VISCOSITIES OF NEWTONIAN & NON-NEWTONIAN LIQUIDS
Abstract This experiment aims to determine the viscosities of two fluids, Glycerol and gelatinized starch and investigate the effect of different shear rates on viscosity of fluids in different temperatures. The experiment also provided the model parameters of Newtonian and non-Newtonian liquids. HAAKE rotational viscometer model VT550 was used to determine viscosity of both fluids. In a desired temperature, the spindle was rotated by the motor at a given speed and torque to rotate the fluid. Shear rate was calculated from speed of rotation and shear stress was calculated from torque. With these, viscosity was computed for the fluid. The results obtained were as expected in that gelatinized starch had higher viscosity than glycerol. Gelatinized starch showed the characteristics of non-Newtonian liquid while glycerol showed the characteristics of Newtonian liquid. The viscosity of gelatinized starch decreased with increasing shear rate but decreased with increasing temperature and the viscosity of glycerol remained constant with increasing shear rate but decreased with increasing temperature. Gelatinized starch is a thixotropic fluid based on the results obtained.
1.0 Introduction 1.1 Newtonian Fluid A Newtonian fluid is the fluid in which the shear stress, created by the flow, is linearly proportional to shear rate. That means that the viscosity of the fluid remains constant as the shear rate changes.
Fig.1
1.
𝛕 = 𝛍𝛄 Where, 𝝉 is shear stress, μ is viscosity and 𝜸 is shear rate. No real fluid perfectly fits the definition of Newtonian fluid. However, many common fluids such as air and water can be assumed to be Newtonian fluid. Newtonian fluids are the basic mathematical model for fluids that account for viscosity. Air, water and thin motor oil are some examples of Newtonian fluid which have different densities and account for different shear stress and shear rate.
1.2 Non Newtonian Fluid Non Newtonian fluids are fluids which have different properties than Newtonian fluids. Unlike Newtonian fluids, viscosity depends on shear rate. In a non-Newtonian fluid, the shear stress is not linearly proportional to shear strain, the relation can be different and time dependant. Therefore, a constant viscosity coefficient cannot be achieved. There are different types of nonNewtonian fluids depending on how viscosity changes with shear rate.
Shear thickening fluid
The viscosity of shear thickening fluid, also known as dilatant fluid, increases with increase in shear rate. The more the fluid is stirred, the more it feels thick. μ = m 𝜸 n-1 where n is more than 1.
Shear thinning fluid
The viscosity of shear thinning fluid, also known as thixotropic fluid, decreases with increase in shear rate. That means, the more the fluid is stirred, the more it feels thin. Paint is one of the example of thixotropic fluid. μ = m 𝜸 n-1 where n is less than 1.
Bingham plastic
Some fluids have linear shear stress and shear strain graph but requires a finite yield stress before they can flow. That means the line does not pass through origin. Such fluids are known as Bingham fluids. Some examples are mustard sauce and mayonnaise. μ=
𝜏𝑜 𝛾
+m
where 𝝉o is yield stress
2.
There are also some fluids whose strain rate is a function of time. These fluids are known as anti-thixotropic fluid. Such fluids require an increasing shear stress to maintain a constant shear rate.
Fig 2. Relation of shear stress and shear rate of different non Newtonian fluids.
2.0 Methodology HAAKE rotational viscometer model VT550 was used for the experiment.
Figure 3. Experimental setup
3.
APPENDIX. Results in Tabulated Form.
Temperature Speed
Temperature Rpm(1/min) (unit)
Viscosity (mPa.s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
Shear Rate(1/s)
30
1
5
31.4
282.7
1.204
4.5
2
8.3
31.6
219.0
1.636
7.47
3
13.9
31.7
154.7
2.048
12.51
4
23.2
32.0
139.3
2.046
20.88
5
45.3
32.1
115.0
2.766
40.76
Speed
Temperature Rpm(1/min) (unit)
Viscosity (mPa.s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
Shear Rate(1/s)
1
5
45.0
280.0
1.204
4.5
2
8.3
45.0
201.0
1.486
7.47
3
13.9
45.0
141.7
1.998
12.51
4
23.2
45.0
121.7
2.480
20.88
5
45.3
45.0
92.5
3.763
40.76
Speed
Temperature Rpm(1/min) (unit)
Viscosity (mPa.s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
Shear Rate(1/s)
1
5
60.0
244.3
1.074
4.5
2
8.3
60.0
177.7
1.382
7.47
3
13.9
60.0
155.7
1.561
12.51
4
23.2
60.0
103.5
2.099
20.88
5
45.3
60.0
79.1
3.225
40.76
45
60
Table 1. Results showing data obtained from experiment for 10% Gelatinized Starch
Temperature
Speed
30
45
60
1
Rpm(1/min) Temperature (unit) 5 31.3
Viscosity (mPa.s) 557.3
Shear Stress(Pa) 2.585
Shear Rate(1/s) 4.50
2
8.3
32.0
414.3
3.199
7.47
3
13.9
32.0
452.0
5.836
12.51
4
23.2
32.2
470.3
9.804
20.88
5
45.3
32.3
480.0
19.710
40.76
Speed 1
Rpm(1/min) Temperature (unit) 5 45.0
Viscosity (mPa.s) 238.3
Shear Stress(Pa) 1.152
Shear Rate(1/s) 4.50
2
8.3
45.1
226.0
1.767
7.47
3
13.9
45.0
237.0
2.841
12.51
4
23.2
45.1
220.3
4.633
20.88
5
45.3
45.1
220.0
8.985
40.76
Speed 1
Rpm(1/min) Temperature (unit) 5 60
Viscosity (mPa.s) 85.1
Shear Stress(Pa) 0.486
Shear Rate(1/s) 4.50
2
8.3
60
109.3
0.793
7.47
3
13.9
60
92.0
1.331
12.51
4
23.2
60
89.4
1.945
20.88
5
45.3
60
92.3
3.737
40.76
Table 2. Results showing data obtained from experiment for Glycerine
Temperature
Shear Rate(1/s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
log shear rate
log shear stress
30
4.5
1.203
0.653
0.080
7.47
1.638
0.873
0.214
12.51
2.048
1.097
0.311
20.88
2.048
1.320
0.311
40.76
2.764
1.610
0.442
Shear Rate(1/s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
log shear rate
log shear stress
4.5
1.203
0.653
0.080
7.47
1.485
0.873
0.172
12.51
1.996
1.097
0.300
20.88
2.483
1.320
0.395
40.76
3.763
1.610
0.576
Shear Rate(1/s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
log shear rate
log shear stress
4.5
1.075
0.653
0.031
7.47
1.305
0.873
0.116
12.51
1.561
1.097
0.193
20.88
2.099
1.320
0.322
40.76
3.199
1.610
0.505
45
60
Table 3. Relation between log shear stress and log shear rate for gelatinized starch
Temperatur e 30
45
60
Shear Rate(1/s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
log shear rate
log shear stress
4.5
1.740
0.653
0.241
7.47
3.199
0.873
0.505
12.51
5.836
1.097
0.766
20.88
9.804
1.320
0.991
40.76
19.710
1.610
1.295
Shear Rate(1/s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
log shear rate
log shear stress
4.5
0.563
0.653
-0.250
7.47
1.024
0.873
0.010
12.51
2.253
1.097
0.353
20.88
3.840
1.320
0.584
40.76
7.910
1.610
0.898
Shear Rate(1/s)
Shear Stress(Pa)
log shear rate
log shear stress
4.5
-0.204
0.653
#NUM!
7.47
0.127
0.873
-0.895
12.51
0.384
1.097
-0.416
20.88
1.126
1.320
0.052
40.76
2.790
1.610
0.446
Table 4. Relation between log shear stress and log shear rate for Glycerine
Starch speed 1
Temperature (K) Viscosity (mPa.s) 1/T 304.8 284.3 0.00328 318.0 278.7 0.00314 333.0 244.0 0.00300 speed 2 305.4 219.0 0.00327 318.1 201.7 0.00314 333.0 177.7 0.00300 speed 3 305.9 155.0 0.00327 318.1 141.0 0.00314 333.0 157.0 0.00300 speed 4 306.1 140.7 0.00327 318.1 121.0 0.00314 333.0 102.5 0.00300 speed 5 306.2 112.3 0.00327 318.1 92.9 0.00314 333.0 79.1 0.00300 Table 5. Relation between ln viscosity and 1/T for gelatinized starch
Glycerin
Temperature (K)
Viscosity (mPa.s) speed 1 304.5 375.0 318.0 119.0 333.0 0.0 speed 2 305.0 414.3 318.0 150.3 333.0 13.6 speed 3 305.0 452.0 318.0 153.0 333.0 20.4 speed 4 305.2 470.3 318.0 177.3 333.0 47.8 speed 5 305.3 480.0 318.0 192.0 333.0 67.2 Table 6. Relation between ln viscosity and 1/T for Glycerine
ln viscosity 5.650 5.630 5.497 5.389 5.307 5.180 5.043 4.949 5.056 4.946 4.796 4.630 4.721 4.532 4.371
1/T
ln viscosity
0.003284 0.003145 0.003003 0.003279 0.003145 0.003003 0.003278 0.003145 0.003003 0.003277 0.003145 0.003003 0.003276 0.003145 0.003003
5.927 4.779 #NUM! 6.027 5.013 2.613 6.114 5.030 3.016 6.153 5.178 3.866 6.174 5.257 4.207