Electronic
Frontier
Foundation
Protecting Rights and Promoting Freedo", on the Electronic Fronti.'
January4, 2006 Alain Levy and CEO
Music
EMI
Chainnan
Lane
Wrights
27
5SW
W8
London
10011
NY
York,
Avenue
publicly
to
Music
EM!
on
call
to
today
writes
(EFF)
Foundation
Mr.
and
Munns:
Frontier
Levy
Mr. Electronic
The
Dear
USA
New
150 Fifth
America
CEO
and
North
Music
EM!
Chainnan
Munns
Kingdom
David
United
security
its
on security
released
vulnerabilities
against
under "ยป
claims ("DMCA
any
problems
with copy-protection
Virgin
including
Group,
Music
discs.
by
controlled
compact
remedied. In response to
Act
assert
not
will
Copyright
it
to identify
computer
and
discs
security compact
address programmers
some
to on
steps
taken
working
labels
several
that
that
agreed
Millennium
has Digital
researchers
used on Sony-HMO
aware
Weare
technologies
were discovered and ultimately
EM!
security
the
Sony-HMO
EFF,
computer
(including
laws
from
letter copyright
a
experts that these vulnerabilities
independent
of
included
recently efforts
the
software
has through
only
copy-protection
Sony-HMO
labels.
the was
It
by
know,
EMI
you labels.
created
As
by
declare that it will not take any legal action against computer security researchers interested in investigating copy-protection technologies used on compact discs released
against
EM!
with
compact
threats included
EM!
legal examine (EULAs)
to
leveled
have reluctant
vendors
be agreements"
may licensing
user
"end
researchers
copy-protection
some
past,
the
the
that
in
because note
researchers
also
We
discs.
security
Unfortunately,
Records, Liberty Records, and Capitol Records, are distributing compact discs in the United Statesthat include copy-protection technology supplied by Macrovision.
.
454 ShotwellStreet. San Francisco,CA94110 USA
. +14154369333 0 +14154369993
www.eff.org
.
[email protected]
legal
by
off
put
be
may
researchers
While
researchers.
for
chill
additional
an
creating
compact discs appear to forbid reverse engineering for computer security research,
response. prompt
your
security
computer
any
to
discs.
compact
EMI
on
identify
to
working
be
will
or
are,
been,
above
described
as
claims
legal
any
waive
to
and
discs;
compact
EM!
on
security
to
security
bring
used
technologies
have
who
used
against
forward
who
customers
its
exposing
protection
agree
also
EMI
to
technologies
discs
look
We
researchers
against
in
copy
with
researchers
security
compact
Records
Records
concerns.
any,
if
interest
no
has
problems
EMI
Capitol
Virgin
CEO,
action
legal
take
to
EMI
protection
protected
CEO,
few,
pose
should
desire
technology
copy
and
and
Chairman
above
against
accompanies
President
Slater,
Flom,
that
security
.
any
assume
We
agreement
license
user
end
the
under
claims
any
assert
to
not
Agree
.
Jason
nor
risks,
discs;
compact
EMI
on
used
technologies
protection
copy
with
problems
security
identify
to
working
statutes
similar
(or
Code
U.S.
the
of
17
Title
under
claims
any
assert
to
not
Agree
.
Andrew
cc: outlined
lines
to:
EMI
urge
we
particular,
In
labels.
EMI
by
released
discs
compact
on
used
technologies
protection
any
take
not
will
it
that
declare
publicly
to
Group
Music
EM!
urges
EFF
Consequently,
remedied.
and
discovered
be
otherwise
might
that
flaws
security
of
informed
adequately
is
public
the
nor
EMI
neither
that
be
may
realities
these
of
result
unfortunate
The
January 4, 2006
Page 2
risks, criminals intent on exploiting securityvulnerabilities,of course,will haveno such legal compunctions.
legal action against computer security researchersinterested in investigating copy-
in other countries) against security researcherswho have been, are, or will be
researchers
(EULA) that who
have been, are, or will be working to identify security problems with copy
Agree to take reasonablestepsto ensurethat vendorswho supply copy protection
vulnerabilities to the attention of the public. Accordingly, a public statement along the Munns
David
and
Levy
Alain