Educate Children At Risk Factors Affecting Cohort Survival Rate - Cagape Final Paper

Educate Children At Risk: Factors Affecting The Cohort Survival Rate

WENDELL GLENN P. CAGAPE, Ph.D. College Board Secretary/Campus Academic Head JH Cerilles State College, Pagadian City Campus, Balangasan, Pagadian City, Philippines [email protected]

Abstract:

Cohort Survival Rate is the measure of the percentage of pupils enrolled in the first grade who finishes Grade IV. Factors such as rural poverty, health issues such as nutrition and vitamin A supplementation, lack of school buildings, inaccessibility of schools are driving pupils away from schooling. This study was conducted in 10 disparity barangays in Zamboanga del Sur, covered under the 6th Country Program for Children by the UNICEF. Alternative livelihood helps resolve the concern.

INTRODUCTION:

The Philippine 1987 Constitution declared in Section 17 that “the State shall give priority to education, science and technology, arts, culture, and sports to foster patriotism and nationalism, accelerate social progress, and promote total human liberation and development” (Bernas, 2003). The emphasis placed on education in this context far exceeds the present-day interventions in relation to improved academic outcomes among pupils, but also encompasses the active participation of all elementary pupils and making them ready for higher educational opportunities by ensuring that they graduate in the primary or elementary level.

In the Philippine setting, almost all provinces and cities, including municipalities have elementary schools in operation however, there are much more to be constructed in barangays situated from far away localities. Zamboanga del Sur is not an exception. There are much to be desired in terms of classroom construction as well as the identification of barangays that needs

teachers and classrooms to supplement the educational needs of the general populace. This may also be one of the factors that affect Cohort Survival Rate in the Province. Because of these realities, the study has been undertaken to understand the factors affecting cohort survival. This study was conducted in 12 areas namely, Barangay Bogo Kapalaran in the Municipality of Molave, Barangay Boloron, in the Municipality of Midsalip, Barangays Sta. Lucia and San Pedro in the City of Pagadian, Barangay Libertad in the Municipality of Dumingag, Poblacion in the Municipality of Pitogo, barangay Lumbog in the Municipality of Margosatubig, Barangay Benuatan in the Municipality of Dinas, in Barangay Lunib in the Municipality of V. Sagun, Barangay Salambuyan in the Municipality of Lapuyan, Barangay Diplo in the Municipality of Kumalarang and at the Poblacion in the Municipality of Lakewood.

REVIEW OF LITERATURES:

The National Statistics Coordination Board (NSCB) defined cohort survival as, “a measure of the efficiency and effectiveness of the delivery of education services in the country, and is defined as the percentage of enrollees at the beginning grade or year in a given school year who reached the final grade or year of the elementary or secondary level” (Virola, 2007). Based on this definition, the “cohort survival rate was at 69.84 percent in the elementary level. This means that about 70 students out of a hundred who entered grade one reached grade six. For the secondary level,cohort survival rate was at 65.83 percent” (Basic Education at a Glance, 2005). The United Nations Statistical Institute for Asia and the Pacific defines this as “The percentage of a cohort of pupils enrolled in grade 1 of the primary level of education in a given school year who are expected to reach a specific grade (Survival rate to Grade 5)” (UNSIAP, 2005).

Based on these definitions, the cohort survival rate of the Province of Zamboanga del Sur from 2002-2007 as provided for by the Department of Education, as presented in this graph, revealed that since 2002, the combined Cohort Survival Rate of male and female elementary pupils are decreasing however, it gains momentum from 2005, when the Province of Zamboanga del Sur and together with the Department of Education, has engaged in massive advocacy campaign in targeted disparity barangays to improve the Cohort Survival Rate among public elementary pupils within the Province of Zamboanga del Sur. In 2002, the combined rate is 60.65%, however in the succeeding 2003 and 2004, this has fallen to 54.34% and 54.29% respectively. Affected in this downtrend of the CSR is the male pupil’s participation and completion rate as contrasted with their female counterparts. In the same years as cited above, female finishing and completing basic elementary education far exceeds the percentage of male finishing and completing the same educational level/grade. Disturbingly still, although the trend since 2005 is increasing, the male pupils have not equaled or surpassed the percentage of female pupils completing elementary, thus explains the sizable number of female students in secondary and college as well as pre-university in the in Zamboanga del Sur and in the Philippines. This data echoes the 2004 Human Development Report in which it states that the ratio of female as a percentage of male in the combined primary, secondary and tertiary gross enrollment is pegged at 104.9% (Human Development Report , 2009). Combined enrollment rate means “the ratio of the sum of elementary and secondary enrolment in the corresponding age group that should be enrolled at those levels to the sum of corresponding school age population” (Technical Notes on the Human Development Index, 2009). These are caused by factors that are otherwise associated with the patterns of investments among the national government agencies as well as the local government units. The Local Government Code of 1991 has envisioned that services of government are to be decentralized and education has not been part of the devolution of these functions in accordance to the Local Government Code hence local government units across the region and in the different municipal local governments continually depend on their Internal Revenue Allotment (IRA) for education and other social services, and is constrained in establishing schools and constructing school buildings. It has been admitted by the local government units as well as the Regional Development Council of Zamboanga Peninsula that the LGU’s dependence on the IRA “still constitutes around 55.7% of the Total Financial Resources (TFR) of the LGUs in the region” (Yebes, 2004).

6 year Comparative CSR in Zamboangadel Sur 100% 80% 60% 40% 20%

55.75 53.66 52.81 54.29 54.34 60.65

50.42 48.37 47.1 47.07 49.25 54.85

61.91 59.78 59.38 62.94 60.13 67.36

0%

2007 2006 2005 2004 2003

Total M/f

Male

Female

2002

The Zamboanga Peninsula Development Plan indicated that “LGU’s expenditures in the region indicate that only Php 1, 652.57 is spent per person. However, of this amount 46.88% is spent for General

Services rather than on Economic Services at 22.30% and Social Services at 21.43%, respectively.” This pertains to the LGU’s spending patterns relative to education which usually impacts the quality of educational services rendered. Another is on the issue of rural poverty that also affects education. Even the Asian Development Bank mentioned in its policy on education that poverty “is both a cause and an effect of insufficient access to or completion of quality education. Children of poor families are less likely to enroll in and complete schooling because of the associated costs of attending school, even when it is provided free. The cost of uniforms, supplies, and transportation may well be beyond the means of a poor family, especially when the family has several children of school age. This means that choices have to be made, and the choice is often to drop out of school or, worse yet, to deny schooling to girls while enrolling the boys, thereby contributing directly to maintaining the inferior status of women. And as poor children who are enrolled grow older, the opportunity cost (their lost labor and the foregone income it may entail) becomes greater, thus increasing the likelihood of abandoning school” (Asian Development Bank, 2009). Poverty in areas where schools are very inaccessible drives lesser participation and thus affects survival through the elementary. As if to provide the impetus for a more driven approach to ensure that pupils in the elementary finished until secondary level, the Philippines passed Republic Act 6655 which expressly elucidated that in the Philippines, secondary schooling is free in public schools. Further, the Philippine government also provided temporary employment opportunities for youths and students to earn an income while on summer and/or Christmas vacation from school as enshrined in Republic Act 7323. Both laws have been widely observed however, there is still a dearth on data of actual implementation, one being that public high schools are also not present and is inaccessible in the barangay level while summer job opportunities under the Department of Labor and Employment can not at all, accommodate all those wishing to avail of the temporary employment. At the barangay level, these two landmark laws are not widely implemented, due to the geographic location of centers of actual opportunity. Usually, those barangays that have higher poverty indices, are located in distant areas, too far away from these opportunities thus, schoolchildren will still have to resort to the traditional way of earning an income. They will help their parents tend to the farm or herd the flocks to augment the family’s income. Another consideration why pupils in the elementary drop out of school is their health. Due to the inclement weather in the Philippines, pupils are forced to be absent from class whenever they got fever and other ailments. Compounding the problem is the lack of barangay health centers that carries a full range of medications that easily addresses these illnesses, most often, the child is usually, home-rested. Home rest is where the parents tend to their sick child with usually, no medical attention and prescription, but rather relied heavily on home-grown medications and homeopathy. The level of nutrition has something to do with active participation in schools too. Nutritional nourishment also ward off sickness thus enabling school children to focus more on school activities than pre-occupied with staying at home due to sickness. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization, “Protein-energy malnutrition (PEM) and micronutrient deficiencies remain the leading nutritional problems in the Philippines. The general declining trend in the prevalence of underweight, wasting and stunting among Filipino children noted in the past 10 years was countered with the increase in the prevalence rate in 1998. About 4 million

(31.8%) of the preschool population were found to be underweight-for-age, 3 million (19.8%) adolescents and 5 million (13.2%) adults, including older persons were found to be underweight and chronically energy deficient, respectively” (FAO Nutrition Country Profile, 2001). Also, malaria is endemic in 65 of the 78 provinces, putting at risk a population of 11 Million, in mostly remote rural areas (Landey, 2004). Further, the report mentioned that twenty-five (25) of these provinces account for 90 per cent of all malaria cases. The state of malnutrition in elementary school in Zamboanga del Sur from 2005 to 2007 revealed that the percentage of malnourished school children is 19.86, 14.60 and 18.18 respectively. The data is taken from the Provincial Nutrition Council of the province. In terms of nourishment through Vitamin A interventions, 2005 data revealed that in Buloron, Municipality of Midsalip it has a total of 220 children aged 1-5 years old. For Bogo Kapalaran, in the Municipality of Molave, it has 232 children. In Libertad, Municipality of Dumingag, it has 195 children. In Poblacion, Pitogo, it revealed that it has only provided Vitamin A supplements to at least 50 children from a population of 500 children. In Lunib, Municipality of Vincenzo Sagun, it has 210 children. In Lumbog, Municipality of Margosatubig, it has provided Vitamin A supplementation on 270 children. In Salambuyan, Municipality of Lapuyan, they have 45 children. In Diplo, Municipality of Kumalarang, it has provided Vitamin A to 326 children. In Poblacion, Municipality of Lakewood, it has provided Vitamin A to 590 children. And in Benuatan, Municipality of Dinas, it has provided the same to at least 80 children. There were no records for San Pedro and Sta. Lucia, both from Pagadian City under this category. As of the 2000 census, Zamboanga del Sur had a population of 836,147, making it the 16th most populous province. The population density was 3,480/km², the 20th most densely populated province. However, a 2007 census revealed that the province has a total of 914,278. It has a total land area of 796,321 hectares. It was made a province on September 17, 1952 by virtue of Republic Act 711, making it the 52 province of the Republic of the Philippines, with 681 barangays in 26 municipalities with 1 independent city which is Pagadian City. The province of Zamboanga del Sur is primarily agricultural. Its rich oil and terrain which consists mostly of considerably low, rolling hills are ideal for the production of a large variety of crops. Fishing and grazing are important industries of Zamboanga del Sur, with fishing offering relatively unlimited opportunities due to the presence of major fishing grounds (Luceno, 2001). METHODOLOGY:

The study employs a survey method of gathering the data from the identified disparity barangays. These are identified by the Province of Zamboanga del Sur through the Provincial Planning and Development Office covered under the Sixth Country Program for Children, an intervention package for the children of Zamboanga del Sur delivered jointly by the UNICEF and the Province of Zamboanga del Sur. Of these areas, five (5) are located in the First Congressional District and seven (7) are located in the Second Congressional District.

It uses survey questionnaires in the survey. In gathering all the data, a research team was organized principally from the Provincial Government of Zamboanga del Sur. This study is a descriptive-qualitative survey thus uses simple percentages and frequencies. It uses random sampling technique.

KEY RESULTS:

From the areas identified as disparity barangays, the study has surveyed a total of 2,638 sampling size comprising 30% of the total population (household population) size of 8,794. The respondents are taken to represent per household and could either be the husband or the wife. Only one respondent is taken from one household.

Of these respondents, 76% are female and only 24% are male. This provided a total picture of the domesticity of female members of the household when the survey was conducted in the areas identified as disparity areas. The researcher has found mostly women tending to the household as men (husbands) are working, mostly on daytime. Of these, 90% of the respondents said they are already married. In terms of educational attainment, only 5% of these respondents said that they have finished college education compared to 24% of whom who said that they have “some elementary education”, but was not able to graduate. In terms of employments, 54% were unemployed while 39% are self-employed, either as a store owner, peddler or farmer. In terms of age, most of the respondents were between the age bracket of 37-40 years old who earns less than Php 2,000 income per month (52%), roughly about US 41.57 per month in the most recent currency conversion, or US$ 1.34 per day. 38% of these respondents from San Pedro, in Pagadian City said they have the most number of school-aged children which totaled to 1,011 school children, followed by Sta, Lucia, still in Pagadian City with at least 926 school children. The areas covered with less number of school-age children in the household is in Salambuyan, Lapuyan with at least, 131 school-age children.

There are a total of 4,895 school-age children in the identified disparity barangays. By distribution, at six (6) years old category, of these school-age children, 321 are presently enrolled in Grade I. Among the 7 years old category, 419 of these are in Grade I and 146 are in Grade II, while 12 are not in school. At the 8 years old category, 218 children are enrolled in Grade I, 282 are in Grade II, 145 are in Grade III, 9 are in Grade IV while 5 are not in school. At the 9 years old category, 94 are in Grade I, 136 are in Grade II, 250 are in Grade III, 129 are in Grade IV, 8 are in Grade V and 10 are not in school. At the 10 years old category, 48 are enrolled in Grade I, 70 are in Grade II, 128 are in Grade III, 214 are in Grade IV, 118 are in Grade V, 8 are in Grade VI while 10 are not in school. At the 11 years old category, 17 are enrolled in Grade I, 45 are in Grade II, 57 are in Grade III, 111 are in Grade IV, 199 are in Grade V, 124 are in Grade VI while 8 are not in school and 3 are in First year high school. At the 12 year old category, 16 are

enrolled in Grade I, 30 are in Grade II, 59 are in Grade III, 76 are in Grade IV, 122 are in Grade V, 208 are in Grade VI while 21 are not in school and 52 are in High School. In the 13 year old category, 10 are enrolled in Grade I, 13 are enrolled in Grade II, 30 are in Grade III, 31 are in Grade IV, 69 are in Grade V, 114 are in Grade VI while 22 are not in school, and at this age, 132 are in High school. At the 14 years old category, 2 are in Grade I, 6 are in Grade II, 15 are in Grade III, 21 are in Grade IV, 42 are in Grade V, 59 are in Grade VI while 19 are not in school and 119 are in High School. At the 15 years old category, 1 child is enrolled in Grade I, 1 in Grade II, 6 are in Grade III, 17 are in Grade IV, 19 are in Grade V, 34 are in Grade VI while 24 are not in school and 149 are in High School.

Among Grade I pupils being covered in the survey, the barangay that has the highest registered pupils is San Pedro, in the City of Pagadian with a total of 72 pupils followed by Barangay Poblacion in the Municipality if Pitogo. The least is Libertad, Dumingag which has only 8 pupils enrolled in Grade I. Among the pupils in Grade VI, the highest areas with 11 years old presently enrolled is Sta. Lucia in Pagadian City with 27, briefly followed by San Pedro, still in Pagadian City with 26 pupils and Poblacion, Pitogo with 23 pupils. The least among the disparity barangays Salambuyan, Lapuyan with only 1 pupil enrolled at this age category. When asked whether their children goes to school, with no particular reference as which grade levels and in reference to children age between 6-12 years old, the respondents replied yes (98%) compared to those who said no (2%). Among those who said NO, the primary concern was No money to spend on school (63%), followed briefly by No School uniform, No notebooks, papers and pencils, no schoolbag, all at 32%. Another 30% said Hard up times is the reason why their children are not in school.

Although a huge percentage of those covered in the survey have children in school, the focus of the study is now pointed towards those who replied NO to the previous question if their child goes to school.

Among those who said that their child has stopped going to school, the concentration of those pupils who last attended school at a specific grade level is from Grade III, IV and V, the highest being in Grade V with 162 dropouts followed by Grade IV with 160 dropouts.

The main reason for those who decided not to go school is poverty (50%) followed by high cost of education (14%), although in the Philippines and even in these areas, primary education is free and relatively cheap. Poverty and high cost of education are two of the factors, considerably affecting school attendance and participation among pupils in school. These concerns are being addressed by one of the factors also that affect school attendance and participation and that is earning a living 11% and doing farm work 7%. These confluences are making it hard for pupils to stay in school after they had hurdle the academic rudiments of Grade I and II, respectively. Understandably, classroom requirements among Grades III, IV and V are also relatively more

frequent as compared to the lower levels, thus compounded by poverty in the countryside, pupils easily gave up schooling to look for a living or undertake farm work to help the parents.

Among those who are in school, an overwhelming (98%) mass of respondents answered that their children do enjoy going and attending classes in the school, at whatever level they are presently in. Further, they responded that their children goes to school between 6:31-7:00AM (68%) followed by those whose children go to school between 6:01-6:30AM (27%) while only 0.1% who said that their children goes to school between 5:01-5:31AM and only 2% said that their children goes to school beyond 7AM. Considerably, the respondents do not accompany their children in going to school (92%) compared to only 8% of them said that they accompany their children in going to school. Usually, their children bring packed meals ‘baon’ (74%) to school to avoid being late because they had to go home for lunch. Also, 74% of these schoolchildren bring school bags to school for their books, notebooks, and for carriage of the packed lunches.

When asked if their children have incurred absences in school, 64% said yes and 36% said no. The causes of the absences of their children are as follows, sickness (55%), rainy season (days) at 22% and no school materials (11%).

One of the questions of the survey is whether their barangay has a barangay public elementary school, the respondents said they have (98%). The disparity barangays as identified is relatively near the Poblacion or in the Poblacion itself, therefore, presence of a public school is observed. The poblacion is a place where considerable concentration of economic activity is present, i.e. stores, public markets, churches, barangay offices and even municipal offices. Laudably, in Zamboanga del Sur, almost all municipalities have public schools strategically located and established in nearby barangays adjacent to a Poblacion, there is still an unmet barangay due to non-establishment of public elementary school, which unfortunately, were not covered under this study. For the 2% that they are located in a locale that do not have a barangay public elementary school, the furthest school is less than a kilometer away to as far as 1-3 kilometers away. Usually, these schools are accessible by paved/concrete roads (51%) and graveled road (46%). In the entire province, most of the barangays are accessible although in some areas, there is a need for more infrastructures linking one area to the other. Further, majority of the school children walk to school (94%) as compared to those who do not because there are modes of transportation like motorcycle and public transportation system. In this context, the child usually walks since public elementary schools are closely located in densely populated areas and/or centers of economic activity, and these school children wear slippers in going to school (95%).

Although the Department of Education do not requires school uniform among public elementary schools in the country, this survey revealed that 96% of the respondents said that the schools that their children attended requires a school uniform. Further, the survey revealed that 78% of the respondents complied with the school uniform requirement and had their children wear uniform

in going to school and 22% of the respondents commented that their children do not wear school uniform in going to school, although they have no idea that the Department of Education does not require school uniform among public elementary schools, among others as evidenced in Department Orders issued by the Department of Education.

In terms of the question of whether their children have enough books, it revealed that 64% of the respondents answered that their children have enough school books, although in this particular question, there was no indication if the books are owned or not, or whether the books are being brought to their respective homes or being used in the classroom. Upon evaluation, the responses revealed that it was rather based on the perceptions of these parents that their children have enough books inside the classroom, although the qualification as to how many is enough is absent.

91% of the respondents revealed that their children have time to study in their homes using the books prescribed in the class. However, when asked if their homes have provision of electricity, 39% of them said that they do not have electricity at home as compared to 61% who said they have. Of the 39% of the respondents who do not have electricity at home, their main source of light at night are the following, lamparilla (table lamp) 99% and candle (1%). For those who have electricity at home, when asked whether they have TV sets at home, the survey revealed that they have a TV set at home 62% as compared to those who have not. When asked how long does their child watch TV on weekdays, it revealed that their child watch TV for 1-2 hours daily (56%) and less than an hour daily (44%).

When asked whether their child makes homework or assignments at home, the survey revealed that 97% of them said YES compared to only 3% who said NO. In effectively participating in many school activities, we have asked if their children have enough papers to write on, 83% of the respondents said YES and 91% of the respondents said that their children also have pencils to be used in school.

According to the respondents, their children, while attending schools are required and has in their possession at least, 8 or more different notebooks (36%), followed by those who said that their children has between 6-7 different notebooks (24%) and between 4-5 different notebooks (20%).

Relatively, as to the question on the number of teachers the elementary school where their children went to school, the respondents said that it has 8 or more teachers (68%) as compared to those who said that there are only between 4-5 teachers in the elementary school where their child goes to (9%). When the respondents were asked whether they knew the school teacher of their children, they answered overwhelmingly with a yes (78%) as compared to those who do not know the school teacher of their children. Further, majority (96%) of the respondents said that

the teacher of their children comes to school early. And when asked whether the teachers conduct classes on a daily basis, their responses are overwhelmingly yes (97%), only 3% of these respondents said that the teachers only have classes at least four times a week.

Considerably, these schools as located in the disparity barangays are not multi-grade schools instead, a complete barangay public elementary school as revealed by those who said that the school where their children attended are not multi-grade schools (95%). These schools, according to the respondents have enough seats inside the classroom (97%) and majority (97%) of the respondents revealed that their children have seats inside the classroom where they are presently enrolled.

CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDATIONS:

Cohort Survival Rate is affected by factors such as poverty, health, distance of schools, motivation as well as incentives of going to school. As evidenced in this study, the cause of low CHR in the province is rather poverty and the inability of the national government to construct more school buildings in strategic areas within the province. Construction of school buildings are still within the ambit of the national government rather than devolved to Local Government Units. In this case, as mandated by the Local Government Code, the proceeds of the Special Education Fund (SEF) usually go to the hiring of locally-paid teachers to augment much needed human resource. These teachers are placed on the payroll as locally-paid teachers until a permanent teaching position is made available. Also, rural poverty plays a critical role. Rural poverty is driving pupils away from schools since they have no sufficient meals to take before going to school and for mid-day lunch. The pangs of hunger always hinder their dream of finishing schooling in the elementary level. At first, they may have a head-start when they enroll in Grades I and II however, due to poverty, they do not often enroll in Grades III and IV. Also, improved nutrition among schoolchildren has to be intensified to ensure that they attend and finished schooling.

For an increased CHR in the province, an intensive intervention that targets rural poverty alleviation should be considered. Intensified alternative mode of living like planting of cassava, high value crops, fruit trees should be encouraged to allow farmers to earn more income to

finance their daily needs, which includes meals for their children prior to going to school and the mid-day lunch. Cassava planting is a viable option to make livelihood in the barangay level work for every farmer since the cassava produce can be harvested after 10 months and it do not necessarily require huge open tracks of land for plantation purposes. This is also small-scale but the potential for earning additional income is higher.

Also, extensive and intensified intervention of the UNICEF and the Province will ensure improved CHR among pupils, thus ensuring more pupils enrolling in secondary and eventually, in the higher education sector.

Bibliography (2005). Retrieved July 27, 2009, from UNSIAP: www.unsiap.or.jp/mdg.../EducationIndicators.ppt Asian Development Bank. (2009). Retrieved August 1, 2009, from Policy on Education: http://www.adb.org/Documents/Policies/Education/educ0300.asp? p=educ Basic Education at a Glance. (2005, February 5). Retrieved August 5, 2009, from Senate Economic Planning Office: http://www.senate.gov.ph/publications/AG %202005-02%20-%20Basic%20Education.pdf Bernas, J. G. (2003). The 1987 Constitution of the Republic of the Philippines: A Commentary. Quezon City: Rex Printing Company, Inc. (2001). FAO Nutrition Country Profile. Rome: FAO. Human Development Report . (2009, January 2). Retrieved August 18, 2009, from United Nations Development Programme: http://hdrstats.undp.org/countries/country_fact_sheets/cty_fs_PHL.html

Landey, D. (2004). A Common View, A Common Journey, A Common Country Assessment of the Philippines. Manila: UNDP Philippines. Luceno, E. A. (2001). History of Zamboanga del Sur. Pagadian City: Alfred Printers. Technical Notes on the Human Development Index. (2009, February 21). Retrieved August 04, 2009, from National Statistical Coordination Board : http://www.nscb.gov.ph/technotes/hdi/hdi_tech_def.asp Virola, R. (2007, January 4). National Statistics Coordination Board. Retrieved August 3, 2009, from NSCB: http://www.nscb.gov.ph/pressreleases/2007/Jan04_PR200701-SS2-01_educglossary.asp Yebes, R. E. (2004). Zamboanga Peninsula Regional Development Plan 2004-2010. Zamboanga City: Regional Development Council/National Economic and Development Authority.