Steve Ankeny
Barnett Keyes et al v Obama et al Pamela Barnett
1
ir e
Federal Court: CA Central District 8:09-cv-00082-DOC-AN Justia - RECAP
F
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
l o
P f ---
o s
d n
Indiana State Court Marion Superior Court 49D10-0812-PL-55511
Appellate Court
---
DISMISSED
Indiana Appellate Court 49A02-0904-CV-353 DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
DISMISSED
9th Circuit: Robinson/Drake: 09-56827 Pending
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Gov. defending
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No ---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a defendant
No Gov. defending
Note: Birthers claim that Obama has spent "millions" of dollars defending all the birther claims. As shown in this chart, Obama's personal (or campaign) attorneys have appeared only in a very very few number of cases. 2 Note: The Justia has easy-to-read explanations of all the various filings. The RECAP, while not as reader-friendly, has links to many of the pleadings filed in the case. 3 Note: American Grand Jury has attempted to file multiple additional "presentments," in the following courts: Alabama Federal Court – Southern District (Donald Gaines); Connecticut Supreme Court (Unknown); Florida Federal Court – Northern District (Norman Caron); Kansas State Court (Wichita/18th Judicial District) (Bradley Kramer); New Hampshire State Court (Salem District) (Unknown); Tennessee Federal Court – Western District (Donald McDougall); Middle District Texas Federal Court – Western District (Lesley Lawson). To date, however, there is no indication that any of these courts have accepted the documents as filed and, therefore, they are not "pending."
r F
m o
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 1 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
6.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court PA Eastern District 2:08-cv-04083-RBS Justia - RECAP
Berg v. Obama et al Philip Berg
DISMISSED
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
3rd Circuit: 08-4340 Pending Appeal Emgcy Motion: DENIED 2nd Emgcy Motion: DENIED
l o
P f
Appeal DISMISSAL AFFIRMED 7.
8.
9.
10.
Federal Court: District of DC 1:2008cv01933 Justia - RECAP
Berg v. Obama Philip Berg False Claims Act Case
Federal Court CA Eastern District 1:08-cv-01538-AWIGSA Justia - RECAP
Beverly v. FEC Arnold Dewalt Beverly
Brockhausen v. Andrade Jody A. Brockhausen
m o
Broe v. Reed James Broe
r F
d n
F
Washington State Supreme Court 82473-8
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i
Application (08A391) DENIED Application (08A505) DENIED Rule 11 Writ (08-570) DENIED
DC Circuit: 09-5362 Pending
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
Yes
No Gov. defending
No
DISMISSED
9th Circuit: 09-15562 DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
---
Obama not a Defendant
DISMISSED
---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Action filed in Supreme Court
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
ir e
Texas State Court Williamson County, (368th Judicial District) 08-1001-C365
o s
DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
c . b
Supreme Court
DISMISSED
No
No ---
Obama not a Defendant
Page 2 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
The Church of Jesus Christ Christian/Aryan Nations of Missouri et al v. Obama et al
Cohen v. Obama L. Charles Cohen
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
DISMISSED (under seal)
---
Federal Court DC District Court 1:2008cv02150 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
Florida State Court State Supreme Court SC08-2338
Connerat v. Obama W. Spencer Connerat III
Florida State Court Pinellas County Small Claims Court No. 09003103SC
Connerat v. Obama W. Spencer Connerat III
Florida State Court Pinellas County Small Claims Court No. 09005522SC
Constitution Party v. Lingle Alan Keyes
Hawaii Supreme Court: No. 29743
r F
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Appellate Court
Federal Court MO Western District 6:2008cv03405 Justia - RECAP
Connerat v. Browning W. Spencer Connerat III
m o
Trial/Original Court
DISMISSED
d n
DISMISSED
ir e
F
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
P f
o s
Action filed in Supreme Court
DISMISSED
Action filed in Supreme Court
DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
l o
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
Unknown
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
---
---
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No ---
---
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
Page 3 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
Filed in Case No. Docket
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Cook v. Good et al Stefan Cook
Federal Court: GA Middle District 4:2009cv00082 Justia - RECAP
TRO DENIED CASE DISMISSED
Cook v. Simtech, et al Stefan Cook
Federal Court FL Middle District 8:2009cv01382 Justia - RECAP
TRO DENIED; CASE DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
Craig v. US Steven Lee Craig
Federal Court OK Western District 5:09-cv-00343-F Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED Leave to Amend DENIED
Dawson v. Obama Kenneth D. Dawson
Federal Court CA Eastern District 2:2008cv02754 Justia - RECAP
Donofrio v Wells Leo Donofrio
m o
Ealey v. Sarah Obama James E. Ealey
r F
F
Federal Court TX Southern District 4:08-mc-00504 Justia - RECAP
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
11th Circuit: 09-14698C Appeal DISMISSED
DISMISSED Recommendation & Order
Action filed in Appeals Court
APPLICATION DENIED
l o
P f ---
o s
d n
ir e
New Jersey State Court
Appellate Court
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
10th Circuit: 09-6082 DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
Writ DENIED (08-10817)
---
---
NJ Supreme Court APPLICATION DENIED
Application DENIED (08A407)
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Gov. defended
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
No DISMISSED
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
---
Obama not a Defendant; Court dismissed sua sponte
Page 4 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
23.
24.
25.
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court KY Eastern District 08-379-GFVT Justia - RECAP
Essek v. Obama Daniel John Essek
Fitzpatrick v. Obama 4 Walter Fitzpatrick III
Unconfirmed North Carolina State Court Tennessee State Court
Greenberg v. Brunner Carol L. Greenberg
Ohio State Court Wood Cty. Com. Pleas Ct 2008CV1024
Hamblin v Obama, (Obama & McCain) Clark Hamblin
4
Trial/Original Court
Federal Court Arizona District 2:2009cv00410 Justia - RECAP
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
---
DISMISSED
o s
(SOS Report, p. 15; Docket)
Costs Assessed against Plaintiff
d n
DISMISSED
l o
P f
DISMISSED
ir e
F
Appellate Court
---
9th Circuit: 09-17014 APPEAL DISMISSED
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No ---
---
Obama not a Defendant
No Gov. defended
Note: According to some websites, Fitzpatrick has filed a few complaints against Obama, including, most recently, a "criminal complaint" reportedly filed with the Clerk of Court, Catawba County, NC, File #09R81 (see American Grand Jury ("AGJ" Article); and an alleged grand jury presentment in Tennessee (see AGJ Article). To date, no official record (docket, etc.) has been located; and court personnel could not confirm the accuracy of these reports. Upon confirmation of the NC state court case, either or both of these cases, we will update the chart accordingly to note such cases as pending and/or resolved. Nov. 30 Update: According to a spokesperson for the County D.A.'s office, the reason for Fitzpatrick's appearance is in regards to his charge of obstruction against the jury foreman and the assistant D.A. stemming from when he was removed from the grand jury at his prior appearance and his "charge of treason" rejected by them. The December 1, 2009 appearance has absolutely nothing to do with his treason charge against President Obama, which is not being reconsidered.
r F
m o
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 5 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Herbert v. Obama & US Susan Herbert
Federal Court FL Middle District 3:08-cv-01164-HESTEM Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED Recommendation & Order
Herbert v. US, John Roberts, et al Susan Herbert
Federal Court FL Middle District 3:08-cv-00634-TJCMCR Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Federal Court FL Middle District 3:2008cv01201 Justia - RECAP
Herbert v. US, Obama, John Roberts Susan Herbert
Hollander v. McCain Fred Hollander
Federal Court New Hampshire District 1:2008cv00099 Justia - RECAP
Hollister v. Soetoro Gregory S. Hollister
r F
m o
F
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
---
l o
o s
P f ---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
th
11 Circuit: 09-10661 APPEAL DISMISSED DISMISSED Recommendation & Order (sua sponte as frivolous and wholly without merit)
d n
ir e
Federal Court DC District 1:2008cv02254 Justia - RECAP
Appellate Court
Writ DENIED (09-6777)
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No
DISMISSED
---
DISMISSED Sanctions Imposed
DC Circuit: 09-5161 (Sanctions: 09-5080) Pending
---
Obama not a Defendant
Yes
Page 6 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
DISMISSED
Federal Court Nevada District 2:2008cv01162 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Federal Court NJ District 1:09-cv-00253-JBS-JS Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Judy v. McCain Cody Robert Judy
Keyes v. Bowen Alan Keyes
CA State Court Sacramento Cty Sup. Ct Court 34200880000096CUWMGDS
m o
r F
F
WA State Court
King County Superior Ct.
08-2-34955-1 SEA
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
5th Circuit: 09-10246 APPEAL DISMISSED
o s
d n
l o
P f ---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
3rd Circuit: 09-4209 Pending
Action filed in Supreme Court
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
Application DENIED (08A524)
---
---
DISMISSED (Docket)
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
No
CA Court of Appeals C062321 Pending
DISMISSED
"Obama Defense" 1
Gov. defending
DISMISSED Costs Assessed against Plaintiff
ir e
CA Supreme Court No. 168690(?)
Lightfoot v. Bowen Gail Lightfoot Marquis v. Reed Steven Marquis
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court TX Northern District 2:2008cv00232 Justia - RECAP
Hunter v. US Supreme Court, et al Darrel Reece Hunter
Kerchner et al v. Obama et al Charles F. Kerchner
Trial/Original Court
Yes
No Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
Page 7 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
Filed in Case No. Docket
Martin v Lingle Andy Martin
HI State Court HI Supreme Court 29414
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Morrow v. Barak Humane Obama Susan A. Morrow
Federal Court FL Southern District 1:2008cv22345 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Neal v. Brunner
Ohio State Court Wood Cty. Com. Pleas Ct 2008CV72726
Neely v. Obama Gerald Lee Neely
r F
m o
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
l o
Haw. Ct. Appeals APPEAL DISMISSED (Docket) Haw. Sup. Ct. Writ DENIED
o s
P f
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
No
---
---
DISMISSED (SOS Report, p. 15; Docket)
---
---
Obama not a Defendant
DISMISSED Sua Sponte
---
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
d n
ir e
F
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
APPLICATION DENIED
DISMISSED (Docket)
Federal Court MI Eastern District 2:08-cv-1523 Justia - RECAP
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
Action filed in Supreme Court
HI State Court HI District Court 1CC08-1-002147
Martin v Lingle Andy Martin
Appellate Court
Obama not a Defendant
No
No
Page 8 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
42.
43.
44.
45.
5
Filed in Case No. Docket
Patriot's Heart Network v Soetoro
Federal Court DC Circuit 1:09-mc-00442-RCL Justia - RECAP
In re Paul Andrew Mitchell 5 Paul Andrew Mitchell
Federal Court PA Eastern District 2:08-cv-04083-RBS Justia - RECAP
Rhodes v. Gates Connie Rhodes
Federal Court TX Western District 5:09-cv-00703-XR Justia - RECAP
Rhodes v.MacDonald Connie Rhodes
r F
m o
Federal Court GA Middle District 4:09-cv-00106-CDL Justia - RECAP
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
F
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
DISMISSED
---
DISMISSED
3rd Circuit
304 Fed.Appx. 113, 2008 WL 5381436
d n
P f
Writ DENIED
TRO DENIED & CASE DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED Sanctions Imposed Final Sanctions Order
l o
Writ of Mandamus (08-4443)
o s
TRO DENIED; DISMISSED
ir e
Appellate Court
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No
---
---
---
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No th
11 Circuit Docket: 09-5418BB Appeal of Sanctions Only Pending (Notice)
Gov. defended
Note: Paul Andrew Mitchell has sought to intervene in multiple birther cases of which this is just one. Because he filed "substantive" briefs with this case/appeal, it is included as a separate case.
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 9 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
6
Robinson v. Bowen (McCain) Markham Robinson
Roy v. [The World] 6 Kamal Kama Roy
Schneller v. Cortes James D. Schneller
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court CA Northern District 3:2008cv03836 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Everywhere*
DISMISSED See Note*
Alabama State Court Montgomery County CV-2008-1906 7
Spuck v. Secretary of State
Ohio State Court Erie County C.P. 2008CV1116
m o
d n
ir e
F
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
---
DISMISSED
DISMISSED (SOS Report, p. 15)
l o
P f
o s
PA State Supreme Court Action filed in Supreme Court Application DENIED 199 MM 2008
Sorensen v. Riley (Obama & McCain) Harold Sorenson
r F
Trial/Original Court
---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
Application DENIED (08A592) Writ DENIED (08-9797) with comments
---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No No defense req'd Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
No State defended; No Obama atty appeared
No ---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Note: Kamal Kama Roy has filed well over a dozen lawsuits, many naming Obama. Although the pleadings are utterly unintelligible, at least a few of his pleadings have included references to various birther claims. The courts always dismiss these cases, typically sua sponte, a frivolous and unintelligible, shortly after he files them. 7 Note: Requires paid subscription to access court documents: Complaint; Motion to Dismiss; Motion to Dismiss Granted. Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 10 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
8
Stamper v. US Gordon Allen Stamper
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court Ohio Northern District 1:08-cv-02593-JG Justia - RECAP
30th Dist. Court (Ingham County)
Strunk v. Patterson Christopher Earl Strunk
NY State Court King County Supreme (Trial) Court 029641/2008
Strunk v. Patterson Christopher Earl Strunk
NY State Court King County Supreme (Trial) Court 029642/2008
Strunk v. NY State Board of Elections Christopher Earl Strunk
Federal Court NY Eastern District 1:2008cv04289 Justia - RECAP
m o
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
"Appeal from this decision could not be taken in good faith"
l o
Michigan App. Ct. No. 291681 Appeal DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
P f
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
No defense req'd Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Unclear (See Docket) 8
---
---
DISMISSED
2d Circuit: 08-5422 APPEAL DISMISSED
---
o s
DISMISSED
d n
ir e
---
c . b
Supreme Court
---
DISMISSED
No. 08-140-MM
F
Appellate Court
DISMISSED
MI State Court
Stumpo v. Granholm Paul Joseph Stumpo, John Carlos Cruz
r F
Trial/Original Court
No
No Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
Note: On November 24, 2009, the Trial Court declined to enter a protective order requested by Strunk in this case.
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 11 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
9
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court DC District Court 1:2008cv02234 Justia - RECAP
Strunk v U.S. Department of State (FOIA) Christopher Earl Strunk 9
Pending Discovery Stayed Motions to Dismiss Pending
Sullivan v. Marshall Lt. Col. Donald Sullivan
NC State Superior Court 08CVS-021393 RSOL
DISMISSED (per RSOL)
Super American Grand Jury Carl Swensson
Federal Court DC District Court 1:09-mc-00346-RCL Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED Motion for Reconsideration Order
Thomas v. Hosemann Daniel Scott Thomas
Federal Court HI District Court 1:2008mc00280 Justia - RECAP
Thomas v. Hosemann Daniel Scott Thomas
Federal Court Miss. District Court 2:08-cv-00241-KS-MTP Justia - RECAP
r F
m o
F
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
Pre-Trial Ct Disposition DC Circuit: 08-5503 Writ DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED DC Circuit: 09-5322 Pending
DISMISSED
Voluntarily DISMISSED
l o
P f
o s
d n
ir e
Appellate Court
---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No
---
Obama not a Defendant
---
---
No defense req'd Court dismissed sua sponte
---
---
Voluntarily dismissed
No
No
No ---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Note: Strunk has filed multiple additional "nonbirther" cases against Obama and/or the Federal Government, including, but not limited to the following: 1:2008cv01196; 1:2009cv01249; and 1:2009cv01295.
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 12 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
61.
62.
Terry v. Handel Bryan Thomas Terry, Sr
Filed in Case No. Docket
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
GA State Court Fulton County # 08CV158774S
DISMISSED (Docket)
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
GA Supreme Court No. S09D0284 DISMISSED; Reconsideration DENIED No. S09A1373 DISMISSED
r F
m o
ir e
d n
F
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
o s
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti
i l o
P f
Wrotnowski v. Bysiewicz CT State Supreme Court Action filed in Supreme Court DISMISSED Cort Wrotnowski SC 18264
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
c . b
Supreme Court
---
Application DENIED (08A469)
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
Page 13 of 13
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Allen v. Soetoro FOIA Kenneth L. Allen
Federal Court District of Arizona 4:09-cv-00373 Justia - RECAP 2
Pending (Docket) Partial Motion to Dismiss Pending
American Grand Jury Mack H. Ellis|Donald McDougall
Federal Court TN Middle District 3:2009mc00215 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
American Grand Jury 3 Robert C. Laity; Robert J. Campbell
Federal Court NY Western District No # Assigned
REJECTED
Ankeny v. Daniels Steve Ankeny
Barnett Keyes et al v Obama et al Pamela Barnett
1
ir e
Federal Court: CA Central District 8:09-cv-00082-DOC-AN Justia - RECAP
F
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
l o
P f ---
o s
d n
Indiana State Court Marion Superior Court 49D10-0812-PL-55511
Appellate Court
---
DISMISSED
Indiana Appellate Court 49A02-0904-CV-353 DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
DISMISSED
9th Circuit: Robinson/Drake: 09-56827 Pending
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Gov. defending
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No ---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a defendant
No Gov. defending
Note: Birthers claim that Obama has spent "millions" of dollars defending all the birther claims. As shown in this chart, Obama's personal (or campaign) attorneys have appeared only in a very very few number of cases. 2 Note: The Justia has easy-to-read explanations of all the various filings. The RECAP, while not as reader-friendly, has links to many of the pleadings filed in the case. 3 Note: American Grand Jury has attempted to file multiple additional "presentments," in the following courts: Alabama Federal Court – Southern District (Donald Gaines); Connecticut Supreme Court (Unknown); Florida Federal Court – Northern District (Norman Caron); Kansas State Court (Wichita/18th Judicial District) (Bradley Kramer); New Hampshire State Court (Salem District) (Unknown); Tennessee Federal Court – Western District (Donald McDougall); Middle District Texas Federal Court – Western District (Lesley Lawson). To date, however, there is no indication that any of these courts have accepted the documents as filed and, therefore, they are not "pending."
r F
m o
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 1 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
6.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court PA Eastern District 2:08-cv-04083-RBS Justia - RECAP
Berg v. Obama et al Philip Berg
DISMISSED
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
3rd Circuit: 08-4340 Pending Appeal Emgcy Motion: DENIED 2nd Emgcy Motion: DENIED
l o
P f
Appeal DISMISSAL AFFIRMED 7.
8.
9.
10.
Federal Court: District of DC 1:2008cv01933 Justia - RECAP
Berg v. Obama Philip Berg False Claims Act Case
Federal Court CA Eastern District 1:08-cv-01538-AWIGSA Justia - RECAP
Beverly v. FEC Arnold Dewalt Beverly
Brockhausen v. Andrade Jody A. Brockhausen
m o
Broe v. Reed James Broe
r F
d n
F
Washington State Supreme Court 82473-8
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i
Application (08A391) DENIED Application (08A505) DENIED Rule 11 Writ (08-570) DENIED
DC Circuit: 09-5362 Pending
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
Yes
No Gov. defending
No
DISMISSED
9th Circuit: 09-15562 DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
---
Obama not a Defendant
DISMISSED
---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Action filed in Supreme Court
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
ir e
Texas State Court Williamson County, (368th Judicial District) 08-1001-C365
o s
DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
c . b
Supreme Court
DISMISSED
No
No ---
Obama not a Defendant
Page 2 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
The Church of Jesus Christ Christian/Aryan Nations of Missouri et al v. Obama et al
Cohen v. Obama L. Charles Cohen
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
DISMISSED (under seal)
---
Federal Court DC District Court 1:2008cv02150 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
Florida State Court State Supreme Court SC08-2338
Connerat v. Obama W. Spencer Connerat III
Florida State Court Pinellas County Small Claims Court No. 09003103SC
Connerat v. Obama W. Spencer Connerat III
Florida State Court Pinellas County Small Claims Court No. 09005522SC
Constitution Party v. Lingle Alan Keyes
Hawaii Supreme Court: No. 29743
r F
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Appellate Court
Federal Court MO Western District 6:2008cv03405 Justia - RECAP
Connerat v. Browning W. Spencer Connerat III
m o
Trial/Original Court
DISMISSED
d n
DISMISSED
ir e
F
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
P f
o s
Action filed in Supreme Court
DISMISSED
Action filed in Supreme Court
DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
l o
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
Unknown
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
---
---
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No ---
---
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
Page 3 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
Filed in Case No. Docket
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Cook v. Good et al Stefan Cook
Federal Court: GA Middle District 4:2009cv00082 Justia - RECAP
TRO DENIED CASE DISMISSED
Cook v. Simtech, et al Stefan Cook
Federal Court FL Middle District 8:2009cv01382 Justia - RECAP
TRO DENIED; CASE DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
Craig v. US Steven Lee Craig
Federal Court OK Western District 5:09-cv-00343-F Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED Leave to Amend DENIED
Dawson v. Obama Kenneth D. Dawson
Federal Court CA Eastern District 2:2008cv02754 Justia - RECAP
Donofrio v Wells Leo Donofrio
m o
Ealey v. Sarah Obama James E. Ealey
r F
F
Federal Court TX Southern District 4:08-mc-00504 Justia - RECAP
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
11th Circuit: 09-14698C Appeal DISMISSED
DISMISSED Recommendation & Order
Action filed in Appeals Court
APPLICATION DENIED
l o
P f ---
o s
d n
ir e
New Jersey State Court
Appellate Court
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
10th Circuit: 09-6082 DISMISSAL AFFIRMED
Writ DENIED (08-10817)
---
---
NJ Supreme Court APPLICATION DENIED
Application DENIED (08A407)
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Gov. defended
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
No DISMISSED
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
---
Obama not a Defendant; Court dismissed sua sponte
Page 4 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
23.
24.
25.
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court KY Eastern District 08-379-GFVT Justia - RECAP
Essek v. Obama Daniel John Essek
Fitzpatrick v. Obama 4 Walter Fitzpatrick III
Unconfirmed North Carolina State Court Tennessee State Court
Greenberg v. Brunner Carol L. Greenberg
Ohio State Court Wood Cty. Com. Pleas Ct 2008CV1024
Hamblin v Obama, (Obama & McCain) Clark Hamblin
4
Trial/Original Court
Federal Court Arizona District 2:2009cv00410 Justia - RECAP
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
---
DISMISSED
o s
(SOS Report, p. 15; Docket)
Costs Assessed against Plaintiff
d n
DISMISSED
l o
P f
DISMISSED
ir e
F
Appellate Court
---
9th Circuit: 09-17014 APPEAL DISMISSED
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No ---
---
Obama not a Defendant
No Gov. defended
Note: According to some websites, Fitzpatrick has filed a few complaints against Obama, including, most recently, a "criminal complaint" reportedly filed with the Clerk of Court, Catawba County, NC, File #09R81 (see American Grand Jury ("AGJ" Article); and an alleged grand jury presentment in Tennessee (see AGJ Article). To date, no official record (docket, etc.) has been located; and court personnel could not confirm the accuracy of these reports. Upon confirmation of the NC state court case, either or both of these cases, we will update the chart accordingly to note such cases as pending and/or resolved. Nov. 30 Update: According to a spokesperson for the County D.A.'s office, the reason for Fitzpatrick's appearance is in regards to his charge of obstruction against the jury foreman and the assistant D.A. stemming from when he was removed from the grand jury at his prior appearance and his "charge of treason" rejected by them. The December 1, 2009 appearance has absolutely nothing to do with his treason charge against President Obama, which is not being reconsidered.
r F
m o
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 5 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Herbert v. Obama & US Susan Herbert
Federal Court FL Middle District 3:08-cv-01164-HESTEM Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED Recommendation & Order
Herbert v. US, John Roberts, et al Susan Herbert
Federal Court FL Middle District 3:08-cv-00634-TJCMCR Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Federal Court FL Middle District 3:2008cv01201 Justia - RECAP
Herbert v. US, Obama, John Roberts Susan Herbert
Hollander v. McCain Fred Hollander
Federal Court New Hampshire District 1:2008cv00099 Justia - RECAP
Hollister v. Soetoro Gregory S. Hollister
r F
m o
F
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
---
l o
o s
P f ---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
th
11 Circuit: 09-10661 APPEAL DISMISSED DISMISSED Recommendation & Order (sua sponte as frivolous and wholly without merit)
d n
ir e
Federal Court DC District 1:2008cv02254 Justia - RECAP
Appellate Court
Writ DENIED (09-6777)
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No
DISMISSED
---
DISMISSED Sanctions Imposed
DC Circuit: 09-5161 (Sanctions: 09-5080) Pending
---
Obama not a Defendant
Yes
Page 6 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
DISMISSED
Federal Court Nevada District 2:2008cv01162 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Federal Court NJ District 1:09-cv-00253-JBS-JS Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Judy v. McCain Cody Robert Judy
Keyes v. Bowen Alan Keyes
CA State Court Sacramento Cty Sup. Ct Court 34200880000096CUWMGDS
m o
r F
F
WA State Court
King County Superior Ct.
08-2-34955-1 SEA
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
5th Circuit: 09-10246 APPEAL DISMISSED
o s
d n
l o
P f ---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
3rd Circuit: 09-4209 Pending
Action filed in Supreme Court
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
Application DENIED (08A524)
---
---
DISMISSED (Docket)
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
No
CA Court of Appeals C062321 Pending
DISMISSED
"Obama Defense" 1
Gov. defending
DISMISSED Costs Assessed against Plaintiff
ir e
CA Supreme Court No. 168690(?)
Lightfoot v. Bowen Gail Lightfoot Marquis v. Reed Steven Marquis
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court TX Northern District 2:2008cv00232 Justia - RECAP
Hunter v. US Supreme Court, et al Darrel Reece Hunter
Kerchner et al v. Obama et al Charles F. Kerchner
Trial/Original Court
Yes
No Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
Page 7 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
Filed in Case No. Docket
Martin v Lingle Andy Martin
HI State Court HI Supreme Court 29414
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Morrow v. Barak Humane Obama Susan A. Morrow
Federal Court FL Southern District 1:2008cv22345 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Neal v. Brunner
Ohio State Court Wood Cty. Com. Pleas Ct 2008CV72726
Neely v. Obama Gerald Lee Neely
r F
m o
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
l o
Haw. Ct. Appeals APPEAL DISMISSED (Docket) Haw. Sup. Ct. Writ DENIED
o s
P f
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
No
---
---
DISMISSED (SOS Report, p. 15; Docket)
---
---
Obama not a Defendant
DISMISSED Sua Sponte
---
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
d n
ir e
F
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
APPLICATION DENIED
DISMISSED (Docket)
Federal Court MI Eastern District 2:08-cv-1523 Justia - RECAP
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
Action filed in Supreme Court
HI State Court HI District Court 1CC08-1-002147
Martin v Lingle Andy Martin
Appellate Court
Obama not a Defendant
No
No
Page 8 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
42.
43.
44.
45.
5
Filed in Case No. Docket
Patriot's Heart Network v Soetoro
Federal Court DC Circuit 1:09-mc-00442-RCL Justia - RECAP
In re Paul Andrew Mitchell 5 Paul Andrew Mitchell
Federal Court PA Eastern District 2:08-cv-04083-RBS Justia - RECAP
Rhodes v. Gates Connie Rhodes
Federal Court TX Western District 5:09-cv-00703-XR Justia - RECAP
Rhodes v.MacDonald Connie Rhodes
r F
m o
Federal Court GA Middle District 4:09-cv-00106-CDL Justia - RECAP
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
F
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
DISMISSED
---
DISMISSED
3rd Circuit
304 Fed.Appx. 113, 2008 WL 5381436
d n
P f
Writ DENIED
TRO DENIED & CASE DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED Sanctions Imposed Final Sanctions Order
l o
Writ of Mandamus (08-4443)
o s
TRO DENIED; DISMISSED
ir e
Appellate Court
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Court dismissed sua sponte
No Court dismissed sua sponte
No
---
---
---
---
Court dismissed sua sponte
No th
11 Circuit Docket: 09-5418BB Appeal of Sanctions Only Pending (Notice)
Gov. defended
Note: Paul Andrew Mitchell has sought to intervene in multiple birther cases of which this is just one. Because he filed "substantive" briefs with this case/appeal, it is included as a separate case.
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 9 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
6
Robinson v. Bowen (McCain) Markham Robinson
Roy v. [The World] 6 Kamal Kama Roy
Schneller v. Cortes James D. Schneller
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court CA Northern District 3:2008cv03836 Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED
Everywhere*
DISMISSED See Note*
Alabama State Court Montgomery County CV-2008-1906 7
Spuck v. Secretary of State
Ohio State Court Erie County C.P. 2008CV1116
m o
d n
ir e
F
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
---
DISMISSED
DISMISSED (SOS Report, p. 15)
l o
P f
o s
PA State Supreme Court Action filed in Supreme Court Application DENIED 199 MM 2008
Sorensen v. Riley (Obama & McCain) Harold Sorenson
r F
Trial/Original Court
---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
---
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
Application DENIED (08A592) Writ DENIED (08-9797) with comments
---
---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No No defense req'd Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
No State defended; No Obama atty appeared
No ---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Note: Kamal Kama Roy has filed well over a dozen lawsuits, many naming Obama. Although the pleadings are utterly unintelligible, at least a few of his pleadings have included references to various birther claims. The courts always dismiss these cases, typically sua sponte, a frivolous and unintelligible, shortly after he files them. 7 Note: Requires paid subscription to access court documents: Complaint; Motion to Dismiss; Motion to Dismiss Granted. Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 10 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
8
Stamper v. US Gordon Allen Stamper
Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court Ohio Northern District 1:08-cv-02593-JG Justia - RECAP
30th Dist. Court (Ingham County)
Strunk v. Patterson Christopher Earl Strunk
NY State Court King County Supreme (Trial) Court 029641/2008
Strunk v. Patterson Christopher Earl Strunk
NY State Court King County Supreme (Trial) Court 029642/2008
Strunk v. NY State Board of Elections Christopher Earl Strunk
Federal Court NY Eastern District 1:2008cv04289 Justia - RECAP
m o
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
"Appeal from this decision could not be taken in good faith"
l o
Michigan App. Ct. No. 291681 Appeal DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED
P f
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i ---
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
No defense req'd Court dismissed sua sponte
No Obama not a Defendant
---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Unclear (See Docket) 8
---
---
DISMISSED
2d Circuit: 08-5422 APPEAL DISMISSED
---
o s
DISMISSED
d n
ir e
---
c . b
Supreme Court
---
DISMISSED
No. 08-140-MM
F
Appellate Court
DISMISSED
MI State Court
Stumpo v. Granholm Paul Joseph Stumpo, John Carlos Cruz
r F
Trial/Original Court
No
No Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
Note: On November 24, 2009, the Trial Court declined to enter a protective order requested by Strunk in this case.
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 11 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Filed in Case No. Docket
Case Plaintiff's full name
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
9
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
Federal Court DC District Court 1:2008cv02234 Justia - RECAP
Strunk v U.S. Department of State (FOIA) Christopher Earl Strunk 9
Pending Discovery Stayed Motions to Dismiss Pending
Sullivan v. Marshall Lt. Col. Donald Sullivan
NC State Superior Court 08CVS-021393 RSOL
DISMISSED (per RSOL)
Super American Grand Jury Carl Swensson
Federal Court DC District Court 1:09-mc-00346-RCL Justia - RECAP
DISMISSED Motion for Reconsideration Order
Thomas v. Hosemann Daniel Scott Thomas
Federal Court HI District Court 1:2008mc00280 Justia - RECAP
Thomas v. Hosemann Daniel Scott Thomas
Federal Court Miss. District Court 2:08-cv-00241-KS-MTP Justia - RECAP
r F
m o
F
Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
Pre-Trial Ct Disposition DC Circuit: 08-5503 Writ DISMISSED Reconsideration DENIED DC Circuit: 09-5322 Pending
DISMISSED
Voluntarily DISMISSED
l o
P f
o s
d n
ir e
Appellate Court
---
c . b
Supreme Court
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti i
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No
---
Obama not a Defendant
---
---
No defense req'd Court dismissed sua sponte
---
---
Voluntarily dismissed
No
No
No ---
---
Obama not a Defendant
Note: Strunk has filed multiple additional "nonbirther" cases against Obama and/or the Federal Government, including, but not limited to the following: 1:2008cv01196; 1:2009cv01249; and 1:2009cv01295.
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
Page 12 of 13
m o
BIRTHER SCORECARD Case Plaintiff's full name
61.
62.
Terry v. Handel Bryan Thomas Terry, Sr
Filed in Case No. Docket
Trial/Original Court Total Cases: 62 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 60 Pending: 2 (FOIA)
GA State Court Fulton County # 08CV158774S
DISMISSED (Docket)
Appellate Court Total Appellate Rulings: 18 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 18 Pending: 5
GA Supreme Court No. S09D0284 DISMISSED; Reconsideration DENIED No. S09A1373 DISMISSED
r F
m o
ir e
d n
F
Last Updated: December 2, 2009 - 9:30:30 AM Latest Changes: Added explanations to defense column.
o s
Total SCT Rulings: 10 Birthers win: 0 Constitution wins: 10 Pending: 0
a j ti
i l o
P f
Wrotnowski v. Bysiewicz CT State Supreme Court Action filed in Supreme Court DISMISSED Cort Wrotnowski SC 18264
N/A: Original filing in Supreme Court
c . b
Supreme Court
---
Application DENIED (08A469)
"Obama Defense" 1
Total Cases: 62 Obama Defense: 3 Gov Defense: 7
No
Obama not a Defendant
No Obama not a Defendant
Page 13 of 13
Related Documents
Birther Case List
June 2020 6
Adr Case List - Copy.docx
June 2020 9
Case List Consti2.docx
November 2019 19
Amended Birther Complaint
May 2020 10
140370_mind List Case 1.docx
May 2020 6