Authenticity

Bentzion Abramovicz Sara Abramson

Pnina Adler

Feiga Adam Rika Auerbach Shabtai Augustowski

Chana Oslerner Moshe Aranowicz Micheline Aaronson Sara Obstbaum Mose Ogurek Liba Ozerowicz

A

Chajm Awroblanski Hersch Ojcer

Bernhard Altman Menachem Amsterdamski

Avraham Ostfeld

Salom Ostrer

Isaac Angel Chaim Anderman Sendl Apelbojm Eti Akselrad

Joshua Oselkas Jospa Ostrzega Szmil Oskola

Frida Openheimer Chana O

Authenticity is a relational and normative concept that acquire meaning through specific contexts, sites, and users. When people make places as stable material Boruch Order Chaja Orenstein Mirjam Ungar Josef Iwanier Elizabet Itzikzon Shifra Ickovski Jeno Ickovicz Matilda Eisner Elena Eiderman Machla Eidelsztein Benzion Eisenbaum Hersch Eisenthal Aharon Aineshtain Rivka Eis traces of the past they give form to their search for a timeless identity, for a mythic sense of self (NB, 214). Estera Ajszenbojm Dawid Eifermann Eduard Eberson Felix Ephraim Flora Ehrlich David Erlihman Else Ermann Georg Brinnitzer Lowis Ten Brink Magarete Goldztein Yedl Guttmann Rachel Gelbart Jacob Dayan Efraim Vai Klara Weinstein Feiga Weisberg Bejla Chrabolowski Esther Cohen

Bluma Kohn

Marie Cohen

Erzsebet Teufel Hedwig Teutsch Hinda Kirschenbaum

Roland Cohen

Jcchak Kohn Lea Kohn

Jacob Tenenbaum

Chana Laub Neny Lazar

Jonasz Tenenbaum Nathan Triebfeder Judith Joskovicz Samuel Kats Samuel Katz Shandor Katz

2

Erno Lautman Naftali Mehr Stefania Polak Mrisja Pikowski

Ester Pirovicz

3

Chana Choina Iankel Pirovicz Mayer P

Moszck Pirovicz Bluma Paist Yenta Paist Israel Paist Sara Paist Eva Peper Philip Peper Bertha Placzek Mejloch Placzek Minycha Prawidlo Tauba Pristin Movsha Pristin Genia Prenska Sua Pszygoda Israel Przygoda Aron F Bentzion Abramovicz Sara Abramson Pnina Adler Feiga Adam Rika Auerbach Shabtai Augustowski Chajm Awroblanski Bernhard Altman Menachem Amsterdamski Isaac Angel Chaim Anderman Sendl Apelbojm Eti Akselrad Chana Oslerner Moshe Aranowicz Micheline Aaronson Sara Obstbaum Mose Ogurek Liba Ozerowicz

Boruch Order

Chaja Orenstein Mirjam Ungar

Estera Ajszenbojm

Dawid Eifermann

Josef Iwanier

Esther Cohen

Bluma Kohn

Moszck Pirovicz Bluma Paist

Marie Cohen

Yenta Paist

Bentzion Abramovicz Sara Abramson

Elizabet Itzikzon Shifra Ickovski Jeno Ickovicz

Eduard Eberson Felix Ephraim

Klara Weinstein Feiga Weisberg Bejla Chrabolowski

Flora Ehrlich David Erlihman

Erzsebet Teufel Hedwig Teutsch Hinda Kirschenbaum

Roland Cohen

Jcchak Kohn Lea Kohn

Pnina Adler

Feiga Adam Rika Auerbach Shabtai Augustowski

Chaja Orenstein Mirjam Ungar

Estera Ajszenbojm

Dawid Eifermann

Josef Iwanier

Eduard Eberson Felix Ephraim

Klara Weinstein Feiga Weisberg Bejla Chrabolowski

Flora Ehrlich David Erlihman

Mejloch Placzek

Hersch Ojcer

Benzion Eisenbaum Hersch Eisenthal

Aharon Aineshtain

Rachel Gelbart

Jacob Dayan

Rivka Eis

Efraim Vai

Ester Pirovicz

Chana Choina Iankel Pirovicz Mayer P

Minycha Prawidlo Tauba Pristin Movsha Pristin Genia Prenska Sua Pszygoda Israel Przygoda

Bernhard Altman Menachem Amsterdamski

Avraham Ostfeld

Salom Ostrer

Aron F

Isaac Angel Chaim Anderman Sendl Apelbojm Eti Akselrad

Joshua Oselkas Jospa Ostrzega Szmil Oskola Benzion Eisenbaum Hersch Eisenthal

Georg Brinnitzer Lowis Ten Brink Magarete Goldztein Yedl Guttmann

Jacob Tenenbaum

Frida Openheimer Chana O

Jonasz Tenenbaum Nathan Triebfeder Judith Joskovicz Samuel Kats Samuel Katz Shandor Katz

Matilda Eisner Elena Eiderman Machla Eidelsztein

Else Ermann

Erzsebet Teufel Hedwig Teutsch Hinda Kirschenbaum

Joshua Oselkas Jospa Ostrzega Szmil Oskola

Erno Lautman Naftali Mehr Stefania Polak Mrisja Pikowski

Chajm Awroblanski

Elizabet Itzikzon Shifra Ickovski Jeno Ickovicz

Salom Ostrer

Georg Brinnitzer Lowis Ten Brink Magarete Goldztein Yedl Guttmann

Jacob Tenenbaum

Chana Laub Neny Lazar

Israel Paist Sara Paist Eva Peper Philip Peper Bertha Placzek

Avraham Ostfeld

Matilda Eisner Elena Eiderman Machla Eidelsztein

Else Ermann

Chana Oslerner Moshe Aranowicz Micheline Aaronson Sara Obstbaum Mose Ogurek Liba Ozerowicz

Boruch Order

Hersch Ojcer

Frida Openheimer Chana O

Aharon Aineshtain

Rachel Gelbart

Jacob Dayan

Rivka Eis

Efraim Vai

Jonasz Tenenbaum Nathan Triebfeder Judith Joskovicz Samuel Kats Samuel Katz Shandor Katz

and yet sporadic method to Pirovicz LibeskindsMayer P epiphany thatPolak Libeskind hadPikowski about the Ester world,Pirovicz depthNeny begins to unravel approach and Mehr first step thatKohn Libeskind took inChana the Laub styleRoland is The EstherLibeskind’s Cohen Blumadeconstructivist Kohn Marie Cohen Cohen Jcchak Lea Kohn Lazar Erno his Lautman Naftali Stefania Mrisja Chana Choina Iankel what allows him to be so authentic with all

winning design for the Extension to the

thought process (JM, 34).

which is that it is shattered in conflict. And I

magic. This magic created is the product

Moszck Pirovicz Bluma Paist Yenta Paist Israel Paist Sara Paist Eva Peper Philip Peper Bertha Placzek Mejloch Placzek Minycha Prawidlo Tauba Pristin Movsha Pristin Genia Prenska Sua Pszygoda Israel Przygoda Aron F show this as an example because of the way of discovery which I believe to be one of the work he does. The deconstructivist era Berlin museum was to breakdown the city Angel Chaim Akselrad Bentzion Abramovicz Sara Abramson Pnina Adler Feiga Adam Rika Auerbach Shabtai Augustowski Chajm Awroblanski Bernhard Altman Menachem Amsterdamski Sendl Apelbojm theAnderman main foundations of not justEti great and his team approachedIsaac the problem/ The official name of this project is ‘exten- he began after modernity. They wanted make a of Berlin itself and its history, which of

Liba Ozerowicz Aranowicz Micheline Aaronson Mose Ogurek Hersch Ostrer Joshua Ostrzegaarchitecture, Szmil Oskola Frida Openheimer project. They began by Oselkas dropping aJospa pot, which but architecture in gen-Chana O sion of the BerlinOjcer museumAvraham with theOstfeld Jewish Salom consists of the holocaust and Jewish Sara Obstbaum Chanabreak Oslerner fromMoshe the methods of modernity to course eral. Figure (5) is Aharon a drawing of the sum-Rivka Eis had bought earlier with the hope that it Hersch museum department,’ but I have called it heMachla mapped out names onIckovski a grid Jeno authentic style Mirjam since modernism Chaja Orenstein Ungar Josefresidents. Iwanier He Elizabet Itzikzon Shifra Ickovicz Matilda Eisner Elena Eiderman Eidelsztein Benzion Eisenbaum Eisenthal Aineshtain Boruchcreate Ordera new

between the lines, I call it this because it is a would contribute the design, out a one-story mation of the process of taking the in the city to begin developing an initial Flora Ehrlich David Erlihman Else Ermann Georg Brinnitzer Lowis Ten Brink Magarete Goldztein Yedl Guttmann Rachel Gelbart Jacob Dayan Efraim Vai shape for the museum. As you can see in project about two lines of thought, or orga- window. Directly after this they hurriedly ran world and literally shattering it. skind along with a few others saw this and Teutsch Hinda Kirschenbaum Jacob Tenenbaum Jonasz Tenenbaum Nathanthe Triebfeder Judith Samuel Kats Samuel Katz Shandor Katz Klara Weinstein Feiga Weisberg Bejla Chrabolowski Erzsebet Teufel Hedwig down to discover result. What theyJoskovicz found the collage in figure (1) he overlaid the Star nization and relationship. One is a straight acted upon it. I observed that by breaking Estherdown Cohenexisting Bluma Kohn Marie Cohen RolandofCohen Lea Kohn Chana Laub Neny LazarintoErno Lautman Naftali Polak Mrisja pieces Pikowski Choina Iankel Pirovicz Mayer P was Stefania a collection of broken theyEster calledPirovicz BelowChana in figure 6 is to me a generalizaline, but broken many fragments; the Mehr David onJcchak top of Kohn the city and then highconstructed things, the deconshards. Tauba He andPristin his team quickly thePrenska tion of authenticity in thePrzygoda extension Aron F otherPlaczek is a tortuous but continuing lighted lines.Eva One is thatPhilip of thePeper Berlin Bertha ablePaist to takeYenta away Paist unnecessary Moszckstructivist Pirovicz are Movsha Pristintook Genia Sua Pszygoda Israel Bluma Israel Paist Saratwo Paist Peper Mejlochline, Placzek Minycha Prawidlo larger pieces upstairs to the studio and began because even though its abstracted and infinitely (JM, 34). - Daniel Libeskind aspects of the thing, so form then begins to wall, the other is a the Spree river, and Klara Weinstein Feiga Weisberg Bejla Chrabolowski Erzsebet Teufel Hedwig Teutsch Hinda Kirschenbaum Jacob Tenenbaum Jonasz Tenenbaum Nathan Triebfeder Judith Joskovicz Samuel Kats Samuel Katz Shandor Katz to reconstruct what they had initially broken down one can read the symbol between them lies a portal to the truth of follow function, which oddly enough is not Estherunlike Cohenmodernism. Bluma Kohn Marie Cohen Rolandthe Cohen Jcchak Kohn Lea Kohn Chana Laub Neny Lazar Erno Lautman Naftali Mehr Stefania(BG, Polak Chana Choina Pirovicz Mayer P of a wrecked star thatIankel is reassembled 231,Mrisja 232).Pikowski The point Ester madePirovicz city’s past, the Museum. He so named Figure (3) is the Imperial War Museum destructed Moszck Pirovicz Bluma Paist Yenta Paist Israel Paist from this example is that there is a distinct inside Sua the Museum. the Sara project “Between the Lines” designed by Libeskind. It is the result of an Prawidlo Paist Eva Peper Philipwhich Peperin Bertha Placzek Mejloch Placzek Minycha Tauba Pristin Movsha Pristin Genia Prenska Pszygoda Israel Przygoda Aron F beginning Dawid to become inauthentic. LibeEsterawas Ajszenbojm Eifermann Eduard Eberson Felix Ephraim

Pnina Adler

Feiga Adam Rika Auerbach Shabtai Augustowski

Chajm Awroblanski

Bernhard Altman Menachem Amsterdamski

Libeskind

Bentzion Abramovicz Sara Abramson

Isaac Angel Chaim Anderman Sendl Apelbojm Eti Akselrad

Hersch of Ojcer Avraham Ostfeld Salomprocess Ostrer Joshua Oselkas Jospa Ostrzega Szmil Oskola Frida Openheimer Chana O The looseness Libeskind’s design is, to Ickovicz Matilda Elena Eiderman Eidelsztein Boruch Order Chaja Orenstein Mirjam Ungar Josef Iwanier Elizabet Itzikzon Shifra Ickovski me, Jeno what leads to Eisner his great work. Machla To the left, inBenzion Eisenbaum Hersch Eisenthal Aharon Aineshtain Rivka Eis Estera Ajszenbojm Dawid Eifermann Eduard Eberson Felix Ephraim Flora Ehrlich David Erlihman Else Ermann Georg Brinnitzer Lowis Ten Brink Magarete Goldztein Yedl Guttmann Rachel Gelbart Jacob Dayan Efraim Vai figure (4), is an initial sketch of the Jewish ExtenKlara Weinstein Feiga Weisberg Bejla Chrabolowski Erzsebet Teufel Hedwig Teutsch Hinda Kirschenbaum Jacob Tenenbaum Jonasz Tenenbaum Nathan Triebfeder Judith Joskovicz Samuel Kats Samuel Katz Shandor Katz tionLaub in Neny plan. This many otherStefania aspects of Pikowski Ester Pirovicz Chana Choina Iankel Pirovicz Mayer P Esther Cohen Bluma Kohn Marie Cohen Roland Cohen Jcchak Kohn Lea Kohn Chana Lazar Ernolike Lautman Naftali Mehr Polak Mrisja Moszck Pirovicz Bluma Paist Yenta Paist Israel Paist Sara Paist Eva Peper Philip Peper Bertha Placzekwork Mejloch Minycha Tauba stages, Pristin Movsha Pristin Genia Prenska Sua Pszygoda Israel Przygoda Aron F Libeskind’s is Placzek very loose inPrawidlo the early Bentzion Abramovicz Sara Abramson Pnina Adler Feiga Adam Rika Auerbach Shabtai Augustowski Chajm Awroblanski Bernhard Altman Menachem Amsterdamski Isaac Angel Chaim Anderman Sendl Apelbojm Eti Akselrad putting them in a somewhat deconstructed form Chana Oslerner Moshe Aranowicz Micheline Aaronson Sara Obstbaum Mose Ogurek Liba Ozerowicz Hersch Ojcer Avraham Ostfeld Salom Ostrer Joshua Oselkas Jospa Ostrzega Szmil Oskola Frida Openheimer Chana O of which to build upon. His designs are without a Boruch Order Chaja Orenstein Mirjam Ungar Josef Iwanier Elizabet Itzikzon Shifra Ickovski Jeno Ickovicz Matilda Eisner Elena Eiderman Machla Eidelsztein Benzion Eisenbaum Hersch Eisenthal Aharon Aineshtain Rivka Eis Estera Ajszenbojm Dawid Eifermann Eduard Eberson Felix Ephraim Flora Ehrlich Daviddoubt andGeorg freshBrinnitzer for theLowis simple factMagarete that he Ten Brink Goldztein Yedl Guttmann Rachel Gelbart Jacob Dayan Efraim Vai Erlihmanoriginal Else Ermann Klara Weinstein Feiga Weisberg Bejla Chrabolowski Erzsebet Teufel Hedwig Teutsch Hinda Kirschenbaum Jacob Tenenbaum Jonasz Nathan Triebfeder Judith Joskovicz Samuel Kats Samuel Katz Shandor Katz designs what needs and wants toTenenbaum be on the site.

Chana Oslerner Moshe Aranowicz Micheline Aaronson Sara Obstbaum Mose Ogurek Liba Ozerowicz

Esther Cohen

Bluma Kohn

Marie Cohen

Roland Cohen

Jcchak Kohn Lea Kohn

Chana Laub Neny Lazar

Erno Lautman Naftali Mehr Stefania Polak Mrisja Pikowski

Ester Pirovicz

Chana Choina Iankel Pirovicz Mayer P