Amendment 1 -
OKI 2030 REGIONAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN
March, 2009 Prepared by the Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional Council of Governments
Acknowledgments
Title
Amendment 1 - OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan
Date
March 9, 2009
Agency
Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional Council of Governments Mark R. Policinski, Executive Director
Project Manager
Robert W. Koehler, P.E.
Participants
Robyn Bancroft Andrew Reser, AICP Dave Shuey Mark Paine Regina B. Fauver
The preparation of this document was financed cooperatively by the Federal Highway Administration, the Federal Transit Administration, the Commonwealth of Kentucky Transportation Cabinet, the Ohio Department of Transportation, and the units of local and county government in the OKI region. The opinions, findings, and conclusions expressed in this document are those of the OKI Regional Council of Governments and are not necessarily those of the U.S. Department of Transportation. This report does not constitute a standard, specification, or regulation
INTRODUCTION This report constitutes an amendment to the regional transportation plan prepared by the Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana Regional Council of Governments (OKI) for the Cincinnati metropolitan area. The OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan “Setting Your Transportation Landscape” (the Plan) was originally adopted by the OKI Board of Directors on June 12, 2008. Periodically, as needs and conditions change, it becomes necessary to modify the Plan. This amendment is undertaken to address two items: 1) Incorporation of projects eligible for the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (federal stimulus bill), 2) Update any project level information as necessary, and 3) Minor revisions to text and figures. A copy of the full OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan is available on CD, printed document or on-line at www.oki.org. PROJECT RECOMMENDATIONS The primary purpose of this amendment is to allow OKI to incorporate projects to be funded by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (federal stimulus bill). This amendment includes projects that are either new to the plan or have new funding sources as a result of the federal stimulus bill. Projects that add capacity are considered non-exempt with respect to air quality conformity and trigger the need to evaluate their regional impacts in terms of traffic and air quality. This amendment to the OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan includes both exempt and non-exempt projects. Non-exempt projects that are new to the plan are added to the travel model assumptions, normally within the highway network, and the impacts on regional emissions are evaluated. Non-exempt projects that represent a change in scope of an existing plan project are required to be added to the travel model assumptions, and the impacts on regional emissions are evaluated. A change in the scope of a project that changes a roadway’s capacity triggers an updated air quality conformity determination. This type of change could be either in termini or breadth of improvement, or both. Non-exempt projects that represent a change in timing of an existing plan project may be required to be part of travel model assumptions for the appropriate analysis year. Only one project in this amendment are considered non-exempt, however it is an are existing Plan project and no change in scope or timing is made, thus OKI will Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
1
rely on the existing air quality determination made on the current Plan as permitted under federal guidance. The remaining projects are exempt and do not trigger an air quality finding. Refer to the Transportation and Air Quality section below. This amendment also includes new revenue estimates expected to be received via the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (federal stimulus bill). Fiscal constraint discussion is provided later in the document. American Recovery and Reinvestment Act Projects To respond to the recession, President Obama and Congressional leadership enacted an economic recovery (i.e. stimulus) package, worth nearly to $1 trillion. This effort would address President Obama’s plan to create 2.5 million jobs by 2011. The intent of funding through an economic recovery package is to stimulate the economy by creating direct and indirect jobs. Therefore, the money will be targeted to “ready-to-go” projects, not planning activities. Funding from the Act for transportation projects is being distributed primarily through state DOT’s, MPO’s and transit agencies. OKI will receive (sub-allocated) funding through traditional Surface Transportation Program processes. Eligible projects are being funded with 100% federal funds (i.e. no non-federal matching funds are required). Transit agencies received a separate allocation consistent with the existing process of distributing FTA 5307 capital funds. Each agency in the region determined their projects using their allocation. All Title 23 requirements such as design standards, public involvement, NEPA requirements, fiscal and air quality conformity etc. apply. This Plan amendment includes transportation projects being funded by all sources of federal stimulus funds. Projects were selected based on guidance received from the oversight agency of record. OKI transportation projects were selected using guidance from the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA). The following criteria help guide project selection: must be a transportation project, roadway projects must be on a federal functionally classified roadway, the project must be “shovel ready” and the project needs to create or retain jobs. The following tables show the recommended projects. Table 1 includes transit projects. Table 2 includes Ohio projects. Table 3 includes Dearborn County projects.
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
2
Table 1 - Recommended Transit Projects Action Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add
Project ID 111204 111304 114304 114403 114211 114207 114220
11.12.04 11.62.02 11.12.01
Sponsor Butler Transit Butler Transit Butler Transit Butler Transit Butler Transit Butler Transit Butler Transit Middletown Transit CTC CTC CTC CTC SORTA SORTA SORTA
Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add Add
11.12.03 11.12.01 11.12.01 11.12.01 11.44.03 11.42.09 11.44.03 11.42.07 11.12.06 11.42.06 11.42.06 11.12.04 11.12.04
SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA SORTA
Add Add
TANK TANK
Add Add Add Add
TANK TANK TANK TANK
Description 5 Replacement <30' buses 8 Expansion <30' buses Construct Storage Facility Rehab/Renovate Facility 4 Replacement Support Vehicles ADP Hardware Replacement Misc Support Equipment Replace 2 ADA Vehicles in 2010 Purchase of 4 Hybrid Light Transit vehicles Purchase of 1 Medium duty bus Purchase of upto 2 support vehicles Construction of a new operations facility 6 30' Hybrid Buses for Arts Line CAD/AVL System Replacement "Mini-Hybrid" Thermal Management Bus Kit fuel efficiency retrofit 12 30' Hybrid buses 57 Hybrid Buses 22 new coaches with chair lifts 4 new coaches with chair lifts Concrete driveway upgrades at fleet facility Driveway reconfiguration Facility exterior door upgrades Fleet watch RF Hubos and system 9 Hybrid articulated vehicles Portable and pit lifts for articulated buses Portable and pit lifts for articulated buses 12 vehicle replacements 65/35 8 Hybrid minibuses for neighborhood circulator vehicles Bus Replacement Replacement of bus automated vehicle location systems Facility Improvements Farebox Replacement Renovate Admin. Facility Concrete Rehab
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
Cost $375,000 $400,000 $670,000 $30,000 $120,000 $15,000 $35,000 $145,000 $500,000 $110,000 $60,000 $700,000 $2,100,000 $8,671,000 $525,000 $4,092,000 $37,500,000 $5,148,416 $1,103,232 $24,000 $192,000 $125,000 $299,732 $7,200,000 $100,000 $140,000 $1,063,399 $1,300,000 $2,812,500 $4,000,000 $150,000 $2,500,000 $187,000 $450,000
3
Table 2 – Ohio Projects Action Add
Sponsor Butler County
Facility Crescentville Rd.
County/Location Butler/Windisch Rd. To Mosteller Rd. Butler/Beissinger Rd. to Taylor School Rd. Butler/SR 747 To International Bl.
Add
Butler County
Eaton Rd.
Add
Butler County
Muhlhauser Rd.
Add
Butler County
River Rd.
Butler/County Line to Fairfield Corp.
Add
Butler County
River Rd.
Add
Butler County
Smith Rd.
Butler/Corp. Line to Corp. Line South of Lake Circle Butler/SR 747 To Bridge
Add
Butler County
Smith Rd.
Butler/Bridge to Beckett Rd.
Add
Butler County
Tylersville Rd.
Butler/Bypass 4 to Morris Rd.
Add
Butler County
Tylersville Rd.
Butler/Fairfield Corp Line to SR 747
Add
Butler County
Tylersville Rd.
Add
Butler County
Tylersville Rd.
Butler County
Tylersville Rd.
Butler/SR 747 To Lesourdsville West Chester Rd. Butler/Lesourdsville West Chester Rd. To Lakotal Hills Dr. Butler/Lady Anne To IR 75
Add
Butler County
Tylersville Rd.
Butler/IR 75 To Cox Rd.
Add
Middletown
University Blvd.
Monroe
SR 63-Britton & SR 63-Main St. (Cin-Day Rd.)
Butler/Between Reinartz Blvd. and Breiel Blvd. Butler/each intersection
Add
PID 83074 Revise Funding Source and Add Funds
Description Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing, pavement markings and RPM's on various roads Resurfacing
New signal at Britton, signal improvements at Main St.
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
Cost $94,569
$407,699
$449,577
$139,353
$71,983
$49,701
$120,453
$42,808
$332,274
$378,230
$257,434
$324,333
$232,196
$3,000,000
$208,000
4
Table 2 – Ohio Projects Action Add
Sponsor Oxford
Add
Oxford
Add
Oxford
Add
Oxford
Facility Traffic Signal LED Upgrade
County/Location Butler/All signaled intersections
US27 / High St US27 / Patterson Ave. US27 South
Butler/Beech St. to College Avenue Butler/High Street and Patterson Ave.
Clermont County
Amelia Olive Branch & SR 125
Clermont County
Merwin Ten Mile Road
Add
Clermont County
Add
Clermont County Addyston
Nine Mile Tobasco Road Wards Corner
PID 75303 Revise Funding Source Add
Add
Add
Arlington Hts
Add
Blue Ash
Add
Blue Ash
Add
Blue Ash
Add
Cheviot
Add
Cheviot
Add
Cincinnati
Main Street
Waldman Drive/Galbrait h Road Blue Ash Traffic Signal Preemption Blue Ash Traffic Signal Upgrade Reed Hartman Highway Glenmore Avenue Harrison Avenue Phase 2 Computerized Traffic Control System Software
Butler/US27Patterson Ave. to Corp limits Clermont/Intersectio n of SR125 and Amelia Olive Branch
Clermont/Locust Corner Road to SR 125 Clermont/US52 to SR125 Clermont/SR126 to SR48 Hamilton/Dining Lane to Catalina Apts. (3000') Hamilton/intersection
Hamilton/Throughout Blue Ash Hamilton/Throughout Blue Ash Hamilton/RHH Cooper to GlendaleMilford Hamilton/Harrison Ave. to South Corp. Line Hamilton/Lovell to School Section Hamilton/Cincinnati Traffic Control
Description Replacement of incandescant signals with LED Rehabilitation of brick street and streetscape Intersection Improvements and signal installation Butler/Installation of new sidewalk to service new High School Includes access road, turn lanes, curb and gutter, extended Amelia Olive Branch Road and park-and-ride Full Depth Repair and Resurfacing of Merwin Ten Mile Road Full Depth Repair and Resurfacing of Nine Mile Tobasco Road Full Depth Repair and Resurfacing Street Rehabilitation, Resurface, Replace Curbs/Walk, Improve Drainage replace entire signal system at intersection
Cost $50,000
$1,250,000 $350,000
$600,000
$3,817,094
$144,000
$318,400
$337,600 $376,000
$100,000
Add emergency preemption on traffic signals on main routes Replace 25 incandescent traffic signals with LED, add UPS Remove deteriorated pavement, replace with SAMI and overlay Total curb replacement, base repair, resurfacing
$390,000
Curb replacement, base repair, resurfacing
$635,000
The City’s Computerized Traffic Control System (CTCS) software/hardware upgrade
$1,000,000
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
$375,000
$840,000
$662,000
5
Table 2 – Ohio Projects Action PID 77484 Revise Funding Source and Add Funds
Sponsor Cincinnati
Facility US 27
Add
Columbia Township
Bramble and Plainville Road
Add
Forest Park
Winton & Sharon Road
Glendale
Sharon Road
Hamilton County
Central Riverfront Intermodal Center Garage Phase I
Add
Montgomer y Newtown
E. Kemper Rd. Village of Newtown
Add
Sharonville
Cornell Rd.
Add
Sharonville
Fields-Ertel Rd.
Add
Sharonville
Add
Sharonville
Mosteller Road Chester Rd.
Add PID 77164 Revise Funding Source and Add Funds Add
County/Location Hamilton/Northside Colerain Avenue between Virginia Av and I-74 Exit ramps and at the intersection of US27 and Virginia Av/West Fork Rd. Hamilton/Bramble Ave and Plainville Road within Township limits Hamilton/Winton Rd. / Sharon Rd. Intersection Hamilton/Sharon Road Hamilton/Cincinnati Central Riverfront
Description Address safety concerns, improve inadequate pavement width and add traffic capacity
Hamilton/East Kemper Road Hamilton County/ from east of Riverhills Drive adjacent to SR32, connecting the existing sidewalk network in the Newtown Road portion of the business district. Hamilton/Cornell Rd, 450' West of Swing Rd. Hamilton/Reed Hartman Hwy to 600' West of Copperfield Dr. Hamilton/Sharon Rd. to Kemper Rd. Hamilton/Chester Rd, South Pedestrian Bridge at Princeton High School
Install Sidewalk
Mill, resurface and reconstuct
Cost $880,000
$2,000,000
New signal poles and signals
$150,000
Resurfacing 1450’
$261,000
Construction of Phase I Intermodal Facility
$1,500,000
$125,000
The sidewalk will improve the pedestrian link between two subdivisions at the top of Riverhills to the business district and the Loveland Bike Trail. Provides multi-modal access from Meridian Biosciences to the main business district Culvert Extension and Roadway Embankment Stabilization Turn Lane Addition and Sight Distance Improvement
$1,000,000
Total Curb Replacement, Base Repair, Resurfacing Steel Pedestrian Bridge Repair and Painting
$1,159,000
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
$500,000
$875,000
$260,000
6
Table 2 – Ohio Projects Action Add
Sponsor Springdale
Facility Northland Bl.
County/Location Hamilton/Northland
Description Repair concrete base, resurface, intersection improvements, pedestrian walkway Pavement and catch basin repair, curb and drive apron replacement, install curb ramps as required, sidewalk replacement. Replace 26 traffic signal heads and pedestrian heads with LED signals and upgrade contollers Replace 1,200 defective rail ties
Cost $950,000
Warren/Various
Storm and Roadway Improvements
$350,000
Warren/Western Row Road and Cintas Bl. Warren/ Little Miami River
Add 2 Left Turn Lanes
$307,880
Replace Bridge Superstructure
$900,000
Add
Terrace Park
Wooster Pike
Hamilton/West of Elm St. to Terrace Park/Milford Corp. Line
Add
Lebanon
Warren/Lebanon, OH
Add
Lebanon
Add
Mason
Add
Mason
Lebanon Traffic Signal Improvement s Railroad Line Improvement s Main St. Improvement s Western Row
Add
Warren
Wilmington Road Bridge Replacement
Warren/Lebanon, OH
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
$837,200
$300,000
$180,000
7
Table 3 - Dearborn Indiana Projects Action Add #0900096
Sponsor Dearborn
County/Location Dearborn/N. Dearborn and N. Hogan Rd.
Description Chip & Seal/Fog Seal
Cost $750,000
Dearborn
Facility N. Dearborn Rd/N. Hogan Rd SR 46
Add #0810415
Dearborn/SR1 to US52
$634,571
Add #0900092 Revise funding source #0088850 Add #0900095
Dearborn
Old US-52
Dearborn
Conwell Street
Dearborn/I-74 to West Harrison Limits Dearborn/US 50 to Exporting Street
District Pavement Project (Non-I),HMA Overlay, Preventive Maintenance Resurface Road Rehabilitation (3R/4R Standards)
$4,216,734
Dearborn
Add #0900093 Add #0900094
Dearborn
State Line Rd/Pribble Rd/Kaiser Rd York Ridge Road Weisburg Road
Dearborn
$600,000
Dearborn/Portion of 3 Roads
Resurface
$650,000
Dearborn/SR-1 to N. Dearborn Dearborn/SR-48 to N. Dearborn
Resurface
$1,300,000
Resurface
$1,000,000
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
8
OTHER MODIFICATIONS In addition to incorporating the AARA projects, this amendment takes the opportunity to make minor corrections identified after publication of the June 2008 version of the Plan. These are listed below in Table 4. Table 4- Corrections to June 2008 Plan Document Page 15-13 (last sentence) These figures do not include the approximate $1.03 $1.325 billion programmed in the current 2008-2011 Transportation Improvement Program. Action: replace $1.03 billion with $1.325 billion Page 15-15 (last paragraph second sentence) ____ As outlined above in the Funding Expectations section, approximately $11.273 billion is estimated to be available for all transportation expenditures in the OKI region over the life of the plan. Action: replace $7.53 billion with $11.273 billion. Page 15-15 (last paragraph third sentence) _________ The estimated cost of the recommendations of this plan including $1.325 billion in the current TIP is an estimated $7.2 $11.065 billion. Action: add the following text (including $1.325 billion in the current TIP) and replace $7.2 billion with $11.065 billion. Page 16-4 through 16-7 Figures 16-4 through 16-7: Data source information added.
____
AMENDED FISCAL CONSTRAINT DETERMINATION As part of the long range plan, the costs of implementing the recommendations are compared with the funding expected to be available. The Plan’s financial analysis was developed in response to the requirements for a “financially constrained plan” that were introduced in ISTEA and continued in TEA-21 and SAFETEA-LU. The Plan considers capital and Operation and Maintenance (O&M) costs associated with the preservation and continued operation of the existing transportation system. It also projects revenues from all sources which will be available to pay for these improvements. Chapter 16 of the Plan describes in detail the base financing plan for the region. Determination of fiscal constraint for this amendment relies on the existing analysis performed on the original Plan adopted by the OKI Board of Directors in
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
9
June, 2008 and on the expectation of funds from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) also referred to as the Stimulus Bill. Final funding levels are not known at this time but guidance from the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) and the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) suggest that the amount will be approximately 200% of fiscal year 2008 funding. This means that OKI could receive approximately $50 million through FHWA and $36 million through FTA to allocate to projects that are eligible and would meet the “shovel ready” requirements of the ARRA. FTA funds will be allocated using existing formula percentages for the region’s transit agencies. Additionally, FHWA and FTA have encouraged metropolitan planning organizations to initiate the Plan and TIP amendment process in order to be able to respond quickly once the Act is signed into law. This amendment is primarily for the purpose of incorporating projects from the ARRA. The final project list may need to be adjusted to match exact funding levels once that is known. OKI will assure that this is accomplished in order to produce a Plan that remains fiscally constrained. TRANSPORTATION AIR QUALITY CONFORMITY Transportation conformity is a mechanism to ensure that federal funding and approval are given to those transportation activities that are consistent with the air quality goals of the State Implementation Plans for Indiana, Kentucky and Ohio. Pursuant to provisions of the CAAA of 1990, U.S. EPA designated a nine county area in the Cincinnati area as a nonattainment area for ozone under the eight-hour ozone standard in April 2004. The Cincinnati ozone nonattainment area includes Lawrenceburg Township in Dearborn County Indiana, the Kentucky counties of Boone, Campbell and Kenton, and the Ohio counties of Butler, Clermont, Clinton, Hamilton and Warren. In December 2004, U.S. EPA designated an eight county area as nonattainment for fine particulate matter (PM2.5) under the annual PM2.5 standard. The boundaries of the PM2.5 nonattainment area are identical to ozone nonattainment area excluding Clinton County, OH. The OKI Regional Council of Governments (OKI), as the Metropolitan Planning Organization (MPO), consists of Dearborn, Boone, Campbell, Kenton, Butler, Clermont, Hamilton and Warren counties.
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
10
All projects, with the exception of PID 75303 (Amelia Olive Branch and SR125 Intersection Improvement), are exempt from air quality conformity requirements. Exempt project types are defined in the federal transportation conformity rules and include projects that do not add capacity to the transportation system. PID 75303 is considered a non-exempt project. It includes a new access road and park-and-ride facility, but it is included in the existing TIP and Plan. This amendment makes no changes to the timing or scope of PID 75303 and OKI is relying on the previous regional emissions analysis as detailed and adopted as part of the June 2008 update to the OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan. PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT The OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan “Setting Your Transportation Landscape” was developed with significant attention to public involvement. Please refer to Chapter 2. Provisions for public comment on this Amendment were provided through a month long public comment period and culminated in public hearing held at 5:00 p.m. on Monday, March 9, 2009 at the OKI offices, 720 East Pete Rose Way, Suite 420, Cincinnati, Ohio. OKI advertised the Amendment in mainstream and minority newspapers and through standing OKI committees. This document was placed for public review in public libraries throughout the region, at the Ohio Department of Transportation and Kentucky Transportation Cabinet district offices and on the OKI website. Through a qualitative evaluation, it is determined that the changes included in this Amendment 2 - 2030 Regional Transportation Plan ensure that low income populations and minority populations receive a proportionate share of benefits from federally funded transportation investments.
Amendment 1 – OKI 2030 Regional Transportation Plan – March 2009
11