Vacuum Cleaner – Acoustic Analysis
1
Objective
The objective of this Acoustic study through CFD analysis is to determine the loudness ranking of a vacuum cleaner part for various design options.
2 2
Extracted Fluid Domain
Large-Radius
Flat
Middle-Radius
Small-Radius
Flat-Rib 3 3
Extracted Fluid Domain (cont…)
Channel-1
Channel-2
Straight
Channel-3
4 4
Velocity Streamlines
Large-Radius
Flat (reverse flow observed @ outlet)
Middle-Radius
Small-Radius
Flat-Rib
5 5
Velocity Streamlines
Channel-1
Channel-2
Straight
Channel-3
6 6
Distribution of Acoustic Power (dB)
Large-Radius
Middle-Radius
Flat
Small-Radius
Flat-Rib
7 7
Distribution of Acoustic Power (dB)
Channel-1
Channel-2
Channel-3
Straight 8 8
Loudness Comparison Tables Vacuum Cleaner–I Project Loudness Ranking using CFD
Sr. No.
Geometry Name
Total Acoustic Power (W)*
1
Large-Radius
1.01 e -10
5
2
Middle-Radius
1.66 e -10
3
3
Small-Radius
1.26 e -10
4
4
Flat
30.2 e -10
1 (Loudest)
5
Flat-Rib
4.16 e -10
2
(based on Total Acoustic Power, W)
Vacuum Cleaner–II Project Loudness Ranking using CFD
Sr. No.
Geometry Name
Total Acoustic Power (W)*
1
Channel-1
2.64 e -10
2
2
Channel-2
2.77 e -10
1 (Loudest)
3
Channel-3
1.93 e -10
3
4
Straight
1.62 e -10
4
(based on Total Acoustic Power, W)
* For details please refer appendix A 9
Appendix-A 1. Following is the Proudman’s Formula# to calculate Acoustic Power per unit volume : P (W/m3) = 0.1*ρ *ε*{√(2*k)/c}5
2. This Acoustic Power can be converted into dB unit using following relation & same is plotted in slide#5 : P (dB) = 10*log10 {P (W/m3) / Pref}
where Pref = 1e-12 W/m3
3. Taking Volume Integral of P (W/m3), total Acoustic Power Generation for respective Geometry can be determined. This calculation can be done in CFX-Post. This variable can be used to compare loudness among various geometries. where ρ – density ε – kinetic energy dissipation k – kinetic energy c – sound speed Pref – Reference Acoustic Power (W/m3)
The Proudman's formula gives an approximate measure of the local contribution to total acoustic power per unit volume in a given turbulence field. #
10