!" #$% & ' '#$%( )* ,+%
-.0/13254 25/625487 9.07:1;7)48.07:.>=?.0@ A"B DCFEGHI51;G;JK13. EL6MN1O=:=:.0@QPRCSBUTFV5V5V
W
X>CYMN.<7 G3G3CF/[Z 25MN\E=?.<4K]013.6]0.
%CSJ1;@^X5.0/678.0/[Z_ 25M`\6E=:.04 ]<13.0/]0.
abCYG;=?.<4 2F7:.0/cK4:CF/>=?dYZ_e=fCY=:1378=:13]<7
a . 1;/>J5.07=?1;I>CY=?.=:96..K=?4:CF]<=:1325/^2 G31;/6cF.<@!2FL 8.0] =48.0\648.078.0/>=fCY=:1325/7 $7
4825M =?.K= 254E67:. 1;/ =?2F\613] =?4?CY]fcK1;/6I$% 7\64:2 JK13@6. E67%C C BU=?2 48.0\648.078.0/>= 48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\67 L .<=".0. 25L 8.<]<=:7 2FE6/6@ 13/b=:.K=ba .^7:962 =:96. E678.Q2/ CY1;J5. ]<254:. .04:.6]0. 48.07825G3E=:1325/ @6E64813/6IQ=?96.N.K=?4:CF]<=:1325/b225L 8.0] =?7 @2.<7 /62F= \64:2 JK13@6. 1;MN\6482 J5.0M`.0/>= 2 J5.04 =?96. CFL67:.6]0. 2 ]02F4:. .<4:.6]0. 48.07:2FG3E=:1325/ a . 1;/>J5.07=?1;I>CY=?. =:96. ]048.SCY=:1325/ 2) G31;/6ce70Z_2F44:.
=?.<4:7(6' Z 254,@62K]0EMN.CF]f9.07N=:4?CF@1;=?1;25/ CFG"]0257813/6.Q7:1;MN1;G CF481;=!B* 96. =?96. 1;/6@62 7813d0.`137G3CF4:I5. = IF1;J5.<7 @1+) .04:.>= CY/67(" .0487 96. =?96., 1;/6@62 7:1;d0.`137 78M CFG;G ZYL6E=@62K.07/62F=\ .04- 254:MCF7.
.
2F4:@67HCF7 ]<25M`\ 25/.0/>=?7 D G;7:26Z =?96.8% ]<.0/>=?.<4:70' CYG3I525481;=:96M(1;7HCFLG3.=?2\64:2 JK13@6. G;2#" .04M`13787,4?CY=:.07 =?96CF/1 9.0/ E7:13/I JF.0] =?25487" 1O=?9Q$7 CF7]025M`\ 25/6.0/>=:7$ 2
35476.8:9<;>=>
[email protected]$9B4
96.DC6.0G3@N2 !/E 2548M C =?132F/N.<=:4:1;.<JYCFG 4:.
=?.<]f96/61+GKE.07MNCFcY. E7:. 2H=:96.\64:.<7:.0/]0. 2&"254:@67 13/UC 78=:2548B^L6E=G;1;=8=?G3.2F=?96.<413/E 2548M C =?132F/
96. B CF48.]0CFG3G;.0@I%8L CFI 2 " 254:@70' =:.0]f96/61+GeE6.07 L .0]0CFE67:. =?96. BN=:4:.0CY="=:.K=,M`.048.0GOB`CF7 C 7:. =SZ2F4 L CFIZ2J"2548@670Z\ 25787:1;L6G;B,1O=?9 /eE6M L .0487 CF787:2K]01 C =?.0@B1;=:9 =?96." 2F4:@67 $.K= ]<25/>=fCF1;/67M E6]f9
M`254:. 13/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/[Z L6E=1;=137@61+K`]0EG;= =?2 MNCFcF. E67:. 2)2F=?9.041;/E 2548M CY=:1325/L !/ =?961;7\ CY\ .<4
". =:48B =:2NMNCFcY.%E67:. 2 MN2548.%13/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/N=:9 CF/M8E678==?9. \4:.078.0/6]<. 2&"254:@67 a . ]025/7:13@.04=:96. \64825L6G;.0M 2 =:25\613]=?4:CF]fce13/6IZN961;]f9R137CN=?CF7:c^13/Q=?96. $25\61;] .<=:.0] =?132F/ CF/6@ $4?CF]fce13/IO D \64825I54?CYMP% !/ =?2F\613] =:4?CF]fce1;/6I6ZC 7B7=?.<M 137IF1;J5. C . . CFM`\6G;.R/6. 7QCF4=?1;]0G3.<7 2 C =:25\613] CF/6@ =?9.R78BK78=:.0M M E78= =:96.0/ MNCFcF. @6.<]01;7:132F/67 CF7 =:2 96. =?96.<42F=:96.04/6. 7CY48=?1;]0G;.07 CF48.25/ =?96.7?CYMN.%=?2F\613]CF7,=:96.. CFM`\6G3.%7=?254813.<7$ Q
a . 1;/>J5.07=?1;I>CY=?. =:96. .K=:4?CF] =?132F/ CY/6@ E67:.^2 G;13/6cY.0@ 25L 8.<]<= 4:.<\64:.<7:.
$% 7 CFG;G32 4:.<\64:.<7:.0/>=?CY=?1;25/ 24:.
4:.
a . .<JYCFG;E CY=:. C JYCF4813.<=!B 2 M`.<=?92@67/ 254]f962K257:1;/6IQ25L 8.0] =?7 CF/6@ ]<4:.0CY=?1;/6IU48.0G3CY=?1;25/67:913\67 = 137/62F= 25L>JK1325E67 962 =?9. $% 7 789625E6G;@ L . E7:.0@ 254`=?4:CF]fce13/6I6Z 7:2 " . 13/>JF.078=:13I>C =?. C M`.<=:962@ 7813M`13G3CF4 =?2 C %8L6CFI 2!"2548@670' CY\6\64:25CF]f9 CF/6@ CFG3782 \648.078.0/>= CU/. M`.<=?92@ ^ 96.NMN2K@61 C .0@ %8L CFIU2!"254:@70' CF\6\4:2>CF]f9,". E67:.1;7D]0257813/6. 7:13M`13G3CF4:1O=!B5Z 254D@2F=)\64:2K@6E6] =SZ>25/ JF.0] =?25487 9.04:. =:96.,]02FMN\ 25/6.=?.<4:7(` ' M`.<=:962K@ 13/`=?961;7 \ CF\ .04
=?7D2 " 254:@7. 1;=?9 ".013IF9e=:13/6IE a 9613G;." .`. CFMN1;/6. =:96. E67:. 2 48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\672F/6G;B 13/R=?9. ]025/>=?.K = 2 =:25\61;] =?4:CF]fce13/6I6Z =?9. =?.<]f96/61+KG E.07CF/6@ .<JYCFG3E6CY=?1;25/U2D =?.<]f96/61HeG E6.<7CF4:. CF\6\G313]0CFL6G;.=:2 CF@6@1;=?1;25/ CFG[=?CF7:ce7 961;7 "254:c`137 CF\6\6G;13]SCYL6G3. =?2 CF/>BN=?CF7:c 96.<4:.=:96.048.%CF4:.@62K]0E6M`.0/>=( =?2 @62K]0E6M`.0/>="]025M`\ CF48137:2F/67:M 13/]0G3E@613/6I/C GO=?.04813/6I 1;=:9 . CFM`\6G3. @62K]0E6M`.0/>=:70Z648.0G3. JYCF/6]0." .0.<@6L CF]fc Z CF/6@ CF/>B 2_ =?96.2Y=?96.<4 =fCY7:ce71;/ !/ =?9."/6.K =7:.<]<=?1;25/[Z
."@61378]0E6787H.K =:4?CF] =?132F/ 2 $%7$H !/ .0] =?1;25/ Z ."@61378]0E6787 =:96. E678. 2H $713/ =?2F\613]=:4?CF]fce13/I" .0] =?132F/ I51OJ5.07 C L64:1;. @6.078]04813\=:1325/^2 13M`\6G3.<MN.>=fCY=:1325/ CY/6@ . ` K ]<13.0/]
= =?96. .<JYCFG;E CY=:1325/ M`.<=:962@25G325IYBRCF/@ 48.07:EG;=?71;/ K.0]<=:1325/7 a . @61;7:]0E7:7%4:.
<6.8M? 6:A$9B4
"!$#%#&!')(*',+-!/.0#214365!$'87:9;3<.059>=1@?BAC9EDGFH'H5IJ,9EK
A . 254:."I51;JK13/I26G313/cF.0@ 25L 8.<]<=D48.0\648.078.0/>=fCY=:1325/70Z " . 4:.<]SCFG;G7825M`."E678. E6G78=?CF/6@ CF48@ 13/ 254:MNC
=?1;25/ 4:. =?4813.<JYCFG =?.0]f9/61HGeE6.<7$ 9.07:. CF48.%78=?2F\6\613/I6Z678=:.0M`MN1;/6I6ZCF/6@Q\ CF48=-!2 7:\ .0.<]f9Q=?CFI5I51;/6I T
K=:25\6\61;/6I%137H=:96.,48.0M`2 JYCFG2 ]025M`M`25/"254:@67)78E6]f9 CY7/%=?9.$'6Z&%:CY/6@'6Z>CY/6@ 7:2%25/ K=?.<MNM`13/6I
137 =?96. ]025/>JF.04:781325/ 2: 2548@67=:2 =?96.<134 4:2K2F=D 2F4:M1# 254.CFM`\6G3.YZ!%M CF48cF. =?13/I
' 9 CY7C 7 =?.0M 2 %8MNCF4:cY.<= 'EDCF4=(!2 ! 7:\ .0.<]f9U=?CFI5I51;/6I G CYL .
5'/9
9ED 3:7:9 H. 9EK<9 '3614365!$',K
!/ CF/ CY=:=:.0M`\= =?2`]SCF\=:E64:. MN2F4:. 13/E 2548M C =?132F/ =?9 CF/ ]0E6484:.0/>=7%8L CFI 2 "2548@670'`MN2K@6.
13G;G[.K=:4?CF] =G;13/6cY.0@Q25L 8.0] =48.0\648.078.0/>=fCY=:1325/7M $%7 "13/6cY.0@U25L 8.0] =48.0\648.078.0/>=fCY=:1325/7CF48. C
C B =?2 ]f9 CF4:CF]<=:.04813d0. 48.0G3CY=?1;25/67:913\67 L . = .<.0/ 2FL 8 .0] =?7$ 7 25L 8 .0]<=:70Z .7 1;G3G\64:1;M CF4813GOB E678.\ .<25\6G;.FZK254:I>CY/613d0CY=?1;25/670ZeG;2]0CY=?1;25/670ZKCF/@ 2F=?9.04,/62FE6/67$D a 913G3.@" .D 13G;G 2K]0E7 25/ =:96.E678. 2 13/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/ 25E6/@U1;/Q/25E6/67
5' 5'
9ED 36K
96. 25L 8 .0]<=:7
.`CF48. 13/>=:.04:.<78=:.0@ 13/ CY4:. \ .025\G3.FZ_254:I>CY/613d0CY=?1;25/670Z G32K]SC =?132F/670Z_CF/6@ 7:. GeE6.0/6]<.07 2_/625E6/67 / 25E6/648E6/67 D a . ]f962578.=:96137)7:. =,2_25L 8.<]<=?7L .0]SCYE67:. =?96. BN78.0.<M =:2 L .13/>=?E1;=?1OJ5.
13M`\ 2548=?CF/>==?2 =:96. 78=:2548B 9 CY=1;70Z[=:96.
=?7 4:.<\ 2F48=?.<@U1;/ =?96.78=:2548B
a .`.K=:4?CF] = \ .025\6G;.FZ$254:I5CF/613d0CY=?1;25/67
=fCYI5I5.04 CYMN.<@!.CF/61;dSCY=:1325/70ZeCF/6@NG32K]SCY=:1325/7$ # 254.CFM`\6G;.FZ%:X>CFM`.07 A 482 /'1;7 C / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=!B5Z L6E=D%896. '1;7/62F=$H CFMN.<@!.>=?1;=!B=fCFIFI5.0487
9 CSJ5. L .<.0/ @6. J5.0G;25\ .0@R=?94:25E6IF9
2F4:cQ@625/6. 52 4=:96. P .<7:7:CFI5. /@6.04878=fCY/6@613/I^ 25/E .<4:.0/]0.
P Z Q $ 96. B =fCYI=?96. / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=?13.<7 25E/6@ 13/ =:96. =:.K=CF/6@ CFG;7:27:\ .0]01 B96. =?96.<4 =?9. / CFM`.0@ !.0/>=:1;=!B 137 C \ .0487:25/[Z 254:I5CF/613d0CY=?1;25/[Z 254 CUG32K]SC =?132F/ CYMN.<@!.CF/61;dSCY=:1325/67
=?E61O=?1OJ5.0GOB 1;MN\ 254=fCF/>=,=:2 =:96.78=:2548B
13/]0.=?96.<4:. 1;7C G32Y=2D13/ 254:MNCY=?1;25/ \648.07:.>=%13/Q78=:254:1;.07 /62F=" 25E6/6@U13/Q/ CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=?13.<70Z
"./1;G3G_CFG3782`.K=?4?CY]<= /625E6/4:E6/67 )-/25E6/648E6/^137C 7:. GKE.0/6]<. 2 25/6.254 M`254:./625E6/67 "25M`. . CFM`\6G;.07D2 /25E6/648E6/67CF48.:% CF1;4:\ 2548=06' ZL8% ]048.0@61O=D]SCY4:@'6Z5CF/6@ %8482]fc M E67813] 7=fCY=:1325/E' !/ 2F4:@6.<4 =?2 48.0@6E6]<. =:96.JYCF4:13CY=?1;25/67,2 2548M 2 .$eG E61OJYCFG3. 2547%4:2K]fcQM E67:1;] 78=?CY=?1;25/' CF/@ 8% 482]fc M E67:1;]%78=?CY=?1;25/670'," 25E6G;@UL 2F=?9^L .P8% 4:2K]fc M E67813]%7=fCY=:1325/'E
"!/. 9E+ 9 . 9 ',D>9
7:9EK
2548. .048.0/6]<. 4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/R1372 =?. @6.078134:CFL6G3. 13/R781;=:E CY=?1;25/67@96.0/ 1;/E 254:MNCY=:1325/Q137.K=?4:CF]<=:.0@
4:2FM =?.K=$% 2548. .048.0/6]<.07CF48. JYCF481 CY=:1325/7 1;/U=:96. \694?CF78. E67:.<@ =?2 4:. .<4=:2 CF/U25L 8.0] = 96. ]02F/678=:4:E6] =?132F/b2 $%7 137 CF/ 13/E 2548M C =?132F/ .K=?4:CF]<=:1325/ =fCF78cN %4:137896MNCF/ Q 1;/6]0G;E6@6.<7 ]02F4:. .<4:.6]0.,48.07825G3E=:1325/ CF7HCF/ 13M`\ 2548=?CF/>= 78=?.<\ 13/ 13/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/.K=?4:CF]<=:1325/[ZFCF/6@ .,]<25/67813@6.<4 ]02F4:. .<4:.6]0.%48.07:2FG3E=:1325/ 713M`\ 254=fCF/]0.13/N25E64 7BK78=?.<MP 9.04:.CF4:.7:.<JF.04:CFG =!BK\ .07 2]<254:. .04 .0/]0.07 2 13/>=:.04:.<78=$) /6.1;7=:96.E7:.2 \64:2F/625E6/67=?2 4:. .<4=:2 C / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=!B # 25413/67=fCF/]0.FZ 1+:% X>CYMN.<7%A 4:2 /^ ' 1;7MN.>=?132F/6.0@ 1;/R=?.K =0Z =:96. 25L 8 .<]<=MNCSBRG C =?.04L . 48. .<4:4:.<@ =:2^CF718% 96. ' 13/U=?96. =:.K = /2F=?96.<4=!BK\ . ]<25/67:1;78=:72) JYCF4:13CY=?1;25/67 25/ / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=?1;.072F4/625E6/4:E6/67 / . CFM`\6G;. 2 =:96137=!BK\ . 2) ]02548. .<4:.0/]0. 1;77:% X>CFM`.07A 482# /E' CF/6@ 8% P 4$ A 4:2 /' 96.048. CF48. 2F=:96.04%=!BK\ .<7 2" ]02F4:. .<4:.6]0.<7 =?9 C = " .`@62U/2F= CY=:=:.0M`\=%=?2Q4:.<7:25GOJ5. /6. =!B\ .`7:13M`13G3CF4=:2 \64825/625E6/7137 =?96. E678. 2) \694?CF78.07%7:E]f9 CY7<% =?9. M E67813]013CF/N ' 2547% =:96. ]<25MN\6CF/>B' =:2 4:. .04=:2 C / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=!B ) ]<4:25/>BKMN7 CF48. CF/62F=:96.04 =!BK\ ./" . @62`/62F= ]<25/67:1;@6.04 ) H.04- 254:M`13/I`]<254:. .04 .0/]0.48.07:2FG3E=:1325/`\ .<4( .<]<=?GOB`137"C @61 N K ]<E6G;==fCY7:c Z6CF71;= " 25E6G3@N4:. KG E134:.7:25M`.@.0I548.0.2 / CY=:E64?CFG G CY/6I5E CFIF. \ CF487:13/I CY/6@ \ .0489 CF\67`E6/6@.04:7=fCF/@613/6IE 2
. J5.04
J5.07=?1;I>CY=?. 7813M`\6G3. =?.<]f96/61+KG E.07 =:9 CY=
.N]025/ 8 .<]<=:E64:.N\ .<4( 2548M 4:.SCY7:25/ CYL6G;B CF/@ .<JYCFG;E CY=:.`=:96.01;4 E7:. a .N2F/6G;B ]02F/67:1;@6.04D]<254:. .048.0/6]<. 48.07825G3E=:1325/ 1;=?913/ 25/.,78=:2548BFZeCF725\6\ 257:.<@ =?2%\ .04- 254:M`13/6I]02548. .<4:.0/]0. 4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/^CF]<4:257877=?254813.07
a . E678. CU7813M`\6G3.`CF\6\4:2>CF]f9 =?2R48.07:2FG;J5.N\64:2F/625E6/b]<254:. .048.0/6]<.07$ 96. \64825/625E/67 2B%96.$'6Z
%87896.$'6Z %8'Z5%8M`.$'6Z5%9613MB'6Z5%89.040'ZeCF/6@I%8M B 'CF4:.MNCF\6\ .0@ =?2=:96.\64:. JK1325E67)\ .0487:25/`/ CFM`.0@ .0/>=:1;=!BI 2FE6/6@ 13/b=:96. =?.K= 9. \64:25/25E6/67 2%-".$'Z%E670'6Z%=:96.
CF/61;dSCY=:1325/ / CYMN.<@! .=?.6]0.<7 8% X>CFMN.<7A"4:2 / CF748.0]0.>=?G;B 13/>=:.048JK1;. " .0@RL>B 4?CF1;I +%1;G3L 254:/ . CF/67- .<4:.0@>eG E6.<78=:1325/67CFL 25E= 96137 M E67813]0CFG 13/ E.0/6]<.07$ ' a .
2FE6G3@ 1;/6]025484:.<]<=?GOB 4:.0\G CF]<. :% .$' CF/6@ % 96137(b ' 13/ =:96.R78.0]02F/6@ 7:.0/>=:.0/6]<.* 1O=?9 :% 4?CF1;I +%13G;L 2548/' /b=?96. 2Y=?96.<4 7:1;@6. 2 =:96. ]02F13/[ZD]<25/67813@6.<4 =?96.<7:. 78.0/>=?.6]0.<7 ?% 4:CF13I +1;G3L 254:/ 7?CY13@ 4:.0]<.0/>=?GOB 13/>=:.048JK1;. " .0@ X>CYMN.<7UA"4:2 / . @61378]0E6787:.0@(96137 M E7:13]0CFG%13/ E6.0/]0.07 ' !/b=?9137 ]0CF7:.YZ " . " 25E6G3@ 48.0\6G3CF]0.F8% ' 1;=:9 ?% 4?CY13I +%13G;L 2F4:/U ' CF/6@ :% .$' CF/@ 8% 96137(' 1;=:9 :% X>CFM`.07 A 482 /[Z ' CFG3G_2 913]f9P" 25E6G;@UL . ]025484:.0] = 4:.0\G CF]<.0M`.0/>=?7 " a . 1;G3G_1;/>J5.07=?1;I>CY=?.=?9. \ .04( 2F4:MNCF/6]0.%2 =:96137 CF\6\4:2>CF]f9Q13/ =:96..<JYCFG;E CY=?1;25/ 7:.<]<=:1325/
! "# $&%')()*" $
a .UC =:=?.<MN\= =?2 4:.07825G;JF. JFCY4:1 C =?132F/67 13/ 25L 8 .0]<=`48. .048.0/6]<.07`=?964825E6I59 7:E6L78=?4813/6I MNCY=?]f961;/6I a 1;=:9613/ C%/ CYMN.<@!.
2=?9. 2F=?96.<4:7`CF7 =:96.^7?CFM`. 25L 8 .0]<=$ # 254 .6CYMN\6G;.FZ1 8% X>CFMN.<7 A 482#/E'6ZM%8P 4$ A 4:2 /'Z
CF/6@ :% A"4:2 /'NCFG3G 2]<]0E6484:.0@Q13/QC 78=:2548BFZ ."25E6G;@Q]<25/67813@6.<4=:96.0M =?2 L .=:96.7?CFM`.%25L 8.<]<=
%:A 482 /' 2 ".<J5.<40Z"1+ %:X>CFM`.07 A 4:2 /' CF/6@ %8P 4$ A 482#/E' 2K]0]<E64:48.0@ 13/bCR78=?2F48B5Z)L6E= %:A 482 /' @613@ /62Y=SZ". 2FE6G3@ /62Y= =?4:.0CY=B%:X>CYMN.<7A 4:2 /'`CF/6@ %8P 4$)A 482 /'`CF7,=?96.%7:CFM`. 25L 8 .<]<=$ a .`@62 /2F= @62U=:96.N78E6L67=?4:1;/6I MNCY=:]f9O 25425L 8.<]<=:7 2 @61+) .048.0/>= =!BK\ .07 =?9.N=!BK\ .<7 CF48.`\ .02F\6G3.YZ 2548I>CF/61;dSCY=:1325/70Z[G;2]0CY=?1;25/670Z CY/6@ /62FE6/64:E/67 41+
.N.0/6]<25E6/>=?.<4 =:96.N\964?CF78. :% A 482 /[ZJ 25E6/6@6.<42 A 482 / )E6L6G;13789613/6I6' ZL" .B" 25E6G;@ /62Y=%=?4:.0CY= :% A 482# / )E6L6G;137:913/6I ^ ' CY7 :% A 482 /' L .0]0CFE67:.I:% A 482 / )E6L6G;137:913/6I ^ ' 1;7 CY/ 2548I>CF/61;dSCY=:1325/ CY/6@ :% A"4:2 /Q ' 137 CQ\ .0487:25/L a . CFG;7:2 E7:. =:96137 MN. =?962K@O 254 /625E6/4:E6/67 !/ CQ78=?2F48B CFL 2FE= ]<4:.<@61;= ]SCF48@670Z]<4:.0@1;= ]SCF48@67 MNC B L . 48. .0484:.<@ =?2%CF7HL 2F=:9>8% ]<4:.<@61;=H]SCF48@670 ' CF/@ 7:1;MN\6GOBP8% ]SCY4:@67('H 961;7D4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/ M`.<=:962K@
!"$# \ .0487:25/ X>CFM`.07 A 4:2 / \ .0487:25/ A 482#/ \ .0487:25/ A 4: 2 / \ .0487:25/ A 482#/ \ .0487:25/ 4?CF1;I`+1;G3L 254:/ \ .0487:25/ 4?CY13I`+%13G3L 2548/ \ .0487:25/ P $4 +%13G;L 2F4:/ \ .0487:25/ P 4 "+%1;G3L 254:/ /62FE6/64:E/ ]048.0@61O=]0CF4:@ /25E6/648E6/ ]SCY4:@ /62FE6/64:E/ L6E67813/6.<7]0CF4:@ /25E6/648E6/ ]SCY4:@ /62FE6/64:E/ ]SCF48@ /25E6/648E6/ ]SCY4:@ G;2]0CY=?1;25/ abCY7:961;/6IF=?2F/ G;2]0CY=?1;25/ a CF7:961;/6IF=:25/ G;2]0CY=?1;25/ abCY7:961;/6IF=?2F/U G;2]0CY=?1;25/ a CF7:961;/6IF=:25/Q \ .0487:25/ .<254:IF.abCF789613/IF=?25/ \ .0487:25/ %.02548I5.%abCF789613/IF=?25/ CFL6G;. Q &%'' (*),+-(/.0),(/12 ),35476819:',;<9>=.79>?A@CBD+EF35)G?>HCI7BD+EJ
"25E6G3@^=?48.SCY==:96.P%8]048.0@61O=]0CF4:@E' CF/@Q=:96.P%8]SCF48@'`/625E6/648E6/67CF7 =?96.7:CFMN.25L 8.0]<=:7$%8]SCY4:@[Z ' /62F= % ]SCF48@670Z ' L .<]SCFE678.
.E678.=:96.%78=:.0M 1;/ /625E6/4:E6/Q]025/78=?48E6]<=:1325/N CFL6G3. Q 78962 7 7825M`. . CFM`\6G;.07 96.<4:. =?96. 78E6L678=:4:1;/6IUMNCY=:]f9613/6I "2548cK7 CF/6@> CF1;G37 96.,C 4878= .CFM`\6G3. 137%G31;cF.K
7:9 ?14365!$',K6FH5
". 9E14365!$'
:= .04D". 9 CSJ5. .=:4?CF] =?.<@ =:96. 25L 8 .0]<=:72)13/>=?.<4:.<78=SZ " . ]048.SCY=:. =?96. 4:.0G3CY=?1;25/6789613\67L . = .<.0/
=?9. 25L 8.0] =?7 Da .! 2K]0E67)25/ .K=?4?CY]<=?1;/6I4:.B =!BK\ .N1;/E 2548M CY=:1325/ 2F/ =?9.N48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\67$ 2 ".<J5.<40Z]<4:.SC =?13/I
4:.
=?9. :% X>CYMN.<7A"4:2 /' 2FL 8.0] =%CF7 =fCYcK1;/6I`25/6G;B 25/6. \ 25781;=:1325/ 96./ 2F4:@67 % =?2 ` ' CF/@ :% C'NCF48.
78=:25\6\ .0@[Z7:2 =:96.Bb\ 257:1O=?1;25/67$ $2*C6/6@ =?96. @61;78=?CF/6]0. L .<=".0. :% X>CYMN.<7 A 482#/E' CF/6@ :% CFE6@61;.0/6]<.$'6Z " . 78E6L=?4:CF]<==?96. \ 2F7:1;=:1325/^2 =?96. :% CFE6@13.0/]0.$'N25L 8.<]<=D 4825M =?9.
!
>X CFM`.07 Q A 4: 2 / Q T 7?CF/I =?2 C
G CF48I5. CFE6@61;.0/6]<. CFL6G;. T ' 3 40=?>BD+EF?>I1
! "$# X>CFMN.<7A 4:2 /O Q 2 DT X>CFMN.<7A 4: 2 O / T 2 DT
CFE6@61;.0/6]<.
Q 2 Q
(7BD9A?>),+-H1 ',; ? ' ',.A1H?>9$J
\ 257:1O=?132F/ 2 =:96.1%:X>CFM`.07A"4:2 /'`25L 8.0] =SZ I5. =:=?1;/6I C @6137=fCF/]0.2
, Q EDa 96.0/.<J5.<4 ". ]02FMN\6E=?. CN@61;78=fCY/6]0. L . = .<.0/ 25L 8.0]<=:70ZN . 7:E6L=:4?CF] ==:96. G;2#".04 \ 257:1O=?132F/< 4825M =?9. 961;I596.<4 \ 257:1O=?132F/[Z[I51OJ1;/6I E67\ 257:1O=?1OJ5. @61;78=fCY/6]0. CY= CYG3G =:13M`.07 !/ MN257=2" 25E64=?.<78=:70ZJ .13G;G 2F/6G;B ]048.SCY=:. C`48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\ 1+$=?96.25L 8.0]<=:796C JF. C @61;78=fCY/6]0.2&6C J5. 254G3.<7:7 ) a . 13G;G[cF.<.0\U=:4?CF]fc 2$=?96.@61;78=?CF/6]0.96.A? 8M?7A$4
AC!
5D9;369ED
365!$'
1@'
AC. 1D 5'
$25\613] .<=:.0] =?132F/RCF/6@U 4:CF]fce13/6I D 137CN\6482 8 .0] =D1;=:9U=:96. I525CFG 2DL .<=8=?.04254:I5CF/613d<13/6I
13/ 254:MNCY=?1;25/ 52 E6/@U1;/ C`78=?48.SCFM 2/6. 7 .0. =?96. 7:EMNMNCF48B CF48=:13]0G;. G3G CY/
Z Q 254 M`254:.%1;E/ 2548M CY=:1325L/ $a . 13G3G ]025/7:13@.04 =?96.%=?CF7:c 2 $=?2F\613]=:4?CF]fce13/I
H.
!/1DGF,9EK
3
96. IF2>CFG$13/ =:25\613] =?4:CF]fce13/6I 1;7=:2 =?4:CF]fc CNcK/2#/ =:25\613] 9 CY=137
. .6CYMN\6G;.7=?254813.07 2$C =?25\13]FZCF/6@^CY7,MN2F4:./. 7 78=:254:1;.07 CY4:.\4:.078.0/>=?.<@Q=:2 =?96.78BK78=:.0MQZ =?9. 78BK78=:.0M MNCFcF.<7 C8 E6@I5MN.>= CF7=?2796. =?96.<4 2F4%/62F=%.0CF]f9 7=?254B 13725/ =?96. 7?CYMN. =:25\613] CF7 =?96.`. CFM`\6G3.`78=:254:1;.07 Q 9. /eE6M L .04 2 .CFM`\6G;.N7=?254813.07 137 @6.62F=?.<@ ^!/ CY@6@61;=:1325/ =?2 \6482 J1;@613/I CR9 CF4:@ F 8 E@6I5M`.0/>=, 254 .0CF]f9 7=?254B5Z)=?96. 7BK78=?.<M CFG3782 \64:2 JK13@.07`C /eE6M L .04]<254:48.078\ 25/@613/6IN=?2 =:96. 96. =?96.<4=?96. 78=?2F48BU137 25/ =:25\61;] 9. 9613IF96.04 =?96. /eE6M L .<4 CF787:2K]01 C =?.0@B 1;=:9 CF/N78=?2F48B5Ze=?9.M`254:.]0.<48=?CF13/`=?96. 78BK78=:.0M 137)=?9 C ="=:96.7=?254B`13725/N=:96.7:CFM`.
=?2F\613] CF7=?9.N.6CYMN\6G;. 78=:254:1;.07$N 96.048.N1;7/621C.<@ 4:CF/6I5., 254%=?9.07:.N/eE6M L .04:7 96.`9 CF48@
%" Y 8E6@6IFMN.
"!$#
H1.05'
36!/.059EK
3
5D>K
!/[email protected]=?2UI5.0/.04?C =?. CQ7:]<254:.B 25496.<=:96.04 =:96.`78=?2F48B 137 25/ =?25\61;]FZ =?96.`78BK7=?.0M /6.0.<@67 =:2 ]02FMN\ CY4:.=?96. 78=:2548B =?2 7:2FMN. 4:.<\64:.<7:.0/>=?CY=?1;25/ 2 =?96. =?25\61;]D13/6]<. =:96.7BK78=?.<M 1;7)I51;JF.0/ 2F/6G;B
.CFMN\G3. 7=?254813.<7H26=:96. =:25\613]YZY=:96.,4:.<\64:.<7:.B = 2Q78=:254:1;.070Z =?96CY=7:]<254:1;/6I M`.<=?92@ ]SCF/bL . E7:.0@ 13/ 78.<JF.04?CYG
C BK7 R! 2 2,=?9. ]02FMNM`25/ CF\6\6482>CF]f96.<7 CF4:.N]0.
CYI5I5G32FMN.<4?CY=:1;J5. ]
Z Q a . E678. =?9. ]0.>=?4:2F13@UCF\6\6482>CF]f9Q13/ 25E64. JFCYG3E CY=:1325/L !/`=:96.]0.CF]f9[Z " . LE613G;@ C48.0\648.078.0/>=fCY=:1325/`2_C%78=?2F48B =:9 CY=)137D=:96.B%8M`13@6@G3.$' 2 =?9. . CFM`\6G3. 7=?254813.<7$ %/. , CSB =:2 @62 =?961;7 137 =?2 ]02F/6]SCY=:.0/ C =?. =?9. 78=?2F4:13.<7 =?25IF.<=?9.040Z MNCFce13/6IQ25/6.`78=:2548B 25E= 2" =?96.N. CFM`\6G3.<7$ /2F=?96.<4 CSB 137=?2U=?CFcF.`=?96.`78BK7=?.0M 7 4:.<\64:. 7:.>=fCY=:1325/ 2
=:96.`. CFM`\6G3. 78=:254:1;.07 CF/6@ CSJ5.<4?CFI5.`=?96.<MP` 961;7 48.$eG E61;4:.07 ce/62 G3.<@6I5. 2 =?9. 78BK7=?.0M 7N48.0\648.07:.>=fCY=:1325/ CF/6@ 2 92# =?96.^7B7=?.<M ]<25M`\ CF4:.<7 = 2 78=:254:1;.07$ 9.U7B7=?.<M =?9.0/ ]02FMN\ CY4:.07 =?96. ]0.0/>=:4:251;@ =?2 =:96. /6. 78=?2F48BQ=?2 I5.6.04:CY=?. C 7:]<254:. =:9 CY==?96. /6. 78=:2548B 137 25/ =?25\13] a . ]<25MN\E=?. =?96. ]0.0/>=:4:251;@ L>BRCSJF.04?CYI513/6I`=?96. 4:.<\64:.<7:.0/>=?CY=?1;25/67$ 96. 7B7=?.<M MNC B CF@6@61O=?1;25/ CFG;G;B /62F4:MNCFG31;d0.=:96.%7:]<254:.%L>B @1;JK13@61;/6I 1O= L>B =?96.CSJF.04?CYI5.2 =?96.%78]02548.07 =?9 C = .SCY]f9 . CFM`\6G3.78=?2F48BN13725/ =:25\61;]D 961;7 96.==?2F\613]<7$ /6.^]04:1O=?1;]01378M 2 =:96.^]0.0/>=:4:251;@ CY\6\64:25CF]f9 1;7 =?9 C =`C JF.04:CFI513/I =:96.^4:.<\64:.<7:.0/>=?CY=?1;25/67 2 7:. J5.<4?CFG 7=?254813.07 M CSBb/2F= MNCFcF. 78.0/678. # 254 13/67=fCF/6]<.FZ)25/6. ]025E6G;@ CF7:7813I5/ .0CF]f9 MN2F/e=:9 2 =?9.BF.SCF4@ 1;=:9QC /eE6M L .<40Z CF/6@Q]02FMN\6E=?.%=?96. CSJ5.<4?CFIF. L61;48=:9QM`25/>=?9^2H C I54:25E\Q2H \ .025\G3. 2 " .<JF.040Z6=:96.048.137"7:25M`.. JK13@6.6]0.=:2 7:92# =:9 CY= CSJF.04?CYI513/6I C @62K]0E6M`.0/>= @62K.07"/62F= L .<9 CSJ5. \ 22548G;BN]025M`\ CF48.0@^=?2 2F=:96.04 =?.<]f96/61+KG E.07$
H1.05 K
"!$#
9E1K<J,. 9 K
96. 7813M`13G3CF4:1O=!BP E6/]<=?1;25/b1;7 CUJF.04Bb13M`\ 2548=?CF/>= ]<25M`\ 25/.0/>= =:2RCU=:25\613] =?4:CF]fce13/6I 78BK78=:.0M1
2Y= 25/6GOB @62K.071O=,I5.6.04:CY=?.%7813M`13G CY4:1;=!B MN.0CF7:E648.07L .<=".0.0/U78=:254:1;.070Z1;= IF1;J5.<7 ]025/78=?4:CF13/>=:7 25/
9 CY=D13/E 2548M C =?132F/ 1;/ =?96.,7=?254813.<7D137DE7:.0@`CF/@ 962 =:9 CY=1;/E 254:MNCY=:1325/ 137DE7:.0@LHa . ]<25/67813@6.<4 =?9. ]<257:1;/6. 7813M`13G3CF4:1O=!BNM`.SCY7:E648. CF/@RCN/. & CF\\64:2>CY]f9 =?9 C =C =:=?.<MN\=?7=?2`M CFcY. L <. =8=?.<4E678. 2H $7$
" " " ' " '
"#$* !"# $
257813/6. 7813M`13G CY4:1;=!B 137%C 7=fCF/6@6CF4:@ M`.SCF78E64:. E678.0@ 13/ 1;/E 254:MNCY=:1325/Q4:. =?4:1;.<JYCFG F2 4]025M`\ CF4813/6I
78=:254:1;.07/ JFCY/ 1 878L .<4:I5.[Z Q D!/^=?9137CF\6\4:2>CF]f9_Z C 7=?254B 137,=:4:.0CY=?.<@ CF7C JF.0]<=:254$CF]f9
2=:96.%]025M`\ 25/6.0/>=:7,13/ =:96.J5.<]<=:254 137 CF7:7813I5/6.<@^C .<13I59>=$ 96.
.<13I59>=:7CF4:.]f9257:.
=?9.9613IF96.04=?96.D".01;I59>=SZK=?96.M`2548.13M`\ 2548=?CF/>="=:96.]<25MN\ 25/6.>= 137=?2 =:96.78=:2548B 96.%]02F7:13/. 7:1;MN1;G CF481;=!B L . = .<.0/ = 2 7=?254813.07137=:96. 1;/6/6.04\64:2K@6E6] =%2=:96. ="2^JF.0] =?25487%/6254:MNCFG;13d0.<@Q=:2
CF4:. J5.<]<=:254:7 4:.0\4:.078.0/>=?1;/6IU="2Q78=?2F4:13.<70Z CF/6@)137%=:96., .<13I59>= 13/Z6=:96.0/^=?96. 2548M E6G3C 254 ]0257813/6.7813M`13G CY4:1;=!B 1;7 "!# ' $ )( %& *( $ $
E6/61O=G3.6IF=?9L` bCY/6@
=?9./ .0CY=?E4:.
2
96.]025M`\ 25/6.0/>=:7 13/ =?9.J5.0] =?254 CF48.=?4:CF@61;=:1325/6CFG3GOBM 2F4:@67\648.07:.>=1;/ =?96.7=?254B 96.<7:.
"254:@67UCF48. 78=?2F\6\ .<@(CY/6@*7=?.<MNM`.0@ 9. ".01;I59>=?7^25/ ]025M`\ 2F/6.0/>=?7QCF48. I51;JF.0/ E67:1;/6I C 7:]f9.0M`.]SCYG3G3.<@ H 96.<4:.CF4:. M CY/eB JYCF481 CY=:1325/725/ .6CY]<=?GOB 962 137]025M`\6E=:.0@ a .B 1;G3GHE7:.N=:96., 254:M E6G CF7%E7:.0@ L>B PRCF787 254 G;G CF/
Z TFV5V5V 96137 137%=?9. c CF\61
.<13I59>=?1;/6I 78]f96.0M`.> 25L .04=?7825/
Z Q ^ 96. ]<25M`\ 25/.0/>= 1;7 C M`.SCY7:E648. =?96CY= 1;/6@61;]SCY=:.07 =?96.U13M`\ 2F48=fCY/6]0.^2 .SCF]f9 =:.048MUZ,2F4N7=?.0M`M`.0@ "2548@[Z =?2 =?96.Q78=:2548B 96. CFL6L4:.<JK13CY=?1;25/ 1377896254= 254=:.04:M 4:. KG E.0/6] B # 4:. KG E.0/6] BR=!BK\613]0CFG3GOBUM`.SCY/67=?96. /eE6M L .<4 2 =?13M`.07CF/`.<JF.0/>= ]0CF/NL . 25L67:.<48JF.0@ @6E64813/6I C\ .<4:132K@ 2_ =:13M`.$ a . @62 /2F=M CFcY.E7:. 78=?4813] = 13/>=:.04:\4:.<=?CY=?1;25/b2 =:96." 254:@F 4:. eG E6.0/6] B .<4:M 48.$eG E6.6]
78=:2548BFZ=?96. M`254:. 1;MN\ 2548=?CF/>=1O=137=?2 =:96. 78=?2F48B
96., 2548M E6G3C 254
=?9 CY=".13G3G E67:. 1;7
I51OJ5.0/QL>B
96.<4:.
V
Q
137=:96./KEM L .<4"2_=?1;MN.<7D=?96.=?.<4:M 2K]0]<E64:713/ =?9.7=?254B5Z 137=:96.G;.0/6IY=?9 2
=?9. 78=:2548B /eE6M L .<4H2"2548@67D.]CF/6@"!# 137 =?96. CSJF.04?CYI5. G;.0/6IF=:9 2 =?96.7=?254813.07)1;/ =:96.78=:2548B 78.<=$ 96137)I51OJ5.07C
7:]02F4:.=?9 CY=)4:CF/6I5.<7: 4:25Md<.0482 =:2 2F/6.FZ 1;=:9
M`254:. ]<25MNM`25/6GOB 2K]0]<E64:4813/6I>"254:@7N48.0]0.<1;JK13/I C 961;I596.04M".01;I59>= 96.
$ %
]<25MN\ 25/6.>=
96.=?7 CF]048257:7 78=:254:1;.072,@1+) .04:.>= G;.0/6IF=:967$` 96.NCFL6L648.<JK1 C =?132F/
7=fCF/6@7" 2541;/eJF.0487:. @62]<E6M`.0/>=@ 4:.$GeE6.6]
961;7 ]<25M`\ 25/.0/>=I51;JF.07961;I596.04 " .01;I59>=?7%=?27"254:@7 =:9 CY= CF48.0/ = ]025M`MN2F/ 13/R=?9.`7=?254B 7:. = CF/6@ G32 .<4 " .01;I59>=?7=:2"254:@67=?9 CY=2K]0]0E42 =:.0/R1;/U=?9. 7:. =%27=?254813.<7$ 96.
137@6. C /.0@
CF7
96.<4:.
G325I '& G;25I Q
137,=?9. /eE6M L .<4 2H7=?254813.07,=:96.%=?.<4:M 2K]0]<E64:713/QCF/@ 1;7,=?96./eE6M L .042 78=:254:1;.07$
".013IF9e=@ 254C =?.<4:M 1;7 7:1;MN\6GOB =:13M`.07 ! / =?96. ]<25/>=?. = 2 =:4?CF]fce1;/6I6Z()*!#5Z Z CF/6@ YC 4:. /62Y=%ce/62 /[Z CF7 ". @62 /62F=%ce/62 13/ 254:MNCY=?1;25/`CFL 25E=,7=?254813.<7"=?96CY=,9 CSJF.%/62F=,]<25M`.13/`B5. ="/6.M`.<=:962@ 2$CF]0]<25M`MN2K@ CY=:13/6I 254%=?9137 137%=?2Q]SCFG;]0E6G3CY=?. =:96.078. /eE6M L .0487 254%=?9.N7=?254813.07=?9.N7B7=?.<M 9 CY7 78.0.0/ E6\ =:2U=?9. ]0E4:4:.>= 7=?254B GO=?.048/ CY=:1;J5.= 4825M =:96. =?4:CF]fce13/6I 7:. = !/ 25E4 =?.07=?7
. CY4:. =?48.SCY=:13/6IN=?96. " .01;I59>=?1;/6I 7:]f96.<MN.`CF7C L6CF7:.
,
#' " *" .-
"# ' /
(
!/ 25E647BK78=?.<MUZ " .,13789R=?2 .<JYCFG;E CY=:. =?96.,GeE CYG31;=!BU24:.
2FE6G3@ L .=?2 =:4:.0CY=,=?9.%4:.0G3CY=?1;25/6789613\67"CF7! .0CY=?E648.07 1;/ C J5.<]<=?2F4$) 96.0/_Z
QV
". ]02FE6G3@^=fCFcY. := 96. ]<257:1;/6. 7:13M`13G3CF4:1O=!B 2H=?9. JF.0]<=:254:7 25478=?2F4:13.<7CY/6@ ]<.0/>=?482513@67CF7CN7813M`1 G CY4:1;=!B E6/]<=?1;25/ ! /67=?.0CF@U2 E7:13/I B CF7!".01;I59>=?7 1;/ =?96.JF.0]<=:2540Z".13G;G_MNCFcF.%E678.%2 =?9. @1378=?CF/6]<. L .<=".0.=?1;/6I 7:]f96.<MN."a 96. ]048.SCY=:13/6I`C 4:.
.<13I59>=, 254 CR48.0G3CY=?1;25/67:913\I .0CY=?E648. 13/ C 78=:2548BFZ: . =?48.SCY= =:96. @61;78=fCY/6]0.<70Z Z)25/ =?9. 4:.=,CF/@N]=?7%=:2 L . M`254:. 1;MN\ 254=fCF/>= $2 @62 =?91370Z" .7:E6L=?4?CY]<= =?96./6. =48.0781378=?CF/6]<./ 4825M ) 96./ 254:M EG C 254,=:961371;7 Q
96.<4:.
1;7 =?96./eE6M L .042$=?9 C = =!BK\ . 2H48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\ ) # 254 .CFM`\6G;.FZ61 =:96.4:.0G3CY=?1;25/6789613\67
".04:."]048.SCY=:.0@1O=?9 CF/@ =?9."25L 8.0]<=:7%:A"13G3G> CY=:.07('CF/6@ %:P 1;]04:2F7:2 =0'2K]0]<E64:48.0@ 13/ C 7=?254B`= 1;]0.YZL 2F=?9`=?1;MN.<7 1O=?9 2FE64 "2548@67,L .<=".0.0/ =:96.0MQZe=?96." .<13I59>="25/ =?9. .SC =?E648. 254O:% A 1;G3G, CY=:.07`137 48.0G C =?.0@ =?2 P 1;]04:2F7:2 =0' 1;/ =:96.^J5.0] =?254B 254 =?96CY= 7=?254B "25E6G3@ L . Q &E Q & Q & 0 % Q &E Q &5T ( % T E 2F=?. =:9 CY==?961;77:.<=:7 C7".013IF9e= 2 d0.0482 25/ C G31;/6c 1 1;= 2K]0]<E64:7^25/G;B 2F/6]0. 1O=?9 9137^CF\6\4:2>CF]f9 =?2F".01;I59>=?13/I =?9.1 .0CY=?E648.07`I51;JF.07`4:.<7:E6GO=?7 7:1;MN1;G CF4 =?2 =`@62K.07`/62F=`]SCY\=?E648. CY/eB /2F=?1;25/ 213/>JF.04:78. @62K]0E6M`.0/>=7 48.$eG E6.0/]
7:13M`13G3CF4:1O=?1;.07 CF]048257:7 78=:254:1;.07 a .`]04:.0CY=?.`C J5.<]<=?2F4 254=:96. =?25\13] L>B CSJ5.04:CFI51;/6I =?9.JF.0] =?254872$ =?9. . CFMN\G3.%78=:254:1;.07
- -
' ( *
!/UCF/QCY=:=:.0M`\= =?2 E678.=:96.4:.
4:.
QQ
NOUNRUN:animal_health_product
NOUNRUN:network NOUNRUN:check
NOUNRUN:bring
ORGANIZATION:91fm-whyy PERSON:joe_pizuto_pimaco
ORGANIZATION:merck
ORGANIZATION:public_radio NOUNRUN:service
NOUNRUN:company
NOUNRUN:show PERSON:charlie_rose NOUNRUN:communicate_solution
NOUNRUN:part ORGANIZATION:public_radio_international NOUNRUN:world
ORGANIZATION:lucent_technologies ORGANIZATION:pri
ORGANIZATION
NOUNRUN:time
PERSON:marty_moss-coane
NOUNRUN:word PERSON:kingsley_smith NOUNRUN:listenermember
NOUNRUN:program
ORGANIZATION:whyy
#H1;I5E64:. Q & %@ )G47I-BDH$),6 @>1$47@>19A1+?>)G?>B8' +*',; ),+ J
]SCY/ L .UJK13. .<@ 2%CY7 C I54?CF\9 96.<4:. =:96.U/2@6.<7 CF48.U2FL 8.0] =?7 CY/6@ G;13/6.<7N.1;78=NL . = .<.0/ 25L 8.<]<=:7`1 =?96. B CF48. 4:.
Q 137 =?96. FI 4?CF\69 2C $% 254 CR78=:2548B W1;. 1;/6I %7$CF7 IF4?CF\69 G3.0CF@67 E67=?2=?913/6c%CYL 25E= 782]<1 CFGF/6.<="254:c CF/6CFG;BK7:1;7$ 96.M%8]0.B^]<25MN\6CF4:1;/6I =?96.25L 8 .0]<=:70Z 254 /62K@6.<7 2F/ C I54:CF\69[Z1O=?961;/ =?9. 7=?254813.07 CY=:96.04 =?96CF/,8E78=G32K25ce13/6I CY==:96. 2FL 8 .0] =?7=?96.<MN78.0G;JF.07
a .`/62 I52Q13/>=:2^=:96.`7:\ .0]01 C ]07 2"=?96.I%8]0.>=?.04870'UMN. =?962K@
a .`4:.<\64:.<7:.0/>= 78=?2F48B L>B C 7:. = 2,25L 8.0] =( J5.0] =?254 \ CF13487$^ 96.N25L 8.0] =?7 1;/ =:96. \ CY134:7 CF48.`=:96. 25L 8 .0]<=:7 13/ =?96. $ ". ]048.SCY=:., 254=?96. @62K]0EMN.1;=?9 CF/ 25L 8 .<]<= 137%]<25/67=?4:E]<=?.<@O 4825M =?9. 25L 8.<]<=:7 G313/cF.0@N=?2 =?9.25L 8.<]<= 9. .<13I59>=?7 25/ =?96.25L 8.0] =?7 1;/ =?96.J5.0] =?254CY4:.=?CFcF. 4:25M =?9."".01;I59>=?7 2F/N=?9.G;13/6ce70ZKCF7]SCYG3]0EG CY=:.0@`E67:1;/6I =:96.48.0781378=?CF/6]<. =:.0]f96/61+eG E6.13/ .<]<=?1;25/C E E T a . ]SCFG;GCF/ 25L 8.<]<=( J5.<]<=?2F4 \ CF1;4 C ]<.0/>=?.<4$ #H1;I5E64:. TUMNCSB 9.0G3\ ]0G CY4:1+ B =:96. ]<25/678=:4:E6] =?1;25/ 2C J5.<]<=?2F4 \ CF1;4:.<@ 1;=:9 CF/ 25L 8.0] = 96.R/2@6.<7 1;/ =:96. ]f9 CY48= CY4:.Q25L 8 .0] =?7=?7 =?2R=?9. 25L 8.<]<= 2,=!BK\ . /25E6/648E6/I 1;=:9 =?9.NJYCFG3E.N2 \G CF/ a . L6E13G3@ =?96.`J5.<]<=?2F4 254=?96. ]<.0/>=?.<4 1;=:9U2FL 8 .0] =/62FE6/64:E/ \G CF/QE67:1;/6I =?96.]02F/6/6.0] =?.<@R25L 8 .<]<=?7
a . 96C JF. ]<134:]=?.<4:7 254C 78=:2548BFZ" .,]SCFG;G C]0.0/>=:.04$H 96.,25L 8 .<]<=)CY7:7:2K]013CY=?.<@ 1;=:9 6137 @6.0/2F=?.<@ CF7 Z5CF/6@ =?9. J5.<]<=:254\ CF1348.0@ 1O=?9R=?9. 25L 8 .0] =137 #H1;I5E648. I51OJ5.07C I54:CF\6961;]SCFG$4:.<\64:.<7:.=:7$ !/ =?96./C I5E4:.FZN 96.0/.<J5.<4CB" 254:@ 254/eE6M L .<4 C .=fCY=:1325/[Z .CSJF.04?CYI5. =?9. " .013IF9e=:7 25/N=?96. 4:.= 13/ =?9.. CFM`\6G;.7=?254813.07 CF/6@N]04:.0CY=?. =?96. J5.<]<=?2F4:7 CF7 CFL 2 J5. 2 ]025M`\ CF48. =:96. 4:.0\4:.078.0/>=fC =?132F/ 2 C 78=:2548B =:2 =:9 CY="2 C=?25\61;]FZeG3. = CY/6@ L .=?96.7:.<=:7 2H ]0.0/>=:.04:7 ]02F/678=:4:E6] =?.0@P 254,=?96.=?2F\613]CF/@Q=:96. 7=?254B5Z 48.07:\ .0] =?1OJ5.0GOB
# 2F4 .SCF]f9 Z ]025M`\ CF48. 1;=:7%J5.0] =?254
.<13I59>=2H =:96. ]<.0/>=?.<40Z Q ,CFG3]<E6G C =?.%=?96. 7:1;MN1;G CF481;=!BN2H =:96. ]0.0/>=:.0425L 8 .0]<=:7 CF/@ ZM E6GO=?13\G;BK13/6I^1O= L>B CFcY. =?96. M C 2 =?961;7 7:EM 2 J5.<4 CFG;G 96.
!
96.<4:.
!(
$ ! ! ( ! #! ! ! (
Q
! (
Q
! (
#H13I5E4:.T<1H?A',@H' +79A?A@C=-H?>B8' +*;',@&) H1+ ?A1$@J
Story center 1 center 2
Vector
Center object vector
center 3 center 4
Object
object 1
weight 1 4
object 2
weight 2 2.5
object 3
weight 3 3
object 4
weight 4 1
object k
weight k 2.5
type PERSON center n
val
Clinton
"!"#$%&'()#*'+#-,./"#0!12%3(4'56 798 :&;
! ( Q 1+ . GeE CFG37 ( V Q 1+ .$GeE CFG;7 (
V
2F=?96.<4(1;7:.
137 =:96. /eE6M L .04 2 ]0.>=?.0487 13/
=?9. ]025M`\6E=?CY=?1;25/R2
!
CF/6@
L6E=
Z
(
GKE6CFG37
D.
$GeE CFG (
D@2.<7 /2F=.
137 =:96. /eE6M L .04 2J5.<]<=:254:7 13/
# 254. J5.<48B ]<.0/>=?.<4 1;/
CF/@
#H13IFE64:.C 7:962 7
ZL". ]025M`\6E=:. =?96.<134]<.0/>=?.<4
7:1;MN1;G CF481;=!B E67:1;/6IR]07813M CF/6@b7=?2548. =?9. JYCFG3E6.N13/ CQ=fCFL6G;.Qa . =:96.0/ 78.0G;.0]<= =?96. MNC
]07813M 7:]<254:.7 254 .SCF]f9 ]0.>=?.04 1;/ !/ =?96. C IFE64:.YZ)=:9 CY= M`.SCF/7 =fCFce13/IR=?96. N M C 13/ .SCY]f9 482 / a . 9 CSJ5. ]01;4:]0G;.0@^=?96. M C#Q7:]02F4:.0713/^=?96. C I5E648. 2Y=?13]<.%=?9 CY= =?9137CFG3G;2# 7M`254:.=?96CF/ 25/. ]0.>=?.04 1;/ =?2RL . \ CY134:.<@I1;=:9b25/6. ]0.0/>=:.04 13/ ! 137 =?96.=!13789Q=:2`C JF.04:CFI5. ! 1;=:9 ! 3 4 6 :6 A$9B4 M 4>;
?"A4>?
96.MN. =?962K@67: .9 CSJ5.@6.<JF.0G32F\ .<@ 4:. GKE134:. M`254:.]02FMN\6E=fCY=:1325/ =?96CF/N=:96. =:4?CF@1;=?1;25/ CFGK=?.<]f9 /61+GKE.07$ 9eE67" . CF4:. ]02F/6]0.<4:/6.<@R/62F=25/6GOB 1;=:9Q=:96.GeE CFG;1;=!B 2H=?9. 48.07:EG;=?7
.SCY7:13L13G31O=!B 2H4:E6//613/6I`=?96. CFG;I5254:1O=?96M 25/ G3CF4:IF. CYMN25E/e=:7213/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/ !/U=?9137 7:.0] =?1;25/ ".! 13G3GK@61;7:]0E7:7D=?9.,. K`]01;.0/6] B 2 =:96.CFG3IF254:1O=?96M`7J 254H\ .04- 254:M`13/6I.K=?4:CF]<=:1325/ CY/6@ =?4:CF]fce13/6I
3<. 1D 3 5 !'
96.`@ CY=?CQ78.<=/ ."254:cY.0@I1O=?9* 254%.<JYCFG;E CY=?1;25/ CFG;4:.SCY@B 9 CF@ 78=:25\6\61;/6I6Z 78=:.0M`MN1;/6I6Z\ CY48=( 2 7:\ .0.0]f9 =fCFIFI513/6IZ)CF/6@ / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=!Bb.K=:4?CF] =?132F/ \ .04- 254:M`.0@ 25/ 1;=$ 2 ".<JF.040ZCY7 =?961;7
137%/2F= CFG+ CSB7%=:96.N]0CF7:.YZ&".,13G;GD@61378]0E6787 =:96. . K`]01;.0/6] B 2,\ .04- 254:M`13/I =?96.<7:.`=fCF78cK7 # 254 .SCY]f9 2[=?9.07:.=fCF78cK7
=fCYI5I513/I ]SCF/ L . @62F/6.N2F/ C^78=:2548BR13/ =?1;MN. G;13/6.0CF4=?2 =:96.N/eE6M L .<4 2 " 254:@7 1;/ =:96. 78=:2548B 96. .K=?4:CF]<=:1325/^7B7=?.<M ]SCF/QE67:. CF/>B / CYMN.<@!.
Q
Story d
Story c csim
c1
c2
c3
c4
c5
c6
d1
0.3
0.5
0
0
0.1
0
d2
0.4
0
0
0.25
0
0.1
d3
0.6
0
0
0.5
0.1
0
d4
0.1
0
0
0.1
0.2
0
d5
0
0.3
0.4
0
0
0.1
d6
0
0.1
0.1
0.2
0
0
#H13I5E4:.H ' 3 47=-?>BD+E 9>BD3 H-(
Q
=?2=?9." 2548M C =@6.<JF.0G;25\ .<@ 1;/`=:96. P .0787?CFI5./6@.04:7=fCF/@613/6I 25/E .<4:.0/]0.a .9 CSJ5.78E6]0]<.0787-
E6G;G;BNE67:.<@ L 2F=?9QA,A, 7 / CFM`.0@ !.0/>=:1;=!B 48.0]<25I5/61;d0.04 CF/@Q2F/6.@6.<JF.0G32F\ .<@RCY= PRCF7:7 #H13/@613/6I/62FE6/64:E/67 1;/`=:.K = 1;7C 7813M`\6G3. =fCY7:c 25/6]<."".96C JF.=:96.\6CF48=-!2 7:\ .0.0]f9`=fCFIFI513/6I 13/ 254:MNCY=?1;25/`13/6]
. E678. 96.<4:.YZ CF71;= 1;7C`7=?4?CY13I59>=0 2F4( CF4:@ =fCY7:c a ., 482F=?.`25E64%2 / ]<2@. =:2^\ .<4( 2548M =?96. 7813M`\6G3. ]<254:. .048.0/6]<. 4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/R=?.<]f96/61+KG E.07 ".`@137:]<E67:
[email protected]:G;13.<4$ E64%]<2@.`@2.<7 \4:25/62FE6/ ]<254:. .048.0/6]<.N48.07:2FG3E=:1325/ 1;/ C 7813/6I5G;. \ CF787 2 =?96. 78=:2548B 7=?96. ]02K@6. \64:25IF4:.0787:.<7=?94:25E6IF9U=?9. 7=?254B5Z 1;=4:.<MN.<M L .04:7=?9. G3CF78= \ .04:7825/ CF/6@ 254:I>CY/613d0CY=?1;25/^7:.0. 13/Q=?96. =?.K =$ a 96. 1;=.0/6]<25E6/>=?.<4:7%CN7:13/I5E6G CY4 \4:25/62FE6/[Z 1;=M CF48ce7 =?9. \64825/625E6/P 1;=?9Q=?96. \64:. JK1325E67\ .<4:7825/ a 96.0/ 1O="6C /6@67%C`\6G3E64:CFG \64:2F/625E6/U1;=M CF48ce7=?9. \64825/625E6/< 1;=:9 =?96.\648.<JK1325E7 2F4:I>CF/13dSC =?132F/ 96. 7:E6L78=?4813/6IQM`.<=?92@ 2" ]02F4:. .<4:.6]0. 4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/R=fCYcF.07 7:2FMN. 9 CY=M`254:. =:13M`. =?96CF/ =?9. \64:2F/625E6/ 48.07:2FG3E=:1325/ =?.0]f9/61HeG E6. !/b=:96." 254:7= ]SCY7:.FZC /6CF1;JF. CFG3IF254:1O=?96M ]<25E6G;@ =fCFcY. D =?13M`.FZ 96.<4:. 137=?96.%/eE6M L .<4,25 2F4:@67 1;/ =?96.%7=?254B5Z=:2M E6G3GOB 4:.<7:25GOJ5.=?9.%25L 8 .0] =?7 a . @2`/2F= @62 ]025M`\6G3. =?.%48.07:2FG3E=:1325/ 9. CYG3I525481;=:96M . E67:. 137 IF1;J5.^L .
! #" %$
137C 9 CF789>=fCFL6G;.96.048. =:96.cF.
CY/6@ =?96.%JYCFG3E.%137,=?9. 2FL 8.0] = " .4:.07825G;JF. =:96.cF. B =?2
&'(
) (+*,'-+*
(
+.&'/%
- .'/+*0,'-+*
12 43% ( 5 +6 ( 7 28%9):/* ; +46 ! " 34:'0 + ( + ! " ! ( "<$ *
!/bCF/ . ) 254= =:2U7:CSJ5.N=:13M`.FZ 25E64 CFG;I525481;=?9M @62K.07 CY= M`2578=
(
78=:.0\67 a 961;G3. =?9137M CSB
/62F= 6E G;G;B 48.07:2FG;J5. =?96.25L 8.<]<=?7
2548@670Z7:2 =?961;7 CFG;I5254:1O=?96M 789625E6G;@ CY= " 254878= MN1;7:7C, . (\ 25787:1;L6G3.%48.07:2FG3E=:1325/67
Q
96. =?13M`. 1O=%=fCFcY.07%=?2^]<25/678=:4:E6] ==?96. 4:.
= 25/ M`254:. =?9 CF/ 8 E67=
=?9.G3.6IF=?9N2=?9.78=:2548B = CFG;7:2 @.0\ .0/6@67 2F/ 2=:96.78=:2548BFZ1O=,]SCY/ 4:.$GeE61;4:.CF4:25E/6@ 25/6GOB 48.$GeE61348.07 CF4825E6/6@
*
( 7=?.0\7$)
*
78=:.0\67
137"]0G;257:. =?2 =:96.G;.0/6IF=:9
1;7 ]02F/678=?CF/>= CF/6@ 78M CFG;G Z>=?9.0/ 1;=
AC. 1D 5'
96. =:13M`. F2 4\ .04- 254:M`13/6INCN=:4?CF]fce13/I 4:E6/ 137
96.048. 31 7 =?96. /eE6M L .042=?25\61;]07
=?96.`78=:254:1;.07 13/ =?96. =?25\13]`CF/6@ =?96.`78=:2548B L .013/I ]02FMN\ CY4:.0@L 96.N=:13M`.M 254%=?96.I%8]<.0/>=?.<4:70' CYG3I525481;=:96M 1;7 ( ? Z 96.<4:. 1;7 =:96. CSJF.04?CYI5. /eE6M L .042"2FL 8.0] =?7CF/R2FL 8.0] =13748.0G3CY=?.<@R=?2> 254=?9. ]025//6.0] =?1;JK1O=!B 2) =:96. /62K@6. CF/6@ 1;7 =?9. /eE6M L .042D25L 8 .0]<=:7, 2F4 .0CY=?E4:.07 Q1;71;/ E6.6]0.<@RL>B CY7 I54:2 7
B =?96.UMN. =?962K@ 2 $% ]048.SCY=:1325/ E67:.<@ 137 G3CF4:IF.FZ>=?96. ]<25E6G3@ L .]0E6L61;]0GOBN48.0G3CY=?.<@ =?2 =:96.G;.0/6IY=?967"2 =?96.78=?2F4:13.<7$D !/ 2F4:@6.<4 =?2 4:E6/N=?96. 8% ]0.= 2[ =?1;MN.YZ " ./6.<.0@ =:2" 254:c, 1;=:9 C 7:MNCFG3G . =:=:13/6I . ` K ]<13.0/>= \ .<4( 2548M CY/6]0.F 254R=:96. % ]0.0/>=:.04:7(' CFG;I525481;=?9M 48.$eG E61348.07 J5.<48B eG E613]fc G32K25ceE6\ 2 JYCFG3E.07$ # 254N=?96. 25\ .04:CY=?1;25/67" . 9 CSJ5. =?2 \ .<4( 2548MUZ 1;= 137 7:1;MN\G3.07= =?2 7=?2548. 78=:254:1;.07^CF/@ =?25\61;]07 1;/ 7:.0\6CF4?CY=:. C G3.<7$ E64:1;/6I Cb=?4:CF]fce13/6I 48E6/[ZCFG3G 2 =?96. =:25\613]<7 CF48. [email protected]@ 13/>=?2 M`.0M`2548B) K=:254:1;.07 CF48.=?9.0/ [email protected]@ 2F/6.%CY=C =:13M`. =:2 L .]025M`\ CF48.0@ =?2 =:25\61;]07$
2F4:MNCFG31;dSCY=:1325/U2
78]02548.07 137%\ .04- 254:M`.0@ C =:.04=?9. =:4?CF]fce1;/6IU48E6/ 137%]<25MN\G3.<=:.0@[Z L6E= =?CFcF.<7 J5.<48B^G;1;=:=:G3. =?13M`.
!"#$%&(')!*,+-!'.#'.#0/1'.$"# 3254768 9 $;: <--'="-> ,?! @!%A"##BC(<# (')-25476D &B-1 E#$ GFH I-J#-($-')(J%AK 9'.#72I476D LEMN"# >B'.!;'.(<-;L/;:,($&:,$!#' $ PO,:,;$
(QP:,$!#' $R?
Q
78BK7=?.0M
2F/ =:25\613] 2) =?2F\613]
=:4:E=:9 25/ =?25\13] 2 )N =?25\61;] CFG378.CFG CY4:M M`137:7
CFL6G3. 7),6D9A1 ),6 )G@C3 ),+-(*3 BD9>9$J
K
= 6.A$9B4
=1@?J,143 5 !'
9>3
# 254 .<JYCFG3E6CY=?1;25/[Z
. E7:. =:96. TN=?4:CF13/L ]<]SCF\R78.<=$ =1;7C 78.<=%2/FV > T`7=?254813.<7]025M`\61;G3.0@
4:2FM ]0G;257:.<@!]0CF\=?1;25/6.<@^=:.K=2H/. 7 L64:2>CY@6]SCF7=?7 2 A Z , Z CF/6@Q a .=:4?CF]fc =?2F\613]<72 J5.<4=?96. 7:.<=2) 78=:254:1;.07$ 96. /eE6M L .042 =?4:CF13/61;/6I`78=?2F4:13.<7\ .04=:25\61;]FZ Z_1;778.<=C = 25E64 D a .1;I5/62548.0@ =?96.%=:25\613]<7! 1;=:9UG;.07:7,=:9 CF/< 25E64 25/ =?2F\613]%7=?254813.07 1;/ =?96.7:. = K
A
DEJ,.6=9EK
!/ 25E4 .<JYCFG;E CY=:1325/[Z " .D CF/>=,=?2 .CFM`13/6.962 .
a .Uce/62 =?9.UE6/@6.048G;BK13/6I @61;78=?4813L6E=?132F/ 2%25/ Y2)N =?25\61;] 78=?CY=?E67 254`CFG;G 78=?2F4:13.<7B 2F4`.0CF]f9
=?2F\613]`13/ 25E64 .<JYCFG;E CY=?1;25/ 7:.<=$ a .`]SCF/ @62U=:96137 L>B M`.SCY7:E64813/6I^=?96.B CFG378. CYG CF48M 4?CY=:. CY/6@ M`137:74:CY=?.
CFG378.`CFG CF48M 2K]0]<E64:7 96.0/ CQ7B7=?.<M 48.0\ 2548=:7 CQ78=:2548B CF725/ =?2F\613]M96.B =?9. /eE6M L .04 2 25/ =?2F\613]`78=:254:1;.07$ 96. 2F4:M E6G3CF7/ 254 =?9. .0484:254 4:CY=?.<7 254C`IF1;J5. =?25\61;] CF48. CFG378.CFG CY4:MP /eE6M L .<4 /e2E6)NM =?25L \6.041;] 28 ) E6 @6=?IF2F.0\6@Q13] 25/ =:25\61;] /eE6M L .<4 2F/ =:25\613] 8 E@6I5.0@Q2) =:25\613] MN1;7:7$ /eE6M L .<4 2F/ =:25\613] E64 78BK78=:.0M`7 @62 /62F= IF1;J5. 9 CF4:@P8 E@6I5M`.0/>=?7 CF7 =:2 96.<=:96.04 CY/ 78=?2F48Bb1;7 25/ =?25\13] 2F4 2) =:25\613] !/678=:.SCF@_Z " . 25E=?\E=C /eE6M L .04 =:96.9613IF96.04 =?9. /eE6M L .<40Z =?96.M`254:.%]<.04=fCF1;/1" . Q
CF48.=?9 C =,=?96.%7=?254B 1;7,25/ =?25\13]%/ 2F4:@6.<4 =?2 ]<25/>J5.04=C /KEM L .<4,13/>=:2 C 78=?4813] =,25/ =?25\13]2F4
2) := 25\613]!8E6@6IFMN.
". ]f9622F7:. C) .0] =?7=?9. CFG378. CFG3CF4:M CF/@R=?96. M`137874?C =?. 13I596.<4=:964:.<7:9625G;@67%]SCY/ @6.0]<4:.SCY7:. =?9. CFG378. CFG3CF4:M'4:CY=?.,LE=)1;=&13G;G1;/6]048.SCF78. =?96. M`13787H4:CY=?. a .!C /6@ 1;[email protected]:CFL6G3.=?2%]<25/678=:4:E6] = C I54?CY\69^2 CYG37:.CYG CF48M CF/@UM`13787,4?CY=:.072 J5.<4CFG;G =:964:.<7:9625G;@67$) 961;7!,CSBFZ ".]SCF/Q13G;G3E67=?4:CY=?. =?9.=:4?CF@.02) L .<=" .0. CFG;7:.CFG3CF4:M 4?CY=:. CF/6@QMN1;7:7 4?C =?. .<=:.0]<=:1325/ .04:48254=:4?CF@6.<2) )D ]<E648JF.07I51;JF. CF/ CY\6\64:2F\64:13CY=?./, CSBU=?2 I54:CF\69 =:9613713/ 2548M CY=:1325/L .<. PRCF4=?13/
Z Q : 254C M`254:.=?96254825E6I59^@6.<7:]<4:13\=?132F/Q2H )*]0E64J5.07 96. \64825I54:CFME678.07") ]0E48J5.<7,CF7C%78=?CF/6@ CY4:@`.<JYCFG3E6CY=?1;25/ =?2K25G ) ]<E648JF.07 \G CF]<. CFG;7:. CFG CY4:M \4:25L CYL613G;1;=!B CYG325/6I =:96./ ! C 137 CF/6@UMN1;7:7\64:2FL CFL61;G31;=!B CFG;25/6I =?96.B C 1;7$, 71;/ P CF48=:13/
Z Q f Z13/67=?.SCY@ 25CE 13/6I =?9.%7:]SCYG3.%CFG;25/6I =:96.C .07,=:2 =:96.%E6/61O=?7,2H \64825L C L61;G31;=!BFZ" .E678. =:96./254:MNCFG6@6. JK1 CY=:.072_ =:96.\4:25L CYL613G;1;=?1;.07$=?2/CE =?96. 7:]0CFG3.D 961;7"@62K.07C . =?913/6I57 =?2 =:96. )&]0E48J5.<7$ #H1;4:7=SZ 1+D =:96. @61;78=?4813L6E=?132F/672) 7:]<254:.<7%I51;JF.0/ =:2 25/ =?25\61;] CY/6@ 2) =:25\613] 78=:254:1;.07CF48. 4:.= .<]025/6@_Z =?9137D7=?4:. =?]f96.<7"2FE=D=?9. G32
.<4D.0/@67)2 =?96. I54:CF\69 96137. CFL6G;.07.0CF78B @6137=?13/]<=?1;25/ 1;/ 4:.=:.04:.<78=:.0@ 1;/N=?9.78BK7=?.0M \ .04( 2F4:MNCF/6]0.CF]048257:7"M CY/eB =:25\61;]07$ 9.04:.CF4:.= 2 ]025M`MN2F/ C BK7 =?2 ]<25/67=?4:E]<=QC ) ]<E648JF.> 254 M E6GO=?1;\6G3.^=?25\13]07 MNCF]<4:2 CSJ5.<4?CFI51;/6I CF/6@ \ 2K25G3.<@ CSJ5.<4?CFI51;/6I # 254 C I51OJ5.0/b=:964:.<7:962FG3@[ZH=:96. =" 2 MN. =?962K@67 ]<25/67=?4:E]<=, CFG;7:. CYG CF48M CF/6@ M`137:7 4?C =?.07 CF7 25G;G32 7 PRCF]<4:2
CFG;7:.CFG3CF4:M M`13787
$
CFG378.CFG CF48M /KEM L .<42H=:25\613]<7 13/^ MN1;7:7 /eE6M L .< 4 2 =:25\613]<713/
$
TFV
H2K25G
$
/KEM L <. 42)N =?25\13] 8E6@I5.0@Q25/ =?25\61;] 254,=?2F\613] /eE6M L .042) =?2F\613]D 2F4,=?25\61;] /eE6M L .<4 2F/ =:25\613] 8E6@6I5.<@U2) =:25\61;]D 254 =?25\13] M`137:7 /eE6M L .<4 2F/ =:25\613] 254,=?25\13] 96.<4:. 1;7=:96.78.<= 2_=:25\613]<7$)PRCY]04:2 CSJ5.04:CFI51;/6I I51OJ5.<7 $. GeE CYNG ".01;I59>="=:2 .<JF.04BN=:25\613]YZ 913G3. \ 225G;.0@QCSJ5.<4?CFI51;/6I IF1;J5.M`254: . ".01;I59>==:2N=?2F\613]<@ 7 1O=?9QG CF48I5.04/eE6M L .04872 D25/ =?25\13]78=:254:1;.0$7 !/ =?9..<JYCFG;E CY=:1325/[Z ". 13G;G 2F/6G;B E678.\ 225G;.0@ C JF.04:CFI513/I CF7 =:96.]02K@6" . 254 MNCF]0482 CSJ5.<4?CFIF13/6I6Z M`.SCF/61;/6I =?96CY= G CF48I5.=?2F\613]=?.<@
CFG378.CFG CY4:M
$
$
(
K
$
D>143 3<9E.
? !@3
a .RCF48.RCFG;7:2 1;/>=?.048.07=?.0@ 1;/ 96. =?96.<4 ="2 78BK78=:.0M`7 I51;JF. 7813M`13G CY4 CF/67- .<4:7$*a .113G3GE678.
7:]0CY=:=:.04\6G;2F=?7%=?2 JK1378E CFG;G;BU13/>J5.<78=?1;I>CY=:.`]<254:48.0G3CY=?1;25/ 2"7:]02F4:.07 CFM`25/6I 78BK7=?.0M`7$N " .`\6G32F= .<JF.04B8E6@I5MN.>==?9. 78BK7=?.0M`7MNCFcF. 52 4=?96. .<JYCFG3E6CY=?1;25/^7:.<=D . CF4:. E67:1;/6I6Z C 7:]0CY=:=:.04\6G32F=
"25E6G3@^9 CSJF. ]=?7 !/Q2F4:@6.<4=:2 4:.0@E6]0.=?96.%/eE6M L .<4 2H\ 2513/>=:7 25/ =?9. \G32F=:70Z " ."1;G3G4:CF/6@62FMNGOB 7?CYMN\6G;. CF\6\4:213MNCY=?.=?CFI5. 225/ =?25\13] 7=?254813.<7 L .0]SCYE67:. =:96.048. CF4:. M CF/>BQM`254:. 2)N =?25\13] 78=?2F4:13.<7=?9.0/ 25/ =?25\13] 78=?2F4:13.<7$% :". \64:.<7:.
!/ =?961;778.0] =?132F/B".\4:.078.0/>==?96.4:.<7:E6GO=?72 25E64=?.<78=?7 Da . C 84 78=\648.07:.>=,7:2FMN. L CY7:.0G;13/6. =:.078=:7 E67813/6I J5.0] =?25487,CF/@ ]02F7:13/.7813M`13G CY4:1;=!Ba .=?96. \648.07:.>=,4:.<7:E6GO=?7"E67:1;/6I =:96.]<.0/>=?.<4:7,M`.<=:962K@
2 ]<25MN\6CF4:1;/6I7=?254813.<7$Ha . @61;7:]<E67:7D=:96. E678. E6G;/6.07872 JYCF4:1;25E67 .K=?4:CF]<=:1325/ =:.0]f96/1HGeE6.071;/ =?9. ]02F/e=:.K= 2)=?96.'5]<.0/>=?.<4:70'UMN. =?962K@
# 13/ CFG;G;BFZN".N]<25M`\ CF4:. =:96. %8]<.0/>=?.<4:70'UMN. =?962K@ =?2 =?9.
' I-(%A E-)&(3"# (G0:,N /$ $'.#GEM>:"M G) -': I(K')/;>=$"M FK')<L#BP'.I' 5$ ')E-) (0:(>1 : B #:')$/1 %A$H(<- :"-/; ?L @ B 'B# B (<#') D'."#G/1)"#(')0E;:;"# (3(<# /1."M1(')$ :, B 7%AG0$:, /$ $'.#FK$ H"-# /1')E-)H!"# G1G<-3(')!?
T
Q
L CF78.0G;13/6.<7$!/UCFG3G 2H2FE64,=?.<78=?7=?4:2F13@^MN. =?962K@^L>B^CSJ5.04:CFI51;/6I
=?9. 48.0\648.078.0/>=fCY=:1325/72$=?9. .CFMN\G3.%78=:254:1;.07
1K<9 ?5',9 K
a .BC 4878= .CFM`13/6. =:4?CF]fce13/I 4:E/67 \ .04- 254:M`.0@ 1;=:9 ]<257:1;/6.N7813M`13G3CF4:1O=!B CY/6@ c CF\61
".013IF9e=:13/6IE #H13IFE64:.
78962 7`=:96. 4:.<7:E6GO=?7, 254 JYCF481325E67 M`.<=:962K@67 2" .SCY=:E64:. 78.0G3.<]<=:1325/
=
137 /62F= 7:E4:\648137:1;/6IU=:9 CY= =?96.NL .<78= \ .<4( 2548MN1;/6IQ78BK78=:.0M 137=?96.N25/6. =?9 CY= E678.07 CFG;G. 2F4:@67 CY7
.SC =?E648.07$ 96.Q2F=?9.04 = 2 G31;/6.07 78962 =?96.7 .0CY=?E648.^7:.0G;.0] =?132F/ E7:13/I / CYMN.<@!.=?1O=?1;.07 CF/6@ /625E6/648E6/67 JF.0487:.07 =?96.NE67:.N2 8E67= /62FE6/64:E/67 1;7 7:2FMN. 9 CY= 7:E648\64:1;7:1;/6I a 9613G;. =?96., .0CY=?E648. 7:.0G;.0] =?132F/ 254%L 2F=:9 MNCFcY.`E7:.`2,25/G;BR/25E6/67B =:96. CF]<==?96CY= I54:25E\613/6I 2 /625E/67 137 @1+) .04:.>= =137G31;cF.0GOBN=:9 CY==?9.04:. CF48.L . =:=?.<4M CY=:]f96.072H / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=?1;.07 CF]<4:257877=?254813.<7 =?96CF/U/25E6/648E6/67$
9 '3<9E. K
? $!/.05 36FH#
1.0514365!$',K
1@'
!$'
3<. 1D 3 5 !'
a . /62 -CF/6CFG;BKd0.@61 )_.<4:.=?.K=2D=:96. 8% ]0.
*
)# 134:7=SZ
". 1;/>J5.07=?1;I>CY=?.96. =?96.<4 =:96.7:1;MN\6G;.]<254:. .04:.6]0. 4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/ =?.<]f96/61HGeE6.<7@.07:]<4:1;L .<@U.0CF4:G;13.04 13M`\ CF] =,=?4:CF]fce13/6IE G3G[2 =:96.%=?.07=?7 7:962 /U13/Q#H13IFE64:.H E678. 48.0G3CY=?1;25/67:913\67,]<25/67=?4:E]<=?.<@RE67 13/I / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=?13.<7 CF/6@Q/625E/64:E6/7$ .
. =0ZD" . 1;/>J5.07=?1;I>CY=?. 48.0M`2 J1;/6I 4:.=?E1;=?1OJ5. =?925E6I59>= L .<9613/6@ 4:.<MN2 JK13/I^=:96.0M 1;7=:9 CY= / CFM`.0@ ! .0/>=:1;=?1;.07%78.0.0M M`254:. 1;M \ 2548=?CF/>=%=?2 =?9.`7=?254B @6@61O=?132F/ CFG3GOB5Z =?96.<4:., 13G;G L . M E6]f9> . " .0448.0G C =?132F/67:961;\670Z_4:.0@E6]01;/6I T5T
vectors with cosine similarity
Random named entities and nounruns words nounruns
90
Miss probability (in %)
80 60 40 20 10 5 2 1 .01.02 .05 .1 .2
.5 1 2 5 10 20 40 False Alarms probability (in %)
60
80
90
# 13I5E648. <1H?A',@C9 &B8?>I 1B8E I?>BD+EJ =?9.`48E6/6/61;/6I =?1;MN. 2,C =:4?CF]fce13/IQ48E6/
#H1;I5E648. 7:962 7=?9 CY=%=:96.048. 137%G31O=:=:G3. @1+) .04:.6]0. 1;/ =?9.\ .04- 254:MNCF/6]<.@9.0/ 48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\67.1;=:9NL 2F=:9N25L 8.0]<=:7,CF7/625E/64:E6/7 CF48.48.0M`2 J5.0@L 96. C I5E4:. CFG;7:296CF7)CG31;/6. 2F4HE67813/6I%25/G;B /625E6/4:E6/67 ) 2F=:. =?96CY=H=:96. G31;I59>=HL6G;E6.%8/2]02548. .<4:.0/]0. 4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/'`G31;/6.2)#H1;I5E64:. N1;7 =:96. 7:CFM`. CF7 =?96. \6E648\6G3. 8% / CFM`[email protected]/>=?1O=?1;.07CF/6@R/62FE6/64:E/67 1;=:9b=?4813M`MN1;/6I 'QG313/. 13/ =?961;7C I5E648. 7M 1;=:9b=?96.NJ5.0] =?254 L CY7:.0@ CF\\64:2>CY]f9[Z=?96. E678. 2 / CFM`.0@ !.0/>=:1;=?1;.07 13M`\6482 JF.07`2 J5.04 =?9. E678.U2 \ CF48=-! 2 7:\ .0.<]f9 =fCYI57 13/ =?96.U]025/67=?48E6]<=:1325/ 2 25L 8 .<]<=:7$ = 7:.0.<MN7
CF78=:. E6GD=:2^/62F=E678.`1;/E 2548M CY=:1325/1 25E6/6@ 1;/RJ5.048L670Z$7:2<" .`96C JF. =?.07=?7/ 96.048. ". ]04:.0CY=?.<@ 4:.0G3CY=?1;25/6789613\67 E67:1;/6I " 254:@67 a . @62 /2F= \ .04( 2F4:M / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=!B . =:4?CF] =?1;25/ 254\ CF4=( 2 ! 78\ .<.0]f9 =fCFI5IF13/6I G3G." 254:@67 CF48.`]<25/67813@6.<4:.0@ 25L 8 .<]<=?7 96. 2F4:@67/ .NE67:.NCF48. 78=:25\6\ .0@ CF/6@ 7=?.<MNM`.0@
7813/6IB 2548@67 13M`\64:2 J5.<748.078E6G;=:77825MN.B #H13I5E4:. f Z LE=1O= ]04:.0CY=?.<7 M`254:.^4:.
variations on coreference resolution
Random pronoun and substring substring pronoun no coreference resolution
90
Miss probability (in %)
80 60 40 20 10 5 2 1 .01.02 .05 .1 .2
# 13I5E648.H
.5 1 2 5 10 20 40 False Alarms probability (in %)
60
80
90
)G@CBD)G?>BD' +-9 ',;1$; 1$@>1+-H1 @>19>' 6D=?>B8' +/=-9>1(/;',@&?>I1AH1+?A1$@C9 ),6DE,',@CB8?>I-3/J
\648E6/613/I@625/6. 1;=:9 /625E6/4:E6/ 48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\670Z#".,9 CSJ5.C=?.07=.96.<4:.!".,E67:. / CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=?13.<70Z
"254:@67=?.<4:70' CFG3I52F4:1;=:96M =?2 =?96.%J5.<]<=:254M`2@.0GL1O=?9Q4:.0G3CY=?1;25/6789613\67 CF7 .SCY=:E64:.<7$ # 13I5E648. 78962 7N=?9.U\ .04- 254:MNCF/6]<.< 2F4 ="2bM`.<=:962@7`24:.
.<.0/ / CFM`.0@ ! .0/>=:1;=?1;.07CF/6@" 254:@67 1;=:9B" 254:@ =?2 " 254:@NG313/cK7=:4:13M`M`.0@ a .CFG;7:213/6]=fC =?132F/67 .0/@ CFL648E6\=:G;B L .0]0CFE67:.Q=?96.<4:.UCF4:.QMNCF/>BbJ5.<]<=?2F4:7 1O=?9 /62 2 JF.04:G3CF\[Z".<J5. 1;=:9 2F/ =:25\613] 78=:254:1;.07 D a .%78.0.=?96CY=\ .<4( 2548M CY/6]0.D 2F4 =?96.78% ]0.=?.<4:7(' ]025M`\ CF48137:2F/ T
Random nounruns named entities and nounruns named entities and nounruns with trimming
90
Miss probability (in %)
80 60 40 20 10 5 2 1 .01.02 .05 .1 .2
.5 1 2 5 10 20 40 False Alarms probability (in %)
60
80
90
#H13IFE64:. @CB 3535BD+EF),+-(*+7),3 1(/1+?>B8? /BD+; ',@C35)G?>BD' + J M`.<=?92@[Z =?96. / CYMN.<@!.=:1;=?1;.07 CF/6@*/625E6/ 4:E/67NE7:13/I =:96. J5.0] =?254N4:.<\64:.<7:.0/>=?CY=?1;25/ CY/6@ ]<257:1;/6.^7:13M`13G3CF4:1O=!B b 9137 7:E6IFI5.07=?7N=:9 CY= =?9. ]02F/6]0G;E67:1;25/67%MNCF@6. CFL 25E=.K=?4:CF]<=:1325/ CF/@ ]<254:. .048.0/6]<.`48.07825G3E=:1325/P 25EG3@ 9625G;@ 52 4]02F7:13/.
7:1;MN1;G CF481;=!BM9.04:.=:96. S. C =?E648.07 13/N=?96.JF.0]<=:254CF48.4:.
=?9. 8% ]<.0/>=?.<4:7(' ]025M`\ CF487:1;25/NM`.<=:962K@NI51OJ5.<7 CF/7(".04:7 @61+) .048.0/>="=:9 CF/NE67:1;/6I =:96. 4:.0G3CY=?1;25/6789613\67 ]02FMN\ 25/6.
M . =?962K@ I51OJ5.<7CF/7(".04:7%@1+) .04:.>= Q Q 1;G3G;E678=:4?CY=:.07 =?9 C ==:96.>%8]<.0/>=?.<4:7(' N 4:2FM E67:1;/6IU=:96. 52 L 8.0]<=:7 CF7 .SCY=:E64:.<7 13/ CQJF.0]<=:2541O=?9 ".01;I59>=?13/I 96. 25L 8.0]<=:7 E678.0@> .<4:. / CYMN.<@! .=?1;/6I 9137 ]<25E6G3@ 9 CF\6\ .0/bL .0]0CFE678.^CF7 CF\6\6482>CF]f96.<70Z=?96.`J5.<]<=?2F4:7 " 13M`13G3CF4:GOB5Z#H13I5E4:.
T
Random named entities and nounruns with trimming words named entities and words with trimming
90
Miss probability (in %)
80 60 40 20 10 5 2 1 .01.02 .05 .1 .2
.5 1 2 5 10 20 40 False Alarms probability (in %)
#H1;I5E64:.
60
80
90
',@C(-9 ),9&',. 1H?>9J
]048.SCY=:.0@ 52 4=?9. ]0.>=?.0487M13G;G96C JF. =?9. 7?CYMN.B .SCY=:E64:.<7 CF7 C 7:1;/6I5G3. J5.<]<=:254 254=?96.N78=:2548B $2 13/>J5.<78=?1;I>CY=:. =?91370Z_#H13IFE64:. Q N T 137C 7:]0CY=:=:.04%\6G;2F="96.048. =?96. JF.0] =?254L6CF7:.<@ M`.<=:962K@R13725/
=?9. 96254813d<25/>=fCFGC 137NCF/6@ =:96. 8% ]<.0/>=?.<4:7(' CF\6\6482>CF]f9 1;=:9
Q V5V 137`\6G CY]0.0@ 25/ =?9. JF.048=:13]0CFG CF]0]<.0787$,!/UL 2F=:9U]0CF7:.<70Z /625E6/4:E6/67@".04:. E67:.<@RCF7@ .SC =?E648.07 25L 8.0] =?7 / =:25\613] 78=:254:1;.07%CY4:. MNCF4:cY.0@ L>B \6G;E677:1;I5/67%CY/6@ 2) =?2F\613] 78=?2F4:13.<7CF4:. @62F=?7 a . 7:.<. =?9 C ==?96.<4:. 1;7 7:2FMN.%]<254:48.0G C =?132F/ 2H78]02548.07 L . = .<.0/ =:96.%= 2`M`.<=?92@6 7
6 ;
9B8
96.<4:.R9 CY7 L .<.0/ " 254:c 25/ =:96. E7:.R2/6CFMN.<@!.>=?1;=:13.<7B 254BC 4:7=( 78=?2F48B @6.<=:.0]<=:1325/
G;G CF/
Z Q ?ZCY/62F=?9.04 =?CF7:c 9.=:1;=?1;.07 9 CY4:M`7 \ .<4( 2548M CF/]0.FZ6CF72F=?96.<413M`\ 254=fCF/>= 2548@67@ 25E6/6@^13/ =:.K =CF4:.@61;7:4:.[email protected]@ @@61;=:1325/ CYG3G;BFZ6=?96. B @137:]<E67:7=?96. E7:. 2)\6CF134872)/6CFMN.<@!.>=?1;=:13.<7$ 91371;7JF.048BU7:1;MN1;G CF4,=:2 T
vectors with LORs compared to centers algorithm Random vector - named entities and nounruns with trimming vectors - named entities and words with trimming centers - named entities and nounruns with trimming centers - named entities and words with trimming
90
Miss probability (in %)
80 60 40 20 10 5
2 1 .01.02 .05 .1 .2
60
80
90
1+?A1$@C9 ),68E,',@CB8?>I73 H' 3 47)G@>1(/?A',1H?A',@ &BD?>I/;1)G?>=-@>19 ',; @>16D)G?>B8' +79>I-B8479J
#H1;I5E648. $% 7 96.<4:.
.5 1 2 5 10 20 40 False Alarms probability (in %)
137 G CY4:I5. 96.01;4 E7:. 2 =:96./ CFM`.0@ .0/>=?1O=!B \ CF1;4:7 1;7 78\ .<]01 C ]%=?2,C 4:7=
78=:2548B @6. =?.0] =?1;25/[ZCF/@I 2FE6G3@b/2F= /6.<]0.<7:7?CY4:13GOB L . @134:.<]<=:G;B CF\6\G313]0CFL6G;. =:2 =?2F\613] =?4:CF]fce13/6I E64 ]025/67=?48E6]<=:1325/U2$% 7 137@61 )_.<4:.
4:.=?1O=!B ^ a . CFG3782 \6G3CF]0.B .<13I59>=?7 25/ =?9. 4:.=:1;=!B \6CF13487 9 CF@Q/62B".01;I59>=?7
=?96.<4 52 4:M`7H2 1;/E 2548M CY=:1325/.=:4?CF] =?1;25/ 9 CSJ5. L .0.`E7:.0@, 254$=?.=)]
Q @61;7:]0E7:7 =:96.E67:."26M`254:.)7825\6961;78=?1;]SCY=:.0@ 13/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/%.K=?4:CF]<=:1325/ 254 9613IF9 \648.0]01;7:1;25/ =?.K=]0G3CF7:781+C ]0CY=?1;25/1O=?961;/ C7:\ .0]<1+C ] @625MNCF13/ 961;7 "254:c 137 4:.0G;1 CF/>= 25/ MNCF/eE CFG3GOB .0/I513/6.<.048.0@ 13/ 254:MNCY=?1;25/> 254 @25M CY13/67 / CF484:2 .<4 =?96CF/b13/ 254:MNCY=?1;25/* 25E6/6@b1;/ /6.7$ a . E678.N. =:4?CF] =?1;25/ 1;/ C^@25M CY13/ 13/@6.0\ .0/6@.0/>= MNCF/6/.040Z 782Q=:9 CY= M CY/KE6CFG.0/6IF13/6.<.04:1;/6I^137%/62Y= 4:. eG E61348.0@ .096/.048=
T
named entities and words with trimming
1.4
1.2
centers algorithm
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 0
0.05
0.1 0.15 vectors with cosine on relationships
0.2
0.25
#H1;I5E64:. Q V H$)G?A?A1$@<4068',? ',; AH1+ ?A1$@ 9 ),68E,',@CB8?>I73 ,1$@C9>19 ,1H?A',@ &B8?>I ;1)G?>=-@>19 ',;-@>16D)G?>BD' +-9>I-B8409$J A 13IF4?CFM`7%CF48. 7:13M`13G3CF4 =?2^25E64 %7%13/ C . , CSBK7$ A"13I54:CFMN7]SCF/ 48. .04%=:2 = 2 2F4:@
\6964:CF7:.<70ZCb\ CF134N2/ 2F4:@67 52 E/6@ 13/ =:96. 7?CFM`.R\ CY7:7?CYI5.FZ 254 Cb\ CY134 2 " 2548@67 52 E6/6@ 1;/
=?9. 7?CFM`. @62K]0E6M`.0/>=$ a 96. L613I54:CFM`74:. .04=:2^C \ CF1;42:"254:@671;/ =?96. 7:CFM`. \ CF787?CFI5. 2F4 @62K]0E6M`.0/>=0Z=?9137137 913I596GOB 4:.
\ CF1;4 25"254:@7 1;/ =?9.%7?CFM`.\ CF787?CFIF.%254,@62K]0E6M`.0/>=1;7,]SCFG;G3.<@ M E6GO=?1 2F4:@ ]<25/6]<.0\=:7$"P E6G;=:1
"254:@Q]025/]0.0\=?71;7C`78.<=2& 2548@67=?9 CY=CF\\ .0CF4/ 254 CF48.4:.$GeE61;4:.<@Q=:2 CF\\ .0CF4 13/Q@62K]0E6M`.0/>=SZ 1+ =?9.]<25/6]0.<\=,1;7)13/NC eG E6.<48B . 1O=?961;/ C 1"2548@ 13/@62 / 96.E7:.2[M E6GO=?1 =?.<4:M-]025/]0.0\=?7 254 13/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/ 4:.<=:4:1;.<JYCFG9 CF7 L .0. 13/>J5.<78=:13I>CY=:.0@ U 96. $% 7 \64:.<7:.
2 =?.<4:M ]<25/6]<.0\=:7 1O=?9 C 13/6@2# 7:1;d0. 2 DCY\6c C G;G CF/F Q 7:962 =?96CY= 254%4:. =?4813.<JYCFGH2
@2]<E6MN.>=?70Z=:96. E67:. 2"M E6GO=?1 =?.<4:M ]025/]0.0\=?7/1;=?9 78M CFG;G 1;/6@62 7 \ .04( 2F4:M`7
2F4:7:. =:9 CF/F 1;=:9 G CF48I5.04 13/6@62 7 a . =?CFcF. =:96. 2F4:cO E48=?9.04 L>B 13/]0G3E@613/6I / CFM`.0@ ! .0/>=:1;=?1;.07 1;/ M E6G;=:1 =?.048M ]<25/6]<.0\=:7$ T
named entities and nounruns with trimming
1.4
1.2
centers algorithm
1
off-topic stories on-topic stories
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 0
0.2
#H1;I5E64:. Q Q ?>=@>19J
0.4 0.6 vector with cosine similarity
0.8
1
1+?A1$@C9*),6DE,',@CB8?>I-3 E B ,19 (-B 1$@>1+ ? ),+79 1$@ 9?>I-),+ ,1H?A',@ &B8?>I ',.A1H?>9 ),9 ; 1)
9B4>? = .A$9B4 M 4>; <= 6:=>8
9B8
a . 9 CSJ5. G3.SCY4:/6.<@ CFL 25E=&9 CY=D1;/E 2548M CY=:1325/1;7 E678. E6G13/ %7$ 96.,E678.,2 / CYMN.<@!.
1;=:9"254:@67DCFG3G;2#7 =?9.,4:.<MN2 JYCFGK2"254:@ =?2 2F4:@ 48.0G C =?132F/67:961;\6751;=?925E=DIF4:.SC =?G;B]f96CF/6I51;/6I =?9.DeG E CFG;1;=!B 2 =:96.\ .04- 254:MNCF/6]<.DG37:2ZK=:96.E678.2 / CY1;J5.]02548. .<4:.0/]0.48.07:2FG3E=:1325/N@62.<7 /62Y= 13M`\6482 JF. \ .04- 254:MNCF/6]<. a . CFG;7:21;/>=?4:2K@6E6]<.0@ C/. =?.K=]<25M`\ CF4:1;7:25/ MN.0CF7:E648. =?96CY=DMNCFcF.<7 E678.2[ %7$D 9.78% ]<.0/>=?.<4:70' MN. =?962K@N2[ ]02FMN\ CY4:137825/ \ .<4( 2548MN7)L .<=8=?.04)=?96CF/ 4:CF/6@625M CY/6@ I51OJ5.07 CF/7(" .04:7=?96CY=CF4:.%@61 _) .<4:.
."@613@/62Y= G;22Fc%CY=$4:.<7:25G;E=?1;25/ CF]048257:7$@62K]0E6M`.0/>=?7B ' = " 25E6G;@ L .\ 2F7:7:1;L6G3.=?2 @62 C ]<254:. .04:.6]0.%48.07825G3E T
centers algorithm with nounruns and maxdist = 100
1.4
1.2
1
off-topic stories on-topic stories
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 0
#H1;I5E64:. Q T
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4 0.5 0.6 vector with cosine similarity
0.7
0.8
0.9
:1+ ?A1$@C9 ),6DE,',@CB8?>I-3 )G4-4-@C' ),HCI19 ,1H?A',@ .0),9A1( ?A1HCI-+-B =19 &BD?>I 6D)G@CE,1
1
J
=?1;25/< 254 =?961;7=!BK\ . 1;/ C M CY/6/6.04 7:1;MN1;G CF4=?29 CY=" . @62 F2 4 \4:25/62FE6/67$,a . ]025E6G;@UcY.0.<\ C G31;78=2D/625E6/67 =?9 C =48. .<4=?2NCN\ .0487:25/ CF/6@ CNG31;78= 2H/625E6/67 =?9 C =48. .04=?2NCF/U254:I>CY/613d0CY=?1;25/
a 96. " .U.6]025E/e=:.04 C /62FE6/ 1;/ .<1;=:96.04 G31;78=0Z " . ]<25E6G;@ CY7:7:2K]013CY=?. =:96. CY\6\64:2F\64:13CY=?. \ .04 7:2F/ Y2548I>CF/61;dSCY=:1325/ 1O=?9 =?9. /625E6/ 13/R=:.K= CF]0]<254:@61;/6I =?2 961;]f9 G;137==?96. /25E6/*,CF7 25E/6@
13/L-/62F=:96.04 ]<254:. .04:.6]0. =!BK\ .*". @62 /62Y=^]025/67813@6.<4 137N=?96. E678. 2 CF]04825/>BM`7 13/ =?.K=$ # 254 1;/678=?CF/6]<.FZ A,P CF/6@ 8% A,P
MNCSB L .R48. .0484:.<@ =?2 CF7 L 2F=:9 8% !/>=?.<4:/ C =?132F/ CFG A E67813/6.<7:7^PRCF]f913/6.<70'
' 1;/RC @62K]0EMN.BKM @ CY=?CFL CF78. 254 CF787:1;78=fCY/6]0.B DCF/ YC ]04:2F/eBKM K2 ]0]0E4:7 13/ =?.=0Z =:96.0/U25/6.]02FE6G3@QG32K25c E6\Q=?96. CF]04825/>BM 1;/U=?9. @ C =fCFL CY7:. CY/6@ ]f96.<]fcU=:2N78.0. 1 CF/>B^2D =:96. CY]04:2F/eBKM 7 @6.C /61;=:1325/7 CFG;7:2 2K]0]<E641;/ =?96. =?.K = CF4:cY.
ZTFV5VFV 96.0/R=:96. CF]<4:25/>BKM CY/6@ @6. 6C /61;=:1325/U]025E6G;@ L .=:4:.0CY=?.<@ CF7 =:96.7?CFM`.%25L 8 .<]<=
5V
96. 8% ]0.>=?.04870' MN. =?962K@
254 ]<25M`\ CF4:1;/6I =:.K=Q@613@ /2F= \ .04( 2F4:M CF7 .=?.<4%7:1;MN1;G CF481;=!B 2F4 CF/ 2FL 8.0] =,13/ C @62K]0E6M`.0/>= 1;=:9 =?96.25L 8 .<]<=?7 13/N=:96.=:25\61;]FZ 254:]<.C MNCY=:]f9 96.048.%CF/N25L 8 .0] = 13/^=?9. =?2F\613] ]SCF/U25/6GOB^L . \ CF1;4:.0@1 1;=:9 25/6. 25L 8 .<]<=13/^=?96. @62]<E6M`.0/>= /2F=?96.<4 JYCF481 CY=:1325/ "25E6G3@ L . =?2\6G CY]0.MN2F4:.!" .013IF9e=)2F/`=:96.]0.0/>=:.047:13M`13G3CF4:1O=!B2 25L 8 .0] =?7 1;=:9NC%G3CF4:I5. /eE6M L .<4 2%48.0G3CY=?.<@ 25L 8 .<]<=:7$ a .U@613@ /62F=`=?.<78= @1+) .04:.>= \ CY4?CFM`.<=:.04:7`M E6]f9L a .U]<25E6G;@ ]f9 CF/I5. =?9.
.<13I59>=:7 25/ =:96. ]<.0/>=?.<4 25L 8 .0] = MNCY=?]f961;/6I 2F4 ]f9 CF/I5. a .U]025EG3@ 1;MN\ 257:. 4:.<78=:4:13] =?1;25/67 25/< 9613]f9Q25L 8 .<]<=:7CF48.%]0., CSB =?2 J1;7:E CYG3G;B ]025M`\ CF48.Q=:96.Q4:.078E6G;=:7N2 25/6.U78BK78=:.0M 1;=:9 CF/62Y=?96.<40ZL6E=Q=:96. ) ]0E48J5.<7P" . \4:.078.0/>=?.<@ @62 /62F=Q9 CSJ5. ]02F/EC @6.6]0. G3.<JF.0G;7Q2F4 =?.07= 96. =?96.<4U=" 2 78BK7=?.0M`7R\ .04- 254:M 7813I5/1+C ]0CF/>=?G;B @61+) .048.0/>= 2F/EC @6.6]0.b1;/>=?.04JYCFG37^]SCY/(L . ]02FMN\6E=?.0@< 96. E67813/6I MNCF]0482 C JF.04:CFI513/IN2$ =?2F\613]<7$ ? 74 9
;
4 6
961;7 MNCY=:.04:13CFGD1;7 L6CF7:.<@ 25/* 2F4:c 7:E\6\ 2F48=?.<@ 1;/ \ CY48= L>B =?96.N CY=:1325/6CFG)]<13.0/]0.N# 2FE6/6@ C
=?1;25/[Z>1;L64?CF4B 2_ 25/6I548.07:7CF/@ .0\ CF4=?M`.0/>=2_ 25M`M`.04:]<.,E6/6@.04]02K25\ .04:CY=?1OJ5. CFIF4:.0.<MN.>=
/eE6M L .0487)" TFV > T `
CF/6@U!@ 5 TFV 5
V , />BQ25\61;/61325/70ZC /6@13/6I57CF/6@U]025/]0G3E7:132F/672F4 4:.<]025M`M`.0/6@ C =?132F/67.\4:.0787:.<@ 1;/ =?961;7MNCY=?.<4:1 CYG CY4:. =:96. CFE=:9625487 [ CY/6@ @62 /62F=/6.0]<.0787?CF4813G;B 4:. .0] ==:962578. 2 =:96.7:\ 25/67:2F4$
Q
8 > 4 ?
G3G3CF/[Z[XOZ X ,CF48L 2F/6.0G;G Z ,[2K@6@61;/6IF=?2F/[ZX "CFM`4:2F/[Z , "CF/IO Q
25\13] @6.
=:.0]<=:1325/ CF/@ =:4?CF]fce1;/6I \613G;2F= 7=?E6@B 6C / CFG48.0\ 2548=$,!/ ,#$$ 0 F
G -# : #" ! -"$ 0 G
G3G3CF/[ZX;Z X51;/[Z6PIC 8M CF/_Z Da CSBK/6.FZ M61;@6.SCZeWM C JK48.0/6cY26Z 25L .048M CY/[Z M ,CF\E=?2 Q
$25\61;] L6CF7:.<@R/62 J5.
G3G3CF/[ZXOZ W C JK48.0/6cY26ZM PRCFG31;/[Z =:13M`.0G31;/6.07 PRCF787CF/@U
G !
E !/
/ ,CF/ TFV5V5V . =?.<]<=?1;25/67
25E6/6@70ZCY/6@
,#$$ 0 !# $# ! 0 -#, 0
Q F!/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/ .K=?4:CF]<=:1325/ H $.0]f96/61+GeE6.07 CF/6@`]f9 CFG3G;.0/6IF.07$#" $"% & !(' ) -# ! " " !
+*-,.%/% "* # , 0*21 " '354768
%4:1;7:96MNCF/[Z5
CF48cF. B5Z O ZK K I513GOJK13.FZePO>e)4:13]<.FZ ' AD> CFM`13G31;2, TYV5V5V > ]0482596\61;G3. / CFE=:25MNCY=?.<@ CF]<4:25/>BKM .K=:4?CF] =?254 CF/6@Q7:.<48JF.04$ !/
,#$$ 0 9
+: ! !;=<#<#<
PI>)4:d BL 2K]fcK1 Q > 96.) ]0E64J5. .04- 254:MNCF/6]<.!/ ,#$$ 0 >'?,0 @* $$# BA 476 Z
P CF48=:13/[Z>;Ze2K@6@61;/6IF=:25/[Z>PI4:@2#78ce1 Z 1;/^CF7:78.07:78MN.>=2 @.<=?.<]<=:1325/ =fCY7:c \ \6\L
Q $ C Q E
Q - !80DFE#E G G H%/, # " !# #$@% E ,#$$ 0 E %/, # 6 ,# - %* ,#$$ 0 IJ31K6
P
HCF\6c CZ / X6G;G CF/ Q
2]<E6M`.0/>= ]0G3CF7:781+C ]0CY=?1;25/ E67813/6I M E6G;=:1+"254:@ .0CY=?E4:.07 !/
,#$$ 0 L M6 " " !
1 $"" " #$F " $"% ! MN5 @ I % " O 1 " NPIQ
13G;2) ZF@ * a > .09/6.04= Q
F!/E 2F4:MNCY=?1;25/ .K=?4:CF]<=:1325/`CF7C%L CF78137: 254961;I59 \64:.<]01;7:132F/ =:.K=( ]0G CY7:7:1 C ]SC =?132F/ R1SI " -# ! " $"% !* % UT@; ? ZKT C E
25L .04=?7:2F/[Z @OZDa CFG3cY.04T
I P " C =0 2548@
Q %+%)C = " [!/ M_CF48M CY/ )@ fZ ,#$$ 0 * ) O' !"
1 $"" " #$ O'91 ! JYCF/U1 87:L .048I5.0/_Z D X5 Q
" $"% ! !"
.<]025/[email protected]@ A"E=:=:.04("254=?967 a CF787:.048M CY/[Z &+,# CFE67= Q * ,#"
P
D I L G M !# & ! Z \6\ C EQ ,CFM L4:13@I5./61OJ5.<4:7:1O=!B )4:.<7:7$