D 'HOLD FDOFXOHD] VXPD FLIUHORU SH FDUH OH DILúHD] FHDVXO HL GLJLWDO&DUHHVWHVXPDPD[LP SHFDUHRSRDWHRE LQH" E 3URGXVXO D QXPHUH QDWXUDOH HVWH úL VXPD ORU HVWH * VL LDFHVWHQXPHUH F /D%DOXO6SLULGXúLORUSDUWLFLS WR LVSLULGXúLLDOHF URUYkUVWHvQ DQLUHSUH]LQW QXPHUHGHFLIUHFXSURGXVXOFLIUHORUùWLLQGF QXH[LVW GRLVSLULGXúLFDUHDXDFHHDúLYkUVW DIOD LFk LVSLULGXúL DXSDUWLFLSDWOD%DOúLFHYkUVWHDX ÌQFXWLLVXQWELOHILHFDUHFXWLHDYkQGVDXELOH6HúWLH F QXP UXO FXWLLORU FX R ELO QX H PDL PLF GHFkW LDU QXP UXO ELOHORUGLQFXWLLOHFXúLELOHvPSUHXQ HVWHPDLPDUHGHFkW &DUHHVWHQXP UXOFXWLLORUFXELOH"$QDOL]D LWRDWHFD]XULOH SRVLELOH /DXQRILFLXSRúWDOF VX HOHSRúWDOHVXQWDúH]DWHSHUkQGXULHJDOH QX PDL PXOW GH UkQGXUL úL QXPHURWDWH FX QXPHUH QDWXUDOH vQFHSkQG GH OD & VX D SRúWDO FX QXP UXO HVWH VLWXDW SH UkQGXOGLQPLMORFLDUFHDFXQXP UXOHVWHVLWXDW vQGUHSWXOHL GDUSHXOWLPXOUkQG&kWHF VX HSRúWDOHVXQW" ÌQWUXQ FOXE VSRUWLY VXQW PDL SX LQ GH GH FRSLL 7R L SUDFWLF XQ VSRUW -XP WDWH GLQ QXP UXO IHWHORU HVWH HJDO FX R WUHLPH GLQ QXP UXO E LH LORU 8QLL SUDFWLF YROHLXO FHLODO L WHQLVXO 2 WUHLPH GLQQXP UXOFRSLLORUFDUHSUDFWLF YROHLHVWHHJDOFXRS WULPHGLQ QXP UXO FHORU FDUH SUDFWLF WHQLVXO ùWLLQG F IHWH IDF WHQLV DIOD LFk LE LH LSUDFWLF YROHL
&ODVDD,,,D
(GL LDD,,,DHWDSDILQDO LXQLH
'DPLDQ0DULQHVFX
6HG úLUXOGHQXPHUH D &RPSOHWD LúLUXOFXXUP WRULLWUHLWHUPHQL
'DQ1HGHLDQX
3HXQUDIWDOXQHLELEOLRWHFLVXQWDúH]DWHvQRUGLQHF U LDVWIHO vQFkW QXP UXO GH IRL SHQWUX GRXD F U L ÄYHFLQH³ DO WXUDWH V GLIHUHFX3RWILSHUDIWF U LÄYHFLQH´DO WXUDWH FDUHV DLE vQWRWDOIRL"'DU"
D $IOD LUHVWXOvPS U LULLQXP UXOXL OD E $IOD LFkWXOúLUHVWXOvPS U LULLQXP UXOXL ⋅ OD ⋅
&ODVDD9D
D 8WLOL]D L FLIUD GH RUL úL RSHUD LL DULWPHWLFH SHQWUX D RE LQH UH]XOWDWXO E $IOD LQXP UXOQDWXUDO[ + + + + = − + [ + + + + D 6 VH DIOH SURGXVXO D WUHL QXPHUH QDWXUDOH úWLLQG F SURGXVXO SULPHORUQXPHUHHVWHSURGXVXOXOWLPHORUQXPHUHHVWH LDUVXPDGLQWUHSULPXOúLXOWLPXOHVWH E &kWHFLIUHDUHSURGXVXO$⋅%GDF QXP UXOQDWXUDO$HVWHVFULVFX GHFLIUHGHLDUQXP UXOQDWXUDO%HVWHVFULVFXGHFLIUHGH" 6XQWXQWkQ UQ VFXWvQVHFROXO8OWLPHOHGRX FLIUHDOHDQXOXL QDúWHULL IRUPHD] XQ QXP U GH RUL PDL PDUH GHFkW QXP UXO OXQLLvQFDUHPDPQ VFXWùWLLQGF QXP UXOOXQLLvQFDUHPDP Q VFXWHVWHGHRULPDLPDUHGHFkW]LXDPHDGHQDúWHUHV VHDIOH GDWDQDúWHULLPHOH /D R FRIHW ULH VXQW DGXVH FXWLL ILHFDUH FXWLH DYkQG FLRFRODWH FXWLL DYkQG FLRFRODWH GH JU LDU R FXWLH FRQ LQH FLRFRODWHGHJU&XPVHSRDWHJ VLFXWLDFXFLRFRODWHGHJU GLQWURVLQJXU FkQW ULUHDYkQGODGLVSR]L LHXQFkQWDUFXJUHXW L SRWULYLWH
&ODVDD,9D
'DQ1HGHLDQX
7UDLDQ3UHGD
6H FRQVLGHU WULXQJKLXULOH DVFX LWXQJKLFH $%& úL $′%′&′ FX vQ O LPLOH$0UHVSHFWLY$′0′úLFXPHGLDQHOH%1&3UHVSHFWLY %′1′úL&′3′ 1RW P$0∩%1 {4}úL$′0′∩%′1′ {4′}6 VHDUDWHF GDF $0≡$′0′úL%1≡%′1′DWXQFL D %40≡ %′4′0′ E GDF vQSOXV&3≡&′3′DWXQFL∆$%&≡∆$′%′&′
7UDLDQ3UHGD
)LH ∆$%& úL SXQFWHOH 2 úL , FHQWUHOH FHUFXULORU FLUFXPVFULVH UHVSHFWLYvQVFULVHvQ ∆$%&6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF GDF P $,% P %,& P &,$ VXQW GLUHFW SURSRU LRQDOH FX P %$2 P &%2 P $&2 DWXQFLWULXQJKLXO$%&HVWHHFKLODWHUDO
/LYLX2SULúHVFX
6 VHGHWHUPLQHVXEPXO LPHDFXQXP UPD[LPGHHOHPHQWHFDUH VH SRDWH DOHJH GLQ PXO LPHD $ { « } DVWIHO FD VXPDRULF URUGRX QXPHUHGLQVXEPXO LPHV VHGLYLG FX
E 'DF D − E + F = DEF∈1V VHGHPRQVWUH]HF GLYLGHQXP UXOED±F
'RUHOD) LQLúLUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
D $IOD LFHOPDLPLFQXP UQDWXUDOFDUHvPS U LWODG UHVWXO vPS U LWODG UHVWXOúLHVWHGLYL]LELOFX
&ODVDD9,D
7UDLDQ3UHGD
3HQWUXQ ∈1Q ≥FRQVLGHU PPXO LPHD$ {«Q} 6SXQHPF PXO LPHD%XQGH % ⊆ $ DUHSURSULHWDWHDÄ0³GDF PHGLDDULWPHWLF DHOHPHQWHORUVDOHHVWHXQQXP UGLQPXO LPHD$ D 6 VH DUDWH F SHQWUX RULFH QXP U QDWXUDO N XQGH ≤ N Q H[LVW RPXO LPH % ⊆ $ FXNHOHPHQWHFDUHDUHSURSULHWDWHDÄ0³ E 6 VH DIOH FkWH PXO LPL % % ⊆ $ GH GRX HOHPHQWH DX SURSULHWDWHDÄ0³
0DULXV'DPLDQUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
E &DOFXOD LVXPDSULPLORUGHWHUPHQLDLúLUXOXL
,RQ%XUF UHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
1LFXODH0DULQ*RúRQLXUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
F SHQWUXRULFHQ∈1 H[LVW [\]∈1DVWIHOvQFkW [ + \ + ] = Q
E H[LVW [\]∈1DVWIHOvQFkW [ + \ + ] =
'DQ1HGHLDQX
6HFRQVLGHU IXQF LDI1 →=I[ D[EDE ∈= 'DF P úLQVXQWQXPHUHQDWXUDOHGLVWLQFWHDVWIHOvQFkW I + I + + I P = −Q úL I + I + + I Q = −P V I + I + + I P + Q VHFDOFXOH]HUDSRUWXO P+Q
6 VHDUDWHF D H[LVW [\]∈1DVWIHOvQFkW [ + \ + ] =
&ODVDD9,,,D
7UDLDQ3UHGD
6HFRQVLGHU ∆$%&DVFX LWXQJKLFúLSXQFWHOH0 ∈>%&@1 ∈>$&@ úL 3 ∈ >$%@ DVWIHO vQFkW $∆$13 ≡ $∆&01 ≡ $∆0%3 ≡ $∆013 6 VH GHPRQVWUH]HF 01úL3VXQWPLMORDFHOHODWXULORU∆$%& $PQRWDW $∆;<= DULDWULXQJKLXOXL;<=
7UDLDQ3UHGD
)LH$%&'XQS WUDWúLSXQFWHOH0 ∈>%&@1 ∈>&'@3 ∈>$'@ DVWIHOvQFkW&0 %0úL$3 ≡%01RW P%1 ∩30 {4}úL $1∩30 {5}'HPRQVWUD LF 1HVWHPLMORFXOOXL>&'@GDF úL QXPDLGDF $4⊥%5
& W OLQ LJ HUX
6 VH DUDWH F GDF S T U VXQW WUHL QXPHUH SULPH úL GDF S T U + + ∈1DWXQFLS T T T U S
6 VHJ VHDVF QXPHUHOHvQWUHJL[úL\FDUHVDWLVIDFHFXD LD \ = [ + [ +
&ODVDD9,,D
'DQ1HGHLDQX
/LYLX6PDUDQGDFKHUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
E )LH[\] ∈5DVWIHOvQFkW[ ∈ \ ∈ ] ∈ 'HPRQVWUD LLQHJDOLWDWHD [ + \] > [] + [\
( − )
&ODVDD,;D
$GLúRU1LVWRU
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX&ULVWLDQ$OH[DQGUHVFX
6HFRQVLGHU IXQF LLOHIJ5→5GHILQLWHSULQ I [ = VLQ [ VLQ [ + FRV [ FRV [ úL J [ = VLQ [ VLQ [ − FRV [ FRV [ 6 VHGHWHUPLQHFHDPDLPDUHúLFHDPDLPLF YDORDUHDIXQF LLORU IúLJ
'DQLHO3HWULFHDQX
6 VHGHWHUPLQHWRDWHIXQF LLOHI>±@ →>±@FDUHYHULILF FRQGL LD I D I [ ⋅ I D I D I [ = I [ I D I [ − [I [ ∀ [∈>±@
,90DIWHL0DULXV5 GXOHVFX
)LHDEF!6 VHDUDWHF D E (D + E ) E F (E + F ) D F (D + F ) D + E + F ≥ + + D + E E + F D + F
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX&RVWHO&KLWHú
6 VHGHWHUPLQHWRDWHIXQF LLOHI5→5FXSURSULHWDWHD I D[ + E\ ≤ DI [ + EI \ ∀ [\∈5∀ DE∈>@
D=
E $IOD L SULPHOH GH ]HFLPDOH GXS YLUJXO DOH QXP UXOXL
ùWHIDQ6PDUDQGDFKH
D 7HWUDHGUXO 6$%& DUH PXFKLD 6$ SHUSHQGLFXODU SH SODQXO $%& 3XQFWHOH'34VXQWSURLHF LLOHSXQFWXOXL$SHGUHSWHOH %&6%UHVSHFWLY6&LDUSXQFWHOH0úL1VXQWSURLHF LLOHOXL'SH 6%UHVSHFWLY6&6 VHDUDWHF GUHSWHOH01úL34VXQWSDUDOHOH
D + E D + E + D E ∈4V VHDUDWHF DE∈4
D 'DF DE∈5 DVWIHOvQFkWDE∈4úL NS
∀ ]∈&
[
[
[
[
$XUHO'RERúDQ/XJRM
[
,90DIWHL3HWUXú$OH[DQGUHVFX
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
6 VHFDOFXOH]H [Q Q [ [ OLP + + + + + + − Q [! Q→∞ Q Q Q )LH0⊂0Q5 Q≥FXSURSULHWDWHDF ;⋅<∈0∀ ;<∈0 úLH[LVW ( ∈0DVWIHOvQFkW; (∀ ; ∈06 VHDUDWHF GDF H[LVW $ ∈ 0 DVWIHO vQFkW GHW $ ≠ DWXQFL ; ⋅ < < ⋅ ; ∀ ;<∈0
Q →∞
DUFWJQ Q ≥ DUFWJ Q + D 6 VHDUDWHF úLUXODQ Q≥HVWHVWULFWFUHVF WRU E 6 VHFDOFXOH]H OLP DQ DQ +DQ
6HFRQVLGHU úLUXO DQ =
&ODVDD;,D
*K6WRLFD3HWURúDQL
$U WD LF GDF WULXQJKLXULOHRUWLFúLELVHFWRUIRUPDWGHSLFLRDUHOH ELVHFWRDUHORU DOH XQXL WULXQJKL DX DFHODúL FHQWUX GH JUHXWDWH DWXQFLDFHVWDHVWHHFKLODWHUDO
[
6 VHUH]ROYHLQHFXD LD + + + < + + [ + [
9LUJLO1LFXOD
)LH QXPHUHOH D E ! D E ≠ D ≠ % úL PD[{D E} 6 VH DUDWHF OJ D ⋅ OJE + F = OJ E ⋅ OJD + F GDF úLQXPDLGDF F
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX0LKDL3LWLFDUL
+ ] S + ] S + + ] NS ≥ − ]
&ODVDD;D
)LHNS∈1 $WXQFLDYHP
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
1LFRODH3DSDFX6ORER]LD
)LH* ⋅ XQJUXSFDUHHVWHUHXQLXQHDDSDWUXVXEJUXSXULSURSULL DOHVDOHGLQWUHFDUHWUHLDXFkWHGRX HOHPHQWHúLRULFDUHGRX GLQ FHOH SDWUX VXEJUXSXUL DX FRPXQ GRDU HOHPHQWXO QHXWUX DO JUXSXOXL6 VHDUDWHF *DUHúDVHHOHPHQWHQXHVWHFRPXWDWLYúL HVWHL]RPRUIFXJUXSXOSHUPXW ULORUXQHLPXO LPLFXHOHPHQWH
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX0LKDL3LWLFDUL
)LHI5→5RIXQF LHFRQWLQX FXSURSULHWDWHDII[ [∀ [∈5$WXQFL D I I úLIHVWHVWULFWFUHVF WRDUHSH5 E ∫ I [ G[ ≥
1LFRODH3DSDFXUHY$UKLPHGH
)LHLQHOXO$⋅ úL[∈$FXSURSULHWDWHDF H[LVW S∈1 DVWIHO vQFkW [ S + = [ S 6 VHDUDWHF − [ + [ HVWHLQYHUVDELO
π
6 VHFDOFXOH]H ∫ π
DUFFRV [ G[ − FRV [
&ODVDD;,,D
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX,RQ6DYX
)LH Q ≥ XQ QXP U QDWXUDO úL $ = [ [ [Q R PDWULFH \ \ \ Q UHDO FXWUHLOLQLLúLQFRORDQHFXXUP WRDUHDSURSULHWDWH 3 3HQWUX RULFH GRX FRORDQH DOH PDWULFHL $ H[LVW R D WUHLD FRORDQ FX SURSULHWDWHD F PDWULFHD FX WUHL OLQLL úL WUHL FRORDQH RE LQXW DUHGHWHUPLQDQWXOQXO6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF D 'DF WRDWHFRORDQHOHPDWULFHL$VXQWGLVWLQFWHUH]XOW F UDQJXO PDWULFHL$HVWHFHOPXOWGRL E 'DF Q H[LVW RPDWULFH$FXSURSULHWDWHD3 úLFXUDQJ$