The Blue Death: Disease, Disaster, and the Water We Drink ! 22 !" 2550 %&'() ' * +,(-)) ") 8 +*' ) "'/ 0
) 1 " / /0& ' ' %&' &23 ,% !- & &1 1 % )23 , &1 1 1 ,*) +*'"/ ' ' ( "'2")) &4, 1 0 / 0 0-' % )) , 5!6 (% ) "' /3 , -,/* !7*8 1 6, 3 & % )%&' /
1 " '&9 3 &,1 ! ,*)3 & 7: & / %&'& : ! (3)) ; < 7 00 &"=0 +*' 2' 3 , %7 ( '( 3)00= 0 >! %&' 0 - ; 7 0' ,2 , 3 , ' ,(? ,*) ,(-,< Robert D. Morris 0 &, /(&' (+*' " ,,0 &1 ( / 4 -%&'0 1 ' / 3 3&3) 5, 7- -; ( 000 ( 34, 0 ) %'" /1 & 310 ' 1 The Blue Death: Disease, Disaster, and the Water We Drink >!- -<
1 &1 Y 2550 +*' , ' &2&', ) 1 0 & 3 1 2370 >! 3' 8 1 33 &,('(-)%, [ /\ (/>, 3 ,% ) "*') 1
3< ( ') />,"' -, , ,) 32 " &1 (3) 1
3<2,/ \ & \! ]6&,"' 2 +*'^, ,(' ) ,) ( () /,3 , 1 ,' %&',7/ ) 4 ," -,/& <&, +*'^,- ! ,) &2/4
33'
3 (3) 3 0% )%&'+ ("&1 : 1 2(-) ' /*) 1 /> ,+" ' < /< +*'?_ (-,< 1 /> /3&3 0 & 3< ,) "'& 3) "&1 / 2375 & 0 & 3< ! ! 1 \) <: (-,<!/)/<% "3 (-,)" `)1 ) 1
3<( -) ,+)
/ (3) 1 /<%&'5!6 /4 -" 1 0% ) 2 &',- 1 &0 & 000 , 5&(1 2 %&' ,%, 1 1a ",) &, ,) %2&( ') " 8,% ) (-,<"&/ \ / 3(:0 1 0 3<%&' ,) \*3' (3) 3< 2 ]6% ) 3 & %\! 8,500 3) /<%&' ' 5!6 3) "
,(-,<( %&' ,7 /``( -,<+*' & , /0- 3 , 1 -/*3 ' , /)+" ' ,7(-,< 1 /,( b & ! ,) &2 1 \! ]&* ' 2388 3<% &'0 (-)0 & !&, 1 0* 3 ((0(&& "/&1 2& %\! 1 c & <3 ?=d( ) /<" 2391 ") (-,)" `),1 ) 3<0 & 57-6 (3)/ < 0% ) 2&', 2) \'
573 " (-)0 & ) , 6,<) 3 0/ 3) / 5, 57/1 )&,0 3 0/ 3) & , /0 (3) -021 +*'^, 5, ,*)"3!&, %&'3&1 3< (&0 ( (3) 72% )) ,%) +*'^, , 00 & ) - ," 0 ( , 1 ,' ,7/ >!(/&\! & 5
!3/ 3b ) / 3 ) / 32a % )/ \ 2%&'&',3 )
%&'+*' ' %(& , ,3" & !( " '& ' /, /)3 ) 7 fg ( /(-) ,%,) /)!
" '+*'%&'01 "' 21 73 " '& 0 & /<3 ' ,) / 0 ) 1 2& (&<7+*' 1 (&3<& %,/ " `)/ & " 1 /< -0) +*' 5, ,*)"/0 %&' /, 0\) ,(3)020// %' "-(' ,%7h, (<!/) / 3 ) 5 2
%&'/ " 'b &/' (/' ' !( /) /, ' (0' 1 " ' 0 ,") (') ,( )
! 1 ) )" ' 3&' , b 3 ' / (< (-) , 3<" & ,( !%
" ' & 3 ,/*\! 4.5% ") :0 , /, & 1 =// 20%'"\ /*)( ) /) /, 0(' % -1('0 ,/*)) /,0\
"' 0) \20 ) 1 "( ) ! ,*)056b +*'&1 5!6 / <-0) 06+*'+3 9 ( ) 5, ( ) /<>!7 ( ) &,0( <( " ' 0 , /,% ) 2396 06 1 ( 0:&*& ( ) /< & 06!"'( ) &0//&" (3) 06 /' ) " )/2 06 "' &0 1 && !% 10 % < ! " '06"' ( ) &0/ &/&/)+" '061 > :< <( c < (S&V) ,7 06"' ( ) &0//& 06/ 3) ( ) ,) &&1 &" *' ( )(3)"3!)
&,(3) 0,"' 063) ' *" 2396 0)) 0' "08
"' / 06 3 & 3<3 ) 0' "08"' 06 S&V -,0 6&, ( 15,000 / 3 0"' 06 ( 0:-, 06&,% ) +*'/,3, a 0 &" +*'/,3 \! 796 /<!
3*0' -1 ' *,0 +*'/,3"' 0' /)" `)% )/ \0 %&' ) - "' 06% () /<! 73' 203 ,) 3 0' -/*< -0) 06 S&V \*3 / > <%33 81 ) 06 ( 0:\! 40 ) ( )) &', !, ""/ 3b ) 1
3<
"&1 , , 2397 & 0 & 3< ! ! 0 &" & !"080' 5, 06"'( &0/ &( ( ) 3) /6b ) 0 &) 0) 1 fg 1 %/ 0) 3) a ! -0) 0) ",) ,0 &/3 3 7 / / & %&' 0) % " ' , +*' 1 /,/&",3/ 0(-0) ( )3' //, / 3 &2a *) 7 ,*)7 (3)' ,*)"/ ,,% )&- 0 %&') / 32a 1
%() /<!3' b +) : 0 &,
! -0)
+*'/,3 3< & ,*) 5,"'0) 3' //, 1 , &1 0) ! , + 5!6 %,b0 \!( ') 8 +*'0+& 0 &' / 40 /)" `)% ) ) ,1 \1 ' * /< (3)- 2/q& "'0) >!) 07 ,& 0 &3&3) 5, 7/1 7("35 /3< b%&'(3)3 !-1 ' / 3 3<- 3 &, /< (0 1 c %<c&%'&', 0 %<c&-0) 0&1 0) ",) 0 &/337 3< ) +*'&1 ( ) 1\! 9 ) () 0 & 2 /,3 ' /, ,) ((( ) &2%&' +'
' fg &2% >30) !) 7/ 3 " '0) 1 + /10') 07 ,1,/ 3b /<) 73 " 0 & 3< "&1 3 2399 0 < &/ " ' 2 " / (-,< the British Medical Association in Birmingham )
3<0 & fg /) / 2 / 3 0 & 3< 7 + -, , /< 8 ! 3 " ' ,' ,0) & /,
% " & & 2 &-' 0 & 3< /</,3 1
,- 45 &',/' 3 "/ (3"&1 \ , 2401 ) "/ \-/*<%&')
3<& 1
% ()
"&1 3 2426 3<%&'0 & ' /*) 3 (-,< , 1 0<3 +*' '-0 1 (0 ,(:- 1 (0 ,0'>! 7/ ) , 1 /,/&" 8!& , -1 %, 3 ") &,8(-,< ?5/>! ,/< /3 < +*') 3 , ?5/(+*''-0:+3 >%&' ) )
3< 0 & ,3<!/)+*'), 1 ,/< :,< (-,< ?5/%,
,3< - /3 <7 -]6< " '% )/&&& 1 0 )
(8!,' , 03 % ,3<&', 1 %\! ,3< %&'+) /*35-+*'/,3 3<(-0) 4 ,") ' +*'/,3 (0, ,*)7 (3 08+ %/',-0 +&37 fg/(& ! 1 %3(-01 *) ' ,1 ,4 -, , 1 %- (&1 ' %,/3<& 1a (3)/3<&'% )/ (& ) v" !/6b ) 1 &) ) - (3)0) /)8(-,< ?5/>! :,<7+*' / \(,1 *) 4 %&' 1 & +*'^,(2% )/ \ " '&"/3<%&') > ' ,- ,3' 00' 1 ) 1 3' /*`/,:,< &', 3< &', 3) b0 ]6" &,%&'" ' %/1 0 / 3 (-) 0 & 3< 33 3-01 * 4 -"3+*'^,(0) +*'^,(+*'/,3&1 &', ! ) 0) / \ 1 ) 3<%&'(7+*'-/* 3b /<)
3<3&3) !0%, ,) 06(%&'0 \! !(/ <( ') ,% ) / \ ,&, 0 & %&'23 /) [ / b " 2043 / /0c< +*'
(0000 0 /3%&'0 ) ' 1 " '
(0000 (000 0& /," )
(00" '000 0& /,) , /,/*)( ) /)( ) &1 1 / 0 ( ,*) ) ( ) % 8 1 % <
(00 (00 /,/ \" '0 1 %&'7 ,) & 2408 1 \%[ /3<, ) ' 3 ' ,08 ) ( ) &1 8 5 % < v*( */3< " '( ) &1 / /, 1 3' /00 3< b! 73' ,' ,) (( )+3 ) % & -1 6 1 /, \!23 1 0 & %&'% ) - ( ) -
,*) ) ),/3<% ) "% )' ( ) 2 7v* < </ 5!6 &) "'% )%&'+"8 !&':('=` " ) &' , 3 / 9) 1 , ) %" >! ) 07 3 "
("35 /3< /\3+*'^,&',' ) / bw 2 & 5% " 2443 1 -, 0.00005% " 2533 &3<%&'-0) [ < >!7/ ) 230" * +&3 a % ' %"0) 0 0&-1 "' % ) / &f g ,*) ( /6b ) ) 73' 3 [ < +&3" , &' 0 0& < x /(&' / bw 2%&'0 , , 5 /3< ) 3 " '&/ [ < " ) < q& ' *%&'% ) 1 /1 0) / bw 32 %&',/ fg &,- ,) , [ < 0 & , ! 3' "' -, , ,) 32 -1 ' 3 0" '%&') %&'0/ fg 7 , /,3) 7 2 1 % )( ' ,-,"& +*' ,%&'0 3 0 < ,"0 , 5 /3< ,*) 6 &1 +*'&1 /)+/ 3 &3/,3) & 2- =// ( 2 %/' " `) 0 \*3) 3' /\ 0 2( ) 3( < x /(&'
7- 6,< ,% )/ \ :0 0& %&'&%) 3 2 7%&' 063) a " 3/ &1 % )3' - 3 -1 " ' &1 8 4 -& ! - ) (3)- 3'&,+*'04 % ), ) ,- / bw % )-,\* +- ,%&' / ) , ( ) , ,[ & "3',-0) 32 %&',3>>!7/ 32 a ,*) ) /3<((0, &', , ) 3/ / bw +` ' 0 ]3,* ,*)"=0 "&1 6 , 2536 (-,< -0) -, 0 1 /3< ( /" 1 23' +`0+*'^, ' /, ,) ( , ,-' a > ' , 33%( - 1 "+*'^, ) 0% )/ \ :0 ,/ 3 ' /,%&' ' *&',)
4 ," -,/&/& <&, +*'^, 0 6 +&3\1 %&')
7 0 & ' ) &,% 0 & ' ) & ' ' "&' ! (3)/\ 8<" +*' , ' v03 &) / 3 % )) ' -,' &, - 0 && ! ,) &2(7' 0 &&,+) 52% )) 7%%&') - %/ 5, 57- " 0 &3' " '& 00 & ,") >!% )& !0+*'^, ,"& "8 , ) 0 &%&' !) ' 8 1 /& <( , ,3 ,) ' a \! ,& /&/& < 0 &!& ! ,) &2
0) 0 0& 1 , ) / 0 (>!% ' /*)0) 0 0&(%
0 0& )((0, +&3 ( ') % ) ) Y , &23 ' v03 !&) 3' 3 0 &!) - ) ' 0 & ' ) 8 1 /& <&?3 "08 % ' %,/ 0! fg */3<7 " ' "/ 032 %&',1 /10 / 3 ,*) , "/&(-,<2%&' 3 0 1 %&' %/' +*'^, -0) + %/' +*'^,32 %&',1 3/&, >!71 -0- "+*'^, &/< % ) 1 /* (/ \ ,*) ) ,/ 3%&' 7&1 ( - ,% ) [ fg " &1 2/ \ " '& 0 & ' )%&'(' -0% ) 3/&, 3'" ' +*', `&' 3&1 ((-,<3 ' //,) 0 & " ,&" '0 ) !/ \ ,&, (-) , %&' (3) ) " ' & 1 3) 1 > , ,1 /, 3/ 1 &', ,) % 2& ' 0 & %&'q&3( ') " 8,% ) " / \ 1 -0 23 "/&8/ 2/ \ 1 -0 ( 2 >!20 ( 220 ") 0 & %' 0 &"\1 %&') 7 0 & ' )" `)/&"35 /3 bw - +*'^, \! 4 (/&, 4 -3' ' 0 6 3"-, 0 ( +*'/,3\! 100 +*' , 2) 0 & ' ) 1 ) x %&' b/4 (
< x / (&'
0, 0-1 0 8 4 - " ) 3 (3) 2529
< x /(&' 73'
0,00 3b " )- 1) < 0&) +- ,%&' 3 " " ' /,3) & 2 (' (&23' 2) +*'+3 0&) fg 1 3/&, >!7 / 3 0 & ' ) 3) -0) ) ) 3 ( '% ) 3b b & +*'^,&',' )" 1 - /* ! 4) , ( & -0) 0'
1 "'/)3 3 & ,1 0 & ' ,) 0' "08&,% ) 1 ( ') 0 0& 1 \1 %&') &) 0 0& ( ) 1 23 0 & ' ) 1 " 2543 0 & ' )2 & ! 1 <3 " &3 "' 1 % ) , 3 / , 1 b
0,0" ) 1 !3' 3&31 3 3 (3)+*' ' 3&31 0,+ 3 ' v03 -01 (0,/
&1 [ < ( .% ' ' !3&31 3 (3)2/ ,%/,(' - 1 18 -]64 2543 -, 0 &2" 1 3' 0&2^,&',' ) ,) (7 +*' ),+*' , &' / : 8/ ' / 0/2-0) ") ) ) 3&31 3 &?3 " ' ) 3% 0) 0 0& , %&'3&31 3 1
.%! - ! 1 73' 3
0 & ' ) ,) ( " ' 1 \! 2,300 ' -( ,' , 3' ' 0 6 3"-, 0 3' +`0=` 0 &' ,( 2 (3' , 0``3 , ) / &" ) ) /0 1 &1 : 2548 b 0 / bw 2,
Y-1 0 1 / 9) 1 (+0 % ) 1 3/&, " " ) 3 ,) 0 & 2) 3 & 3b & !4 , 34,%&'& !(') +*' , 2) ) / \3, -1 0 1 04, - 3' 0\! < 0%&' >! / &/,) 1 1) ( ) / 0(( )
>!7( ) 1 " `)a "/ bw %&'0 0 0&( %&'0 0&"/&/)% )) ) , <"' %
000 0& /,>! -%'"0) - (%&'0 3 (') 2) 0 0&( ) , < ( /> */33<-0) / 3 fg 1
.%" *("': " '3"% ) ' "'( )- ( /' >! ,&) 2-0) 2/ \&/fg * ,*") 3b b &%&') 1
< x /(&' , 0) 3 " '+*'&1 7 2%&' < ( /> */33<!1 "' 3 >-1 0 0& " '0 0 /3( > ' & 1 3 / \9) % ) 3/&, %&'&', ) 2 /)/ `/ 0 / &- / &% ' ) / "',% ) &4, ,*)& < x /(&' / bw &) b 3' ,) " )&( & \! 1 (/% <4 ," 2563 >!3' "') 1 (/' & < ( 2569 b 3' ,) \! 6 ' % <>!3' "' 1 ' ' & < >! %&', - , ) 3' "' 5 (', " ' 3& &>!7/ % )3' &', 3) -]3 +*' 0 4 ' * 0) ) &1 &\! ) 7 - ' ( +3 &( 1 ,' , & %\!+*'0 423' "'- 5 (3) 0 & 0 % &' 8 4 -& ) y 4) 0 &
+*', ' 0:0 (0 84 - %&' 3 0 (/) / ) -1 " '- / \& 0=` %&' ,) /:4 -(&2 b ! " ' / 0/ , -1 ' / , 1 4 , & ! %&' 5) +*') ' , 00 / bw 3 ,*)" 3 , ('&,- ,) ,) , ( ,*)" 0!, () x \* 3 > ' ,: / bw >! () 3 / 2% )/ \x (0,(% ) +3) / < 1 ( (2><&' , 0 & 5, 7- % )-,(3)&05-; (') ,& "5 -;
&', ' *0)) ' ) 7+ &( / & ) 3+*'\! 1.8 ' (" ) 90% 7&2 ,3 ) 5 +*' ,%&', 0 & ' )" 1 ) / : 8b 73 ,) "]&*' 2537 8 0 &, ( ) < ,1 / 0<3/< & %,5*,< / +*' 4,( )/ 3 1 ) -1 & / &" '0+*' -,- %&'-05- ,' ,5-
,*) ) ' ) ,+*' -,- 5- ) %&'7+ /*'0% ) (3)07+ 0 & 3< ' *0)) 4 ," 24 Y -,&, ) 1 " 3 +*' -,- 1 6 -3' /,3 (-,< < (-,<%'- (& 8) ) , +*' -,-3' / &) 3 ' ( -1 & 3 , a 5 1 -,' , 5 (3)) ,0 ( ) -,( )&,1 / 0* +*' -,-"'( ) &1 ( ' 5- +*'/,3%&', 0<3/<!('=` &', 3 " (3) &+*' -,- "' ( ) %&'1 3 " '>!2%&'+& ) / &7=` / `,/ 05 -; "=0 )
1.6 -' &( () 2.6 -' % )/ \ ' \!00/ 40 , [d : < / 3 ) ) % ) / \- 3 &/< 8 , (3&1 3) a >!74, 5 -; %&') / \&
/ &(00/ 40 %&' ,) - ,- ( \! & 5-; ('!3' ), -; 00/ 40 " '05 -;
"0/ +*' ,( ,:<" x 00 %'& 1) b &3, ,0 ,(/ 0/)/ " ' / &-1 & &0 & 2) /' 00x ( ) " ' &, ! % &' , - ) 1 ) < 3) a , ' 3) /)/ "',0 0& & !) & 4) / & ,&',: 3) ) %"' 5) >) (> (,) " ) 6) - 00 / : 4 ) & 7) 3 " - 84 - / &( -,() ('% =`
"#$%!&'(: +*' , /1 ) ) 1 &%' ,) // >!% )/ \ \) , & %&'"0&,) +*'% ) 3'00%&' *'( 0%-' &',( '1 +*' , ) 71 7 3 ,23 ' * +*' , /
3 %&') 6,< ) (3' /*/, - 1 ,*)% " & ) ,>1 7-56&', (3)) ,
2%&' !% )^,0) , " 8&,2 3 ,%&') 1 '
+ %+ 1 % )2% ) &1 ,) -,-
,*)3 & 1 "& + 1 3' &1 1 - & / & 1 2 3 ,", ) !>!3' "'1 7 :&',(' / &1 (?9 3%', /* ! /) 79 3/ ) 3< 1 % )% )/ `- 0 & ,) /' /, ," `) / 1 &, ('=` 1 0 % ) & ,*) " '/ & ) ,3' !\!=,) " ' & &(
&', ) , ,3 &,- "-1>! ' ,( , 7& ,*)(' )*: %/ 0` ( -`.4 - zq, . +, 4 .!/+. 3: -. 2551, ' 129-142.