Buck Mulroney

BUCK

Kernr

FTAG C4R

iQ

1127AM

Sent

To

DFD

BUCK MULRONEY

IN 1DM

SECRET

PIs

It

in

C4R

Safety

Kabul

in

facility

the

thej

proved

pass to General Grant For Vincent

Rigby Also please pass

Canadian embass

of interviewing

hard to locate

the documentation

Of the

hurt

we

visit to

dabar

JAG

to

detainees

made

nad

been

to

detention

be

of monitoring

shocked

carried

detainees

the

iees

all

complained

being held nor did any seem

We

were

ssh to However access

NDS

have

lack

been

on two consecutive

they said they needed

to the

about

Jetainee tenninated

The

said

They

know wby

they did not

sho readily

from the

by

NDS

agreed

NDS

interlocutors

They provided

not to be present

are

general

before they could

director

us with quick

during the interviews allow us physical

facilities

detainees

in

Kabul

are

held in one

of three

facilities

the

tQh

spilover

beside the

facility

and PoliCharki

Detainees

said

they preferred

the conditions

described subpar conditions in the allowed

they

charged

days and

pennission

was signed

Afghanistan

new

could be discussed

of clarity in their cases

pleased with the openness

generally

detainees

to

of Canada and

had

still

the

before

of mistreannent

possibility

el

from between

out in

the governments

the interview before

provided

efforts

with

NDS traumatized

arr

from Kandahar

ing information

with cables

whipped

Kabul

in Kabul

etainees

co

advance

in

facility in

detained

available

sometimes

should be prdvided

photos

NDS

central

are believed

and

limited

interviewed

while in

and was

thai

NDS

the

Although

the

Sederat

detainees

no correspond with the

Better files including

letainees ise

conducted

the

all

of the names or ages di

The

C4 KABUL C4

pass to Suzanne Hurtubise

On city with

Public

detention

CAR

J9

CEO

KANDH KAY Please NDHQ OTT ADM PSEPC

C4R

NDS

Visit to

LAPORTE Eric ID NDHQ OTT ADM POL

Cofleen

NDHQ CEFCOM

KANDH lQ PCOIBCP

Subject

some

DMA C4 SWORDS

David

outside

once

per week

visitors are not

allowed

the impression

of

access

for

Sederat

30

to

in

food

60 minutes

However

none

as is

they had

washing

alleged

facilities

in the cc

to

overcrowded

are dirty

mistreatment

On

or fear

more access

and

small

poor

and

Kabul

in

at

outdoors detainees

least

tQ They are

some cases

nor did the detainees

give

seemed

182008 287

lore

Overview

KABUL lvi Political

On

conducted the

an

Colvin

portion

lo

initial

visit

the Sederat

to

were accompanied

and

On

did not accompany on

1700

We

also

then met

ih

10

the doctor in charge

11

wardens

NDS HQ Palace which

from

drive

detention requires

permission

to

Modalities to

register

at

We

also

had

not yet seen

14

was

and

peculiar

interlocutors

dealt

15 However that

main

to

Jan

16

NDS

While

the

ns

NDS

the

as well

officials readily

to

agreed

nor were there

as

absent

indication

recent

out of the compound

driving

They were walking

prison

on

is

beside the guard

freely

The

buildings

on

Afghan National

NDS

the

each

office

includes

than the

rather

whose purpose

same

National

main

the

Sederat

the

Security Court

complexes

office

The compound

was unclear

from

compound

Strategy the

NDS

Kabul about

as but separate

sireet

Development

Sedarat compound

Generals

Attorney

It is

in central

compound

large sprawling

roads are clear

at

detainee

each

visit

that

visits

the

in

the

within

NDS

prior to

minutes

five

lan

we would

with

is

at

least

one

walled and

they provided

turn

our visit During

up unannounced copy

For each of our meeting

phone numbers of key

contacts

with

Both accepted

of our detainee

two

the

that

so that

iE

which

arrangement

we would

we

visits

they

be allowed

main gate

interviews

we

our

NDS

asked to see and

erroneous

who

When

to

do

so

next

we

and

interlocutors

were

cooperative

with the exception

of one

to tour

we

meet

to receive will

helpful

They

whose recorded name our sense was that

Overall

of meeting our requests

the detention

would need

and even

individual

they were unable to identifjt

with the intention

not granted permission

authority

Amrullah Saieh

alerted

in future

with us in good faith and

were

we

butwere allowed

them

detainee

possibly

first

believe

16

the

to

facility

unrelated

other

gate

tQ up

they did not have

General

the

if

was our

informed

turn

With regard

warden of

enter

the

For

speedily produced

several

this

provided

when we

to the

As

we

and

relaxet

Aurprisingly

NDS zones

reports

and

13

the

of the detainees were shackled

they returned

completely

building

had

access

embassy

two

the

technically

LES

thy

the following

interview with

the

completed

met with

60 minutes

15 minutes and

Sedarat detention

the

compound

separates

rights

hancL

NDS

The

Facility

We

was resumed

but

closing

until

None

as

For

human

speald

by

clinic

was

overall

interviewees

minutes

was

We

interviews

Atmosphere

hoV

1000

between

lasted

the

during

passed

12

from

of the prison

Each interview

themselves

assisted

Kabul

facility in

has received

at

facility

interviewed

arid

was

del

who

during

the

lasted

portion

fromi

detention

MCO

by

both days

NDS

primary

inees

cmll

interview had to be

the

Bloodworth Second Secretary

and

Counsellor

compound

themselves

facilities

expit

approval

ask him to

from

Our

NDS

interlocutors

said

Director

authorization

edo not

usthestateoff

visit

The meetings and

interviews

took place in what

seemed

to

2003 287 of

17 As them

when

General

the

the

While

we

arrived

were being

us an overview

gave

They

were

we

each

for

be

as

Kabul and

in

including transfer to Kabul and

detainee was brought

Yh

be the detention

to

Apart from nonaccess

detention

to the

our detainees

identifying

Canadian

detainees

information

in

knS Was

detainees

one

only have

reasonable confidence

ianh

forces

by

NDS

wrong

20

transferred

Ofthe iv The

did

NDS

that

otherhad

The

name was

his

Srather

similar

and

thar

the

Unfortunately

we

faced

was

listed

we

interviewed

we

were

interviewed

list

he said

he

were

the

We

not even

had

the

very strange

those detained

we

seeking but in other respects

them anyway

detainee his

age was

by

the

produced clearly

is ft

follow

this

NDS

cLv in

said

ywhere

detention

than

for

not

nor

and

of

in the result

in fact

interview because

vever

did

list

Moreover

not Pashto

to

nan

do their best

similarities to those

on

nt

by ISAF

in correctly

Norieofthe

the

was

was

only

ioh

zh old

we

tame of their village

their

We

detainee

only in English

written

to that

of the interviews

Reportsc

case

tQ

not correspond with that

because

difficulty

exjzc ia

detainees

The names were

limited

of each

mation

some

that

at

met with the

ld

that they had

All they

our possession was quite

no photos

main

the

themselves

facilities

room

into the

We

facility itself

ooh 19

asked to interview

room

detainee

The

itself

tseems

yisit

to

names

the

provided

isitweQ Q1SQE

18

followed

room

the registration

an hour after

we know

that

brought to our meeting

of the procedures

showed us

also

1530 ie roughly

and

located

byhis

greeted

detainees

those detainees

isQ around

we

names of th

place of capture

th name

hQl

of

te

This information was not sufficient

no

Individual

The

He

individual

heh

Qlh answers

had been

generally

taken

are

all

in his file

at

at

the

ease talking

start

Meeting

ment

us was

be was whispering

of the meeting

with us and

even

saying he had therefore

been

terminated

asked after

to

himself

smiled

rQ

and had been

approximately

did not wish to talk with

to ask him about

Jan18

marks although

visible

appeared

the

about

visited

by

the

by

others

and

the

and we were not

able

2008 287 of

vQidrQ

isfr

detentionfortherightlengthoftimeabout

islistedinourdatabase

iscrepancyi the

paid

it

ih

and

locatio

info

of capture

from the

is

sought individual

database

in the

It

sex age and

of transfer

date

includes

the

just

name

of birth village and

place

does not provide

It

QtSQQQSQtSQ

NDS

for

facility

approxin

flbehadbeens

Iwhileat

utwhenhehadaskedforL that

he

still

not good

Individual

that

says

He

does get

He

is

from

visits

fed bread

and

tea for rather

enough at the

He

see

has been

interact

the

sun

but also

forthcoming Individual

sat

When

underneath

we

iQiQO

the

one

Individual

lunch and

hands

his feet

When

NOS

he only gets

facility

ih said

TF 30

please

his

he straightened on

the

toes

it

could

place cannot

Jan

18

rooms is

wev

very

he

and expressed

is

he became

happy

seen that the

He

quiet

now

for

gratitude

was

in place

the

new

He

said

that

did not

our visit

General

established

completed rty clothes

it

well

there

is

wh

on

althom

know where

that

to

he

is

and

as

because he thinks

by contrast

iy

roll

be

top of the nail although

than Kabul

rather

bEQEQh

He

minutes

somewhat

sleep

Hes

did not

be got to

twitches

conducted

family doesnt

talk

He was

pasfl

his

He

becanse

iybadandLEQ He

detainees

walk outside

clasped during the meeting

redorange

and

to

to

be preferred

Hesaidhec spent the

on

sleep

washroom

Other

supper

not being allowed

that

say

treatment

brought

appeare

the

fihe his

he was

ng

wash

pray and

an hour

for

and

with some facial

under

happened keen

bread

tQ

next to it were

been

that

sat

seSmed anxious

appeared

ip

and

rice

They to

day

about

time for prayers

careful and

asked him about

Sborate

times for

Fridays

about

room

one

with more people there At the

with his toes curled

of the big toe and

growth

ih

and

quiet

in

four

Sedarat but did

by

visited

was

Individual

nails

and

and

lives out

on

he keeps

because

than rice

about the treatmdnt

walk around to

bsth

of not having

complained

week

he

facility

soninlaw

his

of being fed potatoes

complain

an

NDS

the

at

on the floor They are allowed

mattresses

He

got to Kabul

be

result

no

about

one his

comes

family

to

He

visit is

him

lka

married

and

has

The washing that

over

2008 287

child

they

tQinh They

He

are

let

we and

cables

wires He

he was

hit

said

said

He

has

still

la

said

that

treatment

his

was being put

identified

matched

This individual of origin

dark room for

the

infonnation

from when

restraining

The

few hours

Oven

the

at

time of one

our database

in

his

questions

Canadians

His family has

or

Americi

He

but doesnt

detention

him He was

detained

working

him

in

but were not allowed

Kabul

He

he

said that

NDS gets

get

out to pray

He was

bread

told

and

that

says he does not

and

tea for breakfast

because

he was detained

for

potfOes be

they have to

He

He

Th

lunch and

asked us ff1

said

am

he

said

does not

been able

to

Kabul because

in

watertea only when

they

worked

be bad

serious

some

why

Taliban

didnt

the

Americans

me

keep

inKabul

Hehasbeenhel

He

He

any hehadnevergonerQQQ

know

place

to

Hehasbeenvisitedby

He

and

his

wQ

family was allowed

he

when he

with us

being held in

prefers

problem

of detention

no at

during

and tightened by

of his interrogations

spoke

willingly

any

only specific

length

age

be was detained

some food

and

clothes

of scars on

were shackled

hands

his

device was too tight

also

ameE

even

is

better

has been

in

when the

whether

deliver

the

sethet asked

number

us

provided

This

fingers

said

he was

Kabul

in

relaxed and

appeared

Hec 1say He has been

and

bands

Hest know

hands

Jesaidheis

Individual

electricity

place

very dangeEous

in his

his

He showed

QQ

NDS

while in

He moved

sick

Theyhituswith him with

shocked

also

hes never

because

caused by the beating

was

it

He

they

were

doctor but thats

to

fordays

nQC itself

th

access

him abouthis

legs which he said

only once

requested

asked

Heandthepeoplehe

food money together and buy supplemental and 60 minutes week for total of between 30

put

outside

has never

When his

potatoesandawaterys so

room with

shares

He

saidt

and

others

ldf

When

we asked wire and forced big ankle which he said

it

was

the

Afteriays

18

said

said that to stand

for

two

was from the cable

NDS who

interrogated

of being beaten

There

and the

held

he was

all He showed us

days but

was

hit

on his feet

with

cable

mark on the back of

his

dark red mark on the back of his ankle

He

him

cable and

made

to

stand he was put in

2008

16

him asked

why

he

is still

get his

documents

being detained

either

finalized

and

he should be

for his sent to

family to be jail

allowed

or allowed

to

go

to

visit

He

also

home

Drafted

Approved

Jan 18

Lalani

2008

016